LESSON A SOCIOMETRY OF OPPRESSIONS Used with permission by Susan

Document Sample
LESSON A SOCIOMETRY OF OPPRESSIONS Used with permission by Susan Powered By Docstoc
               Used with permission by Susan Diane R.N., B.A., M.A.

Grade Level               Context
Grades 10-12              The basic premise for this experiential educational
                          exercise came from Logan et al. (1996) who were
Learning                  educating social work students about heterosexual
Outcomes                  privilege. Although this educational tool still includes
-to introduce the         sexual orientation/identity, it has been expanded to
concept of privilege,     include gender, race/ethnicity, age, class, occupation,
oppression and its        ability and religion. It is expanded here to give a sense of
affects on all            the interconnections and complexity of identity within the
individuals               multiple structures of oppression in a hierarchical,
                          capitalist, patriarchal society. Although the activity is
-to develop a better      complex, students can gain a sense of these issues
understanding of          through role-play and assuming another identity.
the complexity of
individuals within        Preparation
our society               ♦ Photocopy and cut identity cards (page 87). Adult
                             identities and youth identities (to use with secondary
-to increase                 students) are after the activities at the end of the
awareness and                lesson.
understanding of          ♦ Photocopy the Sociometry of Oppression Question
the meaning of               sheet on page 91 to read out to the group.
power and control         ♦ A fairly large open space is needed which often
                             necessitates moving furniture, or using a gym or hall.
-to gain a better         ♦ A class of about 15-20 participants seem ideal, but it
understanding of             can be used with smaller or larger numbers.
how and why our
                          ♦ About half an hour is needed to complete the exercise
culture maintains
                             although this will vary depending on the amount of
the status quo
                             time it takes for debriefing each participant.
-to develop
empathy for others
                          Explain that participants will be given an identity card and
                          asked to move forward one step (or its equivalent if there
                          are wheelchair participants) when answering affirmatively
                          to a series of questions. It is helpful to explain that
                          everyone will be taking the same amount of risk in
                          playing the game. If it seems the students may be
                          reluctant, try using a “fish bowl” technique, where some
                          students do the activity and others watch. (All the
                          students report on what they learned from the activity. It
                          does not work as well, but is one way to adapt this for
                          shy students.)
Hand out cards to each participant. Instruct them not to show
their cards to other participants. You may need to help some
participants individually if they have questions about their
identity card. If you have a small number of participants try to
pick identities so that you have a mix of sexual orientations,
genders, ethnic origins, religious denominations and abilities.

Have participants line up against a wall. Start with all
participants facing towards the wall. Ask those who can be
open about their sexuality to turn around and face forward. As
you read out the questions and the students move forward,
those with their face to the wall will walk backwards to step
ahead and those facing forward will walk forward.

Read out the questions regarding social and economic
privileges which are worded so that those who can participate in
the activity (e.g. take out a loan) can take a step forward. Those
who would not be able to do that in our society must remain
where they are. After reading out all the questions, and allowing
participants to move forward to various degrees, have
participants stay in their resulting positions of privilege when the
questions are finished.

Ask each one in turn to read out their identity and discuss what
the experience was like for him/her. You are actually debriefing
each participant, but others will usually join in the discussion as
this process continues. Be sure to have each and every student
discuss what the experience was like for her/him, to ensure they
can make sense of what they experienced. As in any
experiential activity, be prepared for the possibility of someoneʼs
personal experiences being triggered so that further debriefing
may be needed. Participants are asked to take on a pseudo-
identity (a type of role-playing), so this usually does not trigger
major personal revelations.

After each student has shared what it was like, discuss how
privilege works and how those with it can be successful, while
those without it find themselves falling behind in our society.
Talk about "double and triple oppressions.” This is when a
person has a number of interconnecting factors holding them
back (e.g. colour, gender and sexual orientation). Discuss the
reason this happens in our society. Why are groups
oppressed? What is the purpose of oppressing a group of
people? Whose needs does it serve? Is it acceptable? Legal?
Fair? Ethical? What can we do to change this?
How can we do it? Who is responsible for what is happening in
our society? What did we learn from this discussion?

1) Have the students write a journal about any of the questions
    above that they are interested in.

2) Share with the students some historical examples of
   oppression, such as Apartheid, the Holocaust, Black slavery
   in the USA, Stonewall Riots and the continuing oppression
   of gays and lesbians. Have them research a group of
   people (or a specific person) and the oppression they have
   suffered. Have them present their findings to the class.
                         PSEUDO-IDENTITIES (Adult)

                              White, male, bisexual          Asian-Canadian female
                              artist (not famous yet) with   nurse, who is bisexual and
18-year-old, white, single,   a male partner. He also        in a committed
heterosexual, female          has a criminal record for      relationship with a woman.
secretary, who is HIV+.       possession of illicit drugs    They are raising her
                              in the past. Currently he      partnerʼs four Caucasian
                              is a practising Christian.     children.

Stay-at-home,                 First Nations bisexual
heterosexual mother of        female factory worker in a     Male-to-Female
three children, with          relationship with a white      transgendered truck driver
"traditional values", whose   man. She practices             in a relationship with a
husband has a six-figure      traditional native             woman.
income.                       spirituality.

                              20-year-old female
16-year-old high-school                                      Separated single gay
                              Caucasian sex-trade
student who is lesbian and                                   white male who has
                              worker who is
is deaf. She uses sign                                       custody of his 10-year-old
                              heterosexual and in a
language to communicate                                      daughter and who works
                              polygamous relationship
and is a practising                                          as an elementary school
                              with a male pimp. She is
Christian.                                                   teacher.
                              addicted to heroin.

                              35-year-old white
White heterosexual            heterosexual female social     Black heterosexual female
Christian male who is the     worker who is married to a     lawyer who is the only
CEO of a multinational        Jamaican-Canadian man.         woman and the only
corporation. He is married    They have two children.        person of colour working
with three children.          She is a practicing Wiccan     in a prominent firm.

                                                             50-year-old divorced
                                                             female teacher who has
                              White 60-year-old lesbian
White single lesbian stay-                                   raised her children and
                              who is a general medical
at-home mother of 2 small                                    hasnʼt worked for the past
                              practitioner and suffers
children living on welfare.                                  15 years. Her husband
                              from epilepsy.
                                                             has left and he hid their
14-year-old Japanese-         Gay Chinese-Canadian          Indo-Canadian male
Canadian lesbian              man who is raising a          psychiatrist who is
Buddhist high-school          disabled child with his       heterosexual and a
student.                      partner.                      practicing Sikh.

15-year-old Hispanic-         17-year-old white             25-year-old black disabled
Canadian gay male high-       heterosexual student, who     female university student
school student who is a       is a sports jock and very     (uses a wheel chair) and
practising Catholic.          popular in the school.        is a practising Anglican.

                               Catholic Italian mother of
Closeted gay male Jewish      three children who is a
lawyer who is married with    recent immigrant to           Svend Robinson
two children. He lives with   Canada and does not           famous Canadian
his wife but has sex with     speak English. She is         politician, white gay male,
his secret male lover of      married and works in an       partnered, Unitarian
several years.                Italian bakery.

k.d. lang                     David Suzuki
famous Canadian singer,       environmental activist
lesbian, vegetarian,          heterosexual, married,
partnered, white              Japanese-Canadian
                        PSEUDO-IDENTITIES (Youth)

                                                          17-year-old white
18-year-old, black                                        heterosexual student,
                              14-year-old, Japanese
disabled female, using a                                  who is a sports jock and
                              Canadian lesbian high
wheel chair and is a                                      very popular in the
                              school student.
practicing Anglican.                                      school.

                                                          16-year-old female who
16-year-old, high school      16-year-old first nations
                                                          works at the bakery to
student who is lesbian        female student going out
                                                          help her immigrant
and deaf. She uses sign       with a white male. She
                                                          family. She has been
language to                   practices traditional
                                                          raised catholic. Her mom
communicate.                  native spirituality.
                                                          speaks very little English.

19-year-old white             16-year-old white male      16-year-old gay male
heterosexual female who       who lives with his mom.     who is in the closet. He
is in a relationship with     She has drug problems.      dates girls and plays
an older Jamaican-            He was recently beat up     sports. He recently met a
Canadian man.                 by her boyfriend.           guy he likes.

17-year-old female with a
                              17-year-old Caucasian
one-year-old baby, living                                 19-year-old lesbian
                              female who is living on
at home. She is trying to                                 female, who is a
                              the street. She is
finish her last year at                                   practicing Wiccan (witch).
                              addicted to crack.
high school.

15-year-old white male        17-year-old white lesbian   19-year-old, vegetarian
who skips school most         stay at home mom of two     female rock musician, in
days and hangs out at         small children living on    lesbian relationship.
the mall. He is starting to   welfare. She is studying    Considers herself
do drugs.                     by distance education.      bisexual.

                              Grade 12 student who is
16-year-old straight male                                 Grade 10 female student
                              transgendered, M to F.
hippy that smokes dope                                    who cares about the
                              Wants to wear dresses
openly and comes to                                       environment and hassles
                              and make-up to school
school from an island. He                                 others about eating meat,
                              and use the female
was home-schooled.                                        etc.
Grade 12 student who is        17-year-old white           15-year-old white female
an out lesbian. Her            depressed female who is     student who is in a
friends are trying to find a   questioning her sexuality   violent relationship with
sponsor teacher to start a     and has attempted           an older man. She is
GSA in their high school.      suicide 4 times.            scared to tell anyone.

                                                           Grade 8 student with
Gothic dressed white           Grade 8 white male
                                                           learning difficulties,
male student, who is in a      student, skateboarder.
                                                           thinking of dropping out
relationship with a black      He has a close group of
                                                           of school. Parents donʼt
female. His family deals       friends both male and
                                                           really expect him to
with issues of poverty.        female.

17, White heterosexual         16-year-old Cambodian       Indo-Canadian female,
female whose father is         female, ESL. Her family     who is dating a white
rich. She skies in             ignores her and she is      male. Her family is
Whistler and stays in          behind at school by 2       against the relationship.
their condo in Victoria on     years. She is always by     She is thinking of getting
weekends.                      herself and looks lonely.   pregnant.

19-year-old, gay male                                      17-year-old First Nations
                               16-year-old white female,
who has a girlfriend but                                   female. She is talented in
                               who had sex for the first
has sex with guys                                          basketball and wants to
                               time last year. She has
secretly. His girlfriend                                   play. Often late for
                               just found out she is
thinks they should get                                     practice as she has to
married.                                                   look after her siblings.
Sociometry of Oppression Questions

These questions are asked once individuals have their pseudo-identity card
(which they are instructed not to show to others) and are lined up, facing a wall.

   1. If you are free to be open about your sexuality with those close to you
      (example out of the closet in most situations) please turn around and face
      the center of the room?

   2. Can you expect to speak openly and easily about your sexual orientation
      and or gender identity at school or at work without fear of harassment or
      negative consequences?

   3. Do you feel safe walking alone on the streets after dark?

   4. Do you expect to be treated fairly by the police?

   5. Do you expect that you and your body will be treated with respect and
      dignity at school or work, without fear of harassment?

   6. Can you go to the corner store on foot quickly and easily?

   7. Can you walk by a group of teenagers without fear of insults or

   8. Do you expect your children to attend school without discrimination or

   9. Can you legally marry?

   10. Do you expect to be financially well off and be able to travel during your

   11. You are being considered for a promotion. Are you secure your personal
       life or identity will not hinder you?

   12. You are in a new social situation and you are asked if you are married. Are
       you comfortable answering truthfully?

   13. Are you comfortable bringing your partner to the school dance?

   14. Do you expect to be able to get a large loan from the bank easily?

   15. Would it be easy for you to introduce your partner to your family?
   16. Do you think that your chances are good when you are interviewed by a
       social worker to adopt a child?

   17. Are you comfortable holding hands with your partner in public?

   18. If you became sick with AIDS, would some people say you were an
       innocent victim rather than you deserved it?

   19. Can you expect to be a religious leader in your community?

   20. Can you discuss your religious practices and holidays openly at work or
       school without fear of harassment?

   21. Can you communicate easily with others you have just met?

   22. If your partner died, would you be automatically recognized as the next-of-

Diane, S. (1999). Amazing Graces: A Qualitative Study of Lesbian Helping
Professionals. Unpublished Masterʼs Thesis. The University of British Columbia,

Logan, J., Kershaw, S., Karban, K., Mills, S., Trotter, J., Sinclair, M. (1991).
Confronting Prejudice: Lesbian and Gay Issues in Social Work Education.
England: Ashgate Publishing Ltd. (pp. 77-78).

Youth Identities developed by GALE BC (2004)

Shared By: