A STRONG ECONOMY E6 PLANNING SCHEME AMENDMENT C46 - REQUEST FOR by lindahy

VIEWS: 6 PAGES: 10

More Info
									South Gippsland Shire Council                            19 August 2009
                                                             Leongatha


A STRONG ECONOMY

E.6 PLANNING SCHEME AMENDMENT C46 - REQUEST FOR INDEPENDENT
    PLANNING PANEL

APPENDIX 1 -

 SUMMARY OF SUBMISSIONS TO PLANNING SCHEME AMENDMENT C46
               Object Support Other Submitters Comment
FOSTER                               "Looks good" Need more
                         X
SUBMISSIONS                          residential land
                                     345 Fish Creek Road - Please
                                     amend plan to show all land in
                         X
                                     Rural Residential Investigation
                                     Area
                                     50 Foster Prom Road. Would
                                     seek to rezone land in
                         X           combination with 345 Fish
                                     Creek Road        (see above
                                     submission) for Rural Living
                                     Want their land at 345 Fish
                                     Creek Foster Road included in
                                     the      Rural      Residential
                                X
                                     Investigation Area. States this
                                     land is closer to town than
                                     Simons Lane in Leongatha
                                     Council has missed the
                                     opportunity to discuss climate
                                     change        in     Cl21.01-5
                                     Environment. Supports the
                                X
                                     Vision of Council with regard
                                     to Foster being at the forefront
                                     of climate change and rising
                                     sea level
                                     Would like to see improved
                                     pedestrian       and       cycle
                                X    connectivity to town centre.
                                     Better use of land adjoining
                                     Stockyard Creek
                                     Support for intentions for 45
                         X           Cooper Road Foster - Rural
                                     Residential Investigation Area
                                     Support for 35 Foster Prom
                                     Road going into the structure
                         X
                                     plan for Rural Residential
                                     Investigation Area




                                Page 1
South Gippsland Shire Council                                      19 August 2009
                                                                       Leongatha


LEONGATHA                                        Land fronting the South
SUBMISSIONS                                      Gippsland Highway north of
                                X                Boags Road. Does not want to
                                                 be included in 'Commercial
                                                 Investigation Area'
                                                 The      Bazley    St     'Future
                                                 Commercial          Investigation
                                X
                                                 Area' K should be residential
                                                 land
                                                 Bazley Street Leongatha. Do
                                                 not want to be included in
                                X
                                                 'Commercial         Investigation
                                                 Area' - want to be residential
                                                 Want Hughes St land to be
                                                 used for expansion of the
                                X
                                                 Recreation Reserve and not
                                                 future industrial
                                                 Want Hughes St land to be
                                X                used for expansion of the
                                                 Recreation Reserve
                                                 Want Hughes St land to be
                                                 used for expansion of the
                                X
                                                 Recreation Reserve - seek
                                                 alternative land for Industrial
                                                 Want Hughes St land to be
                                X                used for expansion of the
                                                 Recreation Reserve
                                                 Want Hughes St land to be
                                X                used for expansion of the
                                                 Recreation Reserve
                                                 Want Hughes St land to be
                                X                used for expansion of the
                                                 Recreation Reserve
                                                 Support 105 Old K'burra Road
                                                 (Shingler St) for residential
                                                 development but want the
                                    X
                                                 land referred to a 'Preferred
                                                 residential area' and not just
                                                 'investigation area'
                                                 Support inclusion of lot 1
                                                 TP258915U (adjoining the
                                    X
                                                 Bass Highway) in future rural
                                                 residential investigation area
                                                 Requests change to the
                                                 Leongatha Structure Plan to
                                             X
                                                 require Outline Development
                                                 Pland for Leongatha South.




                                    Page 2
South Gippsland Shire Council                                 19 August 2009
                                                                  Leongatha


                                             161 South Gippsland Hwy
                                             (south of Parr St) supports
                                             commercial use adjoining the
                                X
                                             Hwy and wants 'investigation'
                                             removed and replaced with
                                             'preferred expansion area'
                                             225 South Gippsland Hwy.
                                             Supports Bulky Goods Retail
                                X
                                             and Commercial Investigation
                                             Area along Highway frontage
                                             Support for the development
                                             of a Bulky Goods Retail
                                             Precinct on the western side
                                X
                                             of the South Gippsland
                                             Highway north of Simons
                                             Lane
                                             Support for the development
                                             of a Bulky Goods Retail
                                             Precinct on the western side
                                             of the South Gippsland
                                X
                                             Highway, north of Simons
                                             Lane.     Also    support    for
                                             residential        development
                                             behind the retail area.
                                             VicRoads            Submission.
                                             Requests                Overall
                                             Development Plan for all new
                                         X   dev areas adjoining the Road
                                             Zone      Cat.     1.   Further
                                             investigation with VicRoads
                                             Required.
                                             Submission from the West
                                             Gippsland CMA. Anecdotal
                                             information suggest flooding
                                             potential on land east of
                                             L'gatha Cemetery which is
                                         X   identified for residential use.
                                             All new commercial and
                                             industrial areas should plan
                                             for stormwater. Open space
                                             and drainage reserves should
                                             be identified.
                                             Wants 5 Mary St included in
                                         X
LOCH                                         existing township




                                Page 3
South Gippsland Shire Council                                     19 August 2009
                                                                      Leongatha


MIRBOO NORTH                                     Wants land at 3140 Stzelecki
                                                 Hwy rezoned from Farming
                                             X   Zone to the Industrial Zone.
                                                 Currently have machinery
                                                 sales on land.
                                                 Concern that residential use of
                                                 the land behind Murray Street
                                X                (east) would create fire danger
                                                 and climate change will make
                                                 situation worse.
                                                 Support for plan but would like
                                                 to identify Lot 3 PS 416041S
                                    X
                                                 (Castle Street) as a strategic
                                                 redevelopment site
                                                 Support the amendment but
                                                 request that the boundaries of
                                    X            the long term growth area be
                                                 amended to accord with the
                                                 Mirboo North Structure Plan
                                                 Dept of Primary Industry
                                                 submission. Council is to be
                                                 mindful of the proximity of the
                                             X
                                                 sand resource and ensure that
                                                 buffers are maintained and
NYORA                                            that Cl17.09-2 is considered
                                                 Support for use of Toby
                                    X            Paddock (VicTrack land) for
                                                 commercial development
                                                 No more development along
                                                 Henrys Road and Forest
                                                 Drive.        Keep        urban
                                                 devevelopment around the
                                                 town centre. Upgrade the
                                X
                                                 roads. Plan for a commercial
                                                 area. Improve pathways and
                                                 connectivity. End fragmented
                                                 development. Put in building
                                                 controls. No pylons
                                                 Keep rail reserve land as park
                                                 - no supermarket. Community
                                                 facilities to be located near
                                X
                                                 hall. Sewer a priority as is
                                                 equestrian / cycle / pedestrian
                                                 paths.
                                                 Village green should stay
                                                 undeveloped. Shops should
                                X
                                                 be on same side as post office
                                                 or behind it.




                                    Page 4
South Gippsland Shire Council                                     19 August 2009
                                                                      Leongatha


                                                 Lack of infrastructure for
                                                 residential development. Don't
                                X
                                                 change the existing character.
                                                 Council is greedy
                                                 Current infrastructure can't
                                                 cope with development so
                                X                how will new development?
                                                 Peace and quiet is valued and
                                                 should be retained
                                                 No       to     high     density
                                                 development.         No       to
                                                 capitalising on proximity to
                                                 Melb. Came for lifestyle - don't
                                                 want change. Moved to Nyora
                                X
                                                 to 'escape suburbia'. Min
                                                 block size should be 2.5ha.
                                                 No new roads. Need post
                                                 service.     Power     to    be
                                                 underground.
                                                 No 1/4 acre blocks. Don't want
                                                 infrastructure if it lead to
                                                 development. Don't want more
                                X
                                                 traffic. Don't want urban
                                                 sprawl. Don't want more
                                                 people. 'Leave Nyora alone'.
                                                 New sewer system should be
                                                 designed      to    cope    with
                                                 possible growth and should
                                             X
                                                 allow for 'tap in points'.
                                                 Recycled water for parks
                                                 should be provided.
                                                 No 1/4 acre blocks. Don't
                                                 change the town character.
                                X                "where would wallabies and
                                                 wombats go?" No to shops
                                                 and keep Village Green.
                                                 Keep existing low density
                                                 character. Impact on natural
                                X
                                                 environment. Don't turn Nyora
                                                 into suburbia.
                                                 Support a supermarket in
                                    X
                                                 town and encourage rail trails




                                    Page 5
South Gippsland Shire Council                                   19 August 2009
                                                                    Leongatha



                                             Object to high density. No 1/4
                                             acre lots. No to Hatchs and
                                             Forester Road being through
                                             roads. No overpopulation.
                                X
                                             Keep      the    lifestyle.     Any
                                             rezoning should be low
                                             density. Don't want Koo Wee
                                             Rup style dev in Nyora.
                                             No to high density. Nyora is a
                                X            tree change town. Keep
                                             existing character
                                             Lack         of         community
                                             infrastructure       to     support
                                             growth. List of missing assets
                                             provided. K'burra should be
                                X            the shopping spot for Nyora.
                                             Don't need shops in Nyora.
                                             Keep horse friendly town.
                                             Main      roads       can't    take
                                             increased traffic.
                                             Moved from Melb for the
                                X            lifestyle and large lots. Don't
                                             change this
                                             Retain low density character
                                X            of town. Move to area for Tree
                                             Change.
                                             Recently moved to the area.
                                             Keep          low           density.
                                X
                                             Development should be 2.5 to
                                             5 acre lots.
                                             Not opposed to development
                                             but don't want small lot
                                X
                                             development.          Keep       the
                                             current lifestyle.
                                             Support                  residential
                                    X        development between the
                                             cemetery and the town.
                                             UDF is obsolete. Amendment
                                X            is unsympathetic to the
                                             community wishes.
                                             Don't want a "rabbit warren"
                                             subdivision.          Lack        of
                                X            community           infrastructure.
                                             Long list of missing services
                                             provided.




                                    Page 6
South Gippsland Shire Council                                       19 August 2009
                                                                        Leongatha



                                                 Would like their land (lot 1
                                                 TP419334W) rezoned for
                                             X   commericial         development.
                                                 Need                   commercial
                                                 development in Nyora
                                                 Support land for residential
                                                 development - Yannathan
                                    X
                                                 Road (lot 12 LP148069 and
                                                 Lot 2 LP213970)
                                                 Support        for     land      on
                                                 Yannathan Road (lots 1 & &
                                    X
                                                 LP 218761) for residential
                                                 development.
                                                 Support land adjoining the
                                    X            cemetery being used for
                                                 residential development.
                                                 Moved to Nyora 5 years ago.
                                                 Does not want change. Don't
                                X
                                                 want high density. Don't want
                                                 traffic.
                                                 Plans         doesn't       reflect
                                                 community             expectation.
                                                 Development should be small
                                                 acreage.           Lack          of
                                X                infrastructure.      Plans      too
                                                 vague. No population target.
                                                 Need statement of rural
                                                 character. Developing over
                                                 prime agricultural land.
                                                 Don't want high density. Don't
                                                 want Forster and Hatches
                                                 road linked. No supermarket.
                                X
                                                 "Bringing sewer to Nyora is
                                                 going to stink more than the
                                                 current septics".
                                                 All dev should have access to
                                                 paths. Connection to sewer
                                                 important. Lots of different
                                                 density required to plan for
                                                 different life stages - small lots
                                                 near town centre. A green belt
                                             X   through the town centre.
                                                 Some of Toby's Paddock
                                                 could remain and part for
                                                 shops. Linkages to Poowong
                                                 and Loch required. Aged care
                                                 facility in the long term may be
                                                 required.



                                    Page 7
South Gippsland Shire Council                                  19 August 2009
                                                                   Leongatha


                                             "I do not want to see Nyora
                                X
                                             opened up"
                                             Area around Nyora Hall
                                             should be commercial. Leave
                                             Toby's Paddock as park & bus
                                X            terminal on north side of
                                             railway line. Put shops west of
                                             park land. Use the former
                                             hotel site for supermarket.
                                             Exhibition inadequate and
                                             time for comment too short.
                                             Keep lifestyle. Works in
                                             Cranbourne. Likes semi rural
                                             and horses. Don't want 700
                                             lots. No market for small lots
                                             in Nyora. Roads not up to
                                X            standard. Pathways needed.
                                             Road safety issues. Concern
                                             re       sewer    leading      to
                                             development. Lack of social
                                             and physical infrastructure.
                                             Crime. Lack of health care.
                                             Lack of education. Increase in
                                             rates.
                                             Glad to see planning for
                                             Nyora.      Commercial      town
                                             centre should be bounded by
                                             Davis, Newson, Henley and
                                    X        Mitchell St. Bus should go to
                                             station. Alternate commericial
                                             area is diagonally opposite the
                                             post office. SGSC must make
                                             tough decisions.
                                             No high density. 2 acre lots
                                             should be ok. Don't want
                                X
                                             traffic.     Keep      township
                                             character.
                                             No high density surrounding
                                             town. Like lifestyle. Don't want
                                X
                                             streetlights. Nyora should be
                                             left as big blocks.
                                             Don't want small blocks. Don't
                                X            have infrastructure to cope.
                                             Don't want urban sprawl.
                                             Just bought first home raising
                                             family - good place for kids.
                                X            Like horses and large lots. No
                                             to suburbia. "Keep it a
                                             beautiful peaceful town"



                                    Page 8
South Gippsland Shire Council                                      19 August 2009
                                                                       Leongatha


                                                 Keep        Toby's       Paddock.
                                                 Commercial on south side of
                                X                Mitchell St & close to public
                                                 hall.    Put     bus      /  train
                                                 interchange on the site.
                                                 No commercial development
                                X                on Tobby's Paddock. Must all
                                                 be kept for park land.
                                                 Don't want high density. Don't
                                X                change local laws re animals.
                                                 Traffic will increase.
                                                 Development should be 1 acre
                                                 or more to blend in with the
                                X
                                                 existing. Road are unsuitable
                                                 for high density.
                                                 Will require upgrade of
                                                 domestic water supply. Road
                                                 upgrading will be required.
                                                 New        schools       required.
                                X                Rezoning to profit developers
                                                 and not the community. Crime
                                                 will increase. No employment.
                                                 New residents may try to
                                                 close the race track.
                                                 Oppose high density. 2 acres
                                                 plus should be encouraged.
                                X                Keep the village green and put
                                                 the supermarket on the other
                                                 side.
                                                 Moved in 15 months ago.
                                                 Don't want suburban blocks.
                                                 Keep lifestyle. Keep village
                                X                green.          Don't        want
                                                 supermarket but if one is
                                                 required it should be on other
                                                 side of Mitchell Street.
                                                 No subdivision under 1/2 acre.
                                                 Commercial          should      be
                                                 between        Mitchell,    Davis,
                                                 Hewson and Henley. All
                                X
                                                 community facilities should be
                                                 concentrated in this area. Rail
                                                 land should remain open
                                                 space.
                                                 Reference         to     drainage
                                                 scheme which is currently in
                                             X
                                                 development for Loch and
                                                 Nyora




                                    Page 9
South Gippsland Shire Council                                  19 August 2009
                                                                   Leongatha


                                              Rail land should be left for
                                              future rail use in all towns.
                                              Keep      Nyora    rail   land
                                              undeveloped      -    no     to
                                              supermarket on rail land.
                                X
                                              Future need for car parking for
                                              rail use. Land between
                                              Mitchell, Henley, Hewson and
                                              Davis should be identified for
                                              commercial.




                                    Page 10

								
To top