FORMATION THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY TEST AND DATA ANALYSIS

Document Sample
FORMATION THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY TEST AND DATA ANALYSIS Powered By Docstoc
					          FORMATION THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY
              TEST AND DATA ANALYSIS




    Analysis for:                        Mr. Jerry Linning
                                         School District #70, Port Alberni
                                         Secretary Treasurer
                                         4690 Roger St,
                                         Port Alberni, BC V9Y 3Z4



    Test location:                       4100 Roger St, Port Alberni, BC



    Report Date:                         April 20, 2009



    Test performed by:                   MEG Geothermal Corp.
                                         Phone: (604) 988-3388
                                         Fax: (604) 988-3329




402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca
Purpose of the FTC Test

The performance of a geoexchange ground loop system can be greatly dependent on the
characteristics of the rock/soil formation underlying the site and the final field configuration design. A
Formation Thermal Conductivity (FTC) test for thermal conductivity allows an opportunity to predict
the performance of a singular test well, so that the information can be applied to the design of a full-
scale ground loop system.

The geothermal system designer uses the FTC test information to size the ground loop with respect
to the calculated design heating and cooling loads, typically through the aid of computer based
geothermal design programs. Without the FTC information, over-sizing or under-sizing of the ground
loop may occur. An over-sized ground loop will increase capital costs, while delivering little increased
performance. An under-sized ground loop could diminish system economics by requiring increased
energy use from the system heat pumps and causing the field to fall below or climb above the
acceptable operating temperature range.

MEG Geothermal Corp. was retained to provide a Formation Thermal Conductivity (FTC) test at the
4100 Roger St, Port Alberni, BC location. The results of this analysis provide the thermal conductivity
and thermal diffusivity of the soil/rock formation surrounding the test borehole.

Test Procedures

The American Society of Heating, Refrigeration, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) as well
as the article Field Tests for Ground Thermal Properties – Methods and Impact on Ground Source
Heat Pump Design; Kavanaugh, ASHRAE Transactions 2000, Volume 106, Pt.1 recommend a set of
standards for performing formation thermal conductivity tests for geothermal applications. MEG
Geothermal Corp. is committed to adhering to the published specifications. Some of these standards
are listed below:

   1. Required Test Duration – A minimum test duration of 36 hours is recommended, with a
      preference towards 48 hours.

   2. Power Quality – The standard deviation of the power should be <1.5% of the average power,
      with maximum power variation of <10% of the average power. The heat flux rate should be
      15W (51 Btu/hr) to 25W (85 Btu/hr) per foot of borehole depth to best simulate the expected
      peak loads on the U-bend.

   3. Undisturbed Soil Temperature Measurement – The undisturbed soil temperature should be
      determined by recording the minimum loop temperature as the water returns from the U-bend
      at test startup.


302- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca
     4. Installation Procedures for Test Loops – The bore diameter is to be no larger than 6 inches,
        with 4.5 inches being the target diameter. To ensure against bridging and voids, the bore
        annulus is to be uniformly grouted from the bottom to the top using a tremie pipe.

     5. Time Between Loop Installation and Testing – A minimum delay of five days between loop
        installation and test startup is recommended if the formation is expected to have a low thermal
        conductivity or if low conductivity grouts (< 0.75 Btu/hr·ft·ºF) are used. A minimum delay of
        three days is recommended for all other conditions.

     6. The thermal resistance of the bore (pipe and grout) should be minimized so that the measured
        temperature rise is a strong function of the thermal properties of the soil.

     7. The depth of the test bore should be near the expected length of the ground loop.

 For a complete list of recommended procedures, refer to ASHRAE’s 2003 HVAC applications
 handbook, page 32.14.




402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca   3
 Data Analysis

 MEG Geothermal Corp. uses the "line source" method of data analysis. The line source equation
 used is not valid for the results obtained in the first few hours of the test. Also, the line source method
 assumes an infinitely thin line source of heat in a continuous medium. If a U-bend grouted in a
 borehole is used to inject heat into the ground at a constant rate in order to determine the average
 formation thermal conductivity, the test must be run long enough to allow the finite dimensions of the
 U-bend pipes and the grout to become insignificant. Experience has shown that the amount of time
 required to allow early test time error and finite borehole dimension effects to become insignificant is
 approximately four to ten hours.

 In order to analyze real data from a formation thermal conductivity test, the average temperature of
 the water entering and exiting the U-bend heat exchanger is plotted versus the natural log of time.
 Using the Method of Least Squares, the linear equation coefficients are then calculated that produce
 a line that fits the data. This procedure is normally repeated for various time intervals to ensure that
 variations in the power or other effects are not producing erroneous results.
 Through the analysis process, the collected raw data is converted to spreadsheet format (Microsoft
 Excel®) for final analysis.




402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca   4
 Formation Thermal Conductivity Test Report

 Date: …………………………………………... April 14-16, 2009
 Location: ……………………………………….4100 Roger St, Port Alberni, BC



 Borehole Data

 Undisturbed Soil temperature: ……………… Approx. 50.4 F
 Borehole Diameter: ………………………….. 6.0 inches

 Drill Log:

                                                      Diffusivity
     Length                   Type                     (ft2/day)
       0-20'              Brown till                       0.7
      20'-22'          Clay gravel wet                     0.6
      22'-46'                 Till                         0.7
     46'-250'          Shale (no water)                    0.7
       250            Weighted average:                   0.70

 U-bend Size: …………………………………..1” HDPE
 U-bend length: ……………………………….. 251 ft.
 Grout type: ……………………………………. 20% Gopher Grout
 Grouted portion: ……………………………… 0-251 ft

 Test Data

 Test duration: ………………………………… 42.05 hours
 Average Voltage: ……………………………. 236.12 V
 Average Power: ……………………………… 5,000 W
 Logged average circulator flow rate: ……… 5.65 usgpm

                               Power Characteristics
                Item                 Value                         Note
  Std. Dev. Of Average                  0.11%          must be less than 1.5%
  Max. Power Variance                   0.33%          must be less than 10%



402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca   5
                                                   4100 Roger St, Port Alberni, BC
                                                         April 14-16, 2009



                                         TEMPERATURE RESPONSES DURING TESTING


                             100.0

                              95.0                                                                         5000.0

                              90.0
                                                                                                           4800.0
                              85.0
          Temperature (°F)




                              80.0




                                                                                                                    Power (Watts)
                                                                                                           4600.0
                              75.0

                              70.0
                                                                            SUPPLY TEMP                    4400.0
                              65.0                                          AVERAGE TEMP
                                                                            RETURN TEMP
                                                                            POWER
                              60.0                                                                         4200.0
                              55.0

                              50.0                                                                         4000.0
                                  0.02      6.68     13.35     20.02      26.68       33.35       40.02
                                                             Time (hours)




                                                   Figure 1: Temperature vs Time Data




402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.      Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca       6
 Line Source Data Analysis


                                                   4100 Roger St, Port Alberni, BC
                                                         April 14-16, 2009


                                     AVERAGE TEMPERATURE VS NATURAL LOG OF TIME

                       100.0

                        95.0

                        90.0

                        85.0
    Temperature (°F)




                        80.0

                        75.0

                        70.0                                                                 y = 4.1495x + 57.579

                        65.0

                        60.0

                        55.0
                            4.00      4.50        5.00     5.50        6.00         6.50         7.00         7.50         8.00
                                                                   LN (TIME)




                                             Figure 2: Temperature vs Natural Log of Time

                       Time Period       Slope           Average Heat Input                  Thermal Conductivity
                                                         Btu/hr-ft        W/ft               Btu/hr-ft-°F W/m-K
    18.02 - 42.05 hours                  4.1495           67.97           19.9                  1.30          2.25


 The temperature vs. time data was analyzed using the line source analysis for the time period shown.
 An average linear curve fit was applied to the data between 18.02 and 42.05 hours. The slope of the
 curve was found to be 4.1495. The resulting thermal conductivity was found to be 1.30 Btu/hr-ft-°F

402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.       Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca    7
 Estimated Thermal Diffusivity

 A weighted average of the thermal diffusivity values of the various rock/soils encountered in the drill
 log provided an approximate formation thermal diffusivity of 0.70 ft2/day.



 Summary


 Thermal Conductivity (Btu/h-ft-°F): …………………………………... 1.30
 Estimated Thermal Diffusivity (ft2/day): ……………………………… 0.70



 Disclosure

 This report and analysis was completed by MEG Geothermal Corp. and it’s agents for the purpose of
 determining the Formation Thermal Conductivity of the soil/rock formation underlying the site at 4100
 Roger St, Port Alberni, BC. Use of this information, either directly or indirectly, by other parties shall
 be at their own risk.

 The values presented were obtained utilizing the methods and techniques commonly accepted for the
 purpose of FTC testing as of the writing of this report. The values represent the conditions
 encountered and registered at the location of the test borehole. We caution that different underlying
 soil/rock formation characteristics could be encountered elsewhere on the same site thus affecting
 the overall thermal conductivity and diffusivity.

 It is strongly recommended that the thermal conductivity and diffusivity values are used by an
 experienced geothermal field designer, in conjunction with appropriate geoexchange field sizing
 software. It is imperative that the geoexchange field be sized for the anticipated design heating and
 cooling load of the future facility, expressed typically in ton-hours per month, in order to adequately
 predict the effect of loads on the borehole field. Final bore field configuration can also greatly affect
 the final operating success of a geothermal system. To minimize field design errors, FTC information
 and field design should be analyzed by a qualified Registered Professional Engineer who regularly
 practices in the field of geothermal design and energy modeling.

 Note: Owners of buildings designed with geothermal systems are cautioned that building renovations,
 additions, or primary element characteristic changes (modifications to insulation levels or glazing

402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca   8
 characteristics), or major occupancy and use changes, may alter the building load/geoexchange field
 relationship negatively.

 This report and underlying calculations were reviewed by Mr. Emmanuel Lavoie, P. Eng, APEGBC.




 Seal




 Signature:

 Date:




402- 2030 Marine Dr. North Vancouver, B. C. V7P 1V7 CANADA.   Tel : 604 988-3388 Fax : 604 988-3329. info@meggeothermal.ca   9

				
DOCUMENT INFO