Docstoc

Proposition 65 Settlement 2006

Document Sample
Proposition 65 Settlement 2006 Powered By Docstoc
					                                                                                             Proposition 65
                                                                                          Settlement Summary
                                                                                                 2006


                                                          No. of            Total           Injunctive          Civil          % of          Attorney          % of         Other           % of
                        Plaintiff                      Settlements       Settlements      Relief Included      Penalty         Total       Fees & Costs        Total                        Total


CALIFORNIA SPORTFISHING PROTECTION ALLIANCE                  1              $452,500.00          1                   $0.00      0.00%           $275,000.00      60.77%    $177,500.00          39.23%
CALIFORNIA WOMEN'S LAW CENTER                                4               $49,225.00          4               $5,000.00     10.16%                 $0.00       0.00%     $44,225.00          89.84%
CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH                             22              $684,000.00         22               $5,000.00      0.73%           $469,119.00      68.58%    $209,881.00          30.68%
COMMUNITIES FOR A BETTER ENVIRONMENT                         1                $5,000.00          1                   $0.00      0.00%             $5,000.00     100.00%          $0.00           0.00%
ECOLOGICAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION                                 2               $90,500.00          2                   $0.00      0.00%            $40,000.00      44.20%     $50,500.00          55.80%
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW FOUNDATION                                 6              $236,000.00          6                   $0.00      0.00%           $236,000.00     100.00%          $0.00           0.00%
MATEEL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW FOUNDATION                         23              $952,500.00         23                   $0.00      0.00%           $513,750.00      53.94%    $438,750.00          46.06%
WHITNEY LEEMAN, Ph.D.                                        2             $155,000.00           2             $101,000.00     65.16%            $54,000.00      34.84%          $0.00           0.00%
RUSSELL BRIMER                                              32            $1,466,590.00         32             $425,850.00     29.04%         $1,040,740.00      70.96%          $0.00           0.00%

BRIMER v. BOELTER OPT-INS 2006                              102           $4,442,750.00        102           $1,345,000.00     30.27%         $3,097,750.00      69.73%             $0.00           0.00%

Subtotal                                                    195           $8,534,065.00        196           $1,881,850.00     22.05%         $5,731,359.00      67.16%    $920,856.00          10.79%

Joint - OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL; CENTER FOR
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH                                         2            $1,900,000.00         2              $100,000.00       5.26%        $1,299,100.00      68.37%    $500,900.00          26.36%
Joint - OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL; LOS ANGELES
DISTRICT ATTORNEY                                            1            $2,225,000.00         1            $1,000,000.00     44.94%          $725,000.00       32.58%    $500,000.00          22.47%
Joint - OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL; ALAMEDA AND
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT ATTORNEYS                               1              $954,000.00         1              $100,000.00     10.48%          $475,000.00       49.79%    $379,000.00          39.73%

Grand Total                                                 199          $13,613,065.00        200           $3,081,850.00     22.64%         $8,230,459.00      60.46%   $2,300,756.00         16.90%

                                                      Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation,
                                                      emission reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief is often complex, cannot be presented in
                                                      summary form, and requires reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess.
                                                      This report should not be used by itself to evaluate Proposition 65 settlements.




6/7/2007                                                                                                                                                                                              8:27 PM
                                                                      Proposition 65 Settlement Summary
                                                                                   2000-2006

                                                     No. of         Total         Injunctive           Civil        % of        Attorney        % of       Other          % of
                        Plaintiff                 Settlements   Settlements     Relief Included      Penalty        Total     Fees & Costs     Total                      Total
    AMERICAN ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY INST.                 8        $1,227,500.00          8                   $0.00     0.00%      $442,325.98    36.03%      $785,174.02   63.97%
    AS YOU SOW                                         57        $4,377,803.00         56            $267,103.00      6.10%    $1,720,008.11    39.29%    $2,390,712.66   54.61%
    CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY HEALTH ADVOCATES              23          $927,370.00         22             $20,750.00      2.24%      $381,023.65    41.09%      $525,596.68   56.68%
    CALIFORNIA SPORTFISHING PROTECTION ALLIANCE         1          $452,500.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%      $275,000.00    60.77%      $177,500.00   39.23%
    CALIFORNIA WOMEN'S LAW CENTER                       4           $49,225.00          4              $5,000.00     10.16%            $0.00     0.00%       $44,225.00   89.84%
    CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH                   107        $5,568,550.00        100            $282,200.00      5.07%    $4,028,539.45    72.34%    $1,259,310.55   22.61%
    COMMUNITIES FOR A BETTER ENVIRONMENT               26       $11,730,490.00         25          $1,005,000.00      8.57%   $10,243,990.00    87.33%      $481,500.00    4.10%
    CONSUMER ADVOCACY GROUP, INC                       93        $2,503,398.00         93            $138,250.00      5.52%    $1,434,574.00    57.31%     $948,574.00    37.89%
    CONSUMER CAUSE, INC                                62          $728,487.50         43             $22,000.00      3.02%      $327,813.50    45.00%     $378,674.00    51.98%
    CONSUMER DEFENSE GROUP                             50        $2,539,591.50         42                   $0.00     0.00%    $2,088,429.00    82.23%     $451,162.50    17.77%
    CONSUMER JUSTICE FOUNDATION                         1           $70,000.00          1             $35,000.00     50.00%       $35,000.00    50.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    ECOLOGICAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION                       38          $950,750.00         36              $4,500.00      0.47%      $492,500.00    51.80%     $403,250.00    42.41%
    EDWARD CROSS                                        1        $1,300,000.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%    $1,150,000.00    88.46%     $200,500.00    15.42%
    ENVIRONMENTAL LAW FOUNDATION                       18        $1,894,000.00         18                   $0.00     0.00%    $1,133,167.00    59.83%      $760,833.00   40.17%
    ENVIRONMENTAL WORLD WATCH                           3          $352,500.00          3                   $0.00     0.00%      $272,500.00    77.30%       $80,000.00   22.70%
    EUGENE DUFFY                                        1            $9,250.00          0                   $0.00     0.00%            $0.00     0.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    FACTS                                               1            $7,500.00          0                   $0.00     0.00%        $6,000.00    80.00%        $1,500.00   20.00%
    LYNN TODD EDGERTON                                  1          $900,000.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%      $650,000.00    72.22%      $250,000.00   27.78%
    GEORGE P. KONSTANTOUROS                             1           $25,000.00          0                   $0.00     0.00%            $0.00     0.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    MATEEL ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE                      217        $9,604,250.00        218            $248,000.00      2.58%    $5,667,000.00    59.01%    $4,405,750.00   45.87%
    MICHAEL DIPIRRO                                   211        $6,595,324.01        207          $1,649,502.00     25.01%    $4,807,132.01    72.89%     $138,500.00     2.10%
    NORTHERN CALIFORNIA RIVER WATCH                     1           $15,500.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%       $15,500.00   100.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    PHILIP K. STEINER                                   1            $9,825.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%        $9,825.00   100.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    TOXIC INJURIES CORPORATION                          1          $230,000.00          0                   $0.00     0.00%      $230,000.00   100.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    WORKING GROUP ON CISC                               1          $200,000.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%      $150,000.00    75.00%       $50,000.00   25.00%
    PAUL DOWHAL                                         1           $27,500.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%       $27,500.00   100.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    SANTA CLARA CTR. FOR OCC. HLTH & SAFETY             1          $175,000.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%      $100,000.00    57.14%       $75,000.00   42.86%
    THE MCKENZIE GROUP                                  1           $54,800.00          1                   $0.00     0.00%       $27,400.00    50.00%       $27,400.00   50.00%
    RUSSELL BRIMER                                     71        $2,059,448.99         39            $563,850.00     27.38%    $1,495,598.99    72.62%            $0.00    0.00%
    WHITNEY LEEMAN, Ph.D.                              33        $3,307,475.00         33            $901,000.00     27.24%    $2,356,475.00    71.25%       $50,000.00    1.51%
    MICHAEL L. HUDSPETH                                 1                 $0.00         1                   $0.00     0.00%            $0.00     0.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    STEVEN SWARTZBERG                                   1                 $0.00         1                   $0.00     0.00%            $0.00     0.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    BRIMER v. BOELTER OPT-INS                         205        $9,073,750.00        205          $2,812,000.00     30.99%    $6,261,750.00    69.01%            $0.00    0.00%
    SUBTOTAL                                         1242       $66,966,788.00       1164          $7,954,155.00     11.88%   $45,829,051.69    68.44%   $13,885,162.41   20.73%

    OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL                    33         $2,813,175.46        33           $1,451,031.48     51.58%      $771,824.84    27.44%     $589,689.12    20.96%
    ATTORNEY GENERAL / PERRY GOTTESFELD               22         $1,454,631.00        22            $713,611.50      49.06%      $741,019.50    50.94%           $0.00     0.00%
    ATTORNEY GENERAL / NRDC                            2          $945,000.00          2                   $0.00      0.00%     $945,000.00    100.00%           $0.00     0.00%
    ATTORNEY GENERAL / MATEEL                          1          $140,000.00          1                   $0.00      0.00%      $110,000.00    78.57%      $30,000.00    21.43%
    ATTORNEY GENERAL / CEH                             2         $1,900,000.00         2            $100,000.00       5.26%    $1,299,100.00    68.37%     $500,900.00    26.36%
    ATTORNEY GENERAL / LOS ANGELES DISTRICT
    ATTORNEY                                          1          $2,225,000.00        1            $1,000,000.00     44.94%     $725,000.00    32.58%      $500,000.00    22.47%
    ATTORNEY GENERAL / ALAMEDA DISTRICT
    ATTORNEY/LOS ANGELES DISTRICT ATTORNEY             1          $954,000.00          1            $100,000.00      10.48%     $475,000.00    49.79%      $379,000.00    39.73%
    SUBTOTAL                                          62        $10,431,806.46        62           $3,364,642.98     32.25%    $5,066,944.34   48.57%     $1,999,589.12   19.17%

    CITY OF SAN JOSE/PAUL DOWHAL                      2            $560,000.00        0                    $0.00      0.00%     $560,000.00    100.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    CITY & COUNTY OF S.F./ELF                         1          $2,750,000.00        1                    $0.00      0.00%    $1,123,068.26    40.84%    $1,626,931.74   59.16%
    ELF/S.F. CITY ATTORNEY                            1             $83,000.00        1               $15,667.00     18.88%       $67,333.00    81.12%            $0.00    0.00%
    SAN JOAQUIN DISTRICT ATTORNEY                     1               $283.50         1                    $0.00      0.00%         $283.50    100.00%            $0.00    0.00%
    SUBTOTAL                                          5          $3,393,000.00        1               $15,667.00      0.46%    $1,750,401.26    51.59%    $1,626,931.74   47.95%

    GRAND TOTAL                                      1309       $80,791,594.46       1227         $11,334,464.98     14.03%   $52,646,397.29    65.16%   $17,511,683.27   21.68%




6/7/2007                                                                                                                                                                     8:29 PM
                                                  Cumulative Proposition 65 Settlement Report 2006
Date Plaintiff              Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other         Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                            Costs           Distribution    Other Distribution


1/12/2006 Brimer, Russell   Casual Living, Inc.        Reformulation                     $64,000.00             $19,000.00                     $45,000.00           $0.00

1/12/2006 Brimer, Russell   Robinsons-May Stores;      Reformulation                     $106,700.00            $38,000.00                     $68,700.00           $0.00
                            Wells Mfg. USA Inc.

1/12/2006 Brimer, Russell   Signals; Universal Screen Reformulation                      $59,000.00             $17,500.00                     $41,500.00           $0.00
                            Arts, Inc.

2/2/2006 Brimer, Russell    Big A Drug Stores, Inc.;   Reformulation/warnings            $70,000.00             $10,000.00                     $60,000.00           $0.00
                            Drug Emporium, Inc.

2/2/2006 Brimer, Russell    Dave & Buster's, Inc.      Reformulation                     $72,000.00             $32,000.00                     $40,000.00           $0.00

2/8/2006 Brimer, Russell    Michael's Stores, Inc.;    Reformulation, warnings           $34,250.00               $8,000.00                    $26,250.00           $0.00
                            Westrim, Inc.

2/10/2006 Brimer, Russell   Starbucks Corporation      Reformulation                     $43,000.00             $10,000.00                     $33,000.00           $0.00

3/31/2006 Brimer, Russell   Sunbelt Marketing Group,   Reformulation or warnings         $28,000.00               $4,000.00                    $24,000.00           $0.00
                            Inc.

5/1/2006 Brimer, Russell    Lillian Vernon             Reformulation                     $64,000.00             $19,000.00                     $45,000.00           $0.00




                                 Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                 reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                 reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                 Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                          Page 1 of 20
Date Plaintiff               Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other         Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                             Costs           Distribution    Other Distribution


 5/1/2006 Brimer, Russell    Red Envelope               Reformulation                     $49,000.00             $15,500.00                     $33,500.00           $0.00

 5/1/2006 Brimer, Russell    McIlhenny Company          Reformulation                     $52,750.00             $25,000.00                     $27,750.00           $0.00

 5/2/2006 Brimer, Russell    Memory Company, LLC        Reformulation                     $10,690.00             $10,000.00                       $690.00            $0.00

 5/9/2006 Brimer, Russell    Faygo Beverages, Inc.      Summons quashed                      $0.00                     $0.00                         $0.00           $0.00

5/22/2006 Brimer, Russell    Club One, Inc., et al      Dimissed w/o prejudice               $0.00                     $0.00                         $0.00           $0.00

9/14/2006 Brimer, Russell    Moylan's Brewing           Reformulation or warnings          $8,500.00               $1,000.00                     $7,500.00           $0.00
                             Company

10/6/2006 Brimer, Russell    Anthropologie, Inc.;       Reformulation/warnings            $98,000.00             $10,000.00                     $88,000.00           $0.00
                             Urban Outfitters, Inc.

10/12/2006 Brimer, Russell   Heavenly Sports;           Reformulation/warnings            $24,000.00               $4,000.00                    $20,000.00           $0.00
                             Specialty Sports
                             Ventures, LLC

10/19/2006 Brimer, Russell   Gift Link, Inc.; Popular   Reformulation/warnings            $44,500.00             $16,000.00                     $28,500.00           $0.00
                             Creations; Popular
                             Imports, Inc.




                                  Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                  reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                  reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                  Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                          Page 2 of 20
Date Plaintiff               Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other         Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                             Costs           Distribution    Other Distribution


10/26/2006 Brimer, Russell   Crazy Mountain Imports;   Reformulation/warnings             $42,000.00             $16,000.00                     $26,000.00           $0.00
                             Creative Merchandising
                             Ideas

10/27/2006 Brimer, Russell   Catstudio                 Reformulation or warnings          $17,500.00               $1,500.00                    $16,000.00           $0.00

11/15/2006 Brimer, Russell   Blue Sky Brands, Inc.;    Reformulation/warnings             $53,500.00             $20,000.00                     $33,500.00           $0.00
                             Bits and Pieces, Inc.

11/16/2006 Brimer, Russell   Four Star International   Reformulation/warnings             $45,000.00               $6,250.00                    $38,750.00           $0.00
                             Trading Co.; Jo-Ann
                             Stores

11/16/2006 Brimer, Russell   Home Decorators           Reformulation/warnings             $51,500.00             $20,000.00                     $31,500.00           $0.00
                             Collection, Inc.

12/5/2006 Brimer, Russell    Beverages & More, Inc.    Reformulation/warnings             $105,000.00            $40,000.00                     $65,000.00           $0.00

12/8/2006 Brimer, Russell    Votivo, Ltd.              Reformulation/warnings             $100,000.00            $60,000.00                     $40,000.00           $0.00

12/11/2006 Brimer, Russell   Intel Corporation         Reformulation or warnings          $60,000.00                   $0.00                    $60,000.00           $0.00

12/13/2006 Brimer, Russell   McCaulou's Department     Reformulation/warnings             $64,200.00             $14,500.00                     $49,700.00           $0.00
                             Store

12/15/2006 Brimer, Russell   Austram, Inc.             Reformulation/warnings             $22,000.00               $3,000.00                    $19,000.00           $0.00




                                  Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                  reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                  reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                  Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                          Page 3 of 20
Date Plaintiff                Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other          Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                              Costs           Distribution     Other Distribution


12/18/2006 Brimer, Russell    Overstock.com, Inc.        Reformulation/warnings            $29,500.00               $2,500.00                    $27,000.00           $0.00

12/19/2006 Brimer, Russell    International Wholesale    Reformulation/warnings            $20,000.00               $1,000.00                    $19,000.00           $0.00
                              Supply, Inc.

12/20/2006 Brimer, Russell    Hyler Enterprises, Inc.;   Reformulation/warnings            $10,000.00                $500.00                      $9,500.00           $0.00
                              The Wharf's General
                              Stores

12/21/2006 Brimer, Russell    Uncommon Goods, LLC        Reformulation/warnings            $18,000.00               $1,600.00                    $16,400.00           $0.00

12/31/2006 Brimer, Russell    Boelter Opt-Ins            Reformulation/warnings           $4,442,750.00          1,345,000.00                  3,097,750.00           $0.00

Brimer, Russell              Totals                                       33              $5,909,340.00         $1,770,850.00                 $4,138,490.00            $0.00




                                   Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                   reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                   reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                   Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                           Page 4 of 20
Date Plaintiff                   Defendant                     Injunctive Relief        Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


 8/9/2006	 California Sportfishing Meridian Gold Company   Mitigation                        $452,500.00                  $0.00                  $275,000.00       $177,500.00   Rose Foundation(75%);
           Protection Alliance                                                                                                                                                   CSPA (25%)

California Sportfishing        Totals                                        1               $452,500.00                  $0.00                   $275,000.00      $177,500.00
Protection Alliance




                                     Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                     reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                     reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                     Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                              Page 5 of 20
Date Plaintiff                  Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


4/11/2006 California Women's    Maximum Living, Inc.      Enhanced warning labels             $6,200.00               $5,000.00                         $0.00        $1,200.00   To California Women's Law
          Law Center                                                                                                                                                             Center

4/11/2006 California Women's    Madison Pharmacy;         Enhanced warning labels             $6,040.00                   $0.00                         $0.00        $6,040.00   To California Women's Law
          Law Center            Women's Health America                                                                                                                           Center

5/8/2006 California Women's     Matol Botanical           Enhanced warning labels            $33,345.00                   $0.00                         $0.00       $33,345.00   To California Women's Law
         Law Center             International, Ltd.                                                                                                                              Center

5/31/2006 California Women's    Vitamin Shoppe            Enhanced warning labels             $3,640.00                   $0.00                         $0.00        $3,640.00   To California Women's Law
          Law Center            Industries, Inc.                                                                                                                                 Center

California Women's Law         Totals                                        4                $49,225.00              $5,000.00                         $0.00       $44,225.00
Center




                                     Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                     reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                     reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                     Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 6 of 20
Date Plaintiff                   Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                 Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


2/15/2006 Center For             Jaclyn, Inc.               Cease sales in Calfiornia         $18,000.00                   $0.00                    $10,000.00        $8,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                    educational programs

2/15/2006 Center For             Betesh Holding Group       Cease sales in Calfiornia         $18,000.00                   $0.00                    $10,000.00        $8,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health   Corporation                                                                                                                                      educational programs

2/15/2006 Center For             InGear Corporation         Reformulation/warnings            $50,000.00                   $0.00                    $40,000.00       $10,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                    educational programs

4/20/2006 Center For             Wal-Mart, Inc.             Reformulation/warnings            $25,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,953.00        $4,047.00   $3,058 to CEH; $989 to
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                    AYS

5/8/2006 Center For              Gerson Company             Reformulation                     $30,000.00               $1,000.00                    $19,500.00        $9,500.00   To CEH for continuing
         Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                     educational programs

6/6/2006 Center For              Horizon Group USA, Inc.;   Reformulation/warnings            $30,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $10,000.00   To CEH for continuing
         Environmental Health    Michaels Stores, Inc.                                                                                                                            educational programs

8/11/2006 Center For             Fashion Accessory          Reformulation and                 $45,000.00                   $0.00                    $30,000.00       $15,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health   Bazaar                     continued testing                                                                                                     educational programs

8/11/2006 Center For             Lisa Frank, Inc.           Reformulation and testing         $45,000.00                   $0.00                    $30,000.00       $15,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                    educational programs

8/30/2006 Center For             Silver Goose, Inc.         Reformulation and                 $15,000.00                   $0.00                    $10,000.00        $5,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                              continued testing                                                                                                     educational programs




                                      Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                      reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                      reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                      Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 7 of 20
Date Plaintiff                    Defendant                      Injunctive Relief        Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                  Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


9/13/2006 Center For              Nadri, Inc.                 Reformulation/warnings           $30,000.00               $1,000.00                   $19,333.00         $9,667.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                     educational programs

9/13/2006 Center For              Cornerstone Apparel, Inc.   Reformulation/warnings           $49,500.00               $1,000.00                    $32,333.00       $16,167.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                     educational programs

9/21/2006 Center For              Fast Forward, LLC           Reformulation and testing        $55,000.00                   $0.00                    $35,000.00       $20,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                     educational programs

9/21/2006 Center For              Accessory Network           Reformulation and testing        $51,000.00                   $0.00                    $35,000.00       $16,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health    Group, Inc.                                                                                                                                      educational programs

9/21/2006 Center For              Big Dogs USA, Inc.          Reformulation and testing        $24,000.00                   $0.00                    $18,000.00        $6,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                     educational programs

10/10/2006 Center For             BodyBuilding.com            Warning                          $22,500.00                   $0.00                    $17,000.00        $5,500.00   To CEH for continuing
           Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                    educational programs

11/21/2006 Center For             Beads By The Dozen,         Reformulation/warnings           $25,000.00                   $0.00                    $18,000.00        $7,000.00   To CEH for continuing
           Environmental Health   Inc.; Sherman Specialty,                                                                                                                         educational programs
                                  Inc.

11/21/2006 Center For             Candela Sales Company       Reformulation/warnings            $7,500.00                   $0.00                     $5,000.00        $2,500.00   To CEH for continuing
           Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                    educational programs

11/22/2006 Center For             Hennes & Mauritz, LP        Reformulation and                $45,000.00               $1,000.00                    $29,500.00       $14,500.00   To CEH for continuing
           Environmental Health                               continued testing                                                                                                    educational programs




                                       Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                       reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                       reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                       Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 8 of 20
Date Plaintiff                     Defendant                    Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                  Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


11/22/2006 Center For              U&I Import               Reformulation and                  $32,500.00               $1,000.00                    $21,000.00       $10,500.00   To CEH for continuing
           Environmental Health                             continued testing                                                                                                      educational programs

12/5/2006 Center For               Baby Center, LLC         Reformulation and                  $12,500.00                   $0.00                     $8,500.00        $4,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                              continued testing                                                                                                      educational programs

12/5/2006 Center For               Baby Universe, Inc.      Stop purchasing from               $13,500.00                   $0.00                    $10,000.00        $3,500.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health                              supplier and testing                                                                                                   educational programs

12/8/2006 Center For               Romar International      Reformulation and testing          $40,000.00                   $0.00                    $30,000.00       $10,000.00   To CEH for continuing
          Environmental Health     Corporation                                                                                                                                     educational programs

Center For Environmental          Totals                                        22             $684,000.00              $5,000.00                   $469,119.00      $209,881.00
Health




                                       Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                       reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                       reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                       Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 9 of 20
Date Plaintiff                   Defendant                    Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other          Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                Costs           Distribution     Other Distribution


12/15/2006 Communities For A     DYN Maverick, Inc. dba   Elimination of                      $5,000.00                   $0.00                     $5,000.00           $0.00
           Better Environment    Cameo Cleaners           perchloroethylene

Communities For A Better        Totals                                        1                 $5,000.00                 $0.00                     $5,000.00            $0.00
Environment




                                     Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                     reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                     reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                     Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                          Page 10 of 20
Date Plaintiff                  Defendant                    Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                               Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


1/30/2006 Ecological Rights     Provo Craft & Novelty    Reformulation, warnings,           $32,500.00                   $0.00                    $17,000.00       $15,500.00   To Ecological Rights
          Foundation                                     removal from display                                                                                                   Foundation

10/20/2006 Ecological Rights    Kmart; Martha Stewart    Reformulation                      $58,000.00                   $0.00                    $23,000.00       $35,000.00   $17,500 each to ERF and
           Foundation                                                                                                                                                           CEH

Ecological Rights Foundation   Totals                                       2                $90,500.00                  $0.00                    $40,000.00       $50,500.00




                                    Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                    reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                    reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                    Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 11 of 20
Date Plaintiff                 Defendant                      Injunctive Relief       Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other          Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                              Costs           Distribution     Other Distribution


9/22/2006 Environmental Law    Trader Joe's;Mrs.           Warnings                        $150,000.00                  $0.00                  $150,000.00            $0.00

          Foundation           Gooch's; Stater 

                               Bros.;Whole Foods

                               Market of CA


9/22/2006 Environmental Law    Sur La Table, Inc.          Warnings                        $25,000.00                   $0.00                    $25,000.00           $0.00
          Foundation

9/22/2006 Environmental Law    Albeco, Inc.; Dehoff        Warnings                           $0.00                     $0.00                         $0.00           $0.00

          Foundation           Enterprises


9/22/2006 Environmental Law    Draeger's Super Markets     Warnings                        $15,000.00                   $0.00                    $15,000.00           $0.00
          Foundation

9/22/2006 Environmental Law    Berberian Enterprises;      Warnings                         $6,000.00                   $0.00                     $6,000.00           $0.00

          Foundation           Bristol Farms


9/22/2006 Environmental Law    Andronico's Markets, Inc.   Warnings                        $40,000.00                   $0.00                    $40,000.00           $0.00
          Foundation

Environmental Law             Totals                                       6               $236,000.00                  $0.00                   $236,000.00            $0.00
Foundation




                                   Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                   reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                   reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                   Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                          Page 12 of 20
Date Plaintiff                     Defendant                     Injunctive Relief        Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                  Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


4/20/2006 Joint - Office of the    Wal-Mart                   Reformulation                    $25,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,953.00        $4,047.00   To CEH ($3,058) and AYS
          Attorney General and                                                                                                                                                     ($989)
          Center for
          Environmental Health

6/15/2006 Joint - Office of the    Burlington Coat Factory,   Reformulation                   $1,875,000.00          $100,000.00                   1,278,147.00      $496,853.00   To CEH ($186,511)and
          Attorney General and     et al                                                                                                                                           AYS ($60,342) to continue
          Center for                                                                                                                                                               their efforts and $250,000
          Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                     for testing program

Joint - Office of the Attorney    Totals                                       2              $1,900,000.00           $100,000.00                 $1,299,100.00      $500,900.00
General and Center for
Environmental Health




                                       Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                       reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                       reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                       Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 13 of 20
Date Plaintiff                     Defendant                       Injunctive Relief      Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                  Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


 8/3/2006 Joint - Office of the    Alpro Alimentos              Reformulation                  $954,000.00           $100,000.00                   $475,000.00       $379,000.00   To Public Health Trust for
          Attorney General;        Proteinicos, S.A. de C.V.,                                                                                                                      Granting
          Disrtict Attorneys of    et al
          Alameda and Los
          Angeles

Joint - Office of the Attorney    Totals                                        1              $954,000.00            $100,000.00                   $475,000.00      $379,000.00
General; Disrtict Attorneys of
Alameda and Los Angeles




                                       Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                       reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                       reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                       Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 14 of 20
Date Plaintiff                    Defendant                   Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


7/18/2006 Joint - Office of the Pepsi, Inc.               Reformulation                     $2,225,000.00          1,000,000.00                  $725,000.00       $500,000.00   To CA Public Health Trust
          Attorney General; Los                                                                                                                                                  Institute, Physicians for
          Angeles City Attorney                                                                                                                                                  Social Responsibility,
                                                                                                                                                                                 Pacoima Beautiful for lead
                                                                                                                                                                                 outreach

Joint - Office of the Attorney   Totals                                      1              $2,225,000.00         $1,000,000.00                   $725,000.00      $500,000.00
General; Los Angeles City
Attorney




                                     Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                     reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                     reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                     Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 15 of 20
Date Plaintiff                    Defendant                    Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other          Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                 Costs           Distribution     Other Distribution


9/28/2006 Leeman, Whitney R.,     Anaheim Patio &           Reformulation/warnings            $10,000.00               $1,000.00                     $9,000.00           $0.00
          Ph.D.                   Fireside, Inc.; Inmar
                                  Indutries, Inc.; Onward
                                  Manufacturing Co.

10/19/2006 Leeman, Whitney R.,    Monogram International,   Reformulation/warnings            $145,000.00           $100,000.00                     $45,000.00           $0.00
           Ph.D.                  et al

Leeman, Whitney R., Ph.D.        Totals                                       2               $155,000.00            $101,000.00                    $54,000.00            $0.00




                                      Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                      reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                      reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                      Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                          Page 16 of 20
Date Plaintiff                   Defendant                     Injunctive Relief        Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


1/25/2006 Mateel Environmental Helly Hansen US, Inc.        Reformulation                    $35,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $15,000.00   To ERF (50%);CATs (50%)
          Justice Foundation

2/17/2006 Mateel Environmental Midwest Air                  Reformulation/warnings           $30,000.00                   $0.00                    $15,000.00       $15,000.00   To Ca nonprofits for toxic
          Justice Foundation   Technologies, Inc.                                                                                                                                awareness work

3/28/2006 Mateel Environmental East West Distributing Co. Reformulation/warnings             $25,000.00                   $0.00                    $15,000.00       $10,000.00   To CATs and Center on
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                     Race and Pverty

3/28/2006 Mateel Environmental East West Distributing Co. Reformulation                      $20,000.00                   $0.00                    $10,000.00       $10,000.00   To Ecological Rights
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                     Foundation

3/28/2006 Mateel Environmental Winner International, Inc.   Reformulation                    $42,500.00                   $0.00                    $25,000.00       $17,500.00   To ERF (75%);CATs (25%)
          Justice Foundation

3/28/2006 Mateel Environmental Radio Flyer, Inc.            Reformulation; product           $210,000.00                  $0.00                  $100,000.00       $110,000.00   $100,000 to CA nonprofits;
          Justice Foundation                                replacement                                                                                                          $10,000 to advertise
                                                                                                                                                                                 replacement program

5/3/2006 Mateel Environmental Pacific Trail, Inc.; London   Reformulation                    $55,000.00                   $0.00                    $40,000.00       $15,000.00   To ERF (50%);CATs (50%)
         Justice Foundation   Fog Industries, Inc.

6/9/2006 Mateel Environmental Fibrecraft Materials Corp.    Reformulation                    $35,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $15,000.00   To ERF (50%);CATs (50%)
         Justice Foundation

6/9/2006 Mateel Environmental Vanco International, Inc.     Reformulation/warnings           $35,000.00                   $0.00                    $17,500.00       $17,500.00   To ERF(50%);EPIC (50%)
         Justice Foundation




                                     Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                     reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                     reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                     Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                               Page 17 of 20
Date Plaintiff                  Defendant                    Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                               Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


6/16/2006 Mateel Environmental E. Mishan & Sons, Inc.    Reformulation, warnings            $40,000.00                   $0.00                   $22,500.00        $17,500.00   To Ca nonprofits for toxic
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                    awareness work

6/27/2006 Mateel Environmental Alert Stamping            Reformulation, warnings            $40,000.00                   $0.00                   $20,000.00        $20,000.00   To CA nonprofits for toxic
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                    awareness work

6/28/2006 Mateel Environmental Innovage, Inc.            Reformulation                      $35,000.00                   $0.00                   $17,500.00        $17,500.00   To CA nonprofits for toxic
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                    awareness work

7/12/2006 Mateel Environmental Guy Cotton, Inc.          Reformulation, warnings            $25,000.00                   $0.00                    $15,000.00       $10,000.00   To ERF (50%);CATs (50%)
          Justice Foundation

7/18/2006 Mateel Environmental Campbell Hausfield        Reformulation                      $30,000.00                   $0.00                    $15,000.00       $15,000.00   To Ca nonprofits for toxic
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                    awareness work

7/21/2006 Mateel Environmental Darice, Inc.              Reformulation                      $30,000.00                   $0.00                    $17,500.00       $12,500.00   To ERF; Golden Gate Env.
          Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                    Law Clinic

8/11/2006 Mateel Environmental Fluke Electronics         Reformulation/warnings             $35,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $15,000.00   To California non-profits
          Justice Foundation   Corporation

9/1/2006 Mateel Environmental Interdynamics, Inc.        Reformulation/warnings             $35,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $15,000.00   To California non-profits
         Justice Foundation

9/1/2006 Mateel Environmental Nyko Technologies, Inc.    Reformulation/warnings             $37,500.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $17,500.00   To California non-profits
         Justice Foundation




                                    Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                    reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                    reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                    Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                                Page 18 of 20
Date Plaintiff                    Defendant                     Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other            Explanantion of
                                                                                                                                                  Costs           Distribution       Other Distribution


 9/1/2006	 Mateel Environmental ATD Tools, Inc.             Reformulation/warnings             $45,000.00                   $0.00                    $25,000.00       $20,000.00	   To Ecological Rights 

           Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                       Foundation


 9/1/2006	 Mateel Environmental Metra Electronics           Reformulation/warnings             $37,500.00                   $0.00                    $18,750.00       $18,750.00    To California non-profits

           Justice Foundation   Corporation


10/24/2006 Mateel Environmental Lowe's HIW, Inc.            Reformulation/warnings             $35,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $15,000.00	   $7,500 each to CATs and
           Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                       ERF

11/28/2006 Mateel Environmental Restoration Hardware        Reformulation/warnings             $40,000.00                   $0.00                    $20,000.00       $20,000.00	   $10,000 each to CATs and
           Justice Foundation                                                                                                                                                       ERF

12/14/2006 Mateel Environmental Fry's Electronics, Inc.                                           $0.00                     $0.00                         $0.00            $0.00	   Dismissed without prejudice
           Justice Foundation

Mateel Environmental Justice    Totals 	                                     23                $952,500.00                  $0.00                   $513,750.00      $438,750.00
Foundation




                                       Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                                       reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                                       reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                                       Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                                 Page 19 of 20
Date Plaintiff   Defendant                   Injunctive Relief         Total Settlement        Civil Penalty               Attorney Fees          Other           Explanantion of
                                                                                                                               Costs           Distribution      Other Distribution


                             98                                          $13,613,065.00          $3,081,850.00                 $8,230,459.00     $2,300,756.00
  Grand Total




                    Settlements generally include injunctive relief benefitting the public, such as product reformulation, emission
                    reduction, or warnings. This injunctive relief often is complex, cannot be presented in a summary form, and requires
                    reference to actual settlement documents to accurately assess. This report should not be used by itself to evaluate
                    Proposition 65 settlements.                                                                                                                           Page 20 of 20

				
DOCUMENT INFO