Study Period Report on Registration Procedure

Document Sample
Study Period Report on Registration Procedure Powered By Docstoc
					                        SC32WG2 N1070




 Study Period Report
           on
Registration Procedure

SC32WG2 Interim Meeting, Seoul
           071205
         H. Horiuchi
              Current status of the ISO/IEC19763

                                                                                 As of Nov., 2007
     Information Technology – Framework for metamodel interoperability (MFI )-
 •        Part 1: Reference model                                 published
 •        Part 2: Core metamodel                                2nd FCD
 •        Part3: Metamodel for ontology registration             Published
 •        Part4: Metamodel for model mapping                    2nd CD

                             New Parts:
•Part-3 2nd Ed: + Ontology evolution & maintenance                               Preparing WD
•Part-5: Process registration                                                    Preparing WD
•Part 6: Registration Procedure                                                  Study period




 2007/12/07                        The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization                  2
        The goals of the study
• The final goal is preparing a draft WD on
  “Registration Procedure ” to the coming
  Australia Meeting (May, 2008)
• Investigate and Stock take requirements on
  the Registrations as widely as possible.
• Implement and check the procedure
• Propose a common procedure consolidating
  both procedures of MDR + MFI
                    The Registrations
                    Regulation & Standards
        Authority
                                              Registry
                                          Evidence                           It should be
                                          of Approval                        official, reliable
                                                                             and
                                                                             sustainable.
Request             Approval
for
Approval




                                        Public Area
   2007/12/07                                                                                4
                               The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization
Current status of the study project
• Preparing an actual implementation of the
  standards (MFI + MDR+ Core Component)
• The project should be useful for developing a
  new part (Registration Procedure)of MFI
• Especially, the MFI project in Japan is keeping
  contacts and collaborations with PLIB (ISO
  TC184/SC4, IEC SC3D) and JACIC (Japan
  Association for Construction Information
  Center)
     Subject matters of the Part-6
                                                                                         Name
                                         Registration                                      Name
                                                                                         Space
       JTC1                                                          OID Publisher           Name
                                          Authority                                        Space
                                                                                             Space

    SO
     SO                                                                                IRDI
      SO                                   Harmonizer



   USER                     Registered                  Registered
    USER                                                                             Registrar
      USER                    Model                      Objects


Data & Registry
                                   Administered Item                        Data & Registry
Quality Criteria
                                                                            Quality Guidelines
                                                                            Data Formulation
                                                                            Rules (11179-4)
              Maintenance          MFI/MDR Registry
                                                                             Other Dictionary
                                                                                     Termnet
             Current 11179-6
• No specific guideline or criteria for registry
• IRDI acceptance
• No active protocols for change and
  maintenance, including notification of chnage
  on contents
                    Cross Domain ROR (A Proposal to METI )
                                                                                  MFI Registry
      OID                                        Registration Authority
                                                           RA
      UUID                Model Mapping                                            Domain
                          Service                                                  Model

                                                                                   Data Elements
                          Ontology Search                            ROR            基本情報要素


                          Service                                                  Value Domain


                                                                                Basic
                                                                                Ontology
             UID        Domain                                    Domain
                                                     UID
                        Ontology                                  Ontology



                                                                                TerminologyTerminology
             RA                                      RA

                   Terminology                             Terminology         Registration
                                                                               Procedure
         Industrial domain                      Industrial domain              Registration
     Domain A                                   Domain B                       Quality
                                                                                                         8
2007/12/07                       The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization
 Expected Evolution & Study Targets
                                                                  ISO Directive
                                                                  JTC1 Directive
                  MDR+MFI                                          IEC Common
                                                                     Database
                  Registration &                                       Procedure
                  Maintenance                                      ISO 29002
                                                                   ISO 8000
                  Procedure                                        ISO 13584


                                                                   ISO 9000
   Registration
                   ISO/IEC 11179-4;                                ISO 15000
   Procedure                                                       (ebXML RS)
                     Formulation of data
ISO/IEC19763-6
ISO/IEC11179-6

2007/12/07          The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization                    9
                 Approach
                     IEC Common
                       Database          IEC SC3D
                         Procedure
                     ISO 29002          TC184/SC4
MDR+MFI              ISO 8000
Registration &       ISO 13584-XXX

Maintenance
                        UN/CFACT        UN/CEFAC
Procedure                                T TMG
                          CCTS
                          UCM


                          JACIC            TC211
                      (Construction )
                  Expected Evolution of
                      MDR & MFI
                                   Common
                                                                “Common Facility” for
                                 Administration
                                  Information                   both MDR & MFI

Metadata                                                              Model Registration
Registration
               ISO/IEC11179 Edition 3
                                                            ISO/IEC19763
        ISO/IEC11179 Edition 2
                                                                        MOF (ISO/IEC19502)

 ISO/IEC11179 Edition 1                                                         MOF (OMG)

Data Elements                                             IRDS (ISO/IEC 10728)
       SC14
  2007/12/07                      The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization               11
Common facility of                      ISO/IEC19763-3
MDR(ISO/IEC11179 ED3)          MOF       Metamodel for ontology registration
                                        MFI-2
                                MFI Core
            MDR standards       model
                                           MFI-3
                                                         ODM

 Metamodel for                    Metamodel
                                                        Metamodel for
 MDR(ISO/IEC11179)               for Ontology           Metamodel for DL
                                 Registration              Metamodel for OWL

                specify   Administrative Information                 Describe
                                        Registration
       MDR                            MFI Register           Ontology Repository
Administered Item
Data Elements
Basic Classes
Basic Relationship
                               Ontology                   Ontology by ODM
                               components
                                                                                12
             ISO 29002 (TC184SC4)
                                 ISO 29002
         Exchange of Product and Service Characteristic Data (EPSCD)



                                ISO 29002-10                    ISO 29002-20
  ISO 29002-5                       Product                   Concept dictionary
Identifier format              characterization               resolution services
                                 (cataloguing)                     (CDRS)

           constrain                              schema subset
 ISO 22745-13
                               ISO 22745-40                        ISO 22745-14
Identification of
                                Master data                       Dictionary query
  concepts and
                               representation                         interface
   terminology
      Current Par-6 of 11179
                                                                   Registrar/                               Registry
        Submitter                     Steward                       Control
                                                                   Committee


                                                                      Confirms                                   Preferred
                                                                   concurrence as
                                                                 Preferred Standard
                                                                                                                 Standard


                                    Proposes item                 Acknowledges                         Provisionally
                                for Preferred Standard         status & submits for                    Preferred
                                        status                        review                           Standard


                                                                     Confirms
                                                                    concurrence                                   Standard
                                                                    as Standard


                                    Proposes item                 Acknowledges
                                     for Standard              status & submits for                    Provisionally
                                        status                        review                           Standard


                                                                Confirms/resolves                                 Qualified
                                                                  quality of item
                                   Checks quality
                                  of item & reviews            registration proposal
                                         data                                                          Provisionally
                                                                                                       Qualified
                                                                Confirms/resolves
                                                                 completeness of                                 Recorded
                                                               registration proposal
                                                                                                       Request
                                                                                                       Recorded

                                    Checks item
        Submits                      & reviews
       to registry                      data                                                                     Candidate
                                                                                                       Request
                                                                                                       Candidate

                                                                                                                Incomplete
       Identifies &
       documents
          item
                                                                                                                       Registration
                                                                       Identifies path of lead responsibility
                                                                                                                          Status
*Note: Timing of registration status progression is entirely dependent upon the submitter/steward/registrar.           Progression
Core Component Harmonization
Expected Major contents of Part-6
• Concept of operation
• Registries of Administered Items
• Functional operating procedures – Roles and
  Responsibilities; RA,RO,SO,
• Harmonization Process
• IRDI: International Registration Data Identifier
• Registry Quality
• Conformance
                  Schedule
•   The Final report   :   May 2008
•   Draft procedure    :   May 2008
•   Candidate of WD    :   May 2008
•   Proof of Concept   :   Dec., 2008
•   CD