American Society for Engineering Education Benchmarking: How do we compare?
Dr. Neal Gallagher Dean
UCF ORBIT Executive Briefing November 16, 2004 Orlando, FL
Popular ranking sources
American Society for Engineering Education (ASEE)
http://www.asee.org/colleges/
National Research Council (NRC)
http://www.nap.edu/
US News & World Report
http://www.usnews.com/usnews/edu/eduhome.htm
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
2
1
2003 ASEE Profile
358 participating engineering colleges 125 participating computer science within engineering colleges Collection period
Degrees: AY 2002-2003 Student and faculty profile: Fall 2003 Research Expenditures: FY ending in 2003
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
3
ASEE “Rankings”: Students
358 Engineering Colleges
No. 27 or in top 8% of engineering bachelor's degrees awarded No. 29 or in top 8% of engineering bachelor's degrees awarded to women No. 10 or in top 3% of engineering bachelor's degrees awarded to Hispanics No. 40 or in top 11% of civil engineering bachelor's degrees awarded No. 14 or in top 4% of computer engineering bachelor's degrees awarded No. 33 or in top 9% of electrical engineering bachelor's degrees awarded No. 44 or in top 12% of engineering master's degrees awarded No. 48 or in top 13% of engineering doctoral degrees awarded No. 44 or in top 12% of doctoral degrees awarded to foreign nationals No. 20 or in top 6% of engineering undergraduate enrollment No. 31 or in top 9% of engineering graduate enrollment
125 Engineering Colleges with Computer Science inside engineering
No. 7 or in top 6% of computer science bachelor's degrees awarded
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
4
2
ASEE “Rankings”: Faculty
358 Engineering Colleges
No. 40 or in top 11% of the number of teaching faculty members (150)
Teaching Tenure & Tenure Track faculty, Non-Tenure Track Personnel, Full-time equivalent of all part-time personnel)
The number of women faculty in the College of Engineering & Computer Science (11.3% or 15/133 tenure/tenure-track) exceeds the ASEE average (9.9%). No. 15 or in top 4% in the number of African-American Tenured/Tenure-Track Teaching Faculty Members (6) No. 15 or in top 4% in the number of Hispanic Tenured/Tenure-Track Teaching Faculty Members (6) No. 13 or in top 4% in the number of Asian Tenured/Tenure-Track Teaching Faculty Members (48)
No. 33 or in top 9% of engineering research expenditures ($44.6 m)
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
5
2003 ASEE Degrees Profile
Bachelor’s degrees up 5.4% (67,301/70,949)
Computer Science up 8.2% (7,690/8,312) Engineering up 5.1% (59,611/62,637)
Master’s degrees up 12.1% (31,346/35,139)
Computer Science up 34% (3,718/4,997) Engineering up 9.1% (27,628/30,142)
PhD degrees up 1.2% (5,802/5,870)
Computer Science virtually unchanged (385) Engineering virtually unchanged (5,485)
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
6
3
CECS Degree Profile & ASEE*
Bachelor’s Degrees Degree Production UCF Nation* 2003 559 70,949 2002 491 67,301 2001 459 65,113 % Diff. 2002-2003 13.85% 5.4%
Master’s Degrees Degree Production UCF Nation* 2003 231 35,139 2002 208 31,346 2001 229 30,913
% Diff. 2002-2003 11.1% 12.1%
Doctoral Degrees Degree Production UCF Nation* 2003 36 5,870 2002 41 5,802 2001 46 6,085
% Diff. 2002-2003 -13.8% 1.2%
*ASEE Profile participating institutions: 2003 = 358, 2002 = 320, 2001 = 353 . UCF numbers exclude engineering technology degrees but include engineering, computer science, and information technology.
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
7
2003 ASEE Enrollment Profile
Full-time undergraduates up 1.7% (367,684/373,957) Master’s enrollment (FT & PT) up < 1% (90,665/91,551) Doctoral enrollment (FT & PT) up10.2% (47,618/52,493)
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
8
4
CECS Enrollment Profile & ASEE*
Undergraduate (FT) Enrollment UCF Nation* 2003 3,192 373,957 2002 3,046 367,684 Master’s (FT/PT) Enrollment UCF Nation* 2003 698 91,551 2002 735 90,665 Doctoral (FT/PT) Enrollment UCF Nation* 2003 462 52,493 2002 367 47,618 2001 287 41,513 25.9% 10.2% 2001 691 79,324 -5.3% <1% % Diff. 2002-2003 2001 2,795 354,811 4.8% 1.7% % Diff. 2002-2003 % Diff. 2002-2003
*ASEE Profile participating institutions: 2003 = 358, 2002 = 320, 2001 = 353
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
9
CECS Women Profile & 2003 ASEE*
No. 29 or in top 8% of engineering bachelor's degrees awarded to women Degrees Awarded to Women
Student Diversity UCF Nation* Bachelor’s Women % # 20 111 20 14,481 Master’s Women % 23 22 # 55 7,846 Doctoral Women % 17 17 # 6 1,018
* ASEE 2003 Profile includes 358 participating institutions. UCF Degree Totals: Bachelors = 559, Master’s = 236, PhD = 36 Nation Degree Totals: Bachelors = 70,949, Master’s = 35,139, PhD = 5,870
Note: ASEE does not collect enrollment data by gender or ethnicity. Enrollment data collected by full-time and part-time.
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
10
5
CECS Underrepresented Minority Profile & 2003 ASEE*
No. 10 or in top 3% of engineering bachelor's degrees awarded to Hispanics Degrees Awarded to Underrepresented Minorities Student Diversity Bachelor’s Minority Master’s Minority Doctoral Minority % UCF Nation* 18.6% 11.5% # 104 8,154 % 11.4% 5.3% # 27 1,872 % 2.8% 3.4% # 1 202
* ASEE 2003 Profile includes 358 participating institutions. UCF Degree Totals: Bachelors = 559, Master’s = 236, PhD = 36 Nation Degree Totals: Bachelors = 70,949, Master’s = 35,139, PhD = 5,870 Underrepresented Minority = African American, Hispanic, American Indian
Note: ASEE does not collect enrollment data by gender or ethnicity. Enrollment data collected by full-time and part-time.
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
11
Engineering Technology
Methodology 85 participating engineering technology institutions offering BS degrees Collection period Degrees: AY 2002-2003 Student and faculty profile: Fall 2003 Trends Strongly industry oriented by design Attractive career opportunities: women & underrepresented minorities Engineering Technology BS degrees awarded vs. Engineering Women ENT =11.7%, ENG=20.4% Asian Americans ENT =6.1%, ENG =14% Hispanics ENT = 6.2%, ENG = 5.4% African Americans ENT = 8.3%, ENG = 5.1%
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
12
6
Engineering Technology
No. 40 in the number of bachelor’s degrees awarded
Bachelor’s Degrees Awarded to Women and Minorities
Student Diversity Women % UCF Nation* 24.5% 11.7% # 13 698 Asians % 5.7% 5.8% # 3 342 Hispanics % 11.3% 6% # 6 354 African Americans % 17% 7.8% # 9 464
UCF Degree Totals: Bachelor’s = 53 *ASEE Degree Totals: Bachelor’s = 5,936
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
13
Benchmark: US News Ranked Institutions
Institutions Top University of California-Berkeley University of Illinois- Urbana Champaign Georgia Institute of Technology Purdue University University of Michigan Aspirational University of California- Santa Barbara University of Washington University of Florida University of Minnesota-Twin Cities Ohio State University University of California- Los Angeles University of California- San Diego 21 25 26 26 29 16 13 34 20 34 17 25 20 25 3 4 5 8 8 2 5 5 9 7 2005 Graduate Rankings 2004 Undergraduate Rankings
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
14
7
Benchmark: US News
Institutions Peer Arizona State University Colorado State University University of Pittsburgh University of Illinois-Chicago Clemson University University of Central Florida University of California-Irvine Auburn University 50 53 53 60 71 75 42 78 38 59 51 59 59 n/a 51 59 2005 Graduate Rankings 2004 Undergraduate Rankings
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
15
Benchmark Highlights
Benchmark Report Strengths
Microsoft Excel Worksheet
BS & MS degrees awarded per Teaching Tenure & Tenure-Track faculty BS & MS degrees awarded to underrepresented minorities Number of GTAs per Teaching Tenure & TenureTrack faculty
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
16
8
Benchmark Highlights
Moderate
MS &PhD degrees awarded to women % GTAs of total MS & PhD enrollment PhD enrollment per Teaching Tenure & Tenure Track faculty PhD degrees awarded to underrepresented minorities
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
17
Benchmark Highlights
Improvement
Undergraduate & Master’s enrollment per Teaching Tenure & Tenure-Track faculty PhD degrees awarded per Teaching Tenure & TenureTrack faculty GRAs per Teaching Tenure & Tenure Track faculty Undergraduate enrollment per GTA* % GRAs of total MS & PhD enrollment BS degrees awarded to women
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
18
9
UCF CECS
Reach for the Stars!
University of Central Florida
College of Engineering and Computer Science
19
10