Gifted Characteristics Article Critique Rubric
Name: _________________________________________ Article No. ______________
CATEGORY 1 2 3 4 Value
Choice of Article chosen is Article relevance Article chosen is Article is
Article irrelevant to is weak. relevant to class carefully chosen
class material. material. for its relevance
to class material.
Identification of The student The student The student The student
Issues does not identify identifies some identifies most of identifies all of
any major facts of the major the major facts of the major facts
(Characteristics of the article. facts of the the article. of the article.
of the gifted article.
Reflection The student The student The student The student
does not reflect makes some makes thoughtful makes
on relevance of reflection on reflection on thoughtful
this article to relevance of this relevance of this reflection on
his/her teaching. article to his/her article to his/her relevance of this
teaching. teaching. article and
makes plans to
Mechanics and There are many There are There are minor There are few or
Spelling mistakes in several mistakes mistakes in the no mistakes in
mechanics and in the mechanics mechanics and/or mechanics
spelling. and/or spelling. spelling that do and/or spelling.
not detract from
Date Created: July 25, 2007
Rhonda Emmett and Deborah Kelly