DIGITAL PIANO SHOOT-OUT As posted on the Keyboard Magazine forum on August 1, 2007 Went to one of those giant retail-centers today and took about two hours out of my dull and eventless life to compare the current crop of digital piano's out there. I checked all the piano's with the same set of headphones, tried to match levels and –if possible- switched off the internal effects (reverb etc.) Where adjustable, I set the velocity response to "hard". I think of myself as an intermediate jazz-player. * Casio Privia - the sound was very metallic and unresponsive. The action was not bad at all. It's cheap at 600 Euro, so it would make sense as a controller. * Korg SP250 - not outstanding, a bit clangy (sound-wise) and the action is a bit too soft. But it is a sensible package, which is actually reasonably rewarding to play. It comes with a stand, built-in speakers but even without those it is a bargain at 700 Euro. * Kurzweil PC 1SE - A disappointment. Does not live up to its manufacturer's reputation. Weak action, and outdated sounds. Don't bother. * Kurzweil SP88 – This is an older model and it shows. The action does not even pretend to be realistic and although Kurzweil was once famous for its accurate piano simulation, the Japanese competition has this thing beat. Disposable. * Roland FP 4 - Sounds nearly as good as it's bigger sibling the FP 7, in fact, I could barely tell the difference. However, it misses the 7's superb action, but this is still one of the better ones. It just plays nicely, if only a bit too light. Recommended. * Roland FP 7 - In typical Roland style, this is a great instrument that sports new features that nobody really wants (it support USB-flash disks, but plays back only .wav’s and not .mp3’s!) This would be my choice, though, since it sounds the best and has an action that can finally compete with the Yamaha's. * Roland RD 300 SX – Other than the pitchbend lever and (limited) split-keyboard functionality I can’t think of any reason why you’d buy this over a FP4. It sounds alright, but its weak action is not likely to appeal to pianists. * Roland RD 700 SX – Actually very good, the action feels like the FP7 and it sounds good as well. You lose the FP7’s built-in speakers, gain a pitchbend lever and some programability, but this comes at a serious price hike that is –in my eyes- not entirely justified. * Yamaha CP 33 - In short, great action, rigid sound. But thousands of others disagree, so check it out. I find that Yamaha's sounds do not respond very well to velocity. If this action could have the FP sound, or if the FP 4 could have this action... * Yamaha P-140 - Call me loopy, but I actually found this to be a more engaging instrument that the newer CP 33. And it comes at the same price, with speakers but without bend- and mod-wheels. * Yamaha CP 300 - Again, I may be loopy, but I preferred the P 140 over this as well. As with the other Yamaha's, great action but I just can't get with that sound. * Yamaha P 70 - Very basic, no power switch, no line-out, mini-headphone jacks, but a solid action and reasonable sound for an agreeable amount of cash. Feel free to disagree!
Pages to are hidden for
"DIGITAL PIANO SHOOT-OUT"Please download to view full document