old

							Old


2 – 1. CCC Communications Channels                                120         Incomplete
LHC@FNAL shall have the capability for multiple (minimum number?) communications
channels that can be used simultaneously.




4 – 1. Computing                                                          Incomplete
Computing resources shall be available to LHC@FNAL users. Additional work is needed to
determine specifications for computing.
Describe how many PC’s per console, and servers are needed. Webservers etc.



New –
Replace both of these with a joint LHC and CMS requirements
Models for the activities and occupation of LHC@FNAL for both CMS and LHC shall
be developed and used to specify the space, equipment, communications and networking
requirements. Equipment includes computing resources, consoles, video conferencing.
---------------------------------------------------------------
Old
4 – 2. Communications                                                     Incomplete
Reliable communications shall be available to LHC@FNAL users. Additional work is needed
to determine specifications for communications.
Video conferencing reliability , % uptime, 24-7, UPS


New
Reliable communications shall be available to LHC@FNAL users, equivalent to that
normally available at FNAL. Provision for redundant equipment and cabling, including
an independent external phone number, shall be made in the LHC@FNAL space. Cell
phones are expected to provide redundancy as well.
Old


4 – 3. Reliable Networking                                                                   Incomplete
Reliable networking shall be available to LHC@FNAL users. Additional work is needed to
determine specifications for networking.
May not need a highly reliable system. Talk to Al Thomas about typical reliablity of a system
at WH.


New
Reliable networking shall be available to LHC@FNAL users, equivalent to that normally
available to ESNET users. Provision shall be made for redundancy in equipment and
cabling in the local LHC@FNAL space such that reduced operations can continue in case
of failure.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Old


4 – 4. Computing and Networking Security                                                     Incomplete
LHC@FNAL shall have secure computing and networking. Additional work is needed to
determine specifications for the level of security that is needed.
Need anything more?


New
LHC@FNAL shall have secure computing and networking consisten with the
requirements of Fermilab and CERN.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Old


4 – 5. LHC@FNAL Space Security                                            Incomplete
LHC@FNAL space shall be secured. Additional work is needed to determine level of security
that is needed.
Does anything more imply implementation? Who will you grant access to the op center?
Training? Say secuable – to imply we can implement what is needed.


New
LHC@FNAL space shall be designed such that it can be secured and access limited to
authorized persons.