Summary by tyndale

VIEWS: 3 PAGES: 5

									                                              EEF Grants 2004 Evaluation and Summary
                                                                                                                   Board Member Total Scores
No.            1           2                                        Title                                                                            Rank
                                                                                                                  1    2    3    4     5     Mean
                               Cryopreservation of preimplantation embryos of the guinea pig as a
1     Dorsch       Glage                                                                                          16   14   11   14           13.8    11
                               contribution to the 3Rs model of Russell and Burch
                               The cyropreservation of ovaries as an alternative strategy for archiving line of
2     Fentener     Themmen                                                                                        16   15   10   17    0      11.6    13
                               genetically modified mice
                               Magnetic resonance imaging: does it cause stress and abnormal behaviour in
3     Kerton       So                                                                                             17   16   9    17   15.5    14.9    9
                               laboratory mice
4     Hedenqvist   Baumans     Impact of tail biopsy in the mouse – a pilot study                                 20   16   18   19   17.5    18.1    1
                               Refinement and reduction outcomes of environmental enrichment in
5     Nevalainen   Kemppinen                                                                                      18        17   18   16.5    17.4    =4
                               laboratory rats
                               Impact of “living apart together” on post operative recovery on female
6     Baumans      Van Loo                                                                                        19   14   20   18   17      17.6    3
                               laboratory mice compared to social and individual housing
                               Effects of social housing conditions on the reliability of mouse models of
7     Ohl          Moelands                                                                                       17   19   13   18   17      16.8    6
                               anxiety
                               PET-scanning and combined with cognitive testing as an objective and
8     Olsen        Sorensen                                                                                       18   18   10   16   15      15.4    8
                               scientifically based measure of the impact of environment enrichment in rats
                   Ritskes-
9     Jegstrup                 Restricted individual food acquisition for socially housed rats                    17   16        20   16.5    17.4    =4
                   Hoitinga
                   Ritskes-    Humane endpoints in cancer research – evaluation of biochemical and
10    Rud                                                                                                         20   17        17   17      17.8    2
                   Hoitinga    welfare parameters in rat models with hidden tumours
                               A continuing eduction programme in laboratory animal science: Master of
11    Saario       --                                                                                                  0         6     0       2.0    15
                               Laboratory Animal Science
12    Antunes      Olsson      Refinements in laboratory animal anaesthesia                                            16   17   17    0      12.5    12
                               Refinement and Reduction alternatives (Two Rs) to laboratory animals –
13    Ping-Ping    Hackbarth                                                                                      18   18   12                16.0    7
                               contribution to cost assessment in ethical evaluation
                               Long term experimental anaesthesia in the pregnant sow and basic
14    Kovaru       Splichal                                                                                            13   9    15    0       9.3    14
                               physiological parameters of mother and foetus
                               A new modified model of experimental of intracerebral haemorrhage in the
15    Barth        --                                                                                             19   11   8    17   17      14.4    10
                               adult rat
                Scoring Details: 1 = yes, application to second round; 0= no, application not to second round


                        Applicant
No                                              Hans        Timo        Xavier      Merel      Pedro Jose   Total
                  1                      2
1    Tsai                   Hackbarth                                                                           4
2    Otto                                                                                                       3
3    Vainio                 Kohila                                                                              4
4    Inhila                 Kasanen                                                                             3
5    Varela Nieto           Murilla Cuesto                                                                      3
6    Reyes Moreno           Caiza                                                                               0
7    Kovaru                 Zelnickova                                                                          2
8    Bonnet                 Vayssier-Taussat                                                                    1
9    Laaksonen              Voipio                                                                              3
10   Bajramovic             Kondova                                                                             4
11   Kostomitsopoulos       Dontas                                                                              2
12   Zubeldia               Asensio                                                                             1
13   Dontas                 Kostomitsopoulos                                                                    1
14   Algers                 Weber                                                                               4
15   Kadoglu                Katsiboulas                                                                         3
16   Burman                                                                                                     5
17   Bennett                Cobb                                                                                2
18   Antunes                Valentim                                                                            1
19   Summavielle            Antunes                                                                             2
20   Kubinyi                Balogh                                                                              0
                                                blank       blank       blank        blank       blank          0
                        Applicant                            Hans                             Timo
No
                1                       2    A       B        C       D Total A       B        C       D
9    Laaksonen            Voipio                 3       4        3    4 14
4    Inhila               Kasanen                3       4        3    4 14
16   Burman                                      5       5        4    4 18       4       3        3       5
2    Otto                                                                 0   5       2        3       5
1    Tsai                 Hackbarth              4       3        4    4 15   5       3        5       5
3    Vainio               Kohila                 4       4        4    2 14   5       4        3       5
5    Varela Nieto         Murilla Cuesto         4       3        3    3 13   2       3        3       5
6    Reyes Moreno         Caiza                                           0
7    Kovaru               Zelnickova                                      0
8    Bonnet               Vayssier-Taussat                                0
10   Bajramovic           Kondova                4       3        3    3 13       4       4        3       5
11   Kostomitsopoulos     Dontas                                          0
12   Zubeldia             Asensio                                         0
13   Dontas               Kostomitsopoulos                                0
14   Algers               Weber                  3       3        3    3 12       3       3        3       5
15   Kadoglu              Katsiboulas            3       3        3    3 12       5       4        3       5
17   Bennett              Cobb                                            0
18   Antunes              Valentim                                        0
19   Summavielle          Antunes                                         0
20   Kubinyi              Balogh                                          0
                                                                          0
Timo                         Xavier                               Merel                       Pedro Jose
       Total A       B         C       D Total A          B        C       D Total A          B       C       D Total    Total
        0        5       5         4       5 19       5       4        5       5 19                                 0    52.0
        0    5       5         4       5     19   5       4        4       4     17                                 0    50.0
        15       5       4         5       5 19       4       4        4       2 14       4       4       3       3 14   80.0
        15   4       4         4       4     16   5       5        3       3     16                                 0    47.0
        18   5       3         5       5     18   3       3        4       5     15   3       3       3       3     12   78.0
        17   5       4         4       4     17   5       5        3       4     17   4.0     4       3       2     13   78.0
        13   4       4         4       4     16   5       5        4       2     16                                 0    58.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        16       5       5         4       5 19       2       4        4       3 13       5       5       3       3 16   77.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        14       5       4         5       5 19       5       4        3       4 16       4       2       2       3 11   72.0
        17       4       4         5       5 18       3       3        2       4 12                                 0    59.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0     0.0
        0                                    0                                   0                                  0
Mean     Rank   ECLAM   EUR
17.3       1      N           20   FN
16.7       2      Y           20   FN
16.0       3      N           14   UK
15.7       4      N            8   DE
15.6       5      Y            8   DE
15.6       5      N
14.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
15.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
14.4
14.8
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

       Total                  70

								
To top