Efficiency of Concept Maps for the Educational Reconstruction of

Document Sample
Efficiency of Concept Maps for the Educational Reconstruction of Powered By Docstoc
					    Efficiency of Concept Maps for the Educational
      Reconstruction of the topic burning and
     combustion for elementary school students
                   Nina Dunker, Barbara Moschner & Ilka Parchmann
                                University of Oldenburg

    Today in many European Countries it is not any longer the question if children in
primary school are to learn science but how to learn science concepts effectively and
lastingly. Most European curricula have integrated physical and chemical topics by now.
Developmental research studies (CAREY 2000; SODIAN 2002) and studies in the field of
psychology (STERN et al. 2004) formed the basis for this, because they show impressively
that children are cognitively able to grasp these alleged abstract concepts and general
perspectives which was long time doubted. In the past, the method of Concept Mapping has
been proofed to be very effective for adult learners (JUENGST 1995; BERND et al. 2000)
as well as for the use of learning strategies (FISCHER & MANDL, 2000) and diagnostical
knowledge research (STRACKE, 2003; WEBER & SCHUMANN, 2000). According to this
the research questions focused on:

    1. How can the topic burning and combustion be structured for elementary school

    2. Can children learn more efficient by using networking learning methods such as
       Concept Mapping?

    Therefore three different aspects were investigated:

    • By using qualitative methods the students’ preconceptions of the topic burning and
      combustion have been identified.

    • By using qualitative methods experts identified the scientific (chemical) matter of
      the topic burning and combustion.

    • By using quantitative methods the efficiency of Concept Mapping for learning the
      matter burning and combustion has been evaluated.

   All three parts of the study and their influence on the Educational Structuration are
described in detail below.

1     Students’ preconceptions of the topic burning and com-
The Concept Maps of 92 elementary school students at the age of 10 have been evaluated
qualitatively. All propositions (a proposition consists of two concepts linked by a labeled
relation) were analysed for their special content. Over all 118 concepts were counted and
9 different dimensions could be identified:
Scientific concepts: The most prominent concepts were wood as an example for a com-
bustible material, which makes 24% of all scientific concepts and therefore is one of the

most prominent concepts and water as a solution for extinguishing a fire which was named
25 times and makes 21% of all scientific concepts. A lot of other examples for a burning
material were also named (paper, cole and hay), but surprisingly the candle or the burnt
wax was only named three times. Even two children noticed that a fire needs a tempera-
ture for burning and 12 named a source of ignition like the lighter or matches.
Sensitive perception: The most frequently named sensitive perception was fire is hot
(named 55 times). 9 times the generated heat was mentioned.
Destruction and dangerousness: The most important thing the students named under
this aspect was that fire is dangerous not can be dangerous if handled wrongly. They also
mentioned fire to be deathly.
Description of the phenomena: Very rarely the students knew that a fire has a flame
(named 21 times) and smoke occurs (named 23 times).
Own experiences: What is outstanding within this class is the experience of getting
Aesthetic dimensions: Students often described the fire with certain qualities of color
and smell.
Institution fire station: Almost all students named the fire station and their responsi-
bility for extinguishing fires.
Word associations: Special german words are mentioned, but rarely.
Historic dimension: Twice the invention of fire by the prehistoric men was mapped.
It is not remarkable that elementary school students have more everyday concepts than
scientific concepts. What is surprisingly, but is well compliant to other research findings
(PRIETO 1992; RAHAYU 1999) is the fact that there is a dominance of concepts where
fire is describe as being dangerous and destructive. These concepts even outweigh concepts
that are based on own experiences. Working with scientific experiments can help to fill the
gap of own experiences and can also influence the strong believe that fire is dangerous.
Maybe making experiments can even help regarding fire less dangerous but to be handled
well and that it requires a certain carefulness.

2    Identifying scientific matter of the topic burning and com-
     bustion by interviewing experts
The elementarisation of scientific matter, which is in this case the topic burning and
combustion, marks one of the important aspects within the model of Educational Recon-
struction (Kattmann et al. 1997).This model forms the foundation of the whole study.
To identify concepts that are relevant for elementary school students four experts have
been interviewed. These expert all have a scientific background and have developed dif-
ferent educational submissions for elementary school students for the topic burning and
The guidelines for the interviews referred to:
    • What aspects can cause problems for younger learners?
      The experts pointed out that the scientific concept of the state of aggregation causes
      problems because of its difficulty. The students should experience this concept in
      different other situations before transferring it to understand burning processes.

      The experimental samples to acquire deeper understanding are to be chosen well.
      Also the temperature of inflammability was named by the experts to be a rather
      difficult concept to understand for young learners. There are several possibilities to
      show in an experiment this special need for a combustion, but it is not very common
      to do them. The concept of the surface and the degree of dispersion of a combustible
      material causes great problems for young learners because it is hard to reconstruct
      and hard to transfer.

    • What scientific concepts should be specially integrated to help children understand
      these abstract ideas of the topic?
      The experts were discordant. Some regarded the level of particles as helpful to explain
      burning processes others argued against it, because of its abstractness. They agreed
      that CO2 as a product of combustion should be targeted in school lessons.

    • What aspects are relevant for a educational structuration?
      All experts argued for the idea that the three conditions of burning should be offered
      to learners with different possibilities of transfer. They also meant that the specialty
      of the combustible material should get more into focus as well as their similarities in
      the process of burning.The experts all suggested to be aware that lasting concepts
      need time to develop.

3    The efficiency of Concept Mapping
Design of the study: By the help of the CPM-Test (Coloured Progessive Matrices by Ra-
ven) the students’ cognitive abilities were investigated. In form of inquiry learning, the
students acquired the underlying chemical concepts of the topic which was embedded in
an excursion to the chemical laboratory („CHEMOL“) at the University of Oldenburg.
Subsequent to this, two homogeneous groups recorded their knowledge by either taking
traditional linear notes (group A) or building up a Concept Map (group B). A follow-up
knowledge test two weeks later was handed out to show the students overall knowledge.
Data analysis: A quantitative evaluation showed which of the two groups, the linear-notes-
group (A) or the Concept-Mapping-group (B), has learned more effectively than the other
group. Therefore all data have been investigated with a specific score-code: In the linear
notes group all concepts have been counted, then the occurring misconceptions have been
pointed out and at last the scientific concepts, which were taught in the intervention, have
been counted. The same has been done for the Concept Mapping group. These results
have been compared with the data collected from the knowledge test.
Findings: The most outstanding results were the fact that the amount of used scientific
concepts within the Concept Maps have a positive effect on the score of the knowledge-test
(r=.30*,N=48). And surprisingly the level of networking within the Concept Maps has a
positive effect on the score of the knowledge test (r=.80**,N=17). While the results also
show that the level of cognitive ability of the students has no influence on the possibility
to learn effectively with the method of concept mapping it can be used in educational
surroundings to emphasis the scientific concepts and their function for burning processes.
The degree of deeper understanding can be promoted through a directed use of certain
concepts and the intention of maximum linking. How to force those processes without

disturbing the process of construct knowledge is not yet defined.

4      Indications for the Educational Structuration of the mat-
       ter burning and combustion?
The investigation of the students preconceptions brought up several hints to tie up to.
Together with the predictions of the experts the aim is to find guidelines for the work
with elementary school students where their special pre-knowledge is to be considered
and included into the didactic requirements given by the experts. The method of Concept
Mapping will form the promoter for learning concepts more efficient and therefore more
lasting. The combination of all three parts of the study as well as the guidelines for the
Didactical Structuration are still in process and therefore can not be further explicated

     [1] Bernd, Heike; Thomas Hippchen, Karl-Ludwig Jüngst und Peter Strittmatter (2000): Durcharbeiten von Be-
         griffsstrukturdarstellungen in unterrichtlichen und computergestützten Lernumgebungen. In: Mandl, Heinz
         und Frank Fischer (Hrsg.) Wissen sichtbar machen. Wissensmanagement mit Mappingtechniken. Göttingen:
         Hogrefe 2000; pp 15 - 35

     [2] Carey, S. (2000): Science Education as Conceptual Change. In: Journal of Applied Developmental Psycho-
         logy. 21. Jg.; pp 13 - 19

     [3] Fischer & Mandl: Strategiemodellierung mit Expertenmaps. In: Mandl, H. & Frank Fischer (Hrsg.): Wissen
         sichtbar machen. Wissensmanagement mit Mapping-Techniken. Hogrefe: Göttingen 2000

     [4] Jüngst, Karl Ludwig (1995). Studien zur didaktischen Nutzung von Concept Maps. In: Unterrichtswissen-
         schaft, 23(3). 1995; pp 229 - 250

     [5] Kattmann, U., R. Duit, H. Gropengießer, M. Komorek, (1997). Das Modell der Didaktischen Rekonstrukti-
         on - Ein Rahmen für naturwissenschaftsdidaktische Forschung und Entwicklung. In: Zeitschrift für Didaktik
         der Naturwissenschaften 3(3); pp 3-18

     [6] Prieto, T, J.Watson J.Dillon (1992). Students conceptions of combustion. In: Research in Sceince Education
         22, pp 331 - 340

     [7] Rahayu, S. & Russel Tytler (1999). Progression in primary school children’s conception about burning:
         Toward an understanding of Concept of Substance. In: Research and Science Education 29(3); pp 295 - 312

     [8] Sodian, B. (2002). Entwicklung begrifflichen Wissens. In R. Oerter & L. Montada (Hrsg.). Entwicklungs-
         psychologie (5. Aufl.) Kapitel 12. Weinheim: Beltz

     [9] Stracke, I: Concept Maps zur Wissensdiagnose in der Chemie. Waxmann: Münster 2003

    [10] Stern, E., & Möller, K. (2004). Der Erwerb anschlussfähigen Wissens als Ziel des Grundschulunterrichtes.
         Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaften; pp 25-36

    [11] Weber & Schumann: Das Concept Mapping Software Tool (COMASOTO) zur Diagnose strukturellen Wis-
         sens. In: Mandl, H. & Frank Fischer (Hrsg.): Wissen sichtbar machen. Wissensmanagement mit Mapping-
         Techniken. Hogrefe: Göttingen 2000

Nina Dunker
CvO University of Oldenburg
Chemistry Education
Postfach 2503
26111 Oldenburg