Journal of Industrial Technology Manuscript Evaluation Form
\\UCI_1\DIANE\UCIDATA\UCI\NAIT\JOURNAL\Evalblnk
Manuscript Title:
______________________________________________________
Reviewer Number: __________ Date due back from Reviewer: ___________
Criteria Significance of Topic Quality of Ideas Readability Appropriateness for JIT Comments: Excellent Good Adequate Weak Poor N/A
Follows APA Style Grammar & Spelling Tables & Figures References Comments:
Review of Literature Research Design and Methodology Statistical Analysis & Supporting Data Conclusions & Recommendations Comments:
Recommendation: Publish as submitted Return to author for major revisions Not suitable for publication in the JIT Publish with minor editorial changes Check appropriate "Key Word" index categories:
Administration__________ Arch. Drawing_________ Automotive____________ Aviation Tech.__________ CAD_________________ CAM_________________ CIM__________________ Composite Materials_____ Computer Programming__ Computer Science______ Construction___________ Curriculum____________ Design _______________ Desktop Publishing______ Electricity_____________ Electronics____________ Energy_______________ Environ. Issues________ Ethics________________ FMS_________________ Fluid Power___________ Graphic Comm._________ Higher Education_______ Human Relations_______ Industrial Distribution____ Information Tech _______ Internet_______________ Laser Technology_______ Leadership____________ Legal Issues___________ Machine Design________ Machine Tools_________ Management__________ Manufacturing__________ Marketing_____________ Materials & Processes___ Materials Testing_______ Metals________________ NAIT ________________ NC/CNC______________ Packaging_____________ Philosophy____________ Plastics/Polymers_______ Printing_______________ Production____________ Quality_______________ Quality Control_________ Rapid Prototyping______ Research_____________ Robotics______________ Safety________________ Sociology_____________ Teaching Methods______ Technical Writing_______ Motion/Time Study______ Transportation_________ Visual Comm.__________ Welding______________ Suggested: ___________ _____________________ _____________________
Notes to reviewer: Please DO NOT sign this form. A copy of this evaluation will be sent to the author. Please comment under all sections and be specific when items are ranked weak or poor.