1 Shi V. Liu's Comments Hidden by Nature Comments by mrz53354

VIEWS: 0 PAGES: 2

									                           Shi V. Liu’s Comments Hidden by Nature

Comments made on the Nature News “Fusion verdict: misconduct”
(http://www.nature.com/news/2008/080722/full/454379a.html )

The following comments were posted by me and appeared in the above News thread
before they were removed by the Nature on the same day of July 23, 2008.

The “hidden” notices were sent to me from an email address “donotreply@nature.com
but none of these notices gave any reason for the removal of my comments.

Shi V. Liu
SVL@logibio.com
http://im1.biz

July 29, 2008

Hidden notice 1.

Dear Shi Liu:

The following post you wrote on Nature News has been hidden by the moderator.

False "positive" citation has now been condemned as misconduct. What about true negative citation,
i.e. intentionally ignoring pioneering discoveries or prior art so that later re-inventions can be claimed
as (false) discoveries? See many such examples in the Truthfinding Cyberpress (http://im1.biz). ------
Shi V. Liu (SVL@logibio.com; http://im1.biz; http://blog.sina.com.cn/im1)

The moderator gave the following reason for this action:



Please refrain from posting similar types of comments on Nature News.

If you would like to dispute this, please email news@nature.com

Thank you.

-Nature News editors

Hidden notice 2.

Dear Shi Liu:

The following post you wrote on Nature News has been hidden by the moderator.

Finally, the rope for rounding misconduct reached out of the limit set by the boundary of laboratory
notebook! A great breakthrough in fighting high-level misconduct!! A giant victory for truth-finding
scientists!!! ------Shi V. Liu (SVL@logibio.com; http://im1.biz; http://blog.sina.com.cn/im1)

The moderator gave the following reason for this action:




                                                     1
Please refrain from posting similar types of comments on Nature News.

If you would like to dispute this, please email news@nature.com

Thank you.

-Nature News editors


Hidden notice 3.

Dear Shi Liu:

The following post you wrote on Nature News has been hidden by the moderator.

2 of my 14 comments here have now been removed by Nature. I have filed complaints against these
removals. In the future all of the hidden comments of mine will be published in one place in the
Truthfinding Cyberpress (http://im1.biz) under the heading of "Hidden by Nature". Shi V. Liu
(SVL@logibio.com; http://im1.biz; http://blog.sina.com.cn/im1)

The moderator gave the following reason for this action:



Please refrain from posting similar types of comments on Nature News.

If you would like to dispute this, please email news@nature.com

Thank you.

-Nature News editors




                                                  2

								
To top