Get documents about "Enhancing Security of Supply in Europe
Document Sample
Coordinating Energy Security in Supply Activities
project financed by the European Union (EC, DG Research)
under the Sixth RTD Framework Programme
coordinated by
Jean-Michel Glachant & François Lévêque
Armines – École des mines de Paris
Enhancing Security of Supply in Europe
conference organised by
Florence School of Regulation, Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies,
European University Institute, Florence
Badia Fiesolana – 12-13 June 2008
The Theme
The European Union is increasingly dependent on external sources of primary energy.
They are provided by different markets, which differ with respect to competitiveness,
stability, reliability. They differ with respect to their present and future prices and to their
environmental impact. A widely shared worry of an increasing risk is not accompanied
by a consensus on the best solutions. Would they be provided by market on non-market
mechanisms? At the EU level or by Member States? The conference should provide some
clarification and help towards better understanding.
Programme
12 June
14:00 - 14:10 Welcome address
Stefano Bartolini, Director, Robert Schuman Centre for
Advanced Studies/EUI
14:10 - 14:20 Introduction
Jean-Michel Glachant, Paris XI
Pippo Ranci, Director FSR
Session 1 Security of Supply: Definitions, Measures, Outlook
14:20 – 14:40 Introduction and Chair
Pierre Noel, Cambridge University
14:40 – 15:00 How to measure and assess security of supply:
The use of standards
Jacques de Jong, CIEP Clingendael
15:00 – 15:20 Discussion
15:20 – 15:40 A quantitative assessment from a market model:
How dependent Europe is now and how will it be?
Pantelis Kapros,Technical University of Athens
15:40 – 16:00 Discussion
16:00 – 16:10 Final remarks on Session 1
Pierre Noel
16:10 – 16:30 Coffee break
Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies
European University Institute - Via Boccaccio, 151
50133 Firenze – Italy
www.iue.it/RSCAS/
Session 2 How to increase Security of Supply: the role of specific
measures
16:30 – 16:50 Introduction and Chair
Pippo Ranci
16:50 – 17:10 The role of renewables and of energy efficiency in ensuring
Security of Supply
Alberto Pototschnig, FSR
17:10 - 17:20 A comment
Loren Cox, MIT
17:20 – 17:40 Discussion
17:40 – 18:00 The role of system flexibility in increasing security
William D’haeseleer, University of Leuven
18:00 – 18:20 Discussion
18:20 – 18:30 Final remarks on Session 2
Pippo Ranci
20:00 Dinner speech
Looking beyond Copenhagen
Growth and Security in a Low Carbon Future?
Thomas Heller, Stanford University and adviser to the
UN Secretary General on climate change
13 June
Session 3 Competition and Security of Supply
08:45 – 09:05 Introduction and Chair
François Lévêque, École de mines de Paris
09:05 – 09:25 Long-term contracts between security of supply and effective
market opening: A view from the legal side
Marc van der Woude, University of Rotterdam
09:25 - 09:45 Competition and destination clauses in gas contracts
Celine Gauer, EC, DG-COMP
09:45 – 10:05 Discussion
10:05 – 10:25 Long-term contracting from the point of view of
a big industrial energy consumer
Petter Longva, NorskHydro
10:25 – 10:45 Discussion
10:45 – 10:55 Final remarks on Session 2: François Lévêque
10:55 – 11:15 Coffee break
Session 4 Security of gas supply in Europe
11:15 – 11:35 Introduction and Chair
Christian von Hirschhausen, Dresden University of
Technology
11:35 - 11:55 Security of Gas Supply in Europe and the Role of Russia
N.A. Simoniya, Director, Center for Energy Studies, Institute of
World Economy and International Relations, Moscow
11:55 – 12:10 Gas Supply to Europe from pipelines and LNG
Manfred Hafner, FEEM
12:10 - 12:25 Carlos Vázquez Martínez, Gas Natural
12:25 – 13:00 Discussion
13:00 – 13:10 Final remarks on Session 4
Christian von Hirschhausen
13:10 – 13:25 Conclusions
Jean-Michel Glachant
13:25 – 14:30 Lunch
The CESSA Stakeholders Session:
A discussion on EU Energy Security of Supply policy
with the aim of drafting recommendations
A “Chatham House” CESSA brain-storming session aiming at building the rational base
for the future CESSA “European Energy Security of Supply” policy recommendations
to the European Commission in the areas of gas, nuclear and hydrogen. Registering
to attend this Friday session is especially recommended to the representatives of the
CESSA Stakeholders. That brain-storming session is a close-shop session. An additional
registering with CESSA is required.
14:30- 14:45 Introduction
Jean-Michel Glachant
14:45 -16:00 EU SoS: Defining the relevant mix of market and
non-market policy mechanisms
Discussion to be introduced by
François Lévêque
16:00-16:15 Coffee break
16:15-17:25 EU SoS: Disentangling the EU and the Member States
policy levels
Discussion to be introduced by
Pippo Ranci
17:25-17:30 Concluding remarks
Jean-Michel Glachant
Participants
Mariani Abbas University of Surrey, UK
mariani70@yahoo.com
Nozima Student, Jacobs University Bremen, Germany
Akhrarkhodjaeva n.akhrarkhodjaeva@jacobs-university.de
Juozas Augutis Professor, Lithuania Energy Institute, Lithuania
j.augutis@if.vdu.lt
Manuel Baritaud Economist, AREVA- Corporate Strategy Department, France
manuel.baritaud@areva.com
Julián Barquín Professor, Comillas University, Spain
julian.barquin@iit.upcomillas.es
Ronnie Belmans Professor, K.U.LEUVEN, Belgium
ronnie.belmans@esat.kuleuven.be
Daniele Benintendi Senior Researcher, FEEM, Italy
daniele.benintendi@feem.it
Andrea Bigano Senior Researcher, Fondazione ENI Enrico Mattei, Italy
andrea.bigano@feem.it
Patricia Risk and market analyst,Iberdrola S.A.,Spain
Blanco Fernández pblanco@iberdrola.es
Rim Boubaker PhD Student, ADIS/GRJM, University Paris XI Sud, France
rim.boubaker@u-psud.fr
José Luis Student of the “Master on Economics and Management
Calvo de Miguel of Network Industries”, ICAI- University Paris XI Sud, France
jlcalvodemiguel@hotmail.com
Julita Capala Manager, Polish Oil and Gas Company, Poland
julita.capala@pgnig.pl
José Ángel Electric sector master student,Comillas University, Spain
Castro Abad jacabad@gmail.com
Malgorzata Cegiella Senior Specialist, Polish Oil and Gas Company, Poland
malgorzata.cegiella@pgnig.pl
Eshien Chong Assistant Professor, ADIS, University Paris XI Sud, France
eshien.chong@u-psud.fr
Loren Cox Associate Director, MIT Joint Program on Global Change,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA
lorencox@mit.edu
Anna Creti IEFE Università Bocconi, Italy
creti@unibocconi.it
Dragana Damjanović EUI visiting fellow, EUI, Italy
dragana.damjanovic@eui.eu
Francesca Davoli FSR, EUI, Italy
francesca.davoli@eui.eu
Adrien PhD Candidate, University of Manchester and ADIS/GRJM,
De Hauteclocque University Paris XI Sud, France
adrien.de-hauteclocque@postgrad.manchester.ac.uk
Jacques de Jong Senior Fellow, Clingendael International Energy Programme,
The Netherlands
jjong@clingendael.nl
William D’haeseleer Professor/Chairman, University of Leuven Energy Institute/
European Energy Institute(EEI), Belgium
william.dhaeseleer@mech.kuleuven.be
Alessandra Di Renzo Economist, Ricerche per l’economia e la finanza srl, Italy
adirenzo@ref-online.it
Kristin Dietrich PhD Student, Master in Engineering and Management,
IIT (Institute of Research in technology), Comillas University,
Spain
kristin.dietrich@iit.upcomillas.es
Benoît Doin International Regulation, France & Russia, Enel Spa, Italy
benoit.doin@enel.it,gabriella.costantini@enel.it Ute Dubois
Post. doc researcher, University Paris XI Sud, France
ute.dubois@u.psud.fr
Felice Egidi Director Regulatory Affairs, Endesa Italia Spa, Italy
egidi.felice@endesa.it
Andrée Elbaz Strateges Advisor, EDF International & Gaz, France
andree.elbaz@edf.fr
María Soledad MSE Student, Comillas University, Spain
Espejo Domínguez msespejo@gmail.com
Camila Fernandes Student, Comillas University, Spain
kmilafernandes@yahoo.com.br
Dominique Finon Senior Research Fellow, CIRED-CNRS, France
finon@centre-cired.fr
Álvaro Galán Civantos Chemical Engineer, Comillas University, Spain
alvgal19@hotmail.com
Céline Gauer Head of Unit, European Commission, Belgium
celine.gauer@ec.europa.eu,francoise.capla@ec.europa.eu
Nima Ghaeni Project Manager Logistics, Wintershall Erdgas
Handelshaus Gmbh & Co. KG, Germany
nima.ghaeni@wieh.de,renate.behrendt@wieh.de
Jean Michel Glachant CESSA Scientific Coordinator/Professor and Director
of Economics Department at University Paris Sud 11, ADIS/
GRJM, University Paris XI Sud, France
jean-michel.glachant@wanadoo.fr
Andrés Coordination Manager, Comillas University, ICAI, Spain
González García agonzalez@icai.upcomillas.es
Francesca Gostinelli Head of International Regulation, Enel Spa, Italy
francesca.gostinelli@enel.it
Farid Guliyev PhD Candidate, School of Humanities and Social Sciences,
Jacobs University Bremen, Germany
gulyev@jacobs-university.de
Manuela Gusmerotti Research & Development Unit, Gestore Mercato Elettrico
(GME), Italy
manuela.gusmerotti@mercatoelettrico.org
Manfred Hafner Senior Researcher, FEEM, France
manfred.hafner@gmail.com
Michelle Hallack PhD Student, University Paris XI Sud, France
mihallack@yahoo.com.br
Gilbert Hamaide Project Manager, GAZ DE FRANCE / Global Gaz and LNG,
France
gilbert.hamaide@gazdefrance.com
Thomas Heissenberger Managing Director, OMV- AGGM, Austria
thomas.heissenberger@aggm.at
Thomas Heller Professor of International Legal Studies, Stanford University,
USA
theller@stanford.edu
Alex Henney Director, EEE Ltd, UK
alexhenney@aol.com
Céline Hiroux Research Assistant, ADIS/GRJM, University Paris XI Sud, France
celine.hiroux@u-psud.fr Franziska Holz Researcher,
DIW Berlin, Germany
fholz@div.de
Esther Jara Pascual Gas and Power Wholesale Markets, Gas Natural SDG, S.A., Spain
ejara@gasnatural.com,
Pantelis Kapros Professor of Economics, National Technical University of Athens,
Greece
kapros@central.ntua.gr
Krzysztof Kwiecien Natural Gas Analyst, International Energy Agency, France
krzysztof.kwiecien@iea.org,
Guillaume Laprise Comillas University, Spain
guillaumelaprise@hotmail.com
François Lévêque Professor of Law and Economics, Mines Paristech, France
francois.leveque@ensmp.fr
Sebastian Libonatti Student EMIN, Comillas University, Spain
sebastian.libonatti@hotmail.com
Siok Jen Liong Comillas University, Spain
siokjen81@hotmail.com,
Jean Lions Assistant Vice President, GAZ DE FRANCE, France
jean.lions@gazdefrance.com
Petter Longva Vice president, Energy Policy, Norsk Hydro ASA, Norway
petter.longva@hydro.com,
María José Regulatory Affairs, Endesa, Spain,
López Quílez mjlopez@endesa.es
Alvaro López-Peña Assistant Researcher, Pre-doctoral fellow, Comillas University, Spain
alvaro.lopezpena@iit.upcomillas.es
Ilaria Losa Researcher, CESI RICERCA, Italy
ilaria.losa@cesiricerca.it
Gunnar Lundberg Vice president Regulatory Affairs, Vattenfall, Sweden
gunnar.lundberg@vattenfall.com
Maria Lykidi Ph. D Student in Economic Sciences, ADIS/GRJM, University
Paris XI Sud, France
maria.lykidi@orange.fr
Gordon Mackerron Professor and Director, Sussex Energy Group, SPRU (Science
and Technology Policy Research) University of Sussex, UK
g.s.mackerron@sussex.ac.uk
Anne Marcy EMIN Administrative Coordinator, ADIS/GRJM, University Paris XI
Sud, France
anne.marcy@u-psud.fr
Angel Rafael Manager of the Metering Department, Comillas University,
Martín Martínez Spain armartin@unionfenosa.es
Michel Matheu Corporate Strategy Director, France Electricity, France
michel.matheu@edf.fr
Pilar Master of the electricity sector, ICAI - Comillas University, Spain
Meneses de Quevedo pilar.menesesdequevedo@electrabel.com
Jan Moen Director, NVE, Norway
janm@eunet.no
Alessandra Motz Researcher, Ricerche per l’economia e la finanza srl, Italy
amotz@ref-online.it
Alberto Nannoni Country Leader Energy, ARCELORMITTAL Group ,Italy
alberto.nannoni@arcelormittal.com
Pierre Noel EPRG, University of Cambridge, UK
p.noel@jbs.cam.ac.uk
William Nuttall Senior Lecturer Technology Policy, Judge Business School,
University of Cambridge, UK
wjn21@cam.ac.uk Claude Parthenay Associate Professor
of economy, ADIS/GRJM, University Paris XI
Sud, France
claude.parthenay@u-psud.fr
Yannick Pérez Associate Professor in Economics, University Paris XI Sud,
France
yannick.perez@u-psud.fr
Virginie Pignon Researcher, EDF R&D, France
virginie.pignon@edf.fr
Alberto Pototschnig Advisor, FSR, EUI, Italy
apototschnig@mercadosemi.es
Patrick Pruvot Director of the “Energy market analysis and portfolio
development” Department, EDF - Optimisation and
Trading, France
patrick.pruvot@edf.fr
Pippo Ranci Director, FSR, EUI, Italy
pippo.ranci@eui.eu
Vincent Rious Assistant Professor, Supelec, France
vincent.rious@supelec.fr
Franco Romerio University of Geneva, Switzerland
franco.romerio@cuepe.unige.ch
Marcelo Saguan Post Doctorate Researcher, University Paris XI Sud, France,
marcelo.saguan@u-psud.fr
Fabienne Salaun Senior Economist, Electricité de France, France
fabienne.salaun@edf.fr
Pia Saraceno Chief Economist, Ricerche per l’economia e la finanza srl, Italy
psaraceno@ref-online.it
Nodari Simoniya Professor, Director of Center for Energy Studies, ,IMEMO
RAS, State University: Higher School of Economics, Russia
simonia@imemo.ru
Jacopo Torriti Jean Monnet Fellow, FSR, EUI, Italy
jacopo.torriti@eui.eu
Riccardo Vailati Research Group Leader, CESI Ricerca, Italy
riccardo.vailati@cesiricerca.it
Marc van der Woude Partner, Stibbe, The Netherlands
marc.vanderwoude@stibbe.com
Jorge Vasconcelos Chairman, NEWES, Portugal
jvasconcelos@newes.eu
Carlos Vázquez Head of Wholesale Optimization, Gas Natural SDG, S.A., Spain
cvazquezm@gasnatural.com,
Christian Professor, CESSA Work Package Leader, DIW Berlin, and TU von
Hirschhausen Dresden, Germany
chrischhausen@diw.de
Sandrine Wachon Project Manager, RTE, France
sandrine.wachon@rte-france.com
Muhammad Umer University Paris XI Sud, France
Wasim umer.wasim@niit.edu.pk
Alessandro Zani Student of the “Master in the Electricity Sector”, Comillas
University, Spain
alezani81@yahoo.it,
Related docs
