Docstoc

Dansk Center for Scientific Computing

Document Sample
Dansk Center for Scientific Computing Powered By Docstoc
					DCSC REVIEW TEMPLATE
Danish Centre for Scientific Computing

To:

Blegdamsvej 17 DK-2100 Copenhagen OE Denmark Phone Fax E-mail Web CVR EAN +45 3532 5453 +45 3532 5016 info@dcsc.dk www.dcsc.dk 29979812 5798000422490

Peer reviewers for grant applications to DCSC
Copy: From:

DCSC secretariat
Subject:

DCSC Review Template

20 March 2009 /RB

Please fill out the "DCSC Financial Identification Form" to insure that you receive your due payment. DCSC aims for thorough and critical reviews, highlighting strengths as well as weaknesses in the application, the suggested research as well as the research team. Please keep the review at three to four pages in length, when answering the following questions: 1 OVERALL ASSESSMENT TEXT – Executive summary – What might, or might, not merit the project to be support by DCSC (3 – 5 lines)? OVERALL ASSESSMENT GRADE – How would you grade the project proposal in terms of suitability for DCSC financial support or access to DCSC HPC resources? Grade Category Outstanding Excellent Very Good Fair to Good Poor 3 Grade Explanation Among the 10% best within it field Among the 20% best within it field Among the 30% best within it field Non of the above or below Poor application and/or research Grade

2

OBJECTIVES – Are the project objectives achievable, and can the project be said to have reasonable value for the research field or society? WORKPLAN AND RESOURCES – Is the work plan sound in relation to the objectives and description of work, and achievable within the timeframe and budget? Is the methodology sound? Are there deficiencies or redundant elements in the project plan? CONSORTIUM PARTNERSHIP – Is the consortium / research team sufficiently qualified and competent, and is the distribution of effort among partners reasonable/plausible? MANAGEMENT – Is the project management sound and sufficient? OTHER ISSUES recommendation? – Have you any other comments, concerns or

4

5

6 7

2010-01-08 - 02:20:17

b4b43d50-6926-4f4e-bc39-6591c2c5c349.doc

Page 1 af 1


				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:5
posted:1/8/2010
language:English
pages:1