These notes are to assist cataloguers and those training them to index correctly. They are derived partly from Mesh and partly from experience of indexing and using SWIMS. 1. Call up the Subject Headings in SWIMS in two different ways: o First from an item record – the default presentation is Subject Headings (incl. preferred terms) o Secondly from the Workspace Manager – the default presentation is Subject Headings (All subject types) o Look through the various presentations of subject headings and their uses. E. g. (All subject types) will tell you what type of heading it is, Mesh, WMesh, RCH etc and how many hits there are for each heading; (Exact Match) will give you only the term you type in – this is useful for terms such as Child or Adult, where you know that you only need that term but normally it will call up hundreds of variants. o The presentations which are most useful are Preferred Terms, Exact Match and All subject types, but you may also find Retrieve all Variants useful as it will indicate terms related to the subject you have typed in – try Mental Disorders as an example; Retrieve Preferred Terms will give a list of preferred terms only and if you want to see nonpreferred terms, look at Subject Heading Search (non-preferred terms only). o Orphan Terms are headings which have not been used in cataloguing. 2. Look at the different types of headings. Mesh 2004 was downloaded by FDI. Subsequent changes in the way of additions and deletions to Mesh will be dealt with by the Cataloguing Group. See below for updating of Mesh by NLM. WMesh is Wessex Mesh. These are a number of headings which have been added by us over the years to accommodate concepts not included in Mesh, mostly British organisations, such as the Department of Health, or concepts peripheral to the interests of the NLM, such as Offenders, Mentally Disordered. OMesh. These are out-dated terms which used to be allowable in Mesh, such as the old form subheadings, now replaced by Publication Types. These should NEVER be used. NBT, RCH, Plymouth, Cornwall College etc. These are terms used by libraries who had devised their own headings which were brought over by data conversion. These should NEVER be used
3. All headings except Mesh and WMesh should be removed as the catalogue is tidied. If a cataloguer finds any heading but these two used in a record, they should be deleted by using the “Delete item” icon and replaced by a Mesh or WMesh term. 4. When selecting a heading for a work being catalogued, only Mesh or WMesh terms should be selected, however tempting the alternatives seem to be, this rule is not to be broken. 5. Although all cataloguers should be tidying individual records as they find them, only the Cataloguing Group can tidy Authority Files. When tidying an individual record, you may find that a term is repeated as a result of data conversion. Remember to refresh the screen when you have deleted a heading as duplicated headings both disappear when one is deleted and you may need to put it back in again.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 1 of 12
Stages of indexing We now move to the principles of how to chose a subject heading when cataloguing. These rules apply whatever system you are working in. Cataloguers should assume that they will need 20 minutes to catalogue a new work. This will ensure that they do not try to rush the work because too short a time is available. Much of this time should be spent in selecting the classification and subject headings. Readers often want to see what works are available on a particular subject. If the subject heading has not been chosen carefully, they will not find all of the material available. The best search strategy will fail if indexing is poor. The Analytical or interpretative stage. Identify the index-worthy elements. Read carefully and understand the title, remembering that titles do not necessarily reflect the content of the work. Read the chapter headings, and if necessary, also the introduction and any information on the cover. Look at the content of the item if there is any ambiguity or doubt about the subject matter. Bear in mind the greater specificity of subject matter in grey literature than in general textbooks. Look on the title page verso or in Locatorplus on the NLM website for information provided by the National Library of Medicine. http://locatorplus.gov Try a literature search on Medline for the subject and look at the terms used for the articles.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 2 of 12
The selective stage. Understand the meaning of the subject heading. Use MeSH browser www.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/meshhome.html to look at the scope notes and annotations if the term is not clear. Use MeSH browser to ensure that all related terms, synonyms etc have been examined. Ensure specificity of the term by using any necessary subheadings. Check the availability of any subheadings on MeSH browser or Worldview. Check consistency of use of the term within the catalogue for earlier editions, related works etc, but do not assume that the earlier cataloguer was correct. Remember that MeSH is altered every year and that a term you may be familiar with, may have been changed.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 3 of 12
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 4 of 12
QUALITIES OF THE INDEXING OPERATION
CONFORMITY Indexers must adhere to the content of Mesh and to its cross references. They must follow the hierarchy of the headings (the Trees) and the policies governing their use. CONSISTENCY Indexers must apply these practices consistently, using headings in the same way each time so that a searcher may rely on their practices and even predict their application.
SPECIFICITY Indexers are committed to the greatest possible specificity. If the title covers several specific subjects indented under a broader heading in one Tree, use up to 3 individual specific headings. If more than 3 specific headings are used, the cataloguer should use the broader heading in that Tree. This applies only within the same Tree, across Trees, use specific headings. This also applies to subheadings.
JUDGMENT Indexers must draw on their familiarity with the subject field, use the cataloguer's notes provided and differentiate discussion from mere mention of a subject. They should think about where a reader would expect to look for such a work. MULTIPLICITY Indexers should use as many headings as they deem necessary to describe the content of the work. However, this does not mean that every topic covered needs to be detailed. E. g. the Oxford Textbook of Medicine does not need 40 subject headings to cover every possible disease dealt with.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 5 of 12
SPECIALTIES The use of the specialty headings is one of the biggest headaches to cataloguers but in most cases the rules are quite clear In the Tree structure of Mesh there are two categories which cause indexing problems, G1 Biological Sciences and G2 - Health Occupations. The definition for G1 states “Terms here are almost never used to describe organs or diseases since the aspects they represent are better expressed as subheadings.” The definition for G2 states “They are used for the specialties themselves or for the practitioners of those specialty when there is no Mesh term for the practitioner.” When you read the scope notes for these terms, it is quite clear that they are describing the practice of that branch of medicine, not the illnesses dealt with by the practitioners. Scope notes are included in Worldview by calling up the heading and looking at Details by double-clicking or using the Details icon. They are also on the Mesh browser. However, as always, there are some problems. There are some subjects dealt with in books in a very general way for which the use of a subheading is not appropriate. ANATOMY is one of them. Mesh expects an indexer to be able to use the subheading, /anatomy & physiology with the organ or system concerned but this is not possible with a general textbook on anatomy. In this case, where there is no alternative the G1 heading may be used.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 6 of 12
Topical subheadings afford a convenient means of grouping together constantly recurring aspects of a subject, for instance, the anatomy, physiology or pathology of an organ; the cause, epidemiology or treatment of a disease. A topical subheading will always answer the question "What aspect of this main heading is the author writing about?" When indexers have decided on the main headings, they should then consider the standpoint from which the author treats each subject. This assists the searcher to limit their search only to the aspect of the main subject which interests them. Many books will require more than one subheading to cover their content e.g. LIVER /anatomy and LIVER /metabolism. If the aspects of an item do not fit comfortably into the topical subheadings available to the category of the main heading, it is preferable to use none rather than a wrong or misleading one. No more than 2 subheadings should be used at a time, if more are needed, use just the main heading with no subheadings.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 7 of 12
Tree Structures By using the Mesh Browser, you can familiarise yourself with the Tree Structures. These are hierarchical arrangements of headings by subject matter, rather than alphabetical arrangements and they can also be found at the back of printed Mesh. The Trees can be used for two purposes. The main one is to look for alternative headings. If you have selected a heading which seems not quite right, the Tree can lead you to an associated heading which could fit the topic more closely. The other purpose is to check on subheadings which are attached to Trees. Topical subheadings are assigned both by categories and to specific trees within categories. Indexers are allowed to use for any main heading only those topical subheadings listed for the category to which the main heading belongs. Do not try to add a subheading which you think will be useful if it is not in the list assigned to that heading. Sometimes a topical subheading assigned legally to a main heading by category makes a nonsensical combination. It is always necessary to check to ensure that a topical subheading can be used as specific instructions as to the availability of particular topical subheadings is laid out under each heading in MeSH browser as well as on Worldview.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 8 of 12
Changes to MeSH in recent years Experienced cataloguers may expect to add form, geographic and language subheadings to MeSH headings but these were deleted by NLM some years ago. Instead, additional headings are used for Geographic terms and Publication Types. Language is indicated in the Marc record so no provision is made for that and in the event of a library having a book in a language other than English, the language should be indicated in the notes field. Some geographic locations are already included in MeSH but these are generally countries. If you wish to add a local area or town, for instance to indicate a local policy, you should ask your WDC Cataloguing Group rep to add the locality for you. Make sure, if you wish to indicate the form of an item, that you use the correct method. In many cases the SWIMS input page will assist, for instance with audiovisual items it is no longer necessary to add a Publication type as this is indicated in the Media type field. If it is necessary to indicate a Publication type, make sure that you chose the heading with [Publication Type] after it. There is sometimes a Mesh heading with the same name but a different meaning, such as Atlases. The Mesh heading Atlases should only be used for geographic atlases; the Publication Type is used for medical works consisting of pictures with explanatory text. Check Mesh Browser or the detailed page of the subject heading to look at the definition and/or scope note. If you wish to indicate age-related aspects, you should add the appropriate main heading such as ADULT or CHILD, PRESCHOOL; the same applies to the term PREGNANCY but note that there are some precoordinated terms such as PREGNANCY IN ADOLESCENCE which may deal with the topic more succinctly. Instructions for cataloguers are available in the NLM web pages at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/catpractices2006.html which will give more detail on changes to practice each year.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 9 of 12
INDEXING TOOLS In order to index correctly, there are certain tools which it is essential to be familiar with. Cataloguers should expect to spend 20 minutes on average on cataloguing and classifying a book. Much of this time should be spent in examining not only the book, but also the tools mentioned below and in thinking carefully about the match between the selected term and the content of the item being indexed. NEVER ASSUME YOU KNOW A TERM WITHOUT LOOKING IT UP. Mesh headings are revised every year and it is essential that cataloguers work with the current issue of each item below. Mesh This may seem obvious, but it is helpful to look at the hard copy for a heading which is elusive. The Tree structure at the back can be invaluable in leading you away from an alphabetical arrangement to an hierarchical organisation. The Subject Index to the Wessex Classification. This contains all headings used in the catalogue to the date of the production of the list. It includes many cross references, many annotations and definitions from Mesh and some subject headings created locally. See next section. Mesh Browser This is the essential tool for checking on scope notes and correct subheadings. You can also go from a term in an article in Dialog to a definition if you have tried looking for a subject via a literature search of articles. Click on the yellow symbol next to the subject heading listed under the article.
NLM Cataloguing Guide See above for the URL. Some notes are also available at the front of MeSH each year
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 10 of 12
THE WESSEX SUBJECT INDEX The Wessex Subject Index (WSI) to the Wessex Classification Scheme was created in the 1980s by the library staff of the then Wessex Region to facilitate the use of the Classification scheme. The decision was made to stay with Mesh terms but to add new terms which are generally needed to express concepts concerning the NHS and its organisation. Wessex Mesh terms. Occasionally, a new term will be added for an important concept which has not yet been picked up by Mesh. Wessex Mesh, as the additional terms are called, are based on the construction of Mesh, they are assigned to a Tree structure, and will have the subheadings assigned to Mesh terms in that tree. For example, General Practice is the term preferred over Family Practice and will have the same subheadings added to it. Cross references and explanatory additions In addition to the new terms, the Subject Index has tried to be very responsive to the needs of indexers. Mesh is random in its cross-references and an indexer can often find it frustrating and difficult to find a correct term. The users of the Wessex Subject Index are encouraged to add cross-references to their own copies of the index and to report these centrally so that all users can benefit. The WSI also adds help for classificationists. Where is it considered useful, the NLM Mesh scope notes have been added. The Tree structure indicators are added to send a classificationist to look for allied terms and if a term is used in a variety of contexts, the more specific or related aspects are shown underneath the heading. This only applies if there is no specific term to describe the class mark. HOUSING HV900-25 G3 N1 Accommodation for nurses WX171 Accommodation for staff WX470 Design & architecture WX645 Doss houses HV925 Hostels HV925 Independent living housing WM864 Rent rebate HV247 See related HALFWAY HOUSES; HOMELESS PERSONS; HOMELESS YOUTH; POVERTY AREAS New terms If an indexer feels that a new term is necessary to describe a concept not yet covered, they should make a request to the editorial committee to have this added. However, if a term already exists in NLM Mesh, and has just not yet been used by the WSI, it can be selected and used, and if it is felt to be commonly needed, the editorial board should be asked to add it to the index. It is intended for the WSI to be updated each year when the new NLM Mesh is issued. Users of the WSI are asked to keep a record of additions and changes throughout the year and send these to the address below each January, stating the name and address of the librarian so that if necessary further discussion can be held. A form which may be used is laid out below and can be modified to suit needs.
The editorial board is the Cataloguing Group of the SWIMS Project Board for the South West NHS libraries and the e-mail address of the Chair is firstname.lastname@example.org, all requests for changes and help should be addressed to her. D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 11 of 12
Name of librarian
Name of library service
New subject heading
Already in NLM Mesh?
Other links to reference needed.
Other corrections needed
Knock-on effects of change?
This table was created as a Word table and should be used simply as the basis for queries you want to send in. Use any or all of the boxes or add others to explain what you want to add or to point out any errors. It is suggested that you either write additions and corrections on a hard copy, or add to an electronic version in a different font colour as you make them. In January each year, either post or e-mail the corrections, on a form based on this one, to the e-mail address above. If you want a new cross-reference, please try to think of all the headings it may link to, not just the one which prompted your request. e.g. Groups see DIAGNOSTIC RELATED GROUPS; ENCOUNTER GROUPS; ETHNIC GROUPS; MINORITY GROUPS; PEER GROUPS; SELF-HELP GROUPS; SOCIAL IDENTIFICATION Corrections may be simply typing or spelling errors, floating cross-references or confusing instructions. The knock-on effects will be the necessity to change further headings as a result of the correction.
D:\Docstoc\Working\pdf\a1b184d3-5a3d-4c9f-97e4-56306a13ac47.doc Created 7/7/2004, amended 14/6/2005 and on 18/4/2006 by Bobby Noyes Page 12 of 12