Research Proposal Section II Rough Draft - DOC - DOC

							                                 Research Proposal:
                       Section II Rough Draft Feedback Sheet

Student Name:

APA Review:

         Yes No Needs NA            Appropriate Format?           Refer to APA Manual
                Work                                               beginning on page..
                                  Title Page                      10 & 287
                                  Page header                     288
                                  Title at top of first text page 298
                                  Citation of sources             120 & 207
                                  Seriation                       115
                                  Heading levels                  111 & 289
                                  Heading format                  113
                                  Quoting sources                 117
                                  Reference list                  215
                                  Use of numbers                  122
                                  Grammar                         40
                                  Punctuation                     78
                                  Tables                          147
                                  Figures (lit map)               176 & 302
                                  Appendix (literature map)       205 & 299



Literature Review (Draft) (An X does not indicate a value judgment, only if the item
was addressed. All items need to be addressed.)

         Yes No Sometimes Implied                             Elements
                                            Introductory Statement
                                                    Restates topic/problem (as extension
                                                    of Section I)
                                                    Includes marker sentence that
                                                    signals contents of literature review
                                                    (themes/headings) (e.g., “The
                                                    following review of the literature…”
                                            Themes identified – study by study review
                                            grouped under these themes
                                            Study-by-study format (includes abstracts
                                            and analysis of at least 8- 10 empirical
                                            studies)
                                                    Abstracts include: Problem,
                                                    Questions, Data Collection, and
                                                    Results/Findings
                                                 Analysis evidenced through critique
                                                 of study using guiding questions
                                         Transitional sentences from one
                                         heading/theme/study to the next
                                         Concluding statement
                                                 Theme summary (ies) – synthesis of
                                                 studies
                                                 Deficiencies – need for additional
                                                 research
                                                 Rationale for study – 3 to 4 reasons
                                         Literature Map
                                                 Figure included in Appendix
                                                 key terms indicated
                                                 3-4 groupings/themes identified
                                                 specific citations indicated within
                                                 each theme
                                                 “my study” indicated and connected
                                                 to other branches of literature
                                                 literature map appropriately referred
                                                 to in text to intro lit review and
                                                 themes etc.
       Note. Table based on Creswell, pages 110-121

Comments

  1.
  2.
  3.
  4.