About Us General
Contact Politics
HHR Store/Donate Culture/Arts
HHR TV/ Blog Radio Featured
Resources & Blogroll International Affairs
The John Langston Forum HHR Contributors
Why We Are Republican
Opinion/Reviews
Political/Music Interviews & Profiles
What Flier Got Wrong
By HHR | December 2nd, 2009 | Category: Opinion/Reviews |
STAY UP TO DATE
HipHopRepublican.com (RSS) Comments RSS)
By John S. Wilson
Recently Dr. Jeffrey Flier, Dean of Harvard Medical School, weighed in on the health care reform bills circulating in Congress in an opinion piece in The Wall Street Journal. I welcome his perspective because I had yet to hear it and firmly believe all stakeholders in the business of health care should be heard from. However, I find some aspects of his argument puzzling and others downright disingenuous. Flier begins his argument by stating:
HHR NETWORK
“Our health-care system suffers from problems of cost, access and quality, and needs major reform. Tax policy drives employment-based insurance; this begets overinsurance and drives costs upward while creating inequities for the unemployed and selfemployed. A regulatory morass limits innovation. And deep flaws in Medicare and Medicaid drive spending without optimizing care.”
MORE IN OPINION/REVIEWS
What Flier Got Wrong Hip-Hop Conservatism:Pure Unregulated Capitalism (Part 1) Is A GOP Litmus Test Becoming a Reality? Going Rogue: A “Palin”tologist’s Review Health Care and the Moral Imperative All articles in 'Opinion/Reviews' »
Flier exhibits a firm grasp of the many vexing problems that precipitate the need for reform. But what about the solutions that are contained within the Senate and House versions of the bill? He seems to ignore those. These are the three omissions I find particularly troubling. First, he does not mention that employment-based insurance will be buttressed with a public option. This option would be open to those who are uninsured or are unable to afford employer-based coverage. Also, the public option would directly negotiate payment rates with doctors and providers, instead of using Medicare payment rates. By initiating a new public option plan - that the previously uninsured are phased into over a number of years - Congress is able to extend coverage to the millions who are uninsured without having the adverse effect of overburdening the primary care system, which the state of Massachusetts fell victim to when they passed universal insurance. Second, to combat what Flier notes as “overinsurance [that] drives costs upward while creating inequities…” the Senate version would implement a 40 percent excise tax on employer-sponsored group health plans with premiums over $8,500 for individual coverage and $23,000 for each family. Such plans have been colloquially known as Cadillac Plans: rarely do they require deductibles, co-payments, other limits or require authorization. And it is thought that they drive up health care costs by inducing people to use more health care resources. Moreover, insurers would pay the 40% tax when plans exceed these predetermined limits. This will deter insurers from offering these types of plans in the future. And that is not the only cost-slimming measure within either bill being currently debated. The Obama Administration has consistently extolled the benefits of implementing more evidencebased medicine. We know that it is possible. Brent James, Dr. John Wennberg, Dr. Elliot Fisher, and Dr. Jonathan Skinner are just a few of the leaders in the (what I call) evidence-based medicine movement, and their results are notable and can be duplicated. Third, Flier correctly notes that “…deep flaws in Medicare and Medicaid drive spending without optimizing care”. This is why both programs were ground zero for any meaningful reform. Both Senate and House bills distill between 404-436 billion dollars from Medicare. Over a fourth of that total - between 117-118 billion dollars - , would be cut from the Medicare Advantage Program, which many considered to be a boon to the drug companies in the first place when the program was written into law as part of the Medicare Part D legislation.
RECENT POSTS
What Flier Got Wrong “What We Value is PRECIOUS” - The Film Review: by Leette Eaton- White Schwarzenegger Picks Latino “Abel Maldonado” for Lt-Gov of California The American Poor: A Strange Form of Poverty Unlocking The Gates of Hell: A Film Review of Precious Hip-Hop Conservatism:Pure Unregulated Capitalism (Part 1) HHR TV SHOW - Interview with Ex Gang Member & Young Republicans of LA County HHR Music Video of the Week: Melanie Fiona - It Kills Me Joe Watkins: Candidate for Pennsylvania Lt. Governor Happy Thanksgiving
In conclusion, it isn’t that Dean Flier did not ask pertinent questions, it’s that it seems as though he did not look to the bill to answer those questions. What I am seeing more and more with this reform bill is a pretty simple fact: to like it one actually has to read it. POPULAR TAGS Generated by www.PDFonFly.com at 12/2/2009 9:49:55 AM URL: http://hiphoprepublican.com/opinion/2009/12/02/what-flier-got-wrong/
John has written extensively in areas of public policy exploring fissures in health policy, specifically residency and doctor shortages and health care finance, education, mortgage reform, and the public health effects of gun control. He is a B.S. Candidate in sociology at Virginia Commonwealth University and blogs at policydiary.com.
Share This:
Add new tag Africa African-Americans
Barack Obama black black Republicans blacks Bush Canada CNN Conservatism Conservatives crime debate democrats
HARLEM Health Care Heathcare Herb London hip-hop
Election florida gay
GOP
kanye West Lenny
McAllister Liberals
McCain MICHAEL STEELE Moderate Republicans moderates new york city NY-23 Tags: Dean of Harvard Medical School, Dr. Jeffrey Flier, health-care system, The Wall Street Journal
Republican Republican palin Party Republicans RNC sarah
Race racism
urban
Obama President Obama public option
socialism
LEAVE COMMENT
Name (required)
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
5
6 Submit Comment
Visit Hip-Hop Republicans
What Color Is a Conservative? J. C. Watts, Chris... Best Price $0.01 or Buy New $12.56
Privacy Information
Soldier Karen DeYoung Best Price $4.77 or Buy New $12.21
Privacy Information
Generated by www.PDFonFly.com at 12/2/2009 9:49:55 AM URL: http://hiphoprepublican.com/opinion/2009/12/02/what-flier-got-wrong/