livingston_final_09

Shared by: chrstphr
-
Stats
views:
221
posted:
12/8/2009
language:
English
pages:
412
Document Sample
scope of work template
							STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-3 ****************** Private Rd 192.4-2-3 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,672 A'brial Renee Pine Plains 134201 3,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,672 203 Hill Rd Twin Lakes 3,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,672 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 174.00 DPTH 169.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,672 TO M EAST-0684240 NRTH-1178041 DEED BOOK C416 PG-F2081 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,246 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-5 ****************** 203 Hill Rd Lot 165N 192.4-2-5 260 Seasonal res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 A'briat Renee Walz Pine Plains 134201 20,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 73,440 203 Hill Rd Twin Lakes 73,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 73,440 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 178.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,880 BANKN140687 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 73,440 TO M EAST-0684260 NRTH-1177951 DEED BOOK C0298 PG-F2335 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-7 ****************** LOT 164N Hill Rd 192.4-2-7 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,768 A'briat Renee Walz Pine Plains 134201 1,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,768 203 Hill Rd Twin Lakes 1,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,768 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 182.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,768 TO M BANKN140687 EAST-0684240 NRTH-1177891 DEED BOOK C0298 PG-F2335 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-83 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-83 312 Vac w/imprv BAS STAR 41854 0 0 21,352 Acker James Germantown 103602 8,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 Acker Renee FRNT 133.00 DPTH 74.22 21,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 Heissler, Roberta EAST-0685728 NRTH-1194063 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 665 Route 19 DEED BOOK C520 PG-F665 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 21,352 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-35 ***************** Baxter Rd 201.8-1-35 260 Seasonal res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Adams Carol B Pine Plains 134201 26,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,952 18 Baxter Rd Bk18 Pg1374 85,952 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,952 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 59,392 EAST-0682458 NRTH-1173818 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,952 TO M DEED BOOK 585 PG-2138 FULL MARKET VALUE 122,789 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 2 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-31 ****************** C R 10 160.-1-31 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 163,200 Adventist Home Hudson 100600 163,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 163,200 PO Box 218 ACRES 39.00 163,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,200 Livingston, NY 12541-0210 EAST-0684505 NRTH-1206200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 163,200 TO M DEED BOOK C0325 PG-F0070 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 233,143 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-6.200 *************** Twin Dr 171.-1-6.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Agate Michael J Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 205,904 Agate Lisa Lynk 205,904 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 205,904 8 Twin Dr ACRES 1.04 BANKH080005 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 179,344 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686885 NRTH-1200835 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,904 TO M DEED BOOK 00821 PG-00019 FULL MARKET VALUE 294,149 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-15.120 ************** Water St 152.-1-15.120 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,700 Agostino John Copake-Taconic 102801 38,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,700 Agostino Minnie ACRES 5.00 45,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 45,700 60 Mitchell St EAST-0699390 NRTH-1213569 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 45,700 TO M Stamford, CT 06902 DEED BOOK 0653 PG-00306 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-20 ****************** Off Churchtown Rd 141.-1-20 323 Vacant rural COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,224 Aisenberrg James Copake-Taconic 102801 1,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,224 Aisenberg Suzanne FRNT 40.00 DPTH 180.00 1,224 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,224 45 East 85Th St Apt 8d EAST-0703112 NRTH-1217606 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,224 TO M New York, NY 10028 DEED BOOK C378 PG-F1256 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,749 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-61 ****************** 331 Cemetary Rd 149.-1-61 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Albertson Lorraine Germantown 103602 37,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 Rockefeller Laurie FRNT 130.00 DPTH 330.00 116,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 331 Cemetery Rd EAST-0670898 NRTH-1215023 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,856 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0658 PG-00225 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,416 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 166,309 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 3 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-76 ****************** 381 CR 10 149.-1-76 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Albino Elizabeth Anne Germantown 103602 46,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,376 381 County Route 10 #2 C 148,376 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,376 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 2.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 98,106 EAST-0672472 NRTH-1213196 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,376 TO M DEED BOOK C478 PG-1307 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,966 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-9.120 *************** C R 19 170.-2-9.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Albizu Benedicto Jr Germantown 103602 47,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 146,608 575 Co Rt 19 ACRES 2.71 BANKC070170 146,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 146,608 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686265 NRTH-1195894 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,048 DEED BOOK 0621 PG-00202 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,608 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 209,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-24 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-24 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Albright Cheryl L Hudson 100600 40,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 184,400 Simmons Jason Micro 94-118 184,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 184,400 22 Keir Ct ACRES 1.10 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 157,840 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686620 NRTH-0120290 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 184,400 TO M DEED BOOK 577 PG-1730 FULL MARKET VALUE 263,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-65 ****************** 19 Twin Dr 171.-1-65 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Albright Leonard Germantown 103602 39,690 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 19 Twin Dr Lynk Subdivision 198,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,728 ACRES 1.00 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,288 TO M EAST-0687305 NRTH-1201086 DEED BOOK 0590 PG-00408 FULL MARKET VALUE 283,269 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-6 ******************* LOT 17 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-6 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Aldrich Adam Hudson 100600 39,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 180,472 Adldrich Rebekkah Micro 94-118 & 95-283 180,472 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 180,472 33 Mahikan Dr ACRES 1.14 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 153,912 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686102 NRTH-1202633 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 180,472 TO M DEED BOOK 605 PG-1538 FULL MARKET VALUE 257,817 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 4 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-6.120 *************** CR 19 171.-1-6.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Alessi Robin Germantown 103602 27,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,840 PO Box 516 Micro 4852 115,840 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,840 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 0.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,280 EAST-0687245 NRTH-1200756 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,840 TO M DEED BOOK C381 PG-F0109 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,486 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-5 ******************* 11 Stephen Dr 139.-1-5 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Alfred & Joanne Turek Trust Germantown 103602 50,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 228,208 11 Stephen Dr Micro 2408 228,208 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 228,208 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 177,938 EAST-0678769 NRTH-1224898 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,208 TO M PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 DEED BOOK 657 PG-42 Turek Alfred FULL MARKET VALUE 326,011 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-41 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-41 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 245,900 Alger Dennis Hudson 100600 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 245,900 Alger Mary micro06-105 245,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 245,900 123 Willowbrook Rd ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 245,900 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0695950 NRTH-0120470 DEED BOOK 584 PG-639 FULL MARKET VALUE 351,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-11 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-11 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Algie David III Hudson 100600 35,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Algie Joan ACRES 1.00 154,350 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,742 PO Box 183 EAST-0686746 NRTH-1205404 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,742 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0526 PG-00767 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,790 FULL MARKET VALUE 220,500 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,350 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 154,350 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-43 ****************** Hapeman Rd 192.-1-43 920 Priv Hunt/Fi COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 145,928 Allen Stanley T Pine Plains 134201 66,743 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 145,928 Apfelbaum Polly ACRES 10.00 145,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 145,928 4 E Shore Dr EAST-0681170 NRTH-1177845 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,928 TO M Princeton, NJ 08540 DEED BOOK C0343 PG-F2393 FULL MARKET VALUE 208,469 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-36 ****************** Marty Rd. Lot 47 182.-1-36 220 2 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 176,936 Almeida David Germantown 103602 47,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 176,936 Almeida Gloria Micro 3291 176,936 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 176,936 356 Wurtenburg Rd ACRES 2.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,936 TO M Rhinebeck, NY 12572 EAST-0690061 NRTH-1187272 DEED BOOK 0608 PG-00878 FULL MARKET VALUE 252,766 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-48.200 ************** 15 Half Circle Rd 149.-1-48.200 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Almstead Arthur Germantown 103602 34,700 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Almstead Sharon Micro #6031 187,816 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 171,251 15 Half Circle Rd ACRES 0.89 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 171,251 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669306 NRTH-1216252 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 161,256 DEED BOOK 0530 PG-00474 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 187,816 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 268,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-48.100 ************** 17 Half Circle Rd 149.-1-48.100 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 23,147 0 0 Almstead Sharon Germantown 103602 48,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Wambach Eileen Papp Fran ACRES 2.96 115,736 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,589 17 Half Circle Rd EAST-0669216 NRTH-1215959 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,736 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C416 PG-F1554 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,466 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,337 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,736 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-10.200 ************** US 9 140.-1-10.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 66,368 Alvarez John & Sons Inc Hudson 100600 66,368 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 66,368 3572 Rte 9 Micro 93-176 66,368 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,368 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 7.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 66,368 TO M EAST-0692546 NRTH-1220905 DEED BOOK 00744 PG-00097 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,811 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-46.112 ************** Rt. 9 Lot 1 161.-1-46.112 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 70,040 Alvarez John & Sons Inc Hudson 100600 70,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 70,040 3572 Rte 9 Micro 6699 70,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,040 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.85 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 70,040 TO M EAST-0686279 NRTH-1204164 DEED BOOK 0597 PG-00014 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,057 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-69 ****************** Rt. 9 Livingston Lot 2 161.-1-69 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,992 Alvarez John & Sons Inc Hudson 100600 36,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,992 3572 Rte 9 Micro 6699 36,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,992 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.39 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,992 TO M EAST-0686276 NRTH-1204344 DEED BOOK 0597 PG-00014 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-14 ****************** US 9 140.-1-14 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 Alvarez John A Son Inc Hudson 100600 120,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 3572 Rte 9 ACRES 8.39 120,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0693037 NRTH-1220336 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,768 TO M DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00411 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-15 ****************** US 9 140.-1-15 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,320 Alvarez John A Son Inc Hudson 100600 50,320 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,320 3572 Rte 9 ACRES 1.38 50,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,320 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0693078 NRTH-1219846 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,320 TO M DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00411 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,886 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-16 ****************** US 9 140.-1-16 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,640 Alvarez John A Sons Inc Hudson 100600 49,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,640 3572 Rte 9 Micro 5655 49,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,640 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.29 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,640 TO M EAST-0693049 NRTH-1219556 DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00409 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-17.200 ************** 3461 SR 9 140.-1-17.200 240 Rural res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Alvarez John Hudson 100600 70,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 312,392 Alvarez Margaret Micro 96-256 312,392 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 312,392 3461 Rte 9 ACRES 10.60 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 262,122 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692018 NRTH-1220371 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 312,392 TO M DEED BOOK 00407 PG-00187 FULL MARKET VALUE 446,274 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-30 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-30 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 Alvarez John D Copake-Taconic 102801 58,616 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 45 Jacqueline Rd ACRES 2.55 58,616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696989 NRTH-1219094 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,616 TO M DEED BOOK 00664 PG-00062 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,737 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-12.111 ************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-12.111 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,264 Alvarez John II Copake-Taconic 102801 54,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,264 45 Jacqueline Rd ACRES 1.95 54,264 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,264 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0695960 NRTH-1218962 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,264 TO M DEED BOOK 0664 PG-00064 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-28 ****************** 45 Jacqueline Rd 141.-1-28 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Alvarez Judy E Copake-Taconic 102801 29,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 188,904 45 Jacqueline Rd FRNT 166.39 DPTH 162.54 188,904 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 188,904 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696889 NRTH-1219304 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 162,344 DEED BOOK C540 PG-F1937 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 188,904 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 269,863 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-1 ******************* Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-1 120 Field crops COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 Alvarez Thomas Copake-Taconic 102801 43,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 Alvarez Karen ACRES 12.60 54,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 30 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0697208 NRTH-1219654 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,400 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00439 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-21 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-21 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,128 Alvarez Thomas Copake-Taconic 102801 3,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,128 Alvarez John ACRES 2.90 3,128 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,128 30 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0697019 NRTH-1219194 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,128 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0508 PG-00618 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,469 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-12 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 151.-1-12 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,424 Alvarez Thomas Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,424 Alvarez Karen J ACRES 1.00 215,424 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 215,424 30 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0694524 NRTH-1216839 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,424 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0512 PG-00749 FULL MARKET VALUE 307,749 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-13 ****************** 30 Bells Pond Rd 151.-1-13 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Alvarez Thomas Hudson 100600 47,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,700 Alvarez Karen ACRES 4.60 65,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,700 30 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0694174 NRTH-1216688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,140 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0572 PG-00001 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 65,700 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 93,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-34 ****************** 18 Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-34 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Alvarez Thomas Red Hook 134801 17,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,700 Alvarez Karen FRNT 90.00 DPTH 278.37 65,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,700 30 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0676439 NRTH-1193735 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,140 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0489 PG-00635 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 65,700 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 93,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-36.100 ************** 96 Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-36.100 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 78,608 Alvarez Thomas A Hudson 100600 42,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 78,608 Alvarez Karen J ACRES 1.71 78,608 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,608 30 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0696127 NRTH-1205103 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 78,608 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 630 PG-2383 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-5.210 *************** Schneider Rd Par B 161.-1-5.210 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 216,240 Alvarez Timothy Hudson 100600 59,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 216,240 201 Schneider Rd Micro 9685 216,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 216,240 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 6.29 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 216,240 TO M EAST-0693698 NRTH-1209788 DEED BOOK 00688 PG-00089 FULL MARKET VALUE 308,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-29 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-29 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,128 Alverez Judy Copake-Taconic 102801 54,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,128 45 Jacqueline Rd ACRES 1.92 54,128 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,128 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696900 NRTH-1218834 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,128 TO M DEED BOOK 0664 PG-00060 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,326 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-9 ******************* US 9 140.-1-9 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 75,208 Alvrez John & Sons Inc Hudson 100600 75,208 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 75,208 3572 Rte 9 ACRES 4.90 75,208 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 75,208 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692205 NRTH-1221384 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 75,208 TO M DEED BOOK 0512 PG-00771 FULL MARKET VALUE 107,440 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 9 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-17.111 ************** SR 9 170.-1-17.111 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 300,000 Amrod Enterprises, LLC Red Hook 134801 81,765 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 300,000 92 Old Post Rd Micro 9058 300,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 300,000 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 6.78 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 300,000 TO M EAST-0677608 NRTH-1194617 DEED BOOK 565 PG-1295 FULL MARKET VALUE 428,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-17.112 ************** Us 9 & Rt 31 Lot 5 170.-1-17.112 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 Amrod Enterprises, LLC Red Hook 134801 52,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 92 Old Post Rd ACRES 1.67 52,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0677608 NRTH-1194617 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,360 TO M DEED BOOK 565 PG-1295 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-39 ****************** 571 White Birch Rd 138.-1-39 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Amuso James A Germantown 103602 30,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 249,100 Amuso Melissa P FRNT 100.00 DPTH 309.31 249,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 249,100 571 White Birch Rd EAST-0670020 NRTH-1219401 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 222,540 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 595 PG-2138 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 249,100 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 355,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-14 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-14 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 694,688 Anagnost Dino Red Hook 134801 62,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 694,688 Kordel John Micro 2679 694,688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 694,688 202 Buckwheat Bridge Rd ACRES 8.80 BANKC010665 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 694,688 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0679795 NRTH-1191012 DEED BOOK 00738 PG-00298 FULL MARKET VALUE 992,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-20.110 ************** Walkers Mills Rd 160.-1-20.110 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 465,800 Anavian Jozef Germantown 103602 132,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 465,800 303 E 57th St Micro 9525 & 94-262 465,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 465,800 New York, NY 10022 ACRES 20.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 465,800 TO M EAST-0675035 NRTH-1209051 DEED BOOK 00814 PG-00332 FULL MARKET VALUE 665,429 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 10 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-42 ****************** 40 Mener Rd 150.-1-42 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 Anderson Helen Germantown 103602 45,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 40 Mener Rd ACRES 2.20 104,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0674442 NRTH-1212990 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,992 TO M DEED BOOK C375 PG-F1253 FULL MARKET VALUE 149,989 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-15 ****************** 1589 CR 31 170.-1-15 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Anderson John Jr Red Hook 134801 33,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Anderson Denise ACRES 0.75 228,888 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 201,280 1589 Rte 31 EAST-0677196 NRTH-1195326 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 201,280 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0483 PG-00259 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 202,328 FULL MARKET VALUE 326,983 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,888 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-16 ****************** 1607 Blue Hill Rd 170.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Anderson John L Red Hook 134801 35,300 DIS VET/CT 41141 40,650 40,650 0 1607 Blue Hill Rd FRNT 125.00 DPTH 300.02 116,144 AGED T 41803 0 11,972 0 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0677297 NRTH-1195176 AGED C&S 41805 19,154 0 46,458 DEED BOOK 0587 PG-00662 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,920 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,732 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,914 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,416 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,144 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-69 ****************** Rte 9 151.-1-69 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Andrews James E Hudson 100600 52,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 165,000 3168 rte. 9 Changed parcel # to match 165,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 165,000 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 02-03 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,440 ACRES 2.72 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 165,000 TO M EAST-0690460 NRTH-0121320 DEED BOOK 599 PG-2301 FULL MARKET VALUE 235,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-1.220 *************** Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-1.220 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 7,344 Andrews Peter Germantown 103602 7,344 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 7,344 Andrews Martha Micro-11467 7,344 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 7,344 PO Box 41 ACRES 1.03 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 7,344 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688392 NRTH-1192118 DEED BOOK 0655 PG-00041 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,491 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 11 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-5 ******************* Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-5 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Andrews Peter J Germantown 103602 63,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 196,112 Andrews Martha Micro 3053 196,112 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 196,112 PO Box 41 ACRES 10.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 169,552 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688161 NRTH-1192418 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 196,112 TO M DEED BOOK 0603 PG-00671 FULL MARKET VALUE 280,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-41 ****************** Private Rd 150.-1-41 151 Fruit crop COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 Angelone Catherine Germantown 103602 79,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 149 Stonetown Rd ACRES 12.00 120,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 Ringwood, NJ 07456 EAST-0675142 NRTH-1213101 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,768 TO M DEED BOOK C514 PG-F891 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-46 ****************** 636 CR 10 150.-1-46 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 220,000 Anton Frederick Germantown 103602 46,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 220,000 Anton Tracey ACRES 2.70 BANKN140687 220,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 220,000 636 County Rte 10 EAST-0678445 NRTH-1211578 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 220,000 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C431 PG-F794 FULL MARKET VALUE 314,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-23 ****************** Howe Rd 139.-1-23 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Anuska Michael Hudson 100600 41,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,424 156 White Birch Rd FRNT 277.00 DPTH 175.50 130,424 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,424 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674169 NRTH-1224739 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,864 DEED BOOK 00725 PG-00270 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,424 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 186,320 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-65 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-65 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 105,081 105,081 105,081 Apple Barn Farm Co Llc Germantown 103602 106,896 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,815 Brian Shea Member ACRES 13.46 106,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,815 Attn: Mary Beth Boruta EAST-0676089 NRTH-1212223 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,815 414 County Route 10 DEED BOOK C0333 PG-F0711 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,815 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,709 105,081 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 12 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-66 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-66 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 121,280 121,280 121,280 Apple Barn Farm Co Llc Germantown 103602 211,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 228,720 Brian Shea Member ACRES 44.07 350,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 228,720 Attn: Mary Beth Boruta EAST-0677199 NRTH-1211990 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 228,720 414 County Route 10 DEED BOOK C0333 PG-F0711 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,720 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 FULL MARKET VALUE 500,000 121,280 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-67 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-67 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 329,506 329,506 329,506 Apple Barn Farm Co Llcc Germantown 103602 427,584 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 98,078 Brian Shea Member ACRES 92.41 427,584 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 98,078 Attn: Mary Beth Boruta EAST-0677492 NRTH-1210361 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 98,078 414 County Route 10 DEED BOOK C0333 PG-F0711 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 98,078 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 FULL MARKET VALUE 610,834 329,506 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-2 ******************* SR 9 161.-1-2 710 Manufacture COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1035,300 Apple Partners, LLC Hudson 100600 165,396 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1035,300 2990 SR 9 see 161.-1-2.09 1035,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1035,300 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 1293 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1035,300 TO M ACRES 12.00 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 1035,300 TO M PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 EAST-0689020 NRTH-1208689 Apple Partners, LLC DEED BOOK 656 PG-2172 FULL MARKET VALUE 1479,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-3 ******************* SR 9G 138.-1-3 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,248 Aquilio Dominick Hudson 100600 43,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,248 Aquilio Norma ACRES 2.60 43,248 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,248 100 County Rte 10 EAST-0671578 NRTH-1225314 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,248 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0519 PG-01194 FULL MARKET VALUE 61,783 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 13 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-3 ******************* 100 CR 10 149.-1-3 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 157,722 157,722 0 Aquilio Norma Germantown 103602 52,800 AGED C 41802 9,989 0 0 100 Cr 10 ACRES 2.78 177,700 AGED T&S 41806 0 7,991 71,080 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669150 NRTH-0121730 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 DEED BOOK 602 PG-473 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 9,989 FULL MARKET VALUE 253,857 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 11,987 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,350 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 177,700 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-40 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-40 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Armstrong John D Germantown 103602 41,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 133,448 Armstrong Carol A ACRES 1.60 BANK0080490 133,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 133,448 1923 Route 8 EAST-0684801 NRTH-1187802 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 106,888 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 624 PG-161 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 133,448 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 190,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-5 ***************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-5 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 46,240 Arnold Robert Pine Plains 134201 31,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 46,240 37 Mulberry St Twin Lakes 46,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,240 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 128.55 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 46,240 TO M EAST-0682700 NRTH-1177768 DEED BOOK 555 PG-1101 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-41.200 ************** 731 Church Rd 161.-1-41.200 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 156,510 156,510 0 Arnone Michele Hudson 100600 53,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Arnone Gregory ACRES 4.62 158,032 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,522 731 Church Rd EAST-0695339 NRTH-1203731 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,522 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0526 PG-00498 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,472 FULL MARKET VALUE 225,760 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 158,032 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-9.112 *************** C R 19 170.-2-9.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Arsenault Brian Germantown 103602 36,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,784 585 Co Rt 19 Micro 10940 131,784 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,784 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.10 BANK0030385 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,224 EAST-0686085 NRTH-1195674 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 131,784 TO M DEED BOOK C350 PG-F2004 FULL MARKET VALUE 188,263 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 14 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-39.100 ************** 625 Pleasantvale Rd 201.-1-39.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Arsenault Ronnie Pine Plains 134201 45,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,560 625 Pleasantvale Rd ACRES 1.62 147,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,560 Tivoli, NY 12583-5216 EAST-0681251 NRTH-1172045 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,000 DEED BOOK C512 PG-F2422 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,560 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 210,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-17 ****************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Asalone Thomas Germantown 103602 45,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 311,032 20 Fifth Ave Micro 2804 311,032 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 311,032 New York, NY 10011 ACRES 1.40 BANK0180200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 284,472 EAST-0679170 NRTH-1224249 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 311,032 TO M DEED BOOK 0604 PG-00852 FULL MARKET VALUE 444,331 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-29.112 ************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-29.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,640 Asalone Thomas Germantown 103602 49,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,640 20 Fifth Ave Micro 2804 49,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,640 New York, NY 10011 ACRES 1.29 BANK0180200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,640 TO M EAST-0679390 NRTH-1224249 DEED BOOK 0604 PG-00852 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-27 **************** Mountainview Dr 192.20-1-27 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 Ascoli Robert Pine Plains 134201 19,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 62 2nd St #4 Bk22 Pg1602 0001 19,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 Athens, NY 12015-1326 FRNT 55.00 DPTH 118.35 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,040 TO M EAST-0683250 NRTH-1178049 DEED BOOK C459 PG-F1547 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-35 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 140.-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Athens Arthur Hudson 100600 58,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 187,544 Athens Victoria ACRES 3.36 187,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 187,544 117 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0696451 NRTH-1218343 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,984 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0563 PG-00162 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 187,544 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 267,920 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 15 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-10 ****************** 190 Old Sr 82 161.-1-10 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 203,048 Auder Michel Hudson 100600 52,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 203,048 335 Humboldt St Micro No. 4485 203,048 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 203,048 Brooklyn, NY 11211 ACRES 4.30 BANKN140687 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 203,048 TO M EAST-0698231 NRTH-1208107 DEED BOOK C0357 PG-F0530 FULL MARKET VALUE 290,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-35 ****************** 422 Old Sr 82 152.-1-35 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Austin Gerald A Hudson 100600 27,500 DIS VET/CT 41141 17,156 17,156 0 Austin Barbara Ann FRNT 170.00 DPTH 130.00 114,376 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 422 Water St Rd EAST-0697899 NRTH-1209166 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,655 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0426 PG-00576 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,655 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,394 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,106 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,376 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-23 ****************** Sr 9 170.-2-23 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,776 Autovino Melchiorre Red Hook 134801 49,776 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,776 Autovino Carmela ACRES 3.00 49,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,776 980 County Rte 6 EAST-0679157 NRTH-1194790 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,776 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0599 PG-00038 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,109 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-48.200 ************** OFF CR 19 192.-1-48.200 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,184 Avenia Peter Germantown 103602 101,184 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,184 Avenia Giulia Micro 9283 101,184 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,184 166-25 Cryders Ln ACRES 28.82 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 101,184 TO M Beechurst, NY 11357 EAST-0684490 NRTH-1183141 DEED BOOK 0592 PG-00596 FULL MARKET VALUE 144,549 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-5 ****************** Honor Rd 201.8-2-5 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Babolcsay Theodore J Pine Plains 134201 41,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Babolcsay Margaret Bk18 Pg1374 41,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 38 Shore Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 41,072 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682499 NRTH-1173388 DEED BOOK C0490 PG-F1992 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,674 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 16 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-7 ****************** Baxter Rd 201.8-2-7 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 30,328 Babolcsay Theodore J Pine Plains 134201 25,421 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 30,328 Babolcsay Margaret Pb 18 Pg 1374 30,328 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 30,328 38 Shore Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 30,328 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682579 NRTH-1173418 DEED BOOK C0490 PG-F1984 FULL MARKET VALUE 43,326 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-32 ***************** 38 Shore Dr Lot 48 201.8-2-32 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Babolcsay Theodore J Pine Plains 134201 31,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 91,800 Babolcsay Margaret Bk18 Pg1374 91,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 91,800 38 Shore Dr FRNT 53.53 DPTH 122.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,240 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682758 NRTH-1173468 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 91,800 TO M DEED BOOK C0490 PG-F1988 FULL MARKET VALUE 131,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-11 ****************** 49 Klibar Rd 150.-1-11 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 Backer Keith Germantown 103602 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 49 Klibar Rd Lot 2 ACRES 1.00 105,264 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677887 NRTH-1215527 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,264 TO M DEED BOOK 586 PG-1860 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,377 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-32 ****************** CR 10 149.-1-32 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 56,168 56,168 56,168 Baele Gustave Germantown 103602 40,726 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Beale Patricia FRNT 215.00 DPTH 210.00 112,336 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,168 30 Half Circel Dr EAST-0669636 NRTH-1216460 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,168 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0406 PG-00296 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,898 FULL MARKET VALUE 160,480 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 112,336 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-29.200 ************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-29.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bagnall Patricia A Germantown 103602 76,475 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 209,984 Bagnall Geoffrey ACRES 3.37 BANK0080490 209,984 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 209,984 705 Warren St EAST-0679149 NRTH-1224639 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,424 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0313 PG-F0392 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 209,984 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 299,977 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 17 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-47.200 ************** Manorton C.r. 19 Lot 1 181.-1-47.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,384 Balacic Ivan N Germantown 103602 40,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,384 70 Spencer Dr ACRES 2.53 77,384 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 77,384 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0682964 NRTH-1186273 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 77,384 TO M DEED BOOK C529 PG-F1931 FULL MARKET VALUE 110,549 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-64 ****************** 468 Rt 82 Lot 3 161.-1-64 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,152 Balazsi Jolan Hudson 100600 50,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,152 468 Route 82 ACRES 3.60 215,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 215,152 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696771 NRTH-1207794 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,152 TO M DEED BOOK 650 PG-1713 FULL MARKET VALUE 307,360 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-8 ***************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-1-8 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 247,384 Baldea Dumitru Pine Plains 134201 85,660 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 247,384 Baldea Georgina Twin Lakes 247,384 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 247,384 29-05 160th St FRNT 100.00 DPTH 122.48 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 247,384 TO M Flushing, NY 11358 ACRES 0.55 EAST-0682924 NRTH-1178328 DEED BOOK 610 PG-215 FULL MARKET VALUE 353,406 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-32 ****************** Mountainview Dr 192.-1-32 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 102,612 102,612 102,612 Balo Monika H Pine Plains 134201 48,400 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Reilly Alexandria M ACRES 3.00 BANKA060049 205,224 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,612 88 Mountainview Dr EAST-0683716 NRTH-1179820 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,612 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 608 PG-1566 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,342 FULL MARKET VALUE 293,177 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,224 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-10 ****************** 43 Klibar Rd 150.-1-10 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Banks Thomas Germantown 103602 42,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 172,720 Banks Irene ACRES 1.20 172,720 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 172,720 43 Klibar Rd EAST-0677907 NRTH-1215647 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 146,160 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0493 PG-00348 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,720 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 246,743 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 18 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-23.100 ************** PAR 2 & 5 Off Station Rd 138.-1-23.100 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 445,400 Barber Nancy Germantown 103602 74,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 445,400 131 Duane St Micro 8881 445,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 445,400 New York, NY 10013 ACRES 9.48 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 445,400 TO M EAST-0666819 NRTH-1219665 DEED BOOK C0344 PG-F1932 FULL MARKET VALUE 636,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-71 ****************** Rt. 31 Lot 20 139.-1-71 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Baretsky James Germantown 103602 46,700 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 3 55county Rt 31 ACRES 4.43 BANK0080490 160,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,835 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680370 NRTH-1223031 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,835 DEED BOOK 00691 PG-00154 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 133,840 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,143 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,400 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-17 **************** Fairview Rd. Lot 122-N 192.20-2-17 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,136 Barnjak Bruno Pine Plains 134201 44,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,136 43-27 215th St Micro 4395 102,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,136 Bayside, NY 11361-2932 ACRES 0.75 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,136 TO M EAST-0683739 NRTH-1178270 DEED BOOK 0580 PG-00242 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-61 ****************** 377 SR 82 151.-1-61 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Barrientos Gabriel Hudson 100600 54,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 118,728 377 State Rte 82 ACRES 2.10 118,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,728 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696676 NRTH-1210304 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,168 DEED BOOK 592 PG-2309 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 118,728 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 169,611 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-3 ******************* 115 Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-3 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bartolotta Mary Germantown 103602 130,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 291,600 115 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 6.29 291,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 291,600 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679405 NRTH-1216629 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 265,040 DEED BOOK 00789 PG-00053 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 291,600 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 416,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 19 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-5 ******************* 649 CR 19 171.-1-5 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bathrick David Germantown 103602 25,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,088 Bathrick Elizabeth Lynk 154,088 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,088 367 Route 19 FRNT 109.29 DPTH 183.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,528 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686765 NRTH-1200935 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,088 TO M DEED BOOK 00818 PG-00001 FULL MARKET VALUE 220,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-33 ****************** 26 Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-33 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 24,684 24,684 0 Battaglino Marian Red Hook 134801 39,550 AGED - ALL 41800 37,026 37,026 49,368 26 Bingham Mills Rd ACRES 1.00 98,736 EN STAR 41834 0 0 49,368 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676329 NRTH-1193785 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,026 DEED BOOK C477 PG-F478 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,026 FULL MARKET VALUE 141,051 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 98,736 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-54.200 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-54.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Battista John F Jr Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,288 56 Lockwood Rd ACRES 1.00 147,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,288 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0690718 NRTH-1204562 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,728 DEED BOOK 550 PG-626 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,288 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 210,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-31 ***************** Sr 9 161.1-1-31 270 Mfg housing VET458(5) 41001 37,915 37,915 0 Battistello Betty Hudson 100600 40,300 AGED - ALL 41800 17,219 17,219 36,176 Ratliff Bonnie ACRES 1.10 72,352 EN STAR 41834 0 0 36,176 Sr 9 EAST-0687734 NRTH-1206826 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 17,218 PO Box 3 DEED BOOK 553 PG-2258 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 17,218 Livingston, NY 12541 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,352 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-19 ****************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-19 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Battistello Louis Hudson 100600 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 202,096 Battistello Betty ACRES 3.01 202,096 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 202,096 Box 131 EAST-0690774 NRTH-1206312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 175,536 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0505 PG-00282 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 202,096 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 288,709 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 20 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-17.120 ************** Livingston 161.-1-17.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Battistello Tonia Jo Hudson 100600 49,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 169,048 PO Box 43 ACRES 2.42 BANKH080007 169,048 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 169,048 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0691624 NRTH-1206744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 142,488 DEED BOOK 00825 PG-00164 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 169,048 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 241,497 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-10 ****************** LOT 26 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-10 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bauer Melanie Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 189,064 30mahikan Dr Micro 94-118 & 95-283 189,064 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 189,064 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 162,504 EAST-0685811 NRTH-1202943 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 189,064 TO M DEED BOOK 00788 PG-00009 FULL MARKET VALUE 270,091 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-42 ***************** Linda Rd 201.8-2-42 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bay James Pine Plains 134201 37,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 162,520 Bay Yanina Bk18 Pg1374 162,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 162,520 12 Linda Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,960 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKN140687 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 162,520 TO M EAST-0682419 NRTH-1173068 DEED BOOK C400 PG-F1701 FULL MARKET VALUE 232,171 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-37 ****************** Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-37 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 76,160 Beck James Germantown 103602 76,160 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 76,160 PO Box 157 ACRES 11.50 76,160 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 76,160 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0693038 NRTH-1194077 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 76,160 TO M DEED BOOK C504 PG-F1186 FULL MARKET VALUE 108,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-30 ****************** 11 Shook Rd 140.-1-30 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,416 Becker Adam F Hudson 100600 48,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,416 Becker Blake FRNT 220.00 DPTH 220.00 48,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,416 138 Route 44 BANK0070390 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,416 TO M Copake Falls, NY 12517 EAST-0692992 NRTH-1217876 DEED BOOK C431 PG-F1652 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,166 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 21 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-31 ****************** 11 Shook Rd 140.-1-31 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Becker Adam F Hudson 100600 53,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 141,440 Becker Blake ACRES 2.90 BANK0070390 141,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 141,440 138 Route 44 EAST-0692872 NRTH-1217616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 114,880 Copake Falls, NY 12517 DEED BOOK C431 PG-F1652 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 141,440 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 202,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-11 ****************** 1610 CR 8 181.-1-11 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 112,948 112,948 112,948 Beckerle Patricia Red Hook 134801 137,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 1610 County Rt 8 Micro 2679 225,896 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 112,948 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 40.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 112,948 EAST-0679212 NRTH-1192530 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 62,678 DEED BOOK 0420 PG-00542 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 225,896 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 322,709 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-23.100 ************** 3298 US 9 151.-1-23.100 280 Multiple res AG DISTRIC 41720 180,254 180,254 180,254 Bedell Levi Hudson 100600 276,500 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 3298 Rte 9 ACRES 63.00 536,792 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 356,538 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0691737 NRTH-1215434 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 356,538 DEED BOOK 0461 PG-00331 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 329,978 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 766,846 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 356,538 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 180,254 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-82 ****************** Old Sr 82 & Water St 161.-1-82 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,888 Beers Anthony Hudson 100600 58,888 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,888 145 Webb Rd Micro 93-107 58,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,888 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,888 TO M EAST-0733405 NRTH-1635147 DEED BOOK 566 PG-469 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-85 ****************** Old Sr 82 & Water St 161.-1-85 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Beers Jeffrey Hudson 100600 49,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 250,100 Beers Tanya Micro 93-107 250,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 250,100 122 Old Route 82 ACRES 2.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 223,540 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0734085 NRTH-1635268 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 250,100 TO M DEED BOOK C458 PG-F1011 FULL MARKET VALUE 357,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 22 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-61 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-61 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bellinger Robert Hudson 100600 44,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 177,480 Bellinger Carol Micro 9730 177,480 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 177,480 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 1.94 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,920 EAST-0687496 NRTH-1205416 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 177,480 TO M DEED BOOK 0596 PG-00423 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 177,480 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 253,543 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-62 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-62 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 Bellinger Robert J Hudson 100600 57,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 PO Box 21 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 330.00 75,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687376 NRTH-1205346 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 75,888 TO M DEED BOOK 565 PG-723 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 75,888 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 108,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-17.100 ************** 3572 Rte 9 140.-1-17.100 416 Mfg hsing pk BAS STAR 41854 0 0 1560,000 Bells Pond Mobile Home Pk Hudson 100600 793,002 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2875,900 3572 Rte 9 ACRES 89.40 2875,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2875,900 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0691418 NRTH-1219673 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1315,900 DEED BOOK 0407 PG-00187 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2875,900 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 4108,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-38 ****************** 3572 US 9 140.-1-38 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,928 Bells Pond Mobile Home Pk Hudson 100600 37,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,928 3572 Rte 9 Micro 99-50 43,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,928 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 6.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,928 TO M EAST-0691806 NRTH-1221003 DEED BOOK C0333 PG-F1780 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-22 ****************** Us 9 Bells Pond 151.-1-22 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 243,600 Bells Pond Rte 9 Property,LLC Hudson 100600 50,718 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 243,600 913 River Rd Micro 1426 243,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 243,600 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 2.45 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 243,600 TO M EAST-0692094 NRTH-1216544 DEED BOOK 603 PG-99 FULL MARKET VALUE 348,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 23 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-17 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-17 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Belmonte Marie Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 PO Box 615 Pb 18 Pg 1374 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Bronxville, NY 10708 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682687 NRTH-1174298 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F2457 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-18 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-18 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Belmonte Marie Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 PO Box 615 Pb 18 Pg 1374 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Bronxville, NY 10708 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682647 NRTH-1174268 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F2457 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-19 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-19 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 96,152 Belmonte Marie Pine Plains 134201 26,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 96,152 PO Box 615 Reilly Twin Lake 96,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,152 Bronxville, NY 10708 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 96,152 TO M EAST-0682607 NRTH-1174238 DEED BOOK 0659 PG-00114 FULL MARKET VALUE 137,360 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-70.200 ************** 598 White Birch Rd 138.-1-70.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bender Raymond Germantown 103602 37,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 159,664 Bender Deborah ACRES 1.48 159,664 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 159,664 598 White Birch Rd EAST-0669901 NRTH-1218951 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 133,104 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0560 PG-00160 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 159,664 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 228,091 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-33.100 ************** Fox Creek Rd 138.-1-33.100 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 155,011 155,011 155,011 Bender William Germantown 103602 165,784 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 10,773 Bender Judith ACRES 35.86 165,784 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 10,773 650 White Birch Rd EAST-0669548 NRTH-1220180 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 10,773 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 00816 PG-00012 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 10,773 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 236,834 155,011 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 24 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-70.12 *************** 650 White Birch Rd 138.-1-70.12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bender William A Germantown 103602 36,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 133,008 Bender Judith A ACRES 2.50 133,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 133,008 650 White Birch Rd EAST-0668991 NRTH-1218619 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 106,448 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 00772 PG-00258 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 133,008 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 190,011 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-70.111 ************** 670 White Birch Rd 138.-1-70.111 112 Dairy farm COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bender William A Germantown 103602 155,100 AG DISTRIC 41720 111,227 111,227 111,227 Bender Judith A ACRES 40.70 305,728 AGED - ALL 41800 83,447 83,447 97,251 650 White Birch Rd EAST-0669350 NRTH-0121840 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0340 PG-F1654 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 83,446 FULL MARKET VALUE 436,754 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 83,446 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,980 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 194,501 TO M 111,227 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-55 ***************** Shore Dr Lts 13 14 201.2-1-55 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Benedex Charles A Pine Plains 134201 25,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,896 Wegniak Kenneth Reilly Twin Lake 157,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,896 55 Shore Drive FRNT 50.00 DPTH 155.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,336 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682715 NRTH-1175038 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,896 TO M DEED BOOK 563 PG-1873 FULL MARKET VALUE 225,566 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-57 ****************** 14 Twin Dr 171.-1-57 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 159,600 Benedix Barbara Germantown 103602 28,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 159,600 4 Skiba Rd Micro 4852 159,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 159,600 Pine Plains, NY 12567 ACRES 0.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 159,600 TO M EAST-0687065 NRTH-1200825 DEED BOOK 603 PG-1426 FULL MARKET VALUE 228,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-37 ****************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-37 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 76,432 Bennett Alyson Hudson 100600 76,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 76,432 25 Browns Rd ACRES 28.10 76,432 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 76,432 South Kent, CT 06785 EAST-0697029 NRTH-1203655 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 76,432 TO M DEED BOOK 602 PG-417 FULL MARKET VALUE 109,189 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 25 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-49 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-49 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bennett Raymond Pine Plains 134201 45,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 227,800 Bennett Linda Micro 4935 227,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 227,800 722 Co Rt 2 ACRES 1.70 BANK0030385 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 201,240 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683330 NRTH-1172549 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 227,800 TO M DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00029 FULL MARKET VALUE 325,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-17 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Benton James E Hudson 100600 29,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 128,248 Benton Linda J FRNT 55.00 DPTH 535.00 128,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 128,248 Box 85 BANKH080005 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,688 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687385 NRTH-1206046 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 128,248 TO M DEED BOOK 0568 PG-01051 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 128,248 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 183,211 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-86.211 ************** 409 C R 10 149.-1-86.211 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Benzinger John Germantown 103602 140,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,424 Benzinger Omkari ACRES 49.07 BANKC070170 198,424 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,424 409 Co Rt 10 EAST-0671435 NRTH-1211684 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,864 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C394 PG-F136 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,424 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 283,463 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-4.100 *************** 920 C R 10 160.-1-4.100 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 411,672 Bergelin Vern Hudson 100600 72,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 411,672 Ross Mary Ellen Micro 99-8 411,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 411,672 50 Butler St ACRES 10.00 BANKC050190 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 411,672 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11231 EAST-0681221 NRTH-1208033 DEED BOOK C424 PG-F2246 FULL MARKET VALUE 588,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-71 ****************** 335 C R 10 149.-1-71 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Berlt Charles S Germantown 103602 53,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,544 Berlt Marlene ACRES 4.40 153,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,544 335 County Route 10 EAST-0671970 NRTH-1213885 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,984 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0360 PG-F0922 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,544 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 219,349 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 26 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-46.200 ************* Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-46.200 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 Berres Robert Pine Plains 134201 44,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 Rivera Mark ACRES 1.51 BANKF180200 109,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 120 Parker Rd EAST-0681606 NRTH-1174886 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,072 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0628 PG-00100 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-52 ***************** Loyola Rd. Lts 82-83 201.2-1-52 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 114,648 Berrian Thomas Pine Plains 134201 41,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 114,648 Bustamante Omar Bk18 Pg1374 114,648 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 114,648 156 E Fort Lee Rd FRNT 135.00 DPTH 151.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,648 TO M Bogata, NJ 07603 BANK0180200 EAST-0682366 NRTH-1174907 DEED BOOK 0608 PG-00603 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,783 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-65 ***************** Shore Dr. Lts. 58-59 201.2-1-65 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Berrian Thomas Pine Plains 134201 39,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 156 E Fort Lee Reilly Twin Lake 39,440 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Bogota, NJ 07603-1302 FRNT 90.00 DPTH 103.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 39,440 TO M EAST-0682406 NRTH-1174858 DEED BOOK 547 PG-734 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,343 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-52.110 ************** 96 Lockwood Rd 161.-1-52.110 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Berry Christopher Hudson 100600 40,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,976 Berry Jacquelyn ACRES 1.54 110,976 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 110,976 96 Lockwood Rd EAST-0690700 NRTH-1203542 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 84,416 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C452 PG-F1559 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,976 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 158,537 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-15 ****************** 471 Off CR 19 171.-1-15 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 390,458 390,458 390,458 Best Marion Germantown 103602 525,504 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,046 471 Rte 19 ACRES 168.50 525,504 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,046 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688377 NRTH-1200098 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,046 DEED BOOK 00697 PG-00020 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,046 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 750,720 390,458 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 27 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-27.100 ************** 471 Rt 19 171.-1-27.100 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 12,512 0 0 Best Marion Germantown 103602 37,500 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 471 Rte 19 FRNT 215.00 DPTH 199.32 125,120 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 112,608 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686910 NRTH-1198385 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,120 DEED BOOK 00697 PG-00018 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,850 FULL MARKET VALUE 178,743 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,120 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-14 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-14 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 270,900 Bhaagwandin Jerry P Copake-Taconic 102801 45,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 270,900 Bhagwandin Karyl J ACRES 2.60 BANK0080490 270,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 270,900 266 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0699692 NRTH-1217689 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 270,900 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 533 PG-1556 FULL MARKET VALUE 387,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-9 ******************* CR 10 149.-1-9 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,400 Bianciardi Gian David Germantown 103602 55,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,400 Ammann Gabriela C Micro08-10 55,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,400 211 E 3rd St ACRES 7.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,400 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11218 EAST-0522422 NRTH-1216081 DEED BOOK 640 PG-2423 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-33.110 ************** 75 Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-33.110 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bicjan Steven Hudson 100600 69,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,000 75 Willowbrook Rd Micro 93-78 153,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,000 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 9.19 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,440 EAST-0696987 NRTH-1204939 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,000 TO M DEED BOOK C481 PG-1670 FULL MARKET VALUE 218,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-47.2 **************** Old Sr 82 151.-1-47.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,000 Bily Anna Marie Hudson 100600 41,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,000 Eckholm Eleanor Lot #1 41,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 41,000 84 Old Route 82 ACRES 1.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 41,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696900 NRTH-0121080 DEED BOOK 564 PG-2428 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 28 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-47.12 *************** Old Sr 82 151.-1-47.12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bily Anna Marie Hudson 100600 38,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,300 Eckholm Eleanor Lot #2 108,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,300 84 Old Route 82 ACRES 1.60 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,740 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696910 NRTH-0121060 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,300 TO M DEED BOOK 564 PG-2432 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-47.111 ************** Old Sr 82 151.-1-47.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,000 Bily Anna Marie Hudson 100600 40,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,000 Eckholm Eleanor Lot #4 130,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,000 96 Old Route 82 ACRES 1.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0697000 NRTH-0121030 DEED BOOK 564 PG-2440 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-47.112 ************** Old Sr 82 151.-1-47.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,000 Bily Anna Marie Hudson 100600 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,000 Eckholm Eleanor Lot #3 45,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 45,000 84 Old Route 82 ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 45,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696940 NRTH-0121050 DEED BOOK 564 PG-2436 FULL MARKET VALUE 64,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-16 ****************** Glenco 152.-1-16 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Bily Charles Hudson 100600 102,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 32 Schooner Lane @ Riverb ACRES 14.00 102,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Bluffton, SC 29909 EAST-0697475 NRTH-1210975 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,000 TO M DEED BOOK 00695 PG-00063 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-25.112 ************** U.s. 9 & Orchard Rd 140.-1-25.112 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 171,779 171,779 171,779 Birch David Hudson 100600 247,440 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 118,309 PO Box 83 ACRES 58.21 290,088 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,309 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0690822 NRTH-1218012 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,309 DEED BOOK 0594 PG-00798 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 118,309 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 414,411 171,779 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 29 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-30 ****************** US 9 151.-1-30 425 Bar COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 119,000 Birch David Hudson 100600 62,213 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 119,000 451 Orchard Rd ACRES 3.50 119,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 119,000 PO Box 83 EAST-0690617 NRTH-1215151 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,000 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 00731 PG-00015 FULL MARKET VALUE 170,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-52.211 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-52.211 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 115,084 115,084 115,084 Birch David Hudson 100600 155,992 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,908 PO Box 83 Micro 99-122 155,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,908 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 38.70 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,908 EAST-0689490 NRTH-1203640 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,908 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C0343 PG-F2024 115,084 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-98 ****************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-98 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 245,295 245,295 245,295 Birch David Hudson 100600 275,128 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,833 PO Box 83 Micro 99-122 275,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,833 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 27.90 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,833 EAST-0689569 NRTH-1224449 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,833 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C0343 PG-F2024 245,295 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 393,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-99 ****************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-99 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 42,634 42,634 42,634 Birch David Hudson 100600 155,856 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 113,222 PO Box 83 Micro 99-122 155,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 113,222 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 80.20 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,222 EAST-0689872 NRTH-1202341 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 113,222 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C0343 PG-F2024 42,634 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-47 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-47 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bishop John Germantown 103602 31,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 78,472 Bishop Dawn FRNT 238.18 DPTH 118.48 78,472 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 78,472 PO Box 192 BANKC020760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,912 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0685689 NRTH-1193923 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 78,472 TO M DEED BOOK 0571 PG-01084 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,103 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 30 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-42 ****************** Off Old Rte 82 152.-1-42 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,128 Black Carl Hudson 100600 3,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,128 Black Michael ACRES 1.16 3,128 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,128 RD4 8 Short Rd EAST-0698688 NRTH-1209208 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,128 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0569 PG-00289 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,469 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-38 ****************** Old Rte 82 152.-1-38 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,856 Black Carl John Jr Hudson 100600 45,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,856 Black Michael G Micro 4755 155,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,856 RD4 8 Short Rd ACRES 2.20 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,856 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698469 NRTH-1209027 DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F2215 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-1 ***************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-1 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,048 Blackburn Cliff Pine Plains 134201 50,048 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,048 6 King Rd Bk22 Pg1602 0001 50,048 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,048 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 1.34 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,048 TO M EAST-0682489 NRTH-1178557 DEED BOOK 0647 PG-00097 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,497 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-11 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-11 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,504 Blackburn Cliff Pine Plains 134201 32,504 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,504 6 King Rd Bk22 Pg1602 0001 32,504 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,504 Red Hook, NY 12571 FRNT 48.00 DPTH 120.33 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,504 TO M EAST-0682639 NRTH-1178428 DEED BOOK 0647 PG-00099 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,434 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-12 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-12 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 33,456 Blackburn Cliff Pine Plains 134201 33,456 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 33,456 1347 Route 19 Bk22 Pg1602 33,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 33,456 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 33,456 TO M EAST-0682639 NRTH-1178378 DEED BOOK C391 PG-F1443 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,794 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 31 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-1-1 ****************** CR 19 192.4-1-1 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 424,728 Blackburn Clifford Pine Plains 134201 54,510 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 424,728 6 King Rd ACRES 3.00 424,728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 424,728 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0682399 NRTH-1178337 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 424,728 TO M DEED BOOK 0622 PG-00037 FULL MARKET VALUE 606,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-4 ******************* Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-4 270 Mfg housing AGED - ALL 41800 14,280 14,280 14,280 Blanchard Alfred Germantown 103602 22,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 14,280 138 Deerhaven Rd FRNT 70.00 DPTH 208.00 28,560 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 14,280 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0688201 NRTH-1192908 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 14,280 DEED BOOK 0452 PG-00056 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,800 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,560 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-6 ******************* Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-6 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Blanchard Alfred E Jr Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,768 Blanchard Ela Micro 8685 69,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,768 166 Deerhaven Rd ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,208 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0688537 NRTH-1194738 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 69,768 TO M DEED BOOK 0580 PG-00032 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,669 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-18.122 ************** 33 Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-18.122 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 209,304 Blauvelt Brent Red Hook 134801 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 209,304 Blauvelt Nikia Micro 9816 209,304 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 209,304 33 Bingham Mills Rd ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 209,304 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676419 NRTH-1194095 DEED BOOK 618 PG-546 FULL MARKET VALUE 299,006 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-41 ****************** Water St 152.-1-41 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bleau Thomas S Hudson 100600 22,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,296 Bleau Jennifer ACRES 0.37 110,296 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 110,296 390 Water St EAST-0697948 NRTH-1209256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 83,736 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 584 PG-765 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,296 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 157,566 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 32 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-49.200 ************** CR 31 139.-1-49.200 322 Rural vac>10 AG DISTRIC 41720 72,568 72,568 72,568 Blue Hill Fruit Farm Germantown 103602 74,528 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,960 33 Eger Rd ACRES 14.00 74,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,960 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677200 NRTH-1219205 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,960 DEED BOOK C0315 PG-F0867 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,960 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 106,469 72,568 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-29.111 ************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-29.111 323 Vacant rural AG DISTRIC 41720 85,956 85,956 85,956 Blue Hill Fruit Farms Inc. Germantown 103602 91,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,044 33 Eger Rd Micro 2407 91,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,044 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 29.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,044 EAST-0679222 NRTH-1223149 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,044 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C0365 PG-F0680 85,956 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 130,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-45 ****************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-45 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 500,758 500,758 500,758 Blue Hill Fruit Farms Inc. Germantown 103602 571,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 33 Eger Rd ACRES 130.75 1414,672 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 913,914 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677045 NRTH-1221945 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 913,914 DEED BOOK 0575 PG-00263 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 887,354 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 2020,960 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 913,914 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 500,758 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-81 ****************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-81 323 Vacant rural AG DISTRIC 41720 19,539 19,539 19,539 Blue Hill Fruit Farms Inc. Germantown 103602 56,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,861 33 Eger Rd Micro 2407 56,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,861 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 11.70 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,861 EAST-0679222 NRTH-1223149 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,861 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C0365 PG-F0680 19,539 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-43 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-43 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 Blum Henry C Pine Plains 134201 42,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 461 Yorktown Rd #2 FRNT 200.00 DPTH 270.00 108,256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 Croton On Hudson, NY 10520 BANKA040090 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,256 TO M EAST-0682555 NRTH-1172588 DEED BOOK 0550 PG-01036 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,651 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 33 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-67 ****************** 293 CR 10 149.-1-67 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 395,800 Bluttal Steven Germantown 103602 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 395,800 Boice John ACRES 2.41 BANKC080007 395,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 395,800 293 County Route 10 EAST-0671599 NRTH-1214814 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 395,800 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C425 PG-F362 FULL MARKET VALUE 565,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-51 ****************** 540 CR 31 139.-1-51 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 178,304 Boak-Kelly Alexandra Germantown 103602 45,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 178,304 540 Blue Hill Rd ACRES 4.20 BANKC120345 178,304 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 178,304 Hudson, NY 12534-4214 EAST-0677699 NRTH-1219716 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 178,304 TO M DEED BOOK C0500 PG-F2226 FULL MARKET VALUE 254,720 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-35.2 **************** CR 9 170.-2-35.2 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bocchino Terry Red Hook 134801 48,900 DIS VET/CT 41141 55,216 55,216 0 Bocchino Marie ACRES 1.60 240,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 39 W Market St EAST-0680270 NRTH-0119540 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,076 Red Hook, NY 12571 DEED BOOK 557 PG-1018 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,076 FULL MARKET VALUE 344,143 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 214,340 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 240,900 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-46 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-46 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,440 Boccia Joseph Germantown 103602 33,062 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,440 PO Box 171 532 1140 124,440 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 124,440 Red Hook, NY 12571 FRNT 358.09 DPTH 74.22 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,440 TO M EAST-0685788 NRTH-1194233 DEED BOOK C533 PG-F943 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,771 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-45.200 ************** CR 8 182.-1-45.200 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 Boccia Karin Germantown 103602 29,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 2135 Cnty Rt 8 Micro 96-94 52,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.21 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,360 TO M EAST-0689369 NRTH-1186357 DEED BOOK C495 PG-F1857 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,800 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 34 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-7 ******************* Water St 141.-1-7 270 Mfg housing AGED T 41803 0 27,472 0 Bodnar Steve Copake-Taconic 102801 40,900 AGED C&S 41805 34,340 0 34,340 Bodnar Julianna ACRES 1.11 68,680 EN STAR 41834 0 0 34,340 Rte 12 EAST-0700520 NRTH-1218711 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 34,340 PO Box 315 DEED BOOK 0522 PG-00991 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,208 Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 98,114 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 68,680 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-22 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-22 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 68,680 Bogucki Leonard Germantown 103602 56,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 68,680 22 Station Rd ACRES 2.20 68,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 68,680 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0666420 NRTH-1219494 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 68,680 TO M DEED BOOK 0436 PG-00580 FULL MARKET VALUE 98,114 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-50 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-50 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bogucki Leonard Germantown 103602 86,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 22 Station Rd ACRES 16.10 209,576 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 181,968 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0666771 NRTH-1218885 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 181,968 DEED BOOK 0489 PG-00901 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 159,306 FULL MARKET VALUE 299,394 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 209,576 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-1 ******************* OFF CR 31 160.-1-1 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 23,028 23,028 23,028 Bohac Nancy Germantown 103602 24,072 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,044 Collier Sally Bk22 Pg1637 24,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,044 950 Rte 31 ACRES 5.20 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,044 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675659 NRTH-1209572 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,044 TO M DEED BOOK C0305 PG-F1149 23,028 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 34,389 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-2.100 *************** 950 Rt 31 160.-1-2.100 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 24,791 24,791 24,791 Bohac Nancy Germantown 103602 108,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Collier Sally ACRES 23.60 282,336 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 257,545 950 Rte 31 EAST-0676018 NRTH-1209723 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 257,545 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0305 PG-F1149 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 230,985 FULL MARKET VALUE 403,337 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 257,545 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 24,791 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 35 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-2.200 *************** 950 C R 31 160.-1-2.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bohac Nancy A Germantown 103602 39,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 196,520 950 Blue Hill Rd Micro 11128 196,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 196,520 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 1.40 BANKC200201 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 169,960 EAST-0676177 NRTH-1210173 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 196,520 TO M DEED BOOK 0634 PG-00029 FULL MARKET VALUE 280,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-36.120 ************** 42 Maple Ln 170.-2-36.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,216 Boice Todd Red Hook 134801 31,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,216 Boice Nancy Bk11 Pg878 72,216 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,216 10 Pheasant Run FRNT 127.91 DPTH 205.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,216 TO M Ballston Spa, NY 12020 EAST-0681216 NRTH-1195124 DEED BOOK 589 PG-1164 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-40 ****************** 73 Blue Valley Rd 139.-1-40 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bonacker Michael J Germantown 103602 41,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bonacker Tammy J ACRES 2.30 BANK0070390 139,808 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 112,200 73 Blue Valley Rd EAST-0681936 NRTH-1221284 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 112,200 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0345 PG-F1198 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,248 FULL MARKET VALUE 199,726 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 139,808 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-21.110 ************** 157 Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-21.110 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Boonin Pamela Germantown 103602 58,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 535,000 157 Walllkers Mill Rd #16 Micro 11991 535,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 535,000 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 5.00 BANKH080005 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 508,440 EAST-0675533 NRTH-1207412 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 535,000 TO M DEED BOOK 527 PG-2379 FULL MARKET VALUE 764,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-32 ****************** 74 Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-32 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Boor John Hudson 100600 57,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Boor Olga Susan ACRES 5.70 157,352 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,787 74 Willowbrook Rd EAST-0696636 NRTH-1205554 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,787 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0344 PG-F0757 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,082 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,789 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,352 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 36 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-65 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-65 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 25,704 Boor John Hudson 100600 17,225 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 25,704 Boor Olga FRNT 250.00 DPTH 250.00 25,704 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 25,704 74 Willowbrook Rd EAST-0697216 NRTH-1205515 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 25,704 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0546 PG-00631 FULL MARKET VALUE 36,720 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-48 ***************** Church Rd 161.1-1-48 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Boote Michael Hudson 100600 49,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 219,912 Boote Audrey ACRES 3.23 219,912 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 219,912 PO Box 23 EAST-0688754 NRTH-1206468 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 193,352 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0584 PG-00686 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 219,912 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 314,160 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 219,912 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-39 ****************** C R 10 150.-1-39 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 196,656 Boruta Mary Beth Germantown 103602 35,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 196,656 Boruta Timothy ACRES 1.00 196,656 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 196,656 414 Co Rt 10 EAST-0673522 NRTH-1212918 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 196,656 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C378 PG-F2055 FULL MARKET VALUE 280,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-40 ****************** C R 10 150.-1-40 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 20,400 Boruta Mary Beth Germantown 103602 20,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 20,400 Boruta Timothy FRNT 70.00 DPTH 130.00 20,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 20,400 414 Co Rt 10 EAST-0673643 NRTH-1212768 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 20,400 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0357 PG-F2407 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-11.200 ************** 1143 CR 19 192.-1-11.200 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Botknecht Jerry Germantown 103602 58,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,952 1143 Cr 19 ACRES 1.50 153,952 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,952 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682691 NRTH-1182668 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,682 DEED BOOK 599 PG-1358 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,952 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 219,931 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 37 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-15.111 ************** Water St 152.-1-15.111 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 370,508 370,508 370,508 Botta Gian Andrea Copake-Taconic 102801 511,224 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,716 223 Old Route 82 ACRES 122.10 511,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,716 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0699974 NRTH-1211640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 140,716 DEED BOOK C0325 PG-F0683 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 140,716 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 730,320 370,508 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-11 ****************** Old State Rte 82 161.-1-11 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 108,898 108,898 108,898 Botta Gian Andrea Hudson 100600 202,656 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 421,910 Exor America Inc ACRES 50.84 530,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 421,910 223 Old Route 82 EAST-0698471 NRTH-1208047 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 421,910 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0297 PG-F1461 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 421,910 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 758,297 108,898 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-43.100 ************** CR 31 139.-1-43.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 149,192 Bottari Marie Germantown 103602 53,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 149,192 Bottari Albert ACRES 6.30 BANKC120345 149,192 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 149,192 85-34 104 St EAST-0678406 NRTH-1221017 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 149,192 TO M Richmond Hill, NY 11418 DEED BOOK 0610 PG-00573 FULL MARKET VALUE 213,131 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-43 **************** 2 CR 19 192.20-3-43 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Boucher Francois A Pine Plains 134201 40,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Boucher Heather Rosedale Park 119,952 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 103,387 1396 Rte 19 FRNT 142.00 DPTH 125.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 103,387 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKN140687 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,392 EAST-0682501 NRTH-1177218 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,952 TO M DEED BOOK 00824 PG-00062 FULL MARKET VALUE 171,360 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-2.110 *************** Spring Rd 140.-1-2.110 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 103,632 Bove Joseph Hudson 100600 103,632 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 103,632 132 Old Well Rd Micro 96-79 103,632 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,632 Purchase, NY 10577 ACRES 21.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,000 TO M EAST-0684772 NRTH-1223010 DEED BOOK C0328 PG-F1133 FULL MARKET VALUE 148,046 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 38 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-2.200 *************** Spring Rd 140.-1-2.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 310,080 Bove Joseph Hudson 100600 214,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 310,080 132 Old Well Rd Micro 96-79 310,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 310,080 Purchase, NY 10577 ACRES 49.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 310,080 TO M EAST-0685494 NRTH-1222216 DEED BOOK 00825 PG-00253 FULL MARKET VALUE 442,971 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-43 ****************** Rte 9 140.-1-43 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 Bove Joseph Hudson 100600 47,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 Bove Anna ACRES 2.00 47,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 137 Old Well Rd EAST-0691453 NRTH-1217343 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,600 TO M Purchase, NY 10577 DEED BOOK 625 PG-537 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-44.1 **************** U.s. 9 & Orchard Rd Lot 1 140.-1-44.1 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,700 Bove Joseph Hudson 100600 69,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,700 Bove Anna ACRES 11.20 69,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,700 132 Old Well Rd EAST-0730119 NRTH-0547094 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 69,700 TO M Purchase, NY 10577 DEED BOOK 618 PG-1 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-46 **************** Westland Ave 21 & 22 192.20-3-46 220 2 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bowden Raymond V Pine Plains 134201 47,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 181,152 Bowden Gail B Rosedale Park 181,152 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 181,152 11 Westland Ave FRNT 130.94 DPTH 145.97 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 154,592 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC030982 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 181,152 TO M EAST-0682391 NRTH-1177107 DEED BOOK C516 PG-F1821 FULL MARKET VALUE 258,789 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-56 ****************** Prilipper Rd 139.-1-56 240 Rural res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Bower Lawrence Hudson 100600 69,800 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bower Anna ACRES 12.00 BANK0140687 117,368 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,803 RR2 EAST-0684258 NRTH-1219829 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,803 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00733 PG-00113 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 90,808 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,669 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,368 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 39 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-22 ****************** 717 CR 31 150.-1-22 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bower Leo A Germantown 103602 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,072 Attn: Dorothy A Bower ACRES 3.00 92,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,072 717 Rte 31 EAST-0676739 NRTH-1214644 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,512 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0242 PG-00077 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,072 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 131,531 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-2.111 *************** SR 9G 138.-1-2.111 250 Estate BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Brackman Jacob R Hudson 100600 110,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 459,544 Attn: David Ackerman Cpa Micro 8609 459,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 459,544 1 Hudson City Centre 1E ACRES 33.87 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 432,984 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0670688 NRTH-1225352 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 459,544 TO M DEED BOOK 0552 PG-00040 FULL MARKET VALUE 656,491 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-13 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-13 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bradley William W Hudson 100600 28,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 96,288 180 Cr 19 FRNT 109.56 DPTH 219.78 96,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 96,288 PO Box 22 BANK0180200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,728 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0686936 NRTH-1205485 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 96,288 TO M DEED BOOK 635 PG-948 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 96,288 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 137,554 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-19 **************** 46 Lakeview Dr 192.20-1-19 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Brajuha Milan Pine Plains 134201 32,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 95,800 Brajuha Elsie Twin Lakes 0001 95,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 95,800 46 Lakeview Dr FRNT 110.00 DPTH 119.76 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 45,530 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKH110045 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 95,800 TO M EAST-0683109 NRTH-1178159 DEED BOOK 0547 PG-00797 FULL MARKET VALUE 136,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-6 ******************* CR 10 149.-1-6 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Braker Harry Germantown 103602 41,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Braker Audrey ACRES 2.00 41,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 128 County Rte 10 EAST-0669274 NRTH-1217240 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 41,072 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0662 PG-00244 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,674 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 40 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-7 ******************* 128 CR 10 149.-1-7 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 36,361 36,361 0 Braker Harry Jr Germantown 103602 49,100 AGED - ALL 41800 57,844 57,844 76,024 Braker Audrey ACRES 3.20 152,048 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 128 County Rte 10 EAST-0669374 NRTH-1217080 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 57,843 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0331 PG-00309 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 57,843 FULL MARKET VALUE 217,211 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 25,754 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 152,048 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-4.11 **************** 353 Orchard Rd 151.-1-4.11 151 Fruit crop COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bramkamp Louis Hudson 100600 134,500 AG DISTRIC 41720 20,947 20,947 20,947 Bramkamp Viola Liber 299,page 523 305,120 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 353 Orchard Rd ACRES 40.80 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 256,565 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0689360 NRTH-0121640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 256,565 DEED BOOK 0299 PG-00523 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 233,903 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 435,886 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 284,173 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 20,947 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-4 ******************* 17 Mahikan Dr Lt19 161.-2-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Branam Kevin Hudson 100600 35,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,480 17 Mahikan Dr Micro 94-118 & 95-283 143,480 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,480 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.04 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,920 EAST-0686061 NRTH-1203083 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,480 TO M DEED BOOK 622 PG-2137 FULL MARKET VALUE 204,971 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-2 ******************* Greendale Rd 128.-1-2 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 13,700 Brengel Peter W Hudson 100600 13,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 13,700 Greendale Rd Rfd 2 ACRES 2.90 13,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 13,700 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0669384 NRTH-1227629 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 13,700 TO M DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00378 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 19,571 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-27 ****************** 10 White Oak Rd & Co Rte 19 192.-1-27 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Brightly Michael A Pine Plains 134201 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,616 10 White Oak Rd ACRES 2.00 BANK0180200 126,616 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,616 Elizvaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682935 NRTH-1180268 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 100,056 DEED BOOK C0314 PG-F0482 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 126,616 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 180,880 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 41 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-29 ****************** 1283 CR 19 192.-1-29 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Brightly Stephen J Pine Plains 134201 57,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,304 Brightly Carol ACRES 5.60 124,304 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,304 1283 Rte 19 EAST-0682976 NRTH-1179898 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,034 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0423 PG-00329 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,304 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 177,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-1-4.110 ************** 10 Westland Ave 192.4-1-4.110 220 2 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Brillis Peter Pine Plains 134201 49,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 242,760 Brillis Carol Micro 4443 242,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 242,760 10 Westland Ave ACRES 2.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 192,490 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0720887 NRTH-0543077 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 242,760 TO M DEED BOOK 0599 PG-00416 FULL MARKET VALUE 346,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-1-4.120 ************** 10 Westland Ave 192.4-1-4.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,456 Brillis Peter Pine Plains 134201 39,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,456 Brillis Carol Micro 4443 50,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,456 10 Westland Ave ACRES 1.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,456 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0720637 NRTH-0543066 DEED BOOK 0599 PG-00416 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,080 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-1-4.200 ************** Parker Rd 192.4-1-4.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,648 Brills Petros Pine Plains 134201 25,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,648 Brills Carol FRNT 115.40 DPTH 257.30 29,648 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,648 10 Westland Ave Box 46B EAST-0682166 NRTH-1177192 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,648 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 00744 PG-00032 FULL MARKET VALUE 42,354 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-8 ******************* CR 19 181.-1-8 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Broast Linda Germantown 103602 84,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,608 Broast Ronald Biedrzycki 197,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,608 796 Route 19 ACRES 10.58 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,048 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683843 NRTH-1191629 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,608 TO M DEED BOOK 0560 PG-00307 FULL MARKET VALUE 282,297 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 42 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-56 ****************** PARCEL 3 CR 19 181.-1-56 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Broast Linda Germantown 103602 54,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Broast Ronald Micro 96-92 54,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 796 Rte 19 ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,672 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683638 NRTH-1191216 DEED BOOK C0302 PG-F0959 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-4 ****************** Whitman Rd 201.8-3-4 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,272 Bronzo Frank Pine Plains 134201 9,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,272 Bronzo Joan Reilly Twin Lake 136,272 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,272 20 Outerbridge Ave FRNT 65.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,272 TO M Staten Island, NY 10309 EAST-0683037 NRTH-1174299 DEED BOOK 0479 PG-00257 FULL MARKET VALUE 194,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-7 ****************** Whitman Rd 201.8-3-7 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,184 Bronzo Frank Pine Plains 134201 16,184 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,184 Bronzo Joan Reilly Twin Lake 16,184 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,184 20 Outerbridge Ave FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 16,184 TO M Staten Island, NY 10309 EAST-0683067 NRTH-1174259 DEED BOOK 0495 PG-00604 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,120 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-2.120 *************** 161 OAK HILL Rd 138.-1-2.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 258,900 Brooke Allen Anna Hudson 100600 53,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 258,900 Baker Joseph ACRES 3.16 258,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 258,900 17 Greendale Rd EAST-0670307 NRTH-1225951 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 258,900 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 643 PG-510 FULL MARKET VALUE 369,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-43 ****************** 621 White Birch Rd 138.-1-43 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Brophy Thomas Germantown 103602 44,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,760 Brophy Alecia ACRES 3.70 BANKC031730 174,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,760 621 White Birch Rd EAST-0668991 NRTH-1218989 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 148,200 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0313 PG-F0384 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,760 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 249,657 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 43 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-6.120 *************** 136 Old Rte 82 161.-1-6.120 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 234,872 Brown Albert Hudson 100600 143,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 234,872 Brown Barbara Micro 93-107 234,872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 234,872 51 Blacksmith Rd ACRES 12.22 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 234,872 TO M Cedartown, GA 30125-7433 EAST-0697325 NRTH-1208843 DEED BOOK C453 PG-F1493 FULL MARKET VALUE 335,531 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-8 ******************* CR 19 171.-1-8 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 14,933 14,933 0 Brown Jeff Germantown 103602 35,000 AGED - ALL 41800 42,310 42,310 49,776 Munoz Sandra ACRES 1.00 99,552 EN STAR 41834 0 0 49,776 PO Box 216 EAST-0686526 NRTH-1200424 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,309 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK C516 PG-F211 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,309 FULL MARKET VALUE 142,217 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 99,552 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-90.100 ************** 229 Wire Rd 149.-1-90.100 240 Rural res AGED - ALL 41800 90,576 90,576 90,576 Brown Lily H Germantown 103602 83,900 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 229 Wire Rd ACRES 13.43 181,152 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 90,576 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671168 NRTH-1209834 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 90,576 DEED BOOK 00733 PG-00198 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,306 FULL MARKET VALUE 258,789 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 181,152 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-4 ******************* 205 Schnieder Rd 161.-1-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Brown Michael Hudson 100600 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 202,640 Campau Naney Micro 2412 202,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 202,640 205 Schneider Rd ACRES 2.30 BANKC060975 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 176,080 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0693818 NRTH-1209318 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 202,640 TO M DEED BOOK C0312 PG-F2176 FULL MARKET VALUE 289,486 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-62 ****************** 1091 CR 10 160.-1-62 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Brown Ross J Hudson 100600 49,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,400 Brown Amberleigh K micro#05-126 158,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,400 1091 County Route 10 ACRES 2.44 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,840 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685440 NRTH-0120690 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 158,400 TO M DEED BOOK 638 PG-1699 FULL MARKET VALUE 226,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 44 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-49 ****************** Half Circle Rd 149.-1-49 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Brown Stephanie Germantown 103602 43,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,280 Holloway Paul ACRES 1.07 BANK0080490 150,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,280 9 Half Circle Rd EAST-0669143 NRTH-1216238 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 123,720 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0583 PG-00552 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,280 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 214,686 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-31 ****************** Rivenburgh Rd 150.-1-31 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bruno John Germantown 103602 51,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 274,856 Bruno Robin ACRES 1.80 BANKC061197 274,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 274,856 9danski Rd EAST-0682441 NRTH-1213626 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 248,296 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C480 PG-F967 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 274,856 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 392,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-9.100 ************** Sr 9 161.1-1-9.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bruno Scott Hudson 100600 37,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,920 Bruno Barbara ACRES 1.20 BANK0080490 148,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,920 PO Box 64 EAST-0686726 NRTH-1205804 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,360 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 00276 PG-00227 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,920 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 212,743 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 148,920 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-23 **************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-23 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,000 Bruzgul Linda Pine Plains 134201 31,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,000 284 N Mabbettsville Rd Twin Lakes 55,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,000 Millbrook, NY 12545 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,000 TO M ACRES 0.35 EAST-0682530 NRTH-1177628 DEED BOOK 635 PG-1737 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-39 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-39 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,900 Bruzgul Linda Pine Plains 134201 69,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,900 284 N Mbbettsville Rd Bruckert 101,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,900 Millbrook, NY 12545 ACRES 9.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 101,900 TO M EAST-0681255 NRTH-1175435 DEED BOOK 597 PG-1671 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 45 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-31.200 ************** 6 Hamm Rd 151.-1-31.200 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bryant Gary M Hudson 100600 35,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bryant Juanita Micro 7514 149,056 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 121,448 6 Hamm Rd ACRES 1.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,448 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0693705 NRTH-1216182 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,496 DEED BOOK 0560 PG-00961 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 149,056 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 212,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-16.200 ************** 198 C R 10 149.-1-16.200 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 63,510 63,510 0 Buccheri John Germantown 103602 72,600 AGED - ALL 41800 64,941 64,941 96,696 Buccheri Lillian ACRES 4.76 193,392 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 198 County Rte 10 #2 EAST-0670485 NRTH-1216662 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,941 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00245 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,941 FULL MARKET VALUE 276,274 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,426 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 193,392 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-14 ***************** 7 Summerside Ave 201.8-3-14 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 169,320 Bucci Jerry Pine Plains 134201 49,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 169,320 Bucci Joan Granda Bk10 Pg786 169,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 169,320 41 Overlook Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 170.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 169,320 TO M Valhaalla, NY 10595 EAST-0683587 NRTH-1174250 DEED BOOK C497 PG-F0705 FULL MARKET VALUE 241,886 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-14.100 ************** Off Taghkanic Rd 182.-1-14.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,816 Buckhurst Paul Germantown 103602 53,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,816 290 Riverside Drive-10A ACRES 5.12 BANKC030982 170,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,816 New York, NY 10025 EAST-0691246 NRTH-1190114 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,816 TO M DEED BOOK C0295 PG-F1210 FULL MARKET VALUE 244,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-13 ****************** 19 Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-13 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 107,440 107,440 107,440 Budd Gordon A Hudson 100600 60,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Budd Elaine E Micro 4696&95-161&00-133 214,880 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,440 19 Ten Broeck Rd ACRES 6.50 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,440 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696831 NRTH-1213014 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,170 DEED BOOK C0341 PG-F0847 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 306,971 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 46 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-41.120 ************** CR 8 182.-1-41.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,760 Buffa Frank Germantown 103602 55,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,760 Buffa Rebecca ACRES 4.00 155,760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,760 1981 Cty Rte 8 EAST-0685694 NRTH-1186253 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,760 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0311 PG-F0433 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,514 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-41.200 ************** C R 8 182.-1-41.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Buffa Frank Germantown 103602 51,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 247,792 Buffa Rebecca Micro 10303 247,792 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 247,792 1981 Cnty Rt 8 ACRES 4.00 BANKH061230 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 221,232 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685873 NRTH-1186634 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 247,792 TO M DEED BOOK C0281 PG-F0976 FULL MARKET VALUE 353,989 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-15 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-15 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Bulos Yusef Hudson 100600 32,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,648 Genke John FRNT 120.00 DPTH 295.00 148,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,648 PO Box 145 EAST-0687316 NRTH-1205725 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 98,378 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0522 PG-00306 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,648 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 212,354 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 148,648 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-39 ****************** 2120 Rte 9 170.-1-39 421 Restaurant COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 385,560 Bump Richard Red Hook 134801 50,955 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 385,560 Jaeger Steven ACRES 1.90 385,560 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 385,560 181 Hogtrough Rd EAST-0677339 NRTH-1194047 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 385,560 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 639 PG-793 FULL MARKET VALUE 550,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-69 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-69 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 321,800 Burfield Jason Germantown 103602 65,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 321,800 Ragusa-Burfield Maria Micro 07-229 321,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 321,800 30 Park Ave 19B ACRES 4.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 321,800 TO M New York, NY 10016 EAST-0676725 NRTH-1214160 DEED BOOK 629 PG-2147 FULL MARKET VALUE 459,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 47 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-13 **************** 65 Highland Ave 192.20-2-13 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 65,450 65,450 0 Burke Susan Pine Plains 134201 38,100 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 65 Highland Ave Twin Lakes 154,088 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 88,638 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 0.97 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 88,638 EAST-0683859 NRTH-1178500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,818 DEED BOOK 569 PG-581 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,088 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 220,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-21 ****************** 224 Mill Rd 170.-1-21 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Burns George J Jr Red Hook 134801 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,400 224 Mill Rd Micro 12189 122,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,400 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 2.00 BANKC210090 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,130 EAST-0673717 NRTH-1194779 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,400 TO M DEED BOOK 00825 PG-00276 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-4 ***************** LOT 132N Mountainview Dr 192.20-2-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Burns Mark Pine Plains 134201 47,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 Burns Jennifer Micro 4395 & 00-136 170,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 55 Highland Ave FRNT 55.00 DPTH 284.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,440 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683428 NRTH-1178789 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,000 TO M DEED BOOK C517 PG-F732 FULL MARKET VALUE 242,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-23 ****************** 205 Mill Rd 170.-1-23 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Burns Theresa N Red Hook 134801 56,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 252,280 Burns George J Jr Micro 12189 252,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 252,280 205 Mill Rd ACRES 5.29 BANK0130295 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 225,720 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0673858 NRTH-1194420 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 252,280 TO M DEED BOOK 00706 PG-00198 FULL MARKET VALUE 360,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-44 **************** CR 19 192.20-3-44 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Burt Thomas Pine Plains 134201 32,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,800 1400 County Route 19 Rosedale Park 135,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,240 BANKC030614 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,800 TO M EAST-0682591 NRTH-1177158 DEED BOOK 00825 PG-00080 FULL MARKET VALUE 194,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 48 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-47 **************** Bruckert Rd 192.20-3-47 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,496 Burt Thomas Pine Plains 134201 52,496 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,496 1400 County Route 19 FRNT 205.00 DPTH 155.00 52,496 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,496 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC030614 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,496 TO M EAST-0682551 NRTH-1177078 DEED BOOK 00825 PG-00080 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,994 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-48 ****************** Marlin Hill Rd 150.-1-48 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 22,144 22,144 22,144 Burtis Theodore A III Germantown 103602 57,256 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,112 Keefer Judith A ACRES 21.06 57,256 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,112 12 Verandah Pl EAST-0680673 NRTH-1212182 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,112 Brooklyn, NY 11201 DEED BOOK 0603 PG-00660 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,112 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 81,794 22,144 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-51 ****************** Marlin Hill Rd 150.-1-51 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 31,088 31,088 31,088 Burtis Theodore A III Germantown 103602 111,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 216,984 Keefer Judith A ACRES 21.67 BANK0080490 248,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 216,984 12 Verandah Pl EAST-0680725 NRTH-1211382 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 216,984 Brooklyn, NY 11201 DEED BOOK 0601 PG-01034 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 216,984 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 354,389 31,088 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-17.120 ************** 678 C R 31 150.-1-17.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Burtt Norman Germantown 103602 37,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Burtt Cynthia Micro 9462 198,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 678 County Rte 31 ACRES 1.24 BANK0080330 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,728 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0676437 NRTH-1215804 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,288 TO M DEED BOOK 0592 PG-00209 FULL MARKET VALUE 283,269 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-31 ****************** 100 Mountainview Dr 192.-1-31 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Busell Phyllis Pine Plains 134201 49,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 205,900 100 Mountain View Dr ACRES 4.30 205,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 205,900 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683755 NRTH-1180140 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 179,340 DEED BOOK C418 PG-F2473 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,900 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 294,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 49 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-8.100 ************* 51 Highland Ave 192.20-2-8.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bush Stephen Pine Plains 134201 40,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 214,336 Bush Terry Micro 96-27 & 00-136 214,336 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 214,336 51 Highland Ave ACRES 1.53 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 187,776 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683538 NRTH-1178670 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 214,336 TO M DEED BOOK C395 PG-F1257 FULL MARKET VALUE 306,194 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-46 ****************** Half Circle Rd 149.-1-46 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 118,320 Bushey Jeannetta M Germantown 103602 35,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,320 Gordon Lauren S ACRES 0.91 BANKC010015 118,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,320 44 West 96 St Apt 2b EAST-0669617 NRTH-1215930 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 118,320 TO M New York, NY 10025 DEED BOOK C355 PG-F61 FULL MARKET VALUE 169,029 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-57 ****************** 19 Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-57 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Bushnell Robert Red Hook 134801 40,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Bushnell Jeanette Micro 9816 162,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,492 19 Bingham Mills Rd ACRES 1.50 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 134,492 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676929 NRTH-1194096 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 111,830 DEED BOOK C524 PG-F827 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 162,100 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 231,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-62 ***************** Shore Dr.lot 6 201.2-1-62 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,272 Bustamante Omar Pine Plains 134201 19,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,272 114-49 114th St Reilly Twin Lake 102,272 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,272 Ozone Park, NY 11420 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,272 TO M BANK0080490 EAST-0682486 NRTH-1174698 DEED BOOK 0531 PG-00797 FULL MARKET VALUE 146,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-70 ***************** Shore Dr.lot 60 201.2-1-70 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,728 Bustamante Omar Pine Plains 134201 12,948 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,728 114-49 114th St Reilly Twin Lake 16,728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,728 Ozone Park, NY 11420 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 16,728 TO M BANK0080490 EAST-0682356 NRTH-1174787 DEED BOOK 0531 PG-00797 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,897 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 50 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-71 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 61 201.2-1-71 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Bustamante Omar Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 114-49 114th St Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Ozone Park, NY 11420 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682326 NRTH-1174747 DEED BOOK 0550 PG-00752 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-72 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 62 201.2-1-72 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Bustamante Omar Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 114-49 114th St Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Ozone Park, NY 11420 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682306 NRTH-1174697 DEED BOOK 0550 PG-00750 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-18 ****************** Walkers Rd 160.-1-18 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 117,640 Byington Todd Germantown 103602 29,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 117,640 210 Walkers Mills Rd FRNT 130.00 DPTH 195.00 117,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 117,640 Germantown, NY 12526 BANK0030982 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,640 TO M EAST-0675771 NRTH-1208533 DEED BOOK C0325 PG-F1825 FULL MARKET VALUE 168,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-12 ****************** 5431 Rt 9H 140.-1-12 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,776 Byrne John A Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,776 Byrne Irene P ACRES 1.00 185,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 185,776 PO Box 128 EAST-0693466 NRTH-1221097 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,776 TO M Claverack, NY 12513 DEED BOOK C518 PG-F2188 FULL MARKET VALUE 265,394 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-31.100 ************** CR 8 182.-1-31.100 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,400 Cahill John Jr Germantown 103602 105,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,400 164 Nevis Rd Micro 93-305 105,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,400 Tivoli, NY 12583 ACRES 31.70 BANK0070170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,400 TO M EAST-0686399 NRTH-1188355 DEED BOOK C0357 PG-F0593 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 51 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-44 ****************** 106 Half Circle Rd 149.-1-44 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Caldwell James Germantown 103602 45,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Caldwell Barbara ACRES 2.10 BANK0080490 148,240 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,675 106 Half Circle Ext EAST-0669766 NRTH-1216181 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,675 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0501 PG-00505 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,680 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,771 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,240 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-6.100 *************** CR 19 192.-1-6.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,816 Callan Trissy Germantown 103602 59,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,816 325 E 12Th Apt 3a ACRES 7.44 BANKN140687 153,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 153,816 New York, NY 10003 EAST-0682437 NRTH-1184597 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,816 TO M DEED BOOK C0369 PG-F0068 FULL MARKET VALUE 219,737 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-80.110 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-80.110 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,448 Cambalik Helen Hudson 100600 87,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,448 Neceda John ACRES 9.90 87,448 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,448 157 Linden Ave EAST-0693125 NRTH-1205967 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,448 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 DEED BOOK C0289 PG-F0130 FULL MARKET VALUE 124,926 ******************************************************************************************************* 193.-1-2 ******************* White Oak Dr 193.-1-2 581 Chd/adt camp BUSIN8/97 47611 9,000 9,000 0 Camp Eagle Hill Inc Germantown 103602 514,646 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1623,000 Box 12 ACRES 162.20 1632,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1623,000 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0687089 NRTH-1183206 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1632,000 DEED BOOK 0532 PG-00865 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1632,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 2331,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-20.1 **************** CR 19 201.-1-20.1 581 Chd/adt camp - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2195,000 Camp Scatico Pine Plains 134201 498,461 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2195,000 micro 07-31 2195,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2195,000 PO Box 6 ACRES 163.32 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2195,000 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683840 NRTH-0117450 DEED BOOK 0221 PG-00095 FULL MARKET VALUE 3135,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 52 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-8.200 *************** 162 C R 10 149.-1-8.200 270 Mfg housing EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Campbell Donald Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,408 Decker Marion Micro 7095 51,408 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 51,408 162 County Rte 10 ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,138 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669685 NRTH-1216680 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 51,408 TO M DEED BOOK 0571 PG-00167 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-16 ****************** CR 19 201.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,240 Campbell Robert Pine Plains 134201 47,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,240 4 Stone Church Rd ACRES 2.00 80,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,240 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 EAST-0684307 NRTH-1174041 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 80,240 TO M DEED BOOK 0584 PG-01051 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,629 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-41.111 ************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-41.111 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 12,648 Cannata J Hudson 100600 12,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 12,648 334 Rolling Hill Grn micro06-105 12,648 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 12,648 Staten Island, NY 10312 Bk22 Pg1639 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 12,648 TO M ACRES 4.20 EAST-0695830 NRTH-0120450 DEED BOOK 0633 PG-00260 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-41.120 ************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-41.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 253,912 Cannata J Hudson 100600 52,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 253,912 334 Rolling Hill Grn micro06105 253,912 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 253,912 Staten Island, NY 10312 ACRES 4.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 253,912 TO M EAST-0695690 NRTH-0120420 DEED BOOK 0602 PG-01114 FULL MARKET VALUE 362,731 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-41.112 ************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-41.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,456 Cannata Joann Hudson 100600 16,456 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,456 Cannata Rita Micro 06105 16,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,456 334 Rolling Hill Grn ACRES 4.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 16,456 TO M Staten Island, NY 10312 EAST-0695550 NRTH-0120400 DEED BOOK 602 PG-1114 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,509 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 53 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-6 ******************* Stephen Dr 139.-1-6 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 232,000 Cannavo Carmela M Germantown 103602 44,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 232,000 9 Evon Ct Tom Thumb 232,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 232,000 Scarsdale, NY 10583 ACRES 2.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 232,000 TO M EAST-0679299 NRTH-1224929 DEED BOOK 622 PG-1186 FULL MARKET VALUE 331,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-64 ***************** C R 19 161.1-1-64 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cannizzaro Nina E Hudson 100600 42,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,424 Bard College Msc 1527 ACRES 1.75 BANKN140687 147,424 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,424 PO Box 5000 EAST-0687277 NRTH-1205295 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,864 Anandale, NY 12504 DEED BOOK C433 PG-F995 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,424 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 210,606 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 147,424 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-9.200 *************** 37 Klibar Rd 150.-1-9.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Capetola Dolores Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 163,064 Canade Sautman ACRES 1.00 BANKC080005 163,064 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 163,064 270 Henderson St #18 I EAST-0677751 NRTH-1215896 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,504 Jersey City, NJ 07304 DEED BOOK C506 PG-F1606 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 163,064 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 232,949 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-46.111 ************** Rte 9 Livingston Lot 3 161.-1-46.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,392 Carr Wilbourne Hudson 100600 54,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,392 Carr Iris Micro 6699 108,392 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,392 Box 8 ACRES 4.68 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,392 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0686059 NRTH-1203863 DEED BOOK 0598 PG-00776 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-56 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-56 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 15,640 Carrington Jerome Pine Plains 134201 15,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 15,640 Carrington Elaine Micro 97-235 15,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 15,640 650 West End Ave ACRES 3.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 15,640 TO M New York, NY 10025 EAST-0682380 NRTH-1172468 DEED BOOK C0300 PG-F0693 FULL MARKET VALUE 22,343 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 54 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-14 ****************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-14 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Caruso Patricia Pine Plains 134201 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 178,568 103 White Oak Rd ACRES 3.00 BANKC080005 178,568 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 178,568 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684462 NRTH-1181791 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 152,008 DEED BOOK C399 PG-F2244 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 178,568 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 255,097 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-38.100 ************** Deerhaven Rd 171.-1-38.100 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 165,000 Casey Jon A Germantown 103602 165,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 165,000 Casey Sharon J F ACRES 80.00 165,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 165,000 46 Wennington Dr EAST-0693021 NRTH-1195157 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 165,000 TO M Poughkeepsie, NY 12603 DEED BOOK C0505 PG-F0858 FULL MARKET VALUE 235,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-3 ****************** OTS 222 & 222a 1/2 Lots 223 & 223A 201.8-1-3 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,760 Cassidy James Pine Plains 134201 38,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,760 Cassidy Patricia Reilly Twin Lake 140,760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 140,760 2434 Australia Way E Apt 52 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 140,760 TO M Clearwater, FL 33763 EAST-0682866 NRTH-1174788 DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F2016 FULL MARKET VALUE 201,086 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-8 ****************** 1/2 Lot 223 & 223A 201.8-1-8 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 10,336 Cassidy James Pine Plains 134201 10,336 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 10,336 Cassidy Patricia Reilly Twin Lake 10,336 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 10,336 2434 Australia Way E Apt 52 FRNT 25.00 DPTH 130.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 10,336 TO M Clearwater, FL 33763 EAST-0682896 NRTH-1174758 DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F2020 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,766 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-9 ****************** Betty Rd 201.8-1-9 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Cassidy James Pine Plains 134201 34,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 149,219 Cassidy Patricia Reilly Twin Lake 165,784 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 149,219 2434 Australia Way E Apt 52 ACRES 0.17 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 165,784 Clearwater, FL 33763 EAST-0682936 NRTH-1174719 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 165,784 TO M DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F2012 FULL MARKET VALUE 236,834 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 55 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-55 ***************** 23 Shore Dr Lot 25 201.8-2-55 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Castellano John Pine Plains 134201 29,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 146,608 23 Shore Dr Bk18 Pg1374 146,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 146,608 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 51.00 DPTH 180.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,338 EAST-0683128 NRTH-1173489 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,608 TO M DEED BOOK 0596 PG-00861 FULL MARKET VALUE 209,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-15 ***************** Helen Rd 201.8-2-15 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 31,960 Castellano John S Pine Plains 134201 31,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 31,960 Castellano Patricia M Pb18pg1374 31,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,960 23 Shore Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 31,960 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683068 NRTH-1173839 DEED BOOK C426 PG-F1424 FULL MARKET VALUE 45,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-75 ****************** 224 Scuderhook Rd Lot 1 171.-1-75 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ceasarine Peter Germantown 103602 51,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 204,544 Ceasarine Dale Micro 10694 204,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 204,544 244 Scudderhook Rd ACRES 3.90 BANKC030614 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 177,984 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0691981 NRTH-1197615 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 204,544 TO M DEED BOOK C407 PG-F1877 FULL MARKET VALUE 292,206 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-13.111 ************** Off Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-13.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 341,088 Cendroski Edward Germantown 103602 118,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 341,088 85 Bacon Dr Stop43 Micro 00-139 341,088 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 341,088 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 36.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 341,088 TO M EAST-0691015 NRTH-1190494 DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F0676 FULL MARKET VALUE 487,269 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-13.112 ************** Off Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-13.112 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 176,800 Cendroski Edward Germantown 103602 52,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 176,800 85bacon Dr Stop 43 Micro 00-139 176,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 176,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 6.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,800 TO M EAST-0691015 NRTH-1190494 DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F0676 FULL MARKET VALUE 252,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 56 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-31 ***************** Off Pine Rd 201.2-1-31 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 17,816 Chapin Newt Pine Plains 134201 17,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 17,816 860 Larch St FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 17,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,816 Eugene, OR 97405 BANKC061222 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 17,816 TO M EAST-0681203 NRTH-1176055 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F2187 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,451 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-32 ***************** Off Pine Rd 201.2-1-32 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 Chapin Newt Pine Plains 134201 24,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 860 Larch St FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 174,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 Eugene, OR 97405 BANKC061222 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,352 TO M EAST-0681283 NRTH-1176055 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F2187 FULL MARKET VALUE 249,074 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-34.120 ************* Pine Rd 201.2-1-34.120 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 23,800 Chapin Newt Pine Plains 134201 23,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 23,800 Chapin Madeleine Micro 9248 23,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 23,800 860 Larch St ACRES 1.00 BANKC061222 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 23,800 TO M Eugene, OR 97405 EAST-0681434 NRTH-1175866 DEED BOOK C438 PG-F1739 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-35 ****************** SR 9 170.-1-35 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 78,336 Character Unlimited Llc Red Hook 134801 25,764 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 78,336 76 Banks Ln Blue Stores 78,336 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,336 Germantown, NY 12526 FRNT 147.18 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 78,336 TO M EAST-0676250 NRTH-1193375 DEED BOOK 538 PG-1830 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-12.200 ************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-12.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Chen Melvin Germantown 103602 33,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 273,496 Roffman Karin FRNT 204.18 DPTH 195.04 273,496 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 273,496 136 White Oak Rd BANKC120345 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 246,936 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684921 NRTH-1182417 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 273,496 TO M DEED BOOK C513 PG-F2060 FULL MARKET VALUE 390,709 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 57 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-53.22 *************** C R 19 192.-1-53.22 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,432 Chinelli Paul Germantown 103602 42,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,432 Chinelli Leslie Micro 06-287 42,432 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,432 1117 C R 19 ACRES 4.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,432 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683730 NRTH-0118320 DEED BOOK 591 PG-824 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,617 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-53.100 ************** C R 19 192.-1-53.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Chinelli Paul Germantown 103602 62,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 210,200 Chinelli Leslie S Micro 9284 & 6818 210,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 210,200 1117 Co Rt 19 ACRES 9.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,640 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683760 NRTH-0118340 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 210,200 TO M DEED BOOK C502 PG-F0338 FULL MARKET VALUE 300,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-45.200 ************* Baxter Rd 201.8-1-45.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,552 Christensen Andrea Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,552 22 Baxter Rd Reilly Twin Lake 82,552 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,552 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,552 TO M EAST-0691529 NRTH-1175743 DEED BOOK 582 PG-984 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-77.111 ************** CR 10 149.-1-77.111 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Christensen Ryan Germantown 103602 54,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Rowell Teresa Micro-4157 54,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 169 Commons Rd ACRES 3.67 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,672 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671793 NRTH-1212355 DEED BOOK 656 PG-2033 PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,103 Mast James ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-58 ***************** Shore Dr 201.8-2-58 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 285,800 Chu Richard Pine Plains 134201 30,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 285,800 Chu Theresa Reilly Twin Lake 285,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 285,800 30 St Andrews Ln FRNT 51.00 DPTH 210.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 285,800 TO M Hopewell Junction, NY 12533 BANK0180200 EAST-0683288 NRTH-1173549 DEED BOOK 0490 PG-00643 FULL MARKET VALUE 408,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 58 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-59 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 28 201.8-2-59 312 Vac w/imprv - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 23,800 Chu Richard Pine Plains 134201 15,680 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 23,800 Chu Theresa Reilly Twin Lake 23,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 23,800 30 Saint Andrews Ln FRNT 51.00 DPTH 185.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 23,800 TO M Hopewell Junction, NY 12533 EAST-0683328 NRTH-1173579 DEED BOOK C418 PG-F2202 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-19.200 ************** 163 Orchard Rd 140.-1-19.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cichetti Roberta Hudson 100600 56,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,064 163 Orchard Rd Micro 10485 197,064 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,064 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 3.22 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,504 EAST-0687248 NRTH-1219720 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,064 TO M DEED BOOK 0608 PG-00944 FULL MARKET VALUE 281,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-54 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 24 201.8-2-54 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 34,272 Ciferri James P Pine Plains 134201 34,272 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 34,272 Ciferri Rossali Richard C Reilly Twin Lake 34,272 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 34,272 27 Shore Dr FRNT 51.00 DPTH 180.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 34,272 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683088 NRTH-1173469 DEED BOOK 0348 PG-00236 FULL MARKET VALUE 48,960 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-53 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 23 201.8-2-53 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Ciferri Richard C Pine Plains 134201 69,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ciferri Arlene Reilly Twin Lake 164,424 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 27 Shore Dr ACRES 0.29 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683028 NRTH-1173459 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,864 DEED BOOK 0306 PG-00357 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,424 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 234,891 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-41.110 ************** 1909 Rte 8 181.-1-41.110 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Clare Herbert P Germantown 103602 32,623 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 246,296 Clare Michelle FRNT 143.24 DPTH 200.00 246,296 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 246,296 1909 Route 8 BANKC130171 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 196,026 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684521 NRTH-1187821 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 246,296 TO M DEED BOOK C410 PG-F13 FULL MARKET VALUE 351,851 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 59 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-37 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-37 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Clark Carole Hudson 100600 39,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,800 PO Box 122 ACRES 1.48 BANKN140687 215,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,800 LIvingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688613 NRTH-1207138 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 189,240 DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F2107 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,800 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 308,286 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 215,800 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-24 ****************** Churchtown Rd 141.-1-24 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Clark Franklin Copake-Taconic 102801 17,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,880 Clark Eleanor FRNT 90.00 DPTH 115.48 129,880 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,880 Box 166 EAST-0703351 NRTH-1218246 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 79,610 Claverack, NY 12513 DEED BOOK 0516 PG-00401 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,880 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 185,543 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-10 ****************** 5584 SR 9G 128.-1-10 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 178,568 Clarke Patrick Hudson 100600 74,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 178,568 DaMore Melissa ACRES 5.40 178,568 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 178,568 5584 State Rte 9G EAST-0671896 NRTH-1226564 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 178,568 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 564 PG-2122 FULL MARKET VALUE 255,097 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-7 ******************* SR 9G 128.-1-7 515 Media studio COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,208 Clear Channel Broadcastin Hudson 100600 80,343 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,208 20 Tucker Dr Micro#11981 92,208 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,208 Poughkeepsie, NY 12603 ACRES 1.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,208 TO M EAST-0671975 NRTH-1226964 DEED BOOK C403 PG-F1816 FULL MARKET VALUE 131,726 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-12.111 ************** 123 White Oak Rd 192.-1-12.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 228,600 Clements James Germantown 103602 38,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 228,600 160 Chestnut St Micro 7457 & 8419 228,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 228,600 Engelwood Cliffs, NJ 07632 ACRES 1.06 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,600 TO M EAST-0684722 NRTH-1182082 DEED BOOK 550 PG-1991 FULL MARKET VALUE 326,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 60 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-12.120 ************** White Oak Rd Par 2 192.-1-12.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Clements William Germantown 103602 32,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,424 Clements Carol FRNT 216.31 DPTH 125.00 130,424 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,424 PO Box 186 EAST-0684692 NRTH-1181942 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,864 Elizaville, NY 12523-0186 DEED BOOK 0576 PG-00389 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,424 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 186,320 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-13 ****************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-13 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 24,616 Clements William Germantown 103602 23,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 24,616 Clemeents Carol Micro 7457 24,616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 24,616 115 White Oak Rd ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 24,616 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684552 NRTH-1181951 DEED BOOK C0344 PG-F1277 FULL MARKET VALUE 35,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-17.200 ************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-17.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Clum David Hudson 100600 48,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 199,648 Clum Nancy ACRES 3.02 199,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 199,648 PO Box 188 EAST-0690884 NRTH-1206532 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,088 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0544 PG-00986 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 199,648 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 285,211 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-30 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-30 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,592 Clum Edwin Pine Plains 134201 41,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,592 Clum Linda E Bk22 Pg1602 101,592 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,592 69 Nevis Rd FRNT 48.33 DPTH 139.48 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 101,592 TO M Tivoli, NY 12583 EAST-0682610 NRTH-1178008 DEED BOOK C0361 PG-F1992 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,131 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-3 ******************* Off White Birch Rd 139.-1-3 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,960 Cocchia Benjamin Hudson 100600 82,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,960 122 Belvadere Rd ACRES 20.00 82,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,960 Beacon, NY 12508 EAST-0676729 NRTH-1224904 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,960 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00101 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,514 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 61 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-23 ****************** 120 Walkers Rd 160.-1-23 270 Mfg housing COM VET/CT 41131 12,580 12,580 0 Coe Anne Germantown 103602 35,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 120 Walker Mill Rd ACRES 1.00 50,320 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,740 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0674943 NRTH-1207171 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,740 DEED BOOK C0297 PG-F0003 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 23,760 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,886 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,320 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-24 ****************** Walkers Rd 160.-1-24 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 22,984 Coe Anne Germantown 103602 8,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 22,984 120 Walker Mill Rd FRNT 242.00 DPTH 120.00 22,984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,984 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675083 NRTH-1207151 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 22,984 TO M DEED BOOK C0297 PG-F0003 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,834 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-2.220 *************** 311 Orchard Rd 151.-1-2.220 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Coffey Elizabeth Hudson 100600 51,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 323,544 Loring Sondra ACRES 4.00 323,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 323,544 311 Orchard Rd EAST-0688194 NRTH-1216704 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 296,984 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C412 PG-F122 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 323,544 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 462,206 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-25 ***************** CR 19 201.8-3-25 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 58,480 58,480 58,480 Colburn Frances Pine Plains 134201 56,800 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Box 449 Bk10 Pg786 0002 116,960 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,480 Red Hook, NY 12571 FRNT 180.00 DPTH 190.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,480 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,210 EAST-0683678 NRTH-1173930 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,960 TO M DEED BOOK 0613 PG-00532 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,086 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-66 ****************** 43 Cold Spring Rd 139.-1-66 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 126,140 126,140 126,140 Cold Spring Tree Farm, LLC Germantown 103602 293,600 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 43 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 100.00 548,216 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 422,076 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679752 NRTH-1218160 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 422,076 DEED BOOK 645 PG-559 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 395,516 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 783,166 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 422,076 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 126,140 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 62 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-16 ****************** 9 Hill Rd 139.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Cole Robert F Germantown 103602 51,700 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Cole Marcia L Tom Thumb 202,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,492 9 Hill Rd ACRES 2.32 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,492 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679720 NRTH-1224340 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 151,830 DEED BOOK 0417 PG-00407 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 202,100 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 288,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-65.1 **************** Cold Spring Rd 139.-1-65.1 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 296,379 296,379 296,379 Collier Bruce Germantown 103602 310,352 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 13,973 Collier Joyce ACRES 63.70 310,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 13,973 43 Cold Spring Rd EAST-0678042 NRTH-1218177 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 13,973 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0296 PG-F0338 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 13,973 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 443,360 296,379 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-80.200 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-80.200 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,200 Collier Jay Hudson 100600 67,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,200 198 E Lakeview Ave ACRES 12.98 87,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,200 West Harrison, NY 10604 EAST-0693585 NRTH-1205848 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,200 TO M DEED BOOK C377 PG-F1365 FULL MARKET VALUE 124,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-20 ****************** OFF CR 19 192.-1-20 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,416 Collins Alicia Turek Pine Plains 134201 82,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,416 8512 Tuckerman Ln ACRES 24.80 82,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,416 Potomac, MD 20854 EAST-0679756 NRTH-1179822 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,416 TO M DEED BOOK 0550 PG-00322 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,737 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-15 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-15 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Colonial Johnstown Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 7536 N Broadway Micro 94-118 35,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Red Hook, NY 12571-1429 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,000 TO M EAST-0686300 NRTH-0120280 DEED BOOK 00788 PG-00009 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 63 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-18 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-18 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Colonial Johnstown Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 7536 N Broadway Micro 94-118 35,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Red Hook, NY 12571-1429 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,000 TO M EAST-0686200 NRTH-0120340 DEED BOOK 00788 PG-00009 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-49.200 ************** CR 19 161.-1-49.200 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 78,500 Colonial Johnstown Estates Hudson 100600 78,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 78,500 Kim Keil Micro 05-291 78,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,500 7534 N Broadway ACRES 3.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 78,500 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0686380 NRTH-0120240 DEED BOOK 595 PG-17796 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-36.111 ************** Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-36.111 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 325,800 Columbia RST LLC Germantown 103602 325,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 325,800 JR Equities, Inc. Micro 10694 325,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 325,800 38 E 29th St Fl 10th ACRES 74.11 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 325,800 TO M New York, NY 10016 EAST-0691923 NRTH-1196455 DEED BOOK 617 PG-1815 FULL MARKET VALUE 465,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-87 ****************** Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-87 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Columbia RST, LLC Germantown 103602 54,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 38 E 29th St Fl 10th ACRES 2.00 54,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 New York, NY 10016 EAST-0655060 NRTH-0772050 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,672 TO M DEED BOOK 645 PG-12 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-2 ******************* LOT 21 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Colwell Brian T Hudson 100600 43,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 149,700 Colwell Tiffany Micro 94-118 & 95-283 149,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 149,700 PO Box 269 ACRES 1.08 BANKC080007 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 123,140 Claverack, NY 12513 EAST-0685980 NRTH-1203543 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 149,700 TO M DEED BOOK C0289 PG-F0745 FULL MARKET VALUE 213,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 64 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-72.120 ************** LOT 2 CR 19 171.-1-72.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Colwell Matthew Germantown 103602 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 190,200 Colwell Jennifer Micro 12205 190,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 190,200 PO Box 803 ACRES 2.10 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,640 Claverack, NY 12513 EAST-0686369 NRTH-1198994 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,200 TO M DEED BOOK C353 PG-F895 FULL MARKET VALUE 271,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-26 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-26 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Companik Richard Hudson 100600 30,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 Philippe Paul Bk17 Pg1311 170,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 PO Box 26 FRNT 90.00 DPTH 270.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,440 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687784 NRTH-1206406 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,000 TO M DEED BOOK C0286 PG-F1521 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 170,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 242,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-36 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-36 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 Connavo Leonard Germantown 103602 66,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 Connavo Rose ACRES 8.20 109,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 23elmont Ave EAST-0676291 NRTH-1213364 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,480 TO M Port Chester, NY 10573 DEED BOOK 0402 PG-00241 FULL MARKET VALUE 156,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-16 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-16 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 184,960 Connor Thomas Hudson 100600 55,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 184,960 Greene Linda A ACRES 3.00 184,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 184,960 912 President St 2 EAST-0687305 NRTH-1205925 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 184,960 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11215 DEED BOOK 573 PG-205 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 184,960 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 264,229 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-22 ***************** Shore Dr. Lts. 36-37 201.8-2-22 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 138,856 Connors Mary Pine Plains 134201 42,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 138,856 Brudi William Twin Lake Realty Subd 138,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,856 712 Narragansett Villas Dr Pb 18 Pg 1374 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 138,856 TO M Lindenhurst, NY 11757 FRNT 101.94 DPTH 125.00 EAST-0683398 NRTH-1173829 DEED BOOK 578 PG-1491 FULL MARKET VALUE 198,366 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 65 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-20.200 ************** 700 CR 31 150.-1-20.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Conte Armand J Germantown 103602 64,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 196,520 700 County Rte 31 Micro 99-167 196,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 196,520 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 3.90 BANKH080006 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 169,960 EAST-0676348 NRTH-1215274 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 196,520 TO M DEED BOOK C0345 PG-F0882 FULL MARKET VALUE 280,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-5.112 *************** Livingston 160.-1-5.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Conte Derrick Hudson 100600 65,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 231,800 Bovat Nicole L Micro 10099 231,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 231,800 993 County Route 10 Stop ACRES 6.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 205,240 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0722371 NRTH-0546160 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 231,800 TO M DEED BOOK C502 PG-F2034 FULL MARKET VALUE 331,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-5.200 *************** 993 C R 10 160.-1-5.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Conte Ferdinand Hudson 100600 48,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,744 Conte Mary Micro 10099 129,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,744 993 Rte 10 Stop 15 ACRES 2.30 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,184 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0683472 NRTH-1207468 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,744 TO M DEED BOOK 0605 PG-00319 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,349 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-77 ****************** 177 White Birch Rd 139.-1-77 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Conte Linda J Hudson 100600 52,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 177 White Birch Rd Micro 97-198 172,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 4.14 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 146,296 EAST-0675490 NRTH-1224151 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,856 TO M DEED BOOK C0298 PG-F1001 FULL MARKET VALUE 246,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-5.120 *************** 993 C R 10 160.-1-5.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Conte Randall Hudson 100600 62,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Conte Brianna N Micro 10099 198,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 993 C R 10 ACRES 3.76 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,728 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0683232 NRTH-1207637 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,288 TO M DEED BOOK 555 PG-754 FULL MARKET VALUE 283,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 66 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-25 ****************** Feller Rd 161.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cook William Hudson 100600 43,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,848 PO Box 394 FRNT 300.00 DPTH 160.00 56,848 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,848 Claverack, NY 12513-1823 BANKH031871 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 30,288 EAST-0698373 NRTH-1206827 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,848 TO M DEED BOOK C352 PG-F348 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,211 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-32.200 ************** CR 2 201.-1-32.200 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 34,544 Cookingham Oakleigh T Pine Plains 134201 34,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 34,544 Jimenez Stanya III ACRES 4.23 34,544 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 34,544 38 Cookingham Ln EAST-0681540 NRTH-1172756 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 34,544 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 DEED BOOK 0631 PG-00274 FULL MARKET VALUE 49,349 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-8 ****************** 28 Pine Rd 201.2-1-8 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,752 Coon Timothy J Pine Plains 134201 39,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,752 Unson Audrey E Bk16 Pg1966 58,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,752 28 Pine Rd FRNT 110.20 DPTH 140.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,752 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681792 NRTH-1176976 DEED BOOK 575 PG-1665 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-36 ****************** 1877 CR 8 181.-1-36 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Coons Gloria Germantown 103602 54,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,688 1877 Rte 8 ACRES 4.80 BANKH080007 92,688 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,688 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683811 NRTH-1187830 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,128 DEED BOOK 0463 PG-00393 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,688 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 132,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-38 ****************** Private Rd 170.-2-38 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,160 Coons Harold Red Hook 134801 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,160 21 Chip Rd ACRES 1.00 42,160 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,160 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680957 NRTH-1194844 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,160 TO M DEED BOOK 0599 PG-00788 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,229 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 67 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-37 ****************** 21 Maple Ln Off Priv Rd. L 170.-2-37 270 Mfg housing EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Coons Harold J Sr Red Hook 134801 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 59,704 21 Chip Rd ACRES 1.00 59,704 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 59,704 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681077 NRTH-1195004 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 9,434 DEED BOOK 0579 PG-00523 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 59,704 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 85,291 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-19 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-19 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Coons Randy Pine Plains 134201 51,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 186,592 56 Pine Rd Bruckert 186,592 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 186,592 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 3.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,032 EAST-0681073 NRTH-1176565 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 186,592 TO M DEED BOOK C0485 PG-F0988 FULL MARKET VALUE 266,560 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-38 ***************** 10 Honor Rd Lots 95-96 201.8-2-38 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Corbett Lorraine Pine Plains 134201 37,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 168,232 10 Honor Rd Bk18 Pg1374 168,232 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 168,232 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 141,672 BANKC080370 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 168,232 TO M EAST-0682485 NRTH-1175303 DEED BOOK 0630 PG-00302 FULL MARKET VALUE 240,331 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-12.112 ************** 15 Jacqueline Rd 141.-1-12.112 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Corbett Peter Copake-Taconic 102801 44,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Corbett Kathleen ACRES 1.90 BANKH110045 176,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 149,192 15 Jacqueline Rd EAST-0696880 NRTH-1218714 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 149,192 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0570 PG-00415 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,240 FULL MARKET VALUE 252,571 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,800 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-84 ****************** Church Rd 161.-1-84 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cordato Joseph Hudson 100600 55,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 179,520 Cordato Laurie Micro 10189 & 00-151 179,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 179,520 PO Box 156 ACRES 5.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 152,960 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0692515 NRTH-1206146 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 179,520 TO M DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F1751 FULL MARKET VALUE 256,457 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 68 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-81 ****************** OFF CHURCH Rd 161.-1-81 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 31,552 Cordato Joseph W Jr Hudson 100600 31,552 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 31,552 Cordato Laurie A Micro 10189 & 00-151 31,552 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,552 PO Box 156 ACRES 14.43 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 31,552 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0692864 NRTH-1206296 DEED BOOK C416 PG-F212 FULL MARKET VALUE 45,074 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-60 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-60 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 181,806 181,806 0 Cordato.laurie Hudson 100600 45,000 AGED - ALL 41800 8,853 8,853 99,756 Cordato Kristina ACRES 2.00 199,512 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 156 EAST-0687676 NRTH-1205556 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 8,853 PO Box BOX DEED BOOK C458 PG-F2260 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 8,853 Livingston, NY 12541 FULL MARKET VALUE 285,017 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,486 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 199,512 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 199,512 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-86.100 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-86.100 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,888 Cornelius Victor Germantown 103602 71,036 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,888 Wire Rd ACRES 20.90 109,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,888 PO Box 186 EAST-0672396 NRTH-1210916 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,888 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 00814 PG-00201 FULL MARKET VALUE 156,983 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-87 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-87 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 78,880 Cornelius Victor Germantown 103602 78,880 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 78,880 Wire Rd Map Book 8 Page 7 78,880 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,880 PO Box 186 ACRES 5.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 78,880 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671717 NRTH-1210612 DEED BOOK 00814 PG-00201 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,686 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-89 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-89 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cornelius Victor Germantown 103602 51,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 541,960 Wire Rd Micro 3187 541,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 541,960 PO Box 186 ACRES 4.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 515,400 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670878 NRTH-1209923 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 541,960 TO M DEED BOOK 00814 PG-00201 FULL MARKET VALUE 774,229 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 69 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-11 ****************** CR 19 170.-2-11 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cornell Susan Germantown 103602 33,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,712 PO Box 47 ACRES 0.88 107,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,712 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0685796 NRTH-1195163 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,152 DEED BOOK 00696 PG-00070 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,712 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 153,874 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-6 ***************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-1-6 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cortes Marie T Pine Plains 134201 16,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,216 PO Box 79 Pb 22 Pg 1602 0001 123,216 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 123,216 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 180.37 DPTH 231.45 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,656 EAST-0683119 NRTH-1178309 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 123,216 TO M DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00460 FULL MARKET VALUE 176,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-21 ****************** 3326 Us 9 Bells Pond 151.-1-21 421 Restaurant COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 243,984 Costa Paul Hudson 100600 46,097 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 243,984 3326 Rte 9 Micro 1426 243,984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 243,984 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.06 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 243,984 TO M EAST-0692024 NRTH-1216824 DEED BOOK 00778 PG-00199 FULL MARKET VALUE 348,549 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-3.120 *************** CR 31 160.-1-3.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cotsonas Renee Germantown 103602 77,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 285,000 Grzeskow Peter S Micro 00-144 285,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 285,000 993 County Route 31 ACRES 3.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 258,440 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0677630 NRTH-1208886 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 285,000 TO M DEED BOOK C448 PG-F1775 FULL MARKET VALUE 407,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-34.100 ************** 9-H & 82 140.-1-34.100 117 Horse farm AG DISTRIC 41720 566,005 566,005 566,005 Cotswold Holdings Llc Hudson 100600 794,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 817,795 65 Bells Pond Rd Pb 10 Pg 838 Micro 6 1383,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 817,795 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 245.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 817,795 EAST-0694899 NRTH-1219050 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 817,795 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 00783 PG-00166 566,005 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 1976,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 70 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-8 ******************* Sr 82 151.-1-8 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 31,008 Cotswold Holdings Llc Hudson 100600 25,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 31,008 65 Bells Pond Rd FRNT 265.00 DPTH 150.00 31,008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,008 Hudson, NY 12534 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 31,008 TO M EAST-0693374 NRTH-1216907 DEED BOOK C402 PG-F213 FULL MARKET VALUE 44,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-58.200 ************** CR 31 139.-1-58.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 304,200 Counts Michael R Germantown 103602 59,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 304,200 Counts Sharon B Micro 00-86 304,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 304,200 1 Cadman Plz W ACRES 8.30 BANKH030614 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 304,200 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11201 EAST-0678020 NRTH-1219237 DEED BOOK 597 PG-523 FULL MARKET VALUE 434,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-28 **************** Mountainview Dr 192.20-1-28 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 County of Columbia Pine Plains 134201 19,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 401 State St Bk22 Pg1602 0001 19,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 54.77 DPTH 119.55 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,040 TO M EAST-0683260 NRTH-1177999 DEED BOOK 646 PG-935 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-29 **************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-1-29 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,328 County of Columbia Pine Plains 134201 47,328 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,328 401 State St Twin Lakes 47,328 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,328 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 154.77 DPTH 131.08 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,328 TO M EAST-0683130 NRTH-1178029 DEED BOOK 646 PG-938 FULL MARKET VALUE 67,611 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-39 **************** Mountainview Dr 85-86-87 192.20-1-39 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 County of Columbia Pine Plains 134201 38,624 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 401 State St Bk22 Pg1602 0001 38,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 233.01 DPTH 120.83 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,624 TO M EAST-0683280 NRTH-1177889 DEED BOOK 646 PG-941 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,177 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 71 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-8 ******************* Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-8 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Couse Gerald Pine Plains 134201 43,800 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Couse Marilynn ACRES 1.40 BANK0180200 170,680 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,115 Box 1 EAST-0680664 NRTH-1175734 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,115 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0522 PG-00701 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 144,120 FULL MARKET VALUE 243,829 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,680 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-9 ******************* Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-9 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 57,528 Couse Marilynn Pine Plains 134201 57,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 57,528 Couse Gerald ACRES 2.40 57,528 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,528 PO Box 1 EAST-0680715 NRTH-1175514 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 57,528 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 00806 PG-00340 FULL MARKET VALUE 82,183 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-7 ******************* LOT 16 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-7 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,800 Couse Steven Hudson 100600 44,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,800 35 Mahikan Dr Micro 94-118 & 95-283 215,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 215,800 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.97 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,800 TO M EAST-0686031 NRTH-1202983 DEED BOOK C518 PG-F294 FULL MARKET VALUE 308,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-15 ****************** CR 31 160.-1-15 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 Cozelino John Germantown 103602 51,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 Cozelino Susan ACRES 2.60 133,144 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 2252 5th St EAST-0676733 NRTH-1207135 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 133,144 TO M E Meadows, NY 11554 DEED BOOK C0365 PG-F2076 FULL MARKET VALUE 190,206 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-35.111 ************** Route 9 170.-2-35.111 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,000 Cranesville Block Co., Inc. Red Hook 134801 155,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,000 1250 Riverfront Center ACRES 4.50 155,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,000 Amsterdam, NY 12010 EAST-0680310 NRTH-9480492 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,000 TO M DEED BOOK 625 PG-306 FULL MARKET VALUE 221,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-35.112 ************** Route 9 170.-2-35.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,000 Cranesville Block Co., Inc. Red Hook 134801 150,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,000 1250 Riverfront Center ACRES 4.20 150,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,000 Amsterdam, NY 12010 EAST-0680050 NRTH-0119460 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,000 TO M DEED BOOK 625 PG-306 FULL MARKET VALUE 214,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 72 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-39 ****************** OFF CR 8 170.-2-39 340 Vacant indus COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 350,900 Cranesville Block Co., Inc. Red Hook 134801 350,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 350,900 1250 Riverfront Center ACRES 63.50 350,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 350,900 Amsterdam, NY 12010 EAST-0680030 NRTH-1193342 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 350,900 TO M DEED BOOK 625 PG-306 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 501,286 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2012 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-40 ****************** Maple Ln. 170.-2-40 340 Vacant indus COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 710,000 Cranesville Block Co., Inc. Red Hook 134801 710,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 710,000 1250 Riverfront Center ACRES 40.00 710,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 710,000 Amsterdam, NY 12010 EAST-0681258 NRTH-1194434 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 710,000 TO M DEED BOOK 625 PG-306 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1014,286 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2012 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-18.200 ************** Off Podmijersky Rd 140.-1-18.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,120 Creasap Charles Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,120 Creasap Marion ACRES 1.00 125,120 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 125,120 5775 Mosholu Ave EAST-0691649 NRTH-1218673 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,120 TO M Bronx, NY 10471 DEED BOOK 0583 PG-00202 FULL MARKET VALUE 178,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-69 ****************** CR 10 138.-1-69 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 176,256 Crippen Caroline Germantown 103602 52,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 176,256 320 West 87Th Street #31 Bk18 Pg1351 176,256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 176,256 New York, NY 10014 ACRES 3.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,256 TO M EAST-0668853 NRTH-1217939 DEED BOOK 0579 PG-00595 FULL MARKET VALUE 251,794 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-19 ****************** CR 10 150.-1-19 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1073,176 Criterion Atlantic Germantown 103602 271,721 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1073,176 Property Inc ACRES 93.20 1073,176 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1073,176 Attn: Real Estate Dept EAST-0673779 NRTH-1214639 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1073,176 TO M 745 Atlantic Ave 7Th Flr DEED BOOK 0664 PG-00247 Boston, MA 02111-2735 FULL MARKET VALUE 1533,109 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 73 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-42 ****************** Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-42 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Crocco Joseph L Germantown 103602 17,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,600 24 Deerhaven Rd FRNT 205.00 DPTH 130.00 115,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,600 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKH061230 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,040 EAST-0686357 NRTH-1194924 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,600 TO M DEED BOOK 0634 PG-00240 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-3.100 *************** Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-3.100 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,576 Crossman Mark T Pine Plains 134201 124,576 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,576 Crossman Yvonne J ACRES 3.83 124,576 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 124,576 108 High St Ext EAST-0678564 NRTH-1175640 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,576 TO M Lancaster, MA 01523 DEED BOOK C422 PG-F1469 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,966 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-75.2 *************** 107 Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-75.2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cummings Jamie L Pine Plains 134201 46,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 127,704 107 Parker Rd Micro No 11810 127,704 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 127,704 Elizaville, NY 12523 Bk 586 Pg 47 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,144 Bk16 Pg1966 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 127,704 TO M ACRES 1.90 BANK0190462 EAST-0681976 NRTH-1174617 DEED BOOK C0313 PG-F0514 FULL MARKET VALUE 182,434 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-15 ****************** 330 Cr 31 139.-1-15 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Cusumano Salvatore Germantown 103602 50,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 209,440 Cusumano Allison Tom Thumb 209,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 209,440 330 Rte 31 ACRES 1.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 182,880 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679821 NRTH-1223940 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 209,440 TO M DEED BOOK C481 PG-1964 FULL MARKET VALUE 299,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-39 ****************** Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-39 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 220,573 220,573 220,573 Czajka John Germantown 103602 370,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 375,243 98 Middlesex Ct ACRES 155.40 595,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 375,243 Slingerlands, NY 12159 EAST-0688688 NRTH-1194239 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 375,243 DEED BOOK C506 PG-F935 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 375,243 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 851,166 220,573 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 74 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-28 ****************** 479 CR 19 171.-1-28 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Czajka Walter Jr Germantown 103602 58,900 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 22 Elm St ACRES 6.10 178,432 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,824 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0687131 NRTH-1198056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,824 DEED BOOK 629 PG-2206 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 128,162 FULL MARKET VALUE 254,903 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 178,432 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-81 ****************** 381 CR 10 149.-1-81 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 D Allessandro John Germantown 103602 64,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,152 D Allessandro Dorothy D 147,152 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,152 381 County Rt 10 No 1 ACRES 10.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,882 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672433 NRTH-1212606 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,152 TO M DEED BOOK 0481 PG-00458 FULL MARKET VALUE 210,217 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-28 ****************** Church Rd 161.-2-28 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 80,473 80,473 80,473 D'addona Vincent Hudson 100600 167,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 D'addona Anna N Mico 05-319 287,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 207,327 PO Box 45 ACRES 60.80 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 207,327 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0682050 NRTH-1205159 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 180,767 DEED BOOK C0289 PG-F0130 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 207,327 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 411,143 80,473 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-79.200 ************** Private Rd 149.-1-79.200 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 22,168 D'allessandro John Germantown 103602 18,769 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 22,168 D'allessandro Dorothy ACRES 1.89 22,168 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,168 381 County Rte 10 No 1 EAST-0671793 NRTH-1212625 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 22,168 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 00821 PG-00033 FULL MARKET VALUE 31,669 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-18.120 ************** Water St 141.-1-18.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 401,250 D'Arcy Mark G Copake-Taconic 102801 67,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 401,250 D'Arcy Deborah ACRES 4.10 401,250 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 401,250 525 Liberty St Apt 9-B EAST-0700281 NRTH-1218110 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 401,250 TO M New York, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 635 PG-656 FULL MARKET VALUE 573,214 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 75 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-54.1 **************** Off CR 19 171.-1-54.1 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 98,900 Daley Robin A Germantown 103602 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 98,900 Daley Patricia J Fingar 98,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 98,900 PO Box 296 ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 98,900 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0686180 NRTH-1193364 DEED BOOK 606 PG-740 FULL MARKET VALUE 141,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-18.120 ************** CR 19 181.-1-18.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,072 Dalten Kay F Germantown 103602 47,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,072 774 Rt 19 Stop 10 Micro 10729 126,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,072 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 126,072 TO M EAST-0683341 NRTH-1190019 DEED BOOK C350 PG-F1568 FULL MARKET VALUE 180,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-7 ******************* CR 19 181.-1-7 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dalton Kathleen Linda Germantown 103602 44,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 205,700 Brumaghin Robert John III Biedrzycki 205,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 205,700 774 Cr 19 Stop 10 ACRES 1.90 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 179,140 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684112 NRTH-1192330 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,700 TO M DEED BOOK 616 PG-1171 FULL MARKET VALUE 293,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-54 ****************** PARC 4&5 CR 19 181.-1-54 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 145,248 Dalton Kay Germantown 103602 145,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 145,248 774 County Route 19 #15B Micro 96-92 145,248 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 145,248 Elizaville, NY 12523-1101 ACRES 26.61 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,248 TO M EAST-0682907 NRTH-1191167 DEED BOOK C0304 PG-F0083 FULL MARKET VALUE 207,497 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-18.111 ************** 774 CR 19 181.-1-18.111 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 241,808 Dalton Kay F Germantown 103602 78,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 241,808 774 CR 19 Stop 15B Micro 93-145&93-315&96-92 241,808 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 241,808 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 8.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 241,808 TO M EAST-0683652 NRTH-1192249 DEED BOOK 603 PG-22 FULL MARKET VALUE 345,440 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 76 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-25 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-25 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 18,904 Daly Vera J Pine Plains 134201 8,909 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 18,904 Box 92 ACRES 1.00 18,904 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 18,904 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683849 NRTH-1172970 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 18,904 TO M DEED BOOK 0435 PG-00025 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,006 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-5.211 *************** Schneider Rd Parcel C 161.-1-5.211 151 Fruit crop COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 247,112 Damiano Thomas Hudson 100600 110,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 247,112 Damiano Maryanne Micro 9685 247,112 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 247,112 4 Rittenhouse Rd ACRES 35.27 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 247,112 TO M Bronxville, NY 10708 EAST-0694457 NRTH-1209799 DEED BOOK 0643 PG-00092 FULL MARKET VALUE 353,017 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-16 ****************** Lockwood Rd 171.-1-16 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 Dator Nicholas R Germantown 103602 98,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 Dator Karen A ACRES 21.70 125,664 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 11 Signal Hill Rd EAST-0692936 NRTH-1200517 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,664 TO M Brookfield, CT 06804 DEED BOOK C406 PG-F326 FULL MARKET VALUE 179,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-15 ****************** SR 9G 128.-1-15 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Daul Anni Hudson 100600 102,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Attn: Daul Dieter ACRES 1.50 102,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 40 Mill Brook Ct EAST-0670985 NRTH-1227062 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,000 TO M Easton, PA 18045 DEED BOOK 0509 PG-00798 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-58 ****************** CR 10 138.-1-58 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 Dauley Robert Germantown 103602 24,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 Dauley Nancy Micro 5092 531 136,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 23 Cty Rt 10 FRNT 85.00 DPTH 209.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,816 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 BANK0130715 EAST-0667701 NRTH-1218656 DEED BOOK 542 PG-1813 FULL MARKET VALUE 195,451 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 77 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-19 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-19 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 50,238 50,238 0 Dauski Mark Hudson 100600 35,000 AGED C 41802 50,089 0 0 Brockert Mark ACRES 1.00 150,416 AGED T&S 41806 0 45,080 67,687 PO Box 86 EAST-0687455 NRTH-1206196 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK C381 PG-F0379 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,089 FULL MARKET VALUE 214,880 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,098 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,459 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,416 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 150,416 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-29 ****************** CR 31 160.-1-29 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 113,595 113,595 113,595 Davidson Margaret Germantown 103602 274,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 564,909 PO Box 87 ACRES 123.20 BANK0080490 678,504 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 564,909 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0676515 NRTH-1206194 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 564,909 DEED BOOK 0613 PG-01058 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 564,909 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 969,291 113,595 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-32 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-32 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Davis Daniel Germantown 103602 66,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 71,400 Davis Kathryn Micro 2056 71,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 71,400 201 Union St ACRES 2.70 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,840 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0668738 NRTH-1220308 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 71,400 TO M DEED BOOK 0587 PG-01031 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-21 ****************** Orchard Rd 140.-1-21 240 Rural res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Davis George Gray Hudson 100600 72,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 4411 Warrens Way Micro 1187 190,672 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 163,064 Wanaque, NJ 07465 ACRES 10.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 163,064 EAST-0687200 NRTH-1218735 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 164,112 DEED BOOK 0596 PG-00069 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,672 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 272,389 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-27.200 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-27.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,728 Davis Michael Germantown 103602 50,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,728 Architect ACRES 2.16 BANK0140687 50,728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,728 435 Hudson St Ste 702 EAST-0668297 NRTH-1215828 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,728 TO M New York, NY 10014 DEED BOOK 00770 PG-00315 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,469 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 78 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-52 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-52 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,136 Davis Michael Germantown 103602 51,136 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 51,136 Architect ACRES 1.50 BANK0140687 51,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,136 435 Hudson St Ste 702 EAST-0668397 NRTH-1215748 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 51,136 TO M New York, NY 10014 DEED BOOK 00770 PG-00315 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,051 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-56.100 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-56.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 219,640 Davis Michael Germantown 103602 50,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 219,640 Architect ACRES 3.60 219,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 219,640 435 Hudson St Ste 702 EAST-0668318 NRTH-1215458 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 219,640 TO M New York, NY 10014 DEED BOOK 00770 PG-00315 FULL MARKET VALUE 313,771 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-11 ****************** CR 19 201.-1-11 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Davis Theresa Pine Plains 134201 35,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Davis Michael ACRES 1.00 187,816 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 160,208 PO Box 187 EAST-0683785 NRTH-1175420 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 160,208 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0322 PG-F1234 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,546 FULL MARKET VALUE 268,309 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 187,816 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-37.200 ************** Bells Pond Rd 140.-1-37.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Davis Thomas Hudson 100600 65,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 214,472 Raleigh Kimberly D ACRES 8.06 BANK0010570 214,472 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 214,472 114 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0696482 NRTH-1217813 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 187,912 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00756 PG-00031 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 214,472 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 306,389 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-16 ****************** Water St 141.-1-16 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,032 De Bonis Richard Copake-Taconic 102801 56,032 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,032 De Bonis Athena ACRES 2.50 56,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,032 60 Waterstreet Rd EAST-0699992 NRTH-1217430 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,032 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0583 PG-00808 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,046 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-17 ****************** Water St 141.-1-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 De Bonis Richard Copake-Taconic 102801 45,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 239,768 De Bonis Athena ACRES 2.90 239,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 239,768 60 Water St Rd EAST-0699863 NRTH-1217229 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 213,208 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00590 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 239,768 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 342,526 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 79 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-37.100 ************** 132 Bells Pond Rd 140.-1-37.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 De Crosta Paul L Hudson 100600 54,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,576 132 Bells Pond Rd ACRES 4.66 BANK0030614 158,576 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,576 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696831 NRTH-1218043 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 132,016 DEED BOOK 541 PG-1333 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 158,576 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 226,537 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-46 **************** Pleasantview Dr. Lot 127A 192.20-2-46 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,600 De Feo Monica Pine Plains 134201 29,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,600 17 Kings Way FRNT 85.00 DPTH 62.50 64,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,600 Patterson, NY 12563 BANK0210152 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 64,600 TO M EAST-0683860 NRTH-1177730 DEED BOOK 0590 PG-01001 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-65.2 **************** 12 Cold Spring Rd 139.-1-65.2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 De Ieso-Collier Stacy Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 194,000 12 Cold Spg ACRES 2.00 194,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 194,000 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0678042 NRTH-1218177 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 167,440 DEED BOOK 00694 PG-00030 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 194,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 277,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-51 ***************** Loyola Rd. Lot 143 201.8-1-51 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 62,832 De Santis Philip Pine Plains 134201 31,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 62,832 De Santis Pauline Reilly Twin Lake 62,832 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 62,832 3215 Gomer St FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 62,832 TO M Yorktown Heights, NY 10598 EAST-0682578 NRTH-1173628 DEED BOOK C0285 PG-F0324 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,760 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-52.200 ************* Loyola Rd.,lot 144 201.8-1-52.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,312 De Santis Philip Pine Plains 134201 36,312 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,312 De Santis Pauline Reilly Twin Lake 36,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,312 3215 Gomer St FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,312 TO M Yorktown Heights, NY 10598 EAST-0682604 NRTH-1175658 DEED BOOK C0285 PG-F0324 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,874 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 80 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-38.210 ************** Deerhaven Rd 171.-1-38.210 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 262,616 Dealy Christopher Germantown 103602 52,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 262,616 Schaeffer Phyllis Micro 7306 262,616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 262,616 450 North End Ave Apt 11k ACRES 4.04 BANKC010470 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 262,616 TO M New York, NY 10282 EAST-0691309 NRTH-1193424 DEED BOOK C518 PG-F614 FULL MARKET VALUE 375,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-49 ****************** Deerhaven Rd 182.-1-49 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 60,928 Dealy Christopher Germantown 103602 46,684 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 60,928 Schaeffer Phyllis ACRES 20.75 BANKC010470 60,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 60,928 450 North End Avenue Apt EAST-0691686 NRTH-1192719 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 60,928 TO M New York, NY 10282 DEED BOOK C518 PG-F614 FULL MARKET VALUE 87,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-18.111 ************** 20 Water St 141.-1-18.111 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,000 Debonis Richard R Copake-Taconic 102801 49,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,000 Debonis Athena B Micro #08-234 49,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,000 60 Water St ACRES 2.09 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700145 NRTH-1217673 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F68 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-18.112 ************** 20 Water St 141.-1-18.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 59,000 Debonis Richard R Copake-Taconic 102801 59,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 59,000 Debonis Athena B Micro 08-234 59,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 59,000 60 Water St ACRES 3.02 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 59,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700470 NRTH-1217683 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F68 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-31 ****************** 20 Water St 141.-1-31 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,000 Debonis Richard R Copake-Taconic 102801 49,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,000 Debonis Athena B Micro 08-234 49,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,000 60 Water St ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700338 NRTH-1217242 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F68 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 81 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-3.100 *************** Bells Pond Rd 152.-1-3.100 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,784 Decesare Family Limited Copake-Taconic 102801 80,784 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,784 26635 Hickory Blvd ACRES 19.90 80,784 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,784 Bonita Springs, FL 34134 EAST-0699363 NRTH-1216908 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 80,784 TO M DEED BOOK 633 PG-1383 FULL MARKET VALUE 115,406 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-5.100 ************** 34 Pine Rd 201.2-1-5.100 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Decker Jamie L Pine Plains 134201 34,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 Ogden Geraldine Bk16 Pg1966 52,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,360 34 Pine Rd ACRES 0.69 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 25,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681657 NRTH-1177006 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,360 TO M DEED BOOK 0591 PG-00316 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-23 ****************** 34 Lynks Rd 171.-1-23 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Decker Patricia A Germantown 103602 75,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 243,304 Whittaker Duane S Bk24 Pg1751 243,304 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 243,304 34 Lynk Rd ACRES 16.28 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 216,744 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686838 NRTH-1199445 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 243,304 TO M DEED BOOK 538 PG-253 FULL MARKET VALUE 347,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-48 **************** Pleasantview Dr 192.20-2-48 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,680 Dedrick Wayne K Jr Pine Plains 134201 30,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,680 100 Highland Ave Twin Lakes 0001 85,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 85,680 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 62.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,680 TO M BANK0140687 EAST-0683850 NRTH-1177670 DEED BOOK C0292 PG-F1912 FULL MARKET VALUE 122,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-11.112 ************** CR 19 192.-1-11.112 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,712 Defrancis Alexander Germantown 103602 56,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,712 Agnes Rancis ACRES 2.29 56,712 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,712 Alexander Jr EAST-0682941 NRTH-1182598 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,712 TO M 31 Vosburgh Rd DEED BOOK 0530 PG-00831 Elizaville, NY 12523 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,017 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 82 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-11.120 ************** CR 19 192.-1-11.120 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,768 Defrancis Alexander Germantown 103602 69,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,768 Agnes Rancis ACRES 1.71 69,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,768 Alexander Jr EAST-0682970 NRTH-1182898 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 69,768 TO M 31 Vosburgh Rd DEED BOOK 0530 PG-00835 Elizaville, NY 12523 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,669 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-45 ****************** CR 19 192.-1-45 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 Defrancis Alexander Germantown 103602 81,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 Agnes Rancis ACRES 2.00 81,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 Alexander Jr EAST-0682740 NRTH-1182798 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,600 TO M 31 Vosburgh Rd DEED BOOK 0530 PG-00833 Elizaville, NY 12523 FULL MARKET VALUE 116,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-46 ****************** 31 Vosburgh Rd 192.-1-46 240 Rural res AGED C 41802 111,996 0 0 Defrancis Alexander Germantown 103602 74,600 AGED T&S 41806 0 74,664 74,664 Defrances Agnes ACRES 10.70 248,880 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 31 Vosburgh Rd EAST-0683390 NRTH-1182729 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,884 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0530 PG-00837 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,216 FULL MARKET VALUE 355,543 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 123,946 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 248,880 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-9 ****************** Private Rd 192.4-2-9 260 Seasonal res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Degli-Angeli Peter Pine Plains 134201 18,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,888 97 Highland Ave Micro 4395 92,888 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,888 PO Box 145 FRNT 42.80 DPTH 206.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,328 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC130111 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,888 TO M EAST-0684090 NRTH-1177771 DEED BOOK C514 PG-F1870 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-34 ****************** 565 CR 19 171.-1-34 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Deieso Andrew Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 Deieso Gail ACRES 2.00 BANK0080490 95,064 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 565 Rte 19 EAST-0686314 NRTH-1196144 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 68,504 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0549 PG-01121 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 95,064 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 135,806 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 83 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-3 ******************* CR 19 192.-1-3 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 479,944 Del Nunzio Richard E Germantown 103602 75,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 479,944 43 Exeter St Parcel A On Deed 479,944 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 479,944 Forest Hills Gardens,NY 11375 Micro 3622 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 479,944 TO M ACRES 8.10 BANKH130550 EAST-0682445 NRTH-1185517 DEED BOOK 00669 PG-00329 FULL MARKET VALUE 685,634 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-2 ******************* CR 19 192.-1-2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 428,400 Del Nunzio Richard E Germantown 103602 59,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 428,400 43 Exeter St Parcel B 428,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 428,400 Forest Hills Gardens,NY 11375 ACRES 4.49 BANK0030220 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 428,400 TO M EAST-0681895 NRTH-1185586 DEED BOOK 00669 PG-00329 FULL MARKET VALUE 612,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-27.12 *************** 15 Off Wire Rd Lot 2 149.-1-27.12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Delaney John Germantown 103602 53,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,360 Delaney Ann M Micro No 11884 137,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,360 15 Wire Rd ACRES 4.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 110,800 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0667757 NRTH-1215717 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 137,360 TO M DEED BOOK 00691 PG-00137 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,229 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-44.220 ************** C R 10 150.-1-44.220 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 106,488 Delgado Margaret S Germantown 103602 40,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 106,488 490 C R 10 Life Estate Mary Howell 106,488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 106,488 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 1.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 106,488 TO M EAST-0675053 NRTH-1212491 DEED BOOK 591 PG-75 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-83 ****************** Church Rd 161.-1-83 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 57,528 0 0 Deluca Melva Tamburro Hudson 100600 46,700 AGED T&S 41806 0 28,764 28,764 Perry Luane Tamburro Micro 10189 191,760 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 5 New England Dr ACRES 2.17 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,232 Stamford, CT 06903 EAST-0692445 NRTH-1205836 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 162,996 DEED BOOK C468 PG-F827 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 112,726 FULL MARKET VALUE 273,943 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 191,760 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 84 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-25 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-25 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Demarest Peter C Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Demarest Lou Ann Micro 94-118 35,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 20 White Dr ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,000 TO M Milan, NY 12571 EAST-0686650 NRTH-0120270 DEED BOOK 622 PG-675 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-45.1 **************** 1615 Cr 8 Blue Stores 170.-1-45.1 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dempsey Patrick Red Hook 134801 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,960 Dempsey Linda ACRES 2.00 BANK0180200 150,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,960 1527 Route 8 EAST-0677680 NRTH-1193247 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 124,400 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 00757 PG-00262 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,960 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 215,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-73 ***************** 79 Shore Dr Lot 63 201.2-1-73 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,288 Denovio Carolyn Pine Plains 134201 16,512 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,288 % Andrews Bk18 Pg1374 28,288 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,288 77 Shore Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 138.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,288 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523-1510 EAST-0682236 NRTH-1174627 DEED BOOK 0636 PG-00288 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-79 ***************** Shore Dr., Lot 3 201.2-1-79 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 Denovio Carolyn Pine Plains 134201 19,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 Attn: Michael Andrews Reilly Twin Lake 116,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 77 Shore Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,416 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523-1510 EAST-0682356 NRTH-1174547 DEED BOOK 0636 PG-00288 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-80 ***************** LOT 2 Shore Dr 201.2-1-80 312 Vac w/imprv - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 24,480 Denovio Carolyn Pine Plains 134201 19,957 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 24,480 79 Shore Dr Reilly Twin Lake 24,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 24,480 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 24,480 TO M EAST-0682326 NRTH-1174507 DEED BOOK 00697 PG-00331 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,971 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 85 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-81 ***************** LOT 1 Shore Dr 201.2-1-81 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Denovio Carolyn Pine Plains 134201 26,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 264,928 79 Shore Dr Reilly Twin Lake 264,928 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 264,928 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 110.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 238,368 EAST-0682287 NRTH-1174457 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 264,928 TO M DEED BOOK 00697 PG-00331 FULL MARKET VALUE 378,469 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-43 ****************** 2114 SR 9 170.-1-43 280 Multiple res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Depaoli John Red Hook 134801 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 256,500 Depaoli Alice Bk14 Pg1095 256,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 256,500 2114 Rte 9 ACRES 1.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 229,940 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676940 NRTH-1193396 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 256,500 TO M DEED BOOK 0616 PG-00238 FULL MARKET VALUE 366,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-37.100 ************* 1 & 1A Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-37.100 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,928 Desbecker Claire Pine Plains 134201 30,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,928 Recht Raymond Micro 97-46 43,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,928 126 Manhattan Ave ACRES 1.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,928 TO M New York, NY 10025 EAST-0681994 NRTH-1175657 DEED BOOK C412 PG-F344 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-37.200 ************* Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-37.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 Desbecker Claire Pine Plains 134201 47,736 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 Recht Raymond Micro 97-46 47,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 126 Manhattan Ave ACRES 1.02 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,736 TO M New York, NY 10025 EAST-0682186 NRTH-1175664 DEED BOOK C412 PG-F348 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,194 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-56 ***************** LOT 26 Shore Dr 201.8-2-56 280 Multiple res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 269,280 Desbecker Claire Pine Plains 134201 43,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 269,280 Recht Raymond FRNT 70.00 DPTH 195.00 269,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 269,280 126 Mahanttan Ave EAST-0683188 NRTH-1173509 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 269,280 TO M New York, NY 10025 DEED BOOK 00711 PG-00005 FULL MARKET VALUE 384,686 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 86 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-57 ***************** Shore Dr 201.8-2-57 312 Vac w/imprv - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,720 Desbecker Claire Pine Plains 134201 34,212 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,720 Recht Raymond Reilly Twin Lake 53,720 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,720 126 Mahanttan Ave ACRES 0.24 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,720 TO M New York, NY 10025-3801 EAST-0683238 NRTH-1173519 DEED BOOK 00711 PG-00005 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-1.122 *************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-1.122 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Deschaine Michele Hudson 100600 110,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 370,400 Schliff Joseph Micro 03-121 370,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 370,400 98 Coolidge Ave ACRES 14.90 BANKC030982 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 343,840 Queensbury, NY 12804 EAST-0675451 NRTH-1225728 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 370,400 TO M DEED BOOK C496 PG-F385 FULL MARKET VALUE 529,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-9 ***************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-3-9 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,584 Deshmukh Shriniwas Pine Plains 134201 19,584 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,584 445 West Park Dr Twin Lakes 0001 19,584 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,584 New Milford, NJ 07646 FRNT 57.00 DPTH 125.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,584 TO M EAST-0682910 NRTH-1177718 DEED BOOK 549 PG-1248 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,977 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-23 ****************** CR 19 201.-1-23 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 83,776 Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co. Pine Plains 134201 33,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 83,776 6501 Irvine Center Dr FRNT 130.00 DPTH 216.00 83,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 83,776 Irvine, CA 92418 EAST-0684139 NRTH-1173211 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 83,776 TO M DEED BOOK 644 PG-1096 FULL MARKET VALUE 119,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-21.200 ************** CR 19 192.-1-21.200 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 315,112 Deutsche Bank National Trust Pine Plains 134201 72,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 315,112 1761 East St. Andrews Pl ACRES 20.27 315,112 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 315,112 Santa Ana, CA 92705 EAST-0682394 NRTH-1180273 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 315,112 TO M DEED BOOK 652 PG-2083 FULL MARKET VALUE 450,160 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 87 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-40 ****************** 575 White Birch Rd 138.-1-40 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,752 Devlin Diana M Germantown 103602 47,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,752 200 W 90Th St ACRES 3.30 BANKA061220 143,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,752 New York City, NY 10024 EAST-0669760 NRTH-1219460 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,752 TO M DEED BOOK C388 PG-F2007 FULL MARKET VALUE 205,360 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-42 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-42 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dewey Robert Hudson 100600 30,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 106,352 Shaw Robert ACRES 0.57 BANK0080490 106,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 106,352 101 County Route 19 EAST-0688164 NRTH-1206497 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 79,792 PO Box 231 DEED BOOK 0578 PG-00173 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 106,352 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 FULL MARKET VALUE 151,931 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 106,352 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-38.200 ************** Off Blue Valley Roadway 139.-1-38.200 692 Road/str/hwy COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2,720 Di Bella Giuseppe & Hudson 100600 2,720 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2,720 Michelina ACRES 1.92 2,720 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2,720 165 Spring Rd EAST-0684205 NRTH-1221469 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2,720 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0508 PG-00722 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,886 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-38.111 ************** Blue Valley Rd 139.-1-38.111 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 77,860 77,860 77,860 Di Bella Giuseppe Hudson 100600 48,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Di Bella Michelina ACRES 3.45 155,720 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,860 165 Spring Rd EAST-0684235 NRTH-1221609 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,860 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0601 PG-00823 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 27,590 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,457 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,720 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-52 ****************** 3080 Schneider Rd 151.-1-52 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Di Giovanni Louis Hudson 100600 104,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 399,840 3080 Rte 9 Schneider Rd & Rt 9 399,840 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 399,840 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 3949 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 373,280 ACRES 29.36 BANKH030619 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 399,840 TO M EAST-0689836 NRTH-1210780 DEED BOOK C0293 PG-F0940 FULL MARKET VALUE 571,200 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 88 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-38 **************** Pleasantview Rd 192.20-2-38 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 Di Stefano Laura Pine Plains 134201 26,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 Frrancavilla Frank Micro 4395 109,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 97 Highland Ave FRNT 108.10 DPTH 86.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,072 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684010 NRTH-1177750 DEED BOOK 544 PG-720 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-65.112 ************** SR 9G 138.-1-65.112 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 252,280 Diamanti Michael Germantown 103602 60,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 252,280 Diamanti Dolores Micro 10502 252,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 252,280 Box 158 ACRES 6.63 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 252,280 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0667412 NRTH-1218436 DEED BOOK 0609 PG-00120 FULL MARKET VALUE 360,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-6.100 ************** Rte 9 161.1-1-6.100 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 262,072 Diamanti Michael L Hudson 100600 32,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 262,072 Diamanti Dolores Bk25 Pg1843 262,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 262,072 PO Box 158 FRNT 103.70 DPTH 252.09 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 262,072 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687144 NRTH-1206570 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 262,072 TO M DEED BOOK C0331 PG-F2233 FULL MARKET VALUE 374,389 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-9 ******************* Old Sr 82 161.-1-9 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dianda Dawn M Hudson 100600 43,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,224 Link Lisa A Life Use Geo/Nancy Whitbe 154,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,224 Box 170 Old Route 82 FRNT 140.00 DPTH 345.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,664 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698250 NRTH-1208457 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,224 TO M DEED BOOK 570 PG-2481 FULL MARKET VALUE 220,320 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-25 ****************** Mountainview Dr 192.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dicarlo Anthony Pine Plains 134201 53,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 191,080 Mallon Virginia ACRES 4.50 191,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 191,080 107 Mountain View Dr EAST-0683425 NRTH-1180549 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 164,520 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 00747 PG-00182 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 191,080 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 272,971 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 89 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-11 ****************** LOT 25 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-11 210 1 Family Res VET RATIO 41111 29,702 29,702 0 Dicarlo John Hudson 100600 35,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Dicarlo Catherine Micro 94-118 & 95-283 198,016 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 168,314 20 Mahikan Dr ACRES 1.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 168,314 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685801 NRTH-1203063 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 147,746 DEED BOOK C479 PG-F1042 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,016 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 282,880 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-9 ******************* LOT 27 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-9 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Dicks Vincent Hudson 100600 39,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 36 Mahikan Dr Micro 94-118 & 95-283 281,520 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 264,955 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.01 BANK0180200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 264,955 EAST-0685792 NRTH-1202623 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 231,250 DEED BOOK C55 PG-D55 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 281,520 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 402,171 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-19.120 ************** 97 Orchard Rd 140.-1-19.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 57,392 Didomenico Lorraine J Hudson 100600 57,392 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 57,392 Dinnozzi Paul ACRES 2.38 57,392 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,392 36 Linden Ave EAST-0687170 NRTH-0127030 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 57,392 TO M Ossining, NY 10562 DEED BOOK C0514 PG-F2034 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,989 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-40 **************** 8 Pleasant View Dr Lot 10 192.20-2-40 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dier Kevin Pine Plains 134201 22,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 202,776 Dier Elaine Bk22 Pg1602 0001 202,776 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 202,776 8 Mountainview Dr FRNT 157.47 DPTH 84.74 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 176,216 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0060860 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 202,776 TO M EAST-0683450 NRTH-1177869 DEED BOOK 0598 PG-00036 FULL MARKET VALUE 289,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-41 **************** Mountainview Dr 192.20-2-41 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Dier Kevin Pine Plains 134201 21,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Dier Elaine Bk22 Pg1602 0001 21,488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 8 Mountainview Dr FRNT 65.00 DPTH 132.13 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 21,488 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0060860 EAST-0683460 NRTH-1177799 DEED BOOK 0585 PG-00471 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,697 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 90 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-42 **************** Pleasantview Dr 192.20-2-42 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 17,680 Dier Kevin Pine Plains 134201 17,680 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 17,680 Dier Elaine Twin Lakes 17,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,680 Attn: Lockhart Peg & Martin FRNT 112.72 DPTH 191.71 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 17,680 TO M 8 Mountainview Dr EAST-0683560 NRTH-1177790 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C469 PG-F1815 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,257 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-39 ****************** 775 Church Rd 161.-1-39 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dierkes Brian P Hudson 100600 52,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,088 Dierkes Ronald K ACRES 2.70 120,088 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,088 775 Church Rd EAST-0696000 NRTH-1203483 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,528 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C492 PG-F1729 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,088 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 171,554 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-60.200 ************** 694 Church Rd 161.-1-60.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dierkes Ronald Hudson 100600 55,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 225,760 Dierkes Mildred Pb22 Pg1639 225,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 225,760 694 Church Rd ACRES 5.21 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 199,200 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0694119 NRTH-1204049 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 225,760 TO M DEED BOOK 0559 PG-01103 FULL MARKET VALUE 322,514 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-59.110 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-59.110 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 364,584 364,584 364,584 Dierkes Warren Germantown 103602 390,592 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,008 Dierkes Grayce Micro 00-87 390,592 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,008 720 Church Rd ACRES 126.62 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,008 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692312 NRTH-1202615 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 26,008 TO M DEED BOOK C0358 PG-F0250 364,584 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 557,989 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-62 ****************** 720 Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-62 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 57,895 57,895 57,895 Dierkes Warren Hudson 100600 106,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 117,817 Dierkes Grayce ACRES 20.00 BANK0080490 175,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 117,817 720 Church Rd EAST-0695271 NRTH-1202561 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 117,817 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0C373 PG-F1628 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,817 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 251,017 57,895 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 91 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-60.100 ************** 720 Church Rd 161.-1-60.100 113 Cattle farm AG DISTRIC 41720 196,828 196,828 196,828 Dierkes Warren J Hudson 100600 271,500 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dierkes Grayce M Pb22 Pg1639 635,528 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 438,700 720 Church Rd ACRES 109.26 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 438,700 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0694091 NRTH-1203039 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 412,140 DEED BOOK 637 PG-2277 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 438,700 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 907,897 196,828 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 193.-1-12 ****************** Weaver Rd 193.-1-12 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,700 DiMeglio Paolo Pine Plains 134201 61,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,700 141 Weaver Rd ACRES 3.67 61,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,700 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0687408 NRTH-1180893 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,700 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 88,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 193.-1-13 ****************** Weaver Rd 193.-1-13 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,000 DiMeglio Salvatore Pine Plains 134201 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,000 141 Weaver Rd ACRES 1.89 45,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 45,000 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0687244 NRTH-1180323 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 45,000 TO M DEED BOOK 527 PG-2098 FULL MARKET VALUE 64,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-67 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-67 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dimm Lewis Hudson 100600 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 182,900 Dimm Risa Micro 4680 182,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 182,900 Box 74 ACRES 2.10 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 156,340 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0686977 NRTH-1205155 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 182,900 TO M DEED BOOK 0599 PG-00918 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 182,900 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 261,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-20 ***************** Whitman Rd 201.8-2-20 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dipper Timothy L Jr. Pine Plains 134201 37,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 244,120 Basdikis Laura J Reilly Twin Lake 244,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 244,120 8 Whitman Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 217,560 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683328 NRTH-1173909 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 244,120 TO M DEED BOOK 581 PG-2006 FULL MARKET VALUE 348,743 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 92 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-90 ****************** Off Schneider Rd 161.-1-90 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,656 Disavino Michael Hudson 100600 77,656 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,656 119 Park Ave Micro 10692 77,656 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 77,656 East White Plains, NY 10604 ACRES 8.87 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 77,656 TO M EAST-0693143 NRTH-1207197 DEED BOOK 0650 PG-00188 FULL MARKET VALUE 110,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-91 ****************** Off Schneider Rd 161.-1-91 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 93,432 Disavino Michael Hudson 100600 93,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,432 119 Park Ave Micro 10692 93,432 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,432 East White Plains, NY 10604 ACRES 14.66 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 93,432 TO M EAST-0692862 NRTH-1207566 DEED BOOK 0660 PG-00011 FULL MARKET VALUE 133,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-75 ****************** 371 C R 10 149.-1-75 280 Multiple res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Disbrow Ann Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,152 371 County Rte 10 ACRES 1.00 BANKC031720 164,152 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,152 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672361 NRTH-1213416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,592 DEED BOOK C0356 PG-F2312 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,152 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 234,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-56 ****************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-56 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 206,312 Distenfeld Ariel Hudson 100600 72,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 206,312 200 E 27Th St Apt 19b ACRES 10.00 206,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 206,312 New York, NY 10016 EAST-0691249 NRTH-1203833 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 206,312 TO M DEED BOOK 0612 PG-00775 FULL MARKET VALUE 294,731 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-28 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-28 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 17,884 17,884 0 Dobert Robert Hudson 100600 23,000 AGED - ALL 41800 26,826 26,826 35,768 Dobert Betty FRNT 50.00 DPTH 285.00 71,536 EN STAR 41834 0 0 35,768 PO Box 115 EAST-0687874 NRTH-1206547 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,826 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0502 PG-00963 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,826 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,194 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 71,536 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 71,536 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 93 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-78 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 66 201.2-1-78 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 73,032 Doino Jason A Pine Plains 134201 29,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 73,032 82 Shore Dr Reilly Twin Lake 73,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 73,032 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 38.00 DPTH 135.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 73,032 TO M EAST-0682146 NRTH-1174497 DEED BOOK C463 PG-F1853 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,331 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-46 ****************** 5226 SR 9G 138.-1-46 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,500 Dolan Christopher Germantown 103602 26,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,500 701 Voliet Ave FRNT 147.00 DPTH 150.00 183,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,500 Hyde Park, NY EAST-0668060 NRTH-1219557 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,500 TO M DEED BOOK 556 PG-814 FULL MARKET VALUE 262,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-1 ******************* CR 31 150.-1-1 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,056 Dombrowski John Germantown 103602 81,056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,056 Attn: Ronald Dombrowski ACRES 13.30 81,056 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,056 660 Route 31 EAST-0676226 NRTH-1216253 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,056 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0446 PG-00490 FULL MARKET VALUE 115,794 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-15 ****************** 660 CR 31 150.-1-15 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Dombrowski John Germantown 103602 45,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Attn: Ronald Dombrowski ACRES 2.00 119,136 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 91,528 660 Route 31 EAST-0676466 NRTH-1216094 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 91,528 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0446 PG-00490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,576 FULL MARKET VALUE 170,194 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,136 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-3.220 *************** Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-3.220 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 139,400 Dominion Telecom Inc Pine Plains 134201 26,663 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 139,400 Elantic Telecom Micro 99-32 139,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 139,400 PO Box 54288 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 139,400 TO M Lexington, KY 40555 EAST-0679443 NRTH-1176302 DEED BOOK 536 PG-974 FULL MARKET VALUE 199,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 94 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-35.100 ************** 80 Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-35.100 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dominique Kurt Hudson 100600 50,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 94,792 Dominique Tammy Kroger 94,792 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 94,792 80 Willowbrook Rd ACRES 3.65 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 68,232 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696396 NRTH-1205283 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 94,792 TO M DEED BOOK 580 PG-1591 FULL MARKET VALUE 135,417 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-35.200 ************** Off Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-35.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2,992 Dominique Kurt Hudson 100600 2,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2,992 Dominique Tammy ACRES 1.08 2,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2,992 80 Willow Brook Rd EAST-0696136 NRTH-1205413 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2,992 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 580 PG-1591 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,274 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-57 ****************** CR 31 160.-1-57 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Donnelly Robert F Germantown 103602 46,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Donnelly Roxana T Micro 04-253 201,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,135 345 E 80Th St #12C ACRES 2.88 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,135 New York, NY 10021 EAST-0676180 NRTH-0120110 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 175,140 DEED BOOK 527 PG-967 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 201,700 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 288,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-31 ****************** 358 Cr 31 139.-1-31 210 1 Family Res CW_15_VET/ 41162 8,282 0 0 Dooley Roger T Germantown 103602 44,500 CW_DISBLD_ 41172 27,608 0 0 Dooley Jane C Tom Thumb 184,824 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 358 Rt 31 ACRES 3.80 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,934 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679772 NRTH-1223040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 184,824 DEED BOOK 00723 PG-00043 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 158,264 FULL MARKET VALUE 264,034 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 184,824 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-36 ****************** SR 9 160.-1-36 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Doris Philip Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,712 Doris Jane Micro 1081 158,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,712 Box 181 ACRES 1.00 BANKH130015 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 132,152 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0685310 NRTH-1203652 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 158,712 TO M DEED BOOK 0614 PG-00048 FULL MARKET VALUE 226,731 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 95 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-39 ****************** Blue Valley Rd 139.-1-39 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Doty Benjamin Hudson 100600 56,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,032 Doty Linda M ACRES 5.20 158,032 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,032 165 Spring Rd EAST-0683314 NRTH-1221897 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,472 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0318 PG-F1730 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 158,032 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 225,760 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-66 ****************** 26 Twin Dr 171.-1-66 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Doty Brian K Germantown 103602 39,690 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,920 Doty Holly Lynk Subdivision 131,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,920 26 Twin Dr Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,360 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.00 BANKC030950 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 131,920 TO M EAST-0687415 NRTH-1201066 DEED BOOK C0320 PG-F0852 FULL MARKET VALUE 188,457 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-45 **************** 9 Westland Ave Lot 18 192.20-3-45 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 26,962 26,962 0 Douglas Kenneth T Pine Plains 134201 36,100 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Calabrese Lynda Micro 4443 107,848 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,886 9 Westland Ave FRNT 65.47 DPTH 139.25 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,886 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682451 NRTH-1177167 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,578 DEED BOOK C0294 PG-F0496 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,848 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 154,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-53 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-53 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 181,152 Douglass Alan Pine Plains 134201 23,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 181,152 1220 Jackson Corners Rd ACRES 1.40 181,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 181,152 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0684000 NRTH-1172771 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 181,152 TO M DEED BOOK 00674 PG-00164 FULL MARKET VALUE 258,789 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-96 ****************** 148 C R 10 149.-1-96 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 34,068 34,068 34,068 Dresdner Dorothy Germantown 103602 14,500 EN STAR 41834 0 0 34,068 148 Rte 10 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 133.70 68,136 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 34,068 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669435 NRTH-1216740 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 34,068 DEED BOOK 0470 PG-00358 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,337 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 68,136 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 96 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-27 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-27 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,704 Dubois Edna Pine Plains 134201 37,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 110,704 9 Dogwood Ln Micro 3354 110,704 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 110,704 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 110.00 DPTH 140.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,704 TO M BANKC130170 EAST-0681403 NRTH-1176175 DEED BOOK C496 PG-F504 FULL MARKET VALUE 158,149 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-46 ****************** SR 9 170.-1-46 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ducey Daniel Red Hook 134801 44,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 218,688 Ducey Elizabeth @ Blue Stores 218,688 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 218,688 2120 Route 9 ACRES 1.90 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 192,128 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0677450 NRTH-1193247 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,688 TO M DEED BOOK C0484 PG-F1708 FULL MARKET VALUE 312,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-21 ****************** Water St 152.-1-21 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Duffy Kathleen Hudson 100600 27,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,080 321 Water St FRNT 210.00 DPTH 100.00 157,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,080 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.10 BANKC010695 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,520 EAST-0699095 NRTH-1210680 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,080 TO M DEED BOOK 0614 PG-00655 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-38 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-38 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 244,800 Duignan Veronica Pine Plains 134201 45,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 244,800 74 Parker Rd Bruckert 244,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 244,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.70 BANK0180200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 244,800 TO M EAST-0681704 NRTH-1175656 DEED BOOK C384 PG-F1394 FULL MARKET VALUE 349,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-32 **************** Mountainview Dr. 103-104192.20-2-32 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dundon Christopher Pine Plains 134201 44,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 167,960 Blakeley Sara Bk22 Pg1602 0001 167,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 167,960 14 Mountainview Dr FRNT 199.52 DPTH 146.33 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 141,400 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683424 NRTH-1178074 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 167,960 TO M DEED BOOK 550 PG-2099 FULL MARKET VALUE 239,943 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 97 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-8 ****************** Baxter Rd 201.8-2-8 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 138,584 Dundon Thomas Pine Plains 134201 26,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 138,584 Dundon Laraine Life Time Living 138,584 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,584 12 Baxter Rd Reilly Twin Lake FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 138,584 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 EAST-0682668 NRTH-1173548 DEED BOOK 00670 PG-00042 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,977 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-9 ****************** Baxter Rd 201.8-2-9 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 15,776 Dundon Thomas Pine Plains 134201 12,948 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 15,776 Dundon Laraine Reilly Twin Lake 15,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 15,776 12 Baxter Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 15,776 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682698 NRTH-1173508 DEED BOOK 00670 PG-00042 FULL MARKET VALUE 22,537 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-43 ****************** 2019 CR 8 182.-1-43 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dunn Robert T Germantown 103602 86,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 254,728 Dunn Kathy J ACRES 22.71 BANKH110045 254,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 254,728 2019 Co Rte 8 EAST-0686763 NRTH-1186575 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 228,168 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0282 PG-F1646 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 254,728 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 363,897 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-17 ****************** 48 Maple Ln 170.-2-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Dwyer Thomas Red Hook 134801 36,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 146,744 Dwyer Clare FRNT 150.00 DPTH 226.50 146,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 146,744 48 Maple Ln BANKH160373 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,184 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681356 NRTH-1195294 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,744 TO M DEED BOOK 0605 PG-01063 FULL MARKET VALUE 209,634 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-2 ****************** 74 Hapeman Rd 201.2-1-2 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Dykeman Arthur Pine Plains 134201 41,300 AGED C 41802 6,482 0 0 74 Hapeman Rd Bruckert 146,200 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,153 EAST-0681221 NRTH-1177315 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,635 DEED BOOK 00717 PG-00164 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 95,930 FULL MARKET VALUE 208,857 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,200 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 98 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-27 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-27 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 Dykeman David A Copake-Taconic 102801 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 Dykeman Helen G Micro 9063 117,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 2455 Route 47 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,776 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700220 NRTH-1218420 DEED BOOK 644 PG-341 FULL MARKET VALUE 168,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-69 ****************** Twin Dr 171.-1-69 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Eaton Donald Germantown 103602 36,515 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 Eaton Rebecca Lynk subdivision 131,376 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 88 Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,816 PO Box BOX FRNT 133.44 DPTH 263.51 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 131,376 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 BANKN140687 EAST-0687185 NRTH-1200665 DEED BOOK C0293 PG-F0778 FULL MARKET VALUE 187,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-28 ****************** Marty Rd 182.-1-28 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,528 Edip Galid M Germantown 103602 40,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,528 79 Seaman Rd Beach View Hills 40,528 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,528 Stormville, NY 12582 ACRES 5.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,528 TO M EAST-0690089 NRTH-1188362 DEED BOOK 0506 PG-00846 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,897 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-10 ****************** CR 19 192.-1-10 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Edman Russell Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 159,936 1107 Route 19 ACRES 1.00 BANK0080490 159,936 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 159,936 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682888 NRTH-1184158 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 133,376 DEED BOOK C504 PG-F1206 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 159,936 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 228,480 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-20 **************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-1-20 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Edmonds Stephen M Pine Plains 134201 32,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 79,288 45 Lakeview Dr Twin Lakes 0001 79,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 79,288 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 184.57 DPTH 132.59 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,728 EAST-0682939 NRTH-1178118 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 79,288 TO M DEED BOOK C0289 PG-F2475 FULL MARKET VALUE 113,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 99 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-11.111 ************** Off Black Bridge Rd Lot 1 182.-1-11.111 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 22,984 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 22,984 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 22,984 Mvmm Corp ACRES 8.44 22,984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,984 318 E 3Rd St EAST-0687655 NRTH-1190787 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 22,984 TO M Mt Vernon, NY 10550 DEED BOOK 0646 PG-00326 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,834 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-11.200 ************** Off Black Bridge Rd Lot I 182.-1-11.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 15,912 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 15,912 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 15,912 Mvmm Corp ACRES 5.86 15,912 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 15,912 318 E 3Rd St EAST-0688245 NRTH-1190568 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 15,912 TO M Mt Vernon, NY 10550 DEED BOOK 0646 PG-00326 FULL MARKET VALUE 22,731 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-50 ****************** Off Black Bridge Rd Lot 1 182.-1-50 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,216 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 4,216 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,216 Mvmm Corp ACRES 1.55 4,216 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,216 318 E 3Rd St EAST-0687706 NRTH-1190147 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,216 TO M Mt Vernon, NY 10550 DEED BOOK 0646 PG-00326 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-22 ****************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-22 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 211,344 Egan Edward Timothy Ma Germantown 103602 211,344 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 211,344 485 North Owen St Micro 2484 211,344 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 211,344 Alexandria, VA 22304 ACRES 76.38 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 211,344 TO M EAST-0688788 NRTH-1188859 DEED BOOK C522 PG-F2328 FULL MARKET VALUE 301,920 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-56 **************** Private Rd 192.20-2-56 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,728 Egan Mathew T Pine Plains 134201 25,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,728 1727 Route 9 Bk10 Pg786 135,728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,728 Germantown, NY 12526 FRNT 76.30 DPTH 114.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,728 TO M EAST-0683921 NRTH-1177490 DEED BOOK 645 PG-1071 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,897 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 100 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-26 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-26 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 Egan Robert Germantown 103602 56,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 16 Guard Hill Rd ACRES 6.40 95,064 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 Mt Kisco, NY 10459 EAST-0668372 NRTH-1216518 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 95,064 TO M DEED BOOK 00822 PG-00172 FULL MARKET VALUE 135,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-11.112 ************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-11.112 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Egan Robert Germantown 103602 55,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 16 Guard Hill Rd ACRES 2.10 55,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Mt Kisco, NY 10549 EAST-0687933 NRTH-1191487 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,352 TO M DEED BOOK 00709 PG-00170 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,074 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-11.121 ************** Off Black Bridge Rd Lot 2 182.-1-11.121 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 Egan Robert Germantown 103602 19,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 16 Guard Hill Rd ACRES 3.50 19,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,040 Mt Kisco, NY 10549 EAST-0688434 NRTH-1191358 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,040 TO M DEED BOOK 00709 PG-00170 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-18.110 ************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-18.110 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 63,920 Egan Robert Germantown 103602 63,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 63,920 Attn: Mt Vernon Monetary Micro 5356 63,920 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 63,920 Management Corp ACRES 14.51 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 63,920 TO M 403 East Third St EAST-0689634 NRTH-1190881 Mt Vernon, NY 10550 DEED BOOK C0293 PG-F1954 FULL MARKET VALUE 91,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-18.210 ************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-18.210 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,376 Egan Robert Germantown 103602 80,376 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,376 16 Guard Hill Rd Micro 5356 80,376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,376 Mount Kisco, NY 10549 ACRES 20.56 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 80,376 TO M EAST-0688725 NRTH-1190419 DEED BOOK C516 PG-F1715 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,823 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 101 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-18.220 ************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-18.220 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 9,520 Egan Robert Germantown 103602 9,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 9,520 16 Guard Hill Rd Micro 5356 9,520 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 9,520 Mt Kisco, NY 10549 ACRES 3.51 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 9,520 TO M EAST-0689676 NRTH-1190101 DEED BOOK 00740 PG-00007 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,600 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-13 **************** Private Rd 192.20-3-13 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 27,744 Egan Robert Pine Plains 134201 27,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 27,744 16 Guard Hill Rd Bk10 Pg786 27,744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 27,744 Bedford Corners, NY 10549 ACRES 0.18 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 27,744 TO M EAST-0683360 NRTH-1177589 DEED BOOK C417 PG-F702 FULL MARKET VALUE 39,634 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-27.11 *************** Off Wire Rd 149.-1-27.11 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 411,944 Egan Robert & Iris Germantown 103602 173,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 411,944 Mvmm Corp Micro 11884 411,944 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 411,944 318 E 3Rd St ACRES 55.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 411,944 TO M Mt Vernon, NY 10550 EAST-0667646 NRTH-1216226 DEED BOOK 00606 PG-01027 FULL MARKET VALUE 588,491 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-31 ****************** Schuderhook Rd 171.-1-31 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Egan Robert C Germantown 103602 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,056 Nicolosi Michael ACRES 3.00 183,056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,056 1727 Rte 9 EAST-0687831 NRTH-1197777 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 156,496 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 591 PG-408 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,056 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 261,509 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-32 ****************** Schuderhook Rd 171.-1-32 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,264 Egan Robert C Germantown 103602 3,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,264 Nicolosi Michael FRNT 52.00 DPTH 104.00 3,264 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,264 1727 Rte 9 EAST-0687912 NRTH-1197517 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,264 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 591 PG-408 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,663 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 102 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-65.111 ************** CR 10 138.-1-65.111 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,200 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 61,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,200 Egan Iris M Micro 12163 & 95-142 61,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,200 16 Guard Hill Rd ACRES 6.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,200 TO M Mt Kisco, NY 10549 EAST-0667943 NRTH-1217557 DEED BOOK 00800 PG-00130 FULL MARKET VALUE 87,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-75 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-75 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 72,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 Egan Iris M Micro 12163 72,896 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 SR 9G ACRES 17.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,896 TO M Livingston, NY EAST-0667506 NRTH-1217783 DEED BOOK 644 PG-217 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,137 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-12 ****************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-12 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,936 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 125,936 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,936 16 Guard Hill Rd Micro 5356 125,936 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 125,936 Mt Kisco, NY 10549 ACRES 28.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,936 TO M EAST-0689784 NRTH-1191321 DEED BOOK 00760 PG-00027 FULL MARKET VALUE 179,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-18.120 ************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-18.120 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,464 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 64,464 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,464 16 Guard Hill Rd Micro 5356 64,464 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,464 Mt Kisco, NY 10549 ACRES 14.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 64,464 TO M EAST-0689415 NRTH-1190610 DEED BOOK 00699 PG-00047 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,091 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-20 ****************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-20 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 39,168 Egan Robert F Germantown 103602 39,168 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 39,168 16 Guard Hill Rd Micro 6760 & 5356 39,168 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,168 Mt Kisco, NY 10549 ACRES 5.41 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 39,168 TO M EAST-0688496 NRTH-1190209 DEED BOOK 00740 PG-00007 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,954 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 103 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-74 ****************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-74 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,648 Eger David Hudson 100600 13,186 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,648 Eger Holly Micro 96-80 29,648 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,648 314 Picketts Lake Rd ACRES 2.21 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,648 TO M Acworth, GA 30101 EAST-0674746 NRTH-1226200 DEED BOOK C0288 PG-F2447 FULL MARKET VALUE 42,354 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-13 ****************** 5290 SR 9G 138.-1-13 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 173,672 Eger Karl Germantown 103602 45,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 173,672 5288 Route 9G ACRES 1.40 173,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,672 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669197 NRTH-1220919 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 173,672 TO M DEED BOOK C513 PG-F1928 FULL MARKET VALUE 248,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-60 ****************** 581 CR 31 139.-1-60 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 58,616 58,616 58,616 Eger Karl Germantown 103602 32,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 5288 Route 9G Carpentier 117,232 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 Germantown, NY 12526 FRNT 200.00 DPTH 165.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 EAST-0677312 NRTH-1218215 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,346 DEED BOOK C400 PG-F2381 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,232 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 167,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-61 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-61 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,584 Eger Karl Germantown 103602 36,584 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,584 5288 Route 9G Carpentier 36,584 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,584 Germantown, NY 12526 FRNT 157.00 DPTH 150.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,584 TO M EAST-0677242 NRTH-1218065 DEED BOOK C400 PG-F2377 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,263 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-33.200 ************** SR 9G 138.-1-33.200 220 2 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Eger Karl R Germantown 103602 54,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 5288 Route 9G ACRES 3.36 198,288 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669217 NRTH-1220699 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,288 TO M DEED BOOK 00723 PG-00091 FULL MARKET VALUE 283,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 104 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-33.200 ************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-33.200 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,384 Eger Ralph Germantown 103602 67,384 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,384 147 Eger Rd Bk3 Pg287 67,384 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 67,384 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 44.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 67,384 TO M EAST-0681513 NRTH-1212604 DEED BOOK C376 PG-F743 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,263 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-17 **************** 22 North Shore Dr 192.20-3-17 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Eichin Paul J Pine Plains 134201 76,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 161,704 PO Box 76 Twin Lakes 161,704 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 161,704 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 295.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,144 EAST-0683061 NRTH-1177499 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 161,704 TO M DEED BOOK 00674 PG-00105 FULL MARKET VALUE 231,006 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-32.110 ************** PARCEL A CR 8 182.-1-32.110 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,872 Elizaville Brookhaven Germantown 103602 55,577 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,872 Properties, LLC Micro 4207 & 10115 183,872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,872 19 Overland Rd ACRES 1.95 BANKC130220 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,872 TO M Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 EAST-0687371 NRTH-1187632 DEED BOOK 608 PG-778 FULL MARKET VALUE 262,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-32.120 ************** PARCEL B CR 8 182.-1-32.120 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 173,536 Elizaville Brookhaven Germantown 103602 66,716 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 173,536 Properties, LLC Micro 4207 & 10115 173,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,536 19 Overland Rd FRNT 199.67 DPTH 362.76 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 173,536 TO M Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 EAST-0687321 NRTH-1187326 DEED BOOK 608 PG-778 FULL MARKET VALUE 247,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-32.200 ************** CR 8 182.-1-32.200 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 326,944 Elizaville Brookhaven Germantown 103602 116,723 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 326,944 Properties, LLC Micro 10115 326,944 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 326,944 19 Overland Rd ACRES 5.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 326,944 TO M Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 EAST-0687671 NRTH-1187447 DEED BOOK 608 PG-778 FULL MARKET VALUE 467,063 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 105 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-63 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-63 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 Ellis Harold W Germantown 103602 47,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 Attn: Mary Ogden Carpentier 47,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 27 Deerhaven Rd ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,600 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0677133 NRTH-1217845 DEED BOOK 0277 PG-00241 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-5 ******************* 779 CR 19 181.-1-5 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ellison John Germantown 103602 69,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,608 Ellison Monika Micro 99-272 197,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,608 779 Rte 19 ACRES 6.10 BANKC080496 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,048 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684299 NRTH-1191917 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,608 TO M DEED BOOK C349 PG-F1899 FULL MARKET VALUE 282,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-12 **************** Private Rd 192.20-3-12 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,520 Espenscheid Joyce Pine Plains 134201 31,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,520 Espenscheid Gary Twin Lakes 111,520 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 111,520 % Scott Espenscheid FRNT 105.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 111,520 TO M 2104 Our Lane EAST-0683450 NRTH-1177619 Steveson, MD 21153 DEED BOOK 567 PG-1143 FULL MARKET VALUE 159,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-40 ***************** Whitman Rd 201.8-1-40 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Estberg Hugh Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Estberg Roberta Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 112 Staunton St FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M Yonkers, NY 10704 EAST-0682987 NRTH-1174119 DEED BOOK 0546 PG-00748 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-41 ***************** Helen Rd 201.8-1-41 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 112,200 Estberg Hugh Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 112,200 Estberg Roberta Reilly Twin Lake 112,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 112,200 112 Staunton St FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 112,200 TO M Yonkers, NY 10704 EAST-0682927 NRTH-1174039 DEED BOOK 0428 PG-00335 FULL MARKET VALUE 160,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 106 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-60 ***************** Whitman Rd 201.8-1-60 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Estberg Hugh Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Estberg Roberta S Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 112 Staunton St FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M Yonkers, NY 10704 EAST-0683017 NRTH-1174079 DEED BOOK 0439 PG-00012 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-33 ****************** 271 Sr 82 151.-1-33 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Estok Evelyn Hudson 100600 51,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 189,448 271 Rte 82 ACRES 4.00 189,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 189,448 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696462 NRTH-1212763 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 139,178 DEED BOOK C0312 PG-F0567 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 189,448 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 270,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-15 ****************** Sr 82 151.-1-15 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 40,690 40,690 40,690 Estok Paul R Hudson 100600 79,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,062 271 Rte 82 Micro 3530 160,752 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,062 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 13.60 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,062 EAST-0694825 NRTH-1216030 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,062 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 00542 PG-00860 40,690 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,646 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-36 ****************** Sr 82 151.-1-36 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 71,475 71,475 71,475 Estok Stephen Hudson 100600 72,896 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,421 271 Rte 82 ACRES 7.30 72,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,421 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696664 NRTH-1211293 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,421 DEED BOOK 0497 PG-00713 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,421 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 104,137 71,475 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-66 ****************** Estok Rd 151.-1-66 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 203,333 203,333 203,333 Estok Stephen Jr W Hudson 100600 211,616 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 8,283 Estok Edward ACRES 41.30 211,616 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 8,283 271 Rte 82 EAST-0695845 NRTH-1211152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,283 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C465 PG-F1025 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 8,283 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 302,309 203,333 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 107 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-19 ****************** Proper Rd 151.-1-19 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 81,638 81,638 81,638 Estok Stephen Jr Hudson 100600 86,768 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,130 271 Rte 82 ACRES 18.77 86,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,130 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692745 NRTH-1216496 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,130 DEED BOOK 00784 PG-00130 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,130 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 123,954 81,638 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-3 ******************* Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-3 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 149,006 149,006 149,006 Estok Stephen W Jr Copake-Taconic 102801 159,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,938 Estok Edward Merged W/04 207,944 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,938 271 Rte 82 ACRES 46.93 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,938 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698179 NRTH-1219126 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,938 TO M DEED BOOK C463 PG-F1018 149,006 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 297,063 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-42 ****************** 271 Estok Rd 151.-1-42 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 237,604 237,604 237,604 Estok Stephen W Jr Hudson 100600 313,500 AGED C 41802 58,832 0 0 Estok Edward ACRES 130.00 629,816 AGED T&S 41806 0 19,611 19,611 271 Rte 82 EAST-0693903 NRTH-1211858 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C465 PG-F1015 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 333,380 FULL MARKET VALUE 899,737 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 372,601 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 322,331 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 392,212 TO M 237,604 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-6.112 *************** Off Bingham Mill Rd 170.-1-6.112 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ettinger Barbara P Red Hook 134801 101,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 726,104 Attn: Frank O Ramsay Jr Micro 10183 726,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 726,104 Exec Planning Associates ACRES 10.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 699,544 171 E Ridgewood Ave EAST-0674288 NRTH-1197130 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 726,104 TO M Ridgewood, NJ 07450 DEED BOOK 00764 PG-00047 FULL MARKET VALUE 1037,291 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-29 ****************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-29 240 Rural res VET458(5) 41001 182,148 182,148 0 Eva Helen Egan Irrevoc. Trust Germantown 103602 118,700 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 102 Black Bridge Rd ACRES 36.00 317,016 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,868 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0689480 NRTH-1188121 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 134,868 DEED BOOK 658 PG-933 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 290,456 PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 FULL MARKET VALUE 452,880 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 317,016 TO M Egan Peter F Jr ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 108 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-2 ******************* Sr 9 170.-2-2 720 Mine/quarry COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 504,968 F.H. Stickles and Son, Inc. Hudson 100600 218,347 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 504,968 2656 Sr 9 ACRES 70.61 504,968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 504,968 PO Box 600 EAST-0683975 NRTH-1200779 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 504,968 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 601 PG-1569 FULL MARKET VALUE 721,383 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-30 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-30 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 Fader Craig A Germantown 103602 44,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 Maggio Lynne S Tom Thumb 108,256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 27 Mulberry Dr ACRES 3.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,256 TO M Smithtown, NY 11787 EAST-0679812 NRTH-1223460 DEED BOOK 605 PG-1122 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-57 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-57 220 2 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,312 Fair Janice A Pine Plains 134201 43,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,312 716 Rte 2 Micro 12179 104,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,312 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.29 BANKC080345 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,312 TO M EAST-0683190 NRTH-1172569 DEED BOOK C0280 PG-F1203 FULL MARKET VALUE 149,017 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-45 ***************** LOT 15 Shore Dr 201.8-2-45 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 119,816 Fairlie Lani Pine Plains 134201 25,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 119,816 Fairlie Dennis Reilly Twin Lake 119,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 119,816 95 Sandalwood Ln FRNT 50.00 DPTH 155.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,816 TO M Rhinebeck, NY 12572 EAST-0682729 NRTH-1173038 DEED BOOK C509 PG-F1892 FULL MARKET VALUE 171,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-16.2 **************** Maple Ln 170.-2-16.2 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fallon Robert J Red Hook 134801 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 90,856 Fallon Kim M ACRES 2.00 90,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 90,856 112 Maple Ln EAST-0721213 NRTH-0544827 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,296 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C528 PG-F1236 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 90,856 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 129,794 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 109 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-48.1 **************** CR 10 138.-1-48.1 230 3 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fanelli Nicholas S Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 380,000 3530 Route 9G Micro 07-310 380,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 380,000 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 353,440 EAST-0667760 NRTH-1218900 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 380,000 TO M DEED BOOK 561 PG-1431 FULL MARKET VALUE 542,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-48.2 **************** CR 10 138.-1-48.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,000 Fanelli Nicholas S Germantown 103602 55,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,000 3530 Route 9G Bk20 Pg1523 55,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,000 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,000 TO M EAST-0667694 NRTH-1219088 DEED BOOK 561 PG-1431 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-45 ***************** 90 Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-45 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 138,992 Fangmann Steven Pine Plains 134201 43,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 138,992 Fangmann Lucia Pb 16 Pg 1966 138,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,992 239 Southwood Cir ACRES 1.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 138,992 TO M Syosset, NY 11791 EAST-0681625 NRTH-1175146 DEED BOOK C414 PG-F1889 FULL MARKET VALUE 198,560 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-1.112 *************** 241 Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-1.112 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Fanning Guy E Sr Germantown 103602 36,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 241 Blackbridge Rd Micro 10890 259,352 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 242,787 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.01 BANKN140687 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 242,787 EAST-0688633 NRTH-1191849 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 209,082 DEED BOOK C489 PG-F1623 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 259,352 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 370,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-47.100 ************** Betty Rd 192.-1-47.100 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,280 Fanning Raymond Pine Plains 134201 65,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,280 3123 Lexington Ave ACRES 2.40 65,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,280 Mohegan Lake, NY 10547 EAST-0684590 NRTH-1177892 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 65,280 TO M DEED BOOK C403 PG-F1532 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,257 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 110 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-44.100 ************** 633 C R 19 171.-1-44.100 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Farley Brendan Germantown 103602 31,300 AGED - ALL 41800 45,900 45,900 59,704 Farley Winifred ACRES 0.71 119,408 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 633 County Rte 19 EAST-0685967 NRTH-1194828 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,900 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0571 PG-01069 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,900 FULL MARKET VALUE 170,583 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 9,434 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,408 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-11 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-11 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 177,752 Favara Carmelo Pine Plains 134201 39,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 177,752 Favara Chrisie Pb 16 Pg 1966 177,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 177,752 107 Classic Way FRNT 129.87 DPTH 300.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 177,752 TO M Morganville, NJ 07751-4430 EAST-0682142 NRTH-1176947 DEED BOOK 00742 PG-00001 FULL MARKET VALUE 253,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-12 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-12 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 27,200 Favara Carmelo Pine Plains 134201 27,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 27,200 Favara Chrisie Bk16 Pg1966 27,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 27,200 107 Classic Way ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 27,200 TO M Morganville, NJ 07751-4430 EAST-0682272 NRTH-1176907 DEED BOOK 00742 PG-00001 FULL MARKET VALUE 38,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-38 ***************** 71 CR 19 161.1-1-38 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Feli Pauline Hudson 100600 28,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,496 71 Rte 19 FRNT 138.60 DPTH 165.66 120,496 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,496 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688383 NRTH-1207177 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,936 DEED BOOK 0585 PG-00586 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,496 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 172,137 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 120,496 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-27.1 **************** Sr 82 161.-1-27.1 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,300 Feller Arnold Jr Hudson 100600 61,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,300 85 Feller Rd ACRES 8.50 61,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,300 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0697974 NRTH-1206326 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,300 TO M DEED BOOK C375 PG-F919 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 87,571 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2010 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 111 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-17 ****************** 156 C R 10 149.-1-17 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 54,479 54,479 0 Feller Delmar Germantown 103602 27,300 AGED - ALL 41800 15,601 15,601 42,840 Feller Ella FRNT 100.00 DPTH 196.90 85,680 EN STAR 41834 0 0 42,840 156 Rte 10 EAST-0669535 NRTH-1216740 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 15,600 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0330 PG-00553 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 15,600 FULL MARKET VALUE 122,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,680 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-19 ****************** CR 10 149.-1-19 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 25,704 Feller Delmar Germantown 103602 25,704 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 25,704 156 Rte 10 FRNT 95.00 DPTH 133.70 25,704 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 25,704 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669325 NRTH-1216750 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 25,704 TO M DEED BOOK 0389 PG-00154 FULL MARKET VALUE 36,720 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-50 ****************** Half Circle Wire Rds 149.-1-50 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Feller John Germantown 103602 14,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 Feller Michelle L FRNT 85.00 DPTH 85.00 105,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 10 Wire Rd ACRES 0.20 BANK0180200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,704 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669014 NRTH-1216372 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,264 TO M DEED BOOK C416 PG-F2262 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,377 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-44 ****************** 64 Old Sr 82 151.-1-44 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fenoff James Hudson 100600 42,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 DeGraff Christine ACRES 1.70 57,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 64 Old Route 82 EAST-0696765 NRTH-1210894 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 30,560 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 628 PG-964 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 57,120 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 81,600 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-39 ****************** 219 CR 10 149.-1-39 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,752 Ferraioli Michael Germantown 103602 47,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,752 219 Co Rt 10 ACRES 2.60 143,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,752 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670577 NRTH-1215882 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,752 TO M DEED BOOK C350 PG-F1978 FULL MARKET VALUE 205,360 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 112 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-31.200 ************** CR 8 182.-1-31.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 160,072 Ferranti Frank Germantown 103602 53,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 160,072 Ferranti Rosemary Micro 93-305 160,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,072 1996 County Route 8 ACRES 6.50 BANKC010695 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,072 TO M Elizaville, NY 12513 EAST-0685818 NRTH-1187548 DEED BOOK C406 PG-F1434 FULL MARKET VALUE 228,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-17 ****************** Schuderhook Rd 171.-1-17 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 293,352 Ferrara Rosario Germantown 103602 184,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 293,352 Ferrara Carmela ACRES 68.00 293,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 293,352 8215 Fourteenth Ave EAST-0695147 NRTH-1199491 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 293,352 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11228 DEED BOOK 0668 PG-00213 FULL MARKET VALUE 419,074 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-42 ***************** 21 Helen Rd 201.8-1-42 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ferrari Christine Pine Plains 134201 37,600 RPTL 459C 41932 29,852 0 0 21 Helen Rd Reilly Twin Lake 119,408 RPTL 459C 41936 0 17,911 17,911 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 89,556 EAST-0682777 NRTH-1173978 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,497 DEED BOOK C0306 PG-F1209 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,937 FULL MARKET VALUE 170,583 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,408 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-8 ******************* Mambert Rd 152.-1-8 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,328 Ferrari Matthew Copake-Taconic 102801 57,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,328 Ferrari Maryan ACRES 7.50 115,328 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 115,328 134 Jaycox Ave EAST-0700897 NRTH-1215052 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,328 TO M Islip, NY 11751 DEED BOOK C474 PG-F2288 FULL MARKET VALUE 164,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-16 ****************** 131 SR 82 151.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Ferris Ernest Hudson 100600 39,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 131 Route 82 Micro 3530 124,168 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 96,560 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.40 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 96,560 EAST-0694335 NRTH-1216109 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 97,608 DEED BOOK 0548 PG-00216 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,168 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 177,383 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 113 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-1 ******************* Greendale Rd 128.-1-1 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 251,872 Ferris Joshua Hudson 100600 51,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 251,872 Kennedy Elizabeth FRNT 450.00 DPTH 180.00 251,872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 251,872 160 Huntington St EAST-0669174 NRTH-1227709 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 251,872 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11231 DEED BOOK 626 PG-217 FULL MARKET VALUE 359,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-7 ******************* Mambert Rd 152.-1-7 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 193,936 Feuer Zachary S Copake-Taconic 102801 75,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 193,936 Fox Allison ACRES 12.90 193,936 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 193,936 309 W 20th St EAST-0701567 NRTH-1215203 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 193,936 TO M New York, NY 10011 DEED BOOK 562 PG-795 FULL MARKET VALUE 277,051 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-22 ****************** 137 CR 10 149.-1-22 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fieser Eli Germantown 103602 39,130 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 171,224 Fieser Peggy ACRES 1.00 171,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 171,224 137 County Route 10 EAST-0668845 NRTH-1216849 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 144,664 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C503 PG-F1319 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 171,224 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 244,606 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-43.112 ************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-43.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fingar David Hudson 100600 52,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,096 Fingar Linda Micro 96-20 185,096 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,096 PO Box 217 ACRES 4.18 BANKC060975 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 158,536 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0689915 NRTH-1205881 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,096 TO M DEED BOOK 00824 PG-00275 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 185,096 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 264,423 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-33.100 ************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-33.100 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 41,928 41,928 41,928 Finley John J Germantown 103602 176,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Finley Judith A Bk3 Pg287 603,568 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 561,640 PO Box 211 ACRES 68.80 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 561,640 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0680551 NRTH-1213602 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 535,080 DEED BOOK C0279 PG-F2036 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 561,640 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 862,240 41,928 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 114 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-31 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 47 201.8-2-31 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 93,024 Fino Merlyn Pine Plains 134201 29,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,024 6595 Route 9 Bk18 Pg1374 93,024 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,024 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 53.53 DPTH 102.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 93,024 TO M EAST-0682798 NRTH-1173498 DEED BOOK 0606 PG-01024 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,891 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-6.111 *************** Sr 9 170.-2-6.111 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 163,964 163,964 163,964 Fish Mary Ann T Red Hook 134801 308,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 332,980 Attn: Knauss Mary Susan ACRES 98.50 496,944 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 332,980 134 Sparrowbush Rd EAST-0680541 NRTH-1197903 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 332,980 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0581 PG-01001 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 332,980 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 709,920 163,964 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-6.200 *************** Sr 9 170.-2-6.200 280 Multiple res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fish Mary Ann T Red Hook 134801 46,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 368,560 Attn: Knauss Mary Susan ACRES 2.38 BANKH110045 368,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 368,560 134 Sparrowbush Rd EAST-0681133 NRTH-1197004 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 342,000 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0558 PG-00689 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 368,560 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 526,514 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-41 ***************** Livingston C R 19 161.1-1-41 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Fitzpatrick Kenneth G Hudson 100600 47,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,272 Baker Mary Ellen ACRES 2.29 153,272 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,272 PO Box 36 EAST-0688394 NRTH-1206598 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,002 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 00792 PG-00120 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,272 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 218,960 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 153,272 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-47.222 ************** Off Woodchuck Rd 139.-1-47.222 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fix Gary Germantown 103602 42,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 186,400 Fix Pamela Micro 98-44 186,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 186,400 247 White Birch Rd ACRES 4.39 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 159,840 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0711739 NRTH-0547580 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 186,400 TO M DEED BOOK C521 PG-F1103 FULL MARKET VALUE 266,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 115 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-54.111 ************** CR 10 150.-1-54.111 151 Fruit crop COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Fix Robert Germantown 103602 74,800 AG DISTRIC 41720 36,575 36,575 36,575 Fix Linda ACRES 21.09 228,208 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 222 White Birch Rd EAST-0676016 NRTH-1210993 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,025 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C352 PG-F436 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,025 FULL MARKET VALUE 326,011 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 141,363 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 191,633 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 36,575 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-47.210 ************** 59 Fix Rd 139.-1-47.210 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fix William Germantown 103602 49,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 218,008 Fix Eileen Micro 98-44 218,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 218,008 59 Fix Rd ACRES 4.45 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 191,448 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0673457 NRTH-1220988 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,008 TO M DEED BOOK C0312 PG-F2194 FULL MARKET VALUE 311,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-7.1 ***************** 121 Maple Ln 170.-2-7.1 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 55,223 55,223 55,223 Fleming Robert Germantown 103602 105,100 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Fleming Carol Micro08-113 201,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 145,777 121 maple Ln ACRES 18.50 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 145,777 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0068133 NRTH-1195832 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 95,507 DEED BOOK C0491 PG-F1309 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,777 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 287,143 55,223 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-7.2 ***************** 113 Maple Ln 170.-2-7.2 220 2 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 55,223 55,223 55,223 Fleming Robert Germantown 103602 48,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,777 Fleming Carol ACRES 2.00 112,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,777 121 maple Ln EAST-0683095 NRTH-1195848 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,777 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0491 PG-F1309 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,777 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 160,000 55,223 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 116 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-16.1 **************** Maple Ln 170.-2-16.1 270 Mfg housing AG DISTRIC 41720 50,028 50,028 50,028 Fleming Robert L Red Hook 134801 94,000 BAS ST MBH 41864 0 0 10,000 Fleming Carol J ACRES 16.40 204,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,472 121 maple Ln EAST-0721213 NRTH-0544757 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,472 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C528 PG-F1236 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 144,472 FULL MARKET VALUE 292,143 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,472 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 50,028 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-18.112 ************** CR 31 170.-1-18.112 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,984 Forbes Godfrey D Red Hook 134801 56,984 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,984 PO Box 876 Micro 9267 56,984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,984 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,984 TO M EAST-0676546 NRTH-1195225 DEED BOOK 0589 PG-00274 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,406 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-31 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-31 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 Forges Khial D Sr Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 Couse Melissa A FRNT 170.00 DPTH 200.00 123,896 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 PO Box 75 EAST-0682400 NRTH-1172778 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 123,896 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 622 PG-261 FULL MARKET VALUE 176,994 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-36 **************** Pleasantview Dr 146 & 14 192.20-2-36 280 Multiple res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Forringer Jon Pine Plains 134201 33,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 210,800 31 Cammbridge Dr Micro 4395 210,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 210,800 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 0.28 BANKC080345 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 184,240 EAST-0683910 NRTH-1177860 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 210,800 TO M DEED BOOK C541 PG-F572 FULL MARKET VALUE 301,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-39 **************** Fairview Rd 192.20-2-39 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,256 Forringer Jon Pine Plains 134201 40,256 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,256 31 Cambridge Dr Twin Lakes 40,256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,256 Red Hook, NY 12571 FRNT 70.00 DPTH 135.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,256 TO M EAST-0683790 NRTH-1177860 DEED BOOK C541 PG-F576 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,509 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 117 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-6 ******************* CR 10 160.-1-6 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Foster Alexandra Hudson 100600 39,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 163,200 Foster Joseph E Jr ACRES 1.60 BANKC080007 163,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 163,200 1003 County Route 10 EAST-0683333 NRTH-1207218 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,640 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 538 PG-1920 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 163,200 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 233,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-59.120 ************** 113 Wire Rd 149.-1-59.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fowx Jerri M Germantown 103602 62,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 253,232 Fowx Susan M Micro-#95-60 253,232 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 253,232 113 Wire Rd ACRES 7.00 BANKC080496 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 226,672 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668439 NRTH-1214151 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 253,232 TO M DEED BOOK 00792 PG-00237 FULL MARKET VALUE 361,760 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-2.112 *************** 629 Rte 31 150.-1-2.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fox Todd Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 199,500 Fox Renee ACRES 2.00 BANK0080490 199,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 199,500 69 Cedar Ln EAST-0675110 NRTH-0121640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 172,940 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F0199 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 199,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 285,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-36.200 ************** Giambalvo Rd. Lot 3 139.-1-36.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Frank David C Hudson 100600 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 202,500 Frank Racquel L Micro 9515 202,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 202,500 149 Spring Rd ACRES 2.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 175,940 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0683684 NRTH-1221878 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 202,500 TO M DEED BOOK 582 PG-2116 FULL MARKET VALUE 289,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-33 ****************** Sr 9 170.-2-33 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 460,088 Frank Johannes Red Hook 134801 131,061 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 460,088 Frank Renate ACRES 22.64 460,088 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 460,088 213 Cedar Heights Rd EAST-0678629 NRTH-1194069 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 460,088 TO M Rhinebeck, NY 12572 DEED BOOK 0582 PG-00124 FULL MARKET VALUE 657,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 118 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-50 ****************** 3406 CR 19 161.-1-50 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Frantzen-Zammiello Colleen P Hudson 100600 34,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,352 Frantzen Ryan FRNT 200.00 DPTH 195.00 140,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,352 335 County Rte 19 EAST-0686913 NRTH-1201875 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,792 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 591 PG-2026 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 140,352 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 200,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-17 ***************** Private Rd 192.4-2-17 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 Fredericks Richard Jr Pine Plains 134201 44,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 Fredericks Karen A ACRES 0.63 75,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 111 Ritter Rd EAST-0684551 NRTH-1177532 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 75,888 TO M Stormville, NY 12582 DEED BOOK 0561 PG-00828 FULL MARKET VALUE 108,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-30 ****************** CR 8 182.-1-30 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 691,807 Frei Christian Germantown 103602 175,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 691,807 Carpenter Ailsa ACRES 21.70 BANKC030982 691,807 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 691,807 35 Mount Morris Park West EAST-0687170 NRTH-1188126 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 691,807 TO M New York, NY 10027 DEED BOOK C478 PG-F668 FULL MARKET VALUE 988,296 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-55 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-55 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 Friedman Max Germantown 103602 39,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 Romich Thomas A FRNT 290.00 DPTH 165.00 109,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 23 W 11th St EAST-0668518 NRTH-1215458 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,480 TO M New York, NY 10011 DEED BOOK 606 PG-1338 FULL MARKET VALUE 156,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-56.200 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-56.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 Friedman Max Germantown 103602 40,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 Friedman Romich Thomas A Micro 12016 40,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 PO Box 15 ACRES 7.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,800 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0667468 NRTH-1215376 DEED BOOK 00693 PG-00199 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-57 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-57 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 275,400 Friedman Max Germantown 103602 79,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 275,400 Romich Thomas Micro 9740 275,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 275,400 PO Box 15 ACRES 10.27 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 275,400 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668158 NRTH-1215018 DEED BOOK 0596 PG-00611 FULL MARKET VALUE 393,429 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 119 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-59.2 **************** Wire Rd 149.-1-59.2 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 96,968 Friedman Max Germantown 103602 96,968 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 96,968 Romich Thomas ACRES 17.57 96,968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,968 PO Box 15 EAST-0669128 NRTH-1215309 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 96,968 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 677 PG-40 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-59.111 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-59.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,272 Friedman Max Germantown 103602 71,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,272 Friedman Romich Thomas Micro#95-101 102,272 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,272 23 W 11Th St ACRES 11.84 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,272 TO M New York, NY 10011 EAST-0669160 NRTH-1214538 DEED BOOK 00794 PG-00265 FULL MARKET VALUE 146,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-61 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 7 201.2-1-61 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 Frye Francis Pine Plains 134201 19,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 Frye Constance Reilly Twin Lake 87,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 91 Kings Ferry Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,992 TO M Montrose, NY 10548 EAST-0682526 NRTH-1174728 DEED BOOK 536 PG-150 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,703 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-30 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-30 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Fumasoli Mark Pine Plains 134201 38,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 259,216 Fumasoli Valerie R FRNT 170.00 DPTH 210.00 259,216 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 259,216 PO Box 191 BANKC030217 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 232,656 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682550 NRTH-1172798 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 259,216 TO M DEED BOOK C349 PG-F2146 FULL MARKET VALUE 370,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-21.2 **************** 2336 SR 9 170.-2-21.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,500 Funk Elwood Red Hook 134801 42,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,500 Funk Mary micro 06-151 42,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,500 PO Box 402 ACRES 1.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,500 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0680030 NRTH-0119530 DEED BOOK 570 PG-1794 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 120 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-21.11 *************** 2336 SR 9 170.-2-21.11 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,200 Funk Elwood Red Hook 134801 38,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 134,200 Funk Mary micro 06-151 134,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 134,200 PO Box 402 ACRES 1.01 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 134,200 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0679970 NRTH-0119550 DEED BOOK 570 PG-1794 FULL MARKET VALUE 191,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-21.12 *************** 2336 SR 9 170.-2-21.12 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,500 Funk Elwood Red Hook 134801 42,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,500 Funk Mary micro 06-151 42,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,500 PO Box 402 ACRES 1.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,500 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0679850 NRTH-0119530 DEED BOOK 570 PG-1794 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-49 ***************** Honor Rd Lts 129-1/2 Of 201.8-1-49 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Furstinger Nancy Pine Plains 134201 32,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,944 48 Loyola Rd Bk18 Pg1374 122,944 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,944 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,384 BANKC030217 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,944 TO M EAST-0682408 NRTH-1173488 DEED BOOK C423 PG-F1794 FULL MARKET VALUE 175,634 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-53 ****************** 3035 US 9 151.-1-53 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gabriel Kathleen Hudson 100600 41,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 229,160 3035 Route 9 Micro 3958 229,160 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 229,160 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.60 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 202,600 EAST-0688987 NRTH-1210319 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 229,160 TO M DEED BOOK C0340 PG-F0778 FULL MARKET VALUE 327,371 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-49 ****************** Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-49 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,624 Gager Eleanor Germantown 103602 54,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,624 Gager Keith ACRES 4.90 140,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 140,624 3 Roandis Ct EAST-0686538 NRTH-1194205 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 140,624 TO M Ramsey, NJ 07446 DEED BOOK 00806 PG-00183 FULL MARKET VALUE 200,891 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 121 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-4.200 *************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-4.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 Gallery 77 V. N Germantown 103602 116,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 174 Cold Spring Rd Micro 10427 116,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,416 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 19.99 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,416 TO M EAST-0680028 NRTH-1215101 DEED BOOK C454 PG-F579 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-24 ****************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-24 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gallery 77 V. N Germantown 103602 148,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 697,000 174 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 17.40 697,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 697,000 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680678 NRTH-1214792 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 670,440 DEED BOOK C454 PG-F579 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 697,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 995,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-34 ****************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-34 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 Gandolf Roger Germantown 103602 62,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 Attn: Mohrlein Arlene ACRES 5.00 131,376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 316 Middletown Rd EAST-0675649 NRTH-1219862 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 131,376 TO M Colchester, CT 06415 DEED BOOK 0621 PG-00346 FULL MARKET VALUE 187,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-38 ****************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-38 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,416 Gandolf Roger Germantown 103602 150,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,416 Attn: Mohrlein Arlene ACRES 38.80 150,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,416 316 Middletown Rd EAST-0670621 NRTH-1218662 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,416 TO M Colchester, CT 06415 DEED BOOK 0621 PG-00346 FULL MARKET VALUE 214,880 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-71.1 **************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-71.1 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 46,240 Gandolf Roger Germantown 103602 46,240 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 46,240 Attn: Mohrlein Arlene ACRES 17.00 46,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,240 316 Middletown Rd EAST-0671272 NRTH-1218113 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 46,240 TO M Colchester, CT 06415 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-55 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-55 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 189,040 Gannon Jeffrey Hudson 100600 32,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 189,040 Platt Jennifer FRNT 110.00 DPTH 320.00 189,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 189,040 PO Box 204 EAST-0687845 NRTH-1205897 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 189,040 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 567 PG-365 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 189,040 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 270,057 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 122 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-58 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-58 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Gapinski Raymond R Hudson 100600 21,500 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 PO Box 142 ACRES 0.62 BANK0180201 135,320 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,712 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687716 NRTH-1205716 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,712 DEED BOOK C411 PG-F482 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,760 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,314 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,320 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 135,320 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-26 **************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-26 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 Garan Sherrie Pine Plains 134201 38,624 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 Fauci Robert F Twin Lakes 0001 38,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 5137 Marathon Pkwy FRNT 137.50 DPTH 69.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,624 TO M Little Neck, NY 11362 EAST-0682400 NRTH-1177607 DEED BOOK 547 PG-2369 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,177 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-27 **************** CR 19 192.20-3-27 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,856 Garan Sherrie Pine Plains 134201 36,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,856 Fauci Robert F Twin Lakes 0001 36,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,856 5137 Marathon Pkwy FRNT 52.00 DPTH 117.85 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,856 TO M Little Neck, NY 11362 EAST-0682431 NRTH-1177557 DEED BOOK 547 PG-2369 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-28 **************** CR 19 192.20-3-28 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,840 Garan Sherrie Pine Plains 134201 42,840 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,840 Fauci Robert F Twin Lakes 0001 42,840 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,840 5137 Marathon Pkwy ACRES 0.25 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,840 TO M Livingston, NY 11362 EAST-0682461 NRTH-1177537 DEED BOOK 547 PG-2369 FULL MARKET VALUE 61,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-29 **************** CR 19 192.20-3-29 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,800 Garan Sherrie Pine Plains 134201 29,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,800 51-37 Marathon Pkwy Twin Lakes 0001 130,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,800 Little Neck, NY 11363 FRNT 55.00 DPTH 149.13 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,800 TO M EAST-0682511 NRTH-1177508 DEED BOOK C0312 PG-F1828 FULL MARKET VALUE 186,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 123 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-30 **************** CR 19 192.20-3-30 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Garan Sherrie Pine Plains 134201 39,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 51-37 Marathon Pkwy Twin Lakes 0001 39,440 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Little Neck, NY 11363 FRNT 51.88 DPTH 181.16 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 39,440 TO M EAST-0682551 NRTH-1177478 DEED BOOK C0312 PG-F1831 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,343 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-48 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-48 416 Mfg hsing pk BAS STAR 41854 0 0 450,000 Garden Homes Germantown 103602 153,576 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 890,600 29 Knapp St Micro 3326 890,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 890,600 Stamford, CT 06907 ACRES 9.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 440,600 EAST-0686048 NRTH-1194084 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 890,600 TO M DEED BOOK 601 PG-21 FULL MARKET VALUE 1272,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-53 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-53 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 Garden Homes Mobile Germantown 103602 75,888 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 Home Park Co Micro 147 75,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 75,888 29 Knapp St ACRES 5.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 75,888 TO M Stamford, CT 06907 EAST-0685709 NRTH-1193523 DEED BOOK 0571 PG-00841 FULL MARKET VALUE 108,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-13 ****************** Rte 9H - Pine Tree 140.-1-13 416 Mfg hsing pk BAS STAR 41854 0 0 220,000 Garden Homes Mobile Home Hudson 100600 272,550 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 900,864 Park Co ACRES 8.90 900,864 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 900,864 29 Knapp St Box 4401 EAST-0693166 NRTH-1220916 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 680,864 Stamford, CT 06907 DEED BOOK 0581 PG-00144 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 900,864 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1286,949 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-22 **************** 18 Mountainview Dr 192.20-2-22 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 Gardner Katherine Pine Plains 134201 47,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 18 Mountainview Dr Bk22 Pg1602 172,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 154.97 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,856 TO M EAST-0683409 NRTH-1178189 DEED BOOK 610 PG-338 FULL MARKET VALUE 246,937 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 124 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-35 ****************** 616 Pleasantvale Rd 201.-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gardner Ralph A Pine Plains 134201 29,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,592 Gardner Marie A FRNT 238.00 DPTH 159.00 101,592 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,592 616 Pleasantvale Rd BANKC130780 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 75,032 Tivoli, NY 12583 EAST-0680911 NRTH-1172055 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 101,592 TO M DEED BOOK 0635 PG-00320 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,131 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-35.200 ************** Spring Rd 139.-1-35.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gardner Stephen Hudson 100600 42,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,288 Gardner Helene ACRES 2.41 164,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,288 87 Spring Rd EAST-0683933 NRTH-1222488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,728 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0609 PG-00198 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,288 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 234,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-40 ****************** Old Sr 82 152.-1-40 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gargill David Hudson 100600 37,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 346,640 Morse Emily ACRES 1.10 346,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 346,640 171 Old State Route 82 EAST-0698379 NRTH-1208757 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 320,080 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 630 PG-1406 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 346,640 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 495,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-25 ****************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-25 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Garnar Joan Doreen Hudson 100600 39,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 146,608 177 White Birch Rd Micro 869 146,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 146,608 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.07 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,338 EAST-0674161 NRTH-1224049 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,608 TO M DEED BOOK C465 PG-F33 FULL MARKET VALUE 209,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-94.110 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-94.110 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 66,640 Garnar Wortzel Andrew Germantown 103602 66,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 66,640 Garnar Judith ACRES 8.01 66,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,640 251 Wire Rd EAST-0671749 NRTH-1209565 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 66,640 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0313 PG-F0530 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,200 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 125 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-94.120 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-94.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 190,032 Garnar Wortzel Andrew Germantown 103602 65,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 190,032 Garnar Judith ACRES 8.01 190,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 190,032 251 Wire Rd EAST-0671489 NRTH-1209734 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,032 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0313 PG-F0530 FULL MARKET VALUE 271,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-63 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-63 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gatti Regina Hudson 100600 12,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 63,920 167 Co Rt 19 FRNT 65.00 DPTH 75.00 63,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 63,920 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0687236 NRTH-1205425 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,360 DEED BOOK 0659 PG-00311 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 63,920 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 91,314 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 63,920 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-23 ****************** Sr 82 161.-1-23 432 Gas station COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,232 Gaylord Lawrence Hudson 100600 59,250 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,232 Gaylord Sharon Micro No. 2314 185,232 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 185,232 Box 424 ACRES 2.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,232 TO M Niverville, NY 12130 EAST-0697382 NRTH-1207325 DEED BOOK 00781 PG-00039 FULL MARKET VALUE 264,617 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-63.100 ************* 7 Shore Dr 201.8-2-63.100 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Gayton Carol A/k/a Caryll Pine Plains 134201 38,200 AGED - ALL 41800 53,856 53,856 67,660 Gayton Hugh Pb18pa1374 135,320 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 7 Shore Dr FRNT 70.00 DPTH 165.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,856 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683518 NRTH-1173700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,856 DEED BOOK C0327 PG-F1009 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,390 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,314 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,320 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-21 ***************** LTS 34-35 Shore Dr 201.8-2-21 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 Gayton Hugh Pine Plains 134201 47,736 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 Gayton Carol A/k/a Caryll Twin Lake Realty Subd 47,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 7 Shore Dr Pb18 Pg1374 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,736 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 101.94 DPTH 145.00 EAST-0683478 NRTH-1173890 DEED BOOK 0576 PG-00656 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,194 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 126 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-53 ****************** CR 19 99 PCT OF VALUE USED FOR EXEMPTION PURPOSES 181.-1-53 210 1 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 55,574 55,574 55,574 Gazette Deanna Marie Germantown 103602 98,900 AGED C 41802 163,746 0 0 834 Col. Co. rte19 Micro 93-315 330,800 AGED T&S 41806 0 130,997 130,997 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 19.80 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 EAST-0683006 NRTH-1190448 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,480 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 623 PG-2083 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 144,229 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 472,571 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,959 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,900 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-1.111 *************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-1.111 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 241,256 241,256 241,256 Gbbd Farm Partnership Hudson 100600 261,392 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 20,136 215 White Birch Rd Db822pg42 261,392 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 20,136 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 02-253 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 20,136 ACRES 58.44 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 20,136 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT EAST-0673998 NRTH-1225378 241,256 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 DEED BOOK C0310 PG-F1795 FULL MARKET VALUE 373,417 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-26 ****************** Howe Rd 139.-1-26 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 42,645 42,645 42,645 Gbbd Farm Partnership Hudson 100600 61,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,115 215 White Birch Rd #1 ACRES 8.00 123,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,115 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0673222 NRTH-1223327 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,115 DEED BOOK C0310 PG-F1800 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,115 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 176,800 42,645 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-27.100 ************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-27.100 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 51,136 51,136 51,136 Gbbd Farm Partnership Germantown 103602 88,890 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 342,584 215 White Birch Rd #1 ACRES 16.85 393,720 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 342,584 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0673963 NRTH-1223038 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 342,584 DEED BOOK C0310 PG-F1800 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 342,584 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 562,457 51,136 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-27.200 ************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-27.200 220 2 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 238,136 Gbbd Farm Partnership Germantown 103602 48,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 238,136 215 White Birch Rd #1 ACRES 3.14 238,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 238,136 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0673622 NRTH-1223308 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 238,136 TO M DEED BOOK C0310 PG-F1805 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 340,194 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 127 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-46 ****************** Woodchuck Rd 139.-1-46 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 62,105 62,105 62,105 Gbbd Farm Partnership Germantown 103602 66,368 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,263 215 White Birch Rd #1 ACRES 25.00 66,368 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,263 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0675177 NRTH-1220931 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,263 DEED BOOK C0310 PG-F1800 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,263 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 94,811 62,105 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-48 ****************** Woodchuck Rd 139.-1-48 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 203,321 203,321 203,321 Gbbd Farm Partnership Germantown 103602 212,160 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 8,839 215 White Birch Rd #1 ACRES 66.00 212,160 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 8,839 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0673991 NRTH-1218469 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,839 DEED BOOK C0310 PG-F1800 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 8,839 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 303,086 203,321 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-80 ****************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-80 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 133,481 133,481 133,481 Gbbd Farm Partnership Hudson 100600 179,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,847 222 White Birch Rd ACRES 50.50 234,328 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,847 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0675009 NRTH-1224640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 100,847 FULL MARKET VALUE 334,754 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 100,847 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 133,481 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-47.221 ************** Off Woodchuck Rd 139.-1-47.221 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 362,130 362,130 362,130 GBBD Farm Patnership Germantown 103602 382,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 280,990 115 White Birch Rd Micro 98-44 643,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 280,990 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 143.10 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 280,990 EAST-0674139 NRTH-1220363 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 280,990 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 587 PG-1464 362,130 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 918,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-4.200 *************** Orchard Rd 151.-1-4.200 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 197,736 197,736 197,736 Gcard LLC Hudson 100600 248,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 222,504 934 SR 82 ACRES 62.52 420,240 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 222,504 Ancram, NY 12502 EAST-0690515 NRTH-1216531 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 222,504 DEED BOOK 630 PG-955 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 222,504 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 600,343 197,736 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 128 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-35 ****************** 67 Marty Rd 182.-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Geberth Lawrence Germantown 103602 49,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,768 Geberth Jean Beach View Acres 154,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,768 67 Marty Rd ACRES 2.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 128,208 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0689931 NRTH-1187452 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,768 TO M DEED BOOK 0507 PG-00651 FULL MARKET VALUE 221,097 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-9 ******************* CR 31 170.-1-9 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Geigner George Red Hook 134801 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,336 Geignei Christine ACRES 1.00 61,336 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,336 1521 Blue Hill Rd EAST-0676953 NRTH-1197076 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 34,776 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0309 PG-F0203 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,336 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 87,623 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-51 ****************** Schneider Rd 151.-1-51 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 225,080 Gellert Peter Hudson 100600 67,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 225,080 122 E 42Nd St ACRES 8.50 225,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 225,080 New York, NY 10017 EAST-0690486 NRTH-1210421 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 225,080 TO M DEED BOOK 0420 PG-00340 FULL MARKET VALUE 321,543 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-27 **************** Private Rd 192.20-2-27 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 12,688 Gellert Phil Pine Plains 134201 12,688 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 12,688 524 Columbia St Twin Lakes 12,688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 12,688 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 163.70 DPTH 195.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 12,688 TO M EAST-0684050 NRTH-1178031 DEED BOOK C0368 PG-F0424 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-30 **************** LOT 117 Fairview Rd 192.20-2-30 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,928 Gellert Philip D Pine Plains 134201 21,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,928 23 Sir William Farm Rd micro 07-23 77,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 77,928 Hillsdale, NY 12529 FRNT 48.92 DPTH 157.61 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 77,928 TO M ACRES 0.37 EAST-0683580 NRTH-0117810 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F2431 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,326 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 129 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-28 ***************** Summerside Ave 201.8-3-28 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT AGED C 41802 5,331 0 0 Georges-Claire Diana Pine Plains 134201 39,400 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 22 Summerside Av R Twin Lakes 0002 106,624 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,293 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 53.82 DPTH 145.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 106,624 BANKC150016 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,354 EAST-0683877 NRTH-1173990 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 106,624 TO M DEED BOOK 0667 PG-00177 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,320 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-16 ***************** Whitman Rd 201.8-2-16 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Geraghty Daniel Pine Plains 134201 37,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 172,312 Parchen Denise Pb 18 Pg 1374 172,312 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 172,312 13 Loyola Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 145,752 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683148 NRTH-1173899 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,312 TO M DEED BOOK C506 PG-F1696 FULL MARKET VALUE 246,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-68 ****************** Twin Dr 171.-1-68 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gerlach Michael W Germantown 103602 29,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 213,500 Gerlach Tara Lynk Subdivision 213,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 213,500 13 Twin Dr Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 186,940 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 133.00 DPTH 174.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 213,500 TO M BANKC120345 EAST-0687074 NRTH-1180706 DEED BOOK C0304 PG-F2243 FULL MARKET VALUE 305,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-26 ****************** Old Sr 82 152.-1-26 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,176 Gersh Cheryl Hudson 100600 60,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,176 211-04 82 Ave ACRES 6.50 155,176 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,176 Hollis Hills, NY 11457 EAST-0697646 NRTH-1210555 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,176 TO M DEED BOOK 633 PG-949 FULL MARKET VALUE 221,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-53.120 ************** 498 C R 31 139.-1-53.120 240 Rural res AGED - ALL 41800 81,872 81,872 81,872 Giambalvo Mary C Germantown 103602 77,800 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 498-6 Route 31 Micro 9372 163,744 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,872 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 13.58 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,872 EAST-0677808 NRTH-1220226 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,602 DEED BOOK C401 PG-F1982 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 163,744 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 233,920 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 130 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-36.200 ************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-36.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Giangreco Frank Hudson 100600 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 177,072 Giangreco Angelina ACRES 3.01 177,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 177,072 Willowbrook Rd Box 62A EAST-0696027 NRTH-1204963 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,512 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00701 PG-00187 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 177,072 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 252,960 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-15.112 ************** Rt 82 Lot 2 161.-1-15.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Giangreco Maria Hudson 100600 47,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 142,664 PO Box 464 Micro 6596 142,664 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 142,664 Claverack, NY 12513 ACRES 2.56 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,104 EAST-0696612 NRTH-1207594 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 142,664 TO M DEED BOOK C0304 PG-F0031 FULL MARKET VALUE 203,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-28 ****************** Off Howe Rd 139.-1-28 151 Fruit crop COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 608,400 Giauque Dennis L Germantown 103602 284,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 608,400 Yang Bing ACRES 88.21 608,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 608,400 7 W 96th St Apt 7E EAST-0675163 NRTH-1222791 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 608,400 TO M New York, NY 10025 DEED BOOK 576 PG-2155 FULL MARKET VALUE 869,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-13.120 ************** Off Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-13.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gibbons James E Germantown 103602 52,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 284,784 Gibbons Heather L Micro 00-139 284,784 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 284,784 85 Bacon Dr Stop 42 ACRES 6.10 BANKC030217 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 258,224 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0691015 NRTH-1190494 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 284,784 TO M DEED BOOK C420 PG-F2298 FULL MARKET VALUE 406,834 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-11.100 ************** Oak Hill Rd 128.-1-11.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 293,896 Gilford Hillary Hudson 100600 43,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 293,896 Cono Dizeo Micro 93-188 293,896 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 293,896 2250 Broadway Apt 20 ACRES 1.28 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 293,896 TO M New York, NY 10024 EAST-0671255 NRTH-1226783 DEED BOOK C396 PG-F2262 FULL MARKET VALUE 419,851 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 131 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-16 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-16 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gill Steven J Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 220,000 Gill Kathleen M Micro 94-118 220,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 220,000 92 N Creek Rd ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 193,440 Staatsburg, NY 12580 EAST-0686280 NRTH-0120300 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 220,000 TO M DEED BOOK 581 PG-2298 FULL MARKET VALUE 314,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-11.200 ************** 78 Water St 152.-1-11.200 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Giovannucci Mary Copake-Taconic 102801 41,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,608 Giovannucci Luciano ACRES 1.66 61,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,608 78 Water St EAST-0699874 NRTH-1216690 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,048 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0556 PG-00867 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,608 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 88,011 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-11.120 ************** 78 Water St 152.-1-11.120 270 Mfg housing WAR VET/CT 41121 12,648 12,648 0 Giovanucci Luciano Copake-Taconic 102801 46,500 COM VET/CT 41131 21,080 21,080 0 Giovanucci Mary ACRES 2.15 84,320 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 78 Water Street Rd EAST-0699854 NRTH-1216399 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,592 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0554 PG-00658 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,592 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,457 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,760 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 84,320 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 193.-1-7 ******************* LOT 7 Weaver Rd 193.-1-7 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2,312 Giraud Aden Jr Germantown 103602 2,312 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2,312 138 Weaver Rd FRNT 200.00 DPTH 180.00 2,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2,312 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0687415 NRTH-1180537 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2,312 TO M DEED BOOK C0365 PG-F0109 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,303 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-52.120 ************** CR 31 170.-1-52.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Glick Philip O Red Hook 134801 51,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 291,800 1608 Cr 31-Lot 3 Stop 28 Micro-11107 291,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 291,800 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 2.69 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 265,240 EAST-0676317 NRTH-1195115 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 291,800 TO M DEED BOOK 634 PG-604 FULL MARKET VALUE 416,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 132 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-40 ****************** CR 8 182.-1-40 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 Glomb James Germantown 103602 95,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 PO Box 224 Inc Lot 33 - 2001 123,896 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 25.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 123,896 TO M EAST-0687912 NRTH-1187148 DEED BOOK C0355 PG-F1769 FULL MARKET VALUE 176,994 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-58 ****************** CR 31 160.-1-58 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 307,360 Gochman Marita Lindholm Germantown 103602 307,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 307,360 75 Arbor View ACRES 14.52 307,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 307,360 Carmel, NY 10512 EAST-0714742 NRTH-0545485 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 307,360 TO M DEED BOOK 581 PG-1006 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 439,086 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-38.112 ************** Blue Valley Rd 139.-1-38.112 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,488 Godio Angelo Hudson 100600 38,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,488 Godio Anna ACRES 1.73 38,488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,488 81 Brookfield Ave EAST-0684695 NRTH-1221680 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,488 TO M Staten Island, NY 10308 DEED BOOK 0610 PG-00953 FULL MARKET VALUE 54,983 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-6 ******************* 351 Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-6 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Goehring John Pine Plains 134201 57,200 DIS VET/CT 41141 12,152 12,152 0 Goehring Frances ACRES 3.60 243,032 AGED - ALL 41800 101,636 101,636 121,516 351 Pleasant Vale Rd EAST-0678743 NRTH-1176500 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Tivoli, NY 12583 DEED BOOK 0440 PG-00362 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,636 FULL MARKET VALUE 347,189 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,636 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 71,246 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 243,032 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-15.111 ************** 456 Rt 82 Lot 4 161.-1-15.111 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Gomes Robert Hudson 100600 49,000 AGED - ALL 41800 116,022 116,022 124,304 Gomes Frances M ACRES 3.17 BANK0080490 248,608 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 456 Rt 82 EAST-0696571 NRTH-1208153 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,021 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00740 PG-00055 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,021 FULL MARKET VALUE 355,154 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,034 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 248,608 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 133 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-60 ****************** 993 CR 10 160.-1-60 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gonzalez Cristian Hudson 100600 52,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 168,900 Gonzalez Julie ACRES 2.70 168,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 168,900 993 County Route 10,Stop 59 EAST-0683240 NRTH-0120880 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 142,340 Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 241,286 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 168,900 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-33.220 ************** 123 Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-33.220 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 250,100 Goodwin Laura A Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 250,100 Pierce Adrianne E ACRES 1.00 250,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 250,100 123 Willowbrook Rd EAST-0696188 NRTH-1204123 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 250,100 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 625 PG-1538 FULL MARKET VALUE 357,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-15.200 ************** CR 10 149.-1-15.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 195,500 Gordy William Germantown 103602 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 195,500 Gordy Alice A ACRES 1.89 195,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 195,500 3370 Ft. Independence St EAST-0671186 NRTH-1216323 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 195,500 TO M Bronx, NY 10463 DEED BOOK 593 PG-785 FULL MARKET VALUE 279,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-77 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-77 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gorlan Rolf Germantown 103602 36,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 67 Lynk Rd ACRES 1.13 174,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686057 NRTH-1199823 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 147,792 DEED BOOK C412 PG-F1229 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,352 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 249,074 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-72.200 ************** LOT 1 CR 19 171.-1-72.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,608 Grabowski David Germantown 103602 45,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,608 284 Middle Rd Micro 12205 129,608 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 129,608 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.01 BANK0070390 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,608 TO M EAST-0686338 NRTH-1199174 DEED BOOK C0338 PG-F2044 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,154 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-5 ******************* Mambert Rd 152.-1-5 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,400 Grater Mark Copake-Taconic 102801 86,123 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,400 Grater Otto ACRES 50.00 105,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,400 232 Robinson St EAST-0700645 NRTH-1216061 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,400 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 629 PG-883 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 134 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-34.-2 *************** Off CR 8 160.-1-34.-2 271 Mfg housings COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 827,968 Greater Ny Corp Of Hudson 100600 161,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 827,968 Seventh Day Adventist ACRES 20.00 827,968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 827,968 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0685390 NRTH-1205226 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 827,968 TO M DEED BOOK 0467 PG-00197 FULL MARKET VALUE 1182,811 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-35 ****************** 1867 CR 8 181.-1-35 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Greco Ignazio Germantown 103602 57,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Greco Franca ACRES 4.78 160,752 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 1867 Rte 8 EAST-0683480 NRTH-1187969 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0545 PG-00838 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 110,482 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,646 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,752 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-50 **************** 39 N Shore Dr 192.20-2-50 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Green Ilene M Pine Plains 134201 31,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 915 W End Ave Twin Lakes 136,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 New York, NY 10025 FRNT 92.40 DPTH 145.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 110,256 EAST-0683520 NRTH-1177640 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,816 TO M DEED BOOK 638 PG-263 FULL MARKET VALUE 195,451 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-11 **************** Private Rd 192.20-3-11 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,448 Green Ilene M Pine Plains 134201 19,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,448 915 W End Ave Twin Lakes 19,448 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,448 New York, NY 10025 FRNT 149.50 DPTH 76.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,448 TO M EAST-0683340 NRTH-1177709 DEED BOOK 638 PG-263 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,783 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-36.120 ************** Off Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-36.120 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 24,752 Green Stanley Germantown 103602 20,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 24,752 Vogel Richard ACRES 2.60 24,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 24,752 215 W 92Nd St Apt 13b EAST-0691112 NRTH-1197063 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 24,752 TO M New York, NY 10025 DEED BOOK 0549 PG-01054 FULL MARKET VALUE 35,360 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 135 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-36.200 ************** Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-36.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 257,312 Green Stanley Germantown 103602 52,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 257,312 Vogel Richard ACRES 2.00 BANK0080490 257,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 257,312 215 W 92Nd St- Apt 13b EAST-0691177 NRTH-1197423 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 257,312 TO M New York, NY 10025 DEED BOOK 0540 PG-00416 FULL MARKET VALUE 367,589 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-17.200 ************** Water St 152.-1-17.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,008 Greenberg Joan Hudson 100600 48,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,008 312 Water St ACRES 1.06 48,008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,008 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698845 NRTH-1210848 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,008 TO M DEED BOOK C519 PG-F17 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,583 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-19 ****************** 312 Water St 152.-1-19 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Greenberg Joan Hudson 100600 16,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,456 312 Water St FRNT 100.00 DPTH 85.00 101,456 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 101,456 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698955 NRTH-1210848 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,896 DEED BOOK C519 PG-F17 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 101,456 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 144,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-1.120 *************** Deer Haven Rd Par A 182.-1-1.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Greene James A Germantown 103602 35,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 151,912 247 Black Bridge Rd Micro 10890 151,912 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 151,912 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.03 BANK0060860 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 125,352 EAST-0688662 NRTH-1192129 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 151,912 TO M DEED BOOK 00688 PG-00061 FULL MARKET VALUE 217,017 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-12 ****************** 55 Fox Creek Rd 138.-1-12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gregory John Jr Germantown 103602 50,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 103,700 55 Fox Creek Rd ACRES 1.83 103,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 103,700 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670187 NRTH-1220681 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 77,140 DEED BOOK 00798 PG-00205 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 103,700 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 148,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 136 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-38 ***************** 22 Helen Rd 201.8-1-38 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Grima Charles Pine Plains 134201 36,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 139,264 Grima Lydia Reilly Twin Lake 139,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 139,264 22 Helen Rd ACRES 0.75 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 88,994 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682890 NRTH-0117610 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 139,264 TO M DEED BOOK 588 PG-2000 FULL MARKET VALUE 198,949 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-8 ******************* 248 Mill Rd 170.-1-8 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Gropp Henry Red Hook 134801 34,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,240 Gropp Grace FRNT 246.60 DPTH 160.00 148,240 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,240 248 Mill Rd ACRES 2.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,680 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0673227 NRTH-1194899 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,240 TO M DEED BOOK 0423 PG-00167 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,771 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-20 ****************** Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-20 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,680 Gropp Henry J Red Hook 134801 85,680 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,680 Gropp Grace L ACRES 10.00 85,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 85,680 248 Mill Rd EAST-0674218 NRTH-1194580 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,680 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0423 PG-00167 FULL MARKET VALUE 122,400 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-12 ****************** Spring Rd 139.-1-12 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 84,864 Groupp Barry Hudson 100600 43,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 84,864 Groupp Gayle ACRES 1.30 84,864 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 84,864 21 Mt View Ave EAST-0683652 NRTH-1223007 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 84,864 TO M Pearl River, NY 10965 DEED BOOK 0534 PG-00759 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,234 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-18 **************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-18 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 Grover Atul Pine Plains 134201 37,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 94-22 Lefferts Blvd Bk22 Pg1602 0001 37,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 South Richmond Hill, NY 11419 FRNT 125.00 DPTH 69.26 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,672 TO M EAST-0682870 NRTH-1177658 DEED BOOK 585 PG-2197 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,817 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 137 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-38 ****************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-38 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 31,280 Guarino Gioacchino Germantown 103602 31,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 31,280 Guarino Delizia ACRES 2.50 31,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,280 2511 33rd St EAST-0689982 NRTH-1186882 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 31,280 TO M Astoria, NY 11102 DEED BOOK 0531 PG-01127 FULL MARKET VALUE 44,686 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-30 ***************** Helen Rd 201.8-1-30 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 81,532 81,532 81,532 Guerin Carol Pine Plains 134201 46,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 28 Weaver Rd Life Estate 163,064 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,532 Elizaville, NY 12523 Reilly Twin Lake TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,532 FRNT 150.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,262 EAST-0682697 NRTH-1174078 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 163,064 TO M DEED BOOK 566 PG-135 FULL MARKET VALUE 232,949 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-21.120 ************** 177 Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-21.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Guerriero Victor Germantown 103602 51,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 199,376 Guerriero Elisa Micro 11991 199,376 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 199,376 177 Walkers Mill Rd ACRES 4.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 172,816 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675572 NRTH-1207702 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 199,376 TO M DEED BOOK 00698 PG-00235 FULL MARKET VALUE 284,823 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-70.1 **************** Wire Rd 149.-1-70.1 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 111,753 111,753 111,753 Gulinello Frances M Germantown 103602 320,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 PO Box 4 ACRES 147.30 610,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 498,647 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669973 NRTH-1212581 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 498,647 DEED BOOK C0373 PG-F0330 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 472,087 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 872,000 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 498,647 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 111,753 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-70.2 **************** Wire Rd 149.-1-70.2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 133,000 Gulinello Frances M Germantown 103602 46,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 133,000 PO Box 4 ACRES 2.10 133,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 133,000 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670600 NRTH-0121120 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 133,000 TO M DEED BOOK C0373 PG-F0330 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 190,000 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 138 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-14 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-14 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 173,944 Gurvitz Mark J Hudson 100600 51,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 173,944 Baer Lee Ann ACRES 3.80 BANKH061195 173,944 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,944 420 E 23Rd St -#1G EAST-0687096 NRTH-1205685 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 173,944 TO M New York, NY 10010 DEED BOOK C0283 PG-F1184 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 173,944 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 248,491 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-42 ****************** CR 8 182.-1-42 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,208 Gushue Fred Germantown 103602 58,208 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,208 Gushue Carol ACRES 12.40 58,208 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,208 1617 S E 4Th St EAST-0686283 NRTH-1186644 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,208 TO M Deerfield Beach Fla, 33441 DEED BOOK 0483 PG-00255 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,154 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-40.100 ************** Rte 9 Bells Pond Lot 2 140.-1-40.100 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 30,264 30,264 30,264 Guzzi James Hudson 100600 41,344 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 11,080 51 Danski Rd ACRES 12.10 41,344 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 11,080 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0691782 NRTH-1217604 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 11,080 DEED BOOK C531 PG-F1605 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 11,080 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 59,063 30,264 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-7.120 *************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-7.120 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 287,853 287,853 287,853 Guzzi James Germantown 103602 326,808 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,955 41 Danski Ln ACRES 90.50 326,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,955 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0683265 NRTH-1216517 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,955 DEED BOOK 00812 PG-00001 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,955 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 466,869 287,853 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-30.100 ************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-30.100 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,176 Guzzi James Hudson 100600 19,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,176 Guzzi John ACRES 7.07 19,176 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,176 51 Danski Rd EAST-0682751 NRTH-1213296 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,176 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00695 PG-00178 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,394 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 139 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-29.200 ************** Off Rifenburgh Rd 150.-1-29.200 449 Warehouse AG DISTRIC 41720 203,327 203,327 203,327 Guzzi James J Hudson 100600 252,761 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 201,681 Guzzi John A ACRES 50.00 405,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 201,681 51 Danski Rd EAST-0683885 NRTH-1213748 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 201,681 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00671 PG-00293 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 201,681 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 578,583 203,327 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-6 ******************* Rifenburgh Rd 20 PCT OF VALUE USED FOR EXEMPTION PURPOSES 150.-1-6 433 Auto body AG DISTRIC 41720 170,733 170,733 170,733 Guzzi John Hudson 100600 227,757 AGED - ALL 41800 62,075 62,075 62,075 Guzzi James ACRES 56.60 620,744 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 51 Danski Rd EAST-0684817 NRTH-1215220 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 387,936 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00671 PG-00291 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 387,936 FULL MARKET VALUE 886,777 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 337,666 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 450,011 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 170,733 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-73 ****************** CR 19 161.-1-73 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,300 Gyuro Robert M Hudson 100600 24,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,300 36 Worth Ave ACRES 0.46 38,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,300 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686751 NRTH-1203220 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,300 TO M DEED BOOK 588 PG-1363 FULL MARKET VALUE 54,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-12 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-12 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,800 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 49,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,800 Willowbrook Rd Lot 5 micro09-14 49,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,800 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.01 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,800 TO M EAST-0697834 NRTH-1206168 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-27.2 **************** Sr 82 161.-1-27.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 60,000 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 60,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 60,000 346 White Pond Road micro09-14 60,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 60,000 Stormville, NY 12582 ACRES 4.68 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 60,000 TO M EAST-0697613 NRTH-1205659 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 542 PG-73 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2010 FULL MARKET VALUE 85,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 140 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-27.21 *************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-27.21 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 52,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 Willowbrook Rd Lot 5 micro09-14 52,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 Livingston, NY ACRES 2.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,500 TO M EAST-0697642 NRTH-1205980 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-27.22 *************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-27.22 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,400 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 48,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,400 Willowbrook Rd Lot 2 micro09-14 48,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,400 Livingston, NY ACRES 1.54 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,400 TO M EAST-0698176 NRTH-1205886 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-27.211 ************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-27.211 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,700 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 49,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,700 Willowbrook Rd Lot 5 micro09-14 49,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,700 Livingston, NY ACRES 1.68 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,700 TO M EAST-0698274 NRTH-1206088 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-27.212 ************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-27.212 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 62,500 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 62,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 62,500 Willowbrook Rd Lot 5 micro09-14 62,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 62,500 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 3.91 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 62,500 TO M EAST-0698023 NRTH-1205620 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-34.1 **************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-34.1 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 52,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 Willowbrook Rd ACRES 2.05 52,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0697676 NRTH-1206495 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 75,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-34.2 **************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-34.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 52,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 Willowbrook Rd Lot 5 micro09-14 52,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 52,500 Livingston, NY ACRES 2.33 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,500 TO M EAST-0697984 NRTH-1206352 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 141 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-71 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-71 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 233,400 H & S Dziubelski, LLC Hudson 100600 52,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 233,400 Willowbrook Rd Lot 5 micro09-14 233,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 233,400 Livingston, NY ACRES 2.37 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 233,400 TO M EAST-0697417 NRTH-1206112 FULL MARKET VALUE 333,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-23 ****************** Taghkanic Rd 182.-1-23 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,448 Hageman Leo H Germantown 103602 36,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,448 Hageman Barbara Beach View Acres 36,448 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,448 212 ACRES 4.40 BANKC031720 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,448 TO M PO Box WOODS EAST-0690688 NRTH-1188933 Antigua West Indies, DEED BOOK C495 PG-F709 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-7 ******************* Old 82 161.-1-7 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 113,424 Hagin Nancy Hudson 100600 21,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 113,424 174 Old Route 82 FRNT 70.00 DPTH 200.00 113,424 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,424 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698109 NRTH-1208756 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 113,424 TO M DEED BOOK 0581 PG-00897 FULL MARKET VALUE 162,034 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-2.120 *************** Rte 31 150.-1-2.120 210 1 Family Res CW_15_VET/ 41162 8,282 0 0 Hall Jon Germantown 103602 53,700 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hall Marilyn Micro 00-114 149,464 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 141,182 649 Cty Rt 31 ACRES 2.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 149,464 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0676995 NRTH-1216505 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,904 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F0199 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 149,464 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 213,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-25 ****************** 119 Old Manorton Rd 181.-1-25 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ham Hilary Germantown 103602 80,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 119 Old Manorton Rd ACRES 18.50 174,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,352 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682828 NRTH-1189118 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 147,792 DEED BOOK 0433 PG-00161 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,352 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 249,074 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 142 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-56 ****************** Mills Rd 170.-1-56 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 245,300 Hamilton Michael Red Hook 134801 54,643 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 245,300 Seddio Carla ACRES 4.00 245,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 245,300 206 Mill Rd EAST-0712264 NRTH-0544741 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 245,300 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 606 PG-1465 FULL MARKET VALUE 350,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-32 ****************** 29 Hamm Rd 151.-1-32 112 Dairy farm COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Hamm Donald P Hudson 100600 247,700 AG 10 YEAR 41700 105,000 105,000 105,000 29 Hamm Rd ACRES 90.40 717,408 AG DISTRIC 41720 180,083 180,083 180,083 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0694737 NRTH-1214970 AGED - ALL 41800 202,359 202,359 216,163 DEED BOOK C0287 PG-F0019 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1024,869 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 202,358 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2019 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 202,358 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 165,892 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 537,325 TO M 180,083 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-31.100 ************** SR 82 151.-1-31.100 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 181,899 181,899 181,899 Hamm Mary Jean Hudson 100600 265,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 224,197 29 Hamm Rd ACRES 97.70 406,096 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 224,197 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0693008 NRTH-1214816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 224,197 DEED BOOK C501 PG-F2197 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 224,197 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 580,137 181,899 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-5 ******************* 1094 CR 19 192.-1-5 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 81,751 81,751 0 Hammerschmitt Helen Germantown 103602 33,300 AGED - ALL 41800 15,973 15,973 56,848 1094 County Route 19 ACRES 0.77 113,696 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682607 NRTH-1184417 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 15,972 DEED BOOK 0570 PG-00750 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 15,972 FULL MARKET VALUE 162,423 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,578 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 113,696 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-36 ***************** 63 Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-36 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hanaman Harold M Pine Plains 134201 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,896 63 Parker Rd Pb16pg1966 157,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,896 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.60 BANKH110045 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,336 EAST-0682074 NRTH-1175887 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,896 TO M DEED BOOK 527 PG-2277 FULL MARKET VALUE 225,566 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 143 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-25 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-25 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 33,456 Hansen Joyce Pine Plains 134201 33,456 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 33,456 39 Lakeview Dr Twin Lakes 33,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 33,456 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 33,456 TO M BANK0180200 EAST-0682860 NRTH-1178048 DEED BOOK C0336 PG-F1934 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,794 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-26 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-26 260 Seasonal res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hansen Joyce Pine Plains 134201 36,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,192 39 Lakeview Dr Twin Lakes 115,192 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,192 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 150.22 DPTH 65.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 88,632 BANK0180200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,192 TO M EAST-0682950 NRTH-1177998 DEED BOOK C0336 PG-F1934 FULL MARKET VALUE 164,560 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-32 **************** 27 Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-32 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 10,894 10,894 0 Hapeman Elizabeth Pine Plains 134201 46,500 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hapeman Ronald Bk22 Pg1602 72,624 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,730 PO Box 115 ACRES 0.75 BANKC030982 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,730 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682680 NRTH-1177898 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,064 DEED BOOK C0367 PG-F0627 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,624 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 103,749 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-39 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-39 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hapeman William R Hudson 100600 48,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 189,720 PO Box 146 ACRES 2.30 BANKC070180 189,720 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 189,720 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688493 NRTH-1206968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,160 DEED BOOK C404 PG-F2231 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 189,720 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 271,029 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 189,720 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-20.100 ************** Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-20.100 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 226,738 226,738 226,738 Harkins Calvin Germantown 103602 281,400 AGED - ALL 41800 95,119 95,119 95,119 Harkins Richard Micro 6328 416,976 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 106 Scuderhook Rd ACRES 81.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 95,119 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0689674 NRTH-1196351 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 95,119 DEED BOOK 577 PG-1276 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,849 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 595,680 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,238 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 226,738 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 144 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-62 ****************** Scuderhook Rd., Lot 5 171.-1-62 322 Rural vac>10 AG DISTRIC 41720 184,384 184,384 184,384 Harkins Charles Germantown 103602 235,008 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,624 Harkins Gloria ACRES 47.60 235,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,624 51 Concord Dr EAST-0691165 NRTH-1198418 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,624 Mahopac, NY 10541 DEED BOOK 0536 PG-00432 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,624 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 335,726 184,384 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-58 ****************** Scuderhook Rd., Par. 1 171.-1-58 230 3 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 258,536 Harkins Edward Jr Germantown 103602 55,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 258,536 Harkins Helen ACRES 3.00 BANKH110045 258,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 258,536 PO Box 206 EAST-0689421 NRTH-1197650 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 258,536 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0543 PG-01101 FULL MARKET VALUE 369,337 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-60.12 *************** Scuderhook Rd., Lot 3 171.-1-60.12 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 68,300 Harkins Edward Jr Germantown 103602 68,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 68,300 PO Box 206 ACRES 25.17 68,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 68,300 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688765 NRTH-1198269 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 68,300 TO M DEED BOOK 630 PG-1167 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-59 ****************** Scuderhook Rd., Lot 2 171.-1-59 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 Harkins Helen Germantown 103602 40,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 PO Box 206 ACRES 5.00 40,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688971 NRTH-1197749 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,800 TO M DEED BOOK 0553 PG-00046 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-20.200 ************** Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-20.200 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Harkins Richard Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,600 Star Rte Box 185 Micro 93-55 64,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,600 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,040 EAST-0702082 NRTH-1197175 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 64,600 TO M DEED BOOK 00723 PG-00059 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 145 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-7 ******************* CR 10 160.-1-7 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Harp David L Jr Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 103,224 PO Box 133 ACRES 1.00 103,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 103,224 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0682992 NRTH-1207527 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 76,664 DEED BOOK 635 PG-801 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 103,224 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 147,463 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-10 ****************** C R 10 160.-1-10 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 Harp David L Jr Hudson 100600 48,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 PO Box 133 ACRES 3.10 131,376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,376 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0682702 NRTH-1207476 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 131,376 TO M DEED BOOK 635 PG-798 FULL MARKET VALUE 187,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-8 ******************* CR 10 160.-1-8 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,904 Harp Judy M Hudson 100600 35,904 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,904 Cr 10 FRNT 70.00 DPTH 319.00 35,904 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,904 PO Box 133 EAST-0682972 NRTH-1207757 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,904 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 643 PG-808 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,291 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-21 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-21 483 Converted Re BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Harris Fred D Hudson 100600 15,405 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 84,048 Harris-Alford Madeline FRNT 65.00 DPTH 70.00 84,048 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 84,048 PO Box 75 EAST-0687775 NRTH-1206236 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,488 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 573 PG-1074 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 84,048 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 120,069 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 84,048 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-26 ***************** Summerside Ave 201.8-3-26 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,536 Harrison Carrie Lee Pine Plains 134201 32,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,536 Harrison Ricky Bk10 Pg786 0002 122,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,536 345 E. Kerley Corners Rd FRNT 53.82 DPTH 135.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,536 TO M Tivoli, NY 12583 BANK0130715 EAST-0683827 NRTH-1173990 DEED BOOK 437 PG-716 FULL MARKET VALUE 175,051 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 146 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-2 ******************* 355 CR 19 171.-1-2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hasbrouck Michael Germantown 103602 25,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 98,192 Hasbrouck Melissa FRNT 105.00 DPTH 180.00 98,192 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 98,192 355 County Rte 19 EAST-0686824 NRTH-1201225 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 71,632 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 586 PG-2395 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 98,192 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 140,274 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-17 ***************** 43 Pine Rd 201.2-1-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hasbrouck Richard Pine Plains 134201 45,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,480 Balducci Alfred Bruckert 126,480 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,480 43 Pine Rd ACRES 1.70 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,920 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681512 NRTH-1176726 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 126,480 TO M DEED BOOK 0497 PG-00968 FULL MARKET VALUE 180,686 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-52.111 ************** 1608 CR 31 170.-1-52.111 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hayes Edward Red Hook 134801 57,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 218,688 Hayes Cheryl Micro-11107 218,688 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 218,688 1608 Blue Hill Rd ACRES 2.72 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 192,128 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676917 NRTH-1195016 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,688 TO M DEED BOOK C524 PG-F1144 FULL MARKET VALUE 312,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-66 ****************** CR 10 138.-1-66 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,500 Healy Josephine Germantown 103602 48,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,500 Healy James ACRES 1.30 157,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 157,500 64-80 82nd Pl EAST-0668513 NRTH-1217898 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,500 TO M Middle Village, NY 11379 DEED BOOK 550 PG-2253 FULL MARKET VALUE 225,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-12 ***************** 7 Major Rd 201.8-2-12 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Hedges Arthur Pine Plains 134201 29,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hedges Gina Reilly Twin Lake 145,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 128,435 8 Major Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 128,435 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 0.20 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,440 EAST-0682898 NRTH-1173669 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,000 TO M DEED BOOK 581 PG-990 FULL MARKET VALUE 207,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 147 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-24 ****************** 322 Orchard Rd 151.-1-24 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hedin Irene Hudson 100600 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,016 322 Orchard Rd ACRES 3.00 164,016 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,016 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688465 NRTH-1216297 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,746 DEED BOOK 0536 PG-00018 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,016 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 234,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-36 ****************** 1297 CR 19 192.-1-36 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 80,444 80,444 80,444 Hedin Robert E Pine Plains 134201 58,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hedin Christine K ACRES 6.00 160,888 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,444 1297 Rte 19 EAST-0682767 NRTH-1179318 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,444 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0267 PG-00011 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 30,174 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,840 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,888 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-26 ****************** 25 Feller Rd 161.-1-26 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Heffernan Michael A Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 Morse Matthew L ACRES 1.00 81,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 25 Feller Rd EAST-0697823 NRTH-1206976 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,040 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0285 PG-F1178 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,600 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 116,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-78 ****************** Scuderhook Rd Lot 4 171.-1-78 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Heins Harry B Germantown 103602 48,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 271,728 Heins Marion Micro 10694 271,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 271,728 238 Scudderhook Rd ACRES 3.09 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 245,168 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692281 NRTH-1197756 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 271,728 TO M DEED BOOK 674 PG-39 FULL MARKET VALUE 388,183 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-84 ****************** Scudderhook Rd 171.-1-84 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Heins Marion Germantown 103602 54,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 238 Scudderhook Rd ACRES 2.00 54,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692031 NRTH-1197515 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,672 TO M DEED BOOK C349 PG-F2016 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,103 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 148 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-12 ****************** LOT 24 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Heleotis Harry Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 199,648 116 Waltermire Rd Micro 94-118 & 95-283 199,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 199,648 Ghent, NY 12075 ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,088 EAST-0685581 NRTH-1203042 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 199,648 TO M PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 DEED BOOK 655 PG-467 DeVito Orazio FULL MARKET VALUE 285,211 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-65 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-65 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,320 Heleotis Harry E Hudson 100600 33,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,320 116 Waltermire Rd Micro 1088 135,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,320 Ghent, NY 12075 FRNT 106.22 DPTH 339.27 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,320 TO M BANK0190462 EAST-0687167 NRTH-1205205 DEED BOOK 544 PG-534 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-48 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-48 210 1 Family Res CW_15_VET/ 41162 8,282 0 0 Herberg Robert P Pine Plains 134201 38,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Herberg Judith M Micro 12179 280,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 271,918 706 Couty Route 2 ACRES 2.58 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 280,200 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683000 NRTH-1172479 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 253,640 DEED BOOK C346 PG-F518 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 280,200 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 400,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-62 ****************** 106 OLD SR 82 151.-1-62 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 Hermance Betty Hudson 100600 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 McCrady Diane ACRES 2.00 133,144 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 133,144 106 OLD RT 82 EAST-0697117 NRTH-1210164 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 133,144 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 644 PG-1645 FULL MARKET VALUE 190,206 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-26 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-26 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hermance John D Pine Plains 134201 43,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 76,432 54 Parker Rd ACRES 2.40 76,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 76,432 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681713 NRTH-1176136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,872 DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F2286 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 76,432 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 109,189 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 149 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-59 ***************** 18 Loyola Rd 201.8-1-59 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hermance Lynn Pine Plains 134201 43,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 182,528 Hermance Sean Reilly Twin Lake 182,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 182,528 18 Loyola Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,968 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 0.45 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 182,528 TO M EAST-0682987 NRTH-1173959 DEED BOOK 551 PG-2341 FULL MARKET VALUE 260,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-17.200 ************** 670 C R 31 150.-1-17.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hermance Scott D Germantown 103602 38,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,696 670 County Rte 31 Micro 9462 164,696 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,696 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.37 BANKC080007 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,136 EAST-0676406 NRTH-1215934 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,696 TO M DEED BOOK C417 PG-F885 FULL MARKET VALUE 235,280 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-32 ****************** 9 Proper Rd 140.-1-32 210 1 Family Res CW_15_VET/ 41162 8,282 0 0 Hermance William H Hudson 100600 35,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hermance Betty M ACRES 0.80 92,752 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 84,470 9 Proper Rd EAST-0692603 NRTH-1217475 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,752 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 603 PG-2387 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,192 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,503 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,752 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-21.11 *************** Schnieder Rd 161.-1-21.11 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 393,433 393,433 393,433 Hidden Meadow Farms Llc Hudson 100600 529,992 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,559 5 Anne Pl ACRES 133.83 529,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,559 Valhalla, NY 10595 EAST-0694994 NRTH-1206360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,559 DEED BOOK 527 PG-509 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,559 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 757,131 393,433 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-12 ***************** Betty Rd 201.8-1-12 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,280 Hinton Henry Pine Plains 134201 26,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,280 Hinton Mary Reilly Twin Lake 82,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,280 28 Linmouth Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,280 TO M Malverne, NY 11565 EAST-0682886 NRTH-1174488 DEED BOOK 0468 PG-00518 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,543 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 150 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-14 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-14 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Hinton Mary E Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Hinton Henry Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 28 Linsmouth Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M Malverne, NY 11565 EAST-0682847 NRTH-1174418 DEED BOOK 0518 PG-00106 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-27 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-27 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,280 Hinton Mary E Pine Plains 134201 39,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,280 Hinton Henry Reilly Twin Lake 116,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,280 28 Linmouth Rd ACRES 0.25 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,280 TO M Malverne, NY 11565 EAST-0682787 NRTH-1174218 DEED BOOK 0524 PG-00675 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,114 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-78 ****************** 381 CR 10 149.-1-78 240 Rural res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Hitt Mary Ann McKee Germantown 103602 95,800 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 381 CR 10 Stop 4 Trust for David & Anna Mc 206,720 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 190,155 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 20.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 190,155 EAST-0671223 NRTH-1212594 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 156,450 DEED BOOK 645 PG-137 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 206,720 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 295,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-52 ****************** 710 CR 10 150.-1-52 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hochsteler Kirk Germantown 103602 47,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 275,000 Kenny Matthew ACRES 2.66 BANKC130220 275,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 275,000 710 County Route 10 EAST-0679787 NRTH-1210151 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 248,440 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 608 PG-1101 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 275,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 392,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-68 ***************** Loyola Rd Lot 69 201.2-1-68 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoeffer Paul Pine Plains 134201 26,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,264 Hoeffer Diane Bk 18 Pg1374 122,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,264 76 Loyola Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 95,704 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC070170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,264 TO M EAST-0682176 NRTH-1174797 DEED BOOK 0642 PG-00134 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,663 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 151 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-1.120 *************** Pleasant Vale Road Lot 1, 201.-1-1.120 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,392 Hoffman Pine Plains 134201 40,392 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,392 Hoffman O'shaughnessy ACRES 4.50 40,392 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,392 357 Pleasantvale Rd EAST-0678652 NRTH-1177010 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,392 TO M Tivoli, NY 12583 DEED BOOK 0554 PG-00927 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,703 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-5 ******************* Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-5 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,768 Hoffman Pine Plains 134201 1,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,768 Hoffman O'shaughnessy ACRES 1.00 1,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,768 357 Pleasantvale Rd EAST-0678832 NRTH-1176890 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,768 TO M Tivoli, NY 12583 DEED BOOK 0564 PG-00573 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-7 ******************* Proper Rd 151.-1-7 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoffman Charles Hudson 100600 24,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,248 38 Proper Rd FRNT 120.00 DPTH 155.00 43,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,248 Hudson, NY 12534-4625 EAST-0693244 NRTH-1216956 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,688 DEED BOOK C0291 PG-F2149 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,248 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 61,783 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-25 ****************** 202 Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoffman Dan Germantown 103602 48,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 231,472 202 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 3.00 BANKH080005 231,472 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 231,472 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681169 NRTH-1214683 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 204,912 DEED BOOK C0360 PG-F2179 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 231,472 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 330,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-1.200 *************** LOT 2 Off Hapeman Rd 201.-1-1.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoffman Martin Pine Plains 134201 50,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 O'shaughnessy Jane ACRES 2.50 123,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 123,896 357 Pleasantvale Rd EAST-0679151 NRTH-1177621 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 97,336 Tivoli, NY 12583 DEED BOOK 0544 PG-00095 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 123,896 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 176,994 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 152 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-34.2 **************** Ten Broeck Rd 151.-1-34.2 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Hoffman Michael L Hudson 100600 46,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoffman Kristine M ACRES 2.12 190,225 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 173,660 31 Old Rte 82 EAST-0735609 NRTH-0546614 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 173,660 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C502 PG-F882 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,665 FULL MARKET VALUE 271,750 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,225 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-34.1 **************** Ten Broeck Rd 151.-1-34.1 280 Multiple res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hoffman Robert Hudson 100600 55,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 113,968 Hoffman Russelita ACRES 5.06 113,968 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 113,968 31 Old Rte 82 EAST-0735399 NRTH-0546584 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 63,698 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0444 PG-00222 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 113,968 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 162,811 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-28 ****************** 80 Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-28 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoffman Susan D Germantown 103602 40,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,672 80 Walkers Mill Rd Micro 3687 105,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,672 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 1.50 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 79,112 EAST-0674985 NRTH-1206251 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,672 TO M DEED BOOK 0577 PG-01062 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,960 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-44 ****************** 1021 CR 19 181.-1-44 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hogg Mark S Germantown 103602 32,964 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,184 Hogg Debra A FRNT 70.00 DPTH 417.75 135,184 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,184 1021 Co Rte 19 BANKC010090 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,624 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682924 NRTH-1186128 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,184 TO M DEED BOOK C458 PG-F686 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,120 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-41.200 ************** 1915 C R 8 181.-1-41.200 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Hoggan Donald Germantown 103602 21,143 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hogan Linda M ACRES 0.28 BANKC138780 160,888 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 144,323 1915 Rte 8 EAST-0684680 NRTH-1187881 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 144,323 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C383 PG-F1872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 134,328 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,840 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,888 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 153 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-59.120 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-59.120 210 1 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 29,832 29,832 29,832 Holden Betsy Germantown 103602 65,700 AGED C 41802 45,722 0 0 Holden Glasgow Na Micro 12078 182,240 AGED T&S 41806 0 22,861 22,861 28 Hoffman St ACRES 8.10 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Chatham, NY 12037 EAST-0690971 NRTH-1203138 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 106,686 DEED BOOK C472 PG-F770 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,547 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 260,343 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 79,277 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 152,408 TO M 29,832 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-29 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-29 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Holland William M Hudson 100600 35,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 75,752 100 County Route 19 ACRES 0.75 75,752 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 75,752 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0687924 NRTH-1206617 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,192 DEED BOOK 588 PG-1363 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 75,752 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 108,217 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 75,752 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-3 ******************* 323 Orchard Rd 151.-1-3 270 Mfg housing AGED C 41802 2,672 0 0 Holness Ernest Hudson 100600 29,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Holness Gladys FRNT 116.82 DPTH 243.26 53,448 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,776 323 Orchard Rd EAST-0688635 NRTH-1216557 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,448 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00824 PG-00032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,178 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,354 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,448 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-23 ****************** 213 Orchard Rd 140.-1-23 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Holness Raphael Hudson 100600 31,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 184,824 Holness Alda FRNT 200.00 DPTH 150.00 184,824 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 184,824 213 Orchard Rd EAST-0687601 NRTH-1218405 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 158,264 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0500 PG-00240 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 184,824 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 264,034 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-28 ***************** Shore Dr. Lts. 42-43 201.8-2-28 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 Holt Evelyn Pine Plains 134201 47,736 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 26 Stoutenburgh Dr Pb 18 Pg 1374 47,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,736 Hyde Park, NY 12538 FRNT 101.97 DPTH 145.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,736 TO M EAST-0683028 NRTH-1173659 DEED BOOK 00721 PG-00022 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,194 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 154 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-60 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 29 201.8-2-60 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,936 Holt Evelyn Pine Plains 134201 28,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,936 26 Stoutenburgh Dr Pb 18 Pg 1374 125,936 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 125,936 Hyde Park, NY 12538 FRNT 51.00 DPTH 170.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,936 TO M EAST-0683368 NRTH-1173619 DEED BOOK 0607 PG-00509 FULL MARKET VALUE 179,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-83 ****************** 401 CR 10 149.-1-83 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Homeyer John Germantown 103602 46,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,696 Homeyer Denise ACRES 2.52 BANK0010090 147,696 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,696 401 County Rt 10 EAST-0673012 NRTH-1212817 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,136 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0304 PG-F2219 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,696 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 210,994 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-4 ******************* CR 31 170.-1-4 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 7,888 Hooten Alfred Red Hook 134801 7,888 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 7,888 Engelfried Donna FRNT 61.13 DPTH 208.71 7,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 7,888 1515 Blue Hill Rd EAST-0676983 NRTH-1197236 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 7,888 TO M Germantown Nyy, 12526 DEED BOOK C454 PG-F1087 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,269 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-5 ******************* CR 31 170.-1-5 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hooten Alfred Red Hook 134801 27,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,984 Engelfried Donna FRNT 147.58 DPTH 147.58 124,984 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,984 1515 Blue Hill Rd EAST-0676872 NRTH-1197296 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 98,424 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C454 PG-F1087 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,984 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 178,549 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-9 ******************* Klibar Rd 150.-1-9 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 104,596 104,596 104,596 Hopedale Farm LLC Germantown 103602 108,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,204 82 Klibar Rd ACRES 21.23 108,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,204 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0678287 NRTH-1215577 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,204 DEED BOOK 654 PG-1558 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,204 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 155,429 104,596 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 155 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-17.110 ************** CR 31 150.-1-17.110 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,624 Hopedale Farm LLC Germantown 103602 49,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,624 82 Klibar Rd ACRES 3.37 174,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 174,624 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0676427 NRTH-1215564 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,624 TO M DEED BOOK 654 PG-1562 FULL MARKET VALUE 249,463 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-34.110 ************** CR 10 150.-1-34.110 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 357,181 357,181 357,181 Hopedale Farm LLC Germantown 103602 451,248 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 94,067 82 Klibar Rd ACRES 122.72 451,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 94,067 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0678371 NRTH-1213578 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,067 DEED BOOK 654 PG-1567 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 94,067 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 644,640 357,181 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-15.100 ************ 148B Highland Ave 192.20-2-15.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,592 Horton Brendan E Pine Plains 134201 30,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,592 72 Highland Ave FRNT 49.21 DPTH 123.88 67,592 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 67,592 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683934 NRTH-1178270 AG004 AG DIST#4 67,592 TO M DEED BOOK C511 PG-F486 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 67,592 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 96,560 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-35.100 ************** 528 White Birch Rd 138.-1-35.100 270 Mfg housing AGED - ALL 41800 67,048 67,048 67,048 Hotaling Kenneth M Germantown 103602 115,876 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 514 White Birch Rd Life Estate Deloris Sweet 134,096 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,048 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 54.10 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,048 EAST-0671960 NRTH-1219185 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,778 DEED BOOK 649 PG-209 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 134,096 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 191,566 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-11 ****************** 528 White Birch Rd 138.-1-11 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hotaling Patricia Ann Germantown 103602 43,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 139,600 528 White Birch Rd ACRES 1.30 139,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 139,600 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671238 NRTH-1220253 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,330 DEED BOOK 0526 PG-00121 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 139,600 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 199,429 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 156 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-48 ****************** Sr 82 151.-1-48 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Howard Timothy J Hudson 100600 19,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 182,512 Howard Jean A Micro 4673 182,512 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 182,512 361 Route 82 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 150.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,952 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696596 NRTH-1210623 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 182,512 TO M DEED BOOK 618 PG-89 FULL MARKET VALUE 260,731 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-6 ***************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-6 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,016 Howay Steven J Pine Plains 134201 33,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,016 Howay Darette E Pb22pg1602 0001 147,016 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 147,016 115 Pine Tree Rd FRNT 56.92 DPTH 142.33 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,016 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0180200 EAST-0682760 NRTH-1177758 DEED BOOK 0578 PG-00522 FULL MARKET VALUE 210,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-44.210 ************** CR 10 150.-1-44.210 220 2 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Howell Mary Germantown 103602 47,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 203,592 490 Co Rt 10 ACRES 2.78 203,592 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 203,592 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675193 NRTH-1212281 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 153,322 DEED BOOK 0555 PG-00256 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 203,592 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 290,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-43 ****************** 6 Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-43 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hoyt Larry Germantown 103602 56,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 145,384 Welch Marie ACRES 5.34 BANKH110081 145,384 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 145,384 6 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0686187 NRTH-1194834 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,824 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0642 PG-00188 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,384 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 207,691 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-9.111 *************** CR 19 170.-2-9.111 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,344 Hoyt Larry L Germantown 103602 58,344 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,344 Welch Marie T Micro 10940 58,344 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,344 6 Deerhaven Rd ACRES 2.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,344 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0686385 NRTH-1195614 DEED BOOK C432 PG-F468 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,349 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 157 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-66.120 ************** CR 10 149.-1-66.120 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,808 Huang Ning Chu Germantown 103602 54,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,808 Huang Keh Lieh ACRES 2.02 54,808 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,808 135 7th Ave EAST-0673332 NRTH-1213088 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,808 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11215 DEED BOOK 572 PG-7136 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-66.200 ************** 404 C R 10 149.-1-66.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,000 Huang Ning Chu Germantown 103602 45,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,000 Huang Keh Lieh ACRES 2.06 136,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,000 135 7th Ave EAST-0673012 NRTH-1213157 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,000 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11215 DEED BOOK 572 PG-7136 FULL MARKET VALUE 194,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-9 ******************* 1000 CR 10 160.-1-9 270 Mfg housing AGED C 41802 14,402 0 0 Hughes Audrey B Hudson 100600 35,000 AGED T&S 41806 0 7,201 7,201 Attn: Fletcher Lavina R ACRES 1.00 48,008 EN STAR 41834 0 0 40,807 1000 Co Rte 10 EAST-0682863 NRTH-1207247 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 33,606 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0297 PG-F0364 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,807 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,583 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,008 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-12 ****************** 2361 Sparrow Bush Rd 170.-1-12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hughes Guy Red Hook 134801 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,712 Nooney Tara ACRES 1.00 107,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,712 2361 Sparrow Bush Rd EAST-0680464 NRTH-1196253 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,152 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 645 PG-1207 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,712 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 153,874 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-44.200 ************** C R 19 171.-1-44.200 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hughes Willard Germantown 103602 33,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 83,232 Hughes Cindy FRNT 215.20 DPTH 150.00 83,232 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 83,232 Box 124 EAST-0685927 NRTH-1194628 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,672 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0571 PG-00480 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 83,232 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 118,903 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-49 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-49 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 22,848 Hull Barbara Germantown 103602 22,848 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 22,848 223 Hull Rd ACRES 0.23 22,848 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,848 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685922 NRTH-1187224 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 22,848 TO M DEED BOOK 0578 PG-01063 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,640 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 158 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-51 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-51 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 8,160 Hull Barbara Germantown 103602 8,160 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 8,160 223 Hull Rd ACRES 3.00 8,160 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,160 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685533 NRTH-1186773 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 8,160 TO M DEED BOOK 0534 PG-00485 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-50 ****************** 1973 CR 8 181.-1-50 271 Mfg housings BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hull Jay C Germantown 103602 52,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 76,024 1973 Co Rte 8 ACRES 4.10 76,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 76,024 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685662 NRTH-1187153 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,464 DEED BOOK C0292 PG-F2166 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 76,024 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 108,606 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-41.120 ************** CR 2 201.-1-41.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Hung Ming-Hsien Pine Plains 134201 42,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 201,552 Chen Su-Chaun Micro 12147 201,552 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 201,552 561 E Kerley Corners Rd ACRES 2.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 174,992 Tivoli, NY 12583 EAST-0681093 NRTH-1171185 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 201,552 TO M DEED BOOK C405 PG-F2189 FULL MARKET VALUE 287,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-23 ***************** Summerside Ave 201.8-3-23 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,624 Iannolino Michael Pine Plains 134201 11,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,624 53 Jasper St Bk10 Pg786 72,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,624 Staten Island, NY 10314 FRNT 30.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,624 TO M EAST-0683857 NRTH-1174150 DEED BOOK 0611 PG-00801 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,749 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-15 ****************** 250 Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-15 230 3 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 111,860 111,860 111,860 Ingham Robert Copake-Taconic 102801 47,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Ingham Mary Ann ACRES 2.20 BANK0080490 223,720 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,860 250 Bells Pond Rd EAST-0699482 NRTH-1217539 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,860 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0508 PG-00556 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,590 FULL MARKET VALUE 319,600 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 223,720 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 159 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-2 ******************* White Birch Rd 139.-1-2 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 Inman Charles E Hudson 100600 54,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 Inman Cynthia P ACRES 20.00 54,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 PO Box 397 EAST-0676149 NRTH-1225023 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,400 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0419 PG-00123 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-87 ****************** Schneider Rd Lot 3 161.-1-87 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 270,100 Iorfida Ferdinando Hudson 100600 59,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 270,100 Iorfida Carmelo Micro 10692 270,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 270,100 21-26 74th St ACRES 5.32 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 270,100 TO M Flushing, NY 11370 EAST-0694280 NRTH-1208439 DEED BOOK C0498 PG-F1873 FULL MARKET VALUE 385,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-42.200 ************** 2639 SR 9 160.-1-42.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Isherwood Jon Hudson 100600 47,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 218,200 Isherwood Helen Micro 97-57 218,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 218,200 2639 Rte 9 ACRES 2.24 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 191,640 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0684080 NRTH-1202078 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,200 TO M DEED BOOK C0296 PG-F1817 FULL MARKET VALUE 311,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-14.1 **************** Sr 82 161.-1-14.1 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,100 J L Mcnamee Ltd Hudson 100600 40,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,100 PO Box H ACRES 2.50 40,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,100 Claverack, NY 12513 EAST-0697100 NRTH-0120780 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,100 TO M DEED BOOK C509 PG-F966 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-14.2 **************** Sr 82 161.-1-14.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,700 J L Mcnamee Ltd Hudson 100600 38,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,700 PO Box H ACRES 2.10 38,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,700 Claverack, NY 12513 EAST-0697290 NRTH-0120780 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,700 TO M DEED BOOK C509 PG-F966 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 160 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-62 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-62 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 22,848 Jackson Carrol Germantown 103602 22,848 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 22,848 Jackson Esther Carpentier 22,848 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,848 37 Margaret Dr FRNT 70.00 DPTH 145.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 22,848 TO M Coram, NY 11727 EAST-0677192 NRTH-1217985 DEED BOOK 0525 PG-00112 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-58 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-58 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jackson Robert Germantown 103602 77,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 258,672 Corke Frederick ACRES 11.56 258,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 258,672 PO Box 117 EAST-0668319 NRTH-1214568 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 232,112 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0526 PG-00176 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 258,672 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 369,531 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-61 ****************** 1091 CR 10 160.-1-61 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jacque Thomas N Hudson 100600 50,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 195,000 Jacque Claire A Micro05-126 195,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 195,000 1091 Route 10 ACRES 14.42 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 168,440 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0683430 NRTH-0120860 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 195,000 TO M DEED BOOK 583 PG-2035 FULL MARKET VALUE 278,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-55 ****************** 3031 US 9 151.-1-55 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Jahns Dorothy Hudson 100600 47,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 3031 Rte 9 ACRES 1.52 172,856 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 156,291 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688937 NRTH-1210128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 156,291 DEED BOOK 00683 PG-00267 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 146,296 FULL MARKET VALUE 246,937 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,856 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-54 ****************** US 9 151.-1-54 112 Dairy farm AG 10 YEAR 41700 10,000 10,000 10,000 Jahns Maple Hill Farm Llc Hudson 100600 397,000 AG 10 YEAR 41700 67,350 67,350 67,350 3031 Rte 9 ACRES 133.00 804,742 AG DISTRIC 41720 328,754 328,754 328,754 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0687735 NRTH-1211386 BUSIN8/97 47610 25,252 25,252 25,252 DEED BOOK C0306 PG-F0684 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 373,386 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1149,631 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 373,386 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 373,386 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 475,988 TO M 328,754 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 161 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-44 ****************** 2110 SR 9 170.-1-44 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jahoda Thomas Red Hook 134801 50,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 166,600 2110 Us Rt 9 ACRES 3.50 BANKC010015 166,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 166,600 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676630 NRTH-1193375 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 140,040 DEED BOOK C0504 PG-F2299 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 166,600 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 238,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-41 ****************** Sr 9 160.-1-41 210 1 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 53,138 53,138 53,138 Jankovich Katherine Hudson 100600 222,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 383,286 Jankovich Mary Kristina ACRES 77.70 436,424 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 383,286 & Jan EAST-0683708 NRTH-1204788 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 383,286 163 Stone Henge Terr DEED BOOK C0308 PG-F0161 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 383,286 TO M Clark, NJ 07066 FULL MARKET VALUE 623,463 53,138 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-33.120 ************** 65 Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-33.120 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 44,608 44,608 44,608 Jansky Donald Hudson 100600 47,700 EN STAR 41834 0 0 44,608 Jansky Lois Micro 93-78 89,216 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 44,608 65 Willowbrook Rd ACRES 2.80 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 44,608 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0697196 NRTH-1205275 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 DEED BOOK C425 PG-F1883 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 89,216 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 127,451 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-34 ****************** Mountainview Dr 192.-1-34 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jeffreys Maureen Pine Plains 134201 49,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 144,704 76 Mountainview Dr ACRES 3.30 BANK0180200 144,704 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 144,704 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683676 NRTH-1179620 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,144 DEED BOOK 00802 PG-00007 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 144,704 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 206,720 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-12.100 ************** C R 10 149.-1-12.100 220 2 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 282,300 Jensen Ernest J Germantown 103602 144,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 282,300 Jensen Elaine Micro#06-147 282,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 282,300 254 C R 10 ACRES 38.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 282,300 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672140 NRTH-0121650 DEED BOOK 589 PG-1936 FULL MARKET VALUE 403,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 162 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-64 ****************** Twin Dr 171.-1-64 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jimenez Hector Germantown 103602 39,690 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,360 Jimenez Hilda Lynk Subdivision 137,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,360 15 Twin Dr Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 110,800 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.00 BANKC070170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 137,360 TO M EAST-0687185 NRTH-1201105 DEED BOOK 0614 PG-00619 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,229 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-10 ****************** 141 Water St 152.-1-10 210 1 Family Res CLERGY 41400 1,500 1,500 1,500 Johnson Carl D Copake-Taconic 102801 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 113,556 141 Water Street Rd ACRES 2.00 115,056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 113,556 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0699827 NRTH-1214950 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,556 DEED BOOK 0586 PG-01082 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,056 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 164,366 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-29 **************** LOT 123N Fairview Rd 192.20-2-29 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Johnson Ruth A Pine Plains 134201 63,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 202,600 Johnson Donald R Micro 4395 202,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 202,600 22 Fairview Rd FRNT 80.00 DPTH 141.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 176,040 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 202,600 TO M EAST-0683780 NRTH-1177990 DEED BOOK 548 PG-62 FULL MARKET VALUE 289,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-26.100 ************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-26.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jones Karen Germantown 103602 44,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 89,080 Jones Emily Micro 9911 89,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 89,080 PO Box 138 ACRES 1.94 BANKC130015 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 62,520 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0681859 NRTH-1214414 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 89,080 TO M DEED BOOK 598 PG-2248 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,257 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-24 ****************** Water St 152.-1-24 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 242,352 Jones Robert Hudson 100600 42,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 242,352 Jones Christine ACRES 1.20 BANKC080005 242,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 242,352 1 Little Brook Rd EAST-0698913 NRTH-1210118 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 242,352 TO M Rowayton, CT 06853 DEED BOOK 00814 PG-00281 FULL MARKET VALUE 346,217 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 163 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-21 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-21 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jones Sean Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 237,800 Jones Patricia Micro 94-118 237,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 237,800 46 Keil Ct ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 211,240 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686670 NRTH-0120340 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 237,800 TO M DEED BOOK 595 PG-1567 FULL MARKET VALUE 339,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-85 ****************** 190 Lockwood Rd 171.-1-85 116 Other stock AG DISTRIC 41720 148,653 148,653 148,653 Jonis Susan Germantown 103602 217,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bobrowich Barbara A ACRES 106.28 515,984 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 367,331 190 Lockwood Rd EAST-0690816 NRTH-1200383 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 367,331 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0371 PG-F2344 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 340,771 FULL MARKET VALUE 737,120 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 367,331 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 148,653 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-35 ****************** Sr 9 160.-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Joseph James F Hudson 100600 71,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 482,500 152 Madison Ave ACRES 9.70 482,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 482,500 New York, NY 10016 EAST-0685439 NRTH-1204042 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 455,940 DEED BOOK C510 PG-F1663 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 482,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 689,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-22 ****************** 2322 SR 9 170.-2-22 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 53,667 53,667 53,667 Jurkowski Frank Red Hook 134801 73,900 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Jurkowski Mary Wagner 211,480 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,813 2322 Star Rte 9 ACRES 10.50 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,813 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679537 NRTH-1194991 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,543 DEED BOOK 0559 PG-00331 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,813 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 302,114 53,667 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-3.200 *************** Sparrow Bush Rd 170.-1-3.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jurkowski Raymond J Red Hook 134801 48,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 305,700 Jurkowski Laurel A Micro 9251 305,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 305,700 1413 Blue Hill Rd ACRES 2.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 279,140 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676668 NRTH-1199645 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 305,700 TO M DEED BOOK C0347 PG-F1262 FULL MARKET VALUE 436,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 164 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-48 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-48 582 Camping park BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Jva Realty Inc. Germantown 103602 392,354 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 720,800 1947 County Rte 8 ACRES 62.00 720,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 720,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684873 NRTH-1186742 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 694,240 DEED BOOK C0489 PG-F1269 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 720,800 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1029,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-5 ***************** LOT 130N Mountainview Dr 192.20-2-5 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 20,366 20,366 0 Kaelin Stephin J Pine Plains 134201 49,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 53 Highland Ave Micro 4395 81,464 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,098 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 110.00 DPTH 150.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,098 EAST-0683358 NRTH-1178719 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,904 DEED BOOK C353 PG-F1153 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,464 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 116,377 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-21 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-21 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 332,248 Kagan Julia Germantown 103602 37,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 332,248 880 Fifth Ave Apt 19F Micro 7 332,248 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 332,248 New York, NY 10021 ACRES 0.99 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 332,248 TO M EAST-0666319 NRTH-1219784 DEED BOOK C0313 PG-F1210 FULL MARKET VALUE 474,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-16 ****************** Schneider Rd 161.-1-16 534 Social org. COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 71,536 Kalicoontie Rod & Gun Hudson 100600 26,426 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 71,536 Club Micro No 310 & 97-159 71,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 71,536 Box 93 ACRES 23.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 71,536 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0695911 NRTH-1207862 DEED BOOK C0326 PG-F0712 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,194 ******************************************************************************************************* 193.-1-8 ******************* Weaver Rd 193.-1-8 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,352 Kalin Peter Pine Plains 134201 4,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,352 Roman Christopher Micro 00-210 4,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,352 222 E 93Rd St #33G ACRES 1.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,352 TO M New York, NY 10128 EAST-0688957 NRTH-1184500 DEED BOOK C0364 PG-F2092 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,217 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 165 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-27 ***************** 21 Summerside Ave 201.8-3-27 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kane Richard Pine Plains 134201 24,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 114,648 Kane Kathleen Bk10 Pg786 0002 114,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 114,648 21 Summerside Ave FRNT 60.00 DPTH 120.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 88,088 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC030982 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,648 TO M EAST-0683917 NRTH-1174130 DEED BOOK 0605 PG-00861 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,783 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-15 ****************** 2027 Maple Ln 170.-2-15 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kane Vincent E Red Hook 134801 47,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 132,056 120 Maple Ln Micro 4623 132,056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 132,056 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.60 BANKC130170 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,496 EAST-0683227 NRTH-1194668 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 132,056 TO M DEED BOOK C0360 PG-F1955 FULL MARKET VALUE 188,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-36 **************** Private Rd 192.20-3-36 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,400 Kanter Michael Pine Plains 134201 52,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,400 Liu-Kanter Nora Twin Lakes 155,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 155,400 35-25 78th St Apt 33 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 310.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,400 TO M Jackson Heights, NY 11372 EAST-0683031 NRTH-1177439 DEED BOOK 637 PG-468 FULL MARKET VALUE 222,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-45 **************** 7-9 Fairview Rd 192.20-2-45 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 142,300 Kaplan Nancy Pine Plains 134201 31,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 142,300 99 St Johns Pl Lots 110, 126, 127, 14 142,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 142,300 Brooklyn, NY 11217 Micro 95-54 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 142,300 TO M ACRES 0.79 EAST-0683730 NRTH-1177710 DEED BOOK C494 PG-F2127 FULL MARKET VALUE 203,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-16 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 190,400 Kaplan Richard Germantown 103602 15,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 190,400 Kaplan Erwina FRNT 80.00 DPTH 100.00 190,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 190,400 565 Broadway 2Nd Fl EAST-0666288 NRTH-1220564 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,400 TO M New York, NY 10012 DEED BOOK 0616 PG-00045 FULL MARKET VALUE 272,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 166 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-17 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-17 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 537,200 Kaplan Richard Germantown 103602 84,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 537,200 Kaplan Erwina ACRES 16.80 537,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 537,200 565 Broadway 2Nd Fl EAST-0666228 NRTH-1220393 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 537,200 TO M New York, NY 10012 DEED BOOK 0616 PG-00045 FULL MARKET VALUE 767,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-67 ****************** 182 Water St 161.-1-67 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kargacos Charles Hudson 100600 31,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 83,096 182 Old Rte 82 Db736-Pg237 83,096 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 83,096 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 93-107 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,536 FRNT 300.00 DPTH 106.47 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 83,096 TO M EAST-0698069 NRTH-1209096 DEED BOOK 0573 PG-00514 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,709 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-47 ***************** 26 Honor Rd Lt 125 126 201.8-1-47 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Karich Bren T Pine Plains 134201 33,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 128,520 Slater Ian R Revocable Family Trust 128,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 128,520 26 Reilly Twin Lake SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,960 PO Box 147 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 130.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 128,520 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682308 NRTH-1173617 DEED BOOK 598 PG-2363 FULL MARKET VALUE 183,600 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-8 ******************* 311 CR 31 139.-1-8 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Karp Berhnardt Germantown 103602 52,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 228,072 Karp Linda ACRES 3.10 228,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 228,072 311 Route 31 EAST-0680039 NRTH-1224550 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 201,512 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0525 PG-00216 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,072 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 325,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-14.200 ************** CR 31 139.-1-14.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Karp Bernardt Germantown 103602 4,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 311 County Rte 31 ACRES 1.90 4,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680419 NRTH-1224501 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,080 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00021 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,829 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 167 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-14.111 ************** CR 31 139.-1-14.111 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 12,104 Karp Bernhardt Germantown 103602 12,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 12,104 311 County Rte 31 ACRES 5.96 12,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 12,104 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680311 NRTH-1223794 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 12,104 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00018 FULL MARKET VALUE 17,291 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-14.112 ************** CR 31 139.-1-14.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 13,464 Karp Bernhardt Germantown 103602 13,464 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 13,464 311 County Rte 31 ACRES 6.19 13,464 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 13,464 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680290 NRTH-1224191 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 13,464 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00021 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,234 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-14.120 ************** CR 31 139.-1-14.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,400 Karp Bernhardt Germantown 103602 3,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,400 311 County Rte 31 ACRES 1.60 3,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,400 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681690 NRTH-1224204 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,400 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00021 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-69 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-69 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Karp Bernhardt Germantown 103602 4,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 311 County Rte 31 ACRES 5.94 4,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680552 NRTH-1223351 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,080 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00021 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-70 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-70 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Karp Bernhardt Germantown 103602 4,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 311 County Rte 31 ACRES 1.60 4,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681170 NRTH-1224003 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,080 TO M DEED BOOK 00819 PG-00021 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-41 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-41 281 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1015,648 Kathwari Farooq M Germantown 103602 304,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1015,648 Kathwari Farida K ACRES 147.06 1015,648 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1015,648 Pine Cove EAST-0680525 NRTH-1221501 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1015,648 TO M Premium Pt DEED BOOK C0302 PG-F1591 New Rochelle, NY 10801 FULL MARKET VALUE 1450,926 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 168 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-53.110 ************** CR 31 139.-1-53.110 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 Kathwari Farooq M Germantown 103602 87,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 Pine Cove Micro 9372 87,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 Premium Pt ACRES 23.59 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,992 TO M New Rochelle, NY 10801 EAST-0679659 NRTH-1219830 DEED BOOK 0630 PG-00326 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,703 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-57 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-57 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 71,264 Kaufman Marlene G Hudson 100600 29,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 71,264 5801 Rosebury Dr ACRES 0.50 71,264 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 71,264 Dayton, OH 45424 EAST-0687736 NRTH-1205786 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 71,264 TO M DEED BOOK C0361 PG-F0206 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 71,264 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 101,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-16 ****************** 217 Walker Mill Rd 160.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 195,704 Kaufman Michael Germantown 103602 57,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 195,704 Kaufman Sandra ACRES 5.80 BANKH030614 195,704 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 195,704 215 W 92 St- Apt 6d EAST-0676132 NRTH-1208103 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 195,704 TO M New York, NY 10025 DEED BOOK C0335 PG-F2208 FULL MARKET VALUE 279,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-23 ****************** CR 19 181.-1-23 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kaylor Paulette Germantown 103602 38,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,656 1852 CR 8 ACRES 1.36 77,656 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,656 Elizaville, NY 12523-1113 EAST-0683319 NRTH-1188789 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,096 DEED BOOK C540 PG-F422 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 77,656 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 110,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-44 ****************** CR 8 182.-1-44 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,680 Kazukenus John Germantown 103602 51,680 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 51,680 Kazukenus Stefania ACRES 10.00 51,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,680 50 Prescott St Apt 404 EAST-0689514 NRTH-1185981 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 51,680 TO M Colonie, NY 12205-4442 DEED BOOK 0496 PG-00312 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-50 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-50 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,808 Keane Timothy Germantown 103602 31,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,808 Keane Barbara ACRES 0.69 BANKC010070 122,808 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,808 19 Chestnut Ave EAST-0678238 NRTH-1220387 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,808 TO M Pelham, NY 10803 DEED BOOK 00720 PG-00245 FULL MARKET VALUE 175,440 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 169 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-34 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-34 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Keegan Susan Hudson 100600 45,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 193,736 27 Co Rt 19 Micro 2080 193,736 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 193,736 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 167,176 EAST-0688811 NRTH-1208218 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 193,736 TO M DEED BOOK C424 PG-F817 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 193,736 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 276,766 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-12 ****************** 71 Lynk Rd 171.-1-12 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 53,380 0 0 Keeler Elizabeth Germantown 103602 29,300 AGED T&S 41806 0 42,704 42,704 Halloran Debbie FRNT 119.40 DPTH 227.00 106,760 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Santa Harvey EAST-0686087 NRTH-1199933 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,380 71 Lynk Rd DEED BOOK 604 PG-2323 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,056 Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,514 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 13,786 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 106,760 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-36.110 ************** Maple Ln 170.-2-36.110 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 218,960 Keil Albert Red Hook 134801 35,076 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 218,960 28 Maple Ln FRNT 150.00 DPTH 201.29 218,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 218,960 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681216 NRTH-1195124 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,960 TO M DEED BOOK 628 PG-363 FULL MARKET VALUE 312,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-36.200 ************** 28 Maple Ln 170.-2-36.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Keil Albert W Red Hook 134801 55,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 287,100 Keil Dianne Wagner 287,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 287,100 28 Maple Ln ACRES 15.60 BANKC030385 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 260,540 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0680906 NRTH-1195373 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 287,100 TO M DEED BOOK 0582 PG-00690 FULL MARKET VALUE 410,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-18.100 ************** Maple Ln 170.-2-18.100 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 769,352 Keil Equipment Co Inc Red Hook 134801 70,745 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 769,352 2356 Rte 9 Micro 10938 769,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 769,352 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 5.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 769,352 TO M EAST-0680515 NRTH-1195753 DEED BOOK 0364 PG-00482 FULL MARKET VALUE 1099,074 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 170 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-18.200 ************** Maple Ln 170.-2-18.200 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 97,240 Keil Realty Llc Red Hook 134801 17,775 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 97,240 7536 N Broadway Micro 10938 97,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 97,240 Red Hook, NY 12571 FRNT 175.00 DPTH 150.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 97,240 TO M EAST-0680605 NRTH-1196013 DEED BOOK C0291 PG-F1278 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-13.100 ************** Off Klibar Rd 150.-1-13.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,992 Kellenbenz Kenneth W Germantown 103602 44,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,992 Kellenbenz Lorraine M ACRES 1.90 53,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,992 143 County Route 6 EAST-0677878 NRTH-1214967 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,992 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 592 PG-2199 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,131 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-23.112 ************** Klibar Rd 150.-1-23.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kellenbenz Kenneth W Germantown 103602 42,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 280,900 Kellenbenz Tammi S ACRES 1.71 280,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 280,900 78 Klibar Rd EAST-0677538 NRTH-1215016 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 254,340 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C419 PG-F217 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 280,900 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 401,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-54 ****************** CR 31 170.-1-54 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 175,403 175,403 175,403 Kellner Peter Red Hook 134801 251,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 950,133 Mountain Range Farm ACRES 60.06 1125,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 950,133 Farm EAST-0675887 NRTH-1199923 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 950,133 1380 Co Route 31 DEED BOOK 684 PG-270 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 950,133 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 FULL MARKET VALUE 1607,909 175,403 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-6 ****************** Hapeman Rd 201.2-1-6 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 90,984 Kelly Daniel H Pine Plains 134201 32,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 90,984 Kelly Patricia A Bruckert 90,984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 90,984 152 Fernwood Terrace FRNT 113.32 DPTH 220.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 90,984 TO M Stewart Manor, NY 11530 EAST-0681821 NRTH-1177146 DEED BOOK C0312 PG-F1326 FULL MARKET VALUE 129,977 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 171 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-23 **************** Fairview Rd 192.20-2-23 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 Kelly Edward J Pine Plains 134201 36,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 Barbara Kelly Twin Lakes 0001 36,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 7 Salthill Ct FRNT 45.00 DPTH 165.85 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,040 TO M Timonium, MD 21093 EAST-0683549 NRTH-1178270 DEED BOOK 0321 PG-00461 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,486 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-14 ****************** 1055 CR 31 160.-1-14 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 605,880 Kelly James Germantown 103602 193,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 605,880 Kelly Marcia ACRES 70.00 605,880 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 605,880 7 Danson St EAST-0677622 NRTH-1207726 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 605,880 TO M Garden City, NY 11530 DEED BOOK C446 PG-F1109 FULL MARKET VALUE 865,543 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-45 ****************** 42 Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-45 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Kelly Julia A Germantown 103602 49,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 144,432 Kelly Kathlene ACRES 3.30 144,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 144,432 42 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0686467 NRTH-1194554 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,162 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0279 PG-F0385 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 144,432 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 206,331 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-10 ***************** CR 19 201.8-1-10 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,536 Kelly Martha Pine Plains 134201 54,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,536 PO Box 467 Pb18pg1374 54,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,536 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 135.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,536 TO M EAST-0682976 NRTH-1174669 DEED BOOK C352 PG-F1233 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-11 ***************** CR 19 201.8-1-11 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Kelly Martha Pine Plains 134201 47,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,144 4 Betty Rd Pb18pg1374 150,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,144 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 135.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,874 EAST-0683036 NRTH-1174579 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,144 TO M DEED BOOK C352 PG-F1233 FULL MARKET VALUE 214,491 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 172 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-44 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-44 210 1 Family Res AG 10 YEAR 41700 31,000 31,000 31,000 Kemmet Lynndee Germantown 103602 69,200 AG DISTRIC 41720 32,156 32,156 32,156 Ladue Harold ACRES 8.00 BANKH130220 271,592 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 208,436 5248 Route 9G EAST-0668629 NRTH-1219728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 208,436 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C402 PG-F2357 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 208,436 FULL MARKET VALUE 387,989 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 239,436 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 32,156 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-37 ****************** Marty Rd 182.-1-37 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,152 Keneally James Germantown 103602 28,152 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,152 55marty Rd Beach View Hills 28,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,152 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 45.00 DPTH 331.33 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,152 TO M EAST-0690192 NRTH-1187202 DEED BOOK C0305 PG-F1492 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,217 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-39 ****************** SR 9 160.-1-39 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kennedy Joseph Hudson 100600 41,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 196,792 Kennedy Kathleen ACRES 1.60 BANK0080490 196,792 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 196,792 Gray Cottage Farm EAST-0685001 NRTH-1202931 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,232 2709 Route 9 DEED BOOK C0287 PG-F1114 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 196,792 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 281,131 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-55 ****************** Off SR 9 160.-1-55 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,856 Kennedy Joseph Hudson 100600 19,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,856 Kennedy Kathleen ACRES 3.77 BANK0080490 19,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,856 2709 Route 9 EAST-0684250 NRTH-1203580 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,856 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0287 PG-F1114 FULL MARKET VALUE 28,366 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-44 ****************** CR 31 139.-1-44 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 468,744 Kenner Martin Germantown 103602 84,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 468,744 Smith Camilla ACRES 15.40 468,744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 468,744 285 West Broadway Apt 260 EAST-0678046 NRTH-1221067 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 468,744 TO M New York, NY 10013 DEED BOOK C528 PG-F2238 FULL MARKET VALUE 669,634 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 173 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-14 ****************** C R 10 149.-1-14 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,752 Kesting Barry D Germantown 103602 27,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,752 Kesting Brian D FRNT 80.00 DPTH 262.50 92,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,752 221 Traver Rd EAST-0671216 NRTH-1216103 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,752 TO M Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 DEED BOOK 588 PG-2365 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-24 ***************** Shore Dr. Lots 38 & 39 201.8-2-24 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,192 Ketron Harold Pine Plains 134201 47,192 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,192 Ketron Jessie A Twin Lake Realty Subd 47,192 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,192 20 Shore Dr Pb 18 Pg 1374 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,192 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 130.00 EAST-0683268 NRTH-1173789 DEED BOOK C444 PG-F1298 FULL MARKET VALUE 67,417 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-23 ***************** Helen Rd 201.8-2-23 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Ketron Harold R Pine Plains 134201 41,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Ketron Jessie A Twin Lake Realty Subd 41,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 20 Shore Dr Pb18 Pgs 1374 & 1375 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 41,072 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 200.00 EAST-0683158 NRTH-1173809 DEED BOOK C444 PG-F1298 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-26 ***************** Shore Dr Lts 40-41 201.8-2-26 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Ketron Jessie A Pine Plains 134201 39,400 AGED C 41802 101,388 0 0 20 Shore Dr Reilly Twin Lake 230,384 AGED T&S 41806 0 81,110 92,154 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 101.94 DPTH 120.00 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 EAST-0683173 NRTH-1173714 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 101,388 DEED BOOK C444 PG-F1298 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,666 FULL MARKET VALUE 329,120 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,960 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 230,384 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-86 ****************** Schneider Rd Lot 1 161.-1-86 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Keute Darlene Hudson 100600 51,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 249,560 Keute Andrew Micro 10692 249,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 249,560 228 Schneider Rd ACRES 4.52 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 223,000 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0693810 NRTH-1208738 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 249,560 TO M DEED BOOK 587 PG-396 FULL MARKET VALUE 356,514 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 174 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-1.210 *************** Deer Haven Rd Parcel C 182.-1-1.210 270 Mfg housing WAR VET/CT 41121 7,997 7,997 0 Kilmer Arthur Sr Germantown 103602 36,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Box 174 Micro 11467 53,312 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,315 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 1.12 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,315 EAST-0688491 NRTH-1192478 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,752 DEED BOOK C0308 PG-F2326 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,312 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 76,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-19 ****************** 9 Old Manorton Rd 181.-1-19 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kimball David Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,144 Kimball Mary ACRES 1.00 150,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,144 9 Old Manorton Rd EAST-0682256 NRTH-1190006 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 123,584 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0560 PG-00867 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,144 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 214,491 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-52 ****************** Manorton Cnty Rte 19 181.-1-52 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,056 Kimball David Germantown 103602 11,879 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,056 Kimball Mary Micro 93-145 47,056 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,056 9 Old Manorton Rd ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,056 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682296 NRTH-1190236 DEED BOOK 00734 PG-00060 FULL MARKET VALUE 67,223 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-1 ****************** Cold Spring Rd 161.1-1-1 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,800 Kindya Steve Hudson 100600 53,584 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,800 Kindya Jeannette ACRES 3.20 115,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 115,800 42 Marge Ln EAST-0686713 NRTH-1207224 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,800 TO M Calverton, NY 11933 DEED BOOK C509 PG-F713 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-7.110 *************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-7.110 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 55,333 55,333 55,333 King Geoffrey Germantown 103602 140,800 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Box 222 Bk3 Pg287 296,888 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 241,555 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 30.20 BANK0080490 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 241,555 EAST-0682299 NRTH-1214645 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 214,995 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 00595 PG-01108 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 241,555 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 424,126 55,333 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 175 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-35 ****************** 191 CR 10 149.-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Klawson Kevin Germantown 103602 40,495 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 Klawson Margaret ACRES 1.00 120,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 191 County Rte 10 EAST-0670036 NRTH-1216251 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,208 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0301 PG-F1610 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,768 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 172,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-8 ******************* Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-8 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 Klein Kill Fruit Germantown 103602 64,736 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 Farms Corp ACRES 4.60 64,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0681067 NRTH-1215563 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 64,736 TO M DEED BOOK 00795 PG-00113 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,480 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-23.111 ************** CR 31 150.-1-23.111 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 119,814 119,814 119,814 Klein Kill Fruit Germantown 103602 192,700 RPTL483_d 42130 33,764 33,764 33,764 Farms Corp ACRES 43.40 253,752 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,174 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0677049 NRTH-1214325 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,174 DEED BOOK 0328 PG-00401 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 100,174 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 362,503 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 100,174 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 153,578 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-34.200 ************** OFF CR 31 150.-1-34.200 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 63,115 63,115 63,115 Klein Kill Fruit Germantown 103602 66,504 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,389 Farms Corp ACRES 17.71 66,504 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,389 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669526 NRTH-1210960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,389 DEED BOOK 00792 PG-00097 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,389 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 95,006 63,115 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-37 ****************** Private Rd 150.-1-37 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 28,376 28,376 28,376 Klein Kill Fruit Germantown 103602 64,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,824 Farms Corp ACRES 12.00 78,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,824 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675141 NRTH-1213431 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,824 DEED BOOK 00792 PG-00101 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,824 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 111,714 28,376 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 176 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-43 ****************** Private Rd 150.-1-43 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 45,451 45,451 45,451 Klein Kill Fruit Germantown 103602 46,648 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,197 Farms Corp ACRES 9.80 46,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,197 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675162 NRTH-1212791 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,197 DEED BOOK 00792 PG-00105 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,197 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 66,640 45,451 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-57 ****************** C R 10 150.-1-57 449 Warehouse AG DISTRIC 41720 1220,163 1220,163 1220,163 Klein Kill Fruit Germantown 103602 1358,484 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 807,437 Farms Corp ACRES 216.50 2027,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 807,437 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0674147 NRTH-1210429 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 807,437 DEED BOOK 0442 PG-00310 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 807,437 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 2896,571 1220,163 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-60 ****************** CR 10 150.-1-60 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 420,905 420,905 420,905 Klein Kill Fruit Hudson 100600 512,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 415,767 Farms Corp ACRES 164.40 836,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 415,767 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0682318 NRTH-1209646 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 415,767 DEED BOOK 0324 PG-00547 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 415,767 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1195,246 420,905 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-18.100 ************* SR 9 161.1-1-18.100 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,136 Klein Kill Fruit Hudson 100600 51,136 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 51,136 Farms Corp ACRES 1.13 51,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,136 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0687305 NRTH-1206255 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 51,136 TO M DEED BOOK 00792 PG-00109 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 51,136 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 73,051 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-4.100 *************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-4.100 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 500,164 500,164 500,164 Klein Kill Fruit Farm Germantown 103602 543,864 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,700 County Route 10 Micro 10427 543,864 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,700 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 127.21 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,700 EAST-0680696 NRTH-1215972 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,700 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 599 PG-1994 500,164 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 776,949 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 177 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-18 ****************** Schuderhook Rd 171.-1-18 120 Field crops COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 867,952 Klein Mark Germantown 103602 476,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 867,952 Mark Klein Revocable Trust ACRES 192.90 867,952 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 867,952 7607 Tarpon Cove Cir EAST-0693479 NRTH-1198818 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 867,952 TO M Lake Worth, FL 33467 DEED BOOK 649 PG-1348 FULL MARKET VALUE 1239,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-14 ****************** 667 Rt 31 150.-1-14 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kline Donald R Germantown 103602 71,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 219,640 Kline Sharon R ACRES 9.70 219,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 219,640 667 Rte 31 EAST-0677096 NRTH-1216105 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 193,080 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00679 PG-00317 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 219,640 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 313,771 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-34.120 ************** Klibar Rd 150.-1-34.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kline Gregory J Germantown 103602 61,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 250,000 Kline Luanne L Micro 95-13 250,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 250,000 667 Rte 31 ACRES 6.81 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 223,440 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677544 NRTH-1214326 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 250,000 TO M DEED BOOK 00771 PG-00128 FULL MARKET VALUE 357,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-28.110 ************** SR 9 140.-1-28.110 484 1 use sm bld COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 230,384 Kline Pamela Hudson 100600 47,993 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 230,384 PO Box 416 SR 9 & 82 230,384 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 230,384 Claverack, NY 12513 Micro 3648 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 230,384 TO M ACRES 1.11 EAST-0692881 NRTH-1218516 DEED BOOK 0587 PG-00990 FULL MARKET VALUE 329,120 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-67 ****************** Off Ten Broeck Rd 151.-1-67 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 3,578 3,578 3,578 Kline Pamela Hudson 100600 114,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Box 416 Micro 10629 344,488 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 340,910 Claverack, NY 12513 ACRES 26.97 BANKC030217 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 340,910 EAST-0696808 NRTH-1214854 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 314,350 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 00747 PG-00298 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 340,910 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 492,126 3,578 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 178 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-14.112 ************** Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-14.112 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 67,093 67,093 67,093 Kline Pamela B Hudson 100600 179,112 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 112,019 PO Box 416 Micro 95-161&00-133 179,112 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 112,019 Claverack, NY 12513 ACRES 38.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 112,019 EAST-0696849 NRTH-1213864 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 112,019 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 00799 PG-00038 67,093 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 255,874 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-75 ****************** 136 White Birch Rd 139.-1-75 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Klugo Robert Hudson 100600 41,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,488 Klugo Rebecca Micro 97-141 140,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,488 136 White Birch Rd ACRES 2.21 BANKC060975 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,928 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674368 NRTH-1225319 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 140,488 TO M DEED BOOK C0295 PG-F1199 FULL MARKET VALUE 200,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-10.100 ************** 2279 Rte 9 170.-1-10.100 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 259,591 259,591 259,591 Knauss Charles W Jr Red Hook 134801 349,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 168,673 PO Box 193 ACRES 102.80 428,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 168,673 Spencertown, NY 12165 EAST-0677954 NRTH-1196288 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 168,673 DEED BOOK 0586 PG-00247 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 168,673 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 611,806 259,591 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-20 ****************** Stephen Dr 139.-1-20 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Knull Michael Germantown 103602 102,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 246,100 Knull Mary Lou Tom Thumb 246,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 246,100 48 Hill Rd ACRES 7.73 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 219,540 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0678519 NRTH-1224637 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 246,100 TO M DEED BOOK 0653 PG-00207 FULL MARKET VALUE 351,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-30 ****************** CR 8 170.-2-30 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,360 Kohm Robert Red Hook 134801 29,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,360 Kohm Muriel Bk17 Pg1311 69,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,360 57-10 146th St FRNT 195.00 DPTH 132.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 69,360 TO M Flushing, NY 11355 BANKH030950 EAST-0677870 NRTH-1193438 DEED BOOK 0576 PG-00094 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,086 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 179 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-31 ****************** CR 8 170.-2-31 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 93,840 Kohm Robert Red Hook 134801 45,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,840 Kohm Muriel ACRES 2.20 BANKH030950 93,840 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,840 57-10 146th St EAST-0678019 NRTH-1193688 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 93,840 TO M Flushing, NY 11355 DEED BOOK 0576 PG-00090 FULL MARKET VALUE 134,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-3.110 *************** CR 31 160.-1-3.110 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 146,880 Kopec Jolanta Germantown 103602 146,880 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 146,880 Kopec John Micro 00-144 146,880 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 146,880 1023 Route 31 ACRES 44.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,880 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0677630 NRTH-1208886 DEED BOOK C0364 PG-F1450 FULL MARKET VALUE 209,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-3.200 *************** CR 31 160.-1-3.200 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Kopec Jolanta Germantown 103602 64,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kopec John Micro 00-144 296,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 279,435 1023 Route 31 ACRES 8.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 279,435 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676881 NRTH-1208595 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 269,440 DEED BOOK C0364 PG-F1450 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 296,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 422,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-15 **************** Private Rd 192.20-3-15 220 2 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 166,464 Korzekwinski Francis Pine Plains 134201 55,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 166,464 Korzekwinski Lori Ann Micro 3183 166,464 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 166,464 26 N Shore Dr ACRES 0.39 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 166,464 TO M Elizville, NY 12513 EAST-0683241 NRTH-1177509 DEED BOOK 643 PG-2353 FULL MARKET VALUE 237,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-9 ****************** CR 19 201.8-3-9 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 18,088 Korzekwinski Lori Ann Pine Plains 134201 18,088 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 18,088 Lloyd Diane Reilly Twin Lake 18,088 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 18,088 2706 Rowehl Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 110.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 18,088 TO M East Meadow, NY 11554 EAST-0683217 NRTH-1174309 DEED BOOK C406 PG-F1427 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,840 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 180 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-29.100 ************** US 9 140.-1-29.100 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 306,000 Koskey Susan Hudson 100600 113,168 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 306,000 Patzwahl Scott Bk20 Pg1462 306,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 306,000 PO Box 488 ACRES 3.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 306,000 TO M Claverack, NY 12513 EAST-0692531 NRTH-1218335 DEED BOOK C0285 PG-F1483 FULL MARKET VALUE 437,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-41.110 ************** 1989 C R 8 182.-1-41.110 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Kotler Kathleen Germantown 103602 50,400 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Kotler Donald Micro 10303 207,128 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 179,520 1989 Rte 8 ACRES 3.59 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 179,520 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0686102 NRTH-1186984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 156,858 DEED BOOK 536 PG-2068 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 207,128 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 295,897 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-6.100 *************** Water St 141.-1-6.100 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 111,248 111,248 111,248 Koulos Nicholas Copake-Taconic 102801 53,900 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 PO Box 1054 ACRES 4.62 222,496 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,248 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700419 NRTH-1219160 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,248 DEED BOOK C0309 PG-F0728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 60,978 FULL MARKET VALUE 317,851 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 222,496 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-6.200 *************** Water St 141.-1-6.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,552 Koulos Nicholas Copake-Taconic 102801 65,552 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,552 PO Box 1054 ACRES 4.15 65,552 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,552 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700300 NRTH-1218890 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 65,552 TO M DEED BOOK C0309 PG-F0728 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,646 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-20.2 **************** CR 19 201.-1-20.2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 374,500 Kowan Joshua Pine Plains 134201 154,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 374,500 Vogt Christine micro 07-31 374,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 374,500 76 Simpson Rd ACRES 7.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 374,500 TO M Carmel, NY 10512 EAST-0684260 NRTH-0011640 DEED BOOK 606 PG-2236 FULL MARKET VALUE 535,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 181 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-28.120 ************** SR 9 140.-1-28.120 433 Auto body COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 91,528 Krapf Charles Hudson 100600 29,388 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 91,528 592 Taghkanic Rd SR 9 & 82 91,528 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 91,528 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 0.36 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 91,528 TO M EAST-0692880 NRTH-1218658 DEED BOOK 0606 PG-00842 FULL MARKET VALUE 130,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-20.211 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-20.211 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 221,776 Krapf Margaret C Hudson 100600 85,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 221,776 Krapf Herbert J ACRES 13.21 221,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 221,776 360 Vincent Ave EAST-0690686 NRTH-1205732 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 221,776 TO M Lynbrook, NY 11563 DEED BOOK 591 PG-3 FULL MARKET VALUE 316,823 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-7 ******************* CR 19 192.-1-7 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 252,008 Krasilovsky Richard Germantown 103602 112,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 252,008 Attn: Empire Safe Co ACRES 30.95 BANKC061197 252,008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 252,008 6 E 39Th St EAST-0681846 NRTH-1184916 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 252,008 TO M New York, NY 10016 DEED BOOK 0575 PG-00149 FULL MARKET VALUE 360,011 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-88.11 *************** 359 Dales Bridge Rd 149.-1-88.11 240 Rural res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Kreig Guy Germantown 103602 86,300 AGED C 41802 47,246 0 0 Kreig Wanda Micro05-187 185,096 AGED T&S 41806 0 15,749 18,510 359 Dales Bridge Rd ACRES 19.79 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670593 NRTH-1210073 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,242 DEED BOOK 0553 PG-00978 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 141,739 FULL MARKET VALUE 264,423 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,316 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,096 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-94.200 ************** 279 Wire Rd 149.-1-94.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kreig Peter Germantown 103602 65,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 180,336 279 Wire Rd ACRES 8.02 180,336 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 180,336 Germantown, NY 12526-5214 EAST-0671929 NRTH-1209405 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 153,776 DEED BOOK 00687 PG-00050 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 180,336 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 257,623 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 182 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-88.12 *************** 371 Dales Bridge Rd 149.-1-88.12 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,000 Kreig Richard Germantown 103602 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,000 Kreig Teresa Micro05-187 197,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 197,000 371 Dales Bridge Rd ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,000 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670740 NRTH-1210750 DEED BOOK 608 PG-391 FULL MARKET VALUE 281,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-88.200 ************** 337 Dales Bridge Rd Lot 1 149.-1-88.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,000 Kreig Richard Germantown 103602 43,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,000 371 Dales Bridge Rd ACRES 5.00 43,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,000 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670168 NRTH-1209952 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,000 TO M DEED BOOK 0611 PG-00692 FULL MARKET VALUE 61,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-18 **************** Mountainview Dr. Lts 90-9 192.20-1-18 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 49,500 Kreig Tyson Pine Plains 134201 49,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 49,500 973 River Rd Bk22 Pg1602 0001 49,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 49,500 Red Hook, NY 12571 FRNT 110.00 DPTH 117.16 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 49,500 TO M ACRES 0.58 EAST-0683239 NRTH-1178129 DEED BOOK 611 PG-1598 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-14 ****************** 2311 SR 9 170.-1-14 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 339,592 Kreig Tyson M Red Hook 134801 57,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 339,592 973 River Rd ACRES 2.60 339,592 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 339,592 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0679126 NRTH-1195560 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 339,592 TO M DEED BOOK 644 PG-1656 FULL MARKET VALUE 485,131 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-69 ***************** 193 CR 19 161.1-1-69 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Krein Craig P Hudson 100600 49,100 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Krein Frank ACRES 3.20 BANKC060975 148,920 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 121,312 193 Rte 19 EAST-0686657 NRTH-1204994 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,312 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0665 PG-00226 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,360 FULL MARKET VALUE 212,743 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,920 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 148,920 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 183 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-38 ****************** SR 9 160.-1-38 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Krein Ronald Hudson 100600 45,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,700 Krein Cheryl ACRES 2.20 BANK0070390 154,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,700 2715 Route 9 EAST-0685041 NRTH-1203131 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 128,140 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0316 PG-F2366 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,700 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 221,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-2.120 *************** Orchard Rd 140.-1-2.120 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 53,633 53,633 53,633 Kress Erich R Hudson 100600 128,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kress Emily C Micro 96-79 211,072 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,439 4 Orchard Rd ACRES 24.30 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,439 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686304 NRTH-1222203 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,879 DEED BOOK C0279 PG-F1608 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,439 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 301,531 53,633 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-63.200 ************* 5 Shore Dr Lot 33 201.8-2-63.200 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kress Stephen Pine Plains 134201 39,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,816 Gayton Hugh Bk18 Pg1374 153,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,816 5 Shore Dr FRNT 86.00 DPTH 140.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,256 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683544 NRTH-1175750 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,816 TO M DEED BOOK 0576 PG-00656 FULL MARKET VALUE 219,737 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-10 ****************** CR 19 201.-1-10 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,040 Kress Stephen R Pine Plains 134201 53,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,040 Kress Gidget K FRNT 225.00 DPTH 126.00 53,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,040 5 Shore Dr EAST-0683644 NRTH-1175660 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,040 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0326 PG-F0180 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,771 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-11.200 ************** 59 Spring Rd 139.-1-11.200 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,688 Krisniski James Hudson 100600 67,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,688 Krisniski Claudia ACRES 5.28 82,688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,688 59 Spring Rd EAST-0684192 NRTH-1222908 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,688 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0363 PG-V0956 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,126 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 184 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-35.110 ************** Spring Rd 139.-1-35.110 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,688 Krisniski James Hudson 100600 32,905 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,688 59 Spring Rd ACRES 9.59 65,688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,688 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0684279 NRTH-1222149 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 65,688 TO M DEED BOOK 0654 PG-00119 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,840 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-35.120 ************** 59 Spring Rd 139.-1-35.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Krisniski James Hudson 100600 48,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 271,864 Krisniski Claudia ACRES 5.00 271,864 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 271,864 59 Spring Rd EAST-0684619 NRTH-1222109 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 245,304 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0604 PG-01028 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 271,864 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 388,377 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-55 ****************** Off Spring Rd 139.-1-55 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 162,384 Krisniski James Hudson 100600 85,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 162,384 59 Spring Rd ACRES 17.40 162,384 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 162,384 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0684136 NRTH-1220808 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 162,384 TO M DEED BOOK 0583 PG-00616 FULL MARKET VALUE 231,977 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-3-7 ****************** Lakeview Dr 192.4-3-7 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Kropp Carl Pine Plains 134201 46,900 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Kropp Mary FRNT 180.00 DPTH 233.00 207,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 191,335 65 Lake View Dr EAST-0682928 NRTH-1178698 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 191,335 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 560 PG-1094 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 157,630 FULL MARKET VALUE 297,000 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 207,900 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-46 ****************** White Oak Rd 182.-1-46 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 306,389 306,389 306,389 Krupa Edward Germantown 103602 370,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 163,355 Marguerite ACRES 141.70 469,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 163,355 Gerald & Robert EAST-0687945 NRTH-1185318 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,355 2612 Rte 8 DEED BOOK 00780 PG-00176 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 163,355 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 FULL MARKET VALUE 671,063 306,389 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 185 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-18 ***************** Hollow Rd 192.4-2-18 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,000 Kuck Kevin Pine Plains 134201 32,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,000 Kuck Margaret ACRES 1.60 32,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,000 75 Highland Ave EAST-0685010 NRTH-1177902 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,000 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 626 PG-1085 FULL MARKET VALUE 45,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-2 ****************** Private Rd 192.4-2-2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,656 Kuck Kevin W Pine Plains 134201 43,656 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,656 Kuck Margaret M Twin Lakes 43,656 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,656 75 Highland Ave FRNT 237.00 DPTH 146.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,656 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684169 NRTH-1178141 DEED BOOK C0341 PG-F2273 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,366 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-4 ****************** Betty Rd 201.8-1-4 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,256 Kuck Robert Pine Plains 134201 29,935 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,256 Kuck Mary Reilly Twin Lake 40,256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,256 32-31 152nd St ACRES 1.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,256 TO M Flushing, NY 11354 EAST-0682627 NRTH-1176638 DEED BOOK 0542 PG-00494 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,509 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-5 ****************** 219 - 220 Betty Rd 201.8-1-5 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,024 Kuck Robert Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 110,024 Kuck Mary Reilly Twin Lake 110,024 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 110,024 32-31 152nd St FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,024 TO M Flushing, NY 11354 EAST-0682786 NRTH-1174628 DEED BOOK 0453 PG-00212 FULL MARKET VALUE 157,177 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-19 ***************** CR 19 201.8-2-19 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,608 Kuck Robert Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,608 Kuck Mary Bk18 Pg1374 129,608 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 129,608 32-31 152nd St FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,608 TO M Flushing, NY 11354 EAST-0683407 NRTH-1173980 DEED BOOK 0582 PG-00269 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,154 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 186 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-15 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-15 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Kuck Robert H Jr Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Key Hl Bk18 Pg1374 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 PO Box 54-TUR FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682807 NRTH-1174388 DEED BOOK 0582 PG-00924 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-2 ****************** CR 19 201.8-3-2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kuck Robert Sr Pine Plains 134201 24,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 147,968 Kuck Mary T Reilly Twin Lake 147,968 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 147,968 32-31 152 St FRNT 150.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,408 Flushing, NY 11354 EAST-0683117 NRTH-1174449 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,968 TO M DEED BOOK C451 PG-F2390 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,383 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-15.120 ************** 440 SR 82 161.-1-15.120 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Kunda Ronald Hudson 100600 48,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Kunda Mary ACRES 3.00 BANKC010015 139,264 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,656 440 Rt 82 EAST-0696510 NRTH-1208413 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,656 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0306 PG-F2174 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 112,704 FULL MARKET VALUE 198,949 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 139,264 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-22 ****************** Schneider Rd 161.-1-22 484 1 use sm bld COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 89,216 Kurja Bela Hudson 100600 35,076 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 89,216 468 Rte 82 ACRES 38.50 89,216 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,216 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696723 NRTH-1206764 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 89,216 TO M DEED BOOK 0573 PG-01037 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,451 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-29.100 ************** 1508 CR 8 170.-2-29.100 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 72,284 72,284 72,284 Kurzyna Andrew Red Hook 134801 48,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Clum / Keil Irene / Diane ACRES 3.05 144,568 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,284 1508 County Rte 8 EAST-0677849 NRTH-1193758 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,284 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C480 PG-F1571 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,014 FULL MARKET VALUE 206,526 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 144,568 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 187 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-34 ***************** Baxter Rd 201.8-1-34 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,928 Kvrgic Stana Pine Plains 134201 38,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,928 13 Baxter Rd Reilly Twin Lake 111,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 111,928 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 177.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 111,928 TO M EAST-0682348 NRTH-1173727 DEED BOOK 00763 PG-00270 FULL MARKET VALUE 159,897 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-34.110 ************* Pine Rd 201.2-1-34.110 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 Lacku Aurel Pine Plains 134201 48,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 Lacku Elena Bk16 Pg1966, 9248 104,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 677 Woodward Ave ACRES 2.13 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,992 TO M Ridgewood, NY 11385 EAST-0680959 NRTH-1175865 DEED BOOK 0588 PG-00974 FULL MARKET VALUE 149,989 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-6 ****************** Betty Rd 192.4-2-6 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,872 Lagronegro Leonard Pine Plains 134201 47,872 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,872 135 Sterling Ave Micro 4395 47,872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,872 Harrison, NY 10528 FRNT 298.10 DPTH 150.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,872 TO M EAST-0684400 NRTH-1177891 DEED BOOK C477 PG-F2395 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,389 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-25 **************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-25 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,288 Lagronegro Leonard Pine Plains 134201 28,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,288 135 Sterling Ave Bk22 Pg1602 0001 28,288 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,288 Harrison, NY 10528 FRNT 143.73 DPTH 65.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,288 TO M EAST-0682340 NRTH-1177697 DEED BOOK C477 PG-F2398 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,411 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-15.100 ************** SR 9G 138.-1-15.100 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 329,120 Lambert Henry P Germantown 103602 158,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 329,120 Lambert Loretta Crofts 329,120 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 329,120 5265 Rt 9G ACRES 53.59 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 329,120 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668137 NRTH-1221027 DEED BOOK 00824 PG-00311 FULL MARKET VALUE 470,171 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 188 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-15.200 ************** 5265 SR 9G 138.-1-15.200 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lambert Henry P III Germantown 103602 81,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 247,520 Lambert Loretta ACRES 14.29 247,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 247,520 5265 State Rte 9G EAST-0667127 NRTH-1220995 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 220,960 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0557 PG-00330 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 247,520 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 353,600 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-41 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-41 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,048 Landvest Properties LLC Pine Plains 134201 43,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,048 16 Meadow Rd Bruckert 135,048 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,048 Hopewell Junction, NY 12533 ACRES 1.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,048 TO M EAST-0681725 NRTH-1175366 DEED BOOK 648 PG-208 FULL MARKET VALUE 192,926 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-57 ****************** Schneider Rd 151.-1-57 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Langdon De. K. A Hudson 100600 21,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Box 88 FRNT 20.47 DPTH 441.92 21,488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0693529 NRTH-1209157 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 21,488 TO M DEED BOOK 00690 PG-00163 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-58 ****************** Schneider Rd 151.-1-58 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 141,576 Langdon De. K. A Hudson 100600 34,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 141,576 Box 88 FRNT 150.92 DPTH 230.00 141,576 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 141,576 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0693609 NRTH-1209208 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 141,576 TO M DEED BOOK 00690 PG-00163 FULL MARKET VALUE 202,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-21 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-21 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 86,904 Lange Patricia Pine Plains 134201 51,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 86,904 6 Kelley Cir Bk16 Pg1966 86,904 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 86,904 Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 ACRES 3.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 86,904 TO M EAST-0681103 NRTH-1176335 DEED BOOK 575 PG-796 FULL MARKET VALUE 124,149 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 189 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-3 ******************* 134 Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-3 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 23,358 23,358 0 Lapierre Milton P Germantown 103602 29,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lapierre Sally B FRNT 138.00 DPTH 208.00 93,432 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 70,074 134 Deerhaven Rd BANK0140687 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 70,074 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0688101 NRTH-1192908 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,872 DEED BOOK 00818 PG-00043 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 93,432 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 133,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-13 ***************** Corner Bruckert & Pine Rd 201.2-1-13 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 Lapsatis John Pine Plains 134201 42,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 Lapsatis Helen Bruckert 72,896 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 628 80th St ACRES 1.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,896 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11209 EAST-0682412 NRTH-1176867 DEED BOOK 0540 PG-00554 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,137 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-1 ****************** Hapeman Rd 201.2-1-1 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 162,112 Larowitz Randi Pine Plains 134201 52,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 162,112 260 W Broadway Ap8a Micro 4368 162,112 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 162,112 New York, NY 10013 ACRES 4.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 162,112 TO M EAST-0680861 NRTH-1177144 DEED BOOK C348 PG-F2061 FULL MARKET VALUE 231,589 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-53 ****************** 2666 SR 9 160.-1-53 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 72,896 72,896 72,896 Lasher Barbara Hudson 100600 36,547 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 350 Maple Ave Ext FRNT 216.14 DPTH 162.29 145,792 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0684593 NRTH-1202070 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,896 DEED BOOK C0362 PG-F2166 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,626 FULL MARKET VALUE 208,274 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,792 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-44 ****************** CR 19 170.-2-44 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,160 Lasher Robert Germantown 103602 24,375 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,160 Lasher Linda FRNT 119.46 DPTH 130.00 42,160 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,160 PO Box 144 EAST-0685300 NRTH-1193352 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,160 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 00795 PG-00269 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,229 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 190 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 193.-1-4 ******************* Off Weaver Rd 193.-1-4 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,360 Lazie Radoje Germantown 103602 1,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,360 Laazie Radica ACRES 0.48 1,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,360 88-35 Seventy Ninth Ave EAST-0688270 NRTH-1182669 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,360 TO M Glendale, NY 11385 DEED BOOK F377 PG-F528 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,943 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-5 ******************* US 9 140.-1-5 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 LBS Group, Inc. Hudson 100600 21,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 85 W Orchard Rd ACRES 1.50 21,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 Chappaqua, NY 10514 EAST-0690934 NRTH-1221752 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 21,352 TO M DEED BOOK 601 PG-2107 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-22 ***************** Summerside Ave 201.8-3-22 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 121,040 Leary Francis Pine Plains 134201 14,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,040 Leary Daniel Bk10 Pg786 0002 121,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,040 Attn: Judith Leary FRNT 30.00 DPTH 140.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 121,040 TO M 150-43 Coolidge Ave EAST-0683837 NRTH-1174170 Jamaica, NY 11432 DEED BOOK C418 PG-F1023 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-60.2 **************** Scuderhook Rd., Lot 3 171.-1-60.2 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,000 Leckenbusch Michelle Germantown 103602 76,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,000 738 Southwest Bond Rd ACRES 5.12 85,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 85,000 Port ST Lucie, FL 34953 EAST-0688765 NRTH-1198269 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,000 TO M DEED BOOK 630 PG-1164 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-24 **************** Fairview Rd., Lts. 118 & 192.20-2-24 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,720 Lee Susan Tommy Pine Plains 134201 47,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,720 Lee George Twin Lakes 0001 104,720 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,720 25 Soundview Dr FRNT 99.11 DPTH 159.51 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,720 TO M Port Washington, NY 11050 EAST-0683569 NRTH-1178180 DEED BOOK 0545 PG-01116 FULL MARKET VALUE 149,600 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 191 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-93 ****************** Schneider Rd Lot 2 161.-1-93 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lee Timothy Hudson 100600 59,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,000 Schneider Rd Lot 2 Micro 10692 185,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,000 Livingston, NY ACRES 3.52 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 158,440 EAST-0693650 NRTH-1208488 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,000 TO M DEED BOOK 587 PG-396 FULL MARKET VALUE 264,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-22 ***************** Livingston Church Rd 161.1-1-22 449 Warehouse COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 213,520 Leggett Kenneth Hudson 100600 47,756 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 213,520 Rogers Cheryl Bk25 Pg1843 213,520 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 213,520 PO Box 101 ACRES 0.72 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 213,520 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687685 NRTH-1206266 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 213,520 TO M DEED BOOK C349 PG-F2107 FULL MARKET VALUE 305,029 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-24 ***************** Sr 9 161.1-1-24 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Leggett Kenneth Hudson 100600 42,660 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 190,400 PO Box 101 C0285/f0373 190,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 190,400 Livingston, NY 12541 Micro 98-11 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 163,840 ACRES 1.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,400 TO M EAST-0687504 NRTH-1206466 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 190,400 TO M DEED BOOK C478 PG-F24 FULL MARKET VALUE 272,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-45 ***************** Church Rd 161.1-1-45 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,584 Leggett Kenneth P Hudson 100600 26,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,584 PO Box 101 FRNT 128.00 DPTH 138.00 104,584 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,584 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688174 NRTH-1206317 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,584 TO M DEED BOOK 629 PG-252 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 104,584 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 149,406 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-10.112 ************** 56 Link Rd 171.-1-10.112 280 Multiple res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Leifer Eric Germantown 103602 36,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 191,896 Leifer Dorothee ACRES 1.00 191,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 191,896 56 Lynk Rd EAST-0686257 NRTH-1199674 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 165,336 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0318 PG-F1547 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 191,896 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 274,137 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 192 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-72.111 ************** CR 19 171.-1-72.111 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 190,462 190,462 190,462 Leifer Eric M Germantown 103602 219,536 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,074 Leifer Dorothee ACRES 34.60 219,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,074 56 Lynk Rd EAST-0685738 NRTH-1199343 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,074 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0334 PG-F0174 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,074 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 313,623 190,462 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-82 ****************** CR19 171.-1-82 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,728 Leifer Eric M Germantown 103602 50,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,728 Leifer Gerda D Micro 95-15 50,728 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,728 56 Lynk Rd ACRES 2.01 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,728 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686252 NRTH-1199399 DEED BOOK C515 PG-F112 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,469 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-7 ******************* Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-7 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,816 Lener James J Germantown 103602 48,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,816 Lener John J ACRES 3.00 85,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 85,816 Attn: Lener John J EAST-0689072 NRTH-1192360 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,816 TO M 4 Ridge Dr DEED BOOK C0348 PG-F0826 Wetport, CT 06880 FULL MARKET VALUE 122,594 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-25 ****************** Walkers Rd 160.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lentz Richard J Germantown 103602 17,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 88,536 Weed Mildred A FRNT 70.00 DPTH 145.00 88,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 88,536 114 Walker Mills Rd EAST-0675054 NRTH-1206981 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,976 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C501 PG-F433 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 88,536 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 126,480 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-26 ****************** Walkers Rd 160.-1-26 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lentz Thomas Sr Germantown 103602 38,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,776 Lentz Linda ACRES 1.35 100,776 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,776 PO Box 430 EAST-0674854 NRTH-1206911 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,216 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0555 PG-00211 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 100,776 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 143,966 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 193 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-27 ****************** Dansky Rd 150.-1-27 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lenz Peter E Hudson 100600 53,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 250,376 Lenz Colleen D ACRES 4.50 250,376 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 250,376 63 Danski Rd EAST-0685029 NRTH-1214161 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 223,816 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00709 PG-00038 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 250,376 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 357,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-18.100 ************** SR 82 151.-1-18.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 226,168 Leshaj Deda Hudson 100600 55,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 226,168 Leshaj Katrina Micro 2202 226,168 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 226,168 6255 Broadway ACRES 5.03 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 226,168 TO M Bronx, NY 10471 EAST-0693294 NRTH-1216587 DEED BOOK 0556 PG-00833 FULL MARKET VALUE 323,097 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-1-14 ***************** 1357 Rt 19 192.4-1-14 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 182,920 Leubner Steven Pine Plains 134201 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 182,920 Leubner Pattyann ACRES 2.00 182,920 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 182,920 1357 Rte 19 EAST-0682590 NRTH-1178048 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 182,920 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C387 PG-F263 FULL MARKET VALUE 261,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-2 ***************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 212,024 Leubner Steven A Pine Plains 134201 37,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 212,024 Leubner Patty Ann Twin Lakes 212,024 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 212,024 1357 Co Rt 19 ACRES 0.79 BANKC070170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 212,024 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682500 NRTH-1177798 DEED BOOK C404 PG-F208 FULL MARKET VALUE 302,891 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-13.112 ************** Spring Rd 139.-1-13.112 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 42,704 Levin David Hudson 100600 42,704 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 42,704 Betts Sharon S Micro 11858 42,704 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,704 452 W 23rd St 2A ACRES 10.41 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 42,704 TO M New York, NY 10081 EAST-0682571 NRTH-1223425 DEED BOOK 604 PG-1414 FULL MARKET VALUE 61,006 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 194 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-20.122 ************** Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-20.122 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,240 Levingston Bruce M Germantown 103602 148,240 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,240 222 West 23Rd St Micro 94-262 148,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 148,240 New York, NY 10011 ACRES 4.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,240 TO M EAST-0674617 NRTH-1207811 DEED BOOK C399 PG-F0105 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,771 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-14.200 ************** Off Taghkanic Rd 182.-1-14.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 205,496 Lewis Anjali Germantown 103602 55,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 205,496 83 Bacon Dr ACRES 5.10 205,496 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 205,496 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0690957 NRTH-1189643 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,496 TO M DEED BOOK C500 PG-F2400 FULL MARKET VALUE 293,566 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-51 **************** Private Rd 192.20-2-51 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 180,336 Lieber Dr. Ernest Pine Plains 134201 24,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 180,336 Lieber Erika Twin Lakes 180,336 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 180,336 144 E 36Th St FRNT 60.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 180,336 TO M New York, NY 10016 EAST-0683590 NRTH-1177620 DEED BOOK 0470 PG-00523 FULL MARKET VALUE 257,623 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-43 **************** Pleasantview Dr 192.20-2-43 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 20,536 Lieber Erika Pine Plains 134201 20,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 20,536 144 E 36Th St Twin Lakes 0001 20,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 20,536 New York, NY 10016 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 155.14 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 20,536 TO M EAST-0683600 NRTH-1177760 DEED BOOK 00791 PG-00314 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,337 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-64 ****************** CR 10 150.-1-64 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 761,872 Lieberthal Keith Germantown 103602 188,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 761,872 Margulies Julianna ACRES 68.16 761,872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 761,872 200 Park Ave S Fl 8 EAST-0679169 NRTH-1209359 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 761,872 TO M New York, NY 10003 DEED BOOK 640 PG-1358 FULL MARKET VALUE 1088,389 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER RPTL480A UNTIL 2018 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 195 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-4.200 *************** CR 10 160.-1-4.200 311 Res vac land FOREST LND 47460 20,000 20,000 20,000 Lieberthal Keith Hudson 100600 47,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 27,600 Margulies Julianna Micro 99-8 47,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 27,600 200 Park Ave S Fl 8 ACRES 30.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 27,600 New York, NY 10003 EAST-0680211 NRTH-1208501 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,600 TO M DEED BOOK 640 PG-1358 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 68,000 UNDER RPTL480A UNTIL 2018 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-18.200 ************** 134 C R 10 149.-1-18.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Liesendahl Gary Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 110,568 Liesendahl Cheryl A Micro #08-200 110,568 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 110,568 134 Rte 10 ACRES 1.32 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 84,008 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669543 NRTH-1216926 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,568 TO M DEED BOOK 0552 PG-01132 FULL MARKET VALUE 157,954 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-51 ****************** 22 Wire Rd 149.-1-51 271 Mfg housings COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,376 Lighthart Edward Germantown 103602 41,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,376 22 Wire Rd ACRES 1.69 80,376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,376 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668943 NRTH-1216166 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 80,376 TO M DEED BOOK C0357 PG-F1205 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,823 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-7 ******************* Mill Rd 170.-1-7 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 330,472 330,472 330,472 Lindholm Marika Red Hook 134801 521,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 460,028 623 Milburn St ACRES 136.20 790,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 460,028 Evanston, IL 60201 EAST-0672754 NRTH-1196458 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 460,028 DEED BOOK 553 PG-189 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 460,028 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1129,286 330,472 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-6.111 *************** OFF CR 31 170.-1-6.111 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 183,658 183,658 183,658 Lindsay Alexander Red Hook 134801 345,900 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lindsay Joy Micro 11470 807,024 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 623,366 20 S 7th St ACRES 94.62 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 623,366 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0675611 NRTH-1198043 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 596,806 DEED BOOK 00677 PG-00106 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 623,366 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1152,891 183,658 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 196 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-55 ****************** OFF CR 19 171.-1-55 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lipari Joseph Germantown 103602 75,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 186,864 Lipari Barbara Micro 147 186,864 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 186,864 28 Lasher Dr ACRES 11.00 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,304 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0686081 NRTH-1192864 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 186,864 TO M DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00597 FULL MARKET VALUE 266,949 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-3 ******************* Twin Dr 171.-1-3 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 173,264 Lipinski Theodore Germantown 103602 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 173,264 Lipinski Marie A Hilltop Acres 173,264 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,264 Rte 9 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 173,264 TO M PO Box 205 EAST-0687075 NRTH-1201125 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0558 PG-00223 FULL MARKET VALUE 247,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-57 ****************** Stepp Rd 139.-1-57 113 Cattle farm AG DISTRIC 41720 189,301 189,301 189,301 Lippert Charles Germantown 103602 341,800 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lippert Roxanne Life Estate John Stepin 478,992 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 289,691 215-39 26th Ave ACRES 145.90 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 289,691 Bayside, NY 11360 EAST-0682200 NRTH-1219055 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 263,131 DEED BOOK 653 PG-1733 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 289,691 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 684,274 189,301 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-67 ****************** Off Stepp Rd 139.-1-67 321 Abandoned ag AG DISTRIC 41720 115,056 115,056 115,056 Lippert Charles Germantown 103602 119,952 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,896 Lippert Roxanne ACRES 31.80 119,952 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,896 215-39 26th Ave EAST-0681413 NRTH-1217573 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,896 Bayside, NY 11360 DEED BOOK 653 PG-1733 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,896 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 171,360 115,056 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-51.100 ************** CR 19 161.-1-51.100 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 318,776 318,776 318,776 Livingston Farms, LLC Hudson 100600 447,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 486,072 33 S Service Rd Micro 00-244 804,848 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 486,072 Jericho, NY 11753 ACRES 147.20 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 486,072 EAST-0687720 NRTH-1203676 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 486,072 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 571 PG-2113 318,776 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 1149,783 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 197 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-51.200 ************** CR 19 161.-1-51.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 99,416 Livingston Farms, LLC Hudson 100600 57,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 99,416 33 S Service Rd Micro 00-62 99,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,416 Jericho, NY 11753 ACRES 5.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 99,416 TO M EAST-0687137 NRTH-1204865 DEED BOOK 571 PG-2113 FULL MARKET VALUE 142,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-33 ****************** Sr 9 160.-1-33 633 Aged - home COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4250,000 Livingston Hills Realty, LLC Hudson 100600 98,048 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4250,000 PO Box 95 ACRES 11.27 4250,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4250,000 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0686106 NRTH-1205333 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4250,000 TO M DEED BOOK 576 PG-240 FULL MARKET VALUE 6071,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-17 ****************** OAK HILL Rd 128.-1-17 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 109,888 109,888 109,888 Livingston Isabel Church Hudson 100600 53,400 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 PO Box 288 ACRES 15.80 219,776 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,888 Claverack, NY 12513 EAST-0670755 NRTH-1226902 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,888 DEED BOOK C396 PG-F533 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 59,618 FULL MARKET VALUE 313,966 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 219,776 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-16 ****************** OAK HILL Rd 128.-1-16 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Livingston Maria Hudson 100600 49,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 194,616 156 Oak Hill Rd ACRES 1.78 194,616 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 194,616 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0670216 NRTH-1226371 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 144,346 DEED BOOK 00782 PG-00092 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 194,616 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 278,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-62 ****************** CR 10 138.-1-62 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,832 Livingston Memorial Germantown 103602 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,832 Church Of Linlithgo PARSONAGE 130,832 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,832 Co Rte 10 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,832 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668372 NRTH-1218308 DEED BOOK 0250 PG-00303 FULL MARKET VALUE 186,903 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 198 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-1.112 *************** Oak Hill Rd 138.-1-1.112 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 186,184 Livingston Richard Hudson 100600 186,184 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 186,184 Livingston Richard Tyler Micro No 11898 186,184 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 186,184 17 Hampton Ln ACRES 63.10 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 186,184 TO M New Canaan, CT 06840 EAST-0707689 NRTH-0547682 DEED BOOK C503 PG-F1381 FULL MARKET VALUE 265,977 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-18.11 *************** SR 9G 128.-1-18.11 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,200 Livingston Richard H Hudson 100600 26,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,200 17 Hampton Ln ACRES 5.10 26,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,200 New Canaan, CT 06840 EAST-0670275 NRTH-1226961 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 26,200 TO M DEED BOOK 589 PG-906 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-18.12 *************** SR 9G 128.-1-18.12 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,100 Livingston Richard H Hudson 100600 37,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,100 17 Hampton Ln ACRES 10.55 37,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,100 New Canaan, CT 06840 EAST-0670275 NRTH-1226961 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,100 TO M DEED BOOK 589 PG-903 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-18.200 ************** SR 9G 128.-1-18.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,104 Livingston Susan Hudson 100600 65,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,104 34 Ticehurst Ln Micro 00-309 148,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 148,104 Marblehead, MA 01945 ACRES 7.13 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,104 TO M EAST-0669896 NRTH-1226460 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F1136 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-19 ****************** Oak Hill Rd 128.-1-19 250 Estate - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1304,000 Livingston Susan Hudson 100600 333,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1304,000 3 Anchorage Ln Micro 97-101 1304,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1304,000 Marbelhead, MA 01945-2610 ACRES 53.85 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1304,000 TO M EAST-0669055 NRTH-1226879 DEED BOOK C0293 PG-F0328 FULL MARKET VALUE 1862,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 199 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-1.111 *************** Oak Hill Rd 138.-1-1.111 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 83,232 Livingston Susan C Hudson 100600 83,232 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 83,232 34 Ticehurst Ln Micro No 11898 83,232 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 83,232 Marblehead, MA 01945 ACRES 21.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 83,232 TO M EAST-0707648 NRTH-0547792 DEED BOOK 583 PG-1969 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,903 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-2.200 *************** OAK HILL Rd 138.-1-2.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,984 Livingston Tyler Catherine Hudson 100600 56,984 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,984 171 Oak Hill Rd ACRES 4.45 56,984 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,984 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0670018 NRTH-1225591 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,984 TO M DEED BOOK 587 PG-980 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,406 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-1.12 **************** Oak Hill Rd 138.-1-1.12 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 291,856 Livingston, III Henry H Hudson 100600 204,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 291,856 3 Anchorage Ln Micro 11898 & 97-101 291,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 291,856 Marblehead, MA 01945 ACRES 50.15 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 291,856 TO M EAST-0668388 NRTH-1225657 DEED BOOK 589 PG-909 FULL MARKET VALUE 416,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-39 ****************** 35 Cr 8 Black Brg Rd 182.-1-39 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ljutich Paul Germantown 103602 60,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,800 35 Black Bridge Rd ACRES 9.91 BANKH130240 174,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0689382 NRTH-1187000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 148,240 DEED BOOK 00810 PG-00341 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,800 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 249,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-5 ****************** CR 19 201.8-3-5 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 20,264 Lloyd Edward Pine Plains 134201 20,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 20,264 Lloyd Diane Reilly Twin Lake 20,264 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 20,264 5 Straub Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 130.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 20,264 TO M Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 BANKC061222 EAST-0683157 NRTH-1174389 DEED BOOK 00704 PG-00342 FULL MARKET VALUE 28,949 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 200 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-6 ****************** CR 19 201.8-3-6 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,136 Lloyd Edward C Pine Plains 134201 16,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,136 Lloyd Diane 198a 136,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,136 5 Straub Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,136 TO M Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 BANKC061222 EAST-0683187 NRTH-1174349 DEED BOOK 00704 PG-00342 FULL MARKET VALUE 194,480 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-52.220 ************** 88 Lockwood Rd 161.-1-52.220 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lockwood Robert L Hudson 100600 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 180,880 88 Lockwood Rd ACRES 2.10 180,880 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 180,880 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0690679 NRTH-1203802 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 154,320 DEED BOOK 0554 PG-01027 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 180,880 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 258,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-45 ****************** Livingston 161.-1-45 662 Police/fire COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 320,688 Loggerheads Inc Hudson 100600 85,913 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 320,688 3 Hook Rd ACRES 0.67 BANK0130715 320,688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 320,688 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 EAST-0686298 NRTH-1204564 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 320,688 TO M DEED BOOK C531 PG-F1844 FULL MARKET VALUE 458,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-46.120 ************** Livingston Rt. 9 161.-1-46.120 662 Police/fire COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 20,944 Loggerheads Inc Hudson 100600 18,249 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 20,944 3 Hook Rd FRNT 94.31 DPTH 356.43 20,944 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 20,944 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 BANK0130715 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 20,944 TO M EAST-0686248 NRTH-1204463 DEED BOOK C531 PG-F1844 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,920 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-22 ****************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-22 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 171,360 Lombardi Anthony Pine Plains 134201 55,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 171,360 51-49 Sixty-Nineth St ACRES 5.00 171,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,360 Woodside, NY 11377 EAST-0683994 NRTH-1181010 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 171,360 TO M DEED BOOK 0385 PG-00520 FULL MARKET VALUE 244,800 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 201 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-21 **************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-21 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 9,248 Loos Kenneth Jr Pine Plains 134201 9,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 9,248 Loos Jessica Bk22 Pg1602 0001 9,248 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 9,248 PO Box 417 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 9,248 TO M Pine Plains, NY 12567 EAST-0682620 NRTH-1177608 DEED BOOK C424 PG-F1547 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,211 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-22 **************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-22 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,240 Loos Kenneth Jr Pine Plains 134201 16,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,240 Loos Jessica Twin Lakes 80,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,240 PO Box 417 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 80,240 TO M Pine Plains, NY 12567 EAST-0682580 NRTH-1177608 DEED BOOK C424 PG-F1547 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,629 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-2.112 *************** SR 9G 138.-1-2.112 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 68,136 Lossow Delilah M Hudson 100600 68,136 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 68,136 5532 SR 9G Micro 8609 68,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 68,136 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 20.79 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 68,136 TO M EAST-0672068 NRTH-1225585 DEED BOOK 581 PG-1021 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,337 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-33 ****************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-33 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lozier Cathy Pine Plains 134201 289,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 724,200 Lozier Thomas ACRES 175.00 724,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 724,200 106 White Oak Rd EAST-0685396 NRTH-1179823 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 697,640 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 581 PG-2155 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 724,200 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1034,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-11 ***************** Mc Cusker Dev #155-N 192.4-2-11 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,472 Lucente Paul Pine Plains 134201 25,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,472 3830 Jacqueline St Micro 4395 61,472 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,472 Bethpage, NY 11714 FRNT 94.80 DPTH 170.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,472 TO M EAST-0684120 NRTH-1177631 DEED BOOK 0621 PG-00322 FULL MARKET VALUE 87,817 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 202 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-28 **************** Mohr Ln 192.20-2-28 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 39,168 Lucente Vito Pine Plains 134201 39,168 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 39,168 Souquet Justine Micro 4395 39,168 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,168 PO Box 445 FRNT 112.30 DPTH 141.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 39,168 TO M Kinderhook, NY 12106 EAST-0683910 NRTH-1177970 DEED BOOK 0605 PG-00409 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,954 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-22 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-22 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,968 Lucente Vito Pine Plains 134201 28,968 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,968 Lucente Justine Souquet Pb 18 Pg 1374 28,968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,968 22 Albany Ave FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,968 TO M Kinderhook, NY 12106 EAST-0682487 NRTH-1174138 DEED BOOK 572 PG-1417 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,383 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-23 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-23 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,968 Lucente Vito Pine Plains 134201 28,968 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,968 Lucente Justine Souquet Reilly Twin Lake 28,968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,968 22 Albany Ave FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,968 TO M Kinderhook, NY 12106 EAST-0682437 NRTH-1174088 DEED BOOK 572 PG-1423 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,383 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-5 ******************* Water St 141.-1-5 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ludwig George E Copake-Taconic 102801 26,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 91,256 Crosby Louise W FRNT 109.56 DPTH 198.00 91,256 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 91,256 453 Millbrook Rd BANK0190462 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,696 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0700689 NRTH-1219191 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 91,256 TO M DEED BOOK C0317 PG-F2067 FULL MARKET VALUE 130,366 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-19 ****************** 198 Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-19 220 2 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 407,320 Lydon Harris R Germantown 103602 81,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 407,320 Lydon Catherine A Merged 8.24A Fr 20.1 407,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 407,320 17 White St 2B ACRES 12.75 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 407,320 TO M New York, NY 10013 EAST-0675620 NRTH-1208982 DEED BOOK 618 PG-759 FULL MARKET VALUE 581,886 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 203 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-46.100 ************* Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-46.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lydon Timothy Jr Pine Plains 134201 43,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 200,224 Lydon Susan Bk16 Pg1966 200,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 200,224 133 Parker Rd ACRES 1.29 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,664 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681116 NRTH-1174885 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 200,224 TO M DEED BOOK 0645 PG-00246 FULL MARKET VALUE 286,034 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-73 ****************** Twin Dr 171.-1-73 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 14,144 Lynk Donald Germantown 103602 14,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 14,144 67 Lynk Rd Micro 4852 14,144 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 14,144 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 14,144 TO M EAST-0685788 NRTH-1199393 DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00216 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,206 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-88 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-88 720 Mine/quarry COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 24,616 Lynk Donald Germantown 103602 21,537 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 24,616 67 Lynk Rd ACRES 3.49 24,616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 24,616 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0038965 NRTH-0424059 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 24,616 TO M DEED BOOK 565 PG-826 FULL MARKET VALUE 35,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-13 ****************** CR 19 171.-1-13 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lynk Donna S Germantown 103602 53,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 226,500 PO Box 78 ACRES 2.80 226,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 226,500 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0686497 NRTH-1199944 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 199,940 DEED BOOK C523 PG-F1078 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 226,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 323,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-6.111 *************** Twin Dr 171.-1-6.111 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,816 Lynk Gary Germantown 103602 51,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 51,816 Lynk Scott Lynk Subdivision 51,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,816 67 Lynk Rd Micro 4852 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 51,816 TO M Hudosn, NY 12534 ACRES 1.31 EAST-0687086 NRTH-1200475 DEED BOOK C375 PG-F331 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,023 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 204 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-14.100 ************** CR 19 171.-1-14.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lynk Gary Germantown 103602 45,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 254,184 Lynk Frances ACRES 3.25 254,184 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 254,184 2566 Grand Lakeside Dr EAST-0687056 NRTH-1200175 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 227,624 Palm Harbor, FL 34684 DEED BOOK C0488 PG-F2340 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 254,184 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 363,120 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-70 ****************** Twin Dr 171.-1-70 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 169,592 Lynk Gary Germantown 103602 42,979 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 169,592 Lynk Scott Lynk Subdivision 169,592 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 169,592 67 Lynk Rd Micro 4852 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 169,592 TO M Hudosn, NY 12534 ACRES 1.29 EAST-0687436 NRTH-1200596 DEED BOOK C375 PG-F328 FULL MARKET VALUE 242,274 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-24 ****************** 16 Lynk Rd 171.-1-24 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Lyons David J Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,944 Lyons Tammy ACRES 1.00 105,944 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,944 16 Lynk Rd EAST-0686959 NRTH-1198975 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 79,384 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 593 PG-1710 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,944 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 151,349 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-27 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-27 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 266,016 Mac Donald Alton Germantown 103602 81,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 266,016 Mac Donald Pamela Micro 99-243 266,016 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 266,016 5211 Rte 9G ACRES 10.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 266,016 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0667459 NRTH-1219816 DEED BOOK C0353 PG-F1108 FULL MARKET VALUE 380,023 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-26 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-26 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 180,200 Mac Donald Pamela Germantown 103602 70,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 180,200 Proctor Linda Micro 99-243 180,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 180,200 5211 Rte 9G ACRES 7.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 180,200 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0667220 NRTH-1219325 DEED BOOK C0353 PG-F1108 FULL MARKET VALUE 257,429 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 205 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-6.112 *************** Twin Dr 171.-1-6.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Macalluso Giorgio Germantown 103602 40,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 241,264 Macaluso Geraldine Lynk Subdivision 241,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 241,264 31 Twin Dr Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 214,704 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.50 BANKC080007 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 241,264 TO M EAST-0687505 NRTH-1200946 DEED BOOK C0488 PG-F2020 FULL MARKET VALUE 344,663 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-45 ****************** 1023 CR 19 181.-1-45 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Mackechnie Mark Germantown 103602 42,740 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 1023 Cty Rte 19 ACRES 1.50 BANKC070154 120,632 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 93,024 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682884 NRTH-1185978 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,024 DEED BOOK C439 PG-F2127 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,072 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,331 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,632 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-46 ****************** CR 19 181.-1-46 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 31,416 Mackechnie Mark Germantown 103602 31,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 31,416 1023 Cty Rte 19 FRNT 224.70 DPTH 120.00 31,416 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,416 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC070170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 31,416 TO M EAST-0683054 NRTH-1186028 DEED BOOK C439 PG-F2127 FULL MARKET VALUE 44,880 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-13.200 ************** 133A Maple Ln 170.-2-13.200 230 3 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mackey Nancy Germantown 103602 35,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,560 1 33a Maple Ln ACRES 0.93 BANKH030950 198,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,560 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0683842 NRTH-1194769 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 172,000 DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F0916 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,560 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 283,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-41 ****************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-41 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,192 Mackie Lisa Germantown 103602 64,192 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,192 251 W 30Th St Loft 12W ACRES 9.00 BANKC120345 64,192 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,192 New York, NY 10001 EAST-0669360 NRTH-1219290 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 64,192 TO M DEED BOOK 00758 PG-00338 FULL MARKET VALUE 91,703 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 206 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-42 ****************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-42 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,960 Mackie Lisa Germantown 103602 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,960 251 W 30Th St Loft 12W ACRES 1.00 BANKC120345 116,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,960 New York, NY 10001 EAST-0669341 NRTH-1219020 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,960 TO M DEED BOOK 00758 PG-00338 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,086 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-48 ****************** Deerhaven Rd 182.-1-48 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Macri Carlo J Germantown 103602 91,700 FOREST LND 47460 33,360 33,360 33,360 Macri Jennifer A ACRES 38.68 242,896 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 209,536 296 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0690841 NRTH-1192393 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 209,536 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 603 PG-1157 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 182,976 FULL MARKET VALUE 346,994 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 242,896 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER RPTL480A UNTIL 2018 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-38.220 ************** Deerhaven Rd 171.-1-38.220 322 Rural vac>10 FOREST LND 47460 188,115 188,115 188,115 Macri Joseph Germantown 103602 235,144 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,029 Macri Carlo ACRES 72.65 235,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,029 296 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0691158 NRTH-1194144 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,029 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0347 PG-F1768 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 235,144 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 335,920 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER RPTL480A UNTIL 2018 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-44 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-44 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Magarelli Gaetano Pine Plains 134201 24,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 86,768 Magarelli Brenda Bk20 Pg1492 86,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 86,768 Box 181 FRNT 69.30 DPTH 221.60 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 60,208 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC190130 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 86,768 TO M EAST-0682690 NRTH-1172588 DEED BOOK 0583 PG-00591 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,954 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-58 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 11 201.2-1-58 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 117,368 Maggipinto Joseph Pine Plains 134201 24,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 117,368 Maggipinto Theresa Reilly Twin Lake 117,368 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 117,368 432 Kimball Ave FRNT 50.00 DPTH 145.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,368 TO M Yonkers, NY 10704 EAST-0682646 NRTH-1174908 DEED BOOK 0552 PG-00096 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,669 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 207 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-67 ****************** 371 Twin Dr 171.-1-67 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Maguire Debra Germantown 103602 29,938 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 176,528 371 Rt 19 Lynk Subdivision 176,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 176,528 Hudson, NY 12534 Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 149,968 FRNT 122.00 DPTH 182.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,528 TO M EAST-0686705 NRTH-1200835 DEED BOOK C0309 PG-F0320 FULL MARKET VALUE 252,183 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-1.111 *************** 120 Deer Haven Rd 31 PCT OF VALUE USED FOR EXEMPTION PURPOSES 182.-1-1.111 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 16,074 16,074 0 Mahar Terrance Germantown 103602 125,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mahar Margarette ACRES 43.60 207,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 191,326 120 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0688491 NRTH-1192478 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 191,326 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0464 PG-00098 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 180,840 FULL MARKET VALUE 296,286 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 207,400 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-52 ****************** Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-52 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,200 Mahar Terrence Germantown 103602 5,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,200 Mahar Margarette ACRES 1.00 BANKC140695 5,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,200 120 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0687599 NRTH-1193477 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,200 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0502 PG-00611 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-37 ****************** Mountainview Dr 192.-1-37 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,216 Maher Michael Pine Plains 134201 52,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,216 Maher Eileen Micro 00-136 157,216 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 157,216 3991 S Ravine Ave ACRES 4.03 BANKH061222 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,216 TO M Pahrump, NV 89048 EAST-0683667 NRTH-1179310 DEED BOOK C0362 PG-F1759 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,594 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-3-2 ****************** 61 Mountainview Dr 192.4-3-2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Maiello Salvatore Pine Plains 134201 37,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,272 Maiello Ann Marie ACRES 1.20 BANK0080490 153,272 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,272 61 Mountain View Dr EAST-0683157 NRTH-1179309 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,712 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0525 PG-00449 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,272 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 218,960 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 208 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-46 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-46 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,856 Majdan Mrs Ann Pine Plains 134201 33,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,856 PO Box 411 FRNT 79.86 DPTH 343.05 87,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,856 New Hyde Park New YorNY 11040 EAST-0682830 NRTH-1172538 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,856 TO M DEED BOOK 0326 PG-00503 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,509 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-68 ****************** 132 Prillipper Rd 139.-1-68 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 210,396 210,396 210,396 Majercsik William Hudson 100600 259,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 347,748 132 Prilipper Rd ACRES 90.00 558,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 347,748 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0684551 NRTH-1218309 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 347,748 DEED BOOK 0504 PG-00538 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 347,748 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 797,349 210,396 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-5 ******************* Prilliper Rd 150.-1-5 321 Abandoned ag AG DISTRIC 41720 88,163 88,163 88,163 Majercsik William Jr. Hudson 100600 91,120 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2,957 117 Prilliper Rd ACRES 17.00 91,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2,957 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0684905 NRTH-1216550 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2,957 DEED BOOK 635 PG-117 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2,957 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 130,171 88,163 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-26 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-26 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 127,024 Maloney Daniel Pine Plains 134201 26,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 127,024 Maloney Mary Lou Bk18 Pg1374 127,024 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,024 720 Tuckahoe Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 127,024 TO M Yonkers, NY 10710 BANKH061230 EAST-0682597 NRTH-1174058 DEED BOOK 0660 PG-00160 FULL MARKET VALUE 181,463 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-31 ***************** LOT 154 Major Rd 201.8-1-31 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Maloney Daniel Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Maloney Mary Lou Bk18 Pg1374 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 720 Tuckahoe Rd #2K FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M Yonkers, NY 10710 EAST-0682617 NRTH-1174018 DEED BOOK C0357 PG-F1087 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 209 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-34 ***************** Baxter Rd 201.8-2-34 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 Malouf Ernest Pine Plains 134201 26,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 Malouf Linda Reilly Twin Lake 95,064 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 95,064 548 Route 9D FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 95,064 TO M Beacon, NY 12508 EAST-0682609 NRTH-1173378 DEED BOOK 561 PG-1586 FULL MARKET VALUE 135,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-64 ***************** Shore Dr. Lot 4 201.2-1-64 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 Mangold Carol Pine Plains 134201 15,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 Mangold William Reilly Twin Lake 172,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 172,856 4985 SE Lost Lake Way FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,856 TO M Hobe Sound, FL 33455 EAST-0682426 NRTH-1174618 DEED BOOK C446 PG-F135 FULL MARKET VALUE 246,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-49.100 ************** 2728 Rt 9 161.-1-49.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Manko Katina Hudson 100600 40,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 223,176 2728 Rte 9 Micro 94-118 223,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 223,176 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 196,616 EAST-0685710 NRTH-1203542 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 223,176 TO M DEED BOOK C516 PG-F2323 FULL MARKET VALUE 318,823 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-18.200 ************** SR 82 151.-1-18.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Manning Brian Hudson 100600 38,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 190,672 Manning Linda ACRES 1.37 BANK0180200 190,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 190,672 104 State Route 82 EAST-0693665 NRTH-1216487 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 164,112 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0601 PG-00549 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 190,672 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 272,389 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-18.111 ************** CR 31 170.-1-18.111 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Manning John J Red Hook 134801 53,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 270,000 Wood-Mannino Sandra Bk24 Pg1753 270,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 270,000 1620 County Rte 31 ACRES 8.69 BANK0080386 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 243,440 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676898 NRTH-1194636 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 270,000 TO M DEED BOOK C471 PG-F449 FULL MARKET VALUE 385,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 210 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-20.110 ************** 750 CR 31 150.-1-20.110 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 90,039 90,039 90,039 Manuli Phyllis Germantown 103602 121,040 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 31,001 700 Rte 31 Micro 99-167 121,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 31,001 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 19.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 31,001 EAST-0676119 NRTH-1214783 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 31,001 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C0345 PG-F0882 90,039 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,914 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-13.100 ************** Maple Ln 170.-2-13.100 416 Mfg hsing pk BAS STAR 41854 0 0 160,000 Maple Lane Associates, LLC Germantown 103602 119,922 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1557,091 107 Law Rd Micro 4600 1557,091 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1557,091 Briarcliff Manor, NY 10510 ACRES 16.95 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1397,091 EAST-0683878 NRTH-1194379 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1557,091 TO M DEED BOOK 572 PG-1541 FULL MARKET VALUE 2224,416 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-41.200 ************** Blue Stores 170.-2-41.200 323 Vacant rural COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 816 Maple Lane Associates, LLC Red Hook 134801 816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 816 107 Law Rd ACRES 0.30 816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 816 Briarcliff Manor, NY 10510 EAST-0683138 NRTH-1194098 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 816 TO M DEED BOOK 572 PG-1541 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-42 ****************** Private Rd 170.-2-42 416 Mfg hsing pk BAS STAR 41854 0 0 120,000 Maple Lane Associates, LLC Red Hook 134801 170,403 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1686,848 107 Law Rd Micro 4519 1686,848 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1686,848 Briarcliff Manor, NY 10510 ACRES 11.10 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1566,848 EAST-0683339 NRTH-1193898 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1686,848 TO M DEED BOOK 572 PG-1541 FULL MARKET VALUE 2409,783 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-1 ******************* OFF CR 19 181.-1-1 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 255,374 Maple Lane Associates, LLC Red Hook 134801 255,374 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 255,374 107 Law Rd ACRES 76.00 255,374 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 255,374 Briarcliff Manor, NY 10510 EAST-0682490 NRTH-1193097 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 255,374 TO M DEED BOOK 572 PG-1541 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 364,820 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2012 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 211 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-4 ******************* Oak Hill Rd 128.-1-4 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,688 Marcus Bonnie Hudson 100600 34,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,688 5300 S South Shore Dr #46 Micro 1231 116,688 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,688 Chicago, IL 60615-5719 FRNT 110.00 DPTH 240.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,688 TO M BANK0180200 EAST-0671155 NRTH-1227203 DEED BOOK 0602 PG-00192 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-45 ****************** Off CR 19 170.-2-45 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Marino-Sterbenz Rosemary Germantown 103602 13,212 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 89,624 10 Lasher Dr FRNT 108.90 DPTH 119.50 89,624 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 89,624 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685400 NRTH-1193302 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 63,064 DEED BOOK C0358 PG-F1946 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 89,624 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 128,034 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-46 ****************** Off CR 19 170.-2-46 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,536 Marino-Sterbenz Rosemary Germantown 103602 3,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,536 10 Lasher Dr FRNT 110.06 DPTH 198.00 3,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,536 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685550 NRTH-1193253 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,536 TO M DEED BOOK C0358 PG-F1946 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,051 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-47 ****************** Off CR 19 170.-2-47 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 7,072 Marino-Sterbenz Rosemary Germantown 103602 7,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 7,072 10 Lasher Dr ACRES 1.00 7,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 7,072 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685710 NRTH-1193123 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 7,072 TO M DEED BOOK C0358 PG-F1946 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-50 ****************** Off CR 19 170.-2-50 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 50,320 Marino-Sterbenz Rosemary Germantown 103602 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 50,320 10 Lasher Dr ACRES 1.00 50,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 50,320 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685490 NRTH-1193103 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 50,320 TO M DEED BOOK C0358 PG-F1946 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,886 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 212 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-51 ***************** Loyola Rd. Lt. 72-1/2 Of 201.2-1-51 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 11,152 Markot Ivan Pine Plains 134201 11,152 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 11,152 11 Beechtree Ln Reilly Twin Lake 11,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 11,152 Bronxville, NY 10708 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 11,152 TO M EAST-0682206 NRTH-1174957 DEED BOOK 609 PG-1364 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-79 ****************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-79 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Marrish Marc W Hudson 100600 46,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 237,200 Marrish Joanne M Db822pg42 237,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 237,200 215 White Birch Rd Micro 02-253 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 210,640 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.50 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 237,200 TO M EAST-0675638 NRTH-1225182 DEED BOOK C428 PG-F1528 FULL MARKET VALUE 338,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-15 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-15 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Martel Henrietta Carole Pine Plains 134201 47,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,648 PO Box 57 Bruckert 148,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,648 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,088 EAST-0681932 NRTH-1176636 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,648 TO M DEED BOOK 00702 PG-00101 FULL MARKET VALUE 212,354 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-40 ****************** Private Rd 171.-1-40 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 353,600 Martell Michael Germantown 103602 53,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 353,600 Martell Alice ACRES 4.50 BANK0080490 353,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 353,600 1185 Park Ave Apt 3l EAST-0686965 NRTH-1195605 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 353,600 TO M New York, NY 10128 DEED BOOK 0568 PG-00525 FULL MARKET VALUE 505,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-61 ****************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-61 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 Martens Kim Hudson 100600 48,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 Martens Scott ACRES 3.00 64,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 2719 Rte 9 EAST-0695870 NRTH-1203082 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 64,736 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0364 PG-F1286 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,480 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 213 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-37 ****************** 2719 SR 9 160.-1-37 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 60,547 0 0 Martens Lorene M Hudson 100600 47,800 AGED T&S 41806 0 30,274 30,274 2719 Rte 9 ACRES 2.83 151,368 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685110 NRTH-1203321 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 90,821 DEED BOOK C0280 PG-F0271 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,094 FULL MARKET VALUE 216,240 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,824 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 151,368 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-71.2 **************** 546 White Birch Rd 138.-1-71.2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Martin Michelle M Germantown 103602 40,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 114,000 546 White Birch Rd ACRES 2.00 114,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 114,000 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671272 NRTH-1218113 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,440 DEED BOOK C504 PG-F1346 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 162,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-3 ******************* 743 CR 19 181.-1-3 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Martin William Germantown 103602 75,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 228,208 Martin Jane H Micro 4846 228,208 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 228,208 743 CR 19 ACRES 22.00 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 201,648 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685441 NRTH-1192543 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,208 TO M DEED BOOK 0588 PG-00145 FULL MARKET VALUE 326,011 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-2 ******************* 742 CR 19 181.-1-2 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Martin William Jr Germantown 103602 55,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 263,024 Martin Ann E ACRES 22.50 BANK0080490 263,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 263,024 742 CR 19 EAST-0684061 NRTH-1192920 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 236,464 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C416 PG-F2336 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 263,024 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 375,749 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-1.111 *************** Off Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-1.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 184,008 Masi Salvatore Pine Plains 134201 59,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 184,008 Masi Mary Micro 6075 184,008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 184,008 90 Hawthorne Ave ACRES 6.35 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 184,008 TO M Floral Park, NY 11001 EAST-0678890 NRTH-1177670 DEED BOOK 0560 PG-00278 FULL MARKET VALUE 262,869 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 214 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-50 ***************** Church Rd 161.1-1-50 632 Benevolent COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Masonic Hall Hudson 100600 19,633 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Laurence Benson FRNT 60.00 DPTH 100.00 102,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,000 Hudson Widow's Son Lodge #7 EAST-0688415 NRTH-1206128 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,000 TO M 819 Columbia St DEED BOOK 0459 PG-00262 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 102,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-14.120 ************** Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-14.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 213,248 Massana Brian Hudson 100600 62,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 213,248 O-Rorke Toby Micro 96-10 & 97-117 213,248 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 213,248 223 East 10Th Street #2 ACRES 7.22 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 213,248 TO M New York, NY 10003 EAST-0698951 NRTH-1212958 DEED BOOK C376 PG-F63 FULL MARKET VALUE 304,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-47.100 ************** 23 Half Circle Road-Lot 1 149.-1-47.100 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 71,332 71,332 71,332 Massaro Aurora Germantown 103602 35,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 23 Half Circle Rd ACRES 1.00 142,664 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 71,332 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669486 NRTH-1216220 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 71,332 DEED BOOK 0614 PG-00023 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,062 FULL MARKET VALUE 203,806 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 142,664 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-47.200 ************** Half Circle Road-Lot 2 149.-1-47.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,560 Massaro Aurora Germantown 103602 28,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,560 23 Half Circle Rd ACRES 1.67 28,560 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,560 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669457 NRTH-1215910 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,560 TO M DEED BOOK 0614 PG-00023 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-18.200 ************** 518 CR 10 150.-1-18.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Massaro Philip J Germantown 103602 62,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 251,736 518 Co Rt 10 ACRES 7.21 BANK0080490 251,736 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 251,736 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675841 NRTH-1213738 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 225,176 DEED BOOK C0505 PG-F1120 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 251,736 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 359,623 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 215 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-3 ******************* LOT 20 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-3 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mathieu Scott M Hudson 100600 38,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 205,632 Mathieu Cheryl A Micro 94-118 & 95-283 205,632 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 205,632 15 Mahikan Dr ACRES 1.34 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 179,072 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686060 NRTH-1203353 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,632 TO M DEED BOOK 577 PG-2248 FULL MARKET VALUE 293,760 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-21 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-21 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Maylin M. Romanelli Trust Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 1962 Hazelwood Rd Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Toms River, NJ 08753 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682527 NRTH-1174168 DEED BOOK 564 PG-1723 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-20 ***************** Pine Rd 201.2-1-20 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 46,376 Mc Allister Paul Pine Plains 134201 22,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 46,376 20 Lea Court Bruckert 46,376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,376 Garnerville, NY 10923 FRNT 300.00 DPTH 178.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 46,376 TO M EAST-0681363 NRTH-1176545 DEED BOOK 0488 PG-00181 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-3-4 ****************** 75 Lakeview Dr 192.4-3-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mc Ardle Rose Pine Plains 134201 42,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,800 75 Lakeview Dr ACRES 1.00 108,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682978 NRTH-1178908 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,240 DEED BOOK 0450 PG-00245 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,800 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 155,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-7 ***************** Pine Tree Rd 192.20-3-7 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 Mc Cusker James Est. D Pine Plains 134201 21,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 Attn: Charles O'velie Twin Lakes 0001 21,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,352 74 N Water St FRNT 50.00 DPTH 169.12 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 21,352 TO M Poughkeepsie, NY 12603 EAST-0682820 NRTH-1177738 DEED BOOK 0256 PG-00441 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,503 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 216 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-96 ****************** Livingston-Church Rd 161.-1-96 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mc Donald Kevin Hudson 100600 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 208,760 Mc Donald Mary Ann Micro 96-20 208,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 208,760 PO Box 300 ACRES 2.10 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 182,200 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0690295 NRTH-1205961 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 208,760 TO M DEED BOOK 00822 PG-00054 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 208,760 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 298,229 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-30 ****************** Mountainview Dr 192.-1-30 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,680 Mc Fadden Nancy J Pine Plains 134201 51,680 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 51,680 57 Mountainview Dr ACRES 1.90 BANK0080490 51,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 51,680 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683296 NRTH-1179869 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 51,680 TO M DEED BOOK 00717 PG-00119 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-35 ****************** Mountainview Dr 192.-1-35 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,904 Mc Fadden Nancy J Pine Plains 134201 33,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,904 57 Mountainview Dr FRNT 133.67 DPTH 280.00 137,904 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,904 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 137,904 TO M EAST-0683226 NRTH-1179639 DEED BOOK 00717 PG-00119 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,006 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-5.200 ************** Off Pine Rd 201.2-1-5.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mc Ghee Ricky Pine Plains 134201 39,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,912 Mc Ghee Stephanie Micro 9106 134,912 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 134,912 6 Field Rd ACRES 0.86 BANKH150099 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,352 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681686 NRTH-1177191 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 134,912 TO M DEED BOOK 0586 PG-00915 FULL MARKET VALUE 192,731 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-10 ****************** 305 Rt 12 141.-1-10 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Mc Goey John Copake-Taconic 102801 35,000 AGED - ALL 41800 43,588 43,588 57,392 Mc Goey Alice ACRES 3.00 114,784 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 305 Rte 12 EAST-0700380 NRTH-1218540 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,588 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0524 PG-00082 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,588 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,977 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 7,122 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,784 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 217 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-14 **************** Private Rd 192.20-3-14 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 Mc Laughlin Reginald Pine Plains 134201 24,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 Mc Laughlin Iris Twin Lakes 107,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 4 Orchard Meadow Rd FRNT 72.00 DPTH 120.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,032 TO M E Williston, NY 11596 EAST-0683300 NRTH-1177559 DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00111 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,903 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-26.200 ************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-26.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 McCarthy Kelly Germantown 103602 38,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 199,800 229 Cold Spring Rd Micro 9911 199,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 199,800 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.01 BANKC130171 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 173,240 EAST-0681759 NRTH-1214434 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 199,800 TO M DEED BOOK 595 PG-2475 FULL MARKET VALUE 285,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-17.112 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-17.112 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 106,209 106,209 106,209 Mcfarland James R Hudson 100600 185,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mcfarland Lyn J Micro 9778 620,296 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 514,087 PO Box 212 ACRES 50.28 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 514,087 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0687453 NRTH-1207186 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 487,527 DEED BOOK C0331 PG-F0124 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 514,087 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 886,137 106,209 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 620,296 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-68 ****************** Church Rd 161.-1-68 322 Rural vac>10 AG DISTRIC 41720 57,618 57,618 57,618 Mcfarland James R Hudson 100600 82,144 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 24,526 Mcfarland Lyn R Micro 9778 82,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 24,526 PO Box 212 ACRES 23.22 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 24,526 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0690333 NRTH-1207001 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 24,526 TO M DEED BOOK 0597 PG-00379 57,618 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 117,349 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 82,144 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-33 ****************** CR 10 149.-1-33 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 Mcgiver Cornelia Germantown 103602 32,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 Blum Gregory FRNT 152.46 DPTH 175.00 108,256 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,256 82 Block Factory Rd EAST-0669836 NRTH-1216401 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,256 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C533 PG-F669 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,651 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 218 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-28 ****************** Blue Stores 170.-1-28 280 Multiple res VET458(5) 41001 76,175 76,175 0 Mcguire William Red Hook 134801 57,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mcguire Lori ACRES 5.62 213,520 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,345 134 Bingham Mills Rd EAST-0674469 NRTH-1193791 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,345 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C403 PG-F1922 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 186,960 FULL MARKET VALUE 305,029 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 213,520 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-2 ******************* Hapeman Rd 201.-1-2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 121,448 McNeil Robert A Pine Plains 134201 50,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,448 Manetta Susan ACRES 3.10 121,448 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,448 1320 Route 9 EAST-0680612 NRTH-1176954 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 121,448 TO M Tivoli, NY 12583 DEED BOOK 651 PG-1996 FULL MARKET VALUE 173,497 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-10.111 ************** CR 19 171.-1-10.111 720 Mine/quarry AG DISTRIC 41720 475,545 475,545 475,545 Mcr Sand And Gravel Inc. Germantown 103602 1734,272 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1258,727 179 Waterbury Hill Rd Sur Ct #12439 1734,272 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1258,727 Lagrangeville, NY 12540 ACRES 59.86 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1258,727 EAST-0685675 NRTH-1201113 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1258,727 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C478 PG-F1250 475,545 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 2477,531 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-20 ****************** CR 10 149.-1-20 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Meacher Thomas Germantown 103602 25,656 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,800 Box 142 County Rt 10 FRNT 192.72 DPTH 133.32 134,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 134,800 Germantown, NY 12526 BANKC031720 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,240 EAST-0669225 NRTH-1216750 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 134,800 TO M DEED BOOK 0552 PG-00613 FULL MARKET VALUE 192,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-25 ****************** Dock Rd 138.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Meagher Brendan As Truste Germantown 103602 39,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 235,960 Meagher Sophie ACRES 0.75 BANKC031730 235,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 235,960 111 Station Hill Rd EAST-0666800 NRTH-1219285 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 209,400 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C449 PG-F1296 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 235,960 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 337,086 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 219 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-47 **************** Highland Ave 192.20-2-47 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 70,992 Meagher Robert Jr Pine Plains 134201 27,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 70,992 97 Holly Ave Twin Lakes 70,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,992 Hempstead, NY 11550 FRNT 132.03 DPTH 77.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 70,992 TO M EAST-0683990 NRTH-1177640 DEED BOOK C429 PG-F1469 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,417 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-55 **************** Private Rd 192.20-2-55 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,808 Meagher Robert Jr Pine Plains 134201 3,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,808 528 Wateredge Ave Twin Lakes 3,808 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,808 Baldwin, NY 11510 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 101.05 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,808 TO M EAST-0683940 NRTH-1177580 DEED BOOK C0319 PG-F1171 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-57 **************** Private Rd 192.20-2-57 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 118,864 Meagher Robert Jr Pine Plains 134201 59,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,864 528 Wateredge Ave Twin Lakes 118,864 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,864 Baldwin, NY 11510 ACRES 0.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 118,864 TO M EAST-0684061 NRTH-1177521 DEED BOOK C0319 PG-F1167 FULL MARKET VALUE 169,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-42 ****************** Off Weaver Rd 192.-1-42 323 Vacant rural COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 118,048 Meddaugh James Pine Plains 134201 118,048 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,048 78 Vosburgh Rd ACRES 27.00 118,048 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,048 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0686030 NRTH-1177704 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 118,048 TO M DEED BOOK C419 PG-F0047 FULL MARKET VALUE 168,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-8 ******************* 3517 US 9 140.-1-8 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,370 27,370 0 Medins Karlis Sr Hudson 100600 27,500 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Medins Frances C FRNT 89.12 DPTH 244.25 109,480 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,110 3517 Us 9 EAST-0691805 NRTH-1221253 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,110 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 567 PG-50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,920 FULL MARKET VALUE 156,400 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,480 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 220 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-14.210 ************** Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-14.210 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 149,289 149,289 149,289 Meisner Stuart Hudson 100600 198,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 111,695 Meisner Norman Micro 96-10 & 98-267 260,984 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,695 174 Church Rd ACRES 58.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 111,695 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698010 NRTH-1213446 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 111,695 TO M DEED BOOK C0324 PG-F1295 149,289 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 372,834 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-10.100 ************** US 9 140.-1-10.100 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 30,674 30,674 30,674 Meisner Stuart M Hudson 100600 31,280 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 606 Meisner Norman Micro 93-176 31,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 606 174 Church Rd ACRES 2.50 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 606 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692745 NRTH-1221255 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 606 TO M DEED BOOK C499 PG-F428 30,674 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 44,686 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-14 ****************** 5276 SR 9G 138.-1-14 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Melino Angelo Jr Germantown 103602 40,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,688 Melino Candace ACRES 1.10 82,688 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,688 5276 Rte 9G EAST-0668968 NRTH-1220599 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,128 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0493 PG-00778 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,688 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 118,126 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-54 **************** North Shore Dr Lot 9 192.20-2-54 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 102,544 Melnick Mark Pine Plains 134201 62,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 102,544 50 Glenbrook Rd Apt 8B Twin Lakes 102,544 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,544 Stamford, CT 06902 FRNT 145.34 DPTH 161.36 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 102,544 TO M BANK0020715 EAST-0683840 NRTH-1177550 DEED BOOK 605 PG-2275 FULL MARKET VALUE 146,491 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-40.200 ************** Rte 9 Bells Pond Lot 2 140.-1-40.200 465 Prof. bldg. COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 517,480 Meppen Philip A Hudson 100600 91,245 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 517,480 28 Sherwood Acres Rd ACRES 3.00 BANK0080490 517,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 517,480 East Nassau, NY 12062 EAST-0691782 NRTH-1217604 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 517,480 TO M DEED BOOK C0370 PG-F2136 FULL MARKET VALUE 739,257 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 221 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-77.121 ************** Private Rd 149.-1-77.121 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,032 Mergendahl Jerome J Germantown 103602 56,032 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,032 Fenn Kathleen M ACRES 4.09 56,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,032 119 Main St EAST-0671902 NRTH-1213065 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,032 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 628 PG-1189 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,046 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-48 ***************** Honor Rd Lt 127-1/2 Of 201.8-1-48 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Merritt Allen Pine Plains 134201 32,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 24 Honor Rd Reilly Twin Lake 125,664 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,104 EAST-0682368 NRTH-1173537 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,664 TO M DEED BOOK C511 PG-F401 FULL MARKET VALUE 179,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-17.120 ************** Off Water St 152.-1-17.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 10,744 Merritt William Hudson 100600 10,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 10,744 Merritt Nancy FRNT 150.27 DPTH 225.36 10,744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 10,744 308 Water Street Rd EAST-0698875 NRTH-1211008 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 10,744 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0578 PG-00660 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,349 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-18 ****************** 308 Water St 152.-1-18 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Merritt William Hudson 100600 19,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 132,600 308 Water Street Rd FRNT 150.00 DPTH 85.00 132,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 132,600 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698995 NRTH-1210968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 106,040 DEED BOOK 0499 PG-00279 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 132,600 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 189,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-45 ****************** U.s. 9 & Orchard Rd Lot 1 140.-1-45 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 74,800 Messina Ron Hudson 100600 74,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 74,800 200 Tibet Dr ACRES 2.00 74,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,800 Carmel, NY 10512 EAST-0730599 NRTH-0547085 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 74,800 TO M DEED BOOK 543 PG-1364 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-44.2 **************** U.s. 9 & Orchard Rd Lot 1 140.-1-44.2 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,488 Messina Ronald M Hudson 100600 55,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,488 Consigliati Vincenzo ACRES 2.80 55,488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,488 200 Tibet Dr EAST-0730119 NRTH-0547094 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,488 TO M Carmel, NY 10512 DEED BOOK 560 PG-1633 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 222 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-38 ****************** 2120 Rte 9 170.-1-38 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,808 Messina Ronald M Red Hook 134801 54,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,808 200 Tibet Dr ACRES 2.01 BANK0080490 54,808 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,808 Carmel, NY 12512 EAST-0677049 NRTH-1193886 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,808 TO M DEED BOOK 526 PG-2114 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-54.112 ************** 511 C R 10 150.-1-54.112 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 211,700 Meyer George Germantown 103602 36,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 211,700 Moran Martha Drawer 'X' 211,700 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 211,700 54 Murray Hill Sq ACRES 1.02 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 211,700 TO M New Providence, NJ 07974 EAST-0675704 NRTH-1211872 DEED BOOK 569 PG-1353 FULL MARKET VALUE 302,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-27 ****************** Us 9 Bells Pond 140.-1-27 453 Large retail COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 783,088 Mid Valley Oil Co Inc Hudson 100600 142,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 783,088 221 Quinebaug Rd ACRES 1.00 783,088 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 783,088 North Grosvenordale, CT EAST-0688886 NRTH-1218798 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 783,088 TO M 06255-1123 DEED BOOK 00753 PG-00067 FULL MARKET VALUE 1118,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-29.200 ************** CR 31 170.-2-29.200 432 Gas station COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 421,736 Mid Valley Oil Co Inc Red Hook 134801 30,099 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 421,736 221 Quinebaug Rd Micro 10881 421,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 421,736 North Grosvenordale, CT ACRES 0.39 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 421,736 TO M 06255-1123 EAST-0675879 NRTH-1193984 DEED BOOK 00753 PG-00095 FULL MARKET VALUE 602,480 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-59 ****************** Wire Rd 160.-1-59 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Middlebrooks John Germantown 103602 49,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 158,032 556 Wire Rd ACRES 5.26 158,032 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 158,032 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0713552 NRTH-0545733 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,472 DEED BOOK C0485 PG-F1983 FULL MARKET VALUE 225,760 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 223 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-44.110 ************** CR 10 150.-1-44.110 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 346,664 Miller Barbara Kaska Germantown 103602 68,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 346,664 Attn: Steven Miller ACRES 9.00 BANKC061222 346,664 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 346,664 100 Huntington St EAST-0674563 NRTH-1212550 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 346,664 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11231-3917 DEED BOOK C406 PG-F0028 FULL MARKET VALUE 495,234 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-52 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-52 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,600 Miller Christopher M Germantown 103602 17,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,600 Miller Carmen A FRNT 85.00 DPTH 120.00 183,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,600 Route 9G BANK0210090 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,600 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0666852 NRTH-1218565 DEED BOOK C0490 PG-F1473 FULL MARKET VALUE 262,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-30 ***************** 34 Shore Dr Lot 46 201.8-2-30 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 22,032 22,032 0 Miller Filomena Pine Plains 134201 14,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Miller Scott Reilly Twin Lake 88,128 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 66,096 8 Major Rd FRNT 50.97 DPTH 93.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 66,096 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682838 NRTH-1173538 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,568 DEED BOOK 0455 PG-00393 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 88,128 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 125,897 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-98 ****************** 330 CR 10 149.-1-98 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 17,610 17,610 17,610 Miller George Germantown 103602 84,700 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Miller Linda ACRES 18.86 291,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 274,290 330 County Rte 10 EAST-0672529 NRTH-1214606 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 274,290 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 687 PG-172 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 247,730 FULL MARKET VALUE 417,000 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 274,290 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 17,610 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-6 ******************* 107 Oak Hill Rd 128.-1-6 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Miller Janet Dorothy Hudson 100600 30,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 128,520 107 Oak Hill Rd FRNT 81.52 DPTH 268.00 128,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 128,520 Hudson, NY 12534 BANKC130170 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,250 EAST-0671435 NRTH-1227113 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 128,520 TO M DEED BOOK 0608 PG-01100 FULL MARKET VALUE 183,600 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 224 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-4 ****************** 86 Hapeman Rd Lot 4 201.2-1-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Miller Jeffrey Pine Plains 134201 31,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 86 Hapeman Rd FRNT 75.72 DPTH 400.00 120,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,768 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681561 NRTH-1177146 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,208 DEED BOOK 0658 PG-00315 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,768 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 172,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-68 ****************** CR 10 149.-1-68 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 34,005 34,005 34,005 Miller Linda A Germantown 103602 113,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,523 330 county rte. 10 ACRES 37.99 142,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,523 germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671320 NRTH-1214094 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 108,523 DEED BOOK 540 PG-539 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,523 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 203,611 34,005 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-38 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-38 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 140,624 Miller Robert L Hudson 100600 62,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 140,624 151 Willowbrook Rd ACRES 7.00 BANKC061222 140,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 140,624 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696219 NRTH-1203783 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 140,624 TO M DEED BOOK C0303 PG-F1840 FULL MARKET VALUE 200,891 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-79 ****************** Scuderhook Rd Lot 1 171.-1-79 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,152 Miller Ronald Germantown 103602 47,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,152 Mallon Regina Micro 10694 164,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 164,152 210 Scudderhook Rd ACRES 2.23 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,152 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0691501 NRTH-1197564 DEED BOOK C475 PG-F2045 FULL MARKET VALUE 234,503 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-80 ****************** Scuderhook Rd Lot 2 171.-1-80 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Miller Ronald Germantown 103602 55,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Mallon Regina Micro 11741 55,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 210 Scudderhook Rd ACRES 2.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,352 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0691552 NRTH-1197214 DEED BOOK C475 PG-F2045 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,074 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 225 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-49 ****************** 367 SR 82 151.-1-49 270 Mfg housing AGED - ALL 41800 16,320 16,320 16,320 Miller William P Hudson 100600 15,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 16,320 Miller Lynn L FRNT 200.00 DPTH 120.00 32,640 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 16,320 Leonore Coons EAST-0696556 NRTH-1210483 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 16,320 367 State Rte 82 DEED BOOK 00769 PG-00044 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,629 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,640 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-34 ****************** 183 CR 10 149.-1-34 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Millius Susan Germantown 103602 30,429 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,096 183 County Rt 10 FRNT 82.50 DPTH 264.00 100,096 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,096 Germantown, NY 12526 BANKC080005 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 73,536 EAST-0669926 NRTH-1216311 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 100,096 TO M DEED BOOK C0317 PG-F1206 FULL MARKET VALUE 142,994 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-35 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Miszkiel Taddee Pine Plains 134201 30,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,352 135 Ocean Parkway #15R Twin Lakes 0001 157,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,352 Brooklyn, NY 11218 FRNT 55.28 DPTH 125.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,792 EAST-0682930 NRTH-1177858 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,352 TO M DEED BOOK C426 PG-F1113 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,789 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-36 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-36 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 Miszkiel Taddee Pine Plains 134201 37,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 135 Ocean Parkway #15R Twin Lakes 0001 37,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 Brooklyn, NY 11218 FRNT 65.00 DPTH 128.01 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,672 TO M EAST-0683000 NRTH-1177849 DEED BOOK C426 PG-F1113 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-34 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-34 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,008 Miszkiel Taddee Jean Pine Plains 134201 48,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,008 135 Ocean Parkway #15R Pb 22 Pg 1602 0001 48,008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,008 Brooklyn, NY 11218 FRNT 106.00 DPTH 127.31 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,008 TO M EAST-0682840 NRTH-1177868 DEED BOOK C426 PG-F1113 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,583 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 226 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-9.100 *************** 128 Mambert Rd 152.-1-9.100 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Mitchell George Copake-Taconic 102801 83,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Mitchell Anna T ACRES 28.20 184,824 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,216 128 Mambert Rd EAST-0701249 NRTH-1214092 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,216 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00772 PG-00107 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 134,554 FULL MARKET VALUE 264,034 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 184,824 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-29 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-29 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mizutani Nobuo Pine Plains 134201 20,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 152,900 Mizutani Lucie FRNT 51.00 DPTH 210.00 152,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 152,900 693 Route 2 EAST-0682650 NRTH-1172818 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,340 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 613 PG-1550 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 152,900 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 218,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-2 ******************* Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-2 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Molinari Albert Germantown 103602 53,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Molinari Theresa ACRES 9.00 147,288 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 119,680 124 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0687771 NRTH-1192547 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 119,680 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0408 PG-00196 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,728 FULL MARKET VALUE 210,411 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 147,288 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-50.112 ************** 163 schneider Rd 151.-1-50.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Molinski Brian J Hudson 100600 60,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,600 Molinski Gina M ACRES 5.60 215,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,600 163 schneider Rd FULL MARKET VALUE 308,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 189,040 hudson, NY 12534 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,600 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-94 ****************** 490 Off Church Rd Pcl 2 & 3 161.-1-94 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Molinski Tammy Hudson 100600 57,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 247,180 Molinski Walter Jr ACRES 5.57 BANKC130020 247,180 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 247,180 490 Church Rd EAST-0688801 NRTH-1205398 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 220,620 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0647 PG-00091 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 247,180 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 353,114 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 247,180 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-12 ***************** Private Rd 192.4-2-12 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 93,568 Monaco Anthony J Pine Plains 134201 42,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,568 14 Huntington Rd Twin Lakes 93,568 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,568 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 ACRES 0.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 93,568 TO M EAST-0684190 NRTH-1177671 DEED BOOK 00709 PG-00031 FULL MARKET VALUE 133,669 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 227 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-19 **************** Highland Ave 192.20-2-19 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 Monaco Christopher Pine Plains 134201 36,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 14 Huntington Rd Twin Lakes 36,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,040 TO M BANKC080496 EAST-0683519 NRTH-1178369 DEED BOOK C0367 PG-F1067 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,486 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-18 **************** LOT 98N Fairview Rd 192.20-2-18 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Monaco Chrristopher Pine Plains 134201 35,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 14 Huntington Rd Twin Lakes 105,264 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,264 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 FRNT 69.71 DPTH 128.66 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,704 BANKC080496 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,264 TO M EAST-0683589 NRTH-1178360 DEED BOOK C0367 PG-F1067 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,377 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-3-1 ****************** 73 Mt View Dr 192.4-3-1 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 196,384 Mondello Joseph Pine Plains 134201 43,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 196,384 160 Beaver Rd ACRES 1.30 196,384 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 196,384 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0683207 NRTH-1179449 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 196,384 TO M DEED BOOK 619 PG-2161 FULL MARKET VALUE 280,549 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-36 ****************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-36 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 749,768 Montgomery Robert K Germantown 103602 200,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 749,768 404 White Birch Rd ACRES 76.00 749,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 749,768 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672700 NRTH-1219016 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 749,768 TO M DEED BOOK 00798 PG-00158 FULL MARKET VALUE 1071,097 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-37 ****************** Off White Birch Rd 138.-1-37 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,576 Montgomery Robert K Germantown 103602 56,576 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,576 404 White Birch Rd ACRES 11.80 56,576 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,576 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671481 NRTH-1218844 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,576 TO M DEED BOOK C470 PG-F1452 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,823 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 228 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-37 ****************** 1908 CR 8 181.-1-37 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Moon Christopher P Germantown 103602 37,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,072 Concra Margaret M ACRES 1.09 126,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,072 1908 Cr 8 EAST-0684550 NRTH-1188131 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,512 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 599 PG-2330 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 126,072 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 180,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-40 ***************** 85 CR 19 161.1-1-40 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 37,048 37,048 0 Moore Barbara Hudson 100600 45,000 AGED - ALL 41800 48,048 48,048 66,572 PO Box 17 ACRES 2.00 133,144 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0688444 NRTH-1206768 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,048 DEED BOOK C0286 PG-F2142 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,048 FULL MARKET VALUE 190,206 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 16,302 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 133,144 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 133,144 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-43 ****************** 668 CR 19 170.-2-43 240 Rural res AGED C 41802 119,204 0 0 Moore Barbara Germantown 103602 199,300 AGED T&S 41806 0 107,284 107,284 668 Rte 19 ACRES 58.00 BANKH110045 238,408 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684938 NRTH-1194071 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 119,204 DEED BOOK 0511 PG-00141 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,124 FULL MARKET VALUE 340,583 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,854 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 238,408 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-44 ***************** Major Rd Lts 147-148 201.8-1-44 220 2 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Moore Bradley K Pine Plains 134201 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 236,900 17 Major Rd Bk18 Pg1374 236,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 236,900 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 210,340 ACRES 0.57 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 236,900 TO M EAST-0682559 NRTH-1175809 DEED BOOK 631 PG-1871 FULL MARKET VALUE 338,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-42 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-42 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Moore Karen A Germantown 103602 55,016 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 223,312 Moore David ACRES 6.10 223,312 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 223,312 1895 County Route 8 EAST-0684281 NRTH-1187670 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 196,752 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 633 PG-318 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 223,312 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 319,017 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 229 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-18.100 ************* 50 Pine Rd 201.2-1-18.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 Moore Kenneth Jr Pine Plains 134201 48,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 50 Pine Rd ACRES 2.47 117,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681122 NRTH-1176905 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,776 TO M DEED BOOK C0338 PG-F2033 FULL MARKET VALUE 168,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-18.200 ************* 50 Pine Rd 201.2-1-18.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Moore Kenneth Jr Pine Plains 134201 46,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,544 Moore Janet ACRES 1.89 170,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,544 50 Pine Rd EAST-0680952 NRTH-1176755 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,984 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0655 PG-00230 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,544 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 243,634 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-9.200 *************** CR 19 170.-2-9.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,640 Moore Robert Germantown 103602 32,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,640 Moore Laurence E Micro 10940 32,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,640 607 County Rte 19 ACRES 2.90 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,640 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0686205 NRTH-1195894 DEED BOOK C0287 PG-F0269 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,629 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-10 ****************** 607 CR 19 170.-2-10 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 120,817 120,817 0 Moore Robert Germantown 103602 23,900 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Moore Laurence E FRNT 200.00 DPTH 120.00 121,992 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,175 607 County Rte 19 EAST-0686016 NRTH-1195483 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,175 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0287 PG-F0269 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 71,722 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,274 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 121,992 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-68 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-68 230 3 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Moore Robert Q Hudson 100600 20,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,288 PO Box 117 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 175.00 130,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,288 Livingston, NY 12541 BANKH080005 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,728 EAST-0686777 NRTH-1205154 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,288 TO M DEED BOOK 0583 PG-00274 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 130,288 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 186,126 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 230 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-59 ***************** Church Rd 161.1-1-59 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 114,104 Moore Veronica Hudson 100600 57,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 114,104 Maltby Elizabeth ACRES 8.30 114,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 114,104 347 State Farm St EAST-0688126 NRTH-1205557 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,104 TO M Valatie, NY 12184 DEED BOOK 558 PG-773 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 114,104 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 163,006 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-9 ******************* CR 19 192.-1-9 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,864 Morales Aida Germantown 103602 27,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,864 Gambino Maria Melissa FRNT 100.00 DPTH 200.00 67,864 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 67,864 1001 Country Cove Ct BANK0020133 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 67,864 TO M Oviedo, FL 32766 EAST-0682857 NRTH-1184298 DEED BOOK 619 PG-1940 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,949 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-29 ****************** 19 Short Rd 152.-1-29 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Moriarty John Hudson 100600 70,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 218,960 19 Short Rd ACRES 14.67 218,960 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 218,960 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698857 NRTH-1209708 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 192,400 DEED BOOK 00695 PG-00284 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,960 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 312,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-49 ****************** Water St 152.-1-49 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,520 Moriarty John Copake-Taconic 102801 26,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,520 19 Short Rd Micro 97-264 26,520 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,520 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 3.13 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 26,520 TO M EAST-0699491 NRTH-1209808 DEED BOOK C0325 PG-F2428 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,886 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-59.200 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-59.200 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 54,314 54,314 54,314 Morizio Tonino Germantown 103602 109,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,278 Pasquale Gabriel Micro 12078 237,592 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,278 104 Blair Rd ACRES 21.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,278 Oyster Bay, NY 11771 EAST-0691969 NRTH-1203955 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,278 TO M DEED BOOK 00698 PG-00004 54,314 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 339,417 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 231 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-50 ****************** Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-50 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 160,752 Morrison Joseph Germantown 103602 55,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 160,752 Schaff Frank ACRES 5.00 160,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,752 64 Deer Haven Rd EAST-0686719 NRTH-1193945 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,752 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0565 PG-00626 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,646 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-1 ******************* 291 Orchard Rd 151.-1-1 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 59,670 0 0 Morrison Norman F Hudson 100600 57,000 AGED T&S 41806 0 39,780 39,780 Morrison Patricia T Micro 93-146 132,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 291 Orchard Rd ACRES 3.20 BANKH020151 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,930 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0687844 NRTH-1216766 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,820 DEED BOOK 0500 PG-00909 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,550 FULL MARKET VALUE 189,429 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 89,900 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-2.200 *************** 261 Orchard Rd 151.-1-2.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Morrison Norman F Jr Hudson 100600 67,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 162,928 261 Orchard Rd ACRES 6.32 162,928 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 162,928 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688314 NRTH-1217027 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,368 DEED BOOK 00775 PG-00347 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 162,928 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 232,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-2.120 *************** Orchard Rd 151.-1-2.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Morrison Stephen L Hudson 100600 67,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,360 271 Orchard Rd Micro 93-146 154,360 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,360 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 6.32 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,800 EAST-0688146 NRTH-1217084 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,360 TO M DEED BOOK 607 PG-1054 FULL MARKET VALUE 220,514 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-4 ******************* 5532 Jt Greenport 138.-1-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Morrissey/lossow Delilah Hudson 100600 40,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 194,072 5532 Rte 9G ACRES 2.64 194,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 194,072 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0671549 NRTH-1225164 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 167,512 DEED BOOK 0627 PG-00260 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 194,072 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 277,246 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 232 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-13.120 ************** Spring Rd 139.-1-13.120 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,128 Moses Andrew Hudson 100600 37,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,128 542 E 14Th St Apt 19 Micro 10930 37,128 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,128 New York, NY 10099 ACRES 27.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,128 TO M EAST-0681721 NRTH-1223524 DEED BOOK C0339 PG-F2249 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-1.200 *************** White Birch Rd 139.-1-1.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mossman Clint Hudson 100600 56,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 239,768 Mossman Lori Micro 9432 239,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 239,768 152 White Birch Rd ACRES 3.26 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 213,208 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674109 NRTH-1225029 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 239,768 TO M DEED BOOK 0591 PG-00646 FULL MARKET VALUE 342,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-45 ****************** CR 31 Rd 160.-1-45 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 405,667 405,667 405,667 Mountain Range Farms Germantown 103602 502,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 587,405 Dale's Bridge Rd ACRES 168.00 993,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 587,405 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676589 NRTH-1204115 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 587,405 DEED BOOK 00751 PG-00057 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 587,405 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1418,674 405,667 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-48 ****************** CR 31 160.-1-48 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 390,331 390,331 390,331 Mountian Range Farm Red Hook 134801 486,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 307,485 Dales Bridge Rd ACRES 209.54 697,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 307,485 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0677634 NRTH-1201457 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 307,485 DEED BOOK 00751 PG-00054 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 307,485 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 996,880 390,331 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-21 ****************** CR 8 182.-1-21 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 323,680 Mullin's Midwood Manor Germantown 103602 223,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 323,680 Inc ACRES 140.30 323,680 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 323,680 Attn: Margaret M Doerr EAST-0686257 NRTH-1189704 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 323,680 TO M 1326 Route 212 DEED BOOK 00695 PG-00256 Saugerties, NY 12477 FULL MARKET VALUE 462,400 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 233 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-43 ****************** C R 10 149.-1-43 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,528 Munz Jason Germantown 103602 33,974 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,528 203 County Rte 10 ACRES 5.30 40,528 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,528 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670207 NRTH-1215891 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,528 TO M DEED BOOK 583 PG-1997 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,897 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-37 ****************** 203 CR 10 149.-1-37 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Munz Jason A Germantown 103602 34,247 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,080 203 CR 10 FRNT 177.00 DPTH 170.00 123,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 123,080 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670346 NRTH-1216182 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,520 DEED BOOK 649 PG-2310 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 123,080 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 175,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-59 ****************** 551 CR 31 139.-1-59 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Muriel Doyne As Truste J Germantown 103602 40,100 AGED - ALL 41800 41,616 41,616 55,420 Margery Miller Irrevocabl ACRES 2.50 110,840 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 551 Route 31 EAST-0677760 NRTH-1219006 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,616 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C513 PG-F1113 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,616 FULL MARKET VALUE 158,343 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,150 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,840 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-15.200 ************** Water St 152.-1-15.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 23,120 Muro Frank Copake-Taconic 102801 23,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 23,120 Muro Angela ACRES 5.00 23,120 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 23,120 16 Harold Ave EAST-0699489 NRTH-1213939 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 23,120 TO M Greenwich, CT 06830 DEED BOOK 0653 PG-00304 FULL MARKET VALUE 33,029 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-73 ****************** C R 10 149.-1-73 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,888 Murphy Robin Germantown 103602 51,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,888 Murphy Gary ACRES 4.00 143,888 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,888 PO Box 6 EAST-0672641 NRTH-1213606 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,888 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 579 PG-126 FULL MARKET VALUE 205,554 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-52.212 ************** Lockwood Rd 161.-1-52.212 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,376 Murray Suzanne Hudson 100600 78,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,376 Living ACRES 11.98 BANKH061230 148,376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 148,376 28-05 56th Pl EAST-0690123 NRTH-1203498 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,376 TO M Woodside, NY 11377 DEED BOOK 00277 PG-01546 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,966 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 234 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-17.121 ************** CR 31 170.-1-17.121 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,632 Mwd Llc Red Hook 134801 75,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,632 11 Elm St Micro 9058 137,632 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,632 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 1.89 BANKC130170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 137,632 TO M EAST-0716144 NRTH-0544818 DEED BOOK C410 PG-F726 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,617 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-17.122 ************** CR 31 170.-1-17.122 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 224,128 Mwd Llc Red Hook 134801 51,903 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 224,128 11 Elm St Micro 9058 224,128 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 224,128 Red Hook, NY 12571 ACRES 1.10 BANKC130170 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 224,128 TO M EAST-0716054 NRTH-0544838 DEED BOOK C410 PG-F726 FULL MARKET VALUE 320,183 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-17 ****************** 1740 CR 8 181.-1-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Myers Nancy Red Hook 134801 54,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,408 1740 Rte 8 ACRES 2.90 136,408 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,408 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681096 NRTH-1190394 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,848 DEED BOOK 0495 PG-00400 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,408 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 194,869 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-3 ******************* 118 Oak Hill Rd 128.-1-3 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Mylroie Sarah Hudson 100600 55,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 86,500 PO Box 304 ACRES 3.00 86,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 86,500 Chatham, NY 12037-0304 EAST-0670735 NRTH-1227252 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 59,940 DEED BOOK C0281 PG-F1021 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 86,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 123,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-7 ******************* 5461 SR 9G 138.-1-7 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Nack Arthur F Jr Germantown 103602 35,000 AGED - ALL 41800 64,546 64,546 72,828 Nack Karol ACRES 1.00 145,656 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 5461 Rte 9G EAST-0670532 NRTH-1223422 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,545 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0432 PG-00256 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 64,545 FULL MARKET VALUE 208,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 22,558 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,656 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 235 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-5 ****************** 2879 Cold Spring Rd 161.1-1-5 280 Multiple res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Nack Sunnie Hudson 100600 44,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 164,560 Nack Linda Micro 4659 164,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 164,560 2879 Rte 9 ACRES 1.90 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,000 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0687403 NRTH-1206956 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,560 TO M DEED BOOK 00791 PG-00266 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 164,560 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 235,086 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-6 ******************* 5465 SR 9G 138.-1-6 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Nack William T Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 146,880 Nack Claudia E ACRES 2.00 146,880 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 146,880 5465 Sr 9G EAST-0670582 NRTH-1223562 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,610 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 641 PG-1899 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 146,880 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 209,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-3-8 ****************** Lakeview Dr 192.4-3-8 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 66,640 Najda Raymond J Pine Plains 134201 66,640 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 66,640 28 Highland Ave ACRES 1.70 66,640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,640 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683178 NRTH-1178899 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 66,640 TO M DEED BOOK C0344 PG-F1656 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-2 ***************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-2 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 6,773 0 0 Najda Raymond J Pine Plains 134201 64,000 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 28 High Land Ave Twin Lakes 135,456 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 128,683 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 227.12 DPTH 125.80 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,456 EAST-0682869 NRTH-1178478 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 85,186 DEED BOOK C0280 PG-F1876 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,456 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 193,509 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-41.120 ************** C R 8 181.-1-41.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 263,976 Naraine Patrick Germantown 103602 31,259 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 263,976 4114 White Plains Rd ACRES 0.95 263,976 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 263,976 Bronx, NY 10466 EAST-0684591 NRTH-1187781 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 263,976 TO M DEED BOOK 625 PG-2319 FULL MARKET VALUE 377,109 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 236 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-57 ****************** 17 CR 10 138.-1-57 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Navins Peter Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 142,800 17 County Rt 10 Micro 2920 142,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 142,800 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 1.38 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,240 EAST-0667501 NRTH-1218746 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 142,800 TO M DEED BOOK 00745 PG-00236 FULL MARKET VALUE 204,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-13.200 ************** 130 Spring Rd 139.-1-13.200 151 Fruit crop AG 10 YEAR 41700 25,000 25,000 25,000 Nayowith Jessica Hudson 100600 191,500 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 (For Martin Nayowith) ACRES 41.32 329,664 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 304,664 130 Spring Rd EAST-0682673 NRTH-1222636 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 304,664 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 598 PG-2302 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 254,394 FULL MARKET VALUE 470,949 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 329,664 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2010 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-73 ****************** Off Spring Rd 139.-1-73 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2,584 Nayowith Jessica Hudson 100600 2,584 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2,584 (Martin Nayowith Trust) ACRES 0.37 2,584 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2,584 130 Spring Rd EAST-0683504 NRTH-1222157 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2,584 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 598 PG-2306 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,691 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-80.120 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-80.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,632 Neceda Diana Hudson 100600 69,632 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,632 Neceda Richard ACRES 7.50 BANK0080490 69,632 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,632 PO Box 602 EAST-0693503 NRTH-1206758 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 69,632 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0668 PG-00105 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-28 ****************** 356 Water St 152.-1-28 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 160,752 Nehez Nicholas J III Hudson 100600 36,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 160,752 356 Water St Micro 724 160,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,752 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 300.00 DPTH 135.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,752 TO M BANKC031720 EAST-0698557 NRTH-1209977 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F1017 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,646 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 237 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-3-8 ****************** TS 190-19 Whitman Rd 201.8-3-8 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Neilson Linda Marie Pine Plains 134201 19,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,768 Esteves Pamela L Reilly Twin Lake 137,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,768 22 Whitman Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 111,208 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683117 NRTH-1174199 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 137,768 TO M DEED BOOK C0364 PG-F1860 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,811 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-48 ****************** 2710 Rte 9 161.-1-48 210 1 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 11,683 11,683 11,683 Nelson George Hudson 100600 62,300 AGED C 41802 131,762 0 0 Nelson Melanie ACRES 7.39 341,088 AGED T&S 41806 0 82,351 82,351 Box 209 EAST-0685482 NRTH-1202662 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 00788 PG-00009 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,643 FULL MARKET VALUE 487,269 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 247,054 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 196,784 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 329,405 TO M 11,683 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-75.12 ************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-75.12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Neuman Todd H Pine Plains 134201 41,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 101 Parker Rd Micro No 11810 198,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Elizaville, NY 12523 Bk16 Pg1966 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,728 ACRES 1.24 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,288 TO M EAST-0682026 NRTH-1174877 DEED BOOK C478 PG-F705 FULL MARKET VALUE 283,269 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-37 ****************** 9 Short Rd 152.-1-37 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Newberry Raymond Hudson 100600 28,500 AGED C 41802 51,272 0 0 Newberry Anna FRNT 140.00 DPTH 200.00 130,152 AGED T&S 41806 0 46,145 58,568 9 Short Rd EAST-0698189 NRTH-1209007 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0409 PG-00103 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 51,272 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,931 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,399 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,314 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,152 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 238 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-1 ******************* 205 Bells Pond Rd 152.-1-1 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 96,619 96,619 96,619 Nolan Francis X Copake-Taconic 102801 196,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Nolan Deborah M ACRES 55.00 662,592 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 565,973 40 Park Ave Apt 8D EAST-0697803 NRTH-1217305 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 565,973 New York, NY 10016 DEED BOOK C496 PG-F1213 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 539,413 FULL MARKET VALUE 946,560 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 565,973 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 96,619 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-2 ******************* Bells Pond Rd 152.-1-2 322 Rural vac>10 AG DISTRIC 41720 48,474 48,474 48,474 Nolan Francis X Copake-Taconic 102801 61,336 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 12,862 Nolan Deborah M ACRES 11.10 61,336 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 12,862 40 Park Ave Apt 8D EAST-0698323 NRTH-1216986 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 12,862 New York, NY 10016 DEED BOOK C496 PG-F1213 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 12,862 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 87,623 48,474 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 159.-1-1 ******************* 305 Wire Rd 159.-1-1 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Nordfors Felix E Sr Germantown 103602 174,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 274,176 305 Wire Rd ACRES 22.50 274,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 274,176 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672170 NRTH-1208886 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 247,616 DEED BOOK 0574 PG-00809 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 274,176 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 391,680 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-63.200 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-63.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 317,288 Norris Robert Hudson 100600 57,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 317,288 Norris Ilene Margolin Micro 10769 317,288 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 317,288 RR 2 Box 62A ACRES 5.68 BANKH110045 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 317,288 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696811 NRTH-1202544 DEED BOOK 0621 PG-00329 FULL MARKET VALUE 453,269 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-14.220 ************** Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-14.220 312 Vac w/imprv BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Northup Scott Hudson 100600 38,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 52,632 Northup Leslie Micro 98-267 52,632 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 52,632 95 Ten Broeck Rd ACRES 2.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,072 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698566 NRTH-1212618 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 52,632 TO M DEED BOOK C0359 PG-F0917 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,189 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 239 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-40 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-40 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Novak James Hudson 100600 39,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 156,128 160 Willowbrook Rd ACRES 1.40 BANK0080490 156,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 156,128 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0695639 NRTH-1203592 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 129,568 DEED BOOK 0651 PG-00025 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 156,128 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 223,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-50 ***************** Baxter Rd 201.8-1-50 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 NRLL East, LLC Pine Plains 134201 41,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 1 Mauchly Reilly Twin Lake 41,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 41,072 Irvine, CA 92618 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 41,072 TO M EAST-0682478 NRTH-1173558 DEED BOOK 611 PG-568 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-32 ***************** Major Rd Lts 138-151 201.8-1-32 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 99,144 O'connor John Pine Plains 134201 29,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 99,144 O'connor Lenore Reilly Twin Lake 99,144 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,144 424 Jersey Ave FRNT 100.00 DPTH 200.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 99,144 TO M Spring Lake, NJ 07762 ACRES 0.23 EAST-0682508 NRTH-1173928 DEED BOOK 0529 PG-01135 FULL MARKET VALUE 141,634 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-25 ****************** 344 Water St 152.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Obrien Carol Hudson 100600 38,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 106,216 Obrien Geoffrey FRNT 180.00 DPTH 250.00 106,216 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 106,216 344 Water St EAST-0698697 NRTH-1210208 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 79,656 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0605 PG-00359 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 106,216 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 151,737 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-63.11 *************** Church Rd 161.-1-63.11 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 132,899 132,899 132,899 Ockenga Starr Hudson 100600 295,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 PO Box pobox2 Micro 06-211 737,684 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 604,785 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 50.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 604,785 EAST-0696160 NRTH-0120190 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 578,225 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 538 PG-2046 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 604,785 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 1053,834 132,899 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 240 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-63.12 *************** Church Rd 161.-1-63.12 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 244,100 Ockenga Starr Hudson 100600 244,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 244,100 Church Rd Micro #06-211 244,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 244,100 PO Box 2 ACRES 28.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 244,100 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0695270 NRTH-0120170 FULL MARKET VALUE 348,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-60 ***************** Shore Dr., Lot 8 201.2-1-60 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,736 Odarchenko Alexander Pine Plains 134201 22,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,736 1427 Fallsmead Way Reilly Twin Lake 115,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 115,736 Potomac, MD 20854 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 140.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,736 TO M EAST-0682556 NRTH-1174768 DEED BOOK 0536 PG-00803 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,337 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-28 ***************** 71 Private Rd 201.2-1-28 270 Mfg housing WAR VET/CT 41121 8,486 8,486 0 Ogden Bernard Pine Plains 134201 23,800 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Ogden Geraldine FRNT 75.00 DPTH 115.00 56,576 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,090 71 Pine Rd ACRES 0.43 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,090 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681313 NRTH-1176175 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,306 DEED BOOK 0604 PG-00916 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 56,576 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 80,823 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-4 ******************* 96 C R 10 149.-1-4 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ogden Calvin Germantown 103602 46,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 176,256 Ogden Olga Marie ACRES 4.30 BANK0060860 176,256 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 176,256 96 County Rte 10 EAST-0669203 NRTH-1217589 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 149,696 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0649 PG-00325 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,256 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 251,794 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-74 ****************** 359 CR 10 149.-1-74 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Olah Steve J Germantown 103602 53,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,328 Olah Margaret ACRES 4.50 115,328 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,328 359 County Rte 10 EAST-0672161 NRTH-1213615 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 88,768 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0550 PG-00082 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 115,328 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 164,754 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 241 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-40 ****************** Sr 9 170.-1-40 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,200 Olah Steve J Red Hook 134801 58,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,200 Olah Margaret A ACRES 4.30 129,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 129,200 359 Co Rt 10 EAST-0677380 NRTH-1193537 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,200 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C427 PG-F55 FULL MARKET VALUE 184,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-6.112 *************** SR 9 170.-2-6.112 465 Prof. bldg. COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 282,336 Old Farm Road Medical P Red Hook 134801 46,215 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 282,336 Old Farm Rd Micro 8795 282,336 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 282,336 Red Hook, NY 12538 ACRES 1.75 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 282,336 TO M EAST-0681244 NRTH-1196654 DEED BOOK C396 PG-F1704 FULL MARKET VALUE 403,337 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-13 ***************** Loyola Rd.106-107 20 Ft.201.8-2-13 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 Oliveras Esther Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 Guillermo Bk18 Pg1374 117,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 117,776 9 Helen Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,776 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKH110081 EAST-0682953 NRTH-1173749 DEED BOOK 00763 PG-00136 FULL MARKET VALUE 168,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-17 ***************** Whitman Rd 201.8-2-17 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 55,352 55,352 55,352 Oliverius Louis W Pine Plains 134201 37,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 7 Loyola Rd Reilly Twin Lake 110,704 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 EAST-0683267 NRTH-1173989 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,082 DEED BOOK 0553 PG-00938 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 110,704 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 158,149 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-35 **************** Fairview Rd 192.20-2-35 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 Olivieri Joseph Pine Plains 134201 37,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 Curry Mary Twin Lakes 37,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,672 3216 SE 6th St FRNT 60.00 DPTH 135.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,672 TO M Pompano Beach, FL 33062-6202 EAST-0683780 NRTH-1177920 DEED BOOK 0466 PG-00523 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,817 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 242 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-32 ****************** 244 Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-32 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Olsen Thelma R Germantown 103602 89,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 179,248 244 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 17.00 179,248 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 179,248 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681731 NRTH-1213594 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 128,978 DEED BOOK 0521 PG-00218 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 179,248 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 256,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-57 ***************** LOT 12 Shore Dr 201.2-1-57 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 250,000 Olson Craig R Pine Plains 134201 33,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 250,000 Olson Kathleen A Reilly Twin Lake 250,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 250,000 5 Todd Hill Cir FRNT 50.00 DPTH 145.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 250,000 TO M Goldens Bridge, NY 10526 EAST-0682666 NRTH-1174948 DEED BOOK 594 PG-2447 FULL MARKET VALUE 357,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-17 ****************** 112 Rte 82 151.-1-17 220 2 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 67,660 67,660 67,660 Orlich Anthony J Hudson 100600 29,200 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Attn: Orlich Sophie ACRES 0.60 135,320 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,660 112 Rte 82 Apt 2 EAST-0693825 NRTH-1216318 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,660 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0288 PG-F1014 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,390 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,314 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,320 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-50 ****************** Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-50 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ostoyich James G Red Hook 134801 61,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 176,800 Ostoyich Bonnie M Micro 10100 176,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 176,800 41 Bingham Mills Rd ACRES 6.77 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,240 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676288 NRTH-1194335 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,800 TO M DEED BOOK 0602 PG-00903 FULL MARKET VALUE 252,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-5 ******************* 18 Proper Rd 151.-1-5 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Otty John H Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 194,000 Otty Pauline V Micro 5285 194,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 194,000 18 Proper Rd ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,730 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0692733 NRTH-1217115 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 194,000 TO M DEED BOOK 567 PG-646 FULL MARKET VALUE 277,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 243 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-12 ****************** CR 19 170.-2-12 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,272 Ovalle Charles Germantown 103602 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,272 Ovalle Claudia Micro 3130 136,272 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,272 4451 State Route 9G ACRES 2.00 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,272 TO M Germantown, NY 12526-5126 EAST-0685707 NRTH-1194903 DEED BOOK C0282 PG-F1274 FULL MARKET VALUE 194,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-90.200 ************** Wire Rd 149.-1-90.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,824 Owen John Germantown 103602 48,824 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,824 Owen Sandra ACRES 1.17 48,824 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,824 245 Wire Rd EAST-0671493 NRTH-1210119 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,824 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0610 PG-00942 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,749 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-91 ****************** 245 Wire Rd 149.-1-91 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Owen John Germantown 103602 21,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 Owen Sandra FRNT 80.00 DPTH 190.00 125,664 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 125,664 245 Wire Rd BANKH010695 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 99,104 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671617 NRTH-1210265 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 125,664 TO M DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00533 FULL MARKET VALUE 179,520 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-74 ***************** LOT 64 Shore Dr 201.2-1-74 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,856 Paalz Alison Pine Plains 134201 36,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,856 141 Old Country Rd Reilly Twin Lake 36,856 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,856 Melville, NY 11747 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 160.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,856 TO M EAST-0682186 NRTH-1174597 DEED BOOK 642 PG-744 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-77 ***************** 79 Shore Dr Lot 65 201.2-1-77 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 85,000 Paalz Alison Pine Plains 134201 32,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 85,000 141 Old Country Rd Reilly Twin Lake 85,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 85,000 Melville, NY 11747 FRNT 43.00 DPTH 160.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 85,000 TO M EAST-0682166 NRTH-1174537 DEED BOOK 642 PG-744 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,429 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 244 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-15 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-15 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 25,976 Packer Barbara Red Hook 134801 25,976 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 25,976 442 E 58 St FRNT 150.00 DPTH 380.00 25,976 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 25,976 New York, NY 10022 EAST-0680295 NRTH-1190573 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 25,976 TO M DEED BOOK 00681 PG-00070 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,109 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-16 ****************** Buckwheat Rd 181.-1-16 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 226,032 Packer Barbara Red Hook 134801 55,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 226,032 4 42e 58 St ACRES 5.00 226,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 226,032 New York, NY 10022 EAST-0680366 NRTH-1190303 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 226,032 TO M DEED BOOK 00681 PG-00070 FULL MARKET VALUE 322,903 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-15.12 *************** 218 C R 10 149.-1-15.12 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,200 Pagnotta Vincenzo Germantown 103602 37,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,200 Pagnotta Geraldine 06-331 37,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,200 19 Harrison Ave ACRES 2.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,200 TO M Harrison, NY 10528 EAST-0671290 NRTH-0121650 DEED BOOK 620 PG-2158 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-15.111 ************** 218 C R 10 149.-1-15.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,000 Pagnotta Vincenzo Germantown 103602 37,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,000 Pagnotta Geraldine Lot #1 124,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 124,000 458 Halstead Ave Micro 06-331 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,000 TO M Mamaroneck, NY 10543 ACRES 2.20 EAST-0670850 NRTH-0121630 DEED BOOK 620 PG-2158 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-15.112 ************** 218 C R 10 149.-1-15.112 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 37,400 Pagnotta Vincenzo Germantown 103602 37,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 37,400 Pagnotta Geraldine Micro 06-331 37,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,400 19 Harrison Ave ACRES 2.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 37,400 TO M Harrison, NY 10528 EAST-0670960 NRTH-0121660 DEED BOOK 620 PG-2158 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,429 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 245 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-16.110 ************** CR 10 149.-1-16.110 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 118,184 Pagnotta Vincenzo Germantown 103602 88,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,184 Pagnotta Geraldine Micro 4042 & 1306 118,184 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 118,184 19 Harrison Ave ACRES 24.53 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 118,184 TO M Harrison, NY 10528 EAST-0670774 NRTH-1217093 DEED BOOK 0612 PG-00918 FULL MARKET VALUE 168,834 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-38.120 ************** Off Sprin Rd 139.-1-38.120 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 207,672 Pallante Salvatore Hudson 100600 49,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 207,672 Pallante Filomena ACRES 3.45 207,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 207,672 357 Ramona Ave EAST-0684176 NRTH-1221259 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 207,672 TO M Staten Island, NY 10312 DEED BOOK 0601 PG-00829 FULL MARKET VALUE 296,674 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-72 ****************** Off Spring Rd 139.-1-72 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 188,088 Pallente Michael Hudson 100600 59,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 188,088 Pallente Lydia ACRES 3.45 188,088 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 188,088 1427 68th St EAST-0678599 NRTH-1219828 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 188,088 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11219 DEED BOOK 0601 PG-00820 FULL MARKET VALUE 268,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-47 ****************** CR 8 170.-1-47 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,920 Palumbo Joseph A Jr Red Hook 134801 29,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,920 Schultz Lindsay ACRES 1.10 29,920 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,920 81 Old Manorton Rd EAST-0677931 NRTH-1192788 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,920 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 653 PG-1099 FULL MARKET VALUE 42,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-54.2 **************** Off CR 19 171.-1-54.2 411 Apartment COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 340,000 Palumbo Joseph A Jr Germantown 103602 90,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 340,000 Schultz Lindsay A Fingar 340,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 340,000 81 Old Manorton Rd ACRES 4.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 340,000 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0686180 NRTH-1193364 DEED BOOK 638 PG-2091 FULL MARKET VALUE 485,714 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 246 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-22 ****************** 81 Old Manorton Rd 181.-1-22 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Palumbo Joseph Jr Germantown 103602 52,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 208,352 81 Old Manorton Rd Micro 4273 208,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 208,352 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.70 BANKC150023 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 181,792 EAST-0682327 NRTH-1189697 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 208,352 TO M DEED BOOK C0500 PG-F0931 FULL MARKET VALUE 297,646 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-18.122 ************** Off Rte 10 150.-1-18.122 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Papp Adam Germantown 103602 62,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 233,800 Papp Sarah J Micro 99-78 233,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 233,800 23 Memory Ln ACRES 9.04 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 207,240 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674316 NRTH-1216300 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 233,800 TO M DEED BOOK 633 PG-843 FULL MARKET VALUE 334,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-66.112 ************** OFF CR 10 149.-1-66.112 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 Papp Frank Germantown 103602 81,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 Papp Margaret Micro-11867 81,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,600 38 Memory Ln ACRES 10.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,600 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0673001 NRTH-1213647 DEED BOOK 681 PG-272 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 116,571 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-18.123 ************** Off Rte 10 150.-1-18.123 210 1 Family Res VET RATIO 41111 65,750 65,750 0 Papp Margaret Germantown 103602 96,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Papp Frank Micro 99-78 263,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,250 38 Memory Ln ACRES 18.93 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,250 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674316 NRTH-1216300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 236,440 DEED BOOK C0351 PG-F2487 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 263,000 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 375,714 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-18.124 ************** Off Rte 10 150.-1-18.124 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,500 Papp Margaret Germantown 103602 84,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,500 Papp Frank Micro 99-78 157,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 157,500 38 Memory Ln ACRES 9.04 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,500 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674316 NRTH-1216300 DEED BOOK C0351 PG-F2487 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 225,000 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2011 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 247 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-51 ****************** Hollow Rd 192.-1-51 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,500 Papreka Penny Pine Plains 134201 67,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,500 PO Box 153 ACRES 10.10 67,500 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 67,500 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0685010 NRTH-1177902 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 67,500 TO M DEED BOOK 607 PG-1676 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-16 ***************** Private Rd 192.4-2-16 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 106,352 Papreka Penny Pine Plains 134201 25,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 106,352 PO Box 153 FRNT 124.00 DPTH 125.00 106,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 106,352 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684630 NRTH-1177622 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 106,352 TO M DEED BOOK 607 PG-1681 FULL MARKET VALUE 151,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-20 **************** Highland Ave 192.20-2-20 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 20,366 20,366 0 Parker Fred N Pine Plains 134201 36,900 AGED - ALL 41800 30,549 30,549 40,732 Parker Marthe B Twin Lakes 81,464 EN STAR 41834 0 0 40,732 52 Highland Ave FRNT 75.00 DPTH 125.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 30,549 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683449 NRTH-1178379 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 30,549 DEED BOOK 0358 PG-00376 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 0 FULL MARKET VALUE 116,377 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 81,464 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-37 ****************** Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-37 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 160,480 Parkinson Lisa A Red Hook 134801 25,764 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 160,480 Parkinson Timothy S FRNT 147.18 DPTH 120.00 160,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,480 8 Bingham Mills Rd BANKH061222 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 160,480 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676649 NRTH-1193675 DEED BOOK C0487 PG-F1334 FULL MARKET VALUE 229,257 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-54 ****************** Blue Valley Rd 139.-1-54 113 Cattle farm BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Parlman Brian D Germantown 103602 174,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 339,184 Parlman Wendy ACRES 88.60 BANKC080005 339,184 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 339,184 PO Box 866 EAST-0682986 NRTH-1221006 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 312,624 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C533 PG-F585 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 339,184 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 484,549 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 248 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-63 ****************** Hilltop Acres Cr 19 Lo 171.-1-63 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pasco Peter Germantown 103602 36,061 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,200 Pasco Victoria Micro 4852 197,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,200 5 Twin Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 336.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,640 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0687215 NRTH-1201106 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,200 TO M DEED BOOK 575 PG-426 FULL MARKET VALUE 281,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-25 ****************** Marty Rd.,lot 42 182.-1-25 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 59,024 Pastorek Oldrich Germantown 103602 59,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 59,024 Pastorek Violeta Beach View Hill 59,024 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 59,024 22 Maple St FRNT 610.00 DPTH 155.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 59,024 TO M Rutherford N J, 07070 EAST-0690609 NRTH-1188243 DEED BOOK 0440 PG-00429 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,320 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-26 ****************** Marty Rd.,lot 43 182.-1-26 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 43,520 Pastorek Oldrich Germantown 103602 43,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 43,520 Pastorek Violeta Beach View Hills 43,520 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 43,520 22 Maple St ACRES 7.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 43,520 TO M Rutherford N J, 07070 EAST-0690439 NRTH-1188272 DEED BOOK 0522 PG-00001 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,171 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-21 ****************** Private Rd 181.-1-21 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 Paszko Nicholas Germantown 103602 5,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 6570 W 84Th Pl ACRES 2.10 5,712 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 Westchester, CA 90045-2808 EAST-0684848 NRTH-1189192 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,712 TO M DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F1018 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-20 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-20 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 200,013 200,013 200,013 Paszko Steve Germantown 103602 303,500 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Paszko Woodymr ACRES 105.44 471,512 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 271,499 WOODYMR PASZKO EAST-0684437 NRTH-1189901 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 271,499 1880 Route 8 DEED BOOK 628 PG-1228 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 221,229 Elizaville, NY 12523 FULL MARKET VALUE 673,589 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 271,499 TO M 200,013 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 249 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-13 ****************** LOT 23 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-13 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Payne John C Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 212,976 Payne Marilou M Micro 94-118 & 95-283 212,976 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 212,976 4 Mahikan Dr ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 186,416 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685461 NRTH-1203112 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 212,976 TO M DEED BOOK C441 PG-F832 FULL MARKET VALUE 304,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-71 ****************** Twin Dr 171.-1-71 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Peck Bradley H Germantown 103602 40,030 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 162,928 Peck Heather Lynk Subdivision 162,928 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 162,928 61 Twin Dr Micro 4852 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,368 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 208.00 DPTH 222.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 162,928 TO M BANKC061200 EAST-0686836 NRTH-1200545 DEED BOOK C391 PG-F0068 FULL MARKET VALUE 232,754 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-54 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-54 311 Res vac land AG DISTRIC 41720 43,018 43,018 43,018 Peck Charles Pine Plains 134201 53,856 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 10,838 PO Box 122 Micro 4643 53,856 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 10,838 Copake, NY 12516 ACRES 3.30 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 10,838 EAST-0683641 NRTH-1172350 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 10,838 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK C439 PG-F0852 43,018 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-11 ****************** 259 Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-11 114 Sheep farm WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Peck Charles A Copake-Taconic 102801 81,200 AG DISTRIC 41720 36,901 36,901 36,901 PO Box 122 ACRES 17.80 230,656 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Copake, NY 12516 EAST-0699051 NRTH-1218208 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 177,190 DEED BOOK C379 PG-F1594 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 177,190 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 329,509 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 167,195 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 193,755 TO M 36,901 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-67 ****************** 85 CR 10 138.-1-67 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 81,043 81,043 0 Peet Morton W Germantown 103602 44,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Peet Debora J FRNT 150.00 DPTH 225.00 207,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 126,257 85 County Rte 10 ACRES 2.77 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,257 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668411 NRTH-1217661 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 180,740 DEED BOOK 536 PG-2081 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 207,300 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 296,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 250 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-4 ******************* 70 Water St 152.-1-4 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Peischel Martin Copake-Taconic 102801 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 187,816 Peischel Lillian ACRES 2.00 187,816 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 187,816 70 Water St Rd EAST-0699913 NRTH-1216960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,546 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0490 PG-00849 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 187,816 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 268,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-97 ****************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-97 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pelesz Peter Hudson 100600 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 178,024 Pelesz Ann Micro 96-20 178,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 178,024 PO Box 224 ACRES 2.10 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 151,464 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0690256 NRTH-1205671 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 178,024 TO M DEED BOOK C0308 PG-F1753 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 178,024 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 254,320 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-8.1 ***************** Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-8.1 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,800 Pellegrini Teresa Germantown 103602 72,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,800 Strenge Brian W Lot#2 72,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,800 49 Hapeman Hill Rd ACRES 23.30 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,800 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0691810 NRTH-0119180 DEED BOOK C514 PG-F1504 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-8.2 ***************** Deer Haven Rd 182.-1-8.2 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 46,600 Pellegrini Teresa Germantown 103602 46,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 46,600 Strenge Brian W Lot#2 46,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 46,600 49 Hapeman Hill Rd ACRES 10.20 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 46,600 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0692510 NRTH-0119290 DEED BOOK C514 PG-F1504 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-52 ***************** Church Rd 161.1-1-52 210 1 Family Res CW_15_VET/ 41162 8,282 0 0 Peragine Sandra Hudson 100600 27,300 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 115 Rt 19 FRNT 170.00 DPTH 125.00 93,024 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 84,742 Hudson, NY 12534 BANK0080490 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,024 EAST-0687935 NRTH-1206187 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,464 DEED BOOK C0327 PG-F1731 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 93,024 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 132,891 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 93,024 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 251 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-64 ****************** CR 10 149.-1-64 710 Manufacture COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 145,656 Perini John M Germantown 103602 56,044 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 145,656 325 Clinton Corners Rd ACRES 3.50 145,656 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 145,656 Clinton Corners, NY 12514 EAST-0671328 NRTH-1215054 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 145,656 TO M DEED BOOK C0299 PG-F0291 FULL MARKET VALUE 208,080 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-33 ***************** 58 CR 19 161.1-1-33 240 Rural res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Peters Frances Hudson 100600 72,200 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Valenti Barbara ACRES 10.00 171,224 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,616 127 Hall Rd EAST-0688122 NRTH-1207357 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,616 Grahamsville, NY 12740 DEED BOOK 602 PG-2375 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,954 FULL MARKET VALUE 244,606 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 171,224 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 171,224 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-35 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-35 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Peterson Richard A Jr Hudson 100600 65,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 172,312 41 County Route 19 ACRES 8.00 BANKC120345 172,312 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 172,312 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688712 NRTH-1207778 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 145,752 DEED BOOK 434 PG-918 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 172,312 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 246,160 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 172,312 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-56 ****************** 181 Deer Haven Rd 171.-1-56 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 59,840 Pfeiffer Stephen D Jr Germantown 103602 37,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 59,840 235 Black Bridge Rd ACRES 0.99 59,840 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 59,840 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0688921 NRTH-1192659 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 59,840 TO M DEED BOOK 597 PG-324 FULL MARKET VALUE 85,486 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-11.122 ************** Black Bridge (off) Rd 182.-1-11.122 312 Vac w/imprv BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pfeiffer Stephen D Jr Germantown 103602 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,800 235 Black Bridge Rd ACRES 2.10 BANKC060975 130,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,800 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0727204 NRTH-0544509 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,240 DEED BOOK C0488 PG-F1616 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,800 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 186,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 252 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-24 ****************** 185 Mill Rd 170.-1-24 220 2 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Phelan Jo Red Hook 134801 15,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 230,384 116 Pinehurst Ave Apt J33 FRNT 152.00 DPTH 120.00 230,384 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 230,384 New York, NY 10033 BANKC030614 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 203,824 EAST-0673960 NRTH-1193730 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 230,384 TO M DEED BOOK C458 PG-F1494 FULL MARKET VALUE 329,120 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-34 ****************** CR 8 182.-1-34 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 76,160 Phelps Ralph L Germantown 103602 49,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 76,160 Phelps Anne P ACRES 10.00 76,160 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 76,160 Attn: Phelps Ralph L EAST-0688881 NRTH-1187260 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 76,160 TO M 119 Piedra Loop DEED BOOK 581 PG-774 Los Alamos, NM 87544 FULL MARKET VALUE 108,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-25 ***************** Sr 9 161.1-1-25 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 273,900 Phillipe Paul Hudson 100600 37,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 273,900 Companik Richard ACRES 1.20 273,900 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 273,900 PO Box 26 EAST-0687614 NRTH-1206676 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 273,900 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK C498 PG-F163 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 273,900 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 391,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-19 ****************** Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-19 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 79,048 79,048 79,048 Piacquadio Pietro Red Hook 134801 132,328 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,280 Piacquadio Anna ACRES 28.08 132,328 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,280 109 Lake Dr EAST-0675616 NRTH-1195273 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,280 Mahopac, NY 10541 DEED BOOK C0372 PG-F0459 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,280 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 189,040 79,048 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-29 ****************** 25 Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-29 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pillitteri Salvatore Germantown 103602 59,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 203,728 Pillitteri Josephine ACRES 6.20 BANKC070180 203,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 203,728 25 Scuderhook Rd EAST-0687061 NRTH-1197635 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 177,168 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C399 PG-F2342 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 203,728 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 291,040 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 253 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-46 ***************** 21 Baxter Rd 201.8-1-46 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pink Foxx Lanae Pine Plains 134201 37,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,280 Foxx Michael Pb18pg1374 116,280 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,280 PO Box 581 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,720 E. Orleans, MA 02643-0581 EAST-0682418 NRTH-1173638 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,280 TO M DEED BOOK 0564 PG-00414 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,114 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-14 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-14 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,100 Pinto Joanna Hudson 100600 48,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,100 Pinto Isabel Micro 94-118 48,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,100 30 Arden Pl ACRES 1.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 48,100 TO M Yonkers, NY 10701 EAST-0686360 NRTH-0120260 DEED BOOK 628 PG-1683 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-86 ****************** 54600 771970 171.-1-86 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Pinto Joseph Germantown 103602 55,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 Pinto Debra ACRES 2.10 55,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,352 11 Purdy St EAST-0038965 NRTH-0424059 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,352 TO M Harrison, NY 10528 DEED BOOK C419 PG-F1308 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,074 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-20.120 ************** 750 CR 31 150.-1-20.120 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 441,456 Piskin Raymond Germantown 103602 85,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 441,456 Piskin Gina Micro 99-167 441,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 441,456 3457 East Bay Ct ACRES 6.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 441,456 TO M Merrick, NY 11566 EAST-0676119 NRTH-1214783 DEED BOOK C482 PG-F971 FULL MARKET VALUE 630,651 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-26 ****************** Podmijersky Rd 140.-1-26 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 97,036 0 0 Podmijersky Paul M Hudson 100600 31,000 AGED T 41803 0 87,332 0 15 Podmijersky Rd Micro No. 1062 194,072 AGED S 41804 0 0 87,332 Hudson, NY 12534 FRNT 180.25 DPTH 161.66 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 BANK0080490 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 97,036 EAST-0691501 NRTH-1218243 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 106,740 DEED BOOK 598 PG-1175 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 56,470 FULL MARKET VALUE 277,246 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 194,072 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 254 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-18.100 ************** 36 Podmijersky Rd 140.-1-18.100 113 Cattle farm AG DISTRIC 41720 193,002 193,002 193,002 Podmijersky Samuel Hudson 100600 252,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Podmijersky Roxanne ACRES 104.70 401,880 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 208,878 36 Podmijersky Rd EAST-0690009 NRTH-1219550 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 208,878 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0605 PG-00239 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 182,318 FULL MARKET VALUE 574,114 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 208,878 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 193,002 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-29.200 ************** US 9 140.-1-29.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 6,936 Podmijersky Samuel Hudson 100600 6,936 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 6,936 Podmijersky Roxanne FRNT 52.58 DPTH 450.00 6,936 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,936 36 Podmijersky Rd EAST-0692446 NRTH-1218130 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 6,936 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00754 PG-00052 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-20.112 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-20.112 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 Polese Theresa Hudson 100600 57,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 Attn: Paez ACRES 2.34 57,120 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 124 Frank Ave EAST-0691425 NRTH-1206203 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 57,120 TO M Mamaroneck, NY 10543 DEED BOOK 0596 PG-00243 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,600 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-35.12 *************** CR 9 170.-2-35.12 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 251,400 Pollard George Red Hook 134801 53,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 251,400 Pollard Gladys ACRES 2.80 251,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 251,400 106 Old Post Rd N EAST-0680140 NRTH-0119510 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 251,400 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 DEED BOOK 631 PG-284 FULL MARKET VALUE 359,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-38 ****************** 1918 CR 8 181.-1-38 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Pollard Joann Germantown 103602 39,785 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pollard Stanley R Sr ACRES 1.00 143,072 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 115,464 1918 Rte 8 EAST-0684820 NRTH-1188002 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 115,464 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 00723 PG-00192 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,512 FULL MARKET VALUE 204,389 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,072 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 255 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-11 ****************** Livingston 160.-1-11 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 Pollock Marvin Hudson 100600 31,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 Pollock Rochelle ACRES 0.70 136,816 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 136,816 10 Plaza St EAST-0682272 NRTH-1207716 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 136,816 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11238 DEED BOOK 0611 PG-00789 FULL MARKET VALUE 195,451 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-30.120 ************** C R 10 160.-1-30.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,176 Pollock Marvin R Hudson 100600 53,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,176 Pollock Rochelle ACRES 3.07 BANKH030401 53,176 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,176 10 Plaza St EAST-0682264 NRTH-1207637 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,176 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11238 DEED BOOK 00682 PG-00324 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,966 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-23 ****************** Water St 152.-1-23 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,712 Pomilio Vincent Hudson 100600 38,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,712 Bohan Robert Micro 3625 124,712 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 124,712 112 W Houston St #3D FRNT 210.86 DPTH 212.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,712 TO M New York, NY 10012 ACRES 0.92 BANKC030614 EAST-0699002 NRTH-1210325 DEED BOOK C0365 PG-F1994 FULL MARKET VALUE 178,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-28 ****************** Off Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-28 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Pompa Romano Hudson 100600 39,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 88 Stanton Dr ACRES 14.50 39,440 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Stamford Conn, 06902 EAST-0697737 NRTH-1204966 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 39,440 TO M DEED BOOK 00745 PG-00281 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,343 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-6 ****************** Baxter Rd 201.8-2-6 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Ponte Gabriel Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 7 Lincoln Dr Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682558 NRTH-1173458 DEED BOOK C0286 PG-F1240 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 256 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-18 ****************** 1569 C R 19 201.-1-18 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Popp Virginia M Pine Plains 134201 45,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 138,056 1569 C R 19 Twin Lakes 138,056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 138,056 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.60 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,786 EAST-0684233 NRTH-1173539 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 138,056 TO M DEED BOOK 643 PG-2422 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,223 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-2.210 *************** Orchard Rd 151.-1-2.210 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 30,872 Porcelli Joseph Hudson 100600 30,872 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 30,872 Church Rd ACRES 2.00 30,872 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 30,872 PO Box 53 EAST-0688486 NRTH-1216647 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 30,872 TO M Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK C0346 PG-F2472 FULL MARKET VALUE 44,103 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-75 ****************** Church Rd 161.-1-75 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Porcelli Joseph Hudson 100600 45,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 PO Box 53 Micro 10188 165,104 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,496 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 2.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,496 EAST-0691655 NRTH-1205974 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,544 DEED BOOK 0649 PG-00280 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 165,104 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 235,863 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-95.100 ************** OFF Cemetary Rd 149.-1-95.100 322 Rural vac>10 AG DISTRIC 41720 25,172 25,172 25,172 Porreca Rocco Germantown 103602 27,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 2,028 Porreca Carol Ann Micro 10953 27,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 2,028 328 Kipp Rd ACRES 10.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 2,028 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0670188 NRTH-1215211 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 2,028 TO M DEED BOOK 0637 PG-00315 25,172 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 38,857 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-12 ****************** 57 Klibar Rd 150.-1-12 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Postighone Rosemarie Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,288 57 Klibar Rd ACRES 1.00 130,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,288 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677887 NRTH-1215347 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,728 DEED BOOK C0302 PG-F0826 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,288 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 186,126 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 257 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-76.100 ************* 29N Brucket Rd 201.2-1-76.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Potamousis Michael Pine Plains 134201 41,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,448 Potamousis Beatrice ACRES 1.00 BANK0030950 155,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,448 121 Parker Rd EAST-0681506 NRTH-1174666 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 128,888 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C532 PG-F837 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,448 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 222,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-76.200 ************* Brucket Rd 201.2-1-76.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,992 Potamousis Michael Pine Plains 134201 36,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,992 Potamousis Beatrice ACRES 1.78 BANK0030950 36,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,992 121 Parker Rd EAST-0681316 NRTH-1174635 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,992 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C532 PG-F833 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-9.200 *************** Mambert Rd 152.-1-9.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 Powers Patricia Copake-Taconic 102801 5,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 129 Mambert Rd Micro 94-138 5,712 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.60 BANK0190323 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,712 TO M EAST-0701894 NRTH-1215095 DEED BOOK C0289 PG-F2227 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-11 ****************** Lynk Rd 171.-1-11 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 105,536 Pratt Ryan Germantown 103602 28,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 105,536 Pratt Lisa Micro 1900 105,536 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,536 75 Lynks Rd FRNT 91.00 DPTH 294.15 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 105,536 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686097 NRTH-1200053 DEED BOOK 581 PG-2006 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,766 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-22.100 ************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-22.100 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 435,000 435,000 435,000 Prezorski Mark Germantown 103602 490,800 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 80 Hill Rd ACRES 118.40 608,336 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 173,336 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677781 NRTH-1223566 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 173,336 DEED BOOK C397 PG-F2113 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 146,776 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 869,051 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 173,336 TO M UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 435,000 EX ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 258 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-22.200 ************** Tom Thumb Rd 139.-1-22.200 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 78,192 78,192 78,192 Prezorski Mark Germantown 103602 132,056 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,864 80 Hill Rd ACRES 32.48 132,056 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,864 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677993 NRTH-1222606 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,864 DEED BOOK C399 PG-F2113 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,864 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 188,651 78,192 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-47.100 ************** 1049 Manorton County Rte 19 181.-1-47.100 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Privitera Michael L Germantown 103602 130,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 293,896 1049 Manorton County Rte 19 ACRES 39.75 293,896 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 293,896 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683664 NRTH-1186169 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 267,336 DEED BOOK 658 PG-1705 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 293,896 TO M PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 FULL MARKET VALUE 419,851 Privitera Michael ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-2.200 *************** 624 CR 31 150.-1-2.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Pudney Michael A Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 161,840 Pudney Christina Micro 98-69 161,840 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 161,840 624 Co Rte 31 ACRES 2.00 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,280 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0676488 NRTH-1216706 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 161,840 TO M DEED BOOK C0315 PG-F1887 FULL MARKET VALUE 231,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-77.122 ************** Private Rd 149.-1-77.122 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 77,112 Pyle James H Germantown 103602 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 77,112 Moy Sheila J ACRES 2.00 77,112 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 77,112 25 Lake St EAST-0671912 NRTH-1213065 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 77,112 TO M White Plains, NY 10603 DEED BOOK 635 PG-2132 FULL MARKET VALUE 110,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-20.2 **************** 50 Orchard Rd 140.-1-20.2 120 Field crops COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 69,600 Quackenbush Susan Hudson 100600 69,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 69,600 Bucci Jennifer Micro#07-166 69,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,600 50 Prilipper Rd ACRES 11.17 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 69,600 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685305 NRTH-1220988 DEED BOOK 632 PG-981 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 99,429 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2012 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 259 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-20.11 *************** 50 Orchard Rd 140.-1-20.11 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 177,239 177,239 177,239 Quackenbush Susan Hudson 100600 348,600 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Bucci Jennifer ACRES 130.30 550,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 372,761 50 Prilipper Rd EAST-0686309 NRTH-1219543 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 372,761 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 632 PG-981 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 346,201 FULL MARKET VALUE 785,714 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 372,761 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 177,239 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-20.12 *************** 50 Orchard Rd 140.-1-20.12 120 Field crops COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,600 Quackenbush Susan Hudson 100600 72,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,600 Bucci Jennifer Micro#07-166 72,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,600 50 Prilipper Rd ACRES 12.06 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,600 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685244 NRTH-1220658 DEED BOOK 632 PG-981 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 103,714 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2012 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-24 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-24 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 138,040 Quinn Patrick Pine Plains 134201 19,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 138,040 Quinn Patricia Bk18 Pg1374 138,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 138,040 4 Sylvia Ln FRNT 48.00 DPTH 50.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 138,040 TO M New Hyde Park, NY 11040 EAST-0682418 NRTH-1173908 DEED BOOK 00738 PG-00108 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,200 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-25 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-25 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Quinn Patrick Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Quinn Patricia Reilly Twin Lake 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 4 Sylvia Ln FRNT 100.00 DPTH 50.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M New Hyde Park, NY 11040 EAST-0682477 NRTH-1173968 DEED BOOK 0487 PG-00064 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-32.100 ************** CR 2 201.-1-32.100 485 >1use sm bld COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 337,280 Raffaele John Pine Plains 134201 70,508 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 337,280 41 Gleason Blvd ACRES 2.00 337,280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 337,280 Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 EAST-0682090 NRTH-1172737 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 337,280 TO M DEED BOOK 561 PG-585 FULL MARKET VALUE 481,829 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 260 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-35 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-35 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 Ragusa Joseph Germantown 103602 66,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 Ragusa Josephine ACRES 8.30 109,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,480 150 Oceanview Rd EAST-0676300 NRTH-1213914 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,480 TO M East Rockaway, NY 11518 DEED BOOK 0433 PG-00368 FULL MARKET VALUE 156,400 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-11 ****************** Us 23 & 9-H 140.-1-11 330 Vacant comm COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Ramos Mercedes Hudson 100600 21,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 PO Box 38 ACRES 0.20 21,488 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 21,488 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0693575 NRTH-1221187 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 21,488 TO M DEED BOOK C500 PG-F2459 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,697 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-43 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-43 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,304 Ramos Mercedes Hudson 100600 19,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,304 PO Box 38 FRNT 45.00 DPTH 240.00 107,304 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,304 Livingston, NY 12541 BANKH030614 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,304 TO M EAST-0688124 NRTH-1206417 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 107,304 TO M DEED BOOK C0347 PG-F1149 FULL MARKET VALUE 153,291 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-30 ****************** SR 9G 138.-1-30 483 Converted Re COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,600 Ramsey Charles Germantown 103602 47,637 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,600 220 Co Rte 19 ACRES 2.00 183,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,600 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0668368 NRTH-1220298 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,600 TO M DEED BOOK C0291 PG-F0225 FULL MARKET VALUE 262,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-44 ****************** 220 CR 19 161.-1-44 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ramsey Charles Hudson 100600 42,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,144 220 County Rte 19 FRNT 360.00 DPTH 208.21 116,144 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,144 Hudson, NY 12534 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 89,584 EAST-0686348 NRTH-1204734 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,144 TO M DEED BOOK 0660 PG-00309 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 116,144 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 165,920 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 261 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-18.110 ************** Off Rte 10 150.-1-18.110 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 339,456 Ramsey Cynthia Germantown 103602 217,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 339,456 518 Columbia Cty Rt 10 #2 Micro 99-78 339,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 339,456 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 67.01 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 339,456 TO M EAST-0675089 NRTH-1214661 DEED BOOK 00681 PG-00269 FULL MARKET VALUE 484,937 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-9 ****************** 22 Pine Rd 201.2-1-9 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ramsey Shaun Pine Plains 134201 40,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 201,008 22 Pine Rd FRNT 114.83 DPTH 137.00 201,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 201,008 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC070170 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 174,448 EAST-0681892 NRTH-1176946 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 201,008 TO M DEED BOOK C482 PG-F202 FULL MARKET VALUE 287,154 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-14 ****************** 124 Maple Ln 170.-2-14 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,312 Ramsey William M Red Hook 134801 16,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,312 Ramsey Sharon E Micro 4611 87,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 87,312 145A Jones Rd FRNT 65.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,312 TO M Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 EAST-0683297 NRTH-1194918 DEED BOOK 646 PG-877 FULL MARKET VALUE 124,731 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-1 ******************* LOT 22 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-1 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Rapp Angela Hudson 100600 36,300 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 11 Makikan Dr Micro 94-118 & 95-283 292,808 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 265,200 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.11 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 265,200 EAST-0685820 NRTH-1203363 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 242,538 DEED BOOK C517 PG-F1179 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 292,808 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 418,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-47 ****************** 3522 SR 9 161.-1-47 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rapp Joseph Hudson 100600 29,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 178,024 2732 SR 9 FRNT 140.00 DPTH 204.70 178,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 178,024 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685600 NRTH-1203352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 151,464 DEED BOOK 645 PG-2440 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 178,024 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 254,320 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 262 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-20 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-20 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Rapp Joseph G Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Rapp Angela Lot 8 35,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 PO Box 1339 Micro 05-291 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.00 EAST-0686500 NRTH-0120350 DEED BOOK 611 PG-2484 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-66 ***************** 73 Loyola Rd 201.2-1-66 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ratel Christopher Pine Plains 134201 21,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 127,700 Ratel Patricia Bk18 Pg1374 127,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 127,700 73 Loyola Rd Lot 81 FRNT 185.00 DPTH 130.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 101,140 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682306 NRTH-1174847 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 127,700 TO M DEED BOOK 591 PG-1530 FULL MARKET VALUE 182,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-53 ****************** 5141 SR 9G 138.-1-53 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Raylman Robert Germantown 103602 45,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,776 5141 Co Rte 9G ACRES 1.50 100,776 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,776 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0666672 NRTH-1218344 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,216 DEED BOOK C540 PG-F1258 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 100,776 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 143,966 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-1 ******************* Wire Rd 149.-1-1 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,560 Raymond Wayne Germantown 103602 45,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,560 277 County Rte 10 Micro 1466 45,560 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 45,560 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 13.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 45,560 TO M EAST-0668095 NRTH-1216967 DEED BOOK 0597 PG-00936 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,086 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-2 ******************* CR 10 149.-1-2 418 Inn/lodge COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 181,696 Raymond Wayne B Germantown 103602 95,393 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 181,696 277 County Rte 10 ACRES 6.50 181,696 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 181,696 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668674 NRTH-1217208 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 181,696 TO M DEED BOOK 0597 PG-00936 FULL MARKET VALUE 259,566 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 263 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-23 ***************** Sr 9 161.1-1-23 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Reardon Sylvestor Hudson 100600 36,300 AGED C 41802 64,736 0 0 Reardon Muriel Micro 98-11 157,080 AGED T&S 41806 0 58,262 70,686 Livingston, NY 12541 FRNT 130.80 DPTH 319.03 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 EAST-0687424 NRTH-1206366 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 64,736 DEED BOOK 0474 PG-00010 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 71,210 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,124 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,080 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 157,080 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-21.110 ************** CR 19 192.-1-21.110 311 Res vac land AG DISTRIC 41720 141,779 141,779 141,779 Red Wing Properties, Inc. Pine Plains 134201 720,120 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 578,341 PO Box 408 ACRES 196.37 720,120 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 578,341 Stormville, NY 12582 EAST-0719906 NRTH-0543345 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 578,341 DEED BOOK 565 PG-650 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 578,341 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1028,743 141,779 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-21.120 ************** CR 19 192.-1-21.120 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 647,632 Red Wing Properties, Inc. Pine Plains 134201 287,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 647,632 PO Box 408 ACRES 36.66 647,632 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 647,632 Stormville, NY 12582 EAST-0720056 NRTH-0543465 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 647,632 TO M DEED BOOK 565 PG-644 FULL MARKET VALUE 925,189 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-11.200 ************** Oak Hill Rd 128.-1-11.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 20,808 Reed Augusta A Hudson 100600 20,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 20,808 111 Oak Hill Rd Micro 93-188 20,808 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 20,808 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 0.72 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 20,808 TO M EAST-0671229 NRTH-1226918 DEED BOOK 00740 PG-00289 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,726 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-13 ****************** Water St 161.-1-13 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 306,000 Reed Gwendolyn Hudson 100600 124,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 306,000 Bruno Pasquier-Desvignes ACRES 5.98 BANKL050186 306,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 306,000 410 Water St Rd EAST-0697110 NRTH-1208484 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 306,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0639 PG-00287 FULL MARKET VALUE 437,143 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 264 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-30 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-30 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 135,048 Reese Tracy L Hudson 100600 41,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 135,048 20 E 35th St Apt 2D ACRES 1.63 135,048 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,048 New York, NY 10016 EAST-0697045 NRTH-1205625 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 135,048 TO M DEED BOOK 580 PG-199 FULL MARKET VALUE 192,926 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-60 ****************** 132 Wire Rd 149.-1-60 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Reetz Daniel Germantown 103602 69,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 187,544 c/o Karen Risch ACRES 33.00 187,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 187,544 70 Lasher Ave EAST-0669970 NRTH-1214281 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,984 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C428 PG-F1598 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 187,544 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 267,920 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-45.2 **************** 1511 Cr 8 Blue Stores-Lot 2 170.-1-45.2 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Region Gordon Red Hook 134801 42,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 108,528 Region Susan ACRES 1.70 BANKC031720 108,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 108,528 1511 County Rte 8 EAST-0677570 NRTH-1193517 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 81,968 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 683 PG-128 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,528 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 155,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-51 ***************** Church Rd 161.1-1-51 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Reid Alice Marie Hudson 100600 49,800 AGED C 41802 59,193 0 0 Reid Donald ACRES 3.40 148,104 AGED T&S 41806 0 39,462 44,431 PO Box 113 EAST-0688155 NRTH-1206027 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0600 PG-00455 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,346 FULL MARKET VALUE 211,577 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,077 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,403 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,104 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 148,104 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-12.2 **************** 40 Snyderville Rd 201.-1-12.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,300 Reid Michael Pine Plains 134201 26,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,300 Reid Steven Lot 4 26,300 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,300 PO Box 42 FRNT 225.00 DPTH 126.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 26,300 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 0.50 EAST-0685030 NRTH-0117490 DEED BOOK 528 PG-14 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,571 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 265 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-12.12 *************** 42 Peterson Rd 201.-1-12.12 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 80,100 Reid Michael Pine Plains 134201 16,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 80,100 Reid Steven Lot 3 80,100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 80,100 PO Box 42 ACRES 0.91 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 80,100 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0684910 NRTH-0117480 DEED BOOK 528 PG-14 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-24 ****************** C R 19 201.-1-24 414 Hotel COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,192 Reid Steven Pine Plains 134201 44,438 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,192 PO Box 28 ACRES 1.00 BANKC060704 183,192 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,192 Tivoli, NY 12583 EAST-0684119 NRTH-1173061 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,192 TO M DEED BOOK 00818 PG-00056 FULL MARKET VALUE 261,703 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-22 ****************** Twn. Line Churchtown 141.-1-22 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 183,056 Reinckens Corinne Copake-Taconic 102801 21,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 183,056 PO Box 56 ACRES 0.35 183,056 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 183,056 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0703370 NRTH-1218426 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 183,056 TO M DEED BOOK 0550 PG-00015 FULL MARKET VALUE 261,509 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-17.112 ************** Water St 152.-1-17.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Reinckens David Hudson 100600 47,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 224,808 304 Water St Rd ACRES 2.75 BANK0080490 224,808 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 224,808 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698135 NRTH-1210886 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 198,248 DEED BOOK 0649 PG-00029 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 224,808 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 321,154 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-44 ****************** Water St 152.-1-44 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 61,744 Reinckens David Hudson 100600 61,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 61,744 Reinckens Kelly ACRES 3.00 61,744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,744 304 Water St Rd EAST-0698495 NRTH-1210797 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 61,744 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C405 PG-F1658 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,206 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 266 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-43 ****************** 302 Water St 152.-1-43 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Reinckens Kelly A Hudson 100600 49,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 237,728 304 Water St ACRES 2.40 237,728 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 237,728 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0698295 NRTH-1211067 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 187,458 DEED BOOK 591 PG-2442 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 237,728 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 339,611 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-28 ****************** Sr 9 170.-2-28 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 Renate Frank Red Hook 134801 45,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 213 Cedar Heights Rd FRNT 485.00 DPTH 190.00 107,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 EAST-0677938 NRTH-1194268 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,032 TO M DEED BOOK C354 PG-F1416 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,903 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-32 ****************** Sr 9 170.-2-32 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Renate Frank Red Hook 134801 4,080 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 213 Cedar Heights Rd Micro 2311 4,080 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,080 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 ACRES 1.50 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,080 TO M EAST-0678049 NRTH-1193948 DEED BOOK C354 PG-F1416 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,829 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-43 ****************** Sr 82 151.-1-43 421 Restaurant COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 221,000 Rennia Carl Hudson 100600 56,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 221,000 459 Old Route 22 Micro 3362 221,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 221,000 Amenia, NY 12501 ACRES 3.40 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 221,000 TO M EAST-0696315 NRTH-1210913 DEED BOOK 608 PG-1484 FULL MARKET VALUE 315,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-60 ****************** Sr 82 Includes 37 151.-1-60 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 53,448 Rennia Carl Hudson 100600 53,448 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 53,448 459 Old Route 82 ACRES 3.36 53,448 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 53,448 Amenia, NY 12501 EAST-0696347 NRTH-1210143 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 53,448 TO M DEED BOOK 608 PG-1484 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,354 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 267 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-17 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Reppucci John F Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,700 Reppucci Concetta Lot11 185,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,700 41 Keil Ct Micro 05-291 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 159,140 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,700 TO M EAST-0686250 NRTH-0120320 DEED BOOK 592 PG-1218 FULL MARKET VALUE 265,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-38 **************** 14 N Shore Dr 192.20-3-38 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Rieck Frederick Pine Plains 134201 131,700 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 14 North Shore Dr Twin Lakes 165,240 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,675 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 115.00 DPTH 323.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,675 EAST-0683041 NRTH-1177289 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 114,970 DEED BOOK 0521 PG-00698 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 165,240 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 236,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-16 **************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-3-16 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 Rieck Peter Pine Plains 134201 58,616 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 1109 Buck Hollow Rd Twin Lakes 58,616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 58,616 Mohnton, PA 19540 FRNT 164.20 DPTH 175.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 58,616 TO M EAST-0683070 NRTH-1177609 DEED BOOK 0521 PG-00696 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,737 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-27 ****************** Water St 152.-1-27 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 96,968 Riegel Cornelius Hudson 100600 23,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 96,968 1551 Rte 10 Micro No. 724 96,968 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,968 Ancram, NY 12502 FRNT 110.00 DPTH 160.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 96,968 TO M EAST-0698637 NRTH-1210077 DEED BOOK C0320 PG-F1534 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,526 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-53 ****************** Wire Rd 149.-1-53 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 154,496 Ries Stanley Germantown 103602 47,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 154,496 Ries Aline Micro#9254 154,496 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 154,496 48 Great Jones St ACRES 2.82 BANKC120345 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 154,496 TO M New York, NY 10012 EAST-0668865 NRTH-1215807 DEED BOOK 0588 PG-01083 FULL MARKET VALUE 220,709 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 268 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-33 ***************** 12 Off Pine Rd 201.2-1-33 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,504 Riker John Pine Plains 134201 24,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,504 Riker Mildred Bruckert 32,504 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,504 4223 Route 9G ACRES 0.34 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,504 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0681403 NRTH-1176075 DEED BOOK 0650 PG-00162 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,434 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-42 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-42 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 44,744 Riker John III Pine Plains 134201 29,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 44,744 Riker Mildred FRNT 80.00 DPTH 250.00 44,744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,744 4223 Route 9G EAST-0681920 NRTH-1172627 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 44,744 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 DEED BOOK 00708 PG-00275 FULL MARKET VALUE 63,920 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-30 ***************** 74 Pine Rd 201.2-1-30 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 373,320 Riker John III Pine Plains 134201 41,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 373,320 Riker Mildred Bruckert 373,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 373,320 4223 Route 9G ACRES 1.60 BANKH110045 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 373,320 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0680983 NRTH-1176115 DEED BOOK 0414 PG-00310 FULL MARKET VALUE 533,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-27 ****************** 138 Old Manorton Rd 181.-1-27 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ringwood Robin L Red Hook 134801 66,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 161,976 138 Old Manorton Rd ACRES 8.40 BANKC120321 161,976 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 161,976 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681829 NRTH-1188656 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 135,416 DEED BOOK C0323 PG-F1285 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 161,976 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 231,394 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-26 **************** Highland Ave 192.20-2-26 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ripley Scott D Pine Plains 134201 38,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 168,368 Ripley Annette Micro 4395 168,368 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 168,368 PO Box 109 FRNT 211.42 DPTH 165.25 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 141,808 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKH190328 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 168,368 TO M EAST-0683899 NRTH-1178150 DEED BOOK C504 PG-F1305 FULL MARKET VALUE 240,526 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 269 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-2-1 ***************** Mountainview Dr 192.20-2-1 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 193,392 Rippe Henry G Pine Plains 134201 51,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 193,392 Rippe Bernadette Twin Lakes 193,392 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 193,392 27701 Hwy 9 Micro 00-136 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 193,392 TO M Pageland, SC 29728 ACRES 2.71 EAST-0683638 NRTH-1178930 DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F1211 FULL MARKET VALUE 276,274 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-43.200 ************** CR 31 139.-1-43.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 Ritucci-Chinni Franz Germantown 103602 55,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 Gredory ACRES 4.00 BANKC120345 55,760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 93-97 Wickham Way EAST-0678775 NRTH-1221488 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,760 TO M Orlando, FL 32836 DEED BOOK 0652 PG-00023 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-13.200 ************** Off Black Ridge Rd 182.-1-13.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rivenburgh James H Germantown 103602 48,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,744 Rivenburgh Carolann Micro 00-139 129,744 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,744 42 Bacon Dr ACRES 2.39 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,184 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0691595 NRTH-1190555 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,744 TO M DEED BOOK C0363 PG-F0676 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,349 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-49.120 ************** 19 Woodchuck Rd 139.-1-49.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rivera Daniel Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 185,600 Rivera Kimberly FRNT 134.17 DPTH 266.50 185,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 185,600 19 Woodchuck Rd EAST-0676791 NRTH-1218594 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 159,040 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 542 PG-2338 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,600 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 265,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-65 ****************** SR 82 151.-1-65 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 113,152 Rivers Christopher D Sr Hudson 100600 29,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 113,152 PO Box 118 FRNT 280.00 DPTH 101.58 113,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,152 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0696617 NRTH-1209753 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 113,152 TO M DEED BOOK 619 PG-2127 FULL MARKET VALUE 161,646 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 270 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-5 ******************* LOT 18 Mahikan Dr 161.-2-5 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Robbins Michael Hudson 100600 39,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 258,944 Robbins Michelle Micro 94-118 & 95-283 258,944 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 258,944 31 Makikan Dr ACRES 1.08 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 232,384 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0686101 NRTH-1202853 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 258,944 TO M DEED BOOK C408 PG-F1765 FULL MARKET VALUE 369,920 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-30.200 ************** Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-30.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Roberts William Hudson 100600 45,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 238,544 Roberts Deidre ACRES 4.00 238,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 238,544 289 Cold Spring Rd EAST-0682751 NRTH-1213296 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 211,984 Hudosn, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00695 PG-00178 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 238,544 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 340,777 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-12.120 ************** Bells Pond Rd 141.-1-12.120 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Robertson Paul Copake-Taconic 102801 43,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,272 Robertson Cathy ACRES 1.88 BANKC130172 170,272 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,272 7 Jacqueline Rd EAST-0696850 NRTH-1218613 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,712 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0584 PG-00935 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,272 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 243,246 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-36 ****************** CR 2 201.-1-36 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 72,352 Robinson Charles Pine Plains 134201 72,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 72,352 Robinson Sarah ACRES 4.50 BANKA061220 72,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 72,352 4 Carter St EAST-0681441 NRTH-1172366 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 72,352 TO M New Canaan, CT 06840 DEED BOOK 0641 PG-00112 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,360 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-14 ****************** Greendale 128.-1-14 330 Vacant comm - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 8,400 Robinson Jeffrey Hudson 100600 8,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 8,400 Robinson Barbara Ny 200 50-3 9100-109 8,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 8,400 207 Route 9 ACRES 2.60 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 8,400 TO M Ghent, NY 12075 EAST-0668234 NRTH-1227707 DEED BOOK C486 PG-F1689 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 271 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-22 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-22 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rocco Joseph J Hudson 100600 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 214,800 Rocco Katherine M Micro 94-118 214,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 214,800 164 Rhinecliff Rd ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 188,240 Rhinebeck, NY 12572 EAST-0686540 NRTH-0120320 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 214,800 TO M DEED BOOK 572 PG-360 FULL MARKET VALUE 306,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 141.-1-18.200 ************** Water St 141.-1-18.200 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 269,665 269,665 269,665 Rockefeller David Copake-Taconic 102801 289,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,335 Rockefeller Margaret Micro 93-142 289,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,335 Stone House Farm ACRES 57.81 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,335 3161 Route 9 EAST-0701101 NRTH-1218002 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,335 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00732 PG-00314 269,665 EX FULL MARKET VALUE 412,857 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-40.100 ************** US 9 151.-1-40.100 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 659,925 659,925 659,925 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 902,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 850,491 Rockefeller Margaret ACRES 413.42 1510,416 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 850,491 Stone House Farm EAST-0688950 NRTH-1213948 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 850,491 3161 Route 9 DEED BOOK 0546 PG-00598 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 850,491 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 FULL MARKET VALUE 2157,737 659,925 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-40.200 ************** SR 9 151.-1-40.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 131,648 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 45,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 131,648 Stonehouse Farm Micro 97-34 131,648 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,648 3161 Routte 9 ACRES 2.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 131,648 TO M Hudosn, NY 12534 EAST-0687581 NRTH-1215091 DEED BOOK 00546 PG-00598 FULL MARKET VALUE 188,069 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 272 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 159.-1-2.100 *************** Wire Rd 159.-1-2.100 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 497,492 497,492 497,492 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 624,648 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 127,156 3161 Route 9 ACRES 284.70 624,648 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 127,156 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0672727 NRTH-1205197 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 127,156 DEED BOOK C0293 PG-F2102 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 127,156 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 892,354 497,492 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 159.-1-2.200 *************** Wire Rd 159.-1-2.200 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 412,460 412,460 412,460 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 475,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 748,980 Margaret Stone House ACRES 95.28 1161,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 748,980 3161 Route 9 EAST-0672612 NRTH-1207717 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 748,980 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0569 PG-01061 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 748,980 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1659,200 412,460 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 159.-1-3 ******************* Wire Rd 159.-1-3 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 801,879 801,879 801,879 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 1326,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 841,873 Margaret Stone House Farm ACRES 536.30 1643,752 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 841,873 3161 Route 9 EAST-0672995 NRTH-1201008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 841,873 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0562 PG-00152 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 841,873 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 2348,217 801,879 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-20.121 ************** Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-20.121 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 125,565 125,565 125,565 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 132,328 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 6,763 Rockefeller Margaret Micro 94-262 132,328 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 6,763 3161 Rt 9 ACRES 40.40 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,763 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674617 NRTH-1207811 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 6,763 TO M DEED BOOK 00782 PG-00225 125,565 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 189,040 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-27 ****************** 108 Walkers Rd 160.-1-27 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 26,248 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 21,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 26,248 Stone House Farm FRNT 111.50 DPTH 119.46 26,248 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 26,248 3161 Rt 9 EAST-0675074 NRTH-1206891 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 26,248 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0374 PG-F1920 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,497 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 273 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-30.210 ************** CR 10 160.-1-30.210 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 457,911 457,911 457,911 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 606,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 409,089 Margaret Stone House ACRES 315.45 867,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 409,089 3161 Route 9 EAST-0681045 NRTH-1206353 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 409,089 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0644 PG-00136 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 409,089 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1238,571 457,911 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-30.220 ************** Off Schroeder Rd 160.-1-30.220 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 5,712 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 Stonehouse Farm ACRES 1.23 5,712 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,712 3161 Route 9 EAST-0681774 NRTH-1206905 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,712 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0293 PG-F2105 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,160 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-42.100 ************** SR 9 160.-1-42.100 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 179,403 179,403 179,403 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 257,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 339,029 Rockefeller Margaret Micro 97-57 518,432 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 339,029 Stone House Farm ACRES 95.76 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 339,029 3161 Route 9 EAST-0683681 NRTH-1203139 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 339,029 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0546 PG-00816 179,403 EX FULL MARKET VALUE 740,617 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-43 ****************** Platner Rd 160.-1-43 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 671,794 671,794 671,794 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 735,216 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 63,422 Margaret Stone House ACRES 233.00 735,216 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 63,422 3161 Route 9 EAST-0680260 NRTH-1203512 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 63,422 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0562 PG-00152 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 63,422 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1050,309 671,794 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-47 ****************** Walkers Rd 160.-1-47 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 124,032 Rockefeller David Germantown 103602 31,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 124,032 Stone House Farm ACRES 0.74 124,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 124,032 3161 Rtoue 9 EAST-0674519 NRTH-1204491 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 124,032 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00795 PG-00067 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,189 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 274 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-49.111 ************** Rte. 9 Livingston 160.-1-49.111 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 308,400 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 53,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 308,400 Stone House Farm ACRES 4.39 308,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 308,400 3161 Route 9 EAST-0683215 NRTH-1185669 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 308,400 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 590 PG-480 FULL MARKET VALUE 440,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-49.112 ************** Rte. 9 160.-1-49.112 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 313,351 313,351 313,351 Rockefeller David Hudson 100600 336,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 23,249 Margaret Stone House ACRES 86.64 336,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 23,249 3161 Route 9 EAST-0681914 NRTH-1201800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 23,249 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0546 PG-00823 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 23,249 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 480,857 313,351 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-3.100 *************** Sparrow Bush Rd 170.-1-3.100 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 235,078 235,078 235,078 Rockefeller David Red Hook 134801 246,568 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 11,490 Margaret Stone House Micro 9251 246,568 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 11,490 3161 Route 9 ACRES 47.94 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 11,490 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677019 NRTH-1199016 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 11,490 TO M DEED BOOK 0580 PG-00972 235,078 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 352,240 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-6.121 *************** Off CR 31 170.-1-6.121 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 381,325 381,325 381,325 Rockefeller David Red Hook 134801 410,312 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,987 Stone House Farm Micro 98-224 410,312 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,987 3161 Route 9 ACRES 111.67 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,987 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0674304 NRTH-1196401 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,987 TO M DEED BOOK C0325 PG-F0759 381,325 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 586,160 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-3.200 *************** Rt. 9 170.-2-3.200 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 306,379 306,379 306,379 Rockefeller David Red Hook 134801 324,224 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 17,845 Margaret Stone House ACRES 70.16 324,224 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 17,845 3161 Route 9 EAST-0683979 NRTH-1199124 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 17,845 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0547 PG-01132 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 17,845 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 463,177 306,379 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 275 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-6.121 *************** Sr 9 170.-2-6.121 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 330,989 330,989 330,989 Rockefeller David Red Hook 134801 355,096 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 24,107 Margaret Stone House Micro 97-241 355,096 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 24,107 3161 Route 9 ACRES 84.21 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 24,107 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0682093 NRTH-1196666 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 24,107 TO M DEED BOOK 0581 PG-00985 330,989 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 507,280 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-51.200 ************* Shore Dr.lot 21 201.8-2-51.200 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 143,616 Rockensies Raymond Pine Plains 134201 17,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 143,616 Rockensies Mary Twin Lake Realty Subd 143,616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 143,616 114 Westminster Rd Pb 18 Pg 1374 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,616 TO M West Hempstead, NY 11552 ACRES 0.17 EAST-0682899 NRTH-1173329 DEED BOOK 00746 PG-00140 FULL MARKET VALUE 205,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-8 ***************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-3-8 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,920 Rocket Daniel F Pine Plains 134201 29,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,920 15 Poplar St Twin Lakes 0001 29,920 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,920 Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 FRNT 95.97 DPTH 140.55 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,920 TO M EAST-0682950 NRTH-1177758 DEED BOOK 601 PG-1945 FULL MARKET VALUE 42,743 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-1-3 ****************** Elizaville, C.r. 19 192.4-1-3 484 1 use sm bld COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 132,192 Rodan Venture Llc Pine Plains 134201 33,062 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 132,192 PO Box 267 ACRES 0.61 132,192 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 132,192 Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0682270 NRTH-1177827 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 132,192 TO M DEED BOOK C522 PG-F1815 FULL MARKET VALUE 188,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-25 ****************** Sr 9 170.-2-25 442 MiniWhseSelf COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Rodrigues John Red Hook 134801 30,573 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 Rodrigues Ilda ACRES 1.70 198,288 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 198,288 RD 1 EAST-0678758 NRTH-1194619 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,288 TO M PO Box 156 DEED BOOK 0498 PG-00740 Pine Plains, NY 12567 FULL MARKET VALUE 283,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 276 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-26 ****************** 2274 SR 9 170.-2-26 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,848 Rodrigues John Red Hook 134801 32,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,848 156 Skiba Rd FRNT 70.00 DPTH 446.40 107,848 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,848 Pine Plains, NY 12567 EAST-0678648 NRTH-1194579 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,848 TO M DEED BOOK 576 PG-2321 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,069 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-14 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-14 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,368 Rodriguez Victor M Pine Plains 134201 32,368 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,368 34 Parker Rd Bruckert 32,368 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,368 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 305.00 DPTH 110.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,368 TO M BANKC030981 EAST-0682252 NRTH-1176677 DEED BOOK 430 PG-1212 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,240 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-23 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-23 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rodriguez Victor M Pine Plains 134201 47,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 188,632 34 Parker Rd Bruckert 188,632 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 188,632 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.00 BANKC030981 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 162,072 EAST-0682223 NRTH-1176497 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 188,632 TO M DEED BOOK 430 PG-1212 FULL MARKET VALUE 269,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-19 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-19 920 Priv Hunt/Fi COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 45,016 Roe-Jan Creek Boat Club Germantown 103602 39,310 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 45,016 PO Box 144 FRNT 170.00 DPTH 220.00 45,016 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 45,016 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0666199 NRTH-1219963 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 45,016 TO M DEED BOOK 0326 PG-00152 FULL MARKET VALUE 64,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-20 ****************** Washburn Rd 138.-1-20 920 Priv Hunt/Fi COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 Roe-Jan Creek Boat Club Germantown 103602 43,466 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 PO Box 144 ACRES 1.30 57,120 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 57,120 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0666369 NRTH-1220034 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 57,120 TO M DEED BOOK 0326 PG-00152 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,600 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 277 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-41.100 ************** Off Maple Ln 170.-2-41.100 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Roger Richard Red Hook 134801 43,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 286,688 Roger Christine ACRES 1.80 BANKC030950 286,688 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 286,688 120 Maple Ln EAST-0683138 NRTH-1194098 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 260,128 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0371 PG-F0515 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 286,688 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 409,554 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-64 ****************** 389 Sr 82 151.-1-64 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rogers Ramona N Hudson 100600 35,900 RPTL 459C 41930 56,304 56,304 56,304 389 Sr 82 FRNT 105.00 DPTH 388.70 112,608 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 56,304 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0696747 NRTH-1209994 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 56,304 DEED BOOK 630 PG-1959 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,744 FULL MARKET VALUE 160,869 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 112,608 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-54 ***************** Shore Dr Lts 56-57 201.2-1-54 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Romanchuk Linda L Pine Plains 134201 41,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 212,024 Romanchuk Thomas J Reilly Twin Lake 212,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 212,024 58 Shore Dr FRNT 107.06 DPTH 140.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 185,464 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANKC200200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 212,024 TO M EAST-0682486 NRTH-1174988 DEED BOOK 00709 PG-00267 FULL MARKET VALUE 302,891 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-36 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-36 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 316,200 Root David M Hudson 100600 38,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 316,200 Root Robin A ACRES 1.30 BANKH030619 316,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 316,200 1 North Clover Dr EAST-0688522 NRTH-1207358 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 316,200 TO M Great Neck, NY 11021 DEED BOOK C481 PG-F2114 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 316,200 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 451,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-44 ***************** Livingston Church Rd 161.1-1-44 210 1 Family Res COM VET/C 41132 27,608 0 0 Rosand Erling Hudson 100600 27,700 AGED - ALL 41800 74,256 88,060 88,060 Rosand Joan FRNT 108.50 DPTH 181.47 176,120 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 PO Box 191 EAST-0688034 NRTH-1206347 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 74,256 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0511 PG-00571 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 88,060 FULL MARKET VALUE 251,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 37,790 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,120 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 176,120 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 278 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-23 ****************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-23 321 Abandoned ag COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 92,480 Rose Elmer (Edward F) Pine Plains 134201 92,480 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 92,480 Lozier Cathy ACRES 25.00 92,480 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,480 106 White Oak Rd EAST-0684574 NRTH-1180811 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 92,480 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523-1215 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,114 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-15 ****************** White Oak Rd 192.-1-15 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 278,800 Rose Stephen Pine Plains 134201 75,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 278,800 Rose Janine K ACRES 17.00 278,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 278,800 21 E 10th St Apt 12E EAST-0683982 NRTH-1181970 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 278,800 TO M New York, NY 10003 DEED BOOK C0344 PG-F0571 FULL MARKET VALUE 398,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-19 ****************** Black Bridge Rd 182.-1-19 240 Rural res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 278,800 Rosen Richard Germantown 103602 65,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 278,800 Rosen Tracie Lots 5, 6, 7, 8 278,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 278,800 155 Blackbridge Rd Micro 5356 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 278,800 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 10.10 BANKC030982 EAST-0688966 NRTH-1189900 DEED BOOK 00756 PG-00308 FULL MARKET VALUE 398,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-18 ****************** CR 19 192.-1-18 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 156,128 Rosenbaum Margaret Germantown 103602 45,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 156,128 3130 Irwin Ave Apt 5g Micro 4855 156,128 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 156,128 Bronx, NY 10463 ACRES 2.03 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 156,128 TO M EAST-0682672 NRTH-1182128 DEED BOOK 0568 PG-00032 FULL MARKET VALUE 223,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-21.200 ************** Walkers Mill Rd 160.-1-21.200 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 Rosenberg Paula Germantown 103602 40,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 632 Morris St ACRES 5.49 40,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 40,800 Albany, NY 12208-3245 EAST-0675552 NRTH-1208022 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 40,800 TO M DEED BOOK C0294 PG-F1495 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,286 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 279 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-47.200 ************** Betty Rd 192.-1-47.200 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 19,312 Rosenthal Samantha Pine Plains 134201 8,315 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 19,312 175 W 12th St Apt 11N Micro 7334 19,312 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 19,312 New York, NY 10011 FRNT 68.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 19,312 TO M EAST-0684520 NRTH-1177676 PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 DEED BOOK 657 PG-239 Kreig Tyson FULL MARKET VALUE 27,589 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-14 ***************** Betty Rd 192.4-2-14 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 121,992 Rosenthal Samantha Pine Plains 134201 21,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,992 175 W 12th St Apt 11N FRNT 60.00 DPTH 112.00 121,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,992 New York, NY 10011 EAST-0684460 NRTH-1177591 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 121,992 TO M DEED BOOK 657 PG-239 PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,274 Kreig Tyson ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-15 ***************** Cove Dr 192.4-2-15 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 66,776 Rosenthal Samantha Pine Plains 134201 48,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 66,776 175 W 12th St Apt 11N FRNT 105.68 DPTH 140.00 66,776 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 66,776 New York, NY 10011 EAST-0684490 NRTH-1177561 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 66,776 TO M DEED BOOK 657 PG-234 PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2009 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,394 Kreig Tyson ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-36 ****************** Sr 9 170.-1-36 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 225,000 Ross John F Red Hook 134801 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 225,000 Ross Mary ACRES 1.00 BANK0130715 225,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 225,000 29 Whitman Rd EAST-0676460 NRTH-1193555 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 225,000 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK F471 PG-F369 FULL MARKET VALUE 321,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-28 ***************** 29 Whitman Rd 201.8-1-28 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ross John Jr Pine Plains 134201 46,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 187,408 Ross Mary Reilly Twin Lake 187,408 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 187,408 29 Whitman Rd FRNT 150.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 160,848 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 187,408 TO M EAST-0682897 NRTH-1174238 DEED BOOK 0532 PG-01031 FULL MARKET VALUE 267,726 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 280 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-10 ***************** 7 Major Rd 201.8-2-10 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 137,904 Rosselli Bartholomew Pine Plains 134201 19,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 137,904 25-26 South Tambor St Pb 18 Pg 1374 137,904 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 137,904 PO Box 5 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 137,904 TO M Mes, AZ 85209 EAST-0682758 NRTH-1173598 DEED BOOK 598 PG-1997 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,006 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-21 ****************** 705 CR 31 150.-1-21 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rossi Theresa M Germantown 103602 35,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 119,408 Fucito Carol A Life Estate 119,408 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 119,408 705 County Rte 31 ACRES 1.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,848 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0676748 NRTH-1214984 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 119,408 TO M DEED BOOK 583 PG-293 FULL MARKET VALUE 170,583 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-37 ****************** Off Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-37 280 Multiple res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 275,800 Rotger Scott Pine Plains 134201 52,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 275,800 19 Overland Rd FRNT 118.90 DPTH 530.00 275,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 275,800 Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 EAST-0681241 NRTH-1172205 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 275,800 TO M DEED BOOK 547 PG-358 FULL MARKET VALUE 394,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-1 ****************** CR 19 201.8-1-1 230 3 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 211,344 Rouse Gloria L Pine Plains 134201 44,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 211,344 7 Parker Rd ACRES 1.50 211,344 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 211,344 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682706 NRTH-1174858 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 211,344 TO M DEED BOOK C533 PG-F1441 FULL MARKET VALUE 301,920 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-2-1 ****************** 75 Highland Ave 192.4-2-1 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Roush Margaret Pine Plains 134201 40,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 157,624 75 Highland Ave Micro 4395 157,624 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 157,624 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 191.00 DPTH 224.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 131,064 BANK0180200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,624 TO M EAST-0684029 NRTH-1178210 DEED BOOK C0322 PG-F1593 FULL MARKET VALUE 225,177 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 281 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-48 ****************** CR 19 170.-2-48 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rovigo Connie B Germantown 103602 45,788 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 223,720 739 County Rt 19 0400 223,720 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 223,720 Elizaville, NY 12523 ACRES 2.00 BANKC120345 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 197,160 EAST-0685050 NRTH-1193012 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 223,720 TO M DEED BOOK C481 PG-F2286 FULL MARKET VALUE 319,600 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-12.11 *************** 32 Pettersen Rd 201.-1-12.11 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 191,000 Rovner Michael T Pine Plains 134201 40,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 191,000 Skelly Megan F Lot#2 191,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 191,000 67 Morton St Apt 3E ACRES 1.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 191,000 TO M New York, NY 10014 EAST-0684840 NRTH-0117460 DEED BOOK 632 PG-952 FULL MARKET VALUE 272,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-6.200 ************** Henry St 201.8-1-6.200 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Rowley Anne Pine Plains 134201 41,500 AGED C 41802 59,416 0 0 20 Henry St ACRES 1.03 BANKC061222 165,104 AGED T&S 41806 0 37,135 41,276 Elizaviille, NY 12523 EAST-0682708 NRTH-1176488 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 DEED BOOK 0579 PG-00546 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 89,123 FULL MARKET VALUE 235,863 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 111,404 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 73,558 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 165,104 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-16 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-16 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Rowley Anne Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 20 Henry St Bk18 Pg1374 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M BANKC061222 EAST-0682767 NRTH-1174358 DEED BOOK 0579 PG-00549 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-53 ****************** 1586 CR 31 170.-1-53 240 Rural res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Rozycki Lawrence Red Hook 134801 101,100 AGED T 41803 0 107,995 0 1586 Co Rt 31 Micro 11465 286,552 AGED C&S 41805 134,994 0 143,276 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 18.51 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 EAST-0676246 NRTH-1195664 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 134,993 DEED BOOK C0331 PG-F2283 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 161,992 FULL MARKET VALUE 409,360 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 93,006 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 286,552 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 282 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.4-3-3 ****************** Lakeview Dr 192.4-3-3 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,768 Rubin Elizabeth Pine Plains 134201 35,768 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,768 O'hare Family FRNT 200.00 DPTH 108.00 35,768 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,768 Trust EAST-0683037 NRTH-1179159 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,768 TO M 7 Valley View Ter DEED BOOK C0287 PG-F0826 Suffern, NY 10901 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,097 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-1 ****************** Honor Rd 201.8-2-1 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 Rullo Maria Pine Plains 134201 38,624 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 54 Norwood Rd Pb 18 Pg 1374 38,624 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 38,624 Yonkers, NY 10710 FRNT 170.00 DPTH 165.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 38,624 TO M EAST-0682269 NRTH-1173417 DEED BOOK 0568 PG-00773 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,177 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-65.100 ************** 307 C R 10 149.-1-65.100 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Ruocco William Germantown 103602 36,300 AGED - ALL 41800 46,512 46,512 60,316 Ruocco Michael ACRES 0.95 120,632 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 307 Cemetery Rd EAST-0671398 NRTH-1214974 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 46,512 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C377 PG-F1532 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 46,512 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,331 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 10,046 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,632 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-18 ***************** 3 Loyola Rd Lts 118-119 201.8-2-18 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Ruscillo John J Pine Plains 134201 19,800 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Ruscillo Jean E Bk18 Pg1374 185,096 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 168,531 3 Loyola Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 168,531 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0683347 NRTH-1174059 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 134,826 DEED BOOK 0599 PG-00245 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 185,096 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 264,423 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-28 ****************** Off Cold Spring Rd 150.-1-28 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 88,104 88,104 88,104 Rush Thomas J Hudson 100600 246,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 370,596 Rush Dawn P Micro 1329 458,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 370,596 PO Box 616 ACRES 64.13 BANKC030982 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 370,596 Millwood, NY 10546 EAST-0685190 NRTH-0121300 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 370,596 TO M DEED BOOK C0371 PG-F1947 88,104 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 655,286 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 283 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-23.200 ************** Klibar Rd 150.-1-23.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Rushmore Jill Germantown 103602 50,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,560 34 Klibar Rd ACRES 1.71 215,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,560 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0677567 NRTH-1215616 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 189,000 DEED BOOK C448 PG-F1667 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,560 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 307,943 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-34 ****************** Blue Valley Rd 139.-1-34 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 Russo Felice Hudson 100600 55,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 Russo Frances ACRES 4.00 55,760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 106 Cochran Pl EAST-0683703 NRTH-1222378 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,760 TO M Valley Stream L I, 11581 DEED BOOK 0505 PG-00313 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-36.110 ************** Giambalvo Rd. Lot 2 139.-1-36.110 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 Russo Robert Hudson 100600 47,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 Russo Rose Micro 9515 47,600 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,600 3573 Wyant St ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 47,600 TO M Seaford, NY 11783 EAST-0683684 NRTH-1221998 DEED BOOK 0593 PG-00051 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-55 ***************** TS159-160 Major Rd 201.8-1-55 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 59,306 0 0 Rutigliano Antonia Pine Plains 134201 46,600 AGED T&S 41806 0 29,653 29,653 44 Major Rd Bk18 Pg1374 148,264 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 150.00 DPTH 150.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 88,958 ACRES 0.70 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 118,611 EAST-0682782 NRTH-1175834 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 68,341 DEED BOOK 579 PG-1891 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,264 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 211,806 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-58 ***************** LOT 162 Loyola Rd 201.8-1-58 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 132,328 Rutigliano Antonia Pine Plains 134201 26,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 132,328 44 Major Rd Bk18 Pg1374 132,328 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 132,328 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 150.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 132,328 TO M EAST-0682852 NRTH-1175911 DEED BOOK 579 PG-1894 FULL MARKET VALUE 189,040 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 284 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-52.200 ************** C R 19 192.-1-52.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Ruzich Kristoffer Germantown 103602 48,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 228,700 Ruzich Kendle Micro 9284 & 6818 228,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 228,700 PO Box 104 ACRES 4.90 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 202,140 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0722065 NRTH-0543729 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 228,700 TO M DEED BOOK 548 PG-616 FULL MARKET VALUE 326,714 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-37 ***************** Major Rd. Lot 155-156 201.8-1-37 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Ryan Keith W Pine Plains 134201 29,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 20 Major Rd Bk18 Pg1374 29,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 29,104 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 29,104 TO M EAST-0682668 NRTH-1173958 DEED BOOK 559 PG-1780 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,577 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-43 ***************** LOT 157 Major Rd 201.8-1-43 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 201,960 Ryan Keith W Pine Plains 134201 37,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 201,960 20 Major Rd Reilly Twin Lake 201,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 201,960 Elizaville, NY 12523 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 201,960 TO M EAST-0682718 NRTH-1173898 DEED BOOK 559 PG-1780 FULL MARKET VALUE 288,514 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-25 ****************** Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-25 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Saad Theodore W Red Hook 134801 46,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 239,496 52 Grove St Apt 2A ACRES 2.30 239,496 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 239,496 New York, NY 10014 EAST-0674059 NRTH-1193890 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 212,936 DEED BOOK 644 PG-901 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 239,496 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 342,137 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-10.2 **************** 795 CR 19 182.-1-10.2 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Sabatino Edwina Germantown 103602 54,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 16 Westview Ln ACRES 2.00 54,672 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 54,672 Red Hok, NY 12571 EAST-0721041 NRTH-1617523 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 54,672 TO M DEED BOOK 629 PG-94 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,103 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 285 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-9 ******************* 395 CR 19 171.-1-9 220 2 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Sackett Robert Germantown 103602 35,000 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Sackett Pamela ACRES 1.00 153,544 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 136,979 395 Conty Rte 19 EAST-0686466 NRTH-1200234 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 136,979 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00752 PG-00148 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,984 FULL MARKET VALUE 219,349 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,544 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-72 ****************** Schneider Rd Lot 5 161.-1-72 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 63,104 Salcau Daniela Thriver I Hudson 100600 63,104 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 63,104 Salcau Michael E Micro 9685 & 10692 63,104 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 63,104 42-05 48th Ave Apt 6-G ACRES 5.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 63,104 TO M Woodside, NY 11377 EAST-0694761 NRTH-1208080 DEED BOOK 0635 PG-00240 FULL MARKET VALUE 90,149 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-10.200 ************** 2279 Rte 9 170.-1-10.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Salkin Jonathan Red Hook 134801 69,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 429,216 Salkin Lorraine ACRES 6.20 429,216 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 429,216 2279 Route 9 EAST-0717024 NRTH-0544820 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 402,656 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0484 PG-F1885 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 429,216 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 613,166 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-19 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-19 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Salvaggio John J Jr Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Zammiello Teresa M Micro 94-118 35,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 2542 NE 15th Land ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,000 TO M Jensen Beach, FL 34957 EAST-0686300 NRTH-0120350 DEED BOOK 605 PG-414 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-42.200 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-42.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Salvatore Jacqueline Hudson 100600 55,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 348,024 691 Church Rd ACRES 3.00 348,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 348,024 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0694558 NRTH-1204410 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 321,464 DEED BOOK C0367 PG-F1312 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 348,024 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 497,177 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 286 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-61 ****************** LOT 4 Scuderhook Rd 171.-1-61 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 104,473 104,473 104,473 Sammis Peter C Germantown 103602 191,608 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 129,447 226 Cherokee Hill Lane ACRES 55.20 233,920 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 129,447 Tryon, NC 28782 EAST-0689849 NRTH-1198981 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 129,447 DEED BOOK C500 PG-F344 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 129,447 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 334,171 104,473 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-44.120 ************** 510 C R 10 150.-1-44.120 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Santacroce Frank Germantown 103602 50,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 230,520 Santacroce Gloria ACRES 3.71 230,520 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 230,520 510 County Rte 10 EAST-0675553 NRTH-1212262 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 180,250 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0576 PG-00379 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 230,520 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 329,314 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-2 ****************** Loyola Rd 201.8-2-2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 Santagata Grace Pine Plains 134201 39,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 PO Box 3652 Bk18 Pg1374 39,440 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 39,440 New York, NY 10185 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 90.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 39,440 TO M EAST-0682239 NRTH-1173267 DEED BOOK 00794 PG-00208 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,343 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-2-51.100 ************* 39 Shore Dr Lot 20 201.8-2-51.100 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Santagata Joseph Jr Pine Plains 134201 24,100 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Santagata Lucille FRNT 50.00 DPTH 151.00 176,392 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 159,827 39 Shore Dr EAST-0682875 NRTH-1175293 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 159,827 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 0547 PG-00423 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 126,122 FULL MARKET VALUE 251,989 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 176,392 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-23 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-23 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Santandra Andrew Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 2245 Route 83 Micro 94-118 35,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 35,000 Pine Plains, NY 12567 ACRES 1.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 35,000 TO M EAST-0686580 NRTH-0120310 DEED BOOK 619 PG-1014 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,000 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 287 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-2-26 ****************** CR 19 161.-2-26 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 210,000 Santandra Andrew Hudson 100600 35,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 210,000 2245 Route 83 Lot2 210,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 210,000 Pine Plains, NY 12567 Micro 0-291 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 210,000 TO M ACRES 1.00 EAST-0686670 NRTH-0120250 DEED BOOK 613 PG-906 FULL MARKET VALUE 300,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-92 ****************** Schneider Rd Lot 6 161.-1-92 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 70,176 Santoli Domenico Hudson 100600 70,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 70,176 Santoli Tina Micro 10692 70,176 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,176 11 Clark Pl ACRES 6.12 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 70,176 TO M W Harrison, NY 10604 EAST-0693456 NRTH-1208107 DEED BOOK 0660 PG-00013 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,251 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-3-40 **************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-3-40 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 179,928 Sardaro John C Pine Plains 134201 27,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 179,928 Sardaro Mary L Twin Lakes 0001 179,928 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 179,928 126 Shields Rd FRNT 143.18 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 179,928 TO M Red Hook, NY 12571 EAST-0682661 NRTH-1177318 DEED BOOK 635 PG-2000 FULL MARKET VALUE 257,040 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-48 ****************** Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-48 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 9,760 9,760 9,760 Sarubbi Gieseppe Hudson 100600 86,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 116,312 Sarubbi Caterina Micro 97-117 126,072 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 116,312 95 King St ACRES 21.81 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 116,312 Pleasantville, NY 10570 EAST-0697751 NRTH-1211825 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 116,312 TO M DEED BOOK C0294 PG-F0836 9,760 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 180,103 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-14.111 ************** Ten Broeck Rd 152.-1-14.111 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 52,039 52,039 52,039 Sarubbi Giuseppe Hudson 100600 117,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 103,953 Sarubbi Catarina Micro 96-10 & 97-117 155,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 103,953 95 King St ACRES 33.51 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 103,953 Pleasantville, NY 10570 EAST-0698643 NRTH-1211827 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 103,953 TO M DEED BOOK C0371 PG-F0078 52,039 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 222,846 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 288 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-59 ****************** 865 CR 10 150.-1-59 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Sassi Michael Germantown 103602 73,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,500 Sassi Michele ACRES 10.32 197,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,500 865 County Rte 10 EAST-0680539 NRTH-1209412 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,940 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0298 PG-F1570 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 282,143 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-29 ****************** Bingham Mills Rd 170.-1-29 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 120,401 120,401 120,401 Saulpaugh George W & Red Hook 134801 174,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 94,887 Son Inc ACRES 40.00 215,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 94,887 1790 Rt 9 EAST-0675280 NRTH-1193563 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,887 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0280 PG-00075 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 94,887 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 307,554 120,401 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-34 ****************** Sr 9 170.-2-34 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 51,804 51,804 51,804 Saulpaugh George W & Red Hook 134801 55,488 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 3,684 Son Inc ACRES 12.00 55,488 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 3,684 1790 Rt 9 EAST-0679678 NRTH-1194271 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 3,684 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0280 PG-00075 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 3,684 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 79,269 51,804 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-10.100 ************** CR 8 181.-1-10.100 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 316,396 316,396 316,396 Saulpaugh George W & Red Hook 134801 370,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 120,164 Son Inc ACRES 76.19 436,560 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,164 1790 Rt 9 EAST-0681093 NRTH-1191684 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,164 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0344 PG-00023 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 120,164 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 623,657 316,396 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-8 ******************* CR 19 192.-1-8 151 Fruit crop AG DISTRIC 41720 548,877 548,877 548,877 Saulpaugh George W & Germantown 103602 641,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 206,875 Son Inc ACRES 149.90 755,752 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 206,875 1790 Rt 9Tar Rte EAST-0681199 NRTH-1183335 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 206,875 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0495 PG-00404 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 206,875 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 1079,646 548,877 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 289 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-10.200 ************** 1790 C R 8 181.-1-10.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Saulpaugh Alan Red Hook 134801 57,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 388,008 1790 Rte 9 Micro 9894 388,008 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 388,008 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 5.61 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 361,448 EAST-0680330 NRTH-1190783 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 388,008 TO M DEED BOOK 0625 PG-00110 FULL MARKET VALUE 554,297 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-1 ******************* CR 19 192.-1-1 312 Vac w/imprv AG DISTRIC 41720 138,464 138,464 138,464 Saulpaugh George Germantown 103602 206,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 174,200 Saulpaugh Son ACRES 89.40 312,664 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 174,200 1790 Rte 9 EAST-0680915 NRTH-1185524 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 174,200 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0505 PG-00744 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 174,200 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 446,663 138,464 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-13 ****************** Blue Stores 170.-1-13 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Saulpaugh Linda Red Hook 134801 39,600 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 370,872 2323 Rte 9 ACRES 1.46 370,872 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 370,872 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0679506 NRTH-1195561 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 344,312 DEED BOOK C0364 PG-F2354 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 370,872 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 529,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-3.210 *************** Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-3.210 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 372,194 372,194 372,194 Saulpaugh Marian Pine Plains 134201 408,544 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,350 1960 Route 9 ACRES 108.80 408,544 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,350 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0679732 NRTH-1176752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,350 DEED BOOK 0574 PG-00038 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,350 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 583,634 372,194 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-2-1 ******************* Mills Rd 181.-2-1 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 119,868 119,868 119,868 Saulpaugh Marion Red Hook 134801 129,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,260 Saulpaugh Laurence ACRES 30.03 156,128 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,260 1960 Rte 9 EAST-0674592 NRTH-1192581 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,260 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C511 PG-F1666 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,260 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 223,040 119,868 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 290 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-11 ****************** Off SR 9 170.-1-11 105 Vac farmland COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 13,736 Saulpaugh Vernon Red Hook 134801 11,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 13,736 1960 Rte 9 ACRES 1.30 13,736 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 13,736 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0679665 NRTH-1195701 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 13,736 TO M DEED BOOK 0495 PG-00382 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,623 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-49 ****************** Sparrow Bush Rd 170.-1-49 140 Truck crops AG DISTRIC 41720 270,880 270,880 270,880 Saulpaugh Vernon Red Hook 134801 339,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 318,408 1960 Rte 9 Micro 8597 589,288 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 318,408 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 113.66 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 318,408 EAST-0679043 NRTH-1197120 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 318,408 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 0554 PG-01094 270,880 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 841,840 ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-8.1 ***************** Maple Ln. 170.-2-8.1 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 70,992 Saulpaugh Vernon Germantown 103602 70,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 70,992 1960 Rte 9 ACRES 9.60 70,992 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 70,992 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0723363 NRTH-0544821 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 70,992 TO M DEED BOOK 0513 PG-00044 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,417 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-28 ****************** CR 8 181.-1-28 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 526,955 526,955 526,955 Saulpaugh Vernon Red Hook 134801 599,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1124,221 1960 Rte 9 ACRES 68.04 1651,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1124,221 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0681057 NRTH-1189744 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1124,221 DEED BOOK 0554 PG-01091 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1124,221 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 2358,823 526,955 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-33.1 **************** Pleasant Vale Rd 201.-1-33.1 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 198,132 198,132 198,132 Saulpaugh Vernon Pine Plains 134201 293,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 252,768 1960 Rte 9 ACRES 85.80 450,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 252,768 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0679948 NRTH-1173553 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 252,768 DEED BOOK 00761 PG-00185 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 252,768 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 644,143 198,132 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 291 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-45.200 ************* Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-45.200 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 60,112 Saunders Francis Jr Pine Plains 134201 45,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 60,112 283 Old Johnstown Rd ACRES 1.70 60,112 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 60,112 Johnstown, NY 12095 EAST-0681515 NRTH-1175101 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 60,112 TO M DEED BOOK C0283 PG-F0409 FULL MARKET VALUE 85,874 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-36 ****************** 197 CR 10 149.-1-36 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Savarese Paul Germantown 103602 38,181 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Davison Amy FRNT 140.00 DPTH 264.00 117,368 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 100,803 197 Cr 10 EAST-0670186 NRTH-1216221 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 100,803 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 598 PG-925 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 90,808 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,669 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 117,368 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-5.111 *************** Livingston 160.-1-5.111 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 85,992 85,992 85,992 Savarese Paul J Hudson 100600 300,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 468,708 Davison Amy Jo Micro 05-126 554,700 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 468,708 412 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 153.08 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 468,708 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685000 NRTH-0120800 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 468,708 TO M DEED BOOK 585 PG-1085 85,992 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 792,429 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-63 ****************** 412 Cold Spring Rd 160.-1-63 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 235,800 Savarese Paul J Hudson 100600 76,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 235,800 Davison Amy Jo Micro05-126 235,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 235,800 412 Cold Spring Rd ACRES 5.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 235,800 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0685860 NRTH-0120820 DEED BOOK 585 PG-1091 FULL MARKET VALUE 336,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-33 ****************** Schuderhook Rd 171.-1-33 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 169,456 Scali Dominick Germantown 103602 48,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 169,456 2301 80th St ACRES 3.00 169,456 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 169,456 Brooklyn, NY 11214 EAST-0688282 NRTH-1197118 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 169,456 TO M DEED BOOK C515 PG-F1453 FULL MARKET VALUE 242,080 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 292 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-35 ****************** Schuderhook Rd 171.-1-35 322 Rural vac>10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 260,440 Scali Dominick Germantown 103602 260,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 260,440 Scali Angela ACRES 101.60 260,440 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 260,440 2301 80th St EAST-0687604 NRTH-1196337 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 260,440 TO M Brooklyn, NY 11214 DEED BOOK 0539 PG-00467 FULL MARKET VALUE 372,057 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-74.100 ************** SR 9G 138.-1-74.100 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 Scavone Salvatore J Hudson 100600 90,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 Scavone Anthony Micro 8609 107,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 107,032 32 Madison Ave ACRES 20.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 107,032 TO M West Harrison, NY 10604 EAST-0672041 NRTH-1223895 DEED BOOK C0326 PG-F0871 FULL MARKET VALUE 152,903 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-22 ****************** Walkers Rd 160.-1-22 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 221,136 Schell Maurice Germantown 103602 53,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 221,136 Civiello Laura Micro 95-159 221,136 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 221,136 610 W 110Th St Apt 7a ACRES 1.80 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 221,136 TO M New York, NY 10025 EAST-0675013 NRTH-1207381 DEED BOOK 00798 PG-00236 FULL MARKET VALUE 315,909 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-26 ****************** Lottas Ln 151.-1-26 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 103,177 103,177 103,177 Schenk Mary Hudson 100600 407,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 394,447 Joseph Schenk ACRES 164.00 497,624 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 394,447 867 S Granite Cir EAST-0686177 NRTH-1215163 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 394,447 Anaheim, CA 92806 DEED BOOK 578 PG-1843 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 394,447 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 710,891 103,177 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-33 ****************** 385 Cr 31 139.-1-33 240 Rural res AGED - ALL 41800 99,008 99,008 99,008 Scherer Franz Germantown 103602 67,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Scherer Erna ACRES 10.60 198,016 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 99,008 385 Rte 31 EAST-0680243 NRTH-1222471 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 99,008 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 0462 PG-00562 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 48,738 FULL MARKET VALUE 282,880 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,016 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 293 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-10 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-10 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Scherer James Pine Plains 134201 34,000 DIS VET/CT 41141 12,022 12,022 0 Scherer Mary Twin Lakes 240,448 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 44 Cottonwood Rd FRNT 203.33 DPTH 137.11 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 211,861 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0080490 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 211,861 EAST-0682809 NRTH-1178328 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 190,178 DEED BOOK C410 PG-F1209 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 240,448 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 343,497 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-11.112 ************** 96 Water St 152.-1-11.112 270 Mfg housing BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schmid Raymond K Copake-Taconic 102801 47,400 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,672 96 Water Street Rd Micro 6381 122,672 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,672 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.24 BANKN140687 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 96,112 EAST-0699745 NRTH-1216114 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,672 TO M DEED BOOK C464 PG-F1488 FULL MARKET VALUE 175,246 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-12 ****************** 1632 CR 8 181.-1-12 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Schmidt James Red Hook 134801 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,584 Schmidt Mildred ACRES 2.00 BANKC130171 155,584 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,584 1632 Country Rt 8 EAST-0679773 NRTH-1191641 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 105,314 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 00708 PG-00251 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,584 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 222,263 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-47.1 **************** Deerhaven Rd 182.-1-47.1 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schmidt Philip A Germantown 103602 59,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 197,000 Schmidt Nicole G ACRES 10.99 197,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 197,000 224 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0728743 NRTH-0544552 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,440 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 618 PG-347 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 197,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 281,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-47.2 **************** Deerhaven Rd 182.-1-47.2 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Schmidt Ralph P Germantown 103602 62,288 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schmidt Donna ACRES 6.41 BANK0080490 262,288 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 245,723 214 Deerhaven Rd EAST-0728224 NRTH-0544551 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 245,723 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 533 PG-1432 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 235,728 FULL MARKET VALUE 374,697 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 262,288 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 294 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-46.200 ************** Rt 19 Lot 4 161.-1-46.200 271 Mfg housings AGED C 41802 71,604 0 0 Schmidt Richard Hudson 100600 54,000 AGED T&S 41806 0 50,123 50,123 Schmidt Maria ACRES 2.90 143,208 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 PO Box 228 EAST-0686499 NRTH-1203814 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 71,604 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 00676 PG-00247 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 93,085 FULL MARKET VALUE 204,583 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 42,815 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 143,208 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-77.200 ************** CR 10 149.-1-77.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schmitz David A Germantown 103602 54,536 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 215,100 Schmitz Magdalena B ACRES 3.56 215,100 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 215,100 381 CR 10 EAST-0671722 NRTH-1213065 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 188,540 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 588 PG-95 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 215,100 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 307,286 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-95 ****************** Church Rd 161.-1-95 314 Rural vac<10 AG DISTRIC 41720 72,037 72,037 72,037 Schneider Beverly Hudson 100600 73,440 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 1,403 Box 7 ACRES 8.90 73,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 1,403 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0689125 NRTH-1205799 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 1,403 DEED BOOK 0611 PG-00388 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1,403 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 104,914 72,037 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 73,440 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-50.111 ************** Schneider Rd 151.-1-50.111 112 Dairy farm AG DISTRIC 41720 257,281 257,281 257,281 Schneider Charles Hudson 100600 312,500 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Schneider Beverly ACRES 107.91 566,984 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 309,703 Box 7 EAST-0692468 NRTH-1209715 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 309,703 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00778 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 259,433 FULL MARKET VALUE 809,977 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 309,703 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 257,281 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-17.111 ************** Church Rd 161.-1-17.111 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 148,066 148,066 148,066 Schneider Charles Hudson 100600 158,440 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 10,374 Schneider Beverly ACRES 48.59 158,440 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 10,374 Box 7 EAST-0690803 NRTH-1206882 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 10,374 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0514 PG-00774 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 10,374 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 226,343 148,066 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 295 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-43.111 ************** Livingston Church Rd 161.-1-43.111 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 30,020 30,020 30,020 Schneider Charles A Jr Hudson 100600 71,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 122,028 Schneider Beverly Micro 93-45&94-120&96-20 152,048 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 122,028 Livingston, NY 12541 ACRES 11.77 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 122,028 EAST-0689486 NRTH-1205530 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 122,028 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 0529 PG-00751 30,020 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 FULL MARKET VALUE 217,211 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 152,048 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-27 ***************** CR 19 161.1-1-27 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 140,898 140,898 0 Schneider Marvin Hudson 100600 31,900 AGED C 41802 8,119 0 0 Schneider Katherine FRNT 100.00 DPTH 275.00 167,960 AGED T&S 41806 0 4,059 25,194 PO Box 72 EAST-0687824 NRTH-1206486 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Livingston, NY 12541 DEED BOOK 0561 PG-00717 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 18,943 FULL MARKET VALUE 239,943 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 23,003 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 92,496 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 167,960 TO M LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 167,960 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-59 ****************** 31 CR 10 138.-1-59 210 1 Family Res WAR VET/CT 41121 16,565 16,565 0 Schneider Walter Germantown 103602 27,100 AGED - ALL 41800 48,838 48,838 57,120 Schneider Jean FRNT 104.42 DPTH 210.11 114,240 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 31 County Rte 10 BANKC130170 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 48,837 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0667791 NRTH-1218627 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 48,837 DEED BOOK 0584 PG-00100 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 6,850 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,200 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,240 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 201.8-1-13 ***************** Henry St 201.8-1-13 260 Seasonal res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schoen Jesse Pine Plains 134201 26,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 619 Pleasantvale Rd Pb 18 Pg 1374 87,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 87,992 Tivoli, NY 12683 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 61,432 EAST-0682917 NRTH-1174449 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 87,992 TO M DEED BOOK C0504 PG-F2356 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,703 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-46 ****************** 72 Old Sr 82 151.-1-46 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schoep James A Hudson 100600 31,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 Schoep Dorothea M Micro No. 3373 104,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,992 72 Old Rt 82 FRNT 126.22 DPTH 239.97 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 78,432 Hudson, NY 12534 BANKC030385 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,992 TO M EAST-0696965 NRTH-1210924 DEED BOOK C0285 PG-F1555 FULL MARKET VALUE 149,989 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 296 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-24 ****************** Sr 82 161.-1-24 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schrader Brian E Hudson 100600 39,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 74,528 511 State Route 82 FRNT 315.00 DPTH 200.00 74,528 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 74,528 Hudson, NY 12534 BANKC061222 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 47,968 EAST-0697583 NRTH-1207036 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 74,528 TO M DEED BOOK 611 PG-1023 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,469 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-56 ****************** 41 CR 10 160.-1-56 220 2 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schroeder Jay Hudson 100600 73,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 280,600 Schroeder Adam Micro 96-138 280,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 280,600 41 Schroeder Rd Hco ACRES 4.80 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 254,040 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681453 NRTH-1207194 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 280,600 TO M DEED BOOK C0307 PG-F1419 FULL MARKET VALUE 400,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-12 ****************** 20 Schroeder Rd 160.-1-12 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 109,083 109,083 0 Schroeder John E Hudson 100600 54,600 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Schroeder Patricia Micro 93-104 164,016 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,933 20 Schroeder Rd ACRES 2.96 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,933 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0681462 NRTH-1207554 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 113,746 DEED BOOK C0319 PG-F0105 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 164,016 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 234,309 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-30.112 ************** 982 CR 10 160.-1-30.112 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schroeder Luke Hudson 100600 49,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 155,992 PO Box 1 ACRES 3.25 155,992 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 155,992 Livingston, NY 12541 EAST-0682914 NRTH-1207127 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 129,432 DEED BOOK C0319 PG-F0108 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 155,992 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 222,846 ******************************************************************************************************* 160.-1-13 ****************** 84 Schroeder Rd 160.-1-13 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schroeder Martin Hudson 100600 93,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 222,088 Schroeder Erika ACRES 24.18 222,088 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 222,088 84 Schroeder Rd EAST-0680302 NRTH-1207772 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 195,528 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK C0319 PG-F0105 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 222,088 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 317,269 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 297 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-18.210 ************** Manorton Pcl 2 181.-1-18.210 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schuhknecht Rolf Germantown 103602 60,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 273,904 Schuhknecht Susan Lee Micro 10729 273,904 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 273,904 868 Co Rt 19 ACRES 8.50 BANK0080490 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 247,344 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682957 NRTH-1189758 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 273,904 TO M DEED BOOK C405 PG-F2351 FULL MARKET VALUE 391,291 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-18.220 ************** Manorton Pcl 2 181.-1-18.220 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 74,800 Schuhknecht Rolf Germantown 103602 74,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 74,800 Schuhknecht Susan Lee Micro 10729 74,800 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 74,800 868 Co Rt 19 ACRES 2.01 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 74,800 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682957 NRTH-1189758 DEED BOOK C405 PG-F2351 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-68 ****************** CR 10 138.-1-68 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 65,960 Schulze Albert J Germantown 103602 33,600 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 65,960 Schulze Rebecca Micro 95-142 65,960 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 65,960 93 CR 10 FRNT 171.22 DPTH 225.58 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 65,960 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0668643 NRTH-1217578 DEED BOOK 647 PG-2357 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,229 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-8 ******************* SR 9G 128.-1-8 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 78,540 78,540 78,540 Schumacher Fred Hudson 100600 71,100 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Reed Augusta Ann ACRES 5.70 157,080 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 78,540 111 Oak Hill Rd EAST-0671855 NRTH-1226834 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 78,540 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 00671 PG-00146 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,270 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,400 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 157,080 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-6.120 *************** Off CR 31 170.-1-6.120 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 102,563 102,563 102,563 Schumer Robert P Red Hook 134801 110,024 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 7,461 Oxenberg Ruth P Micro 11470 & 98-224 110,024 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 7,461 80 John Bay Rd ACRES 10.36 BANKN140687 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 7,461 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0675044 NRTH-1196502 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 7,461 TO M DEED BOOK C0342 PG-F0749 102,563 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 157,177 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 298 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-1-51 ****************** Off CR 31 170.-1-51 240 Rural res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Schumer Robert P Red Hook 134801 128,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 602,616 Oxenberg Ruth P Micro 10668 602,616 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 602,616 80 John Bay Rd ACRES 29.87 BANKN140687 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 576,056 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0676044 NRTH-1196604 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 602,616 TO M DEED BOOK C0342 PG-F0749 FULL MARKET VALUE 860,880 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-4 ******************* 359 Twin Lake Dr 171.-1-4 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 114,512 Schwarze Angela Germantown 103602 27,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 114,512 PO Box 417 Micro 4852 114,512 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 114,512 Germantown, NY 12526 FRNT 126.00 DPTH 175.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 114,512 TO M EAST-0686795 NRTH-1201125 DEED BOOK 618 PG-689 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,589 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-45 ****************** 70 Old State Rte 82 151.-1-45 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 67,320 Scofield Jessie Hudson 100600 31,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 67,320 164 Boston Corners Rd Micro 3373 67,320 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 67,320 Millerton, NY 12546 FRNT 126.22 DPTH 235.47 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 67,320 TO M EAST-0696935 NRTH-1211004 DEED BOOK C531 PG-F134 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,171 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.1-1-49 ***************** 467 Church Rd 161.1-1-49 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Scorca Leonard Hudson 100600 42,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,408 Scorca Antoinette Pb 9 Pg 755 170,408 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,408 467 Church Rd ACRES 1.73 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 120,138 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0688944 NRTH-1206429 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,408 TO M DEED BOOK 0609 PG-00376 LT461 LIVINGSTON LIGHT 170,408 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 243,440 ******************************************************************************************************* 140.-1-34.200 ************** Bells Pond Rd 140.-1-34.200 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 52,166 52,166 52,166 Scott Alfred Hudson 100600 91,200 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 150,202 655 Park Ave #8D ACRES 24.10 202,368 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 150,202 New York, NY 10021-5937 EAST-0694882 NRTH-1217590 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 150,202 DEED BOOK 0536 PG-00231 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 150,202 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 289,097 52,166 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 299 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-10 ****************** Bells Pond Rd 151.-1-10 120 Field crops AG 10 YEAR 41700 3,000 3,000 3,000 Scott Alfred Hudson 100600 231,200 AG DISTRIC 41720 155,057 155,057 155,057 Von Wiesenthal Ruth ACRES 67.90 732,224 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 574,167 655 Park Ave EAST-0696324 NRTH-1216663 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 574,167 New York, NY 10021 DEED BOOK 0574 PG-00841 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 574,167 FULL MARKET VALUE 1046,034 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 577,167 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT 155,057 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-14.100 ************** 125 SR 82 151.-1-14.100 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 130,152 Scott Alfred Hudson 100600 32,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 130,152 800 Third Ave FRNT 105.00 DPTH 323.56 130,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 130,152 New York, NY 10022 EAST-0694605 NRTH-1216379 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 130,152 TO M DEED BOOK C389 PG-F1655 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,931 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-11 ****************** Sr 82 151.-1-11 210 1 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 22,952 22,952 22,952 Scott Alfred L Hudson 100600 60,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 132,768 655 Park Ave ACRES 8.00 155,720 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 132,768 New York, NY 10021 EAST-0694684 NRTH-1216689 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 132,768 DEED BOOK 0389 PG-00525 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 132,768 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 222,457 22,952 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-68 ****************** Ten Broeck Rd 151.-1-68 105 Vac farmland AG DISTRIC 41720 82,752 82,752 82,752 Scott Alfred L Hudson 100600 87,176 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,424 Vonwiesenthal Ruth ACRES 18.30 87,176 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,424 655 Park Ave EAST-0695928 NRTH-1214722 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,424 New York, NY 10021 DEED BOOK C0325 PG-F0512 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,424 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 124,537 82,752 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-42.100 ************** CR 10 149.-1-42.100 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 5,576 Scrodin Leo Germantown 103602 5,576 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 5,576 Weaver Ann ACRES 2.06 5,576 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 5,576 227 Co Rte 10 EAST-0670858 NRTH-1215343 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 5,576 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK C0319 PG-F1444 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,966 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 300 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-62 ****************** 659 C R 10 150.-1-62 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Scrodin Mary Ann Germantown 103602 37,700 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 94,928 659 County Rt 10 Micro 7070 94,928 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 94,928 Germantown, NY 12526 ACRES 0.97 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,658 EAST-0678896 NRTH-1210959 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 94,928 TO M DEED BOOK 0601 PG-00262 FULL MARKET VALUE 135,611 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-95.200 ************** 341 Cemetary Rd 149.-1-95.200 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 66,665 66,665 66,665 Scrodin Michael Germantown 103602 67,200 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Scrodin Lisa Micro 10953, Bk1 Pg6 187,680 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 121,015 341 Cemetery Rd ACRES 10.47 BANK0180200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 121,015 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670249 NRTH-1214912 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 94,455 DEED BOOK 0633 PG-00324 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 121,015 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 268,114 66,665 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-55 ****************** 914 CR 31 150.-1-55 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 52,027 0 0 Scrodin Paul Jr Germantown 103602 28,700 AGED T&S 41806 0 22,297 22,297 Scrodin Emelia FRNT 175.00 DPTH 164.00 148,648 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 914 Rte 31 EAST-0676346 NRTH-1211134 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 96,621 Germantown, NY 12526 DEED BOOK 0324 PG-00088 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 126,351 FULL MARKET VALUE 212,354 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 76,081 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,648 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-40 ****************** 227 C R 10 149.-1-40 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 95,959 95,959 0 Scrodin Timothy Germantown 103602 48,600 AGED - ALL 41800 46,677 46,677 94,656 227 Co Rte 10 ACRES 5.00 189,312 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0670817 NRTH-1215793 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 46,676 DEED BOOK C0335 PG-F0846 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 46,676 FULL MARKET VALUE 270,446 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,386 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 189,312 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-42.200 ************** 237 C R 10 149.-1-42.200 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Scrodin Timothy Germantown 103602 47,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 198,016 Scrodin Patricia Micro 9724 198,016 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 198,016 237 County Rt 10 ACRES 2.74 BANKC040280 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 171,456 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0671087 NRTH-1215653 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 198,016 TO M DEED BOOK 0595 PG-00719 FULL MARKET VALUE 282,880 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 301 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 139.-1-13.111 ************** Spring Rd 139.-1-13.111 210 1 Family Res COM VET/CT 41131 27,608 27,608 0 Seder Samuel Hudson 100600 81,500 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 120 Spring Rd Micro 11858 237,048 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 209,440 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 10.54 BANKC030614 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 209,440 EAST-0683341 NRTH-1223577 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 210,488 DEED BOOK C540 PG-F438 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 237,048 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 338,640 ******************************************************************************************************* 152.-1-36 ****************** 182 Water St 152.-1-36 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 44,608 Sedlock Andrew Hudson 100600 44,608 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 44,608 878 West End Ave Db736-Pg237 44,608 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 44,608 New York, NY 10025-4957 Micro 93-107 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 44,608 TO M ACRES 1.25 EAST-0698250 NRTH-0120840 DEED BOOK 0573 PG-00514 FULL MARKET VALUE 63,726 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-37 **************** Lakeview Dr 192.20-1-37 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Seibel Christopher A Pine Plains 134201 36,100 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 123,760 Seibel Katrine T Twin Lakes 123,760 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 123,760 12 Cottonwood Rd FRNT 86.30 DPTH 104.87 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 97,200 Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0130715 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 123,760 TO M EAST-0683130 NRTH-1177879 DEED BOOK C0360 PG-F0300 FULL MARKET VALUE 176,800 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.20-1-38 **************** Cottonwood Ln 192.20-1-38 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 Seibel Christopher A Pine Plains 134201 36,040 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 Seibel Katrine T Twin Lakes 36,040 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,040 12 Cottonwood Rd FRNT 60.00 DPTH 125.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,040 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 BANK0130715 EAST-0683190 NRTH-1177869 DEED BOOK C0360 PG-F0300 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,486 ******************************************************************************************************* 151.-1-23.200 ************** US 9 151.-1-23.200 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 82,008 Seidman Ellen S Hudson 100600 45,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 82,008 Scofield Peter B ACRES 2.02 82,008 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 82,008 414 Greene St EAST-0690888 NRTH-1214982 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 82,008 TO M Ogdensburg, NY 13669 DEED BOOK 630 PG-2071 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,154 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 302 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-5 ******************* CR 19 170.-2-5 116 Other stock AG 10 YEAR 41700 53,800 53,800 53,800 Sequel Stallions New York LLC Germantown 103602 253,300 AG 10 YEAR 41700 74,000 74,000 74,000 14216 N US Hwy 27 ACRES 158.80 1375,800 AG DISTRIC 41720 180,578 180,578 180,578 Ocala, FL 34482 EAST-0685432 NRTH-1197332 RPTL483_d 42130 111,000 111,000 111,000 DEED BOOK 593 PG-1361 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 956,422 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1965,429 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 956,422 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2019 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 956,422 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 1084,222 TO M 291,578 EX ******************************************************************************************************* 170.-2-8.2 ***************** Maple Ln. 170.-2-8.2 120 Field crops AG DISTRIC 41720 377,816 377,816 377,816 Sequel Stallions New York LLC Germantown 103602 393,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 15,684 14216 N US Hwy 27 ACRES 65.40 393,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 15,684 Ocala, FL 34482 EAST-0722813 NRTH-0544940 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 15,684 DEED BOOK 593 PG-1361 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 15,684 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 562,143 377,816 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-68 ****************** CR 31 150.-1-68 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Sestir James Germantown 103602 45,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 205,500 Sestir Carol ACRES 2.00 205,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 205,500 61 Cedar Ln EAST-0675320 NRTH-0121640 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 178,940 Hudson, NY 12534 DEED BOOK 562 PG-1434 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 205,500 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 293,571 ******************************************************************************************************* 149.-1-29 ****************** 145 Linlithgo Rt 10 149.-1-29 210 1 Family Res AGED - ALL 41800 54,400 54,400 54,400 Shaffer Arthur Germantown 103602 32,627 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 145 County Rte 10 FRNT 130.00 DPTH 210.00 108,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0669165 NRTH-1216639 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 54,400 DEED BOOK 0577 PG-00269 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,130 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,429 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 108,800 TO M ******************************************************************************************************* 182.-1-24 ****************** Taghkanic Rd 182.-1-24 314 Rural vac<10 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 4,352 Shafran Charles Germantown 103602 4,352 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 4,352 Shafran Robin Micro 3291 4,352 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 4,352 7 West 96Th St Apt 5a ACRES 1.60 BANK0080490 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 4,352 TO M New York, NY 10025 EAST-0690709 NRTH-1188573 DEED BOOK 0593 PG-00135 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,217 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 303 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 201.-1-17 ****************** 1563 CR 19 201.-1-17 210 1 Family Res BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Shanahan Michael Pine Plains 134201 43,000 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 148,000 Shanahan Jean ACRES 1.70 148,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 148,000 1563 Rte 19 EAST-0684268 NRTH-1173811 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 121,440 Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 00751 PG-00329 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 148,000 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 211,429 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-31 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-31 260 Seasonal res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 Shapiro Jeanne Hudson 100600 72,900 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 Frank Caruana ACRES 10.20 109,072 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 109,072 67 First St EAST-0696855 NRTH-1206114 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 109,072 TO M Garden City Park, NY 11040 DEED BOOK 00702 PG-00150 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,817 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-29 ****************** CR 19 181.-1-29 220 2 Family Res AG DISTRIC 41720 233,707 233,707 233,707 Shapiro Robert Germantown 103602 470,500 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 778,405 950 Rte 19 ACRES 137.00 1012,112 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 778,405 Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0681361 NRTH-1187525 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 778,405 DEED BOOK 0619 PG-00065 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 778,405 TO M MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 1445,874 233,707 EX UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 181.-1-32 ****************** CR 19 181.-1-32 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 141,032 Shapiro Robert Germantown 103602 48,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 141,032 Shapiro Judith ACRES 3.00 BANKH130392 141,032 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 141,032 950 Rte 19 EAST-0683110 NRTH-1187918 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 141,032 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK C0311 PG-F1110 FULL MARKET VALUE 201,474 ******************************************************************************************************* 171.-1-74 ****************** 250 Scuderhook Rd Lot 2 171.-1-74 210 1 Family Res AGED C 41802 109,276 0 0 Shaw Alfred C Germantown 103602 45,000 AGED T&S 41806 0 98,348 98,348 250 Scudderhook Rd Micro 10694 218,552 EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.00 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 109,276 EAST-0692451 NRTH-1197726 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 120,204 DEED BOOK 00694 PG-00171 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 69,934 FULL MARKET VALUE 312,217 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 218,552 TO M ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 304 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 150.-1-47.100 ************** Marlin Hill Rd 150.-1-47.100 240 Rural res AG DISTRIC 41720 148,530 148,530 148,530 Shea Brian J Germantown 103602 399,900 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 654,006 Shea Lindsay D ACRES 110.60 802,536 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 654,006 Attn: Mary Beth Boruta EAST-0679685 NRTH-1211290 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 654,006 414 County Route 10 DEED BOOK C0289 PG-F1704 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 654,006 TO M Germantown, NY 12526 FULL MARKET VALUE 1146,480 148,530 EX MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2013 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-42 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-42 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 28,152 Shea John Pine Plains 134201 28,152 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 28,152 Shea Kim C Bruckert 28,152 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 28,152 1370 Rte 19 ACRES 1.70 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 28,152 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682065 NRTH-1175427 DEED BOOK 00699 PG-00096 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,217 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-43 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-43 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 41,752 Shea John Pine Plains 134201 19,200 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 41,752 Shea Kim Bk16 Pg1966 41,752 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 41,752 1370 RT 19 FRNT 251.00 DPTH 105.00 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 41,752 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682125 NRTH-1175167 DEED BOOK 645 PG-656 FULL MARKET VALUE 59,646 ******************************************************************************************************* 201.2-1-44 ***************** Bruckert Rd 201.2-1-44 270 Mfg housing COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 Shea John Pine Plains 134201 41,300 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 Shea Kim C Bruckert 55,760 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 55,760 1370 Rte 19 FRNT 250.13 DPTH 175.58 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 55,760 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 EAST-0682005 NRTH-1175157 DEED BOOK 00699 PG-00098 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,657 ******************************************************************************************************* 192.-1-44 ****************** Hapeman Rd 192.-1-44 432 Gas station COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 142,936 Shea Kim Pine Plains 134201 53,444 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 142,936 Shea John ACRES 7.70 142,936 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 142,936 1370 Route 19 EAST-0681780 NRTH-1177756 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 142,936 TO M Elizaville, NY 12523 DEED BOOK 548 PG-1886 FULL MARKET VALUE 204,194 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 305 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-9.110 *************** 48 CR 14 128.-1-9.110 210 1 Family Res VET458(5) 41001 162,890 162,890 0 Sheak Wallace Hudson 100600 53,400 BAS STAR 41854 0 0 26,560 Sheak Karen Micro No 9883 193,800 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 30,910 48 Rte 14 ACRES 3.10 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 30,910 Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0672936 NRTH-1226466 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 167,240 DEED BOOK 00722 PG-00108 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 193,800 TO M FULL MARKET VALUE 276,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-9.120 *************** CR 14 128.-1-9.120 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,912 Sheak Wallace Hudson 100600 32,912 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,912 Sheak Karen Micro No 9883 32,912 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,912 48 Rte 14 ACRES 3.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,912 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0672566 NRTH-1226406 DEED BOOK 00722 PG-00108 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,017 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-9.200 *************** CR 14 128.-1-9.200 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 32,368 Sheak Wallace Hudson 100600 32,368 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 32,368 Sheak Karen Micro No 9883 32,368 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 32,368 48 Rte 14 ACRES 3.10 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 32,368 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 EAST-0672606 NRTH-1226696 DEED BOOK 00722 PG-00108 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,240 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-13.2 **************** SR 9G 128.-1-13.2 311 Res vac land COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 36,400 Sheak Wallace Hudson 100600 36,400 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 36,400 Sheak Karen Lot#3 36,400 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 36,400 48 Route 14 micro05-211 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 36,400 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.80 EAST-0672410 NRTH-0122610 DEED BOOK C519 PG-F884 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,000 ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-13.11 *************** SR 9G 128.-1-13.11 230 3 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 Sheak Wallace Hudson 100600 71,800 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 Sheak Karen Lot#2 170,000 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 170,000 48 Route 14 micro05-211 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 170,000 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 2.00 EAST-0671610 NRTH-0122610 DEED BOOK C519 PG-F884 FULL MARKET VALUE 242,857 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY - Columbia TOWN - LIVINGSTON SWIS - 104600

2 0 0 9 F I N A L A S S E S S M E N T R O L L T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 OWNERS NAME SEQUENCE UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 070.00

PAGE 306 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2008 TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2009

TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------SCHOOL CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS ACCOUNT NO. ******************************************************************************************************* 128.-1-13.12 *************** SR 9G 128.-1-13.12 312 Vac w/imprv COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 83,200 Sheak Wallace Hudson 100600 46,000 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 83,200 Sheak Karen Lot#1 83,200 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 83,200 48 Route 14 micro05-211 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 83,200 TO M Hudson, NY 12534 ACRES 14.70 EAST-0671650 NRTH-0122640 DEED BOOK C519 PG-F884 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,857 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-10 ****************** White Birch Rd 138.-1-10 210 1 Family Res COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 104,448 Sheffer Alvin Germantown 103602 52,500 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 104,448 430 White Birch Rd ACRES 2.00 104,448 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 104,448 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672316 NRTH-1221175 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 104,448 TO M DEED BOOK 00721 PG-00159 FULL MARKET VALUE 149,211 ******************************************************************************************************* 138.-1-35.200 ************** 430 White Birch Rd 138.-1-35.200 210 1 Family Res EN STAR 41834 0 0 50,270 Sheffer Alvin W Germantown 103602 65,300 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUE 153,136 Sheffer Nancy Micro 11968 153,136 TOWN TAXABLE VALUE 153,136 430 White Birch Rd ACRES 9.90 SCHOOL TAXABLE VALUE 102,866 Germantown, NY 12526 EAST-0672238 NRTH-1220485 FD461 LIVINGSTON FIRE 153,136 TO M DEED BOOK 00699 PG-00316 FULL MARKET VALUE 218,766 ******************************************************************************************************* 161.-1-29 ****************** Willowbrook Rd 161.-1-29 210 1 Family Res COUNT