Title by akgame

VIEWS: 41 PAGES: 16

More Info
									Month Year

Title

doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0

IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Submission Designator: doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/1952r10 Venue Date: March 2008
First Author:Clint Chaplin, SISA Subject: Full Date: Author(s):

IEEE 802.11 Non-Procedural Letter Ballot Results
2008-03-29 Name(s) Clint Chaplin Company SISA Address 75 W. Plumeria Dr., San Jose, CA 95134 Phone: 408-544-5815 Fax: email: clint.chaplin@gmail.com
Results of IEEE 802.11 non-procedural Letter Ballots

Abstract:

Notice: This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 802.11. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.

Release: The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications thereof, in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication; to copyright in the IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 802.11. Patent Policy and Procedures: The contributor is familiar with the IEEE 802 Patent Policy and Procedures <http:// ieee802.org/guides/bylaws/sbSubmission 1 Name, Company

Month Year

Title

doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0

Patent Policy and Procedures <http:// ieee802.org/guides/bylaws/sbbylaws.pdf>, including the statement "IEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s), including patent applications, provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder or applicant with respect to patents essential for compliance with both mandatory and optional portions of the standard." Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in the development process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication. Please notify the Chair <stuart@ok-brit.com> as early as possible, in written or electronic form, if patented technology (or technology under patent application) might be incorporated into a draft standard being developed within the IEEE 802.11 Working Group. If you have questions, contact the IEEE Patent Committee Administrator at <patcom@ieee.org>.

Submission

2

Name, Company

Month Year

Title

doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0

ght in the

802

Submission

3

Name, Company

Month Year

Title

doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0

to patents

ibility for

Submission

4

Name, Company

PAR Approved Document IEEE 802.11 IEEE 802.11a 9/16/1997 IEEE 802.11b 12/9/1997 IEEE 802.11c 12/9/1997 IEEE 802.11d 6/26/1999 IEEE 802.11e 3/30/2000 IEEE 802.11F 3/30/2000 IEEE 802.11g 9/21/2000 IEEE 802.11h 12/7/2000 IEEE 802.11i 3/30/2000 IEEE 802.11j 12/11/2002 IEEE 802.11k 12/11/2002 IEEE 802.11ma 3/20/2003 IEEE 802.11n 9/11/2003 IEEE 802.11p 9/23/2004 IEEE 802.11r 5/13/2004 IEEE 802.11s 5/13/2004 IEEE 802.11.2 8/12/2004 IEEE 802.11u 12/8/2004 IEEE 802.11v 12/8/2004 IEEE 802.11w 3/20/2005 IEEE 802.11y 8/22/2007 IEEE 802.11z 8/22/2007 IEEE 802.11aa 3/27/2008

Initial WG Ballots (f

D1.0 D1.1 D2.1 D1.0 D1.0 D1.0 D1.0

LB27 LB26 LB33 LB29 LB25 LB56 LB71

4/5/2001 4/5/2001 1/31/2002 7/25/2001 4/5/2001 1/1/2003 8/2/2004 3/19/2006 3/2/2006 12/7/2006 6/8/2007 7/31/2007

5/15/2001 D2.0 5/15/2001 D2.0 3/11/2002 86 104 45.26% 9/3/2001 5/15/2001 D2.0 5/12/2003 172 45 79.26% 9/11/2004 211 74 74.04% D2.0

LB30 LB28

LB35 LB73

D1.0 LB84 D1.0 LB81 D1.0 LB93 D1.0 LB107 D1.0 LB108

4/29/2006 149 171 46.56% 4/11/2006 167 117 58.80% D2.0 LB92 1/6/2007 128 138 48.12% D2.0 LB126 7/8/2007 111 8/30/2007 132 62 64.16% D2.0 LB122 77 63.16% D2.0 LB123

D1.0 LB127

4/3/2008

5/3/2008 103

59 63.58%

Initial WG Ballots (failed)

Initia

12/5/2001 7/25/2001

1/16/2002 101 84 54.59% D3.0 LB39 9/3/2001

5/23/2002

3/25/2002 2/3/2005

5/4/2002

92 ## 44.44%

3/15/2005 217 86 71.62%

12/6/2006 4/3/2008 2/14/2008 2/14/2008

1/5/2007 166 83 66.67% D3.0 LB110 5/3/2008 103 67 60.59% 3/15/2008 125 53 70.22% 3/15/2008 126 62 67.02% D3.0 LB133

8/13/2007

D1.0 7/2/2002 106 110 49.07% D4.0 D3.0 D3.0 D2.0 D3.0 D1.2 D3.0 D1.0 D2.0 9/12/2007 143 50 74.09% D4.0 D1.0 D1.0 D3.0

6/13/2008

7/13/2008 106

47 69.28% D1.0 D1.0

Initial WG Ballot (passed)

Months between start of first Initial Letter Ballots Ballot and and end of drafts letter to gain ballot Recirc 75% gaining voting WG 75% WG pool

LB51 LB32 LB41 LB36 LB52 LB64 LB78 LB74 LB97 LB125 LB79 LB101 LB132 LB88 LB94

11/28/2002 1/8/2003 228 1/29/2002 3/10/2002 139 7/23/2002 9/1/2002 176 3/26/2002 5/5/2002 165 12/2/2002 1/12/2003 209 12/5/2003 1/14/2004 212 10/3/2005 11/12/2005 295 3/29/2005 5/8/2005 348 2/7/2007 3/9/2007 231 4/3/2008 5/3/2008 136 11/25/2005 1/4/2006 268 4/16/2007 6/12/2008 5/16/2007 163 7/12/2008 113

47 37 44 52 65 27 75 36 46 37 64

82.91% 78.98% 80.00% 76.04% 76.28% 88.70% 79.73% 90.63% 83.39% 78.61% 80.72%

1 4 3 2 2 3 2 3 1 2 4 1 1 3 1 1

21.14 11.15 7.00 9.34 21.27 12.43 15.35 1.32 11.67 26.07 1.32 0.99 13.15 1.32 0.99

321 290 382 330 321 463 514 542 325 234 518 307 213 427 347

D1.6 D5.0 D3.1 D4.0 D2.1 D4.0 D1.3 D4.0 D2.0 D3.0

LB21 LB59 LB38 LB49 LB42 LB57 LB66 LB83 LB75 LB115

D2.0 LB82

52 75.81% 34 76.87% 34 85.59% 59 75.52%

10/10/2006 11/19/2006 202 12/8/2006 1/7/2007 182

D2.0 LB102 D2.0 LB104

Recircu

3/27/2000 4/4/2000 8/1/2003 8/22/2003 5/8/2002 6/16/2002 10/17/2002 11/1/2002 7/23/2002 9/1/2002 5/22/2003 6/6/2003 2/4/2004 3/11/2004 3/16/2006 3/31/2006 7/7/2005 7/17/2005 10/7/2007 10/27/2007 3/15/2006

240 142 217 208 218 258 308 387 240

34 37 33 24 61 17 73 26 43

87.59% 79.33% 86.80% 89.66% 78.14% 93.82% 80.84% 93.70% 84.81%

D1.9 LB22 D6.0 LB63 D5.0 D2.2 D5.0 D1.4 D5.0 D3.0 D4.0

6/12/2000 6/26/2000 12/4/2003 12/20/2003 248 30 89.21% D7.0 1/8/2003 11/1/2002 8/19/2003 4/20/2004 9/16/2006 8/19/2005 4/12/2008 256 220 243 273 325 397 253 34 13 36 13 59 20 34 88.28% 94.42% 87.10% 95.45% 84.64% 95.20% 88.15% D6.1 D6.0 D6.0 D4.0 D5.0

LB50 11/27/2002 LB48 10/17/2002 LB60 8/4/2003 LB68 4/5/2004 LB86 9/1/2006 LB76 8/8/2005 LB124 3/28/2008

4/4/2006 316 44 87.78% D3.0 LB87

9/29/2006 10/14/2006 318 50 86.41% D4.0

4/17/2007 4/19/2007

5/2/2007 227 29 88.67% D3.0 LB114 5/5/2007 221 41 84.35% D3.0 LB106

10/4/2007 10/19/2007 245 21 92.11% D4.0 6/5/2007 6/20/2007 242 24 90.98% D4.0

Recirculation WG Ballots

LB65 LB54 LB61 LB90 LB77 LB129 LB91

1/31/2004 1/20/2003 9/24/2003

2/15/2004 258 19 93.14% D8.0 LB67 2/4/2003 285 7 97.60%

2/24/2004

3/10/2004 262 16 94.24%

10/9/2003 257 21 92.45% D7.0 LB62

10/20/2003 1/29/2007

11/4/2003 264 14 94.96% 2/15/2007 361 30 92.33%

11/1/2006 11/15/2006 354 36 90.77% D7.0 LB96 9/9/2005 9/19/2005 411 15 96.48% 5/23/2008 6/12/2008 261 29 90.00% 11/20/2006 12/4/2006 335 30 91.78% D5.0 LB98

3/20/2007

4/4/2007 350 19 94.85%

LB117 12/12/2007 LB109 8/6/2007

1/5/2008 245 21 92.11% D5.0 LB121 8/21/2007 250 17 93.63% D5.0 LB112

2/5/2008 2/20/2008 259 14 94.87% 9/28/2007 10/13/2007 257 11 95.90%

Months between start of first WG recirc Letter Ballot and Ballots end of during Ballots last WG WG at WG recirc recirc. level ballot

Months between start of first Initial WG Letter Ballot and end of last WG recirc ballot

Initial

D7.0 LB103

4/18/2007

5/5/2007 363 29 92.60%

2 4 1 3 2 4 2 5 3

3 8 4 5 4 7 4 8 4

2.99 7.30 1.28 3.62 3.32 5.46 2.50 13.64 2.43

35.18 14.37 12.13 15.25 31.00 15.62 33.07 5.72

D2.0 D8.0 D4.0 D6.2 D3.0 D7.0 D1.5 D8.0 D5.0

D6.0 LB105

5/28/2007

6/13/2007 360 11 97.04%

5

6

14.96

18.58

D7.0

D6.0 LB128 4/3/2008 D6.0 LB116 11/23/2007

4/18/2008 266 12/8/2007 271

8 97.08% 2 99.27%

5

6

7.66

12.00

D7.0

Initial Sponsor Ballot

1/31/2001 3/1/2001 38 3 92.68% 4/7/2004 5/30/2004 91 16 85.05% 9/18/2002 10/28/2002 50 7 87.72% 2/6/2003 3/9/2003 54 10 84.38% 12/12/2002 2/6/2003 48 4 92.31% 11/20/2003 12/20/2003 117 15 88.64% 6/2/2004 7/2/2004 66 9 88.00% 7/11/2007 8/10/2007 89 10 89.90% 10/21/2005 11/20/2005 86 14 86.00%

D3.0 D9.0 D4.1 D7.1 D3.6 D8.0 D1.6 D9.0 D6.0

4/3/2001 4/13/2001 42 0 ###### 8/6/2004 8/31/2004 95 14 87.16% 12/4/2002 12/19/2002 56 3 94.92% 3/25/2003 4/8/2003 58 10 85.29% 4/15/2003 4/30/2003 53 2 96.36% 2/26/2004 3/12/2004 122 11 91.73% 7/30/2004 8/14/2004 74 3 96.10% 9/24/2007 10/4/2007 91 11 89.22% 4/10/2006 5/10/2006 95 10 90.48%

D10.0 D5.0 D8.2 D3.11 D9.0 D10.0 D7.0

7/31/2007

8/30/2007

79 13 85.87%

D8.0

9/27/2007

10/7/2007

86 10 89.58% D9.0

12/21/2007

1/30/2008

87

7 92.55%

D8.0

2/27/2008

3/8/2008

91

5 94.79% D9.0

Recirculation Sponsor Ballots

9/23/2004 2/7/2003 4/29/2003 6/10/2003 3/26/2004 11/28/2007 6/21/2006

10/8/2004 100 2/17/2003 57 5/14/2003 64 6/26/2003 56 4/10/2004 131 12/8/2007 7/11/2006

9 2 3 1 3

91.74% D11.0 10/27/2004 11/11/2004 106 96.61% D6.0 3/25/2003 4/8/2003 61 95.52% 98.25% 97.76% D10.0 4/23/2004 5/8/2004 130 1/7/2008 8/25/2006 1/17/2008 103 9/9/2006 111

5 95.50% D12.0 1 98.39%

3 97.74% 5 95.37% D12.0 5 95.69% D9.0

94 9 91.26% D11.0 99 10 90.83% D8.0

1/7/2008

1/17/2008

95

4 95.96% D9.0

1/22/2008

2/1/2008 100

3 97.09%

3/12/2008

3/27/2008

95

4 95.96% D10.0

4/3/2008

4/18/2008

98

3 97.03%

ation Sponsor Ballots

12/8/2004 12/23/2004 107

5 95.54% D13.0

2/3/2005

2/18/2005 109

4 96.46% D13.0

1/22/2008 10/23/2006

2/1/2008 105 11/7/2006 111

5 95.45% D12.0 5 95.69%

2/4/2008

2/14/2008 105

5 95.45% D13.0

Months between start of first Sponsor ballot and end of last REVCOM/S Ballots at Total Sponsor tandards Sponsor number recirc Voter Board IEEE level of ballots ballot Pool Approval Publish

4/1/2005

4/16/2005 113 1

99.12%

3/3/2008

3/18/2008 106 3

97.25%

2 7 4 3 3 4 2 7 5

5 15 8 8 7 11 6 15 9

2.37 12.30 6.64 3.19 6.44 5.59 2.40 8.25 12.56

55 161 73 96 75 163 93 135 145

9/22/2005 11/11/2005 6/12/2003 7/14/2003 6/12/2003 6/27/2003 9/11/2003 10/14/2003 6/24/2004 7/24/2004 9/23/2004 10/29/2004 5/9/2008 3/8/2007 6/12/2007

4

10

6.08

130

5/9/2008

4

10

3.91

128

Days between start of first letter ballot and REVCOM / Standards Board Approval

Months between start of first letter ballot and REVCOM / Standards Board Approval

Years between start of first letter ballot and REVCOM / Standards Board Approval

Days between PAR approval and REVCOM / Standards Board Approval

Months between PAR approval and REVCOM / Standards Board Approval

Years between PAR approval and REVCOM / Standards Board Approval

1631 798 497 778 1176 631 949 709

53.62 26.24 16.34 25.58 38.66 20.75 31.20 23.31

4.47 2.19 1.36 2.13 3.22 1.73 2.60 1.94

2002 1169 994 1008 1547 652 1976 1449

65.82 38.43 32.68 33.14 50.86 21.44 64.96 47.64

5.48 3.20 2.72 2.76 4.24 1.79 5.41 3.97

896

29.46

2.45

1457

47.90

3.99

Month Year

References

doc.: IEEE 802.11-yy/xxxxr0

References:

Submission

16

Name, Company


								
To top