this-chart---Center-for-American-Progress

							Senate Proposed Senate House American House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Recovery and Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Investment Act, Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in H.R. 1 millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program SMART GRID/TRANSMISSION
Smart-grid related activities, including work to modernize the electric grid, enhance security and reliability, perform energy storage research, development, demonstration and deployment, and provide worker training; Construction of new transmission and upgrading of electric power transmission lines and related facilities necessary to deliver power generated by renewable energy $11,000 resources

Smart grid for more efficient electricity transmission, distribution, and production systems.

Electricity Delivery and $11,000 Energy Reliability.

Renewable energy and transmission line construction loan guarantees. Grid/transmission subtotal

New loan guarantees aimed at standard renewable projects such as wind or solar projects and for electricity $8,000 transmission projects $19,000

$10,000 $21,000

BUILDING/APPLIANCE EFFICIENCY

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1
General Services Administration (GSA) program to increase energy efficiency in federal buildings.

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
Repair of federal buildings to increase energy efficiency using $6,000 green technology

Federal energy $6,000 management program.

VA hospital and medical facility: Energy-related construction and improvements

$329

Local government energy efficiency block grants. Energy efficiency housing retrofits. New program to make Housing and Urban Development (HUD) sponsored low-income housing more energy efficient.

Army Corps of Engineers: operation and maintenance activities Energy Efficiency and Conservation Grants and State Energy $6,900 Program

$1,900

$4,700 State Energy program.

Department of Housing and Urban Development’s assisted housing for energy and green retrofit $2,500 investments

$1,368

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1
Native American housing block grants. Rehabilitate and improve energy efficiency at some of the over 42,000 housing units maintained by Native American housing programs.

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program

Native American $500 housing block grants

Dept. of Energy Tribal energy activities $510 funding.

Self-help and assisted homeownership program. Projects using sustainable and energyefficient building and rehabilitation practices.

$10 Dept. of Defense Energy Conservation Investment Program. Improvements to existing facilities and utilities systems to upgrade design, eliminate waste, and install energy saving devices. Projects are designed for minimum $3,200 energy consumption.

Sustain, renovate and modernize Dept. of Defense facilities: energy efficiency (HVAC, water, sewage, insulation, etc).

Facilities Sustainment, Restoration and Modernization to be used to invest in energy $1,791 efficiency projects

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
Energy efficiency upgrades and construction of alternative energy projects, including wind and solar power and photovoltaic roof systems.

$613

Grants and loans institutions for energy sustainability and efficiency recovery funding Public Housing Capital Fund. Improves energy efficiency, increases affordable housing projects that are readyto-go, and address the housing needs of senior citizens and people with disabilities.

Grants to make schools and hospitals more $1,500 energy efficient Public Housing Capital Fund. Priority investments, including investments that leverage private sector funding or financing for renovations and energy conservation retrofit $1,000 investments.

$1,600

Public Housing Capital $2,000 Fund Program.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program

Dept. of Defense research on energy efficiency at military installations.

Air National Guard Operational readiness, energy upgrades, and alternative energy $350 projects

$110

Appliance rebate program for Energy Star products.

$300

Energy Star Program. HOME Investment Partnerships Program. Assists States and local governments expand the supply and affordability of housing to low- and very low$450 income people.

HOME Investment Partnerships Program. Helps local communities build and rehabilitate low-income housing using green technologies.

Incentivize investments of HOME funds in projects that promote energy efficiency and $1,500 green technologies

Industrial energy efficiency via capture of waste heat energy.

$500

Industrial technologies.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
Operational needs of Job Corps Centers, which may include training for careers in the energy efficiency, renewable energy, and environmental protection $300 industries Weatherization Assistance Program. Install efficiency measures in low-income $6,200 households.

Job corps facilities. Upgrades job training facilities and energy efficiency at facilities for at risk youth. Weatherization Assistance Program. Install efficiency measures in low-income households.

Energy saving investments for Job $24 Corps facilities.

Weatherization $2,900 Assistance Program.

Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) Building/appliance efficiency subtotal

$1,000 $30,351 $25,704

Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP).

RENEWABLE ENERGY AND ALTERNATIVE ENERGY

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) programs (not including building, vehicle or industrial technologies; weatherization assistance, state energy, tribal energy, federal energy $2,600 management).

Renewable energy research Dept. of Energy Advanced Research Project Agency to accelerate the innovation cycle for both traditional and alternative energy sources and energy efficiency.

Energy efficiency and renewable energy research, development, demonstration and deployment activities to accelerate the development of $2,000 technologies

$400

Carbon capture and sequestration research for coal fired power plants.

Fossil Energy Research & Development (One or more near-zero emissions; Clean Coal Power Initiative Round III Funding Opportunity Announcement; projects that demonstrate carbon $2,400 capture)

Clean Coal Power Initiative and Clean Coal Technology $4,600 Program

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service: construction, improvement, acquisition, or removal of buildings and other facilities required in the conservation, management, investigation, protection, and utilization of fishery and wildlife resources, and the acquisition of lands and interests (no $110 mention of energy).

U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service facilities construction, with emphasis on energy efficiency and renewable energy.

U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service facilities $300 construction. Rural business initiatives in development of renewable energy

$250

Renewable energy and alternative energy subtotal

$5,100 GSA Federal fleet: Replacement of older motor fleet vehicles owned by the Federal Government with alternative fuel automobiles that will save on fuel costs and reduce carbon $600 emissions.

$7,560

CLEAN VEHICLES

General Services Administration (GSA) program to purchase alternative fuel vehicles and plug-in hybrids for federal fleets.

Federal Transit Authority’s clean fuel $600 bus grant program.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
Electrical infrastructure projects that encourage the use of plug-in electric drive vehicles and for near term largescale electrification $200 projects.

Electrification of transportation to reduce emissions.

$200

Alternative fueled vehicles pilot grant program.

Clean Cities program of the Department for acquisition and alternative fuel or fuel$400 cell vehicles.

$350 Vehicle technologies Advanced battery storage technology research, development and demonstration for electric, hybrid-electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles, advanced combustion engine research and development, materials technology, fuels technology, technology $2,000 integration.

Advanced battery research loans and grants.

Manufacturing of advanced batteries systems and components and vehicle $2,000 batteries.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program

Diesel Emissions Reduction Act (DERA) Grants and Loans. Clean vehicles subtotal

Diesel Emission $300 Reduction Act grants $3,500

Diesel Emissions Reduction Act (DERA) $300 Grants and Loans. $3,450

TRANSIT
Urbanized area programs; Bus and bus facility grants; Over-theroad bus; Planning programs; National Transit Database; Alternatives analysis program; Alternative transportation for parks $8,400 and public lands. Fixed guideway modernization for trains and other conveyances with an exclusive right of way.

New transit construction, mass transit spending added through amendment.

Investments in public $2,500 transportation

Transit upgrades & repair.

$2,000

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

House American Recovery and Investment Act, H.R. 1

Senate Proposed Senate House Recovery Appropriations Recovery Bill, H.R. 1, Recovery Package Package Grant/Loan (in S. 336 Grant/Loan Grant/Loan (in millions) (in millions) millions) Existing program
Competitive grants to state and local governments for transportation investments - including highway, transit, rail, or $7,500 port infrastructure. Investments in rail transportation, including high speed rail corridors, intercity passenger rail $1,100 and Amtrak $13,100

Transit capital assistance and improvements.

Capital investment grants for new transit $5,500 projects. Operations, capital improvements and debt service to the National Railroad Passenger $3,100 Corporation (Amtrak). $17,000

Amtrak & intercity passenger rail construction grants. Transit subtotal

Workforce Investment Act - Green jobs allocation.

Job training including State formula grants for adult, dislocated worker, $500 and youth programs

$3,400

Total

$71,551

$78,114

*Percentages are rounded. House stimulus package: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d111:h.r.00001: Senate stimulus package: http://appropriations.senate.gov/ FY 2009 appropriations: http://thomas.loc.gov/home/approp/app09.html FY 2009 appropriations for all programs were the same as FY 2008 except for Weatherization Assistance and LIHEAP.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$140

7857%

7857% We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009.

$140

13571%

15000%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$20

30000%

30000% Additional Senate bill project similar to House GSA program for federal buildings. Additional Senate bill project similar to House GSA program for federal buildings; improvement of energy efficiency at Corps owned buildings is a subset of total.

$45

15333%

10444% We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$6

8333%

Senate bill does not contain language on energy 8500% provisions. We could not identify a program comparable to House stimulus package proposal in FY 2009 or in Senate bill.

$70

2559%

4571%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009. We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 82% 2009.

$2,439

41%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes
We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009; in Semite bill, energy efficiency and renewable energy spending are a subset of total spending. We could not identify a program comparable to House proposal in Senate bill. We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009. We could not identify a program comparable to House proposal in Senate bill.

$49

612%

$65

769%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$1

20027%

1602%

$250

2480%

1160%

$5,100 $8,045

20% 377%

FY 2009 appropriation is $4.5 billion, with a contingency fund of $590 million; we could not identify a program comparable to House proposal 0% in Senate bill. 319%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$1,159

173%

Breakdown between investment in renewable energy and energy efficiency research unclear 224% in Senate bill. We could not identify a program comparable to House proposal in FY 2009 appropriations or in the Senate bill.

$311

772%

1479%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$34

882%

Energy efficiency and renewable energy spending was a subset of 2009 program; no language on energy provisions in 324% Senate bill. Additional Senate bill project on renewable energy.

$1,504

339%

503%

$73

822%

822%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes
We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009. We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009.

$215

930%

930%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$49 $337

612% 1039%

Authorized in Energy Policy Act of 2005; we could not identify a program comparable to House proposal 612% in Senate bill. 1024%

$6,388

39%

$1,309

153%

Unclear how much of proposed spending in Senate bill is for new 131% construction. We could not identify a program comparable to House proposal in Senate bill.

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org

FY 2009 funds appropriated under Continuing Resolution (in millions)

*House recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

*Senate recovery package spending compared to FY 2009 Appropriation under Continuing Resolution

Notes

$1,569

478%

351%

$1,325 $10,591

83% 124%

234% 161% We could not identify a program comparable to stimulus package proposal in FY 2009; in Senate bill, green jobs training is a subset of total

$20,617

347%

379%

2009, Center for American Progress | www.americanprogress.org