t
'":~s:-r:J "'-.
F .--~~ " ror-
1
.2
3 4
Cindy A. Cohn. Esq. (SmtcBar No. 145997) Gwen A. Hinze, Esq. (StateBer No. 209562) BLEcrR.ONIC FRONTIER.FOUNDATION 4.54 Shotwell Street SanFrandsoo,CA 94110 Telephone: (415) 436~9333 xl08 FacsImile: (415) 436-9993 David Greene(StateBarNo. 160107) FIRST AMENDMENT PROJECT 1736Franklin St. Ninth Floor Oakland,CA 94612 Telephone:(510) 208-7744 Facsimile: (510) 208-4562 Attorneys fotDcfendant (:)",h Po~od PQ(~ JOHN DOE
~'IA
1 ,.to) ; 1.1'\
..-
7 PM ~=
. ',. 1'.
.:. . . .-" '-""-~
I i_"
"" ;"-:. .. ~..".
':O.-""I.'~ .. r.",..
~
~
l.. '-"
". -"I-"', I,. L,r
.~-, ,1..1... ~ I.L...,.. """. . ;'-:' .. I
.,~...
/ ~'-, .'
.,.
-~,;.
s
6 7
8
~. . ,:;.
.
9
10
11 12
13 B. VAN CULLENS,
SUPERIORCOURT OF 'niP. STATS OF CALIFORNIA IN AND FOR 'I1m COUNTY OF SAN'! A CLARA
UNLIMITED1TJPJSDICTION
No. CV 814664 Plaintiff. ~OTICE OF MOTION A'!\~ MOTION TO OUASH SUBPOENA Date: ~ril 17.2003 Time: 9:00 8.m. Depl: 2. Hon. WilliamJ. ElMng
14 IS 16
.7
v.
JOmtl DO~ Defendant
18 19
20
21
22
23
]A
TO ALL PAl.TIES AND THEIRATTORNBYS RECORD: OF PLEASETAKE NOTICE THAT, on Thm'Sday, Apri11?, 2003,at 9:00 a.m.,or as soon
thercaftu that the matter may be heard. in the court1'OOm the Honorable William J. Elfving, of Departm~t 2. 191 North Fim Street, San Jose. C8lifomia 9S113. Defendant John Doe (.Def~dant.) will and hercby doesmove the Comt for an Order,pursuantto Section 418.10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, aranting Defendant's Motion to QuashSubpoela. The motion is made on the groundsthat Plaintiff cannotestablisha compelling needfor the discoverythat outweighsthe Fint Amendmentrights of DefendantDoe.
-
2.1 26
27
Q)
~"i:1. 28 ,0&
NO'ftC:E OF MOTION AND M~TION TO QUASH SUBPO~A
-
~'i
-
~.04
£666~'Jp'J Q1 ~~ ~lS 311~;j ~ ~:9'J ~ L'J ~
~.d
1 2 3
4 5 6
Defendant'smotion is basedupon this Notice of Motion, the Motion to Quash Subpoena, and the Declarationof Cindy A. Cohn in supportthereof,filed concurrentlyherewith.the pleadings on file in this case,and on suchother and further argumentand evidenceas the Court may receive at the hearingof this matter.
DATED: March 17,2003
7
8 9
1.0
Bf~~~~~~~ ?
Attorneys for Defendant JOHN DOE
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION 454 Shotwell Street SanFrancisco,CA 94110 Telephone: (415) 436-9333xl08 Facsimile: (415) 436-9993
1 12
13 14 15
16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26
27
28
2 NonCE OFMonON AND MonON TO QUASHSUB ENA