Docstoc

Review-of-EVI-data-4-case-study-areas-by-WP5.xlsx - Livediverse

Document Sample
Review-of-EVI-data-4-case-study-areas-by-WP5.xlsx - Livediverse Powered By Docstoc
					                             No of the     No of the   No of not    No of the    No of the
               No of the
                             available    indicators   available      data      data to be
  Country       relevant
                               data      been looking    data      completed    completed
               indicators
                            indicators      for data  indicators   indicators   indicators
Vietnam           41            36            0            5          36            0
Costa Rica        37            23            8            6          23            8




South Africa      44            26            6           12          26            6




India             32            23            3            7          23            3
  No of the
ready to EVI
                     Remarks (from VN)
 calculation
 indicators
    36         EVI calculation completed
     3         Shortage of data useful for EVI
               calculating. Few data are at basin
               scale (11.80%). Please provide with
               the acurate file names and paths.
               Example: Costa Rica\Socio-
               economic and livelihood\Socio-
               Economic\ATTRIBUTE
               DATA\Construction.xlsx. Provide
               us data in English.
     7         Pls. provide us with ready to use
               data in exel format, not website. For
               more details pls. see "Remarks (from
               Vietnam team)" in the sheet "South
               Africa EVI data Aug10"
     2         There are some indicators should be
               applicable as country dispersion,
               border, ... (for more details pls. see
               "Remarks (from Vietnam team)" in
               the sheet "India EVI data Aug10".
                                                                     Extremely vulnerable          365+
                                                                     Highly vulnerable             315+
                                                                     Vulnerable                    265+
                                                                     At risk                       215+
                                                                     Resilient                     <215




        Ba Be Na Hang Complex                                                                      SCORE        DATA%


                     0     1    2    3    4     5    6    7    EVI                                  308        87.80
           Wind 1                                              CLASSIFICATION:                            Vulnerable
             Dry 2
            Wet 3
                                                               ASPECTS OF VULNERABILITY:
             Hot 4
            Cold 5                                             Hazards                             2.67          81
            SST 6                                              Resistance                          3.50          100
       Volcano 7                                               Damage                              3.78          100
   Earthquake 8
       Tsunami 9
        Slides 10
                                                               LEGEND FOR INDICATOR TYPES:
         Land 11                                               Weather & Climate
   Dispersion 12                                               Geology
     Isolation 13                                              Geography
        Relief 14
   Lowlands 15
                                                               Resources & Services
     Borders 16                                                Human Populations
   Imbalance 17
   Openness 18
                                                               POLICY-RELEVANT SUB-INDICES:
    Migratory 19
    Endemics 20                                                Climate Change                      2.90          91
Introductions 21                                               Exposure to Natural Disasters       2.86          88
 Endangered 22                                                 Biodiversity                        3.71          93
  Extinctions 23
  Vegetation 24
                                                               Desertification                     2.70          100
    Loss Veg 25                                                Water                               3.15          100
    Fragment 26                                                Agriculture / Fisheries             3.15          81
 Degradation 27                                                Human Health Aspects                3.00          100
    Reserves 28
        MPAs 29
      Farming 30
    Fertilisers 31
   Pesticides 32                                               ISSUES OF GREATEST ENVIRONMENTAL VULNERABILITY:
      Biotech 33
    Fisheries 34
   Fish Effort 35
        Water 36
            Air 37
       Waste 38
   Treatment 39                                                ISSUES OF LEAST VULNERABILITY OR GREATEST RESILIENCE:
     Industry 40
         Spills 41
        Mining 42
    Sanitation 43
     Vehicles 44
      Density 45
      Growth 46
     Tourists 47
      Coastal 48
 Agreements 49
     Conflicts 50
                                                               CHANGES SINCE LAST EVALUATION:   None, this is first assessment
                          Resilient            Vulnerable
                         Blanks = No data or Not applicable;
                                 EVI scores are 1-7
                                                 EVI calculating status for Babe Nahang
                                                                                                               EVI
                                                                       Status of
                                  Relevant Availabili                               raw                   value                          Score
No   Indicators     Aspects                              Scale           data                raw value             Score      Score
                                 indicators   ty                                   value                  (Total                         (Total
                                                                      collection             (Na Hang)             (Ba Be)   (Na Hang)
                                                                                   (Ba Be)                Area)                          Area)
1     High winds     Hazards         Y         Y        Case   area       C                                ND                              4
2    Dry periods     Hazards         Y         Y        Case   area       C                                5.22       4         4          4
3    Wet periods     Hazards         Y         Y        Case   area       C                               11.04       4         4          4
4     Hot periods    Hazards         Y         Y        Case   area       C                                4.16       3         3          3
5    Cold periods    Hazards         Y         Y        Case   area       C                                3.25       1         1          1
           Sea
6                    Hazards         N                                                                                                    ND
     temperature
7     Volcanoes      Hazards         N                                                                                                    ND
8    Earthquakes     Hazards         Y         Y        Case area         C                                 0                              1
9      Tsunamis      Hazards         N                                                                                                    ND
10        Slides     Hazards         Y         N        Case area        ND                              undone                           ND
11    Land Area     Resistance       Y         Y        Case area         C        438.18     372.49     810.67       5         6          5
        Country
12                  Resistance       Y         Y        Case area         C                                           1         1          1
      dispersion
13      Isolation   Resistance       N                                                                                                    ND
        Vertical
14                  Resistance       Y         Y        Case area         C                                           1         1          1
         Relief
15    Low lands     Resistance       N                                                                                                    ND
16      Borders     Resistance       Y         Y        Country           C                                                                3
      Ecosystem
17                   Damage          Y         Y        Country           C          0         ND                     1       undone       1
       inbalance
     Enviromental
18                   Hazards         Y         N        Case area        ND         ND         ND          ND                             ND
       Opennes
      Migratory
19                  Resistance       Y         Y        Case area         C          10         10        12.34       6         6          5
        Species
        Endemic
20                  Resistance       Y         Y        Case area         C          11         11       13569.02     7         7          6
        Species
        No of
21   Introduced       Damage    Y   Y   Case area   C     7        7       8.63      7      6   5
       Species
     Endangered
22                    Damage    Y   Y   Case area   C     54      54      66.61      7      7   7
       species
23    Extintions      Damage    Y   Y   Case area   C     3        3       3.70      7      7   7
     Vegetation
24                    Damage    Y   Y   Case area   C    72.90   59.17    61.61      2      3   2
        cover
25   Cover loss       Hazards   Y   Y   Case area   C    -0.05   -0.11    -0.10      5      5   5
        Habitat
26                    Damage    Y   Y   Case area   C                                3      3   3
     Fragmetation
27   Degradation      Damage    Y   Y   Case area   C    0.08     3.49     1.52      1      1   1
      Terrestrial
28                    Hazards   Y   Y   Case area   C            224.02            undone   1   1
       Reserves
        Marine
29                    Hazards   N                                                               ND
       Reserves
       Intensive
30                    Hazards   N                                                               ND
        Farming
31    Fertilisers     Hazards   Y   Y   Case area   C    683.5   163.92   423.71     4      3   4
32    Pesticides      Hazards   Y   Y   Case area   C    7.39     0.05     3.72      5      2   4
     Biotechnolog
33                    Hazards   Y   Y   Case area   C                       0                   1
           y
      Productive
34                    Hazards   Y   N   Case area   ND                     ND                   ND
      overfisihng
35   Fishing effort   Hazards   Y   N   Case area   ND                     ND                   ND
      Renewable
36                    Hazards   Y   Y   Country     C                                           2
         water
        Sulfure
37      dioxide       Hazards   Y   Y   Country     C                                           2
       emisions
             Waste
  38                       Hazards     Y    Y   Case area     C                                     0                 1
          production
             Waste
  39                       Hazards     Y    Y   Case area     C                                     0                 1
          treatement
  40        Industry       Hazards     Y    Y   Case area     C                                     0                  1
  41          Spills       Hazards     N                                                                              ND
  42         Mining        Hazards     Y    N   Case   area   ND                                  ND                  ND
  43       Sanitation      Hazards     Y    Y   Case   area    C      37.2         22.34         29.77       6    5    5
  44       Vehicles        Hazards     Y    Y   Case   area    C      11.9         4.99           8.45       5    3    4
  45      Population       Damage      Y    Y   Case   area    C      57.4         24.03         40.72       4    2    3
          Population
  46                       Hazards     Y    Y   Case area     C       1.23          1.26          1.25       5    5   5
             growth
  47         Tourist       Hazards     Y    Y   Case area     C       5.2           0.99          3.10       1    1   1
            Coastal
  48                       Damage      N                                                                              ND
          Settlements
         Enviromental
  49                       Hazards     Y    Y   Country       C                                                       2
         Agreements
  50       Conflicts       Damage      Y    Y   Case area     C                                                       5

Total number of indicators             50                          No of CChange/relevant indicators         11
No of the relevant indicators          41                          No of Exp2NDisasters/relevant              8
No of the data completed imndicators   36                          indicators
                                                                   No of Biodiversity /relevant indicators   15
No of the data to be completed          0                          No of Desertification /relevant           10
indicators available data indicators
No of not                               5                          indicators
                                                                   No of Water/relevant indicators           13
No of the EVI completed indicators     36                          No of AgFish/relevant indicators          16
                                                                   No of Human Health /relevant
No of hazard/relevant indicators       26                                                                    6
                                                                   indicators
No of resistance/relevant indicators   6
No of Damage/relevant indicators       9
VN

4
5
7
2
1
4
1
1
1
5
2
3
1
3
5
3
1

7

1

6
2
1
5           %R2008 %R2005
6    BB    0.728968 0.877423

2    NH    0.591726 0.909745

7            %R08    %R05
5   BB+NH 0.616121 0.904323

5



5


1

5

7

2


2
   4
   1
   1
   7

   7
   5
   1
   6


   2

   5
  157
356.8182
     Summary of EVI data completion for Babe Nahang Complex (Vietnam)
                       Relevant                        Status of data Status of EVI
No      Indicators               Availability Scale
                      indicators                         collection    calculation
1        High winds       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
2       Dry periods       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
3       Wet periods       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
4        Hot periods      Y          Y       Case area       C              C
5       Cold periods      Y          Y       Case area       C              C
              Sea
6                         N                                                ND
        temperature
7        Volcanoes        N                                                ND
8       Earthquakes       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
9         Tsunamis        N                                                ND
10           Slides       Y          N       Case area      ND             ND
11       Land Area        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
           Country
12                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
          dispersion
13         Isolation      N                                                ND
           Vertical
14                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
             Relief
15       Low lands        N                                                ND
16         Borders        Y          Y        Country        C              C
         Ecosystem
17                        Y          Y        Country        C              C
          inbalance
        Enviromental
18                        Y          N       Case area      ND             ND
          Opennes
          Migratory
19                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
           Species
           Endemic
20                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
           Species
             No of
21       Introduced       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
           Species
        Endangered
22                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
            species
23        Extintions      Y          Y       Case area       C              C
         Vegetation
24                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
             cover
25       Cover loss       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
            Habitat
26                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
        Fragmetation
27      Degradation       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
         Terrestrial
28                        Y          Y       Case area       C              C
          Reserves
            Marine
29                        N                                                ND
          Reserves
          Intensive
30                        N                                                ND
           Farming
31        Fertilisers     Y          Y       Case area       C              C
32       Pesticides       Y          Y       Case area       C              C
          Biotechnolog
   33                         Y            Y       Case area        C        C
                 y
           Productive
   34                         Y            N       Case area       ND        ND
           overfisihng
   35     Fishing effort      Y            N       Case area       ND        ND
           Renewable
   36                         Y            Y        Country         C        C
               water
              Sulfure
   37         dioxide         Y            Y        Country         C        C
            emisions
              Waste
   38                         Y            Y       Case area        C        C
           production
              Waste
   39                         Y            Y       Case area        C        C
           treatement
   40        Industry         Y            Y       Case area        C         C
   41          Spills         N                                              ND
   42         Mining          Y            N       Case   area     ND        ND
   43       Sanitation        Y            Y       Case   area      C         C
   44       Vehicles          Y            Y       Case   area      C         C
   45      Population         Y            Y       Case   area      C         C
           Population
   46                         Y            Y       Case area        C        C
              growth
   47         Tourist         Y            Y       Case area        C        C
             Coastal
   48                         N                                              ND
           Settlements
          Enviromental
   49                         Y            Y        Country         C        C
          Agreements
   50       Conflicts         Y            Y       Case area        C        C

Y= Yes; N=No; NY= Not yet; ND= No data; C= Completed; TBC= To be completed
Total number of indicators                  50
No of the relevant indicators               41
No of the available data indicators         36
No of not available data indicators          5
No of the data completed imndicators        36
No of the data to be completed indicators    0
No of the EVI completed indicators          36
     Summary of EVI data completion for Terraba River Basin (Costa Rica)
                         Relevant    Data                     Status of data Readiness for
No     Indicators                                  Scale
                        indicators Availability                 collection EVI calculation
1       High winds          Y          N                           ND             N
2      Dry periods          Y          Y          Regional          C             N
3      Wet periods          Y          Y          Regional          C             N
4      Hot periods          N
5      Cold periods         N
             Sea
6                           N
       temperature
7       Volcanoes           Y           N          Basin          ND              N
8      Earthquakes          Y           Y          Basin           C              N
9        Tsunamis           N
10          Slides          N
11      Land Area           Y           Y          Basin           C              Y
          Country
12                          Y           Y          Basin           C              Y
         dispersion
13        Isolation         N
14    Vertical Relief       Y           Y          Basin           C              Y
15      Low lands           N
16        Borders           N
        Ecosystem
17                          Y           N                         ND              N
         inbalance
      Enviromental
18                          Y           Y         National         C              N
         Opennes
         Migratory
19                          Y           Y         National         C              N
          Species
          Endemic
20                          Y           Y         National         C              N
          Species
            No of
21      Introduced          Y           Y         National         C              N
          Species
       Endangered
22                          Y           Y         National         C              N
           species
23       Extintions         Y           Y         National         C              N
        Vegetation
24                          Y           Y          Basin           C              N
            cover
25      Cover loss          Y           Y          Basin           C              N
           Habitat
26                          Y           Y            ?             C              N
      Fragmetation
27     Degradation          Y           N                         ND              N
        Terrestrial
28                          Y           Y          Basin           C              N
         Reserves
           Marine
29                          Y           Y          Basin           C              N
         Reserves
         Intensive
30                          Y           N         Regional        ND              N
          Farming
                                                  National
31      Fertilisers         Y          NY          (maybe         TBC             N
                                                  regional)
                                                      National
    32         Pesticides            Y      NY         (maybe          TBC   N
                                                      regional)
    33      Biotechnology            N
              Productive
    34                               N
              overfisihng
    35       Fishing effort          Y      NY        Regional         TBC   N
              Renewable
    36                               Y      NY          Basin          TBC   N
                 water
            Sulfure dioxide
    37                               N
               emisions
                 Waste
    38                               Y      Y         Regional          C    N
              production
                 Waste
    39                               Y      NY        Regional         TBC   N
              treatement
    40          Industry             Y      NY        Regional         TBC   N
    41            Spills             N
    42           Mining              N
    43         Sanitation            Y       Y        Regional          C    N
    44         Vehicles              Y      NY        Regional         TBC   N
    45        Population             Y       Y        Regional          C    N
              Population
    46                               Y      Y         Regional          C    N
                 growth
    47           Tourist             Y      Y         Regional          C    N
                Coastal
    48                               Y      NY          Basin          TBC   N
              Settlements
             Enviromental
    49                               Y      Y         Regional          C    N
             Agreements
    50         Conflicts             Y      N             ?            ND    N

Y= Yes; N=No; NY= Not yet; ND= No data; C= Completed; TBC= To be completed
Total number of indicators                   50
No of the relevant indicators                37
No of the available data indicators          23
No of the indicators been looking for data    8
No of not available data indicators           6
No of the data completed indicators          23
No of the data to be completed indicators     8
No of the ready to EVI calculation
                                             3
indicators
Basin indicators                                 11           29.73
                                              EVI data review for Costa Rica case area
                     Relevant Actual State
No   Indicators                                   Scale     Clasification *        Source
                    indicators     of data
1    High winds         R      Data not                                       National
                               available to                                   Meteorological
                               make daily                                     Institute (IMN)
                               calculations
2    Dry periods        R      Complete          Regional   Biophisic (page IMN
                                                            8)
3    Wet periods       R      Complete           Regional   Biophisic (page IMN
                                                            10)
4    Hot periods
5    Cold periods
6        Sea
     temperature
7     Volcanoes        R                          Basin     Biophisic         CEPREDENAC
8    Earthquakes       R      Complete            Basin     Biophisic         Volcanological
                                                                              and Seismological
                                                                              Observatory of
                                                                              Costa Rica
                                                                              (OVISCORI)
9     Tsunamis
10      Slides
11    Land Area        R      Complete            Basin     Biophisic (page Atlas by Institute
                                                            2)              of Technology
                                                                              (TEC)
12     Country         R      Complete            Basin     Biophisic         Atlas by Institute
      dispersion                                                              of Technology
                                                                              (TEC)
13     Isolation
14      Relief         R      Complete            Basin     Biophisic (page Atlas by Institute
                                                            5)              of Technology

15    Low lands
16     Borders




17    Ecosistems       R
      inbalanace
18   Enviromental      R      Complete           National                     COMEX: (Total
       Opennes                                                                Imports_CR_198
                                                                              0-2009)
19    Migration      R   Complete          National    Biophisic       National
                                                                       Biodiversity
                                                                       Institute (INBio):
                                                                       Biodiversity_INBi
                                                                       o-MINAE
20    Endemics       R   Complete          National    Biophisic       INBio:
                                                                       Biodiversity
21   Introductions   R   Complete          National    Biophisic       INBio:
                                                                       Biodiversity
22    Endareged      R   Complete          National    Biophisic       INBio:
       species                                                         Biodiversity
23    Extintions     R   Complete          National    Biophisic       INBio:
                                                                       Biodiversity
24    Vegetation     R   Complete           Basin      Biophisic (page IMN (shp: Land
        cover                                          19-25)          Cover 2000
                                                                       available on LD
                                                                       DataBase)
25    Cover loss     R   Complete           Basin      Biophisic (page IMN (shp: Land
                                                       19-25)          Cover 2000 and
                                                                       1990 available on
                                                                       LD DataBase)
26      Habitat      R   Complete             ?                        Regional Statistics
     Fragmetation                                                      by MIDEPLAN
                                                                       and Atlas by
                                                                       Institute of
                                                                       Technology (shp:
                                                                       Basin Térraba,
                                                                       available on LD
                                                                       DataBase)
27   Degradation     R   Not found yet
28    Terrestrial    R   Complete           Basin      Biophisic (page Atlas by Institute
      Reserves                                         26-29)          of Technology
                                                                       (shp:
                                                                       EVI_Reservas)
29     Marine        R   Complete           Basin      Biophisic (page Atlas by Institute
      Reserves                                         26-29)          of Technology
                                                                       (shp:
                                                                       EVI_Reservas)
30    Intensive      R   Not found yet     Regional    Socioeconomic Ministry of
       Farming                                                         Agriculture and
                                                                       Livestock (MAG)

31    Fertilisers    R   Looking for       National    Socioeconomic   MAG or Institute
                         data to replace    (maybe                     for Studies on
                         general           regional)                   Toxic Substances
                         numbers.                                      (IRET)
32    Pesticides      R   Looking for       National    Socioeconomic   Web page http://
                          data to replace    (maybe                     www.elpregon.org/
                                                                        costarica/ambiente/
                          general           regional)
                                                                        470-costa-rica-no-
                          numbers.                                      es-el-pais-ecologico-
                                                                        de-america-central

33   Biotechnology




34    Productive
      overfisihng
35   Fishing effort   R   Looking for       Regional    Socioeconomic   Costa Rican
                          data                                          Institute of
                                                                        Fishing and
                                                                        aquaculture
                                                                        (INCOPESCA)
36    Renewable       R   Looking for        Basin      Socioeconomic   Costa Rican
        water             data                                          Electric Institute
                                                                        (ICE)
37      Sulfure
        dioxide
       emisions
38      Waste         R   Complete          Regional    Socioeconomic   Municipalities
      production                                                        (Osa, Buenos
                                                                        Aires, Pérez
                                                                        Zeledón, Cot
                                                                        Brus)
39       Waste        R   Looking for       Regional    Socioeconomic   Municipalities
      treatement          data
40      Industry      R   Looking for       Regional    Socioeconomic   ICE
                          data
41       Spills
42      Mining
43     Sanitation     R   Complete          Regional    Socioeconomic   Regional Statistics
                                                                        by MIDEPLAN




44     Vehicles       R   Looking for       Regional    Socioeconomic   IMN CONAVI
                          data
  45    Population    R   Complete          Regional   Socioeconomic   INEC
                                                       (page 30)




  46    Population    R   Complete          Regional   Socioeconomic   INEC
         growth                                        (page 30)




  47     Tourist      R   Complete          Regional   Socioeconomic   Costa Rican
                                                                       Tourism Institute
                                                                       (ICT) (Tourist
                                                                       2006, 2007, 2008,
                                                                       2009)
  48     Coastal      R   Looking for        Basin     Socioeconomic   Atlas by Institute
       Settlements        data. We                                     of Technology
                          know how                                     (TEC)
                          much
                          settlements
                          are, but we
                          can´t calculate
                          the population
                          density
  49   Enviromental   R   Complete          Regional   Socioeconomic   MINAET
       Agreements
  50    Conflicts     R                        ?


• Please provide with the acurate file names and paths
Example: Costa Rica\Socio-economic and livelihood\Socio-Economic\ATTRIBUTE D
area
                             Remarks (from Vietnam
        Data file name
                                      team)




       Metereological      which year?
       Data.xlsx
       Metereological      which year?
       Data.xlsx




       http://             Not in English
       www.ovsicori.una.
       ac.cr/sismologia/
       sismicidad_reciente
       .htm#



       LiveDiverse-D2.1- OK
       knowledge-base
       (page 2)
       shp: Basin Terraba- OK
       Sierpe available on
       LD DataBase

       LiveDiverse-D2.1- OK
       knowledge-base
       (page 5)

                           It is considered as
                           Number of land and sea
                           borders (including EEZ)
                           shared with other
                           countries. It should use
                           data at country level
                           Which scale?

       Total            Total Imports of the whole
       Imports_CR_1980- Costa Rica
       2009
Biodiversity_INBio- No migration in this file
MINAE



Biodiversity_INBio- found(in the whole Costa
MINAE               Rica)
Biodiversity_INBio- found(in the whole Costa
MINAE               Rica)
Biodiversity_INBio- found(in the whole Costa
MINAE               Rica)
Biodiversity_INBio- found(in the whole Costa
MINAE               Rica)
shp: Land Cover     Can not open
2000 available on
LD DataBase

shp: Land Cover      Can not open
2000 and 1990
available on LD
DataBase
Regional Statistics Not in English
MIDEPLAN
Summary and shp:
Basin Térraba,
available on LD
DataBase




shp: EVI_Reservas Can not find this name in
                  the file name list up loaded


shp: EVI_Reservas Can not find this name in
                  the file name list up loaded
http://               Not in English
www.elpregon.org/
costarica/ambiente/
470-costa-rica-no-es-
el-pais-ecologico-de-
america-central




Municipalities        Can not find this name in
                      the file name list up loaded




http://             Not in English
www.estadonacion.
or.cr/index.php/
biblioteca-virtual/
costa-rica/estado-
de-la-nacion or
Regional Statistics
MIDEPLAN
(pages: 54-55)
       LiveDiverse-D2.1- Not in English
       knowledge-base
       (page 2) or http://
       www.inec.go.cr/

       LiveDiverse-D2.1- Not in English
       knowledge-base
       (page 2) or http://
       www.inec.go.cr/

       http://              Not in English
       www.visitcostarica.
       com/ict/paginas/
       modEst/
       estadisticas.asp?idI
       dioma=1




ic\ATTRIBUTE DATA\Construction.xlsx
     Summary of EVI data completion for Mutale River Basin (South Africa)
                                                               Status of Readiness
                      Relevant    Data
No     Indicators                                 Scale          data      for EVI
                     indicators Availability
                                                              collection calculation
                                               Mutale River
1      High winds        Y           Y                            C          Y
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
2      Dry periods       Y           Y                            C          Y
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
3     Wet periods        Y           Y                            C          Y
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
4      Hot periods       Y           Y                            C          Y
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
5     Cold periods       Y           Y                            C          Y
                                                 Basin
         Sea
6                        N
      temperature
                                               Mutale River
7      Volcanoes         Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
8     Earthquakes        Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
9       Tsunamis         N
                                               Mutale River
10       Slides          Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
11     Land Area         Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
        Country
12                       Y           Y                            C          N
       dispersion
13      Isolation        N
                                               Mutale River
14 Vertical Relief       Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
15     Low lands         Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
16      Borders          Y           Y                            C          N
                                                 Basin
       Ecosystem                               Mutale River
17                       Y           Y                            C          N
        inbalance                                Basin
      Enviromental                             Mutale River
18                       Y          NY                          TBC          N
        Opennes                                  Basin
        Migratory                              Mutale River
19                       Y           Y                            C          N
         Species                                 Basin
         Endemic                               Mutale River
20                       Y           Y                            C          N
         Species                                 Basin
          No of
                                               Mutale River
21     Introduced        Y          NY                          TBC          N
                                                 Basin
         Species
      Endangered                               Mutale River
22                       Y           Y                            C          N
         species                                 Basin
                                               Mutale River
23     Extintions        Y          NY                          TBC          N
                                                 Basin
      Vegetation               Mutale River
24                    Y   Y                   C     N
        cover                    Basin
                               Mutale River
25    Cover loss      Y   NY                  TBC   N
                                 Basin
        Habitat                Mutale River
26                    Y   Y                   C     N
     Fragmetation                Basin
                               Mutale River
27   Degradation      Y   NY                  TBC   N
                                 Basin
      Terrestrial
28                    Y   Y                   C     N
      Reserves
       Marine
29                    N
      Reserves
      Intensive                Mutale River
30                    Y   N                   ND    N
       Farming                   Basin
                               Mutale River
31     Fertilisers    Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
                               Mutale River
32    Pesticides      Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
                               Mutale River
33   Biotechnology    Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
      Productive               Mutale River
34                    Y   N                   ND    N
      overfisihng                Basin
35   Fishing effort   N
      Renewable                Mutale River
36                    Y   Y                   C     N
         water                   Basin
        Sulfure
                               Mutale River
37      dioxide       Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
       emisions
         Waste                 Mutale River
38                    Y   N                   ND    N
      production                 Basin
         Waste                 Mutale River
39                    Y   N                   ND    N
      treatement                 Basin
                               Mutale River
40     Industry       Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
41       Spills       Y   NY                  TBC   N
                               Mutale River
42      Mining        Y   Y                   C     N
                                 Basin
                               Mutale River
43     Sanitation     Y   Y                   C     N
                                 Basin
                               Mutale River
44     Vehicles       Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
                               Mutale River
45    Population      Y   Y                   C     N
                                 Basin
      Population               Mutale River
46                    Y   N                   ND    N
       growth                    Basin
                               Mutale River
47      Tourist       Y   N                   ND    N
                                 Basin
        Coastal
48                    N
      Settlements
        Enviromental                             Mutale River
 49                       Y            Y                              C      Y
        Agreements                                  Basin
 50       Conflicts       Y            Y         Country-level        C      Y

Y= Yes; N=No; NY= Not yet; ND= No data; C= Completed; TBC= To be completed
Total number of indicators              50
No of the relevant indicators           44
No of the available data indicators     26
No of the indicators been looking for    6
data not available data indicators
No of                                   12
No of the data completed indicators     26
No of the data to be completed           6
indicatorsready to EVI calculation
No of the
                                       7
indicators
                                              EVI data review for South Africa case area

                     Relevant                                                                            Remarks (from
No   Indicators                Availability       Scale         Time                       Note
                    indicators                                                                           Vietnam team)

1    High winds         R      A               Mutale River from 1997 Data for station [0723664 6] -           OK
                                                 Basin                THOHOYANDOU WO -23.0870
                                                                      30.3840 614 m. File: EVIdata
2    Dry periods        R      A                                      Data for station [0723664
                                               Mutale River from 1997 SouthAfrica20May2010 6] -                OK
                                                 Basin                THOHOYANDOU WO -23.0870
                                                                      30.3840 614 m. File: EVIdata
3    Wet periods        R      A               Mutale River from 1997 SouthAfrica20May2010 6] -
                                                                      Data for station [0723664                OK
                                                 Basin                THOHOYANDOU WO -23.0870
                                                                      30.3840 614 m. File: EVIdata
                                                                      SouthAfrica20May2010
4    Hot periods        R      A               Mutale River from 1997 Data for station [0723664 6] -           OK
                                                 Basin                THOHOYANDOU WO -23.0870
                                                                      30.3840 614 m. File: EVIdata
5    Cold periods       R      A               Mutale River from 1997 SouthAfrica20May2010 6] -
                                                                      Data for station [0723664                OK
                                                 Basin                THOHOYANDOU WO -23.0870
6        Sea                                                          30.3840 614 m. File: EVIdata
     temperature                                                      SouthAfrica20May2010
7     Volcanoes         R      A               Mutale River              No vulcanoes
                                                 Basin
8    Earthquakes        R      A               Mutale River              No earthquakes
                                                 Basin
9     Tsunamis

10      Slides          R      A               Mutale River              No slides
                                                 Basin
11   Land Area          R      A               Mutale River              GIS calculation from drainage   Where is drainage
                                                 Basin                   coverage                         coverage file?
12     Country          R      A                                         GIS calculation from drainage   Where is drainage
      dispersion                                                         coverage                         coverage file?
13     Isolation


14      Relief       R   A   Mutale River   GIS DTM and Basin boundary,             Where is DTM and Basin
                               Basin        Highest point subtracted from the           boundary file?
15    Low lands      R   A   Mutale River   lowest point in Mutale River Basin
                                            GIS DTM, No such points in Mutale
                               Basin        River Basin
16     Borders       R   A   Mutale River   GIS Basin boundary and countries
                               Basin        map, No such borders for the Mutale
17    Ecosystem      R   A   Mutale River   River Basin
                                            http://www.csir.co.za/rhp/                  It seem have no
       inbalance               Basin        state_of_rivers/state_of_letluv_01/      appropriate data in this
18   Enviromental    R       Mutale River   luvuvhu.html#mut Not easily available
                                            Data availability:                               website
                                                                                    Which scale is available?
       Opennes                 Basin        at this scale

19    Migration      R   A   Mutale River   Use number of migratory birds            We don't need website,
                               Basin        (www.sabap2.org)                         please give us statistical
20    Endemics       R   A   Mutale River   Soutpansberg conservancy reports                   data
                                                                                       Data file's name and
                               Basin                                                           path?
21   Introductions   R   ?   Mutale River                                                        ?
                               Basin
22   Endangered      R   A   Mutale River   South African Red Data species data       Data file's name and
       species                 Basin                                                          path?
23    Extintions     R       Mutale River                                                        ?
                               Basin
24    Vegetation     R   A   Mutale River   GIS landcover data?                     Yes. Data file's name and
        cover                  Basin                                                         path?
25    Cover loss     R   ?   Mutale River   Remote sensing data                     Yes. Data file's name and
                               Basin                                                         path?
26      Habitat      R   A   Mutale River   GIS data                                  Data file's name and
     Fragmetation              Basin                                                          path?
27   Degradation     R   ?   Mutale River   GIS landcover data                        Data file's name and
                               Basin                                                          path?
28     Terrestrial     R    A                   GIS data – only Makuya Park                Data file's name and
       Reserves                                                                                    path?
29      Marine         NR
       Reserves
30     Intensive       R    NA   Mutale River
        Farming                    Basin
31     Fertilisers     R    NA   Mutale River
                                   Basin
32     Pesticides      R    NA   Mutale River
                                   Basin
33   Biotechnology     R    NA   Mutale River
                                   Basin
34    Productive       R    NA   Mutale River
      overfisihng                  Basin
35   Fishing effort    NR




36    Renewable        R    A    Mutale River   Not at this scale, but for larger area in Pleas send us the data (in
        water                      Basin        South African Water Resources                     number)
                                                Strategy
37   Sulfure dioxide   R    NA   Mutale River   Not available, but no major producers
        emisions                   Basin
38       Waste         R    NA   Mutale River
       production                  Basin
39        Waste        R    NA   Mutale River
       treatement                  Basin
40      Industry       R    NA   Mutale River
                                   Basin
41       Spills        R
42     Mining       R    A    Mutale River             Tshikondeni mine annual report        Pleas send us the data (in
                                Basin                                                                number)

43    Sanitation    R    A    Mutale River             Population c ensus data (2001)          Population census data
                                Basin                                                          (2001) is census in four
                                                                                             local municipality: Musina,
                                                                                                 Mutale Thulamela,
                                                                                             Makhado. Is Mutale river
                                                                                               basin include these four
                                                                                                 local municipality?
44     Vehicles     R    NA   Mutale River
                                Basin
45    Population    R    A    Mutale River 2001         (population census 2001)               Population census data
                                Basin                                                          (2001) is census in four
                                                                                             local municipality: Musina,
                                                                                                 Mutale Thulamela,
                                                                                             Makhado. Is Mutale river
                                                                                               basin include these four
                                                                                                 local municipality?
46    Population    R    NA   Mutale River 1995, 2001 only population census data for 1995              too old
       growth                   Basin                 and 2001
47     Tourist      R    NA   Mutale River
                                Basin
48     Coastal      NR
     Settlements
49   Enviromental   R    A    Mutale River             Same as http://                                  OK
     Agreements                 Basin                  www.vulnerabilityindex.net/
                                                       EVI%20Country%20Profiles/ZA.pdf,
                                                       but applicable to Mutale Basin
50    Conflicts     R    A    Country-level            Same as http://                                  OK
                                                       www.vulnerabilityindex.net/
                                                       EVI%20Country%20Profiles/ZA.pdf
     Summary of EVI data completion for the Warana River Basin (India)
                                                                    Status of Readiness
                          Relevant      Data
No      Indicators                                     Scale          data      for EVI
                         indicators   Availability
                                                                   collection calculation
1        High winds          Y             Y           Basin           C          N
2       Dry periods          Y             Y           Basin           C          N
3       Wet periods          Y             Y           Basin           C          N
4       Hot periods          Y             Y           Basin           C          N
5       Cold periods         Y             Y           Basin           C          N
              Sea
6                            N
        temperature
7        Volcanoes           N
8       Earthquakes          N
9         Tsunamis           N
10           Slides          Y             N             ?            ND          N
11       Land Area           Y             Y           Basin           C          Y
           Country
12                           N
          dispersion
13         Isolation         N
14     Vertical Relief       Y             Y           Basin           C          Y
15       Low lands           N
16         Borders           N
         Ecosystem
17                           Y             N             ?            ND          N
          inbalance
       Enviromental
18                           N
          Opennes
          Migratory                                   Western
19                           Y             Y                           C          N
           Species                                   Ghats level
           Endemic                                    Western
20                           Y             Y                           C          N
           Species                                   Ghats level
             No of
21       Introduced          Y             Y             ?             C          N
           Species
        Endangered                                    Western
22                           Y             Y                           C          N
            species                                  Ghats level
                                                      Western
23       Extintions        TBD            NY                         TBC          N
                                                     Ghats level
         Vegetation
24                           Y             Y             ?             C          N
            cover
25       Cover loss          Y             Y             ?             C          N
           Habitat
26                           Y             Y             ?             C          N
        Fragmetation
27      Degradation          Y             Y          Basin ?          C          N
         Terrestrial
28                           Y             Y          Basin ?          C          N
          Reserves
           Marine
29                           N
          Reserves
          Intensive
30                           N
           Farming
    31        Fertilisers          Y         Y             ?           C               N
    32        Pesticides           Y         N                        ND               N
    33      Biotechnology          N
              Productive
    34                             Y         N                        ND               N
              overfisihng
    35       Fishing effort        N
              Renewable
    36                             Y         Y             ?           C               N
                 water
            Sulfure dioxide
    37                             N
               emisions
                 Waste
    38                             Y         N          Basin ?       ND               N
              production
                 Waste
    39                             Y         N                        ND               N
              treatement
    40          Industry           Y         Y             ?           C               N
    41            Spills           N
    42           Mining            Y         Y             ?           C               N
    43         Sanitation          Y         Y             ?           C               N
    44         Vehicles            Y         N           Basin        ND               N
    45        Population           Y         Y          Basin ?        C               N
              Population
    46                             Y         Y          Basin ?        C               N
                 growth
    47           Tourist           N
                Coastal
    48                             N
              Settlements
             Enviromental
    49                             Y         NY            ?          TBC              N
             Agreements
    50         Conflicts           Y         NY            ?          TBC              N

Y= Yes; N=No; TBD= To be decided; NY= Not yet; ND= No data; C= Completed; TBC= To be
completed
Total number of indicators                   50
No of the relevant indicators                32
No of the available data indicators          23
No of the indicators been looking for data    3
No of not available data indicators           7
No of the data completed indicators          23
No of the data to be completed indicators     3
No of the ready to EVI calculation
                                             2
indicators
                                                                              EVI data review for India case area
                        Applicability for   Availability   Scale of   Status of data
No       Indicator                                                                       Data Requirement           Availability of data/Source
                       Warana basin area      of data       data        collection
     1 High Wind      Applicable                 A          Basin         TBC          Daily data for last        Data with sufficient detail is
                                                                                       five(2005 to 2009) and     available only from one site
                                                                                       monthly for last 30        within the basin (the village
                                                                                       years(1979 to 2009)        Shigaon, lower basin). We will
                                                                                                                  know what data are there and
                                                                                                                  collect it by (20 Aug).
     2 Dry Periods    Applicable                 A          Basin         TBC          Monthly data for last 30   Last five years daily data for
                                                                                       years. (1979 to 2009)      all the blocks falling in the
                                                                                                                  basin is available over the
                                                                                                                  website. Complete data set
                                                                                                                  would be ready by (20 Aug).
     3 Wet periods    Applicable                 A          Basin         TBC                                     Complete data set would be
                                                                                                                  ready by (20 Aug).
     4 Hot periods    Applicable                 A          Basin         TBC          Daily data for last        Data with sufficient detail is
                                                                                       five(2005 to 2009) and     available only from one site
                                                                                       monthly for last 30        within the basin (the village
                                                                                       years(1979 to 2009)        Shigaon, lower basin). We will
                                                                                                                  know what data are there and
                                                                                                                  collect it by (20 Aug).
     5 Cold periods   Applicable                 A          Basin         TBC                                     Complete data set would be
                                                                                                                  ready by (20 Aug).
     6 Sea surface    NA                                                               The basin is not adjacent to the sea.
       Temp.
     7 Volcanoes      NA                                                               There are no volcanos in the basin.
     8 Earthquakes    NA                                                               Data on earthquajes available in public domain shows that there have not be
                                                                                       earthquakes with the required specifications within 100 km distance of the b
 9 Tsunamis       NA                                     Too far inland and at high elevation

10 Slides         Applicable    NA                 N     No. of slides in last five Data is not available
                                                         years (2005 to 2009)
11 Land Area      Applicable    A      Basin       C     Basin area is 2095 sq km. (data is there in Excel sheet)
12 Country        NA
   Dispersion




13 Isolation       NA                                    There is no islanding effect.
   (Islanding)
14 Vertical Relief Applicable   A      Basin       C     Toposheets

15 Lowlands       NA                                     There are no lowlands in the basin.
16 Shared         NA                                     There are no shared border with other countries.
   borders




17 Ecosystem      Applicable    NA                 N     Trophic level change for Data not available.
   Imbalance                                             trophic level slice 3.35
18 Environmental NA                                      There is no international movement of materials within the basin of the kind
   Openness
19 Migratory     Applicable     A     Western      TBC   Fauna database (birds,     Data is available at Western
   species                           Ghats level         mammals, fishes)           Ghats level. Discussion is on
                                                                                    with experts to filter the lists
                                                                                    down to basin level. Data
                                                                                    should be ready by (20 Aug).
20 Endemic        Applicable      A     Western      TBC   Flora/ Fauna database       Data is available at Western
   species                             Ghats level                                     Ghats level. Discussion is on
                                                                                       with experts to filter the lists
                                                                                       down to basin level. Data
                                                                                       should be ready by. (20 Aug).

21 No of          Applicable      A        ?         TBC   It is not clear whether
   Introduced                                              one means wild species
   Species                                                 introduced or agricultural
                                                           or domestic species.
                                                           Please let us know. Data
                                                           availability assessment
                                                           and collection will depend
                                                           on that.
22 Endangered /   Applicable      A     Western      TBC   Flora/ Fauna database      Data is available at Western
   Vulnerable                          Ghats level                                    Ghats level. Discussion is on
   Species                                                                            with experts to filter the lists
23 Extinctions    To be decided   NY    Western      TBC   Flora/ Fauna database      down is available at Western
                                                                                      Data to basin level. Data
                                       Ghats level                                    should be ready by (20 is on
                                                                                      Ghats level. Discussion Aug).
                                                                                       with experts to filter the lists
                                                                                       down to basin level. But needs
                                                                                       clarification see next cell

24 Vegetation     Applicable      A        ?         TBC   % Natural & regrowth        Would be ready by (20 Aug).
   Cover                                                   vegetation (remaining)

25 Loss of cover Applicable       A        ?         TBC   Net % change –last 5
                                                           yrs.
26 Fragmentation Applicable       A        ?         C     Total length of all roads/ Mapping is being carried out
   of Land                                                 land area                  from toposheets and Google
                                                                                      Earth. (data is there in Excel
                                                                                      sheet)
27 Degradation        Applicable   A    Basin ?   TBC   % of land area degraded. Mapping is proceeding. It was
                                                                                   suggested that types of
                                                                                   degradation can be separately
                                                                                   plotted on map. This has to be
                                                                                   decided and analysis has to be
                                                                                   merged with RS info. Results
                                                                                   should be (30 Aug).
28 Terrestrial        Applicable   A    Basin ?   C     % of terrestrial land area Latest map of tiger reserve
     Reserves                                           legally set aside as PA    being procured. (data is there
     (PAs)                                                                         in Excel sheet)
29 Marine             NA                                No marine areas in the basin.
   Reserves
30 Intensive          NA                                No intensive livestock rearing as described in the manual.
   Farming
31 Fertilizer use     Applicable   A      ?       TBC   Average annual use last    Data for lower half of the
                                                        5 yrs./entire area         basin has been acquired. Still
                                                                                   for half to be collected.
                                                                                   Probably complete would be
                                                                                   ready by 20 Aug.
32 Pesticides         Applicable   NA             N     Averageannual.use (kg/     Not available.
                                                        km2/yr) for entire land
                                                        area-last 5 yrs.
33   Biotechnology    NA                                No deliberate field trials of genetically modified organisms in the basin.
34   Overfishing      Applicable   NA             N     Data unlikely to be available
35   Fishing effort   NA                                Basin does not have a coastline.
36   Renewable        Applicable   A      ?       TBC                                Can be estimated. Broad
     water                                                                           estimates being prepared.
                                                                                     Should be ready by (20 Aug).
37 SO2 Emissions NA                                     No SO2 emissions within the basin.
38 Waste        Applicable   NA   Basin ?   N     Averageannual.net            As per the data there is no
   production                                     amount of waste/             hazardous waste generating in
                                                  sq.km.land area              the area.
39 Waste        Applicable   NA             N     Mean annual. % of            NA
   treatment                                      waste effectively treated-
                                                  last 5 yrs.
40 Industries   Applicable   A      ?       TBC   Average annual use of        Data being collected from
                                                  electricity for industry-    MSEB regional offices. Data
                                                  last 5 yrs.                  should be available by (20
                                                                               Aug).
41 Spills       NA                                No marine environment, no major spills of the kind described.
42 mining       Applicable   A      ?       C     Average annual.mining        (data is there in Excel sheet)
                                                  production/sq./last 5 yrs.
43 Sanitation   Applicable   A      ?       C     Density of population        As per data records, none is
                                                  without access to safe       without access to safe
                                                  sanitation                   sanitation.. (data is there in
                                                                               Excel sheet)
44 Vehicles     Applicable   NA   Basin     N     No. of vehicle/sq. km.       Difficult to get data. Data not
                                                                               disaggregated below taluka
                                                                               level. Data not available at
                                                                               relevant scale.
45 Population   Applicable   A    Basin ?   C     No/sq.km                     (data is there in Excel sheet)
   density
46 Human        Applicable   A    Basin ?   C     Annual growth rate –last Population data available for
   population                                     5 yrs.                   1991 and 2001. Census 2011 is
   growth                                                                  ongoing but will take a few
                                                                           years to become available.
                                                                           Best that can be done is to
                                                                           extrapolate the 1991-2001
                                                                           growth rate.. (data is there in
                                                                           Excel sheet)
47 Tourists      NA                          No significant international tourists.

48 Coastal       NA                          No coastal settlements in the basin
   settlements
49 Environmental Applicable   NY   ?   TBC   No of environmental         Should we just borrow the data from the country
   Agreements                                treaties in force in a      should we treat it as non-applicable?
                                             country
50 Conflicts     Applicable   NY   ?   TBC   The description seems to refer to international armed conflict and does not s
                                             apply to basin level. Or should we jus borrow the data from country level?
                  Suggestions        Remarks (from Vietnam
                                             team)




shows that there have not been any
thin 100 km distance of the basin.
el sheet)                                                OK
                                            This indicator is defined
                                            as the Ratio of length of
                                            borders (land and
                                            maritime) to total land
                                            area. So it's should be
                                            applicable to the case
                                            area


            (data is there in Excel                    OK
            sheet)

s.                                          Number of land and sea
                                            borders (including EEZ)
                                            shared with other
                                            countries. So it's should
                                            be applicable to the case
                                            area at country level




s within the basin of the kind described.
It is not clear how you will
calculate for million sq. km.
We feel that it is
unnecessary scaling up.




It is not clear whether the     extinction at local level
extinction is to be                     is better.
considered at local level or
India level. Please clarify.


                                     scale of data ?


                                     scale of data ?

                                Excel file name? scale of
                                          data ?
                           ?




he manual.




 organisms in the basin.
                                              scale of data ?




kind described.
                                         Excel file name? scale of
                                                   data ?
                                         Excel file name? scale of
                                                   data ?




                                         Excel file name? scale of
                                                   data ?
            Please indicate whether this Excel file name? scale of
            is acceptable.                         data ?
w the data from the country level? Or    The data at country
non-applicable?                          scale should be used

armed conflict and does not seem to     The data at basin scale
he data from country level?                should be used

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:2
posted:3/24/2014
language:English
pages:43