Marc Rotenberg _privacy140_ on Twitter

Document Sample
Marc Rotenberg _privacy140_ on Twitter Powered By Docstoc
					Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                                                                                                                                           Have an account? Sign in




      Tweets

      Following

      Followers

      Favorites
                                                                                                Marc Rotenberg
      Lists
                                                                                                    @privacy140
                                                                      EPIC - following privacy issues in Washington, DC
                                                                                                Washington, DC · epic.org
      Follow Marc Rotenberg

        Full name
                                                        835          78                            2,471                                                                                 Follow
        Email                                           TWEETS       FOLLOWING                     FOLLOWERS


        Password


                            Sign up                     Tweets


                                                                 Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        5 Jul
                                                                 Sign the EPIC petition to stop domestic surveillance #NSApetition
      Worldwide Trends · Change                                  #privacy epic.org/NSApetition/
                                                                          http://www.




      #22PersonasEspeciales                                      Expand
      #CitePessoasLindasDaTL
      #LasPalabrasQueMasDuelen
      #LosDelFondo
      #SpiritDay
                                                                 Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                 8 May
      Throwback Thursday
                                                                 EPIC on #Huffpost Live today "Our Startlingly Limitless
      M&G
                                                                 Surveillance State". @EPICprivacy huff.lv/10FLNVu              http://




      Kim K
                                                                   View media
      Windows 8.1
      Vuce



                                                                 Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                 6 May
                                                                 Speaking with @ErinBurnettCNN tonight about Internet
      © 2013 Twitter About Help Terms Privacy                    surveillance and freedom of expression. @EPICprivacy
      Blog Status Apps Resources Jobs Ads                        Expand
      Advertisers Businesses Media Developers
      Directory



                                                                 Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                 27 Apr
                                                                 My editorial for CNN on the Google Streetview non-fine.
                                                                 #privacy cnn.com/2013/04/27/opi
                                                                                  http://www.        …          nion/rotenberg - google - privacy/index.html ? c=opinion




                                                                 Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      19 Mar
                                                        ast day to sign @EPICprivacy's domestic #drone petition in
                                                        support of #privacy regulations. epic.org/drones_petitio … Spread the
                                                                                         http://                n/




                                                        word!
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      19 Mar
                                                        RT @EPICprivacy: Just under 7 hours left to sign the #petition
                                                        asking for #privacy rules for #drones > epic.org/drones_petitio …
                                                                                                   http://              n/




                                                        Sign + Share!
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       23 Jan
                                                        RT @EDRi_org: #cpdp2013: @EDRi_org is now debating the
                                                        #DataProtection Directive for police -- still many dangerous loopholes
                                                        #eudatap
                                                        Expand




                                                        EDRi @EDRi_org                                                       23 Jan
                                                        #cpdp2013: @EDRi_org is now debating the #DataProtection
                                                        Directive for police & justice which has still many dangerous
                                                        loopholes #eudatap
                                                           Retweeted by Marc Rotenberg
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     23 Jan
                                                        Privacy protection is to the information economy as
                                                        environmental production is to the industrial economy. #cpdp2013
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                           23 Jan
                                                        Data protection rocks! #cpdp2013 #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                           23 Jan
                                                        Data protection rocks! #cpdp2013
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    23 Jan
                                                        EU and US consumer groups favor GDPR #cpdp2013
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    27 Dec
                                                        @SenatorLeahy #fisa #privacyhero
                                                        #democracyrequirescourage
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    27 Dec
                                                        With @PeteWilliamsNBC today to discuss #fisa, #facebook,
                                                        and #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 27 Dec
                                                        @RonWiyden citing Brandeis in Olmstead (1928) during #FISA
                                                        debate. Really cool. #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               27 Dec
                                                        #FISA debate today @epicprivacy favors amendments - more
                                                        accountability = good gov't, #privacy, and security
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        Thanks! #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        #1 "Petraeus Case Raises Fears About Privacy in Digital Era,"
                                                        New York Times, November 13, 2012 nyti.ms/ZEB28e #privchat A1
                                                                                             http://




                                                          View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        <long pause> #privchat


https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Dec
                                                        <throat clearing noises> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Dec
                                                        <more worried expressions> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Dec
                                                        <drum roll> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Dec
                                                        Ok, thank you for staying with us. We are now on to the Top
                                                        Privacy Story of 2012. #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Dec
                                                        #2 "Facebook vote results: New policies are in, voting rights
                                                        are out" #privchat A2 lat.ms/QVARUJ
                                                                                         http://




                                                          View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        #3 "U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens
                                                        " #privchat A3 on.wsj.com/Z1zicu
                                                                               http://




                                                          View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Dec
                                                        #4 "Justices Say GPS Tracker Violated Privacy Rights"
                                                        #privchat A4 nyti.ms/T5Yvhd
                                                                     http://




                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        #5 #privchat A5 Obama unveils Consumer Privacy Bill of
                                                        Rights, CNet, February 22, 2012, cnet.co/T5Yfil
                                                                                                http://




                                                          View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        #5 “White House Backs Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights”
                                                        #privchat A5
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                              18 Dec
                                                        #6 TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports,
                                                        Pro Publica, October 19, 2012 bit.ly/S1GSvZ #privchat
                                                                                      http://




                                                          View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        ;_> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        ;->>
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        #6 “TSA Unplugs, Boxes-Up Airport X-Ray Backscatter
                                                        Devices” #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        #7 “Fusion Centers Wasteful, Inefficient, and Expensive!”
                                                        #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        #8 "Tracking School Children With RFID Tags? It's All About
                                                        the Benjamins," Wired #privchat


https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                                       18 Dec
                                                        #8 “Chipping Children: RFID Tags in Schools” #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                                       18 Dec
                                                        From Comput privchat computerworld.com/s/article/9223
                                                                                       http://www.                                    441/DHS_media_monitoring_could_chill_public_dissent_EPIC_warns ?




                                                         …
                                                        taxonomyId=84




                                                                        View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  18 Dec
                                                        #9 “DHS Monitors Twitter Feeds #whydotheydothat?” #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                18 Dec
                                                        Google's Updated Privacy Policy Under Fire Again, PC
                                                        Magazine, Feb. 23, 2012 pcmag.com/article2/0,281 … #privchat
                                                                                                     http://www.   7,2400604,00.asp




                                                                        View summary




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 18 Dec
                                                        #10 “March 1, 2012: One Google Privacy Policy to Rule Them
                                                        All” #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                                       18 Dec
                                                        #10 privacy story of 2012 #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                                       18 Dec
                                                        <worried expressions> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                                                                       18 Dec



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        <expectant giggles> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        <tearing of envelope> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        <drumroll> #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        And now on to our Top Privacy Stories for 2012. #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        Honorable mention: "FISA Reauthorization Looms" #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        Honorable mention: "“States Pass Social Media Workplace
                                                        Privacy Laws: Sorry, boss, you can’t have my password.”#privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               18 Dec
                                                        Honorable mention: "“EU-US Privacy Impasse: Storms Ahead
                                                        in the Cloud” #privchat
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Dec
                                                        First, honorable mentions. #privchat
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        Ready for top 10 privacy stories 2012? #privchat?
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Dec
                                                        Hi, all. Ready for top 10 Privacy Stories of 2012?
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      5 Dec
                                                        More than 250,000 FB users have VOTED for EXISTING
                                                        documents! You should 2! #facebook #privacy
                                                        apps.facebook.com/fbsitegovernan …
                                                        http://                            ce/




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      5 Dec
                                                        More than 200,000 FB users have VOTED for EXISTING
                                                        documents! You should 2! #privacy
                                                        apps.facebook.com/fbsitegovernan …
                                                        http://                            ce/




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      5 Dec
                                                        VOTE for EXISTING documents #privacy
                                                        apps.facebook.com/fbsitegovernan …
                                                        http://                            ce/




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      5 Dec
                                                        #FB users VOTE for #ExisitngDocuments . Protect #privacy.
                                                        Reduce #spam. Preserve #voting,
                                                        apps.facebook.com/fbsitegovernan … RT
                                                        http://                            ce/




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   8 Aug 12
                                                        Require the Transportation Security Administration to Follow
                                                        the Law! wh.gov/OBth
                                                                  http://




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   2 Aug 12



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        EPIC needs support for White House Petition on Airport body
                                                        scanners. #privacy #scanTSA bit.ly/LCqLqq
                                                                                         http://




                                                        Expand




                                                        Christopher Elliott @elliottdotorg                        23 Jul 12
                                                        Only a few more signatures before the @Whitehouse is
                                                        required to respond to #TSA petition: wh.gov/OBth @EPICprivacy
                                                                                                             http://




                                                           Retweeted by Marc Rotenberg
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                          31 Jul 12
                                                        White House petition on airport body scanners. #privacy .
                                                        #ScanTA. Sign now! And pls RT. bit.ly/LCqLqq
                                                                                                   http://




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    17 Jul 12
                                                        In #bodyscanner case, EPIC files petition to compel action by
                                                        TSA. #privacy epic.org/2012/07/epic-f …
                                                                       http://                                         iles - mandamus- petition - t.html




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                          28 Jun 12
                                                        Good outcome for EPIC. We were aligned with the party
                                                        who did not want S Ct
                                                        to overturn lower court opinion. #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                          28 Jun 12
                                                        First American was "dismissed." #privacy That's good!!
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                          28 Jun 12
                                                        First American decision is expected next. #privacy
                                                        @epicprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                                          28 Jun 12




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        EPIC filed a "friend of the court" brief to protect federal
                                                        privacy laws. These laws create "standing."
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                            28 Jun 12
                                                        First American v. Edwards concerns "standing," the right to
                                                        bring a case. Very important to protect #privacy.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                            28 Jun 12
                                                        At Supreme Court, Stolen Valor (1st Amd) case is
                                                        announced first.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jun 12
                                                        Waiting 4 Supreme Court in 1st America, consumer #privacy
                                                        case. EPIC filed a brief. epic.org/amicus/first-a …
                                                                                  http://                    merican/default.html




                                                        Expand




                                                        Viviane Reding @VivianeRedingEU                              3 Feb 12
                                                        Good that Europe's data protection authorities are ensuring
                                                        @Google 's new privacy policy complies with EU law bit.ly/xiz8U6            http://




                                                        #EUDataP
                                                           Retweeted by Marc Rotenberg
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                             1 Feb 12
                                                        With Tom Ashbrook today for @onpointradio -- #google #fb
                                                        #privacy -- @EPICprivacy #goodtoreallyknow @stevenlevy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                                            10 Jan 12
                                                        EPIC on #dianerehm today Tuesday "Facebook and
                                                        #privacy "-- @drshow @EPICprivacy bit.ly/zx5yW2
                                                                                                   http://




                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        EPIC @EPICprivacy                                           31 Oct 11
                                                        Ornelas Nuñez: "Storming the Digital Bastille" --- Austrian
                                                        student demanding Facebook data can start a revolution. #kwtk
                                                        #tpv11
                                                           Retweeted by Marc Rotenberg
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                2 Jun 11
                                                        Ralph Nader to speak at EPIC dinner in Washington DC June
                                                        13 #privacy http://ww.epic.org/june13/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  19 May 11
                                                        EPIC - Senate Holds Hearing on Privacy and Mobile
                                                        Services http://epic.org/2011/05/senate-holds-hearing-on-privac.html
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   19 May 11
                                                        Widespread misunderstanding at Senate Privacy hearing -
                                                        everyone says privacy policies protect privacy. They could not be
                                                        more wrong.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    19 May 11
                                                        EPIC - European Privacy Officials Release New Report on
                                                        Mobile Privacy. http://epic.org/2011/05/european-privacy-officials-
                                                        rel.html
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  18 May 11
                                                        EPIC briefing on Street View and Privacy today #wifiprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                18 May 11
                                                        EPIC to host forum on Google Street View & Privacy in DC
                                                        May 18. http://epic.org/events/wifiprivacy/resources.html
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    2 May 11
                                                        Last day for privacy comments to the FTC .
                                                        https://epic.org/fixgoogleprivacy/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  8 Apr 11
                                                        EPIC has launched "Fix Google Privacy" campaign. Submit
                                                        your comments today! https://www.epic.org/fixgoogleprivacy/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Apr 11
                                                        EPIC has launched "Fix Google Privacy" campaign. Submit
                                                        your comments to the FTC! http://epic.org/fixgoogleprivacy/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    30 Mar 11
                                                        FTC to announce settlement in EPIC Google Buzz privacy
                                                        complaint! http://www.epic.org and http://ftc.gov
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    14 Mar 11
                                                        [I am speaking on DNS Abuse at next session in Grand
                                                        Ballroom. Your thoughts?] #icann #iTownhall
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  14 Mar 11
                                                        Rod Beckstrom shout-out to Thomas Jefferson. Good
                                                        timing. Tomorrow is Jefferson's birthday. Celebrate open gov't.
                                                        #icann #iTownhall #foia
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 14 Mar 11
                                                        ICANN folk, be sure to check out the Internet Town Hall on
                                                        Tuesday at 6 pm. http://bit.ly/fYFrwK #icann #itownhall
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    14 Mar 11



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Strickling - need to "provide meaningful opportunity to
                                                        participate in ICANN." Yes, that is the challenge. ;-> #iTownhall
                                                        #icann
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       14 Mar 11
                                                        [My view : multistakeholderism =/= privacy. Gov't + law +
                                                        int'l norms are critical to protect privacy] #iTownhall #icann
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  14 Mar 11
                                                        Strickling at ICANN40 -- Goals for US: Privacy, Security,
                                                        Copyright, Access to Info -- How? Trust, Multistakeholders.
                                                        #iTownhall #icann
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                              10 Jan 11
                                                        EPIC conference "Stripping Freedom (TSA Body Scanners)"
                                                        on CSPAN2 Tonight! View online. http://cs.pn/hr9YRU
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                3 Jan 11
                                                        EPIC Body Scanner privacy conference - Ralph Nader, Bruce
                                                        Schneier, Jeff Rosen - Jan 6 - Washington DC #ScanTSA
                                                        http://bit.ly/fg4wOu
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  23 Nov 10
                                                        Nov 24. Say No to Body Scanners. Post this image. RT.
                                                        Repeat. #tsa #wontfly #optout #privacy http://bit.ly/hv1KXa
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Nov 10
                                                        Air travelers - send screening reports to EPIC Body Scanner
                                                        Incident Report #TSA #privacy.
                                                        http://epic.org/bodyscanner/incident_report/
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Nov 10
                                                        Air travelers - send screening reports to EPIC Body Scanner
                                                        Incident Report #TSA #privacy.
                                                        http://epic.org/bodyscanner/incident_report/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 19 Nov 10
                                                        Excellent summary of body scanner issue from Bruce
                                                        Schneier.
                                                        http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/11/tsa_backscatter.html?
                                                        nc=96
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      19 Nov 10
                                                        EPIC (Rotenberg) is on Keith Olbermann tonight (Friday),
                                                        Diane Rehm Monday morning. #privacy #tsa
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    19 Nov 10
                                                        Support National Opt-out Day! If airports can opt-out it, why
                                                        shouldn't passengers?? ;-> #privacy http://bit.ly/bBFhKy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       19 Nov 10
                                                        EPIC Body Scanner Incident Report. Please ask air travelers
                                                        to go to this page: http://epic.org/privacy/airtravel/backscatter/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      19 Nov 10
                                                        Sorry for long absence. EPIC has been very busy with
                                                        privacy and body scanners. Will start posting news items.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   2 Nov 10
                                                        EPIC is holding a press conference today on EPIC v. DHS, to
                                                        suspend the body scanner prgrm. #privacy http://bit.ly/bDrDyd
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     21 Sep 10
                                                        Timely article. Activists protest Facebook for limiting online
                                                        activism. http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0910/42364.html
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   21 Sep 10
                                                        Good #privacy def. - "to promote free and open discussion,
                                                        please do not film anyone offstage without that person's permission"
                                                        #IAL2010
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      2 Sep 10
                                                        Last day to vote FOR #privacy in TheEconomist online poll.
                                                        http://www.economist.com/debate/debates/overview/181
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               31 Aug 10
                                                        Economist Debate -"Governments must do far more to
                                                        protect online #privacy." Vote FOR (AGREE). And RT. Thx!
                                                        http://bit.ly/dcEdUi
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   2 Jul 10
                                                        #kagan #scotus judicial philosophy = "Law all the way down."
                                                        Ironic?!
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan vote count. Early prediction - mid-60s. Post hearing -
                                                        mid-70s.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - non-ironic use of "it's law all the way down." Any
                                                        other examples of this?
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   30 Jun 10
                                                        "Witness bankshots." def. asking the witness a question with
                                                        the purpose of making a point to one of the other Committee
                                                        members. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan, after Sen. Klobuchar corrects record, "Isn't email a
                                                        wonderful thing? You can learn you are wrong right away." ;->
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               30 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Franken asking #kagan about media concentration and
                                                        First Amendment
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    30 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Klobuchar recounting top hits from 1980 at #kagan
                                                        hearing ;->
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               30 Jun 10
                                                        On NPR Connecticut Thursday around 9:20 discussing
                                                        #Congress & #computer security. EPIC has a #FOIA lawsuit against
                                                        #NSA.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    30 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC web page on #privacy and #kagan
                                                        http://epic.org/privacy/kagan/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan Sen. Kyl just cited this column by George Will. (Ok to
                                                        cite newspaper columnists but not foreign law?! ;-> )
                                                        http://bit.ly/dkvmtI
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      30 Jun 10
                                                        (Sen. Kyl is tying himself in knots trying to press the foreign
                                                        law issue with #kagan. There is a concern but she gets the better of
                                                        this.)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      30 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Specter is frustrated that #kagan is not giving more
                                                        direct answers, particularly in light of her 1995 article
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan "who has standing to challenge surveillance if you
                                                        don't know you are are being surveilled?" (Good question. What is
                                                        the answer?!)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      30 Jun 10
                                                        Specter now discussing warrantless wiretapping. Wants to
                                                        know which cases #kagan would vote to consider.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - "I don't want to count my chickens (assume I'm
                                                        confirmed)" Specter - "I'm one of your chickens." #morehumor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan Quick shoutout to @RadioBoston for segment
                                                        yesterday on #streetview and #privacy. EPIC's page provides
                                                        updates http://bit.ly/doop0z
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan now discussing Katz (key #privacy case). "Might be
                                                        the circumstances where a court would overturn a precedent" - facts
                                                        changed
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan "when something false goes around the Internet,
                                                        that's a real harm and the law should not pretend it's not."
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan discussing NY Times v. Sullivan (cornerstone 1st
                                                        Amd case) - recognizes reputational harm for private actors
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      30 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Klobuchar asking #kagan about the "calling balls and
                                                        strikes" metaphor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       30 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - "doctrine of precedent is a doctrine of constraint, . .
                                                        . a doctrine of humility."
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      30 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Whitehouse up now. Former AG, as are on many
                                                        members of the Committee. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                30 Jun 10
                                                        Back underway at #kagan hearing. Leahy would like to wrap
                                                        up today.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Graham - "Where were you on Christmas Day?"
                                                        #kagan - "Like all Jews, I was probably at a Chinese restaurant." ;->
                                                        #humor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 29 Jun 10
                                                        Senator Specter now up at #kagan hearing. I need to take a
                                                        break for an interview with WBUR about Google Street View and
                                                        #privacy. Back soon
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Grassley is still pressing #kagan on foreign law. She is
                                                        responding thoughtfully, not making the easy play or going all
                                                        theoretical.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Grassley asking #kagan about requiring int'l law at
                                                        Harvard law School.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Grassley resumes questioning of #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Feingold asking #kagan about nat'l security,
                                                        Youngstown decision - key question about scope of Presidential
                                                        power
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Kyl says that S Ct takes 80% of cases when SG files
                                                        petition for review. Wow. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - "It's law all the way down." (Not turtles?! ;-> )
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Kyl is up, then Sen. Feingold, then break for lunch.
                                                        #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan argues for Youngstown - deference to Congress
                                                        where it has passed laws = limits powers of the President
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Feinstein discussing #FISA and Role of President.
                                                        Good question. Goes to warrantless wiretapping #privacy #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 29 Jun 10
                                                        (Enjoying discussion of 1st Amd and books with #kagan.
                                                        Once tried to give a book to an FTC Comm. He refused, citing ethics
                                                        rules! #nonsense)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        (Enjoying discussion of books and 1st Amd with #kagan.
                                                        Once gave a textbook to an FTC
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Hatch asking #kagan about First Amendment
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan won't answer her question from Sen. Kohl "In what
                                                        direction would you move the Court?"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - cases to consider: (1) conflicts among lower cts, (2)


https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        challenges to acts of Congress, (3) significant legal questions
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan to Sen. Kohl - "I will take this one case at a time . . .
                                                        not right for a judge to have a particular passion."
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan is discussing interpretation of Fourth Amd with
                                                        Senator Sessions
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               29 Jun 10
                                                        Leahy asks #kagan whether she should recuse on nat'l sec
                                                        cases in which she provided advice to WH.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  29 Jun 10
                                                        Leahy mentions Rehniquist's decisions to decide Laird v.
                                                        Tatum (a gov't surveillance case) though he was in the admin.
                                                        #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        Leahy now asking #kagan about recusal and conflicts of
                                                        interest. (She represented the US in several cases as Solicitor
                                                        General. )
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               29 Jun 10
                                                        First two cases discussed at #kagan hearing are #privacy
                                                        cases, involving the Fourth Amendment and new technology (!)
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        First two cases discussed at #kagan hearing are #privacy
                                                        cases, involving the
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - "they didn't live with bomb sniffing dogs (Cabelles)
                                                        and heat detecting devices. (Kyllo)"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                29 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan discusses Fourth Amendment. "Incredible wisdom . .
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        Leahy asks #kagan how Constitution should be interpreted in
                                                        the modern era. Great question. Goes directly to judicial philosophy.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     29 Jun 10
                                                        Senator Leahy begins questioning this morning about
                                                        #kagan. Asks about family and values.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan hearing adjourned till 9 am Tuesday
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan - Supreme Court is "wondrous institution" but it must
                                                        also be "a modest one"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jun 10
                                                        Kagan - Law = "those wise restraints that make us free" =
                                                        "the blessings of liberty".= "the rule of law"
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan is off to a good start -- thoughtful, measured,
                                                        respectful, and personal warmth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Ok. Now the nominee. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jun 10
                                                        When Justice O'Connor was asked what recommendation
                                                        she had for Obama about next Justice, she said "Just two words. A
                                                        woman." ;-> #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Introduction of #kagan about to begin. First, the two
                                                        Massachusetts Senators - Sen. Kerry and Sen. Brown.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC sends letter to Senate recommending discussion of
                                                        #privacy during #kagan hearing. http://bit.ly/ai1RAK
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jun 10
                                                        Senate Whitehouse expressing concern about 5-4 decisions,
                                                        bias for companies #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Senator Durbin is defending Justice Marshall's legacy. (Does
                                                        it really need a defense?!) #kagan
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Schumer on #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Graham - "The fact that you grew up in a liberal
                                                        household is something we're going to have to talk about"?! Huh?!
                                                        #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        And now Senator Graham. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Specter now up. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Opening statements are proceeding as they normally do -
                                                        alternating D's and R'
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Committee opening statements are proceeding as they
                                                        typically do - alternating D's and R
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Feingold now speaking at #kagan hearing. Raised
                                                        #privacy questions during Sotomayor hearing.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Grassley speaking now. Wants a "fair respectful
                                                        process" also "thorough." #kagan



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Senator Feinstein expressing support for #kagan. Noting her
                                                        role as SG and former dean at Harvard Law School.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Hatch voted for Justice Ginsburg. He has said that
                                                        President's get to pick their nominees, but he voted against
                                                        Sotomayor. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jun 10
                                                        Senator Hatch is speaking. Notes passage of Sen. Byrd and
                                                        also Prof. Ginsburg (Georgetown faculty), the husband of Justice
                                                        Ginsburg. #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Kohl - "Your decisions will implicate our most fundamental
                                                        rights. From the right to privacy . . ." #kagan
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Now up in Sen. Kohl
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Sessions is making a point about the direction of Obama
                                                        administration
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Sen. Sessions now delivering his statement - "not a
                                                        coronation, but a confirmation process."
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Nice statement by Leahy - straightforward, heartfelt, speaks
                                                        to the importance of the Constition
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jun 10
                                                        Leahy notes that only 3 of 111 US Justices have been
                                                        women. (Chief Justice of Canadian High Court is a women).
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jun 10
                                                        Senator Leahy describes procedure - each Senator will have
                                                        about 10 minutes for an opening statement. Leahy notes passing of
                                                        Senator Byrd
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        #kagan now enters with Senator Leahy (Committee
                                                        Chairman) and Senator Sessions (Ranking Member = Top
                                                        Republican)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        General background on #kagan hearing at http://bit.ly/IXLXa
                                                        EPIC has a web page devoted to #privacy issues http://bit.ly/discHf
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        Senators now entering Committee room. #Kagan hearings
                                                        are broadcast live on CNN. http://bit.ly/b6crqV
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC live tweeting of #kagan nomination about to begin.
                                                        Listening for #privacy.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  25 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC will be tweeting Kagan Supreme Court hearing, starting
                                                        Monday at 12:30 pm. ET Follow @privacy140. Background
                                                        http://bit.ly/discHf
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     24 Jun 10
                                                        FTC rules in favor of Privacy for Twitter users. EPIC has
                                                        details: http://bit.ly/ceu0q4
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC posts page on Investigations of Google Street View.
                                                        #privacy http://bit.ly/doop0z
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Jun 10
                                                        . . . maybe "Freedom from Surveillance" but that is wordy.
                                                        #BillofRights
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Jun 10
                                                        Problem with @ehasbrouk "5.5" proposal - breaks nice
                                                        symmetry of affirmative principles. #billofrights
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Jun 10
                                                        Keep first two principles separate - two distinct ideas!
                                                        #billofrights
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Jun 10
                                                        agree with @ehasbrouk. Simplicity is a virtue. #billofrights
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Jun 10
                                                        Impressive list of privacy principles ! #billofrights
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Jun 10
                                                        Privacy International Launches System to Shed Light on
                                                        Controversial Technologies http://bit.ly/b2xgUw
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC Recommends Consumer Privacy Protections for
                                                        California Smart Grid http://bit.ly/aenOb7
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Jun 10
                                                        EPIC, Privacy Groups Recommend Further Changes for
                                                        Facebook http://epic.org/2010/06/epic-privacy-groups-
                                                        recommend.html
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   15 May 10
                                                        Google captured 600 gb of Wi-Fi data in more than
                                                        30countries, including the US. #privacy? http://nyti.ms/cU7sI6
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 May 10
                                                        EPIC files FTC complaint about #Facebook and #privacy.
                                                        http://bit.ly/8Zo7QT
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   24 Mar 10
                                                        Costco members, please vote "no" on whole-body scanner
                                                        proposal. #privacy http://bit.ly/b9waul
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Mar 10
                                                        Senator Patrick Leahy receives award for Open


https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Government. #FOIA
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  10 Mar 10
                                                        Still at OECD for #privacy meetings. Kirby to receive award
                                                        from EPIC later today for OECD Privacy Guidelines. #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - "Privacy enables the projection of our humanity"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson 7: "We mustn't give up on privacy. It's a
                                                        fundamental human rights. In all human rights doctrines." #privacy
                                                        #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson 6: Some of the guidelines need revision , e.g.
                                                        purpose specification (impact of search engine), consent #privacy
                                                        #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson 5 - General guidelines may be better approach
                                                        than formal rules. #privacy #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson 5: Local rules will not work. #privacy #oced30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson 3: Special problem with online privacy -



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        freedom of expression. (Americans indelibly marked with 1st Amd )
                                                        #privacy #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson 2: Gaining an international treaty is difficult,
                                                        guidelines may be preferable. #privacy #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - Lesson #1: with global technology, we need int'l
                                                        solutions. #privacy #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     9 Mar 10
                                                        Big battle (Euros v. US) over selection of chair. Picked Kirby
                                                        because he was from an "unimportant country" (Australia). #privacy
                                                        #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   9 Mar 10
                                                        Expert meeting in 74, conference in 76, expert group created
                                                        in 78. Kirby became chair of OECD group. #privacy #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        9 Mar 10
                                                        Kirby - need to open up discussion, include US, Japan, NZ,
                                                        Australia. Opportunity for OECD. #oecd30 #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        9 Mar 10
                                                        Justice Kirby (Australia) describing the early days -- late '70s.
                                                        Fundamental flaw was belief that national law would work. #privacy
                                                        #oecd30
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  9 Mar 10
                                                        In Paris for OECD discussion on beginning of famous OECD
                                                        #privacy guidelines. 30 year celebration this year. #oecd30
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 18 Feb 10
                                                        In courthouse. Doesn't look good for cellphones. And now I
                                                        have to go through a separate entry for laptops. :-(. #gbs
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        Thanks @ARLpolicy. Will start using #gbs instead of
                                                        #googlebooks. Almost at courthouse.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        Line moved quickly. Now in cab to courthouse. Not sure if I
                                                        can tweet there- "no cellphones" but maybe diff rules for lawyers
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Feb 10
                                                        Cold and windy but sun is bright in cab line outside of Penn
                                                        Station in New York. #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  18 Feb 10
                                                        Quick stop at Staples at Penn station for Post It notes and
                                                        highlighters, and then cab to the courthouse. #privacy #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        Conclusion: this settlement can't be fixed. The court must
                                                        toss it out. New York city skyline now visible over the snowbanks.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        But now I think the fixes are not enough. Ok if Acme Inc
                                                        proposed the digital library. But Google is building a data empire.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Feb 10
                                                        Now, have to figure out significance of Google Buzz dust-up.
                                                        Oh, PRIVACY POLICIES DON'T PROTECT PRIVACY (that was
                                                        easy). ;-) #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  18 Feb 10
                                                        Fixing the Google settlement. Here are good suggestions.
                                                        #privacy #googlebooks http://epic.org/privacy/googlebooks/policy.html
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               18 Feb 10
                                                        EPIC web pages are excellent. ;-) Found good quote from
                                                        Vaidhyanathan - Google is "personal information vacuum." #privacy
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  18 Feb 10
                                                        Need to look at local rules soon. Still time to review EPIC
                                                        web pages. And get more coffee. Just now passing through Phil.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  18 Feb 10
                                                        Grimmelmann also makes good points about #privacy in his
                                                        Internet Law article. "consumers need protection." #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        Just finished excellent privacy discussion in Samuelson /
                                                        academic authors letter to court. Crisp, clear, and compelling.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   18 Feb 10
                                                        Finished review. Conclusion about settlement: no real
                                                        privacy safeguards for readers. Even worse - lots of new tracking.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Feb 10
                                                        Here is the security and breach section. Nothing about
                                                        privacy. #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        Ok.Here we go. 6.6f. No PII to registry. But no definition of
                                                        PII. What about IP addresses? And what about other third parties?
                                                        ?#googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Feb 10
                                                        Found another privacy provision. This one for the
                                                        rightsholders. Still nothing for the reader. #privacy #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Feb 10
                                                        Finally found a privacy provision. 4.2. It's between Google
                                                        and the Registry :-(. Nothing to do with reader privacy. ;-((
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                              18 Feb 10
                                                        OMG watermarks for consumer purchases also?!? Every
                                                        purchase?? People need to read RMS On the Road to Tyco.
                                                        #privacy #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      18 Feb 10
                                                        Watermarks on all printed pages identifying institutional
                                                        users?! All libraries. All universities. Incredible #privacy
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        18 Feb 10
                                                        This provision is crazy - NO hyperlinking, except to other
                                                        Google services. #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         18 Feb 10
                                                        "google's exclusion of books"??! Who wrote this settlement?
                                                        It's like an anti-library. Still looking for privacy stuff. #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        18 Feb 10
                                                        "right to remove" books?! Wow. Remember Amazon and
                                                        1984? Now 1000x. #googlebooks #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Feb 10
                                                        Also brought favorite fountain pen - Parker Frontiet stainless
                                                        steel, medium nib with blue ink. Inexpensive but reliable.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        Brought the serious hard-sided briefcase for the court
                                                        hearing instead of the regular Tumi. Love the sound of the latches.
                                                        #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                18 Feb 10
                                                        EPIC brief looks good. I'm persuaded. ;-). Time now for
                                                        coffee. Then review of amended settlement. #privacy #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        18 Feb 10
                                                        We're underway. Time to start reviewing EPIC brief.
                                                        #googlebooks #privacy
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    18 Feb 10
                                                        It's cold and dark at 6 in the morning outside Union Station
                                                        in DC. Snow still piled high on the sides of the streets. #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     18 Feb 10
                                                        At train station in DC heading to NYC for court hearing on
                                                        #privacy and #googlebooks
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     11 Feb 10
                                                        Euro Parl rejects #SWIFT deal! #privacy #victory
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                9 Feb 10
                                                        EPIC - Google-NSA partnership should be more public, less
                                                        private #privacy http://bit.ly/cHGTpM
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     9 Feb 10
                                                        US Patriot Act confronts EU #Privacy Laws in SWIFT data
                                                        dispute. Euro Parl to vote Wednesday #orwell http://bit.ly/bUxpAk
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      8 Feb 10
                                                        SWIFT banking deal = US Patriot Act v. EU Privacy Laws
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Feb 10
                                                        US Patriot Act confronts EU Privacy Laws in SWIFT data
                                                        dispute. Euro Parl to vote this week. #privacy http://bit.ly/bUxpAk
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      4 Feb 10



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        EPIC Sues NSA to Force Disclosure of Cyber Security
                                                        Authority http://bit.ly/cuciKb
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                          4 Feb 10
                                                        EPIC Seeks Records on Google-NSA Relationship #privacy
                                                        http://bit.ly/9eeyv1
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                           1 Feb 10
                                                        Don't understand @EdFelten comment. For privacy analysis,
                                                        Fair Info Practices is starting point, not retreat. #fllatirons #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                          1 Feb 10
                                                        FY2011 budget out today -- waaaay too much $$$ for Big
                                                        Brother. #privacy #orwell
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         21 Jan 10
                                                        HRC - "US firms should challenge foreign govt's demands
                                                        for censorship and surveillance." #privacy #freedom
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     21 Jan 10
                                                        HRC - "Governments that violate the basic rights of Internet
                                                        users risk walling themselves off from progress . . ." #freedom
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      21 Jan 10
                                                        HRC - On anonymity, real problems should not be excuse
                                                        for govt's to track citizens engaged in peaceful activity. #privacy
                                                        #freedom
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Jan 10
                                                        HRC - Some governments have "violated the privacy rights
                                                        of their citizens." #freedom #privacy http://www.state.gov/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Jan 10
                                                        Cool. Clinton just invoked Universal Declaration of Human
                                                        Rights. #freedom
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Jan 10
                                                        Hilary Clinton speaking this morning on Internet Freedom.
                                                        http://netfreedom.state.gov/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  20 Jan 10
                                                        PBS Newshour looks at "naked machines" and #privacy
                                                        tonight Jan 20. http://www.pbs.org/newshour/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                              11 Jan 10
                                                        Questions the press should ask about #bodyscanners Also
                                                        #privacy #orwell http://bit.ly/856QLx
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 11 Jan 10
                                                        CNN report on EPIC FOIA docs, body scanners and
                                                        #privacy. Yes, they record images! Also have hard drives and USB!
                                                        http://bit.ly/7QUMSw
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Jan 10
                                                        listening to White House review of Dec 25 attack #privacy
                                                        http://bit.ly/6JtTeQ
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   6 Jan 10



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Stop Airport Strip Searches. Protect #privacy #bodyscanner
                                                        Join FB group here -- http://bit.ly/7OOsQ3
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   5 Jan 10
                                                        Stop Airport Strip Searches. Protect #privacy. Join FB group
                                                        here -- http://bit.ly/7OOsQ3
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    4 Jan 10
                                                        Excellent statement from Privacy International on body
                                                        scanners. http://bit.ly/6T3pcL
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    4 Jan 10
                                                        NY Times editorial on responding to Detroit bomber.
                                                        http://bit.ly/6F7SxH
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    4 Jan 10
                                                        WashPost article on body scanners and #privacy risks.
                                                        http://bit.ly/7svNbB
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    4 Jan 10
                                                        NPR report on EPIC Facebook #privacy complaint.
                                                        http://bit.ly/4R3jvp
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   17 Dec 09
                                                        RT @huffingtonpost Jose Antonio Vargas: With The Rise of
                                                        Social Media, No Privacy for Tiger Woods http://cli.gs/Tbaet
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 9 Dec 09
                                                        NYT Quote of the Day: "Has anyone else noticed that Google



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        announcements sound like proclamations from a King?" #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Heading to the gym across the street. Back for the last
                                                        panel. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        DNA person says redlining is illegal. (!?) #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Walmart privacy person is asked about behav ads versus
                                                        contextual ads. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Szoka on advertising - "dollars in real world are being
                                                        replaced by cents in online world". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Szoka - "attention is being commodified". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        "Madrid privacy declaration" - good agenda/framework for
                                                        privacy. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Madrid privacy declaration - good agenda/framework for
                                                        privacy. Http://www.thepublicvoice.org/Madrid-declaration/ #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC privacy conf - room is still packed. People are standing
                                                        around the room. Impressive for mid-afternoon. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Chester - advertisers are targetting individuals. This data is
                                                        personally identifiable. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Wills - no control over flash cookies. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Ngo - no real enforcement in industry self-reg principles.
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Ngo - emphasizes OECD privacy guidelines - good
                                                        framework for privacy protection. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Ngo - Some consumers know about data collection, but many
                                                        do not. (Founded PrivacyLives. Good site for privacy info). #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Morgan - "in the past, we had scarcity for distribution. Now
                                                        we have scarcity for attention". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Bluekai - transparency is key to privacy. "Innovate around
                                                        transparency". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 7 Dec 09
                                                        Chester CDD (discussing advertising). "you can buy
                                                        Hispanics. You can buy African-Americans. You can buy kids".
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Chester - privacy problem much bigger than people realize.
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Question from audience - "isn't privacy gone?" (question
                                                        asked anonymously ;-) ). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Woolley - 100 million people made purchases on cyber
                                                        Monday. (but how many got free shipping? ;-) ) #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        (szoka's economic arguments on privacy are filled with holes.
                                                        He drops coase lbut doesn't understand significance.) #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Szoka - paywalls don't work. Need more advertising. Supports
                                                        behavioral advertising. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC asks question about contextual advertising and
                                                        behavioral advert'g (not all advert'g is bad, but not all is good)
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Richard Smith discussing loyalty cards. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Turning now to behavioral targeting. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Harbour - dissented in Google-dclk merger. (could turn out to
                                                        be the Olmstead dissent of the modern era). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Harbour - "privacy protection is non-price factor to consider in
                                                        competition analysis" re Google and DCLK merger #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Harbour - "we have strayed far from the original fair
                                                        information practices". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Harbour - "notice and choice have been insufficient".
                                                        "concepts are largely illusory". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Harbour - calling for real action on privacy. "consumer privacy
                                                        is under seige." "Data is currency". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC comm Pamela harbor now speaking. One of the real
                                                        privacy champions in the US gov't. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Turow - risk of much greater secrecy about decisions
                                                        impacting consumers in the future. (he's right) #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        Thierer - enforce contracts, but do not legislate. #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        Thierer, CATO - about privacy notices - "Let a thousand
                                                        flowers bloom.". (wasn't that Mao? ;-) ) #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Kelsey, consumer advocate - "notice and choice has failed.".
                                                        Need national framework for privacy protection. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Kelsey - "there is a difference in a consumer's brain between
                                                        google as search engine and google as advertising network." #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Cranor - research data - "privacy notices are impenetrable."
                                                        Need nutrition labels for privacy. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  7 Dec 09
                                                        Turow - polling data - many favor prison time for companies
                                                        that misuse personal data. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               7 Dec 09
                                                        Turow - polling data - most Americans MISTAKENLY believe
                                                        privacy policy = privacy protection. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Westin - consumers are ill-informed about most issues, not
                                                        just privacy. Consumers rely on organizations they trust. #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       7 Dec 09
                                                        Thierer - Notes popularity of firefox extensions for privacy, eg
                                                        adblocker plus, noscript #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Kelsey - consumers assume that government is protecting
                                                        them from abuse. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Westin -health information is most sensitive. American public
                                                        split on benefits and privacy risks of elec health records #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC asking Google about seach for Alzheimers. Google says
                                                        it does not generate ads based on health querries. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        "cuties in Potomac" want to meet Jules. ;-). #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  7 Dec 09
                                                        Davidson - "transparency and consumer choice" is foundation
                                                        of privacy. (not really) #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Kelsey - consumers make effort to protect privacy, eg
                                                        deleting cookies, but companies ignore, eg flash cookies. #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  7 Dec 09
                                                        Polonetsky - user settings should not become as complicated
                                                        as "dashboard of a 767." #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Davidson - "there is a bit of a bargain here." #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Davidson, google - launched " interest based" advertising
                                                        (=behavioral targetting).
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Cranor - "people don't understand consequences of actions."
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Thierer - favors "rational ignorance." #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Cranor, CMU cs prof agrees. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Turow, Annenberg prof - "consumers have very little idea of
                                                        what goes on behind the curtain, under the hood." #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 7 Dec 09
                                                        Panel 2 - "consumer expectations and privacy" (panel needs
                                                        more consumers) #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Grant, consumer advocate - "implement Fair Information
                                                        Practices into law." #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     7 Dec 09
                                                        Purcell - reciprical accountability - consumers should be able
                                                        to track directors of companies. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Acquisti - discussing genuine privacy enhancing technology -
                                                        Chaum. (a really good way to think about privacy). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Hintze - mobile ad could be cool. Useful information at
                                                        appropriate time. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Harper - need to focus on gov't access to data - "very
                                                        important concern." (I agree). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Rosen - new concerns about mobile wireless purchases?
                                                        Locational targetting? #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC - what about secret lists on consumers that limit
                                                        opprtunities? #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Purcell - prohibit reuse of sensitive data. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Hoffman - not reasonable to expect that consumers make
                                                        informed decisions, eg parents can't evaluate lead ppm in toys.
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Lots of good information about conference at FTC.GOV.
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Rosen - use of data (eg people with mental health issues) by
                                                        list brokers. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        Acquisti - privacy risks - small cost, but high probability.
                                                        Difficult to evaluate. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Acquisti- notification, control, and transparency, necesary but
                                                        not sufficient for privacy protection. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 7 Dec 09
                                                        Purcell - Companies want complicated privacy statements to
                                                        avoid liability. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  7 Dec 09
                                                        Hoffman - world renowned experts can barely understand
                                                        data flows. How can the individual consumer? #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        Harper,the libertarian - "don't regulate too soon." (wait until
                                                        the problem is out of control ;-) ). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09
                                                        Rosen - "could we limit period of data retention?" #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy (Good idea)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                        7 Dec 09



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Hintze (MS) - need privacy safeguards - multiple strategies -
                                                        anonymization, "break link of search sessions" #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                          7 Dec 09
                                                        Purcell - "make it difficult to reidentify data". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        Susan grant, consumer advocate - "privacy is a fundamental
                                                        right. Consumers should not trade privacy for services." #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         7 Dec 09
                                                        Rosen - "broader concerns? Intellectual freedom? Human
                                                        dignity?autonomy?" #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   7 Dec 09
                                                        Jeff describes AOL search disclosure fiasco, viacom access
                                                        to YouTube data. "What is risk of disclosing search times?" #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         7 Dec 09
                                                        Jeff rosen discussing Brandeis and Olmstead dissent.
                                                        (Brandeis also helped establish FTC). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         7 Dec 09
                                                        Title "benefits and risks of collecting, using, and retaining
                                                        consumer data" #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         7 Dec 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Panel 1 about to begin. Jeff Rosen will chair. #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  7 Dec 09
                                                        Finally privacy and mobile phones- "a computer that happens
                                                        to have a cellphone connected to it." #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Richard now looks at social networks FB and advertising.
                                                        Also dev access to user data. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Richard looks at flow of medical data. There is a lot "behind
                                                        the curtain". #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Chart - personal data "ecosystem". Consumer in middle, next
                                                        familiar businesses, and then two concentric circles - #ftcpriv
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Data storage is much cheaper today. 1 g drives are cheap.
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09
                                                        Richard Smith now discussing technologies of data flows.
                                                        #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      7 Dec 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Not much enthusiasm for "notice and choice" or "harms"
                                                        approach. (I agree). #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC chair supports opt-in. Concerned about sensitive data,
                                                        vulnerable groups. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC chair discussing sears case - major enforcement
                                                        discussion. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC conference room is packed. Over 400 with many people
                                                        standing. #ftcpriv #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC chair discussing targetting #privacy #ftcpriv
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC chair "another watershed moment" #ftcpriv
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    7 Dec 09
                                                        FTC chair opens with Brandeis #ftcpriv
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Legal note on CCTV on privacy: problem is that law regulates
                                                        audio surveillance not video surv. Problem is gap in coverage.
                                                        #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        On CCTV protest, worth noting EPIC campaign in
                                                        Washington, DC http://observingsurveillance.org/ #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        On CCTV protest, worth noting EPIC campaign in
                                                        Washington, DC http://observingsurveillance.org/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Colin Bennett, who studies privacy activism, is speaking now.
                                                        #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 3 Nov 09
                                                        Jaiok KIm recommends international standards for biometric
                                                        identifiers. #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  3 Nov 09
                                                        Ann Cavoukian discussing risks of centralized biometric
                                                        databases. (She has done good work on better designs for biometrics
                                                        ) #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Allen describes suspicion based on race. #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Peter Shaar, German DPA, makes a very important point
                                                        about the emergence of mass surveillance. #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Rodriguez reviewing privacy campaigns from around the
                                                        world. #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Rodriguez thanks Public Voice coalition. @globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    3 Nov 09
                                                        Marzouki reports that government databases established to
                                                        fight terrorism are ultimately used to police minor crimes.
                                                        #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  3 Nov 09
                                                        Public Voice Madrid conference #globalprivacy #privacy nice
                                                        web page with updates at http://bit.ly/1vwATO @thepublicvoice
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @thepublicvoice: #globalprivacy Ann Cavoukian data
                                                        minimization goal one to many biometric encryption app will be
                                                        developed, is essential
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @nigelwoz: #globalprivacy Cavoukian etal courageous in
                                                        endorsing PET businesses but dangerous without ability to fully audit
                                                        it?
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @thepublicvoice: #globalprivacy Stephen Lau @PBD
                                                        Asian cultural perspectives, enhance communications 60% earth pop
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @txitua: RT @thepublicvoice: #globalprivacy Privacy
                                                        Cartoons - Chris Slane cartoons http://bit.ly/4elaXJ
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @nigelwoz: #globalprivacy hustinx key point -need
                                                        incentives for privacy enhancing technologies both push and pull to
                                                        encourage adoption
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     2 Nov 09
                                                        RT #globalprivacy Dix @PBD right of locational privacy US
                                                        National Surface Infrastructure feb 09 study, massive surveillance
                                                        infrastructure
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @thepublicvoice: At Privacy by design, focus on needs of
                                                        aging population, sensors and aids whose feeds need protection
                                                        #globalprivacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     2 Nov 09
                                                        RT @jmcesteves: RT @thepublicvoice "Those interested in
                                                        #privacy follow #globalprivacy this week"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    22 Oct 09
                                                        Senft - "What can we learn about how kids deal with
                                                        celebrity. Who are the 'we'?" #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    22 Oct 09
                                                        Terri Senfit now speaking #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "Technology allows kids to break free of constraints."
                                                        #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "Kids lie about identity to hide online" #berkyouth
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "Kids in US have not thought much about advertising
                                                        model for the Internet." #privacy #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "Online communities are also about role of
                                                        institutions, data collection, advertising." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "With teenagers, privacy is not about space; it is
                                                        about networks and control." #privacy #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "Privacy for kids is all about control of information."
                                                        YES #privacy #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        boyd - "Kids deeply care about privacy, but they
                                                        conceptualize privacy different from their parents." #berkyouth
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        boyd - "There will always be privacy in public." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        danah boyd is speaking now about Youth Attitudes Toward
                                                        Public and Private Spheres. #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        Burkert - There is ambiguity in this conversation -> broadcast
                                                        transformation #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        Burkert - "We are moving from conversation mode to
                                                        broadcast mode." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        Herbert Burkert gives lunch talk #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        Meztger - "Youth goes to digital media first." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        Miriam Metzger discussing information quality, reputation.
                                                        #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     22 Oct 09
                                                        Urs Gasser discussing information quality. #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09
                                                        trevor hughes - "there are controls on the device -- point of
                                                        access, carrier" #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09
                                                        ursgasser - policy helps shape behavior - rules, legislation,
                                                        norms #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09
                                                        question - what is "policy"? #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09
                                                        jpalfrey discussing policy opportunities for translating
                                                        research into outcomes #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   22 Oct 09
                                                        Ito "10 year rule -- 10 years from intro of new tech till
                                                        adoption of new norms. We are at 5 year point now for social media"
                                                        #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09
                                                        Ito - "Kids create multiple online identities - Facebook and
                                                        WoW." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09
                                                        Ito - "We negotiate knowledge. We don't consumer
                                                        knowledge." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      22 Oct 09



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Ito - "Japan study - texting emerged from kids. More polite
                                                        than voice calls which are disruptive. Example of how norms change."
                                                        #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        Ito - "Need to capture voice and perspectives of kids."
                                                        #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        Ito - "Whose voice is represented in new standard setting?
                                                        There is a fight over new standards." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    22 Oct 09
                                                        Ito - "goal is not to look at just problems; goal is to look
                                                        online and find constructive alternatives, new norms." #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        "mapping online practices from a youth centered
                                                        perspectives" - Ito #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        Comments by Mimi Ito #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09
                                                        First topic - "DIgital Natives' content creation and information
                                                        dissemination practices: State of play and open questions -
                                                        #berkyouth
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       22 Oct 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Conference at the Berkman Center today on youth and the
                                                        net #berkyouth #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    8 Oct 09
                                                        Senate committee considers Patriot Act today. Time to restore
                                                        #privacy. Dems have no excuses. Good NYT editorial here:
                                                        http://bit.ly/3jraeb
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  25 Sep 09
                                                        "Modern privacy begins with the understanding that personal
                                                        information will be widely accessible." #privacy #paradox
                                                        http://bit.ly/hW2vc
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     25 Sep 09
                                                        "The freedom to disclose is based on the freedom to
                                                        withhold and the freedom to control." #privacy http://bit.ly/hW2vc
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    25 Sep 09
                                                        "The freedom to disclose is based on the freedom to
                                                        withhold and the freedom to control." http://bit.ly/hW2vc
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   10 Sep 09
                                                        Good for Vivek! He talked about promoting access to gov't
                                                        data *and* protecting #privacy and #security. That is the right
                                                        approach. #g2s
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    10 Sep 09
                                                        EPIC comments on promoting gov't transparency , #g2s
                                                        *and* protecting #privacy here: http://bit.ly/1qhAiM
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     10 Sep 09
                                                        RT @dberlind: Carl Malamud @ #g2s: Artificial and unjust
                                                        limits on access to public information must be abolished
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  10 Sep 09
                                                        R“If a meeting is be part of the lawmaking process, it must
                                                        be public. That means on the Internet."-@CarlMalamud #g2s on
                                                        transparency
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      10 Sep 09
                                                        RT @dberlind: Carl Malamud @ #g2s: Has 3 propositions:
                                                        1. If a document as the force of law, it must be available for all to
                                                        read
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      10 Sep 09
                                                        RT @eportelance: Carl Malamud: Lack of freely available
                                                        public information is a barrier to innovation and the public interest.
                                                        #g2s
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   10 Sep 09
                                                        RT @DivaDanese: @carlmalamud keynote "How can we be
                                                        a nation of laws if the laws are locked behind a cashregister?" #g2s
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      10 Sep 09
                                                        Listening to @CarlMalamud appraising Obama for setting
                                                        "default" to "open" for information, but critiquing monetization of
                                                        public info #g2s
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      9 Sep 09
                                                        is following #g2s today. 'Hope there is some discussion of
                                                        #privacy.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      19 Aug 09
                                                        Time to VOTE for #privacy and NO on national ID! Check
                                                        out the Parade poll and pls RT http://bit.ly/4xJBi
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   6 Aug 09
                                                        Last year, Justice O'Connor was asked what advice she
                                                        would give to the President about a #scotus pick. "Pick a woman,"
                                                        she said. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       6 Aug 09
                                                        Senate confirms #sotomayor for #scotus 68-31.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       5 Aug 09
                                                        Senate vote underway on #sotomayour #scotus #cnn.
                                                        Current tally is 58-28-14 (uncommitted) http://bit.ly/dB1Fo
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        saltzman - argument for intervention: class action suits do not
                                                        adequately represent public interest #gbsworkshop09
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        saltzman - collusive dynamic in class action settlements
                                                        (discussion is turning toward need for public participation)
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        sigall (former US copyright office) - "Witness to public failure
                                                        of Congress enacting orphan works legislation." #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        (And there is a real danger that the >Change Congress<
                                                        obscures other important political goals.) #gbsworkshop09
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        (I agree with larry up till the conclusion. Congress is no more
                                                        or less corrupt than most other powerful institutions.)
                                                        #gbsworkshop09
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        very inspiring clip from Gore TED speech on solving
                                                        "democracy crisis," i.e. need to engage as *citizens# (I agree)
                                                        #gbsworkshop09 http: ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        books will become like documentary films, encumbered by
                                                        agreements, available only in snippets. #gbsworkshop09
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    31 Jul 09
                                                        now, this gets interesting (Larry began talk with kittens and
                                                        tiger cubs are both cute and cuddly. Then the tiger grows up.)
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        lessig "there is progress in this" - the settlement > fair use
                                                        claim. Creation of registry is key. #gbsworkshop.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        larry focusing on middle category in settlement ("orphan
                                                        works") - 75% of books in settlement #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   31 Jul 09
                                                        lessig - "Google objective to google-ize books" #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     31 Jul 09
                                                        interesting moment in history of cyberlaw about to occur . . .
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                             31 Jul 09
                                                        people following Google Book Settlement conference at
                                                        Berkman -- both #gbsworkshop and #gbsworkshop09 in use
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        lessig - books are free "as in beer, not as in speech." that's a
                                                        shout-out to RMS. #gbsworkshop09
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        posted tweets to #gbsworkshop -- tag is actually
                                                        #gbsworksop09 -- sorry for the confusion
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - key is establishing standards for format, image quality,
                                                        search, etc so "that stuff doesn't get lost." #gbsworkshop09
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        contrasting example of Japanese national library
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  31 Jul 09
                                                        grimmelmann - terms of settlement prevent commercial use of



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        books that would compete with Google #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        concerns about quality -- scan resolution, accuracy, etc.
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - univ users will have to go to "Googleland" to use the
                                                        materials. Key is the cookie #privacy #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 31 Jul 09
                                                        darnton - univ can't use digital copies of its own public
                                                        domain works. They belong to Google. Google will provide access
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        darnton - "mere civilians can't understand the settlement." ;->
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09
                                                        darnton - settlement focuses on protecting libraries from
                                                        litigation. Use of digital copies is "extremely limited" #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 31 Jul 09
                                                        Wow. Darnton says "settlement could be considered a defeat
                                                        for fair use." #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       31 Jul 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Here is the Darnton article. Required reading. #gbsworkshop
                                                        http://bit.ly/163dV5
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        Bob Darton now speaking (Harvard librarian, wrote famous
                                                        article in NYRB on problems with GBS, change the debate)
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        discussion about public engagement, campaigns
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        @jpalfrey asks "is this issue really any different from other
                                                        consumer issues? why no environment-like movement?"
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        suber - agreeing with Siva but asks "how do we persuade
                                                        public institutions it's not too late?" #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - "We (not Google) are the problem. Google is doing
                                                        what they should do. " -- arguing for political engagement
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 31 Jul 09
                                                        Peter Wayner passed along a timely paper "Can Libraries
                                                        Protect Users' Privacy While Tracking Books?" #gbsworkshop
                                                        #privacy http://bit.l ...
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09
                                                        marx - library community has trust and authenticity
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09
                                                        marx - interconnected nodes could be subject areas (=
                                                        decentralized / distributed knowledge ?) #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09
                                                        marx - "need to protect #privacy even if it seems our users
                                                        don't care . . . intellectual freedom has to be fundamental"
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09
                                                        marx - "new facilities for 'non-consumptive research'" (my
                                                        view - really scary concept) #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     31 Jul 09
                                                        marx - discussing functionality of open digital library.
                                                        digitization is just the beginning, e.g. open data APIs. #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09
                                                        Maura Marx from Open Knowledge Commons is now
                                                        speaking. #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - "It's not too late. It's never too late." (!!) #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                         31 Jul 09



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        siva - proposes "the human knowledge project" (modeled
                                                        after the Human Genome Project" #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - The future (Google, Internet, etc.) could be very
                                                        different from today. #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - "Why are search results 'customized'? what is the
                                                        impact on the understanding of knowledge" #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - "We don't know why one book ranks above another
                                                        book in Book Search." #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - "Privacy is important to Google., it is important to
                                                        Google on Google's terms" #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - "we have not fully taken account of the scope of the
                                                        settlement." #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    31 Jul 09
                                                        siva "Nothing is free" e.g. we pay for GBS with donation of
                                                        books to Google that public institutions have paid for #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      31 Jul 09
                                                        siva - GBS is an example of "public failure" (market failure)



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                31 Jul 09
                                                        palfrey on Google Book Settlement "What would be better"?
                                                        #gbsworkshop
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     31 Jul 09
                                                        at Berkman today for a conference on Google Book
                                                        Settlment follow #gbsworkshop notes on #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        For @privacy140 followers, EPIC will begin regular updates
                                                        on #privacy issues in Washington and in the news. http://bit.ly/IUk9d
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Final vote on #sotomayor for #scotus 13-6. (I predicted 15-4,
                                                        but did not expect Sen. Hatch and Sen. Grassley to vote against.)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy (top D) acknowledging good working relationship
                                                        with Sen. Sessions (top R) for #sotomayor nomination for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy entering endorsement letters for #sotomayor to
                                                        the record for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Franken raises interesting question -- is #sotomayor or



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        the current #scotus "judicial activist"?
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Franken speaking about "individual rights, individual
                                                        protections, individual liberties." #scotus #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter - #sotomayor is "well qualified" for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter also concerned about limited review by #scotus
                                                        of important issues (This is a reference to #privacy #wiretap)
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter recalling Bork hearings for #scotus. Lessons
                                                        learned and thoughts about how hearings after #sotomayor could be
                                                        more useful
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter on #sotomayor and #scotus "Life of the law is
                                                        experience not logic" (Justice Holmes)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter is voting for #sotomayor for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kaufman on #sotomayor. Also thanks Sen. Leahy.



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        Interesting exchanges between Sens. about #scotus - is 2nd
                                                        amd "fundamental" right? This is not so much about #sotomayor.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has posted the complete hearing transcript for
                                                        #sotomayor for #scotus. Check references for #privacy, etc. (Big PDF
                                                        file) http://bi ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has a comprehensive page on #sotomayor and
                                                        #privacy http://epic.org/privacy/sotomayor/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Klobuchar (D-MN) now up.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Whitehouse discussing standard for voting for or against
                                                        nominees for #scotus This issue will come back with nominee after
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Whitehouse will vote in favor of #sotomayor for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Cardin just mentioned #privacy rights and #sotomayor.
                                                        "She will advance #privacy in the 21st cent." #scotus.



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Coburn also expressing concern about limited answers
                                                        given by #scotus nominees. Kudos to Sen. Leahy though.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Coburn (R-OK) is now giving his statement on
                                                        #sotomayor for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Durbin mentions the strip search case #privacy
                                                        #sotomayor was out ahead of #scotus on that decision
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Durbin (D-IL) to vote yes. (Tally: 7-4, Kyl skipped)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        New standard for voting on #scotus appears to be whether
                                                        the nominee's views match the views of the Senator voting,
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Interesting question to consider, given this #sotomayor vote,
                                                        whether Obama should have nominated someone less moderate for
                                                        #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Cornyn is now up. Will vote no. #sotomayor #scotus
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Schumer #sotomayor"If my colleagues cannot support
                                                        a moderate pick, then it appears they cannot support any pick from
                                                        the President."
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Schumer is voting for #sotomayor for #scotus,
                                                        emphasizing judicial career over "wise Latina woman" comment.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Graham "You want to reward good lawyers, whether you
                                                        agree with them or not." #sotomayor #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Graham notes that Dems voted for Roberts, though they
                                                        would not have nominated him for #scotus #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen Graham (R-SC) will vote for #sotomayor for #scotus. "I
                                                        feel good about Judge Sotomayor." (tally: 5-3)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feingold votes in favor of #sotomayor. (tally: 4-3)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feingold concerned that nominees cannot discuss
                                                        opinions on previously decided #scotus cases. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feigngold discussing #privacy and #PatriotAct. Liked
                                                        #sotomayor responses. Also notes deference to Congress. #scotus.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 28 Jul 09
                                                        Statements on #sotomayor continue to be interesting. Some
                                                        Senators emphasize process of judging, others outcomes. #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                              28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feingold beginning his statement on #sotomayor.
                                                        Acknowledging scope of hearing. Commends Sen. Leahy for
                                                        #transparency #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Grassley goes into detail on #sotomayor opinions,
                                                        particularly concerned about property rights and Ricci (tally: 3-3)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Grassley "cannot support" nom. of #sotomayor for
                                                        #scotus. Another surprise. Sen. Grassley votes for Pres. nominees
                                                        and is a moderate.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feinstein describes #sotomayor as "impressive." Will
                                                        vote in favor for #scotus (tally: 3-2)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch says that #sotomayor follows her feelings, not the
                                                        law. Surprising basis for this vote. #scotus
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch is voting against #sotomayor for #scotus. This is
                                                        surprising. Sen. Hatch routinely votes for the President's nominees,
                                                        Dem or Rep
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kohl will vote for #sotomayor (tally: 2-1) #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Sessions will vote against #sotomayor. #scotus.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Sessions now discussing #sotomayor rulings -- Ricci,
                                                        guns, and property rights.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       28 Jul 09
                                                        In the Jud Comm, Senators (mostly lawyers, former
                                                        prosecutors) argue forcefully. Agree or disagree, it's worth listening.
                                                        #sotomayor #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  28 Jul 09
                                                        Member statements are interesting, -- explaining the reason
                                                        for a vote. Doesn't happen enough in Congress. #sotomayor #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       28 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC page on #sotomayor and #privacy includes materials
                                                        on nomination process, commentary, major decisions
                                                        http://bit.ly/DHpQw
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       28 Jul 09



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Sen. Sessions is now speaking about #sotomayor. "Wise
                                                        Latina woman" comment appears to be the basis for his vote.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy "looks forward to a bipartisan vote" on
                                                        #sotomayor for #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy opens committee meeting on vote for
                                                        #sotomayor for #scotus. Notes public interest -- hearings, tv,
                                                        webcast, blogs, etc
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        Committee vote on #sotomayor for #scotus about to begin.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has posted the complete hearing transcript for
                                                        #sotomayor for #scotus. Check references for #privacy, etc. (Big PDF
                                                        file) http://bi ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        C-Span video archive of #sotomayor hearing for #scotus
                                                        http://bit.ly/FLUGh
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Roberts won with a 78-22 vote #scotus. But Alito was a little
                                                        more controversial. His vote was 58-42. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        The vote for Kennedy for #scotus was 97-0.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        In recent years, the nominees for #scotus have typically
                                                        picked up large majorities.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Two of President Nixon's nominees for #scotus were also
                                                        defeated -- Clement Haynsworth and Harold Carswell
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        In 1987, Judge Robet Bork lost a vote for #scotus 42-58.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Quick history on #scotus votes and #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        Last week, I explained that votes on #scotus nominees can
                                                        be very dramatic. Better word might be "surprising." #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        Next thing you know, Sen. Grassley will vote against
                                                        #sotomayor, an exceptionally well qualified moderate
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        Last week, I predicted a 15-4 vote in committee for
                                                        #sotomayor but didn't anticipate Sen. Hatch's bizarre announcem't he
                                                        would vote against.
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        The full Senate vote on #sotomayor should still take place
                                                        before Aug 7, which is the date the Senate hopes to go out on
                                                        August recess
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        If #sotomayor receives a favorable report (+ vote) from the
                                                        Committee , the full Senate will then vote on the nomination for
                                                        #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        There are 12 Democrats and 7 Republicans on the
                                                        Committee that will vote on #sotomayor. http://judiciary.senate.gov/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        The committee vote on #sotomayor for #scotus will be
                                                        webcast at 10 am ET. Details here: http://bit.ly/DGJlW
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   28 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has posted the complete hearing transcript for
                                                        #sotomayor for #scotus. Check reference for #privacy, etc. (Big PDF
                                                        file) http://bit ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     28 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has a comprehensive page on #sotomayor and
                                                        #privacy http://epic.org/privacy/sotomayor/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    28 Jul 09
                                                        The #sotomayor vote for #scotus takes place today at 10 am
                                                        ET in the Senate Judiciary Committee http://judiciary.senate.gov/
                                                        Expand



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                              21 Jul 09
                                                        The Committee was unable to obtain a quorum =
                                                        Republicans wanted more time. #sotomayor Here are the Committee
                                                        rules: http://bit.ly/nUB0W
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        Well, the #sotomayor vote has been delayed till next week.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        Statement from Sen. Leahy at the end of the nomination
                                                        hearing for #sotomayor http://bit.ly/49iYV
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        Roberts won with a 78-22 vote #scotus. But Alito was a little
                                                        more controversial. His vote was 58-42.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        The vote for Kennedy for #scotus was 97-0.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        In recent years, the nominees for #scotus have typically
                                                        picked up large majorities.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        Two of President Nixon's nominees for #scotus were also
                                                        defeated -- Clement Haynsworth and Harold Carswell
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        In 1987, Judge Robet Bork lost a vote for #scotus 42-58.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Jul 09
                                                        Vote on #scotus nominees can be very dramatic. Some times
                                                        the votes are very close, some times there are unexpected votes.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Jul 09
                                                        The full Senate vote on #sotomayor should take place before
                                                        Aug 7, which is the date the Senate hopes to go out on August
                                                        recess.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        If #sotomayor receives a favorable report (+ vote) from the
                                                        Committee , the full Senate will then vote on the nomination.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                21 Jul 09
                                                        The committee vote on #sotomayor will be webcast at 10 am
                                                        ET. http://bit.ly/ADICq
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    21 Jul 09
                                                        There are 12 Democrats and 7 Republicans on the
                                                        Committee that will vote on #sotomayor.
                                                        http://judiciary.senate.gov/about/members.cfm
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   21 Jul 09
                                                        The #sotomayor vote for #scotus takes place today at 10 am
                                                        ET in the Senate Judiciary Committee http://judiciary.senate.gov/
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      21 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has a comprehensive page on #sotomayor and
                                                        #privacy http://www.epic.org/privacy/sotomayor/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  21 Jul 09
                                                        Reporting this morning on the #sotomayor committee vote for
                                                        #scotus. #privacy implications.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 17 Jul 09
                                                        The Economist-"Speedy they may be, but chipped ID cards
                                                        are horrendously insecure." EPIC-"Shut down the 'Enhanced ID'
                                                        programs." #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy wraps up with #sotomayor. I'll stick with 15-4.
                                                        #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      16 Jul 09
                                                        (Just voted for the Turkey sandwich in Dirksen during the
                                                        lunch break at @scotusblog ;-> ) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      16 Jul 09
                                                        (Quick q to Sen. Coburn - what about earlier arg that fed ct
                                                        should enforce fund rights (i.e. Heller gun case) against the states? ;-
                                                        >)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Coburn asking #sotomayor about states' rights. Ref to
                                                        Madison, Federalist Papers.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomoyar just mentioned #wikipedia as source of ideas for
                                                        the law. Subtle point - distinguish influences and precedents
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Cornyn still with Heller . . . .#sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Graham is now pleading his military tribunal case before
                                                        #sotomayor. ;-> Will there be a ruling?
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Graham asks #sotomayor about military commission
                                                        cases
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kyl back up. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Grassley just said "Justice" #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch asking #sotomayor q from constituent about
                                                        originalism . . .
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch asking #sotomayor q's on behalf of constituents.
                                                        That's kind of cool. Not sure this has happened before.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch asking #sotomayor about args in PRLDEF.
                                                        Interesting because Sen. Hatch voted for Ginsburg, J., though she
                                                        was lawyer at ACLU.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch now up for round 3. (D's and R's working
                                                        together. Process is important even when disagreement about
                                                        outcomes.) #sotomayor.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Sessions - floor vote before August, no filibuster
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy - Repubs asked for a third round - 10 mins each.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        (Sen. Leahy had good time with Sens. Sessions and Coburn
                                                        on gun laws. Wouldn't want to be a deer in VT ;->) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor defending judicial independence with Sen.
                                                        Coburn.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy says Committee vote on #sotomayor may be next
                                                        Tuesday. My prediction - 15-4.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Coburn asking #sotomayor about Congressional intent.
                                                        "How to do a better job?"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Coburn is now up for round 2. Discussing foreign law.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     16 Jul 09
                                                        (That would satisfy Sen. Specter) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     16 Jul 09
                                                        (#sotomayor really could say more. How 'bout - "#scotus
                                                        should look closely at cases that speak to the fund. structure of the
                                                        #Const." ?)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter - "Isn't that [checks and balances] a category of
                                                        the highest magnitude." #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter asking #sotomayor about separation of powers.
                                                        Key to #privacy. Also #FISA
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter still concerned about #scotus need to address
                                                        conflicts between Cong and Pres #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter now asking #sotomayor about televising
                                                        #scotus
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter is up for round 2 then a short break.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Cornyn asks #sotomayor "Is there a difference between
                                                        making the law and interpreting the law?"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Cornyn is now up for round 2. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Klobuchair is now up for round 2. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Graham making good arg, but should concede that he
                                                        basically wants #sotomayor to agree with him about what #scotus
                                                        should do
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 16 Jul 09
                                                        (Sen. Graham asking #sotomayor how she will decide. It's a
                                                        good question. She's not really answering.)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Graham pressing #sotomayor on big issue - ability of
                                                        #scotus to enforce "fundamental rights" (e.g. gun ownership) against



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter

                                                        states.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen/. Graham is now up in round 2. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feinstein asks #sotomayor "What is 'per curiam'?"
                                                        (Relevant to Ricci. But note Bush v. Gore was per curiam) One def.
                                                        here http:/ ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feinstein is now up in round 2 for 20 mins. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kyl is back to Ricci (firefighters case) with #sotomayor.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kyl is recognized for "up to" 20 minutes. (Sen. Leahy is
                                                        trying to move things along). #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                             16 Jul 09
                                                        EPIC has posted a comprehensive page on #sotomayor and
                                                        #privacy http://epic.org/privacy/sotomayor/
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor hearing resumes today with Sen. Kyl and 2d
                                                        round of q's. 9 remaining Sens. 20 min each. Could wrap up by noon.
                                                        Then witnesses.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   16 Jul 09
                                                        CDN report finds #privacy problems with Facebook, violations
                                                        of Canadian law. http://bit.ly/iE2Ye
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    16 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor recap - #privacy is fund. right; ok on 4th amd.;
                                                        gets anon.; gets SSN risk; likes Internet; defers to Congress
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                16 Jul 09
                                                        RT @schneierblog: Privacy Salience and Social Networking
                                                        Sites: Reassuring ppl about privacy makes them more concerned
                                                        http://tr.im/sBEZ
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  16 Jul 09
                                                        Answer to #sotomayor trivia question - "The Case of the
                                                        Deadly Verdit" is the one murder case that Perry Mason loses.
                                                        (Rated 9.7 on IMD ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                16 Jul 09
                                                        Starting early this morning. Report from Canadian privacy
                                                        c'mish on Facebook and #privacy expected at 9 am. #sotomayor
                                                        hearing begins 9:30.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Break now tll 9:30 am Thurs #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Another question that #sotomayer can't answer. Might be
                                                        good if a Sen. asked her about doctrinal issues, and not just Heller
                                                        and incorp.
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Cardin now up (round 2) #sotomayer
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        (Observation - remarkably little discussion of her opinions.
                                                        Seems like that would be a top priority for a judicial nomination.)
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Grassley is following Feingold strategy, asking
                                                        #sotomayor about current law, not her views.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Grassley (round 2) now up (and the Senators wanting
                                                        to go home) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor "this is a special circumstance, given the
                                                        pendency of that case."
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feingold found a clever way to ask a question about a
                                                        pending case. He asked #sotomayor about current state of law, not
                                                        her views.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Feingold (round 2) now up. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter


                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor discussing #privacy. Again with the liberty clause
                                                        ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Hatch up (round 2) then a break #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor - difficult to answer in the abstract when to
                                                        decide to review cases
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kohl asking about how #scotus picks cases
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        (Interesting culture clash - D and R Sens are both asking
                                                        #sotomayor to agree with them on policy goals. Not her role, she
                                                        keeps saying)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kohl asks #sotomayor about major antitrust case
                                                        twombly
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Kohl (round 2) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Sessions (round 2) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy asking about right to counsel. (Big fan of
                                                        Gideon's Trumpet book by Tony Lewis) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   15 Jul 09
                                                        Wow. #sotomayor. Sen. Leahy making a powerful point about
                                                        composition of Court, following Redding case. Here is Lithwick
                                                        column http://b ...
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy discussing oral arg in Redding strip search case.
                                                        (I was there. It was a disaster. See Dahlia Lithwick column)
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy now discussing strip search case. (#sotomayor
                                                        was ahead of #scotus on this) #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Now Sen. Sessions will introduce letters for the record.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy adding letters to the record (lawprof letter up to
                                                        1,200). #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                      15 Jul 09
                                                        Technical problems in hearing room #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Now on to second round of questions. Likely to be more
                                                        detailed. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  15 Jul 09
                                                        According to answers.com "Only on three occasions did Perry
                                                        lose a case on TV, and only one of those was a murder case--"
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Leahy - schedule - closed session now. Hearing
                                                        resumes later this afternoon. #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        Ok. Trivia question of the #sotomayor hearings: in which case
                                                        was Perry Mason's client found guilty?
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        (would be nice if there was more discussion about info
                                                        #privacy. This is the 21st c. after all.) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        (#sotomayor keeps returning to the liberty provision in the
                                                        due process clause, but that's actually pretty narrow in terms of
                                                        #privacy.)
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Franken "Does the const. contain a fund right to
                                                        #privacy?" #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter



                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomator #internet implicates many interests "freedom of
                                                        speech, freedom with respect to property rights, gov't reg"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                  15 Jul 09
                                                        (Sen. Franken, these are good questions for an FCC hearing.
                                                        ;->) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor "as a citizen, Internet has revolutionized comm in
                                                        US . . . but role of Court is not to make policy"
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor analogies - telephone, tv -- regulation (= "policy
                                                        chooser") is up to Congress.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       15 Jul 09
                                                        (Sen. Franken, trying to ask a question about net neutrality . .
                                                        . ) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                   15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Franken discussing #internet and access to infornation.
                                                        #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Franken knows his Perry Mason. ;-> #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                       15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Franken now up. #sotomayor


https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter on to tv in the courts. (Plug for oyez site
                                                        http://www.oyez.org/. Nice to at least hear audio!) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter - wow. Anything Congress can do if nominee
                                                        says one thing and then Justice then does another? #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        Sen. Specter asking about deference to Congress (and
                                                        expressing frustration about Roberts, CJ) #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor is talking in generalities, doesn't want to address
                                                        facts of wiretap case. #privacy Sen. Specter told her question was
                                                        coming.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                 15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor cautious. Sen. Specter presses on. This is good
                                                        stuff. This is about the role of the #scotus.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                    15 Jul 09
                                                        (Sen. Specter looking for a way to get #sotomayor to say that
                                                        #scotus should have taken case.) #privacy
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                     15 Jul 09
                                                        (Sen. Specter wants to know why S Ct didn't review



https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]
Marc Rotenberg (privacy140) on Twitter




                                                        warrantless wiretapping case.) #privacy #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                                15 Jul 09
                                                        VERY IMPORTANT Sen. Specter now on to warrantless
                                                        wiretapping program (not TSP) #privacy #sotomayor Huge issue of
                                                        Pres. powers.
                                                        Expand




                                                        Marc Rotenberg @privacy140                               15 Jul 09
                                                        #sotomayor "Ct needs to think about processes" Sen.
                                                        Specter :How about taking more cases?" Then moves on #sotomayor
                                                        Expand




https://twitter.com/privacy140[10/17/2013 9:07:17 AM]

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:3
posted:10/20/2013
language:English
pages:93