Appeal by mcherald

VIEWS: 0 PAGES: 13

									   BRADLEY W. HERTZ, State Bar No. 138564
   JAMES R. SUTTON, State Bar No. 135930
 2 ERIKA M. BOYD, State Bar No. 259633
   The Sutton Law Firm, PC
 3 150 Post Street, Suite 405
   San Francisco, California 94108
 4 Tel: 415/732-7700
   Fax: 415/732-7701
 5 bheltz@campaignlawycrs.com

 6   Attorneys for Petitioner and
     Appellant JAMES BOGAN
 7

 8                 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
 9                              FOR THE COUNTY OF MONTEREY
10                                  UNLIMITED JURISDICTION
11

                                                     ~
     JAMES BOGAN,                                          Case No. M122980
12

                                                     ~)
                  Petitioner,                              NOTICE OF APPEAL; ELECTION
13                                                         TO PROCEED UNDER CRC 8.124;
                  v.                                       DESIGNATION OF REPORTER'S
14                                           )             TRANSCRIPT
   MICHAEL A. HOULEMARD, JR.,                 )
15 in his capacity as Executive Director and)              Judge:             Kay T. Kingsley
   District Elections Official of the Ford   )             Dept:              14
16 Ord Reuse Authority; LINDA TULETT, )
   in her capacity as Registrar of Voters of )
17 the County of Monterey; and DOES          )
   1 to 10, Inclusive,                       )
18                                           )
                  Respondents.               )


                                                     l
19

20 JASON CAMPBELL; CHRIS MACK;
   LUANA CONLEY; and MICHAEL
21 SALERNO, in their capacities as
   Proponents of the Protect Ford Ord
22 Open Space Access Initiative,
                                                    !
                                                    )
                                                    )
23                Real Parties in Interest.          )

24
     -------------~)

25

26
27

28
                                             NOTICE OF APPEAL




                                                                                                                               - 6
                         '---"--~--'-"-"'--~-------"'-----""'-""'--'-------'''-   --"'--   --_   _-_   -. __   _
                                                                                                               .._---_ ..--_         _---
                                                                                                                               -r-'-..
                                 TO THE CLERK OF THE SUPERIOR COURT AND TO RESPONDENTS
                    2 MICHAEL A. HOULEMARD, JR. AND LINDA TULETT; TO REAL PARTIES
                    3 IN INTEREST JASON CAMPBELL, CHRIS MACK, LUANA CONLEY, AND
                    4 MICHAEL SALERNO; AND TO THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
                    5

                    6                                             NOTICE OF APPEAL
                    7            Pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure section 904.1 (a)(1), Petitioner and

                    8 Appellant JAMES BOGAN ("Appella.l1t") hereby appeals from the Judgment entered in
                    9   this action on July 3,2013, a true copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A as part

                   10 of the Notice of Entry of Judgment, which was served on Appellant on July 10,2013.

                   1\   (It should be noted that the July 3, 2013 Proof of Service that is part of the Notice of
                   12 Entry of Judgment pertains to the [Proposed] Judgment and not the entered Judgment,

                   13 which is the subject of a separate July 10, 2013 Proof of Service that is also a part of the

                   14 Notice of Entry of Judgment attached hereto as Exhibit A.)

                   15

                   16                  NOTICE OF ELECTION TO PROCEED UNDER CRC 8.124
                   17            Appellant elects to proceed under California Rules of Court, Rule 8.124, and will

                   18    file a party-prepared appendix instead of a clerk's transcript.

                   19

                   20                          DESIGNATION OF REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT
                   21            Appellant elects to proceed under California Rules of Court, Rules 8.12 I and

                   22    8.130, with a reporter's transcript of all proceedings in this matter in Department 14,
                  23    Superior Court of the State of California for the County of Monterey, as follows:

                   24   Date                       FulllPartial Day           Description               Reporter's Name

                  25    May 1,2013                 Partial                   Ex Parte Hearing           Pamela C. Ferry
                                                                                                        CSR No. 13221
                  26
                        June 21,2013               Partial                    Writ of Mandate           Helyn A. Johnson
                  27                                                          Hearing                   CSR No. 10770

                  28
                                                                       NOTICE OF APPEAL
                                                                                 1




- - - . - - - - - - ------.------------------...------.------.------ ..-------.-------_.-------------------------------- ------- _·__·-------------T-----
           Pursuant to California Rules of Court, Rule 8.130(b)(1 )(B), Appellant has
 2   deposited with the Clerk of the Superior Court the approximate cost of transcribing the
 3   designated proceedings in the sum 0[$650, calculated as two partial days (May 1,2013
 4   and June 21,2013.

 5

 6   Dated: September 5, 2013          By:(l,               /. _   ~_/'} _
                                                                       _

 7                                         Ja res R. Sutton
                                           The Sutton Law Firm, PC
 8                                         Attorneys for Petitioner
                                           and Appellant JAMES BOGAN
 9
10
11

12
13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20
21

22

23

24

25

26
27
28
                                         NOTICE OF APPEAL
                                                 2
 2



 4

 5
 6

 7
 8

 9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18
19

20
21

22
23

24

25

26
     EXHIBIT A
27
28
       NOTICE OF APPEAL
              3
  Fredric D. Woocher (SBN 96689)
  Beverly G.rossman Palmer (SBN 234004)
2 Rachef A. Deutsch (SBN 275826)
  STRUM\VASSER& WOOCHERLLp·
3 10940 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 2000
  Los Angeles, California 90024
4 Telephone: (310) 576-1233 .
      Facsimile:      (310) 319-0156.
 5 . fwOOChelr strumwooch.com .
      bpalmer        strumwooch.com
 6    rdeutsch strumwooch.com
 7    Attorneys for Real Party in Interest Jason Campbell
 8
 9·                    SUPERIOR COURT OPTHE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10                               FOR THE COUNTY OF MONTEREY
II
12    .
          JAMES BOGAN .    .                      Petitioner,
                                                                  No~   GNM122980

13
                Vo                                                NOTICE OF ENTRY OF
14                                                                JUDGMENT
15        :MICHAEL A. HOULEMARD JR· -in his
            .                     . )        ,
          capacity as Executive Director.and District
16        Elections Official of the Fort Ord Reuse
17        Authority; LINDA TULEIT; in her capacity as
          Registrar of Voters of the County of Monterey;
18        and DOES 1-10, Inclusive,
19
                                               Respondents,
20
21
          JASON CAMPBELL; CHRIS MACK; LUANA
22
          CONLEY; and MICHAEL SALERNO, their         in
23        capacities as Proponents of the Protect Fort Ord
          Open Space Access Initiative,
24

25                                  Real Parties in Interest.
26
27
28



                                           PRINTED ONRECYCLED PAPER

                                          NOTICE OFENTRYOF JUDGMENT
      TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
 2          PLEASETAKB NOTICE that on July 3, 2013, the Honorable Kay T. Kingsley,
 3 Courtroom 14 of the Monterey County Superior Court, entered j udgment inthe above-entitled
 4    case.. A copy of the Judgment is attached hereto.
 5
 6    Dated: July 10, 2013                              Respectfully submitted,

 7                                                      STRUMWASSER & \VOOCHER LLP
                                                        Fredric D. Woocher
 8
 9

10
                                                        :cg0L
                                                        Beverlv Grossman Palmer


                                                                every Grossman Palmer
11                                                        Attorneys for Real Party in Interest
12·

13
14

15
16

17
18

19

20
21
22
23
24

25

26
27

28

                                                    1
                                        NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
                                                                        JUL 03 2013
                                                             . CONNIE   ww.la   .
                                                              CLEIf f:3fdft0~lg~pWRT




           . SUPERIOR COURT OF 'mE STATEOF CALIFORNIA
                      FOR THE COUNTY OF MONTEREY

                                                         No. GNlv1l22980
JAMES BOGAN,
                                       Petitioner,
      v.                                                 [PROPOS~JUDGMENT


MI~"HAEL A. HOULEMARD,          JR., in his
capacity as Executive Director and District
Elections Official ofthe Fort Ord Reuse
Authority; LINDA TULETI, in her capacity as
RegisftarofVoters ofthe COlIDty ofMonterey;
and DOES 1-10, Inclusive,

                                    Respondents,


JASON CAMPBELL;CHRISMACK; LUANA
CONLEY; and MICHAEL SALERNO, in their
capacities as Proponents ofthe"ProtectFort Ord
Open Space Access Initiative,

                         .Real Parties in Interest.




                                PRINTeD ONRECYCLED PAPBll.

                                   [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT
 1                On June 21, 2013, Petitioner James Bogan's ("Petitioner's") Motion for Issuance of

 2 Peremptory Writ of Mandate came on for hearing beforethe Honorable Kay T. Kingsley, in
 3     Department 14 ofthe Monterey County SuperiorCourt. Bradley W. Hertz and James R. Sutton
 ;} appeared Oil behalf of Petitioner, Beverly Grossman Palmer appeared on behalfof Real Party in
 5 InterestJason Campbell, Kathryn Reimann appeared on behalf of Respondent Monterey County .
 6 Registrar of Voters Linda Tulett, and Cassie r\1. Bronson appeared en behalf of Respondent Michael
 7     A. Houlemard, Jr., in his capacity as Executive Director and District Elections Official of the Fort
 8 Ord Reuse Authority.
 9       -PUrsuant to the Court's review ofthe pleadings, motion papers, declarations, arid exhibits filed
10     in support of and in opposition to the Motion, and after hearing the arguments of the parties, the
11     Court denied the Petition for Writ of Mandate, for the reasons articulated by   the Courtat the hearing
12 and set forth in the      Order Denying Petitionfor Writ of Martdate.
13          Accordingly, ITIS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGEb, AND DECREED that:
14 .        (1)     The Petition for PeremptoryWrit ofMandateisDENIED.
·15         (2)     Real Party in Interest Campbell   is awardedcosts in the amount of $.               .
1_6
17
18 Dated:          . JUtlJ 3 2013    ,2013                    KAy 1-. KINGSLE1(
                                                            Honorable Kay T. Kingsley
19
20 .Submitted by:
21     SrRUMWASSER & WOOCHER LLP
22

23     By    :i~U~
24           Fredric D. Woocher

25 Attorneysfor Real Party in Interest
26 Jason Campbell

27

28



                                                 [PROI'OSFD) JUDGMENT
..   '




                                                PROOF OF SERVICE

           STATE OF CALIFORNIA
           COUNTY OF MONTEREY

                  ,Re:     James Bogan 'Y. Michael A. Houlemard, Jr., et at,
                           Case No. GNM 122980

                  I am employed in the'Countyof L,08 Angeles, State of California, I am overthe ageof 18
           and not a party to the within action.. My business address is 10940 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite
           2000, Los Angeles, California 90024.

                   On July 3,'2013, I served. the docurrient(s) described as [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT on
          .all appropriate parties in this action, as listed below, bythe method stated.

                   o      If-electronic-mail service is indicated, by causing a true copy to be sent via
           electronic transmission from Strumwasser & Woocher LLP's computer network in Portable
           DocumentFormat (pDF) this dateto the e- mail address(es) stated,to the attentionof theperson(s)
           named.           .

                    I8l   . 1fU.S. Mail service is indicated, byplacingthisdate for collectionformailing true
            copies in sealed envelopes, first-class postage prepaid, addressedto each person as indicated, .
         . pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 1013a(3). I am readily familiar with the firm's
          . practice of collection and processing correspondence for mailing. Under that practice.it would
            be depositedwith theLl.S, Postal Service on that sameday with postage thereon fully prepaidat
            Los Angeles)California,in the ordinarycourseofbusinesa 1amaware that on motionof the party
            served, service is presumed invalid if postal cancellation date or postage meter date is more than
            one day after date of deposit for mailing contained in the affidavit.

                   o      Ifovernight service is indicated, byplacingthis date for collectionby sendingtrue.
           copies in sealed envelopes, addressed to each person as indicated, pursuant to Code of Civil
           Procedure, section l013(d). I am readily familiar with this firm's practice of collecting and
         . processingcorrespondence. Under that practice.it would be depositedwith an overnightservice
           in Los Angeles Countyon that same daywith an active accountnumber shownforpayment,in the
           ordinary course of business.

                   I declare.under penalty ofperjury underthelaws of the State of Californiathat the above
          is true and correct Executed on July 3~ 2Q13, atLos Angeles,california.
                                     Service List
                      JamesBogan v. Michael A. Hculemard; Jr., et 01.
                               CaseNo. GNM 122980


 Bradley W. Hertz                                KathrynReimann
 James R. Sutton                                 DeputyCountyCounsel
 Erika E: Boyd -                                 County of Monterey
 THE SUTTON LAW FIRM, PC                         168 West Alisal Street, 31d Floor
 150 Post Street, Suite 405                      Salinas, California 93901
 San Francisco, California 94107                 Tel: (831)755-5045
                                                 Fax: (831) 755·5283
 Tel: (415) 732-7700
 Fax: (415) 732-7701                             Email: reimannk@co.montercy-.ca.us     .
                                                                                        -

 Email: bhertz@campaignlawyers.com
                                                 Attorneyfor Respondent LindaTulett -
 Attorneysfor James Bogan

  Jonathan Ross Giffen-
  KENNEDY ARCHER & HARRAY
_2459i Silver Cloud Ct., Suite 200
  Monterey, Califomia93940
- Tel: (831) 373·1500 -    -
  Fax,: (8.31) 313-7555- -
  Email: jgiffen@kaglaw.tiet

 Attorneyfor Respondent Michael A.
 Houlemard, Jr.




                     -----------------------------_.    -
                                      PROOF OF SERVICE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF MONTEREY

         Re:    James Bogan v. Michael A. Houlenwrd, Jr .. et al,
                Case No. GNM 122980

       I am employed in the County of Los Angeles, State of California. I am over the age of 18
and not a party to the within action. My business address is 10940 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite
2000, Los Angeles, California 90024.

    On July 10, 2013, I. served the documentts) described as NOTICE OF ENTRY OF
JUDGMENT on all appropriate parties in this action. as listed below, by the method stated.

       o       If electronic-mail service is indicated, by causing a true copy to be sent via
electronic transmission from Strumwasser & Woocher LLP's com.puter network in Portable
Document F ormat (PDF}this date to the e-mail addressfes) stated, to the attention ofthe person(s)
named.

         ~      lfU.S. Mail service is indicated, by placing this datefor collectionfor mailing true
copies in sealed envelopes, first-class postage prepaid, addressed to each person as indicated,
pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 1013a(3). I ani readily familiar with the firm' s
practice of collection and processing correspondence for mailing. Under that practice, it would
be deposited with the U.S. Postal Service on that same day with postage thereon fully prepaid at
Los Angeles, California, in the ordinary course ofbusiness. I am aware that on motion ofthe party
served, service is presumedinvalidifpostalcallcellation date or postage meter date is more than
one day after date of deposit for mailing contained in the affidavit.

        o      Ifovernight service is indicated, by placing this date for collection by sending true
copies in sealed envelopes, addressed to each person as indicated, pursuant to Code of Civil
Procedure, section l013(d). I am readily familiar with this firm's practice of collecting and
processing correspondence. Under thatpractice, itwould be deposited with an overnight service
in Los Angeles County on that same day with an active account number shown for payment, in the
ordinary course of business;

         I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws ofthe State of California that the above



                                           -: 4.-Y-b-a
is true and correct. Executed on July 10,2013, at.Los Angeles, California.



                                                              LaKeitha Oliver
                                     Service List
                     James Bogan v. Michael A. Houlemard, Jr., et 01.
                               Case No. GNM 122 980


Bradley W. :Herlz-                              Kathryn Reimann
James R. Sutton                                 Deputy County Counsel
Erika E. Boyd                                   County of Monterey
THE SUTTON LAWFIRM,-PC                          168 West AlisalStreet, 3rd Floor
150 Post .Street, Suite 4Q5 -                   Salinas, California 93901 _
SanFrancisco, California 94107                  Tel: (831) 755-5045
Tel: (415) 732-779° -                           Fax: (831) 755-5283 -
Fax: (415) 732-7701                             Email: reimannk@co.monterey.ca.us
Email: bhertz@campaignlawyers~com
                                                Attorneyfor Respondent Linda Tulett
Attorneys for James Bogan-

Jonathan RossGiffen -
KENNEDY ARCHER &HARRAY
245~1 Silver: Cloud Ct., Suite 200
Monterey,- California 93940
Tet: (831}373-7500
Fax: (831) 373~7555: _
Email: jgiffen@kaglaw.net

Attorneyfor Respondent Michael A.
Houlemard, Jr.
                                              PROOF OF SERVICE

 2            1.   I am employed in the City and County of San Francisco, State of California. 1 am over the
     age of eighteen years and not a party to the within action. My business address is 150 Post Street, Suite
 3
     405, San Francisco, CA 94108.
 4
              2.     On September 5, 2013, I served the foregoing document described as "Notice of Appeal;
 5   Election to Proceed Under CRC 8.124; Designation of Reporter's Transcript" on the following parties to
     this action, as follows:
 6
      Jonathon Ross Giffen, Esq.                              Attorneys for Respondent MICHAEL A.
 7
      Kennedy Archer & Giffen                                 HOULEMARD, JR., in his capacity as Executive
 8    24591 Silver Cloud Ct., #200                            Director and District Elections Official of the
      Monterey, CA 93940                                      Ford Ord Reuse Authority
 9    jgiffen@kaglaw.net

10    Kathryn Reimann, Esq.                                   Attorneys for Respondent LINDA TULETT,in
      Deputy County Counsel, County of Monterey               her capacity as Registrar ofYoters of the County
11    168 West Alisal St., 3d FIr                             of Monterey
      Salinas, CA 93901
12    reimannk@co.monterey.ca.us
13                                                            Attorneys for Real Parties in Interest
      Beverly Grossman Palmer, Esq.
14    Strumwasser & Woocher, LLP                              JASON CAMPBELL; CHRIS MACK;
      10940 Wilshire Blvd., Ste. 2000                         LUANA CONLEY; and MICHAEL SALERNO,
15    Los Angeles, CA 90024                                   in their capacities as Proponents of the Protect
      bpalmcri«stn i)l1\\i.!~1C h,'<:.iil\l                   Ford Ord Open Space Access Initiative
16
                                                              Certified Shorthand Reporter
17    Pamela C. Ferry, C.S.R.                                 for May 1,2013 Proceedings
      P.O. Box 2055
18    Monterey, CA 93942                                      Certified Shorthand Reporter
                                                              for June 21, 2013 Proceedings
19    Helyn A. Johnson, C.S.R. No.1 0770
      240 Church Street
20
      Salinas, CA 9390]
21
     _X_ (VIA OVERNIGHT MAIL) By enclosing the document(s) in an envelope or package provided
22 by an overnight delivery carrier and addressed to the persons at the addresses listed above. r placed the
     envelope or package for collection and overnight delivery at an office or a regularly utilized drop box of
23   the overnight delivery carrier.
24           Executed on September 5, 2013, at San Francisco, California.
25
     (State) I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Califomia that the above is true
26   and correct.

27
                                                                 Linda Chan
28
                                                NOTICE OF APPEAL
                                                         11




                                                                                   _ ... ..
                                                                                       ~   -.---.---~-~---   .----.--.-·-.~·_·-------T----·-----··-----·

								
To top