; lawsuit
Learning Center
Plans & pricing Sign in
Sign Out




More Info
  • pg 1
									                     Lawsuits for Crew Members of Costa Concordia Begin
Following the terrifying capsizing of the cruise ship, Costa Concordia, off the coast of
Italy on January 13, the crew members have started filing U.S. lawsuits to seek class-
action status. Gary Lobaton, a crew member of the ship, argues that he was not aware
of the dangerous conditions the cruise ship was in until it was too late to abandon the
ship. Lobaton is suing individually, but is also asking the court to grant class-action
status to the lawsuit for him and his similarly affected fellow crew members. Lobaton
further argues that Captain Francesco Schettino delayed the order to abandon ship and
deploy lifeboats, which resulted in many lives lost.
While jurisdiction to hear the case has not yet been decided, crew members may have
to file in Italy, rather than the U.S.; jurisdiction may be dependent on their employment
contracts. Further, liability of Costa/Carnival, the operator/owner of the vessel, may be
affected by individual crew members citizenship. Costa/Carnival may be able to take
advantage of international treaties, and the laws of either the U.S. or Italy; whichever
provides greatest limitations and immunities. Whether in Italy or the U.S., the sinking of
Costa Concordia will bring many more lawsuits, but the amount recoverable is still
undetermined. Again, courts will be looking to employment contracts to determine if
there is a cap on the amount the crew members can recover.

To top