技嘉 P35T-DQ6 vs 華碩 P5K3 Deluxe 溫度測試報告 by yurtgc548

VIEWS: 1 PAGES: 6

									   GIGABYTE P35-DQ6
   vs ASUS P5K Deluxe
130W QX6850 / 65W E6850
    Temperature Test
   GIGABYTE P35-DQ6 v.s. ASUS P5K Deluxe
VRM Zone Average Temperature Comparison with QX6850
Use 130W QX6850 CPU, run P4 MaxPower & 3DMark 2006, use water
cooling to avoid air flow for accurate & fair measurement

                              22.1 deg C Gap!(P4 Max Power
            WIN!   Cool !!!
                   Cool !!!   34.5 deg C Gap!(3DMark 2006)
                               WIN!    Cool !!!
                                       Cool !!!

                                 Loser     HOT !!!
                                           HOT !!!
                                 !
                                              Loser
                                                    HOT !!!
                                                    HOT !!!
                                              !
   GIGABYTE P35-DQ6 v.s. ASUS P5K Deluxe
VRM Zone Average Temperature Comparison with E6850
Use 65W E6850 CPU, run P4 MaxPower & 3DMark 2006, use water
cooling to avoid air flow for accurate & fair measurement

                               27 deg C Gap!(P4 Max Power)
                   Cool !!!
           WIN!    Cool !!!    32.8 deg C Gap!(3DMark 2006)
                    WIN!      Cool !!!
                              Cool !!!

                                           Loser    HOT !!!
                                                    HOT !!!
                                           !
                                              Loser
                                              !      HOT !!!
                                                     HOT !!!
 Run P4 MAX POWER for 20mins then record temperature,
  use QX6850 & E6850 CPU, and water cooling to avoid air
flow for accurate & fair measurement (room temp 25 deg C)
      QX6850 – 130W                              E6850 – 65W
                         ASUS                                     ASUS
 Location     GIGABYTE                    Location     GIGABYTE
                          P5K     Gap                              P5K     Gap
  (deg C)     P35-DQ6                      (deg C)     P35-DQ6
                         Deluxe                                   Deluxe
MOSFET 1        79.4     96.8     17.4   MOSFET 1        55.9      76      20.1
MOSFET 2        76.3     92.9     16.6   MOSFET 2        57.6     85.7     28.1
 Choke 1        90.6     116.3    25.7    Choke 1        61.7     94.9     33.2
 Choke 2        84.6     118.2    33.6    Choke 2        59.8     95.2     35.4
Capacitor 1     82       102.8    20.8   Capacitor 1     56.6     82.2     25.6
Capacitor 2     76.6     95.1     18.5   Capacitor 2     54.2     73.5     19.3
 Average                                  Average
  Temp
                81.6     103.7    22.1     Temp
                                                         57.6     84.6     27
           Cool!
           Cool!    Hot!
                    Hot!                   Cool!
                                            Cool!    Hot!
                                                     Hot!
 CPU VRM Zone Average Temperature Gap 22.1 deg C (QX6850) &
 27 deg C (E6850)!!
 Run 3DMark2006 for 20mins then record temperature, use
QX6850 & E6850 CPU, and water cooling to avoid air flow for
   accurate & fair measurement (room temp 25 deg C)
      QX6850 – 130W                              E6850 – 65W
                         ASUS                                     ASUS
 Location     GIGABYTE                    Location     GIGABYTE
                          P5K     Gap                              P5K     Gap
  (deg C)     P35-DQ6                      (deg C)     P35-DQ6
                         Deluxe                                   Deluxe
MOSFET 1        52.5     83.5     31     MOSFET 1        48.5      74      25.5
MOSFET 2        49.2     77.2     28     MOSFET 2        45.4     80.8     35.4
 Choke 1        56       99.4     43.4    Choke 1        50.9     91.7     40.8
 Choke 2        54.9     98.2     43.3    Choke 2        50.3      91      40.7
Capacitor 1     51       86.6     35.6   Capacitor 1     46.6      78      31.4
Capacitor 2     50.2     76.1     25.9   Capacitor 2     45.5     68.7     23.3
 Average                                  Average
  Temp
                52.3     86.8     34.5     Temp
                                                         47.9     80.7     32.8
           Cool!
           Cool!      Hot!
                      Hot!                 Cool!
                                            Cool!    Hot!
                                                     Hot!
 CPU VRM Zone Average Temperature Gap 34.5 deg C (QX6850) &
 32.8 deg C (E6850)!!
                    Conclusion
Use QX6850 & E6850 CPU; GIGABYTE P35-DQ6
 Temperature is still much cooler than P5K
 Deluxe !!!
P35-DQ6 is cooler due to:
  p Ultra Durable 2
     p Low R(ds)on MOSFET
     p Ferrite core choke
     p All solid SMD capacitor
  p Virtual 12 phase power design – DQ6 series
Lower component temperature means longer life
  time and more overclocking margin !
Example: Solid capacitor temperature gap up to 30 deg C,
  GIGABYTE solid capacitor life time is 27 times longer
  than ASUS !!! (solid capacitor life time triples in every 10 deg
  gap)

								
To top