Learning Center
Plans & pricing Sign in
Sign Out

Application Development and Lifecycle ManagementThe Impact of


More information from

Application Development and Lifecycle Management: The Impact of
Agile Practices on People, Processes, and Tools

Description:    CATALYST
                Application development continues to evolve with processes and methodologies receiving significant
                attention through Agile practices, while on the tooling side a new generation of Application Lifecycle
                Management (ALM) products are appearing with process and workflow support figuring largely.

                Software application development is one of those subjects that never disappears but is always
                evolving. Since the last general survey Report published on this subject – Application Lifecycle
                Management (ALM), published in September 2005 – there has been a lot of activity in the ALM
                field. With our colleagues, we published an ALM Decision Matrix in 2007 that looked at the vendor
                ALM suite market, and we now repeat that exercise in this Report with all the leading vendors
                participating. (The Decision Matrix also replaces what used to be the Market Lifecycle Ratings in
                Technology Evaluation and Comparison Reports).

                The areas that are currently receiving the greatest activity in application development are:
                - Agile development and Agile project management.
                - ALM.
                - Testing and test management.
                - Enterprise Web 2.0.

                The application development subjects that are on the horizon, and which predicts will take centre
                ground, are:
                - Development in the Cloud.
                - Parallel programming (especially General Purpose computing on Graphics Processing Units – or
                - Extension of ALM to overlap IT governance.
                - RESTful Service Oriented Architecture. (REST is Representational State Transfer).

                While what and how applications are being developed evolves, developers are still needed to
                programme the machines and create these applications. It had been considered that advanced
                modelling such as Model Driven Development (MDD) in the guise of software factories would at
                some point deliver on the next leap forward, a technological breakthrough such as a higher
                abstraction compiler that takes models rather than a high-level programming language to churn out
                the machine code. The Object Management Group’s Model Driven Architecture (MDA) appeared to
                be moving in that direction. This did not transpire, and is not likely to in the immediate future.
                These themes are expanded upon below.

                Business Issues

                Ultimately, software applications are built to satisfy the needs of the business, and the subject of
                the clash of two different cultures – the IT department and the rest of the business – has been
                discussed often, possibly to exhaustion. Some intractable problems become ‘solved’ through
                irrelevance because the ground has moved, and it can be said that whereas in the early days of
                computing the computer department in a business was a quite distinct function, a place where data
                was sent to be processed and returned with some useful statistics or reports, today there are
                businesses whose sole basis for existence relies on the IT function. Examples vary from obvious
                ones such as online banks and Web 2.0 companies, to less obvious virtual companies that operate
                solely due to the existence of the Internet and products with embedded software where the
                software component has grown exponentially. The net result of this shift towards greater reliance
                on IT is that the business has to take a greater interest in its IT function to succeed in the market,
                especially if the IT people are not delivering.

                Having talked about the software crisis: the bad track record of large software projects that
overrun budget, deliver late (often by 100%), have quality problems, and so forth. A real-world
example illustrates how businesses are tackling this problem (names are omitted for confidentiality
reasons): an IT company arose from being a small operation to having a billion dollar turnover in a
short period. This company used to release its key platform application on an annual basis, but as a
result of this rapid growth its current releases were taking 18 months and longer. The CEO gave
the Chief Technology Officer (CTO) the highest priority directive to solve the problem. The CTO
decided that all the company’s developers would switch to Scrum, the most popular Agile
methodology, in big-bang fashion. The switchover was a success and delivery was back to a 12-
month cycle. BT is another example where in this instance the CEO directed the company to adopt
Agile, and an incremental adoption plan is in progress. Finding that Agile methodology adoption is a
competitive differentiator for companies, and that this works best when there is a champion at the
highest level. Alternately, the concept of reducing waste is a message that many businesses
understand and this is central to Lean Development, which takes many ideas from the lean
movement and Total Quality Management, and combines them into an Agile methodology. Lean
Development is found to be more comprehensible to businesses than some of the more developer-
oriented Agile practices.

Businesses also want greater real-time insight into software project progress, and the new
generation of BI solutions integrated into ALM suites provide this capability. Rather than reacting
post-event, senior managers can act to avert problems escalating into software crisis dimensions.
In particular, visibility into quality control and test performance of the work in progress is
necessary. When schedules become pressured, testing is the area that is traditionally cut by Project
Managers. Therefore senior business managers must keep track of testing and quality – getting this
wrong incurs long-term damage to the organisation in the marketplace. Agile methodologies are
liked by business executives because they make testing an integral part of the development
lifecycle, not the last activity before shipping.

Enterprise Web 2.0 represents a puzzle to many company executives: they see staggeringly
successful businesses emerge, based on the Internet and the set of concepts and technologies
behind Web 2.0, but do not see how this is relevant for them, or how they can emulate that
success. This is likely to change as Web 2.0 culture permeates the workforce, that were raised in
the Internet age, and use of the Web grows. Cloud Computing will accelerate that process, as
various entrants trial new business models for earning revenue by offering utility-like computing
services. Addressing security concerns is paramount though and will act as the brake whenever any
mission-critical applications are considered. Expendable, low-risk business activity will find its way
to the Cloud today. It will probably take the Internet mark 2 (there are various initiatives for
upgrading the Internet, increasing bandwidth and improving security at nodes being prime
motivations), for Cloud Computing to become truly ubiquitous.

Technology Issues

The ALM suite represents the best investment to support developers and management. However,
its takeup has tended to be at the large enterprise level, with many smaller organisations relying
on point solutions. This has changed in the last few years with the increasing adoption of Agile
methodologies and the need to support the greater discipline and process required in these
practices. The waterfall process is relatively straightforward, with simple stage-gates and linear
workflow, whereas an Agile methodology like Scrum has iterations (daily Scrums) within iterations
(Sprints, Spikes, and Retrospectives) within iterations (the release plan). In order to support
complex projects and distributed team members there is a need for tooling that allows Agile work
items, called ‘stories’ or ‘features’, to be easily moved around the workflow. Developer testing is a
core activity in Agile, so rigging-up automated, continuous testing is necessary. Real-time reports
with charts for velocity and burndown need to be easily accessed and displayed to all team
members. The project managers need the electronic equivalent of a white board to easily manage
an Agile project and perform the various activities in the process. For example, at the iteration end
a retrospective is held that requires all stakeholders to attend and the product owner to re-prioritise
stories. This needs to be easily performed and tracked. A new generation of ALM solutions have
appeared on the market to support these activities – discussed in Section 2.3 of this Report. ALM
architecture, our state-of-the-art view of ALM given in Section 3.1, makes a number of distinctions:
it separates out core ALM activity, cross-cutting the lifecycle segments, from plug-in ALM tools via a
Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) integration layer, and from external development tools like
Integrated Development Environments, test tools, and third-party ALM tools via an interoperability
layer. The core layer comprises: a workflow engine and common repository as essential; Software
Change and Configuration Management (SCCM); reporting (and ideally BI analytics capability);
process and methodology support through Web-based guides and wikis (authoring and publishing
tools, two-way access for users to read and change content), and all accessible from the ALM tools
at any point in the workflow; collaboration support; software estimation (which is underrepresented
in ALM but should be integral); and issue and defect management (commonly found in operations
but good practice for use in development).

Beliefs that support for modelling (MDD or MDA) should be an integral part of core ALM. In reality,
as mentioned in the introduction to this Section, there have been setbacks in the vendor modelling
community. Certainly the developer community appears divided between those that support
modelling and those that do not, with many in the Agile community shunning the activity. The fact
remains that for complex projects modelling is a necessity – the telecom, automotive, and
aerospace industries are examples where modelling is successfully used. The limited take-up of
MDA by customers has more to do with the lack of a reference system and the slow evolution of an
action/behaviour language: this is a programming language that is used to describe the business or
application logic. The most successful modelling tools on the market combine visual models with an
action language for the detailed work. A big mistake in the early days of MDA was to assume that
everything should be done with the Unified Modeling Language – the truth is that it is not flexible
enough and it is also a boring activity. Programming is successful because it is versatile and also
fun. The trick is to combine visual models with an action language.

Rich Internet Applications (RIAs) continue to feed into modern, Web-based applications, and are
now a standard fixture. The name will probably fade away as the technology continues to become
the default – the application development tools will make non-rich Web components and widgets
obsolete. The shift is towards what is being built and this is where business-oriented Web 2.0, or
Enterprise Web 2.0 (the terminology preferred in this Report), takes centre stage.

Market Issues

Integration is one of the thorniest questions in ALM today. The first initiative to create an open ALM
framework based on the Eclipse platform failed due to lack of widespread vendor support (known
as Application Lifecycle Framework, the project’s lead vendor, Serena Software, shut it down in

Meanwhile IBM, the originator of Eclipse, created a new server-side ALM platform named
Jazz is designed to be open and a number of application development tool providers are building
plug-ins for it, but the platform is being used for integrating a host of IBM Rational products, legacy
and new generation, and in perfect timing, ALM products from the Telelogic acquisition that
concluded in 2008.

The other ALM leaders alongside IBM – Borland and Microsoft – are also making integration a key
forward strategy. Borland is building an integration layer (Borland Open ALM Framework or BOAF)
and is planning on providing connectors for two third-party leading products in each ALM segment
(requirements, change and configuration, etc.). It is also moving its legacy solution to this
integration layer, with the new-generation Borland Management Solution already built on
BOAF.Microsoft also has an ALM platform in Visual Studio Team System (VSTS), with an ecosystem
of vendors providing products that plug-into the platform. However, the upcoming release – VSTS
2010 – will take Microsoft to the ranks of end-to-end ALM vendors, competing directly with IBM and
Borland at the top. VSTS is a natural candidate for Microsoft developers building .NET solutions, its
support for other languages and operating systems is limited though.

ALM system architecture (see Section 3.1) has SCCM as a core ALM tool, but a number of ALM suite
vendors have opted out from competing in a segment of the market they view as mature and
saturated. Vendors like Compuware, HP, and Rally Software will need to provide deep and
orchestrated native integration to a range of SCCM products in order to achieve what's considered
to be essential ALM functionality. They all support the popular open source Subversion SCCM
product. Compuware and HP are long-time ALM providers, spanning mainframe and distributed
systems, and also offer strong Application Performance Management solutions. HP Software also
incorporates what was the Mercury product line and has deep capability in testing tools. Rally
Software is one of a new breed of ALM solution providers with an Agile development focus and a
hosted solution business model (although Rally Software will consider on-premises provision). The
appearance of these new ALM vendors, Polarion Software and TechExcel are further examples that
appear for the first time in this Report, indicates that there is a great opportunity in the market to
address customer needs. In its early years ALM had a mainly large enterprise appeal, so the market
            is wide open for expansion. Finally, MKS and Serena Software continue to mature and build on their
            ALM solutions, are a short distance from the leading group, and can offer their unique takes on the
            ALM market. For MKS it is all about organic growth and tight integration, each time we visit MKS it
            has added another segment to its native ALM capability. Serena Software has also made progress
            with support for business mashups and Agile development as core activities. The ALM solution
            market as being in a revitalised state, with Agile and Software-as-a-Service creating new
            opportunities that should see ALM adoption reach further into the developer community. Despite
            the world economic recession at the time of writing this Report, investment in an ALM approach is a
            sound course of action to take that will lower development costs in the long run, and also help
            deliver better software products.

            Late Breaking News

            As this Report went to publication the news broke that Micro Focus International (a UK company) is
            to acquire Borland in a cash deal described as a definitive agreement. Furthermore it was also
            announced that Micro Focus is to acquire assets from Compuware’s Quality Solutions portfolio,
            covering Application Testing and Automated Software Quality products. The move, if concluded
            successfully, will catapult Micro Focus into the front rank of the ALM market. This acquisition follows
            the recent acquisition of Sun Microsystems by Oracle, with particular interest to developers
            concerned with the future of Java. It is the opinion that Oracle will be a good guardian of Java.

Contents:   Section 1: Management Summary
            1.1 Management Summary

            Section 2: Application Development and Lifecycle Management Today
            2.1 Report Introduction and Objectives
            2.2 Application Development Trends
            2.3 Advances in Processes and Methodologies
            2.4 The People Aspects of ALM
            2.5 Application Development in Emerging Environments

            Section 3: The Butler Group ALM Evaluation Model
            3.1 The Butler Group Application Lifecycle Management System Architecture
            3.2 The ALM Solution Features Matrix

            Section 4: Agile Development and Project Management
            4.1 Understanding Agile Development
            4.2 Agile Software Change and Configuration Management
            4.3 Advances in Project Management

            Section 5: Testing and Test Management
            5.1 New Tools in the Market
            5.2 Test Driven Development
            5.3 Advances in Test Management

            Section 6: Market Analysis
            6.1 Butler Group Application Development and Lifecycle Management Features Matrix
            6.2 The Application Development and Lifecycle Management Decision Matrix
            6.3 Vendor Analysis

            Section 7: Technology Audits
            Aldon – Aldon ALM Solution
            Borland – Borland ALM Portfolio
            Compuware Corporation – Compuware ALM Suite
            HP – HP ALM Solution Set
            IBM Rational – IBM Rational Software Delivery Platform
            Microsoft – Microsoft Visual Studio Team System 2010
            MKS – MKS Integrity 2009
            Polarion Software – Polarion ALM Enterprise 3.2
            Rally Software – Rally Enterprise ALM Platform
            Serena Software – Serena ALM Suite
            TechExcel – TechExcel DevSuite
            Section 8: Vendor Profiles
            edge IPK
            Electric Cloud
            Perforce Software

            Section 9: Glossary

Ordering:   Order Online -

            Order by Fax - using the form below

            Order by Post - print the order form below and send to

                         Research and Markets,
                         Guinness Centre,
                         Taylors Lane,
                         Dublin 8,
                                                           Page 1 of 2

Fax Order Form
To place an order via fax simply print this form, fill in the information below and fax the completed form to 646-607-
1907 (from USA) or +353-1-481-1716 (from Rest of World). If you have any questions please visit

Order Information
Please verify that the product information is correct and select the format(s) you require.

               Product Name:           Application Development and Lifecycle Management: The Impact of Agile
                                       Practices on People, Processes, and Tools
               Web Address:  
               Office Code:            OC8DIRNMSSUSXR

Product Formats
Please select the product formats and quantity you require:


               Hard Copy:                EURO€ 2,435.00 + Euro €50 Shipping/Handling

               Electronic -
                                         EURO€ 2,356.00
               Single User:
               Electronic -
                                         EURO€ 5,890.00

* Shipping/Handling is only charged once per order.

Contact Information
Please enter all the information below in BLOCK CAPITALS

      Title:                  Mr              Mrs           Dr           Miss                 Ms     Prof

      First Name:                                                  Last Name:

      Email Address: *

      Job Title:




      Postal / Zip Code:


      Phone Number:

      Fax Number:

     * Please refrain from using free email accounts when ordering (e.g. Yahoo, Hotmail, AOL)
                                                              Page 1 of 2

Payment Information
Please indicate the payment method you would like to use by selecting the appropriate box.

          Pay by credit card:                     American Express

                                                  Diners Club

                                                  Master Card

                                           Cardholder's Name

                                           Cardholder's Signature

                                           Expiry Date

                                           Card Number

                                           CVV Number

                                           Issue Date
                                           (for Diners Club only)

          Pay by check:                    Please post the check, accompanied by this form, to:

                                           Research and Markets,
                                           Guinness Center,
                                           Taylors Lane,
                                           Dublin 8,

                                           Please transfer funds to:
          Pay by wire transfer:
                                           Account number                   833 130 83
                                           Sort code                        98-53-30
                                           Swift code                       ULSBIE2D
                                           IBAN number                      IE78ULSB98533083313083
                                           Bank Address                 Ulster Bank,
                                                                        27-35 Main Street,
                                                                        Co. Dublin,

     If you have a Marketing Code please enter it below:

           Marketing Code:

      Please note that by ordering from Research and Markets you are agreeing to our Terms and Conditions at

                                              Please fax this form to:
                                  (646) 607-1907 or (646) 964-6609 - From USA
                          +353-1-481-1716 or +353-1-653-1571 - From Rest of World

To top