Sequester and Pension - Two Topics We Can t Get ... - Lumesis

Document Sample
Sequester and Pension - Two Topics We Can t Get ... - Lumesis Powered By Docstoc
					Sequester and Pension - Two Topics We Can’t Get Enough Of!                                Feb. 19, 2013

This week we take a look at which States may be hit hardest by the imposition of the sequester. We then turn
our attention to pensions and focus in on funded status, annual required contributions and just who may be left
holding the bag (hint, it is who you think).

While we had hoped the folks in DC would have used their time since ...( how long has it been?)... to pass a
budget and take a less dramatic approach than sequestration to addressing the deficit, March 1 is quickly
approaching. The President did mention the need to take steps in his State of the Union and Marco Rubio (after
his drink of water) delivered a reply that said all the right things. The muni audience heard promising rhetoric at
Jack Lew’s confirmation hearing when he acknowledged the 28% muni cap was not a great idea. It would be
nice to hear the Executive and Legislative branches similarly opine v. a cabinet nominee.

Perhaps, the President and Congress, knew exactly what they were doing 18 months ago. Knowing full well
compromise was not palatable, they adopted the idea of sequester. Now, they can blame each other for things
that go wrong and take credit with party hardliners for holding the line. Who knows, maybe once things kick in,
they can adopt a budget, tweak some of the more aggressive aspects of the sequester and engage in real
dialogue about tax and spending reform. Hope springs eternal.

Until then, you need to take a good, hard look at the impact of the across the board reduction in spending
growth and specific areas where cuts are expected to occur. Given cuts in defense spending are a primary
aspect of sequestration, and will arguably have the most immediate impact, we take a look at States most
reliant on Defense Expenditures as a % of their GDP.




         Source: DIVER Analytics; Map Module; Bureau of Economic Analysis
Put another way:




        Source: DIVER Analytics; Filter Module; Bureau of Economic Analysis

While Connecticut and Virginia are the only two of the above five in the bottom half of our DIVER Muni Index, it
may be worth following these five States closely over the next twelve months. The DIVER Muni Index is
available across the DIVER solutions platform.

Now, to Pensions. Over the past year or so, these pages have featured commentaries on issues such as Funded
Ratios, Pension Obligation Bonds and other related topics. It has led to our creation of a database of 15 data
sets for more than 900 State and city pension plans. Last week, Carl DeMaio penned a column for the February
7 Opinion page of the WSJ. Mr. DeMaio added some depth to points we’ve previously commented on:

    -   Outstanding State and local pension liabilities are “more than all the bonded debt officially listed on
        state and local balance sheets combined.”
    -   “[A]ll the federal tax hikes approved by Congress on January 1 would pay less than 20% of America’s
        state and local pension debt over the next ten years.”

DeMaio goes on to suggest ways in which the Feds can help solve the pension issue (never mind these are the
same folks that can’t seem to pass a budget or take steps to solve our Nation’s fiscal issues). He starts by
suggesting “Erisa-like” standards to avoid cooking the books (there are standards coming in to play in 2014) and
suggests eliminating the tax-exemption for pension obligation bonds.

While I am not sure I agree with Mr. DeMaio’s approach, we have, in the past discussed the idea of productive v
non-productive debt and the tax-exemption for the same. We have also been ardent supporters of standards
for reporting financial information (for pensions and for all municipalities for their CAFRs and budget). The
point, as Mr. DeMaio makes somewhat clear, there is this looming liability and real concern that the Nation’s
taxpayers will be left holding the bag despite having no say in how these liabilities are reported and accounted
for. If you thought banks were too big to fail…

In support of the idea of a level of standardization, a few weeks back, I happened upon an article that talked
about companies with pension plans that were being forced to pump in cash due to low interest rates (Ford
spent $5 billion, Verizon contributed $1.7 billion). Why? They are required to calculate their liability using a
discount rate tied to corporate bond yields. Imagine if all municipalities were required to calculate liabilities on
the same basis? If you are interested in doing your own field leveling, we track and make available Discount
Rate information for more than 730 State and City pension plans.

Our data gathering helps provide some perspective on the points raised above. The below map shows the
Funded Ratio of plans for 2011 (2012 data collection is underway but is hampered by the fact that much of it is
yet to be reported).
         Source: DIVER Analytics; Map Module; CAFRs.

DeMaio concluded his Opinion column discussing the importance of getting the pension issue under control so
that State and local funds can be spent productively - think infrastructure, schools and other vital services. To
his point, the amount of the Annual Required Contribution as a Percent of General Fund Expenses is as high as
67% (New Mexico) while the majority of the red States (below) are in the teens.




         Source: DIVER Analytics; Map Module; CAFRs.

Just because the ARC is a certain percent, doesn’t mean it is paid (borrowing from the Fed, some States have
been allowing the can to be kicked down the road). The below map highlights the Percent of the Annual
Required Contribution Paid for 2011 – essentially, anything other than blue is less than 100% of the ARC being
paid (in other words, getting worse, not better). Let’s hope the can kicking syndrome perfected by the folks in
DC doesn’t become a staple of the States budget solving tools.
         Source: DIVER Analytics; Map Module; CAFRs.



This last table sums it up for you:




Source: DIVER Analytics; Filter Module; Bureau of Economic Analysis

In the past, we have applauded those State and local governments that have taken steps to get their pension
and OPEB houses in order. However, like Mr. DeMaio, we worry about those pension liabilities that are too big
to fail and will require a bailout like the banks did – perhaps the only difference will be that the banks paid back
the bailouts!

As they say, more to come on both issues.
This Week’s Data (and two new ones):

        NEW: Defense Expenditures as % of GDP, State, 2010, 2011, 2012
        NEW: General Fund Balance, State, 2012, 2011, 2010, 2009
        Foreclosures, County and State, January 2013
        Weekly Initial and Continued Jobless Claims, State, 2/2/2012
        Muni Index, Pt. in Time/Trend, County, February 2013
        Drought Intensity, County, 2/12/201
        Food Stamp Change and Rank, State, November 2012

On the Road: Gregg will be in New York City and St. Louis this week. Please look for our booth (and us) at the
upcoming BDA, Bond Buyer, Florida Conference. Check our website for the list of conferences we will be
attending.


Gregg L. Bienstock
CEO& Co-Founder, Lumesis, Inc.



A suite of powerful analytical and visualization tools serving Credit Analysts, Portfolio Managers and Risk
Managers. Access hundreds of datasets from more than 50 sources and generate detailed credit analysis by
geography or CUSIP for your holdings.



Comprehensive information delivery and compliance solution serving Financial Advisor networks. Improve
customer satisfaction, while protecting your firm. A simple to generate CUSIP-driven report delivers email ready
content for your client and adherence to MSRB Rules and Compliance requirements.



Delivers CUISP-driven, dynamic, sector based reports that aggregate key information and data within seconds.
Available for all 1.4M+ municipal bonds and displays the most current data available in the market including
terms and features, EMMA disclosure filings, price and yield, call provisions, sector driven key economic and
demographic data and links to primary news sources from every issuer community.

Contact Us: inquiries@lumesis.com, or 203.276.6500 Vist our website: www.lumesis.com

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:0
posted:4/4/2013
language:Unknown
pages:5