Docstoc

Enlace - Evergreen Valley College

Document Sample
Enlace - Evergreen Valley College Powered By Docstoc
					                                              Evergreen Valley College
                                           Program Review Feedback Form
                                                 ENLACE PROGRAM

Date: 4/30/11
Reviewed by: Institutional Effectiveness Committee: (Mata & Ruppenthal)

SUMMARY OF THE DEPARTMENT/PROGRAM
Did the Review Team clearly articulate summary? Yes (Mata & Ruppenthal) If not, provide concrete
feedback on information needed. Excellent summary of the ENLACE program. A must-read for anyone
that is not familiar with the program and its historical roots. (Mata)
Did the Review Team clearly identify and assess strength and areas of improvements in relevant
areas? Yes (Mata & Ruppenthal ) Were there action plans included that would address areas of
improvement? Yes (Mata & Ruppenthal) If not, provide concrete feedback on information needed in
specific section.

PART A: Overview of Program
Did the Review Team answer all questions thoroughly? Yes (Mata & Ruppenthal) If not, identify
additional information needed. While areas of improvement were not directly stated, the presence of
the Enlace Program Goals and Five-Year Goals provide action plans for addressing student needs and
internal/external factors mentioned. Analysis of Enlace’s program rates and patterns including transfer
rates were clearly explained and addressed. Very good overview of the program with rich and
meaningful evidence. (Mata)
The overview of this program was very well done and documented with data (Ruppenthal).
Did the Review Team provide necessary culture of evidence (data, references, etc.)? Yes (Mata &
Ruppenthal) If not, identify additional information and analysis needed.
Did the Review Team include action plans for areas that need improvements? Yes (Mata &
Ruppenthal) If not, identify areas and information needed.

PART B: CURRICULUM
Did the Review Team answer all questions thoroughly? Yes (Mata & Ruppenthal) If not, identify
additional information needed. This section is basically covered under “Overview of the Program.”
(Mata)
Did the Review Team provide necessary culture of evidence (data, references, etc.)? Yes (Mata &
Ruppenthal) If not, identify additional information and analysis needed.

Did the Review Team include action plans for areas that need improvements? Yes (Mata &
Ruppenthal) If not, identify areas and information needed. While not directly stated, the information is
present in the analysis of data and the goals set forth under “Overview of the Program”. (Mata)



                                                        1

Program Review feedback form
IEC (Mata & Ruppenthal) feedback 4_30_11
VP Academic Affairs
ENLACE is a non-traditional academic program and therefore, the curriculum information was handled
differently. The description of the program and its goals were handled quite adequately in the prior
section. (Ruppenthal)

PART C: STUDENT OUTCOMES
Did the Review Team answer all questions thoroughly? No (Mata & Ruppenthal) If not, identify
additional information needed. SLOs for the ENLACE program are not provided. As described in the
criteria, list all the ENLACE courses that have current SLOs. SLOs should also be identified at the program
level. (Mata)
SLOs are not included and should be developed (Ruppenthal)
Did the Review Team provide necessary culture of evidence (data, references, etc.)? Yes, the evidence
is there. (Mata) Yes (Ruppenthal) If not, identify additional information and analysis needed. Once
SLOs are set, assessment measures and instruments (surveys, etc.) should be geared towards measuring
those SLOs. (Mata)
Need to include SLOs and any plans for assessing them (Ruppenthal)
Did the Review Team include action plans for areas that need improvements? Yes (Mata &
Ruppenthal) If not, identify areas and information needed.



PART D: FACULTY AND STAFF
Did the Review Team answer all questions thoroughly? No (Mata & Ruppenthal) If not, identify
additional information needed. This section needs to be completed. I recommend requiring a follow-up
report next year (Ruppenthal)
Did the Review Team provide necessary culture of evidence (data, references, etc.)? No (Mata &
Ruppenthal) If not, identify additional information and analysis needed.

Did the Review Team include action plans for areas that need improvements? No (Ruppenthal) If not,
identify areas and information needed. Section not completed. (Mata)



PART E: FACILITIES, EQUIPMENT, MATERIALS AND MAINTENANCE
Did the Review Team answer all questions thoroughly? No, this information is not provided in the
program review. (Mata), No (Ruppenthal) If not, identify additional information needed. This section
needs to be completed in a follow-up report (Ruppenthal)
Did the Review Team provide necessary culture of evidence (data, references, etc.)?        If not,
identify additional information and analysis needed.
Did the Review Team include action plans for areas that need improvements?          If not, identify
areas and information needed.

PART F: FUTURE NEEDS


                                                     2

Program Review feedback form
IEC (Mata & Ruppenthal) feedback 4_30_11
VP Academic Affairs
Did the Review Team answer all questions thoroughly? No, this section of the program review was not
provided. (Mata) No (Ruppenthal) If not, identify additional information needed. This section needs to
be completed in a follow-up report (Ruppenthal)

Did the Review Team provide necessary culture of evidence (data, references, etc.)? If not, identify
additional information and analysis needed.
Did the Review Team include action plans for areas that need improvements? If not, identify areas
and information needed.




PART G: ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Provide concrete questions or feedback if needed.
Excellent program review so far! (Mata)




                                                   3

Program Review feedback form
IEC (Mata & Ruppenthal) feedback 4_30_11
VP Academic Affairs

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:0
posted:3/14/2013
language:Unknown
pages:3