Docstoc

Evaluation report 2008-0900100

Document Sample
Evaluation report 2008-0900100 Powered By Docstoc
					                  Dubalagun
                  di to
                  Varvatti,                          Road
9    Humnabad                   2006-07   KREGS                 Pits      5     36.00    180.00
                  Sedam                              side
                  cross road
                  side
                                          SGRY(
                  Sevanagar                          Private
10   Bhalki                     2006-07   SCP/TS                Pits      1     100.00   100.00
                  SCP – plot                         land
                                          P)
                  GHPS
11   Bhalki       Dhannur       2006-07   RSVY       School     Pits      1     53.33    53.33
                  School
                  Kardiyal
12   Bhalki       Gurukul       2006-07   RSVY       School     Pits     1.5    72.30    108.45
                  School
                  Valsang to
                                                     Road
13   Bhalki       Ganeshpur     2004-05   RSVY                  Pits      6     49.91    299.46
                                                     side
                  wadi
                  Bus-depot                          Govt
14   Bhalki                     2005-06   RSVY                  Pits      2     77.78    155.56
                  – Bhalki                           Land
                                          SGRY/      Private
15   Bhalki       Bhatandra     2004-05                         Pits      1     50.40    50.40
                                          SCP        land
                  GHS                                School
16   Bhalki                     2005-06   RSVY                  Pits     1.4     0.00     0.00
                  Bhatambur                          forestry
                  Atterga
                                          KSFM
17   Bhalki       Demonstrat    2005-06              M-08       Pits      1      0.00     0.00
                                          BC
                  ion plot
                                          SGRY/
                                                     Private
18   Bhalki       Mehkar        2006-07   SCP/TS                Pits      1      0.00     0.00
                                                     land
                                          P
19   Bhalki       Balegaon      2005-06   RSVY       Forest     Trench   20     45.86    917.20
                  Madakati
                                                     Road
20   Bhalki       to approach   2006-07   NREGS                 Pits     1.75   11.14    19.50
                                                     side
                  road
                                                     Road
21   Aurad        Chintaki      2005-06   SGRY                  Pits     10      6.00    60.00
                                                     side
                                          SGRY/
                  Karangi                            Private
22   Aurad                      2006-07   SCP/TS                Pits     2.5    79.20    198.00
                  (B)                                land
                                          P
                  G.H.School              School
23   Aurad                      2006-07              School     Pits     1.84   48.37    89.00
                  Yangunda                forestry
                                                     Private
24   Aurad        Korayal       2005-07   SGRY                  Pits     2.5    76.00    190.00
                                                     land
                  Kamalanag
                                                     Road
25   Aurad        ar to murki   2005-06   RSVY                  Pits      7     39.00    273.00
                                                     side
                  road side
                  G.H.School                         School
26   Aurad                      2005-06   RSVY                  Pits      1     78.00    78.00
                  Khatgaon                           forestry
                  Sawargaon
                                                     Road
27   Aurad        to Bhanthi    2006-07   NREGS                 Pits      5     30.10    150.50
                                                     side
                  road side
                                          KSFM
                  Lingiwadi-
28   Aurad                      2005-06   BC/SC      M-08       Pits      1     38.00    38.00
                  Demo plot
                                          P
                                          SGRY/
                  Ladha SCP                          Private
29   Aurad                      2004-05   SCP/TS                Pits      1     36.00    36.00
                  plot                               land
                                          P
     Basavakaly                           SGRY/      Private
30                Kodyal        2006-07                         Pits      1      0.00     0.00
     ana                                  SCP        land
                  Manthal-
     Basavakaly                                      School
31                school        2006-07   RSVY                  Pits      1     31.50    31.50
     ana                                             forestry
                  forestry
     Basavakaly                           SGRY-      Private
32                Kondihal      2006-07                         Pits      1     32.80    32.80
     ana                                  SCP        land

                                                                                                  294
                    Chickanaga
       Basavakaly                              NREG     Road
33                  on to         2006-07                          Pits         5      49.04     245.20
       ana                                     A        side
                    Kalkhora
                    Govt. High
       Basavakaly                                       School
34                  school,       2005-06      RSVY                Pits         1      81.67      81.67
       ana                                              forestry
                    Mudbi
       Basavakaly   Toglur-                    NFFW     Road
35                                2005-06                          Pits         5       0.00      0.00
       ana          Goruta                     P        side
       Basavakaly                              KSFM
36                  Rajeshwar     2005-06               M-08       Pits         1      80.00      80.00
       ana                                     BC
       Basavakaly   Chukinala                           Govt
37                                2004-05      SGRY                Pits         11     75.37     829.07
       ana          damsite                             Land
       Basavakaly   Narayanap                  KSFM
38                                2005-06               M-08       Pits         1      58.00      58.00
       ana          ur                         BC
       Basavakaly   Murkundi                            Govt
39                                2005-06      SGRY                Pits        17.5    60.36     1056.30
       ana          TFS                                 Land
                    Gadagi to                           Road
40     Bidar                      2006-07      NREGP               Pits         5      55.00     275.00
                    Nandagaon                           side
                    Bidar
                    college
                    Norma                               Private
41     Bidar                      2006-07      RSVY                Pits         1      30.00      30.00
                    Findrock                            land
                    High
                    School
                                               KSFM
42     Bidar        Kanthana      2005-06               M-08       Pits         1      56.67      56.67
                                               BC
                                               KSFM
43     Bidar        Kanthana      2005-06               M-08       Pits         1      33.33      33.33
                                               BC
                    Tadlapur-
                    gumma                               Road
44     Bidar                      2005-06      RSVY                Pits         7.5    58.58     439.35
                    Malegaon                            side
                    road
                    Malegaon                            Private
45     Bidar                      2005-06      RSVY                Pits         1      29.09      29.09
                    School                              land
                    Nadagaon                            Private
46     Bidar                      2006-07      SGRY                Pits         1      60.00      60.00
                    patta land                          land
                                                                                       Seedli               Weig-
                    Location of
       Name of                     Year of     Budget              Plant ing    Ext.   ng       Weight-ed   hted
Slno                   the                              Model
       the Range                  Plantation   Head                Met hod     in ha   Surviv   Prod uct    Avera
                    Plantation
                                                                                       al %                 ge
                    Khayapur                   SGRY     Private
47     Bidar                      2004-05                          Pits         0.5    60.00      30.00
                    patta land                 SCP      land
                    Hokrana                    SGRY     Private
48     Bidar                      2004-05                          Pits         0.5    50.00      25.00
                    Patta land                 SCP      land
                    Morarji
                    Desai
49     Bidar                      2006-07      RSVY     School     Pits         1      60.00      60.00
                    School,
                    Bagdal
                                                                   Total       164.5   46.88     8042.86    48.90

        The overall survival percentage of seedlings planted for the entire district is over 45
per cent. The details of individual plantation survival percentage are given in the table- 2(b)
4.1.3 . Plantation Model-wise performance:
        As indicated in the guidelines for evaluation, survival percentages of different types
of planting models were also compiled so as to assess the feasibility of continuation of the
said models in the district. For this purpose, plantation models are broadly classified based on
the land preparation and the protection etc in the block planting, natural regeneration and
roadside planting. Planting model wise survival percentage of both Territorial and Social
Forestry Divisions are given in the following Table- 3(a) and Table- 3(b).




                                                                                                             295
            Table 3(a) : Details of planting model wise survival percentage for Bidar Forest
            Division (Territorial).

                                                                                No. of
                                         Method of Land      Seedling bag                                 Extent     Survival
   Sl no       Planting model                                                   Plantations
                                         Preparation         size                                         (Ha)       percentage
                                                                                evaluated

        1      Block Plantation          Pits                Small/ Big                   2                 54             36.93
        2      Block Plantation          Trench              Small                    17                   364.08          66.44

        3      Natural Regeneration   Only protection        Seed sowing                  2                 236                 -

Table 3(b) : Details of planting model wise survival percentage for Bidar Social Forest
Division.
                                                                            No. of
                                  Method of Land          Seedling bag                        Extent
  Sl no      Planting model                                                 Plantation                       Survival percentage
                                  Preparation             size                                (Ha)
                                                                            s evaluated

    1        Block Plantation     Pits                    Small/big             29                71.5                  50.44

    2        Block Plantation     Trench                  Small                 1                  20                   45.86
    3        Road side            Pits                    Big                   10                57.25                 33.48
    4        School Plantations   Pits                    Big                   9                 15.74                 50.37
         From the above tables, it is evident that survival percentage of plantations raised by
using tall seedlings grown in bigger size bags are higher than the plantations raised by using
small seedling. School plantations have over 50 percent survival percentage. Road side
plantation although show 33.48 percent survival, the component of protection has played an
important part in their survival. Among the block plantations raised with trenches formed
either manually or by machines have slightly better survival than the pit plantations.
         By looking at the above tables, it would be advisable to use tall seedling grown in
larger bags for raising block plantations also depending upon the cost norms of the given
schemes. Possibly, these roadside and town plantations might have got better care than the
block plantations by way of watering, protection due to the fact being near to urban area.
4.1.4 Qualitative aspects of plantations:
         In order to assess the success and failure of plantations, it is necessary to ascertain the
suitability of site along with giving proper protection to the plantation. In this direction, all
plantations evaluated are classified in to very good, good, poor / failed based on survival
percentage. Reasons for the failure broadly fall into inappropriate site selection, species
selection, protection and model selection which should be thoroughly ascertained by the
division before contemplating the plantation. Apart from these, some adverse climatic,
edaphic and biotic factors, which are sometimes beyond human control. Based on the above
criteria, plantations evaluated are grouped and are given in table 4.
         Table 4(a): Bidar Division:

                                           Failed       Poor          Satisfactory      Good
                                                                                                               Very Good
                                         (Survival   (Survival         (Survival      (Survival
   Sl no.     Name of the Range                                                                             (Survival percent
                                          percent     percent           percent        percent
                                                                                                                80-100)
                                           0-19)       20-39)            40-59)         60-79)

     1        Aurad                             1                                             1
     2        Basavakalyana                                                 2                 1
     3        Bhalki                                                        2
     4        Bidar                                                         3                 1                     4
     5        Humnabad                                                      1                 3



                                                                                                                                    296

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:2
posted:1/28/2013
language:Unknown
pages:3