Real Estate Financing
Zagreb, 6 May 2008
The Fourth Annual International Conference
on the Real Estate Market in Croatia
Thibault Dutreix, Principal Banker Property and Tourism Team, EBRD
Structure of presentation
General state of the loan markets Real estate financing: what is changing? Croatian real estate and hospitality sectors prospects EBRD significant real estate transactions and support in Croatia
General state of the loan market
Global Loan Markets are currently facing difficulties and uncertainties, following the mid 2007 Credit Crunch
– Progressive expansion of the Credit Crunch & liquidity compression from the US, to Western Europe to the Emerging Markets, including EBRD region
– Global and regional Loan volume for Q1 2008 was sharply lower than last year
Global: 1Q08 volume of USD 790 billion (33% decrease from LY) EBRD Regions: 1Q08 volume of USD 25 billion (40% decrease from LY)
General state of the loan market (cont.)
– Key changes at the macro level are:
Re-intermediation of the debt financial market – Little activity for non bank lenders – Bond market has been shut or near-shut in the last 9 months – Borrowers have turned to the banks for support
Greater caution from Banks
– Deal size has decreased significantly – Leveraged finance market is almost shut – Rare corporate transaction above EUR 200 million – Pressure on more equity financing
Crisis of Confidence
– “Liquidity management”: Banks are more selective and tend to allocate available funds to existing clients
Debt re-pricing
Real estate financing: what is changing?
Recent real estate market sector boom in the region and in Croatia
– Level of equity raised targeting real estate development and acquisition has boomed over the last years
Strong macroeconomics prospects EU membership process Capitalization rate compression
– Professional real estate development companies have increased their operations and equity commitment
International: Trigranit, GTC, Europolis Croatian: Hidrocommerce, Ingra, Tehnika
Real estate financing: what is changing? (cont.)
Recent access to financing has been ample, cheap, at increasingly long maturities
– Debt considered as a commodity
– Numerous banks mostly “volume driven” – Downwards pressure on debt pricing
What is currently changing?
– Reduced access to real estate debt financing
Credit Crunch began in collapse of US real estate mortgage, as a result to excessive lending to the subprime sector Banks are more cautious Reduced volumes
Real estate financing: what is changing? (cont.)
– Reduced access to real estate debt financing (cont’d)
Almost no more large real estate acquisition Repriceing of debt
Banks increasingly selective
– Importance of track record, expertise and reputation
– Fear of propagation of the Credit Crunch to real estate markets
Cap rates have already slightly increased in some markets (Poland, Czech Republic, Hungary, Romania) Most real estate stocks are trading at discount to NAV
Croatian real estate and hospitality sectors prospects
Positive factors to the real estate and hospitality sectors
– Strong economy, good macroeconomics prospects and EU accession process creating long term demand for quality real estate space
– Prime real estate yields have dramatically converged from 14% in 2002, to 7.0 – 7.5% today
– Landmark real estate developments and developers – Privatization of the Croatian tourism industry
– Croatian coast is maintaining its attractiveness and improving competitiveness
– Increased opportunities in the regions
Croatian real estate and hospitality sectors prospects (cont.)
Real estate financing
– Strong development in the recent years through the activity of several large local and international banking groups – Access to competitive debt financing and long maturity for both construction and acquisition real estate financing – In light with current Global loan market trends, it is expected to see:
Greater selectivity and liquidity management Increased pricing and control of risk
EBRD involvement in the property sector
Total commitments as of the end of March 2008:
Development of new annual commitments
450 400 350
€1.575 billion to 95 projects (including equity participation in funds) €5.6 billion total project value 2 projects per year refinanced by commercial banks 1 project per year: equity exit to co-shareholders or other investors
€ millions
300 250 200 150 100 50 0 '99 '00 '01 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 Mar '08
EBRD significant real estate transactions and support in Croatia
EBRD mission to support transition to market economy via investments in private sector, including Property & Tourism
– Debt and Equity instruments
Croatia and the Balkan countries are a key priority to the EBRD
– Property & Tourism sector team now based in Zagreb to cover the local market and the Balkan region – Little involvement in Croatian real estate sector to date given strong banking sector & reduced EBRD “additionality”
EBRD significant real estate transactions and support in Croatia (cont.)
– EBRD recent strong involvement in Tourism sector through 2 large debt & equity transactions in:
Jadranka Hotels: EUR 24.0 million equity investment Adriatic Luxury Hotels: EUR 53.0 million debt + equity investment
– Current real estate financing market trend: opportunity for EBRD to increase its role in the Croatian real estate market
Case Study – Jadranka Hotels
P&T / RO joint deal EUR 24 million Equity Investment in Jadranka Hotels for a 30% stake Pre IPO investment Hotel repositioning from 1/2stars to 3/4 stars Jadranka DD (Sponsor) keeps control International Hospitality Asset Manager to ensure smooth implementation
Case Study - Adriatic Luxury Hotels
EUR 25 million Equity investment for a 25% stake in the company EUR 27.5 million debt package Corporate and financial restructuring of the company
Bellevue
Palace
Contacts
Thibault Dutreix Principal Banker
Property & Tourism Team
Tel: +385 6000 310 dutreixt@ebrd.com
Thank you
http://www.ebrd.com