Leadership Portfolio Holistic Scoring Rubric
PASSING NOT PASSING
Strong introduction; discusses content pieces, Weak introduction; missing clear overview of
provides adequate reflection; well-written; well- the portfolio; lacking reflection; content
organized; meets length requirement. inadequately addressed; poorly written or
Leadership Coursework and Experiences
Provides exceptional representations of Some leadership work is included, but may not
leadership work from all courses in the be entirely comprehensive; connection to
curriculum or transfer courses; includes professional interests is somewhat obvious;
developed group and individual assignments; does not provide adequate representation of
direct professional connection clear in included undergraduate leadership experience.
items; experiences are represented completely Comments:
and holistically; experience range throughout
undergraduate years; clear and integrated
connection to leadership.
Content Required by the College
All content pieces specified by the College are Samples of academic coursework included but
included; includes coursework that speaks to may be missing content required by the
development of specific and personal College; editing and revision of content pieces
leadership skills; connection between needed to be considered professionally
coursework examples and leadership presented.
experiences is strongly evident; all content Comments:
pieces are professionally presented.
Organization and Presentation
Well-organized; professional presentation and Somewhat organized, though some
format, either in a binder or electronic; requirements may be missing; presentation is
presentation is appropriate to the student’s inappropriate for the student’s major or simply
major; includes cover page, table of contents, unclear; formatting and editing problems
contents checklist, and is overall clearly throughout.
organized; pages are numbered and sections Comments:
are clearly labeled; well-edited.