Docstoc

order denying MPO

Document Sample
order denying MPO Powered By Docstoc
					Case 1:12-cv-22211-JLK Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/26/2012 Page 1 of 5




                      UN I                    CT
                          TED STA TES DISTR I C O URT
                      SO UTH ER N D I     CT
                                     STR I O F FLOR IDA
                                  A      VI O
                              M I M ID I SI N

                                       2-    - V- NG
                          CA SE N O . 1 2221I CI KI


  RAANAN K ATZ,

         a ntf ,
        Pli if



  RI           NA
  I NA CHEVALD I ,

          e nt
        Def nda .
                                /

                       N      NT                      VE
         OR DER D EN YI G JO I M OTION FO R PR O TECTI OR DER

            S       s or he       t     he r i     nt    i or r
        TH I CAU SE i bef e t Cour upon t Pa tes'Joi M oton f Enty of

   tpu a in nd r e     n o e tve de g r i      nfd n i l nf r to DE
  S i l to a Ag e d Upo Pr tc i Or rRe a dng Co i e ta l o mai n (
    2) ie t be 2, 2. r i , he ri s u te       opo e o i n i lt
  #2 ,fldOco r2 201 The en t pa te s bmit d apr s d c nfde taiy
   de , ch hey   d          r s        y oce ngs i he our e hi
  or r whi t w oul have gove n di cover pr edi durng t c s oft s

   ii i
  ltgaton.

           t r evi    he te oi         i nd opos or r t Cour fndst t
        A fe a r ew oft pari s'J ntM oton a pr ed de , he   t i ha

  he tes ve f ed           lng i o       t n he   ts ong- t ndi
  t pari ha of er no com peli bas st overur t Cour ' l s a ng

    i pl       ac i       nt i ng    t oc ngs             s    i s- -
  prnci e and pr tce ofm ai a ni Cour pr eedi and docum ent publc. Slhe

      r udi ar s al l ot t he i              l tz     o r      n        i
  Fede alJ ci y ha ze ousy pr ec ed t rghtofa1 cii enst fee,ope and publc

  ras' r man . a e , 0 2
       '                        , 00      368 66, t S. Fl . 0 .
  ti l. Do s v Glz r No. 3- 2861 2 4 W L 1 8 a *1( D. a 20 4)

     n u ca pr e di s r ç td n he prncpl h t usie a ot u vv hid
                        r
  Ope j diil oc e ng aeûooe i t t i i eta j tc c nn s r iebe n
Case 1:12-cv-22211-JLK Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/26/2012 Page 2 of 5



  he l      ience, a i t lr dii
  t wals ofs l                          o-     rc     s nlt or ecr r al
                 ' nd n he t a tonalA ngl A m e i an di t s f s etti s.'''

    e r Ma we l 8 S. 33 49 1 6) Exc p n a e nsa e , t s he i ht
  Sh ppa dv. x l,3 4 U. 3 ,3 ( 96 . e ti r r i tnc s i i t rg of
     y     rca o ee he   i s i s          td n       n or m l     hi
  ever Am e i n t s t publc' busnes conduc e i an ope f u . U ndert s
                                                                          *
   rc d n,udiil c me s r rs tvey valbl o he blc t y e ld
  p e e e tj ca do u nt aep eumpi l a ia et t pu i bu ma bes ae
  f he i o ess s w ghed by ot hi ri e ess f i non- s os e.
  i t rghtt acc i out ei    her ghe nt r t avorng di cl ur

   x , r r          niato , n . 4    S. 9, 2 1 78 . s u t s oa
  Nion v Wa ne Commu c ins I c , 35U . 58 60 ( 9 ) Thi Co r ha br d
   s r ton     n   ua i uch
  di c e i w he eval tng s a m oton.f reAl xande Grant& Co.Lii ,820 F.
                                 i n     e      r           tg.      2d

    2, 5 1 t r 98 .i e ve e n l e n a e c a i ns r , o
                       ca
  35 3 7 ( 1h Ci.1 7) i s sha b e cos do r r o c so whe e f r
   xa e, s os e       r an nf m ton    d hr t      tonals iy orpl an
  e m pl di cl ur ofce t i i or a i woul t ea en na i   ecurt   ace

  ndi dua n a       i
  i vi li gr ve phys calda    .'    s
                          nger' D or man,2004 W L 1368866,at*2.

           h ae      i    r
        Suc r r occasons a enotpr enti t a
                                es n he bove- t ed m a t r. l
                                            s yl      te ndeed, he pa tes
                                                               t     ri

    ve ovi       de     ven ugges i s need. or
  ha pr ded no evi nce e s       tng uch         r he    t es n
                                           M eove ,t Cour not a

  n o itnc n fn nt oni he nsa t to I r e on       to o s s
  ic nsse yi Dee da j i ngt i tn moin.nhe S c dM oint Dimis
  DE 4 , f nd n r ue t e g h h t an if a ui s ie t d t r ve tng
  ( #1 ) De e a ta g da ln t t a Pl itf slws twa d r c e a p e n i
     r      ihi      i    ws ri es rtca   ai i f    i s hi se
  herfom publs ng onlne ne a tcl c ii lofPl ntf sbusnes ;t s ca w as

    l dl        e ha      te     o iencehers h. w ih t sJ ntM oton,
  alege y no m or t n an a tm ptt s l      peec But t hi oi     i

  antf nd f nda         o p he a ua       opm    hi e e e .
 Pl i i fa D e e ntw antt kee t f ct ldevel entoft scas s cr t Though

 he   i         rt             i         s o e ral s      y t r al, he
 t publc hasno Fis Am endm entrghtofacces t pr t i di cover m a e i s t

   ri      t how good causef a pr ec i or .l r A lxander Gr & Co. Lii ,
 pa tesm us s               or ot tve der n e e            ant      tg.

         ae    orda n 967,ens i t s m e prnci e by pass oft Fl i Gover
  'The St t ofFl i , i 1     hrned he a   i pl         age he orda         n
                                                                      nmenti
    s ne w, a      os xp nsve c pe s onfnne       hi u e n r s . t f a
                                                                   y
 Sun hi La a lw wh e e a i s o wa c i d by t sJ dg i Be n v Ci o M imi
   ac , u ubls e pi o , f d       d 4 Fl.          97 , i s har d y 45 o.
 Be h ( np ih d o nin) af' 231So.2 8 7 ( a 3d DCA l 0) wrtdic ge b 2 S 2d
    Fl. 971.
 38( a 1 )
                                       2
Case 1:12-cv-22211-JLK Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/26/2012 Page 3 of 5



       2d
  820 F. at357.

          n ddto t ris lce o e k a efnd eif n blcy peae
          l a iin,hepa te ee tdt s e (ndd e )rle i apu il o rtd
  or nam y he t      a es s rc      t or he her s rct    or da
  f um , el t Unied St t D iti tCour f t Sout n D iti ofFl i . The

   oce ngs l n ede al nd t t ours r  n o   i     e va i
 pr edi he d i f r a sa e c t a e ope t publc obs r ton by any

 nt r t      t    s nt o     l e 4 or he    her s rc      orda
 i e esed pary. Pur ua t Loca Rul 5. f t Sout n D it itofFl i , absent

  ome xror nay e d o e r c te u cil cs ro me h d pe o lc
 s e ta di r n e frs ce y,h j di a a t pefr ds oul beo nt pubi
  c utny
 s r i ,2

               u ti ha he ris ve t ho oo a e o usiy her e ie
          TheCo r tndst tt pate ha no s wng dc us t j tf t i d sr
 or ecr y. r or he     t     ,           , ppr   he    i or ot tve
 f s ec The ef e,t Cour cannot and doesnot a ove t m oton f pr ec i

   de .
 or r

               di y, t     ar ul evi  he ecor     i    her s uly
          Accor ngl afera c ef r ew oft r d and be ng ot wi e f l

    s t s her or                            nd        ha he tes
 advied,i i t ef e,O RD ER ED ,AD JU DG ED a DECR EED t tt Pari '

   i      i n or r f        n i lt de DE 78 , nd h a s r b
 Jo ntM oto f Ent y o Connde ta iy Or r( # )be a t e s m ei he e y,
 DENIED.

               nd          n    m s he am
       D O NE a O RD ER ED i Cha ber att J esLawr       ng    al us i
                                                 ence K i Feder J tce

   l ng        t    a es sr c     t e, am , orda hi h             obe ,
 Buidi and U nied St t D iti tCourhous M i i Fl i t s 26t day ofOct r


  01
 21.                                            .   '            v
                                                                 .
                                                                     /
                                   ,-   f                    N
                                             ES LA W N CE KI G       z
                                                                    z'
                                            I              STRI JU G E
                                             TED STA TES D I   CT
                                        SOU TH ERN D I    CT
                                                      STRI O F FLORIDA

     le 4 lng             ; s al        e     eri s
 2 R tI 5. Fii U nder Seal Dipos of Seald M at al - A.G ener Polc Unl s ot
                                                             al iy.  es henvies
   ovi      aw,    t ul
 pr ded by l Cour r e orCour or ,pr
                              t der oceedi i t Unied St t Diti Courtar publc and
                                          ngs n he t     a es srct    e    i
      t ii r      ts       i ecor
 Cour flngsa e mater ofpublcr d.
                                            3
Case 1:12-cv-22211-JLK Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/26/2012 Page 4 of 5




  Cc:

  a ntf      e
 Pli lrsCouns l
   an
 A l Jay K luger
   uger     an, l r n, zen,   ne
 K l ,K apl Sive m a Kat & Levi , PL
       Bi ca      e d
 201 S. s yne Boul var
    t
 Suie 1700
    am ,
 M i i FL 331 31
     379-
 305- 9000
 Fax:379-3428
    i: kl e @kl r pln.om
 Emal a ug r ugeka a c
 Joshua Evan Salzt
   rt        al    r nn,
 Pe e z,Ches & H erm a PL
          s yne vd.
 201 S.Bi ca B l
    t
 Suie 1750
    a ,
 M i m i FL 33131
     341-
 305- 3000
   x: -
 Fa 371 6807
    irs lz h-plw.o
 Emaljat@pc i a c m
 Mi    l
   chae B.C hesal
   et      al     r nn,
 Per z,Ches & H er m a PL
        sc yne eva d
 201 S Bi a Boul r
    t
 Suie 1750
   a ,          -
 M im i FL 33131 8424
     341 3000
 305- -
         -
 Fax:371 6807
    i: hea@pc i a c
 Emalmc s l -plw.om
  fe a ' ns l
 De nd ntsCou e
               e    n,
 R obertC harl s K ai Jr.
    i       s a es t ne       w A
 K a n & A s ocit ,Ator ysatLa ,P. .
            r
 900 SE Thid Avenue
    t
 Suie 205
    t        dal
 For Lauder e,FL 3331   6
      768-
 954- 9002

                                       4
Case 1:12-cv-22211-JLK Document 23 Entered on FLSD Docket 10/26/2012 Page 5 of 5



         - 58
  Fax:768 01
     i:kan@ o e p.o
  Emalr i c mplxi c m
     ren         em
 D ar JoelSpi l an
    n      s a es t neysa La , P. .
 K ai & A s oci t ,A tor t w A
           r
 900 SE Thid Avenue
    t
 Suie 205
   .     r e,
 Ft Laude dal FL 3331  6
     768-
 954- 9002
         01
 Fax:768- 58
    i: pil n@ omplxi c m
 Emalds ema c e p.o
 M arc John R andazza
             m    i
 6525 W .W ar SprngsRd.
    t
 Suie 100
         s,
 LasVega N V 8911  8
 888-667-1113
         437-
 Fax:305- 7662
    i: R@ a a z .o
 EmalM l rnd z ac m

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:842
posted:10/27/2012
language:Unknown
pages:5