mmst current method profile

Document Sample
mmst current method profile Powered By Docstoc
					MMST Input Form

Criteria                                 Score %

Methods           Attitudes                14
                  Mental Skills            14
                  Physical Skills          14
                  Knowledge                14
                  Scope                    14
                  Standards                14
                  Complexity               14
Total             Total                   100




Discussion        Interactive              17
                  Electronic Resources     17
                  Physical Resources       17
                  Non Verbal Comms         17
                  Continous Themes         17
                  Peer to Peer             17
                  Total                   100

Lecture           Interactive              50
                  One way                  50
                  Total                   100

Simulation        Deployability            16
                  Fidelity                 9       10
                  Part Tasks               9
                  Immersive                9
                   Haptics                  9
                   Instruments              9
                   Collective               9
                   Updates                  9
                   Scenarios                9
                   Safety                   9
                   Total                   100
                   Simulation%
Tutorial           Real Time Interaction    17
                   Physical Resources       17   16.66666667
                   Electronic Resources     17
                   Audio                    17
                   Visual                   17
                   Text                     17
                   Total                   100
                   Tutorial%
Theory Lesson      Real Time Interaction   50
                   Non Verbal Comms         50
                   Total                   100
                   Theory%
Practical Lesson   Electronic Resources     33
                   Physical Resources       33
                   Fidelity                 33
                   Total                   100
                   Practical%
Self Study         Referencing              33
                   Peer to Peer             33
                   Interactive              33
                   Total                   100
                   Self Study%
Embedded           Procedural              25
                   References              25
                   Software                25
Complex Tasks    25
Total           100
Embedded%
                                       Discussion          Lecture        Simulation     Tutorial   Theory Practical   Self Study    Embedded       Total
                                                                                                    Lesson Lesson
Current Methods Profile                    5                 10               0             10        40      30           5             0              100




                                                        Current Methods Profile
 45
 40
 35
 30
 25
 20
 15
 10
  5
  0
           Discussion     Lecture         Simulation           Tutorial            Theory Lesson    Practical Lesson    Self Study           Embedded




                                    Augmented Reality    Face to Face        CBT         Emulator    EPSS      Forum     IETM        m-Learning         ILE
Current Media Profile                      0                  60              10            0         0          0         0             0               0


                                                        Current Media Profile
      70
      60
60
50
40
30
20
10
 0
Simulator   Tele conference   Virtual World   VLE   Vodcast   Webinar   Web Docs   Total
   10              0                0          0       0        0         20        100
Title of T&E:

Reference:


                                        Current Methods Profile
  45
  40
  35
  30
  25
  20
  15
  10
   5
   0
           Discussion        Lecture    Simulation     Tutorial    Theory   Practical   Self Study Embedded
                                                                   Lesson    Lesson



                             Recommended Methods Blend                                                            Methods
      30
      25
      20
  % 15
      10
       5
                                                                                                                  Total
       0
                                                                                                                  Discussion
                Discussion    Lecture    Simulation     Tutorial   Theory   Practical   Self Study Embedded
                                                                   Lesson    Lesson
                                                              Methods



                                                                                              Web Docs
                                          Methods Blend                                       Webinar
           30
                                                                                              Vodcast             Lecture
           25                                                                                 VLE
           20                                                                                 Virtual World
                                                                                              Tele conference
  %        15                                                                                                     Simulation
                                                                                              Simulator
           10                                                                                 ILE
                                                                                              m-Learning
           5
                                                                                              IETM
           0                                                                                  Forum
                                                                                              EPSS
                                                                                              Emulator
                                                                                              CBT
                                                                                              Face to Face
                                                      Methods                                 Augmented Reality
                                   Media Blend
      30
                                                                             Embedded
      25
                                                                             Self Study
      20                                                                     Practical
                                                                             Theory
   % 15                                                                      Coaching
      10                                                                     Simulation
                                                                             Lecture
       5
                                                                             Discussion
       0




                                            Media


                                  Score %                                        Score %
Methods    Attitudes                 14             Tutorial     Real Time             17
           Mental Skills             14                          Interaction
                                                                 Physical              17
           Physical Skills           14                          Resources
                                                                 Electronic            17
           Knowledge                 14                          Resources
                                                                 Audio                 17
           Scope                     14                          Visual                17
           Standards                 14                          Text                  17
           Complexity                14                          Total                100
Total      Total                    100             Theory       Real Time             50
Discussion Interactive               17             Lesson       Interaction
                                                                 Non Verbal            50
           Electronic Resources      17                          Comms
                                                                 Total                100
           Physical Resources        17             Practical    Electronic            33
           Non Verbal Comms          17             Lesson       Resources
                                                                 Physical              33
           Continous Themes          17                          Resources
                                                                 Fidelity              33
           Peer to Peer              17                          Total                100
           Total                    100             Self Study   Referencing           33
Lecture    Interactive               50                          Peer to Peer          33
           One way                   50                          Interactive           33
           Total                    100                          Total                100
Simulation Deployability             16             Embedded     Procedural            25
           Fidelity                  9                           References            25
           Part Tasks                9                           Software              25
           Immersive                 9                           Complex Tasks         25
           Haptics                   9                           Total                100
           Instruments               9
           Collective                9
           Updates                   9
           Scenarios                 9
           Safety                    9
           Total                    100
Course Title                                                                             Total Hours       18
Course Reference

        Ref No.                      TO/Lesson             Methods               Media                 Hours
1.1.1              Introduction                  Self_Study          CBT                                   0.5
                                                 Self_Study          VLE                                     1
                                                 Lecture             Vodcast                               0.5
                                                 Discussion          Webinar                               0.5
                                                 Tutorial            Face2Face                               4
1.1.2              Familiarisation               Simulation          Emulator                                2
                                                 Practical           Face2Face                               1
1.1.3              SOPs                          Self_Study          CBT                                     2
                                                 Theory              Face2Face                               2
                                                 Embedded            IETM                                  0.5
                                                 Simulation          Emulator                                1
1.1.4              Assessment                    Simulation          Simulator                               1
                                                 Practical           Webinar                                 2
Notes

                                                                                   MMST Media Blend
                     30

                     25

                     20

                 % 15
                     10

                     5

                     0




                                                                                       Media



                                                                             Actual Media Blend
        AR           F2F       CBT         Emulator   EPSS       Forum        IETM    Simulator
                 0         7         2.5          3          0           0        0.5         1

             8

             7

          6
        H
          5
        o
     5
   o
   u 4
   r 3
   s
     2

      1

      0
                AR           F2F   CBT       Emulator    EPSS   Forum        IETM     Simulator




                                                                MMST Methods Blend
           30

           25

           20

     % 15
           10

           5

           0
                     Discussion    Lecture        Simulation    Tutorial        Theory Lesson




                                                                           Methods



                                                                Actual Methods Blend
Discussion Lecture    Simulation Tutorial Theory   Practical Self_Study Embedded
       0.5        0.5          4         4       2          3       3.5      0.5

     4.5
  4.5

    4

  3.5

    3
H
o 2.5
u
r   2
s 1.5

    1

  0.5

    0
        Discussion   Lecture   Simulation   Tutorial
MMST Media Blend

                                                                           Embedded
                                                                           Self Study
                                                                           Practical
                                                                           Theory
                                                                           Coaching
                                                                           Simulation
                                                                           Lecture
                                                                           Discussion




Media Blend
              ILE       mLearning TeleConf Vir World   VLE       Vodcast Webinar Webdocs   Total
                    0           0        0         0         1        0.5     2.5      0           18
         Simulator         ILE     mLearning    TeleConf   Vir World   VLE   Vodcast   Webinar      Webdocs
                   Media



                                                                                Web Docs
 Methods Blend                                                                  Webinar
                                                                                Vodcast
                                                                                VLE
                                                                                Virtual World
                                                                                Tele conference
                                                                                Simulator
                                                                                ILE
                                                                                m-Learning
                                                                                IETM
                                                                                Forum
   Theory Lesson     Practical Lesson    Self Study        Embedded
                                                                                EPSS
                                                                                Emulator
                                                                                CBT
                                                                                Face to Face
                                                                                Augmented Reality


Methods Blend
                                        Total
                                                18
Tutorial             Theory   Practical   Self_Study   Embedded
           Methods
Benefits Analysis

                                          Current         MMST
Course Title                              Test
Reference Number                          T001

Length of Course in Hours                           200

Instructor Ratios
                            Discussion             4
                               Lecture            40
                            Simulation            10
                               Tutorial            2
                                Theory            20
                              Practical           10
                            Self_Study           200
                            Embedded            1000

          Average Instructor Capitation        60000
            Instructor Hours per course
       Number of Instructors per Course

Students
            Average Number per Course             20
             Average Student Capitation        30000
               Average T&S per Student           100

Set Up Resources
                            Classroom
                            Equipment
                              Software
                                  Misc

Ongoing Resources
                            Classrooms
                            Equipment
                              Handouts
                                   Misc
                                             Discussion   Lecture   Simulation Tutorial

                        Current                    5         10         0           10
                        Instructor Hours           50        10         0           200


                        MMST Methods                7         9         16           14
                        Instructor Hours           71         9         66          271

                                                        Face        C
                                             Augmented Realityto Face BT       Emulator
                                                 2           26          6          5
Set Up

                        Current costs per Course
Ongoing
          Instructors
            Students


                                0
                            41096
Theory      Practical   Self Study Embedded   Total       Cost
Lesson      Lesson
    40          30         5           0            100
    80         120         1           0            461          9473


       16        7         24          7            100
       31       29         5           0            482          9910

EPSS        Forum       IETM     m-Learning   ILE                              Virtual VLE
                                                          Simulator Tele conference World
       2        3           4         2              2        7          2          6      10


                                 Vars
                                 Instperhr     20.54795
                                 Studperhr     10.27397
Vodcast   Webinar   Web Docs Total
    4        13        6        100
                               Enter      For each        Hover          The rest of   Methods
                               Data in    group divide    over small     the
                               this       100 between     red            worksheet
                               column     each criteria   triangles      is locked.
                                                          for more
                                                          info
Criteria                       Score % Discussion         Lecture        Simulation Tutorial        Theory
                                                                                                    Lesson
             Attitudes               14             30               0            25           15            10
             Mental Skills           14              0              10            30           10            20
             Physical Skills         14              0               0            20           30             0
             Knowledge               14             10              20             0            0            20
             Scope                   14             10              10            10            0            10
             Standards               14              0               0            30           20            20
             Complexity              14              0              20             0           20            30

Total        Total                  100    7.14285714 8.571429 16.428571 13.57143 15.71429

                                                                                        Media
                                          Augmented       Face to        CBT           Emulator EPSS
                                          Reality         Face
Discussion   Interactive             17               0             25             0            0             0
             Electronic              17               0              0             0            0             0
             Resources
             Physical                17               0         100                0            0             0
             Resources
             Non Verbal              17               0             70             0            0             0
             Comms
             Continous               17               0              0             0            0             0
             Themes
             Peer to Peer            17               0       20                   0            0             0
             Total                  100               0 35.83333                   0            0             0
             Discussion %                             0 2.559524                   0            0             0
Lecture      Interactive             50                       50
             One way                 50
             Total                  100               0       25                   0            0             0
             Lecture%                                 0 2.142857                   0            0             0
Simulation   Deployability           16                                                        50
             Fidelity                 9                             60
             Part Tasks               9                                                        70
             Immersive                9
             Haptics                  9                                                        30
             Instruments              9                                                        70
             Collective               9                             20
             Updates                  9                             40                         10
             Scenarios                9                             40
             Safety                   9
             Total                  100               0       15                   0 24.6875                  0
             Simulation%                              0 2.464286                   0 4.055804                 0
Tutorial           Real Time        17                   50
                   Interaction
                   Physical         17                   70
                   Resources
                   Electronic       17
                   Resources
                   Audio            17
                   Visual           17                   60
                   Text             17                    0
                   Total           100           0       30         0        0         0
                   Tutorial%                     0 4.071429         0        0         0
Theory Lesson      Real Time        50                   50
                   Interaction
                   Non Verbal       50                   90
                   Comms
                   Total           100           0       70         0        0         0
                   Theory%                       0       11         0        0         0
Practical Lesson   Electronic       33
                   Resources
                   Physical         33          20       70
                   Resources
                   Fidelity         33                   100
                   Total           100   6.66666667 56.66667        0        0         0
                   Practical%            0.47619048 4.047619        0        0         0
Self Study         Referencing      33                                                10
                   Peer to Peer     33
                   Interactive      33                             70
                   Total           100           0        0 23.333333        0 3.333333
                   Self Study%                   0        0 5.6666667        0 0.809524
Embedded           Procedural       25          30                                   40
                   References       25
                   Software         25                                      60
                   Complex Tasks    25           70                                  20
                   Total           100           25       0         0       15       15
                   Embedded%             1.78571429       0         0 1.071429 1.071429

Media Results                            2.26190476 26.28571 5.6666667 5.127232 1.880952


                                         Media Blend
       30

       25

       20

   % 15
       10

           5
0




    Media
                                                                                          Methods Blend
                                                       30
                                                       25
Practical Self Study Embedded Total                    20
Lesson
         0         20        0    100                % 15
        10         20        0    100                  10
        40         10        0    100                   5
         0         30       20    100
                                                        0
         0         30       30    100
                                                            Discussion Lecture Simulation Tutorial          Theory    Practical
         0         30        0    100                                                                       Lesson     Lesson
         0         30        0    100                                                             Methods

7.142857      24.28571    7.1428571       100


Forum        IETM        m-Learning ILE         Simulator Tele       Virtual        VLE       Vodcast       Webinar
                                                          conference World
         0          0             0         0           0            25        25      0                0            25
        25          0             0         0           0             0        25     25                0            25

         0          0             0         0           0              0        0         0             0             0

         0          0             0         0           0              0        0         0             0            30

        60          0             0         0           0              0        0     20                0

       0            0             0         0           0         20       20  20                       0         20
14.16667            0             0         0           0         7.5 11.6667 10.8                      0    16.6667
1.011905            0             0         0           0 0.53571429 0.83333 0.77                       0    1.19048
                                                                                                                  50
                                                                                                 100
         0          0             0         0           0              0        0         0       50              25
         0          0             0         0           0              0        0         0 4.285714         2.14286
                                           30                                  20
                                                       40
                                                       20                      10
                                           20          50                      30
                                                       50                      20
                                                       30
                                                       40                      40
                                           20          10                      20
                                           20          10                      30
                                                      100
         0          0             0 10.313        32.8125              0 17.1875          0             0             0
         0          0             0 1.6942       5.390625              0 2.82366          0             0             0
                                                            10                              40

                                                 30

                                                                    20                      80

                                                            60      20                       20
                                                 20                                          20
                                                                          80                 20
          0         0             0    0    8.333333 11.6666667 6.66667 13.3        0        30
          0         0             0    0    1.130952 1.58333333 0.90476 1.81        0   4.07143
                                                                     20                      30

                                                                                            10

          0         0             0    0          0          0      10     0        0        20
          0         0             0    0          0          0 1.57143     0        0   3.14286
                                                                                            100

                                                                                            10


          0         0             0    0          0          0       0     0        0   36.6667
          0         0             0    0          0          0       0     0        0   2.61905
                   20                                                     20
      30                                                                  70
                                30
      10      6.666667          10     0          0          0       0   30         0        0
2.428571      1.619048   2.4285714     0          0          0       0 7.29         0        0
                    30
                    70

                    10
          0       27.5            0    0          0          0       0     0        0        0
          0   1.964286            0    0          0          0       0     0        0        0

3.440476      3.583333   2.4285714 1.6942   6.521577 2.11904762 6.13318 9.87 4.285714   13.1667


                                                                 Methods Blend
                             30

Embedded                     25
Self Study
                             20
Practical
Theory                   % 15
Coaching
                             10
Simulation
Lecture                       5
Discussion   0
                 Discussion   Lecture   Simulation   Tutorial   Theory   Practical   Self Study
                                                                Lesson    Lesson




                                                            Methods
Methods Blend




           Practical Self Study Embedded
            Lesson




            Web Total
            Docs
                 0                 100
                 0                 100

                 0                 100

                 0                 100

                20                 100

                0                 100
             3.33                 100
             0.24         7.142857143
                                  100
                                  100
                 0                100
                 0        8.571428571
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                                  100
                 0                100
                 0        16.42857143
              100

              100

              100

               100
               100
               100
  0            100
  0    13.57142857
               100

              100

  0            100
  0    15.71428571
               100

              100

               100
  0            100
  0    7.142857143
 50            100
               100
               100
16.7           100
4.05   24.28571429
               100
 30            100
 40            100
               100
17.5           100
1.25   7.142857143

5.54          100
                                 100

                 Web Docs
                 Webinar
                 Vodcast
                 VLE
                 Virtual World
                 Tele conference
                 Simulator
                 ILE
                 m-Learning
                 IETM
                        IETM

Self Study   Embedded   Forum
                        EPSS
                        Emulator
                        CBT
                        Face to Face
                        Augmented Reality
                       Media
Methods   Discussion   Face2Face     Forum       Teleconf   Virt World VLE      Webinar
          Lecture      Face2Face     Webinar Vodcast
          Simulation   Face2Face     Emulator ILE           Simulator Virt World
          Tutorial     Face2Face     Simulator Teleconf     Virt World VLE       Webinar
          Theory       Face2Face     Virt World Webinar
          Practical    Face2Face     Aug Reality Webinar
          Self_Study   CBT           EPSS        Forum      IETM      mLearning VLE
          Embedded     Aug Reality   Emulator EPSS          IETM      Web Docs
Web Docs
                                     Discussion         Lecture       Simulation    Tutorial
Current Methods Profile                  5               10.0             0           10
MMST Methods Profile                     7                8.6            16           14


                                  Augmented Reality   Face to Face       CBT        Emulator
Current Media Profile                    0                60.0            10           0
MMST Media Profile                       2                26.3            6            5


Methods Conversion                     Change         % Reduction Assumptions
                   Discussion            2.1              0.9     50% of Discussion can be online in 20% of th
                      Lecture            -1.4
                  Simulation            16.4              3.3        Simulation will reduce training time (mainly
                      Tutorial           3.6
                       Theory           -24.3
                     Practical          -22.9
                  Self_Study            19.3              9.6        Self Study (mainly CBT) reduces learning tim
                  Embedded               7.1              7.1        Embedded replaces training time 100%
% Course Length Reduction                0.0             20.9                      % Reduction including Self Stu

Media Conversion
           Augmented Reality             2.3              1.1        AR reduces learning time by 50%
                  Face to Face          -33.7
                           CBT           -4.3             -2.2       CBT reduces learning time by 50%
                     Emulator            5.1              1.0        Simulation reduces training time by 20%
                          EPSS           1.9              1.9        EPSS is embeded
                        Forum            3.4              2.8        Online forums reduce discussion time by 80%
                         IETM            3.6              0.7        IETMs reduce learning time by 20% overall
                   m-Learning            2.4              0.7        m-Learning reduces learning time by 30%
                            ILE          1.7              0.3        Simulation reduces training time by 20%
                    Simulator            -3.5             -0.7       Simulation reduces training time by 20%
              Tele conference            2.1
                Virtual World            6.1              1.2        Simulation reduces training time by 20%
                           VLE           9.9              4.9        Online learning reduces learning time by 50%
                      Vodcast            4.3                         Replaces lecture so no reduction
                      Webinar           13.2                         Replaces lecture so no reduction
                    Web Docs            -14.5                        Cost saving but no time savings
% Course Length Reduction                0.0              12                       % Reduction including Self Stu
             Theory Lesson Practical Lesson         Self Study   Embedded     Total
                  40              30                     5          0          100
                  16               7                    24          7          100


                  EPSS              Forum             IETM       m-Learning    ILE    Simulator Tele conference
                   0                  0                 0            0          0        10            0
                   2                  3                 4            2          2         7            2




 sion can be online in 20% of the time

ll reduce training time (mainly practical) by 20%




ainly CBT) reduces learning time by 50%
places training time 100%
 % Reduction including Self Study                      31


arning time by 50%

earning time by 50%
duces training time by 20%

s reduce discussion time by 80%
 learning time by 20% overall
educes learning time by 30%
duces training time by 20%
duces training time by 20%

duces training time by 20%
ng reduces learning time by 50%
ure so no reduction
ure so no reduction
ut no time savings
 % Reduction including Self Study                      25
Virtual World   VLE   Vodcast   Webinar Web Docs   Total
      0          0       0        0       20           100
      6         10       4        13       6           100

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:2
posted:10/4/2012
language:Latin
pages:37