ns articlereview

Document Sample
ns articlereview Powered By Docstoc
					Article review for Nature and Science

Dear Colleague,

I would be grateful if you could kindly review the enclosed manuscript that has been submitted to Nature
and Science (ISSN 1545-0740, http://www.sciencepub.net/nature).

Please use the following evaluation category for you evaluation.

1. Corrections, comments and suggestions to this article:

2. Academic:
A. Very Good
B. Good
C. Preliminary
D. Poor
E. Very Poor
This article match (select one of the above levels):

3. Understandable:
A. Very Good
B. Good
C. Normal
D. Poor
E. Very Poor
This article match (select one of the above levels):

4. Valuation
A. Top 5%
B. Top 10%
C. Top 25%
D. Top 50%
E. Bottom 50%
Compared with other articles in the field, judge this article to be in the rank (select one of the above levels):

5. Recommendation:
A. Accept Now
B. Accept with Minor Amendment
C. Re-evaluate with Major Amendment
D. Reject
This article is recommended (select one of the above levels):

6. Description of your evaluation, recommendation and suggestions on this article if you have any:

If you cannot review this article, please email to me.

Thank you very much for your help!

Sincerely yours,

Ma Hongbao, Editor-in-Chief, PhD, Professor
Nature and Science
Marsland Press
PO Box 180432, Richmond Hill, New York 11418, USA
Telephone: 347-321-7172
E-mail: sciencepub@gmail.com; editor@sciencepub.net
Website: http://www.sciencepub.net

Shared By: