Instructions to Reviewers by wlJtk55

VIEWS: 1 PAGES: 3

									                                    The Society of Earth Scientists
            e-Journal Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
                                  Email: earthscienceindia@gmail.com



                                     Reviewers Guide

PART A: Editorial Office Only

SECTION I

Reviewer’s Name:
E-Mail:
Affiliation:
Title:



Date Sent To Reviewer:
Date Expected From Reviewer:
Areas of Specialisation (if you
wish to add your names and
affiliation as a reviewer)



PART B: Reviewer Only

SECTION II: Comments per Section of Manuscript

                         Is the length of the paper adequate?


                         Are the title and the abstract pertinent, descriptive and concise?


                         Does the paper contain new data or new ideas or both of them?


                         Is the language fluent and precise?
General comment:

                         Does the author give proper credit to related work and does he/she indicate clearly
                         his/her own contribution?


                         The figures are up to the mark in quality/ printing?
                                      Technical Comments

Introduction:



Main content:




Results:




Conclusion/Discussion:



SECTION II (Cont.)



References:



Others:



Decision:




SECTION III - Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)

Originality:
Contribution To The
Field:
Technical Quality:
Clarity of Presentation :
Depth of Research:
SECTION IV - Recommandation: (Kindly Mark With An ‘X’)

Accept As Is:
Requires Minor Corrections:
Requires Moderate Revision:
Requires Major Revision:
Submit To Another Publication Such As:




Reject On Grounds of (Please Be Specific):




SECTION V: Additional Comments

(Reviewer can also make comments on the body of MS: correction codes are - Red color – Incorporate;
Blue Color – Delete; Green Color - Consider and include appropriately)


Please add any additional comments (if any):

								
To top