Get documents about "university of illinois trademark complaint
Document Sample
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 1 of 30
E-FILED
Thursday, 06 September, 2012 05:42:54 PM
Clerk, U.S. District Court, ILCD
~T~~~~~ ~~~I~~~~~i
LJI'~T~~I~~.~~~'~~ C~~' I~,~,II~TO~S,
~1air~~zfr, ~~s~ ~T~.
J~adg~
1~~.U~~~~ t~✓~~k~~,~I°~~, ~n i~~avi~~al d/b/~ I~~~z~tz°~t~ J~d~~
~~~~n~az~t.
I'laxz~ti~ ~'he flax°d oz Tz°ust~es ~f t~~ IJniv~rsit~ c~z Ill~r~~is (`~~'lai~ti~r ' ox `~t~~
"
~Jniv~rszty"~ by az~d tl~z°c~~~~h its attor~~y~, ~'r~;~b~~i°n ~ ~~t~rs ~,i,P, ~o~~p~ains ~~ainst ~~f~,~dant
l~~u~i~~ I~/I~hlin~, a~ individual ~/b/a Proje~9 fie' "I~ef~r~d~nt" ox `~~'zr~j~~t ~'~"') ~s ~o11ow~:
(
1. Tl~i~ is a civil ~~;ti~n alleging dix~~t ~~d/oz° ~o~al~z~ib~ztc~ry ~x~d~rnaa°~ ar~~zi~g~~~sa~,
ur~~~zz° ~o~petiti~~, ar~~ tz~d~r~a~l~ dzlutio~ ax~isir~~ u~d~~• ~~~ti~ns 32 and ~3 o~'tka~ Lanham ~c;t, 1 ~
U.S.C. §§ 1114{1)~a) Utz°ode ~z°k in~z°x~g~rr~~x~~), 112~(~) {azz~fai~• ~~~zp~titi~a~), aid X125{~)
(~~~~1~ ~~1~ ~il~t~o~~, as will ~s ~i~l~tfo~~ ~f the ~llz~~~as ~'z°a.~~ ~rl~ ~~~istratzc~n ar~d ~'xs~t~~~~~n
l~.~t, 765 I~,~~ § 103~/l, ~ts~q., ~llzzaois ~?~~~ptiv~ ~'~ad~ ~t°a~ta~~s pct, $1~ I~~~~ ~ 510/1, et.s~q.,
Illia~oas C~nsuz~z~r ~'~aud a~~ ~e~ep~~v~ ~~iszne~s ~ra~~i~~~ l~~t, X 15 ~I,~~ ~ X05/J , et seq.,
~c~~~z~ 1~~~~ zni.sappa•~pxi~t~c~s~ ~f tz°a.d~z~~r~~, and ~~z~zn~n l~vv u~faix ~~~~~t~~~r~.
2. ~s d~s~z°ib~d z~.oz~~ f~11y l~elo~v, wit~Z~ut tk~~ authorzty ~f the Ur~1v~x~rty, ~e~~ndant
h~.s ananufactuz•~d and ~~ld c~~hiz•~s t~.~~ ~~pz~~ssly extol "dz•z~l~ing" and c`d~bau~h~ry," ~~d that b~ax
c~~°t~ir~ ~~z of the IJnzv~z~sily, i~cl~din~, but got lx~rzat~d t~, the LJnivcrszty's Ul~iI~T~,I~~~T~I ~~
°ks
1
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 2 of 30
I~~,~I°~iO~S w~z~d .ark, its "~~,~~Y ~" ~~sa_~n r~~a~~c, ar~~ its ~I~~~~' I~,I,I~°~:f~V~~~ ~l~s~~;n ~~xlc.
~~fe~da~t's ~.~~authc~xi~~d u~~ of suc;~ rra~rk~ 1~~~ pz~od~~~d. a~~ will ~~nti~u~ tc~ pzod~~~ ~;~~~~.z~~z
~~nfu~~.~~ ~n~1 ~~~~~o~ic~n, ~n~ will d~lut~ aid taxr~ish the ~J1niv~x~ily'~ tra~~~n~rk~.
3. /~lkh~u~h ~~f~ncl~nt ~a~ b~~z~ apps°is~~l cif its i~l~~al ~o~d~~t, at h~~ l~rg~ly i~r~c~r~d
chi ~J~iv~z°sity's cs~rr~r~~tzni~a~i~zas ~n~ d~lib~xat~~_y x~fus~d t~ ~~rr~ply with tie ~J~~v~z~sity's
~l~~azads, thereby anif~stir~~ its ir~t~z~t icy ~~ntinu~ t~ wx~r~~f~.~lly ~~~i•~r~~~ ~pc~n, ~.ilut~ az~~1 t~rni~~
the Ua~i~~z•szty'~ tx~c~~ ~x1~s. I1~l~s~ ~~jo~n~d, I~~f~r~daz~t ~vz~l ~~.~?~~ fi~Y°tt1~~x z~z°~p~~°~bl~ z~j~ary,
l~,av~r~g ~~~ YT~iv~z~sity with zoo ~.~1~~u~~~ r~ ~dy at law. ~~ ~~l~zti~n, the ~Jz~iv~~•s~~y s~~~~~ ara ~w~rd
of d~rn~g~s a~~ X11 a~~~~nta~g ~f ~~f~r~da~~'s r~~~n~~s ~n~/~x pr~_~its, ~s ;~v~ll ~s attc~z~~ys' ~~~~,
~~sts, end. ~xp~~as~s fc~r 3~~~f~nd~r~t's z~it~ntz~nal ~z~d wzllfu~ ~or~du~t.
~. l~l~i~ti~f, Thy ~o~rcl of ~'rus~~~s o~ the LJ~iv~rsi~y ~f~ ~lliza~is, i_~ a booty ~o~iti~ ~;n~
~o_rps~ra~~ ~~t~blisk~~d ~,~nd~r 11~~ ~!~~stit~tiQ~. ~a~d ~aw~ ofthe ~t~t~ ~f ~llir~c~is, t~o ~ov~~~z~ ~n~. ~~~~~~is~
~u~ka~rity c~~~~r tl~~ '~Tr~iv~x°sity ~f Illinois, wh~s~ oz°igirz~l ~~z~npu~ is lc~~at~d in Urb~r~a-~harz~~~i~n.
~l~i~t~ff is z~f~xr~~ try b.~z°~i~ as "tl~~ ~J~iv~rsit~."
~. ~~;f~~~az~t I~/~au~~ic~ 1~~~1zn~ ~s ~za iradividu~l ~vs~~, ~z~ zz~:co~ ~~is~n ~r~~ belief,
z°~sid~~ ~t 2209 ~~~t U~~v~~°~ity ~v~,, ~t~, ~, IJg°b~r~~, Illz~a~z~ 5~~02, and i~ ~~zng 1~~a.~z~~~~ ~~
~roj~~t ~'~', a ~~ast~~ s~r~~z~ ~rr~tin~ ~n~l ~~r~.bz°oid~x°y b~szr~~~s ~rztiiy with its pxiz~~ip~[ ~la~~ cif
b~~in~~~ ~1so ~t 2209 East ~Tz~~~~xsity l~v~., Sty, ~, IJzb~r~a, Illizaois 61 ~~2.
~T~~~~~~'~~~1 ~1~1~ ~1~~T~
6. ~'~s ~~tion ~ris~s ~~~~x ~t~.~ ~1~it~d ~tat~s ~'r~d~s~ax°1~ ~,~vv~, ~oz~ra~s~r~l~ ~~~w~ ~~
the I~anha~ l~~t. T'l~as ~oux~Y has c~ri~inal s~bj~~~ m~tt~~ juz•isdi~ti~r~ over ~hi~ act~o~ ~ursu~nt to 15
~J.~.~". § 1121 (Lar~h~z~ ~~~); 2~ IJ.~.~. ~ 1331 (~d~z°~l qu~sti~za)9 ar~~ 2~ IJ.~.~;. ~ 133~(~)
(txader~axk ~c~ions~. The ~ouz~ h~~ ~Lippl~m.~ntal juris~i~tion ~av~z ~l~intif~'s ~th~r ~lai~s
~~,
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 3 of 30
pu~•sua~t ~0 2~ ~J.~.~. ~ ~36'7(~). i,h~~ a~tx~n is got ~ ~~ll~siv~ one to ~oz~~~~° j~?x°zscl~~t~or~ o~ ~ ~ol~~t
~f'~1~~ U~it~~ ~t~t~~ that z~ would ~o~ <~th~rwis~ I~~v~.
%, ~T~~u~ is ~z~o~~r Sri ti~i~ d~~iz•i~t u~d~x 2~ U.~.~. §§ 13~1(b) ~~~d {~), in that t1~~
~ef~~~~n~ txaz~~~~t~ busir~~~~ within thas ju~ti~~al ~ist~•z~t9 ~_z~~l~di~_~ tk~~ s~l~ ~f iza~ir~giz~g pxodu~t~
~?~dl~~° ~~xvx~~~ ~~at are tl~~ s~abj~~t ~f chis a~ti~r~.
~. `~'k~~ ~J~.iv~xsity c~~n~ nuYraexou~ l~~bmsta~~li~~ a~z~l w~llml~nown t~~~c~~z~ariz~, to°~~1~
~.~z~.~s, and logos that axe used in ~c~nn~~~ic~r~ v~ith the LJnxv~r~i~y, its ~~hl~tic t~;~z~~, and
~r~ha~dis~ sold by the LT~iv~~sz~y b~~xin~ those rr~arks.
~3. ~oz~ znan~ y~~z°~, the IJ~iv~rsity grad its au~hc~xia~~ bu~in~s~ p~~°~~~r~, sponsor
aid/air li~~a~s~~s, hive ~~~d tl~e~e txadem.arl~s, sp~~ifi~ally in~lu~i~g, foa~ p~rpos~s of this
C~~ra~l~int, the UI~~SI~~S~~'Y Ok' ~~,LII'~~I~ word z~~rl~, t~~ "~~,O~I~ I'" d~si~z~ maxl~, end the
~~IE~ I~,~,~I~iI~IE~ cl~si~,;n z~ar~c, zn ~~z~~~~tzoz~ with the IJ~iv~p°si~ty's busi~~ss ref s~x~~nazi~~,
~~~du~tz~~, ar~~ ~i°~zn~t~z~~ the Llt~xv~rsi~y cif Illinois ire ~Jrbaz~~Po~h~a~~a~bn,
1(~. ~a~ ~lditi~n ~~ ~~z~mon lave t~•~~l~a~~rl~ ir~ht~ in t~a~ z~iarA~s s~~ ~~at~a zza. ~'~r~~~°a~1~ 9,
Thy ~7a~%v~z°sity i~ the ~~~l~siv~ ~~razz~~° s~f t~~ fs~ll~v~in~ v~lic~, ~a~~~nt~s~a'c~l~, ~z~~~ ~z~fo~~~abl~
tr~.d~z~~xlc ~~~istrati~r~s rn~ith t1z~ ~Jnit~~l ~ta~~~ ~~t~nt ~n~1 "~'~aderra~xl~ ~~~i~~("LT~~~'O"), among
€~~h~r~:
k~~~i~tx~ti~~n 1°~T~. 1,~3b,2~1 fox LJI~TI~T~~~I~'~' Ok` ~~,L~1,T~I~
~,~,A~ZI~TII~~G ~ ~,1~~3~~ ~~IA~TF~~I~ 1X67 ~.G~ICUI,~'~7~Z~.
~~~~;I~i~~; fi~ A~~'deign ~xl~ fog°, a~z~~n~ ~t~~r ~~o~l~ aza~ s~rvi~~s,
ccb~~~S9 ~c~~5~ ~7.~15~ ~~1~~59 ~t~A~~ll~ ~~~CS~y~~ SW~~~S~1x~59 SW~~~p~X1~S~
sw~atja~l~~ts, warms-up suits, shiz'ts, sl~~z°fig, j~~l~~ts, ir~~a~t weax,
~l~~pw~~~, paa~ts, r~i~w~ag°, l~nitw~~r; z~a~a~ly ~l~v~~;, ~itt~z~~,
~~arv~s, ~o~l~s" iz~ ~l~ss 25 (IJ.~. Clasp 3~),
3
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 4 of 30
~gistratz~r~o i~T~. 2431 x,363 fog "~3~,~~5~ I" ~~~i~r~ mark ~o~°, ~z~~~~;
oth~~° ~oo~s ~n~ s~~v~~~s, "~1~1~aaz~~, ~azn~ly, f~~rons, ~.d~al'~ az~d
~l~.il~lr~n's ja~k~ts, ~r~d vests, z~~n'~ s~i~-t~, spirt s~iz-t~, ties, z~i~ht
shii-~s, ~,~cli~s' tips, adult ~~d chilclr~z~'~ j~r~~y~, ~~.ps, ~po~t yaps,
V1bOS ~~~5y 5k1 ~C`~~~J~ 5~~1V~S9 ~W~~L~Z`S9 bOTa.C~7~S~ ~~43V~S~ S~J1L~~;SAS~
gold s~v~~t~z~s, la~i~s' ~n~ ra1~~'s and ~hil~r~n's t-shirts, baseball
shi~~ts, ~oQtb~l~ shit°ts, f~ot'oa11-style jexs~ys, l~di~s' and rnens's
~~o~1s, so~l~s, adult and ~ha~~lx~r~'s w~rz~-up ~~zts, baby s~~~p~rs,
baby shiq-t~, w~st~rca hats, t~z~nis ;~at~, r~v~°ist..b~~i~ds ~~~ sva~atb~n~s"
iz~ ~1~~~ ~S (~J.~. ~lass~s 22 ~~~ 39); ~~c1
~gzs~~~~ion I~io. 2,2 2,024 ~o~ the ~~~~~' I~,~~~~~~~I~~ d~si~;~
~z•1~ ~~r, az~~ng ot~~x ~oo~s end sex°vies, "~~t~t~i~g, ~. .~1y9
apz°ons, ~~1~1~ ja~l~~ts, arad vests, en's s~i~~1~, spur% shirt, tics,
L,~.di~~' t~~~, yaps, spo~'~ ~~ps, visor• ~:~~~, s1~i yaps, ~~~rv~s, sva~at~~s,
~~r~~hos, ~~~z ~w~at~x~, ladies' ~r~d z~~r~'~ .and ~;hild~°en's t-s~~rts,
f~c~~ba~l ~hzz~~, baby sl~~p~~°~, baby shits, t~n~1~s h~~s" iz~ ~las~ 25
{U.~. ~1ass~~ 2~ ~z~d 3~).
1 11 of t1~~ ~~x~z~aor~ law ~~d ~~~zs~~~ed ~~~°l~s sit foz-t~~ in ~~z°age°aph~ 9 aid 10 are ~c~ll~~~iv~ly
~E~~xr~c~ t~ h~z~~~z~ ~s Xh~ 6`~~~e~~~~~~~a~ ~~°,~~." ~'ru~ ~~n~ ~oxr~~t ~c~pz~s cif t~~ r~~i~tr~~z~r~.
~~z~tifi~;~te~, ~l~z~~ wzth prim ~~ts ~f ~h~ st~tu~ ~i ~a~l~ z•~giJ~~~~~d rriazk fr~z~ t~~ ~1~~~'~'s
data~ZS~, ~r~ r~s~~ctiv~ly attash~~l ~s ~xhibit~ ~—~ ~er~to.
"11. ~'la~+~~gl~ ~l~~ad~s ~f l~~b~ta~adiz~~ ~n.d ~o~atz~.~~1 use, t~~ ~Jz~iv~7•s~ty'~ tz°~.d~z~~rl~s,
ix~~l~c~~nb, ~u~ ~~t l~~it~~l t~, ~kz~ ~J;~ivexsicy I~~zl~s, k~~.v~ d~v~l~~~d ~xt~~a~iv~ ~~~~~aill ~z~~. h~v~
a~t~~n~d a ~ai~~ ~l~gz~~~ ~f ~°~cog~itios~ ~~ad dist~n~tiv~n~ss tl~zou~~.ou~ ~h~ ~J.~. zn ~~~r~~~tioz~ wz~h
~s~~d~ end ~~.c~~i~~~ ~~g~~~r~ly a.s~o~iate~ ~vit~ ~ ur~iver~~ty as a~ ~d~~~tior~~l ira~t~tu~i~~.
~2, ~~r~k~~~~r~ and ~r~~p~~tiv~ p~x~:k7as~~~, as ~~11 ~s ~~ka~r z~.~~&~~r~ of the pub1~~, are
farnili~,~• with the Ua~iv~~sity 1~✓~~1°l~s ar~~ a,ssoci~t~ the ~Jni~~r~i~y ~.~~k~ vait~ the ~Jxaiv~rsx~y; ~h~~
~nd~z~tand ~r~d ~~~~~t ~~at ~. wide vex°i~ty of gods ~.n~l s~~vi~~s off~z~~d ire ~on~~~~io~ with Gh~
LJnzv~rsity I az•k~ aa°~ af~ili~t~~, sp~n~~r~~, ~n~/ox l~c~ns~d by the ~Tz~iversit~.
13. :~'h~ Uz~iv~xsity I~~•ks az•~ ~r~s~~tly us~~l iz~ ~~~n~~ti~~ ~vitk~ ~, v✓~d_~m~~~z~~~ of ~o~~s
~r~d ~~rvi~~s ~fzer~d by the IJniv~rsity ~~ad its ~uthoxiz~d li~~ns~~:;. (~`e~ E~h~bit ~ ~.ez°eto.)
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 5 of 30
~ 4. ~'h~ Uz~iv~rs~iy Baas ~xp~nd~~l ~~z~~id~~ably azaaouz~~~ ~f t~r~~, ~~f~xt aid ~~p~z~~~ ~~
pr~rr~~t~ xls s~rva~~~ ~n~ prod~~ts throughout the ~Jnit~~ ~tat~~ ~t~~ ~~ prc~t~~t tk~.~ r~~hts ~~~c~~;z~t~d
with the ~Jr~iv~z°sz~y l~ai°l~s.
1 ~. ~~ a result ~~ its ~~t~~.~iv~ i~a~~l~~~tiz~~ ~~forts anal its ~fl~ti~~~~as use of t~~
tT~zv~r~ity I ~.xl~s fog° 1~any ~l~~ad~~, t~~ ~T~~~v~x~~~y hay d~v~lo~~~ ~ubst~z~~aal z•i~~~s end ~o~d~wa~l
z~ the I1s~xv~~~ity 1~/~a.~~l~s, ~z~d ~h~ public 'r~a~ ~o ~ ~c~ ass~o~i~t~ ~u~l~ rr~ac•1~s as id~ra~i£z~rs cif ~oux~~,
a~pxc~val, aid/~x licera~irz~ zap ~~~n~ctic~r~ with t1z~ ~ar~~us ~~s~ds and ~~x°v~c~~ ~ff~~•ed by t~i~
~Jz~iv~a~sity end zts ~uthot•i~~d la~~~s~~s.
16. ~~~~r~~ani i~ ~n~~g~d zn ~~~ ~dv~z~isin~, r~ark~tx~~, ~an~~'a~tuxi~g, s~11a~1g, ~~d
pro~l~~~i~n ~f ~~s~o~ scz~~~n printing ~~~1 ~z~abroi~~z°Y goods and/~r s~xvz~es, s~~h ~~ ~~shirts ~~~
~t~i~r app~x~l, that i~£iri~g~ ~h~ IJniv~rsity's z~azl~s zn tk~~ ~Jr~it~d ~tat~~.
1 %. ~p~~ifz~ally4 ~~f~ndant l~a~ zn~z~ufactur~d ar~d sold t-s'~irts bearir3.g the
~a.z~~~thoxzz~~ ~as~ ~f the IJ~iv~x°sity's t~~ad~z~aaxl~s to t~.i.z~lmpa~~ty ~ons~a~~r~ in ~c~~z~~~tzc~~ vvit~
"`~~J~o~i~i~l" fit. ~~txi~k'~ ~~ ~~x 2~~7.
1 ~. ~~ ir~foz°z~a_~.lic~~ ~z~c1 b~~z~f, "~1s~c~ffi~i_~1" fit. ~~.txic~'s ~y zs a~ ~v~~t h~l~l o~.
~a~~i~~~ ~~r~zv~z•~xty ~~rr~pu~e~ Zr~~un~ tJ~~ ~o~az~tz°y, which aiz~s #c~ z•~pla~~ t~.~ ~~l~bratzo~ ~f t~~
~f~~i~~ St, ~~~tri~k's ~~.~ hc~laday with ~~~~ssiv~ ~riz~~in~ of ~lcc~~c~l. ~'~i~ ~v~r~t z~ ~,ls~al~y
~~l~bxa~t~c~ c~r~~ or two va~elcs'~~~~r~ c~a ~~t~~° a un~v~x~ity'~ ~~px~z~~ b~°~alc.
1 ~. ~n ~x about I~~rch 2, 2011, aChard-~~r~~ zaar~~d k~.i~h~rd ~,acy p7~~vi~~~ a d~~x~z~ ~o
~~f~~dazat ~z~d subz~ilt~~ ~n ~z°dux ~~ II~~~'~n~az~t for s~v~nty~ti~~ (12) tashi~°~s, gall b~ar~a~~ t~~.t
d~si;s~, wzt~a a ~l~po~it ~~ X300.00.
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 6 of 30
20. The design in question resembles the label on a bottle of Budweiser beer, which
itself may infringe Anheuser-Busch's trademarks. The design says "Genuine" on the left and right
side of block wording in the middle, which states, among other things: "Unofficial Day of
Drinking","Quench our Thirst in the Name of Debauchery","World's Largest Shit Show", and, at
the very bottom, "University of Illinois, Champaign, IL." In addition to the University's
UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS word mark, the design also bears other marks of the University,
including, but not limited to, the "BLOCK I" design mark and the CHIEF ILLINIWEK design
mark. The t-shirts bearing this design that were produced and sold by Defendant are hereinafter
referred to as the "`Unofficial' t-shirts," an image of which is attached hereto as Exhibit E and
reproduced immediately below.
2208 E. University Ave. By aiyning Ehis form I hereby approve the arCwork as print ready
Urbana, iL 61802 and am thus liable forthe payment due.
prolculLC2209:?gmail.com Signature
Prink:
217.344.9833 Date:
Fan:344.9835
l~]
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 7 of 30
21. ~~ ~~- ~~~~t i~~rch ~, 2011, ~~f~ndant ~~11~~ 1'e/~r. I~a~y'~ ~~•d~r b~ s~x~e~~ pt•intia~_~
t~~ d~si~;~? c~ni~ the "'U~c~~~icz~1" t-shi~~, p~~~in~; ~~~ c~~si~;~. ~n the Ir~_t~~°nit, ~~d s~l~a~~ 1~~
"~J~flf~"~~ial" ~~shir1:s to I~r. ~,~~~. ~~~~~d~r~~ z°~c~iv~~ a total ~~ X61 x.77 a~ ~~ym~~t. (~S'en ~,~~~
Iiav~i~~, ~tr~~l~~d hereto as ~~~ibi~~ ~'.)
~~. ~'h~t ~~.;c~~ ~~y, ~~f~~z~~r~t gold f~~a~ (4) a~~.i~i~~?~~ "~Jc~~~f~~i~.l" tw~hzr~~ to az~~ch~.r
thir~~p~xxy ~on~~as~a~r z~az~aa~~ J~1~~ IVa~axd~~h fir a dotal ~~~~3_.7~. (~~'~c I~✓.~ur~c~~h Ir~voi~~, atta~h~~
h~r~to a~ ~~hibi9 ~.)
23. ~n in~ox~~tz~r~ ~x~~l b~~i~~; bo~:h I~x. Lary az~~ Tyr. I'✓~~zz•d~~h x~~s~l~ t~a~
46ITn.~f~i~i~l" t-s~x~°t~ ~z~n~~~ctur~~ by ~~f~nd~r~~ ts~ o~h~$•s ~luxi~.~ thy; "IJz~c~~fi~i~l" fit. ~~t~z~]~'s
2~. ~~i~r~~~z~~, I~/~r. ~~a~y and IV~z. u~~doc;h h~v~ n~v~i~ rcc~iv~d the ~Jniv~rszty's
~~xmisszoiz ~~° ~.p~z°oval ~o u~~ ~th~ IJ~za~~rsity I`~axlcs, nor Piave ~~f~nda~t9 1~/Ix. Z,a~y c~z• l' r.
1'~~rdoc~ ~v~~- ~~nt~~t~~ t~~ ~J~~v~~si~y tc~ ~•~~~~~t p~z~zs~z~z~ ~o use tk~~ ~Jniv~r~ity l a~l~~ ~~a
x~l~,tio~ ts~ its ~~~ds.
2~. ~~f~~da~.t i~ z~_ot ~ ~~~.~~ac~ux~z~ licensed by ~~~ ~Jrziv~xsity's ~'ra~~~a~rl~ ar~d
~,i~~~si~g O'~fi~;~, a;nd i~ n~~ auth~z°zz~~ ~~ c~~~ t~~ ~1~a~ve~~s~ty'~ 1r•~~~~~a~r~. `~'h~ ~~.~th~xiz~d
lic~z~s~z~~ ~~px~senta~i~~~ of t~~ ~J~i~r~~~sity i~ ~~al~~i~~~ ~~~~z~si~~~ ~~r~~~r~y ~"~~,~")
A~~;c~rdir~~~y, n~ ~n~ is at~ih~ciz~d tc~ z~a~~,ifa~~ur~, dastz•z1~ut~, ~~v~z°~is~, ~~f~r for s~.l~ az~d/c~~• ~~11
~.~y pr~du~ts b~a~°inb tl~~ IJniv~z•sity's tz•~d~zn~rl~s witk~~ut tie ~x~~~~s~ wxit~~n ~ons~~~ ~f ~~~ {~~a
~~h~lf ~~ the ~J~iv~xs%ty) ancl/~z° t~~ ~Jniversity.
~6. ~n or .bout arch ~, ?~11, c~uns~l ~~r ~~,~ ~oz~ta~t~~l I~~f_~~dant ~s~ pr~t~st
~~~F~~d~r~t's u~authoriz~d u~~ of tk~~ Uz~iv~rsity'~ ti°~cler~a.az•1~~ and tc~ d~z~~a~~l that ~~~~~c~a~t
~~zn~~li~t~iy ~~as~ ~ra~ desist usia~g the ~Jn~vexsity T~~°ins. (~~'~e 3/x/11 ~,~tt~x, ~tta~h~~ h~z•~t~ as
7
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 8 of 30
~xhibi~ I-~.) Ire z°~sp~ns~, ~~~~n~~nt ~~z~i~~l ~r~y wz°~ra~~c~xs~~ ~a~cl ~ri~~l t~ ~~rziz~~zniz~ its invc~lv~r~~~t
in the ~~afriz~~in~ a~~ivi~y by ~h~~°~~t~a°izi~~ its ~~~xoz~s ~s .ra~~~~~ p~~it~ti~g f_o~~ a ~;li.~~~t.
2%. ~'~~ ~~~ti~~ ~~~~zan~~~ cm~ ail ~c~g°r~~~~nd~~~~ iz~ ,Tung 20l 1 in ~~ ~t~~z~p~ ts~ p°~sc~ly~
this disput~9 bit ~v~x~ ~z~suc~~s~ful i~ t1~~ir a~t~~za~ts.
2~. ~~ ~'ebru~ry ~, 2~~2, ~s~uns~~ foz° the IJr~iv~a~~i_ty ~~~~t az~~t~.~z° ~~~~~~ t~ ~€~~~d~n~~
~~~in prc~t~stz~.~ ~~f~z~~l~~3:'~ ~a~~ut~oi°i~e~ use of'tk~~ ~1r~av~r~~ty'~ tr~~l~a~z~~~~s end ~~~nandi~a~ th~~
I~~~end~a~t ~rn~edi~i~ly ~e~s~ and c1_~s~~t f~oz~ t~~ ~ria~tinb, ~~1~, ~ff~z°ink for ~~1~ ~n~/or
distxibu~i~z~ c~~ the 66U~~o~fi~ial" ~-shiz°t~ ~a~~l ~~y other px•oc~ucts b~a~°ir~g ~r~y tz~.d~~~xlcs c~~ the
~J~.~v~~•saty, ar~d de~a~~zdi~g pay~~nt ~o~• 1h~ li~~~si~~, f~~ ~~x prX~~ir~g ~n1 s~l~ ~~ the `GUr~~ffi~i~.l~~
~mshzr~t~ ~n~ 1~~a1 ~e~~ i~~~~°t°~d ~o ~1~zs p~i~~, ~znc~n~; ~t~~r i~~rns. (~~'~~ 2/$/12 L~~t~z, ~tt~~h~d h~~~~to
as ~xhibi~ I.)
29. ~ft~r ~~~ha~~;x~~ voi~~~~x~s, ~ouns~l far• t~~ ~T~iv~~~sity ~r~~zlly sp~l~~ t~ ~~f~nd~r~~
~~ ~~~ about ~.p~il 2, 2012. ~~f~~.d~nt ag~a~a d~ni~a any ~rz~~ngd~i~~ end, d~s~i~~ ha~~in~ b~~z~ ~u~
c~~ r~oti~;~ of the ~Tnz~a~.~~s~~y's tx•~d~r~~~~C z~~~~~is, s~i~ zt ~v~s hzs ~us~~~a~;as' ~•~s~o~~ibiliGy cc~ avoid
uz~~~at~or~z~d use cif t~a~ IJn~~~rsi~y's tz°ad~r~~r~cs, nc~t ~~f~n~~~t'~, which; th~~°~fox~~, s~~~~sts to
t~i~ ~J~av~r~ity that ~~~~~ ~r~fzin~~~~e~ats ~vi11 ~~r~ti~~i~ u~11~ss ~~~~join~d.
~0. ~'.~ d~t~, ~~~~n~ar~t his _r~~~~~d ~o ~;~~~1~ vai~h the ~Jz~a.v~rsit~'~ ~l~~~az~~~.
31, ~~f~n~1~~9 z~ l~~ac~d i~ tka~ ar~~ o~c~~ IJ~_iv~rs~ty'~ ~h~~p~~~~9~J~•baa~~ ~~r~~us ~~~,
on zz~F~x•~~~~z~aa ~szd b~l~~~, shc~u~~ b~ ~w~x~ of the Uni~~x~sity'~ ~vv~ll-kr~c~tivz~ tz°~d~z~arks, zn~ludi~~.~
the ~Tniv~~sitJ I~1Iark~, ~n.~ tk~~t such rr~~rlc~ ~r~ ~~rx~z~.tly i~ use. T~~f~~ad~~t i~~~~ fuz~th~_r pit on
r~c~~ti~~ ~~ t~~ ~1n_x~e_r~~ty'~ z~~;~~s in tk~~ ~Jnxv~x°~i~y axes sine at lest 1'~~z°~;h d, 2011 vvh~~ the
~Ja~iv~rsity (th~c~ugh its ~~~nt, ~I.,~) s~~~ ~n i~i~ial ~~as~ a~~ ~~s~~t l~tt~r tc~ TJ~fend~nt.
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 9 of 30
~2. ~n iz~f~z°rx~ati~n ~n~ b~li~:f, ~~f~nd~~t'~ ~~~utk~oz°iz~d use of tk~~ Ur~i~~rszty l~/~asks
tiv~~ld l~~ult i~a d~ma~~ end z~jury to ~h~ ~Jniv~rsity a~ it ~s lil~~ly to c~u~~ c~r~~i~~i~~9 znistal~e and
d~~~ptio~ ~r~ b~h~l~ of ~~n~um~z°s with z°~~~~~t t~ the o~°i~in ~~ad so~x~~ ~~ ~~f€nd~~t's ~;c~c~~~ i~
that; the ~~~bli~ will r~zsta~C~~l~ b~li~v~ that the "~J~offi~ial" ~~~hirt~, a~~ ~~~ ~i~~r shixt~ b~ara~a~
t~a~ Una~~r~~ty ~/~z~x~cs ~x ot~a~~~ tz~d~~aarlcs ~f tl~~ ~Jni~~~~ity, ha~~ b~~z~ li~~ns~~, sp~n~o~°~c~ c~z
aiat~oxiz~~ by the IJniv~z~ity. !~~ ~ x~sL~lt, ~~r~.~~~z~~z•s ~z~~ ~~~~ive~ a~~ ~n~~z~d by ~~~~~daz~t`~
zz~iz~z~~;i~~ ~~~iviti~s.
33. '~'hos~ f~n~ili~z° vaicl~ the ~Ir~iv~rsity I ax1~s w~~J_~ b~ lik~Iy t~ ~u~ I)~;~~nc~a~t'~
g~od~ ~s and fc~r a. px~~u~t zx!ad~ ~~~ ~~ld by tk~~ U~iv~x~a~~. ~~~~x~iz~gly, ~~y d~f~~t, c~bj~~t~,~r~ or
r~~~~~ f~a~x~c~ with ~~f~nd~~t's ~c~ods, car ~~y ~~~~tiv~ ~ss~~;ia~ic~n ~;c~~r~~,~t~d t~~x~vaitl~, would
n~~;~ssaz°ily refl~~t ~~gatively upon ~r~d s~c•a~~asly injuz°~ tk~~ z•~put~t~o~ ~~cl ~o~dwil~ vv~i~h the
~1~iv~rsity has ~st~b~isk~~~ fox its prvdv~t~ sold ~lnd~~° its L7niv~z~sity i~axks.
34. ~n ad~itio~, I~~f~~zd~a~1'~ un~uthoziz~d ~~~ €~i~ the ~J~iv~rsity 1'~~xl~~ in ~~nn~~ti~z~
wz~~a ~ t-shirt ~h~t ~x~~~~s~ly ~xt~ls 66dz•inl~ir~~" aid "d~baL~~kz~~•y" ~~ o~ ~~a~~ti~nab~~ t~st~, and h~~
izaj~z~~l end thz°~~~~~~d ~ut~.ix~ iz~juz°y to tl~~ Uz~~v~~°s~~y by sp~~i~z~ally ~Iirnzz~ashir~~ its ~c»dwi1~ i~
t~~ iTz~iv~rsity 1V~az°~~s aid ~~z°r~ishzz~~ th~~~ vv~ll~l~~~wrz zr~az°~~s.
~5, ~~a z~.fc~x~~~tzoz~ and b~li~f, T~~~~z~d~rzt'~ in~'xi~zffin~ a~tij~i.~2~~ ~x~ ~~1 li~~t~~ t~ ~~Z~
~i~~nl~ tm~~irt i~. ~~~sti~~, and ~~f~~da~t ~c~ntxzau~~ ~o use ~h~ IJr~zv~rszty I axk~ ~n~ ~th~r
~rad~z~~rl~~ of the ~Jzaiv~rs~ty vaitk~~u~ ~ ~i~~~s~.
36. 3~~f~~d~nt's ~r~authvz~zz~d u~~ ~~~ the ~fc~r~z~~~ti~n~d ~z~~zks in~xiz~g~s ~~p~z~ aria
°ks,
~~i~lac~s ~h~ z°i~hts s~f~h~ IJniv~r~ity in its vv~ll~l~o~rn Paz a~zd has darna,g~d anal is ~ontanuin~ t~
pause iz~?reparabl~ injux~ to the IJr~iv~~sit~'s business, x~~~latioz~ aid goodwill.
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 10 of 30
~'~~7I~'~' ~e
3'~. ~'~~ U~~zv~xsx~y an~;~z~~or~te~ by x~f~r~z~~~ ~'~~ ~11~gatz~n~ ~~nt~in~d in :~~ra~zaph~ 1
t'~r~~~l~ ~6 as if fully set _forth h~z~in.
3~. ~~Z~ LJni~~rs~~y o~vz~~, his the ~x~lu~iv~ c•i~h~ 1~ ~a~~, grad us~~ the tJ~.~v~rsity 1'~a~l~~
ixi ~~n~~~tio~ with a wa~~ r~r~~~ ~~ gc~~ds ~a~d s~rvi~~s, az~~~udi~g, 'gut ~~~ lX~i~t~~ to, t-shzz°t~ az~d
oth~z~ v~~~a•ar~g ~p~az~~l.
39. Thy LTniv~~~ity his s~~~nc substantial a ~u~ts ~f z~c~n~y ~n~ ~~foz°t ~.~v~lopi~~ the
~Jr~~v~xsity 1~1~a.~~lcs, ~~ will_ ~s gos~d~vill ~~d ~~nut~tio~ i~ i~~ b~sin~ss.
40. ':~"h~ [Tniv~~~~~ty h~~ the ~x~l~~~s~~ zz~ht ~~ ~~rl~~t, brand, ~~d s~11 ~~c~cls throughout
~h~ IJni1~~ ~tat~~ ~asir~~ the ~Jniv~~csity i~~rl~s.
41. ~~uti~z~ 32 ref the ~a~h~m l~~r, 15 ~J.~.~. ~ 1114(1)(x), pr~vic~~~ in ~~rt~~~z~t pa~~t
that "[~~ny ~~z°son why sh~li, v~it~a~ut the ~oz~~~r~t o~ the m~~istx~~at —use ia~ ~~t~a~er~~ ar~y
r~~xc~~~,~~tic~~a, ~o~r~t~r~~i~, co~Y~ ~i• ~~~~z•~bl~ iznit~ti~n c~~ ~ z~~gi~~~r~~ zn~rl~ i_r~ ~~~a~~~~~~x~ with tie
s~l~, ~i~~z°i~~ ~o~° s~l~, dis~xzbL~~io~, sir ~.dv~~•tiszr~g ~f any ~o~ds ox s~zvi~~~ ~~z ox an ~s~r~~~~~taon with
~vhz~~ ~~~h u~~ is lik~~y t~ ca~as~ c~a~f~x~i~~z, ~r ~~ ~~~as~ a ~n~sY~~~~, ~x to d~~~iv~ ...shall b~ lia~l~
i.xa ~ ~i~~il actz~n b~ t~~ ~°~~x~~z~~~t , . , ,~~
42. ~~~~r~d~~t has, v~zthcj~t ~~z~s~r~~ ~r ~uthorizati~t~ ~i~ x~~ Univ~z~sity, ~~~d tk~~
~J~iv~z•~a~y T~/~~zl~s ~o a~a~~u~astu~~, sill, ~f~~x to s~11, distl°ibu1~ ~,~c~/+~r adv~rt~~~ pr~rlu~ts aid
s~i•vi~es w~a.~~ az°~ 1h~ s~z~~ tyo~ of g~od~ that ~~°~ c~ff~x~~ b~ tl~~ ~Jnz~~~~s~ty (i. ~., tw~hzrts), a~ad
~v~i~~ axe ~f ~~I~siioxl~bl~ t~st~ at~d l~~al.aty ~~rQ~~~h its w~bsit~.
~3. Thy ~s~ ~~ the Unav~x•sity 1V`ark~ by ~~~~r~d~nt ~l~przv~s the ~Jniv~rsiiy oC its
subst~z~taal z~~tic~a~al goodyvill and is li~~ly ~~ ~aus~ ~onfusi~~, z~istak~ znd d~~~~ta~~ tc~ ~~~surnez~~
l~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 11 of 30
as t~ i~~ affili~,ti~n, ~~ra~ect~~z~, €~r a~s~~i~~i~~ of ~~~~~z~~l.~rzt's ~oo~s, ~~~•vx~~~, ~x ~~a~~z°~~~~
~~tivz~i~s ~~zth t~~ U~.~~~~~~ity, aid a~ t~ the ~~i~i~a, ~~onsc~rs~,~r~, +~x ~~px~val cif 3~~f~r~~lan~'s ~o~ds,
~~1°vies, ~x ~o s~~r~~~l a~tavita~s b~ 1h~ U~i~~x•si~y. ~'~i~s~ f~r~zli~x wi~~ the Uz~~~~~r~ity Paz°~~
~~s~uld b~ 1z1~~1y tc~ kuy T~~f~r~daa~t's ~~od.s as ~~_cl fc~z° a ,~xc~du~t ~~d~ a~z~ sold by t~.~ LJniv~r~~cy.
~~~o~°c~i~~l~, any ~l~f~~t, ~bj~~ti~~ c~~° fa~Xl~ ~~u~?.~ with ~~f~n~l~~t'~ ~~c~d~, sic° ~~r~y ~~~a~iv~,
~s~~~za~a~z~ ~~nn~~~t~d th~x~with, ~~v~u~~ n~c~s~~z~ily ~~~1~~1 ~~~~~~v~l~ ~apo~ ~~~ s~~~iously injux°~ the
~•~,t~u~~ti~~ and ~oc~~vvill w~i~h t~.~ ~T~xv~xszty has ~~t~.'r~li~~ed foz• its ~~rod~a~ts ~~ld u~~3ex i~:~
LJr~ivexsit~ l~~xk~.
44. I~~f~zada~t's ~~.~~.~tho~•zz~d ~~~s ~on~~i~~~t~ dir~~t i~a~z~zn~;~z~~zat~ of t~~ IJa~iv~xsi~y's
rz~ht~ x~ the ~Jr~iv~x~ity S~arl~s ~~ viol~t~oz~ ~f ~e~tion ~?(1; ~~ t~~ ~,ank~az~ Apt, 2~ ~J.~.~. §
1114~(1)(a).
~~. ~'~~ ~~~r~s~a~ c~nd~~t of T~~f~~d~~~ zs ~aillfial, d~lib~rat~, int~nt~~a~~l, a.~dan bad
~ait~ in tk~at ~~fi~~~~nt infxang~~ end ~~~tinu~d t~ ir~zz~iz~g~ the IJr~iv~rsi~y I'~/~~°l~s with ~uli
k~owl~d~~ that the ~Jniv~x~~tJ Evans ~~zc~ has t1~~ ex~;lusiv~ ~~~~:ht to ~a~~ t~~ ~J~i_v~xsitJ l ~z°ks, end
~f~~x ~otic~ fi-a~zn t1~~ ~J~i~~~rsity t~ ~~~.se its iz~f~ir~~i~a~ a~ti~i~i~~.
;~.6. ~'h~ ~Ja~iv~xsaty is a~~c~~rri~~l ~~~d'u~li~v~s, ~c~d oz~ that ba~z~ ~1~~~~~, ghat ~~f~~a~ta~_t
~~~1 ~~r~tinu~ c~ use the U~~v~x°sity mat°~~s aid otl~~x~ tr~~~ irks ~f t~~, ITni~~.rsity ur~l~~s ~njoin~~.
~-7. A~ a ~ir~~t and ~sc~xir~~~~ Y°~s~lt ~f ~~f~nd~r~t~~ ~ora~luct, the ~Jnzv~~sity h~~
s~ff~r~d, ~z~~ ~~ill ~~n~x~a~~ ~~ ~uff~~•, ~~.l~~s ~~~d ~~~d~~t i~ ~~jc~zr~~~ by thzs ~~uxt, both s~bst~n~ia~
~ra~n~t~ry d~~~~~s, z~a ara ~mac~~az~t t~ b~ px~v~n ~t tz~i~1, and substantial i~r~p~z~ab1~ i.nju~°y i:o its
gs~odwill and z°eput~tzon fox w~z~h thez~ z~ ~~ ad~c~~~t~ r~~.~~1~ ~t lava.
4~. ~ux~u~nt t~ l~ U.~.~. ~ 1 l 17(a), ~1~~ ~Jniv~rsity is ez~ti~l~d to ~r~ ac~c~~ntzn~ for, and
~ dis~c~:rg~m~nt cif, X11 c~ ~~'r~nc~ant's z°~venu~s and/or pz~~fi~s d~z°i~~d fr~~a its in~i•ar~~;xn~ use s~fih~
l~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 12 of 30
Unzve~~si~y Ntaxk~ ~_n ~c~~z~~~tzo~ with ~~~ L`LJz~off~_~za~" t-sham end ~;ny oth~z- ~-sl~izt~ ~~• ~o~~d~, ~s
~~~11 ~~ ~~zy ~l~ma~~~ kh~ IJr~iv~r~i~y l~~s ~uff~r~~ ~z~d the ~~~t~ c~~bxin~zn~ this a~ti~~.
~~. ~d~x~iozz~~ly, '~y z°~aso~ of the vvillf~l ~r~~ d~lzb~x~t~ ~~t~ ~~ndu~t~~l by ~~~f~~~la~t
~n ~ons~i~~~s ~z~regard for the rig~its of t~~ U~iver~ity, the ~Js~iv~xsi~y as ~~~atitl~~ to tx~ble d~rr~~~~~
~a~c~~x 1~ ~T.~.~. g~ X117{~).
~~?. ~'urth~rz~~r~,1k~~ ~Jr~i~~x~aty ~s ~~~~a~1~d t~ r~c~v~z its ~ttc~r~~y~" fees ~~ l~~f~z~d~~t'~
~~~r~~s w~z~ ~n~~llful end ~~;lib~xat~, ar~d ~~z•ti~u~a~•ly ~~r~~i~~~ ~iv~n t~~ ur~_~~athc~~°i~~~ ~~e o~ ~1~~
~Jniv~r~zty'~ ~z~ade~z~l~~ i~ ~oz~~~ti~n vazth g~~~~ ~z q~aestio~~bl~ t~st~ that ~x~r~ssl~ ~~to~.
"drix~kz~~~~ end ~`d~bz~~c~exy," r~~d~zir~~ tk~i~ ~~ "~x~~ptro~~al" case uz~d~~~ l~ I.J.S.~'. ~ 11170).
~~~J~T~' ~~a
m_ _ _ - _.
~~~ ~J9~a~'o ~ ~~~~~~~
~1. ~'h~ ~T~iverszLy in~oz~~or~t~s by x~~~r~~~~ the alleQati~~s ~~z~~air~e~ iii ~a~•~~~~~h~ 1
th~~~~gh ~0 ~s if hilly sit £oz°th ~z~r~in.
~2. "I'1~~ (Trzxv~~i•~ity owns,~~~ the ~x~l~siv~ ~°i~~it ts~ u~~, and_ ~as~s chi ~Jn~~~xs~ly l~~ax?~s
~n ~~~n~~ci~~ v✓i~th a wi~~ z~~.nQ~ c~:f~ g~~~~ ~a~d ~~z°vi~~s, znclud~~g, but ~~~t l~~~zt~d t~, tm~h~z~t~ ~~zd
°~1.
~t~~x ~a~~ran~; apps;
~3. ~'~~ U~iv~x~zty'ci~s s~~r~t subst~r~ti~~ az~fl~rat~ o~:rnc~~a~y ~nc~ ~f.~c~zt d~v~J.~~an~, t~~
~Jz~zv~x~aty i`~a~~c~, ~s ~v~ll as ~~c~~~~z~l aid ~~~ut~.ti~~ ~z~ its b~a.~i~~s~.
~4. ~'~~ IJniv~~~szty has ih~ ~x~l~sav~ rzgk~~ tc~ ~arlc~t, bzar~~, ~~~ s~lJ. ~~od~ thz~s~~~k~a~~
lh~ U~it~d ~tat~s us~~g tl~.~ ~Js~iv~z•sz~y ~rk~.
55. ~ec~iora 4~(a) of ~~~ ~,~nharn pct, 15 IJ.~.~. § 11~~(~), ~z~vz~l~s rn p~~°~i~a~~at ~~~c
tk~~t 66~a~zay :P~~s~n ~v~c~, ~n ~~ an ~~~n~~tzc~~ vazth az~y g~c~d~ oz° s~xvic~s .. , ~as~s in ~~z~m~r~~ any
vaord, t~rrn, name, s~s~bol ... or ~a~y ~~~s~ d~si~~aatior~ of origin, false oa° ~isl~adin~ d~s~z•i~ti~~ off'
12
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 13 of 30
f~~t, oa- £~ls~ ~z~ z~i~l~adzng r~px°~~~~t~ti~~ of~f~~t, which — is l~lc~ly tc~ ~~~?~~ co~f~~ior~, cox io ~~us~
a~ist~l~~, c~~ t~ d~~~iv~ ~s t~ ~fraliation ... ~z° ~s t~ the o~°z~;iz~, ~pc~z?~~rsh~p, car ~~prs~v~~ ~z... ~~~c1s,
s~rvz~~~, ~~° ~~~rr~ex~zal a~~tivi~i~s ... shz~ll be lia~]~ i;~ a civil a~~~~~ ....'~
56. ~~f~~adant ~a~, vvithc~lit ~c~~~~r~~ yr ~~th~x°izatioz~ fr~~~ the ~Jz~av~rgaty, u~~d ~h~
~J~r~xv~rsi~y I~~~~ks t~ ~~~.~fa~c~r~, ~~11, ~ff~x• ~~ ~~ll, d~~iribiit~ ar~~/~e~ adv~~~tis~ ~roduc~ts ~~d
s~xvi~~~ vv~ai~~ ~r~ ~~~ s~s~~ ty~~ ~f ~ooc~s that axe ~~'ea-~~ b~ t1~~ ~J~ai~~~r~ity (z.~., ~~~~~rt~)9 and
w~i~h ~z°~ ~f qu~st~~n~bl~ ~ast~ arad ~~~al~~y thx~ugh z~~ websz~~.
57. ~'~~ use c~.f the ~Jniv~rs~ty 1~/~~i°lc~ '~y ~e~er~l~r~t d~p~°iv~~ the ~Js~iv~x~ity or zt~
su'~st~nt~al ~atioz~~~ g~~~will a~~~ is lal~~ly to ~~us~ ~on~u~is~~, rn~st~1~~ ~~a~ ~~~~pkior~ t~ ~~n~uzn~z•~
as to the ~~~ilzatzoz~, ~;~r~ne~ti~n, ox as~o~i~ti~r~ of ~~~~~d~~c"s foods, s~rvi~~s, o~ c~z~amer~zal
a~~iviti~s ~witl~ the Uaai~v~xsity, a~c~ as tv zk~~ origin, spo~sors~ap, ~z a~pr~v~l ~~'~~~~z~~1~~at'~ ~o+~ds,
s~xvi~~s, car ~oz~an~x~ial ~~~xv~~i~s by the Univez•sity. Thc~~~ ~~ ~li~r v~ith_ the ~Jr~iv~z~s~ty 1'✓~~r~g
would b~ likely to buy ~~fez~dar~t's ~oo~s ~s end z~z• ~ ~xodLi~t made anc~ gold by t~~ IJniv~rsi~y.
~.~c~oz•clin~ly, ~r~y ~l~f~~t, ~bj~~tx~z~ ~~ fz+.ult fo~n~Y ~~it~ I~~f~~~a~t°s ~o~~~, c~:~~ ~t~y ~a~~~tive
~.~s~~~~ta~n ~~r~z~~ct~~ t~~r~wzt~, ~r~~l~ s~~~;~ssaxily x~#le~t z~~~~tiv~ly u~s~n and s~Yi~u~~J z~jur~ ~h~
~~;~~c~t~c~r~ ~~d ~~~c~~~zll ~v'~z~:~ t~~ ~1~~v~~~ity ~a~~ ~~t~'o~~~~~d fc~z• zts p~•~~lu~xs 5~1~ ~nd~~° its
LJ~iv~z°sity I~~rl~~.
5$. I~~~~r~danl's uz~authox~ze~ ~~ts coz~~tit~i~~ ~als~ cl~si~nati~~ cif oxigzn, fal~~
~~v~z~tisin~ az~d ~nf~ir ~ozx~p~tlti~~ in vi~l~ti~n ~f the L,a~~~~n ~~~, l~ ~1.~.C, ~ 112~~a).
5~, ~'~~ a~or~s~i~ ~~n~u~~ ~~ ~~f~~d~~~ is ~vX11~u1, ~~lib~r~t~, i~at~~ti~z~al, ~racl i~ b~~
~'ait~ x~ that ~~f~nda~t iz~~z°zn~~c~ ar~d c;c~r~tir~u~d tc~ i~.zz•i~b~ the ~Jz~i~~xsity T~/~~xlcs (a) wit~a null
l~z~owl~d~~ tk~aY the IJ~iv~rsity owns end has the ~x~l~asiv~ z~i~ht to ease the IJniv~~•saty l~/~axl~s9 (b)
13
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 14 of 30
~r~th the ir~t~r~tz~n cif ~~usi~a~ a lilc~~iho~d cif ~oz~f~2si~oz~ az~d z~istak~ ~n~ ~~ d~~~iv~, a~~ (c) ~f«~
n~~z~~ ~z~z~n t~~ ~Jn~v~xszly ~s~ ~~as~ ~i~ ir~f~°z~~in~ ~~~zviti~s.
~0. "~h~ IJ~zv~~sity z~ in~~~°reed aa~~l b~li~~~s, al~ad ors th~~ b~si~ ~.11~g~s, that ~~f~~cla~t
will ~~z~~iz~~i~ c~ use ~hc; ~Jniv~z~sitJ l~/I~x~k~ ~r~d other tra~~r~~r~~s ~f ~~~ ~Jz~gv~~°pity ~z~~~~s ~z~jc~in~d.
6~.. ~~ a dix~~~ ~.~~ pzo~~axaa~~ x~~ult of I~~f~nda~t'~ ~~~~~a~~, t~~ ~T~iv~r~it~ ~a~s
s~af~~x~~d, a~ad ~vil1 ~~nti~z~~ to ~~f~~z•, ~r~l~s~ sa~cl ~~n~~ct is ~~.jozra~d by phis ~s~~x-~, b~t~a ~~~b~~~r~t~al
z~~r~~t~x~ d~rn~~~s, zr~ ~.r~ arn~~a~t i~ l~~ ~~°s~v~~ ~t trial, aa~d subst~.al~i~?1 arr~p~i°ably z~j~ry to ~.~~
~~~~~vill azas~ ~~put~~ioz~ fs~r vv~i~~ th~r~ is r~o ad~q~~at~ z-~r~~dy ~t law.
62. ~uxs~a~~i to ~ ~ IJ.~.~. ~ 1117(x), the ~[Jni~~~rszty is ~~titl~d ~~ ~n ~~~ou~ltz~~ ~~x, and
~ disgoi•~~z~~nt ~~', X11 ~f ~~f~~d~~t'~ z•~v~~~~~s ~~~/ox profits ~1~rivea f~~ its z~frin~in~ u~~ ~fthe
~Tniv~~~sity I~~rl~s in ~c~n~l~~taon with. tla~ ~`~T~~f~"i~ial" t~shirt ~~d ~~y ~~h~z~ ~-shiY~ts ~r goods, ~.~
~~11 ~~ ~r~y ~~z~a.~~s ~J~~ Uzziv~z°~xty I~a~ ~ufx~red ~~d the co~~~ ~f brir~~~~g this ~~ti~z~.
~3. ~d~itiaz~~lly, by z~asc~n of the r~~al_~~'ul end d~lib~z°ate ~~t~ ~o~~u~t~~ by ~~f~~.da~.t
i~ ~;oras~;i~u~ diss~~~a~rd z~r the z°i~~ts ~~'~~~ ~Jniv~rsit~, the ~Jx~ivexgi~~ is ~z~tit]~~1 ~~ tr~bl~ ~am~~~s
u~zd~~ 15 ~J.~.~. § ~11`~(~).
64. ~'~izth~r_rz~c~x•~, i~~ r7n~~r~~~~~tJ a~ ~z~9ztl~~ t~ ~~~~~v~x• its ~~torn~ys' f~~s ~s ~~f~~adant'~
~~ti~~s ~v~z~e ~v~llx`~ul ~.~~ d~~ib~xa~~, ~z~d p~xta~aa_1~~1y ~~~~gac~u~ give ~h~ u~~~thc~i°xz~~ ~~~ of t~~
~Tz~~v~x°sity's t~°~d~rr~~rlcs i~ ~c~nn~~~i~~ with ~oo~s of gl~~sti~r~~bi~ t~~t~ t~~t ~xp~~ssl~ ~x~o~
"~xi iz~~'~ ~~a~ `~~~~a~a~h~ry,~' r~r~c~~xzng this ~~ "`e~~~~~i~~~1" ~as~ under 1 ~ IJ.~.~. § 1 117(a).
~'~~JI~T""
~~__o
(1~ ~10~0~'4 ~ ~~~~(~)~
65. ~1~~ Uni~~xsity z~1~o~°p~xa~~~ by r~fer~z~~~ the all~~atio~s ~o~.~ain~~ i~ ~~r~~r~p~s J
tl~rc~~gh b4 as it ~~lly ~~t foxth her~i~.
1~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 15 of 30
66. ~'h~ ~1z~zv~z°sity s~v~r~s, hay the ~x~~~sav~ rz~h~t tc~ use, ~~~ u~~~ tk~~ ~Jnz~~~~°s ty 1'~axks
a~ ~~z~~~~t~~~ ~rai~k~ ~. w~~~ r~n~e c~z ~c~~d~ ~n~ s~xvi~e~, ix~clu~zr~~, ~OU~ ~~t lai~~1 t~, t~-sl~i~~t~ ~~zc~
c~th~x ~~v~a~~in~ ~p~ar~l.
57. Thy U~ai~v~rsity has sp~rzr s~b~ta~iial ~~ou~ts of ~c~~a~y ~~~~ ~~ort ~ev~lo~zn~ the
Uz~iv~r~~ty ax~~, ~s ~~a~3.1 ~~ ~~~dwill ~r~~ r~~utati~~ ~~ its b~sin~~~.
6~. ~'~.~ LJ~i~v~rs~~y h~~ ~1~~ ~~clu~iv~ ri~h~ t~ zx~arl~~t, bz°~n~, ~.~d ~el~ ~00~1~ thr~u~h~ut
the ~1~it~~l ~tat~s usi~~ the IJa~iv~rsity 1~~r~~s.
69. ~~~ti~z~ 43(x) ~~?~h~ I,ar~ha~ A.~~, 1~ U.~.~. ~ 112~(~), ~zovid~~ z~a p~~tin~t~t part
~~i~~ `s[t]~~ ~~~~a~Y~ o~ a fa~~~s ~.x~ th~~ i~ distin~ti~~ ... sl~~ll b~ ~~~ixl~~ t~ a~ znja~~c~i~~ ~~~~~s~
~nothex° p~rs~~~ ~~vho, ~t any tzn~~ ~ft~;r the ~wn~z's rn~r~ kzas b~~c~zrz~ ~'~.~~us, ~omra~~r~~~s use <~~'
~~rl~ ox txade ~az~~ in ~o~arn~~~~ that i~ 1il~~ly to cause ~il~ti~n by l~luz~•i~~ ox ~ilutio~ by
tarr~ishrrz~~t of t~~ f~znous ~i~rlc."
7fl. T~i~ IJ~i~~~xszty I'~~z~~~s axe ~l~stxt~~;~iv~ az~~i h~v~ b~~c~z~~ ~rr~~~s w~thi~ the ~~~~~iz~~
71. ~~f~n~ar~~ hay, ~vit~Z~ut ~~ns~~.t ~~ ~u~h~xzz~tior~ f~o~ the I7z~z~v~.rszcy, used. t~~
~Jz~iv~~si~y ~f~~~ks ~c~ r~~z~~?f~~t~are, s~~19 off~~ to ~~11, ~i~tribur~ ~,n~/or a~.v~rtis~ aorodu~~s a~z~.
~~rvz~;~~, ~n~l ~vh~~~~ ~.~°~ ~f ~la~~~tior~~b~e la~t~ end 1~~ality t~~~ ~x~r~s~ay ~x~~l "~xinkz~~~' ar~d
G6~~b~.uch~i °Y~" 9:hxc~~gh z~~ ~v~bsi~~.
%Z. {~
~~f~nd~nt's ~~~ ~~ the ~J~aiv~r3ity I~~rk~ b~~~.~~ long ~~t~z° the t7~a~~~c~si'r.J I~~z1
b~~~~ far~.o~~.
7~. ~~f~rad~nt'~ u~a~athox~z~d ~a~e ~~ t1~~ ~Tr~iv~xsity 1✓I~rks k~~as c~~~s~d, end will
~onl7nu~ t~ cause, dil~atio~ by bl~x-~iz~,~ (b~s~d orgy tl~~ ~J~i~v~rsaty's l~s~ ~f ~oz~~~•ol over its ~rl~s)
~~c~ ~liluti~r~ by t~.rnishs~z~nt (ba~~~ o~ the 66Ux~of~i~ial" t-shz~~' ~xpr~ss asso~iati~z~ wit~i
15
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 16 of 30
`~~lcz~k~z~~" ~n~ "d~i~a~~~.~xy"~ ~~~h~ ~Jn~v~xsity I~✓[ax~~, wzth ~~~~~~u~~at ~~.~~?b~ t~ rho ~J~z,~~raa~y
a~.d the business ~n1 ~~~dwi11 asss~~~iat~d with i~.
74. ~~f~~~d~~.t's ~r~~utl~~~°iz~d arts ~~nstitut~ dilu~:ic~r~ ~~ci ~a~°zai~h~~~t o~~~Z~ IJniv~r~zly
l~~xl~~ iz~ vir~l~tion of l ~ ~J.~,~'. ~ 112~(~).
I~. ~h~ a~~r~~~.~d ~s~~d~~t ~f~ ~~f~z~~~~t ~s ~v~llful, ~~1~b~~~t~, int~n~ic~r~~1, and i~ bad
~~~~~ ~n ~l~at I~~f~n~l~s~t iz~~izz~g~d ~~d ~oz~ti~a~~~ ~o d~lu~~ ~h~ ~Tz~i~v~~~sity 1`✓~~rl~s with fi~Illc~iowl~~~~
that t'~~ ~J~~v~~°sity o~v~~ at~d his t~~ ~~c~usiv~ z°ight t~ ~~~ ~~~ ~7~i~~~sixy I°~~r~s, ~~a~ ~~~r~~ t~~
willful zn.~~~tzc~r~ of t~adiz~g ~;~ the r~~~at~tic~n o_f the ~1niv~z°sits r~~ ~ az~d ~~°c~du~t Iir~e ~.n~ ~;~~~iz~g
~iluti~n ~~t~~ U~iv~~~ity Iv✓~arl~~.
%6. "~'~~ ~Jrazvers~ty z~ ~z~foxnl~d end b~li~v~s, ~n~l c~rz that b~~is all~~~s, t1a~~ ~~~~x~dant
~~~~11 ~ontinu~ to Lire t~_e IJni~✓~rsity i`~axl~s aid ~tl~~x tra~l~rnaz~l~s of tk~e ~Jnav~~~~ity ua~~~~ ~~jc~i~~~l.
77, ~s ~ c~.ir~~t aid ~x°o~iaz~~t~ result ~f T~ef~~d~.n~'s ~r~n~i~~'~, the Unzvez°sate his
s~~f~x~ ,and ~~all ~;~ntzn~~ to suffer, u~l~ss ~ai~ ~;c~r~d~~t is ~~joi~~d by thzs ~~uz-~, bath s~bst~z~~ial
z~~ora~~axy d~rna~~s, zn ~n ~~z~unt tc~ b~ pr~v~~ ~t 9~ial, ~~~ ~ubstanti~l 1z•z~~p~~~b~~ ~nj~~ry ~~ its
~~c~d~~aXll end ~°~~ut~ii~~ foz° which th~.r~ i~ ~~~ ~d~c~~~.t~ z~ez~~dy ~t l~~r.
'~~. ~L~xsLa t to l~ L1.~.~. ~ 11 J %(~), t~~ LT~~v~xsi~y ~~ ~r~t~~l~~ t~ a~ a~cc~~ar~~~~~ for, az~~.
~ ~z~~~r~~~~~~~ ~a`', ~1~ ~~~~~~~d~~t'~ r~v~r~~ae~ and/s~~~ ~r~~it~ c~~~°iv~~ fr~~ its i~~~i~~i~g ~?~~ ~~ t~~
~U~aiv~r~i~-y i~a~~1~~ zz~ ~~aan~~~i~r~ with ~1~~ "~Jnof~i~ial" t~~~~°r_ ~n~ any ~~~~x t~~~aart~ ~z~ go~~~, as
vv~;ll a~ ~~y da~~a.~~s ~:h~ U~iv~z°szty ~~s s~.t~~x•~d aid the ~~>~ts o~ briz~gin~ t~ais ~~tion.
7~. l~d~litic~nall~, b~/ z~~~soz~ cif 1~~ wilful ~~d d~1~_b~r~1~ arts c~~du~t~d b~ ~~z~nd~n~
i~ ~o~s~io~~ d~s~~g~~°d for ~1~~ x~ig~ts cif t~~ Unav~xs~iy, the ~1z~iv~~•sity ~s ~~t~tl~d to ~x~bl~ ~la~~g~s
~~c~~x 1~ U.~.~. § 11170).
16
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 17 of 30
$0. ~~a~•th~x~~~°~, the U~zv~~~3.ty x~ ~r~tztl~r~ t~ r~~;€~v~~~ its ~tt~x~~~~s' f~~~ as ~a~f~~a.c~~x~t's
a~ti~~s ~%v~r~ vaill~~ul ~s~d ~~lib~x~t~, ~a~d ~a~°ti,cu~~rly e~x•~~~s~~s ~iv~z~ '~~~ un_aut~~r~z~~ u~~ of ~~i~
LJ~iv~z°~zcy'~ trad~~rzaxl~s z~ ~onz~~~tior~ ~vath ~s~~ds ~f ~u~scic~z~~b~~ t~st~ ~~~t ~xpr~s~ly ~~t~l
"~xiz~ki~~,~ and "d~~b~~,l~h~ry," ~°~nd~xin~ 1hi~ era ~`~~~~ptioz~~l" ~~s~ under l~ U.~.~. ~ 111 ~(~).
~~~11~~' ~`~Ia
~ 1. ~'~i~ U~iv~xs~~~ ~n~~xpox~t~~ b~ z°~f~~°~za~~ t~~ ~1]~ga~io~~ ~~~t~~n~~ i~ ~~r~,~x~~hs l
~hrr~u~h $0 ~~ ~f fully ~~t fo~:h hex~zz~.
~2. fit X11 x~l~vaz~t ~irr~~~, ~h~ I~liza~i~ ~~~~acl~rn~l~ ~.~~istxatioz~ an1 T~xo~~~tioz~ ~~~
~"~'} ~ was i~ ~f~~~t in ~llii~oi~.
")
~3. ~~f~~d~~t's uz~~uthoris~~ ~s~ of~th~ IJni~~~x~zty ~~xks ~~d Qth~x tx~d~z~ar~~s of the
~Jniv~a•szty, ~z~l~ss ~~j~i~e~l by this ~ouxt, wild ~~z~~zz~~~ t~ ~~u~e a litc~l~hc~od ~~ ~c~~f~sio~ c~z ~f
~.s~n~l~rsta~d~.~~ ~s to t~~ ~ouz•~~, ~n~r~s~rsk~~p~ ~~pr~v~l, ar~d/or ~~t°t~~i~~t~~~ ~f ~~f~nd~~t's
~s~ods, ~vz~~a ~~s~s~~~~zat ~1az~n~~~ tc~ the ~Jniv~r,~ity ~~.d the bu~in~ss aid ~;c~c~dv~ill a~so~i~t~d with zt.
~~. ~'hos~ ~~xnilx~z° tiait~ t~i~ Uz~iv~r~ity ~arlcs w~~ald b~ l~~~ly t~ "bey ~:~~~~nda~~'s
~c~~~ls a.~ ~~d for ~ ~x~du~t rn~d~ ~z~.c~ s~l~ by the ~Iniv~x~~it~. l-~~~~xdr~.~ly, any d~f~~t, ~bj~ctio~ ~x
fault f~~~~ v~it~ ~~~~n~l~~t's ~~~~s, ~r ~a~y a~e~~tiv~ ~sso~;ia~a.c~~ corzz~~~1:~~1 t~~x°~with, uvould
ri~~~ss~rily z~~~l~~t ~~~atav~ly upon and ~~ri~usly inj~r~ the ~~p~t~~tion aid ~o~d~v~l1 whi~;k~ the
~Tr~iv~x°saty ~~.as ~st~blished ~~r zt~ products ~flld un~l~1° its LJz~iv~xsity I~~xlc~.
~~. ~~f~z~dant's knowing ~~~1 vai~lf~l ~~a~~~~t, ~s ~~s~~ib~~l ~bo~a~, ~~r~s~i~ul~s
tz•~d~zn~zk i~fring~~~nt within ~h~ rra~a~in~ ~f ~~~~is~r~ 60 ~:f the T_ ~,%6~ ~~,~~ ~ 1036/60.
~6. ~s a diz~~ct ~s~d pz•oxi;r~~t~ z°~su1t cif ~~f~~~~r~t's unauth~~•iz~~ ~ct~, ~h~ University
his suff~r~~, end will ~~n~inue to suffer, u~l~ss ~~id ~or~~l~ct ~s ~~join~d by this ~~urt9 b~tk~
1~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 18 of 30
s~bstanti~~ ~c~~~~tax~ d.a~~~~~, ~~a ~~ ~noun~ t~ b~ ~z°~v~r~ ~t ~;zi~1, and ~ub~ta~tz~l ~~x~p~~°~bl~ ~~j~y
to ids g~~dwill anal x~~u~~~ion f~~ wr~i~h t~~r~ is ~~ ad~q~~at~ z•~m~~ly at law.
~%. '~h~ ~Jniv~zsity is ~z~titl~d to ~~.j~ara~tiv~ x~li~f ~nc~ r~oaaeta~y da~a~g~s, ~~ ~n~ell ~~ x,11
pz°c~f~~~ ~a~d/or r~v~nu~s ~;~i~~a by 5~~~~ndan~ ~s a r~s~Ct ~~' icy unlaiv~u~ as;i~, un~~z '7~~ I~,~~
~ fl~ x/7(3.
~~. A~~liti~~~lly, ~~fe~~l~.za1's va~llful ~~n~uct ~ x~~kl~s~ iz~d~~f~x~r~~~ ~t~o the
~J~iv~xs~ty'~ rigkat~ ~z~titl~~ the ~Jn~v~rsity ~o ~. ~°e~o~~~y ~~its r~ason~bl~ attc~xa~~y~' ~~€~s az~d t~•~bl~
~amag~~ pur~u~nt to 76~ IL~~ § ~036/7~.
~~~Ji~1'~' ~4
~~. "~'h~ IJz~iv~r~z~y i~~~x~c~rat~s by ~~~~z~n~~ ~~~ all~ga~i~z~s ~c~n~azn~d i~ ~ara~z•aphs 1
tk~z°ouch ~~ ~s zf fully ~~~ forth h~~~i~.
90. ~t all r~?~v~nt tzrm~s, t~a~ Illinois ~I'~~d~i~~.xk ~.~ istx~~i~n ~~~ ~z•~tcctz~z~ A.~~
"~'~ wa5 ~~ ~f~~~t iz~ ~ll~~oi~.
{ ")
9~. ~'~~ IJriiv~~~z~y I~/i~lc~ are dis~in~;~~~~ ~~a~ l~a~e b~corza.~ fa ~u~ witk~.~ ~k~~ r~~~aa~i~~
of ~~~t~~n 6~ ~f the ~'~~~, 76~ ~~,C~ ~ 1036/65, ~~ ~v~11 ~s S~~t~c~z~ ~3(~) of the ~,~r~~Za ~~t, 1~
~J.~.~. ~ 112 {~),
~~. ~~f~~daz~t h~~, ~~zt~out ~on~~~~ cox ~.~~thc~xiz~9:ion fz~ 1h~ ~Jza~v~r~ity, ~a~~,~ ~:h~
U~~iv~z~sity l~~z°~c~ tc~ r~~~~fa~t~az~~, ~~Jl, ~~~~x• to sill, cli~~i°~b~t~ ~~zd/~z° ~.c~v~~-~zs~ p~o~u~;~s end
~~xvi~~~, and which a~°~ o~ ~u~stz~~~b~~ t~~t~ ~z~d l~~a~zty t~iat ~xpz~~sly ~~~~1 "dra~~a~~~~ ~ncl
"dcb~u~;~~xy," thz~~~~h i~~ w~bsi~~.
~~. ~~£~r~dazat'~ ~~~~ cif the ~Tz~x~~~r~ity lU~ar~s b~~aa1 lo~~ after tk~~ ~Tz~iv~z~ity 1'~at~ks
b~~;am~ f~zn~us.
l~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 19 of 30
R4. ~~f~r~daz~_t'~ ~~aut~a~x°iz~c~ use ~~ the Uz~iv~~•~i~y l~/~~~1~~ ~.~s ~aus~d, ar~c1 w~l~
~~~tir~u~ ~o ~~u~~, diltiti~z~ 1~~ bluxxir~g ~b~s~c1 ~~a tb.~ ~Tz~iv~~sity'~ 1~~~ of ~o~'~rol ~~w~r its s~~.r~~)
~n~ ~lilutio~ b~ t~r~.ish~~nt (ba~~d ~n the "U~~ffi~i~l" tw~~azr~s' ~xpr~~s a~~~~iatxo~a v~zth
66~ri~l~ia~~~~ ~.nd 6L~l~b~uck~~xy")cif the U~iv~r~ily ~.z-lc~, ~~ith ~ons~~~~~.t d~.zn~.~~ ts~ the ~Tz~iv~z°city
~~d ~k~~ busir~~ss ~~d ~~c~~l~~z~l ~s~s~~~~l~~ yvi.th it.
~~. ~~f~~d~~t's l~~~o~vzz~~ aa~d va~llf~a:~ ~oz~du~;~, ~~ ~~s~z°a~~~ ab~v~, ~~~~titut~s d~lu~zon
~~d t~z~~as'az~~r~t o~t~~ L7~i~~rsity 1°~~xl~s within tk~~ z~~anzn.~ cif ~~~ti~~ 65 ~~th~ T ~,~6~ ~~,~~
§ 1fl~6/6~.
96. ~~ ~ dzr~~t ar~~ ~rox~~ai~ r~~ul~ ~iF T~~~~~~~nt's u~au~l~c~riz~~ ~~ts9 the ~Jr~iv~~~sity
kz~s su~f~z•ed, and will ~ontira~,~~ t~ suffer, unless s~i~ cc~;~au~~ is ~~~jozr~~d by this Court, both
s~bsta~~i~l z~on~t~r~ ~az~a~~s,i~ az~ ~~z~~nt to b~ p~•~v~n ~~ dial, a~~ s~abst~nti~l az~~•~~a~•abl~ z~juz-y
to its ~;~~dwi11 ~~~ x~~ut~~tion ~~~• wl~i~h tk~~r~ is no ad~~ua1~ z~~zn.~dy ~t l~tiv.
97. `~'l~~ ~Jniv~xsi~y i~ ~~~itl~~ t~ inju~~tiv~ x~l~~~ ~r~d o~~taxy d~z~ag~s9 ~~ will ~s ~Il
p~°c~~i~s ~r~cl/~r r~v~n~~~ ~~iz~ed ~y I)~f~nd~.n~ as a x~sul~ ~~ ~_t~ ur~l~vvful ~.~ts, ua~d~r 76~ I~,~~ §
1036/`70.
9~. ff~ddatzoraal~y, ~~~'~n~~.~t's ~ai~l~~al c~xac~u~;t grad r~cl~l~s~ ir~~z~f~g°~r~~~ i~ the
~J~aiv~~~ity~~ xi~~its ~ntz~l~~ t~~ U~zv~x~ity t~ a ~°~~ov~~y s~f ~~~ x~~~~~~bl~ att~r~ey~' f~~s ~ra~ tz•~bl~
~~~g~s pur~~~ar~~ t~ 765 ~~,C~ § 106/~Q.
99. `~la~ ~J~iv~~~sity ir~~or~~t°at~s by z°~~~r~r~~~ the ~ll~~;~tions ~~~tain~d in ~~~a~x•ap~s 1
t~ou~h 9~ ~~ if~ hilly sit ~~z°t~ h~r~in.
19
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 20 of 30
1 fly. ~~ X11 z°~l~v~t~t tzr~a~~, the I~linoi~ L1~~X~~c~z~z~ ~~~~r~tz~r~ ix°~~~ ~~°~~tic~s ~~;t
( ")
"~i~T~~ way iz~ ~~f~~t iz~ Il]in~is.
1(~1. ~ef~~i~ant'~ ~n~ut1?~r~z~cl u~~ ~f ~h~ ~Jniv~rsity 1+/4arlss, i~z~l~ss ~njoiz~~~ by ~t1~~~
~~ur~, tivill ~ar~~inu~ to ~~us~ ~ lik~li'~o~rl of ~or~f~sao~ oz° o~~ ~isu~d~rstax~dzr~~ a~ ~~ t~~ sour~~,
~~or~~~r~~xP~ ~ppz°c~v~l, ~~~/or ~;~x~ifi~a~i~~ ~f ~~f~~d~r~t's ~c~oc~s. ~'~~c~s~ f~r~xli~r wx~h t~~
~J~~zv~x~~ty I~ar~~s ~vo~~~~ b~ li~~ly 10 bey ~~~~z~cl~r~~'~ g~oo~~ ~s ~z~cl ~~~° ~? pr~du~t ~~~~ and sold by
t~a~ IJnivez~~ity. ~~~fl~diz~gly, any c~~f~~t, ~bje~t~~n <~r f~t,~lt fend w~~h ~ef~~~an~'~ ~~c~d~, ~x az~y
~~~~tiv~ ~s~c~~x~ta~~ ~~~~~~t~d th~x~ewit~, ~vo~l.d n~~~ss~x~~1y ~°~:~~~t ~egativ~ly u~~z~ aid s~ri~usly
ir~ju~~ the ~~p~at~tz~r~ ~r~~1 gc~c~~w~l~ w1~i~~ ~h~ IJz~ivexsity l~_~s ~st~'~lish~~ fir ids pxodu~t~ sc~l~ ~z~~~~°
its ~Jz~ivexsit~ I'~~il~s.
X02. ~~f~nd~r~t's knowing ~z~~. willk~ul ~c~nd~~~, ~~ ~~~crzt~~~ ~bov~, ~~~statut~s
d~;~eptiv~ tx~~~ p~•a~ti~~s tivithir~ the e~.ni~~ c~~ ~e~tio~ 2 of the ~J~~'~~., ~ 15 I~,~~ ~ 5 J_ 0/2.
~{~3. !~s ~ c~ir~ct arad. ~r~~iz~~t~ r~~ult of ~~~~r~~i~~.~'s ur~~LZt~~xi~~d ~~ts, t~.~ IJ~iv~xsity
ka~~ ~uff~r~d, end wzll ~~~tinL~~ to su£~f~x, ural~~s s~a~ ~o~duc~ ~~ ~njoi~~c~ 'oy t~iis ~~u~°t, bs~th
~~b~tan~i~l ~~o~~Lary c~~a~~~;~s, ire. ~n ~~.c~unt ~o b~ prove ~t ~r~.~1, ~n~ ~ubs~~~ti~1 x~°r~,~~r~bl~ zz~~u~°'I
~;~ ~~~ ~€~~d~~all ~~cl x~p~~~i~~;~ ~oz° w~.i~h th~z-~ ~s ~o ~~l~~u~~~ t~~ ~~y ~t lava.
10~. ~h~ ~Jn~v~;zs~ty i~ ~~~atl~~_ « ~~~~y o~~' ~~r~z~n~~1 i~j~~n~~iv~ ~~1~~~ ~xohibi~i~~
~~~~r~~~r~t ~i°ozn ~oz~tinuis~~ its ~~fri~gi~~ ~s~ oaf ~~~ ~Jz~zv~rszt~ 1'~az•l~s in vis~l~tzor~ ~ f the ~J~~'~A,,
~n~ az~ ~~va~d of ~~~p~~~~tzon _fix aray X11 ~~d all ~~. ~~~~, injury ~r ~iaxz~ i~~uxred ~s ~ ~~~~]f s~f
~~f~n~l~~a~'s ~z~l~va£~l ~ora~~~;t.
1~3~. ~~f~nd~r~t's wxllfi~l ~;~~d~.~~~ az~d r~~kl~ss ira~~fE'~~~~~~~ ~o t~~ U~zv~r~i~y's x~ghts
entitles tkt~ IJr~i~~rsity t~ a r~~~very of ids ~txoz~n~ys' f~~s aid posts puxsuant to ~ 15 ~L~~ § 51(3/x,
~:~ w~11 ~~ pu~ati~v~ d~zna~~s.
~~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 21 of 30
~'~~1~T'~' ~T~~o
V ~OJ ~.rE~~M~FlY~ ~i9'~ 2A%e'i A9J~~1 ~I Y1'~~ ~+LS"AV~~J 1Y913~J31~ ~ NJ k:P`
l J6. ~'~i~ ~Jz~~ver~ity an~oxporal~s b~ ~ef~~~n~~ t?~~ ~11~~~ti~ns ~~~t~.in~~1 an ~~agra~h~ 1
th~~~a~~ 1~5 ~~ if f~l~y sit firth h~x~ir~.
1 fl%. ~~t X11 ~°~1~v~~t t~zn~s, the Illinois ~on~~rr~~x ~'xa~~ az~d ~~~~ptiv~ ~u~~z~es~
(
z~~ci~~~ pct "~~'~'~) w~~ in e~'f~~l i~ ~11i.z~Q~s.
~fl~. ~~f~ndaz~t's una~choriz~~l ~s~ ~f t~Z~ ~Tr~zv~zs~ty 1~1~~r1~~, uz~l~ss ~r~j~zz~~~ by t~~~
~~~~~t, will ~or~ti~u~ t~ ~a~~s~ a lik~lih~o~ ~f ~o~afuszc~~ ~r ~~ rnisua~d~rst~r~di~~ ~s t~ the s~ux-~~,
~p~r~soz°~l~zp, ~.ppxova~, as~~l/~r ~~z°tifi~~tio~ of ~~{~ez~dant's ~ood.s. Th.~s~ ~~mili~~ with the
U~.iv~r~i~y l~/Iax1~~ would. b~ lil~~l~ to bl~y ~~f~rada~t's g~~d~ ~~ ~n~ fog ~ ~xor~u~~ xn~d~ a~~ ~~~d. by
~~~ ~7~iv~~~i~y. ~~~~rdin~ly, ~s~y ~1~~~~~t, objection c~~° fault ~~u~~ r~vzth ~~f~nd~.nt's bonds, six any
n~~ativ~ as~o~iatic~n ~c~~n~~icd tk~~x~v~ith, ~»ul~l r~~c~~s~z°ily r~~~~t z~~g~~ively up~x~ ~n~l ~~r~~usly
injure t~i~ ~°~p~tatzoz~ end goodwill ~~h~~h the Urai~~ersity has ~stablish~d. ~o~ its pra~l~~t~ sold ur~.d~r
zt~ IJ~iv~xsit~ I~~.a°~s.
a_fl~. ~~'~nd~.nt'~ 1t~owin~ ~a~d w~1~fu~ ~;~n~~~;t, ~.s d~~crzb~d ab~v~, ~~ns~xtut~s
~~~;~~~iv~ ~~~~d~ p~°~~~~~~~ wit~iz~ ~~~ z~~~ni~~ of ~~~ti~~ 2 ~~ z~~~ ~1~~'~~, ~1S ~~,~~ ~ 51D/2. ~s
5~~h, ~~f~~d_ant'~ ~c~~ac~~.~~t also vaolat~~ ~~~tio~ 2 ~f t~Z~ ~~'~, X15 ~~,~~ § ~~~/~.
13.0. f~.~ a ~l~z~~t anal pz~xi~~t~ ~•~~~11 cif ~~f~~d~~t'~ u~.~~t~~~z~~c1 ~,~ts, ~h~ ~J~iv~xszty
has sr~f~'~x~d, a~ad ~vzll ~oratinu~ to suf~~x, un1~~s said ~ond~~t zs ~z~jo~r~~d by this C~~ri, bath
~~~~~t~ntial ~~~et~~~ dazesages,zn az~ ~.rno~z~~ tc~ b~ p~°~~~r~ ~t ixz~~, ~~d s~ab~~a~ti~1 irr~p~r~'~~~ ~~jury
to zts g~od~vill az~~ x~put~tior~ ~~~° ~vh~ch ~~a~r~ is nc~ ~.d~~ua~~ x~zn~~y ~t law.
11 ~. T~~ U~~v~zsity is ~nti~l~d to ~~e~ov~c ids ~~t~~l d~r~ag~~ ~az~d~x ~~5 I~.,~~ ~ ~~5/10~.
zl
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 22 of 30
1X2, ~~idztio~al~~, ~~f~~~ant'~ vvillfi~l ~c~n~lu~t end x~~l~l~s~ iza~if~ex~nc~ to the
~Jr~~~~r~ity'~ ri~ht~ ~ntitl~s tk~~ L7~it~~rs~~ to inj~ra~tiv~ ~~li~f, a~ will a~ a r~~o~v~rJ ~f ~~s ~os~s,
~tt~z°n~f~' f~~s, ~r~d pua~itiv~ d~zn~g~s ~u~°suan~ to ~ 1 ~ I~,~~ ~ ~~~/1 fly.
~'~~TT~'~(' ~~~~a
a ~3. ~'~~ IJr~i~~~z°pity in~c~z°~~x°~t~~ by r~f~z•~a~~~ ti~~ ~11~g~tioz~s ~~ni~.in~~ ~n ~~~°~~x~phs 1
~hx~~~~i ~ J ~ ~,s if fully ~~t ~~~~ h~x~iz~.
114. ~'~~~ ~Trai~~~~sity has ~p~r~~ ~~b~ta~ti~l a~~z~ts of x~z~r~~y a~~ e~f~~~t ~~v~l~~z~g t~~
~Jr~iv~x~ity S~xl~~, as w~~l ~s goc~dwzJ_l a:~d ~°~~ut~tion ix~ its b~sin~~s.
115. `~'h~ Uz~zv~a•sity l~arl~s are tk~e pxo~~x~~ ~fthe ITzs~v~xsify.
116. ~'k~~ ~1niv~x°saty owns, ~a~s t'~c ~x~lusiv~ right t~ u~~, a~~d uses ~h~ ~J~iv~r~iYy I~/~arl~~
t~o~ k~~~at ~h~ ~J~ite~l ~t~t~~ ire ~~~~~~tz~r~ vait~ ~, wz~~ ran~~ ~f goods a.~~ spa°vi~~~, ~~~~~dir~~, but
~~t lzr~it~d t~, t-~hirt~ end ~t~~z~ vv~~~°zng ~~p~.x°~t.
117. T~~ Univ~~~saty IUf~rks ~r~ znt~~x~.~ p~i~ts oftie lJ~.~v~~•sity'~ b~?sir~~~s,
~ 1 ~. ~~f~~d~~t's u~~u'~horiz~~ u~~ ~f tk~~ IJniv~r~~x~ 1V.~ar~~ s~e~~ ~~ d~~xiv~ ~~.~
IJnav~~•sit~ ~f'th~ ~u~~~~n~x~l ~~~dvai~l ~~~ ~xclu~zv~ ri~~t~ i~~ the ~T~iv~xszly l az°~s, and is lrlc~ly tt~
~~.us~ ~~z~~~~i~a~ ~s Lc~ ti~~ ~~ux~~ cif ~~f~radant's ~oocas iza that t~.~ p~.~bl~~ may ~ss~~z~.t~ su~;h g~o~~
~v1t1~ end a~ ~rigir~atin~ from t~~ ~~Jz~iv~z°pity. ~'hc~s~ f~zz~i~.i~x w~tl~ the ~J~1v~rs~ty I'~~xl~s v~~ulc~ b~
~~l~elJ t~ buy ~~f~~d~~t'~ ~~~ds ~~ ~~d ~o~ ~ p~°~d~~~~t ~ad~ ~~c~ ~~1~ by t1~.~ ~J~~v~z~3_a~,
~~~~.rclin~;ly, ~.x~y ~~~~~;~, c~bj~~tzc~r~ c~z° ~~u~t f~un~ vaith ~~f~nd~z~t's ~c~~~1~, o~• ~~.y ~e;~t~v~
~ssc~~X~ti~n ~or~~c~t~~ th~x~with, ~~ti~ld ~~~~~s~r~ly x°~~1~~t n~~ativ~~y u~o~ end s~~xo~a.~ly ir~ju~°~ t~~
r~~i.~~~ti~n ~n~ ~o~dwill ~a~ich the L7z~i~~xsity ~~s ~~t~.blish~d for zts pxc~~u~ts sold_ ~~~.d~x~ its
IJn~~~rszty 1U~~x1~~.
22
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 23 of 30
7.1~. ~~f~nd~nt'~ a~tic~~s ~c~~sti9ut~ ~ wi~lfi~l azad za~t~~ti~x~l z~zs~pp~•~p~-iatx~s~ cif ~:h~
~T~aav~~~~i~ty 1'~~rl~~, t~~ IJ~a~v~rsity's ~~~l~~i~v~ rigk~t~ i~ the ~Tr~iv~x~i~t~ I~/t~z•l~s, ~r~d the ~Tr~iv~z~~~ty's
~o~~wi~l, ire vz~l~ti~n ~f the ~o~rzz~~~. lam of tra~~~~~°k ~z~f~~z~~~~~~t of the ~tat~ of ~llin~z~.
120, ~~f~n~,~t~~'~ ~cti~~s ~av~ k~axrn~d ara~ wall ~on~~n~a~ ts~ ~;~u~~ irr~parabl~ ~~~°,
d~ ~~~ end znj~axy ~c~ tka~ ~Jnav~~•~~'~~, ~~d t~~ IJ~iv~rsa~ty hay ~~ ~d~c~~at~ ;~~r~~d~ ~t la~v ~~x° the
zz~juxy ~~us~~ ~~.~ t~ b~ ~~~zs~d by I~~f~z~danc'~ u~au~hori~~~l a~;ts.
1~,7.. ~s a ~ir~~t ~r~~ px~x~rrz~t~ ~•~s~lt ~f ~fe~~~~t's ~~r~d~~1, the Urai~~~z~zty ~.as
su~~~r~c~, ~~d is ~ntitl~~l t~, dar~~~g~:~ in an az~~un_t ~~ b~ pz°c~v~ci at trail.
122. f~.d~litic>n~~l~, I~~~~n~a~at's ~villf~l ~;ond~~~t ~n~ ~•~~~l~ss z~~dif~'~xeza~~ t~ t~~
~Tni~~a•~~t~'~ rights ~~~itl~s 1~~ IJniv~rsxty t~ i~ijun~tiv~ ~°~l~~f, a~ well as ~ z°~~c~v~xy ~z ~~s ~o~ts,
a~:tc~~~n~y~' f~~s, ~~~d pur~.itiv~ dar~z~g~s.
~'~~Tl~t~' ~~a
123. T~~ ~7n~v~rs~ty arn~c~z~~or~tes by z•~~~z°~z~~~ t~~ ~1leg~tions ~s~~t~ined ire ~~rag~°~phs .l
~~ZZ°~~a~;~ 122 ~~ ~f fully s~~ f~z-lh k~~~~ir~.
124. ~'k~~ ~Jz~~v~rsz~y ~vuns, hay the ~xcl~~iv~ z°~~~1 t~ ~~~, ~~~c1 u~~~ t~a~ ~Jr~iv~r~ity I~/~~rl~s
i~ ~oz~r~~~;~ic~sa vvi~1~ ~ wz~~ r~ng~ ~f ~os~~s aid ~~x~vi~~s, in~lu~a~~, but not li~z~~d t~,, 1~shi~°ts aid
ot~.~r ~~~ari~~ ~~pa~°~~.
?2~, ~~~~nd~at, ~lar~u~h its ~~na~th~riz~~d ~~~ ~f the ~J~iv~~~~it~'S trad~r~~~s, ~~
~~~~~r~~xiat~~ v~l~z~bl~ ;~~°~p~~°ty ~z~~ts ~~ the U~~v~x~~ty aid h~.~ c~a~~d o~ the ~oo~vaill
sy~balzz~d 1~y t~~ disti~~tiv~ ar~d vv~llal~~w~ ?J~zv~rszty I~~r~~. I~~f~a~~ara~'~ a~s~ i~ 1i1~~1~ t~
~a~s~ ~~nl~rsion ~n~ ~~~ezv~ t~~~~b~z~ s~f~th~ ~~ra~uan~ p~,ibli~;, i~ vic~l~.tio~ ~~th~ ~~rns~o~ l~.w ~~
u~fazx ~s~ p~t~ti~z~ ~f t~~ ~t~~~ s~f Illinc~i~. ~'hos~ ~~ ili~~ with ~~~ IT~iv~rsity l~~rlcs would l~~
li~~el~ ts~ buy I~~~f~z~~lant's ~s~~ds ~~ ~a~c~ for a pr~duc~t rnar~~ ar~d ~~lc~ by the ~J~xv~~sit~.
~3
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 24 of 30
A~~~r~li~~~y, any ~~f~~9;, c~'~j~~ti~o~ car ~~,~1t found ~v~tl~ ~~f~n~l~z~t'~ g~~~ls, ~~ ~z~_y ~~~at~v~;
~sss~~;iati~~ ~:c~~r~~~t~d thez~ew~.th, vv~uld s~~~~~~~rily z°~~l~~t n~gati-v€~ly upon ~z~c~ s~~~ioi~sl~ ~~juz-~ 1:h~
r~put~tio~ and ;oodwa~l ~v~~~~a the ~Jniv~xsxty ka~s ~~~~~lish~~ fox its ~rc~du~ts ~ol~ ~nd~r its
IJniv~z°szty l~arl~s.
126. ~~~~nd~~~'s ~ozad~.~~t, ~s d~~~~°i'o~~. above, coz~~t~tut~,~ f~,l~~ d~~igr~~~~on ~~£ ~rigi~a
aid i~ lil~~~.y t~ ~a~,ts~ ~~~f~si~r~, ~zst~1~:~, ~r ~~c~~txon zr~ violation of~~h~ ~c~~n~~r~_ l~,~w cif she stag;
of Illinois, in th.~ ~'o~~s of txacl~z~~.r~t ira:.fi°ia~g~ ~~t end ~zaf~.z~ ~~r~p~ti~i~n.
127. ~~~~r~d~r~t'~ actions ~~v~ ~arrn~c~. a~~ wzll ~oz~tir~u~ to ~a~~~ i~~~paz~bl~ h~3° ,
d~ ~.~~ ~z~~ i~ajuxy ~~ ~h~ ~Jn.iv~~~zty, ~~.~ t~Z~ Ur~zv~xsi~y has zoo ~cl~~~zat~ r~rrz~c~~ ~t lavv fir the
inj~xy ~~us~d ~~d t~ b~ ~aus~cl by ~~f~nd~nt's un~uthoz°az~d acts.
124. ~,~ ~ ~li~°~c~ aa~d ~roxirs~at~ z•~su~~ o~ ~ef~nd~s~t'~ ~~s~~u~~, 1~~ ~Tniv~~sity has
s~~~~x~~, ~~d is ~~~atl~d to, d~~a~~s i~ an az~.o~aaat to b~ ps~~~~d ~t trial.
1~9. ~~clit~~a~~lly, ~~~~n.dznt':~ r~aillf~l ~;orz~u~t end x~~l~l~ss i~~z~f~x~n~~ tc~ the
~Jnivex~s~ty'~ r~~k~ts ~nti'~1e~ the ~Jr~iv~x~sit~ ~o injun~tiv~ r~li~f, ~s will ~s a ~~~c~v~~°y of its ~~~~~,
~~t~xn~,y~' ~'~~s, ~z~d puz~itiv~ cl~m~g~~.
130. ~1~_~ Univ~x~zt~ in~~xpor~t~s by z~_f~r~r~~~ the ~ll~~~~ior~s ~~~t~i~~d iz~ l~ax~~a-~~~s 1
1:~rc~u~~ 7.29 ~~ i~ ~i~lly sit ~~r~h ~~r~i~,
131. T~i~ ~Tz~iv~rsity ~~~z~~, ~a~~ the ~x~lu~zv~ r~~ht ~o ~~~, a~~1 u~~s ~~a~ ~In_iv~rs~t~ ~~z•l~s
iz~ ~c~n~~~ti~~ with ~ ~id~ x~~a~;~ ~f ~s~~ds ~~d s~rvi~~s, i~~luain~, but ~c~t lzmzt~d to, t~-sl~i~•ts and
~~h~z va~~z°i~~ ~ppa~°~1.
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 25 of 30
l ~2. Thy tlniv~~°sity hay ~p~nt subst~~ti~l ar~~unts ~z rnoz~~y a~~ ~f~oxt d~~~lopiz~~ the
~Jz~iv~~°~i~y i ~rl~s, ~~ vv~ll ~~ ~oo~l~~zll end r~p~?~t~tion i~z its'~u~in~ss.
133. ~'h~ ~Jn.3v~xsaly h~~ the ~x~lusiv~ xz~hc ~o z~arl~~t, b~°~nc~, ~~~d sill ~;oo~~ th~c~u~ho~,~t
the ~T~it~~l ~t~t~s u~i~~ ~h~ U~iv~rszty ~~xl~~.
13~-. ~~fe~d~~~ h~~, v~~zt~a~~t cox~s~~t ~x ~~a~hoz~iz~~z~n fi~oz~ t~~ IJ~aiver~zty, 1~~~~ur~n~~y
~z°~~~c~d ~~~_ ~s~n~tx~ibut~d to thiz•d p~xtx~~' x~~~a1~, ~ff~x~ fix x~~~sale, dish°ib~zt~~n zcl/o~°
~~v~ztis~~~r~c of p~°oc1~~t~ ~a~~ ~~xvi~;~~ ~i~azzn~ t~~ Uz~zv~xsaty l~~z°1~s whi~1~ ~~~ cif ~u~stior~ak~l~
~a~t~ az~d ~~~ality, with tk~~ in~er~t that said gird ~axti~~ ws~uld put t~~ prod~~l:s ~r s~zvic~s t~ use i~
~c~mznzt~in~ the viol~tio~s. 5~~h con~u~~ h~~ d~pz°iv~d ~h~ ~J~~~~e~~sity ~f its subst~nt~~i ~.atzc~~al
~~~~will ar~d ~s 1i1~~1y ts~ ~aus~ ~o~afusioz~, istak~ ~n~ de~~p~xoz~ t€~ pe;xsp~;~iiv~ or ~~tua1
~ons~~a~~s, ~~ will ~s dilution ar~~ t~rnishr~~z~t o~t~~ distin~~iv~ ~u~licy ~~~t~~ U~zv~rsity l~~x•lcs.
13~. ~'hos~ faznili~~ vdith the Univ~x~sity Niarlcs tivould b~ lzk~ly tc~ buy S~~f~nd~n.~'~
~~~a~ ~~ ~nc1 fog• a pr~~u~t xa~ad~ ~~c~ ~c~ld by t~~ ~Jniv~xszty. A.~;c;ordi~~ly, ~n~ d~~~~t, obj~~;tioz~ ~x
fault f~u~~_ with ~~f~z~d~~t's ~~c~ds, ~r zr~y z~e~ativ~ as~o~;ia~aon ~os~r~~~~~~ ~:h~z•~vait~Z, dv~uld
z~~~~ssa~°~1~ z~fi~ct ~~~~~~_v~~y ~apc~r~ and ~~x°zo~sly i~j~.~z•~ t~a~, x•~p~a~~tio~ and goodwill wi~.i~h the
~~Jc~zv~~°si~~ zaa~ ~~t~.~lis~.~d f~~• zfis prc~du~ts s~~~l ~z~c~er z1s [Jz~zv~xszt~ ~/~~rks.
X36, T~~f~nda~t ~r~as ~it~~z• willfully bli~.~ t~ any or~~~zr~~ vic~~~~i~n~ ~~ tk~~ [Jz~av~~°~zty'~
z°fights i~ 9~'~~ ~Jnav~xsaty I~~xl~s, ~or int~xa~i~r~~lly supplied th~~~ thi~~ paa°ki~~ ~r~it~ p~°~~~~ts ~r
s~rvi~~~ ~~~pi~~ 1~~~ivi~~ t~a~ they w~r~ ~ng~~isa~ its xz~f~zz~giz~~ a~txviti~~. 3~~ r~~~~~ t~a~x~o~;
~~f~rzd~~at ~s ~ontz°i~bu~orily r~sp~n~ibl~ f~~° the ~.ar~ t1~at has r~sult~~ t~ the ~.Jniv~rsity f~•~zn the
infxingin~ a~tzvi~i~s of th~s~ third ~~z~ti~s.
13'7. ~~fendant's ur~a~lhoriz~d acts ~~~st~t~a~~ ~ontribut~xy infring~~~~t of t~~
~J~a~v~xsi~y'~ xi~hts 7_~ ~h~ ~Jniv~x°~at~ 1~a~lcs, as v✓~11 a~ ~c~~tz•i~ut~r~ ~n~air ~orrr~p~ti9i~r~, iz~ vX~lata~n
25
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 26 of 30
cif ~~~t~~~~ 3~{1)9 ~~(~.), az~d ~3(~) ~~ tla~ Z,~~~aaz~ ~~t, 2~ ~T.~.~. §§ 111~(1)(a.), J_ 12~(a) and
112 {~), ~~~~ion~ 6~ end C~~ ~f the T ~~, 76~ I~,~'~ ~~ ~fl36/6fl and ~036/~~; a~~d the ~~r~r~~~.
l~~v.
13~. ~'h~ ~fc~r~s~i~ ~s~z~~~,~~t o~ ~~f~n~.~~t as tivill~ial, ~elib~r~t~, iz~t~~ti~~~l, ar~_~ ~n bad
ac~i~l~ ire th~~ ~~f~r~~~r~t'~ a~t~ off' ~;~~t~~ib~.it~~•y a~fx~~~~~a~~t c~f~ the ~J~iv~xsity l ar~~s w~r~
p~~~foz°zlra~d with ~ul~ ~~n~vvled~~ that ~h~ U~iv~xsaty ov✓~s ~n1 has ~~_~ ~~~lusiv~ t~i~ht cc~ ease the
;
IJni~a~x°city 1`~arl~s, arzd after n~t~~~ £x°orn t~~ Un~v~~°sity t~ ~~as~ i~~ i~frir~~i~ ~~tivit~~s.
~~9. °endaz~~
~,~.~ IJ~iv~Y•~ity is ia~r~rzn~d and'r~~li~v~s, and ors th~~ basis alleges, that I~e~
iv~1J_ ~oa~taz~~,~~ t~ use the ~J~~iv~xszty 1~/Marks and ~th~x ~r~d~~n~rl~~ ~r t~~ U~.~ve~~sily uz~l~s~ ~njs~i~~~.,
1~~. l~s a dir~~t end prc~xia~at~ x~~sult of ~~f~nc~az~t's a~~~ c~~ ~ontxibutoxy infi•iz~~~m~nt,
9~~ ~J~i~~~~°sity leas ~uff~~•~cl, ~a~d v~ill cc~ntxnu~ tc~ s~aff~x, u~1~ss said ~~~du~~ zs ~~.j~in~d by this
C~~~, bath saabst~n~ial ~~nc~taxy dam~~~s, i~ ~n ~m~u~~ to b~ pxov~~ ~~ 9ria1, a~~ s~bst~~tzal
a~~~~ar~bl~ izajuzy to its ~~~dv~~~l ~~d ~•~b~~a~a~r~ foz~ ~vhi~h ~h~~~; x~ i~~ a~Y~~~~t~ r~~ae~3y ~t l~~v.
1~1, ~~~°~ua~tto l~ ITe~.~. ~ ~11~(a) aa~~ 16~ ~~,~5 ~ 103F~/`7~, ~~a~.IJr~iv~~-sit~i~ ~~ntit~ed
to an ~~;~~~z~~~ng fc~r, end a ~~s~~x~~r~~r~.~ ~f, X11 ~f ~~f~rzr~~~at'~ z°~~~~u~s end/c~x~ ~z~~~zt~ cl~_riv~cl.
rc~ ~t~ iz~~~i~~~~a~ ~~e of the U~i~~xsity I~~rl~~ ix~ ~c~~~~~ticz~ ~itk~ t~~ "~Tn~ffi~i~l" t--~hzxt an1 any
c>ch~i° t-~~~z~~ ~r ~oc~d~, ~~ will a~ ar~~ daz~~~;~~ the ~J~~iv~~~~ity ~~~~ suff~z°~d end t~~~ ~s~sts s~f'1~~ir~~i~~~
t~ais ~,~~~c~z~.
X42, ~.~dzta~r~~1ly, by r~as~n ~~'xh~ ~~vzll~~l ~~d ~l~lib~x~t~ a~;~~ ~c~nd~~~~~~ by ~~f~~d~n.~
icy ~c~aa~~;i~a~s disz°~g~zd :foz~ the rights cif lh~ IJz~i~v~x~z~~, tl~~ ~J~iv~zsity is ~z~tz~l~d t~ t~~bl~ ~~.rnage~
~~~~x 1~ IJ.~.~. § ~ 117(a) ~z~~ '165 ILC~ § 1036/"70.
143. ~uz-t~~xz~ao~~, the ~Tniv~xsity ~~ ez~tzt~ed to ~e~ov~z~ its attoin~ys' ~'~~s as ~~~~nda~~t's
~~tzo~.s tiv~x~ willful az~~ ~~liberat~, and p~~ti~ulaz~ly ~gr~~ic~us given the ~r~autk~~oriz~d ~a~e of the
26
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 27 of 30
xJniv~r~aty's txad~rs~a~•1~~ ire ~onr~~~tzc~n witk~ ~;o~~s o~ ~~~~stic~nabl~ t~sk~ t~~~ ~~pres~ly ~~~ol
"dx~z~lc~ng" end `~~~bau~l~~xy," x~zz~l~rin~ this ~~ "~~c~~ti~z~~~" ~as~ ~~a.~e~ 1~ ~1.~.~. ~ 111"I(~) a~~
7~5 ~i,~~ ~ 1036/70.
~~I ~ ~'~ E, ~~ to X11 ~o~nts ~~' ~hzs Ct~ plai~z~, the U~iv~~~a~y prays fez° ~udg~~~zat ~~
foll~~vse
{~) ~ ~ir~~ir~~ 'ghat:
(1) ~~~~r~d.~nt hay ~~ga~~d ire acc~ of~dzl°~~t and/or ~c~~t~~zbuto~y t~~~.del~arl~
~r~frir~~~m~~t, f~1~e d~~iQn~,ti~~~ o~~ oxi~ir~9 f~ls~ d~~~rxp~i~n ~r Ll~~~ir
~c~rn~~titi~~9 a~~ t~a~~l~~z°~s c~iluti~r~ is~ vXOl~t~c~n ~~ 15 ~J.~.~. §~
(2) ~~f~nd~nt bias ~n~a~~d a~ ~~~~ i~ violation cif tk~e ~ll~~ois ~'x~de ar~~
~~ist~•~~i~n ~z~d ~ic~t~~ti~z~ Act,'765 I~,C~ 1036/1, ~t seq., I_ll~z~~is
I~~~~ptive Tra~~ ~~•~.~tic~s ~.~t, X15 ~~,CS § Slfl/1, ~t,~eq., ~n~]. t~~ illi~oi~
~~ns~a~~x Fa~~ud ~~d ~~~~~~~v~ F~z~ines~ ~z°actz~~s Apt, X15 IL,CS § ~0~/l,
~t s~~.; an~1
(3) ~~f~~dar~t has ~s~~~g~~ is~a u~_fai~ ~~xnp~l~tz~n and ~x~~~rz~~k i~frixab~r~~~t
in viol~ti~n of the c~rnr~oz~ I.aw ~~ chi ~tat~ ~f Illia~c~zs.
(~) Pex~as~~z~~ i~j~ncti~~~ ~e~i~~, gxaz~t~d ~~xsu~z~t to 15 IJ.~,~. § ~ 1160.) ~z~c~ c~~k~~x
a~pla~~b1~ ~l~ir~~z~ ~t~tutos°y a7~d ~~~a~c~~~ lavv, zn tl~~ f~xz~z of ~n ~xd~r ~r~hibitira.~ ~~~'~nd~~1, aid
a~i c~~h~~°s a~t~z~~ X~ ~c~~~~s°t ox° p~rti~;i~atin~; with ~~~`'~nd~a~t, ~x~:ra ~n~ :~u~~l~~z° ~as~ ~x day°~~~ ~cx
~;o~tai~~~tc~x°y ir~f~~in~~rn~nt ~f t~a~ ITniv~r~~ty 1V~~z°~~s ~r ~z~y c~th~x° L1~ai~~~z°pity 3:x~~~maz•1<s. ~'~i~ x~lz~~
s~~~~#i~~lly a~~~~~1~s the ~followir~~ ~r~hib~ti~z~~:
(1) d~x~;~~ly or ~~dia•~~t1y ~~z~ufa~t~~~n.~, ~~lling, ~~~~r~z~g fir s~l~,
distz•ibu~ia~~, px•odu~i~~, ~;zrcul~.ti~~, aid/or ~dvet°~isiz~~ products ~~° s~r~ii~~s
~v~i~h b~~x ~.ny ~~py ~r ~c~lc~z•abl~ zrr~i~katzon ~f the IJn?~a~~°sity'~ tz•~d~ ~z°1~~,
ar~d vahi~~ are likely to ~~a.~s~ ~o~fusi~~, to ~~us~ r~~s1~1~~, ox to ~~us~
d~c~pti~~. with ~z• with ~°~sp~c~ t~ tie Ur~iv~rsity's trad~~.~~~ks;
(2) ~as~ng in ~za~ rna~n~Y° the ~Tnzv~~°~i~J l~az•ks ~~~ ~z~y ~~~~r ~~°adez~naY~l~, tr~d~
name, s~rvi~~ mark, cc~~-~or~t~ n~~~, ox any otk~~t~ d~sz~z~atz~n kl~~t zs
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 28 of 30
co~fusia~~l~/ sirnila~ ~~ the [Ja~iv~r~ity'~ txa~~z~~xlss ~~ t~ b~ l.ik~ly ~k~ ~~~~s~
~~r~fizsaoz~, d~~~pti~r~, c~z° ~rzist~l~~,
~3) ~assin~ ~f~, zz~cl~~~iz~~, ox• ~~aablir~~ €~t~~xs tc~ s~l~ cox piss off any ~oc~ds car
s~rvi~~s ~~ b~in~ ~ppxov~~I by 1h~ ~J~iv~r~i~y, which g~c~~s az~cl s~z°vz~~~
are riot ~~ :fait appz•ov~d b~ the L1n~v~rsity, oA° fir ~~1~ under ~t~~ az°ks
owr~~~ ~y the Unzv~xsity c~a• any ~~~iex rrr~~rk ~v~aa~~ so x~s~mbl~s tk~~
IJr~zv~z•~ity'~ ~~~lcs as to b~ 1il~~~y to ~a~?s~ ~~n~~~aon, de~~pti~~, ~~•
r~istal~~;
(4~) ~~~~itti~~ az~y ~~t~, in~l~ading use of ~r~y f~ls~ ~l~,~a~z~~t~~n ~f t~r~g~~ ~z°
~~als~ c~e~~;ri~ti~r~, ~1~~~1~ ~~r~ ~r is lil~el~ i~ l~a~ ~h~ tr~d~ ~r p~b~i~, ~~
in~ivi~~~1 a~~~~b~r~ t~~x°~~f, t~ ~z~t~lc~s~zy'o~1z~v~ that ~a~y product ~i°
s~rvz~~ a~v~~•~is~~l, ~e~rr~s~t~~, of_f~~~d, or sold b~ ~ef~~da~t i~ ~poz~sc~~~~,
~z~dox°s~~, ~~nn~~~~d vvath, ~pp~•s~vecl, oz° aut~.o~•i~~~1 by the I1z~iv~z•sity,
(~) i~nit~tiz~~, ~o~yi~~, dupla~atir~~, or ~~h~zvdzs~ rnaki~~ ax1J ~~~ ~f the
Ua~iv~~~sity tr~.~~za~a~lcs ~z any z~,~xl~ ~o~f~sz~~~y szrraalax t~ the ~Tz~zv~rsity's
tz~~~d~z~axlc~;
(6) ~~~a~~ra~ i~ ar~y o~l~~z° apt ~~nstituting un~aix ~c~mp~tition ~sx• s~~~~~tiv~
pra~tic~s with the ~Jn~v~xszty ox ~onstitutir~~ are inf~r~n~~m~z~t ~~ the
University's rights i~a anal ~~ its t~°~d~zn~~l~~;
(%) fuz~ther ~ilutiz~~ a~~1 ~z~~ri~~~in~ ~~e LTnivexsity's trad~~arl~~ a~c~ da~ag~~g
its gc~o~v,~x~l; ar~d
(~) ~upplyi~.~ any ~th~z pexs~~ ~r b~.,iszn~~~ ~~atity ~vitn p~oc~~act~, ~~xv~~~~, ~r
~th~r g•~s~uz~c~~ ~u~~~i~~t tc~ ~raabl~, ~z~~ag~, ~t° p~xfc~z•sza ~~ay of tla~
a.nfrzs~~i~g ~~~ivXti~s ~~.~zz~~x~.t~c~ in sub~~xa~r~phs (l) k~ {"7) ab~ov~, ~~
~1~.~r~vas~ zn~~~i~~, ~ssi~tin~, ai~in~, ~~• ~b~itzz~~; ~.:~c~t~~z~ p~z°~o~ cox
b~si~a~ss ~~tit~ ire ~~~~ i~f~in~iz~~ ~c~xvzta~~,
~~) ~n ~zd~~• ~i~~i~~l ~~fend~~s ~~r ~~y ~~~.~ ~l~ c~~.~a~~~ ~ va~lgbl~ p~z°~u~rzt t~ l 5 ~J.~,~.
§ 111`7(~) ~~~. ~t~Z~x aAr~~l~~~b1~ ~l~izz~x~ sta~ut~xy ~.nd ~o~n~o~ law, zz~ ~~.ount ~~ b~ ~x~~r~~. at t~i~19
~~d ~~~~~~~all~ lz~~lu~lixzg but nit lir~i~~~ t~: (l) z~~n~taxy d~s~a~g~s ~~~t~i~~d by t~~ U~aiv~rszty,
~n~lu~laz~g tz°~bl~ d~~~~es;(2) all ~;aia~~, a°~~a~r~u~3, p~°c~~its end/~r adv~nt~~~~ ~arr~e,d ~~ ~ r~~~alt ~zthe
unl~~vf~l ~~ts ~f ~~f~ndant as sit forih h~r~i~; (3) posts ~n~ px~jLic~grrn~nt z~t~r~st; ~xzd (4)
r~~so~a~bl~ atto_rr~~ys' f~~s.
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 29 of 30
(~) ~u_~:~ c~~her ~~d furth~x ~~~1i~in~ry ~~d final r~1i~f that ~~~ ~C~~rt ~~~~a~ j~s~,
~~~it~~l~ ~r~c~ prs~p~z, r~~l~~~lia~g an ~~v~z°d o~ p~ni~i~~ end ~x~ pl~xy c~az~a~~;~~.
~~J ~` ~~l~il~i~
~l~.ir~ti~~ ~~reby ~.~a~~nd~ ~ trim by ja~iy s~~z X11 ~~~.~r~t~ ~s~ tri~ble.
~~ate: ~~pt~z~.b~$° 6, 2~3~2 ~~p~~~fiall~ s~bi~t~r~,
~T1~TI~J~~Z~~~'~' ~~' ~~,~,~I~IO~~, ~~ai~~~~~
Oa~~ ~f Its A.ttor~~y~
~a~ric~ L. Tyr I~~1~z~
3~ ~ ~. ~I~~kex fix°., ~uit~ 3(~Ofl
C111~~P~, I111a~0i~ 6006
(312)36~-600fl
~ters~c~len@fr~~'~~~°z~p~t~xs.~;orr~
1~~to~n~ysfog plaintiff
2.645841 v3/1461 ~-0059
~~
2:12-cv-02236-HAB-DGB # 1 Page 30 of 30
V~~2I~+'I~'~~'I~~
I, Martin I~aufi~la,nrl, ~eiz~~ duly svwoi-il uridcz~ oat~~, he1-eby declaz-e anc~ vez-ify under penalty
of I~erj~~lxy under the laws of tk~e united Mates cif America that the state~~ie~~ats set fortl~l iTZ the
at~tacl~eci t~exi~ed Co~n~~laint are true; and coy-rest, ~xce~~f as to matters therein stated to be o.c~
i~~foz-~mation ~~~d belief ~i~id as to such nlattez:s the uzidersigned ec~-~i~es as aioresaicl that he vca~ily
bclieti'es the same to be true.
IvIAR"I,IN I~AU~'MNI~ i'
SUBSCZIBED AND S~7JORN to before Inc
this ,~~~•_--day of Scpte~nber 2012
O~FfCI~L.~S AL
~,~I~~?1_ ~1. P-I~~f~AFI
NOTARY PUBI.lC, 5YATE OF ILLINOIS
~~~,Ir,~..~~,_.~~ ya_,`~. MY C~Mliy ES2~6~2~16,
~..__~~...~j,'~~ t.M ~
~ _ ..
Notary Public
~.
