Learning Center
Plans & pricing Sign in
Sign Out

Fury as welfare police order kidney dialysis patient back to work


Paul Mickleburgh, 53 was diagnosed with renal failure when he was 19. He is so ill that doctors have taken him off the transplant list. The dialysis machine is the only thing keeping him alive. Yet he has been ordered back to work!

More Info
  • pg 1

Fury as Tory welfare police order kidney dialysis patient Paul
Mickleburgh back to work
May 31 2012 By Claire Elliot

HE’s one of the world’s longest surviving kidney dialysis patients and has had 33 years of
renal treatment, four failed transplants and 14 heart attacks.
But now, in a shameful indictment of Tory welfare cuts, Paul Mickleburgh, 53, has been
deemed fit to work.
The dad of three, who was diagnosed with renal failure when he was 19, was forced to
give up his job as a technician 20 years ago after his body rejected a fourth donor
He is now so ill doctors have taken him off the transplant list as he would not survive a
fifth operation and will spend the rest of his life on dialysis.
The machine, which cleans his blood, is now the only thing keeping him alive.
But after more than three decades hooked up to it for five hours, three days a week,
other organs, including his heart, are also failing.
The Government insists that under their new employment and support allowance scheme,
which replaces incapacity benefit, “those found to be too sick or disabled to work won’t
be expected to”.
But Paul, from Aberdeen, who has also battled cancer, pneumonia, 14 heart attacks in
the last five years and suffers from spontaneous internal bleeding and brittle bones, has
been placed in a “work-related activity group”.
This requires him to attend “work-focused interviews” and actively look for employment
or his incapacity benefits will be cut.
Incredibly, the Department for Work and Pensions reached their decision without Paul
even being interviewed or given a medical.
Paul said: “How ill do I need to be? Apart from being dead, I don’t know how I can get
much worse. It makes me so angry.
“I was asked to tell them all my illnesses and when I had finished it was a page and a
“I enclosed all my medical history, medication, dialysis times and what it does to me after
being on it for 33 years.
“But to my shock I have been passed fit for work and must attend work focus interviews
and do everything possible to find work or lose my benefits.
“I’d liken this to what the Nazis did, working the disabled and the sick until they dropped
dead and were no longer a burden.”
Paul, who has a mechanical valve fitted in his heart, a twisted bowel and suffers
agonising joint pain as a result of prolonged renal treatment, has now written to his MP,
Malcolm Bruce.
He needs painkillers just to get him through each dialysis session and it takes him a day
to recover.
Paul wrote to the Department for Work and Pensions urging them to reconsider his
position but his plea was rejected.
He was told: “You must take part in work-focused interviews with a personal adviser to
continue to receive employment and support allowance in full.
“The adviser will help you take reasonable steps to move towards work.”
Paul said he believed it was “all to save money and they don’t care who they upset”.
He said: “It’s unrealistic and unreasonable to expect me to attend these meetings when
there is no realistic prospect of an improvement in my health.
“I’m worried sick about these changes and I believe I took my last heart attack due to
this cruel policy which makes the disabled feel they are a burden.
“My wife and children have all worked since leaving school. We’re not a family on the
Paul’s wife, Joyce, who runs her own dog grooming business, said: “I understand that
they’ve got to sort out the benefits, but there are better ways to go about it.
“There is just no way he can go to these meetings, let alone go to work. When he comes
off the machine he goes home to bed and I don’t see him until the next day, he’s so
“What’s he to do, kart the machine around behind him? It’s crazy.”
Aberdeen South Labour MP, Dame Anne Begg, said: “A lot of the changes being made by
this Government seem to be particularly harsh on disabled people. And the people who
are getting hit the hardest are those who have worked hard all their lives.”
A spokeswoman for the Department for Work and Pensions said they did not comment on
individual cases.

To top