Cloud Computing - PowerPoint

Shared by: HC120808003416
Categories
Tags
-
Stats
views:
98
posted:
8/7/2012
language:
English
pages:
58
Document Sample
scope of work template
							Manjrasoft




                         Manjrasoft




                  Cloud Computing:
             The Next Revolution in Information Technology

1
Manjrasoft




                  Manjrasoft




2
             Green Cloud Computing
 Energy-Efficient Cloud Computing:
   Opportunities and Challenges

Dr. Rajkumar Buyya
Cloud Computing and Distributed Systems (CLOUDS) Lab           Manjrasoft
Dept. of Computer Science and Software Engineering     Innovative Solutions for Cloud Computing

The University of Melbourne, Australia                                        Dr Rajkumar Buyya

www.cloudbus.org                                                                    Chief Executive Officer

                                                                                          Manjrasoft Pty Ltd


www.buyya.com
                                                        Room 5.31, ICT Building, 111, Barry Street, Carlton,
                                                                           Melbourne, VIC 3053, Australia
                                                               P: +61-3-8344 1344 | F : +61-3-9348 1184


www.manjrasoft.com
                                                                                     E: raj@manjrasoft.com
                                                                              http://www.manjrasoft.com




                           Major Sponsors/Supporters




                                                                                  Manjrasoft
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
4
             Clouds offer Subscription-Oriented IT
             Services: {compute, apps, data,..} as a
Manjrasoft               Service (..aaS)
                                                     Public Cloud




                          Cloud
                         Manager


                          Private
               Clients     Cloud




                                        Other                      Govt.
                                    Cloud Services             Cloud Services



5
             Cloud Computing
Manjrasoft


                              3 Main Types or Personalities


                   Software-as-a-Service (SaaS): A wide range of
                 application services delivered via various business
                 models normally available as public offering



              Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS): Application development
              platforms provides authoring and runtime environment



               Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS): Also known as elastic
              compute clouds, enable virtual hardware for various uses




6
                                                     Animoto, Sales Force, Google
                                                                       Document
                                      Scientific Computing, Enterprise ISV, Social
                User Applications                 Networking, Gaming




                                                                                       Cloud Economy
                                                  Google AppEngine, MapReduce,
                                                          Aneka, Microsoft Azure
       SaaS




                                       Cloud Programming Environment and Tools:
                                        Web 2.0, Mashups, Concurrent and Distributed
                                                   Programming, Workflow
                 User-level and          Cloud Hosting Platforms: QoS Negotiation
              infrastructure level       Admission Control, Pricing, SLA Management,
                    Platform                             Monitoring
   PaaS
IaaS




                                                    Amazon EC2, GoGrid, RightScale,
                                                                            Jovent

                                     Cloud Physical Resources: Storage, virtualized
                                              clusters, servers, network.
                Infrastructure
                                                                        Public Cloud
                                                                          (IaaS)
Manjrasoft



       User



                 User
              Middleware




                           Master Node


                            Private Cloud
                     (Heterogeneous Resources)                 Hybrid Cloud




                       Slave Nodes
                                                 Slave Nodes
                                                   (Cluster)
8
                   Several Benefits……
Manjrasoft



                              Service
                              Oriented
                                                 Elastic


             Virtualized



                                   Cloud               Dynamic
                                 Computing          (& Distributed)


             Autonomic

                               Market           Shared
                              Oriented       (Economy of
                           (Pay As You Go)      Scale)

9
                       Dark side…..
Manjrasoft

     •   Gartner Report 2007: IT industry contributes
         2% of world's total CO2 emissions




     •   U.S. EPA Report 2007: 1.5% of total U.S.
         power consumption used by data centers which
         has more than doubled since 2000 and costs
         $4.5 billion
10
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
11
             Powering Cloud Infrastructure
Manjrasoft

     •   Modern data centers, operating under the Cloud
         computing model, are hosting a variety of
         applications ranging from those that run for a few
         seconds (e.g. serving requests of web applications
         such as e-commerce and social networks portals) to
         those that run for longer periods of time (e.g.
         simulations or large dataset processing).
     •   However, Cloud Data Centers consume
         excessive amount of energy:
         •   According to McKinsey report on “Revolutionizing Data
             Center Energy Efficiency” :
              •   A typical data center consumes as much energy as 25,000 households.
         •   The total energy bill for data centers in 2010 was over $11
             billion and energy costs in a typical data center doubles
             every five years.
12
                      Where Does the Power Go?
Manjrasoft

                                                      Server/Storage             50%
               Power Consumption in the Datacenter
                                                         Computer Rm. AC   34%


                                                            Conversion     7%


                                                            Network        7%


                                                            Lighting       2%



                                                      Compute resources and
                                                     particularly servers are at
                                                      the heart of a complex,
                                                          evolving system!



     Source: APC
13
                       Clouds Impact on the
Manjrasoft
                           Environment

            Data centers are not only expensive to
             maintain, but also unfriendly to the
             environment.
                Carbon emission due to Data Centers worldwide is
                 now more than both Argentina and the Netherlands
                 emission.
                High energy costs and huge carbon footprints are
                 incurred due to the massive amount of electricity
                 needed to power and cool the numerous servers
                 hosted in these data centers.


14
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
15
                              Background
Manjrasoft


            Traditionally, HPC (commodity clusters) & Data center
             community has focused on performance (speed).
            At the same time, microprocessor vendors have not
             only doubled the number of transistors (and speed)
             every 18-24 months, but
             they have also doubled
             the power densities.
            Moore’s Law for
             Power Consumption:




16
                     Research Motivations of Power
                    Aware/Energy Efficient Computing
Manjrasoft

        Rapid uptake of Cloud Data Centers for hosting industrial
         applications
        Reducing the operational costs of powering and cooling Data
         Centers:
             The tremendous increase in computer performance has come with an even
              grater increase in power usage.
             According to Eric Schmit, CEO of Google, what matter most to Google is
              “not speed but power, because data centers can consume as much
              electricity as a city.”
        Improving reliability
             As a rule of thumb, for every 10°C increase in temperature, the failure rate
              of a system doubles.
             Computing environment affected the correctness of the results.
                  The 18-node Linux cluster produced an answer outside the residual (i.e., a silent error)
                   when running in dusty 85°F warehouse but produced the correct answer when running
                   in a 65°F machine-cooled room.
17
                        Reliability/Implications
Manjrasoft


            Reliability of
             Leading Edge
             Supercomputer
             (D. Reed, 2004)




            Estimated Cost of
             An hour of system
             downtime (W.
             Feng, (ACM
             Queue, 2003):




18
                       Power Aware Computing
Manjrasoft


        Power Aware (PA) computing/communication:
            The objective of PA computing/communications is to improve power
             management and consumption using the awareness of power
             consumption of devices.
            Power consumption is one of the most important considerations in mobile
             devices due to the limitation of the battery life.


        System level power management
            Recent devices (CPU, disk, communication links, etc.) support multiple
             power modes.
            Resource Management and Scheduling Systems can use these
             multiple power modes to reduce the power consumption.




19
                  DVS (Dynamic Voltage Scaling)
Manjrasoft

                DVS (Dynamic Voltage Scaling) technique
                     Reducing the dynamic energy consumption by lowering the supply voltage at
                      the cost of performance degradation
                     Recent processors support such ability to adjust the supply voltage
                      dynamically.
                     The dynamic energy consumption =  * Vdd2 * Ncycle
                          Vdd : the supply voltage
                          Ncycle : the number of clock cycle
                An example

     Power                                       deadline       Power                         deadline
     5.02

                                                                2.02

                       10 msec                    25 msec                    10 msec           25 msec
                (a) Supply voltage = 5.0 V                             (b) Supply voltage = 2.0 V
20
                  DVS-based Power Aware Scheduling
Manjrasoft



            Motivation:
                Develop Resource Management and Scheduling Algorithms
                 that aim at minimizing the energy consumption at the same
                 meet the job deadline.
                Exploit industrial move towards Utility Model / SLA-based
                 Resource Allocation for Cloud Computing




21
                       Taxonomy of Power Management
                                Techniques
Manjrasoft




                                          Power Management Techniques


                       Static Power Management (SPM)        Dynamic Power Management (DPM)


                     Hardware Level       Software Level     Hardware Level       Software Level


     Circuit Level    Logic Level     Architectural Level               Single Server         Multiple Servers, Data
                                                                                               Centers and Clouds

                                                                  OS Level       Virtualization Level




22
                       Data Center Level
Manjrasoft
                                                                     Yes
                                      Virtualization
                                                                     No

                                                               Single resource
                                    System resources
                                                             Multiple resources

                                                               Homogeneous
                                     Target systems
                                                               Heterogeneous


                                                           Minimize power / energy
                                                                consumption

                                                            Minimize performance
             Data center level            Goal
                                                                    loss

                                                             Meet power budget

                                                                    DVFS

                                 Power saving techniques     Resource throttling

                                                                    DCD

                                                           Workload consolidation

                                                                  Arbitrary

                                        Workload            Real-time applications

23                                                            HPC-applications
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
24
                     Cloud Providers Measures
Manjrasoft


            Cloud service providers need to adopt measures to
             ensure that their profit margin is not dramatically
             reduced due to high energy costs.
                Amazon.com’s estimate the energy-related costs of its data centers
                 amount to 42% of the total budget that include both direct power
                 consumption and the cooling infrastructure amortized over a 15-year
                 period.
                Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo are building large data centers in
                 barren desert land surrounding the Columbia River, USA to exploit
                 cheap hydroelectric power.
            There is also increasing pressure from Governments
             worldwide to reduce carbon footprints, which have a
             significant impact on climate change.
               Carbon Tax (July 2012 in Australia) on industries
25
              Green Cloud: “performance” 
Manjrasoft
                   “energy efficiency”
            As energy costs are increasing while availability
             dwindles, there is a need to shift focus from
             optimising data center resource management for pure
             performance alone to optimising for energy
             efficiency while maintaining high service level
             performance.
            We propose Green Cloud computing model that
             achieves not only efficient processing and utilisation of
             computing infrastructure, but also minimise energy
             consumption.



26
             Green Cloud Computing
Manjrasoft

                                  Revenue




                                   Power
                                Consumption




27
                                Cloud Usage Model
Manjrasoft




                                   Cloud
                                Datacenter A




                                                               LAN and Gateway
                                                                    router
     End User                                                 (Network Devices)
                                                                                        Cloud
                                                                                      Computing
                                                              VM and Storage
                                                  Cloud          (Server)
                                               Datacenter B

                                                              Air Conditioning, and
        Internet                                                     Chiller
         Service   Routers                                      (Cooling Devices)
        Provider

                                                              UPS, PDU, lighting
                                                              (Electrical Devices)

                                              Cloud
                                           Datacenter C          Datacenter
                     Internet




28
             Green Cloud Computing
Manjrasoft
                  Architecture




29
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
30
                  Case Study 2: Dynamic VM
Manjrasoft
                        Consolidation

                            User             User              User


                      VM provisioning SLA negotiation Application requests

                                   Global resource managers
               Virtual         Consumer, scientific and business
              Machines                  applications
                 and
                users’
             applications

                                   Virtualization layer
                              (VMMs, local resources managers)

               Pool of
               physical
              computer
31              nodes                Power On            Power Off
                         Three Sub-Problems
Manjrasoft

        When to migrate VMs?
         •   Host overload detection algorithms
         •   Host underload detection algorithms


        Which VMs to migrate?
         •   VM selection algorithms


        Where to migrate VMs?
         •   VM placement algorithms


32
             Proposed “Power-Aware” Algorithms
Manjrasoft

     •   Host overload detection
         •   Adaptive utilization threshold based algorithms
              •   Median Absolute Deviation algorithm (MAD)
              •   Interquartile Range algorithm (IQR)
         •   Regression based algorithms
              •   Local Regression algorithm (LR)
              •   Robust Local Regression algorithm (LRR)
     •   Host underload detection algorithms
         •   Migrating the VMs from the least utilized host
     •   VM selection algorithms
         •   Minimum Migration Time policy (MMT)
         •   Random Selection policy (RS)
         •   Maximum Correlation policy (MC)
     •   VM placement algorithms
         •   Heuristic for the bin-packing problem – Power-Aware Best Fit
             Decreasing algorithm (PABFD)
33
                          Performance Metrics
Manjrasoft

     •   SLA violation metrics
         •   Overloading Time Fraction (OTF) - the time fraction, during
             which active hosts experienced the 100% CPU utilization
         •   Performance Degradation due to VM Migrations (PDM)
         •   A combined SLA Violation metric (SLAV):
             SLAV = OTF * PDM


        A combined metric that captures both energy
         consumption and the level of SLA violations, Energy
         and SLA Violation (ESV):
            ESV = Energy * SLAV:


34
                           Simulation Setup
Manjrasoft

     •   CloudSim with a power package
     •   A Data Center consisting:
         •   800 heterogeneous physical servers containing HP
             ProLiant ML110 G4 and HP ProLiant ML110 G5
             servers.
     •   More than 1000 Heterogeneous VMs
         corresponding to Amazon EC2 instance types
        Workload traces from more than 1000 VMs from
         servers located in more than 500 places around
         the world.
            The data were obtained from the CoMon project, a
             monitoring infrastructure for PlanetLab
35
                Best Algorithm Combinations and
Manjrasoft
                     Benchmark Algorithms




     Dynamic VM consolidation significantly reduces energy consumption compared to non-power aware
               allocation and static allocation policies, like DVFS, NPA (non-power aware)


36
             Case Study 1: Key Observations
Manjrasoft

        Dynamic VM consolidation algorithms significantly outperforms
         static allocation policies.
        Heuristic-based dynamic VM consolidation algorithms substantially
         outperform the optimal online deterministic algorithm (THR-1.0) due
         to a vastly reduced level of SLA violations.
        The MMT policy produces better results compared to the MC and
         RS policies, meaning that the minimization of the VM migration time
         is more important than the minimization of the correlation between
         VMs allocated to a host.
        Dynamic VM consolidation algorithms based on local regression
         outperform the threshold-based and adaptive-threshold based
         algorithms due to better predictions of host overload, and therefore
         decreased SLA violations and the number of VM migrations.



37
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
38
                     Green Cloud or Brown Cloud?
Manjrasoft

     •   Ideally, for every server virtualized, save
         –    ~$700 and ~7,000 kWh / year
         –    4 tons of CO2 emissions / year
     •   Plus
         –    Power down underutilized physical servers, saving 40%
         –    Desktop management, saving 35% / year
     •   But currently
     Cloud         Location       Estimated power   %    of     Dirty   % of Renewable
     datacenters                  usage             Energy              Electricity
                                  Effectiveness     Generation
     Google        Lenoir         1.21              50.5% Coal,         3.8%
                                                    38.7% Nuclear
     Apple         Apple, NC                        50.5% Coal,         3.8%
                                                    38.7% Nuclear
     Microsoft     Chicago, IL    1.22              72.8% Coal,         1.1%
                                                    22.3% Nuclear
     Yahoo         La Vista, NE   1.16              73.1% Coal,         7%
                                                    14.6% Nuclear
39
                                                     Some Observations
Manjrasoft

      Datacenters has heterogeneous properties
              –        Geographically distributed datacenters (different
                       environmental factors and electricity prices)
              –        Each resource site has different CPU configurations
              –        Each site has different energy efficiency
              –        Different Carbon-footprint




40
     Source: Best   Practices for Data Centers: Lessons Learned from Benchmarking 22 Data Centers by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory’s report   40
                  Green Cloud Architecture
Manjrasoft
                          End User



                                                  d) Allocate
                                                  service
                                                                           Private
             a) Request                                                     Cloud
             a cloud
             service

                            Green Broker                           c) Request
                                                                   energy
                                                                   efficiency
                                                                   information


                                                                   b) Request        Carbon Emission
                                                                   any green
                              Routers                              offer                Directory
                                                  Internet
                                     e) Request
                                     service
                                     allocation




                                                                                           Green Offer
                  Public Cloud A                                                            Directory
41                                                        Public Cloud B
             Third Party: Green Offer and Carbon
Manjrasoft
                     Emission Directory
        Carbon Emission Directory
            Contains data on Power Usage Effectiveness (PUE), cooling
             efficiency, carbon footprint, network cost
            Helps user to select cloud services with minimum carbon
             footprint
            Incentive for providers
                 Advertising tool to increase the market share, e.g. Google
            Require more carbon transparency from providers
                 Government role by enforcing policies such as Carbon Tax
        Green Offer Directory
            Incentive for users
                 Choosing more carbon efficient hours
            Lists services with their discounted prices and green hours
42
                                             User: Green Broker
Manjrasoft


                                                        •   A typical Cloud broker
                                                            –   Lease Cloud services
             User
                                                            –   Schedule applications
                     Green Broker
                    Cloud Request Services
               QoS
                          Application
                           Profiling
                                           Cloud
                                           Offers
                                                        •   Green Broker
                    CO2 Analysis Services
                                                            –   1st layer: Analyze user
                Cost
             Calculator
                          CO2 Emission
                           Calculator
                                            Green
                                         Information
                                                                requirements
                                            System

               Brokering Services such as
                                                            –   2nd layer: Calculates cost
                scheduling, monitoring                          and carbon footprint of
              Green         Cloud
             Policies      Leasing
                                         Scheduler              services
                                                            –   3rd layer: Carbon aware
                                                                scheduling
         Private Cloud                   Public Cloud

43
             Provider: Green Middleware
Manjrasoft




44
                    Case Study: IaaS Cloud
Manjrasoft


        Carbon Emission Directory: Stores all carbon
         emission rates for each IaaS provider

        Green Offer Directory: Receives number of
         VMs that can be initiated at a particular time for
         maximum energy efficiency

        Green Broker: Computes schedule with the
         lowest carbon emission based on application
         requirements
45
                 Carbon Efficient Green Policy
Manjrasoft
                           (CEGP)
        Collect resource requests from user and
         resource site information such as VMs, carbon
         emission rate, DCiE, CPU power efficiency
        Sort jobs based on deadline
        Sort resource sites based on carbon footprint:


                   Carbon    Datacenter        Energy
                  Emission   Efficiency   Efficiency of VM

        Schedule greedily the most urgent deadline jobs
         on the most power efficient resource site.

46
                                                             Simulation Setup
Manjrasoft


         Parallel Workload: first week of LLNL Thunder
          trace from Parallel Workload Archive (PWA)
                    Deadline generated based methodology proposed by
                     Irwin et al. (2004)1
         Configuration of Cloud resource sites2:




         1D.   Irwin, L. Grit, and J. Chase, “Balancing risk and reward in a market-based task service,” in Proc. of the 13th IEEE International Symposium on High
                                                            Performance Distributed Computing, Honolulu, USA, 2004.
47        2    L. Wang and Y. Lu, “Efficient Power Management of Heterogeneous Soft Real-Time Clusters,” in Proc. of the 2008 Real-Time Systems Symposium,
             EDF: Carbon-Efficient (CEGP) VS EST
               (Early Start-time) Algorithm (EST)
Manjrasoft




48
                 Case Study 2: Summary
Manjrasoft


     •   Presented a Carbon Aware Green Cloud Framework to
         improve the carbon footprint of Cloud computing.
     •   Proposed framework provides incentives to both users
         and providers to utilize and deliver the most “Green"
         services.
     •   Proposed a Carbon Efficient Green Policy (CEGP) for
         IaaS providers.
     •   Green Policy CEGP can save up to 23% energy while
         reducing the carbon footprint by about 25%.




49
                                   Outline
Manjrasoft


            Cloud Computing at a Glance
                Cloud Benefits and Challenges
            Powering Cloud Infrastructure
                Energy Consumption, Costs, Implications
            Power-Aware Computing
                Trends, Foundations, Issues, Taxonomy
            Green Cloud Computing: Framework
            Energy-Efficient Resource Management
                Within a Cloud Data Center
                Across Multiple Data Centers (InterCloud)
            Summary and Thoughts for Future
50
                              Conclusions
Manjrasoft


        Clouds are essentially Data Centers hosting application
         services offered on a subscription basis. However, they
         consume high energy to maintain their operations.
             high operational cost + environmental impact
        Proposed heuristics for energy-efficient dynamic VM
         consolidation that significantly reduce energy
         consumption, while providing a low level of SLA
         violations.
        Presented a Carbon Aware Green Cloud Framework to
         improve the carbon footprint of Cloud computing
        Open Issues:
            EE Data Structures + Algorithms
            EE Resource Management for other workloads (e.g., workflows)
51
                                           References
Manjrasoft


        Keynote Paper
            R. Buyya, A. Beloglazov, J. Abawajy, Energy-
             Efficient Management of Data Center Resources
             for Cloud Computing: A Vision, Architectural
             Elements, and Open Challenges, Proceedings of
             the 2010 International Conference on Parallel
             and Distributed Processing Techniques and
             Applications (PDPTA2010), Las Vegas, USA,
             July 12-15, 2010.
        Taxonomy + EE InterClouds:
            A. Beloglazov, R. Buyya, Y. Lee, A. Zomaya, A
             Taxonomy and Survey of Energy-Efficient Data
             Centers and Cloud Computing Systems,
             Advances in Computers, Volume 82, 47-111pp,
             M. Zelkowitz (editor), Elsevier, Amsterdam, The
             Netherlands, March 2011.
            S. Garg, C. Yeo, A Anandasivam, R. Buyya,
             Environment-Conscious Scheduling of HPC
             Applications on Distributed Cloud-oriented Data
             Centers, Journal of Parallel and Distributed
             Computing, 71(6):732-749, Elsevier Press,         Wiley Press, New York, USA,
             Amsterdam, The Netherlands, June 2011.                     Feb 2011


52
                   Thanks for your attention!
Manjrasoft


            Are there any
                Questions?
                Comments/Suggestions
                                               Manjrasoft




                    We welcome you to:
        Study/Research with Us | Do Business with us!
        http:/www.cloudbus.org | www.Manjrasoft.com
         rbuyya@unimelb.edu.au | raj@manjrasoft.com
53
Manjrasoft




                  Manjrasoft




54
             Green Cloud Computing
                                   Simulation Results: ESV
Manjrasoft
                    7

                    6

                    5
      ESV, x0.001




                    4

                    3

                    2

                    1

                    0
                        8     8    8    5       5     5   5      5    5      3      2    2   3      3    2
                     0.     0.  0.   1.      1.    1.   2.    2.   2.     1.     1.   1.   1.    1.   1.
                   RS MC M T R S MC MT RS MC MT RS MC MT RS MC MT
                 R               R                                  R                  R
                H HR R M I Q IQR R M AD AD D M L R RR R M L L R R M
               T T                                M M                   L
                         TH               IQ              M
                                                            A                 LR               L
55
                                      Simulation Results: Energy
Manjrasoft


                     130

                     120

                     110
      Energy, kWh




                     100

                      90

                      80

                      70

                      60
                              8     8    8      5       5     5      5      5    5      3      2    2     3      3    2
                           0.     0.  0.     1.      1.    1.     2.     2.   2.     1.     1.   1.     1.    1.   1.
                         S                 S                    S                  S                  S
                        R MC M T R MC MT R MC MT R MC MT R MC MT
                      R                R                                       R                  R
                     H HR R M I Q IQR R M AD AD D M L R RR R M L L R R M
                    T T                                   M M                      L                        L
                               TH                 IQ                 M
                                                                       A                 LR
56
                                      Simulation Results: SLAV
Manjrasoft

                       9
                       8
                       7
      SLAV, x0.00001




                       6
                       5
                       4
                       3
                       2
                       1
                       0
                            8     8    8      5       5     5      5      5    5      3      2    2     3      3    2
                         0.     0.  0.     1.      1.    1.     2.     2.   2.     1.     1.   1.     1.    1.   1.
                       S                 S                    S                  S                  S
                      R MC M T R MC MT R MC MT R MC MT R MC MT
                    R                R                                       R                  R
                   H HR R M I Q IQR R M AD AD D M L R RR R M L L R R M
                  T T                                   M M                      L                        L
                             TH                 IQ                 M
                                                                     A                 LR
57
                                     Simulation Results: the Number of
Manjrasoft
                                              VM Migrations
                              22.5
       VM Migrations, x1000




                              20.0

                              17.5

                              15.0

                              12.5

                              10.0

                               7.5

                               5.0
                                        8     8    8      5      5     5      5     5   5      3      2    2      3      3    2
                                     0.    0.   0.     1.     1.    1.     2.     2.  2.    1.     1.   1.     1.     1.   1.
                                   S                 S                   S                S                  S
                                  R MC MT R MC M T R MC MT R M C MT R MC MT
                                R                R                                     R                 R
                               H HR R M I Q IQR R M AD AD D M LR RR R M L LR R M
                              T T                                  M M                    L                         L
                                        TH                 IQ               M
                                                                                A               LR
58

						
Related docs
Other docs by HC120808003416
102407 Masterbuilt
Views: 2  |  Downloads: 0
Job Description
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
Application Guidance
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
ra sarbanesoxley presentation
Views: 1  |  Downloads: 0
2012 Silver Recipient Press Release Template
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
ENFIELD PRIMARY CARE TRUST
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
Trust Board Strategic Development
Views: 1  |  Downloads: 0
Rhode Island Free Clinic
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
wlriwg281003
Views: 3  |  Downloads: 0
COUNTY OF SIMCOE
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0