SGI 09-11 by wanghonghx

VIEWS: 2 PAGES: 73

									Sustainable Governance Indicators


Indicator


Status Index

I | Status of Democracy

S1 | Electoral Process
S1.1 | Candidacy Procedures

S1.2 | Media Access

S1.3 | Voting and Registration Rights



S1.4 | Party Financing

S2 | Access to Information
S2.1 | Media Freedom

S2.2 | Media Pluralism
S2.3 | Access to Government Information

S3 | Civil Rights

S3.1 | Civil Rights
S3.2 | Political Liberties

S3.3 | Non-discrimination

S4 | Rule of Law

S4.1 | Legal Certainty

S4.2 | Judicial Review

S4.3 | Appointment of Justices

S4.4 | Corruption Prevention
S4.5 | Rule of Law
S4.6 | Control of Corruption
II | Policy Performance

A | Economy and Employment

S5 | Economy

S5.1 | Economic Policy

S5.2 | GDP per capita

S5.3 | Inflation

S5.4 | Product Market Regulation



S5.5 | Competitiveness
S6 | Labor Market
S6.1 | Labor Market Policy

S6.2 | Unemployment



S6.3 | Long-term Unemployment

S6.4 | Youth Unemployment



S6.5 | Low-skilled Unemployment

S6.6 | Employment Rate

S6.7 | Intensity of Active LMP

S7 | Enterprises

S7.1 | Enterprise Policy



S7.2 | Enterprise Regulation

S7.3 | Unit Labor Costs



S7.4 | Corporate Investment

S7.5 | Energy Costs for Enterprises



S7.6 | Real Interest Rates

S8 | Taxes

S8.1 | Tax Policy



S8.2 | Tax Evasion



S8.3 | Marginal Tax Burden (individuals)



S8.4 | Marginal Tax Burden (businesses)



S8.5 | Tax System Complexity

S8.6 | Total Tax Rate

S9 | Budgets
S9.1 | Budgetary Policy



S9.2 | Debt-to-GDP



S9.3 | Net Debt Ratio
S9.4 | Debt Interest Ratio



S9.5 | Budget Consolidation



S9.6 | Soundness of Banks

B | Social Affairs

S10 | Health Care
S10.1 | Health Policy



S10.2 | Private-to-Public HC Spending

S10.3 | Spending on Pharmaceuticals

S10.4 | Spending on Preventive and Health Programs

S10.5 | Life Expectancy-to-HC Spending

S10.6 | Infant Mortality

S11 | Social Inclusion

S11.1 | Social Inclusion Policy



S11.2 | Poverty

S11.3 | Life Satisfaction

S11.4 | Youth not in education and unemployed



S11.5 | Gini Coefficient

S11.6 | Gender Equality



S11.7 | Social and Political Participation

S12 | Families

S12.1 | Family Policy

S12.2 | Child Care Density



S12.3 | Child Poverty

S12.4 | Fertility Rate

S12.5 | Spending on Family Policy

S13 | Pensions

S13.1 | Pension Policy
S13.2 | Older Employment



S13.3 | Senior Citizen Poverty



S13.4 | Dependency Ratio

S13.5 | Public Pension Coverage

S14 | Integration

S14.1 | Integration Policy



S14.2 | Foreign-born secondary attainment



S14.3 | Foreign-born Tertiary Attainment



S14.4 | Foreign-born Unemployment



S14.5 | Foreign-born-to-Native Employment

C | Security

S15 | External Security

S15.1 | External Security Policy



S15.2 | Conflicts fought



S15.4 | Relations with Neighbors

S16 | Internal Security

S16.1 | Internal Security Policy

S16.2 | Homicides

S16.3 | Burglaries and Robberies



S16.4 | Reliability of Police Services

S16.5 | Costs of Crime

D | Resources

S17 | Environment



S17.1 | Environmental Policy



S17.2 | Energy Intensity
S17.3 | CO2 Emissions

S17.4 | Energy Mix



S17.5 | Water Usage



S17.6 | Waste Management

S18 | Research and Innovation

S18.1 | Research and Innovation Policy



S18.2 | Public R&D Spending



S18.3 | Industry R&D personnel

S18.4 | Science and Technology Degrees

S18.5 | Triad Patents

S18.6 | Computer and Internet Access

S19 | Education

S19.1 | Education Policy



S19.2 | Upper Secondary Attainment

S19.3 | Tertiary Attainment

S19.4 | Continuing Education
S19.5 | PISA Results

S19.6 | Pre-primary Education

Management Index
I | Executive Capacity

A | Steering Capability:


M1 | Strategic Capacity
M1.1 | Strategic Planning



M1.2 | Medium-term Fiscal Framework
M1.3 | Scholarly Advice

M2 | Inter-ministerial Coordination

M2.1 | GO Expertise

M2.2 | GO Gatekeeping

M2.3 | Line Ministries
M2.4 | Cabinet Committees
M2.5 | Senior Ministry Officials
M2.6 | Line Ministry Civil Servants
M2.7 | Informal Coordination Procedures

M3 | Evidence-based Instruments

M3.1 | RIA Application
M3.2 | Needs Analysis
M3.3 | Alternative Options
M4 | Societal Consultation



M4.1 | Negotiating Public Support
M5 | Policy Communication
M5.1 | Coherent Communication
B | Policy Implementation:




M6 | Effective Implementation
M6.1 | Government Efficiency

M6.2a | Ministerial Compliance

M6.2b | Monitoring Line Ministries
M6.2c | Monitoring Agencies



M6.2d | Internal Auditing

M6.3a | Task Funding

M6.3b | Constitutional Discretion

M6.3c | National Standards
C | Institutional Learning:



M7 | Adaptability

M7.1 | Domestic Adaptability

M7.2 | International Coordination

M8 | Organizational Reform Capacity

M8.1 | Self-monitoring

M8.2 | Institutional Reform

II | Executive Accountability
D | Citizens:



M9 | Citizens' Participatory Competence
M9.1 | Policy Knowledge



M9.2 | Voter Turnout
E | Legislatature:



M10 | Structures and Resources of Legislative Actors
M10.1 | Number of Committees



M10.2 | Committee Size



M10.3 | Pro-government Committee Chairs

M10.4 | Deputy Expert Staff

M10.6 | Legislature's Expert Staff

M11 | Legislative Accountability



M11.1 | Non-majority leverage
M11.2 | Obtaining Documents
M11.3 | Summoning Ministers
M11.4 | Summoning Experts
M11.5 | Task Area Coincidence
M11.6 | Audit Office
M11.7 | Ombuds Office
F | Intermediary Organizations:



M12 | Media

M12.1 | Media Reporting

M12.2 | Newspaper Circulation

M12.3 | Quality Newspapers

M13 | Parties and Interest Associations

M13.1 | Party Competence
M13.2 | Association Competence (business)
M13.3 | Association Competence (others)
dicators


       Description

       Status Index scores are weighted composites. The democracy category comprises half of the index score,
       and the four policy-specific categories combined comprise the other half.
       Democracy scores are weighted composites, with each of the four criteria contributing one-fourth of the
       total value.
       Electoral process scores are weighted composites, with each of the four qualitative assessments
       contributing one-fourth of the weighting.
       How fair are procedures for registering candidates and parties?
       To what extent do candidates and parties have fair access to the media and other means
       of communication?
       To what extent do all citizens have the opportunity to exercise their right of participation
       in national elections?
       To what extent is private and public party financing and electoral campaign financing
       transparent, effectively monitored and in case of infringement of rules subject to proportionate
       and dissuasive sanction?
       Access to information scores are weighted composites, with each of the three qualitative assessments
       contributing one-third of the weighting.
       To what extent are the media independent from government?
       To what extent are the media characterized by an ownership structure that ensures a
       pluralism of opinions?
       To what extent can citizens obtain official information?
       Civil rights scores are weighted composites, with each of the three qualitative assessments contributing
       one-third of the weighting.
       To what extent does the state respect and protect civil rights and how effectively are
       citizens protected by courts against infringements of their rights?
       To what extent does the state concede and protect political liberties?
       How effectively does the state protect against discrimination based on gender, physical
       ability, ethnic origin, social status, political views or religion?
       Rule of law scores are weighted composites. Four qualitative assessments contribute one half of the
       weighting, with two quantitative measures contributing the other half.
       To what extent do government and administration act on the basis of and in accordance
       with legal provisions to provide legal certainty?
       To what extent do independent courts control whether government and administration
       act in conformity with the law?
       To what extent does the process of appointing (supreme or constitutional court) justices
       guarantee the independence of the judiciary?
       To what extent are public officeholders prevented from abusing their position for private
       interests?
       Values reflect index scores drawn from the Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI) project
       Values reflect index scores drawn from the Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI) project

       Economy and Employment scores are weighted composites, with each of the five criteria contributing one-
       fifth of the total value.
       Economy scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
       with four quantitative measures contributing the other half.
       How successful has economic policy been in providing a reliable economic framework
       and in fostering international competitiveness?
       Values express real GDP per capita, in USD (at current prices, PPP). Source: OECD Economic Outlook 87,
       online database
       Values reflect percentage change in the consumer price index. Lower values translate into higher scores.
       Source: OECD Economic Outlook 87
       Values range from 0 (lowest) to 6 (most restrictive), based on data. Lower values translate into higher
       scores. Source: OECD Produkt market regulation database.
       Values are derived by aggregating several ratings of international competitiveness. Source: Institute for
       Management Development: World Competitiveness Scorebook 2009; World Economic Forum: Global
       Competitiveness Report 2009-2010.
Labor market scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the
weighting, with six quantitative measures contributing the other half.
How effectively does labor market policy in your country address unemployment?
Values reflect standardized unemployment rates. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD
Economic Outlook 87

Values express the 2008 percentage of long-term unemployed (+12 months) to the civilian labor force.
Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Economic Outlook 87; OECD Factbook 2010.
Values express the percentage of unemployed persons who are between 15 and 24 years old. Lower
values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Employment Outlook 2010
Values express the percentage of unemployed persons who have completed less than an upper secondary
education. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Employment Outlook 2010; OECD
Employment Outlook 2006
Values express the percentage of persons of working age who are in employment. Source: OECD Labour
market statistics; OECD Employment and Labour Market Statistics database.
Values reflect public expenditure on active measures as percentage of total public expenditure for labor
market programs. Source: OECD Employment Outlook 2010
Enterprises scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with five quantitative measures contributing the other half.
How successful has enterprise policy been in fostering innovation, entrepreneurship and
economic competitiveness, and in stimulating private investment?
Values are derived by aggregating four ratings of regulatory quality (ease of doing business, creation of
firms, start-up days, start-up procedures). Source: Institute for Management Development: The World
Competitiveness Yearbook 2009, World Bank: Doing Business 2010
Values reflect percentage change in the business sector’s unit labor costs, compared to previous year.
Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Economic Outlook 87

Values reflect a four-year average of corporate investment as percentage of GDP. Source: Eurostat
Structural Indicators; OECD Factbook 2009; Worldbank, Business environment snapshots for Chile 2006
Values reflect average growth rates of real energy prices indices for industry. Source: IEA Energy prices
and taxes; OECD Main Economic Indicators 2010
Values reflect yields on 10-year benchmark government bonds, or similar financial instrument, adjusted for
inflation. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Economic Outlook 87; OECD Factbook
2010
Taxes scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting, with
five quantitative measures contributing the other half.
To what extent does taxation policy realize goals of equity, competitiveness and the
generation of sufficient public revenues?
Values range from 1 (50% or more of business is unofficial or unregistered) to 7 (all businesses are
registered). Source: World Economic Forum, Global Financial Development Report 2009; World Economic
Forum, Global Competitiveness Report 2006-2007.

Values reflect income tax plus employee contributions, minus cash benefits, as a percentage of gross
wage. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Taxing Wages 29; SGI estimate
Values reflect business tax rate as a proportion of the gross-of-tax return on capital for additional (marginal)
investments. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: Cato Institute, Tax & Budget Bulletin No.
62 May 2010
Values reflect a composite index, based on average time needed to complete taxes and the number of
yearly tax payments, based on 2010 data. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: World Bank,
Doing Business 2010
Values reflect general government total tax and non-tax receipts as percentage of nominal GDP. Source:
OECD Economic Outlook 87; World Bank Database; SGI estimate
Budgets scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with five quantitative measures contributing the other half.
To what extent does budgetary policy realize the goal of fiscal sustainability?
Values reflect gross general government financial liabilities as a percentage of GDP. Lower values translate
into higher scores. Source: OECD Economic Outlook Nr. 87; World Bank, Chile at a glance 2008; World
Bank, Mexico at a glance 2008; Eurostat Structural indicators
Values express general government financial surplus or deficit as percentage of nominal GDP. Source:
OECD Economic Outlook Nr. 87; World Bank, Chile at a glance 2008; World Bank, Mexico at a glance
2008; Eurostat Structural indicators
Values reflect total interest payments on net general government debt, as a percentage of nominal GDP.
Source: OECD Economic Outlook Nr. 87; World Bank, Chile at a glance 2008; World Bank, Mexico at a
glance 2008; World Bank, Turkey at a glance 2008.
Values reflect index scores, based on an analysis of governments’ budget consolidation efforts. Higher
scores indicate better alignment of revenues, expenditures and liabilities. Source: Prof. Uwe Wagschal,
University of Freiburg
Values range from 1 (banks are insolvent and may require a government bailout) to 7 (banks are generally
healthy with sound balance sheets). Source: World Economic Forum, Global Competitiveness Report 2009-
2010
Social affairs scores are weighted composites, with each of the five criteria contributing one-fifth of the total
score.
Health care scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with five quantitative measures contributing the other half.
How effective and efficient are health care policies in your country?
Values reflect the distance from 1 (perfect parity) in the ratio of private to public health-care spending
growth, averaged over 4 years. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Health Data
2010; SGI estimate
Values express spending on pharmaceuticals as a percentage of current health care expenditure. Lower
values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Health Data 2010.
Values express spending on preventive and health programs as a percentage of health care expenditure.
Source: OECD Health Data 2010; SGI estimate.
Values reflects total spending on health care per capita in relation to life expectancy in years. Lower values
translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Health Data 2010.
Values reflect deaths per 1000 live births. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Health
Data 2010.
Social inclusion scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the
weighting, with six quantitative measures contributing the other half.
To what extent does social policy in your country prevent exclusion and decoupling from
society?
Values express percentage of persons with disposable income below 50 percent of national median,
adjusted for household size. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Society at a Glance
2009; OECD Economic Surveys Chile 2010; SOEP (Socio-economic Panel).
Values reflect average points of life satisfaction on an 11-step ladder from 0-10 in a Gallup world poll.
Source: OECD Society at a Glance 2009.
Values reflect the percentage of the young population (age 20-24) not in employment, education or training.
Source: OECD Society at a Glance 2009, SGI estimate.

Values express the Gini coefficient, a measure of income and wealth inequality. Lower values represent a
more equal distribution. Source: OECD Factbook 2009; OECD Economic Surveys Chile 2010.
Values reflect the percentage of estimated average female earned income to male earned income. Source:
OECD Gender, Institutions and Development Database 2009.
Values are derived by aggregating two ratings of social and political participation (percentage of citizens as
members in labor unions and political parties). Figures are from different years. Source: Values Survey
Database.
Families scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with four quantitative measures contributing the other half.
To what extent do family support policies in your country enable women to combine parenting
with participation in the labor market?
Values reflect enrolment rates for 3-5-year-olds in formal pre-school services and in primary schools (if they
exist). Source: OECD Society at a Glance 2009.
Values reflect percentage of children 0 to 17 years old, in households with disposable income below 50
percent of national median. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Society at a Glance
2009; Unicef, Child Poverty in Latin America.

Values reflect average number of children born to women aged 15 to 49. Source: OECD Factbook 2010.
Values reflect the percentage of public expenditure for families to total social expenditure. Source: OECD
Social Expenditure Database 2009.
Pensions scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with four quantitative measures contributing the other half.
To what extent does pension policy in your country realize goals of poverty prevention,
inter-generational equity and fiscal sustainability?
Values reflect the employment rate among the older labor force (55-64 years). Source: OECD Employment
Outlook 2010.
Values reflect percentage of citizens 65 or older in households with disposable income below 50 percent of
the national median. Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Pensions at a Glance 2009;
OECD Labour Marked and Social Policies Chile 2009.
Values reflect the age-population ratio between those typically not in the labor force (under the age of 15 or
over the age of 64) and those typically in the labor force (age 15-64). Source: OECD Pensions At A Glance
2009.
Values reflect the percentage contribution of public components of the pension system to weighted average
pension wealth. Source: OECD Pensions at a Glance 2009.
Integration scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with four quantitative measures contributing the other half.
How effectively do policies in your country support the integration of migrants into
society?
Values reflect percentage of foreign-born population, aged 15 years or more, with upper secondary
education (ISCED levels 3 or 4). Source: OECD A Profile of Immigrant Populations in the 21st Century
2008.

Values reflect percentage of foreign-born population, aged 15 years or more, with tertiary education (ISCED
5/6). Source: OECD A Profile of Immigrant Populations in the 21st Century 2008.

Values reflect percentage of unemployed persons among the foreign-born population. Lower values
translate into higher scores. Source: OECD A Profile of Immigrant Populations in the 21st Century 2008.

Values reflect the ratio of foreign-born to the native employment rate for the 15-64 population. Source:
OECD Factbook 2010; OECD A Profile of Immigrant Populations in the 21st Century 2008.
Security scores are weighted composites, with each of the two criteria contributing one-half of the total
score.
External security scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the
weighting, with two quantitative measures contributing the other half.
How effectively does external security and defense policy in your country protect citizens
against security risks and safeguard the national interest?
Values reflect an assessment of the number of external and internal conflicts fought on a scale from 1 to 5
by the Uppsala Conflict Data Program. Source: Institute for Economics and Peace, Global Peace Index
2010.
Values reflect an assessment of relations with neighboring countries ranging from 1 (very poor) to 5 (very
good) by the Economist Intelligence Unit. Source: Institute for Economics and Peace, Global Peace Index
2010.
Internal security scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment comprises half of the weight,
and four quantitative measures comprise the other half.
How effectively does internal security policy in your country protect citizens against
security risks?
Values reflect total recorded intentional completed homicides per 100,000 people. Lower values translate
into higher scores. Source: UNODC Homicide Statistics, online database, 2010.
Values reflect total recorded robberies and burglaries per 100,000 people. Lower values translate into
higher scores. Source: UNODC Homicide Statistics, online database, 2010.

Values range from 1 (police services cannot be relied upon at all) to 7 (police services can always be relied
upon). Source: World Economic Forum: Global Competitiveness Report 2009-2010.
Values are derived by aggregating two ratings of the costs imposed on businesses by crime. Source: World
Economic Forum: Global Competitiveness Report 2009-2010.
Resources scores are weighted composites, with the three criteria each comprising one-third of the total
score.
Environment scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the
weighting, with five quantitative measures contributing the other half.

How effectively does environmental policy in your country protect and preserve the sustainability
of natural resources and quality of the environment?

Values express total primary energy supply, in millions of tons of oil equivalent, per unit of GDP (in year
2000, billions of USD at PPP). Lower values translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Factbook 2010.
Values express kilograms of CO2 emissions per unit of GDP at PPP. Lower values translate into higher
scores. Source: IEA Key World Energy Statistics 2009.
Values reflect contribution of renewables as percentage of total primary energy supply. Source: OECD
Factbook 2010.
Values reflect intensity of fresh water use, in annual cubic meters per capita. Lower values translate into
higher scores. Source: OECD Factbook 2010; UN Environmental Indicators and Selected Time Series; SGI
estimate.
Values reflect intensity of municipal waste generation, in annual kilograms per capita. Lower values
translate into higher scores. Source: OECD Factbook 2010; UN Statistics Division Environmental
Indicators.
Resarch and innovation scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment comprises half of the
weight, and five quantitative measures comprise the other half.
To what extent does research and innovation policy in your country support technological
innovations that foster the creation and introduction of new products?
Values reflect gross public expenditure on R&D as a percentage of GDP. Source: OECD Main Science and
Technology Indicators 2009/2; Institute for Management Development: The World Competitiveness
Yearbook 2009.

Values reflect total business enterprise R&D personnel per thousand employed in industry. Source: OECD
Main Science and Technology Indicators 2009; OECD Factbook 2010; SGI estimate.
Values reflect number of employed science graduates (age 25-34) to 100,000 employed workers. Source:
OECD Education at a Glance 2009; OECD Education at a Glance 2006.
Triad patents are those filed in the EU, Japan and the United States. Source: OECD Factbook 2009; OECD
Factbook 2009, Economic, Environmental and Social Statistics (online database).
Values reflect number of people subscribing to broadband internet access. Source: OECD Broadband
Portal.
Education scores are weighted composites. One qualitative assessment contributes half of the weighting,
with five quantitative measures contributing the other half.
To what extent does education policy in your country deliver high-quality, efficient and
equitable education and training?

Values reflect percentage of population, aged 25 to 64, that has attained at least upper secondary
education. Source: OECD Education at a Glance 2009; OECD Factbook 2010, online database.
Values reflect percentage of population, aged 25 to 64, that has attained tertiary education. Source: OECD
Education at a Glance 2009.
Values reflect percentage of population participating in non-formal job-related education and training, at all
levels of education. Source: OECD Education at a Glance 2008
Values reflect mean student score on OECD’s PISA test. Source: OECD PISA 2009.
Values express public expenditure on pre-primary education as a percentage of GDP. Source: OECD
Education Online Database; OECD Factbook 2010; SGI estimate.
Management Index scores are weighted composites. Accountability comprises half of the index score, and
the combined three remaining categories comprise the other half.


Steering capability scores are weighted composites, with each of the five criteria contributing one-fifth of the
total value.
Strategic capacity scores are weighted composites, with two qualitative assessments and one quantitative
measure contributing one-third of the weighting.
How much influence does strategic planning have on government decision-making?
Values are derived from the OECD’s annual survey of budget practices and procedures. High values
indicate more detailed budgetary plans. Source: OECD budget practices and procedures survey 2007-
2008.
How influential are non-governmental academic experts for government decisionmaking?
Inter-ministerial coordination scores are weighted composites, with each of the seven qualitative
assessments contributing one-seventh of the weighting.
Does the government office / prime minister’s office (GO / PMO) have the expertise to
evaluate ministerial draft bills substantively?
Can the government office / prime minister’s office return items envisaged for the cabinet
meeting on the basis of policy considerations?
To what extent do line ministries have to involve the government office/prime minister’s
office in the preparation of policy proposals?
How effectively do ministerial or cabinet committees prepare cabinet meetings?
How effectively do senior ministry officials prepare cabinet meetings?
How effectively do line ministry civil servants coordinate policy proposals?
How effectively do informal coordination mechanisms work?
Regulatory impact assessment scores are weighted composites, with each of the three qualitative
assessments contributing one-third of the weighting.
Does the government regularly assess the potential socioeconomic impact of the draft
laws it prepares (regulatory impact assessments, RIA)?
To what extent do RIA analyze the purpose of and need for a regulation?
To what extent do RIA analyze alternative options?
Societal consultation scores are composed of a single qualitative assessment.
To what extent does the government consult with trade unions, employers’ associations,
leading business associations, religious communities, and social and environmental interest
groups to support its policy?
Policy communication scores are composed of a single qualitative assessment.
To what extent does the government implement a coherent communication policy?

Policy implementation scores reflect assessments drawn from the single criterion of implementation.
Effective implementation scores are weighted composites. The first indicator accounts for one-third of the
total score, the following four indicators collectively account for an additional one-third, and the final three
collectively comprise the final one-third.
To what extent can the government achieve its own policy objectives?
To what extent does the organization of government ensure that ministers do not seek to
realize their self-interest but face incentives to implement the government’s program?
How effectively does the government office / prime minister’s office monitor line ministry
activities?
How effectively do ministries monitor the activities of executive agencies?
Values reflect an index, scaled from 1 to 10, based on OECD data. Higher scores express a higher
percentage of line ministries with auditing units. Source: OECD International Budget Practices and
Procedures Database 2007/2008.
To what extent does the central government ensure that tasks delegated to subnational
self-governments are adequately funded?
To what extent does central government ensure that subnational self-governments may
use their constitutional scope of discretion?
To what extent does central government ensure that subnational self-governments meet
national standards of public services?
Institutional learning scores are weighted composites, with each of the two criteria contributing one-half of
the total value.
Adaptability scores are weighted composites, with each of the two qualitative assessments contributing one
half of the weighting.
To what extent does the government respond to international and supranational developments
by adapting domestic government structures?
To what extent does the government participate in the international coordination of
joint reform initiatives?
Organizational reform capacity scores are weighted composites, with each of the two qualitative
assessments contributing one half of the weighting.
To what extent do actors within the government monitor whether institutional arrangements
of governing are appropriate?
To what extent does the government improve its strategic capacity by changing the
institutional arrangements of governing?
Accountability scores are weighted composites. The Citizens criterion counts for a third of the score, while
the four other criteria collectively provide the remainder.



Citizens’ participatory competence scores are weighted composites, with one qualitative assessment and
one quantitative measure contributing one half of the weighting.
To what extent are citizens informed of government policy-making?
Values reflect the percentage of registered voters who have participated in national elections (lower house).
Data does not always refer to the most recent, but most relevant election for the SGI 2011 review period.
Source: Inter-Parliamentary Union, PARLINE Database.



Parliament’s resources scores are weighted composites, with each of the five quantitative measures
contributing one-fifth of the weighting.
Values reflect how close to the optimal range the number of committees is (different years). 12-18
committees are optimal (lower numbers preclude discussion, higher numbers lead to fragmentation).
Source: Bertelsmann Stiftung.
Values reflect how close to the optimal range the average committe size is (different years). 13-25
members are optimal (lower numbers preclude discussion, higher numbers lead to fragmentation). Source:
Bertelsmann Stiftung.
Measuring governing parties’ influence, values reflect the ratio of pro-government committee chairpersons
to the number of deputies (different years). Lower ratios translate into higher scores. Source: Bertelsmann
Stiftung.
Measuring legislature’s support capacities, values reflect a deputy’s expert support staff number (different
years). Source: Bertelsmann Stiftung.
Measuring legislature’s support capacities, values reflect the ratio of legislative research staff to the number
of deputies (different years). Source: Bertelsmann Stiftung.
Legislative accountability scores are weighted composites, with one quantitative measure and six
qualitative assessments contributing one-seventh of the weighting.
Values express the non-governmental deputies’ supervisory capacity by giving the ratio of deputies from
governmental parties to deputies not in governmental parties. Data from different years. Source:
Bertelsmann Stiftung.
Are parliamentary committees able to ask for government documents?
Are parliamentary committees able to summon ministers for hearings?
Are parliamentary committees able to summon experts for committee meetings?
To what extent do the task areas of parliamentary committees and ministries coincide?
To what extent is the audit office accountable to the parliament?
Does the parliament have an ombuds office?



Media scores are weighted composites, with one qualitative assessment and two quantitative measures
contributing one-third of the weighting.
To what extent do the TV and radio stations in your country provide substantive indepth
information on decisions taken by the government?
Values reflect ratio of total paid daily newspaper circulation to adult population (copies per 1000 people).
Source: World Association of Newspapers, World Press Trends 2008.
Values reflect number of titles per million adults. Source: World Association of Newspapers, World Press
Trends 2008.
Parties and interest associations scores are weighted composites, with each of the three qualitative
assessments contributing one-third of the weighting.
To what extent do the electoral programs of major parties in your country propose plausible
and coherent policies?
To what extent do economic interest associations propose reasonable policies?
To what extent do non-economic interest associations propose reasonable policies?
Indicator Value


(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)


(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)



(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)

(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
(1=lowest, 10=highest)
                                                                                                                                       S1.3 | Voting and Registration Rights
                                                                                   S1.1 | Candidacy Procedures




                                                                                                                                                                                                        S2 | Access to Information
                                I | Status of Democracy




                                                          S1 | Electoral Process




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S2.2 | Media Pluralism
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     S2.1 | Media Freedom
                                                                                                                                                                               S1.4 | Party Financing
                                                                                                                 S1.2 | Media Access
                 Status Index

Australia        7.75           8.46                      9.5                      10                                9                 10                                           9                   7.7                              8                       7

Austria          6.86           7.40                      7.8                      10                                7                          9                                   5                   6.0                              6                       5

Belgium          7.17           7.89                      8.5                            8                           7                          9                              10                       7.7                              9                       7

Canada           7.89           8.52                      9.3                      10                                9                 10                                           8                   7.3                              9                       6

Chile            6.51           6.99                      6.3                            8                           5                          7                                   5                   7.3                          10                          5

Czech Republic   6.78           7.42                      8.5                      10                                8                          9                                   7                   7.7                              7                       8

Denmark          8.34           9.05                      9.5                      10                                9                 10                                           9                   9.0                              9                       9

Finland          8.52           9.37                      9.0                      10                            10                    10                                           6                   10.0                         10                     10

France           6.74           7.32                      8.8                      10                                9                          9                                   7                   6.0                              6                       5

Germany          7.77           8.76                      9.5                      10                            10                    10                                           8                   8.3                              8                  10

Greece           5.12           6.00                      6.5                      10                                5                          9                                   2                   6.0                              5                       5

Hungary          5.94           6.39                      6.5                            9                           6                          8                                   3                   6.3                              5                       6

Iceland          7.65           8.41                      8.8                      10                                9                 10                                           6                   7.0                              8                       6

Ireland          7.37           8.64                      8.5                            9                           9                          8                                   8                   9.0                          10                          9

Italy            5.70           6.26                      7.8                            9                           5                          9                                   8                   5.3                              4                       4

Japan            6.54           6.93                      8.0                            9                           9                          8                                   6                   7.0                              7                       7

Luxembourg       7.60           7.97                      7.8                      10                                5                          8                                   8                   8.0                              9                       7

Mexico           5.25           5.47                      7.8                            8                           7                          8                                   8                   6.3                              7                       6

Netherlands      7.63           8.50                      7.8                      10                                9                 10                                           2                   8.7                              9                       8

New Zealand      8.51           9.22                      9.3                      10                                9                          9                                   9                   8.3                              9                       7

Norway           8.64           9.43                      9.5                      10                                9                 10                                           9                   9.7                          10                          9

Poland           6.33           7.31                      8.5                      10                                7                          9                                   8                   7.7                              8                       7

Portugal         6.59           7.54                      8.3                            9                           8                          9                                   7                   7.3                              6                       9

Slovakia         5.48           5.81                      7.8                      10                                7                          8                                   6                   5.0                              4                       6

South Korea      5.82           5.47                      6.8                            8                           6                          9                                   4                   4.7                              4                       5

Spain            6.35           7.24                      7.5                            8                           7                 10                                           5                   6.7                              7                       8

Sweden           8.65           9.38                      9.0                      10                                9                 10                                           7                   9.3                          10                          8

Switzerland      8.12           8.66                      7.8                      10                            10                    10                                           1                   9.7                          10                     10
Turkey           4.65   4.90   6.3   7    5   9   4   6.0   6    5

United Kingdom   7.22   7.66   7.5   9    6   9   6   7.3   8    6

United States    7.49   8.60   8.5   10   7   9   8   8.7   10   8
S2.3 | Access to Government Information




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                A | Economy and Employment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S4.3 | Appointment of Justices


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S4.4 | Corruption Prevention




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       S4.6 | Control of Corruption
                                                                                                                 S3.3 | Non-discrimination




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      II | Policy Performance
                                                                                    S3.2 | Political Liberties




                                                                                                                                                                                         S4.2 | Judicial Review
                                                                                                                                                                S4.1 | Legal Certainty




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S4.5 | Rule of Law
                                                              S3.1 | Civil Rights




                                                                                                                                             S4 | Rule of Law
                                          S3 | Civil Rights




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             S5 | Economy
         8                                8.0                     8                       8                            8                     8.7                     9                   10                              6                               8                        9.31                 8.93                           7.04                      7.3                          7.5
         7                                7.3                     7                       9                            6                     8.5                     8                        8                          9                               7                        9.86                 8.20                           6.33                      6.0                          6.8
         7                                8.0                     8                       8                            8                     7.4                     7                        7                          9                               7                        7.99                 6.57                           6.45                      5.7                          6.3
         7                                9.0                     9                       9                            9                     8.5                     8                        9                          5                               9                        9.48                 8.93                           7.27                      7.1                          7.8
         7                                7.0                     7                       8                            6                     7.4                     8                        8                          9                               6                        7.54                 6.43                           6.03                      6.6                          7.0
         8                                7.7                     8                       9                            6                     5.8                     9                        7                          8                               4                        6.16                 3.18                           6.15                      5.7                          5.6
         9                                8.0                     8                       9                            7                     9.7                     9                   10                       10                                     9                        9.86                 9.93                           7.63                      7.5                          7.7
10                                        9.7                 10                    10                                 9                     8.8                10                            9                          3                               9                        9.69                 10                             7.67                      7.3                          8.1
         7                                7.7                     8                       9                            6                     6.9                     6                        9                          5                               5                        8.06                 6.85                           6.16                      5.0                          5.6
         7                                8.7                     9                       9                            8                     8.5                     9                   10                              8                               7                        9.17                 8.03                           6.77                      6.5                          7.0
         8                                7.0                     6                       9                            6                     4.5                     4                        5                          8                               3                        5.81                 2.25                           4.23                      3.2                          2.7
         8                                7.0                     6                       9                            6                     5.7                     8                        7                          7                               4                        6.05                 3.80                           5.50                      5.2                          6.1
         7                                9.3                     9                 10                                 9                     8.6                     9                        9                          2                               9                        9.83                 9.93                           6.88                      5.9                          5.3
         8                                9.0                     9                       9                            9                     8.1                     6                        9                          9                               6                        9.24                 7.99                           6.11                      5.2                          5.8
         8                                7.3                     6                       9                            7                     4.6                     5                        7                          8                               3                        4.70                 2.35                           5.15                      4.5                          5.1
         7                                6.7                     6                       9                            5                     6.1                     6                        7                          2                               5                        8.06                 6.23                           6.15                      5.7                          6.7
         8                                7.7                     7                       8                            8                     8.5                     6                        8                          9                               8                        9.52                 8.89                           7.22                      6.9                          7.4
         6                                4.7                     4                       5                            5                     3.1                     4                        6                          9                               2                            1                      1                        5.03                      5.5                          4.0
         9                                9.0                     8                 10                                 9                     8.6                     9                        8                          7                               7                        9.31                 9.48                           6.76                      6.8                          7.8
         9                                9.7                 10                    10                                 9                     9.6                10                       10                              8                         10                             9.62                 9.93                           7.80                      7.7                          7.1
10                                        9.3                 10                          9                            9                     9.2                10                       10                              9                               8                        10                   8.41                           7.85                      8.0                          8.1
         8                                7.7                     7                       9                            7                     5.4                     7                        8                          6                               6                        4.91                 3.22                           5.35                      5.5                          5.0
         7                                8.0                     8                       9                            7                     6.6                     7                        7                          8                               6                        6.75                 5.64                           5.63                      5.1                          6.2
         5                                6.0                     7                       7                            4                     4.5                     5                        5                          6                               3                        5.02                 3.39                           5.16                      5.0                          5.3
         5                                5.0                     5                       5                            5                     5.5                     7                        8                          5                               5                        5.95                 3.46                           6.17                      6.5                          6.2
         5                                8.0                     7                       9                            8                     6.8                     8                        7                          7                               6                        7.23                 5.98                           5.46                      4.8                          5.5
10                                        9.3                     9                 10                                 9                     9.9                10                       10                       10                               10                             9.79                 9.65                           7.91                      7.4                          7.7
         9                                8.3                     9                       8                            8                     8.9                     9                   10                              5                               9                        9.65                 9.34                           7.59                      8.0                          8.0
7   3.7   4   4    3   3.7   5   5    4   4   3.53   2.25   4.40   4.7   3.6
8   7.7   7   8    8   8.1   9   8    7   7   9.03   8.03   6.78   6.4   7.0
8   8.7   7   10   9   8.5   9   10   8   9   8.93   7.27   6.38   6.2   7.8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S6.5 | Low-skilled Unemployment
                                                                    S5.4 | Product Market Regulation




                                                                                                                                                                                                       S6.3 | Long-term Unemployment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              S6.7 | Intensity of Active LMP
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       S6.4 | Youth Unemployment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             S7.2 | Enterprise Regulation
                                                                                                                                                    S6.1 | Labor Market Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     S6.6 | Employment Rate




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S7.1 | Enterprise Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S7.3 | Unit Labor Costs
                                                                                                       S5.5 | Competitiveness
S5.1 | Economic Policy


                         S5.2 | GDP per capita




                                                                                                                                                                                 S6.2 | Unemployment
                                                                                                                                S6 | Labor Market




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               S7 | Enterprises
                                                 S5.3 | Inflation




     8                   4.55                    7.70               7.71                               7.71                     7.9                       8                      8.49                  9.19                            8.74                        9.26                              8.14                     3.38                             6.9                     7                     9.76                           7.80

     7                   4.67                    8.62               6.41                               6.77                     7.4                       7                      8.97                  8.76                            9.21                        8.96                              8.04                     3.10                             5.6                     6                     5.14                           4.97

     6                   4.28                    8.88               6.53                               6.35                     5.8                       6                      7.10                  4.76                            5.71                        7.77                              5.46                     3.31                             6.2                     7                     6.47                           5.41

     8                   4.43                    8.69               9.35                               8.21                     7.6                       8                      6.86                  9.47                            7.65                        8.22                              8.01                     2.51                             6.9                     7                     8.91                           6.35

     9                   1.12                    8.62               5.65                               4.76                     6.1                       6                      5.35                  8.82                            6.35                        9.26                              4.35                     2.83                             4.5                     5                     5.01                           3.77

     6                   2.60                    8.23               5.41                               4.29                     6.3                       6                      7.83                  6.91                            7.26                        6.04                              6.44                     5.07                             6.0                     7                     4.89                           7.23

     8                   4.37                    8.03               8.71                               8.86                     8.7                       9                      8.25                  9.32                            8.85                        9.71                              9.10                     4.85                             7.2                     8                     10                             5.09

     9                   4.46                    7.83               7.94                               8.47                     6.8                       7                      6.92                  8.41                            5.79                        8.49                              7.21                     3.21                             6.6                     8                     9.03                           3.58

     5                   3.72                    8.82               6.41                               5.74                     5.4                       5                      6.13                  5.81                            5.56                        8.04                              6.05                     3.57                             4.8                     5                     5.99                           6.48

     7                   3.96                    8.75               7.12                               7.85                     7.7                       9                      7.34                  4.47                            8.91                        6.26                              7.73                     3.73                             5.8                     7                     4.89                           4.90

     2                   3.23                    8.03                      1                                1                   4.1                       3                      6.13                  4.60                            4.56                        8.83                              5.36                     1.60                             3.4                     3                     1.24                           4.34

     8                   1.82                    6.12               7.29                               1.81                     4.9                       5                      5.83                  4.73                            4.35                        6.04                              3.86                     3.99                             4.7                     5                     7.32                           5.41

     6                   5.05                       1               9.06                               3.20                     6.5                       5                      7.52                  9.93                            7.44                        9.97                              9.92                     2.83                             7.0                     7                     8.66                           6.03

     4                   4.98                    10                 9.53                               5.72                     4.8                       4                      4.68                  7.40                            4.53                        8.46                              5.69                     2.87                             5.9                     6                     8.05                           10

     5                   3.51                    8.36               6.82                               1.90                     5.8                       6                      7.22                  5.46                            4.68                        8.67                              4.40                     3.00                             4.0                     4                     3.92                           4.40

     6                   3.86                    9.80               8.41                               7.37                     7.4                       7                      8.79                  8.18                            9.47                        8.86                              7.63                     4.08                             5.8                     6                     6.23                           7.29

     7                   10                      8.88               5.76                               6.92                     6.6                       6                      8.61                  7.39                            7.09                        9.36                              6.39                     3.92                             6.1                     7                     6.59                           4.27

     5                        1                  5.40               4.06                               1.72                     6.9                       5                      8.55                  10                              9.21                        10                                4.89                     10                               4.9                     5                     3.68                           3.14

     8                   4.74                    8.23               9.24                               8.10                     7.8                       7                      9.82                  8.66                            10                          9.73                              9.12                     4.01                             6.0                     7                     6.35                           4.78

     8                   3.12                    7.50               7.53                               6.37                     8.6                       9                      8.19                  9.84                            7.26                        9.65                              8.38                     5.76                             7.1                     8                     9.76                           5.78

     9                   5.99                    7.44               8.12                               7.55                     9.0                       9                      10                    9.88                            9.44                        9.63                              9.30                     5.33                             5.8                     6                     7.57                           5.03

     7                   1.60                    6.39               1.65                               2.13                     6.2                       6                      6.92                  7.10                            6.06                        7.58                              4.87                     5.81                             5.3                     7                     1.73                           6.41

     7                   2.23                    9.47               6.53                               3.13                     5.4                       5                      6.07                  4.70                            6.26                        8.62                              6.67                     3.04                             5.0                     5                     8.18                           4.78

     6                   2.11                    8.29               5.35                               2.99                     3.6                       4                      4.62                         1                        4.12                               1                          5.10                     3.06                             4.0                     3                     5.50                           4.84

     7                   3.08                    7.04               6.29                               5.39                     7.0                       6                      9.70                  9.97                            9.26                        9.97                              5.80                     3.56                             5.5                     6                     3.43                           6.22

     5                   3.18                    9.08               8.88                               3.24                     3.4                       3                          1                 6.19                                  1                     7.13                              5.20                     2.14                             4.8                     4                           1                        7.73

     8                   4.67                    9.08               7.29                               8.89                     7.7                       8                      6.86                  8.99                            4.79                        8.75                              8.19                     6.55                             5.9                     7                     7.69                           4.97

     8                   4.96                    9.21                      8                           9.49                     8.2                       8                      9.21                  8.35                            9.74                        9.04                              10                       4.18                             6.9                     8                     7.45                           5.28
5   1.08   4.74   1.12   1.59   3.8   3   4.26   6.32   4.71   8.09    1     2.83   4.7   6    7.32    1

7   4.19   7.44   10     6.65   7.2   7   7.28   8.02   6.59   8.99   7.78   6.22   6.1   8    5.86   5.22

7   5.64   9.08   10     10     6.2   6   6.26   9.22   6.97   7.96   7.01    1     8.0   10   6.72   8.62
                                                                                                                                                                                                  S8.4 | Marginal Tax Burden (businesses)
                                                                                                                                                       S8.3 | Marginal Tax Burden (individuals)
                              S7.5 | Energy Costs for Enterprises




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S8.5 | Tax System Complexity
S7.4 | Corporate Investment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S9.5 | Budget Consolidation


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    S9.6 | Soundness of Banks
                                                                    S7.6 | Real Interest Rates




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S9.4 | Debt Interest Ratio
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S9.1 | Budgetary Policy
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S8.6 | Total Tax Rate




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S9.3 | Net Debt Ratio
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S9.2 | Debt-to-GDP
                                                                                                                                  S8.2 | Tax Evasion
                                                                                                              S8.1 | Tax Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S9 | Budgets
                                                                                                 S8 | Taxes




8.57                          4.06                                  4.31                         6.9              7               7.80                 4.53                                       2.97                                      8.53                           10                      7.1                 8                    9.95                 4.90                    5.88                               1                       9.70

5.37                          6.68                                  4.19                         4.8              5               7.02                 3.35                                       3.13                                      6.27                           3.47                    5.5                 6                    7.32                 5.09                    4.25                               1                       7.60

4.79                          6.95                                  3.74                         5.4              5               6.14                          1                                 10                                        8.15                           3.44                    4.6                 5                    5.73                 4.08                    2.50                               4                       4.60

3.94                          10                                    4.51                         6.5              7               7.59                 4.32                                       2.52                                      8.87                           6.60                    6.8                 8                    6.69                 4.45                    5.75                               1                       10

2.77                          5.71                                  2.46                         6.3              7               7.59                 5.23                                       5.71                                      6.58                           3.18                    9.2            10                        9.25                 7.71                    5.50                         10                            9.40

4.70                          3.92                                  3.79                         5.4              6               3.44                 5.56                                       5.68                                      3.05                           6.11                    5.2                 5                    8.77                 4.15                    5.63                               1                       7.60

4.20                          7.96                                  5.09                         6.7              8               8.86                 3.37                                       4.64                                      8.69                                1                  7.0                 8                    8.27                 5.31                          6                            4                       6.70

2.60                          5.47                                  5.23                         7.1              9               8.83                 3.35                                       4.34                                      7.69                           1.86                    7.9                 9                    8.23                 5.46                    7.63                               4                       8.80

3.02                          3.79                                  3.98                         5.1              5               5.31                 6.66                                       1.13                                      9.04                           3.51                    4.2                 4                    6.49                 3.51                    4.25                               1                             7

2.26                          6.04                                  4.46                         5.4              6               6.73                 2.57                                       3.30                                      6.93                           4.76                    6.4                 8                    7.01                 5.13                          4                            4                       4.30

3.10                          6.46                                  3.79                         3.8              2               2.48                 4.94                                       5.99                                      7.58                           7.20                    2.0                 1                    4.81                 1.30                          1                            1                       6.70

3.19                          3.47                                  2.99                         5.0              6               3.18                 1.14                                       5.64                                      5.69                           4.43                    5.4                 7                    6.59                 4.90                    1.75                               1                       4.30

8.91                                  1                             10                           7.2              8               10                   4.92                                       6.51                                      5.17                           5.38                    3.8                 5                    4.62                 2.95                    3.63                               1                             1

5.71                          4.17                                        1                      6.6              6               8.11                 4.82                                       5.92                                      9.34                           8.12                    3.1                 3                    7.32                      1                  4.50                               1                       2.20

3.78                          3.82                                  4.00                         3.9              4               2.17                 4.43                                       2.69                                      5.60                           3.97                    4.0                 4                    4.30                 4.41                    1.38                               4                       5.50

4.62                          4.94                                  4.68                         5.5              5               7.56                 7.87                                       1.33                                      5.69                           8.02                    3.1                 3                        1                3.66                    5.63                               1                       4.90

1.50                          9.58                                  3.78                         7.1              8               8.44                 5.21                                       4.60                                      7.47                           5.65                    7.4                 8                    10                   6.10                    8.50                               1                       8.50

3.02                          7.94                                  6.56                         4.4              3               1.39                 10                                         5.16                                      5.04                           7.69                    7.2                 8                    9.95                 5.88                    5.25                               4                             7

1.84                          7.24                                  4.70                         6.9              8               7.80                 3.83                                       5.06                                      8.38                           4.10                    5.3                 6                    7.40                 4.38                    4.88                               1                       5.50

5.12                          6.26                                  4.21                         8.1              9               10                   5.79                                       4.75                                      9.56                           5.78                    7.8                 9                    9.13                 5.05                          8                            1                       9.70

2.85                          7.41                                  5.47                         7.2              9               8.26                 3.93                                       3.43                                      10                             1.03                    9.7            10                        8.40                 10                      10                           10                            8.20

1.84                          2.74                                  5.47                         5.6              6               4.48                 7.73                                       5.64                                            1                        7.03                    5.2                 6                    7.93                 3.70                    4.38                               1                       4.90

4.36                          5.54                                  2.61                         5.1              4               7.93                 5.67                                       4.56                                      6.76                           5.65                    4.0                 4                    6.46                 2.84                    3.25                               1                       6.10

8.49                          2.09                                  3.81                         6.9              8               3.46                 7.07                                       5.94                                      3.91                           8.15                    5.3                 5                    8.92                 3.81                    5.63                               1                       8.50

8.15                          2.62                                        5                      6.6              7               4.48                 9.22                                       1.52                                      6.67                           8.68                    6.9                 8                    9.14                 6.36                          8                            1                       4.90

10                            5.97                                  3.39                         6.0              6               5.15                 6.61                                       1.89                                      8.01                           7.92                    4.4                 4                    7.71                 2.16                    5.25                               1                       7.90

      1                       6.41                                  3.98                         7.5              9               9.04                 5.75                                       4.36                                      9.94                           1.30                    8.3            10                        8.27                 5.95                    6.50                               4                       7.90

4.11                          7.23                                  4.69                         8.0              9               7.74                 7.17                                       4.95                                      7.11                           8.12                    8.7            10                        8.79                 6.63                    6.38                         8.50                          6.70
1.76   4.10   2.67   4.8   4    1     5.91   7.70   6.80   6.64   6.5   8   8.24   5.73   5.13   1   4.90

1.08   3.41   5.75   6.9   8   6.21   4.94   2.63   9.13   6.11   4.6   6   7.21   2.13   4.75   1   1.30

1.84   8.99   3.94   5.5   5   5.77   5.64    1     7.97   9.31   3.4   3   6.66   2.24    5     1    4
                                                                                                                                               S10.4 | Spending on Preventive and Health Programs




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S11.4 | Youth not in education and unemployed
                                                                                                                                                                                                    S10.5 | Life Expectancy-to-HC Spending




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S11.7 | Social and Political Participation
                                                                 S10.2 | Private-to-Public HC Spending


                                                                                                         S10.3 | Spending on Pharmaceuticals




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S11.1 | Social Inclusion Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S11.6 | Gender Equality
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     S11.3 | Life Satisfaction
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        S11 | Social Inclusion




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S11.5 | Gini Coefficient
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             S10.6 | Infant Mortality
                                         S10.1 | Health Policy
                     S10 | Health Care
B | Social Affairs




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S11.2 | Poverty
7.3                  7.5                      8                  9.68                                    7.49                                  3.01                                                 6.67                                     8.64                       7.0                             7                          5.12              8.36                        8.71                                            7.90                       8.23                      4.26

6.3                  7.5                      8                  9.61                                    7.86                                  2.75                                                 5.79                                     8.88                       7.3                             8                          9.11              7.55                        7.03                                            8.80                       2.93                      4.41

6.8                  8.3                      9                  9.79                                    6.70                                  5.70                                                 6.44                                     9.05                       7.1                             8                          7.60              8.36                        3.57                                            8.80                       4.86                      3.60

7.7                  8.1                      8                  9.98                                    6.40                                  10                                                   6.16                                     8.05                       6.9                             7                          5.40              8.36                        6.44                                            7.30                       6.95                      5.84

5.7                  7.1                      7                  9.06                                    6.36                                  4.22                                                 9.75                                     6.92                       3.6                             4                          2.37              5.09                        3.10                                                 1                     3.09                      4.34

6.5                  6.9                      7                  7.42                                    5.20                                  3.28                                                 8.64                                     9.41                       6.8                             7                          9.66              5.64                        7.43                                            8.80                       6.14                      2.36

7.9                  8.1                      9                  9.79                                    9.63                                  2.07                                                 6.24                                     8.70                       9.1                             9                          10                10                          8.81                                            10                         8.39                      7.89

7.5                  8.1                      8                  9.40                                    7.45                                  7.99                                                 7.06                                     9.53                       8.0                             8                          8.63              8.91                        5.35                                            8.80                       8.07                      8.50

6.5                  6.9                      7                  9.76                                    6.70                                  2.88                                                 6.19                                     8.82                       6.0                             6                          8.76              7.27                        2.38                                            8.50                       6.46                      2.71

6.4                  7.2                      7                  9.30                                    7.19                                  5.16                                                 6.08                                     8.99                       6.4                             7                          7.11              6.18                        3.97                                            7.90                       6.30                      2.74

4.7                  6.0                      5                  10                                      3.55                                  4.22                                                 7.47                                     9.47                       4.2                             4                          4.98              5.64                                  1                                     7.30                       5.02                      2.61

5.6                  5.3                      4                  9.33                                            1                             5.70                                                 9.02                                     7.75                       5.3                             5                          8.76              2.36                        5.35                                            8.20                       7.27                      1.71

7.5                  7.6                      8                  9.69                                    7.64                                  2.34                                                 6.66                                     9.59                       7.7                             7                          8.76              7.00                        8.39                                            8.50                       8.23                      10

6.6                  6.6                      6                  9.82                                    6.36                                  4.22                                                 5.99                                     9.23                       6.5                             8                          3.47              4.55                        7.13                                                 7                     5.82                      2.35

5.1                  6.8                      7                  9.30                                    5.95                                              1                                        7.59                                     8.88                       4.7                             5                          5.81              1.82                        3.97                                            6.40                       4.38                      3.60

5.9                  7.1                      7                  9.94                                    5.31                                  3.42                                                 7.56                                     9.53                       6.1                             7                          3.40              5.91                        8.13                                            7.30                       3.89                      2.67

7.7                  7.6                      8                  9.10                                    9.70                                  1.67                                                 5.39                                     10                         7.7                             9                          8.08              6.73                        6.14                                            9.10                       5.34                      2.82

5.3                  5.3                      5                  9.77                                    2.24                                  3.96                                                 9.90                                     2.07                       3.7                             3                             1              6.45                        8.64                                            2.80                       3.25                      4.73

7.1                  7.2                      7                  6.93                                    8.54                                  7.04                                                 5.64                                     8.82                       7.9                             8                          8.35              8.91                        10                                              8.80                       7.11                      4.18

8.2                  8.1                      8                  8.77                                    9.33                                  7.04                                                 7.51                                     8.16                       7.6                             8                          6.22              8.36                        8.81                                            6.70                       8.07                      4.93

8.4                  7.2                      7                  9.83                                    10                                    2.88                                                 4.41                                     9.47                       9.4                      10                                8.97              8.64                        9.11                                            8.50                       9.20                      8.53

5.0                  6.0                      5                  9.67                                    4.38                                  3.42                                                 9.39                                     7.75                       4.6                             5                          3.61              4.27                        1.89                                            5.80                       6.14                      3.14

5.5                  6.9                      7                  9.14                                    4.68                                  2.75                                                 8.17                                     9.11                       3.8                             4                          4.78              2.91                        2.88                                            4.30                       6.30                                1

5.4                  5.1                      5                           1                              2.31                                  6.91                                                 8.62                                     7.57                       5.0                             5                          8.08              2.36                        1.40                                            8.80                       5.98                      3.34

5.5                  7.3                      8                  8.91                                    3.89                                  2.88                                                 8.69                                     8.64                       5.0                             5                          3.61              3.73                        7.59                                            7.60                       4.86                      2.74

5.6                  7.0                      7                  9.65                                    5.16                                  3.55                                                 7.26                                     8.99                       5.0                             5                          3.95              7.55                        3.67                                            7.30                       5.02                      2.14

8.1                  8.4                      9                  9.74                                    7.90                                  5.03                                                 6.51                                     9.59                       8.9                             9                          10                8.36                        5.15                                            10                         10                        8.85

6.9                  8.1                      9                  9.84                                    8.99                                  3.28                                                 5.03                                     8.70                       7.6                             8                          7.66              8.64                        6.84                                            8.50                       7.11                      4.22
4.4   5.0   5   7.91   2.88   3.42   10      1     3.0   4   1.62    1     2.98   4.00    1     1.65

7.3   7.1   7   9.06   8.43   2.75   7.07   8.28   6.8   7   7.94   7.27   5.45   6.70   7.75   4.34

6.7   6.6   7   9.59   8.39   5.03    1     7.10   6.1   6   1.89   8.09   6.74   5.50   6.79   8.42
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               S14.2 | Foreign-born secondary attainment


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S14.3 | Foreign-born Tertiary Attainment


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S14.4 | Foreign-born Unemployment
                                                                                                                       S12.5 | Spending on Family Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S13.5 | Public Pension Coverage
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S13.3 | Senior Citizen Poverty
                                         S12.2 | Child Care Density




                                                                                                                                                                                                     S13.2 | Older Employment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S13.4 | Dependency Ratio




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S14.1 | Integration Policy
                                                                                                                                                                            S13.1 | Pension Policy
                                                                      S12.3 | Child Poverty
                 S12.1 | Family Policy




                                                                                              S12.4 | Fertility Rate




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              S14 | Integration
                                                                                                                                                           S13 | Pensions
S12 | Families




7.2                   7                  5.68                         6.38                    7.73                     9.48                                7.2                   9                   6.27                       4.76                             5.74                       4.52                              7.6                       9                      3.83                                        5.38                                       7.43

6.2                   6                  7.29                         8.61                    3.00                     6.31                                6.2                   6                   3.21                       8.76                             3.68                       10                                4.6                       4                      5.64                                                 1                                 6.41

8.2                   9                  9.98                         7.09                    6.73                     6.01                                5.9                   6                   2.21                       7.67                             3.09                       10                                4.8                       6                      1.33                                        4.53                                       3.11

6.8                   8                  7.71                         5.06                    5.27                     4.20                                8.4                   9                   6.03                       9.40                             5.89                       10                                8.2                       9                      3.58                                        9.06                                       7.71

5.6                   6                  7.71                              1                  8.00                     4.36                                7.4                   8                   5.71                       8.80                             4.89                       8.14                              4.8                       4                      4.78                                        4.44                                       5.61

6.0                   6                  8.06                         6.97                    3.82                     5.51                                7.2                   7                   4.18                       9.83                             5.52                       10                                5.6                       5                      8.25                                        1.45                                       5.46

8.7                   9                        9                      10                      7.36                     7.37                                7.3                   9                   6.01                       8.25                             4.34                       3.54                              6.3                       7                      5.61                                        4.81                                       7.47

8.0                   9                  4.43                         9.40                         7                   6.80                                7.9                   9                   5.69                       7.69                             3.76                       10                                5.3                       7                      2.64                                        3.30                                               1

9.1              10                      10                           8.05                    8.36                     6.26                                5.6                   5                   2.85                       8.49                             3.35                       10                                5.0                       6                      2.28                                        3.05                                       3.50

6.4                   7                  8.86                         6.77                    2.73                     5.10                                6.8                   7                   5.77                       8.80                             1.81                       10                                5.3                       6                      5.64                                        2.09                                       4.34

4.2                   4                  4.31                         5.82                    3.91                     3.64                                3.7                   2                   3.40                       5.62                             2.62                       10                                5.4                       5                      6.22                                        2.39                                       6.59

5.8                   5                  8.59                         7.61                    2.45                     8.06                                6.2                   7                   1.79                       9.34                             4.34                       6.32                              5.5                       5                      5.58                                        3.57                                       7.93

9.1                   9                  9.46                         7.77                    9.64                     10                                  6.8                   7                   10                         9.28                             6.47                              1                          6.2                       6                      4.78                                        4.44                                       8.80

6.9                   7                  4.47                         4.58                    9.27                     8.61                                6.3                   6                   5.06                       3.99                             7.13                       10                                7.0                       7                      2.86                                        10                                         6.38

4.7                   4                  9.94                         4.90                    3.00                     3.62                                5.2                   5                   2.28                       7.67                             1.70                       10                                4.3                       4                      4.03                                        1.27                                       5.75

5.5                   6                  8.68                         5.62                    2.64                     3.17                                5.0                   4                   7.38                       5.77                                  1                     10                                5.6                       4                      7.00                                        6.65                                       8.35

8.0                   9                  8.44                         6.14                    4.73                     8.94                                7.5                   8                   2.71                       9.67                             5.26                       10                                7.7                       9                      6.28                                        4.14                                       8.98

6.3                   6                  6.78                         2.23                    9.27                     7.90                                5.2                   5                   5.16                       4.53                             10                         1.84                              5.8                       4                      2.00                                        8.10                                       10

6.9                   8                  5.48                         6.50                    6.27                     4.99                                7.0                   8                   5.17                       9.88                             5.04                       3.66                              6.5                       8                      3.50                                        3.39                                       8.00

8.6                   9                  9.41                         5.10                    10                       8.26                                8.3                   8                   8.51                       10                               6.03                       10                                8.2                       9                      8.72                                        6.95                                       7.19

9.2              10                      8.99                         9.24                    8.00                     7.69                                8.2                   9                   7.93                       8.43                             4.56                       8.93                              7.9                       8                      8.94                                        6.80                                       7.29

4.6                   6                  3.66                         2.51                    2.82                     3.69                                6.2                   7                   1.70                       9.32                             5.89                       4.58                              3.7                       4                      5.92                                        1.18                                       5.43

4.8                   5                  7.71                         4.46                    2.64                     3.66                                5.1                   4                   4.68                       6.88                             3.42                       10                                6.6                       8                      1.92                                        3.42                                       7.68

5.4                   5                  7.10                         6.73                    2.18                     7.53                                6.4                   7                   2.95                       9.09                             6.88                       4.09                              5.0                       4                      10                                          2.33                                       3.32

3.7                   4                  2.89                         7.01                         1                   2.97                                6.2                   6                   6.51                              1                         8.31                       10                                5.1                       4                      4.78                                        4.44                                       8.21

5.1                   5                  9.75                         4.19                    3.45                     3.68                                5.6                   5                   3.72                       6.88                             4.01                       10                                5.2                       6                               1                                  3.96                                       4.48

9.0              10                      8.44                         9.48                    7.55                     6.56                                7.7                   9                   8.17                       9.07                             2.84                       5.38                              6.7                       7                      7.56                                        4.93                                       7.61

4.5                   4                  4.43                         7.33                    3.64                     4.33                                7.7                   9                   7.88                       6.68                             4.12                       7.00                              6.6                       7                      4.36                                        4.74                                       7.68
3.6   4    1     1.28   9.64    1     6.0   5    1     7.19   9.82   10   4.5   4   3.39   2.18   5.46

8.1   8   8.98   7.05   8.00   8.69   7.5   8   6.01   8.18   3.79   10   7.0   8   1.53   8.10   7.43

6.1   7   5.52   2.87   9.45   2.91   7.0   7   6.54   5.44   6.00   10   7.4   8   4.36   5.47   7.96
S14.5 | Foreign-born-to-Native Employment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          S16.4 | Reliability of Police Services
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       S16.3 | Burglaries and Robberies
                                                                                                                                                   S15.4 | Relations with Neighbors
                                                                                     S15.1 | External Security Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                S16.1 | Internal Security Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S17.1 | Environmental Policy
                                                           S15 | External Security




                                                                                                                                                                                      S16 | Internal Security
                                                                                                                        S15.2 | Conflicts fought




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S16.5 | Costs of Crime




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S17 | Environment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S16.2 | Homicides




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            D | Resources
                                            C | Security




7.78                                        8.2            8.2                              9                           4.60                       10                                 8.2                              9                           9.22                5.89                               8.62                                     5.67                     5.5             4.8                       5

7.47                                        8.1            8.1                              7                           8.20                       10                                 8.2                              8                           9.90                5.93                               8.15                                     9.33                     5.6             6.4                       6

5.06                                        7.8            9.1                              9                           8.20                       10                                 6.6                              7                           8.43                       1                           7.92                                     7.67                     6.2             5.9                       6

9.30                                        8.2            7.9                              9                           8.20                       5.50                               8.5                              9                           8.83                7.42                               9.08                                     6.33                     6.3             4.6                       5

7.28                                        7.8            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 6.7                              7                           3.93                6.25                               9.08                                     6.00                     4.4             6.1                       5

9.72                                        7.4            7.7                              8                           4.60                       10                                 7.1                              7                           8.53                8.15                               3.77                                     8.00                     5.5             6.4                       7

4.88                                        7.9            7.7                              8                           4.60                       10                                 8.1                              8                           9.02                5.16                               9.77                                     8.67                     7.3             7.1                       8

7.65                                        8.6            8.6                              8                           8.20                       10                                 8.6                              8                           8.04                8.81                               10                                       9.67                     8.0             7.0                       8

7.54                                        7.7            8.2                              9                           4.60                       10                                 7.3                              7                           9.12                7.80                               7.92                                     5.67                     6.4             6.2                       6

6.59                                        8.6            8.6                              8                           8.20                       10                                 8.7                              9                           9.61                8.28                               9.08                                     7.00                     6.6             7.0                       8

8.01                                        6.9            7.9                              9                           8.20                       5.50                               5.8                              5                           9.41                8.85                               3.77                                     4.67                     3.4             4.5                       3

7.28                                        6.6            7.4                              8                           8.20                       5.50                               5.7                              4                           8.92                8.63                               4.92                                     7.33                     5.0             6.6                       7

7.28                                        8.3            8.1                              7                           8.20                       10                                 8.6                              8                           9.80                7.60                               9.54                                     10                       6.5             5.2                       4

8.53                                        8.1            8.6                              8                           8.20                       10                                 7.6                              7                           8.43                8.02                               8.38                                     7.67                     5.4             5.9                       6

7.10                                        7.6            8.2                              9                           4.60                       10                                 7.0                              7                           9.22                9.03                               5.38                                     4.33                     4.6             5.6                       5

6.95                                        7.4            6.3                              7                           10                                1                           8.5                              9                           10                  9.59                               8.15                                     4.00                     6.6             6.6                       7

5.89                                        9.0            9.1                              9                           8.20                       10                                 8.9                              9                           8.92                7.62                               9.08                                     9.33                     5.8             6.1                       7

10                                          5.1            7.4                              7                           10                         5.50                               2.9                              3                               1               8.40                                        1                                    1                   3.8             5.6                       5

5.29                                        7.8            7.7                              8                           4.60                       10                                 8.0                              8                           9.41                8.38                               9.08                                     5.33                     5.5             5.3                       5

6.92                                        8.9            9.5                              9                           10                         10                                 8.4                              9                           9.32                5.35                               8.85                                     7.33                     6.5             6.2                       6

7.78                                        8.7            8.2                              9                           4.60                       10                                 9.2                              9                           9.80                8.47                               9.31                                     9.67                     6.3             7.2                       8

         1                                  6.4            5.4                              8                           4.60                              1                           7.3                              8                           9.02                8.65                               4.23                                     4.67                     5.1             5.9                       6

8.16                                        8.2            8.6                              8                           8.20                       10                                 7.9                              8                           8.73                8.11                               6.31                                     8.00                     5.0             6.2                       6

8.11                                        6.5            6.0                              7                           4.60                       5.50                               7.1                              7                           8.83                8.93                               3.08                                     7.67                     4.1             5.3                       4

7.28                                        7.0            6.3                              7                           10                                1                           7.7                              8                           8.14                10                                 5.85                                     6.00                     6.3             4.7                       4

8.06                                        7.7            8.6                              8                           8.20                       10                                 6.8                              7                           9.51                5.44                               7.92                                     3.67                     4.9             5.4                       5

5.76                                        8.5            9.1                              9                           8.20                       10                                 8.0                              8                           9.22                6.29                               9.08                                     7.33                     8.0             7.8                       8

8.06                                        8.5            8.1                              7                           8.20                       10                                 8.9                              9                           9.71                7.36                               9.54                                     8.33                     7.6             7.4                       8
8.63   4.9   4.6   7    1     3.25   5.2   5   7.26   9.44   3.08   2.00   3.6   5.3   4

6.90   7.2   7.7   8   4.60   10     6.7   7   9.02   6.02   7.23   3.67   6.3   6.8   7

9.72   6.2   6.0   7   4.60   5.50   6.4   7   5.01   7.28   8.38   2.67   6.4   4.5   6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S18.4 | Science and Technology Degrees
                                                                                                                                                         S18.1 | Research and Innovation Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S18.6 | Computer and Internet Access




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S19.2 | Upper Secondary Attainment
                                                                                                                         S18 | Research and Innovation




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S18.3 | Industry R&D personnel
                                                                                                                                                                                                  S18.2 | Public R&D Spending




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S19.4 | Continuing Education
                                                                                              S17.6 | Waste Management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S19.3 | Tertiary Attainment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S19.1 | Education Policy
S17.2 | Energy Intensity


                           S17.3 | CO2 Emissions




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          S18.5 | Triad Patents
                                                                        S17.5 | Water Usage
                                                   S17.4 | Energy Mix




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S19 | Education
7.47                            1                  1.42                 5.29                  7.38                       5.0                                      5                               7.07                          3.45                             6.15                                     2.47                    5.58                                   6.7                    8                     6.05                                 6.50                          4.54

9.44                       7.75                    3.70                 7.89                       5                     5.1                                      5                               7.59                          6.42                             2.51                                     4.67                    5.18                                   5.2                    5                     7.53                                 2.63                          4.68

7.75                       6.32                    1.32                 7.15                  6.67                       5.9                                      7                               3.41                          6.22                             3.63                                     3.77                    7.42                                   6.7                    7                     6.03                                 6.11                          4.07

5.78                       1.82                    2.67                 3.04                  8.17                       6.0                                      7                               5.60                          6.11                             3.11                                     2.84                    7.60                                   8.1                    9                     8.34                                 10                            6.17

8.31                       5.50                    3.26                 10                    9.42                       3.0                                      4                               4.66                          1.82                             1.31                                     1.01                    1.21                                   4.0                    4                     3.79                                 1.58                          4.54

6.91                       1.20                    1.40                 9.58                  10                         4.0                                      5                               5.60                          3.51                             2.70                                     1.12                    2.24                                   6.1                    7                     8.82                                 1.70                          2.80

9.72                       7.14                    2.89                 9.81                  1.50                       7.3                                      8                               5.92                          8.62                             3.80                                     5.00                    9.98                                   7.4                    7                     6.96                                 6.14                          9.68

6.91                       5.09                    3.64                 8.00                  6.33                       8.1                                      9                               7.80                          9.85                             5.80                                     6.09                    6.68                                   8.9               10                         7.58                                 7.14                          8.95

8.59                       8.77                    1.67                 7.55                  5.83                       6.7                                      7                               7.17                          6.52                             6.55                                     4.19                    7.84                                   6.1                    6                     6.11                                 4.84                          4.68

8.88                       6.11                    1.77                 8.11                  5.17                       7.0                                      8                               6.34                          6.06                             3.20                                     6.89                    7.84                                   5.9                    6                     8.06                                 4.24                          2.95

9.44                       5.70                    1.40                 6.30                  7.33                       2.6                                      3                               1.94                          2.18                             1.77                                     1.09                    3.58                                   3.1                    3                     4.98                                 3.86                                1

8.31                       6.32                    1.51                 7.27                  7.17                       3.7                                      5                               3.51                          2.23                                      1                               1.31                    3.83                                   4.8                    4                     7.42                                 2.66                          1.15

     1                     8.57                    10                   7.38                  5.50                       6.9                                      8                               10                            6.11                             2.17                                     2.54                    8.63                                   7.2                    8                     5.59                                 5.56                          4.54

10                         7.34                    1.24                 8.85                  1.83                       5.4                                      7                               3.30                          3.91                             5.37                                     2.28                    4.36                                   4.8                    5                     5.98                                 6.14                          2.76

9.72                       7.34                    1.75                 6.17                  5.67                       3.7                                      4                               4.45                          2.99                             2.91                                     2.01                    4.68                                   4.5                    5                     4.08                                 1.67                          1.15

8.88                       6.11                    1.19                 6.87                       8                     6.7                                      7                               4.66                          7.60                             3.50                                     9.73                    6.06                                   6.4                    6                     10                                   8.25                          4.54

9.16                       6.11                    1.10                 6.36                  3.33                       6.7                                      8                               1.94                          7.55                             3.98                                     4.81                    8.32                                   4.5                    4                     5.74                                 4.77                          2.98

8.31                       5.50                    1.90                 6.31                       9                     2.1                                      3                                     1                              1                         1.68                                          1                  1.08                                   3.7                    4                     1.72                                 2.22                          4.54

8.59                       6.11                    1.33                 7.15                  4.33                       5.3                                      5                               6.02                          4.63                             1.56                                     5.83                    10                                     5.9                    6                     6.67                                 5.80                          2.46

8.03                       5.91                    4.60                 5.23                  8.13                       5.6                                      7                               4.35                          3.66                             5.39                                     2.00                    5.55                                   7.8                    9                     6.47                                 8.25                          4.54

8.31                       9.18                    5.66                 7.49                       1                     5.6                                      6                               6.76                          5.91                             1.62                                     3.20                    8.98                                   6.0                    6                     7.38                                 6.62                          4.54

7.75                       1.41                    1.50                 8.74                  9.50                       3.6                                      5                               2.47                          1.15                             4.64                                     1.01                    2.01                                   5.8                    6                     8.30                                 2.90                          2.34

9.16                       7.14                    2.86                 5.69                       7                     4.6                                      6                               4.66                          2.07                             4.63                                     1.06                    3.85                                   4.1                    5                             1                            1.70                          1.95

7.47                       4.68                    1.40                 9.81                  10                         2.9                                      4                               1.63                          1.31                             3.44                                     1.04                    1.84                                   4.1                    3                     8.39                                 1.79                          4.78

6.91                       3.66                        1                7.10                  8.50                       7.7                                      8                               7.38                          5.19                             10                                       5.53                    8.86                                   6.5                    7                     7.26                                 6.71                          4.54

9.16                       6.52                    1.67                 6.19                  5.17                       4.1                                      5                               4.77                          3.20                             2.21                                     1.41                    4.91                                   5.0                    5                     3.88                                 5.37                          1.68

8.03                       10                      4.46                 8.90                  6.17                       8.2                                      9                               7.38                          10                               3.25                                     8.34                    8.48                                   7.9                    8                     8.09                                 5.92                          10

10                         9.80                    3.10                 8.51                       3                     8.1                                      9                               5.92                          5.86                             4.49                                     10                      9.53                                   7.3                    8                     8.26                                 5.92                          7.22
9.72   6.52   1.89   7.10   7.67   2.8   4   2.57   1.20   2.45   1.01    1     2.6   3   1.15    1     4.54

9.72   7.14   1.14   9.58   5.33   6.0   7   4.77   4.02   5.69   3.14   7.57   6.2   6   6.06   6.04   6.80

7.19   2.84   1.42    1     2.17   7.4   9   6.86   7.55   2.61   5.19   6.58   7.3   7   8.50   8.08   9.27
                                                                                                                                                                                     M1.2 | Medium-term Fiscal Framework




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     M2 | Inter-ministerial Coordination




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M2.6 | Line Ministry Civil Servants
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              M2.5 | Senior Ministry Officials
                       S19.6 | Pre-primary Education




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  M2.4 | Cabinet Committees
                                                                                                                                                         M1.1 | Strategic Planning
                                                                                                    A | Steering Capability:




                                                                                                                               M1 | Strategic Capacity




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M2.2 | GO Gatekeeping
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M1.3 | Scholarly Advice
                                                                           I | Executive Capacity




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M2.3 | Line Ministries
S19.5 | PISA Results




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M2.1 | GO Expertise
                                                       Management Index




8.24                   1.46                            7.71               7.81                                8.2              6.8                             8                     5.50                                       7                    8.7                                       9                 10                           9                         9                            8                                   8

6.09                   6.33                            6.39               6.17                                5.9              4.3                             4                             4                                  5                    4.9                                       3                      5                       2                         5                            6                                   5

6.93                   8.51                            6.00               5.04                                4.7              5.2                             7                     3.50                                       5                    7.3                                       7                      5                  10                       10                                 9                                   4

8.37                   3.51                            7.04               8.01                                7.7              7.2                             8                     5.50                                       8                    8.6                                       9                      9                       9                         8                     10                                         8

3.02                   7.10                            6.15               6.56                                7.2              6.5                             9                     2.50                                       8                    8.6                                       9                      9                       9                         9                            8                                   8

6.48                   6.17                            5.88               5.68                                5.5              4.8                             4                     5.50                                       5                    5.6                                       5                      6                       6                         5                            5                                   5

6.41                   9.66                            7.90               8.29                                8.1              7.2                             8                     5.50                                       8                    8.6                                       7                      9                       9                         9                            9                                   9

10                     5.39                            7.79               8.38                                8.7              7.0                             8                             7                                  6                    9.1                                       9                      8                       9                   10                          10                                         9

6.35                   9.46                            5.82               6.83                                6.2              4.5                             5                     4.50                                       4                    8.3                                       8                 10                           9                         8                     10                                         5

7.78                   5.92                            6.84               6.72                                5.9              6.3                             4                     10                                         5                    6.3                                       6                      5                       7                         5                            9                                   5

4.52                   2.13                            4.54               4.16                                4.1              3.0                             4                             1                                  4                    4.7                                       4                      7                       6                         3                            3                                   3

6.67                   10                              5.71               5.96                                5.4              6.0                             5                             7                                  6                    7.6                                       7                      9                       9                         7                            9                                   6

6.22                   9.82                            7.23               7.09                                6.0              5.2                             3                     6.50                                       6                    7.7                                       8                 10                           8                         5                            9                                   7

    7                         1                        6.33               6.26                                6.6              5.7                             5                             6                                  6                    8.0                                       7                      9                       9                         5                            9                                   9

5.76                   7.19                            5.62               5.49                                5.4              4.8                             6                     2.50                                       6                    6.6                                       6                      8                       6                         7                            8                                   4

9.02                   2.13                            6.41               6.39                                6.5              4.7                             6                             4                                  4                    6.3                                       8                      6                       8                         4                            5                                   5

5.43                   6.30                            7.05               6.60                                6.4              5.3                             4                             7                                  5                    8.3                                       7                      8                       8                         8                            9                                   8

    1                  7.80                            5.87               6.74                                7.2              6.0                             7                             4                                  7                    7.6                                       8                      9                       7                         8                            7                                   6

7.91                   6.01                            6.84               7.04                                7.4              6.3                             5                             7                                  7                    7.1                                       6                      6                       8                         9                            8                                   7

8.57                   5.53                            7.72               8.18                                8.2              7.3                             8                             7                                  7                    8.9                                       7                      9                       9                   10                                 9                                   9

6.48                   4.79                            8.20               8.03                                8.2              7.3                             8                             5                                  9                    8.0                                       9                      9                       8                         1                     10                                 10

    7                  7.59                            5.79               6.26                                6.2              5.5                             7                     2.50                                       7                    6.7                                       8                      9                       7                         4                            8                                   4

6.02                   5.74                            5.76               6.41                                5.9              4.7                             6                             2                                  6                    6.7                                       7                      7                       7                         9                            7                                   2

5.83                   5.30                            4.75               4.41                                4.2              4.3                             3                             7                                  3                    5.4                                       4                      5                       3                         6                            7                                   5

8.96                   2.37                            5.92               6.67                                5.9              6.0                             7                             5                                  6                    7.4                                       8                      9                       9                         7                            9                                   5

5.70                   8.75                            6.03               6.22                                5.8              4.8                             6                     2.50                                       6                    7.3                                       7                      8                       7                         8                            9                                   5

6.15                   8.84                            8.29               8.39                                7.8              7.7                             8                             7                                  8                    7.1                                       7                      9                       7                         1                     10                                         8

7.59                   3.55                            6.79               7.34                                7.5              4.7                             4                             4                                  6                    6.7                                       5                      5                       7                         2                     10                                         9
3.48   1.20   6.07   6.43   6.1   7.2   6   8.50   7   7.6   5   9    9    5   9   8

7.39   5.47   6.82   7.40   7.5   7.0   7    7     7   9.1   9   10   9    9   9   9

6.61   5.33   7.24   7.78   8.8   7.0   9    4     8   9.4   9   9    10   9   9   10
M2.7 | Informal Coordination Procedures


                                          M3 | Evidence-based Instruments




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M6.2b | Monitoring Line Ministries
                                                                                                                                                                                       M4.1 | Negotiating Public Support




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M5.1 | Coherent Communication




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M6 | Effective Implementation




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   M6.2a | Ministerial Compliance
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M6.1 | Government Efficiency
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M5 | Policy Communication




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M6.2c | Monitoring Agencies
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       B | Policy Implementation:
                                                                                                                                                          M4 | Societal Consultation
                                                                                                                             M3.3 | Alternative Options




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M6.2d | Internal Auditing
                                                                                                     M3.2 | Needs Analysis
                                                                            M3.1 | RIA Application




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   M6.3a | Task Funding
         8                                8.7                                    8                        9                        9                      8.0                                  8                           9.0                                9                                   7.7               7.7                                   7                        10                               10                                         9                       10                              7

         8                                6.3                                    6                        7                        6                      9.0                                  9                           5.0                                5                                   7.4               7.4                                   7                               6                                 6                                  9                       10                              8

         6                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      7.0                                  7                           3.0                                3                                   5.2               5.2                                   3                               6                                 5                                  8                             6                         4

         7                                6.0                                    6                        7                        5                      8.0                                  8                           9.0                                9                                   8.5               8.5                                   8                        10                               10                                         7                       10                              8

         8                                6.0                                    8                        5                        5                      7.0                                  7                           8.0                                8                                   6.5               6.5                                   6                               9                                 8                                  8                       10                              6

         7                                6.3                                    8                        6                        5                      7.0                                  7                           4.0                                4                                   6.0               6.0                                   4                               6                                 5                                  7                       10                              7

         8                                7.7                                    8                        9                        6                      9.0                                  9                           8.0                                8                                   8.3               8.3                                   8                               9                                 8                                  8                             9                         8

         9                                9.3                                    9                   10                            9                      10.0                         10                                  8.0                                8                                   8.2               8.2                                   9                               9                                 8                                  8                             8                         6

         8                                4.0                                    5                        3                        4                      5.0                                  5                           9.0                                9                                   7.6               7.6                                   7                               9                                 9                                  7                       10                              6

         7                                7.7                                    8                        8                        7                      6.0                                  6                           3.0                                3                                   7.1               7.1                                   7                               8                                 5                                  7                       10                              5

         7                                2.0                                    2                        2                        2                      5.0                                  5                           6.0                                6                                   3.8               3.8                                   4                               3                                 4                                  4                             7                         4

         6                                3.7                                    4                        3                        4                      5.0                                  5                           5.0                                5                                   6.4               6.4                                   7                               8                                 8                                  6                       10                              4

         7                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      7.0                                  7                           9.0                                9                                   7.8               7.8                                   9                               9                         10                                         3                             1                         8

         8                                6.3                                    7                        6                        6                      5.0                                  5                           8.0                                8                                   5.4               5.4                                   3                               7                                 7                                  5                       10                              6

         7                                4.7                                    5                        5                        4                      5.0                                  5                           6.0                                6                                   6.1               6.1                                   7                               7                                 5                                  4                       10                              5

         8                                8.7                                    9                        9                        8                      7.0                                  7                           6.0                                6                                   6.4               6.4                                   6                               6                                 7                                  7                       10                              5

10                                        1.3                                    2                        1                        1                      8.0                                  8                           9.0                                9                                   6.9               6.9                                   7                               8                                 6                                  8                             1                         8

         8                                8.3                                    9                        8                        8                      7.0                                  7                           7.0                                7                                   6.5               6.5                                   5                               8                                 8                                  7                       10                              7

         6                                8.7                                    9                        9                        8                      8.0                                  8                           7.0                                7                                   7.4               7.4                                   8                               8                                 8                                  6                       10                              8

         9                                10.0                              10                       10                      10                           8.0                                  8                           7.0                                7                                   8.3               8.3                                   8                               9                                 9                                  9                             6                     10

         9                                7.7                                    8                        8                        7                      10.0                         10                                  8.0                                8                                   7.9               7.9                                   9                               9                                 9                                  9                             1                         9

         7                                4.7                                    6                        5                        3                      7.0                                  7                           7.0                                7                                   5.9               5.9                                   4                               8                                 5                                  6                       10                              5

         8                                5.0                                    5                        5                        5                      5.0                                  5                           8.0                                8                                   6.6               6.6                                   6                               9                                 8                                  7                       10                              5

         8                                3.3                                    4                        3                        3                      5.0                                  5                           3.0                                3                                   5.3               5.3                                   5                               4                                 4                                  5                       10                              6

         5                                7.0                                    8                        7                        6                      3.0                                  3                           6.0                                6                                   7.4               7.4                                   7                        10                                       9                                  9                       10                              6

         7                                3.0                                    3                        3                        3                      7.0                                  7                           7.0                                7                                   6.3               6.3                                   7                               8                                 7                                  8                             1                         7

         8                                6.3                                    7                        7                        5                      9.0                                  9                           9.0                                9                                   8.3               8.3                                   8                        10                                       9                                  9                       5.50                            8

         9                                8.0                                    8                        8                        8                      10.0                         10                                  8.0                                8                                   8.6               8.6                                   9                               8                                 9                                  5                       10                              9
8    2.7   2    3    3    6.0   6   7.0   7   6.4   6.4   7   9    7   6   10   6

9    9.3   8    10   10   4.0   4   8.0   8   7.7   7.7   8   9    9   7   10   7

10   9.7   10   10   9    9.0   9   9.0   9   7.5   7.5   7   10   9   8   10   6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M10 | Structures and Resources of Legislative
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M9 | Citizens' Participatory Competence
                                                                                                                                                                                      M8 | Organizational Reform Capacity
                                                                                                                                                  M7.2 | International Coordination
M6.3b | Constitutional Discretion




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    II | Executive Accountability
                                                                                                                   M7.1 | Domestic Adaptability
                                                                 C | Institutional Learning:
                                    M6.3c | National Standards




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     M8.2 | Institutional Reform




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              M9.1 | Policy Knowledge
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            M8.1 | Self-monitoring




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        M9.2 | Voter Turnout


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               E | Legislatature:
                                                                                               M7 | Adaptability




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    D | Citizens:




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Actors
       4                                  8                                 7.5                8.5                       8                                9                           6.5                                        6                         7                       7.61                                  8.5        8.5                                            7                    10                            8.0                    6.6
       8                                  6                                 5.3                6.5                       6                                7                           4.0                                        3                         5                       6.60                                  6.5        6.5                                            6                    7.06                          6.9                    5.1
10                                        5                                 5.3                7.5                       7                                8                           3.0                                        3                         3                       6.95                                  7.2        7.2                                            5                    9.32                          7.7                    6.6
       9                                  8                                 7.8                8.0                       8                                8                           7.5                                        8                         7                       6.07                                  4.7        4.7                                            6                    3.37                          7.5                    6.4
       5                                  3                                 6.0                6.0                       5                                7                           6.0                                        6                         6                       5.74                                  6.2        6.2                                            4                    8.49                          6.9                    6.1
       7                                  7                                 5.5                6.5                       7                                6                           4.5                                        4                         5                       6.08                                  4.7        4.7                                            5                    4.41                          7.7                    6.3
       8                                  9                                 8.5                9.0                       9                                9                           8.0                                        9                         7                       7.52                                  8.2        8.2                                            8                    8.49                          7.5                    5.7
       9                                  7                                 8.3                8.0                       8                                8                           8.5                                        9                         8                       7.20                                  5.8        5.8                                            7                    4.51                          8.1                    6.5
       6                                  9                                 6.8                8.0                       9                                7                           5.5                                        5                         6                       4.81                                  4.3        4.3                                            5                    3.66                          5.8                    4.8
       8                                  7                                 7.3                8.0                       7                                9                           6.5                                        5                         8                       6.97                                  6.9        6.9                                            7                    6.86                          7.5                    6.2
       3                                  2                                 4.5                4.5                       5                                4                           4.5                                        4                         5                       4.93                                  5.1        5.1                                            4                    6.19                          6.2                    6.0
       4                                  5                                 6.0                7.0                       6                                8                           5.0                                        5                         5                       5.46                                  4.5        4.5                                            4                    4.98                          7.8                    6.4
10                                        8                                 7.5                8.0                       9                                7                           7.0                                        7                         7                       7.37                                  8.5        8.5                                            9                    7.94                          7.1                    5.6
       5                                  7                                 6.8                8.5                       9                                8                           5.0                                        5                         5                       6.40                                  6.4        6.4                                            8                    4.88                          6.6                    5.3
       5                                  4                                 5.0                6.0                       7                                5                           4.0                                        4                         4                       5.75                                  6.2        6.2                                            5                    7.37                          6.5                    5.8
       4                                  8                                 6.3                7.0                       6                                8                           5.5                                        6                         5                       6.42                                  6.0        6.0                                            7                    4.96                          7.1                    6.7
       7                                  9                                 6.5                7.5                       7                                8                           5.5                                        5                         6                       7.51                                  8.7        8.7                                            8                    9.43                          6.6                    4.2
       7                                  5                                 6.5                7.0                       7                                7                           6.0                                        5                         7                       5.00                                  4.2        4.2                                            5                    3.38                          6.3                    4.7
       4                                  7                                 6.3                6.5                       5                                8                           6.0                                        7                         5                       6.64                                  6.2        6.2                                            5                    7.34                          7.4                    6.1
       8                                  8                                 8.0                8.0                       7                                9                           8.0                                        8                         8                       7.25                                  7.6        7.6                                            8                    7.18                          7.6                    6.3
       6                                  8                                 8.0                7.0                       5                                9                           9.0                                        9                         9                       8.37                                  7.9        7.9                                            9                    6.80                          8.0                    6.4
       7                                  7                                 6.8                8.0                       8                                8                           5.5                                        5                         6                       5.32                                  3.7        3.7                                            5                    2.45                          7.7                    5.9
       5                                  6                                 6.8                7.0                       7                                7                           6.5                                        7                         6                       5.11                                  4.2        4.2                                            4                    4.37                          6.8                    6.4
       5                                  4                                 3.8                3.5                       4                                3                           4.0                                        4                         4                       5.10                                  3.8        3.8                                            5                    2.60                          6.9                    6.1
       5                                  6                                 6.8                7.0                       7                                7                           6.5                                        7                         6                       5.17                                  3.5        3.5                                            6                        1                         7.5                    8.1
       6                                  5                                 6.5                8.0                       8                                8                           5.0                                        5                         5                       5.84                                  5.7        5.7                                            5                    6.41                          6.4                    4.4
       9                                  9                                 9.0                9.5                       9                        10                                  8.5                                        8                         9                       8.19                                  8.3        8.3                                            9                    7.64                          8.1                    6.6
10                                        7                                 6.0                5.5                       6                                5                           6.5                                        8                         5                       6.23                                  4.7        4.7                                            8                    1.42                          6.6                    6.2
4   3   6.8   7.5   7   8   6.0   6   6   5.72   6.5   6.5   5   8.04   6.5   6.5
5   7   7.0   7.0   6   8   7.0   6   8   6.24   5.5   5.5   7   3.91   6.7   5.0
7   6   7.0   7.5   8   7   6.5   7   6   6.70   5.3   5.3   6   4.62   9.0   8.7
                                                        M10.3 | Pro-government Committee Chairs




                                                                                                                                                                     M11 | Legislative Accountability




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               F | Intermediary Organizations:
                                                                                                                                M10.6 | Legislature's Expert Staff




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                M11.5 | Task Area Coincidence
M10.1 | Number of Committees




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M12.2 | Newspaper Circulation
                                                                                                                                                                                                        M11.1 | Non-majority leverage




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      M11.3 | Summoning Ministers
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        M11.2 | Obtaining Documents




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M11.4 | Summoning Experts




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M12.3 | Quality Newspapers
                                                                                                  M10.4 | Deputy Expert Staff




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               M12.1 | Media Reporting
                               M10.2 | Committee Size




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M11.7 | Ombuds Office
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                M11.6 | Audit Office




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M12 | Media
      9                        8.88                     5.98                                      2.80                          6.16                                 9.5                                8.41                                  9                       10                            10                                 9                        10                     10                                   6.3                  3.9                7                    2.80                            2.02

      5                        10                       6.41                                      1.45                          2.49                                 8.7                                8.02                                  7                             8                       10                                 8                        10                     10                                   6.4                  5.1                8                    5.61                            1.71

      9                        10                       8.64                                      1.45                          3.92                                 8.9                                7.17                                  9                       10                                  9                            8                        10                          9                               5.9                  3.9                7                    2.73                            1.97

      7                        8.88                     8.24                                      2.80                          5.07                                 8.6                                9.13                                  9                             9                       10                                 8                            9                       6                               6.0                  4.4                8                    2.92                            2.32

      8                        10                       5.98                                      1.90                          4.73                                 7.6                                9.17                                  8                             9                             9                            7                            8                       3                               4.1                  2.6                4                           1                        2.68

10                             10                       8.07                                      1.90                          1.63                                 9.0                                8.88                            10                            10                            10                                 9                            7                       8                               5.9                  5.1                7                    3.18                            5.08

      7                        10                       8.37                                      1.45                          1.52                                 9.4                                9.73                                  9                       10                                  9                            8                        10                     10                                   6.8                  5.2                7                    4.59                            4.06

10                             10                       8.57                                      1.45                          2.61                                 9.7                                7.58                            10                            10                            10                          10                              10                     10                                   7.8                  7.5                8                    8.10                            6.46

      8                             1                   10                                        3.25                          1.69                                 6.8                                8.51                                  9                             8                       10                                 3                            7                       2                               4.3                  3.3                6                    2.61                            1.35

      8                        8.88                     9.77                                      1.90                          2.38                                 8.8                                5.83                            10                            10                            10                                 9                        10                          7                               6.5                  5.3                8                    4.76                            3.00

10                             7.75                     8.64                                      1.45                          1.92                                 6.5                                8.82                                  9                             9                             9                            6                            2                       2                               3.4                  3.6                3                    3.63                            4.04

10                             10                       9.70                                      1.45                                  1                            9.2                                8.51                                  9                       10                            10                                 9                            9                       9                               4.1                  3.1                5                    2.32                            2.01

10                             8.88                     5.65                                            1                       2.32                                 8.7                                6.64                                  8                             9                       10                                 7                        10                     10                                   6.5                  5.4                7                    2.74                            6.48

      7                        10                       6.98                                      1.45                          1.23                                 8.0                                8.76                                  7                             6                       10                                 8                            9                       7                               6.1                  4.9                9                    3.90                            1.82

10                             5.50                     9.60                                      1.45                          2.61                                 7.2                                8.49                                  9                             9                             9                            8                            5                       2                               4.6                  3.1                6                    1.96                            1.37

10                             7.75                     9.37                                      2.35                          4.15                                 7.5                                6.66                                  9                             9                             7                            9                            7                       5                               6.2                  6.3                8                    10                                    1

      8                        10                                1                                      1                       1.17                                 8.9                                7.46                                  9                       10                                  9                            8                            9                  10                                   7.2                  6.1                5                    4.98                            8.39

      1                        8.88                     9.67                                      2.35                          1.57                                 8.0                                10                                    8                             8                             9                            5                            8                       8                               4.5                  2.9                5                    1.07                            2.67

      8                        10                       7.08                                      1.68                          3.52                                 8.8                                8.60                                  9                             9                             9                            9                            8                       9                               6.3                  4.6                8                    4.40                            1.54

10                             8.88                     7.14                                            1                       4.55                                 8.9                                9.05                                  9                             8                       10                                 6                        10                     10                                   6.6                  5.2                8                    3.59                            3.94

10                             10                       9.20                                      1.45                          1.46                                 9.5                                8.76                            10                            10                            10                                 8                        10                     10                                   9.2                  9.4                9                    9.31                            10

      7                        8.88                     9.30                                      1.90                          2.66                                 9.4                                8.70                            10                            10                            10                                 9                        10                          8                               4.6                  3.5                7                    2.13                            1.28

10                             10                       9.40                                            1                       1.75                                 7.2                                8.66                                  8                             9                             9                            7                            5                       4                               4.3                  3.0                6                    1.22                            1.64

      9                        8.88                     9.07                                      2.13                          1.29                                 7.8                                8.27                                  6                             8                             8                            9                            7                       8                               4.6                  2.9                5                    2.05                            1.54

10                             10                       9.17                                      4.15                          7.08                                 6.8                                8.78                                  7                       10                            10                                 6                            5                       1                               4.6                  4.5                5                    5.40                            3.03

      6                        5.50                     8.31                                      1.23                          1.11                                 8.4                                9.01                                  8                             9                             9                            8                            8                       8                               5.4                  3.7                7                    1.91                            2.32

10                             10                       9.63                                      1.43                          1.92                                 9.5                                8.80                            10                            10                            10                                 8                        10                     10                                   8.2                  7.4                9                    7.25                            5.91

10                             10                       8.57                                      1.45                          1.11                                 7.0                                       1                        10                            10                            10                                 8                            8                       2                               7.4                  7.4                9                    5.77                            7.40
10   10     9.37   1.45   1.80   6.4   7.63   7    7    10   7   4    2   4.2   3.0   6   1.71   1.34

2    8.88   8.87   2.35   2.89   8.4   8.47   8    8    10   7   10   7   6.6   5.2   9   5.03   1.53

7    7.75   8.57   10     10     9.3   8.02   10   10   10   9   10   8   5.8   4.3   6   3.54   3.44
                                                                     M13.2 | Association Competence (business)
M13 | Parties and Interest Associations




                                                                                                                 M13.3 | Association Competence (others)
                                          M13.1 | Party Competence




8.7                                            9                              9                                           8

7.7                                            7                              8                                           8

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

7.7                                            7                              8                                           8

5.7                                            7                              4                                           6

6.7                                            7                              7                                           6

8.3                                            9                              8                                           8

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

5.3                                            6                              4                                           6

7.7                                            7                              8                                           8

3.3                                            3                              4                                           3

5.0                                            4                              5                                           6

7.7                                            6                              8                                           9

7.3                                            7                              8                                           7

6.0                                            6                              6                                           6

6.0                                            7                              7                                           4

8.3                                            8                              8                                           9

6.0                                            6                              7                                           5

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

8.0                                            9                              7                                           8

9.0                                            9                              9                                           9

5.7                                            5                              6                                           6

5.7                                            6                              5                                           6

6.3                                            5                              6                                           8

4.7                                            2                              6                                           6

7.0                                            8                              7                                           6

9.0                                            9                              9                                           9

7.3                                            8                              8                                           6
5.3   4   7   5

8.0   9   8   7

7.3   7   7   8
                                                                                                                                                              S1.3 | Voting and Registration Rights
                                                                                                          S1.1 | Candidacy Procedures




                                                                                                                                                                                                                               S2 | Access to Information
                                                      I | Quality of Democracy




                                                                                 S1 | Electoral Process




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S2.2 | Media Pluralism
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S2.1 | Media Freedom
                                                                                                                                                                                                      S1.4 | Party Financing
                                                                                                                                        S1.2 | Media Access
All scores and the aggregation
displayed in this sheet refer to the

                                       Status Index
interpolated data for SGI 2009 which
are calculated on the basis of the
revised SGI 2011 methodology. See
also: FAQ on www.sgi-network.org

Norway                                 8.68           9.60                       9.8                      10                            10                    10                                           9                   9.7                          10                          9

Sweden                                 8.52           9.20                       9.3                      10                            10                    10                                           7                   9.3                          10                          8

New Zealand                            8.51           9.23                       9.5                      10                                9                 10                                           9                   8.3                              9                       7

Finland                                8.48           9.31                       9.0                      10                            10                    10                                           6                   9.7                          10                          9

Denmark                                8.35           8.89                       9.8                      10                            10                    10                                           9                   8.7                              8                       9

Canada                                 8.10           8.73                       9.3                      10                                9                 10                                           8                   8.0                              9                       7

Netherlands                            8.02           8.76                       8.0                      10                            10                    10                                           2                   9.3                          10                          8

Switzerland                            7.92           8.47                       7.5                      10                                9                 10                                           1                   9.3                          10                          9

Ireland                                7.81           8.59                       8.8                      10                                9                          8                                   8                   8.3                              9                       8

Iceland                                7.79           8.16                       8.8                      10                                9                 10                                           6                   6.3                              7                       5

Germany                                7.76           8.86                       9.5                      10                            10                    10                                           8                   8.7                              9                       9

Luxembourg                             7.62           8.02                       7.8                      10                                5                          8                                   8                   7.7                              9                       6

Australia                              7.57           8.16                       9.3                      10                                9                          9                                   9                   7.3                              8                       7

Austria                                7.44           7.84                       8.3                      10                                8                 10                                           5                   7.0                              8                       5

United Kingdom                         7.43           7.99                       8.3                      10                                8                          9                                   6                   7.7                              9                       7

Belgium                                7.42           8.22                       8.8                            9                           7                          9                              10                       8.0                              9                       7

United States                          7.37           8.17                       8.0                            9                           7                          8                                   8                   9.3                          10                          9

France                                 6.82           7.50                       8.8                      10                                8                 10                                           7                   6.7                              7                       6

Czech Republic                         6.75           7.29                       8.8                      10                                8                 10                                           7                   8.0                              9                       7

Portugal                               6.66           7.68                       8.3                            9                           8                          9                                   7                   8.7                              9                       9

Japan                                  6.63           6.90                       7.8                            9                           7                          9                                   6                   7.0                              7                       7

Spain                                  6.46           7.09                       7.8                            9                           7                 10                                           5                   6.7                              8                       7

Slovakia                               6.29           6.88                       8.5                      10                                9                          9                                   6                   7.3                              7                       7

South Korea                            6.17           6.19                       7.5                            9                           7                 10                                           4                   6.3                              7                       5

Hungary                                6.11           6.81                       7.3                      10                                7                          9                                   3                   6.7                              5                       7

Italy                                  5.86           6.62                       8.3                            9                           6                 10                                           8                   6.3                              6                       5

Poland                                 5.38           6.05                       8.5                      10                                7                          9                                   8                   6.3                              4                       7
Greece   5.33   6.14   7.0   9   7   10   2   5.7   6   5

Mexico   5.29   5.53   7.5   8   6   8    8   6.7   7   5

Turkey   4.22   4.37   5.8   6   5   8    4   5.3   5   5
S2.3 | Access to Government Information




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                A | Economy and Employment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S4.3 | Appointment of Justices


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S4.4 | Corruption Prevention




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       S4.6 | Control of Corruption
                                                                                                                 S3.3 | Non-discrimination




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      II | Policy Performance
                                                                                    S3.2 | Political Liberties




                                                                                                                                                                                         S4.2 | Judicial Review
                                                                                                                                                                S4.1 | Legal Certainty




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S4.5 | Rule of Law
                                                              S3.1 | Civil Rights




                                                                                                                                             S4 | Rule of Law
                                          S3 | Civil Rights




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             S5 | Economy
10                                        9.7                 10                    10                                 9                     9.3                10                       10                              9                               9                        9.79                 8.47                           7.76                      7.7                          7.5
10                                        8.7                     9                       9                            8                     9.6                10                       10                       10                               10                             9.37                 8.88                           7.84                      7.4                          7.0
         9                                9.7                 10                    10                                 9                     9.4                10                       10                              8                         10                             9.30                 9.31                           7.78                      7.7                          6.4
10                                        9.7                 10                    10                                 9                     8.9                10                            9                          3                         10                             9.65                 10                             7.65                      7.3                          7.1
         9                                7.7                     8                       8                            7                     9.5                     9                   10                       10                                     9                        9.61                 9.34                           7.81                      7.8                          7.6
         8                                9.7                 10                    10                                 9                     8.0                     8                        9                          5                               8                        9.16                 7.91                           7.47                      7.7                          7.2
10                                        9.0                     9                       9                            9                     8.7                     9                   10                              7                               9                        8.81                 8.47                           7.29                      7.3                          7.2
         9                                8.3                     9                       9                            7                     8.7                     9                   10                              5                               9                        9.47                 8.81                           7.38                      7.5                          7.4
         8                                9.0                     9                       9                            9                     8.3                     8                   10                              9                               8                        8.56                 7.03                           7.02                      7.4                          6.7
         7                                9.0                     9                       9                            9                     8.6                     9                        9                          2                               9                        10                   9.78                           7.41                      7.3                          6.4
         8                                8.7                     9                       9                            8                     8.6                10                       10                              8                               8                        8.84                 7.59                           6.65                      6.0                          6.5
         8                                8.3                     9                       9                            7                     8.3                     6                   10                              9                               7                        9.12                 8.25                           7.23                      7.2                          7.9
         7                                7.7                     8                       8                            7                     8.4                     9                   10                              6                               8                        9.05                 8.03                           6.97                      7.5                          7.0
         8                                7.7                     8                       8                            7                     8.4                     8                        9                          9                               7                        9.26                 8.03                           7.05                      6.7                          6.4
         7                                7.7                     7                       7                            9                     8.4                     9                   10                              7                               8                        8.74                 7.84                           6.87                      7.2                          7.3
         8                                8.7                     9                       9                            8                     7.5                     8                        8                          9                               7                        7.65                 6.16                           6.63                      6.1                          6.3
         9                                7.7                     7                       7                            9                     7.7                     8                   10                              8                               7                        8.18                 6.03                           6.56                      7.1                          8.0
         7                                7.7                     8                       8                            7                     6.9                     7                        8                          5                               7                        7.62                 6.56                           6.15                      4.9                          5.9
         8                                6.7                     7                       7                            6                     5.8                     8                        8                          8                               5                        5.41                 3.13                           6.20                      5.7                          4.5
         8                                7.3                     7                       7                            8                     6.5                     7                        8                          8                               6                        6.08                 5.31                           5.65                      5.2                          4.8
         7                                6.7                     7                       7                            6                     6.2                     7                        7                          2                               6                        7.62                 6.19                           6.35                      6.3                          7.1
         5                                7.3                     7                       7                            8                     6.6                     8                        8                          7                               6                        6.43                 5.56                           5.82                      6.2                          5.1
         8                                6.7                     7                       7                            6                     5.0                     7                        7                          6                               5                        4.22                 3.28                           5.71                      5.8                          4.6
         7                                5.7                     6                       6                            5                     5.3                     7                        8                          5                               5                        5.38                 3.22                           6.16                      6.2                          5.6
         8                                7.3                     8                       8                            6                     6.0                     8                        9                          7                               5                        5.59                 3.94                           5.41                      4.4                          2.9
         8                                7.0                     7                       7                            7                     4.9                     7                        6                          8                               4                        3.98                 3.03                           5.10                      4.5                          4.8
         8                                5.0                     5                       5                            5                     4.4                     5                        7                          6                               4                        3.77                 2.66                           4.70                      4.1                          2.7
6   6.7   7   7   6   5.2   5   8   8   4   5.38   3.03   4.51   4.1   3.6
8   4.3   4   4   5   3.6   5   7   9   4    1      1     5.05   5.5   3.3
6   3.0   3   3   3   3.4   4   5   4   4   2.82   2.25   4.07   4.2   1.4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S6.5 | Low-skilled Unemployment
                                                                    S5.4 | Product Market Regulation




                                                                                                                                                                                                       S6.3 | Long-term Unemployment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              S6.7 | Intensity of Active LMP
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       S6.4 | Youth Unemployment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             S7.2 | Enterprise Regulation
                                                                                                                                                    S6.1 | Labor Market Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     S6.6 | Employment Rate




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S7.1 | Enterprise Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S7.3 | Unit Labor Costs
                                                                                                       S5.5 | Competitiveness
S5.1 | Economic Policy


                         S5.2 | GDP per capita




                                                                                                                                                                                 S6.2 | Unemployment
                                                                                                                                S6 | Labor Market




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               S7 | Enterprises
                                                 S5.3 | Inflation




7.5                      6.04                    9.38               7.46                               7.07                     9.2                 10                           9.80                  9.57                            9.46                        9.46                              8.07                     4.30                             5.1                     5                     7.39                           1.32

     7                   4.79                    7.83               7.17                               8.28                     7.9                       9                      6.16                  9.30                            3.17                        8.90                              7.81                     4.91                             6.1                     7                     7.13                           4.49

6.4                      3.28                    7.62               8.65                               5.86                     8.5                       9                      8.58                  9.78                            7.94                        9.81                              7.70                     4.19                             6.9                     8                     8.70                           5.46

7.1                      4.34                    8.45               7.97                               7.56                     7.0                       8                      5.35                  8.26                            4.90                        8.30                              6.67                     1.99                             7.1                     8                     7.39                           6.76

7.6                      4.55                    8.34               8.48                               8.96                     9.0                 10                           8.48                  9.30                            9.13                        9.29                              8.12                     3.21                             7.5                     9                     9.22                           3.43

7.2                      4.57                    7.93               8.65                               7.65                     7.9                       9                      6.26                  9.53                            7.34                        8.47                              7.35                     1.93                             6.8                     7                     9.22                           5.22

7.2                      4.63                    8.45               7.72                               8.00                     7.9                       8                      9.09                  8.39                            10                          9.44                              7.61                     2.79                             6.8                     8                     6.74                           5.86

7.4                      4.93                    9.38               6.20                               9.04                     8.0                       8                      8.69                  8.59                            9.57                        8.84                              8.45                     3.42                             6.1                     6                     7.78                           6.35

6.7                      5.25                    7.10               7.76                               6.55                     8.1                       9                      7.67                  8.62                            7.99                        9.25                              6.39                     2.89                             6.5                     7                     7.52                           6.59

6.4                      5.11                    4.83               8.39                               7.09                     9.3                 10                           10                    9.84                            9.51                        9.94                              10                       1.89                             6.2                     7                     10                             3.03

6.5                      3.92                    7.72               6.70                               7.68                     6.0                       7                      3.83                  4.82                            7.07                        6.19                              6.34                     1.78                             6.0                     7                           4                        7.57

7.9                      10                      7.31               7.21                               6.96                     6.3                       6                      8.08                  8.78                            5.17                        9.42                              5.29                     3.27                             6.9                     8                     6.74                           6.19

     7                   4.65                    7.72               8.56                               7.01                     7.7                       8                      7.88                  9.23                            8.32                        9.27                              7.18                     2.71                             7.3                     8                     9.22                           4.24

6.4                      4.56                    7.83               6.03                               7.26                     7.6                       8                      7.88                  8.84                            8.70                        8.77                              6.87                     1.88                             6.3                     7                     5.83                           6.35

7.3                      4.26                    7.72               10                                 7.16                     8.1                       9                      6.97                  8.93                            5.61                        9.25                              7.07                     5.42                             6.3                     8                     5.30                           5.38

6.3                      4.31                    8.24               6.75                               5.89                     5.4                       6                      4.74                  5.79                            3.22                        7.83                              4.81                     1.87                             6.3                     7                     4.78                           5.78

     8                   5.80                    7.10               9.20                               10                       8.1                       9                      7.67                  9.61                            7.72                        8.69                              6.96                     2.02                             7.7                10                         7.52                           5.22

5.9                      3.80                    8.45               6.07                               5.38                     5.0                       5                      3.83                  6.42                            3.28                        8.11                              5.25                     2.62                             4.7                     5                     5.43                           6.11

4.5                      2.47                    7.00               5.10                               3.32                     6.5                       7                      6.97                  6.38                            7.61                        5.67                              5.71                     4.23                             6.3                     7                     3.87                           5.14

4.8                      2.27                    7.62               6.54                               2.71                     5.1                       5                      4.13                  6.30                            4.42                        8.84                              6.08                     1.78                             5.4                     5                     7.13                           6.59

7.1                      3.94                    10                 7.51                               6.96                     7.7                       8                      8.38                  8.77                            9.24                        9.03                              6.72                     1.66                             6.7                     7                     5.96                           10

5.1                      3.26                    7.21               6.37                               3.69                     6.1                       7                      3.93                  7.71                            3.55                        8.54                              5.82                     1.86                             5.5                     5                     1.65                           4.32

4.6                      1.75                    8.14               5.69                               2.77                     4.6                       7                          1                        1                        2.52                               1                          4.53                     3.66                             6.0                     6                     4.91                           7.73

5.6                      2.94                    7.52               5.94                               5.96                     6.2                       5                      9.09                  10                              8.64                        9.91                              5.23                     1.92                             5.7                     6                     4.39                           6.27

2.9                      1.85                    1.83               5.39                               2.46                     5.5                       6                      4.84                  6.86                            3.66                        7.29                              3.78                     3.08                             4.9                     5                     5.43                           2.78

4.8                      3.71                    8.03               5.82                               1.71                     5.6                       6                      6.06                  6.71                            2.41                        8.99                              4.09                     2.47                             4.4                     4                     3.74                           5.62

2.7                      1.40                    7.52                      1                                1                   4.2                       5                      2.62                  3.58                            1.65                        6.92                              3.72                     2.47                             4.3                     5                     1.39                           4.49
3.6   3.13   7.00   2.56   1.63   4.1   4   3.93   5.44    1     8.92   4.68    1     4.5   4    1     4.41

3.3    1     5.97   4.97   1.15   6.9   5   8.58   9.95   9.78   10     4.61   10     4.8   5   2.96   4.49

1.4   1.09    1     2.52   1.12   4.6   5   3.43   7.14   2.57   8.69    1     1.89   4.4   5   6.61    1
                                                                                                                                                                                                  S8.4 | Marginal Tax Burden (businesses)
                                                                                                                                                       S8.3 | Marginal Tax Burden (individuals)
                              S7.5 | Energy Costs for Enterprises




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S8.5 | Tax System Complexity
S7.4 | Corporate Investment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S9.5 | Budget Consolidation


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    S9.6 | Soundness of Banks
                                                                    S7.6 | Real Interest Rates




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S9.4 | Debt Interest Ratio
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S9.1 | Budgetary Policy
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S8.6 | Total Tax Rate




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S9.3 | Net Debt Ratio
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S9.2 | Debt-to-GDP
                                                                                                                                  S8.2 | Tax Evasion
                                                                                                              S8.1 | Tax Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S9 | Budgets
                                                                                                 S8 | Taxes




2.23                          10                                    5.30                         7.3              9               9.38                 3.98                                       3.80                                      9.96                                1                  9.3            10                        7.27                 10                      10                                 7                       8.65

      1                       6.31                                  7.23                         7.4              9               9.38                 3.09                                       4.56                                      10                             2.23                    8.4            10                        7.92                 4.47                    5.74                               6                       9.55

4.82                          4.06                                  5.50                         8.0              9               10                   4.96                                       4.78                                      9.43                           6.05                    8.5                 9                    9.17                 4.66                    7.75                         10                            8.65

2.64                          7.48                                  6.53                         7.2              9               9.38                 3.61                                       4.78                                      5.67                           3.18                    8.4                 9                    8.26                 5.13                    7.28                         10                            8.65

4.81                          6.04                                  6.66                         6.4              7               10                   3.21                                       5.11                                      8.71                           2.09                    8.4                 9                    8.69                 4.97                    6.09                         10                            9.55

3.51                          8.39                                  7.06                         7.7              9               8.45                 4.79                                       2.78                                      8.84                           7.20                    8.6            10                        6.90                 3.73                    5.86                         10                            9.55

2.88                          6.04                                  6.54                         7.6              9               8.76                 3.36                                       5.56                                      8.32                           5.50                    7.1                 8                    7.65                 3.18                    4.67                               6                       9.10

5.08                          4.36                                  6.98                         8.3              9               8.45                 7.21                                       5.80                                      6.77                           9.52                    7.9                 9                    7.97                 3.73                    5.86                               6                       10

7.40                          1.25                                  7.67                         7.8              8               8.76                 5.02                                       6.31                                      9.21                           8.57                    8.1            10                        9.02                 3.14                    5.50                               4                       9.55

3.43                          5.85                                  4.81                         7.2              8               10                   5.18                                       6.91                                      4.93                           4.82                    7.3                 7                    7.58                 5.21                    7.63                         10                            7.30

2.86                          3.61                                  7.24                         5.9              6               9.07                 3.17                                       3.18                                      7.16                           6.15                    5.3                 6                    6.88                 3.18                    3.72                               1                       8.65

2.43                          6.58                                  7.41                         7.8              9               8.14                 5.46                                                5                                7.16                           7.51                    7.2                 8                    10                   4.51                    7.75                               1                       9.10

7.87                          6.00                                  5.69                         7.4              8               9.07                 4.37                                       2.73                                      8.44                           9.15                    8.4                 9                    9.83                 3.77                    5.86                         10                            9.10

5.77                          2.86                                  7.10                         6.7              8               9.07                 3.29                                       3.38                                      6.19                           4.65                    6.8                 8                    7.06                 2.91                    4.20                               6                       7.75

2.15                          3.54                                  6.57                         7.3              8               9.38                 4.70                                       2.87                                      9.13                           6.97                    7.0                 9                    7.92                 2.05                    4.32                               1                       9.55

4.19                          6.78                                  6.72                         5.6              5               7.52                          1                                 10                                        8.10                           4.65                    7.0                 8                    5.56                 3.03                    2.18                         10                            9.55

2.59                          4.63                                  7.41                         6.5              7               5.97                 5.97                                       1.24                                      6.90                           9.49                    5.2                 6                    7.08                 2.01                    4.32                               1                       7.30

3.00                          1.40                                  6.55                         4.6              4               7.83                 6.72                                       1.27                                      6.35                           4.17                    4.3                 4                    6.62                 2.05                    3.61                               2                       8.65

6.59                          4.24                                  7.79                         5.8              6               6.59                 6.11                                       5.98                                      2.39                           6.83                    5.3                 6                    8.72                 2.83                    5.74                               2                       4.15

5.40                          2.64                                  7.19                         5.7              5               7.52                 5.74                                       5.02                                      7.21                           6.35                    5.0                 6                    6.55                 2.05                    3.13                               1                       7.75

5.11                          3.68                                  7.52                         6.5              6               9.38                 8.01                                       1.47                                      6.18                           9.66                    3.7                 5                        1                2.17                    5.86                               1                       1.90

10                            6.42                                  7.67                         6.9              7               8.45                 7.15                                       3.38                                      7.47                           7.07                    7.6                 8                    8.21                 3.84                    5.26                         10                            8.20

8.51                          2.02                                  6.64                         7.9              9               7.21                 6.75                                       6.44                                      3.32                           10                      6.1                 7                    8.80                 2.36                    5.38                               2                       7.30

9.23                          1.07                                  6.46                         6.6              7               4.10                 9.17                                                1                                6.51                           9.73                    6.9                 8                    8.90                 4.94                    8.34                               3                       3.70

4.62                                  1                             10                           5.3              5               7.21                 2.55                                       6.24                                      6.09                           5.91                    3.5                 4                    6.51                 1.19                    2.18                               1                       3.70

4.49                          3.68                                  6.78                         4.5              4               6.28                 4.49                                                3                                5.75                           5.26                    3.2                 4                    4.16                 2.52                          1                            1                       3.70

2.03                          5.27                                  5.20                         4.9              5               3.17                 6.59                                       6.13                                            1                        7.34                    4.2                 5                    7.67                 2.36                    4.55                               1                             1
6.49   5.38   7.63   4.0   3    1     4.29   6.60   5.56   7.55   4.5   6   4.63    1     1.59   2    5.95

4.32   5.92   5.79   5.7   5   5.03   10     5.82   2.63   8.36   6.7   7   9.55   3.03   5.03   10   4.60

3.83   6.31    1     4.3   2   5.66   5.99   7.20   6.93   7.38   6.2   7   8.38   2.64   4.91   10   1.45
                                                                                                                                               S10.4 | Spending on Preventive and Health Programs




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S11.4 | Youth not in education and unemployed
                                                                                                                                                                                                    S10.5 | Life Expectancy-to-HC Spending




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S11.7 | Social and Political Participation
                                                                 S10.2 | Private-to-Public HC Spending


                                                                                                         S10.3 | Spending on Pharmaceuticals




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S11.1 | Social Inclusion Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S11.6 | Gender Equality
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     S11.3 | Life Satisfaction
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        S11 | Social Inclusion




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S11.5 | Gini Coefficient
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             S10.6 | Infant Mortality
                                         S10.1 | Health Policy
                     S10 | Health Care
B | Social Affairs




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S11.2 | Poverty
8.3                  7.7                      8                  9.77                                    9.88                                  2.97                                                 4.75                                     9.22                       9.3                      10                                8.97              8.15                        9.22                                            8.13                       9.20                      8.53

8.0                  8.3                      9                  8.50                                    7.95                                  5.08                                                 6.73                                     9.40                       9.0                             9                          10                8.29                        6.57                                            10                         10                        8.85

8.2                  8.4                      8                  9.71                                    9.00                                  8.88                                                 7.66                                     8.41                       7.6                             8                          6.22              8.46                        9.48                                            5.88                       8.07                      4.93

7.4                  8.1                      8                  8.96                                    7.72                                  7.61                                                 7.22                                     9.40                       8.7                             9                          8.63              9.09                        7.54                                            8.50                       8.07                      8.50

7.9                  8.4                      9                  9.88                                    9.96                                  3.53                                                 6.21                                     8.97                       9.1                             9                          10                9.30                        9.61                                            10                         8.39                      7.89

7.6                  8.1                      8                  10                                      6.56                                  10                                                   5.89                                     8.45                       7.0                             7                          5.40              8.49                        8.12                                            6.63                       6.95                      5.84

7.4                  7.9                      8                  9.21                                    8.73                                  6.77                                                 5.96                                     8.71                       8.5                             9                          8.35              10                          9.68                                            8.50                       7.11                      4.18

6.8                  8.1                      9                  9.39                                    9.23                                  3.25                                                 5.34                                     8.71                       7.8                             8                          7.66              9.19                        8.77                                            8.13                       7.11                      4.22

6.9                  7.1                      7                  9.29                                    6.52                                  4.09                                                 6.69                                     9.01                       6.5                             7                          3.47              9.28                        8.83                                            6.25                       5.82                      2.35

7.7                  8.1                      9                  9.78                                    7.76                                  2.27                                                 6.63                                     10                         8.0                             7                          8.76              9.55                        9.88                                            8.13                       8.23                      10

6.4                  7.2                      7                  9.19                                    7.53                                  4.94                                                 6.16                                     8.97                       6.6                             7                          7.11              8.11                        5.34                                            7.38                       6.30                      2.74

7.5                  8.1                      9                  9.91                                    10                                    1.70                                                 5.09                                     9.53                       8.0                             9                          8.08              8.70                        8.12                                            8.88                       5.34                      2.82

7.1                  7.5                      8                  9.78                                    7.72                                  2.55                                                 6.66                                     8.58                       7.0                             7                          5.12              7.87                        9.29                                            7.38                       8.23                      4.26

6.9                  8.1                      9                  9.54                                    8.18                                  2.97                                                 5.95                                     9.05                       7.6                             8                          9.11              8.82                        9.09                                            8.50                       2.93                      4.41

7.0                  7.1                      7                  9.03                                    8.49                                  2.83                                                 6.97                                     8.45                       6.5                             6                          7.94              7.19                        8.45                                            5.88                       7.75                      4.34

7.0                  8.2                      9                  9.50                                    6.79                                  5.36                                                 6.57                                     8.88                       7.1                             8                          7.60              8.10                        4.82                                            8.50                       4.86                      3.60

6.3                  6.2                      6                  9.76                                    8.53                                  5.22                                                          1                               7.72                       5.7                             5                          1.89              8.13                        8.90                                            4.38                       6.79                      8.42

6.6                  7.5                      8                  9.72                                    6.87                                  2.97                                                 6.28                                     8.97                       6.1                             6                          8.76              5.92                        5.21                                            8.13                       6.46                      2.71

6.6                  6.8                      7                  8.00                                    4.44                                  2.55                                                 8.84                                     9.18                       7.3                             8                          9.66              6.07                        6.31                                            8.50                       6.14                      2.36

5.6                  6.5                      6                  9.96                                    4.82                                  2.83                                                 7.99                                     9.18                       4.2                             4                          4.78              5.34                        6.31                                            2.88                       6.30                                1

5.8                  7.0                      7                  9.79                                    5.67                                  2.83                                                 7.54                                     9.48                       6.0                             7                          3.40              3.74                        9.45                                            6.63                       3.89                      2.67

5.6                  7.0                      7                  9.67                                    4.90                                  3.53                                                 7.63                                     8.97                       5.0                             5                          3.95              5.83                        6.24                                            6.63                       5.02                      2.14

5.8                  5.3                      6                           1                              1.77                                  3.53                                                 9.07                                     7.76                       6.0                             7                          8.08              2.65                                  1                                     8.50                       5.98                      3.34

5.6                  7.4                      8                  9.74                                    3.43                                  2.69                                                 8.93                                     8.84                       5.5                             6                          3.61              2.75                        8.96                                                 7                     4.86                      2.74

5.6                  5.9                      5                  9.17                                            1                             6.34                                                 8.84                                     8.15                       5.3                             5                          8.76                    1                     7.41                                            7.75                       7.27                      1.71

5.2                  6.7                      7                  8.96                                    5.60                                              1                                        7.38                                     9.01                       5.1                             5                          5.81              6.57                        5.14                                            5.50                       4.38                      3.60

4.6                  5.3                      4                  8.96                                    2.74                                  3.53                                                 9.71                                     8.02                       4.5                             5                          3.61              3.30                        2.81                                            4.75                       6.14                      3.14
4.3   5.2   4   7.00   4.48   4.09   7.46   9.01   3.9   3   4.98   5.06   4.43   6.63   5.02   2.61

5.2   5.6   5   9.44   3.09   4.94   9.92   3.63   4.4   4    1     8.27   10      1     3.25   4.73

4.1   4.6   4   8.21   2.97   3.53   10      1     2.6   3   1.62   1.26   5.86   2.50    1     1.44
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               S14.2 | Foreign-born secondary attainment


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S14.3 | Foreign-born Tertiary Attainment


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S14.4 | Foreign-born Unemployment
                                                                                                                       S12.5 | Spending on Family Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S13.5 | Public Pension Coverage
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S13.3 | Senior Citizen Poverty
                                         S12.2 | Child Care Density




                                                                                                                                                                                                     S13.2 | Older Employment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S13.4 | Dependency Ratio




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S14.1 | Integration Policy
                                                                                                                                                                            S13.1 | Pension Policy
                                                                      S12.3 | Child Poverty
                 S12.1 | Family Policy




                                                                                              S12.4 | Fertility Rate




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              S14 | Integration
                                                                                                                                                           S13 | Pensions
S12 | Families




9.1              10                      8.99                         9.22                    7.69                     7.19                                8.1                   9                   7.52                       8.43                             3.84                       8.82                              7.3                       8                      8.94                                        6.80                                       7.29

8.9              10                      8.44                         9.47                    7.26                     6.15                                7.5                   9                   7.70                       9.07                             2.01                       5.03                              6.2                       7                      7.56                                        4.93                                       7.61

8.3                   9                  9.41                         4.95                    8.63                     7.75                                8.7                   9                   7.96                       10                               5.74                       10                                8.2                       9                      8.72                                        6.95                                       7.19

7.9                   9                  4.43                         9.38                    7.17                     6.49                                7.8                   9                   5.34                       7.69                             3.39                       10                                4.6                       7                      2.64                                        3.30                                               1

8.7                   9                        9                      10                      7.26                     7.22                                7.3                   9                   5.90                       8.25                             3.88                       3.99                              5.9                       7                      5.61                                        4.81                                       7.47

6.7                   8                  7.71                         4.90                    5.03                     3.99                                8.3                   9                   5.67                       9.40                             5.46                       10                                8.2                       9                      3.58                                        9.06                                       7.71

7.3                   9                  5.48                         6.38                    6.14                     4.76                                7.3                   9                   4.30                       9.88                             4.73                       3.37                              5.9                       7                      3.50                                        3.39                                       8.00

4.5                   4                  4.43                         7.25                    3.74                     4.24                                7.0                   8                   7.24                       6.68                             3.59                       6.62                              6.6                       7                      4.36                                        4.74                                       7.68

6.7                   7                  4.47                         4.41                    7.69                     8.82                                7.2                   8                   5.22                       3.99                             6.47                       10                                7.1                       7                      2.86                                        10                                         6.38

9.4              10                      9.46                         7.70                    9.14                     9.23                                6.8                   7                   10                         9.28                             5.78                       1.31                              6.2                       6                      4.78                                        4.44                                       8.80

6.3                   7                  8.86                         6.67                    2.80                     4.42                                6.7                   7                   4.77                       8.80                             1.77                       10                                5.4                       6                      5.64                                        2.09                                       4.34

6.6                   6                  8.44                         6.01                    5.46                     8.94                                7.3                   8                   1.76                       9.67                             4.65                       10                                7.3                       8                      6.28                                        4.14                                       8.98

7.1                   7                  5.68                         6.26                    7.00                     10                                  6.5                   8                   5.59                       4.76                             5.30                       4.19                              7.5                       9                      3.83                                        5.38                                       7.43

6.2                   6                  7.29                         8.56                    3.49                     6.19                                7.1                   8                   2.79                       8.76                             3.59                       10                                5.7                       6                      5.64                                                 1                                 6.41

7.4                   7                  8.98                         6.96                    7.17                     8.39                                6.9                   7                   5.72                       8.18                             2.95                       10                                6.9                       8                      1.53                                        8.10                                       7.43

8.2                   9                  9.98                              7                  6.83                     5.90                                6.3                   7                   2.14                       7.67                             2.22                       10                                5.0                       7                      1.33                                        4.53                                       3.11

5.6                   6                  5.52                         2.64                    9.40                     2.99                                6.4                   6                   6.40                       5.44                             5.50                       10                                7.6                       9                      4.36                                        5.47                                       7.96

8.5                   9                  10                           7.99                    8.37                     6.02                                6.0                   6                   2.74                       8.49                             2.58                       10                                5.1                       6                      2.28                                        3.05                                       3.50

6.4                   7                  8.06                         6.88                    2.80                     5.25                                7.1                   7                   3.94                       9.83                             5.09                       10                                5.3                       5                      8.25                                        1.45                                       5.46

4.9                   5                  7.71                         4.29                    3.06                     4.11                                5.5                   5                   4.71                       6.88                             2.78                       10                                7.1                       9                      1.92                                        3.42                                       7.68

5.0                   5                  8.68                         5.48                    2.71                     2.94                                5.5                   5                   7.07                       5.77                                  1                     10                                5.6                       4                      7.00                                        6.65                                       8.35

5.1                   5                  9.75                              4                  3.23                     3.43                                5.5                   5                   3.72                       6.88                             3.11                       10                                5.7                       7                               1                                  3.96                                       4.48

5.2                   5                  7.10                         6.63                    2.03                     6.16                                7.3                   9                   2.34                       9.09                             6.43                       4.15                              5.2                       4                      10                                          2.33                                       3.32

4.2                   5                  2.89                         6.92                         1                   2.45                                5.7                   5                   6.22                              1                         8.50                       10                                5.1                       4                      4.78                                        4.44                                       8.21

5.9                   5                  8.59                         7.53                    2.97                     8.19                                5.2                   5                   1.93                       9.34                             3.80                       6.34                              5.8                       5                      5.58                                        3.57                                       7.93

4.6                   4                  9.94                         4.74                    2.97                     3.52                                4.6                   4                   2.04                       7.67                             1.16                       10                                4.9                       5                      4.03                                        1.27                                       5.75

3.5                   4                  3.66                         2.27                    2.29                     3.41                                6.1                   7                   1.40                       9.32                             5.38                       4.54                              3.8                       4                      5.92                                        1.18                                       5.43
3.7   3   4.31   5.68   3.49   3.73   3.6   2   3.38   5.62   2.14   9.99   5.2   5   6.22   2.39   6.59

5.3   4   6.78   1.99   10     7.95   4.6   4   5.30   4.53   10      1     6.3   5   2.00   8.10   10

3.6   4    1      1     10      1     5.5   4    1     7.19   9.76   10     4.1   4   3.39   2.18   5.46
S14.5 | Foreign-born-to-Native Employment




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          S16.4 | Reliability of Police Services
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       S16.3 | Burglaries and Robberies
                                                                                                                                                   S15.4 | Relations with Neighbors
                                                                                     S15.1 | External Security Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                S16.1 | Internal Security Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S17.1 | Environmental Policy
                                                           S15 | External Security




                                                                                                                                                                                      S16 | Internal Security
                                                                                                                        S15.2 | Conflicts fought




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S16.5 | Costs of Crime




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            S17 | Environment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S16.2 | Homicides




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            D | Resources
                                            C | Security




3.61                                        9.2            9.5                              9                           10                         10                                 8.9                              9                           9.83                8.08                               8.90                                     8.20                     6.0             7.2                       8

1.87                                        8.9            9.5                              9                           10                         10                                 8.3                              9                           9.65                5.46                               7.80                                     7.48                     7.7             7.7                       8

6.52                                        8.9            10.0                      10                                 10                         10                                 7.7                              8                           9.13                5.13                               8.02                                     7.48                     6.5             6.4                       7

1.87                                        8.8            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 8.6                              8                           8.51                8.68                               10                                       10                       7.7             6.6                       7

         1                                  8.5            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 8.0                              8                           9.30                5.07                               9.78                                     7.84                     7.3             7.3                       8

9.13                                        8.3            9.1                              9                           8.20                       10                                 7.6                              8                           8.86                6.97                               8.68                                     4.60                     6.3             4.6                       5

4.48                                        8.4            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 7.7                              8                           9.39                8.13                               8.24                                     3.88                     6.3             5.7                       6

8.26                                        9.1            9.5                              9                           10                         10                                 8.8                              9                           9.56                7.09                               9.56                                     7.84                     7.0             6.9                       7

9.71                                        8.4            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 7.8                              8                           9.04                7.77                               7.59                                     5.68                     5.6             5.4                       5

7.68                                        8.7            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 8.4                              8                           9.56                7.43                               9.34                                     8.92                     6.3             5.0                       4

7.39                                        9.0            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 8.9                              9                           9.65                8.20                               9.78                                     7.84                     6.6             6.8                       8

7.10                                        9.0            9.5                              9                           10                         10                                 8.5                              9                           8.78                7.78                               8.02                                     7.48                     5.6             5.8                       6

7.68                                        7.6            7.7                              8                           4.60                       10                                 7.6                              8                           9.30                5.09                               8.46                                     5.68                     5.3             4.3                       5

8.84                                        8.8            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 8.6                              9                           9.83                5.45                               8.90                                     8.56                     6.6             7.3                       8

6.52                                        6.8            6.8                              8                                1                     10                                 6.9                              8                           9.21                5.31                               7.15                                     1.72                     6.2             6.6                       7

2.74                                        7.9            9.5                              9                           10                         10                                 6.3                              7                           8.60                       1                           7.15                                     5.68                     6.1             6.4                       7

6.81                                        6.6            7.4                              8                           8.20                       5.50                               5.7                              6                           5.63                7.18                               7.80                                          1                   6.1             4.4                       6

7.97                                        8.1            9.1                              9                           8.20                       10                                 7.2                              7                           9.04                7.46                               8.02                                     4.96                     6.1             6.7                       7

7.10                                        7.9            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 6.9                              7                           8.86                7.94                               3.63                                     6.40                     5.3             6.3                       7

7.68                                        8.5            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 8.0                              8                           9.30                7.96                               7.15                                     7.48                     4.5             5.7                       5

6.52                                        7.3            6.3                              7                           10                                1                           8.4                              9                           10                  9.39                               7.80                                     4.24                     6.6             6.6                       7

8.26                                        7.3            8.1                              7                           8.20                       10                                 6.5                              7                           9.65                3.10                               7.59                                     3.52                     4.5             4.6                       4

9.71                                        7.5            7.9                              8                           10                         5.50                               7.1                              7                           8.69                8.62                               4.29                                     7.12                     4.2             5.0                       4

7.68                                        7.3            6.8                              8                           10                                1                           7.9                              8                           8.51                10                                 7.37                                     4.96                     6.3             5.2                       5

9.42                                        8.2            9.0                              8                           10                         10                                 7.3                              7                           9.04                8.53                               5.83                                     7.12                     4.9             6.0                       6

8.55                                        7.5            8.6                              8                           8.20                       10                                 6.5                              6                           9.48                9.03                               5.83                                     3.52                     4.3             5.1                       4

1.58                                        6.9            7.4                              8                           8.20                       5.50                               6.4                              7                           9.13                7.72                               4.07                                     2.44                     4.4             5.9                       6
6.52   7.9   7.9   8   10     5.50   7.9   8   9.48   9.06   5.61   7.12   3.2   4.6   3

10     5.4   7.4   7   10     5.50   3.5   4    1     8.40    1     1.36   3.7   5.7   5

5.94   5.0   4.9   7   4.60    1     5.1   4   6.68   9.47   5.39   3.52   3.2   4.8   3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S18.4 | Science and Technology Degrees
                                                                                                                                                         S18.1 | Research and Innovation Policy




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  S18.6 | Computer and Internet Access




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      S19.2 | Upper Secondary Attainment
                                                                                                                         S18 | Research and Innovation




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S18.3 | Industry R&D personnel
                                                                                                                                                                                                  S18.2 | Public R&D Spending




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S19.4 | Continuing Education
                                                                                              S17.6 | Waste Management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S19.3 | Tertiary Attainment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S19.1 | Education Policy
S17.2 | Energy Intensity


                           S17.3 | CO2 Emissions




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          S18.5 | Triad Patents
                                                                        S17.5 | Water Usage
                                                   S17.4 | Energy Mix




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S19 | Education
8.20                       9.61                    5.53                 6.48                  2.08                       4.9                                      5                               5.60                          5.60                             1.85                                     2.84                    8.58                                   5.9                    6                     8.33                                 6.69                          4.54

7.90                       10                      4.32                 8.99                  6.22                       8.2                                      9                               7.65                          10                               3.61                                     7.38                    8.52                                   7.2                    7                     9.17                                 5.92                          10

7.90                       6.48                    4.55                 2.79                  7.48                       5.4                                      7                               3.93                          2.91                             5.35                                     2.10                    4.94                                   7.7                    9                     8.53                                 8.34                          4.54

6.10                       6.67                    3.57                 8.16                  6.58                       7.7                                      8                               7.75                          9.86                             5.46                                     5.62                    8.55                                   8.9               10                         8.54                                 7.16                          8.95

9.40                       8.04                    2.75                 10                    2.62                       7.2                                      8                               5.70                          7.99                             3.46                                     4.64                    10                                     7.5                    7                     8.83                                 6.88                          9.68

5.20                       2.96                    2.69                 2.73                  7.84                       6.0                                      7                               5.40                          5.88                             3.19                                     2.69                    7.54                                   8.2                    9                     9.38                                 10                            6.17

8.50                       6.28                    1.29                 7.54                  3.88                       6.3                                      7                               6.48                          4.64                             1.69                                     6.09                    9.60                                   6.9                    8                     7.62                                 6.04                          2.46

9.70                       10                      2.95                 8.71                  2.80                       7.4                                      8                               5.50                          5.64                             3.81                                     9.72                    8.99                                   6.7                    7                     9.09                                 5.72                          7.22

10                         7.65                    1.19                 8.83                       1                     5.6                                      7                               2.96                          3.87                             7.31                                     2.28                    4.81                                   5.8                    7                     6.67                                 5.80                          2.76

     1                     9.41                    10                   7.65                  1.54                       7.0                                      8                               10                            6.84                             2.59                                     1.52                    8.97                                   6.8                    8                     6.45                                 6.14                          4.54

8.50                       6.48                    1.56                 8.27                  3.16                       6.8                                      8                               5.99                          5.69                             2.65                                     6.66                    6.55                                   6.3                    7                     9.11                                 4.68                          2.95

8.50                       5.11                    1.07                 9.89                  2.98                       6.6                                      8                               1.59                          7.75                             3.65                                     5.02                    7.59                                   4.5                    3                     6.84                                 5.15                          2.98

7.30                       1.78                    1.47                 5.47                  2.26                       5.9                                      7                               6.09                          3.30                             6.03                                     2.46                    6.30                                   5.7                    6                     6.73                                 6.44                          4.54

9.10                       7.85                    3.64                 8.04                  4.60                       6.0                                      7                               7.75                          5.64                             2.20                                     4.22                    5.28                                   6.3                    7                     8.77                                 3.00                          4.68

9.40                       7.65                    1.09                 9.27                  3.70                       5.9                                      7                               4.62                          3.63                             5.31                                     3.14                    7.14                                   6.1                    6                     6.95                                 5.92                          6.80

7.60                       6.28                    1.25                 7.04                  6.76                       5.3                                      6                               3.45                          5.84                             2.63                                     3.79                    7.13                                   6.6                    7                     6.87                                 6.27                          4.07

     7                     3.35                    1.43                     1                 1.36                       7.3                                      9                               6.67                          7.13                             2.91                                     5.07                    6.47                                   6.7                    6                     9.72                                 8.24                          9.27

8.20                       9.22                    1.63                 7.54                  4.96                       6.1                                      6                               6.97                          5.88                             7.03                                     4.16                    6.80                                   5.5                    5                     6.90                                 4.88                          4.68

6.10                            1                  1.39                 9.55                  9.64                       3.5                                      4                               4.72                          3.20                             1.84                                     1.12                    3.94                                   6.2                    7                     10                                   1.84                          2.80

9.10                       7.46                    2.90                 5.86                  6.58                       3.8                                      5                               3.45                          1.34                             2.86                                     1.04                    3.86                                   4.0                    5                     1.67                                 1.77                          1.95

8.50                       6.87                    1.26                 6.87                  7.30                       6.6                                      7                               4.52                          7.22                             3.44                                     10                      6.20                                   6.7                    7                     9.22                                 8.47                          4.54

8.80                       7.07                    1.62                 5.64                  2.98                       4.1                                      5                               3.74                          2.91                             2.84                                     1.36                    4.89                                   4.8                    5                     4.60                                 5.57                          1.68

6.10                       3.54                    1.40                 9.55                  9.28                       3.0                                      4                               1.88                          1.67                             3.24                                     1.04                    1.96                                   4.6                    4                     9.44                                 1.99                          4.78

6.70                       4.52                        1                7.60                  7.66                       7.3                                      8                               5.30                          4.35                             10                                       4.72                    8.48                                   6.3                    7                     8.11                                 6.41                          4.54

7.90                       6.48                    1.41                 7.60                  6.40                       3.6                                      5                               3.64                          1.81                                      1                               1.30                    3.73                                   5.2                    5                     8.22                                 2.83                          1.15

9.40                       7.85                    1.70                 6.59                  5.32                       3.6                                      4                               4.42                          2.48                             2.91                                     1.98                    4.69                                   4.3                    5                     4.77                                 1.62                          1.15

7.30                       1.59                    1.51                 8.99                  10                         3.1                                      4                               2.27                          1.24                             3.85                                     1.02                    2.24                                   4.3                    4                     4.95                                 2.78                          2.34
9.40   7.07   1.54   6.03   6.94   2.0   2   1.78   2.20   2.77   1.05   2.55   3.0   2   5.70   3.87    1

8.50   5.89   1.96   6.59   8.92   2.1   3    1     1.24   1.78    1      1     3.4   4    1     2.29   4.54

9.40   6.09   2.16   7.43   8.20   2.7   4   1.98    1     2.00   1.01   1.47   2.0   2   1.78    1     4.54
                                                                                                                                                                                     M1.2 | Medium-term Fiscal Framework




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     M2 | Inter-ministerial Coordination




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M2.6 | Line Ministry Civil Servants
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              M2.5 | Senior Ministry Officials
                       S19.6 | Pre-primary Education




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  M2.4 | Cabinet Committees
                                                                                                                                                         M1.1 | Strategic Planning
                                                                                                    A | Steering Capability:




                                                                                                                               M1 | Strategic Capacity




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M2.2 | GO Gatekeeping
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M1.3 | Scholarly Advice
                                                                           I | Executive Capacity




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M2.3 | Line Ministries
S19.5 | PISA Results




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M2.1 | GO Expertise
                                                       Management Index




5.53                   3.83                            8.27               8.02                                8.3              7.9                       10                          5.80                                       8                    8.1                                       9                      9                       9                         1                     10                                 10

6.47                   5.92                            8.02               8.53                                8.1              7.1                             9                     6.40                                       6                    8.6                                       7                      9                       9                         9                            9                                   9

8.06                   3.02                            7.96               7.64                                6.8              8.7                       10                          8.20                                       8                    7.1                                       8                      8                       7                         1                     10                                         8

10                     4.32                            7.83               8.20                                8.5              6.2                             8                     4.60                                       6                    8.9                                       9                      7                       9                   10                          10                                         8

6.06                   8.54                            7.80               8.32                                8.1              7.4                             7                     8.20                                       7                    8.4                                       7                      8                       9                         9                            8                                   9

8.29                   2.85                            7.62               7.25                                6.4              5.2                             3                     7.60                                       5                    8.0                                       8                 10                           8                         5                            9                                   9

7.76                   5.06                            7.42               7.47                                7.1              5.2                             6                     4.60                                       5                    7.9                                       9                      9                       7                         7                            8                                   7

    7                  2.90                            7.42               7.89                                8.0              8.4                             9                     8.20                                       8                    8.3                                       9                 10                           9                         7                            9                                   7

6.76                          1                        7.15               7.50                                8.6              6.5                             8                     4.60                                       7                    7.6                                   10                    10                           9                         3                            8                                   3

5.76                   5.55                            7.08               6.87                                6.9              6.7                             5                     8.20                                       7                    8.6                                       8                 10                           8                         9                     10                                         5

7.24                   4.43                            7.08               7.59                                8.2              8.4                             8                     8.20                                       9                    8.4                                       7                      9                       9                         9                     10                                         9

5.47                   10                              7.03               7.25                                7.7              6.2                             8                     4.60                                       6                    8.0                                       7                      9                  10                             4                            9                                   9

7.88                   1.60                            6.94               6.73                                5.6              6.1                             5                     8.20                                       5                    6.4                                       6                      5                       7                         5                            9                                   6

6.94                   4.88                            6.91               7.61                                8.2              7.7                             8                     8.20                                       7                    8.6                                       6                 10                           8                         9                            9                                   9

7.18                   4.16                            6.74               6.61                                5.5              4.5                             4                     4.60                                       5                    6.7                                       5                      5                       7                         8                            7                                   7

6.88                   6.54                            6.70               7.12                                7.3              4.3                             4                     2.80                                       6                    6.4                                       5                      5                       9                         2                            6                                   9

5.65                   3.87                            6.50               6.01                                5.2              6.3                             7                             7                                  5                    7.9                                       7                 10                      10                             9                            9                                   4

    6                  7.57                            6.46               7.11                                6.8              6.5                             8                     4.60                                       7                    7.4                                       8                      9                       9                         7                            9                                   5

7.06                   4.87                            6.36               6.70                                5.4              7.7                             7                     8.20                                       8                    6.3                                       5                      7                       4                         8                            7                                   5

4.76                   4.79                            6.21               6.57                                5.9              7.7                             9                     8.20                                       6                    8.0                                       8                      9                       9                         9                            9                                   6

8.12                   1.88                            6.11               6.02                                5.5              4.9                             5                     4.60                                       5                    6.3                                       8                      7                       7                         2                            7                                   5

5.59                   5.66                            6.04               6.45                                5.6              4.9                             7                     1.60                                       6                    6.7                                       5                      8                       8                         7                            6                                   5

5.59                   4.59                            5.97               5.86                                5.4              3.9                             5                     1.60                                       5                    7.3                                       6                      9                       7                         8                            9                                   5

7.59                   1.53                            5.77               6.46                                5.8              4.5                             5                     4.60                                       4                    8.4                                       7                      9                       9                         8                            9                                   9

6.53                   8.36                            5.75               5.95                                5.6              7.3                             6                     10                                         6                    7.4                                       6                      9                       8                         5                            8                                   8

4.82                   5.36                            5.71               6.72                                6.5              5.3                             7                     2.80                                       6                    8.3                                       8                      9                  10                             9                            8                                   6

6.18                   6.26                            5.70               5.52                                4.6              5.2                             5                     4.60                                       6                    5.7                                       5                      6                       4                         6                            7                                   5
4.71   4.72   5.67   5.20   4.3   4.2   3   4.60   5   5.3   5   5   5   5   5   5

 1     5.62   4.68   4.28   3.4   3.3   3   2.80   4   4.6   4   5   4   5   3   4

1.82   1.15   4.66   3.99   3.6   2.3   3    1     3   5.4   4   9   9   5   2   2
M2.7 | Informal Coordination Procedures


                                          M3 | Evidence-based Instruments




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M6.2b | Monitoring Line Ministries
                                                                                                                                                                                       M4.1 | Negotiating Public Support




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M5.1 | Coherent Communication




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M6 | Effective Implementation




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   M6.2a | Ministerial Compliance
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M6.1 | Government Efficiency
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M5 | Policy Communication




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M6.2c | Monitoring Agencies
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       B | Policy Implementation:
                                                                                                                                                          M4 | Societal Consultation
                                                                                                                             M3.3 | Alternative Options




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M6.2d | Internal Auditing
                                                                                                     M3.2 | Needs Analysis
                                                                            M3.1 | RIA Application




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   M6.3a | Task Funding
         9                                8.7                                    9                        9                        8                      9.0                                  9                           8.0                                8                                   7.5               7.5                                   8                               9                                 8                                  9                             1                         9

         8                                8.0                                    8                        9                        7                      9.0                                  9                           8.0                                8                                   8.7               8.7                                   9                               9                                 9                                  8                             9                         7

         8                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      9.0                                  9                           8.0                                8                                   7.9               7.9                                   8                        10                                       9                                  9                       5.50                            6

         9                                9.3                                    9                   10                            9                      10.0                         10                                  8.0                                8                                   8.1               8.1                                   9                               9                                 7                                  8                             8                         6

         9                                8.7                                    8                        9                        9                      8.0                                  8                           8.0                                8                                   8.9               8.9                                   9                               9                                 9                                  9                             6                     10

         7                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      9.0                                  9                           9.0                                9                                   7.8               7.8                                   9                               9                         10                                         3                             1                         8

         8                                7.3                                    7                        7                        8                      6.0                                  6                           9.0                                9                                   8.1               8.1                                   9                        10                                       9                                  8                       10                              6

         7                                7.3                                    8                        8                        6                      7.0                                  7                           9.0                                9                                   8.2               8.2                                   8                        10                               10                                         8                       10                              6

10                                        9.7                               10                       10                            9                      9.0                                  9                           10.0                        10                                         7.7               7.7                                   5                        10                               10                                         9                       10                              9

10                                        1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      9.0                                  9                           9.0                                9                                   7.3               7.3                                   8                               8                                 6                                  8                             1                         8

         6                                8.3                                    8                        9                        8                      9.0                                  9                           7.0                                7                                   7.8               7.8                                   8                               7                                 8                                  7                       10                              9

         8                                7.3                                    7                        7                        8                      9.0                                  9                           8.0                                8                                   7.3               7.3                                   7                               9                                 8                                  6                       10                              7

         7                                4.7                                    6                        4                        4                      7.0                                  7                           4.0                                4                                   7.8               7.8                                   8                               4                                 8                                  9                       10                              7

         9                                9.7                                    9                   10                      10                           6.0                                  6                           9.0                                9                                   8.1               8.1                                   9                               9                                 9                                  7                       10                              9

         8                                4.3                                    5                        5                        3                      7.0                                  7                           5.0                                5                                   7.3               7.3                                   7                               9                                 6                                  8                       10                              7

         9                                7.7                                    7                        8                        8                      10.0                         10                                  8.0                                8                                   8.3               8.3                                   8                               8                                 9                                  5                       10                          10

         6                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      7.0                                  7                           4.0                                4                                   7.6               7.6                                   7                        10                                       9                                  7                             6                         6

         5                                8.0                                    8                        8                        8                      5.0                                  5                           7.0                                7                                   7.3               7.3                                   7                        10                                       9                                  9                       10                              5

         8                                3.0                                    3                        3                        3                      6.0                                  6                           4.0                                4                                   7.9               7.9                                   9                               8                                 5                                  7                       10                              9

         6                                3.0                                    3                        3                        3                      5.0                                  5                           6.0                                6                                   6.5               6.5                                   7                               8                                 8                                  7                       10                              4

         8                                3.3                                    5                        4                        1                      7.0                                  7                           6.0                                6                                   6.6               6.6                                   6                               7                                 7                                  8                       10                              5

         8                                2.3                                    2                        2                        3                      5.0                                  5                           9.0                                9                                   7.0               7.0                                   7                               9                                 9                                  7                       10                              5

         7                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      8.0                                  8                           7.0                                7                                   6.1               6.1                                   7                               9                                 6                                  7                             1                         6

         8                                4.0                                    2                        6                        4                      4.0                                  4                           8.0                                8                                   7.6               7.6                                   7                               9                                 9                                  7                       10                              8

         8                                1.0                                    1                        1                        1                      5.0                                  5                           7.0                                7                                   6.3               6.3                                   7                               9                                 7                                  7                       10                              5

         8                                7.0                                    8                        7                        6                      5.0                                  5                           7.0                                7                                   6.9               6.9                                   6                               9                                 9                                  8                       10                              7

         7                                3.3                                    3                        4                        3                      7.0                                  7                           2.0                                2                                   5.7               5.7                                   6                               5                                 4                                  5                       10                              5
7   2.0   2   2   2   6.0   6   4.0   4   6.6   6.6   6   6   5   7   10   6

7   3.0   4   3   2   3.0   3   3.0   3   5.2   5.2   5   4   4   6   10   4

7   1.0   1   1   1   5.0   5   4.0   4   4.4   4.4   5   7   3   4   7    4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M10 | Structures and Resources of Legislative
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M9 | Citizens' Participatory Competence
                                                                                                                                                                                      M8 | Organizational Reform Capacity
                                                                                                                                                  M7.2 | International Coordination
M6.3b | Constitutional Discretion




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    II | Executive Accountability
                                                                                                                   M7.1 | Domestic Adaptability
                                                                 C | Institutional Learning:
                                    M6.3c | National Standards




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     M8.2 | Institutional Reform




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              M9.1 | Policy Knowledge
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            M8.1 | Self-monitoring




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        M9.2 | Voter Turnout


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               E | Legislatature:
                                                                                               M7 | Adaptability




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    D | Citizens:




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Actors
       5                                  9                                 8.3                7.5                       6                                9                           9.0                                        9                         9                       8.52                                  7.9        7.9                                            9                    6.89                          8.1                    6.4
       9                                  9                                 8.8                9.0                       9                                9                           8.5                                        9                         8                       7.50                                  8.3        8.3                                            8                    8.63                          7.5                    5.5
       8                                  8                                 8.3                9.0                       8                        10                                  7.5                                        8                         7                       8.29                                  8.4        8.4                                            9                    7.85                          8.1                    6.6
10                                        6                                 8.0                7.5                       8                                7                           8.5                                        9                         8                       7.47                                  6.6        6.6                                            7                    6.11                          8.2                    6.5
       9                                  9                                 8.0                8.5                       8                                9                           7.5                                        8                         7                       7.27                                  7.9        7.9                                            8                    7.90                          8.1                    6.3
10                                        8                                 7.5                8.0                       9                                7                           7.0                                        7                         7                       7.99                                  9.6        9.6                                       10                        9.23                          7.2                    5.3
       5                                  7                                 7.3                7.5                       7                                8                           7.0                                        7                         7                       7.37                                  8.0        8.0                                            6                    10                            8.1                    6.8
       8                                  7                                 7.5                7.5                       6                                9                           7.5                                        8                         7                       6.96                                  6.6        6.6                                            8                    5.18                          7.8                    6.6
10                                        6                                 6.3                5.5                       5                                6                           7.0                                        7                         7                       6.81                                  5.4        5.4                                            5                    5.89                          8.9                    8.9
       7                                  9                                 6.5                8.0                       7                                9                           5.0                                        5                         5                       7.29                                  8.4        8.4                                            7                    9.87                          6.5                    4.0
       5                                  8                                 6.8                7.0                       6                                8                           6.5                                        7                         6                       6.57                                  5.2        5.2                                            6                    4.37                          7.9                    6.6
       5                                  8                                 6.8                8.0                       9                                7                           5.5                                        5                         6                       6.81                                  6.9        6.9                                            9                    4.82                          6.7                    6.1
       7                                  9                                 6.8                8.0                       7                                9                           5.5                                        4                         7                       7.16                                  7.3        7.3                                            7                    7.69                          7.8                    6.1
       5                                  6                                 6.5                7.0                       6                                8                           6.0                                        5                         7                       6.20                                  5.1        5.1                                            6                    4.20                          6.7                    5.1
       7                                  6                                 7.0                7.5                       8                                7                           6.5                                        7                         6                       6.86                                  7.8        7.8                                            7                    8.59                          6.2                    4.4
10                                        7                                 5.8                5.5                       6                                5                           6.0                                        7                         5                       6.29                                  4.9        4.9                                            8                    1.80                          6.5                    5.9
10                                        7                                 5.3                7.5                       7                                8                           3.0                                        3                         3                       6.99                                  7.4        7.4                                            5                    9.86                          7.7                    6.5
       5                                  6                                 7.3                7.5                       7                                8                           7.0                                        8                         6                       5.82                                  5.2        5.2                                            6                    4.48                          7.6                    7.8
       9                                  4                                 6.8                8.0                       8                                8                           5.5                                        6                         5                       6.02                                  5.6        5.6                                            5                    6.11                          7.5                    6.1
       4                                  5                                 7.3                7.5                       7                                8                           7.0                                        6                         8                       5.85                                  5.1        5.1                                            4                    6.28                          7.8                    6.4
       4                                  8                                 6.0                7.5                       7                                8                           4.5                                        5                         4                       6.20                                  5.7        5.7                                            7                    4.37                          7.3                    6.7
       6                                  5                                 6.8                7.5                       8                                7                           6.0                                        6                         6                       5.63                                  4.9        4.9                                            5                    4.72                          6.9                    6.2
       7                                  4                                 6.0                7.5                       7                                8                           4.5                                        4                         5                       6.08                                  6.2        6.2                                            5                    7.36                          6.6                    4.7
       5                                  8                                 6.0                7.0                       8                                6                           5.0                                        4                         6                       5.07                                  6.0        6.0                                            7                    5.07                          5.3                    4.7
       4                                  2                                 6.0                7.5                       8                                7                           4.5                                        4                         5                       5.55                                  6.2        6.2                                            5                    7.32                          6.4                    6.5
       6                                  4                                 6.8                6.5                       7                                6                           7.0                                        7                         7                       4.70                                  3.1        3.1                                            5                    1.25                          6.2                    4.6
       6                                  4                                 6.3                8.0                       7                                9                           4.5                                        4                         5                       5.89                                  7.0        7.0                                            6                    8.05                          6.5                    5.8
7   7   4.8   5.0   5   5   4.5   4   5   6.13   4.5   4.5   5   4.03   7.9   6.5
5   5   4.3   5.0   4   6   3.5   3   4   5.09   3.0   3.0   5    1     7.6   5.7
3   2   4.0   4.5   4   5   3.5   3   4   5.34   5.0   5.0   3   7.09   7.0   6.2
                                                        M10.3 | Pro-government Committee Chairs




                                                                                                                                                                     M11 | Legislative Accountability




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               F | Intermediary Organizations:
                                                                                                                                M10.6 | Legislature's Expert Staff




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                M11.5 | Task Area Coincidence
M10.1 | Number of Committees




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M12.2 | Newspaper Circulation
                                                                                                                                                                                                        M11.1 | Non-majority leverage




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      M11.3 | Summoning Ministers
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        M11.2 | Obtaining Documents




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    M11.4 | Summoning Experts




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         M12.3 | Quality Newspapers
                                                                                                  M10.4 | Deputy Expert Staff




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               M12.1 | Media Reporting
                               M10.2 | Committee Size




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M11.7 | Ombuds Office
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                M11.6 | Audit Office




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 M12 | Media
10                             10                       9.11                                      1.42                          1.46                                 9.8                                9.75                            10                            10                            10                                 9                        10                     10                                   9.5                  9.7                9                    10                              10

      7                        10                       7.73                                      1.47                          1.52                                 9.5                                9.65                                  9                       10                            10                                 8                        10                     10                                   6.7                  5.0                6                    4.96                            4.01

10                             10                       9.44                                      1.50                          1.92                                 9.7                                9.56                            10                            10                            10                                 8                        10                     10                                   8.3                  7.6                9                    7.68                            6.26

10                             10                       8.49                                      1.50                          2.61                                 9.8                                8.49                            10                            10                            10                          10                              10                     10                                   7.7                  7.4                8                    8.15                            6.05

10                             8.88                     7.31                                            1                       4.55                                 9.8                                9.53                                  9                       10                            10                          10                              10                     10                                   5.8                  3.9                4                    3.98                            3.80

10                             8.88                     4.05                                      1.50                          2.32                                 9.0                                8.82                                  8                       10                            10                                 7                        10                          9                               7.2                  6.4                8                    4.84                            6.37

10                             8.88                     6.35                                      2.50                          6.16                                 9.4                                8.49                                  9                       10                            10                                 9                        10                          9                               6.0                  3.7                6                    3.25                            1.92

      8                        8.88                     7.96                                            3                       5.07                                 9.1                                9.61                                  9                       10                            10                                 6                        10                          9                               6.5                  4.9                9                    3.49                            2.22

      8                        7.75                     8.78                                      10                            10                                   8.8                                8.87                                  9                       10                            10                                 8                        10                          6                               6.1                  4.9                7                    4.31                            3.33

      8                        8.88                              1                                      1                       1.17                                 9.0                                7.94                                  8                       10                                  9                            9                            9                  10                                   6.9                  6.5                7                    4.99                            7.62

10                             10                       8.09                                      1.50                          3.52                                 9.2                                8.36                                  9                             9                       10                          10                                  9                       9                               6.6                  5.2                9                    4.99                            1.76

10                             10                       7.73                                      1.50                          1.23                                 7.4                                8.84                                  5                             6                             8                            8                        10                          6                               6.8                  4.8                9                    4.00                            1.55

      8                        8.88                     9.44                                            2                       2.38                                 9.4                                9.10                                  9                       10                            10                                 9                        10                          9                               6.3                  5.7                9                    5.14                            2.91

      1                        10                       9.01                                      2.50                          2.89                                 8.3                                7.89                                  9                             8                       10                                 6                        10                          7                               6.8                  5.3                9                    5.40                            1.54

      3                        8.88                     5.80                                      1.60                          2.49                                 8.0                                4.01                                  7                             8                       10                                 7                        10                     10                                   6.6                  5.6                9                    5.99                            1.73

10                             10                       6.52                                            2                       1.11                                 7.1                                       1                        10                            10                            10                                 8                            9                       2                               7.4                  7.5                9                    6.36                            7.22

      9                        10                       8.32                                      1.50                          3.92                                 8.8                                7.78                                  9                       10                            10                                 6                        10                          9                               5.9                  3.7                6                    3.11                            2.07

      9                        10                       9.08                                            4                       7.08                                 7.4                                9.04                                  8                       10                            10                                 9                            5                       1                               4.6                  5.1                7                    6.30                            2.12

10                             8.88                     8.32                                      1.85                          1.29                                 9.0                                8.96                                  8                       10                                  9                            9                            9                       9                               5.0                  3.6                7                    2.16                            1.75

10                             10                       9.44                                      1.50                                  1                            9.3                                9.01                                  9                       10                            10                                 9                            9                       9                               4.6                  4.1                7                    3.14                            2.26

10                             7.75                     9.28                                      2.50                          4.15                                 7.8                                8.62                                  9                             9                             7                            9                            7                       5                               5.7                  6.3                8                    9.91                                  1

10                             8.88                     9.15                                            1                       1.75                                 7.6                                8.98                                  8                             9                             9                            7                            6                       5                               5.2                  3.7                8                    1.62                            1.38

      7                        5.50                     8.78                                      1.21                          1.11                                 8.5                                9.28                                  8                             9                             9                            8                            8                       8                               5.5                  3.6                6                    2.40                            2.32

      8                             1                   10                                              3                       1.69                                 5.9                                8.11                                  8                             7                       10                                 2                            5                       1                               3.9                  3.4                6                    2.94                            1.33

10                             10                       9.28                                      1.50                          1.80                                 6.4                                7.61                                  7                             8                             9                            5                            6                       2                               4.0                  3.1                6                    2.01                            1.26

      1                        8.88                     9.18                                      2.50                          1.57                                 7.9                                10                                    8                             8                             9                            5                            9                       6                               4.7                  3.1                6                           1                        2.39

10                             5.50                     9.57                                      1.50                          2.61                                 7.2                                8.46                                  8                             9                             9                            7                            7                       2                               4.1                  2.9                5                    2.28                            1.40
10   10     8.65    2     1.63   9.3   9.06   10   10   10   9   9    8   6.0   5.0   7   3.37   4.71

6    8.88   9.15    2     2.66   9.6   8.87   10   10   10   9   10   9   4.6   3.6   7   2.45   1.23

10   10     7.57   1.50   1.92   7.8   8.74   8    9    10   7   6    6   4.0   2.9   5   1.60   2.13
                                                                     M13.2 | Association Competence (business)
M13 | Parties and Interest Associations




                                                                                                                 M13.3 | Association Competence (others)
                                          M13.1 | Party Competence




9.3                                            8                     10                                          10

8.3                                            9                              8                                           8

9.0                                            9                              9                                           9

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

7.7                                            9                              7                                           7

8.0                                            6                              9                                           9

8.3                                            9                              8                                           8

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

7.3                                            6                              8                                           8

7.3                                            8                              7                                           7

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

8.7                                            8                              9                                           9

7.0                                            7                              7                                           7

8.3                                            9                              8                                           8

7.7                                            7                              8                                           8

7.3                                            8                              7                                           7

8.0                                            8                              8                                           8

4.0                                            2                              5                                           5

6.3                                            5                              7                                           7

5.0                                            5                              5                                           5

5.0                                            7                              4                                           4

6.7                                            8                              6                                           6

7.3                                            8                              7                                           7

4.3                                            5                              4                                           4

5.0                                            3                              6                                           6

6.3                                            7                              6                                           6

5.3                                            6                              5                                           5
7.0   7   7   7

5.7   5   6   6

5.0   5   5   5

								
To top