Docstoc

Firefighters train on Texas props Firefighters train on Texas props.pdf

Document Sample
Firefighters train on Texas props Firefighters train on Texas props.pdf Powered By Docstoc
					IFW                     Industrial
                        Fire
                        World
Firefighters train on Texas props




Friendly
Fire
   P.O. BOX 9161, COLLEGE STATION, TX 77842                                                      s
                                               PRSRT STD
                                                                                             dard
                                                                                          tan
                                              US POSTAGE
                                                    PAID
                                               Permit #204                            :  S
                                                                                    ue
                                                                                 iss Air
                                              Bollingbrook, IL

                                                                               s
                                                                            thi ew
                                                                         in      N
                                                                     Also Vs.
                                                                       es
                                                                   hoic
                                                               ineC
   Volume 23, No. 5 September-October 2008
   Volume 23, No. 5 September-October 2008
                                                            Eng
2   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
IFW CONTENTS
                                                                                                                                                                                     SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 2008
                                                                                                                                                                                                   Volume 23
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Number 5


                                                                                                                                                                               DEPARTMENTS
    21: COVER STORY
           FRIENDLY                                                                                                                                                          4: Dave’s Notes
                FIRE                                                                                                                                                         By David White
          BY ANTON RIECHER                                                                                                                                                   What happens when a simple
                                                                                                                                                                             system tries to regulate a complex
                                                                                                                             Photo by Anton Riecher
                                                                                                                                                                             system? One word — trouble.
    Firefighters attended the annual Industrial Fire School at Texas A&M Uni-
    versity in College Station to test themselves against the newest fire ‘prop,’                                                                                            17: Industry News
    a replicia of an industrial process unit that boasts 18 duel fuel-leak points.                                                                                            • Federal Signal sells E-ONE
                                                                                                                                                                              • Alabama fire school renamed
 6: Coming Clean                                                                    25: A Fire Truck for Trona                                                                • Ferrara distributes First Attack
 Engine manufacturers faced with                                                    A California minerals operation                                                           • Feds probe Houston fire.
 stringent new EPA standards are                                                    upgrades to the latest model off
 opting out of the fire truck market.                                               the Ferrara assembly line.                                                               23: Incident Log

 8: Emissions Mandate                                                                                                                                                        40: Risk Assessment
                                                                                    28: Temperature Rising
 To date the impact of new EPA                                                                                                                                               By John Frank
                                                                                    Report attributes an explosion at a
 emissions standards on fire                                                                                                                                                 Systems knowledge essential to
                                                                                    Texas refinery to a cracked pipe.
 apparatus remains largely unseen.                                                                                                                                           adequate emergency preplanning.
                                                                                    32: Dust to Dust
 12: Silent Alarm                                                                                                                                                            41: Focus on Hazmat
                                                                                    OSHA slams sugar refiner with
 A pencil jammed in an alarm                                                                                                                                                 By John Townsend
                                                                                    near record fines after blast.
 switch contributed to a 2001 fire                                                                                                                                           Unintended consequences have too
 aboard a ship loaded with ammo.                                                                                                                                             often negated new regulations.
                                                                                    34: Firefighters on Demand
                                                                                    Illinois company specializes in
 16: Failure to Lift                                                                                                                                                         45: EMS Corner
                                                                                    keeping fire departments staffed.
 Crane safety makes national                                                                                                                                                 By Bill Kerney
 headlines after a refinery accident                                                                                                                                         Big changes are on the way.
                                                                                    36: 15 Minutes
 that left four workers dead.                                                       Combustion equipment requires                                                            46: Industrial Service
                                                                                    special care by skilled technicians.                                                          Directory
 18: Proper Respect
 Emergency Services Training                                                        39: Decision Pending                                                                     48: Spotlight Ads
 Institute initiates new live-fire                                                  State budget crisis may force
 process unit training prop.                                                        Nevada fire academy to close.                                                            49: New Products

 Publisher                                                                     Technical Consultant                                                                              INDUSTRIAL FIRE
 David White
 Editor
                                                                               Louis N. Molino, Sr.
                                                                               Incident Log Editor
                                                                                                                                                                                    WORLD®
 Anton Riecher                                                                 Jason Marsh                                                                                                   SINCE 1985
 Circulation Manager                                                           Hazmat Contributor                                                                                         (ISSN 0749-890X)
 Gloria Thompson                                                               John S. Townsend, Ph.D.                                                                          P.O. Box 9161/540 Graham Rd.
 Marketing Manager                                                             EMS Contributor
                                                                                                                                                                                 College Station, TX 77842/45
 Lynn White                                                                    Bill Kerney
 Associate Editor                                                              Education Contributor
                                                                                                                                                                                        (979)690-7559
 Kendra Graf                                                                   Attila Hertelendy                                                                                      FAX (979)690-7562
 Marketing Representative                                                      Risk Contributor                                                                                   E-MAIL ind@fireworld.com
 Sherrill Miller                                                               John A. Frank                                                                                     WEB SITE www.fireworld.com

 Industrial Fire World, September-October 2008, Volume 23, No. 5. Industrial Fire World (ISSN 0749-890X) is published bimonthly by Industrial Fire World, Inc., P.O. Box 9161, College Station, Texas 77842. (979) 690-7559. Fax:
 (979) 690-7562. E-mail: ind@fireworld.com. All rights reserved under International Convention. Copyright © 2007 by Industrial Fire World Inc., all rights reserved. Industrial Fire World is a registered trademark of David White Investments,
 Inc., College Station, Texas. The design and content are fully protected by copyright and must not be reproduced in any manner without written permission of the publisher. Bulk rate postage paid at Fulton, MO, and additional mailing
 offices. Subscription rates: USA, one year $29.95, two years $49.95, and three years $59.95; Canada and foreign, add $20 per year postage. Single copies $6. Back issues available at $6 a copy plus postage. Payment must accompany
 orders for single copies. All inquiries regarding subscription problems, change of address and payments, call (979) 690-7559. Please allow six to eight weeks for your first subscription copy to be shipped. Please state both old and new
 addresses when requesting an address change and notify us at least six weeks in advance. (If possible enclose subscription address label.) Industrial Fire World is edited exclusively to be of value for people in the industrial fire protection
 field. Subscriptions are reserved to those engaged in the area of industrial fire protection and related fields or service and supply companies’ personnel. Address advertising requests to Marketing Director, Industrial Fire World, P.O. Box
 9161, College Station, Texas 77842. (979) 690-7559. Advertising rates and requirements available on request. Editorial Information: Industrial Fire World welcomes correspondence dealing with industrial fire and safety issues, products,
 training and other information that will advance the quality and effectiveness of industrial fire and safety management. We will consider for publication all submitted manuscripts and photographs. All material will be treated with care, although
 we cannot be responsible for loss or damage. Submissions should be accompanied by a stamped, self-addressed envelope. (Any payment for use of material will be made only upon publication.) Industrial Fire World assumes no responsibility
 for the return of unsolicited manuscripts or photographs. Industrial Fire World reserves the right to refuse any editorial or advertising material submitted for publication. Information and recommendations contained in this publication have
 been compiled from sources that are believed to be reliable and representative of the best current opinion on various topics. No warranty, guarantee, or representation is made by Industrial Fire World as to the absolute validity of sufficiency
 of information contained within the publication. Industrial Fire World assumes no responsibility for statements made by contributors. Advertising in Industrial Fire World does not imply approval nor endorsement by Industrial Fire World.
 Printed in the USA. CPC publication number 40801529. Postmaster: Send address changes to Industrial Fire World, P.O. Box 9161, College Station, Texas 77842. For subscription inquiries call: (979) 690-7559.
                                                                                                                                                                                      SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008                                  3
                             DAVE’S NOTES

                            Shortsightedness breeds crisis
                                  Trying to regulate                         thinking. Ethanol sounded like a good idea
                                                                             until food prices started going up. Some
                                  complex systems                            experts maintain that the Americans with
                                                                             Disabilities Act has actually resulted in lower
                                 using simple ones                           employment levels among the disabled.
                                                                                Lack of foresight in our drive to deal with
                                                        By DAVID WHITE
                                                                             environmental issues is creating other




                            W
                                                 hat happens when a          problems for emergency responders as well.
                                                 simple system tries to      Our choices with regard to diesel engines for
                                                 regulate a complex          fire apparatus will soon be severely restricted
                                                 system? It seems simple     thanks to EPA intervention (see page 6). We
                                                 for our political system    are accustomed to a wide range of choices
                            to clear up problems with regulations.           about the engines we use in our fire engines.
                            According to Columbia University                 That is about to change dramatically. Soon
                            Professor Andrew Gelman, a simple system         there will be only one manufacturer left who
                            operates with limited information (rational      is willing to take on the challenge in light of
                            ignorance), short time horizons, low             the new, more restrictive EPA emissions
                            feedback, and poor and misaligned                standards. Not only will there be a supply
                            incentives. Society and society, in contrast,    and demand factor at work, but the diversity
                            are complex, evolving, high-feedback,            of engine sizes and capacity will be severely
                            incentive-driven systems. When a simple          curtailed. Engine cost is project to rise from
                            system tries to regulate a complex system        about $15,000 to as much as $45,000 per
                            the ultimate outcome can be unforeseen.          engine. Thank the environmentalists for
                               We live in a world today challenged by        scoring another crunch on our economy by
                            emergencies that we failed to envision           inhibiting the market and prohibiting
                            despite our best science and reason. For         firefighters from driving what we need and
                            example, in the HazMat column of this issue      want.
                            you will see how something as simple as             Another area where best intentions do not
                            compact fluorescent light bulbs have major       always translate into better service is
                            unintended consequences. These are               emergency health care. Starting with me, no
                            miniatures of full-sized fluorescents that       one wants less than top notch care when we
                            serve as a more energy efficient alternative     have a medical emergency. Hence, the push
                            to the ordinary incandescent bulbs               to improve the capabilities of EMS personnel
                            commonly used. CFLs are four times more          from basic to paramedic. In many instances,
                            efficient and last up to 10 times longer than    this push has improved the level of care the
                            incandescents.                                   public can access. However, there is a
                               All of this is positive as long as the        downside. Rural communities and industrial
                            contents of CFL bulbs stay out of the            plants were formerly able to keep a few
                            environmental waste stream once the bulb         paramedics on hand by granting them the
                            expires. CFLs contain toxic materials that may   time necessary to get the required training.
                            be released if the bulb is broken. Although      But with new training standards requiring
                            household CFL bulbs may legally be               more and more hours of training, the rank of
                            disposed of with regular trash in most states,   paramedic in industrial plants has almost
                            they are categorized as household                disappeared. People can not be away the
                            hazardous waste. Apparently, the impact on       number of hours needed for training to the
                            emergency responders who encounter CFLs          new standards, particularly in the more
                            at a fire scene never appeared on the DOE        remote areas where they are most needed.
                            or EPA radar screen, let alone the long term     Once again, the unintended consequences
                            problems of placing this waste in sanitary       generate results that reduce the quality of
                            landfills.                                       operations when the intention was to
                               There are other examples of such loose                              Continued on Page 33
4   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
                 P.O. Box 9161 • 540 Graham Road • College Station, TX 77842/45 • 979.690-7559
                       Fax 979.690-7562 • E-mail ind@fireworld.com • www.fireworld.com
           24th Industrial Fire World Emergency Responder Conference & Exposition
                                   COMPANY SPONSOR FORM
A company sponsorship for the 24th Industrial Fire World Emergency Responder Conference and Exposition offers
general session presentations, free workshops, special demonstrations, product exhibits, recognition in marketing
materials and a time and place to host a company meeting.

Our company commits to support Industrial Fire World, ISTC/BEST Complex, Sabine Neches Chiefs Association and
area industries by assuring the group participation of fire and emergency response managers and personnel. We
recognize that the group rate does not include special fees like certification workshops or the LNG Symposium.
Register each individual at www.fireworld.com using the provided group pass code.

Signature: _______________________________________________________________ Date: ____________

Please type or print

Company: ________________________________________________________________________________
Number of people in my group: __________________

Bill our company for payment of the group rate checked below:
   ( ) $1,000 for up to 5 people
   ( ) $2,000 for 6 - 10 people
   ( ) $3,000 for more than 10 people (Unlimited.)

Contact person to receive the group code and coordinate individual registration of group members through
the www.fireworld.com registration page:
Name: ________________________________________________________
E-mail address: _________________________________________________
Phone: ________________________________________
FAX: __________________________________________

Bill group registration fee to:
Name: __________________________________________________________________
Title: ___________________________________________________________________
Mailing Address: __________________________________________________________
City: __________________________________ State: _____ Zip: ___________________
Purchase Order Number: ____________________________
Phone: __________________________________________
FAX: ____________________________________________
E-Mail: __________________________________________________________________

Or charge to the following credit card:
Account Number: _____________________________________
Expiration Date: ______________________________________
Name on Account if different from name above: _____________________________________
Card Billing Address if different from above:
 Address: __________________________________________________________________
 City: ____________________________ State: _____ Zip: __________________________

           24th Industrial Fire World Emergency Responder Conference & Exposition
                                       March 23-27, 2009            SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008 5

                        Holiday Inn Beaumont Plaza ... Beaumont, Texas
APPARATUS




              Coming
               Clean
       Engine manufacturers opt out of the emergency
     services market in the face of new, more stringent
    EPA emissions standards being phased in by 2010
                                                                   By ANTON RIECHER/IFW EDITOR

             egend states that Henry Ford once       new Environmental Protection Agency                  space. For example, SCR systems require a



L            said his Model T was available in
             any color the public wanted – as
             long as it was black. Something
             similar can be said for the choices
that fire chiefs will have in fire truck engines
beginning in 2010.
   You can have any engine you want as long
                                                     emissions regulations beginning in 2007 have
                                                     been essentially invisible to the end user so far.
                                                     The same will not be true once the complete
                                                     set of regulations take effect in 2010, said
                                                     Donald Frazeur, Los Angeles City Fire
                                                     Department division commander in charge of
                                                     supply and maintenance for 1,200 vehicles.
                                                                                                          supplementary tank with urea, an organic
                                                                                                          compound that fights nitrogen oxide emissions
                                                                                                          when injected into a vehicle’s exhaust.
                                                                                                             “A urea tank is fairly common in Europe,”
                                                                                                          Barraclough said. “They’ve been meeting
                                                                                                          standards similar to these for a long time.”
                                                                                                             The moment engineers add more complexity
as it is Cummins. Behind this radical market             “What we don’t know is how the fire              and hardware to the truck, it means encroaching
constriction are new EPA emissions standards         apparatus industry is going to incorporate these     somewhere else on the vehicle, he said.
being phased in by 2010.                             requirements into their designs,” Frazeur said.         “Right now, the size of the primary DPF
   Caterpillar and Detroit Diesel have chosen        “It is going to have an impact on the engine         has encroached into the pump area and
to pull out of the emergency services market         doghouse and the ability to provide the cooling      underneath the cab, both in space and in heat,”
and the over-the-road truck market as well,          that’s required. So you’re seeing design changes     Barraclough said.
said fire truck consultant Robert Barraclough.       as we speak.”                                           For chassis manufacturers, the trick is
Mercedes, which owns Detroit Diesel and                  Frazeur serves as chairman of the National       finding an efficient way to configure the exhaust
Freightliner, is eliminating its Series 60 engines   Fire Protection Association’s Fire Department        system. Unfortunately, the new EPA
rather than make them compatible with the new        Apparatus Committee. New NFPA                        regulations frown upon extensive exhaust
2010 standards.                                      requirements dealing with exhaust issues             modifications.
   “Mercedes will have alternate engines,            stemming from the EPA standards are under               “The fire truck manufacturers used to be
probably coming from Germany or Brazil for           consideration.                                       able to move exhaust whenever it got in the
their over-the-road trucks – but only theirs,”           As of 2007, the use of diesel particulate        way of anything,” Barraclough said. “They’d
Barraclough said. “A new engine is being built       filters (DPF) on diesel engines has been             just cut and splice and get it done. You can’t do
by Detroit Diesel in addition to those from          mandated by EPA to lower emissions as the            that anymore. Once you get a chassis that has
Germany and Brazil but, again, I understand          first step in phasing in tougher emissions           an exhaust system you’re probably going to
they will only be available in Freightliner          standards by 2010. An ultra-low-sulfur diesel        have to leave it right where it is.”
products.”                                           fuel must be used with this device. With the            In a recent issue of the Darley Times
   Mack has engines capable of being certified       sulfur content in diesel reduced from 500 parts      newsletter, W.S. Darley Co. Vice President for
to the 2010 requirements but so far has been         per million to 15 parts per million, the use of      Engineering Mike Ruthy said that a SCR
uninterested in manufacturing “vocational”           this fuel presents a variety of problems for         system would encroach on the Darley pump
engines that could be sold to others for custom      engine manufacturers.                                house and may be problematic for other brands
chassis, Barraclough said. Only Cummins has              Finding room to add the DPF is hard enough.      of pumps.
announced its intention to remain available for      By 2010, secondary catalytic reduction (SCR)            “It will take up a lot of extra space, but I
commercial and custom chassis.                       emission systems will be mandated on most            hear Cummins has a ‘design-around’ solution
   Engine changes to fire trucks imposed by          chassis, making further serious demands for          that accommodates midship pumps,” he said.
6   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
    Darley midship pumps have a narrow gear           power rating. Exhaust gas temperatures can rise      Beginning in January 2007, all
box because of its vertical gear alignment,           to 1,200 degrees Fahrenheit downstream of the        Cummins on-highway engines utilize
meaning less trouble fitting new exhaust              DPF. However, NFPA 1901 standards effective          exhaust aftertreatment for particulate
systems, he said. CAFS (compressed air foam           in 2009 limit tailpipe gas to 851 degrees F.         control as well as a crankcase
systems) may need to be reconfigured to                   “NFPA is coming down with added
                                                                                                           coalescing filter to control crankcase
accommodate the exhaust, but it would merely          requirements to deal with some of the changes
                                                                                                           emissions.
be a matter of mirroring the current design of        in design, particularly with the DPF,” Frazeur
the driver’s side instead of the passenger’s side.    said. “It’s not so much where you put it but
    PTO (power take off) driven pumps will            exhaust temperatures are going to be a lot higher.   allow us that,” Frazeur said.
be harder to work around, Ruthy said. Unless          We’re going to have to regulate these                   Dealing with the heat problem is going to
chassis manufacturers change to the 3000 EVS          temperatures so that we’re not driving around        mean a bigger radiator, among other things. To
transmission with the top mounted PTO,                starting grass fires.”                               gain the space for that added equipment is
options may be limited.                                   One temperature issue of concern to              probably going to mean a redesign of the cab
    “That said, I cannot say that any chassis         firefighters is emissions control by steady state    interior. But updates such as SCBA integrated
manufacturer has laid down a clear and firm           burn off of particulates. When the emissions         into special seats built to crash standards make
direction, so I expect some future surprises,”        system reaches a certain level of particulates,      that redesign difficult.
Ruthy said.                                           the exhaust flow reverses to burn them out.             Giving up the custom chassis in favor of a
    The simple fix would seem to be vertical          Under the right circumstances, this burn off         return to commercial chassis for fire trucks is a
exhaust, but that presents its own problems           can constitute a fire danger during emergency        possibility, Frazeur said. Some tough tradeoffs
under special circumstances, Frazeur said. For        operations. Emissions controls will slow or          would have to be made regarding available
instance, what if the truck is parked under a         shut down the engine when a certain level of         space.
canopy?                                               emissions is sensed to allow the burn off,              “The problem with those apparatus is that
    “Rather than just say ‘route it up vertically,’   potentially affecting pump pressure at a critical    they’re made for over-the-road truckers, not
I think we have to keep the exhaust within a          moment.                                              firefighters,” Frazeur said. “There are design
certain temperature,” he said.                            “An override on the burn off is one of the       issues regarding durability and access in an
    The combustion-ignition cycle of an engine        things we are specifying,” Frazeur said. “The        emergency.”
involves a fixed mass of air being acted upon. A      engine doesn’t automatically go into burn off.          The most immediate impact is expected to
basic four-stroke diesel cycle consists of            The operator has the ability to override if          be larger emergency vehicles in the future, he
combustion being replaced by heat added to            you’re in a bad spot, such as pumping at a           said. The cost of the engines to pull these bigger
the air. Exhaust is then replaced by a heat           scene and you’ve got grass up against the            trucks will probably range between $25,000
rejection process that restores the air to its        exhaust.”                                            and $30,000.
initial state.                                            Requiring an override for fire trucks may           “It looks to me like it is going to impact our
    The 2007 EPA standards have increased             mean obtaining a special exception from the          apparatus, especially ambulances,” Frazeur
total heat rejection between five and 30 percent,     EPA, he said.                                        said. “It looks like our apparatus is going to
depending on the engine make, model and                   “The EPA has not shown a willingness to          grow one to two feet longer.”                   C

                                                                                                                    SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008              7
                                                                                      expected to reduce smog-causing nitrogen oxide (NOx)
 To date, the impact of engine changes                                                emissions nearly 2.6 million tons. Soot or particulate
     on fire apparatus mandated by the                                                matter (PM) will be reduced by 110,000 tons a year.
                                                                                         With the sulfur content in diesel reduced from 500
             EPA remain largely unseen                                                parts per million to 15 parts per million, the use of this
                                                                                      fuel presents a variety of problems for engine
                                                                                      manufacturers.



Emissions                                                                                Sackett and Pierce Manufacturing Director of Research
                                                                                      and Development Roger Lackore worked together on a
                                                                                      presentation entitled “Impact of 2007 Engine Changes
                                                                                      on Fire Apparatus” presented in January at the 20th
                                                                                      annual Apparatus Specification & Vehicle Maintenance




MANDATE
                                                                                      Symposium. Sackett focused on power and torque ratings
                                                                                      while Lackore’s contribution dealt with exhaust
                                                                                      aftertreatment.

                                                                                                ENGINE & COOLING SYSTEMS
                                                                                         The combustion-ignition cycle of an engine involves
                                                                                      action to a fixed mass of air. A basic four-stroke diesel
                                                                                      cycle consists of combustion being replaced by heat
                                                                                      addition to the air and exhaust is replaced by a heat
                                                                                      rejection process which restores the air to the initial
                                                                                      state.
                                                                                         According to Sackett, the 2007 engine changes have
                                                                                      increased total heat rejection between five and 30 percent
                                                                                      depending on engine make, model and power rating.
                                                                                         “In most cases, the contribution of heat rejection
                                                                                      between the radiator and charged air cooler has changed
                                                                                      significantly,” Sackett said.
                                                                                         This has meant heat exchanger enhancements. The
                                                                                      radiator and charge-air-cooler now require different core
                                                                                      sizes, new core materials, different fin density and
                                                                                      internal turbulation. For example, the series packaging
                                                                                      cooling system offered by Spartan utilizes a radiator
                                                                                      with a 1,434-inch core area, increased from 1,116 inches.
                                                                                      The core material is now copper instead of aluminum.
                                                                                      The charge-air cooler has increased from 881 square
                                                                                      inches to 941 square inches.
                                                                                         The parallel packaging cooling system offers a radiator
                                                                                      with a 900 square inch core area, up from 600 square
                                                                                      inches. The charge-air cooler has increased from 300 to
                                                                                      500 square inches.
                                                                                         Air flow enhancements to the fan and shroud include
Increased engine tunnel heat rejection should not increase under hood                 fan size, speed, material, emersion, number of blades
                                                                                      and shroud shape. In Spartan’s series packaging cooling
temperatures significantly, but some components may now be closer to
                                                                                      system, the fan has increased from a 30-inch diameter to
the tunnel. Items like Turbo Chargers now may be required.
                                                                                      32 inches. The shroud shape is now optimized for fan


                        E
    By Mark Sackett &           ngine changes to fire trucks in response to new       emersion. Transmission cooler has moved from the
       Roger Lackore             Environmental Protection Agency emissions            bottom tank to a separate shell and tube unit.
                                 regulations have been essentially invisible to the      The parallel packaging cooling system expands the
                        end user, a presentation by spokesmen for two leading         fan diameter from 28 to 30 inches. Blade depth and
                        fire truck makers states.                                     shape has also been changed. Transmission cooler is
                           With regard to power and torque ratings, engine            changed from air to oil. All cooling system components
                        offerings remain similar to those offered before the lower    are aluminum.
                        emissions mandated by EPA in 2007, Mark Sackett,                 Higher fuel flow rates on certain engines may require
                        chief engineer for Spartan Chassis, reported.                 changes in supply and return line size and fuel cooler
                           As of 2007, the use of diesel particulate filters on       restriction. Regarding air intake, certain engines appear
                        diesel engines has been mandated by the EPA to lower          to be more sensitive to air intake temperatures than in
                        emissions. An ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuel must be used       the past. Intake locations have been changed and baffles
                        with this device. The new diesel engine standards are         have been added to avoid recirculation.
8   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
            EXHAUST AFTERTREATMENT
    Under the heading of exhaust aftertreatment, new leak-
proof requirements are in place. Leak-proof designs are
mandatory to deal with atomized fuel in the exhaust
pipe during dosing. Spiral-wrap style flex joints have
been replaced with metal bellows to provide a hermetic
all-metal pressure barrier and seal that flexes various
directions. A heavy duty band clamp known as a Marmon
is now used for joints.
    Increased engine tunnel heat rejection may be a
problem. Under-hood temperatures should not increase
significantly, but some components may be closer to the
tunnel than before. Items such as turbo charger shields
may be required to protect other components.
    Since 2007, all diesel engines are required to have
diesel particulate filters (DPF) to lower emissions. Engine   limited warranties on chrome due to discoloration from     Measuring for exhaust
to DPF insulation is now required by all engine               high temperatures.                                         skin temperature.
manufacturers. The DPF itself is insulated, and the area         Exhaust modifications are mostly frowned upon.
behind the DPF may require insulation or shielding to         Commercial and custom chassis manufacturers will not
protect body compartments.                                    allow exhaust modifications between the engine and the
    Exhaust insulation lowers skin temperature from as        DPF. Some modifications after the DPF may be
high as 700 degrees Fahrenheit to as low as 200 degrees       permissible. Modifications between the turbo and the
F. As insulation, stainless steel mat and silica quilt mat    DPF could cause serious operational problems and a
are the most effective. Header wrap is less effective.        loss of EPA certification.
    Exhaust gas temperatures can rise to 1,200 degrees F         Exhaust gas aftertreatment involves a process known
downstream of the DPF. However, NFPA 1901-2009                as regeneration. With passive regeneration, no fuel is
limits tailpipe gas to 851 degrees F, meaning that exhaust    added. Regeneration happens on its own when the
diffusers will be needed. As a result, while bright chrome    temperature is high. With automatic active regeneration,
tailpipes may be offered, do not expect them to stay          fuel is added to increase DPF temperature. This puts
bright. Most commercial manufacturers are offering only       the engine in control. Regeneration happens only if




                                                                                                               SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008     9
                                                                                             Names That Once Figured
                                                                                                 Prominently in
                                                                                                 Diesel Engines

                                                                                                   Seagraves •            • Continential
                                                                                                    Americanni            • Waukasha
                                                                                                    LaFrance •            • Mack
                                                                                                  Ahrens-Fox •            • Ford
                                                                                                 International •          • GMC
Diesel particulate         needed. Manual active regeneration occurs while the                            INDOOR AIR QUALITY
filters (DPF) are larger   vehicle is stationary and is initiated by the operator.            The 2007 EPA regulations place limits on four main
than the 2006 muffler        DPFs must be cleaned between 50,000 and 150,000               pollutants for diesel engines.
and       may     force    miles of use. The middle section of the unit must be               • Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx) – 1.2 gm/bhp-hr (grams/
compartments to be         removed to perform cleaning. It also requires special           brake horsepower-hour)
                           equipment. As of yet, 2007 engines do not have enough              • Non Methane Hydrocarbons (NMHC) – 0.14 gm/
blistered or notched.
                           miles on them to provide experience yet.                        bhp-hr
                                                                                              • Carbon Monoxide (CO) – 15.5 gm/bhp-hr
                                          CAB DESIGN CHANGES                                  • Particulates – 0.01 gm/bhp-hr
                               Exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) works by recirculating         Likewise, OSHA has established indoor air quality
                           a portion of an engine’s exhaust gas back to the engine         limits as per 29CFR§1900.1000.
                           cylinders. Engines meeting the 2007 emission standards             • Nitric Oxide (NO) – 30 mg/m3 (milligram per cubic
                           have an enlarged profile for larger or dual turbochargers       meter) (eight hour average)
                           and additional EGR piping on the engines. For example,             • Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) – 9 mg/m3 (ceiling)
                           radiator capacity increases by almost 15 percent to                • Carbon Monoxide (CO) – 55 mg/m3 (eight hour
                           compensate for additional demands on the cooling                average)
                           system.                                                            Particulates not otherwise regulated are likewise
                               To provide the required engine enclosure clearance,         restricted.
                           some manufacturers maintain their current cab width                • Total Dust – 15 mg/m3 (eight hour average)
                           and provide pocketed areas or offset engine enclosures             • Respirable Fraction – 5 mg/ m3 (eight hour average)
                           to provide the required engine enclosure clearance. Some           These limits are based on a fire truck in a sealed garage
                           manufacturers increase cab width to accommodate the             measuring 14 feet by 14 feet by 50 feet. The truck
                           wider engine profiles.                                          measures eight feet by nine feet by 40 feet. While idling,
                               Lackore also addressed the issue of increased engine        the engine consumes 25 hp. Emissions should be 20
                           tunnel heat rejection.                                          percent nitrogen dioxide and 80 percent nitric oxide.
                               “Under-hood temperatures should not increase                   Testing under these conditions indicates the time by
                           significantly, but some components may be closer to the         which OSHA limits are reached varies by the substance
                           tunnel than before,” Lackore said. “Multi-layered               involved. For nitrous oxide, the limit is reached in 15
                           insulations are available to enhance protection. Thinner        minutes. For carbon monoxide, the time limit is 16
                           or denser insulations are also being utilized.”                 minutes, while nitrogen dioxide reaches the limit in 18
                               Ground clearance of vehicles may be reduced                 minutes. It takes almost four hours before the limit on
                           dramatically in the area of the DPF. Because a DPF is           particulate matter is exceeded.
                           larger than the 2006 approved muffler, manufacturers               “Pulling apparatus into a garage bay and shutting
                           may be forced to use blistered or notched compartments.         down the engine within a minute or two should never
                           With approximately two inches of clearance for heat             exceed the OSHA indoor air quality limits,” Lackore
                           shielding and service access, only 28 inches are available      said.
                           for compartments or accessories mounted outboard of                Exhaust extraction should be used if operations
                           the DPF.                                                        require vehicle engines to be running while indoors.
                               Regarding exhaust system packaging, the engine to
                           DPF pipe cannot be modified by a body builder. This                                 CONCLUSION
                           ensures EPA compliance. The DPF is primarily a straight             Now that 2007 diesel engines are being installed and
                           exhaust routing installation for most of the larger engines     shipped in fire apparatus chassis, manufacturers are
                           utilized in custom fire chassis. With the limited flexibility   learning more about the impact these engines will have.
                           of the exhaust system piping, vertical exhausts and             While the trucks remain almost the same on the exterior,
                           specialized installations will have limitations.                firefighters should be aware of changes under the hood.C
10   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008   11
     A pencil jammed in an alarm switch
     almost turns an ammunition ship into
     a floating bomb




     By ANTON RIECHER/IFW Editor




     Silent
     Alarm                                                                                                               Photo Courtesy of The State Port Pilot




I
    magine fighting a fire inside a giant steel oven. Worse, imagine having      According to a subsequent Coast Guard report, the ship’s second
     to fight that fire blind. Southport (NC) Fire Department volunteer       assistant engineer started a transfer of about 20 tons of heavy fuel oil
     John Sledge said that describes the conditions responders faced          from the port and starboard overflow tanks to a central settling tank.
     battling a fire aboard a loaded ammunition cargo ship in July 2001.      The transfer was left unsupervised other than by automatic equipment.
   “By the time you got five feet inside the (engine room) door, you             “Their electronic system measured the tank levels and sounded an
couldn’t see your hand in front of your face,” Sledge said.                   alarm if the preset levels were exceeded,” Sledge said. “If you are starting
   From gaining access to enduring broiling heat, firefighters overcame       to overfill the tanks, it sounds a warning tone.”
a variety of difficulties and brought the ship fire under control within         Unfortunately, because cables to several tanks had become
six hours. The blaze never came close to reaching the five million pound      contaminated with fuel oil, false alarms had become a repeated nuisance.
cargo of explosives aboard.                                                   The easiest solution was to simply turn off the alarms.
   “Most of us had little or no experience with shipboard fire fighting,         “There was a spring-loaded switch on the control panel that you
particularly of this type, so we were in somewhat unfamiliar territory,”      held down to acknowledge that the alarm had sounded,” Sledge said. “A
Sledge said.                                                                  pencil had been jammed into that switch to keep it in the acknowledged
   The Sunny Point Military Ocean Terminal at Sunny Point, NC, is             position. It had been that way for months before the fire.”
the largest ammunition port in the nation and the Army’s primary east            Fuel oil overfilled the settling tank and began overflowing into the
coast deep-water port. For this reason, the 16,000-acre Army-owned            vent piping connecting it to the main engine mixing tank. The fuel oil
site near the Cape Fear river includes a large undeveloped buffer zone        mixed with about one ton of diesel fuel oil, then overflowed into the
and huge sand berms for safety, in case of explosion.                         venting system for that tank. Eventually, the fuel reached a common
   Sunny Point is the only Department of Defense terminal equipped            vent chamber tying together the vent systems for all the tanks aboard.
to handle containerized ammunition, as opposed to ammunition loaded              “Because of all the different branches, it is called the Christmas
on pallets. The terminal transshipped more than 90 percent of the             tree,” Sledge said.
resupply munitions sent to and from the Persian Gulf during operations           During the two weeks before the fire, repeated difficulties with
Desert Shield, Desert Storm and Desert Sortie, amounting to nearly 2.1        transfers of heavy fuel oil had been reported, indicating that the transfer
million tons of cargo.                                                        system was developing blockages that needed to be repaired. The
   At about 4:10 p.m. on July 14, 2001, a fire started onboard the 950-       Christmas tree was a suspected source for those blockages.
foot container ship SSG Edward A. Carter, Jr., while the vessel was               “The concern was that rust and corrosion had plugged up some of
moored at the south wharf of the terminal. Since the fire occurred on a       these lines,” Sledge said. “So they disassembled parts of it.”
Saturday afternoon, the explosive cargo was not being handled. Eighteen          The Coast Guard report states that the chief engineer failed to tag
of the vessel’s crew were onboard when the fire started.                      out the heavy fuel oil transfer pump and associated valves to ensure
12    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
that the transfer system remained off-line while the Christmas tree
flanges were disconnected. As a result, the mixed diesel and fuel oil was
forced up through two disconnected lines and spilled one deck above
the main deck.
    “The specific area where this happened is called the fidley, which is
like a pipe chase through which the smokestack travels up through the
main deck,” Sledge said. “There are other conduits and various pieces of
equipment found in this pipe chase.”
    The mixed fuel cascaded over the 01 level deck, which is one deck
above the main, or weather deck, making contact with the hot auxiliary
boiler exhaust stack several feet away, resulting in ignition. Fire spread
quickly throughout the aft levels of the engine room and inside the
fidley. A witness reported burning globs of fuel oil the size of baseballs
raining down inside the engine room, rapidly expanding the blaze. An
initial attempt to use a dry chemical extinguisher to control the fire
failed.
    Other issues compounded the emergency. An initial attempt to start
the main fire pump from the bridge failed, leading to a 10-minute delay
in providing water to crew members battling the blaze. It would be 35
minutes into the fire before a low-pressure CO2 system was activated,
its effectiveness hopelessly compromised by the open portside doors
on either side of the vessel.
    “That was allowing a lot of ventilation to get to the fire, allowing it
to grow,” Sledge said. “There were a number of other hatches that had
not been closed to isolate the fire. Smoke spread through the rest of the                                  Photo Courtesy of U.S. Coast Guard
ship.”                                                                        Within the engine control room, there are visual
    Two fatalities resulted from the fire. The vessel’s third assistant
                                                                              and audible alarms, called the Tank Level Indicator,
engineer was found on the 03 level inside the fidley about 12 feet from
                                                                              that actuates when the bilges or any liquid storage,
the fire door leading to the galley. The wiper (the most junior engine
room crew member) drowned in the Cape Fear river after jumping                settling, or service tank has reached a high or low
overboard through the open port sideport door to escape the engine            level. Previous problems with the TLI had resulted
room. Although a crew member tossed the wiper several life rings, he          in creative alterations to the system.
was unable to reach them before disappearing from sight.
    Thick smoke limited access to emergency gear stored where the crew
had been trained to muster. No attempts were made to shut any watertight
or fire doors to form a fire boundary around the engine room. Soon the
fire fighting effort was limited to cooling the main deck and forcing
water down the supply vents.
    Sunny Point terminal firefighters arrived within 10 minutes of the
first alarm. At the time of the call, only nine terminal personnel were on
duty, including the dispatcher.
    “Fairly shortly after the federal fire department responded they
called the Brunswick County 911 center requesting mutual aid,” Sledge
said. “Our volunteer department is the closest to the terminal. By the
time the emergency was over, every fire department within a five-
county area had some amount of equipment or personnel there.”
    Southport, population 2,300, is an idyllic community near the mouth
of the Cape Fear river that has served as a location for television shows
like “Dawson’s Creek” and several movies. Before the fire aboard the
Edward A. Carter, Jr., the closest thing to marine fire fighting handled
by the volunteer department involved the city’s small boat marina,
Sledge said.
    “It’s become less commercial and more tourist oriented now, but we
used to have a lot of commercial fishing boats,” Sledge said. “My
department has been to a lot of boat fires, but the biggest of those was
a 40- or 50-foot shrimp boat.”
    That inexperience would hinder fire fighting operation. Any cargo
vessel weighing more than 500 gross tons is required to have an
international shore connection permitting the shipboard fire main systems
to be charged from another source. Unfortunately, an accident damaged
                                                                                                          SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008                13
                                                                                                                          Photo Courtesy of The State Port Pilot

the hand-wheel controlling the starboard aft end connection.                produced a great deal of steam. Radio contact could not be established
    “Somebody stood up on top of the handle and broke it off,” Sledge       because of the vessel’s metal structure. Firefighters relayed information
said. “We weren’t able to open that valve.”                                 to the incident command through a messenger system.
    The crew failed to alert firefighters responding from onshore that a        At about 6 p.m. the vessel’s emergency generator failed. After
second shore connection was available along the port aft end of the         attempts to restart it failed, firefighters ordered the ship’s crew to
second deck.                                                                evacuate to shore. By this time, the shoreside fire response included
    Likewise, the ship’s fire control plan was mislaid after an initial     nearly 150 firefighters from 30 surrounding volunteer, city and county
review by firefighters upon arrival. The firefighters were unaware that     fire departments.
a duplicate of the fire plan was kept on the vessel’s main deck.                About 20 minutes later, a 32-foot fire boat from the Wilmington
    “We went for hours where they couldn’t find the plans,” Sledge said.    (NC) Fire Department arrived on scene. The fire boat was directed to
“That didn’t help.”                                                         use their monitor to cool the sideshell plating along the port side of the
    Key personnel in the Southport VFD could call upon their experience     engine room space and two cargo holds. A fire boat operated by the
as industrial emergency responders. The fire chief worked at a nearby       terminal was not available until approximately 8 p.m. because it was
Archer Daniels Midland citric acid plant Sledge was an operator and         only manned during regular business hours Monday through Friday.
shift brigade commander at the two-unit, 1,875 megawatt Brunswick           Once the terminal’s boat arrived, three monitors delivering 7,500 gpm
Nuclear Plant located next to the military terminal.                        were directed to cool the aft end of the engine room exhaust stack above
    The first challenge faced by arriving firefighters was gaining access   the main deck.
to the vessel, Sledge said. The open sideport door provided the most            During most of the fire, the Southport VFD responders found
immediate access to the engine room. However, crossing the gap between      themselves applying water from a catwalk overlooking the engine room.
the vessel and the wharf would be the first test of courage for the             “That night after the fire was extinguished and the smoke cleared, I
firefighters.                                                               went back,” Sledge said. “Past the railing you were looking at the top of
    “They had put down a gang plank between the vessel and the wharf,”      the diesel engine. It was a 15- to 20-foot drop in some places.”
Sledge said. “It was scary crawling across this board 15 or 20 feet above       Worse than the blindness was the heat, Sledge said.
the water. It was very unstable, what with the movement of the ship             “It was a matter of just going in and gritting it out,” he said. “It was
and everything.”                                                            the hottest fire I’ve ever experienced. It was like walking into an oven.”
    Six firefighters gained access into the engine room with two charged        What the Southport VFD lacked in experience it made up for in
hoses through the open starboard sideport door. The fire hoses were         equipment. It was the closest department that owned a thermal imaging
charged by fire trucks located on the wharf, which were supplied water      camera. Brought aboard after the first 90 minutes of fire fighting, that
from nearby fire hydrants. Firefighters did not use any of the vessel’s     camera became an important tool in locating the fire deep in the smoke-
fire hoses because the pressure was too low.                                clogged innards of the burning vessel.
    Once aboard the vessel, the firefighters were reduced to working            “The camera allowed for better stream placement and foam
blind because of the intense smoke.                                         application,” Sledge said.
    “You couldn’t see the fire but you knew what general direction it           With the camera identifying hot spots, two fire teams were able to
was in,” Sledge said. “So we were just shooting water in that direction.    move further in the engine room. The camera identified the highest
Probably a lot of that water was not effective. You had no way of           concentration of heat right below the main engine.
knowing.”                                                                       The fire was declared under control by 10 p.m. and extinguished by
    Two teams were set up inside the engine room, one on either side of     1:30 a.m. on Sunday.
the engine. The teams used a water and foam mixture to cool the hotspots        Firefighters with the terminal brigade routinely train in marine fire
which were predominately located below the main engine in the aft           fighting. But despite the July 2001 fire, training for marine fire fighting
sections of the engine room.                                                on the scale this emergency required remained a low priority for most
    Firefighters used 1,300 gallons of AFFF against the fire. The team      area fire departments, Sledge said.
was initially unable to advance through the engine room due to the              “That was literally the one time that I have done anything like that
intense smoke and heat. Water sprayed into the back of the main engine      in the 25-plus years I have been with the department.”                    C
14    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008   15
                                                                                    for the entire site will take care of it.”
                                                                                        Burkart’s comments follow a July 20th accident at a Houston refinery
                                                                                    in which a 30-story-tall crane capable of lifting one million pounds
                                                                                    collapsed, killing four employees of the contractor hired for the specific
                                                                                    lift.
                                                                                        The crane had been assembled to lift the top off a coker unit in order
                                                                                    to replace the drum. However, the collapse occurred prior to that
                                                                                    operation. An investigation is being conducted by the Occupational
                                                                                    Health and Safety Administration (OSHA).
                                                                                        Two high profile construction crane collapses in New York City that
                                                                                    involved fatalities earlier this year had focused attention on crane safety
                                                                                    even before the Houston incident. In the week following the Houston
                                                                                    collapse, fatality accidents involving cranes were reported in Smithville,
                                                                                    TX, and Normal, IL.
                                                                                        Burkart is president of his own consulting firm, Aegis Corporation.
                                                                                    He has been involved in construction litigation and has served as an
                                                                                    expert witness for OSHA and many of the country’s most well-known
                                                                                    law firms. A widely published author, he also serves on American Society
                                                                                    of Civil Engineers construction site safety committee as well as other
                                                                                    committees governing the construction industry.
                                                                                        An industrial fire chief should take an early interest in any big lifts
                                                                                    scheduled for his facility, Burkart said.
                                                                                        “The fire chief should ask a) what is the crane going to be picking up
                                                                                    and b) what is it going to be swinging over?” he said. “These cranes have
                                                                                    a long reach. If you’re reaching over places where people are working
                                                                                    and where there are hazardous materials, you need to give it a second
                                                                                    thought.”
                                                                                        Before a lift is made, a lift plan is formulated. It describes the machine,
                                                                                    its capacity, what is being lifted, where it is going to be picked up from,
                                                                                    where it is going to be set down, the radius the crane will operate within
                                            USCG photo by PA3 Christopher Grisafe   and a general description of the rigging and all the lifting devices that
Workers assess damage after a construction crane crashed                            might be used.
atop a floating fuel pier at Auke Bay Harbor, AK.                                       Emergency response is not usually part of the lift plan, Burkart said.
                                                                                    That is usually left to the facility’s overall emergency action plan.
Crane safety makes national headlines                                               However, that action plan rarely addresses the specifics of a crane
                                                                                    accident.
following accident at Houston refinery                                                  “The crane is treated as just another piece of equipment,” Burkart
                                                                                    said.




Failure
                                                                                        Given the congested nature of most industrial facilities, avoiding all
                                                                                    risk when developing a lift plan is not always practical, he said.
                                                                                        “You’re going to have to identify the risks, probably pick the least
                                                                                    hazardous and develop your own plan for dealing with that area of the
                                                                                    plant if something does happen,” Burkart said.
                                                                                        ANSI A10 standards govern construction and demolitions operations.




To Lift
                                                                                    Among Burkart’s current projects is developing an A10 standard for
                                                                                    emergency response plans. Current OSHA crane standards were
                                                                                    promulgated in the agency’s early days and have not changed since the
                                                                                    1970s.
                                                                                          “The real difficulty when a catastrophe occurs on a construction
                                                                                    site is coordinating and controlling what goes on,” Burkart said. “You
                               By ANTON RIECHER/IFW Editor                          have to have someone in charge. But that person may not be in the
                                                                                    construction business or know much about it.”
                                                                                        Too often, the first step taken by emergency responders is to run off



A
               ccidents involving construction cranes are not usually
               identified in an industrial facility’s emergency action plan         anyone with construction expertise, he said. Construction supervisors
               as a specific hazard, said crane expert Matthew Burkart.             should integrate emergency personnel into the project at an earlier stage.
               Unfortunately, the risk is not usually addressed in the                  “Don’t wait until you have an emergency,” Burkart said. “Go down
               specific lift plan governing the crane’s operation either.           and grab hold of these rescue people whether they are industrial,
  “I’ve lifted over chemical vessels, nuclear vessels and oil refineries,”          municipal or volunteer firefighters. Get them out to the site to size up
Burkart said. “The lift plan is intended to keep things from going wrong.           the hazard potential and confer on actions to reduce risks. Take the
The assumption is that if it does go wrong the emergency action plan                opportunity to stage emergency responders in the safe zone.”                 C

16    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
INDUSTRY NEWS

Federal Signal announces E-ONE sale
F
       ederal Signal Corporation (NYSE: FSS), a leader in advancing            Jim Goodwin, interim CEO, stated, “We are pleased to be nearing
       security and well-being, announced in July that it has signed a     completion of this divestiture. The E-ONE employees in Ocala have
       definitive agreement to sell E-ONE, a manufacturer of fire          been a part of Federal Signal for many years. With a strong management
apparatus located in Ocala, FL, for approximately $20 million to           team led by Peter Guile, and the experience of American Industrial
American Industrial Partners. AIP has confirmed that E-ONE                 Partners, I am confident that the future of E-ONE is in good hands and
management will invest alongside AIP as significant shareholders of the    that they will be able to focus on continuing to build quality, innovative
company. The transaction is expected to close by mid-August. BMO           fire apparatus and growing their customer base. I would like to thank all
Capital Markets has acted as the exclusive financial advisor to Federal    of the E-ONE employees as well as the dealers and customers who have
Signal on the deal.                                                        supported E-ONE while it has been part of Federal Signal.”               C




   Alabama fire school                                                        First Attack nozzles
   assumes new name                                                           wins 1st distributor
                                                                              F
                                                                                       errara Apparatus of Holden, LA, has agreed to serve as

   T
           he Oliver Field Emergency Response Training Center near
           Mobile, AL, that reopened in April 2007 after being closed                  distributor for International Fog Inc.’s First Attack pierc-
           nearly seven years, is now operating under a new name --                    ing fog nozzle in the southern United States, said First
   The Gulf Coast Emergency Response Academy.                                 Attack inventor Eugene Ivy.
      Mike McCreary, a co-owner in the company that reopened                      Ferrara is the first company to sign up as a distributor of the
   the facility, has joined with a new group to buy out control of the        First Attack nozzle, a slender device with a stainless steel tip
   academy, said James W. Kiesling, one of those involved in the              honed to a 25 degree angle. Behind this piercing tip is a rotating
   purchase. Kiesling is a captain with the Fire Department of New            sleeve made from Kevlar that creates a 30-foot diameter fog pat-
   York’s special operations command.                                         tern.
      The 52-acre site is mainly set up for industrial training but               Available in two, three and four foot lengths, the First Attack
   plans are to expand beyond that, Kiesling said.                            normally operates in a water pressure range between 50 to 225
      “There are numerous haz mat (tanker trucks, rail cars, etc.)            psi. However, Ivy has tested it at as much as 400 psi.
   props and numerous confined space entries (above and below                     Ivy, a former Port Arthur, TX, firefighter, designed First At-
   ground),” Kiesling said. “A local steel mill that is currently under       tack for volunteer fire departments with limited manpower and
   construction has expressed an interest in duplicating some of their        water resources. It atomizes water into a fog pattern of droplets
   extensive underground system on our site.”                                 sized anywhere between five and 20 microns. The nozzle pro-
      The fire school is built around a four-story industrial mock-up         duces a shield that can reduce the amount of heat reaching the
   that can simulate as many as 30 different fire scenarios, including        firefighter by 80 percent.
   mishaps involving chemical process, railcar loading, pumps, tanks,             Ferrara is a leading manufacturer of fire and rescue apparatus.
   vessels, flanges, overhead pipe rack, acetylene cutting torches and        The company has apparatus in service in 35 major U.S. cities,
   electrical transformers.                                                   China, South America, the Middle East and The Philippines.
      The fire training academy was originally owned by the past                  “We welcome Ferrara is our first distributor,” Ivy said. “We
   Greater Mobile Industrial Association, a not-for-profit industrial         are looking for others as well to represent us in other regions of
   mutual aid organization.                                          C        the U.S.”                                                          C




CSB probes fatal Houston heat exchanger rupture
T
       he U.S. Chemical Safety Board (CSB) announced in August that        exchanger, while ammonia flowed through a cylindrical steel shell that
       it is proceeding with an investigation of the causes of a recent    surrounded the tubes.
       accident at a rubber manufacturing facility in southeast Houston,      The day prior to the accident, the process was shut down for
in which one employee was killed and seven others were injured,            cleaning. During the shutdown, an isolation valve was closed between
including contract workers who were exposed to anhydrousammonia.           the heat exchanger and a pressure-relief device designed to protect the
   CSB investigators have now completed two week-long visits to the        heat exchanger from possible over-pressure. On the morning of the
plant conducting interviews and gathering other evidence.                  accident, an operator used steam to clean out process piping; the steam
   The accident occurred on June 11 during a maintenance operation on      also flowed through the heat exchanger tubes. The steam heated the
a heat exchanger, which used pressurized, liquid ammonia to cool           liquid ammonia remaining in the exchanger shell which caused the pressure
chemicals that are later processed to make synthetic rubber. The rubber-   to build. With the path to the pressure-relief device blocked, the heat
making chemicals were pumped through steel tubes inside the heat           exchanger ruptured catastrophically.                                   C

                                                                                                             SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008               17
                                Photos by Anton Riecher

At far right, the new process unit prop at
TEEX’s Emergency Services Training Insti-
tute is fired up. At top, firefighters work their
way up to the top level of the burning prop.
Immediately above, firefighters move against
a ground fire at the base of the unit. At im-
mediate right, a firefighter organizes for the
next test as instructors discuss the first fire.

Emergency Services Training Institute initiates new process unit replicia

                                                           Proper
18   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
                                                          Respect
O
             n July 14, Brayton Fire Training Field’s new prop – Prop         important concern and we can always burn the new prop tomorrow.”
             No. 31/Process Unit – was planned to be used for training           At its highest point, the process unit stands an amazing 66 feet tall
             for the first time. It’s the largest live prop on the largest    and is a multi-level prop encompassing 21,608 square feet. It boasts six
             live-fueled fire training facility in the world.                 fixed monitors and burns LPG and E3 fuel.
   At approximately 3:50 p.m. – literally seconds after the prop was lit         The project contains 18 dual-fuel leak points, although not all are lit
– the lightning prediction system sounded at the fire field. The prop         at once. The valve station controlling the project is 12 feet wide to
was shut down and firefighters on hand to attend the 46th annual Industrial   accommodate the large number of valves involved. The project can
Fire Training School had to clear the field.                                  simulate various scenarios such as a process sump fire, truck-loading
   Safety is always the top priority at the Texas Engineering Extension       area fire and various other process unit-related emergency situations.
Service’s Emergency Services Training Institute in College Station, TX.          Cost of the new prop exceeded $1 million.
The lightning prediction system is an automatic signal to clear the field.       The first test burn on the new prop, which involved fire field
   “There were a lot of people who were here to see the new prop              instructors only, was held on June 16. A successful training burn for
burn,” said Ron Peddy, lead safety official. “But, safety is our most         instructors was conducted on July 12.                                   C
                                                                                                                SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008             19
At top,students
attending the
TEEX Industrial
Fire School at
the Emergency
Services Train-
ing Institute deal
with a critical ex-
posure at the
tank and dike
project. Above,
at right, an in-
structor advises
on connecting a
fire hose. At
right, an instruc-
tor supervises a
hose team. Be-
low, a hose team
tackles the tank
and dike project.
Below, at right, a
firefighter suits
up to train.




20   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
Industrial emergency responders gather for fire training in Texas



Friendly Fire
T
               hree million inhabitants of the Caribbean nation of Jamaica          “It is important for purposes of insurance that we be certified under
                depend on a single refinery, Petrojam Ltd., to provide          NFPA 1081 exterior structural fire fighting,” Soso said.
                their petroleum. For that reason, Sean Soso and other               Certification was an important issue to many of the firefighters on
                refinery employees attended the 46th annual Industrial          hand this year. Whereas exterior structural fire fighting has been the
                Fire School at the Emergency Services Training Institute        chief concern in year’s past, certification under NFPA 1081 interior
                in College Station, TX.                                         structural fire fighting has also become a focus. Joseph Melton, an
   “The fact is we’re working at a refinery and there is a likelihood of        operator at the ExxonMobil refinery in Baytown, TX, was one such
fire at any time,” Soso said. “We are the first people to respond.”             firefighter.
   More than 580 industrial firefighters and safety personnel representing          “Most of us have industrial certification and we had to come get the
23 states and 10 countries attended the July fire school held at the Texas      interior part to deal with fires inside control rooms, trailers and office
Engineering Extension Service’s Brayton Fire Training Field.                    buildings,” Melton said. “It’s an area that we have overlooked in the
   Firefighters from The Bahamas, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia,              past.”
Equatorial Guinea, Jamaica, Mexico, Trinidad and the United States                  Working beside the students on the fire field are the instructors.
attended the industrial school.                                                 More than 200 highly qualified guest instructors and speakers from
   Brayton boasts more than 100 specific training sites or “props,”             industrial and manufacturing companies trained the emergency responders
many of them live-fire, fueled training replicas representing everything        through extensive classroom and hands-on exercises.
from oil tankers to refineries.                                                     Melvin Templeton, a safety inspector with Eastman Chemical in
   Soso said he was a first time visitor to the school. On the first day of     Longview, TX, has helped manage the LPG training prop for five years.
live-fire exercises, he and his Jamaican colleagues trained using the railcar   However, he resists being dubbed an expert.
loading rack prop.                                                                  “You’re never an expert,” Templeton said. “If you’ve been in the




                                                                                                                  SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008             21
                                business 50 years, you’re never an expert. There is always something
                                you don’t know and need to learn.”
                                   Kevin Parker, an operator at the Marathon refinery in Texas City,
                                TX, visited the fire school for the first time in three years to obtain his
                                NFPA 1081 exterior fire fighting certification. A fire marshal for Union
                                Carbide for 17 years before joining Marathon, Parker formerly served
                                as an instructor at the industrial fire school.
                                   “It’s good for beginners and it’s also good for senior people,” Parker
                                said. “You get to go through the different projects and different
                                experiences. Some of those you can use inside the plant.”
                                   Parker, who also served as a municipal firefighter in Texas City, only
                                recently joined the fire brigade at Marathon.
                                   “I promised my wife I wouldn’t join,” Parker said. “The next thing
                                I know somebody told her I was on the fire brigade again.” He said the
                                couple has since made peace over the issue.                              C




Above, firefighters move into
position to tackle the pipe
alley project at TEEX’s Emer-
gency Services Training In-
stitute. Above, at right,
firefighters are carefully
monitored for any signs of
heat exhaustion. At immedi-
ate right, the first blazing
moments after the railcar
loading project is ignited.




22   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
INCIDENT LOG                Underline Items Denote Fatality                                                For August Incident Logs, Visit www.fireworld.com

July 1 – Birmingham, UK: A fire broke out at           explosions were reported at a metals              broke out at a beauty supply plant.
a factory in the center of the city.                   processing plant.                                 July 8 – Tonawanda, NY: A grass fire spread
July 1 – Cedar Rapids, IA: 3 workers were              July 4 – Ferndale, MI: A chemical plant pump      to a large tank of tar at a coking plant.
injured in an accident involving an elevator shaft     used to transfer polymer disintegrated in use,    July 8 – Wells Twp., MI: 2 workers were
at a cereal plant warehouse.                           triggering an evacuation.                         burned in a paper mill accident.
July 1 – Godfrey, IL: A fire in a vacuum               July 4 – Industriepark Hochst, Germany: A         July 9 – Alton, IA: A grain dust explosion in
system forced a plastics plant evacuation.             water curtain was used by refinery firefighters   an elevator set fire to 60,000 bushels of corn.
July 1 – Grandview, WA: An electrical fire             after diphyl fumes were released.                 July 9 – Blackpool, UK: Explosions and fire
spread through a food processing plant.                July 4 – Kearny, NJ: An electrical fire at a      were reported at a factory.
July 1 – Hardin County, TX: Lightning ignited          power plant sent smoke billowing into the sky.    July 9 – Blount County, IN: A fire broke out
a fire in a tank battery at an oil transfer station.   July 4 – Tarbock Green, UK: A blaze at an         at an aluminum plant.
July 1 – Lubeck, WV: A transformer exploded            ink factory threatened to ignite highly           July 9 – Cedar Rapids, IA: A rail car valve
at a plastics recycling plant.                         flammable solvents.                               leaked hydrochloric acid at an agricultural
July 1 – Milford, CN: Firefighters were tested         July 5 – Clinton, PA: Heavy smoke resulted        products plant.
for toxic exposure after a paint factory fire.         from a fire at a fertilizer plant.                July 9 – Chalan Piao, China: Fire destroyed
July 1 – Niigata, Japan: Fire broke out in the         July 5 – Kerteh, Kuala Lumpur: A flash fire       a garment factory.
dryer ductwork at an ethanol plant.                    at a power distribution station shut down a gas   July 9 – Crystal Lake, IL:A fire damaged a
July 1 – Plock, Poland: A refinery fire injured        processing plant.                                 plant manufacturing process equipment.
2 workers.                                             July 5 – Mataura, New Zealand: A wood dust        July 9 – Kingsport, TN: A lightning strike
July 1 – Sakai, Japan: A small fire near a             explosion at a factory injured one worker.        interrupted production at an ammunition plant.
crude distillation unit was enough for officials       July 5 – Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan: A truck         July 9 – Medellin de Brave, Mexico: A man
to shut down production at an oil refinery.            with 43,000 pounds of dynamite caught fire.       received severe burns when an industrial
July 1 – Sitra, Bahrain: Fire destroyed a paint        July 6 – Kentland, IN: A fire at a plastics       alcohol warehouse exploded.
factory.                                               plant filled the air with acrid smoke.            July 9 – Morfeklen-Waldorf, Germany: A
July 1 – Winchester, KY: A small fire broke            July 6 – Mitchell, SD: A rail car loaded with     phosphoric acid release was reported at a
out at a biodiesel plant.                              smeltering byproducts began leaking fumes.        refinery.
July 1 – Edison, NJ: Trace amounts of                  July 6 – Muhlenberg, PA: Ammonia leaked           July 9 – North Somerset, UK: Fire erupted
cadmium leaked at an avionics plant.                   at a dairy plant.                                 in a paint booth at a plant specializing in molds
July 2 – Crystal Lake, IL: Fumes ignited in a          July 7 – Arteixo, Spain: A wildfire threatened    and casts.
paint booth, severely damaging a plant                 a refinery.                                       July 9 – Somerset, UK: Local residents were
specializing in conveyor systems.                      July 7 – Bollene, France: Nearly 8,000 gallons    evacuated when fire broke out at a factory.
July 2 – Louisville, KY: A reaction in a methyl-       of solution containing a low level of uranium     July 10 – Angola, IN: A plant for repackaging
methacrylate railcar triggered a hazmat                spilled at a power plant, entering two rivers.    firewood was destroyed by fire.
emergency at a chemical plant.                         July 7 – Clyde, OH: An appliance factory          July 10 – Bastrop, TX: Oil leaking on a hot
July 2 – New Milford, CN: 2 paper mill workers         worker suffered a head injury.                    power plant turbine ignited.
became ill after being exposed to vapor venting        July 7 – Kurashiki, Japan: Nearly 250 gallons     July 10 – Belgachia, India: Fire broke out in
from a tank of bleach.                                 of sulfuric acid leaked at an oil refinery.       a heat treatment factory.
July 2 – Newport Beach, CA: A 300-gallon               July 7 – Porto, Portugal: Fire destroyed a        July 10 – Burns Harbor, IN: A coke oven at
barrel of overheated hypoxy triggered an               chemical warehouse at an industrial park.         a steel foundry began leaking carbon
evacuation at an adhesives plant.                      July 7 – Royal City, WA: Several thousand         monoxide, forcing workers to evacuate.
July 2 – Savannah, GA: 3 men were injured              wood pallets surrounding anhydrous ammonia        July 10 – College Grove, MN: Natural gas
in an explosion at an aerospace manufacturer.          tanks caught fire.                                ignited in a heat recovery unit at a power plant.
July 2 – Wilmington, DE: A worker at an ash            July 7 – Tacoma, WA: Partially refined crude      July 10 – Corpus Christi, TX: The Coast
processing plant was trapped 30 feet in the air        oil spewed from a vent stack when a power         Guard established a one-mile safety zone after
by a conveyor belt.                                    outage shut down a refinery.                      a vessel released chloride monomer fumes.
July 2 – York, NE: Fire broke out in the dryer         July 7 – Taiz, Yemen: An electrical fire spread   July 10 – Hastings, UK: A furniture plant
ductwork at an ethanol plant.                          through a biscuit factory.                        warehouse burned.
July 3 – City of Industry, CA: A fire broke            July 7 – West Palm Beach, FL: A concrete          July 10 – Oxnard, CA: A fire in a water cleaning
out at a plastics plant.                               recycling plant worker was trapped beneath        machine damaged a saw making plant.
July 3 – Cork, Ireland: Hydrochloric acid              fallen debris.                                    July 10 – Port Adelaide, Australia: A small
leaked at a fertilizer plant.                          July 7 – Wheatfield, NY: A furnace fire broke     fire damaged a factory.
July 3 – Elyria, OH: A 4-story factory used            out at a chemical plant.                          July 10 – Red Bay, AL: An auto parts plant
for making sinks was destroyed by fire.                July 8 – Belle, WV: Pressure built inside a       worker was injured when he caught his arm in
July 3 – Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta: A                 tanker car when flammable liquid penetrated       machinery.
storage well at a chemical plant began leaking.        the inner tank.                                   July 11 – Abilene, TX: A freight company
July 3 – Hantsport, Nova Scotia: Fire spread           July 8 – Berngen, Belgium: An explosion           forklift punctured a 55-gallon drum of acetone
through the ventilation system at a power plant.       rocked a silo filled with polypropylene powder.   and methyl-ethyl-ketone.
July 3 – Jusuit Bend, LA: 3 contract workers           July 8 – Curtis Bay, MD: A contractor repairing   July 11 – Boise, ID: A manufacturing building
doing maintenance on an oil refinery steam             a valve on a sulfuric acid tank at a chemical     at a timber plant was destroyed by fire.
line were scalded by a release.                        plant was sprayed in the face.                    July 11 – Bradford, UK: 2 workers at a food
July 3 – Kahna, Pakistan: 1 person died and            July 8 – Greensboro, NC: Fire broke out in a      processing plant suffered flash burns.
11 were injured when a vessel exploded at a            dumpster at an industrial waste facility.         July 11 – Gothenburg, Sweden: A small fire
pharmaceuticals plant.                                 July 8 – Hoboken, NJ: A dust collector at a       broke out on the roof of a turbine building at a
July 3 – Lanesburo, MN: A tanker truck                 pump valve factory was destroyed by fire.         nuclear power plant.
spilled more than 3,000 gallons of ethanol.            July 8 – Northampton, PA: A sprinkler             July 11 – Green River, WY: Fire broke out on
July 3 – Xinjiang, China: 7 people died in an          system extinguished a smoke fire at a plant       the roof of a soda ash plant.
oil tank explosion.                                    that processes waste plastics.                    July 11 – Kiev, Ukraine: 4 workers died when
July 4 – Boode Guarnizo, Spain: Several                July 8 – Omaha, NE: A fire fueled by acetone      oxygen tanks exploded at a metals factory.
                                                                                                                  SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008               23
July 11 – Neptune, NJ: An electrician was           July 16 – Arjun Nagar, Pakistan: An                 July 21 – Chignik Bay, AK: Fire gutted a
injured by a flash fire at an electronics plant.    ammonia release followed an explosion at an         seafood processing plant.
July 11 – Paterson, NJ: A water tower at a          ice factory.                                        July 21 – Lafourche, LA: An ammonia leak
cable manufacturing plant burned.                   July 16 – Athens, Greece: 3 factories               at a shrimp processing plant halted traffic
July 11 – Rothschild, WI: A sulfur storage          producing timber products and auto parts            nearly 3 hours.
bin caught fire at a power plant.                   were destroyed by a forest fire.                    July 21 – Louisville, KY: Production resumed
July 11 – Rye, UK: Flames spread from a             July 16 – Bedfordshire, UK: A factory for           shortly after a fire at a bakery plant.
factory spray booth.                                Formula One racing cars caught fire.                July 21 – Manchester, UK: At least 1 gas
July 11 – Seattle, WA: Smoke rose over a            July 16 – Inoi, Greece: A forest fire threatened    cylinder detonated during a lengthy fire at a
cement plant.                                       a munitions factory.                                pallet factory.
July 12 – Crossville, TN: A tanker crash            July 16 – Kaesong, N. Korea: A worker died          July 21 – Mildred Lake, AB: An oil refinery
spilled titanium tetrachloride on the interstate.   when a steel frame at an industrial complex         worker collapsed while inside a vessel used
July 12 – Lower Heidelburg, PA: An                  collapsed.                                          to clean hydrocarbons.
aluminum foundry worker doing repair work           July 16 – Kenly, NC: An evacuation was              July 21 – Minas Gerais, Brazil: A fire broke
died when he fell 12 feet.                          ordered when vapor escaped from a tanker            out in a delayed coker at an oil refinery.
July 12 – Melksham, UK: Fire broke out at a         truck hauling silicon tetra fluoride.               July 21 – Mount Pleasant, TX: A firefighter
tire factory.                                       July 16 – Lynchberg, VA: Baling equipment           received minor injuries from a fire at a food
July 13 – Ashland, NY: Fire destroyed a             caught fire at a corrugated cardboard factory.      processing plant.
tannery.                                            July 16 – Miami, FL: A concrete recycling           July 21 – Muskegon County, MI: A major
July 13 – Minneapolis, MN: A fire at a              plant worker was crushed to death by a loader.      highway was closed when ethanol spilled while
recycling plant threatened nearby buildings.        July 16 – Solihull, UK: Fire destroyed a plant      an overturned tanker was being emptied.
July 13 – Moscow, Russia: A power failure           that mades curtains and blinds.                     July 21 – Paso Robles, CA: An outbuilding at
triggered a release of gas at an oil refinery.      July 16 – Tullamore, Ireland: Sprinklers            a chemical plant caught fire.
July 13 – Potter, PA: Zinc oxide fueled a fire      contained a fire at a candle factory.               July 21 – Salix, IA: A worker at an agricultural
at a metals plant.                                  July 17 – Butte, MT: An acetylene tank              plant died when he was buried in soybeans.
July 13 – Sana’a City, Yemen: 1 worker died         caught fire at a metal processing facility.         July 21 – Thibodaux, LA: An ammonia leak
and 4 were injured in a gas factory explosion.      July 17 – Coldwater, MI: Fire broke out in the      at a seafood processing plant closed down
July 13 – Starkville, MS: Fire started in a         furnace room of a brake parts plant.                area traffic for three hours.
ventilation system at a furniture plant.            July 17 – Shanghai, China: Three firefighters       July 22 – Columbia, TN: An overturned
July 14 – Baytown, TX: A small flash fire was       died battling a plastics factory blaze.             tanker leaking argon injured two people.
reported at an oil refinery.                        July 18 – East Bridgewater, MA: An electrical       July 22 – Esmeraldas, Ecuador: A gas leak
July 14 – Elwood, IN: Fire spread through a         fire broke out at a meat packing plant.             at a refinery caused concern.
paint room at an auto parts plant.                  July 18 – Grand Blanc, MI: A sulfuric acid          July 22 – Martinsville, VA: Fire broke out at
July 14 – Mansfield, LA: Vapor from mixing          tank exploded at a factory.                         a furniture finishing plant.
paints threatened to ignite at a power plant.       July 18 – Hawke’s Bay, New Zealand:                 July 22 – Mt. Clemens, MI: A solvent spill
July 14 – New Haven, IN: A stack of 55-             Flames from a cold storage facility threatened      disrupted operations at a car finishes plant.
gallon drums containing hydrofluoric acid           an ammonia plant.                                   July 22 – Naperville, IL: A dust system caught
collapsed at a chemical plant.                      July 18 – Leggiuno, Italy: An explosion             fire at a plant specializing in plastic coloring.
July 14 – Les Roces, Spain: An explosion            occurred at a hydrogen peroxide maker.              July 22 – Schwarza, Germany: A chemical
occurred in a sawdust silo.                         July 18 – Perris, CA: A plastics recycling          tank exploded at a metalworking plant.
July 14 – Oak Ridge, TN: Workers evacuated          worker died when he was pulled into the             July 22 – Toowoomba, Australia: Fire
a waste processing plant when a chemical            rotating blades of some heavy equipment.            spread inside an 80-ton grain silo.
reaction produced yellow smoke.                     July 18 – Saginaw County, MI: A pipe                July 22 – Toronto, ON: Corrosive hydrogen
July 14 – Rockdale, Australia: A chemical           ruptured at a semi-conductor plant, releasing       peroxide leaked from a storage tank at an
spill at a factory forced neighboring businesses    silicon vapor.                                      empty dye plant.
to evacuate.                                        July 18 – Stamford, CN: A fire at a pool            July 23 – Almelo, Netherlands: An explosion
July 14 – Springfield, MO: Responders were          chemicals warehouse resulted in 13 police           rocked a plant where centrifuges for
decontaminated after exposure to onion juice        officers being treated for toxic exposure.          separating uranium were made.
during a food processing plant fire.                July 18 – Williston, FL: Fire erupted at a          July 23 – Detroit, MI: An auto plant employee
July 14 – Tiffin, OH: An equipment fire broke       water bottling plant.                               was crushed to death by machinery.
out at a furniture factory.                         July 19 – Essex, UK: A press drying machine         July 23 – Mt. Eden, New Zealand: Fire broke
July 15 – Baytown, TX: A small flash fire at        caught fire at a printing plant.                    out at a foundry for precious metals.
an oil refinery was put out with a steam lance.     July 19 – Harrison Twp., PA: A 3-hour blaze         July 23 – Offenbach, Germany: A rail tanker
July 15 – Camp Taylor, KY: A fire broke out         broke out at a specialty metals manufacturer.       leaked crotonaldehyde in a freight station.
in two overheated asphalt processing tanks.         July 19 – Ludwigstad, Germany: A fire broke         July 23 – Willemstad, Netherlands Antilles:
July 15 – Elgin, IL: A worker at an aluminum        out in a filtering unit of a melting furnace at a   Fire broke out in an oil refinery distillation unit.
products plant was splashed with sulfuric acid.     metallurgical plant.                                July 23 – York, PA: A transformer at a nuclear
July 15 – Fagras, Romania: 2 people were            July 19 – Rush Twp., PA: Several firefighters       power station caught fire.
missing after an explosion during demolition at     suffered heat exhaustion at a manufacturing         July 24 – Auckland, New Zealand:
an aggregate plant.                                 plant specializing in aluminum flake pigment.       Firefighters may have been exposed to arsenic
July 15 – Graham, TX: A fire at a plant for         July 19 – St. Charles, IL: Fire spread through      during a fire at a metals factory.
flotation devices severely injured 3 workers.       the high rack storage in a chemical plant           July 24 – Cameron, TX: Fire broke out at a
July 15 – Louisville, KY: A fire at an asphalt      warehouse.                                          pipe plant.
plant produced thick smoke.                         July 20 – Frisco, TX: Fire broke out at an          July 24 – Fort McMurray, AB: A pipeline at a
July 15 – Marion, PA: An explosion rocked a         electronics plant.                                  tar sands operation was vandalized.
fireplace manufacturer.                             July 20 – Jundiz, Spain: A worker at an             July 24 – Harmattan, AB: A fire in a heater
July 15 – Panaktos, Greece: A forest fire           industrial products plant was struck by a cover     closed a natural gas extraction plant.
threatened a munitions plant.                       flung during an explosion.                          July 24 – Porvoo, Finland: Phosphoric acid
July 15 – Port Arthur, TX: A refinery reported      July 21 – Betim, Brazil: A fire broke out at an     leaked from a corroded valve at an oil refinery.
a hydrogen sulfide leak.                            oil refinery.                                                            Continued on Page 31
24    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
An isolated industrial facility in southeast California buys a new
fire truck. The result is better fire protection for the entire region.

A Fire Truck for Trona                                          By ANTON RIECHER/IFW Editor




                                                                                                          Photo courtesy of Searles Valley Minerals




                                                                A
                                                                               cross California is a chain of dry pleistocene lakes which
                                                                               were formed during the Ice Ages. Today, the lake bed
                                                                               near Trona, CA, contains a plethora of sodium and po-
                                                                               tassium minerals of the carbonate, sulfate, borate and
                                                                               halide classes, due to long sedimentation and evapora-
                                                                 tion processes, which occurred over a period of about 150,000 years.
                                                                    Ed Townsend, chief of emergency services at the Searles Valley
                                                                Minerals Operations in Trona, said it feels like it took almost that long
                                                                to get an okay for his new Ferrara Intruder II pumper, collected fresh
                                                                off the assembly line in early August.
                                                                    “I was using a 1986 Boardman pumper that held 750 gallons of
                                                                water and pumped 1,250 gallons per minute,” Townsend said. “It seated


                                                                Above, the Searles Valley Minerals plant in Trona, CA. At
                                                                left, the new truck delivered to Trona in August. Below, at
                                                                left, the truck early in construction at Ferrara. Below, the
                                                                truck nearly finished.
                             Truck photos courtesy of Ferrara




                                                                                            SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008                   25
Work in progress on the
new Trona fire truck. Ferrara
customers are able to
check the current status of
work on their vehicles visu-
ally via the Internet.
                                                                                                                                       Photo courtesy of Ferrara
about two large people, and that was all.”                                    west, to the Colorado River on the east, to the Nevada State line and
   By comparison, Townsend’s new Ferrara seats five firefighters.             Kern and Inyo counties on the north.
Built from heavy duty extruded aluminum, it boasts a 400 horsepower               Trona is only one of 53 communities that the San Bernardino County
Cummins ISL-400 engine, an Allison 3000 EVS automatic transmission            Fire Department serves. That results in the brigade responding to as
and a single stage Waterous CSU pump capable of 1,500 gallons per             many as eight structural fires a month. Trona, population 1,885, has
minute. The pumper comes with a 1,000 gallon water tank and a 20              been losing residents for many years, resulting in a large number of
gallon foam tank.                                                             unoccupied houses.
   “There aren’t a whole lot of extras, but it’s sure a lot nicer than what       Searles Valley Minerals also has a mutual aid agreement with a nearby
we’ve got,” Townsend said.                                                    coal-fired power plant that serves as a public utility.
   Searles Valley Minerals manages extensive operations in California’s           Beside the new pumper, the Trona brigade operates two brush units
Searles Valley. Power and production facilities cover more than 339           referred to as “squad and rescue” units, each carrying 300 gallons of
acres at the Argus, Trona and Westend plants. Of these three, the             water. One of the trucks is kept in Trona near Townsend’s office and
Trona facility is the oldest, dating back to 1916. It uses a solvent          another is kept at a Searles Valley Mineral facility six miles away.
extraction method to recover boric acid from weak Searles Lake brines.            Townsend’s brigade trains weekly. In addition, Townsend brought in
   “We pump the brine out of the dry lake bed to get the salt crystals        Baton Rouge, LA – based Roco Rescue, specialists in confined space
we need,” Townsend said. “From that, we recover sodium sulfate and            and rope rescue training, to conduct two 100-hour classes for the
boron products.”                                                              volunteers.
   In addition to boric acid, the Trona facility produces anhydrous               “We have everyone on the brigade certified,” Townsend said. “We
borax containing low sulfate values and borax decahydrate.                    get together for rescue training twice a month for six hours and for fire
   “We have our own coal fired boilers, so we are self sufficient for         training twice a month for four hours per session. We also do 50 hours
energy,” Townsend said. “We employ about 650 employees, and 100               a year of hazmat training.”
contractors.”                                                                     All of the Trona firefighters are certified as Firefighter I in the state
   Protecting the Trona plant is a fire rescue and hazmat team consisting     of California. Townsend himself has attended training in industrial fire
of 34 volunteers. Townsend, an 18-year veteran of the plant fire brigade,     fighting at Emergency Services Training Institute in College Station,
has served as chief for the last eight. He said it was obvious that the       TX.
time had come to replace his former pumper.                                       As for large scale training exercises, the Trona volunteer gets together
   “We’ve thrown money at it and more money at it,” Townsend said.            with the county firefighters when possible, Townsend said. Often joining
“Finally, it came down to repairing the pump again. I said, ‘Wait a           them are firefighters from the Navy’s single largest facility, the China
minute – let’s stop throwing money at this and get something we can           Lake Naval Weapons Center, located about 20 miles away. The center is
really use.’”                                                                 dedicated to airborne weapons testing and training.
   The local challenge is not limited to industrial fires. The Trona              Trona’s new fire truck came close to its first emergency even before
brigade has a mutual aid agreement with the San Bernardino County             it left the Ferrara plant in Holden, LA. Tropical Storm Edouard,
Fire Department. At 20,160 square miles, San Bernardino County is             threatening the Gulf Coast, concerned Searles Valley Minerals when
the largest county in the continental United States. The fire department’s    Townsend visited Holden to pick up the finished truck.
jurisdiction encompasses 18,353 square miles of extremely diverse                 “They said bring it straight back here as safe as you can,” Townsend
environments that stretch from the Los Angeles County line on the             said.                                                                      C

26    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008   27
FINAL REPORT



February 2007 refinery blast attributed to cracked piping

Temperature Rising
A
               massive fire that injured four workers and caused the legs can pose special hazards in refineries that should be carefully
               total shutdown and evacuation of a refinery in Sunray, managed.” Holmstrom said the refinery (then owned by another
               TX, in February 2007 likely occurred after water leaked company) did not identify hazards arising from the dead-leg when it
               through a valve, froze and cracked an out-of-service was created in the 1990s and did not implement safeguards, such as
               section of piping, causing a release of high-pressure liquid removing the piping, isolating it from the process using metal plates
propane, the U.S. Chemical Safety Board (CSB) said in a final known as blinds for protecting it against freezing temperatures.
investigation report issued in July.                                            Over time, water seeped past the leaking valve and built up inside
   The CSB’s final report concluded the root causes of the accident the low point of the piping elbow. A period of cold weather in early
were that the refinery did not have an effective program to identify and February 2007 likely caused the water to freeze, expand and crack the
freeze-protect piping and equipment that was out of service or piping. On Feb. 16, the daytime temperature increased and the ice
infrequently used; that the refinery did not apply the company’s policies began to melt. At 2:09 p.m., high-pressure liquid propane flowed through
on emergency isolation valves to control fires; and that industry and the leaking valve and was released through the fractured elbow.
company standards did not recommend sufficient fireproofing of Investigators estimated that propane escaped from the pipe at an initial
structural steel against jet fires.                                          rate of 4,500 pounds per minute, quickly creating a huge flammable
   “This was a significant accident that seriously burned three people, vapor cloud, which drifted toward a boiler house where CSB investigators
shut down a major oil refinery for two months, and contributed to believe it contacted an ignition source.
gasoline shortages hundreds of miles away in Denver,” said CSB                  “Once the fire started, there was no way to shut off the supply of
Chairman John Bresland. “The CSB investigation points to a number of fuel because the refinery had not implemented company procedures
areas where oil industry practices should be improved to reduce the requiring the installation of remotely operable shutoff valves,”
likelihood and the severity of process-related fires. Fireproofing, remotely Holmstrom said. “Such valves are especially critical in high-pressure
operable shutoff valves, and effective water deluge systems can spell service to prevent large inventories of flammable material inside process
the difference between a small, quickly
contained fire and a massive blaze that
cripples a large industrial facility.”
   The fire occurred in the refinery’s
propane de-asphalting unit, which uses
high-pressure propane as a solvent to
separate gas oil from asphalt; gas oil is
used as a feedstock in other gasoline-
producing refinery processes. The
propane leaked from an ice-damaged piping
elbow that was believed to have been out
of service since the early 1990s, CSB
investigators said. Unknown to refinery
personnel, a metal object had wedged under
the gate of a manual valve above the piping
elbow, allowing liquid to flow through the
valve. Piping above the valve contained
liquid propane at high pressure, and small
amounts of water were entrained in the
propane.
   “The elbow was part of a ‘dead-leg’
formed when the piping was taken out of
service,” said CSB Investigations
Supervisor Don Holmstrom. “This was a
section of piping that remained connected
to the process but was not intended to                                                                             Photo Courtesy of U.S. Chemical Safety Board

have any flow of liquid through it. Dead- Surveillance video reveals the emergency scene 90 seconds after the first alarm.
28    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008   29
equipment from contributing to a
fire.”
    The growing fire caused the
failure of a pipe flange on a large
extractor tower filled with propane,
igniting a powerful jet fire that was
aimed directly at a major pipe bridge
carrying liquid products throughout
the refinery. Because the pipe bridge
supports were not fireproofed, they
quickly collapsed, severing process
pipes that were essential to the
operation of the refinery.
    Company and industry standards
“require fireproofing of structural
steel supports up to a maximum of
50 feet from possible fuel sources,”
Holmstrom said. “The collapse of a
non-fireproofed pipe bridge 77 feet
away from the source of the jet fire
indicates that industry practices
need to be revised.”
    The fire also caused the release
of an estimated 5,300 pounds of
toxic chlorine from three one-ton
cylinders stored 100 feet from the
fire. The chlorine, used to disinfect
cooling water, could have posed a
serious threat to emergency
responders had they not already
been evacuated, investigators said.
In addition, the fire threatened a
large spherical tank that contained
up to 151,000 gallons of highly
flammable liquid butane. As a result
of the growing fire, the valves
controlling a water deluge system
designed to cool the sphere became
inaccessible to operators and could
not be opened.
    “The consequences of this
accident could have been even more
serious, under slightly different
circumstances,” Bresland said.
“Refineries should minimize the                                                                                   Photo courtesy of U.S. Chemical Safety Board
presence of hazardous substances Crack found in the 10-inch diameter propane mix control station inlet elbow at Sunray.
near units where they may be
exposed to fire hazards and should ensure that emergency systems alternatives such as bleach. The CSB also recommended that refinery
remain operable if a disaster strikes.”                                     staff work with United Steelworkers, which represents employees at
    The CSB made recommendations to the American Petroleum Institute the plant, to upgrade hazard analysis procedures.
(API), a leading oil industry trade association that develops safety           The CSB is an independent federal agency charged with investigating
practices that are widely followed in the U.S. and overseas. The CSB industrial chemical accidents. The agency’s board members are appointed
called on the API to develop a new recommended practice for freeze- by the president and confirmed by the Senate. CSB investigations look
protection of refinery equipment and to improve existing practices into all aspects of chemical accidents, including physical causes such as
related to fireproofing, emergency isolation valves and water deluge equipment failure as well as inadequacies in regulations, industry
systems. The report also called on the refinery’s owner to improve standards and safety management systems.
freeze protection, fireproofing, hazard analysis and emergency isolation       The CSB does not issue citations or fines but does make safety
procedures at its 16 North American refineries.                             recommendations to plants, industry organizations, labor groups and
    The CSB urged the refinery to implement its strategic plan to eliminate regulatory agencies such as OSHA and EPA. Visit the CSB Web site at
the use of chlorine for water treatment in favor of inherently safer www.csb.gov.                                                                          C


30    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
Incident                                            asphalt.
                                                    July 26 – Surrey, UK: Fire spread through a
                                                    plant specializing in pharmaceutical packaging.
                                                                                                        were splattered with hot plastic from a machine
                                                                                                        used to make disposable trays.
                                                                                                        July 28 – Ulsan, S. Korea: A researcher died
Continued from Page 24
                                                    July 27 – Bucharest, Romania: An explosion          in a laboratory explosion at a chemical plant.
July 24 – Toledo, OH: A smoky fire broke out        in a sawdust dryer at a wood processing             July 29 – Brownsville, NY: Fire erupted in
at a recycling plant.                               factory injured 23 people.                          the ceiling of a fiberboard manufacturing plant.
July 24 – Tronchiennes, Belgium: A tanker           July 27 – Gardner, MA: Fire broke out at a          July 29 – Hamilton, TX: Fire broke out in the
truck filled with acid rolled on its side.          furniture factory.                                  dust control unit at a molding mill.
July 24 – Torgan, Germany: 2 workers were           July 27 – New Orleans, LA: A massive oil            July 29 – Iowa City, IA: Fire ignited on the
severely burned in an explosion at a wood           spill into the Mississippi River shut down river    roof of a detergent factory.
pellet plant.                                       traffic for days.                                   July 29 – Kitakyushu, Japan: A conveyor
July 25 – Brimingham, UK: Fire broke                July 27 – Potter Twp., PA: A fire broke out at      belt fire spread to a steel plant.
through the roof of a factory.                      a zinc plant fire.                                  July 29 – Laurel County, KY: A security
July 25 – Bridgeton, NJ: A worker fell from         July 27 – San Bernardino, CA: A machine             guard at a waste management company died
the roof of a textile plant.                        that injects preheated dye into plastic caught      when a heavy iron security gate fell on him.
July 25 – Jefferson County, OH: Machinery           fire at a plastics manufacturing plant.             July 29 – Loves Park, IL: An equipment fire
caught fire at a power plant.                       July 28 – Henley, UK: Heavy smoke made              at a machining plant spread through the facility.
July 26 – Bethlehem Twp., NJ: A worker              extinguishing a fire at an air conditioning plant   July 29 – Owego, NY: Fire tore through a
suffered serious injuries when machinery            difficult.                                          recycling plant.
exploded at a plastics processing plant.            July 28 – Hillsville, VA: Fire broke out at a       July 29 – Pori, Finland: A storage building at
July 26 – Calvert City, KY: An explosion at a       textile plant.                                      a hardboard factory caught fire.
chemical plant caused no injuries.                  July 28 – Lenoir, NC: A fire shut down a wood       July 29 – Port of Vancouver, WA: A
July 26 – Hunterdon County, NJ: A plastics          panel plant.                                        smoldering fire spread through a hopper at a
plant worker was burned in an explosion.            July 28 – Mina Abdullah, Kuwait: Six                malting plant.
July 26 – Marquion, France: Traffic was             workers were injured in a refinery fire.            July 29 – Prince George County, MD: A
interrupted for six hours when nitric acid was      July 28 – Palm Beach, FL: Firefighters used         power plant fire injured one worker.
discovered leaking from a tank truck.               dry chemical to extinguish a magnesium fire         July 29 – St. John, New Brunswick: A brief
July 26 – Newcastle, UK: A fire at a packaging      at a metal recycling plant.                         fire at an oil refinery lit up the skies.
plant sent company shares tumbling.                 July 28 – Port Neches, TX: Fire broke out at        July 29 – Tomahawk, WI: 3 workers
July 26 – Nelson, New Zealand: Fire                 a chemical plant.                                   performing maintenance atop a fiber storage
destroyed a bitumen plant.                          July 28 – Richmond, CA: A sulfuric acid spill       tank at a paper mill died in an explosion.
July 26 – Phoenix, AZ: A parked tanker truck        at an oil refinery caused no injuries.              July 29 – Wisconsin Rapids, WI: A paper
caught fire at a plant specializing in rubberized   July 28 – Rockaway Twp., NY: 2 workers                                  Continued on Page 33




                                                                                                                SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008              31
                      Photos courtesy of OSHA
Photos taken by OSHA investigators
showing the depth of sugar dust found
at a Gramercy, LA, sugar refinery.



                                                I
                                                    n the wake of a February 7 explosion that killed 13 workers at a sugar refinery
February sugar refinery blast                       near Savannah, GA, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration
results in near record fines                        (OSHA) issued citations in July proposing penalties totaling $8.7 million
                                                against a Sugarland, TX-based company and its two affiliates, the third largest
                                                fine in OSHA history.




Dust to
                                                    More than $5 million of the proposed fines were for violations at the Port
                                                Wentworth, GA, refinery. OSHA added nearly $4 million related to inspections
                                                at the company’s Gramercy, LA, refinery following the February explosion.
                                                    “I am outraged that this company would show a complete disregard for its
                                                employees’ safety by knowingly placing them in an extremely dangerous work
                                                environment,” said OSHA Assistant Secretary for Labor, Edwin G. Foulke, Jr.
                                                    Despite the explosion at Port Wentworth, the company has done little to
                                                ensure abatement of the combustible dust hazards at its other plant, he said.




  Dust
                                                    “If OSHA investigators had not inspected and posted an imminent danger
                                                notice regarding areas at the second plant, the same thing could have happened
                                                again,” Foulke said. That notice resulted in a temporary shut-down of the mill.
                                                    The company filed a notice that it intends to fight the citations.
                                                    OSHA inspections at both facilities found that there were large accumulations
                                                of combustible sugar dust in workrooms, on electrical motors and on other
                                                equipment. The investigation also determined that officials at the company
                                                were well aware of these conditions but took no action.
                                                    At the Gramercy refinery alone, accumulations on the workroom floor were
                                                measured as deep as 48 inches.
                                                    Officials theorize that cumulative sugar dust inside the packaging elevator of
                                                one of three silos caught fire. Speculation is that a bucket came loose from the
                                                elevator system, igniting the suspended sugar. A second explosion in the silo
                                                gallery and tunnel spread to the packaging house and adjacent building.
                                                    Aside from the fatalities, 40 workers were injured.
                                                    The citations included 108 instances of willful violations related to the
                                                combustible dust hazard. A willful violations was defined as a violation committed
                                                with plain indifference to, or intentional disregard for, employee safety and
                                                health. OSHA also issued 10 citations for other willful violations and 100 citations
                                                for serious violations.
                                                    The largest fine in OSHA history was $21.3 million issued against a major oil
                                                company after an explosion on March 23, 2005, at its Texas City, TX, refinery.
                                                That explosion killed 15 people and injured more than 170 others. The second
                                                largest fine was against a Louisiana fertilizer company in 1991 after an explosion
                                                that killed eight workers and injured 128 others.                                 C
32   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
Incident                                              a fire in a crude oil storage tank.
                                                      July 30 – St. George, Australia: A chocolate
Continued from Page 31                                factory was destroyed by fire.
                                                      July 30 – Summerside, UK: A generating
mill employee who suffered burns was                  engine at a power plant caught fire.
transported by helicopter.                            July 31 – Almaty, Kazakhstan: An oil spill
July 30 – Biblis, Germany: A crane struck a           briefly halted production at a steel plant.
utility line at a nuclear power plant, triggering a   July 31 – Bitola, Macedonia: A power plant
shutdown.                                             fire was quickly extinguished.
July 30 – Brisbane, Australia: A gas leak at          July 31 – Busalla, Italy: Fire engulfed an
a food processing plant sent six people to the        atmospheric distillation column.
hospital.                                             July 31 – Cardon, Venezuela: An oil refinery
July 30 – Byram, MS: An explosion and small           electrician was burned by a high voltage shock.
fire were reported at a plant that extracts oils      July 31 – Durham, UK: A tractor plant worker
from various materials.                               hurt his back in a fall.
July 30 – Catoosa, OK: Fire broke out at an           July 31 – East Lothian, UK: A worker was
industrial coatings plant.                            sprayed with chemical from a burst drum at a
July 30 – Chicago, IL: A candy plant worker           recycling center.
was crushed to death by a pallet mover.               July 31 – Jaranwak, Pakistan: Seven
July 30 – Clydach, UK: An auto suspension             workers were critically injured when fire broke
plant damaged by fire is expected to be closed        out following an explosion in a textile mill boiler.
for months.                                           July 31 – Moorabbin, Australia: A forklift
July 30 – Columbia, SC: Sparks ignited a              ruptured a high pressure gas line at a factory
gas line at a steel factory.                          making construction materials.
July 30 – Hartford, CN: A small fire broke out        July 31 – Palmasola, Bolivia: More than
at a trash-to-energy power plant.                     80,000 gallons of diesel spilled from a ruptured
July 30 – Jackson, MS: A fire broke out at a          pipeline at a refinery.
plant that processes grease from fast food            July 31 – Parkgate, UK: A steelworker
restaurants.                                          became trapped underneath a cooling bed.
July 30 – Javene, France: A worker at a               July 31 – Pensnett, UK: An office fire broke
hazmat disposal plant suffered burns when             out at a factory.
waste being handled reacted.                          July 31 – Plano, TX: Fire from a storage silo
July 30 – Indiantown, FL: A fuel pressure             incinerator spread to the roof of a paper
line ruptured at a power plant, causing a small       processing plant.
fire.                                                 July 31 – Rochester, NY: Two workers at a
July 30 – LaPlace, LA: A worker died when             metal recycling plant suffered smoke
he was pinned by a truck at a steel plant.            inhalation.
July 30 – Lee, MA: An equipment explosion             July 31 – Shelbyville, IN: Fire broke out in a
at a plate glass factory injured two.                 new warehouse at an insulation manufacturing
July 30 – Richmond, KY: Fire damaged a                plant.
battery plant.                                        July 31 – Spokane Valley, WA: Cardboard
July 30 – Rock Hill, NC: Fire forced the              ignited at a recycling plant.
evacuation of a carbon fibers plant.                  July 31 – Taunton, MA: Flames broke out at
July 30 – Seoul, S. Korea: Lightning triggered        a recycling plant.                               C


   Dave’sPage 4
   Continued from
                  Notes
   improve them.
     These examples leads to an important question for emergency responders —
   will the failure to think issues such as these through to their potential ultimate
   conclusion pose a greater danger in the future? The challenge is enhanced by
   today’s emergency responders’ more limited hands-on experience with the broad
   range of potential disasters that still rank among the less likely but still possible.
   Our planning and training must identify new emerging hazards, even from familiar
   sources, and thinking through “What if?”
     As environmental issues become increasingly important it becomes more and
   more critical for both researchers and practitioners to understand what are these
   indirect impacts and the directions these indirect environment impacts will compel
   business and economies to move towards. It sets an agenda for future research.C


     2009 IFW Emergency Responders Conference & Expo
               March 23 - 27th • Beaumont, TX
                                                                                                             SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008   33
                         Illinois company specializes in keeping fire departments
                         fully staffed with certified professional responders


                                                          Firefighters
                                                          On Demand
                                                                                                                                Photo Courtesy of Kurtz




                              W
Above, Kurtz firefighters                                   hen industry contracts with    1980s.
tackle a live-fire training                                 an outside company for fire       “In 1984, the Chicago area had a great push for fire
prop to keep their certifi-                                 protection, it usually means   departments to have a contractual arrangement so they
cation current.                                             the plant fire brigade is      could utilize our personnel to provide firefighters and
                                                            reorganized to suit the        EMS services,” Vana said. “Then, in 1999, the fire
                                                            company taking charge.         chief of a major refinery approached us about
                                                            However, Kurtz Industrial      providing industrial fire protection.”
                              Fire Services, based in the Chicago area, seeks to work         The biggest difference in recruiting industrial
                              with the organization in place.                              firefighters is that while fire fighting experience is
                                  Kurtz President and CEO Tom Vana said his                required, it is not always possible to hire personnel
                              company provides trained fire fighting personnel that        with first-hand knowledge of industrial fire fighting.
                              supplement existing industrial fire brigade operations.      The minimum requirement was an Illinois State
                                  Kurtz employs more than 100 industrial firefighters      Firefighter II certificate.
                              working for six industrial sites in four different states.      “Because of the inherent risks in a refinery, an
                              Proposals are on the table to add two more industrial        industrial firefighter should also be a state licensed
                              sites to the Kurtz list. In total, Kurtz employs more        EMT-B at a minimum before they come on board
                              than 300 firefighters when its 16 Chicago-area               with us,” Vana said.
                              community fire departments are included.                        Utilizing various fire fighting schools such as
                                  The advantage to industry is that Kurtz carries the      Refinery Terminal Fire Company in Corpus Christi,
                              load with regard to paperwork.                               TX, Emergency Services Training Institute in College
                                  “We handle all the wage and benefits, liability,         Station, TX, and the University of Nevada, Reno Fire
                              workers comp and employment practices part of the            Science Academy near Elko, NV, Kurtz firefighters go
                              business,” Vana said. “Our clients simply pay us a           through an extensive 12-week training program before
                              flat fee to provide them X amount of personnel.”             ever going into a plant.
                                  Industry in major cities often has the option of            Retired refinery Fire Chief Dale Pirc recently took
                              participating in a mutual aid organization that unites       charge of the Kurtz Consulting and Training Division.
                              various fire brigades for the common good. The same          His mission is to have all Kurtz employees NFPA
                              is not always true for plants and refineries operating       1081 ProBoard certified.
                              in remote locations across the Midwest and other areas          “One important thing to remember is that the people
                              of the country,” Vana said.                                  Tom is providing are not intended to replace employees
                                  “These plants may be isolated but they have good         in their existing emergency response organization,”
                              infrastructure in place,” Vana said. “They also have         Pirc said. “It’s meant to supplement the existing
                              good leadership. We provide them with the firefighters       organization and provide a good quality core
                              to follow that leadership.”                                  organization.”
                                  Kurtz started as a private ambulance service in 1977,       A frequent problem for mandatory brigades is job
                              he said. The move into fire fighting came in the mid-        turnover, Pirc said. For example, someone who works
34   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
in the laboratory is designated as driver of a         shift. At other
fire truck. Despite the time and effort to train       times, the Kurtz
that person to a sufficient level, all that may        personnel will
well be lost when the lab assistant transfers to       either conduct or
another position that does not require time on         assist in conduct-
the fire brigade.                                      ing classes for
    Likewise, personnel trained as emergency           refinery employ-
responders may find themselves with other              ees including
operational priorities from their primary job          firefighting for
and unable to respond in an emergency, Pirc            operators, main-
said.                                                  tenance, fire bri-
    “The emergency may be in their area of the         gade personnel
plant,” he said. “They may have to go out and          or, in some cases,
close valves on tanks or perform an emergency          clerical employ-                                                                    Photo Courtesy of Kurtz

shutdown or by-pass procedure.”                        ees. Training de-       Kurtz firefighters undertake a live-fire training assignment.
    To avoid this, Kurtz provides a fixed number       pends on roles
of trained fire fighting personnel who are on          and responsib-ilities of the em-ployees. Time The quick self generated actions of the Kurtz
hand no matter what happens to supplement              not spent at the fire stations goes toward fire firefighters in the area of the incident did in
volunteer or mandatory responders, Pirc said.          prevention in other ways – industrial hygiene, fact save a life that day.
    “You know what you’ve got seven days a             fire extinguisher inspections, fire water system         “That man would clearly have died had
week, 24 hours a day,” Pirc said. “A lot of            flushing and preventative maintenance, flushing there not been a rescue team or fire brigade at
facilities don’t have that. The same holds true        monitors, maintaining nozzles, air pack that refinery,” Vana said. “That refinery
for high angle and confined space rescue, haz-         inspections and record keeping.                     manager gave awards to our guys because they
mat and emergency medical services                         “At one refinery, our staff began to do all prevented a death in the refinery that day.”
responses.”                                            the fit testing,” Vana said. “If it costs $25 or       The financial cost to the refinery could have
    With the advantages the Kurtz approach             more to fit test each person, imagine what you been staggering as well.
offers, getting industry interested is not such a      save if you have 1,000 employees and another           “Take the increased premiums and other
hard sell, Vana said.                                  700 to 800 contractors. Hose testing is another numbers into account and our firefighters paid
    “OSHA and NFPA have established so                 chore we’ve taken over as well.”                    for themselves for about two or three years in
many regulations that there is no way                      After dinner, firefighters can either utilize that one incident alone,” Vana said.
volunteers or mandatory responders can                 their time in exercise or computer-based                In addition to emergency response services,
maintain their competencies in all areas of            training, Pirc said.                                Kurtz Industrial Fire Services can provide in-
emergency response and still keep an industrial            To date, Kurtz industrial firefighters have house reviews of existing in-place fire
facility completely compliant,” he said.               handled three major process unit fires. In one protection facility services including fire, haz-
    Lower insurance rates are one major selling        case, the damage reached $350 million.              mat and rescue.
point, Vana said. Mustering workers from                   “We held it to the point of origin,” Pirc said.    The reviews provide a thorough third party
various points across the plant and deploying          “The process supervisor told me, ‘Thank God set of eyes to review compliance with NFPA
them as firefighters costs valuable minutes.           for the fire crew because if it wasn’t for them, and OSHA codes and standards including
Keeping the fire stations staffed with Kurtz           the fire would not have been contained to the training procedures and record keeping, fixed
firefighters means an instant response.                point of origin.’”                                  and mobile equipment maintenance and testing
    “For what it costs to put 15 trained people            In at least one case, having Kurtz firefighters procedures and documentation, emergency
into a refinery, it is almost a wash insurance-        on site was the difference between life and response plans, policy and organization
wise,” he said. “Your insurance drops                  death for two contract refinery workers, Vana statements, employee training and compliance
dramatically when you can demonstrate that             said.                                               with OSHA 1910.119, section 13, Emergency
you have firefighters available 24/7, not just an          Two contract employees were inadvertently Planning and Response.                                    C
emergency response organization composed of            trapped by a
employees hopefully coming from their normal           catalyst which
job duties.”                                           had formed a
    However, these firefighters do not spend           crust at an
the day just waiting for the fire bell, Pirc said.     inspection door
    “Our people work a 24 hour shift, just like        on a catal-yst
municipal firefighters,” he said. “Every morning       hopper. The
starts with a safety talk and reviewing what is        catalyst gave
going on in the facility that day. Then they           way and con-
tackle a safety issue, usually related to the daily    sumed both em-
facility activites in the field. Half of the workday   ployees while
in the morning is spent on what we call                they attempted
mechanical integrity or equipment checks.”             to escape on a
    In the afternoon, training is always               large catwalk and
emphasized for the Kurtz personnel on duty             stairway area.
                                                                                                                       SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008                35
Failure to properly care for combustion                                          Gas trains keep gas out of the combustion chamber when no
                                                                              combustion is taking place through a series of tight closing , specially
equipment can have fatal consequences                                         designed shut-off valves that are spring-loaded to close. These are the
                                                                              safety shut-off and blocking valves.




15
                                                                                 Equipment codes and laws require these valves to be tightness tested
                                                                              on a regular basis. Auditors at Combustion Safety, Inc. find that proper
                                                                              checkouts and testing are seldom performed on the building code required
                                                                              schedules. Leaking gas through these valves into a combustion chamber
                                                                              can enhance the chances of an explosion.
                                                                                 2) Bad things can happen in control panels! Critical safety
                                                                              components can be mistakenly jumpered out and/or unreliable
                                                                              wiring or controldocumentation may exist.




                                                                                 C                                     D



Minutes
Can Save Your Life
                                                                                 E                                     F
                                                                                  The photographs show evidence of jumpered out safety components,
                By JOHN R. PUSKAR, PE/CEC Combustion                          poor wiring installations and/or poor documentation practices. (c)
                                                                              indicates wiring not labeled and not arranged such that it can be
  afety within manufacturing plants is an ongoing issue that
S                                                                             understood without a high probability of error. The wiring diagram
              needs more focus and attention from those who are in charge
                                                                              shown in (d) has been customize in the field. This may or may not be
              of maintenance and safety. Combustion equipment can be
                                                                              accurate or correct.
              a main source of explosions. These types of disasters are
                                                                                  Bypassing safety circuits is a big no-no. In the case of (e), an obvious
              preventable even for someone who does not work with
                                                                              electrical jumper wire bypasses a control. It is a wire that is not the
combustion equipment on a daily basis. What follows is no substitute
                                                                              same as the others, is connected with alligator clips and is of a different
for a skilled technician but it can help to save lives if someone is guilty
                                                                              gauge and color. In (f) a popsicle stick is broken off and jammed into an
of even one of the 10 deadly combustion equipment sins that follow.
                                                                              air switch contact to hold it open. These are things to look for and find
This screening takes less than 15 minutes. In each case the issue is
                                                                              before trying to start equipment.
spelled out along with the potential hazard.
                                                                                  3) Obsolete burner management systems can make for long
   All of the 10 “deadly sins” illustrated below are real-life examples of
                                                                              outages and less protection.
what auditors at Combustion Safety, Inc. have come across when asked
to evaluate the safety of combustion equipment. All of these examples
could make for a dangerous working environment that could result in a
fire or explosion under the right conditions.
   1) Tightness testing of safety shut-off valves and blocking valves
is not being carried out.

                                                                                G                                      H
                                                                                 The burner management system in (g) is a new model RM7800 from
                                                                              Honeywell. An older electro mechanical model R4138 is shown in (h).
                                                                              Burner Management Systems (BMS) are the most important single
                                                                              safety component that exists for any piece of gas-fired equipment.
 A                                     B                                      Recent advances have put more features and safety into this equipment.
                                                                              For example, newer BMS have purge timers that are solid state and not
   The photographs show evidence of valve testing plugs that do not           adjustable. Many explosions have occurred where purge timers have
appear to have ever been removed. This is an obvious sign that the            been turned down in the field, making for ineffective removal of flammable
required gas train automatic valve tightness testing is probably not          mixtures before pilot light-off cycles have occurred. Another important
taking place.                                                                 issue is BMS obsolescence. If a BMS system or component fails that is
36    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
no longer manufactured, it could take days of rewiring for a newer,
different style to be installed.
   4) Valves in the instrument lines can render switches /
instruments ineffective.

                                                                                       M                               N



     I                                    J                                                            O
   Valves in instrument lines can be left in the closed position, rendering
switches out of service and functionally incapable of operating. This           leaked. These valves are usually spring-loaded to close (not needing the
could leave personnel and equipment unprotected. Valves should always           hydraulic fluid for closing). The risk here is mostly one of equipment
be removed or at least locked open as soon as they are found. This              downtime when least expected since the hydraulic fluid is needed to
especially applies to (i) high / low gas pressure sensing lines, steam          open the valve to light the unit.
pressure switches and water column connections.                                    8) Lubricated plug valves can be leaking in the closed position
   5) Set points that are obviously wrong can render switches /                 or be frozen in place and inoperable.
instruments ineffective.
   Instruments and / or safety devices without correct set points provide



                                                                                              P                          Q


  K
little or no protection. Gas pressure switches are shown that have set                         R                           S
points pulled all the way to one side or the other. These are most likely
not set correctly. Improper gas pressures could cause flameouts and
explosions.
    6) Flame roll-out (hard starting) can be a warning for dangerous
conditions that may get worse.                                                                  T                          U

                                                                                    Lubricated plug valves fail a number of ways, including leaking when
                                                                                in the closed position and being stuck in the open or closed position.
                                                                                Inspections at more than 200 sites found that more than 60 percent
                                                                                leaked in the closed position. A typical plug valve showing the body,
                     L                                                          plug and lubricant coating on the plug that makes the seal is shown in
                                                                                (p). A frozen valve that cannot be closed in an emergency is indicated in
                                                                                (q). Exterior stem corrosion is shown in (r). A valve that has been
   When the bottom of equipment is burned or scorched, it may indicate
                                                                                painted shut is shown in (t). A valve in the closed position that is
flame rollout. This can occur when flues are partially blocked and / or         leaking through the inside of the pipe downstream is indicated in (u).
fuel and air mixtures are set incorrectly. In these cases combustible           Lubricated plug valves need to be properly maintained on a regular
mixtures and flames can exist outside of the firebox.                           basis. This means installing the proper sealant material and making sure
   One of the risks is catching things on fire that are near the base of this   the valves are exercised.
equipment. Another is that as things continue to degrade, the flame                 9) Vent valves can be failed open, disrupting burner operating
rollout condition could turn into a catastrophic explosion from the             conditions that put live fuel on roofs and sending improper mixtures
accumulation of unburned gasses that ignite at once.                            into burners.
   7) Automatic valve actuator failures (safety shut-off valve,                     Normally open vent valves are installed in gas trains to improve
blocking valve, pilot or vents) can make for hazardous operating                safety when equipment is off (v). They allow gas leakage through the
conditions and down time.                                                       first automatic valve to get outside instead of to the firebox. When the
   Hydraulic valve actuator failures are sometimes indicated by the             burner tries to light, they are supposed to close tight so all the gas goes
presence of hydraulic fluid on the valve’s exterior. These photographs          to the burner. If they are failed and leaking, they can vent natural gas
show oil stains on the sides of valves (m), puddling at the valve (n) and       from the gas train while the burner tries to operate (w). This makes for
obvious excessive leakage (puddling under the equipment) (o). This              risks from ignition sources on the roof. It also makes for burners with
condition it indicates that some of the actuator’s hydraulic fluid has          unstable flames that cannot stay lit. If this happens, back-up systems
                                                                                                                  SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008              37
Boilers                                                                     protection from leaking safety shut-off valves / blocking valves or for
                                                                            relieving failed components. Safety codes require protected vent
Continued from Page 37
                                                                            terminations (z) be installed with screening devices.
                                                                               Gas And Combustion System Explosions Can Be Avoided
                                                                               For companies that are combustion system sinners, salvation can
                                                                            often be found in the form of awareness and training. It is also most
                                                                            likely going to take a culture change at the facility and a new found
                                                                            respect for combustion equipment. Consider the case of a 100-gallon
                                                                            water heater. The energy stored in a 100-gallon water heater can be
  V                                    W                                    equivalent to 10 sticks of dynamite. If a company has10 sticks of
                                                                            dynamite stored at its facility, it would treat the dynamite with respect.
must recognize the loss of flame and be called upon to shut off the gas.    Combustion equipment is not like fall protection or employees wearing
If these fail, an explosion is likely.                                      safety glasses. This equipment has the power to destroy people and
    10) Outside vent terminations can be blocked with insect nests.         property on a massive scale. It only gives one chance. That chance can
    Most instruments and switches are vented with pipes outside to          mean death and destruction for those that may be working on or near
safe locations (x) to allow for proper operation and for gas to escape if   the equipment, as well as many innocent bystanders. Companies must
a diaphragm failure occurs. Vent terminations are often found to be         find 15 minutes to review their sites!                                 C
blocked with insect nests (y). A clogged vent can mean that there is no
                                                                            For more information, please visit www.combustionsafety.com
                                                                            or contact Combustion Safety at 1-888-826-3473.

                                                                                      2009 IFW Emergency Responders
                                                                                          Conference & Exposition
  X                       Y                       Z                                     March 23-27 • Beaumont, TX




38    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
                                                                                                                                        Photo by Lynn White
Firefighters tackle one of 25 fire training ‘props’ available at the University of Nevada, Reno Fire Science Academy.

State budget crisis may force closure of Nevada fire academy

Decision Pending
              decision on closing the University of Nevada, Reno Fire         unrealistic cost, enrollment and revenue projections.”



A             Science Academy (UNR) near Elko, NV, in response to a
              state budget crisis has been postponed by university
              regents until October to allow more time to pursue possible
              funding partnerships with industry.
    The regents’ action comes in the wake of a report by an advisory
council chaired by former Nevada governor Kenny Guinn and prominent
business people recommending closure of the facility.
                                                                                  “While we wish our recommendation to close the FSA could be
                                                                              otherwise, we believe it to be in the best long-term interests of the
                                                                              university, the Nevada System of Higher Education, present and future
                                                                              students and the taxpayers of Nevada,” the report states.
                                                                                  For the 2009-11 biennium, state agencies face a mandated budget cut
                                                                              of 14 percent to make up for a projected state shortfall approaching $1
                                                                              billion. The university gets 60 percent of its funding from the state’s
    According to The Elko Daily Free Press, regents are unanimous in          general fund.
their decision to continue discussion about the closure, but disagree on          Located in the Ruby Mountain region of northern Nevada, the UNR
whether they should allow until October or December for progress to           Fire Science Academy is home to 25 full-sized live burn props, together
be shown.                                                                     with a staff residence, administration building, cafeteria and recreation
    UNR president Milt Glick recommends the regents to continue the           building, classrooms and observation tower. The isolated location
discussion to allow more time for the partnerships to be explored.            permits year-round live burns, as opposed to the annual eight-month
University representatives are talking to oil companies and mining            schedule allowed at the academy’s previous home in Stead near Reno.
companies who are customers of the academy.                                       The 426-acre academy near Elko opened in March 1999. Eighteen
    The university is also in discussion with an oil company trade            months later, amidst much red ink and unexpected environmental impact,
association representing more potential students.                             FSA ceased live-burn training operations. By November 2000, it closed
    The Guinn report notes that the fire academy has a long-term capital      its doors at the new site completely.
debt of $27.1 million, which is being paid off through student fees. The          After untangling a myriad of legal problems, the school reopened in
academy also faces operating and construction repair deficits totaling        2002. That year, FSA trained more than 1,800 firefighters. Enrollment
$12 million. Costs of closing the school after this season could run          has steadily increased since then to more than 4,000 students in 2007.
another $3.5 million.                                                             Denise Baclawski, FSA executive director, said the school continues
    According to the Associated Press, the report says the academy is         to train firefighters at that enrollment level.
well run and recognized internationally for its fire fighting training, but       “We are committed to providing the same quality services the clients
it has a business plan that was “fatally flawed from the outset with          have come to expect,” she said.                                         C

                                                                                                               SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008                39
RISK ASSESSMENT


Pre-planning then and now                                                                                           By JOHN FRANK/XL GAPS


I
     recently had an opportunity to vacation on the Florida island where      sticking sprinkler heads up with no pipe. This was before a full time fire
    I served as a volunteer firefighter in the combination (part paid, part   marshal position was created, and had it not been for our daily
    volunteer) department from 1982-1985. I was lucky enough to serve         construction walk throughs, we may have never found this situation.
under company officers who believed in pre-planning and that helped               Now for what I know to look for now that I did not know then:
spark the interest in this column – where pre-planning is a central focus.        1) I do not remember ever talking about the operation of the building
Now, 23 years after I left and armed with my experience as a fire             fire pump. We knew the building had one and that was about it. The
protection engineer, I had a chance to reflect on pre-planning then and       recent series of articles by Jeff Roberts describes in detail how to ensure
what more could have been done with more systems knowledge. The               that a building pump will reliably operate during the fire and how to
analogies apply to planning for all types of firefighting but more so to      keep it running in an emergency.
industrial operations.                                                            In the case of the condominium, adequate flow and pressure could be
    Interestingly enough, the day I left for the vacation, I read a news      delivered by our 1,000 gpm pumper through the fire department
story in one of the online fire magazines that continues to drive home        connection. But what about a petrochemical plant with a demand of
the need for industrial pre-planning. It seems that a medium-sized            20,000 gpm at 125 psi; or even a warehouse with a sprinkler demand of
municipal fire department was faced with a fire in a baled paper              2,000 gpm at 135 psi and a 4-inch fire department connection? The
warehouse. As was to be expected, the tightly packed bales of paper           facility pump(s) had better work in those cases.
posed a challenge. One of the chief officers stated that due to the               2) Even though we focused on construction, I think we missed the
difficulty of the fire, they had to come up with a plan on how to deal        potential combustion hazards of Exterior Insulation Finishing Systems
with the bales. The entire focus of this series is that a planning session    (EIFS) that were being installed everywhere. It looks like most
should have been done well before the fire, not in the middle of it. The      condominiums on the island uses EIFS. This is often a combustible
site was there, presumably for years, and unlike a highway hazmat             exterior finish that most industrial property insurance companies and
incident, you can know what you can expect before you ever get the            property loss prevention companies recommend to pass a large scale
call.                                                                         fire test such as FM Approvals Corner Test or the test described by
    Back to the island condominium. Some of the things that we did pre-       NFPA 285 Standard Fire Test Method for Evaluation of Fire Propagation
plan were:                                                                    Characteristics of Exterior Non-Load-Bearing Wall Assemblies
    1) How to deal with the fact that the aerial ladder could not access      Containing Combustible Components. Systems that have not passed
the beach side of the structure. We had 55-foot ground ladders and we         such a test could present responders with an unexpectedly severe exterior
were probably one of the last fire departments to carry and actually          fire.
intend to use scaling ladders so we could go floor-to-floor as needed. We         A recent hotel and casino fire in Las Vegas reportedly involved an
also carried short escape ropes — just long enough to go the floor below      EIFS, although some blogs speculate that it may have been something
if we got trapped on the beach side. We could also rappel down the            else. Although major industrial insurance companies look for this, I
beach side from the roof. One positive was that building codes limited        rarely — if ever — hear the fire service discussing its hazards.
construction to 75 feet high so the aerial could at least get to the roof         EIFS is not as common on industrial facilities as in commercial
from the front. At the time, there were two mutual aid ladder companies       construction; however, in areas where industrial buildings are trying to
as well.                                                                      blend into the community, it is more common because it looks nice.
    This leads to another point with aerial operations. The outrigger         Unfortunately for the responder, it looks like trowel-finished masonry
spread on newer aerials is much wider than in the past. This is safer, but    construction (which is the intent) so it is hard to notice.
it takes more space to set them up. Looking at parking lot congestion, a          3) Although we were well aware of our hydrant flow at 20 psi, we
longer aerial will probably be needed to get to those same roofs.             really needed is to know the flow at the sprinkler system demand
    Think about high rise industrial occupancies with similar congestion      pressure. If the sprinkler system has a demand of 300 gpm at 125 psi,
and limited access. What is your plan? Can the newer, longer, safer           we need to know if that demand can be met with and without the pump
aerials even negotiate some of the turns or clear pipe racks?                 and while supplying hose streams. In dealing with fire protection system
    2) We were well versed in the construction features of the building.      hydraulics, both the flow and pressure must be known. Having class
We used to walk through the condominiums, which were just being built         AA hydrants (1,500 gpm at 20 psi) is meaningless for system analysis.
at the time, every shift. We compared what we found to what Frank             Saying we have “good” pressure (whatever “good” means) is also
Brannigan had to say in Building Construction for the Fire Service and        meaningless since the flow is not stated.
planned accordingly. Brannigan also covered industrial occupancies,               What is needed is a statement like “the water spray system needs
especially warehouses, tilt-up concrete construction and combustible          3,000 gpm at 125 psi and we need an additional 2,000 gpm at 125 psi
metal deck roofs. Anyone who fights structural fires should study his         for monitors for a total of 5000 gpm @ 125 psi. Then, through flow-
book. Brannigan does not cover process structures specifically, but he        testing, if you know you can supply 6,000 gpm at 150 psi even with
had a lot to say about steel construction that can be applied.                the largest pump out of service. Then you know something. You can
    3) Of course, we know where to find the utility cutoffs, the fire         satisfy system volume and pressure requirements and you have enough
alarm panel, the fire department connection, hydrants, flow available at      reserve to operate two more 500 gpm monitors if needed to.
20 psi, pool chemicals and the like.                                              4) I don’t recall discussing wind driven flames. The wind blows in
    4) We even found that a few unscrupulous contractors were just                                                          Continued on Page 45
40    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
FOCUS ON HAZMAT


Did we really mean to do that?                                                                                    By DR. JOHN S. TOWNSEND


U
          ntil the dawn of the twentieth century, Americans and most of      Consequences, often cited but rarely defined, is that actions of people—
          the rest of the world for that matter, were pretty much on their   and especially of government—always have effects that are unanticipated
          own so far as insuring the quality of the food they ate, the       or unintended. Economists and other social scientists have heeded its
medicines they took for their illnesses or the safety of their workplace     power for centuries; for just as long, politicians and popular opinion
environments. America was an agrarian society made up of small isolated      have largely ignored it.”
communities in which everyone knew everyone else and one knew who               In many cases, these “unintended consequences” have actually
milked his cow, churned his butter, baked his bread and prepared his         negated the original purpose of the regulation. Thus we have the
medicines; and, he knew how it was done and what went into the final         Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which was intended to increase
product. He knew that he needed to keep his hand out of the feed mill        opportunities for those with disabilities, but, because it increased the
and also what would happen to him if he did not. Any untoward                cost of hiring employees with disabilities, it has actually decreased their
happening was considered to be his own fault; it was too bad but he          opportunities for employment.
should have known better or been more attentive to what he was doing.           Fire prevention measures within forested areas have actually increased
    As the urban population grew as a result of the great migration from     the danger of fire and the damage caused by it through the accumulation
Europe, this idyllic picture of American society changed radically. Foods,   of debris. The corn-based ethanol program has increased the demand for
drugs and other essential commodities became products, created in            corn and resulted in a large increase in food prices, not only in the
inanimate factories by anonymous employees of aggressive and                 United States but around the world. The environmental movements has
sometimes insensitive entrepreneurs and, as always, there were those         delayed, if not actually prevented, the construction of newer, more
who would place profits before quality. In 1906, Upton Sinclair              efficient oil refining facilities, and this has contributed, at least in part,
published his muckraking novel The Jungle, which dealt with conditions       to the current high price of motor fuel.
in the U.S. meat packing industry. The public uproar that followed is           In the Desert Southwest, water is a precious commodity. When we
credited, at least in part, with the passage of the Pure Food and Drug       find it, we clean it up and use it. When the EPA mandated that all runoff
Act and the Meat Inspection Act in 1906. Thus began the first sustained      water had to be confined to the site where it originated, the result was
effort on the part of the government to insure the health and safety of      the construction of containment ponds to hold this runoff water. The
its citizens through regulations and their enforcement.                      idea seems to have been that any contained water would percolate into
    The trend has continued until the present day, expanding                 the soil (and in the process possibly contaminate the underground
exponentially with the creation of the Centers for Disease Control           aquifers) instead of flowing to the river where it could be caught in
(CDC), the Occupational Health and Safety Administration (OSHA),             reservoirs downstream for later use. The lawmakers failed to reckon
the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA), the Department             with our “adobe” clay soils. These soils hold water like a jug. This is
of Transportation (DOT), The Federal Aeronautics Administration              also true of the red clay in Georgia and the “red bed” of west Texas
(FAA) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) among others,            among many others.
all of which promulgate rules and regulations and have a bearing on             To comply with the EPA directive, property owners have constructed
legislation passed by Congress.                                              holding ponds on the grounds of their buildings to contain the runoff
    As a result, the American public has become used, or almost addicted     water and keep it on site. As a result, there are numerous, nicely
to the idea that the way to protect against any risk or hazard is to         landscaped ponds all over the community. These are usually filled with
legislate against it, or, at least, regulate it, and this is the duty or     large rocks to prevent people or animals from falling in and drowning.
responsibility of government. John Q. Public wants to be guaranteed a        These ponds have no outlet and once filled simply sit until the water is
risk free environment; but I’ve got news for John Q “it ain’t gonna          removed by pumping or evaporated by the sun. The water stagnates,
happen.”                                                                     becomes a source of odor, and, worse, provides, an ideal breeding place
    To be sure, most of the protective laws and agencies, especially the     for mosquitoes, some of which can, and on occasion do, carry West Nile
earlier ones, were created for laudable reasons to satisfy a real need to    Virus (WNV). Rains produced by the remnants of Hurricane Dolly
protect health or safety of the citizenry or the environment. Certainly      have prompted local government to initiate a frantic effort to get all of
no one should be allowed to use formaldehyde to preserve fresh milk or       these ponds sprayed before the WNV-carrying mosquitoes can
sell cosmetics containing salts of lead, mercury bismuth or other heavy      reproduce. Of course, spraying introduces more pesticide into the
metals.                                                                      environment.
    Other laws have been enacted for the sake of political expediency.          The basic tenants of the promulgations of EPA and OSHA are good
After all, what politician wants to be seen as opposed to preserving the     and well intentioned, but the “unintended consequences” that have
environment or providing a safe work environment? Some laws were             accompanied these regulations have at times created more hazards than
created in response to the pressure generated by public concern and in       they have eliminated.
some cases actual fears, which were sometimes exacerbated by the                Another “unintended consequence” of legislation has been the creation
media. Whether these concerns or fears are valid does not really matter;     of a climate of fear in the mind of the public. As a result, we have seen
they exist, and they can cause a lot of political heat to be generated.      proposed legislation based on what might happen rather than credible
    Legislation, and indeed most human endeavor, is subject to the “law      evidence of an existing hazard. No matter how badly society wants it, a
of unintended consequences.” In an article appearing in The Concise          risk-free world simply does not and will not exist. Every action carries
Encyclopedia of Economics, Rob Norton states, “The Law of Unintended         with it a certain amount of risk. When one steps out to cross the street
                                                                                                                 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008               41
there is a risk present, even though the light is with the pedestrian. Does   thermostats, electrical switches and dental fillings. It is also used to fill
the pedestrian want to get to the other side of the street badly enough to    various gauging instruments (thermometers and barometers) and
justify the inherent risk?                                                    manometers (the doctor’s sphygmomanometer for example).
   The search of a risk-free society has been a windfall to the personal          Mercury is also a component of batteries and, with the proliferation
injury lawyers. Almost nightly we see television advertisements asking,       of small efficient electronic devices such as in-ear hearing aids, cell
“Have you been hurt by so and so or think you might have been? If so,         phones, pocket radios and digital cameras, the number of these being
call this number you may be entitled to compensation.” Another                used and later discarded into the environment is growing exponentially,
television ad actually starts off with the words if you or a loved one has    becoming a matter of concern to environmentalists.
died……” It would be interesting to know just how many inquiries this              Because metallic mercury was formerly used in various oil field gauging
lawyer has gotten from people who have died. There is risk involved in        instruments, the petroleum industry has now been required to spend
the use of virtually any medicine, but look at the alternatives; would        great sums of money to clean up the sites of numerous pipeline gauging
anyone in his right mind want to have his appendix removed sans               stations and refineries.
anesthetic because of the risk? Would a patient with 98 percent heart             In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, large amounts of
blockage forego bypass surgery because the drug Trasylol carries a risk       mercury were used as a component of the amalgam process to extract
of kidney problems? I think not. The means (relief of surgical pain or        precious metals from their ores. In this process, up to 300 pounds of
bleeding) would justify the risks involved; and besides, you can always       mercury are combined with a ton of metallic ore, thus an amalgamation
sue your doctor later, at least according to some of the personal injury      of the mercury and other metallic minerals is formed. This method, for
lawyers.                                                                      example, extracted some 50-85 percent of the precious metals from the
   Risks are not restricted to medical issues and as a result we have         Comstock Lode ores it was used to treat. In the process, however, one
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS) that warn us of the hazard of              to three pounds of metallic mercury were usually lost to the environment
dropping a steel plate on toes or being hit on the head with it. The coffee   in a typical operation. In the case of the Comstock Lode, several million
cup that one gets at the fast food restaurant now carries the warning         pounds (up to 14 million pounds by some estimates) of elemental
that coffee is hot (one would think that the sense of touch would tell        mercury now exists in the Carson River down stream from the mills.
him that), as if anyone would want his morning coffee at room                 This mercury will eventually be converted to soluble compounds and
temperature.                                                                  slowly find its way into the food chain as methylmercury or other
   Mercury (atomic number 80, atomic weight 200.59) is one of the             compounds which can be assimilated by the human body.
transition (“B” family) elements. Its oxidation states are +2 and +1.             While the amalgam process has been superseded by the cyanide
Due to its low melting point (-38.58ºC), mercury exists as a liquid at        process in the United States, mercury is still used in many Third World
room temperature. It is the only metal with this property but gallium         countries to treat precious metal ores and continues to be a source of
(atomic number 31) is closest with a melting point of 29.76 ºCelsius.         environmental contamination. Cyanide on the other hand will rapidly
   Mercury is considered toxic but in reality its toxicity when in the        degrade into carbon and nitrogen in sunlight or in contact with the
elemental (metallic) state is not nearly as great as it is when combined or   atmosphere. Cyanide can also be rapidly neutralized by hydrogen
when it is encountered in the vapor state. In fact, “elemental mercury is     peroxide and other chemicals. Even though cyanide is highly poisonous,
usually quite harmless if touched or swallowed. It is so thick and slippery   the fact that it will deteriorate in the environment makes it more desirable
that it usually falls off your skin or out of your stomach without being      than the amalgam process.
absorbed.”1 This accounts for its successful use as a weight when                 Another source of mercury is the exhaust from coal burning power
introducing some of the early stomach tubes for gastric analysis.             plants. Now there is, of course, nothing unique about power plants.
   In order to be toxic, a substance must be absorbed into the tissues,       Any coal fired factory will emit mercury, but the generation of power
and for this reason compounds of mercury which are soluble are far            accounts for the largest amount of coal consumption in the U.S.
more toxic than the pure metal which is virtually insoluble. Thus the             In recent years, the rising cost of energy has caused the general
government has banned many mercury-containing medicinals such as              population to focus on efficiency in the home and in the work place.
red mercurochrome and merthiolate.                                            One of the biggest, if not the biggest, energy wasters is the incandescent
   While it has not yet been banned, thiomerosal, a common preservative       light bulb. This device has been around for almost a hundred years and
for vaccines and used since the 1930’s, has been under scrutiny as a          it was truly one of the great inventions of the twentieth century; but it
cause of autism and other brain development disorders found in young          is very inefficient with 95 percent of the energy consumed being given
children. So far mainstream medical opinion is that no convincing             off as heat rather than as light. This is not a bad thing when you are
scientific evidence supports these claims but the Centers for Disease         brooding baby chicks with a couple of 150 watt light bulbs but it does
Control (CDC) and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) under              become a problem when these same lights raise the temperature of an
the precautionary principle, which is an assumption that there is no          already stifling living room in the summer.
harm in exercising caution even if it later turns out to be unwarranted,          The problem becomes more acute with the advent of air conditioning.
have asked vaccine manufacturers to remove thiomerosal from vaccines          Now we find ourselves paying to create the heat as a by product of light
as quickly as possible. The compound has been rapidly phased out of           and then paying again to pump it out of the house. The same thing, by
most U.S. and European vaccines.                                              the way, applies to the domestic refrigerator. The heat extracted from
   Mercury vapors are also toxic and the inhalation of these vapors           the food compartment is discharged into the room through the condenser,
emanating from spilled mercury can have serious consequences. This is         thus increasing the load on the air conditioning system and causing us to
the rationale for the current efforts to reduce the amount of metallic        spend more money to remove it.
mercury in the environment. Mercury that has been absorbed into the               In 1992 the EPA initiated the Energy Star program to promote
body tends to remain in the body.                                             efficiency. Part of this program encourages the phase out of tungsten
   While the average citizen is not aware of it, there is a great deal of     lamps in favor of more efficient types. In reality this means Compact
elemental mercury in the ordinary environment. It is present in               Fluorescent Lamps (CFLs). These lamps are 75 percent more efficient
42    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
than conventional tungsten lamps. For instance, a standard 150 watt locations and sometimes in public buildings. This usually takes shape
tungsten lamp will consume, you guessed it, 150 watts of energy and in the form of a flexible clear plastic tube fitted with sealing end caps
produce 2,600 lumens, the equivalent CFL emitting the same light (2,600 that slips over the lamp at the time of installation and contains the
lumens) will consume on the average 41 watts of power to produce the fragments and the metallic mercury in the event of breakage. We have
same 2,600 lumens; a saving of about 75 percent. The energy saved found no indication of this requirement for fluorescent tubes installed in
translates into less required generation of power and less carbon private homes. Neither is there any record of any secondary containment
emissions, or a smaller “carbon footprint.”                                 requirement for CFLs.
   The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (the “Energy               To be sure, each vapor discharge lamp contains only a small amount
Bill”), signed by the President on December                                                              of elemental mercury (four to five mg) but
18, 2007 requires all light bulbs use 30                                                                 look at a modern city, operating refinery or
percent less energy than today’s                                                                         other similar industrial installation at night
incandescent bulbs by 2012 to 2014. The                                                                  to get an idea of the number of mercury-
phase-out will start with 100-watt bulbs in                                                              containing lamps in operation. In aggregate,
January 2012 and end with 40-watt bulbs                                                                  this represents a significant quantity of
in January 2014. By 2020, a Tier 2 would                                                                 mercury and this amount will increase as
become effective, which requires all bulbs                                                               CFLs become more common.
to be at least 70 percent more efficient                                                                     One retailer has announced a sales goal
(effectively equal to today’s CFLs). While                                                               of one million CFLs for 2008. This goal is
this legislation does not specifically mandate                                                           llikely to be met and possibly even exceeded.
the use of compact fluorescent lamps, they                                                               The main reason is that conversion of an
are about the only viable alternative to the                                                             existing light fixture to use CFLs is usually
tungsten lamp currently available. On the                                                                easy. Unlike the traditional fluorescent
surface, this legislation has a laudable                                                                 tubes or other vapor discharge lamps, CFLs
purpose, but that “Law of Unintended                                                                     do not require a special fixture containing a
Consequences” does come into play.                                                                       ballast transformer and/or a starter. All of
   All of the high efficiency lamps now                                                                  these components are contained in the base
available contain mercury. This is true                                                                  of the lamp. All that is necessary for
whether they are the mercury vapor lamps                                                                 conversion is to unscrew the old tungsten
or the high pressure sodium vapor lamps              Any policy decision has multiple im-                bulb, screw in the new CFL and turn on the
that light streets, factories and plant areas        pacts/consequences, positive and nega-              switch; nothing else is required. It is also
or the common fluorescent tubes that light           tive, as well as intended and unintended.           true that as CFLs are discarded, more
supermarkets, offices and classrooms. All            We can reduce the negative by thinking              valuable materials, mainly metals, are lost
contain some mercury. Each CFL or                    them through and anticipating costs vs.             and may revert to the environment unless a
fluorescent tube contains about four or five         benefits before finalizing policy.                  vigorous effort is initiated and pursued.
mg of the metal. The exception is the low                                                                    The current OSHA standard for mercury
pressure sodium (LPS/SOX) lamps which                                                                    in air is 0.1mg/m3; therefore the 5 mg in an
usually do not contain mercury but these are not suitable for general average CFL could contaminate 50 cubic meters of atmosphere. An
illumination where the ability to distinguish colors is essential. This average ten by twelve foot room with an eight foot ceiling contains
mercury is a source of environmental contamination in the event of 27.19 m3, thus a spill of the mercury contained in one CFL could
breakage or when the lamp is discarded at the end of its useful life.       significantly contaminate two rooms. Parameters like whether or not
   Presently most mercury-containing lamps (particularly those types the lamp was operating at the time or if the mercury contained in it
containing the most mercury) are contained in fixtures that are would be warm and therefore more likely to be released in the vapor
inaccessible to the general public such as signs, street lights, large state as opposed to the emanation from a cold, or non operating, lamp
manufacturing facilities and athletic fields, gymnasiums or auditoriums. which might release some metallic mercury which is less dangerous. A
Lamps in such installations are normally fairly well protected from catastrophic event such as a fire, explosion or violent weather, impacting
breakage by their housings and their inaccessible locations and are usually a large industrial installation or city could cause the breakage of a
maintained by professionals who see to it that the replaced lamps were significant number of mercury-containing lamps and concurrently the
disposed of in a safe manner. There are relatively few vapor discharge release of a dangerously large amount of mercury.
lamps in the average home, and those that are present are the familiar         Firefighters responding to an incident in even a moderate sized
fluorescent tubes. These are usually located in mounted fixtures and are mercantile or industrial establishment should bear in mind the large
out of reach of children or pets.                                           number of mercury containing lamps in these locations and always use
   With the advent of the CFL this is changing. CFLs are now found in appropriate respiratory protection. This admonition should also be
desk lamps, in mechanic’s drop lights and in other portable lighting heeded by clean up crews removing debris after the initial event.
applications throughout the home, office, plant or factory where they          Government guidelines for handling a broken CFL or regular
have simply been installed in existing fixtures to replace the heat fluorescent lamps include:
generating and power hungry tungsten lamps previously utilized. CFLs           • Evacuation of the room and preclusion of the use of a vacuum
in these applications are far more susceptible to breakage than are those cleaner, which would spread the contamination.
housed in inaccessible mounted fixtures. Because of this possibility of        • Ventilation of the area for 15 minutes before attempting clean up
accidental breakage, many jurisdictions now require secondary and the continuation of ventilation for several hours afterward. This
containment of the traditional fluorescent tubes when used in hazardous may lower the concentration of mercury in the room but it will spread
                                                                                                               SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008             43
                                                                                      induced another potential hazard, increased mercury content, into the
HazMat
Continued from page43
                                                                                      homes and workplaces of America. Is the risk justified by the benefits?
                                                                                      Is the energy saving and the concomitant reduction of the carbon footprint
                                                                                      worth the increased risk of mercury contamination? Have we really
it over a larger area. Air conditioning may well circulate the contamination          achieved the projected benefits or have we merely moved the source of
throughout the entire system.                                                         contamination from the smokestack to the light socket? Do we need to
    • Pat the area of the spill with the sticky side of duct tape, packing            re-evaluate the risks from mercury exposure and take into consideration
tape or masking tape to pick up fine particles. Wipe the area with a wet              the toxic properties of compounds of mercury as opposed to those of
wipe or damp paper towel to pick up even finer particles. This is good                the metallic element?
practice so far as picking up shards and small particles of glass, but just               Should we, perhaps, defer the phase-out of the tungsten lamp to
how much mercury will be picked up is questionable since the metal                    await the advent of non-mercury sources of illumination such as the
does not readily adhere to such surfaces.                                             light emitting diode (LED), which will very likely reach a state of
    • Devices for picking up spilled mercury in the laboratory have been              practical viability for use in general illumination in the fairly near future?
around for years. These devices take advantage of the fact mercury will               If so, should we not place greater emphasis on the development of this
adhere to a clean copper surface. They usually take form in the shape of              technology?
a scoop and some sort of sweeper, often a series of copper washers,                       Once introduced into the environment, and worse into the body,
mounted on an axle, which will pick up the spilled mercury. These                     mercury is tenacious and remains for years, even centuries. The mercury
fairly inexpensive devices are much more effective than masking tape. A               contamination caused by the use of the amalgam process at the site of
small wad of copper wool (sometimes sold under the name of “Chore                     the Comstock Lode in Nevada during the nineteenth and early twentieth
Girl”) used for scrubbing pots in the kitchen can also be found to                    centuries is proof enough of that. The metal per se may do little or no
effectively retrieve spilled mercury.                                                 harm, but as it is gradually incorporated into the environment, it is
    • Governmental guidelines also suggest that removal of carpeting                  absorbed by living organisms, such as fish and other marine life, and
may be necessary since cleaning this material is extremely difficult at               converted into methylmercury (any of the compounds containing the
best and often is a practical impossibility.                                          CH3Hg complex) and other toxic compounds or vapors. There is already
    Practical questions such as central air conditioning and the ability to           a lot of mercury out there to convert. In light of the problems associated
adequately ventilate interior rooms should be considered. In short, how               with inadvertent mercury exposure from compounds like thiomerosal,
many building occupants will actually go to the trouble of following all              do we want to add more?
these guidelines? Commercial establishments subject to OSHA                               As mercury-containing lamps reach the end of their useful lives,
regulations may be required to do so but will the average homeowner or                they must be disposed of. Will their disposal in community landfills
tenant follow suit?                                                                   create a new source of mercury contamination near each center of
    Now this is not to make light of the recommendations for handling                 population or will recycling be made “consumer friendly” and
breakages involving mercury-containing lamps. In fact, a cleanup carried              economically feasible enough that people will actually use it? These
out following these guidelines would very likely protect persons working              questions and others should give us pause to re-think our initial question
or living in the vicinity from another hazard, namely the phosphors                   with regard to increasing the number of mercury-containing lamps. Did
used to coat the inside of the lamps. Some of these are thought to be                 we really mean to do that?                                                   C
toxic or carcinogenic.
    So, in an effort to conserve energy, bring operational costs down and               1
                                                                                          See: National Library of Medicine, Medline Plus entry
reduce mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants, we have, due                   “mercury” (http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/
to the inexorable operation of the “law of unintended consequences,”                  002476.htm).


Riskfrom page 40
Continued                                                                                CSB Probes Fatal Mill Explosion
from the beach side but the only platform for attack was the street side.
The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has recently
done research in this area for high rise structure fires. Wind also has to
                                                                                         T   he U.S. Chemical Safety Board (CSB) announced in August
                                                                                             that it will conduct a full investigation of the storage tank
                                                                                         explosion that killed three workers and injured a fourth at a
be considered at industrial locations when planning attack points. An                    corrugated cardboard mill in Tomahawk, Wisconsin, on July 29.
excellent example is the tank pre-plan published in Hildebrand and                          The accident occurred as workers were performing welding to
Noll’s text Storage Tank Emergencies. Pads for monitor nozzle trailers                   repair a flange fitting on top of an 80-foot-tall storage tank, which
were set up for prevailing wind conditions and an alternate attack point                 contained recycled water and paper fiber. The three workers
was also pre-planned.                                                                    were standing on a catwalk above the domed, cylindrical tank
   This article will continue with a Part 2 in the next issue. Feel free to              performing welding when an internal explosion ripped open the
contact this author at John.Frank@xlgroup.com or at +1 404-431 2673.C                    tank lid. All three workers died of traumatic injuries, including
                                                                                         two who were found on the ground beneath the tank. A fourth,
John Frank, P.E., CFPS is with XL GAPS, a leading loss prevention services               who had been observing the work from a further distance, survived
provider and part of the XL group of companies. Through its operating subsidiaries,
XL Capital Ltd (NYSE: XL) is a leading provider of global insurance and reinsurance
                                                                                         with minor injuries.
coverages to industrial, commercial and professional service firms, insurance               Among the issues the probe will examine is whether anaerobic
companies, and other enterprises on a worldwide basis. As of September 30, 2007,         microbes, which grow in the absence of oxygen and feed on organic
XL Capital Ltd had consolidated assets of approximately $60.9 billion and
consolidated shareholders’ equity of approximately $11.4 billion. More information
                                                                                         matter, produced flammable gas to fuel the explosion.               C

about XL Capital Ltd is available at www.xlcapital.com
44    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
EMS CORNER


Musings from the Chalkboard                                                      By WILLIAM R. KERNEY/College of Southern Nevada




I
      f you have been paying attention at all, you are aware of major             Now I’m all for the concept of competency-based education (we
      changes that are coming down the pipeline regarding EMS. These           really have been doing it for years and, after all, we do want them
      changes are significant and puzzling in the same breath and can          competent, don’t we?) but this creates a real flux when it comes time to
      severely impact many of you. While these may not even be fully           “set the standards” if you will. For instance, if the new standard
      released until 2010 (and of course, textbooks gearing up for shortly     recommends the airway component to be set at eight hours (and these
after that!) with an implementation date for some obscure date post            hours are purely hypothetical and for example only) and one program
release, we will need to BR ready and able to make these changes when          teaches it in eight hours, but another completes it in four and states it
they come about. Notice, I did not say willing. There is already               has achieved competency (and might have other variables such as
squawking going on about the new standards and these have been out             instructor/student ratio), who is to say one is better than the other or
for review in first and second drafts for some time now. While the noise       one is more competent than the other? If it is competency based, then all
has been somewhat loud regarding the changes, the curriculum comes             you can judge it on is whether or not the student is competent in the
from a broad and versatile group of individuals representing many big          areas necessary.
players in the EMS game, such as the International Association of Fire            Okay, so what is the problem with this you ask? If we achieve a
Chiefs (IAFC), International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) and           competent provider, where have we made a mistake? The only way that
National Volunteer Fire Council (NVFC), not to mention the National            we have to evaluate the students (or employees if you are a training
Association of EMS Educators (NAEMSE). After all of the reviewing              director given the task of training your staff) is through examinations,
is completed, they seek to submit the new package to the National              both written and practical. Written exams will test the depth and breadth
Highway Traffic and Safety Administration (NHTSA) sometime this                of the knowledge base, and the skills exams test, the psychomotor
Fall.                                                                          component or the hands-on skills we work so hard to teach in a lab
    Some of the changes will involve some standardization of the               setting.
classifications that seemed to have plagued EMS from the beginning.               How do we keep instructors from “teaching to the test?” If I ‘teach
Many will remember EMT Cardiac Rescue Technician (okay, maybe                  to the test’ will this really give me a measure of any sort of competency
only the REAL old timers for that one), EMT-IV, EMT-D and so on                in the skill areas? If I “teach to the test,” will I truly be able to measure
and so forth. Then we went to First Responder, EMT-Basic, EMT-                 any sort of real depth and breadth of the knowledge base with the core
Intermediate (and for this you used either a 1992 or 1999 curriculum for       material? Will my student have any real penetration of the knowledge if
scope of practice) and of course EMTP. Now they want to go with a              my only concern is that he passes the exam?
simple 4 category standard with some austere name changes. First                  This has never created good, sound thinking providers and that is
Responder will become Emergency Medical Responder (EMR), EMT-                  what we truly want. All we seem to hear is we need them fast, we need
Basic will go back to Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) and EMT-              them now; you are not doing it fast enough. The hell with quality
Intermediate will become Advanced Emergency Medical Technician                 (although they don’t come right out and say that…), give us quantity!
(AEMT). Paramedic will remain Paramedic (EMTP).                                All we care about is that you can crank ‘em out! More, more, more! If
    Seems simple enough, right? Well for the name changes, I agree, but        they can pass the national exams and pass the skill tests to get their
the real issue will come in with the hours necessary to acquire these          certs, we are happy. The topic of good quality providers gets swept
certifications. The words “certification” and “license” seem to be used        under the carpet. We ask, “Don’t you want high quality, good EMS
interchangeably in some of the literature, but realize there is a distinct     providers?” They respond in the affirmative (how can they not?), but
difference where Project Medical Directors (PMD) “hold” certifications         then re-assert, “But ya gotta do it fast!” That is what we are hearing
(and allow you to practice under their license) and where a license is         from agencies that need trained personnel. No one is denying the need,
held by a regulatory agency and can be interpreted to be “free-standing.”      which is desperate in some areas, but quality cannot be set aside for
It seems that the real drift appears that these are still meant to be          speed or quantity.
certifications held by the PMDs although some areas are granting                  With training facilities having a “sliding scale” for the necessary
licensure at the paramedic level. How that whole process plays with            hours, quantity can be substituted for quality. If students can test out,
the PMDs and how they are overseeing and “regulating” licensed                 then they must be competent, right? An individual being tested may
individuals is still out, but it has been successful in some areas. In         know when to perform a certain skill. He may also know how to perform
reality, I do not think it makes a whole lot of difference or will matter if   a certain skill, but if he does not know why and does not have the
someone needs a license or certification “pulled.” That can happen in          knowledge or the critical thinking skills to back up the how, when, and
the blink of an eye.                                                           why, then he is not a health care provider. He is merely a machine
    Contact hours for the various levels are also increasing. EMR is           trained like a robot. As a robot he is unable to tolerate any variance in
increasing to 48 total hours. EMT is going to 166 to 180 clock hours.          the programming. He is stuck “in the box” and cannot climb out of it.
AEMT will now require 140to166 hours and may require an internship             Unique patients that present him or her with inconsistent problems
at the conclusion of the didactic and clinical training. Paramedic training    that may not fit into the classical mold will not receive the care that they
will come in somewhere at the 1,300 hour mark, but here is the corker          need, or worse, may receive substandard care. That is not the kind of
on the whole gig! It is going to be competency-based training and the          professional we seek to train in EMS. I not only consider this a detriment
hours are “recommended,” and are not carved in stone.                          to the profession but dangerous to the public at large.                    C
                                                                                                                  SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008               45
INDUSTRIAL SERVICE DIRECTORY
        COMPRESSED AIR TESTING                                      FIRE APPARATUS                                       FOAM
            & CERTIFICATION                             E-ONE
TRACE ANALYTICS, INC.                                   1601 SW 37th Ave.
15768 Hamilton Pool Rd.                                 Ocala, FL 34474
Austin, TX 78738                                        352/237-1122 • www.e-one.com
800/247-1024 • Fax 512/263-0002
                                                                                               “Exclusively in the Foam Business” — Sales & Service
sales@airchecklab.com • www.airchecklab.com
                                                                                               1 Rossmoor Drive
        CONSULTING/TRAINING                             Ferrara Fire Apparatus, Inc.           Monroe Township, NJ 08831
                  EMERGENCY                             Holden, Louisiana                      690/655-7777 • Fax 609/655-9538
                  SERVICES TRAINING                     Toll Free 800/443-9006                 E-mail — harp@foamtechnology.us
                  600 Marina Drive                      www.ferrarafire.com
                  Beaumont, TX 77701                                                           NATIONAL FOAM - KIDDE FIRE FIGHTING
409/833-BEST • Fax 409/833-2376                         NATIONAL FOAM - KIDDE FIRE FIGHTING    150 Gordon Drive
                                                        150 Gordon Drive                       Exton, PA 19341
              CHUBB LOSS CONTROL                        Exton, PA 19341                        24 Hr. Red AlertTM
              UNIVERSITY                                24 Hr. Red AlertTM                     610/363-1400 • Fax 610/524-9073
              “Hands On” Fire Protection                610/363-1400 • Fax 610/524-9073        www.kidde-fire.com
              Training                                  www.kidde-fire.com
Sprinklers Activated, Fire Pumps and More                                                      WILLIAMS FIRE &
Sam Lee 908/903-7172                                    PIERCE MANUFACTURING                   HAZARD CONTROL
www.chubb.com/lu                                        2600 American                          P.O. Box 1359
                                                        Drive                                  Mauriceville, TX 77626
FIRE & SAFETY SPECIALISTS INC.                          Appleton, WI 54913                     409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021
P.O. Box 9161                                           920/832-3231 • www.piercemfg.com
College Station, TX 77842                                                                                      FOAM EQUIPMENT
979/690-7559 • Fax 979/690-7562                                     SUTPHEN CORPORATION
                                                                    P.O. Box 0158
INDUSTRIAL FIRE TRAINING CONSULTANTS                                Amlin, OH 43002
P.O. Box 17947 • Nashville, TN 37217-0947                           800/848-5860
                                                                                               FOAMPRO-HYPRO
615/793-5400 • iftc.fire@iftcfire.com
                                                                                               375 Fifth Ave. N.W.
www.iftcfire.com
                                                              FIRE APPARATUS HARDWARE          New Brighton, MN 55112
                                                        HARRINGTON, INC.                       651/766-6300 • 800/533-9511 • Fax 651/766-6614
LSU FIRE & EMERGENCY CONSULTANTS
6868 Nicholson Drive                                    2630 West 21st St.
Baton Rouge, LA 70820                                   Erie, PA 16506 • 800/553-0078
800/256-3473 • Fax 225/765-2416                         814/838-3957 • Fax 814/838-7339
http://feti.lsu.edu • Ltu1996@lsu.edu

NATIONAL FOAM - KIDDE FIRE FIGHTING
150 Gordon Drive
Exton, PA 19341                                                                                TASK FORCE TIPS, INC.
24 Hr. Red AlertTM                                                                             Valparaiso, IN 46383 • 800/348-2686
610/363-1400 • Fax 610/524-9073                                                                sales@tft.com • www.tft.com
www.kidde-fire.com                                      TASK FORCE TIPS, INC.                  “An American Owned Company.”
                                                        Valparaiso, IN 46383 • 800/348-2686
SALT LAKE CITY ARFF TRAINING                            sales@tft.com • www.tft.com            WILLIAMS FIRE &
CENTER                                                  “An American Owned Company.”           HAZARD CONTROL
P.O. Box 22107                                            FIRE FIGHTING & HAZARD CONTROL       P.O. Box 1359
Salt Lake City, UT 84122                                WILLIAMS FIRE &                        Mauriceville, TX 77626
www.slcairport.com/arff •                               HAZARD CONTROL                         409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021
david.steward@slcgov.com                                P.O. Box 1359
                                                        Mauriceville, TX 77626                                     FOAM PUMPS
                                                        409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021
                                                                     FIRE PROTECTION
                                                        KBS PASSIVE FIRE
TSB LOSS CONTROL CONSULTANTS                            Fire Stop Coating &
3940 Morton Bend Road – Rome, GA 30161                  Penetration Seals                      Manufactured at:
706/291-1222 • Fax 706/291-2255                         604/941-1001                           800 Airport Road
www.tsblosscontrol.com                                  Fax 604/941-1029 •                     North Aurora, IL 60542
Industrial fire, hazmat & technical rescue training &   www.KBSpassivefire.com                 Sales Office: 630/859-7000 • Fax 630/859-1226
consulting — An FM Global company

WILLIAMS FIRE &                                                                        Visit www.fireworld.com
HAZARD CONTROL
P.O. Box 1359
                                                                                       for details on the
Mauriceville, TX 77626
409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021
                                                                                       2009 IFW Conference & Expo
46    INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
              FOAM TESTING                                         HOTELS                                         MONITORS
                                                                                                 NATIONAL FOAM - KIDDE FIRE FIGHTING
                                                                                                 150 Gordon Drive
                                                                                                 Exton, PA 19341
         ISO 9001: 2000 Certified                                                                24 Hr. Red AlertTM
       www.dynetechnologies.com                                                                  610/363-1400 • Fax 610/524-9073
          Toll Free: 866/713-2299                                                                www.kidde-fire.com
     Email: lab@dynetechnologies.com
         HARD SUCTION HOSE
                                                 2355 IH-10 South — Beaumont, TX 77705
                                                 409/842-3600 • Fax 409/842-0023
                                                 e-mail: pattiowens@mcmelegante.com

                                                                                                 TASK FORCE TIPS, INC.
                                                                                                 Valparaiso, IN 46383 • 800/348-2686
                                                                                                 sales@tft.com • www.tft.com
TASK FORCE TIPS, INC.                            HOLIDAY INN BEAUMONT PLAZA                      “An American Owned Company.”
Valparaiso, IN 46383 • 800/348-2686              3950 I-10 S & Walden Rd.                        WILLIAMS FIRE &
sales@tft.com • www.tft.com                      Beaumont, TX 77705                              HAZARD CONTROL
“An American Owned Company.”                     409/842-5995 • Fax 409/842-7878                 P.O. Box 1359
           HAZMAT EMERGENCY                             INCENTIVES/AWARDS/GIFTS                  Mauriceville, TX 77626
          RESPONSE EQUIPMENT                                                                     409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021
SKEDCO, INC.                                                                                                       NOZZLES
10505 SW Manhasset Drive                                                                         NATIONAL FOAM - KIDDE FIRE FIGHTING
Tualatin, OR 97062                                                                               150 Gordon Drive
503/691-7909 • Fax 503/691-7973                  180 Franklin St.                                Exton, PA 19341
www.skedco.com                                   Framingham, MA 01702                            24 Hr. Red AlertTM
                                                 www.firecatalog.com • 1-800-729-1482            610/363-1400 • Fax 610/524-9073
                                                 Gifts, badges, & accessories for firefighters   www.kidde-fire.com
21 Commerce Drive                                             LDH EQUIPMENT
Danbury, CT 06810                                HARRINGTON, INC
888/473-6747 • Fax 203/207-9780                  2630 West 21st St.
                                                 Erie, PA 16506 800/553-0078
        HOSE/HOSE COUPLINGS                      814/838-3957•Fax 814/838-7339
NATIONAL FOAM - KIDDE FIRE FIGHTING
150 Gordon Drive
Exton, PA 19341                                                                                  TASK FORCE TIPS, INC.
24 Hr. Red AlertTM                                                                               Valparaiso, IN 46383 • 800/348-2686
610/363-1400 • Fax 610/524-9073                                                                  sales@tft.com • www.tft.com
www.kidde-fire.com                                                                               “An American Owned Company.”
                                                 TASK FORCE TIPS, INC.
WILLIAMS FIRE &                                  Valparaiso, IN 46383 • 800/348-2686             WILLIAMS FIRE &
HAZARD CONTROL                                   sales@tft.com • www.tft.com                     HAZARD CONTROL
P.O. Box 1359                                    “An American Owned Company.”                    P.O. Box 1359
Mauriceville, TX 77626                                            MONITORS                       Mauriceville, TX 77626
409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021                                                                  409/727-2347 • Fax 409/745-3021
                  HOTELS                                                                         RESCUE EQUIPMENT- CONFINED SPACE
COURTYARD BY MARRIOTT                                                                            SKEDCO, INC.
3939 State Highway 6 South                                                                       10505 SW Manhasset Drive
College Station, TX 77845                                                                        P.O. Box 3390
979/695-8111 •                                   P.O. Box 86 • Wooster, OH 44691
                                                                                                 Tualatin, OR 97062
Fax 979/695-8228                                 800/228-1161 • Fax 800/531-7335
                                                 custserv@akronbrass.com                         800/770-7533 • Fax 503/639-4538
Celebrating 80 Years of Hospitality Excellence
                                                 www.akronbrass.com                              www.skedco.com
                                                                                                               TURNOUT GEAR

          2009 IFW Emergency Responder Conference Specials

          • Conference registration at half the cost for five or more                            103 S. Main St.
                 • Company group meeting space available                                         Quakertown, PA 18951-1119
                                                                                                 215/536-2991 • Fax 215/538-2164
   • Contact kendra@fireworld.com to make your group’s arrangements.                             info@quakersafety.com •www.quakersafety.com


                                                                                                  Visit the IFW Store at
                                                                                                  www.fireworld.com
                                                                                                         SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008                47
SPOTLIGHT ADS




                               Sept. 2008:
                               15-19         Rope Rescue
                               22-26         Confined Space Rescue
                               29-Oct. 3     HAZWOPER 40-HR HazMat Technician

                               Oct. 2008:
                               6-10          HazMat Chemistry
                               7-9           HazMat On-Scene Incident Commander
                               7-10          Entry Level Industrial Firefighter
                               14-17         Advanced Exterior Industrial Firefighter




  48   INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
   EDITORIAL BOARD                                                      INDUSTRIAL
                                                                        FIRE
                                                                        WORLD

   Richard Coates                                  Mark A. Hawkinson                                    Robert Stegall
   Johnson Controls                                BP America Production Co.                            Rio Tinto Mineral Co.

   Kendall C. Crawford                             John A. Meleta                                       Tommy Sullivan
   Crawford Consulting Associates                  L.A. County Fire Dept. Capt. (Ret.)                  Howard County (TX) VFD

   Woody Cole                                      Larry Phillips                                       Thomas G. Talley
   Calpine Corporation                             Northwest Region Fire/Rescue                         Deep South Crane & Rigging Co.

   John A. Frank                                   Niall Ramsden                                        Sherrie C. Wilson
   XL GAP Services                                 Resource Protection International                    Dallas Fire Rescue/Emergency
                                                                                                        Management Rescue
   Joseph H. Gross                                 Kenneth Roxberry
   Roberts Company, Inc.                           Premix Inc.                                          Robert J. Wood
                                                                                                        Chevron (Ret.)


New Products




          SMARTDOCK GEN 2                               iEVAC FIRE ESCAPE HOOD                               AG SERIES GAS BOOSTERS
LifeGuard Technologies®, a division of IMMI,       Elmridge Protection Products announces the            A new series of –50 ratio gas boosters offering
has announced the introduction of its seat-based   introduction of the iEvac® Fire Escape Hood           higher flow rates and faster fill times for a wide
SmartDock Gen 2. SmartDock is an innovative        is first to earn Certification to the new American    range of industrial and military applications
SCBA holder that enables single-motion             Standard ANSI/ISEA110. iEvac® protects                has been introduced by Haskel International,
insertion of the SCBA and hands-free release,      against fire-related risks including toxic gases,     Inc. The AG Series air driven gas boosters can
without straps or levers.                          harmful particulates and life-threatening             be oxygen cleaned to meet MIL STD 1330D,
    SmartDock is designed to help protect          physical hazards. American certification              the highest oxygen cleaning standard approved
firefighters by containing the SCBA and            involves rigorous independent testing against         by the US Navy. The boosters satisfy emerging
preventing it from becoming a projectile in the    many challenges including carbon monoxide,            requirements for greater gas flow than –30 ratio
event of a collision. The Gen 2 design has one     smoke, hydrogen cyanide, sulfur dioxide, other        units operating at maximum capacity. At the
model number and is engineered so it fits with     gases, particulates, fumes, soot, flammability,       same time they offer higher gas volumes than –
the majority of SCBAs used in today’s North        radiant heat & environmental conditioning.            75 ratio boosters operating at their lowest
American fire departments. With its low            Additional testing has been performed by the          pressure. For divers and emergency equipment
profile, SmartDock interfaces effectively with     US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological                  operators, this new ratio provides faster fills
a wide variety of fire apparatus seats.            Center. The iEvac® contains a HEPA filter             at higher pressures for recently developed
    SmartDock was launched in September            that removes more than 99.97% of sub-micron           smaller, lightweight bottles. It is also designed
2006. When evaluated to the NFPA 1901              particles such as anthrax, smallpox &                 for high flow production applications. The
Standard for Automotive Fire Apparatus,            radioactive particles; also protects against          boosters provide outlet pressures up to 15,000
SmartDock Gen 2 met requirements for               ammonia, chlorine, phosphine & more. One              psi (1,034 bar) with built-in cooling. They
retaining both the cylinder and the pack in        universal size can be put on in 30 seconds.           require no electricity or airline lubrication. With
dynamic testing.                                   Easy-to-breathe dual-cartridges, compact,             assured separation between the air drive and
    SmartDock Gen 2 will be available for          lightweight, vacuum sealed in a foil bag for a        gas booster sections, they are hydrocarbon free.
purchase in the fall of 2008. For information      long shelf life. High visibility reflective strips    Units are available in various configurations of
on availability, contact LifeGuard                 for easy recognition. Unobstructed view with          single stage-single acting, single stage-double
Technologies® at 866-765-5835 or visit             eyeglasses. Visit www.elmridgeprotection.com          acting and two-stage models. Call 1-818-843-
lifeguardtechnologies.com.                         or call 561.244.8337                                  4000 or visit www. haskel.com.
                                                                                                                  SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2008               49
Preparing      Make plans to attend the 24th Industrial
               Fire World Emergency Responder
yourself       Conference & Exposition
and your       • Receive a FREE general admission pass to the IFW conference with a 3-
                 year subscription to Industrial Fire World magazine. Subscribe online at

responders       www.fireworld.com.
               • Group rates for ½ price are available! Complete the Corporate Sponsor
                 Form on Page 5.
with           • Schedule space for your corporate meeting while your chiefs are in one
                 place. Contact IFW at (979)690-7559.
top value,     • Interact with industry professionals for certification and training on
                 emergency issues to help you excel as an industrial emergency responder.

top quality    Visit www.fireworld.com for more information about these 2009 IFW
               Conference Workshops:
&              • ASSE Seminar*
               • CFPS Prep Course & Exam*

top training   • Fire Instructor I*
               • Flammable Liquids/Storage Tank Fire Protection
               • Incident Safety Officer Certified Training*
               • LNG Symposium
               • New Standards & Technologies
               • NFPA 1005: Marine Fire Fighting for Land-based Firefighters*
               • NFPA 1081: Leadership Training*
               • NIMS 300: Intermediate Incident Command System*
               • NIMS 400: Advanced Incident Command System*
               • Pre-Emergency Planning for Industrial Facilities

                 * Fee-added workshop
                 ProBoard or IFSAC certification courses are italicized.
                                      INDUSTRIAL FIRE WORLD
                                      EMERGENCY RESPONDER
                                      CONFERENCE & EXPO
                                      March 23 - 27, 2009
                                      Beaumont, Texas
                                       Industrial Fire World
                                       emerged 23 years ago
                                       for you, the industrial
                                       emergency responder,
                                       based on the expertise of
                                       IFW publisher David
                                       White. He and other
                                       leading experts gather
                                       each year at the IFW
                                       conference to address
                                       cutting edge issues that
                                       face industrial fire and
                                       emergency response
                                       managers and personnel.
                                       Make sure that your
                                       brigade receives
                                       professional development
                                       through certified and
                                       informational sessions at
                                       the premier
                                       conference
                                       designed
                                       especially
                                       for you.


P.O. Box 9161 • College Station, TX 77845 • PH# 979.690.7559 • FX# 979.690.7562 • E-MAIL ind@fireworld.com • www.fireworld.com
WILLIAMS
 FP-4C

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:38
posted:7/12/2012
language:English
pages:52
suchufp suchufp http://
About