Section 1001 Performance Related Specification

							                      Comment Summation Sheet for Sec 303
Team Leader:    Mark Shelton
Team Members:   Dale Williams        Jerry Hirtz           Rob Lauer            Joe Ulrich
John Donahue    Perry Dummitt


Attachment Commenter and
  Number    Company Name                    Comment                                 Action Taken    If No Action Taken, Explain Why
1          Kirsten Munck        Numerous editorial comments.            Editorial changes made.
           MoDOT
2          Dan Hall             Require top 2” of 2 foot rock fill be   None.                      The current specification requires that
           Freesen              aggregate base.                                                    the top 2 inches of the base consist of
                                                                                                   material with a maximum top size of
                                                                                                   2 inches with at least 50 percent
                                                                                                   retained on the Number 4 sieve or a
                                                                                                   Type 5 aggregate base. Therefore, the
                                                                                                   top 2 inches allow “fine” grading with
                                                                                                   fine grading types of equipment. In
                                                                                                   cases where grading and paving
                                                                                                   contracts are awarded separately,
                                                                                                   Design should evaluate the grade
                                                                                                   prior letting the paving contract.
2          Dan Hall             Pay for additional processing.          None.                      Prior to processing the rock base,
           Freesen                                                                                 contractors should select the proper
                                                                                                   type of equipment. By using the
                                                                                                   correct type of equipment, the
                                                                                                   contractor has some control over their
                                                                                                   processes. When unforeseen
                                                                                                   circumstances arise, there are
                                                                                                   procedures in place for compensation.
3   Russell Crane   Require top 2” of 2 foot rock fill be      None.                The current specification requires that
    Emery Sapp &    aggregate base.                                                 the top 2 inches of the base consist of
    Sons                                                                            material with a maximum top size of
                                                                                    2 inches with at least 50 percent
                                                                                    retained on the Number 4 sieve or a
                                                                                    Type 5 aggregate base. Therefore, the
                                                                                    top 2 inches allow “fine” grading with
                                                                                    fine grading types of equipment. In
                                                                                    cases where grading and paving
                                                                                    contracts are awarded separately,
                                                                                    Design should evaluate the grade
                                                                                    prior letting the paving contract.
3   Russell Crane   Remove washing requirement from            None.                This is an option the contractor can
    Emery Sapp &    303.2.                                                          use when material does not meet
    Sons                                                                            specifications. It is not a requirement.
3   Russell Crane   Clarify 303.5.1.2, payment is for          Comment addressed.
    Emery Sapp &    furnishing and hauling. There is
    Sons            already a contract unit price
                    established for placement.
3   Russell Crane   Fixed unit price for additional off-site   None.                This concern should be addressed by
    Emery Sapp &    material is unfair.                                             the Section 109 team.
    Sons