ch 22 by xuyuzhu


									                                           Chapter 22

                            The Battle for National Reform (p. 593)

- The word “progressive” had many                  MI: Reforming National Government
meanings, so even progressives didn’t know
what exactly that word meant. ->                   ++- Beginning early in the 20th century, the
                                                   state a local levels began to look to the
                                                   federal government, but all of them were
                                                   weak and delayed due to partisan politics.

                                                   ++- Progressives wanted to make it more
- seemed poorly suited to serve as an agent        responsive to their demands. Some
of reform->                                        reformers urged an end to the election
                                                   system, by which made the Senators be
                                                   elected by their state legislatures. Instead,
                                                   the direct popular election was proposed.
-They believed that it would make the
Senate more effective to the public demands        ++- In 1912, the 17th Amendment passed by
->                                                 Congress was ratified by the states in 1913,
                                                   brought about that change.

                                                   ++- Even a reformed Congress wasn’t able
-Why that kind of leadership wasn’t                to take a leadership for the progressive
coherent for the progressive agenda?               agenda, the only solution was the

                                                   ++- The presidency was still firmly in the
-The Republican party believed that the            hands if conservative leaders of the
government and its leader should work first        Republican party. After President William
and foremost to stabilize existing conditions      McKinley’s death, his vice president,
and protect wealth and poverty                     Theodor Roosevelt, came into power.
                                                   Roosevelt’s presidency brought variety
                                                   advantages to the nation. After he left in
                                                   1909, he was replaced by his friend William
                                                   Howard Taft, who disappointed Roosevelt
                                                   and his progressive followers.

                                                   ++- The next president, Woodrow Wilson
                                                   created new regulatory mechanisms that
                                                   gave the government the power to protect
-During that time Washington established           the safety of food, regulation of trade and
itself as the great power enters of American       fight monopoly, and the bank system’s
government.            ->                          control.
Summary: Beginning early in the 20th century, the state a local levels began to look to the federal
government, but all of them were weak and delayed due to partisan politics. The Senators
weren’t elected by their state legislatures anymore. Instead, there was a direct popular election
proposed. In 1912, the 17th Amendment passed by Congress was ratified by the states in 1913,
brought about that change. In 1912, Woodrow Wilson came into presidency; he created new
regulatory mechanisms that brought benefits for the country.
                    Theodore Roosevelt and the Modern Presidency

(p.594) The Accidental President

- Roosevelt’s Background- In September 1901, after President William McKinley died, the Vice
President, Theodore Roosevelt came into presidency. Roosevelt was the youngest president. His
reputation as a wild man was a result less of the substance of his early political career than its
style. He never openly rebelled against the leaders of his party; he became rather, a champion of
cautious, moderate change. Reform, he believed, to protect society against more radical changes.

Government, Capital, and Labor

-Roosevelt’s Vision of Federal Power- Roosevelt considered the federal government as a
mediator of the public good, with a president at it center. He was not opposed to the principle of
economic concentration, but he acknowledged that the consolidation produced dangerous abuses
of power. Therefore, he allied himself with those progressives who urged regulation of the trusts.

- (p. 595) Northern Security Company- In 1903, the new Department of Commerce and Labor
was established. Roosevelt made a highly publicize efforts to break up trusts, by ordering the
Justice Department to invoke the Sherman Antitrust Act against a new railroad monopoly in

“The Square Deal”

-Reform wasn’t Roosevelt’s top priority during his first years as president. He was more
concerned with winning reelection, which meant that he couldn’t be against the Republican Old
Guard. By dispensing patronage to conservatives ad progressives alike, by reshuffling the
leadership of unstable Southern Republican organizations, by winning the support of northern
businessmen, Roosevelt won the 1904 election.

-The Interstate Commerce Act of 1887, establishing the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC)
had been an early effort for regulation of industry, by asking Congress to increase fed power to
oversee rates. The Hepburn Regulation Act of 1906 required restoring the authority to the
government, but the bill was cautious that it satisfied few progressives. (p. 596)

-Roosevelt also urged Congress to pass Pure Food and Drug Act, which stopped the sale of
dangerous and ineffective medicines. When Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle came up in 1906, which
described the truth about meatpacking industry, Roosevelt supported the Meat Inspection Act,
which helped to eliminate many diseases from meat. From 1907, he also proposed 8-hour day for
workers, better compensation for victims of industrial accidents, inheritance and income taxes,
regulation of the stock market and others.
Roosevelt and Conservation

- Roosevelt’s strict policies on behalf of conservation lead to that gulf; he had been concerned
about the unregulated exploitation of American natural resources and its wilderness. So, he
restricted private development on government acres, by adding them to the previously modest
national forest system.

-In the early 20th century, many people who considered themselves “conservationists” (such as
Giffold Pinchot, the 1st director of National Forest Service)- promoted policies to protect land for
carefully managed development. Pinchot and Roosevelt believed that it should apply to the
landscape the same scientific method standards of management of cities and industries.

-In 1902, the president backed the National Reclamation Act or the Newlands Act, which was
the culmination of years of lobbying by businessmen and others from the West. This act
provided federal funds for the construction of dams, reservoirs, and canals in the West- project
that will bring cheap electric power.

Roosevelt and Preservation

- Roosevelt was also interested in concerns of naturalists- those within the conservation
movement committed to protecting land, wildlife from human intrusion. In the early presidency,
Roosevelt even spent 4 hour day camping. He created the expansion of the National Forest
System for protecting public land from exploitation or development at all, but also grew National
Park System to protect lands from any development.

(p. 598) The Hetch Hetchy Controversy

- In 1906, Hetch Hetchy Valley in Yosemite National Park seen as beautiful land by naturalists,
but San Francisco residents Roosevelt’s head of National Forest System Gifford Pinchot wanted
land to build dam reservoir for city’s growing water needs.

-Competing Conservationists Visions- There was a battle between naturalists and the advocates,
which consumed the energies of John Muir for the rest of his life. To Pinchot, the issue was the
practical one of whether saw needs of city more important than claims of preservation; issue
placed in 1908 referendum, dam approved by large margin in election.

The Panic of 1907

-Despite the flurry of reforms Roosevelt was able to enact, the government still had little control
over the industrial economy. In 1907, a serious panic and recession began. As in 1893, American
industrial production had outrun the capacity of either domestic or foreign markets to absorb it.

-Conservatives blamed Roosevelt’s “mad” economic policies for the disaster. J.P. Morgan
pooled assets of NY banks to prop up banks, made deal with Pres to allow U.S. Steel of the
shares of the Tennessee Coal and Iron Company.
-The Panic of 1907, combined with Roosevelt’s growing “radicalism” during his second term. In
1904, he had made a public promise to step down four years later.

                                 The Troubled Succession

In 1909, William Howard Taft assumed the presidency, had been Theodore Roosevelt’s most
trusted lieutenant and his hand-picked successor.

(p. 599) Taft and the Progressives

-Taft’s 1st problem arose in the opening months of the new administration when he called
Congress into special session to lower protective tariff rates, an old progressive demand. During
early administration called on Congress to lower tariff, refused to oppose Republic Old Guard.
The result was the feeble Payne-Aldrich Tariff, which reduced tariff rates at all and in some
areas raised them. Progressives resented Taft’s passivity.

-A sensational controversy broke out late in 1909 that helped destroy Taft’s popularity with
reforms. Ballinger- Pinchot Dispute in which Head of Forest Service Gifford Pinchot was told
that Sec of Interior Richard Ballinger had sold public lands in Alaska for personal profit. Taft
thought charges groundless, Pinchot leaked info to press. President discharged Pinchot for
insubordination, and the congressional committee appointed to study the controversy.

(p. 600) The Return of Roosevelt

- Theodore Roosevelt was in Africa or Europe; he had no plans to reenter politics. However, on
September 1, 1910, in Osawatomie, Kansas, he outlined a set of principles, which je labeled the
“New Nationalism,” that moved a considerable away from the cautious conservatism. He argued
that social justice was possibly only effort of strong fed government could bring social justice.

Spreading Insurgency

-The Congressional elections of 1910 provided many further evidence of how far the progressive
revolt had spread. Republicans suffered defeat candidates lost and progressives reelected. The
Democrats, who were now offering progressive candidates of their own, won the control of the
House of the Representatives for the 1st time in 16 years.

(601) Roosevelt versus Taft

-La Follette retained some diehard support. Taft remained the choice of most party leaders, who
controlled the nominating process. had support of conservative Republicans and party leaders,
Roosevelt supported by the new Progressive Party, was nominated himself as its presidential
candidate. At convention Republican National Committee gave nomination to Taft.

                        Woodrow Wilson and The New Freedom

Woodrow Wilson
-Reform sentiment had been gaining strength within the Democrats as well as the Republican
Party in the first years of the century. At the 1912 Democratic Conversation in Baltimore in June,
Champ Clark, the conservative Speaker of the House, was unable to assemble most of the
majority for nomination; finally, became the governor of NJ.

-Wilson had been a professor at Princeton in political science until 1902; was named as the
president of the university; in 1910, became the governor of NJ. In 1912, presented a progressive
program “New Freedom.” It differed from Roosevelt’s New Nationalism in its approach to
economic policy and the trusts. Roosevelt and Taft split Republican vote; Wilson won.

(p. 602) The Scholar as President

-Wilson was a bold and forceful president- used position as leader of Democrats to build
coalition to support his program. His 1st triumph as a president was the fulfillment of an old
Democratic goal: substantial lowering of the protective tariff. Greatly lowered tariff in
Underwood-Simmons Tariff in order to introduce competition into market and breakup trusts; to
make up for revenues past graduated income tax

-On December 23, 1913, the Federal Reserve Act was established, which created 12 regional
banks which were controlled by other banks. The regional Federal Reserve banks hold certain %-
used reserves in order to support loans to private banks at an interest (“discount” ) rate, issued
Federal Reserve notes backed by government, shifted funds to meet credit demands and protect

- (p. 602) In 1914, Wilson proposed 2 measures to deal with monopoly. The Congress passed
Federal Trade Commission Act (created a regulatory agency that would help business determine
whether their actions acceptable to the government) and Clay Antitrust Act (did little for
protection from conservative assaults). (p. 603)

Retreat and Advance

-By the fall of 1914, Wilson believed that the New Freedom was complete. He refused to support
progressive suffrage movement and efforts to halt segregation in federal agencies after
Democrats had heavy losses in Congress in 1914 elections to Republicans Wilson began new
reforms. He supported a measure for farmers for receiving credit and compensation or federal

-Wilson was sponsoring measures that expanded the role of the national government in
significant ways. In 1916, Wilson supported the Keating-Owen Act, which was the 1st federal
law regulating child labor. Appointment of progressive Louis Brandeis to Supreme Court;
supported measured expanding role of federal government 1916 Keating-Owen Act regulated
child labor. The Smith-Lever Act of 1914 supported agricultural extension education. (p. 604)

                 The “Big Stick”: America and The World, 1901-1917
Roosevelt and “Civilization”

- Racial and Economic Basis of Roosevelt’s Diplomacy- Roosevelt believed in the value and
significance of using American power in the world, but he thought that an important distinction
existed between the “civilized”(predominantly white and Anglo-Saxon or Teutonic) and
“uncivilized”(nonwhite such as Latin or Slavic) nations.

(p. 605) Protecting the “Open Door” in Asia

-Great White Fleet- In 1904 the Japanese made a surprise attack on the Russian fleet at Port
Arthur in Southern Manchuria (a province of China that both nations craved to control).
Roosevelt helped Russia and Japan to end the Russo-Japanese War - got the Nobel Prize in 1906.

(p. 606) The Iron Fisted Neighbor

-Roosevelt became interested in Latin America. He embarked on a serious of ventures in the
Caribbean and South America; established a pattern of American intervention in the region that
would long serve his presidency.

-In 1902, Venezuela began to renege on debts to European bankers- Germans bombarded its
port. Roosevelt pressured the German navy to withdraw.

-In 1904, he announced the “the Roosevelt Corollary” to the Monroe Doctrine.

The Panama Canal -The most famous accomplishment of Roosevelt’s presidency (linked in the
Atlantic and the Pacific)

-John Hay – the secretary of state, who negotiated an agreement with Columbian diplomats in

- Panamanian Revolt- In November 1903, Philippe Bunau- Varilla (chief engineer of French
canal project) helped to organize and finance a revolution in Panama- it had support from U.S. –
Roosevelt send troops from the U.S.S. Nashville in Panama.

(p. 607) – Taft’s secretary of state, Philander Knox, worked aggressively to extend American
investments into less- developed regions- “Dollar Diplomacy”.

-Investigation in Nicaragua- In 1909, the revolution broke in Nicaragua; the administration allied
with the insurgents and sent American troops into the country to seize the customs houses; then
to protect the regime.

Diplomacy and Morality

-In 1905, The U.S. took control of the finances in DR, and in 19106 established a military
-(p. 608) Wilson’s Moral Diplomacy – wasn’t similar with his predecessors with Mexico. In
1910, Diaz had been replaced by Francisco Madero, who promised American business in
Mexico. He and Wilson dragged into conflict.

- Wilson saw a bloodless action, but in a clash with Mexican troops in Veracruz the America
killed 126 defenders.

(p. 609) – Intervention in Mexico- Wilson ordered General John J. Pershing to lead and
American expeditionary force across the Mexican border in pursuit of villa- never found it and
lost 12 troops. Again, the U.S. and Mexico were in conflict.

To top