Docstoc

roar-unitary-analysis

Document Sample
roar-unitary-analysis Powered By Docstoc
					                                Plans used

Original Proposed NES           Discussion document

Revised Proposed NES            Information booklet - second comments period




                                Gisborne District Council Combined Regional Land and
Gisborne DC                     District Plan.


                                The regional plan for discharges to land and water


Tasman DC




                                Tasman Resource Management Plan

Marlborough DC                  Wairau Awatere Resource Management Plan



                                Marlborough Sounds Resource Management Plan
Nelson CC                       Nelson Resource Management Plan


Methodology
The original proposed NES is the control/starting point where all other councils are compared to (scores '0' for each activity and ov
Where a rule is more stringent in a plan than the original proposed NES (green column) it gets a '+ 1', less stringent gets a '- 1', an
NES ability to be more stringent (red column) gets a '0' when mentioned in plan (recording these will help identify where councils a
Where resource consent is required for an activity it is considered more stringent than all original proposed NES conditions in the g
When a plan has a condition not covered in the original proposed NES it is recoded in the blue column and given a '+1'
The revised proposed NES policy will be evaluated against original proposed NES
Only rules have been compared (many councils may address issues differently - sometimes using non-comparable/non-regulatory
Only rural zone provisions have been compared as well as any general performance standards (or similar) that apply to an activity

Assumptions
Building/roading shading rules are considered more stringent than absolute values for setbacks
Hazardous substances rules applied to all activities as all could use/store fuel onsite for machinery
Nuisance rules (such as noise) applied to all activities as all may have some form of mechanisation etc
                                                                         ⁰ ⁰
Indigenous vege clearance rules applied to all activities as all could need to clear indigenous vegetation to undertake activity
                                                                     ⁰            ⁰
Orange areas (original policy) = moderate erosion (see Nelson plan 25 -35 , MDC 20-35⁰ )
Red areas (original policy) = severe erosion (see Nelson plan: >35 , MDC >35 , MDC ARMP Land use class 8)
Note: In MDC there are different rules for Rural 1 and Rural 2 (Rural 2 has been used for analysis)
The Rural One zone has been identified as a high risk area for particularpotentially adverse effects of forestry operations. The char
•A large number of waahi tapu sites;
•A particularly long coastal/land boundary;
•Slopes that generally drop steeply and directly into the sea;
•Large areas of public land set aside for conservation purposes;
•Areas of pastoral land that are reverting to scrub and bush;
•Areas of commercial and woodlot forestry;
•A unique “drowned valley” topography;
•A public road network that is not designed for high intensity, heavy vehicletraffic;
•The Marlborough Sounds is characterised by a large Rural One Zone, aswell as a widespread scattering of residential properties,
                      Plan status                        Date
                                                         Sep-10
                      Proposed
                                                         May-11
                      Proposed




                      Operative in part                  31-Jan-06


                      Operative in part                  8-Jul-06




                      Operative                          18-Sep-08

                      Operative in part                  9-Mar-09
                      Operative in parts on the 28
                      February 2003 and on 28 March
                      2003                          28-Mar-03
                      Operative                     5-Jun-07



er councils are compared to (scores '0' for each activity and overall)
NES (green column) it gets a '+ 1', less stringent gets a '- 1', and equal/similar '0'
 ned in plan (recording these will help identify where councils are likey to be more stringent in the future)
 ore stringent than all original proposed NES conditions in the green column
ES it is recoded in the blue column and given a '+1'

  differently - sometimes using non-comparable/non-regulatory approaches)
 ral performance standards (or similar) that apply to an activity


bsolute values for setbacks
store fuel onsite for machinery
ve some form of mechanisation etc
   ⁰ ⁰
need to clear indigenous vegetation to undertake activity
           ⁰
 25 -35 , MDC 20-35⁰ )
 MDC >35 , MDC ARMP Land use class 8)
 2 has been used for analysis)
cularpotentially adverse effects of forestry operations. The characteristics of theRural One zone that can contribute to its higher risk are:




ne, aswell as a widespread scattering of residential properties, most of whichare within the Sounds Residential Zone.
                      Comments/assumptions




                      Overlays 1,2&3 same conditions for harvesting.
                      Used Rural P (productive for comparison)
                      a) Land Overlay 1 - comprises LUC Classification Unit Classes I -V and VIe1, 2, 3, 5, 7 and 8 inclusive. This land
                      overlay recognises the district’s flat land and easy hill country. Land Overlay 1 is mapped in order to provide some
                      indication of land which is capable of a wide range of sustainable land uses. Land Overlay 1 excludes the beds of
                      lakes and rivers. (Compared to green area)
                      b) Land Overlay 2 - comprises the balance of LUC Classification Units in Class VI. This land overlay describes hill
                      country land which is moderately limited in terms of its capability for sustainable use. Land Overlay 2 excludes the
                      beds of lakes and rivers.
                      (Compared to green area)
                      c) Land Overlay 3 - comprises land in LUC Classification Unit Classes VII and VIII. Options for sustainable landuse in
                      these classes of land are severely limited. It is the most susceptible to erosion, sediment generation and soil loss.
                      Land Overlay 3 excludes the beds of lakes and rivers. Land Overlay 3 includes LO3A.
                      (Compared to orange area)




                      Council is currently applying these setbacks. They are subject to resolution of some minor changes to the conditions
                      – none of them particularly substantive in relation to forestry controls.
                      The TRMP can be compared to the proposed NES, although some of the relevant provisions about plantation forest
                      and land disturbances in section 18.5 are subject to changes/variations that have not been fully resolved yet. Any
                      changes in 18.5 are not likely to affect the forestry controls in any substantive way (as they result mainly from coastal
                      environment area and new residential zoning changes ) (TDC 11 April 2011)

                      Covers about 50% of region


                      Covers about 50% of region. Has two rural zones. In Rural 1 forestry is limited discretionary (36-20) and in Rural 2
                      forestry is permitted (36-20) . See below for a description of Rural 1.




 - 1', and equal/similar '0'
uncils are likey to be more stringent in the future)
 in the green column


 ulatory approaches)
he characteristics of theRural One zone that can contribute to its higher risk are:




perties, most of whichare within the Sounds Residential Zone.
                          Afforestation Replanting MLP       Harvesting Pruning and thinning Earthworks Quarrying River Crossings
Proposed NES                           0          0      0             0                     0         0         0               0
Gisborne DC                            0          1      4             7                     4        -2        -8              -7
Tasman DC                              6          8      7            -4                    -1         5         1               1
Marlborough Awatere RMP                2          5      0             0                    -1         2        -2              -4
Marlborough MSRMP                      8          6      8             1                    -1         2        -3             20
Nelson CC                             -5         -6      0             0                    -2        -6       -10              -3
Total Stringency Score
                           0
                          -1
                          23
                           2
                          41
                         -32
                Afforestation provisions in regional plans


                                                                           Gisborne DC                       Tasman DC                Marlborough Awatere RMP              Marlborough MSRMP                     Nelson CC
               Stringency                                          less     same      more       less        same      more        less      same      more         less        same     more        less        same      more
               Archaeological                                                                1                                1                                 1                               1           -1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams <3m                          -1                            -1                                                      1            -1                             -1
               Setbacks - wetlands                                        -1                            -1                                -1                                                    1           -1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams >3m                          -1                                         0                    -1                                                    1           -1
               Setbacks - lakes larger than 0.25ha                        -1                                         0                    -1                                                    1           -1
Proposed NES Setbacks - Coastal Marine Area                                                  1                                1                                 1            -1                             -1
  conditions   Setbacks - adjoining properties                                     0                                 0                              0                                  0                                 0
               Setbacks - dwellings                                                0                                 0                                          1                               1           -1
               Setbacks - urban/res zones                                 -1                                                  1           -1                                                    1                                 1
               Setbacks - roading                                                            1                       0                              0                                  0                                          1
               Auditing                                                   -1                            -1                                -1                                 -1                             -1
               Default                                                                       1                                1                                 1                               1                                 1
               Afforestation in Red Areas                                 -1                            -1                                -1                                                    1           -1
               Fire risk
               Flood hazard zones mapped
               Geothermal and karst areas mapped
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified                              0                                                                                                   0
               Indigenous vegetation clearance                                     0                                 0                              0                                                                    0
 Ability to be Network utilities infrastructure setbacks
more stringent Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
               Nuisance issues                                                     0                                 0                              0                                  0
               ONFL identified                                                     0                                 0                              0
               Significant Natural Areas identified                                                                  0                                                                 0                                 0
               Water yield catchments identified
               Wilding tree potential
               Hazardous substances                                                          1                                1                                 1                               1
               Conservation overlay                                                                                                                                                                                               1
               Setbacks other than water                                                                                                                        1                               1
   Council     Rural One Zone                                                                                                                                                                   1
  conditions   Indigenous forestry                                                                                                                              1
  not in NES   Planting near mapped viewpoints                                                                                1
               Stopbanks                                                                                                      1
               Airport protection area                                                       1                                1
               Groundwater protection area                                                                                    1
               Surface water yield protection area                                                                            1
               Setbacks from farm buildings                                                  1
               Sub totals                                                 -7                 7          -4                    10          -6                    8            -3                 11          -9                    4
               Score                                                           0                                 6                              2                                  8                                -5

                District Conditions in NES
                Regional Conditions in NES
                Conditions not covered in NES
                Replanting provisions in regional plans


                                                                           Gisborne DC
               Stringency                                          less     same      more
               Archaeological                                                                1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams <3m                          -1
               Setbacks - wetlands                                        -1
Proposed NES Setbacks - rivers and streams >3m                            -1
  conditions   Setbacks - lakes larger than 0.25ha                        -1
               Setbacks - Coastal Marine Area                                                1
               Understorey vegetation                                               0
               Auditing                                                   -1
               Default                                                                       1
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified
               Indigenous vegetation clearance                                      0
 Ability to be Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
more stringent Nuisance issues                                                      0
               Hazardous substances                                                          1
               ONFL identified                                                               1
               Significant Natural Areas identified
   Council     Conservation overlay
  conditions   Setbacks other than water
  not in NES   Rural One Zone
               Indigenous forestry
               Planting near mapped viewpoints
               Stopbanks
               Airport protection area                                                       1
               Groundwater protection area
               Surface water yield protection area
               Sub totals                                                 -5                 6
               Score                                                            1

                District Conditions in NES
                Regional Conditions in NES
                Conditions not covered in NES
            Tasman DC               Marlborough Awatere RMP              Marlborough MSRMP
less         same    more        less      same      more         less        same     more
                             1                                1                               1
       -1                                                     1            -1
       -1                                                     1                               1
                    0                   -1                                                    1
                    0                   -1                                                    1
                             1                                1            -1
                    0                             0                                  0
       -1                               -1                                 -1
                             1                                1                               1
                                                                                     0
                    0                             0

                    0                             0                                  0
                             1                                1                               1
                             1                    0
                             1                                                                1

                                                              1                               1
                                                                                              1
                                                              1
                             1
                             1
                             1
                             1
                             1
       -3                   11          -3                    8            -3                 9
                8                             5                                  6
            Nelson CC
less        same      more
       -1
       -1
       -1
       -1
       -1
       -1
       -1
                             1
       -1

                    0




                             1




       -8                    2
               -6
                MLP provisions in regional plans


                                                                           Gisborne DC                        Tasman DC                Marlborough Awatere RMP              Marlborough DC                       Nelson CC
               Stringency                                          less     same      more        less        same      more        less      same      more         less     same       more        less        same      more
               Archaeological                                                                1                                 1                                 1                              1                                 1
               Fuel                                                       -1                                          0                    -1                               -1                              -1
               Methods                                                    -1                             -1                                          0                                0                     -1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams <3m                          -1                             -1                                -1                                                   1           -1
Proposed NES Setbacks - wetlands                                          -1                             -1                                -1                                                   1           -1
  conditions   Setbacks - rivers and streams >3m                          -1                             -1                                -1                                                   1           -1
               Setbacks - lakes larger than 0.25ha                        -1                             -1                                -1                                                   1           -1
               Setbacks - Coastal Marine Area                                                1           -1                                -1                               -1                              -1
               Understorey vegetation                                              0                                  0                              0                      -1                              -1
               Auditing                                                   -1                             -1                                -1                               -1                              -1
               Default                                                                       1                                 1                                 1                              1                        0
               Geothermal and karst areas mapped
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified                                                                                                                                 0                                  0
 Ability to be Indigenous vegetation clearance                                     0                                  0                              0                                                                   0
more stringent Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
               Nuisance issues                                                     0                                  0                              0                                0
               Significant Natural Areas identified                                0                                  0                                                               0                                  0
               Hazardous substances                                                          1                                 1                                 1                              1
               ONFL identified                                                               1
               Coastal and natural hazard areas mapped                                       1                                                                                                                                    1
               Sediment discharge concentrations                                             1                                 1                                                                1                                 1
               Erosion control                                                               1
               Soil, slash and debris                                                                                          1                                 1                              1                                 1
               Max area                                                                                                        1
               Soil disturbance in orange areas                                                                                                                                                 1                                 1
   Council     Soil disturbance in red areas                                                 1                                 1                                 1                              1                                 1
  conditions   Iron pan
  not in NES   Notification
               Stabilisation                                                                 1                                 1                                 1                              1                                 1
               Effects on neighbouring properties                                                                                                                                                                                 1
               Conservation overlay                                                                                                                                                                                               1
               Granite geology                                                                                                  1
               Soil conservation                                                                                                1
               Slash and debris                                                              1                                  1                                1
               Dissolved oxygen                                                                                                 1
               Sediment and storm water control                                                                                 1
               Flood hazard                                                                                                     1
               Subtotals                                                  -7                 11          -7                    14          -7                    7          -4                  12          -9                    9
               Score                                                           4                                  7                              0                                8                                  0

                District Conditions in NES
                Regional Conditions in NES
                Conditions not covered in NES
                Harvesting provisions in regional plans


                                                                           Gisborne DC
               Stringency                                          less     same      more
               Notification                                                                   1
               Archaeological                                             -1
               Fuel                                                       -1
               Methods                                                    -1
Proposed NES Stabilisation                                                                    1
  conditions   Riparian disturbance                                       -1
               Slash and debris management                                -1
               Auditing                                                   -1
               Default                                                                        1
               Soil disturbance in red areas                                                  1
               Geothermal and karst areas mapped
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified
 Ability to be Indigenous vegetation clearance                                      0
more stringent Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
               Nuisance issues                                                      0
               Significant Natural Areas identified                                 0
               Hazardous substances                                                           1
               ONFL identified                                                                1
               Soil disturbance                                                               1
               Sediment discharge concentrations                                              1
               Erosion control practices                                                      1
               Effects on aquatic life
   Council     Indigenous wetlands                                                            1
  conditions   Coastal margin                                                                 1
  not in NES   Threatened habitats/biodiversity
               Harvesting setbacks                                                            1
               Conservation overlay
               Dissolved oxygen
               Discharge of vegetation
               Vegetation clearence in orange areas                                           1
               Sub totals                                                 -6                 13
               Score                                                            7

                District Conditions in NES
                Regional Conditions in NES
                Conditions not covered in NES
            Tasman DC              Marlborough Awatere RMP              Marlborough MSRMP
less         same    more       less       same     more         less        same     more
       -1                               -1                                -1
       -1                                                    1                               1
                    0                  -1                                 -1
       -1                                        0                                  0
       -1                              -1                                 -1
       -1                              -1                                 -1
       -1                              -1                                 -1
       -1                              -1                                 -1
                            1                                1                               1
       -1                                                    1                               1

                                                                                    0
                    0                            0                                  0

                    0                            0                                  0
                    0                                                               0
                            1                                1                               1

                                                             1                               1
                                                             1                               1




                                                                                             1

                            1
                            1

       -8                   4          -6                    6            -6                 7
               -4                            0                                  1
            Nelson CC
less        same      more
       -1
                             1
       -1
       -1
                             1
       -1
       -1
       -1
                             1
       -1

                    0
                    0


                    0



                             1




                             1
                             1
                             1



       -7                    7
                0
Pruning and thinning provisions
in regional plans


                                           Gisborne DC                       Tasman DC
Stringency                        less      same      more       less         same    more
Slash                                    -1                             -1
Fuel                                     -1                             -1
Threshold (trees per hectare)                                1
Coastal overlay                                              1
SNA                                                          1
ONFL                                                         1
Default activity status                                      1
Nuisance issues                                              1                               1
Sub totals                               -2                  6          -2                   1
Score                                          4                                -1
   Marlborough Awatere RMP              Marlborough MSRMP                    Nelson CC
less       same     more         less        same     more       less        same      more
        -1                                -1                            -1
        -1                                -1                            -1




                             1                               1
       -2                    1            -2                 1          -2                    0
             -1                                 -1                              -2
                Earthworks provisions in regional plans


                                                                            Gisborne DC
               Stringency                                          less      same      more
               Maintenance and upgrade red areas                                               1
               Notification                                                -1
               Archaeological                                              -1
               Fuel                                                        -1
               Design matters                                              -1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams <3m                           -1
               Setbacks - wetlands                                         -1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams >3m                           -1
Proposed NES Setbacks - lakes larger than 0.25ha                           -1
  conditions   Setbacks - Coastal Marine Area                                                  1
               Fill material                                               -1
               Stabilisation and containment                               -1
               Sediment and stormwater control                             -1
               Sediment discharge concentrations                           -1
               Auditing                                                    -1
               Default activity status                                                         1
               Earthworks in an orange area                                                    1
               Earthworks in an red area                                                       1
               Coastal and natural hazard areas mapped                               0
               Geothermal and karst areas mapped
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified
               Indigenous vegetation clearance                                       0
 Ability to be Network utilities infrastructure setbacks
more stringent Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
               Nuisance issues                                                       0
               Significant Natural Areas identified                                  0
               Hazardous substances                                                            1
               Max face height                                                                 1
               ONFL identified                                                                 1
               Flood hazard zones mapped
               Volume not on erosion prone land                                                1
               Volume on erosion prone land
               Soil conservation                                                               1
               Roading/tracking/trenching
               Runoff control                                                                  1
   Council     Erosion control practices
  conditions   Vegetation clearence
  not in NES   Effect on neighbouring properties
               Conservation overlay
               Gradient of side cut
               Setbacks other than water
               Granite geology
               Flood hazard
               Slash and debris
               Coastal margin
               Dissolved oxygen
               Sub totals                                                 -13                 11
               Score                                                            -2

                District Conditions in NES
                Regional Conditions in NES
                Conditions not covered in NES
            Tasman DC                Marlborough Awatere RMP               Marlborough MSRMP
less         same     more        less       same     more          less        same      more
                    0                               0                                   0
       -1                                 -1                                 -1
                              1                                 1                                 1
                    0                    -1                                  -1
       -1                                -1                                            0
       -1                                                       1            -1
       -1                                                       1                                 1
                    0                    -1                                                       1
       -1                                -1                                                       1
                              1          -1                                  -1
       -1                                                       1            -1
                    0                    -1                                  -1
                    0                    -1                                  -1
       -1                                                       1                                 1
       -1                                -1                                  -1
                              1                                 1                                 1
                              1          -1                                  -1
       -1                                                       1                                 1


                                                                                       0
                    0                              0


                    0                              0                                   0
                    0                                                                  0
                              1                                 1                                 1
                              1



                                                                1                                 1
                              1
                              1

                              1
                                                   0                                              1


                                                                1                                 1
                                                                1
                              1
                              1
                              1                                 1
                              1
                              1
       -9                    14         -10                    12            -9                  11
                5                              2                                   2
             Nelson CC
less         same      more
                     0
        -1
                              1
        -1
        -1
        -1
        -1
        -1
        -1
        -1
                     0
                     0
        -1
        -1
        -1
                              1
        -1
        -1
                     0

                     0
                     0



                     0

                              1
                              1
                              1




                              1
                              1




       -13                    7
                -6
                Quarrying provisions in regional plans


                                                                            Gisborne DC                        Tasman DC                Marlborough Awatere RMP               Marlborough MSRMP                        Nelson CC
                Stringency                                         less      same      more       less         same      more        less       same     more          less        same     more          less         same      more
                Notification                                                                  1           -1                                 -1                                 -1                                -1
                Archaeological                                             -1                                                   1                                 1                                   1                                 1
                Fuel                                                       -1                                          0                    -1                                  -1                                -1
                Design matters                                             -1                             -1                                -1                                               0                    -1
                Setbacks - rivers and streams <3m                          -1                             -1                                                      1             -1                                -1

               Setbacks - wetlands                                         -1                             -1                                                      1                                   1           -1
               Setbacks - rivers and streams >3m                           -1                                          0                    -1                                                        1           -1
               Setbacks - lakes larger than 0.25ha                         -1                             -1                                -1                                                        1           -1
Proposed NES Setbacks - Coastal Marine Area                                                   1                                 1           -1                                  -1                                -1
  conditions   Fill material                                               -1                             -1                                                      1             -1                                              0
               Stabilisation and containment                               -1                                          0                    -1                                  -1                                              0
               Sediment and stormwater control                             -1                                          0                    -1                                  -1                                -1
               Sediment discharge concentrations                           -1                             -1                                                      1                                   1           -1
               Volume                                                      -1                                                   1           -1                                  -1                                -1
               Setbacks                                                    -1                             -1                                -1                                  -1                                -1
               Fill or spoil                                               -1                             -1                                -1                                  -1                                -1
               Site restoration                                            -1                             -1                                -1                                  -1                                -1
               Auditing                                                    -1                             -1                                -1                                  -1                                -1
               Default activity status                                                        1                                 1                                 1                                   1                                 1
               Coastal and natural hazard areas mapped                               0
               Geothermal and karst areas mapped
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified                                                                                                                                        0
               Indigenous vegetation clearance                                       0                                 0                               0                                                                        0
 Ability to be Network utilities infrastructure setbacks
more stringent Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
               Nuisance issues                                                       0                                 0                               0                                     0
               Significant Natural Areas identified                                  0                                 0                                                                     0
               Erosion susceptibility
               Hazardous substances                                                           1                                 1                                 1                                   1
               ONFL identified                                                                1
               Max Area on erosion prone land                                                                                                                                                         1
               Volume not on erosion prone land                                               1
               Volume on erosion prone land                                                                                                                       1
               Erosion control practices                                                                                        1
               Vegetation clearence                                                                                                                               1                                   1
   Council     Max face height                                                                                                                                                                                                          1
  conditions   Effect on neighbouring properties                                                                                                                                                                                        1
  not in NES   Conservation overlay                                                                                                                                                                                                     1
               Setbacks other than water                                                                                                                          1
               Granite geology                                                                                                  1
               Soil conservation                                                              1                                 1
               Slash and debris                                                                                                 1                                 1
               Stopbanks                                                                                                        1
               Dissolved oxygen                                                                                                 1
               Coastal margin                                                                                                   1
               Runoff control                                                                 1
               Sub totals                                                 -16                 8          -11                    12         -13                    11           -12                    9          -15                    5
               Score                                                            -8                                 1                              -2                                    -3                                -10




                                                                                                                                                                                     Document ID: a8aa1c6c-80c3-417b-8fc1-999982415b1a.xls
District Conditions in NES
Regional Conditions in NES
Conditions not covered in NES




                                Document ID: a8aa1c6c-80c3-417b-8fc1-999982415b1a.xls
Document ID: a8aa1c6c-80c3-417b-8fc1-999982415b1a.xls
Document ID: a8aa1c6c-80c3-417b-8fc1-999982415b1a.xls
Document ID: a8aa1c6c-80c3-417b-8fc1-999982415b1a.xls
                River crossing provisions in regional plans


                                                                             Gisborne DC
               Stringency                                          less       same      more
               Maintenance of structures permitted                                    0
               Notification                                                -1
               Archaeological                                                                  1
               Fuel                                                        -1
               Fill material                                               -1
               Stabilisation and containment                               -1
               Sediment and stormwater control                             -1
               Auditing                                                    -1
Proposed NES Default activity status                                                  0
  conditions   Catchment <100ha                                                       0
               Erosion/flooding
               Water course and levels                                     -1
               Public access                                               -1
               Construction methods                                                   0
               Maintenance                                                            0
               Contaminants                                                -1
               Fish passage                                                -1
               Culverts                                                    -1
               Fords                                                       -1
               Bridges                                                     -1
               Coastal and natural hazard areas mapped
               Geothermal and karst areas mapped
               Areas of heritage/wahi tapu identified
 Ability to be Indigenous vegetation clearance
more stringent Network utilities infrastructure setbacks
               Setbacks from nationally significant water bodies
               Nuisance issues                                                        0
               Significant Natural Areas identified
               Hazardous substances                                                            1
               Sediment discharge controls
   Council     Navigation of vessels
  conditions   Removal or Demolition of structures
  not in NES   Land drainage canal                                                             1
               Threatened habitats/biodiversity                                                1
               Riparian overlay
               Public safety
               Vegetation removal                                                              1
               Change and reconstruction                                                       1
               Sub totals                                                 -13                  6
               Score                                                             -7

                District Conditions in NES
                Regional Conditions in NES
                Conditions not covered in NES
                                                                         Consent required
            Tasman DC               Marlborough Awatere RMP             Marlborough MSRMP
less         same     more       less      same      more          less      same      more
                    0                                          1                               1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
                             1                                 1                               1
                    0                   -1                                                     1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
                             1                                 1                               1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
                    0                   -1                                                     1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
                    0                   -1                                                     1
                    0                   -1                                                     1
       -1                               -1                                                     1
                    0                   -1                                                     1
                    0                   -1                                                     1
                             1                                 1                               1
                    0                                          1                               1
                    0                                          1                               1


                    0                              0                                 0
                    0


                    0                              0                                 0
                    0                                                                0
                             1                                 1
                             1                                 1
                             1
                             1

                             1

                                                               1
                                                               1
                             1
       -8                    9         -14                    10                              20
                1                             -4                                20
             Nelson CC
less         same      more
                              1
        -1
        -1
                     0
        -1
        -1
        -1
                              1
        -1
                              1
        -1
        -1
                     0
        -1
        -1
        -1
                     0
                              1
        -1
                              1



                     0




                              1

                              1

                              1
                              1



       -12                    9
                -3

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:4
posted:2/16/2012
language:
pages:43