Docstoc

Project judging form 2009

Document Sample
Project judging form 2009 Powered By Docstoc
					  Now:                                                    FLL Number                                                                                  Team Name                                                             Score         Evaluation

3:56 AM                                                    Completed                                                                                                                                                          1      Needs Improvement
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              2             Fair
Schedule:                                                         Score                           0.00                                             Quality Project                                                            3             Good
                                                            Evaluation                                                                                                                                                        4           Excellent
                                           Other Comments

                           Required Project Elements (check all that
                           apply):
                            This team cannot be considered for a Project award.
                            They did not demonstrate all three required Project   Identified a Problem                         Provided a Solution                          Shared Their Project With Others
                                                elements.

                                                 Project Judging Feedback
                                                                 FLL Number
                                                                  Team Name

                                  Identified a Problem                            Provided a Solution                          Shared Their Project With Others
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            FALSE           FALSE
                                      Needs Improvement                                           Fair                                         Good                                     Excellent                         Item Score Weight Within Group

                                  No clearly defined research problem or it       Research problem is vague or relates         Research problem is fairly clear and         Research problem is explained clearly and
                                                                                                                               concise, and relates fairly well with FLL                                                      0               1
                                  does not relate to the FLL theme                poorly to FLL theme                                                                       concisely, integrates well with FLL theme
                                                                                                                               theme
                                                                                                                                                                            Cited multiple sources used in research
                                                                                  Limited outside sources used in research     Cited a diverse variety of outside sources
                                  No outside sources used in research                                                                                                       including communication with a                    0               1
                                                                                  or few mentioned                             used in research
                                                                                                                                                                            professional(s) (or attempts to)
                                                                                  Limited research on the impact of the                                                     Impact of problem thoroughly examined
   Research




                                  No research on the impact of the problem                                                     Impact of problem clearly researched                                                           0               1
                                                                                  problem                                                                                   and applied to solution
                                                                                                                               Present solutions and technologies clearly   Clearly researched existing solutions and
                                  No research on existing solutions or            Limited research on existing solutions or
                                                                                                                               researched but not considered in             technologies, applied knowledge when              0               1
                                  technologies used to address the problem        technologies used to address the problem
                                                                                                                               developing solution                          developing solution
                                                                                  Alternative theories or interpretations      Considered alternative theories or           Alternative theories or interpretations
                                  Alternative theories or interpretations
                                                                                  dismissed and/or arguments obscured by       interpretations and presented clear          presented and addressed in persuasive             0               1
                                  ignored, no clear arguments
                                                                                  jargon                                       arguments                                    arguments
                                  Did not demonstrate understanding of            Demonstrated a limited understanding of      Demonstrated understanding of technical      Demonstrated and shared a complete
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              0               1
                                  technical terms                                 technical terms                              terms but didn’t explain them clearly        understanding of technical terms

                                                                                                                               Solution is described but not clear how it   Solution is concisely described and clearly
                                  No solution presented                           Solution is unclear                                                                                                                         0               1
                                                                                                                               addresses the problem                        addresses the problem
 Innovative
  Solution




                                  No data presented in support of proposed        Weak or limited data to support proposed                                                  Substantial data supports proposed
                                                                                                                               Adequate data supports proposed solution                                                       0               1
                                  solution                                        solution                                                                                  solution
                                                                                  Solution is somewhat innovative, or
                                                                                                                               Solution is innovative and applies some      Solution is innovative and applies
                                  Solution is not innovative or new               limited knowledge of science and/or                                                                                                         0               1
                                                                                                                               knowledge of science and/or technology       knowledge of science and/or technology
                                                                                  technology applied
                                                                                                                               Shared their project, research or solution   Shared their project, research and solution
                                  Did not share their project, research or        Shared their project, research or solution
                                                                                                                               with others beyond parents such as a         with others such as their school,                 0               1
   Sharing




                                  solution with anyone outside team               with team parents
                                                                                                                               class, sponsors, or other teams              community, or experts in their field
                                  Did not consider how their problem and/or       Considered how this might impact             Considered how this might impact
                                                                                                                                                                            Considered how this impacts others and
                                  solution might impact themselves or             themselves or their family, but did not      themselves and their family and                                                                0               1
                                                                                                                                                                            implemented a plan to produce change
                                  consider what changes to make                   consider changes                             recommended changes
                                                                                                                               Presentation organization is clear,          Organized presentation with clear
                                  Presentation rambles                            Presentation organization is weak            integration and/or logical progression       beginning, middle and end; well-                  0               1
                                                                                                                               could be improved                            integrated; logical progression
                                  Limited number of team members                                                               Most of the team participated in the         All or almost all team members
                                                                                  Less than half of the team participated                                                                                                     0               1
                                  participated in project presentation                                                         presentation                                 participated

                                                                                                                                                                            Comprehensive answers to judges’
                                  Unable to answer judges’ questions              Weak answers to judges’ questions            Adequate answers to judges’ questions                                                          0               1
                                                                                                                                                                            questions
   Creative Presentation




                                  Team member ideas were not integrated           Team member ideas not well-integrated        Project is a group effort                    Collaboration of group is seamless                0               1

                                                                                  Ineffective visual aids or weak support      Visual aids or support material              Carefully chosen visual aids and/or
                                  No visual aids or support material                                                                                                        support material clearly add to                   0               1
                                                                                  material                                     complement presentation
                                                                                                                                                                            presentation
                                                                                  Information presented with limited
                                  Lacks excitement or creativity                                                               Team uses creativity doing presentation      Excellent use of creativity                       0               1
                                                                                  creativity
                                                                                                                               No apparent adult intervention but           Clearly the work of the children from
                                  Excessive adult intervention                    Adult intervention is apparent               difficulty with setup/take down within       beginning to end including all visual aids        0               1
                                                                                                                               allotted time                                and material

                                  Many errors or not rehearsed                    Few errors or should have rehearsed more     Very few evident errors, well rehearsed      No evident errors and well rehearsed              0               1


                                  Too long                                        Slightly too long                            Proper length                                Excellent use of time
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              0               1

                                  Plagued with technical difficulties             Several technical difficulties               Very minor technical difficulties            No technical difficulties                         0               1
Additional Comments:




                       v2009



                               0
This team cannot be considered for a Project award. They did not demonstrate all three required Project elements.
All three required Project elements demonstrated.




    FALSE                               FALSE
Group Weight Contribution to Score

      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0                0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0                0


      1                  0


      1                  0                0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


      1                  0


                         0
      1

      1                  0                0
0

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:0
posted:2/13/2012
language:
pages:4