russian

K,*,D":\>Z6 JD@&,>\ FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,,>>ZN SH"H"N !4, *:b FJ*,6 4 FJ*,$>ZN FB,P4":4FH@& 2"DJ$,0>ZN FHD">



9,@>4*"F C":\L ;,8"4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" FJ*@& ES!. =" DJFF846 b2Z8 B,D,&,: ?D:@& !.%.



2



K,*,D":\>Z6 JD@&,>\ FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,,>>ZN SH"H"N !4, *:b FJ*,6 4 FJ*,$>ZN FB,P4":4FH@& 2"DJ$,0>ZN FHD">

A@*D"2*,:,>4, FJ*,6 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4 7@Z4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD FJ*@& ES! Thurgood Marshall Federal Judiciary Building Washington, D.C. 20544 2001, 42*. &H@D@, ="FH@bV,, 42*">4, $Z:@ D"2D"$@H">@ !*4FHD"H4&>ZHD@"8@@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,42"P4,6, JFHD@6FH&@@T,>4,@*"H,:\>@6 4 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &,H&b" L,*,D":\>@,. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD @FJV,FH&:b,H B@**,D08J FJ*,$>@6 &,H&4 &:"FH4, @H&,R",H 2" @D(">42"P4` JBD"&:,>R,F8@6, H,N>4R,F8@6, BD"&@&@6 4 4>@6 B@**,D084 L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,4,



]H" $D@T`D" $Z:" D"2D"$@H">" & !*4FHD"H4&>@HD, FJ*@& ES! F P,:\` @2>"8@48@& BD"&@FJ*4b 4>@FHD">>ZN (@FJ*"DFH& F L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,42"P4,6, JFHD@6FH&@@T,>4,@*"H,:\>@6 4 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &,H&b" L,*,D":\>@,. ?>" $Z:" D"2D"$@H">" & 7@Z4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" FJ*@& ES! B@ B@DJR,>4` 7@@6 !FF@P4"P44 B@ "D@*>ZZ@T,>4b"b !FF@P4"P4b E@,*4>,>>ZN SH"H@& BD,*FH"&:b,H F@$@6 >"P4@>":\>Z6 @D(">, @BD,*,:b`V46 :4>4` B@&,*,>4b L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&. +, &@2(:"&:b,H BD,*F,*"H,:\ %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" ES!. % !FF@P4"P4` &N@*bH ,V, 26 FJ*,6 – 13 BD,*F,*"H,:,6 L,*,D":\>ZN "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*@&, B@ @*>@FH">P44, 42$4D",ZN @8DJ(@& ES!, 4 BD,*F,*"H,:\ FJ*" B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4. EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P44 & ,, *,bH,:\>@FH4 B@Z 8@H@DZN >"2>"R"`HFb AD,*F,*"H,:,"D@*>ZN FJ*,$>ZN @H>@T,>46 F@FH@4H 42 F,ZN FJ*,6 4 BD,*FH"&4H,:b '@FJ*"DFH&,>>@(@ ),B"DH"H" ES!. A@:>@4D@&">4, @H>@T,>46 F FJ*,$>Z42"P4b@FHD">>ZN (@FJ*"DFH& 4 BD@R442"P4bH,D,F@&">>Z"D@*>ZN FJ*,$>ZN @H>@T,>4bN, & JFH">@&:,>44 4 D"FBD@FHD">,>44 F4FH,4, B@FD,*>4R,F8@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4 B@ D,T,>4` BD@$:,ZN &@BD@F@& @6 !FF@P4"P4,6, &F,6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH," L,*,D":\>@,,



4



5



E@*,D0">4,

7@>FH4HJP4b E@,*4>,>>ZN SH"H@& !"b L@D4b 1"8@>@*"H,:\>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4 3FB@:>4H,:\>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4 EJ*,$>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4 C@:\ L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& & "F8@6 L@D4b K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z 4 7@>(D,FF K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z 4 4FB@:>4H,:\>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4 K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z 4 @$V,FH&@ EJ*,$>Z, D"6@>Z 4 @8DJ(" & ES! _D4F*48P4b L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& ?H>@T,>4b Z L,*,D":\>ZZ, FJ*\4 ES! ="2>"R,>4, FJ*,6. EJ*\4 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4 7@>FH4HJP44 ;@D":\ 4 >D"&FH&,>>@FH\ & L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,F"P44 EH"D,6T4, EJ*\4. IN@* >" B,>F4` EJ*,6F8@, @$D"2@&">4, A,DF@>": FJ*\4 ?F@$,>>@FH4 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,@FH4 E4FH,Z 4 FJ*,$>Z, 42*,D084 3FB@:>,>4, FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46 AD@P,FFJ":\>Z, BD"&4:" BD@&,*,>4b FJ*,$>ZN BD,>46 AD@H@8@:4D@&">4, FJ*,$>ZN BD@P,*JD AJ$:48"P4b FJ*,$>ZN ,>46 ?F>@&>Z, R,DHZ FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF" 'D"0*">F846 BD@P,FF I(@:@&>Z6 BD@P,FF E:J0$" BD4Fb0>ZN ),:" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 ($">8D@HFH&,) !B,::bP44 K,*,D":\>"b FJ*,$>"b "*4FHD"P4b 3>*4&4*J":\>@FH\ FJ*@& EJ*,$>Z6 B,DF@>": 7:,D8 FJ*" AD@R46 B,DF@>": FJ*" ?8DJ0>Z, CJ*,$>Z, C@&,HZ EJ*,$>"b !FF@P4"P4b !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD FJ*@& ES!

7 8 8 9 10 10 10 11 14 16 16 16 18 18 19 20 20 20 21 22 22 22 23 23 24 24 24 25 25 27 29 32 35 37 37 37 38 39 39 39 40



6



K,*,D":\>Z6 FJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD 7@Z6 $`*0,H 1*">4b FJ*". ED,*FH&" @$F:J04&">4b. ?$,FB,R,>4, $,2@B"F>@FH4 3>L@D>Z, H,N>@:@(44 4 FJ*,$>"b &:"FH\ EHD"H,(4R,F8@, B:">4D@&">4, 4 BD@*J8H4&>@FH\ JBD"&:,>4b & L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*"N ?H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ )4FP4B:4>"D>Z, 42Z, 42Z, 42@ZN FJ*"N =,8@H@DZ, `D4*4R,F84, H,DZ ?$ !*4FHD"H4&>@HD, FJ*@& ES!



41 42 42 43 44 44 46 46 47 48 49 52 59



7



7@H"D44



GD,H\b EH"H\b 7@>FH4HJP44 ES! K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z ES! EJ*,$>Z, D"6@>Z 4 @8DJ(" & ES! C"2(D">4R,>4, 8@P44 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& 4 FJ*@& TH"H" 7@*,8F ZN BD4>P4B@& FJ*,6 ES! GD,$@&">4b, BD,*Xb&:b,Z4, @H @$b2">>@FH4 @FJV,FH&:bH\ *,bH,:\>@FH\ BD4Fb0>@(@ A@Db*@8 F:J0$Z BD4Fb0>ZN %4*Z *,: @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 M"D"8H,D4FH48" L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 "*4FHD"P44 A,DF@>": FJ*" 7@@6 !FF@P4"P44 3FH@R>484 *@B@:>4H,:\>@6 4>L@DFH4HJP4b E@,*4>,>>ZN SH"H@& !"b L@D4b



§ §



7@>FH4HJP4b ES!, BD4>bH"b & 1789 (@*J, 42,>4b 8 8@H@D@6 BD4>4,R"FH@, b&:b,HFb @F>@&>Z@FH4HJP4b BD@&@2(:"F4:" D,FBJ$:48">F8@, BD"&:,>4,, B@2&@:b`V,, @H*,:\>Z4H\ 2>"R4H,:\>Z6 FJ&,D,>4H,H 4 B@:>@4H,:\>"b ((J$,D>"H@D), 2"8@>@*"H,:\>"b F4FH,"b F4FH,@, (4:4 >"P4@>":\>@,) BD"&4H,:\FH&@ – &,F\"b, >@ @(D">4R,>>"b &:"FH\ – *,6FH&J,H & BD,*,:"N B@:>@>ZN 7@>FH4HJP4,6. %Fb @FH":\>"b &:"FH\ 2"8D,B:b,HFb H@6 0, 7@>FH4HJP4,6 2" TH"H@"4b &:"FH,6 "P4@>":\>Z""" B@* B@>bH4,FH4HJP44 B@:JR4:4 >"2&">4, «#4::\ @ BD"&"N». #4::\ ("D">H4DJ,H @F>@&@B@:"("`V4, BD"&" (D"0*">",@$@F>@&">>ZN *,6FH&46 @D(">@& &:"FH4. ]H4 BD"&" &8:`R"`H F&@$@*J F:@&", F&@$@*J F@$D">46, BD"&@ >" )&, @H:4R4H,:\>Z, R,DHZ «&@24, @$4*Z», 2"V4HJ @H @D(">42"P44 &:"FH4 F@(:"F>@ >,@$@F>@&">>@(@ @$ZF8" 4 "D,FH", *@:0>@, BD"&@BD4,>4,, 2"V4HJ @H 7@>FH4HJP44: &Z>J0*,>>@(@ F">@FH4 $,2 FBD"&,*:4&@6 L,*,D":42F"P44, $,2@H:"("H,:\>@, 4 @H8DZH@, BD@42&@*FH&@ B@ J(@:@&>Z" FJ* BD4Fb0>ZN 8"8 B@ F4FH,F84Z48" BD4 J(@:@&>@,>44. 7@>FH4HJP4b @BD,*,:4:" HD4 @H*,:\>Z, &,H&4 &:"FH4 – 2"8@>@*"H,:\>J` (EH"H\b I), 4FB@:>4H,:\>J` (EH"H\b II) 4 FJ*,$>J` (EH"H\b III). %F, HD4 &,H&4 &:"FH4 L,*,D":\>@(@ BD"&:,>4b @(D">4R,>Z 8@>FH4HJP4@>>@6 F4FH,J,@ >,2"&4F4FH4HJP4@>>Z, B@:>@@*"H,:\>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4

7@>(D,FF ES!, >"P4@>":\>Z6 @D("> 2"8@>@*"H,:\>@6 &:"FH4, F@FH@4H 42 *&JN B":"H - ^H@ E,>"H 4 A":"H" AD,*FH"&4H,:,6. 7"0*Z6 TH"H BD,*FH"&:b`H *&" F,>"H@D", 42$4D"," 6 :,H. GD,H\ E,>"H" B,D,42$4D",HFb 8"0*Z, *&" (@*". Q:,>Z A":"HZ AD,*FH"&4H,:,6 42$4D"`HFb & 42$4D"H,:\>ZN @8DJ("N TH"H@&. 7"0*Z6 TH"H BD,*FH"&:b,H @BD,*,:,>>@, 8@:4R,FH&@ R,:@&,8 & 2"&4F4"F,:,>4b. A":"H" AD,*FH"&4H,:,6 B,D,42$4D",HFb R,D,2 *&" (@*". AD,*:@0,>>Z6 2"8@>@BD@,8H, BD,0*, R,@ BD@6H4 @$, B":"HZ 7@>(D,FF" 4 B@:JR4H\ @*@$D,>4, AD,24*,>H". +F:4 0, AD,24*,>H >, B@*B4FZ&",H BD@,8H, H.,. >"8:"*Z&",H &,H@, BD@,8H &F, 0, >J` F4:J, >@ H@:\8@ & H@(D,FF". 7@>FH4HJP4b ES! >, BD,*JF@&:,>4, B"D:"HF8@(@ JBD"&:,>4b, 8"8 & %,:48@$D4H">44 4 Db*, *DJ(4N *,@ 7@>FH4HJP44 ES! AD,24*,>H @*>@&D,>@ b&:b,HFb (:"&@6 (@FJ*"DFH&" 4 (:"&@6 BD"&4H,:\FH&", @> >"2>"R",H 8"$4>,H 4FHD@&, F@FH@bV46 42 DJ8@&@*4H,:,6 8DJB>,6T4N 4FB@:>4H,:\>ZN *,B"DH"H@& (4FH,DFH&) 4 "(,>HFH&; >@ >4 AD,24*,>H, >4 8H@-:4$@ 42 8"$4>,H" 4FHD@& >, BD4>444 7@>(D,FF". A"DH44 AD,24*,>H" 8 H@, @$b2"H,:\>@ @$:"*"H\ $@:\T4>FH&@(D,FF,, RH@$Z @FH"&"H\Fb J &:"FH4:



F4HJ"P4b, 8@(*" $@:\T4>FH&@ @6 42 A":"H 4:4 & @$,4N A":"H"N BD4>"*:,04H @BB@24P4@>>@6 AD,24*,>HJ B"DH44, >, b&:b,HFb >,@$ZR>@6. % 8"0*@6 A":"H, 7@>(D,FF" ,FH\ F&@4 8@@& A":"HZ 4 FL@D>Z, B@ &4*"@FH4. ]H4 8@4@BD@,8H@&, @FJV,FH&:b`H B"D:"HF846 >"*2@D 2" BD"&4H,:\FH&,>>Z"4">F@&Z, 2"8@>@BD@,8HZ @ L4>">F4D@&">44 BD"&4H,:\FH&,>>ZN @B,D"P46 4 @FJV,FH&:b`H 8@>HD@:\ >"* &ZB@:>,>4,ZN BD@(D"Z, FJ*Z, 8 BD4Z@&">4b4H,:\>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4

AD,24*,>H 42$4D",HFb 8"0*Z, R,HZD, (@*" 4, F@(:"F>@ 7@>FH4HJP44, >, 44b AD,24*,>H L@D,H, &F, R:,>Z 8@H@D@(@ *@:0>Z $ZH\ @*@$D,>Z $@:\T4>FH&@"H". 7"0*Z6 R:,> 8"$4>,H" b&:b,HFb DJ8@&@*4H,:,H" 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4. G"8, & 8"$4>,H &N@*bH, 8 BD4>Z6 F,8D,H"D\, 4FHD @$@D@>Z, 4FHD L4>">F@& ES! 4 L,*,D":\>Z6 BD@8JD@D ((,>,D":\>Z6 "HH@D>,6). AD,24*,>H, ,(@ BD"&4H,:\FH&@ 4 *DJ(4, R:,>Z BD,24*,>HF8@6 "*4FHD"P44 @FJV,FH&:b`H 4FB@:>4H,:\>J` &:"FH\ >" L,*,D":\>@,, @>4 BD@&@*bH & 042>\ 4 @FJV,FH&:b`H 2"8@>Z. K,*,D":\>Z6 BD@8JD@D, b&:b`V46Fb (:"&@6 ;4>4FH,DFH&" `FH4P44 ES!, @H&,R",H 2" BD@42&@*FH&@ B@ J(@:@&>ZH,D,FZ (@FJ*"DFH&" & (D"0*">F84N *,:"N, JBD"&:b,H #`D@ G`D,"HJD":42"P44 4 Db*@4H,:\>ZN @D(">42"P46. =" 4P4B":\>@, 8"0*Z6 42 94 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*,$>ZN D"6@>@& BD,*FH"&:,> D"6@>>Z"2>"R",H@Z@4FH,DFH&@ `FH4P44 ES! >, BD4>4">F4D@&">44 4 JBD"&:,>44 L,*,D":\>Z@*"H,:\>Z">F@&ZZ, @D(">Z F&b2">Z >,B@FD,*FH&,>>@ F 7@>(D,FF@"b &,H&\ &:"FH4

K,*,D":\>"b FJ*,$>"b &:"FH\ b&:b,HFb B@:>@FH\` >,2"&4F4Z, FJ*Z R"FH@ >"2Z&"`H FHD"0"FH4HJP44, B@F8@:\8J 4N B@FH">@&:,>4b 2"V4V"`H BD"&" 4 F&@$@*Z, ("D">H4DJ,FH4HJP4,6. E&@4Z,BD,*&2bHZ@&:,>4b4 JFH">"&:4&"`H L"8HZ 4 H@:8J`H BD"&@ F P,:\` D"2D,T,>4b BD"&@&ZN FB@D@&. EJ*Z >, BD4>4Z: ^H@ &N@*4H & @$b2">>@FH4 7@>(D,FF". EJ*Z >, \ 2"8@>Z: ^H@ &N@*4H & B@:>@H" 4 @(@R4F:,>>ZN ),B"DH"H@& 4 "(,>HFH& 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4. =@ J FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 ,FH\ B@:>@Z, 2"8@>Z, D,T"H\ &@BD@F @$ 4N 8@>FH4HJP4@>>@FH4 4 D"2D,T"H\ FB@DZ, F&b2">>Z, F >4FH4HJP44 F@R:4 >,@$N@*44, EH"H\b III 7@>FH4HJP44 ES!: FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 & P,:bN @$,FB,R,>4b FBD"&,*:4&@FH4 4 D"&>ZN BD"& &F,N EJ*,$>"b &:"FH\ E@,*4>,>>ZN (D"0*"> E@,*4>,>>ZN SH"H@&. SH"H@& @FJV,FH&:b,HFb %,DN@&>ZFH4HJP4b BD,*B@:"(",H >,2"&4F4@6 &:"FH4 B@ *&JP4B4":\>Z@&">4bZ, FJ*\4 2">4@ 4 ,>Z @H *@:0>@FH4 H@:\8@ R,D,2 BD@P,*JDJ 4H" 4 @$&4>,>4b 7@>(D,FF@>@6 42,, &2bH@R>4R,FH&, 4 BD@R4N FJ*,$>@>"8"2J,4bN». %@-&H@DZN, «&ZB:"HZ L,*,D":\>Z, \T,>Z, B@8" :4P@ BD@*@:0",H 2">4"R",H, RH@ >4 AD,24*,>H, >4 7@>(D,FF >, \T"H\ 2"D"$@H>J` B:"HJ $@:\T4>FH&J L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*,6. ]H4 *&, "BD"&:,>Z >" 2"V4HJ >,2"&4F4@6 &:"FH4 4 >" @HBD"&:,>4, ,` BD"&@FJ*4b >,2"&4F4>ZN >"FHD@,>46 4 B@:4H4R,F8@(@ &@2*,6FH&4b.



12



4 JRD,0*"H\Fb 7@>(D,FF@@(@ EJ*", H"8 4 FJ*\4 >42T4N FJ*@& F@ND">b`H F&@4 *@:0>@FH4, B@8" 4N B@&,*,>4, b&:b,HFb $,2JBD,R>Z@&:,>>Z, FD@84 @>4 B@:JR"`H 2" F&@` F:J0$J &@2>"(D"0*,>4,, 8@H@D@, >, \T,>@, B@8" @>4 >"N@*bHFb & *@:0>@FH4.



13



C@:\ L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& & "F8@6 L@D4b



K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z 4 7@>(D,FF

7@>FH4HJP4b >"*,:b,H 7@>(D,FF HD,@&>Z>@FHb@FH\ L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&. %@-B,D&ZN, 7@>(D,FF F">8P4@>4DJ,H F@2*">4, >@&ZN L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&, >"N@*bV4NFb >" F:,*J`V,@(@ EJ*" JD@&>,, @BD,*,:b,H 4N `D4F*48P4` 4 D,T",H, F8@:\8@ FJ*,6 *@:0>@ $ZH\ & H@@4b E,>"H JH&,D0*",H 8">*4*"H" >" *@:0>@FH\ L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*\4, BD,*:@0,>>@(@ AD,24*,>H@(D,FF JH&,D0*",H $`*0,H L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& 4 &Z*,:b,H *,>\(4 >" B@:>@P,>>J` D"$@HJ FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4. #`*0,H FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 &,F\ – @8@:@ 0,2% L,*,D":\>@(@ $`*0,H" FHD">Z.



K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z 4 4FB@:>4H,:\>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4

E@(:"F>@ 7@>FH4HJP44 8">*4*"H@& & FJ*\4 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4 @H$4D",H AD,24*,>H. 7">*4*"HJD" *@:0>" $ZH\ @*@$D,>" $@:\T4>FH&@"H", JH&,D0*,>>Z6 8">*4*"H 2">4@FH\ $,FFD@R>@. AD,24*,>H @$ZR>@ BD@&@*4H 8@>FJ:\H"P44 F F,>"H@D"Z@FH>ZP4":\>ZN 8">*4*"H@& >" 2"4, &"8">F44 L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*\4. AD"&@ AD,24*,>H" >"2>"R"H\ >@&ZN L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*,6 – ^H@ >, ,*4>FH&,>>@, B,D,F,R,>4, FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 F 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6. ;4>4FH,DFH&@ `FH4P44 ES! R"T, *DJ(4N b&:b,HFb FH@D@>@6 B@ *,:"ZN FJ*"N ES!, H.8. &ZB@:>b,H BD@42&@*FH&@ B@



14



J(@:@&>ZH,D,FZ (@FJ*"DFH&" & (D"0*">F84N *,:"N. % FJ*,$>J` F4FH,Z >,8@H@DZ, *DJ(4, @D(">Z 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4. E:J0$" ;"DT":@&, 8 BD4@FH\ 2*">46 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& 4 F"4FHD"P4b @$V4N F:J0$ 2">4@H,N>4R,F844,46 FJ*". % BD,*,:"N 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4 @FJV,FH&:b`H F&@` *,bH,:\>@FH\ &@,>>Z, FJ*Z, Db* FB,P4":424D@&">>ZN FJ*@& 4 "*4FHD"H4&>ZN "(,>HFH&, JB@:>@>ZN D"2D,T"H\ & B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 FB@DZ, 2"HD"(4&"`V4, FB,P4":\>Z, L,*,D":\>Z, "8HZ 4 BD@(D"@FH4, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ @ >":@(@@$:@0,>44, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ @ F@P4":\>@44, B"H,>H>@, 4 "&H@DF8@, BD"&@, HDJ*@&@, BD"&@, B@*H&,D0*,>4, :4P,>244 >" D"*4@- 4 H,:,&,V">4, 4 *D. 3 N@Hb ^H4 @D(">Z >, b&:b`HFb R"FH\` FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,>@6 EH"H\,6 III 7@>FH4HJP44 ES!, "B,::bP44 B@ D,T,>4b@& $J*JH D"FFZ, FJ*Z 4 @$V,FH&@

A@ @$V,4b 42 8@H@D@(@ FHD@(@ @(D">4R,>Z, BD@P,FF & L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*"N b&:b,HFb @H8DZHZ4b FJ*" B@FHD@,>Z H"84JT"H\ (D"0*">"4, B,D,* HD"*4P4,6 4 P,:\` FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF" & ES!. ;>@(4, 2*">4b FJ*" b&:b`HFb B"48"4>, 0,:"`V46 B@>"$:`*"H\ 2" FJ*,$>Z4,@ BD46H4 & 2*">4, L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*", 42JR4H\ D"FB4F">4, FJ*,$>ZN F:JT">46,



8@H@D@, &Z&,T4&",HFb >" *@F8, 4:4 B@8"2Z&",HFb >" 4H@D"N, 4 B@BD4FJHFH&@&"H\ >" H@@@44. 9`$@6 R,:@&,8 "8@H""*@ @$D"H4H\Fb 8 8:,D8J (FB,P4":4FHJ) F BD@F\$@6 BD,*@FH"&4H\ 8@B44 *@8JH@& B@ *,:J. % >"FH@bV,, &D,@, D"FB4F">4,, FB4F@8 *,: 8 F:JT">4`, FJ*,$>Z, D,T,>4b, ,>4b, 2"b&:,>4b &F, R"V, *@FHJB>Z R,D,2 4>H,D>,H. % @H:4R4, @H FJ*@& >" JD@&>, TH"H" H,:,- 4 D"*4@^L4DZ 42 2*">4b FJ*" >, D"2D,T"`HFb. AD"&@ >" *@FHJB 8 FJ*,$>Z@ &ZH,8",H 42 7@>FH4HJP44, R"FH4R>@ 42 HD"*4P46 FJ*,$>ZN 2"F,*">46 4 @$V,(@ BD"&". AD@&@*b &F` FJ*,$>J` D"$@HJ >" (:"2"N J >"F,:,>4b, FJ*\4 J8D,B:b`H *@&,D4, (D"0*"> 8 FJ*""H\, 8"8 D"$@H",H FJ*,$>"b F4FH,JHD4. % @H*,:\>ZN F:JR"bN *@FHJB 8 *@8JH"P44 4:4 F"4b@ @(D">4R4&",HFb. AD4 D"FF44 >,8@H@DZN (D@,*@FH"H@R>@ 46 *:b &F,N 0,:"`V4N. )@FHJB & 2": 2"F,*">46 $Z&",H H"80, 2"8DZH B@ *DJ(4""BD4, $,2@B"F>@FH4, & P,:bN 2"V4HZ >,F@&,DT,>>@:,H>,(@ 4:4 8@>L4*,>P4":\>@(@ F&4*,H,:b. ="8@>,P, ,F:4 >,8@H@DZ, *@8JHZ @$Xb&:b`H F,8D,H>Z4ZN (D"0*"> >,&@2. E,8D,H>@6 4>L@D"&"H\Fb *@8JHZ, F@*,D0"V4, 8@J, >,8@H@DZ, BD"&@@ND">4H,:\>Z, @HR,HZ, *@8JHZ, 8"F"`V4,Fb >,F@&,DT,>>@:,H>4N, 4 &@BD@FZ, 2"HD"(4&"`V4, >"P4@>":\>J` $,2@B"F>@FH\.



15



16



EHDJ8HJD" L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&

1" >,8@H@DZ4,Z, FJ*Z JB@:>@Z D"FFZ6 FJ*\b D"FFF84,, H"8 4 J(@:@&>Z, *,:", FB@DZ B@ @$V,FH&,>>@@H,D,FZ L424R,F84N :4P, 8@DB@D"P46 4:4 *"0, @D(">@& &:"FH4. ?>4 44` "B,::bP44 B@ D,T,>4bbHZ4FHD"H4&>ZHFH&",H @H*,:\>ZN 8@>FH4HJP4@>>ZN FJ*@&, H"8 8"8 &F, L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z 4 FJ*\4 BD"&@Z D"FFFH4HJP4@>>@FH4 L,*,D":\>ZN 2"8@>@& 4 *DJ(4N *,6FH&46 @D(">@& &:"FH4, 8"F"`V4,Fb D"FFFH">P44

C"6@>>Z, FJ*Z ES! b&:b`HFb @F>@&>ZFH">P44. C"6@>>Z, FJ*Z JB@:>@Z BD4>44` BD"8H4R,F84 &F, 8"H,(@D44 L,*,D":\>ZN *,:. %F,(@ F@2*">@ 94 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*,$>ZN D"6@>", 8"8 4@, @(@ D"6@>" &N@*4H FJ* B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, b&:b`V46Fb FB,P4":424D@&">>Z4,>ZN FJ*@&; @> 4"P4@>":\>J` `D4F*48P4` B@ &F,>Z,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH\` :4P, 2" 4F8:`R,>4,>ZN F J(@:@&>ZbH@ 8 D"FF4` *">>ZZ, &@BD@FZ Z >" ,(@ D"FF4,. EJ*Z B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 @$ZR>@ JBD"&:b`HFb FB,P4":424D@&">>Z"P4@>":\>@6 `D4F*48P4,6 B@ @BD,*,:,>>ZZ6 FJ* B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4 D,T",H FB@DZ, 8"F"`V4,Fb "D@*>ZN H@D(@&ZN @H>@T,>46 4 H">@(@ BD"&". K,*,D":\>Z6 BD,H,>24@>>Z6 FJ* D,T",H *,:", F&b2">>Z, F (@FJ*"DFH&,>>ZHD"8H"@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4 & B@:\2J (@FJ*"DFH&", F L4>">F@&Z244 BD,*Xb&:,>Z E@,*4>,>>ZZN FJ*"N B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 D"FF@:4R>@, 4>@(*" F JR"FH4,ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6, 8@H@DZ, JFH">"&:4&"`H L"8H4R,F84, @$FH@bH,:\FH&" B@ *">>@FH4HJP4b BD,*JF" FJ* BD4Fb0>ZN B@ @(4Z, J(@:@&>Z, *,:", 2) (D"0*">F84, *,:", B@ 8@H@DZ" FJ* BD4Fb0>ZN ("D">H4D@&":@F\ >@D(:@F"8F@>F8@(@ BD"&" B@F:, BD4@$D,H,>4b ES! >,2"&4F4(D,FF ES! FB,P4":\>@ BD,*JF" FJ* BD4Fb0>ZN.



!B,::bP4@>>Z, FJ*Z

),&b>@FH@ R,HZD, FJ*,$>ZN D"6@>" @$X,*4>,>Z & 12 @8DJ(@&, & 8"0*@8P4@>4DJ,H L,*,D":\>Z6 "B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ*. ]H@H FJ* BD4>4>Z>@(@ @8DJ(", D"&>@ 8"8 4 L,*,D":\>Z4FHD"H4&>ZHFH&",>4, 8 ^H@>Z6 FJ* B@ L,*,D":\>@"P4@>":\>J` `D4F*48P4` 4 44` "B,::bP44 B@ FB,P4":\>Z"BD4H>@4bbHZZ"D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4 4 L,*,D":\>Z24@>>Z@FH\ "B,::bP44 BD,*JF" *:b &F,N @8@>R"H,:\>ZN D,T,>46, BD4>4>Z4b & "B,::bP4@>>@, 8"FF"P4b, 4 *,:@ @ H@:\8@ & H@" 42 FH@D@> F&@,&D,>@ B@*"FH "B,::bP4` >" D,T,>4, >40,FH@bV,(@ FJ*" 4:4 "*4FHD"H4&>@(@ "(,>HFH&". A@F:, B@*"R4 "B,::bP44 FJ* B,D,F4, 4 *@8JH"P4` >40,FH@bV,(@ FJ*" :4$@ "*4FHD"H4&>@(@ P,>HD". !B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ* >, &ZF:JT4&",H *@B@:>4H,:\>Z, B@8"2">4b, 4 B@ @$V,>ZFH">P44. +F:4 HD,$J,HFb 42JR,>4, *@B@:>4H,:\>ZN *@8"2"H,:\FH&, "B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ* JH\ *,:@ & B,D&@>"R":\>J` 4>FH">P4`. ?*>"8@ 8 &@2&D"V,>4` & B,D&@>"R":\>J` 4>FH">P4`, 8"8 BD"&4:@, >, BD4$,("`H, 4 "B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ* :4$@ @Hb,H D,T,>4, >40,FH@bV,(@ FJ*", :4$@ 0, @FH"&:b,H ,(@ & F4:,. % F:JR", 8D"6>,6 >,@$N@*4" D,T,>4,, BD4>bH@, 8@::,(4,6 42 HD,N FJ*,6, "B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ* Z6 EJ* ES! 2"F,*"H\ en banc (& B@:>@>ZN FJ*,6, D"$@H"`V4N & *">>@ZN !B,::bP4@>>Z, FJ*Z @8DJ(,. % B@:>@>Z6 FJ* B@



B,D,F4,, BD4>bH@, 8@::,(4,6 FJ*,6.



%,DN@&>Z6 EJ* ES!

%,DN@&>Z6 EJ* ES! – &ZFT46 FJ* L,*,D":\>@6 `D4F*48P44. % ,(@ F@FH"& &N@*bH BD,*F,*"H,:\ %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" 4 &@F,@&. EJ* &F,(*" 2"F,*",H en banc, H@ ,FH\ &F, *,&bH\ FJ*,6 F@&@ F:JT"`H *,:@ 4 BD4>4,4,. _D4F*48P4b *">>@(@ FJ*" *4F8D,P4@>>"b, H@ ,FH\ BD,*@FH"&:,>" >" JF4, F"bH4b *,:" 8 D"FF4`, HD,$J,HFb F@(:"F4,, 8"8 44R,>>@"BD4Z@&:,>44 (D">4PZ Z6 EJ* 8P4@>4D@&"H\ & 8"R,FH&, FJ*" B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 4:4 @FJV,FH&:bH\ "B,::bP4@>>Z6 B,D,F46). A@ @$V,Z6 EJ* BD4>44` FB@DZ H@:\8@ & H,N F:JR"bN, 8@(*" ,>4, FJ*,6 "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*" >, @BD,*,:4:@F\, 8@(*" 2"HD@>JH 8@>FH4HJP4@>>Z6 &@BD@F 4:4 &@BD@F B@ L,*,D":\>@,>4b.



K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z ES!:

%,DN@&>Z6 EJ*



!B,::bP4@>>Z, EJ*Z



18



EJ*Z B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 C"6@>>Z, FJ*Z (94 FJ*,$>ZN D"6@>" FH@:\8@ 0, FJ*@& B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4). K,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4. K,*,D":\>Z6 BD,H,>24@>>Z6 FJ*. AD@R4, L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z &>, F4FH,@6 &,H&4 &:"FH4 EJ*Z B@ *,:">@F:J0"V4N (B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 4 "B,::bP4@>>Z,). EJ* B@ "B,::bP4b@&. EJ* B@ &@BD@F"":@(@@$:@0,>4b. !*4FHD"H4&>Z, "(,>HFH&" 4 8@Z, D"6@>Z 4 @8DJ(" & ES!. G,DD4H@D4":\>"b B@*FJ*>@FH\ FJ*"FH">P44 4 "B,::bP4@>>ZZ6 @8DJ(: ?8DJ( 7@:J(H@>



'D">4P""R,>Z:



22



'D">4PZ FJ*,$>ZN @8DJ(@&: 'D">4PZ TH"H@&: 'D">4PZ FJ*,$>ZN D"6@>@&:



23



_D4F*48P4b L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&

?H>@T,>4b " H@, RH@ L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z D"FB@:@0,>Z & 8"0*@4 b&:b`HFb >, ,*4>FH&,>>Z@, $@:\T4>FH&@ BD"&@&ZN FB@D@& & !@6 F4FH,>@6 & 8"0*@FH&" FJ*,$>ZN F4FH,@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,FH">P44 @$V,6 `D4F*48P44, "B,::bP4@>>Z, FJ*Z (FD,*>,, 2&,>@) 4 %,DN@&>Z6 EJ* TH"H". % D"FB@Db0,>44 TH"H" H"80, "N@*4H\Fb BD@R4, FJ*Z >42T,(@ JD@&>b, FJ*Z (D"LFH&, 4P4B":\>Z, FJ*Z, >,$@:\T4, BD,H,>24@>>Z, FJ*Z 4:4 ,2>"R4H,:\>Z, FB@DZ. A@ FD"&>,>4` F L,*,D":\>Z"@(@ $@:\T, 4 &8:`R",H $@:\T,, D"2>@@$D"24, &@BD@F@&. EJ*"Z BD"8H4R,F84 &F, $D"8@D"2&@*>Z, *,:", *,:" @$ @B,8, 4 B@B,R4H,:\FH&,, *,:" @ >"F:,*@&">44 4 &FHJB:,>44 & F4:J 2"&,V">46, &@BD@FZ >,*&404,F@&,DT,>>@:,H>4N. % ^H4N 0, FJ*"N D"FFFH&@ J(@:@&>ZN *,:, FB@DZ B@ 8@>HD"8H""DJT,>4b BD"&4: *@D@0>@(@ *&40,>4b 4 *,:" @ BD4R4>,>44 &D,*" 4 JV,D$". K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z, B@ @$V,44` *,:", (*, & FB@D &@&:,R,>Z L,*,D":\>Z, @D(">Z &:"FH4 4:4 4N *@:0>@FH>Z, :4P", 7@>FH4HJP4b ES!



4:4 L,*,D":\>Z, BD"&@&Z, "8HZ. % ^H4N FJ*"N D"FFZHD@@FHD">>Z & L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* H"80, & H@, 8"F",HFb F@$FH&,>>@ L,*,D":\>@(@ BD"&", >@ ,F:4 FH@D@>", D"2>ZN TH"H@& 4:4 ,F:4 FB@D &@2>48 4>@4>@@FHD">>@(@ (@FJ*"DFH&". =" >"R":\>@6 FH"*44 FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF" 4FH,P BD,*@FH"&:b,H BD"&@&@, @$@F>@&">4, B@*"R4 4F8" & H@H :4 4>@6 FJ* F JR,H@@F4H >,2"&4F44, @ B@*FJ*>@FH4 4 B@*&,*@>@FH4 ,>@(@ *,:". +F:4 4F8 42>"R":\>@ B@*"> & L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ*, " H@H BD4N@*4H 8 &Z&@*J, RH@ >, JB@:>@ &Z>@F4H\ D,T,>4b B@ *">>@@ $ZH\ BD,8D"V,>@. AD4 @BD,*,:,>>ZN @$FH@bH,:\FH&"N 4F8, >,BD"&4:\>@ B@*">>Z6 & L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ*, "BD"&:,> & FJ* TH"H", 8@H@D@>@, *,:@ B@*FJ*>@. 3 >"@$@D@H, 4F8, B@*">>Z6 & FJ* TH"H", BD4 @BD,*,:,>>ZN JF:@&4bN & L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ*. K,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* 4 FJ* TH"H" *@:0>Z @H>@F4H\Fb 8 D,T,>4bZ4,@ BJ>8HJ 2 FH"H\4 VI 7@>FH4HJP44 ES! @ FJBD,@, BD"&@ 4"* BD"&@Z L,*,D":\>ZZ BD4@6 B@*FJ*>@FH4 FJ*@& TH"H" 4:4 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&, D"&>@



24



8"8 4 BD4"H4&>@6 B@*FJ*>@FH4, H.,. *,:, 8@H@DZ, Z 8"8 L,*,D":\>Z4R,>4, 8@P44 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& 4 FJ*@& TH"H"

EJ* TH"H" K,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* E J * T H " H " L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* 4 : 4



AD,FHJB:,>4b, BD,*JF>Z, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@FH4HJP44 TH"H", 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&" TH"H", BD@P,FFJ":\>ZN >@D46 TH"H" %@BD@FZ B@ *,:",*&404*, #@:\T4>FH&@ FB@D@&, &ZH,8"`V4N 42 R"FH>ZN *@(@&@D@& ( 8D@,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4) #@:\T4>FH&@ &@BD@F@& HDJ*@&@(@ BD"&" ),:" @ *@:0>@FH>ZN BD,FHJB:,>4bN 4 BD@L,FF4@>":\>@6 >,$D,0>@FH4 ),:" @ FB@D"N & DJ8@&@*FH&, `D4*4R,F84N :4P, >"BD4,D>ZN @$V,FH&"N ),:" @ BD4R4>,>44 JV,D$" 4:4 &D,*" R,:@&,8J IV,4, BD"& D"$@H>48@& ="F:,*FH&,>>@, BD"&@ 4 &@BD@FZ @ 2"&,V">44 ="DJT,>4, BD"&4: *@D@0>@6 $,2@B"F>@FH4 4 D,(4FHD"P44 "&H@- 4 FB@DH".



AD,FHJB:,>4b, BD,*JF>Z, "8H"(D,FF" ),:", 2"HD"(4&"`V4, L,*,D":\>Z, 2"8@>Z: >":@(@@$:@0,>4,, F@P4":\>@, @$,FB,R,>4,, D"*4@- 4 H,:,&,V">4,, (D"0*">F84, BD"&") ;,0*J>"D@*>Z, @H>@T,>4b 4 @H>@T,>4b 4, EB@DZ @ P,>>ZN $J4, @$V,FH&,>>ZN @$X,*4>,>46) EB@DZ "D@*>"b H@D(@&:b !&H@DF8@,, B"H,>H>@, BD"&@ 4 2"V4H" 4>H,::,8HJ":\>@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4 ),:", 2"HD"(4&"`V4, 4>@FHD">>Z, (@FJ*"DFH&" 4 4N (D"0*">; BD"&", BD,*JF>Z, *@(@&@D"@FbV4,Fb 8 `D4F*48P44 FJ*@& TH"H", & F:JR", D"2:4R4b (D"0*">FH&" FH@D@> ),:" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 EB@DZ ,BD48@F>@&,>>@FH4 :4R>@FH4



AD,FHJB:,>4b, B@*FJ*>Z, 8"8 L,*,D":\>@Z, 8@>FH4HJP4@>>Z, &@BD@FZ ?BD,*,:,>>Z, 4F84, 8"F"`V4,Fb (D"0*">F84N BD"& 7@::,8H4&>Z, 4F84 %@BD@FZ, &ZH,8"`V4, 42 ^8@:@(4R,F8@(@ BD"&". =,8@H@DZ, &@BD@FZ, 2"HD"(4&"`V4, L,*,D":\>@, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@.



26



="DJT,>4, BD"&4: *@D@0>@6 $,2@B"F>@FH4 4 BD@R4, BD,FHJB:,>4b, BD@4FT,*T4, >" H,DD4H@D44, @H>@FbV,6Fb 8 L,*,D":\>@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4.



27



K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4 ES!



="2>"R,>4, FJ*,6. EJ*\4 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4 7@>FH4HJP44

EJ*\4 %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" ES!, FJ*\4 "B,::bP4@>>ZN 4 D"6@>>ZN FJ*@& ES!, FJ*\4 L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*" B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4 >"2>"R"`HFb F@(:"F>@ HD,H\,6 FH"H\4 7@>FH4HJP44 ES!. 7">*4*"HZ BD,*:"("`HFb AD,24*,>H@" @*@$D,>4, E,>"HJ. EJ*\4 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4 2">4@FH\ $,FFD@R>@ 4 ,>Z @H *@:0>@FH4 H@:\8@ R,D,2 BD@P,*JDJ 4H" & 7@>(D,FF,. A@Db*@8 ^H@6 BD@P,*JDZ @BD,*,:,> & 7@>FH4HJP44. EJ*,$>"b &,H&\ &:"FH4 H"84,>" @H BD@P,FF" @H$@D" 4 JH&,D0*,>4b 8">*4*"H@&. ':"&>Z, 8D4H,D44, B@ 8@H@DZ*4*"H@& >" *@:0>@FH\ – ^H@ @BZH D"$@HZ 4 "8"*,4b. =48"84N FB,P4":\>ZN ^82"@& *:b 8">*4*"H@& >, BD,*JF@. G@R>,,, 8">*4*"H >" *@:0>@FH\ L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*\4 *@:0,> 2"B@:>4H\ @(D@@, 8@:4R,FH&@ L@DH@&, *,H":\>@ D"F8DZ&"`V4N ,(@ :4R>@FH>Z, N"D"8H,D4FH484, 042>,>>Z, *@FH40,>4b, H.,. B@:JR,>>@, @$D"2@&">4,, @BZH D"$@HZ, *4FF,DH"P44 4 BD@R4, BJ$:48"P44, 042>,>>Z, FHD,4b, FJ*,$>Z, *,:", & 8@H@DZN BD4N@*4:@F\ JR"FH&@&"H\, 4 &>,D"$@R"b *,bH,:\>@FH\. 7">*4*"HZ BD@N@*bH *,H":\>Z, F@$,F,*@&">4b, 4N 042>,>>Z6 BJH\ $J*,H HV"H,:\>Z 4 & B@F:,*J`V,. A@:4H48" 4(D",H 2"J` D@:\ BD4 >"2>"R,>44 FJ*,6 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4.



28



7">*4*"HZ, 8"8 BD"&4:@, @H$4D"`HFb AD,24*,>H@>@(@ F,>"H@D"@FH>ZH" & H@F4b. % *@B@:>,>4, 8 ^H@*4*"H AD,24*,>H" @$b2"> BD4FJHFH&@&"H\ >" 2"F,*">44 EJ*,$>@6 7@"H", " E,>"H *@:0,> BD@&,FH4 (@:@F@&">4, B@ 8"0*@6 @H*,:\>@6 &"8">F44. 7">*4*"H"" 2"4, &"8">F44 @$ZR>@ FH">@&bHFb 42&,FH>Z, BD"8H48J`V4, "*&@8"HZ, *DJ(4, L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4, 2">4428@, B@:@0,>4,, FJ*\4, D"$@H"`V4, >" JD@&>, TH"H", 4:4 BD@L,FF@D" `D4*4R,F84N L"8J:\H,H@&, BD@04&"`V4, & H@,, (*, @H8DZ:"F\ &"8">F4b. 7"0*Z6 L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ*\b >"2>"R",HFb 4 JB@:>@, 4:4 @8DJ(,. EJ*\4 >, 4 >" ^H@ FB,P4":\>@ >, JB@:>@Z. IR4HZ&"b B,D,(DJ0,>>@FH\ FJ*@& & >,8@H@DZN D"6@>"N, FJ*\b *:b D"FF4b *,:" & *DJ(@6 D"6@>. )DJ(4, L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4 EJ*\4 B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 4 @FH>Z" JD@&>, D"6@>>ZN FJ*@&, >, b&:b`HFb FJ*\bHZ, >4 AD,24*,>H, >4 E,>"H >, 4(D"`H >48"8@6 D@:4 & BD@P,FF, 4N >"2>"R,>44. 3N >"2>"R"`H "B,::bP4@>>Z, :4$@ D"6@>>Z, FJ*Z F JR,H@,>4b (DJBBZ FB,P4":4FH@&, F@FH@bV,6 42 `D4FH@& 4 BD@FHZN (D"0*">, F@$4D"`V,6Fb *:b @$FJ0*,>4b 8">*4*"H@&. EJ*\4 B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 4 $">8D@HFH&, >"2>"R"`HFb FJ*\b>ZN FJ*@& >" 14-:,H>46 FD@8. ;4D@&Z, FJ*\4 >"2>"R"`HFb FJ*\b>ZN FJ*@& >" &@F\46 FD@8. A@ 4FH,R,>44



FD@8" FJ*, JB@:>@>Z6 >"2>"R"H\ ^H4N FJ*,6, BD4 0,:">44 BD@*:4H\ 4N B@:>@@FH4 ^H4N FJ*,6 4 F@2&"H\ (DJBBJ FB,P4":4FH@& *:b *"R4 2"8:`R,>4b @ &@2@FH4 >"2>"R,>4b :4P" >" &H@D@6 FD@8. EJ*\4 L,*,D":\>@(@ BD,H,>24@>>@(@ FJ*" >"2>"R"`HFb AD,24*,>H@" FD@8 15 :,H, BD4 ^H@4, AD,24*,>H" *@:0>@ $ZH\ @*@$D,>@ E,>"H@44b B@ $@:\T4>FH&J *,: & E@,*4>,>>ZN SH"H"N !"8@ @>4 >, &N@*bH & L,*,D":\>J` F4FH,4 b&:b`HFb R"FH\` FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,"&:4&"," @,. 7"8 4 L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4, FJ*\4 TH"H" *@:0>Z D"$@H"H\ & F@@H&,HFH&44 F 7@>FH4HJP4,6 (@FJ*"DFH&" 4 *"0, "H\ 8"8@6-:4$@ >@D@-BD"&@&@6 "8H TH"H" >, F@@H&,HFH&J`V4FH4HJP44. EJ*\,6 TH"H" FH">@&bHFb B@-D"2>@FH4HJP44 4 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&" F"FH&, F:JR",& @>4 :4$@ 42$4D"`HFb >" &F,@$V,44, :4$@ >"2>"R"`HFb (J$,D>"H@D@" @BD,*,:,>>Z6 FD@8, " 2"H,Z 4:4 @BbH\ BD@6H4 BD,*JF>J` 2"8@>@"2>"R,>4b.



;@D":\ 4 >D"&FH&,>>@FH\ & L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,@ 2"8@>J L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4 >, @ @ BD,*4 4FBZHZ&"`H :4R>J` >,BD4b2>\ 8 8"8@6-:4$@ FH@D@>, & *,:,, ,F:4 BD4>4>@@6 42 FH@D@> 4:4 4">F@&Z6 4>H,D,F 8 FH@D@>, 4:4 BD,*Z,



29



FJ*\4 *@:0>Z &,FH4 F,$b F@(:"F>@ 7@*,8FJ ZN BD4>P4B@& FJ*,6 ES!, 8@H@DZ6 BD,*FH"&:b,H F@$@6 >"$@D ^H4R,F84N BD4>P4B@& 4 DJ8@&@*bV4N J8"2">46, D"2D"$@H">>ZN EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6 ES!. 7@*,8F ZN BD4>P4B@& FJ*,6 ES! 4 8@H"D44 8 >,@6 >,BD48@F>@&,>>@FH4 4 >,2"&4F4@FH4, *,bH,:\>@FH4, >, F&b2">>@6 >,B@FD,*FH&,>>@ F FJ*,6F8@6, D"F8DZ&",H B@>bH4b >,8@DD,8H>@(@ B@&,*,>4b 4 ,(@ BD4R4>Z. EJ*\4 FHDJ8P44 B@ &@BD@F"@FH4 @H 7@ZP4B"@6 !FF@P4"P44. ]H@H 8@b`V46 FJ*,6, JB@:>@ 8"8 D"2D"$"HZ&"H\ Z, BD4>P4BZ, H"8 4 *"&"H\ B4F\>Z, ,>4b 4 F@&,HZ FJ*\b48",8@H@DZ, 2"8:`R,>4b, @F>@&">>Z, >" L"8H"N, BD,*FH"&:,>>ZN 8 ,(@ D"FF4`. ]H4 2"8:`R,>4b >, JB@"`H 44 FJ*\4 4:4 FJ*,6, BD@F4&T4N BD4>bH\ 2"8:`R,>4,, >@ *@FHJB>Z *:b @2>"8@4b 8"8 & @$ZR>@6, H"8 4 & ^:,8HD@>>@6 L@D">F@&ZN 2:@JB@HD,$:,>46, L,*,D":\>@, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ BD,*B4FZ&",H &F,@ 8"8 4 BD@R4>Z@&>48"@ BD,*FH"&:bH\ @HR,H, & 8@H@D@Z $ZH\ B,D,R4F:,>Z 4>@FH4, 2">4@FH4, B@:JR,>>Z, B@*"D84 4 8@F"P44 F"ZN FJ*,6 4 >,8@H@DZN *@:0>@FH>ZN :4P, BD,*FH"&:b`V4N FJ*,$>J` &:"FH\, ND">bHFb & !*4FHD"H4&>@HD, 4 Z B@



HD,$@&">4` *:b @2>"8@4b &F,, 4@FH\`, BD,*BD4>44,46), BD"8H48@&"H\ BD"&@. =@ @>4 >@6 4 BD,B@*"&"H,:\F8@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4. ),6FH&4H,:\>@, &ZFHJB:,>4b, >"JR>Z, D"$@HZ 4 BD,B@*"&">4, &F,(*" B@:@04H,:\>@ F8"2Z&"`HFb >" 8"D\,D, FJ*\4. ]H@ BD42>",HFb 7@*,8F@ZN BD4>P4B@&, B@@VDb`V4@FH4, FB@F@$FH&J`V,6 J:JRT,>4` 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&", BD"&@&@6 F4FH,4` BD"&@FJ*4b. )@N@* @H H"8@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4, F8"0,4b, >, *@:0,> BD,&ZT"H\ 15% 2"D"$@H>@6 B:"HZ FJ*\4.



EJ*,6F84, 8@F"P44

K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4 B@:JR"`H 2"DB:"HJ 4 B@F@$4b, JFH">@&:,>>Z, 7@>(D,FF@4 &B@:>, F@B@FH"&4"(D,FF" 4 *DJ(4>Z@FH>ZFH4HJP4b H"80, BD,*JF, \T,>" & BD@P,FF, @FJV,FH&:,>4b 4@" B,>F4`

EJ*\4 "B,::bP4@>>ZN 4 D"6@>>ZN FJ*@& 4 L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*" B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4 >, 4ZN @(D">4R,>46 F@(:"F>@ 7@>FH4HJP44, H@ ,FH\ >, JN@*bH & @HFH"&8J BD4 *@FH40,>44 @BD,*,:,>>@(@ &@2D"FH". =@ B@ F@$FH&,>>@4` BD4 *@FH40,>44 65 :,H 4 BD4 >":4R44 >,8@H@DZN BD,*JF>ZN HD,$@&">46 @>4 " B,>F4`



30



F F@ND">,>4,@6 2"D"$@H>@6 B:"HZ. #@:\T4>FH&@ FJ*,6 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4, JN@*b >" B,>F4`, BD@*@:0"`H BD4>444 *,: & 8"R,FH&, FH"D,6T4N FJ*,6 $,2 *@B@:>4H,:\>@6 @B:"HZ. EJ*\4 B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 4 $">8D@HFH&,, 24@>>ZN FJ*@&, &ZT,*T4, >" B,>F4`, H"80, Z» >" F:J0$J. #,2 H"8@6 $,2&@2@6 B@Z FH"D,6T4N FJ*,6, &ZB@:>b`V4N 15-20% &F,6 D"$@HZ D"6@>>ZN 4 "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*@&, FJ*""*@$4:@F\ $Z >"@(@ $@:\T, FJ*,6, RH@$Z FBD"&4H\Fb F@ &F,4,

K,*,D":\>Z6 EJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD – @D(">42"P4b, &N@*bV"b & F4FH,@6 &:"FH4 – b&:b,HFb @F>@&>ZHD@HD@4b 8&":4L48"P44 FJ*,6. ?> BD@&@*4H @(@R4F:,>>Z, @$D"2@&"H,:\>Z, BD@(D"Z@"2>"R,>4b >" *@:0>@FH\ L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4 *@:0>Z BD@6H4 FB,P4":\>Z, 8JDFZ & ^H@HD,. #@:,, H@(@, B,D4@*4R,F84 FJ*\4 BD4(:"T"`HFb >" F,"DZ B@ &@BD@F",>4b >@&@(@ 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&", D"2&4H4b BD,P,*,>H>@(@ BD"&" 4 FB,P4L4R,F844bHD H"80, D"2D"$@H": Db* P,:,&ZN BD@(D"@(4, 42 >4N & F@HDJ*>4R,FH&, F `D4*4R,F844&,DF4H,H@&), 8@H@DZ, (:J$@8@ 42JR"`H J284, @$:"FH4 BD"&", 8 BD4H,::,8HJ":\>@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4 4:4 4FB@:\2@&">4, >"JR>ZN *@8"2"H,:\FH&. % *@B@:>,>4, 8 F,"D"HD &ZBJF8",H @(D@@, 8@:4R,FH&@ &4*,@- 4



"J*4@8"FF,H, $D@T`D 4 BD., RH@$Z B@@FH4. % B@Db*8, B@*(@H@&84 FJ*,6 !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD @D(">42J,H BD@(D"4` 8@@6 B:"HZ 4 B@F@$46, B@ >"6":", JFHD@6FH&J 4 LJ>8P4@>4D@&">4` FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4, FJ*,$>@6 ^H484 4 :4R>@6 $,2@B"F>@FH4. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD H"80, (@H@&4H FB,P4":\>Z, BD@(D",*0HJ 4 &@BD@F"4b *:b >@&ZN BD,*F,*"H,:,6 D"6@>>ZN, "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*@& 4 FJ*@& B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. K,*,D":\>Z6 EJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD, !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD 4 7@@ JBD"&:b`H H,:,HD">F:bP4@>>@6 F,H\` 4 ,0,*>,&>@ B@8"2Z&"`H @$D"2@&"H,:\>Z, 4 4>L@D>Z, BD@(D"48@& FJ*". 7D@,8@H@DZ, FJ*Z F"@ BD@&@*bH BD@(D""8@4b *:b >@&ZN FJ*,6, " H"80, @D(">42J`H 8DJ(:Z, FH@:Z *:b BD@&,*,>4b *4F8JFF46 ": FJ*\4

% *@B@:>,>4, 8 D"$@H>48"">bH\ :4R>Z6 B,DF@>":, 4J,":@">bH\ F,8D,H"Db *:b B@42"P44 *,:", 8:,D8@& (FB,P4":4FH@&) *:b BD@&,*,>4b 4FF:,*@&"H,:\F8@6 D"$@HZ 4 B@*(@H@&84 *@8JH@&. =" «B,DF@>": B":"HZ» H"80, D"FBD@FHD">b,HFb *,6FH&4, 7@*,8F" ZN BD4>P4B@&. ?$b2">>@FH4 «B,DF@>":" B":"HZ» >@FH,6 D"$@HZ 4 BD,*B@RH,>46 F"@ >"$:`*"`H 2" D"$@H@6 B,DF@>":". 3FB@:\2@&">4, B,DF@>":" *:b



31



BD@&,*,>4b BD"&@-4FF:,*@&"H,:\F8@6 4 4>ZN D"$@H, >, HD,$J`V4N :4R>@(@ JR"FH4b FJ*\4, *",H 8"0*@@FH\ :JRT, @FJV,FH&:bH\ *,bH,:\>@FH\ B@ @HBD"&:,>4` BD"&@FJ*4b.



7@*,8F ZN BD4>P4B@&: § EJ*\b *@:0,> FB@F@$FH&@&"H\ F@ND">,>4` P,:@FH>@FH4 4 >,2"&4F4@6 &:"FH4. § EJ*\b *@:0,> 42$,("H\ >,JZN 4 $,FH"8H>ZN *,6FH&46, " H"80, >, *@BJF8"H\ &@2@FH4 4N B@b&:,>4b. § EJ*\b *@:0,> 4FB@:>bH\ F&@4 @$b2">>@FH4 FH"D"H,:\>@ 4 @$X,8H4&>@. § EJ*\b & &>,FJ*,$>J` *,bH,:\>@FH\ F P,:\` J:JRT,>4b BD"&", BD"&@&@6 F4FH,42"P44 BD"&@FJ*4b. § %>,FJ*,$>"b *,bH,:\>@FH\ >, *@:0>" &FHJB"H\ & 8@>L:48H F >,B@FD,*FH&,>>Z>@FHb B,D4@*4R,F84 (@H@&4H\ @HR,H @ *@N@*"N 2" BD@L,FF4@>":\>J` 4 >,FJ*,$>J` *,bH,:\>@FH4. § EJ*\b *@:0,> &@2*,D04&"H\Fb @H B@:4H4R,F8@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4.



E4FH,@FH4

EJ*,$>Z6 BD@P,FF & ES! BD4>bH@ >"2Z&"H\ F@FHb2"H,:\>Z@&Z&",HFb >" Hb0JV4NFb, BD,*FH"&:b`V4N F&@, ,>4, @ BD,*H" &Z>,F,>4b >,2"&4F44b FJ*\4. E@(:"F>@ "F8@6 BD"&@&@6 HD"*4P44, J>"F:,*@&">>@6 @H @$V,(@ BD"&" !>(:44, >"4:JRT4ZbH\ BD"&4:\>@, D,T,>4, b&:b,HFb &FHD,R" @BB@>,>H@& B,D,* FJ*@,8@H@DZN BD"&@&ZN F4FH,4, F P,:\` @$>"DJ0,>4b 2>"R4,6T,(@ 4N BD,*FH"&:,>4b & FJ* BD@&@*4HFb FH@D@>"48"42"P44 4 >"BD"&:,>44 *,bH,:\>@FH4 FH@D@> F F@$:`*,>4,>@FH4 4 JFH">@&:,>4,F8"b FJ*,$>"b F4FH,@(@@&">" >" ">(:46F8@H,DBD,H4DJ,HFb FJ*\b, 8"84Z,>4` *@8JH""BD4, (*, F@2*">Z FB,P4":\>Z, 8@*,8FZ. ?F>@&>"b N"D"8H,D>"b R,DH" F4FH,>@FH4 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,H. ]H@ @2>"R",H, RH@ BD4 D"FF44 FB@D" FJ*\b $J*,H DJ8@&@*FH&@&"H\Fb BD"&@&ZP4B"@&:,>>Z>4N *,:"N F@ FN@*>Z42T,6 4>FH">P44 @$b2">Z F:,*@&"H\ J8"2">4b@(@ BD"&" 7@>(D,FF@bHZ *,H":424D@&">>Z, FH"HJHZ, 4>@(*" >"2Z&","&:4&"`H LJ>*"H":\>Z, BD"&@&Z, BD4>P4BZ & @BD,*,:,>>ZN FL,D"N BD"&". AD4@(@ BD"&" b&:b`HFb 7@*,8F @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 ($">8D@HFH&,), =":@(@&Z6 7@*,8F, 1"8@> @



F@P4":\>@44, 1"8@> @ P,>>ZN $J @ P,>>ZN $J,>4, 8 ^H@b:4 Db* @$T4D>ZN 2"8@>@&, 8"8, >"BD4Z6 7@Z R"FH@ B@:JR"`H *":\>,6T,, D"2&4H4, 4 H@:8@&">4, >" L,*,D":\>@, 4 JD@&>, TH"H". =,F" D"2&4H4, FH"HJH>@(@ BD"&" & BD@T:@bHZ, 2"8@>Z, *"0, >"2Z&",,H,DBD,H4DJ`HFb FJ*"H@&. G"8, >"BD4,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, D"FF@ BD@&,D4H, >, $Z:@ :4 BD4>bH@ 8"84N-:4$@ D,T,>46 %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" 4:4 "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*", H@:8J`V4N 7@*,8F @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 & H@6 4:4 4>@6 ,(@ R"FH4, 4@T,>4, 8 @$FH@bH,:\FH&"44 *,:" $J*JH *@8"2Z&"H\ >, H@:\8@ H@, RH@ *,:@ F@@H>@F4>@6 R"FH\` 7@*,8F", >@ 4 $J*JH BZH"H\Fb *@8"2"H\, RH@ *,:@ *@:0>@ $ZH\



D"FF@ & F@@H&,HFH&44 F D">,, BD4>bHZ4," *">>Z6 2"8@>. %F, FJ*\4 ES!, >,2"&4F4b FJ*", 8@H@DZ6 @>4 BD,*FH"&:b`H, @FJV,FH&:b`H B@:>@@(@ 8@>HD@:b. =,F" H@, RH@ @$ZR>@ BD,2`@FH\ 4 @$@F>@&">>@FH\ FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46, 2"8@>@& 4 *DJ(4N "8H@&, FJ*\b H,, ,, "H\ 4N >,F@@H&,HFH&J`V4FH4HJP44. EJ*\b *@:0,> @FH"&"H\Fb &,D>Z@&, FH"&bV,6 7@>FH4HJP4` ES! &ZT, &F,N *DJ(4N 2"8@>@&. 3>"R, (@&@Db, FJ*\b, F:,*Jb BD,P,*,>HJ BD4 H@:8@&">44 2"8@>@&, "8H@& 4 *,6FH&46 BD,*FH"&4H,:,6 FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4, $J*,H BD4 ^H@" F@@H&,HFH&4, 4N 7@>FH4HJP44.



A@T:4>Z 4 FJ*,$>Z, 42*,D084

+V, @*>@6 N"D"8H,D>@6 R,DH@6 "F8@6 F4FH,Z, 8"8 BD"&4:@, F", 2"&4F4@ & 4N B@:\2J 4:4 >,H. K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z &24,$@:\TJ` @B:"HJ, 8"8 BD"&4:@, JFH">@&:,>>J` 7@>(D,FF@"BD44b ^8FB,DH42Z, >"@(@ 2>"R4H,:\>,,. 'D"0*">F846 4FH,P, >, 4@FH4 @B:"H4H\ FJ*,$>Z, 42*,D084, 44 ,(@ @H JB:"HZ &2>@F@&. % >,8@H@DZN 8"H,(@D4bN (D"0*">F84N *,:, &8:`R"`V4N *,:" @ >"DJT,>44 (D"0*">F84N BD"&, 4FH,P, &Z4(DZ&"&T46 *,:@, @@FH\



33



@$&4>,>4b 4 D"FF:,*@&">4b BD,FHJB:,>4b @B:"R4&",HFb 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH\`. +F:4 @$&4>,>>Z6 & J(@:@&>@>"8"2J,44 >, 48", H@ BD"&4H,:\FH&@ H"80, @$,FB,R4&",H ,(@ "*&@8"H@,>4, FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46

3FB@:>,>4, FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46 4 BD"&@BD4,>4, b&:b`HFb @$b2">>@FH\` FH@D@> BD@P,FF", " >, FJ*". % J(@:@&>@4FH,DFH&" `FH4P44 4 >"2>"R",H@Z6 @8DJ(, >,F,H @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ 2" F@*,D0">4, 2"8:`R,>>@(@ B@* FHD"0,6. +F:4 FJ* @$b2": FH@D@>J @B:"H4H\ J(@:@&>Z6 THD"L, FB,P4":\>Z6 FJ*,$>Z6 F:J0"V46 B@:JR",H *,>\(4 4 D"FBD,*,:b,H 4N F@(:"F>@ J8"2">4` FJ*". ;4>4FH,DFH&@ `FH4P44 H,, ,, JB@:>@@ BD4>4J*4H,:\>Z, ,>4b FJ*,$>@(@ D,T,>4b – 42Z,0>Z, FD,*FH&" 4 4,>>Z6 F"@ >, @B:"H4: BD,*B4F">>Z, THD"LZ. % (D"0*">F8@Z F",FJH @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ 2" 4FB@:>,>4, FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46, *:b ^H@(@ FJ* &,*,H 2"B4F4 &F,N FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46, @H8DZHZ, *:b &F,@$V,(@ @2>"8@4b. ),>,0>Z, FD,*FH&" B@ @(4Z4b@(@ D@*" FHD"N@&">4b44 B@:JR"`H 4>L@D,>44 D,T,>4b & (D"0*">F8@" 44 B@48" 4 BD4>bH\ @BD,*,:,>>Z, >@FH4,



>"N@*bV,6Fb & D"FB@Db0,>44 *@:0>48". G"80, &Z4(D"&T"b FH@D@>" ,>44 D,T,>4b, BD4>bH@(@ L,*,D":\>Z@ B@FD,*FH&@4b BD"&": >"BD4>@FH4 42 2"DB:"HZ, >":@0,>4," 4Z. % @$V,@, D,T,>4, *",H BD"&@ >":@0,>4b "D,FH" >" 448" F JR,H@>@6 >@DH" B@:>@(@ 4FB@:>,>4b @$b2"H,:\FH&.



AD@P,FFJ":\>Z, BD"&4:" BD@&,*,>4b FJ*,$>ZN BD,>46

E@(:"F>@ !8HJ @ DJ8@&@*bV4N FJ*,$>ZN BD"&4:"N @H 1934 (@*" @$b2">>@FH\ B@ D"2D"$@H8, >@D@(@ D"2$4D"H,:\FH&" :,04H >" F"@6 FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4. E@(:"F>@ ^H4@"b F4FH,"N@0*,>4b 4 4FF:,*@&">4b *@8"2"H,:\FH&, " H"80, BD"&4:" (D"0*">F8@(@, J(@:@&>@(@, "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*@BD@42&@*FH&" 4 BD@42&@*FH&" B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. ]H4 BD"&4:" $Z:4 D"2D"$@H">Z F P,:\` JBD@FH4H\ BD@P,*JDJ, *@FH4R\ FBD"&,*:4&@(@ 4 R,FH>@(@ D"FF4b *,:", " H"80, 42$,0"H\ >,@$@F>@&">>ZN 42*,D0,8 4 BD@&@:@R,8. ?>4 F@(:"F@&Z&"`HFb & 8@4&,DF4H,H@&, >"2>"R,>>Z@(@ EJ*", " 2"H,4FHD"H4&>ZHD@4b @$V,FH&,>>@(@ ,>4b, JH&,D0*"`HFb EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6 4 BD@&@2(:"T"`HFb %,DN@&>Z@&bHFb 2"8@>@(D,FF >,



34



BD@&,*,H (@:@F@&">4, B@ 4N @H, 4:4 42,>4`.



AD@H@8@:4D@&">4, FJ*,$>ZN BD@P,*JD

%F, FJ*,$>Z, BD@P,*JDZ, BD@&@*444 FJ*", 2"B4FZ&"`HFb BD@H@8@:4FH@" 2&J8@>@F4H,:\. AD@H@8@:4FH – ^H@ R,:@&,8, FB,P4":\>@ @$JR,>>Z6 2"B4FZ&"H\ &F, @$FH@bH,:\FH&" *,:" 4 &Z&@*4H\ B@F:@&>J` 2"B4F\ &F,(@ F8"2">>@(@ – HD">F8D4BH. A4F\>Z6 HD">F8D4BH *:b "B,::bP44 4:4 B@ HD,$@&">4` @*>@6 42 FH@D@> B@ *,:J, " H"80, HD,H\4N :4P.



B@:\2@&">4b 8@::,(4b"" 8@@&,. #@:\T4>FH&@ FJ*@& 4>Z, F"6HZ & 4>H,D>,H, 4 D"2" >4N ,>4b & ^:,8HD@>>@,8@H@DZ, `D4*4R,F84, L"8J:\H,HZ >"R":4 F$@D FJ*,$>ZN ,>46, & @F>@&>@bHZN "B,::bP4@>>ZZ R,D,2 4>H,D>,H. AD448@& ,>46 %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" 4 "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*@& @, & R"FH>@FH4, >"6H4 B@ F:,*J`V4ZN ,>46

A@F8@:\8J BD4 @$V,@&Z&"`HFb >" BD,P,*,>H, 4 H@:8@&">44 BD"&", 8D"6>, &"0>@, RH@$Z FJ*,$>@, ,>4, B@ H@@@ FJ*J 4 "*&@8"H"J&T4Z@:@(46 $@:\T4>FH&@ B@FH">@&:,>46 4 ,>46 FJ*,6 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& F,(@*>b B@*(@H"&:4&",HFb >" 8@4,@(@ @$,FB,R,>4b. K"8H4R,F84 0,, &F, ,>4b 4 B@FH">@&:,>4b *@FHJB>Z *:b @$@2D,>4b 4 8@B4D@&">4b & 2*">44 FJ*". =,8@H@DZ, ,>4b @BJ$:48@&Z&"`HFb, 4N B,R"H\ @$ZR>@ @FJV,FH&:b`H R"FH>Z, 8@44. % *@B@:>,>4, 8 ^H@Z, `D4*4R,F84, 42*"H,:\FH&" 4 8@Z, BD"&@&Z, B@4F8@&Z, $"2Z, H"84, 8"8 Westlaw 4:4 Lexis/Nexis, BD,*@FH"&:b`H FJ*,$>Z, ,>4b, FH"HJHZ 4 *DJ(J` `D4*4R,F8J` :4H,D"HJDJ *:b



?F>@&>Z, R,DHZ FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF"



35



'D"0*">F846 BD@P,FF

'D"0*">F846 BD@P,FF >" L,*,D":\>@, &F,(*" &8:`R",H & F,$b BD"&@&@6 FB@D "4P44D@&"H\ BD@P,FF & L,*,D":\>@H – 4F8 (0":@$J), BD,*FH"&:b,H ,(@ & FJ* 4 @$,FB,R4&",H @H&,HR48" 8@B4,6. 3F8 - ^H@ >,$@:\T@, B@ L@D4,, & 8@H@D@,>>Z6 ,@&">4,, *"`V,, BD"&@ >" FJ*,$>J` 2"V4HJ), FB@F@$ ,(@ BD4R4>,>4b 4 BD@F4H FJ* BD4>bH\ @&:,>4` BD"&". 3FH,P ,0>J` 8@F"P4` 2" BD4R4>,>>Z6 JV,D$ 4:4 BD@F4H\ FJ* 2"BD,H4H\ &D,*>J` *:b >,(@ *,bH,:\>@FH\. EJ* "BD44, BD"& 4FHP" & @BD,*,:,>>ZN F4HJ"P4bN. =" B@*(@H@&4H,:\>@6 FH"*44 FH@D@>Z B@*$4D"`H *@8JHZ, 8@H@DZ, @&"H\ HD,$@&">4b H@6 4:4 4>@6 FH@D@>Z. AD4 ^H@Z *@:0>Z BD,*@FH"&4H\ 4>L@D@FH4, 4" F&4*,H,:,6, 4N @04*",4b, 8@B44 &F,N *@8JH@&, @H>@FbV4NFb 8 *,:J. )@8"2"H,:\FH&" *@:0>Z $ZH\ F@$D">Z HV"H,:\>ZZ @ &Z2@&, & FJ* *:b *"R4 B@8"2">46. O,:\ ^H@6 FH"*44 2"8:`R",HFb & HV"H,:\>@6 B@*(@H@&8, 8 D"FF4` *,:" FJ*@4, >,*@D"2J46 &@ &D,@(@ D"2$4D"H,:\FH&". AD,*,:Z ^H@6 FH"*44 &,F\>ZN BD@&@*4HFb FH@D@>"@ JFH">@&:,>>ZZ & ^H@H BD@P,FF :4T\ & D",@$N@*4HD@:\ 4 D"2D,T"H\ D"2>@(:"F4b, &@2>48"`V4, "4,>>ZN >@, B@8"2">4, B@* BD4Fb(@6, BD4@$V",4b B@* BD4Fb(@6 & BD4FJHFH&44 BD@H@8@:4FH" FJ*". )DJ(4,>>ZZ6 :4FH *:b B@8"2">46, B@*(@H"&:4&",@6 42 FH@D@> B@ *,:J *:b *DJ(@6 FH@D@>Z, 4 @H&,H >" 8@H@DZ6 H"80, *",HFb B@* BD4Fb(@6 4 BD4@$V",HFb 8 *,:J. GD,H46 " FH@D@>" HZ 4 *DJ(4, "N@*bV4,Fb B@* ,, 8@>HD@:,@(@ 4FF:,*@&">4b F@$FH&,>>@FH4 *DJ(@6 FH@D@>Z, ,F:4 ^H@ 4FF:,*@&">4, F&b2">@ F @$FH@bH,:\FH&"" 4b 4:4



36



N@*"H"6FH&" F P,:\` BD4>bH4b FJ*@46 B@ 8"84Z F @H>@F4@FH4 D"2D,T,>4b *">>@(@ FB@D" `D4*4R,F84,>44 4F8@&@(@ 2"b&:,>4b, 8 BD4" @HFJHFH&4, J 4FHP" @F>@&">46 *:b 4F8" & B@:>@@" @HFJHFH&4, J FJ*" `D4F*48P44 F:JT"H\ *,:@ F JR"FH4,Z 4:4 B@ B@&@*J H@(@ 4:4 4>@(@ BD,*H>@FH\ &Z>@F4H\ D,T,>4b 4 D"FFJ*4H\ FH@D@>Z. M@*"H"6FH&@ @ BD4>bH44 D,T,>4b $,2 JR"FH4b BD4Fb0>ZN @2>"R",H, RH@ FH@D@>Z >, @FB"D4&"`H L"8HZ 4 BD4Fb0>Z,H >,@$N@*4"&:4&"H\. % H"8@Z BD@FbH D"FF>@H, 4 $ZFHD,, @(:"F4H\ D,T,>4,, @F>@&Z&"bF\ >" >@D4@&:,>4b @$FH@bH,:\FH& 4 FB@DZ @ BD"&4:"N >"N@0*,>4b *@8"2"H,:\FH&: ^H@ 8"F",HFb R"FH>@6 4:4 >,BD48@F>@&,>>@6 BD4D@*Z @BD,*,:,>>@6 4>L@D4, FJ*" & >,@$N@*4bH4b ,>4b *@8"2"H,:\FH& *:b FJ*,$>@(@ 2"F,*">4b. )DJ(4, N@*"H"6FH&" ZN &@BD@F@&, 8"8H@: 4b *,:", H,DD4H@D4":\>"b B@*FJ*>@FH\, &D," B@*(@H@&4H,:\>J` FH"*4` 4:4 F"4,, 4, >"8@>,P, *,6FH&4b, @FJV,FH&:b," FJ*,$>@44. % P,:bN 42$,0">4b >,@$@F>@&">>ZN 2"HD"H 4 ^8@>@4, FJ*\b BD,*:"(",H Hb0JV4JH\ 4, B@ FB@D>@@, 2"F,*">4, F JR"FH4,, >" 8@H@D@Z bH\ F@(:"T,>4, @ B,D,*"R, *,:" >" D"2D,T,>4, B@FD,*>48J-BD4FH&@ (D"0*">F84N *,: 2"8">R4&",HFb H"844,\T,, B@F:, J*@&:,H&@D,>4b N@*"H"6FH&" @$ @H8:@>,>44 4F8@&@(@ 2"b&:,>4b. +F:4 F@(:"T,>4b *@FH4R\ >, J*":@F\, >"2>"R",HFb FJ*,$>@, F:JT">4,. A@ T4D@8@ 4FH4HJP4@>>@, BD"&@ N@*"H"6FH&@&"H\ @ F:JT">44 *,:" FJ*@ZN. +F:4 FH@D@>Z @H8"2Z&"`HFb @H ^H@(@ BD"&", H@ *,:@ $J*,H D"FF@ FJ*\,6 $,2 JR"FH4b BD4Fb0>ZN. AD4 BD@&,*,>44 FJ*,$>@(@ 2"F,*">4b 2"F:JT4&"`HFb F&4*,H,:\F84, B@8"2">4b: F&4*,H,:4 BD4>@FbH BD4Fb(J 4 @H&,R"`H "*&@8"H""$:`*,>4, F@@H&,HFH&@&"H\ &F,>Z4b @6 FBD"&,*:4&@FH4, >"*,0>@FH4 4 H@R>@FH4 F&4*,H,:\F84N B@8"2">46 4 *@8JH@&. A@F:, BD,*Xb&:,>4b *@8"2"H,:\FH& 8"0*"b FH@D@>" 4" 2"8:`R4H,:\>J` D,B:48J. +F:4 *,:@ D"FFZN, FJ*\b D"2XbF>b,H 2"8@> 4 @$XbF>b,H BD4Fb0>Z $ZH\ D"2D,T,>. +F:4 0, *,:@ F:JT",HFb $,2 JR"FH4b BD4Fb0>ZN, FJ*\b F"@ BD4>44, @ L"8H"N 4 BD"&,. % (D"0*">F8@" 4FHP", 8@H@DZ6 *@:0,> J$,*4H\ BD4Fb0>ZN (4:4 FJ*\`, ,F:4 BD4Fb0>ZN >,H) & >":4R44 $@:,, &,F84N *@8"2"H,:\FH& F ,(@ FH@D@>Z, & B,D,&,F, *@8"2"H,:\FH&, H@ ,FH\ & H@, R,, *@:0,> >,FH4 @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ 2" BD4R4>,>4, &D,*" 4FHPJ.



37



I(@:@&>Z6 BD@P,FF

I(@:@&>Z6 BD@P,FF @H:4R",HFb @H (D"0*">F8@(@ >,F8@:\84>ZH"",Z6 BD@8JD@D (BD,*FH"&4H,:\ ;4>4FH,DFH&" `FH4P44) 4 B@*FJ*4Z6). E:,*FH&4, B@ J(@:@&>Z4FH,DFH&@4H,:\>Z"4H,:\>J` &,H&\ &:"FH4. EJ* >, BD4>4@,>44 BD"&" 4 BD4>bH44 @$@F>@&">>ZN D,T,>46. 7@>(D,FF ES! D"2*,:4: &F, J(@:@&>Z, BD"&@>"DJT,>4b >" HD4 (DJBBZ: Hb084,, FD,*>4, (@DZ) 4 :,(84, (>,2>"R4H,:\>Z,). 7 B,D&@6 8"H,(@D44 @H>@FbHFb BD"&@>"DJT,>4b, BD,*JF"8"2">4, F&ZT, @*>@(@ (@*" :4T,>4b F&@$@*Z. %@ &H@DJ` (DJBBJ &8:`R"`H ,, F,D\,2>Z, BD"&@>"DJT,>4b, >"8"2">4, 2" 8@H@DZ, >, @(@ (@*" H`D,@(@ 2"8:`R,>4b. ="4,, F,D\,2>Z, BD"&@>"DJT,>4b, @H>@FbV4,Fb 8 HD,H\,6 (DJBB,, BD,*JF"8"2">4, >, &ZT, B@:J(@*" :4T,>4b F&@$@*Z, @*>"8@, FJ* R"FH@ F&@*4H >"8"2">4, 8 THD"LJ. IB@:>@>Z6 BD,*FH"&4H,:\ FJ*,$>@6 F:J0$Z B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:" BD@&@*4H *@BD@F @$&4>b,,L@D@&">44 B@:JR,>>ZN *">>ZN FJ*\b D,T",H &@BD@F @ &@2@FH4 @F&@$@0*,>4b B@*2"V4H>@(@ *@ FJ*,$>@(@ D"2$4D"H,:\FH&", & H@44 @$&4>b,>Z, @$&4>,>4b, D,T",H &@BD@F @ P,:,F@@$D"2>@FH4



F@*,D0">4b @$&4>b,@(@ BD@P,FF" 4 @BD,*,:b,H, ,FH\ :4 FJV,FH&,>>Z, @F>@&">4b B@:"("H\, RH@ BD,FHJB:,>4, $Z:@ F@&,DT,>@ 4 RH@ @>@ $Z:@ F@&,DT,>@ 4>@ @$&4>b,L@Db,, @(@ "*&@8"H", @$ 4N BD"&, >" $,FB:"H>@(@ 2"V4H>48", >"2>"R,>>@(@ FJ*@@ 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&J & 8"0*@>@ $ZH\ D"2D"$@H"> 424b $,FB:"H>@(@ "*&@8"H" H,, 48" F"@. E ^H@6 P,:\` FJ* "2>"R4H\ @$V,FH&,>>@(@ 2"V4H>48", D"$@H"`V,(@ >" L,*,D":\>@, &:"FH4 (^H@ @H>@F4HFb 8 "B,::bP4@>>Z" @, &:"FH4 (& *">>@>Z6 2"V4H>48 b&:b,HFb, 8"8 BD"&4:@, F@HDJ*>48@FJ:\H"P44, B@:JR"`V,6 *@H"P44 @H FJ*,$>@6 &,H&4 &:"FH4), :4$@ 0, R"FH>@(@ "*&@8"H", F@(:"F4&T,(@Fb >" B@*@$>@, >"2>"R,>4, 4 JF:@&4b, BD,*:@0,>>Z, FJ*@>ZN F:JR",& *,bH,:\>@FH\ 2"V4H>48" @B:"R4&",HFb FJ*@(D,FF@b,44 BD,FHJB:,>4b, ,F:4 FJ* >, FR,: >,@$N@*44, & F:,*FH&,>>ZN 42@:bH@D"N, bH\Fb >,8@H@DZ, @(D">4R,>4b & F&@$@*, 4N *,bH,:\>@FH4: *@46 "D,FH 4:4 BD@&,D8" >" >"D8@H4R,F8J` 2"&4F4@6 F:J0$, B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:", RH@ *@:0>@ FH"H\ ("D">H4,6 4N B@b&:,>4b & FJ*,. E@(:"F>@ 7@>FH4HJP44 BD@P,FF B@ Hb084Z4b"R":\>@6 FH"*44 8



38



B@F:,*J`V,6 H@:\8@, ,F:4 H"8 >"2Z&",Z, 2"F,*"H,:4, D,T"`V4, &@BD@F @ BD,*">44 FJ*J, F@RHJH ^H@ >,@$N@*4Z, @P,>4&"`H *@8"2"H,:\FH&", BD,*FH"&:,>>Z, L,*,D":\>Z@FH4 *:b BD@&,*,>4b FJ*,$>@(@ 2"F,*">4b. %@ &D,@(@ 2"F,*">4b @$&4>b,@T,>4, 8 BD,*Xb&:,>>ZZ,>4bFH&@ @$&4>b,"`H F&@` &4>J, RH@$Z 42$,0"H\ *@:(@(@ FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF". a&:,>4,, 8@(*" @$&4>b,",H F&@` &4>J & @$ >" ,, FJD@&@, >"8"2">4, 4:4 >" @$,V">4, @H@2&"H\ @$&4>,>4, B@ 8"844H,:\>Z8H""2&">4, «F@(:"T,>4, @ BD4>bH44 &4>Z @$&4>b,b,",H F,$b &4>@&>Z" ^H@44, N@Hb, 8"8 BD"&4:@, >"2>"R",H *@B@:>4H,:\>@, F:JT">4,. +F:4 @$&4>b,, BD42>",H F,$b &4>@&>Z"2>"R",HFb FJ*,$>@, D"2$4D"H,:\FH&@. A@ J(@:@&>ZF84@ @(D">4R,>4, *@FJ*,$>ZN BD@P,*JD B@ &D,4, & R"FH>@FH4, F P,:\` 2"V4HZ 4>L@D48@L@D,>4b, 4 &@ 42$,0">4, 2"BJ(4&">4b F&4*,H,:,6. 1"V4H" 44 BD,*FH"&:b`H F@$@6 BD@T,>4b, 2"b&:,>>Z, *@ >"R":" FJ*,$>@(@ D"FF4b *,:" 4 F&b2">>Z, F &@BD@F"@FH4 FJ*". G"8, >"BD4@(4, "*&@8"HZ B@*"`H N@*"H"6FH&" @$ @H8:@>,>44 8"8@(@:4$@ *@8"2"H,:\FH&", H.,. 4F8:`R,>44 ,(@ 42 FB4F8" *@8"2"H,:\FH&, BD,*Xb&:b," FJ*,, ,F:4 2"V4H>48 FR4H",H, RH@ *">>@, *@8"2"H,:\FH&@



$Z:@ B@:JR,>@ F >"DJT,>4,FH4HJP4@>>ZN BD"& @$&4>b,@4b :,04H >" (@FJ*"DFH&,. ?$&4>b,, *@:0>Z *@8"2Z&"H\ F&@` >,&4>@&>@FH\. ="@$@D@H, 2"*"R" @$&4>,>4b 2"8:`R",HFb & F$@D, *@FH"H@R>ZN *@8"2"H,:\FH& *:b H@(@, RH@$Z J$,*4H\ BD4Fb0>ZN & &4>@&>@FH4 B@*FJ*4@"@(@ &ZT,, R,F8@4 *@:0>Z $ZH\ «&>, D"2J@(@ F@,>4b». ]H@ @2>"R",H, RH@ BD,*FH"&:,>>Z, *@8"2"H,:\FH&" *@:0>Z $ZH\ >"FH@:\8@ J$,*4H,:\>ZZ, @F>@&">4b *:b F@,>4b & F@&,DT,>44 BD,FHJB:,>4b @$&4>b,@FH\` 4F8:`R":4F\. EJ*\b D"2XbF>b,H BD4Fb0>Z>@FH4, " H"80, >,B@>bH>Z, 4, BD42>"> &4>@&>Z B@*:,04H @F&@$@0*,>4`, " @$&4>4H,:\ >, 4" "B,::bP4`. ?$&4>4H\ B@*@2D,&",44 ,V, D"2 H"80, >,:\2b: 7@>FH4HJP4b 2"BD,V",H «&H@D4R>@, BD4&:,R,>4, 8 J(@:@&>@6 @H&,HFH&,>>@FH4 2" @*>@ 4 H@ 0, BD,FHJB:,>4,». AD4 &Z>,F,>44 BD4(@&@D" @$&4>b, DJ8@&@*FH&@&"H\Fb FB,P4":\>@6 4>FHDJ8P4,6, 42*">>@6 7@@@6 &:"FH4. ]H" 4>FHDJ8P4b BD,F:,*J,H F:,*J`V4, 2"*"R4: § @L@D4, P,:,6 BD4(@&@D" (H.,. BD@FH@ >"8"2">4,, JFHD"T,>4,, @(D">4R,>4, BD"&@- 4/4:4 *,,FB@F@$>@FH4, @BD"&*">4, 4 &@FFH">@&:,>4, & BD"&"N); § @$,FB,R,>4, FBD"&,*:4&@FH4 4 @BD,*,:,>>@FH4 >"8"2">4b (^H@ *@:0>@ B@,@$@F>@&">>@6 >,F@D"2@FH4 >"8"2">4b BD,FHJB>48@& 2" F@&,DT,>4, 4*,>H4R>ZN BD,FHJB:,>46 BD4 B@N@04N @$FH@bH,:\FH&"N, BD4 ^H@@FH\ BD@b&4H\ (4$8@FH\ BD4 &Z>,F,>44 BD4(@&@D" 4 JR,FH\ F4,, & D"@(@, D"2&4H4b 2>">46 @ R,:@&,R,F8@44, 4@T,>4, 8 @FJV,FH&:,>4` J(@:@&>@(@ FJ*@BD@42&@*FH&". 3>FHDJ8P4b F@*,D04H J8"2">4, >" &@2Z, >"8"2">4b 2" F@&,DT,>>@, BD,FHJB:,>4, F JR,H@@FH4 4 F JR,H@@FH4 BD,FHJB>48", ,(@ FJ*4@&Z&"bF\ >" F,D\,2>@FH4 F@&,DT,>>ZN BD,FHJB:,>46, 4>FHDJ8P4b D"2*,:b,H $@:\T4>FH&@ BD,FHJB:,>46, B@*FJ*>ZN L,*,D":\>Z" 43 JD@&>b. 7"0*Z6 @FJ0*,>>Z6 B@B"*",H H"80, & @*>J 42 T,FH4 8"H,(@D46 & 2"&4F4":\>@(@ BD@T:@(@, 2*,F\ JR4HZ&"`HFb *"&>@FH\ 4 Hb0,FH\ F@&,DT,>>ZN D">,, BD,FHJB:,>46. ="8"2">4, @BD,*,:b,HFb B@ H"$:4P,, BD4&@*4FHDJ8P44: *@:0>@, >"8"2">4, >"N@*4HFb & 8&"*D"H, >" B,D,F,R,>44 JD@&>b BD,FHJB:,>4b 4 8"H,(@D44 BD,FHJB>48". E H,@FH\ BD@b&4H\ (4$8@FH\ BD4 &Z>,F,>44 BD4(@&@D", 8"0*Z6 8&"*D"H &8:`R",H & F,$b 4>H,D&": &@2@(@ >"8"2">4b: @ &@2@, BD,&ZT",H 4@ &@2@, >" 25% 4:4 >" 6 &Z$D"H\ >"8"2">4,, BD,*JF>@, 4>FHDJ8P4,6, ,F:4 H@:\8@ >, $J*,H JFH">@&:,>@, RH@ 7@, JR,: 8"8@6->4$J*\ L"8H@D, 8@H@DZ6 *@:0,> BD4&,FH4 8 *DJ(@"8"2">4`. %



:`$@ @$@F>@&"H\ &Z>,F,>4, BD4(@&@D". +F:4 >"8"2">4,, JFH">@&:,>>@, FJ*@@&:,>>Z, 4>FHDJ8P4,6, H@ BD4(@&@D B@*:,04H B,D,F>@6 4>FH">P44 B@ BD4R4>, 2:@JB@HD,$:,>4b F&@$@*@6 &Z$@D". 3>"R, (@&@Db, &F, BD4(@&@DZ Z BD4 >,BD"&4:\>@,>44 4>FHDJ8P44 4:4 4>ZN >@D44 *,: B@ @F@$@ Hb0844b,F,>4,@FH>@(@ :4P", @FJV,FH&:b`V,(@ >"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Z@&J` 4>L@D,@$N@*4,F,>4b BD"&4:\>@(@ D,T,>4b, 4 &8:`R",H 4FR,DBZ&"`V,, 42JR,>4, @$FH@bH,:\FH& *,:", N"D"8H,D4FH484 BD"&@>"DJT4H,:b, ,(@ BD@T:@,. )@8:"*R48 H"80, F@@H>@F4H F@&,DT,>>@, BD,FHJB:,>4,, B@ 8@H@D@b,"> &4>@&>ZFHDJ8P4,6 4 F BD,*B@:"(","8"2">4,,F,>4b BD4(@&@D" FJ* , H@:\8@ *@8"2"H,:\FH&", 4FF:,*@&">>Z, &@ &D,@(@ 2"F,*">4b, >@ 4 &F` FJV,FH&,>>J` 4>L@D>J` FJ*,$>@6 F:J0$@6 B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:", (,>,D":\>Z@6 2"V4HZ. % @F@$ZN F:JR"bN FJ* &BD"&, @H@6H4 @H &Z>,F,>4b >"8"2">4b & FHD@(@FHDJ8P4,6. AD4(@&@D 4b, D"2":@0,>>@(@ THD"L" & B@:\2J (@FJ*"DFH&", >"2>"R,>4, @$V,FH&,>>ZN D"$@H, &@24, J$ZH8@& B@FHD"*"&T44b. +F:4 0, @FJ0*,>>Z6 @HBJF8",HFb >" F&@$@*J, H@ F:J0$", @FJV,FH&:b`V"b >"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Z,>44 &F,N JF:@&46 BD4(@&@D", >":@0,>>ZN FJ*@48"" 2:@JB@HD,$:,>4, ":8@(@:,"D8@H48"Z, BD@(D"FJ:\H4D@&">4, B@ &@BD@F"bH@FH4, &Z$@D ":\H,D>"H4&>@(@ F@*,D0">4b B@* "D,FH@ZN

IR"FH4, @$ZR>ZN (D"0*"> & FJ*,$>@" L,*,D":\>@,, B@0":J6, :JRT4ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6. C"2:4R"`H *&" &4*" F:J0$Z BD4Fb0>ZN B@ 4N LJ>8P4b44 BD"&@FJ*4b: BD4Fb0>Z,, BD4>4,B@FD,*FH&,>>@ & FJ*,$>@44 («ZN»), 4 BD4Fb0>Z,, D,T"`V4, &@BD@F @ BD,*">44 FJ*J («$@:\T@, 0`D4»). % (D"0*">F8@ZN &8:`R",H 6-12 2"F,*"H,:,6. AD4Fb0>Z6, BD4>4F8@ F:JT"H\ BD,*FH"&:,>>Z, *@8"2"H,:\FH&" 4 @$XbF>,>4b 4 D,T"H\, *,6FH&4H,:\>@ :4 @H&,HR48 JV,, &ZB@:>4: B@ @H>@T,>4` 8 >,@ $ZH\ >"8"2">4, 4:4 D"2F"P44. 7@::,(4b BD4Fb0>ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6 & J(@:@&>@@&. AD4Fb0>Z, D,T"`H, *,6FH&4H,:\>@ :4 @$&4>b,4, & H@@ ,8D44DJ,HFb. AD4(@&@D @$ZR>@ @(:"T",HFb FJ*\,6, &,D*48H 0, BD4Fb0>ZN *@:0,> $ZH\ BD4>bH ,*4>@(:"F>@, 8"8 & (D"0*">F8@@F8@Z ">44



>,,*4>@(:"F>@(@ D,T,>4b BD4Fb0>ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6. E@&,V">4, BD4Fb0>ZN *@:0>@ BD@N@*4H\ 8@>L4*,>P4":\>@; FJ*\b, Hb0JV4,Fb, F&4*,H,:4 4 BD@R4, :4P" >, , H@:\8@ BD4>4ZN, >@ 4 $ZH\ 4N F:JR"6>Z@ F@FH@4H 42 1623 R:,>@& 4 4@Z6 BD@8JD@D BD,*FH"&:b,H $@:\T@>Z, & N@*, F:,*FH&4b *@8"2"H,:\FH&" F H,Z, @&">4b B@:"("H\, RH@ BD,FHJB:,>4, $Z:@ F@&,DT,>@ *">>Z@ :4 ^H@ :4P@ BD,*FH"H\ B,D,* FJ*@Z, BD4*JH 8 &Z&@*J, RH@ *@8"2"H,:\FH& *@FH"H@R>@, H@ B@*@2D,&", @$&4>4H,:\>Z6 "8H. 1"F,*">4b $@:\T@(@ 0`D4 H"80, b&:b`HFb 2"8DZHZ*4*"HZ & BD4Fb0>Z, &Z$4D"`HFb >" @F>@&">44 :`$@(@ 4FH@R>48", F@*,D0"V,(@ FH"H4FH4R,F84, *">>Z, @ >"F,:,>44 & P,:@ZN &Z$4D"`H >"J("* FD,*4 44, :4R>@FH4 (&@*4H,:\F84, BD"&") 4 04&,H & *">>@,. ?H@$D">>Z, 8">*4*"HZ *@:0>Z 2"B@:>4H\ ">8,HZ: ^H@ B@4 *@FH"H@R>J` 8&":4L48"P4` *:b H@(@, RH@$Z $ZH\ BD4Fb0>Z8,H FJ*\b >"J("* &Z2Z&",H :4P & FJ* *:b BD,*FH"&:,>4b & 8"R,FH&, BD4Fb0>ZN. G"8@6 @H$@D *",H ("D">H4` H@(@, RH@ BD4Fb0>Z, 2"F,*"H,:4 @HD"0"`H &F, >"F,:,>4, D"6@>" &>, 2"&4F4"P4@>":\>@FH4, &@2D"FH" 4:4 B@:4H4R,F84N &2(:b*@&. AD4Fb0>Z, B@:JR"`H F8D@J` 8@F"P4` 2" F&@` D"$@HJ & @HBD"&:,>44 BD"&@FJ*4b. ?*>"8@ BD@N@0*,>4, @H$@D" 4 BD,*FH"&:,>4, B,D,* FJ*@P4":\>@(@ BD4Fb0>@(@ ,V, >, *",H ("D">H44 H@(@, RH@ :4P@ $J*,H BD4FJHFH&@&"H\ >" FJ*, & 8"R,FH&, BD4Fb0>@(@. 7@(*" &@2>48",H >,@$N@*444 BD4Fb0>ZN, (DJBBJ @H@$D">>ZN 8">*4*"H@& BD4(:"T"`H & 2": FJ*", (*, *@:0>@ BD@6H4 FJ*,$>@, 2"F,*">4,. EJ*\b 4 BD,*FH"&4H,:4 FH@D@> BD@&@*bH BD,*&"D4H,:\>J` BD@&,D8J *@BJFH4ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6 (voir-dire), H.,. $,F,*J F P,:\` &ZbF>,>4b 4N $,FBD4FHD"FH>@FH4 4 >,BD,*J$,0*,>>@FH4: BD4Fb0>Z4N H,N, 8H@, &@2@, >, FbH\ @$X,8H4&>@, D,T,>4,. G, 8">*4*"HZ & BD4Fb0>Z,, 8@H@DZ, 2>"8@4$J*\ 42 :4P, JR"FH&J`V4N & *,:,, >"N@*bHFb & 8JDF, D"FFZ, BD,*J$,0*,>4b BD@H4& :4P, L"8H@&, D"FF484 H@0, 4>@, 8@:4R,FH&@ BD4Fb0>ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6 $,2 J8"2">4b 4b, BD,*Xb&:b,Z4, @H @$b2">>@FH4 @FJV,FH&:bH\ *,bH,:\>@FH\ BD4Fb0>@(@.

GD,$@&">4b 8 BD4Fb0>ZFH&@ ES!. § %@2D"FH – >, 4, & FJ*,$>@, >, ,, (@*". § 1>">4, ">(:46F8@(@ b2Z8". § ?HFJHFH&4, J>ZN 4:4 L424R,F84N @H8:@>,>46, &:,8JV4N @HFHD">,>4, @H @FJV,FH&:,>4b *,bH,:\>@FH4 BD4Fb0>@(@. § ?HFJHFH&4, >,B@("T,>>ZN @$&4>,>46 & F@&,DT,>44 @F@$@ Hb084N BD,FHJB:,>46, " H"80, @HFJHFH&4, BD42>">4b &4>@&>Z4bF84, BD"&" B@:>@FH\` &@FFH">@&:,>Z).



A@Db*@8 F:J0$Z BD4Fb0>ZN



ED@8 § ):b ZN JFH">"&:4&",HFb FJ*@,8@H@DZN FJ*"N JFH">"&:4&",HFb F:J0$" >" @*4> *,>\ :4$@ >" FD@8 D"FF4b *,:", & *DJ(4N 0, >" @BD,*,:,>>Z6 FD@8. § E:J0$" #@:\T@(@ 0`D4 \, 4>@(*" BD4Fb0>Z@, B4H">4, 4 &@24, D"FN@*@& >" BD@,2*. '"D">H44 2">bH@FH4 E@(:"F>@ 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&J D"$@H@*"H,:4 @$b2">Z @HBJF8"H\ D"$@H>48" *:b @FJV,FH&:,>4b 4>@FH,6 BD4Fb0>@(@ F 4:4 $,2 F@ND">,>4b 2"D"$@H>@6 B:"HZ. I&@:\>,>4,, 2"BJ(4&">4, 4 &FbR,F8@, BD4>J0*,>4b D"$@H>48" H"80, >,2"8@>>@.



?F&@$@0*,>4, @H F:J0$Z BD4Fb0>ZJ` F:J0$J & &@@DJ0,>>ZN F4:"N. § A@:4P,6F84, 4 B@0"D>Z,, >,8@H@DZ, F@HDJ*>484 ^H4N B@*D"2*,:,>46. § ?BD,*,:,>>Z, @$V,FH&,>>Z, *,bH,:4. § =,8@H@DZ, *DJ(4, :4P" B@ 4>*4&4*J":\>Z"BD4,@H:@0>J` B@,*"&>,4ZN) %@2@, @F&@$@0*,>4, ;@0,H $ZH\ BD,*@FH"&:,>@ FJ*@"ZN 2"HDJ*>,>46 4:4 8D"6>,(@ >,J*@$FH&"».



44



),:" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 ($">8D@HFH&,)

K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z D"FB@:"("`H 4F8:`R4H,:\>@6 `D4F*48P4,6 B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. 3>"R, (@&@Db, *,:" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 FJ*", D"FF,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 $Z:4 F@2*">Z 7@>(D,FF@4, D"6@>>ZN FJ*@&, DJ8@&@*FH&@ ^H4N FJ*@& @FJV,FH&:b,HFb FJ*\b,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. ':"&>Z@*"H,:\FH&" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 b&:b`HFb: 1) *"H\ T">F R,FH>@48J >"R"H\ «&F, F >J:b», @F&@$@*4& ,(@ @H $@:\T4>FH&" *@:(@&; 2) B@("F4H\ *@:(4 8D,*4H@D"48 @$:"*",H 4" 8@H@D@, @ &2ZF8">4,; 3) D,@D(">42@&"H\ >,J*"R>Z6 $42>,F F B@42"P44 F""H4&Z, @BD,*,:4H\ B@Db*@8 :48&4*"P44 D"2@D4&T,(@Fb BD,*BD4bH4b; 4) BD,*@H&D"V"H\ 4 4FBD"&:bH\ >,R,FH>Z, *,6FH&4b F@ FH@D@>Z 8D,*4H@D@& 4:4 *@:0>48@&, 8@H@DZ, 4` BD4>P4B@& 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. 1"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 >"BD"&:,>@ >" F@2*">4, BD,*F8"2J,44 >" DZ>8,, F@2*"&"b BD,*,:Z D4F8" 8D,*4H@D"4, >,*&404>Z48@48>@&,>4b, RH@ *@:0>@ FH"H\ 2":@(@@FH4 & BD,*BD4>4,P,



FJ*Z B@@VDb`H BD,*BD4>4@FH\ H,"R": F&@, *,:@, >@ B@ BD4R4>", 2"&4FbV4,(@, D"2@D4:Fb, >"R"H\ &F, «F >J:b». % ES!, & @H:4R4, @H @(4N FHD">, BD@42&@*FH&@ B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 >@F4H *@$D@&@:\>Z6 N"D"8H,D, *DJ(44P44DJ,HFb F"48@H44 4FB@:>,>4b *@:0>48@">44 >,F@FH@bH,:\>Z"R4>",HFb B@F:, B@*"R4 *@:0>48@4b & FJ*. G"8@, BD@T,>4, @ L424R,F84Z4, @ 4 8D,*4H@D@"BD"&:,>@ >" 2"V4HJ F&@4N BD"& & @H>@T,>44 *@:0>48", J8:@>b`V,(@Fb @H JB:"HZ *@:(@&. ?*>"8@ ^H@ &,F\4, & E@,*4>,>>ZN SH"H"N, 4 $@:,, 99% &F,N *,: @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 >@FbH *@$D@&@:\>Z6 N"D"8H,D, H.,. 4>4P44DJ`HFb F"48@48, >, F@(:"F>Z6 F 2"b&:,>4,">44 ,(@ >,F@FH@bH,:\>Z, & *,:@, B@8" >, $J*JH F@$:`*,>Z @BD,*,:,>>Z, JF:@&4b 4 B@8" 8D,*4H@D >, BD,*Xb&4H *@8"2"H,:\FH&" H@(@, RH@ *@:0>48 >, B:"H4H B@ *@:(""FHJB:,>4b. )@:0>48 *@:0,> BD,*FH"&4H\ FB4F@8 4484 4 D"2>@FH4 4 &F,N 8D,*4H@D@& (4", "*D,F, D"24b @ BD42>">44 >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 "&H@48" 4 ,(@



45



F@$FH&,>>@FH4. 32 ^H@(@ BD"&4:" ,FH\ 4F8:`R,>4b, BD,*JF>Z, 7@*,8F@,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, >"BD4>Z, F J(@:@&>Z, 4b, >,&@2@ >":@0,>4, "D,FH" >" 2"D"$@H>J` B:"HJ, 42XbH4, F@$FH&,>>@FH4 B@ 2"8:"*>ZH"4, HD,$@&">46 @ &ZB:"H, $,2 B@:JR,>4b D"2D,T,>4b 42 FJ*" B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. EJ* J&,*@48 B@*": 2"b&:,>4, @ BD42>">44 ,(@ >,F@FH@bH,:\>Z4b *:b H@(@, RH@$Z 4" *@:` & F@$FH&,>>@FH4 *@:0>48". #@:,, 70% *,: @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 B@*"`HFb & B@Db*8, ':"&Z 7 7@*,8F" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. ]H" (:"&" BD,*JF>@FH4 F@$FH&,>>@FH\` *@:0>48". % H"84N F:JR"bN >"2>"R",HFb *@&,D4H,:\>Z6 F@$FH&,>>48 – F@HDJ*>48 ;4>4FH,DFH&" `FH4P44, 8@H@DZ6 @FJV,FH&:b,H >"*2@D 2" BD@&,*,>4,"2>"R",H :4P@, D"FB@Db0"`V,,Fb 4" >"R":"N *@&,D4H,:\>@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4, @$,FB,R4&"`V,, 8@>HD@:\ >"* BD"8H4R,F84 &F,6 F@$FH&,>>@FH\` *@:0>48" 2" 4F8:`R,>4," 8@H@DZ, >, @ &2ZF8">4,. ]H@ JB@:>@>@, :4P@ B,D,&@*4H &F` F@$FH&,>>@FH\ & *,>\(4 4 D"FBD,*,:b,H 4N FD,*4 8D,*4H@D@& F@(:"F>@ FB4F8J @R,D,*>@FH4, JH&,D0*,>>@"8:"*Z&",HFb @$b2">>@FH\ B@ @H&@*J >,@$@F>@&">>ZN HD,$@&">46 8D,*4H@D@&, D"FF:,*@&">4, &@2@(@ >,J*@&:,H&@D4H,:\>@(@ 4FB@:>,>4b F&@4N @$b2">>@FH,6 *@:0>48@4b ,(@ 2"b&:,>4b, D"FF4, 2"b&:,>46 @ &@2&D"V,>44 F@$FH&,>>@FH4 HD,H\4N :4P, @8"2"&T,6Fb J *@:0>48", 4:4 &@24b J$ZH8@& HD,H\4N :4P, >"BD4>4R,F8@(@ B,D,&@*" *,>,0>ZN FJ,2"*@:(@ *@ >"R":" BD@P,*JDZ $">8D@HFH&". A@ @8@>R">44 BD@P,*JDZ *@:0>48, 8"8 BD"&4:@, B@:JR",H D"2D,T,>4, >" @F&@$@0*,>4, ,(@ @H &F,N L4>">F@&ZN @$b2"H,:\FH&, &@2>48T4N *@ D"FF4b 2"b&:,>4b FJ*@4, >, &8:`R",H @F&@$@0*,>4, B@ >,8@H@DZ">F@&Z, Z», >"BD4@6 B@**,D08, 40*4&,>P,& 4:4 >":@(@@$:@0,>4`. 9`$"b 42 FH@D@>, BD,*FH"&:b`V"b F&@6 4>H,D,F & *,:,, &8:`R"b 8D,*4H@D@& 4 JBD"&:b`V,(@ 8@>8JDF>@6 4b 8"8@(@-H@ @H*,:\>@(@ *@:(" 4:4 &F,N *@:(@& B@ H"8@6, >"BD4,, 8"8 >4R,FH&@ :4P", 2"b&:b`V,(@ @ F&@,6 >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. +F:4 BD@H,FH BD4>,F,> &@&D,4,, >" 8@H@D@4, FB@D>@(@ *@:(" 4:4 &F,N *@:(@& D"2@48>JH\ 4 & Db*, *DJ(4N F:JR",&. ="BD44b &@BD@F@&: 8H@ b&:b,HFb 2"8@>>Z>@FH4, 8"8 F:,*J,H ,, D"FB@Db*4H\Fb, 8"8@&" @$V"b 2"*@:0,>>@FH\, F8@:\8@ F:,*J,H JB:"H4H\ "*&@8"H", $JN(":H,D"4FH"Z6 BD@P,FF B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 & P,:@ H"8 0,, 8"8 4 B@ (D"0*">F84>ZN FJ*"N. 1*,F\ @ $ZH\ &Z*,:4H\ H"84, FH"*44, 8"8 F$@D 4>L@DZ, F:JT">4b, B,D,(@&@DZ @ BD444 FH@D@> 4 F@$FH&,>>@ F:JT">4, *,:".



46



AD4 :48&4*"P44 BD,*BD4bH46, (*, *@:0>48">@FH4 *:b B@8DZH4b *@:(@& 7@*,8F@,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 @$ZR>@ >,*@FH"H@R>@, " H@ 4 >,H &@&F,. ($">8D@HFH&,) BD,*JF@ HD4 H4B" % H"84N F:JR"bN 2"*@:0,>>@FH\ B@ FJ*,$>@(@ BD@42&@*FH&": B@HD,$4H,:\F8@>@FH4 F:JT">4b, :4$@ BD@&,*,>4b FJ*,$>@(@ *@:0>48", 8D@" 8@H@DJ` >, 4, BD@N@*4H & @$D"V,>@ &2ZF8">4,, JBD@V,>>@H,. 1"b&:,>4b @ D"FBD,*,:,>4, &ZDJR,>>@6 BD42>">44 *@:0>48" >,F@FH@bH,:\>Z42"P44 *@:(" 4 BD4>bH4b § ID,(J:4D@&">4, *@:(@& *@:(@FD@R>@(@ B:">" ,(@ B@("T,>4b. % L424R,F8@(@ :4P" (F,@6 11 ':"&, 7@*,8F" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 B"DZ), B@2&@:b`V,, &ZB:"H4H\ B@*R,D84&",HFb, RH@ L4>">F@&@ *@:(4 BD,*BD4bH4b D"FFD@R8J, >,2"&4F44, FJ*" @ &ZB:"H, B@:JR4H\FD@8 *@ BbH4 :,H F@(:"F>@ *,H":\>@J, *@:(" $,2 >,B@FD,*FH&,>>@6 JH&,D0*,>>@>"b 13). § C,@D(">42"P4b DJ8@&@*bVJ` (:"&", BD,*JF">F@&@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4 *@:0>48" (8"8 D@:\ FJ*", @H:4R",H 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ @ BD"&4:@, `D4*4R,F8@(@ :4P") >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 & ES! @H *DJ(4N F@(:"F>@ B:">J, &ZD"$@H">>@@ F FJ*@, (*, &@2Z 8@Z, F@(:"T,>4b *@:0>48" F 8D,*4H@D"Z6 F@$FH&,>>48 >" F:JT">44 *,:" >, >"2>"R",HFb, RH@ B@2&@:b,H *@:0>48J JBD"&:bH\ BD,*BD4bH4,4b. 7@>,R>@6 P,:\` 11 ':"&Z b&:b,HFb JH&,D0*,>4, B:">" D,@D(">42"P44. ):b @FJV,FH&:,>4b >"*2@D" 2" *,bH,:\>@FH\` *@:0>48" 4 F@(:"F@&">4b B:">" D,@D(">42"P44 >"2>"R",HFb 8"8 4" 8@Z, " H"80, &ZD"$@H">>@, FH@D@>"4,, B,D,R4F:b`V,, 4N BD"&" 4 JF:@&4b 4>*4&4*J":\>@(@ FR,H", B,D,*"`HFb & FJ*. +F:4 B:"> JH&,D0*",HFb FJ*@4b BD,@$D"2@&">" & B@Db*8, 11 ':"&Z 7@*,8F": &F, *@:(4, >"8@B:,>>Z, *@ FJ*,$>@(@ F:JT">4b ">>J:4DJ`HFb, " 4N 4>Z6 B:">. +F:4 H"8@6 B:"> F@(:"F@&"H\ >, J*":@F\ 4:4 ,F:4 FH@D@>", 2"b&:b`V"b F@$FH&,>>Z6 4>H,D,F, J$,*4:" FJ* & >,BD"8H4R>@FH4 D,@D(">42"P44, FJ* 42"P44 & *,:@ @ :48&4*"P44, 8@H@D@, $J*,H D"FF@ & B@Db*8, 7 ':"&Z 7@*,8F". ':"&" 13 7@*,8F" BD,*JF>Z6 &"D4">H D,@D(">42"P44 *@:(" *:b L424R,F84N :4P, F@ND">b`V4N 4FH@R>48 *@N@*". ]H@H *@:( >, *@:0,> BD,&ZT"H\ JFH">@&:,>>J` 2"8@>@>"b (:"&" BD,*JF@FH\ &ZB:"HZ *@:(" 42 $J*JV4N *@N@*@& :4P", " >, 2" FR,H D"FBD@*"04 ,(@ F@$FH&,>>@FH4. =" BD"8H48, ^H@ @$ZR>@ @2>"R",H, RH@ &,F\ R4FHZ6 *@N@* *@:0>48" 2" B,D4@* @H HD,N *@ BbH4 :,H " B@8DZH4, *@:(@&. +F:4 FJ* F@RH,H, RH@ B:"> D"2D"$@H"> *@$D@F@&,FH>@, H@ @> JH&,D0*",H ,(@, *"0, >, &24D"b >" BD@H,FHZ 8D,*4H@D@&. ):b >"*2@D" 2" &ZB@:>,>4," >"2>"R",HFb *@&,D4H,:\>Z6 F@$FH&,>>48. )@:0>48 &ZB:"R4&",H ,>Z, B:">@48 *@$D@F@&,FH>@ @FJV,FH&:b,H BD,*JF>Z, &ZB:"HZ, @> & 8@>,R>@4, @H Db*" *DJ(4N @$b2"H,:\FH&, 2" 4F8:`R,>4,4, @H 8@H@DZN 2"BD,V,>@ 7@*,8F@8D@HFH&, 4>4P44DJ,HFb & B@Db*8, 304 A"D"(D"L", BD,*JF4, *,:" B"D"::,:\>@ F @F>@&>Z,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 4>@FHD">>@(@ :4P", BD@N@*bV4" H,DD4H@D44 ,(@



(@FJ*"DFH&". % F:JR"bN, 8@(*" >" *@:0>48" D"FBD@FHD">b,HFb 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, *,6FH&J`V,, & 4>@FHD">>@48 &:"*,,H F@$FH&,>>@FH\` >" H,DD4H@D44 ES!, BD,*FH"&4H,:\ 4>@FHD">>@(@ (@FJ*"DFH&" 4P44D@&"H\ FJ*,$>Z6 BD@P,FF & ES! & B@Db*8, 304 A"D"(D"LJ. EJ* 8@H,> @BD,*,:bH\ &@2Z, J0*,>4b, &8:`R"b F@(:"F4, >" FJ*,$>Z6 2"BD,H >" 4>4P44D@&">4, 4 BD@*@:0,>4b FJ*,$>@(@ D"2$4D"H,:\FH&" & *DJ(4N FJ*"N ES!, 8"F"`V,(@Fb :4R>@FH4 *@:0>48" :4$@ ,(@ F@$FH&,>>@FH4. EJ* H"80, @ D,":42@&"H\ 448" & B@:\2J BD,*FH"&4H,:b 4>@FHD">>@(@ (@FJ*"DFH&".



!B,::bP44

AD@4(D"&T"b FH@D@>", >, F@(:"F4&T4F\ F D,T,>4,J` FJ*,$>J` F4FH,>@, BD"&@ >" "B,::bP4`. !>":@(4R>Z>@Z D,T,>4b, BD4>bHZ, "*4FHD"H4&>Z"4H,:\>J` &:"FH\. A,D,F46 >,8@H@DZN L,*,D":\>ZN "(,>HFH&, >"BD4@4`, "R":" @FJV,FH&:,> & D"6@>>@, & "B,::bP4@>>@F8@ &BD"&, @$0":@&"H\ FJ*,$>@, D,T,>4,. % J(@:@&>@4b 2"8D,B:,>@ 2" @$&4>b,">4b ,(@ &4>@&>Z @BD"&*">, H@ FH@D@>" @$&4>,>4b >, 4,. ?*>"8@ F"">4b @$&4>b,@&>Z @$,4"FH&, F:JR",& "B,::bP44 >" D,T,>4b, BD4>bHZ, FJ*",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, Z & D"6@>>Z6 FJ*. % >,8@H@DZN @8DJ("N F@2*">" FB,P4":\>"b !B,::bP4@>>"b 7@::,(4b, FB,P4":424DJ`V"bFb 4F8:`R4H,:\>@ >" "B,::bP4bN B@ D,T,>4b,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. G"8 4:4 4>"R,, 8"0*"b FH@D@>" & F:JR", BD@4(DZT" & "B,::bP4@>>@6 4>FH">P44, F@ND">b,H BD"&@ B@*"H\ &H@D4R>J` "B,::bP4` – & "B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ*. #@:\T4>FH&@ "B,::bP46 >" D,T,>4b >ZN FJ*"N. ?*>"8@ ,F:4 FJ*\b D"FF, H@ "B,::bP44 >" ,(@ D,T,>4b D"2$4D"`HFb J0, H@:\8@ & "B,::bP4@>>@", B@*"`V"b "B,::bP4`, BD,*FH"&:b,H *@8"2"H,:\FH&" H@(@, RH@ FJ* B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 :4$@ "*4FHD"H4&>@, "(,>HFH&@, F@&,DT4:4 BD"&@&J` @T4$8J, B@&:,8TJ` >,BD"&4:\>@, &Z>,F,>4, D,T,>4b. !B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ* BD4 D"FF44 "B,::bP44 @F>@&Z&",HFb >" BD@H@8@:"N 4 BD@R4N 2"B4FbN, F*,:">>ZN &@ &D,4b *,:" B@ FJV,FH&J; @> >, 4FHD,$J,H *@B@:>4H,:\>ZN B@8"2">46 4 >, 2"F:JT4&",H F&4*,H,:,6. !B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ* ,8@H@DZ, L"8HZ B@ *,:J, JFH">@&:,>>Z, D">,,, >@ 424H\ &,D*48H &BD"&, H@:\8@, ,F:4 ^H4 L"8HZ «>,F@,>>@ @T4$@R>Z,». =, D"FF@&Z, @$FH@bH,:\FH&" B@ *,:J, FJ* "BD"&4H\ F"" *@B@:>4H,:\>@, D"FF4, & FJ* B,D&@6 4>FH">P44. C,T,>4, B@ "B,::bP4b4@. EH@D@>", B@*"&T"b "B,::bP4`, BD,*@FH"&:b,H FJ*J 8D"H8@, B4F\>@, 42:@0,>4,



*,:" F BD4&:,R,>4,H@&, F 8@H@DZ" F@$4D",HFb &ZFHJB"H\ & FJ*,. % >," BZH",HFb J$,*4H\ FJ*,6, RH@ FJ* B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 F*,:": 8"8J`-H@ @T4$8J 4 D,T,>4, *@:0>@ $ZH\ B,D,F@. )DJ("b FH@D@>" H"80, (@H@&4H 42:@0,>4, *,:", & 8@H@D@4, FJ*" BD4>bH@ BD"&4:\>@ 4:4 @T4$8" FJ*" >, b&:b,HFb *@FH"H@R>@ F,D\,2>@6 *:b B,D,F4b. #@:\T4>FH&@ *,: D"2D,T",HFb >" @F>@&, ^H4N B4F\>ZN 42:@0,>46 BJH,,F,>4b 8@D@H84N B@FH">@&:,>46 FJ*", @*>"8@ *@FH"H@R>@ R"FH@ >"2>"R"`HFb JFH>Z, &ZFHJB:,>4b 4 BD,>4b FH@D@>, ^H@ F&@,(@ D@*" *4F8JFF4b @6 8@::,(4,6 B@ BD"&@&Z, *",HFb >,8@H@D@, &D,@ @8@:@ 15 JH) *:b BD,*FH"&:,>4b F&@4N FJ0*,>46 B@ *,:J. EJ* @$ZR>@ 4, & B4F\>ZN ,>4bN. EJ*\b, BD4>444 8@::,(44, 4 >, F@(:"F>Z6 F BD4>bHZ4,>@, @F@$@, ,>4,, 8@H@D@, ,6T,":42, *,:", ,F:4 @>@ $J*,H B,D,*">@ & F:,*J`VJ` 4>FH">P4`. A@FH">@&:,>4, "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*", 8"8 BD"&4:@, b&:b,HFb B@F:,*>44,, B,D,*">@ & FJ* B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 >" >@&@, D"FF4, 4:4 ,F:4 FH@D@>Z >, BD@FbH %,DN@&>Z6 EJ* ES! B,D,F,8@H@DZN F:JR"bN D,T,>4, 8@::,(44 FJ*,6 @ B@:>Z>@(@ FJ*". EH@D@>", BD@4(D"&T"b *,:@ & "B,::bP4@>>@@Z6 EJ* ES! BD4>bH\ *,:@ 8 D"FF4`. ]H@, @*>"8@, >,



49



b&:b,HFb @$b2">>@FH\` %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*", 2" 4F8:`R,>4,,$@:\T@(@ 8@:4R,FH&" H4B@& *,:, BD,*JF>ZN FB,P4":\>Z,Z6 EJ* B@:JR",H @8@:@ 8 000 BD@T,>46 & (@* @$ 4FHD,$@&">44 *,:", >@ BD4>4@ %,DN@&>Z6 EJ* 4FHD,$J,H *,:@ :4T\ & F:JR"bN, 2"HD"(4&"`V4N 8D"6>, &"0>Z6 BD"&@&@6 "FB,8H, 4:4, ,F:4 *&" 4:4 $@:,, L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*" B@D"2>@4:4 BD"&@. +FH\ ,V, P,:Z6 Db* @$FH@bH,:\FH&, BD4 >":4R44 8@H@DZN %,DN@&>Z6 EJ* *@:0,> BD4>bH\ *,:@ 8 D"FF4` 4:4 D"FF" D,T,>4, L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*" B,D&@6 4>FH">P44. %@ &D,4b *,:" FH@D@>Z BD,*@FH"&:b`H B4F\>Z, 42:@0,>4b *,:, FJ* H"80, &ZF:JT4&",H JFH>Z, 2"b&:,>4b. 7D@Z, 4"R4H,:\>Z6 4>H,D,F 8 BD"&@&ZJHZ4b 4"R,>4, *:b *,:" F@@$D"0,>4b 4:4 4>L@D4P4"H4&, F F@(:"F4b FJ*" F"@, D"FF:,*@&">4,. % H"8@4b 4H,:\>"b GD4 @H:4R4H,:\>Z, R,DHZ &:"FH\, BD,*FH"&:,>>"b & :4P, &ZFT,(@ L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 `FH4P44 R4>@&>48" ;4>4FH,DFH&" "*4FHD"P44: (2"4FHD" `FH4P44): ,(@ § EJ*,$>"b &:"FH\ b&:b,HFb BD,*:@0,>4b 4H\ 8"8@6>4$J*\ @H*,:\>@6, >,2"&4F44, >" &:"FH4, 4@R"H,:\>@, D,T,>4,. F"@ JBD"&:bH\ %,DN@&>Z6 EJ*, 8"8 4 >40,FH@bV4, F&@,6 J8"2Z&",H BD4R4>Z FJ*Z, @$ZR>@*,bH,:\>@FH\`, >">4": 4 @B:"R4&"H\ & &4*, F&@,(@ D,T,>4b, @L@D>ZN ,>46. ;>,>4b $`*0,H. § IBD"&:,>4, FJ*,$>@6 %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" b&:b`HFb &:"FH4 &@ @(@HD":42@&">@. BD,P,*,>H@"b !FF@P4"P4b ES!. 7"8 4 & "B,::bP4@>>@6ES! D"2D"$"HZ&",H @$VJ` 4>FH">P44, FJ*\b, >, F@(:"F4&T46Fb F B@:4H48J, JH&,D0*",H $`*0,H D,T,>4,FH&", @6 &:"FH4, % H,N F:JR"bN, >"B4F"H\ @F@$@, ,>4,.BD4 ^H@b,H 8@(*" FJ*\b F@(:"F,> F BD4>bHZ4,@ >, F@(:"F,> F ,(@ B4T,H F@BJHFH&J`V,, ,>4,, F@&B"*"`V,, F B@24P4,6 $@:\T4>FH&" F@FH"&" FJ*".



K,*,D":\>"b FJ*,$>"b "*4FHD"P4b



50



>"&:4&"`H @$V4, 424b FJ*"Z, "*4FHD"H@DZ, FB,P4":4FHZ >">bHZ >" D"$@HJ FJ*\bZ H@:\8@ 4*4&4*J":\>@FH\ FJ*@&

#@:\T"b R"FH\ @H&,HFH&,>>@FH4 2" @D(">42"P4` BD"&@FJ*4b :,04H F,(@*>b >" @H*,:\>ZN FJ*"N. E@(:"F>@ 2"8@>J 4 F:@04&T4"2>"R"H\ F@$FH&,>>Z6 TH"H 4 F"@ D,T"H\ &>JHD,>>4, *,:". #@:,, H@(@, BD@(D"HD":42"P44 FJ*,$>@(@ $`*0,H", BD,*JF4, >" @H*,:\>Z, FJ*Z $`*0,H>ZN &@BD@F@& 4 "*4FHD"H4&>@6 @H&,HFH&,>>@FH4. % 8"0*@4bN *,:", >,F,H "*4FHD"H4&>J` @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ 2" @D(">42"P4` *,bH,:\>@FH4 FJ*". AD,*F,*"H,:,>@>ZN 4 "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*@&, FJ*@& B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4 *@:0>Z $ZH\ bH\ *@:0>@FH\ BD,*F,*"H,:b FJ*". ?>4 " *">>@6 *@:0>@FH4 *@ F,@ H@:\8@ *@ *@FH40,>4b F,,(@ &@2D"FH". AD,*F,*"H,:\ FJ*" b&:b,HFb B,D&Z@FH\` FJ*", BD4>4@FH4 4 @$,FB,R4&",H @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ FJ*" B,D,* >"D@*@Z6 @D(">, 4 &F, &"0>Z, D,T,>4b BD4>4@ B@* >,B@FD,*FH&,>>ZZ6 B,DF@>":

C"$@H>484 FJ*,$>@6 &,H&4 &:"FH4 >, @H>@FbHFb 8 4FB@:>4H,:\>Z", &N@*bH & L,*,D":\>J` F4FH,@6 7@>L,D,>P4,6 4 *4D,8H@D@4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" FJ*@& ES! $Z:" &ZD"$@H">" @H*,:\>"b



AD@H@8@:4FH EJ*,$>Z6 $4$:4@H,8"D\ SH"H>Z, "*&@8"HZ E@HDJ*>484 F:J0$Z B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:" )@:0>@FH>Z, :4P", @FJV,FH&:b`V4, >"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Z4b D"$@H>48"*"DH>Z, 8&":4L48"P44 *:b >,8@H@DZN *@:0>@FH,6, FB@F@$Z D"2D,T,>4b HDJ*@&ZN FB@D@& F D"$@H>48"@FH4 BD,*@FH"&:,>" 2>"R4H,:\>"b F&@$@*" & >"648@&. EJ*,$>Z6 B,DF@>": B@*R4>b,HFb >, !*4FHD"H4&>@HDJ, " >,B@FD,*FH&,>>@ FJ*\b>@(@ FJ*", 8@H@DZ, @FJV,FH&:b`H 8@>HD@:\ 2" 4N *,bH,:\>@FH\`.



7:,D8 FJ*"

A@@(@ «B,DF@>":" B":"HZ» (8:,D84, F,8D,H"D4) FJ*\b@FH4 H"80, B@484 FJ*". ':"&>Z@FH>Z4FHD"H4&>Z 2">4,`D4*4R,F8@6 D"$@H@6 FJ*" & F@@H&,HFH&44 F BD"&4:"@ R,D,2 BD,*F,*"H,:b FJ*"). ED,*4 ,(@ B@:>@@ &Z*,:4H\: § &,*,>4, JR,H" 4 @B4F4 FJ*",



A,DF@>": FJ*" A@@(@ B,DF@>":" 8"0*@(@ FJ*\4 – «B,DF@>":" B":"HZ» FJ*\4 & F&@,6 D"$@H, " F@HDJ*>48@& FJ*", & H@" F:,*J`V4N :4P: 7:,D8 (FB,P4":4FH)



52



§ JBD"&:,>4, 8@ZHD@:\ 2" $`*0,H@4, JR,H" F@$FH&,>>@FH4 4 8"DH@H,84 B,DF@>":", § JB:"H" B@T:4>, THD"L@&, D"FN@*@& 4 BD@R4N *,>,0>ZN FJ4FH,DFH&" L4>">F@&, § JBD"&:,>4, @H$@D@ZN 2"F,*"H,:,6, § @$,FB,R,>4, B,D,&@*R48"ZN FJ*,$>ZN J&,*@46 4 &Z2@&@&, § @$,FB,R,>4, B@**,D084 2":" FJ*", § @$V,>4, 4 @H&,HZ >" &@BD@FZ "*&@8"H@& 4 (D"0*">.



>"JR>@-4FF:,*@&"H,:\F8@6 D"$@H, 4 & B@*(@H@&8, BD@,8H@& ,>46. EJ*,$>Z, BD@H@8@:4FHZ @FJV,FH&:b`H B@F:@&>J` 2"B4F\ FJ*,$>ZN F:JT">46 4 (@H@&bH HD">F8D4BH. #4$:4@H,8"D4 FJ*" F@*,D0"H FJ*,$>Z, $4$:4@H,84, @$,FB,R4&"`H FJ*,6 4 `D4FH@& >,@$N@*4Z, EJ*,$>Z, E@&,HZ

EJ*,$>Z, E@&,HZ, 4@"$:`*,>4, 2" "*4FHD"H4&>@6 *,bH,:\>@FH\` FJ*@& @8DJ(". % 8"0*Z6 E@&,H &N@*bH ,(@ BD,*F,*"H,:\ 4 D"&>@, 8@:4R,FH&@ FJ*,6, BD,*FH"&:b`V4N "B,::bP4@>>Z, FJ*Z 4 FJ*Z B,D&@6 4>FH">P44. % 8"0*@4FHD"H@D, D"$@H"`V46 & H,F>@4R,FH&, F BD,*F,*"H,:,4b Db*" "*4FHD"H4&>ZN &@BD@F@& FJ*,$>@(@ @8DJ(". C"FB@:"("b T4D@84@HD@:\ >"* @(4@FH4 FJ*@&, E@&,H FH">@&4HFb ("D">H@@FH4 >"F,:,>4`. E@&,H JB@:>@ (@H@&4H\ BD48"2Z 8"8 *:b @H*,:\>@ &2bHZN FJ*,6, H"8 4 *:b &F,(@ D"$@R,(@ B,DF@>":" FJ*". ):b *@FH40,>4b ("D">H44 H@(@, RH@ FJ*Z D"$@H"`H ^LL,8H4&>@, E@&,H ,8@H@DZN "FB,8H@& *,bH,:\>@FH4 FJ*@&, >"BD4ZN, @$,FB,R,>4, BD"&@&@6 2"V4HZ >,4b,4, DJH4>>ZN *,:, Z, BD@P,FFJ":\>Z, BD"&4:" FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF". A@>@(@, E@&,H *4&4*J":\>Z4b @H8:@>4H\Fb @H FHD@(@(@ F@$:`*,>4b L,*,D":\>ZN 4>FHDJ8P46 @ 8"*D@&@,0>@": FJ*"

C"$@H>484 FJ*,$>@6 F:J0$Z B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:" 4 *@:0>@FH>Z, :4P", @FJV,FH&:b`V4, >"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Z@Z *@BD"T4&"H\ @$&4>b,@(@ 2"F,*">4b, 42JR"H\ BD@T:@, B@*@2D,&",Z, *@8:"*Z & B@@FH4 @F&@$@0*,>4b 4:4 2"*,D0">4b BD,FHJB>48@& *@ FJ*,$>@(@ F:JT">4b, B@ &@BD@F"4b BD4(@&@D@& *:b @FJ0*,>>ZN, @FJV,FH&:bH\ >"*2@D 2" @F&@$@0*,>>Zb,Z, "*&@8"HZ 4 *DJ(4, FJ*,$>Z, D"$@H>484 BD4>444. EJ*,$>Z6 E@&,H D"2D,T4H\ &@BD@F, 8@H@DZ6 ,(@ BD,*F,*"H,:\ 4:4 Z, FJ*Z >, @.



#,2@B"F>@FH4 4 @$@DJ*@&">4b #`*0,H>Z6 ;,0*J>"D@*>ZN FJ*,$>ZN @H>@T,>46 A@ "&H@,*D,>4` >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46 A@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 ($">8D@HFH&,) A@ 8@*,8FJ ZN BD4>P4B@& A@ >"*2@DJ 2" *,bH,:\>@FH\` @8DJ0>ZN EJ*,$>ZN E@&,H@& A@ P4B"@6 "*4FHD"P44 4 JBD"&:,>4` A@ J(@:@&>@4b L4>">F@&ZN BD,FHJB:,>46 E:J0$ 2"V4H>48" EJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 (2"DB:"HZ, :\(@HZ FJ*,6) EJ*,$>ZN D,FJDF@& (D,T,>4b FJ*,6 GD,H\,6 EH"H\4, 8"*D@&@, @$,FB,R,>4,) (BD4>44b 4 8"*D@&@, @$,FB,R,>4, FJ*@&), "&H@,*D,>4, >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46, 8@*,8F ZN BD4>P4B@&. ?F>@&>Z"b !FF@P4"P4b ES!

EJ*,$>"b !FF@P4"P4b, F@2*">>"b >" @F>@&">44 2"8@>" 1922 (@*", b&:b,HFb L,*,D":\>Z@4, L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&; @>" BD,*FH"&:b,H &F` FJ*,$>J` F4FH,@(@ EJ*" ES! @FJV,FH&:b,H DJ8@&@*FH&@ *,bH,:\>@FH\` *">>@(@ @D(">", & 8@H@DZ6 H"80, &N@*bH ,V, 26 FJ*,6: BD,*F,*"H,:4 &F,N "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*@&, B@ @*>@>@@(@ FJ*" B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4. ),bH,:\>@FH\ EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P44 @FJV,FH&:b,HFb ,, 8@4b @BD,*,:,>>ZN &@BD@F@&, B@*(@H@&84 D,8@*"P46 B@ Db*J H@&, 2"8@>@*"H,:\>ZN BD,*:@0,>46, 8"F"`V4NFb FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4. %F, 8@"2>"R"`HFb AD,*F,*"H,:,@(@ EJ*" 4 F@FH@bH, 8"8 BD"&4:@, 42 FJ*,6. ]H4 8@"b "*4FHD"P4b, D"FF4, *,:, J(@:@&>@, BD"&@, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&@ @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, FJ*,$>Z, D,FJDFZ



7@@6 !FF@P4"P44, D"$@H"`V4, & >"FH@bV,, &D,4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD (@$V46 8@@D*4>"H@D)



54



@$b2">>@FHb@6 !FF@P4"P44 b&:b`HFb: § JH&,D0*,>4, (@*@&@(@ $`*0,H" FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 ($`*0,H (@H@&4HFb !*4FHD"H4&>ZHD@Z@6 !FF@P4"P44); § D"2D"$@H8" BD,*:@0,>46 B@ JF@&,DT,>FH&@&">4` 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&", @$2@D 4 8@H4D@&">4, BD"&@&ZN "8H@&, 2"HD"(4&"`V4N D"$@HJ FJ*@&; § D"FBD@FHD">,>4, 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&" R,D,2 &ZBJF8 @$V,>"P4@>":\>ZN BD"&4:, 4>FHDJ8P46; § >"*2@D 4 >"BD"&:,>4, *,bH,:\>@FH4 !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" B@ H"844,, $JN(":H,D4b 4 L4>">FZ, "&H@,*D,>4, >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46, FH"H4FH48", "*4FHD"H4&>Z, F:J0$Z B@**,D084; § D"2D"$@H8" 4 8@DD,8H4D@&8" @$V4N BD"&4: BD4,>4b BD"&" 4 @FJV,FH&:,>4b FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF" & L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*"N (F @*@$D,>4b %,DN@&>Z(D,FF@4L48"P44 4 JF8@D,>4` FJ*,$>@(@ BD@42&@*FH&"; § JF4:,>4, 2>"R,>4b BD"&4: B@&,*,>4b, ^H484, FJ*,$>@6 *4FP4B:4>Z; § B@*(@H@&8" D,8@*"P46 7@>(D,FFJ B@ F@2*">4` >@&ZN FJ*@&; § BD@&,D8" >":4R4b 4b BD"&@FJ*4b.



!*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD FJ*@& ES!

!*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD @$,FB,R4&",H B@**,D08J *,bH,:\>@FH4 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& ES! & FJ*,$>@6, BD"&@&@6, JBD"&:,>R,F8@6, "*4FHD"H4&>@6 FL,D"N, " H"80, & FL,D, &>,*D,>4b >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46 4 D"2D"$@H84 >@&ZN BD@(D"4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD – ^H@ @D("> FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4, F@2*">>Z6 >" @F>@&">44 2"8@>" 1939 (@*". +(@ *,bH,:\>@FH\ 8@@D*4>4DJ,HFb EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6, R\4 JFH">@&84 b&:b`HFb @$b2"H,:\>Z,>4` !*4FHD"H4&>ZHD@4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" >"2>"R",HFb AD,*F,*"H,:,@(@ EJ*" B@F:, 8@>FJ:\H"P44 F R:,>"@6 !FF@P4"P44. )4D,8H@D b&:b,HFb *@:0>@FH>Z@FH\ 8@H@D@(@ H,F>Z" F "*4FHD"P4,6 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&, @> >"*,:,> "*4FHD"H4&>Z@>Z@DZ(D,FF". ED,*4 LJ>8P46 !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" F:,*J,H >"2&"H\: § @$,FB,R,>4, 8"*D@&@6 B@**,D084 4 8@>FJ:\H"P44 EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P44 4 ,, 8@4, 8@>FJ:\H"P46 B@ JBD"&:,>4` 4 B@**,D08, FJ*@&; § B@*(@H@&8" 4 JBD"&:,>4, $`*0,H@@6 &:"FH4; § D"FBD,*,:,>4, FD,*FH& FD,*4 FJ*@&; § BD@&,D8" @HR,H>@FH4 L4>">F@&ZN *@8JH@& FJ*@&; § JBD"&:,>4, BD@(D"4b;



55



§ @$,FB,R,>4, BD"&@&@6 F:J0$Z FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4; § F$@D 4 ">":42 *">>ZN *:b B@*(@H@&84 *@8:"*" @ *,bH,:\>@FH4 FJ*@&; § JBD"&:,>4, BD@(D",*D,>4` >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46; § BD@&,*,>4, 4FF:,*@&">46, 42JR,>4, D,2J:\H"H@& BD@(D"@&ZN *,:@&ZN @FH4 FJ*@&; § 42*">4, JR,$>@6 :4H,D"HJDZ, B@F@$46 4 H.*.; § @$,FB,R,>4, F&b24 F 2"8@>@*"H,:\>@6 4 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &,H&b4, @$V,FH&,>>@6 4>L@D@6 &:"FH4. AD4>444,, RH@ FJ*Z B@ Db*J &@BD@F@& 4@FH\ BD4>bH\ D,T,>4,, :JRT, @H&,R"`V,, 4N HD,$@&">4b@6 F4HJ"P44, )4D,8H@D & H,R,>4, >,F8@:\84N B@F:,*>4N :,H B,D,*": Db* B@:>@4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" FJ*"HD":42"P44 *",H &@2@FH\ 8"0*@"R4H,:\>@6 "&H@>@P4BZ JBD"&:,>4b & F@@H&,HFH&44 F B@Db*8"" @@bN. ]H@ >@&@&&,*,>4, J0, BD4>,F:@ B@:@04H,:\>Z, D,2J:\H"HZ 8"8 *:b F"":@(@B:"H,:\V48@&, B@F8@:\8J B@@VDb,H &&,*,>4, >@&T,FH& 4 ^8@>@@4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD @$,FB,R4&",H 4N B@*D@$>ZFHDJ8P4b4>(4, BD,*@FH"&:b,H H,N>4R,F8J` B@H@& 4 D,&424` $JN(":H,DF84N 8>4(.



K,*,D":\>Z6 EJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD

K,*,D":\>Z6 EJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD $Z: F@2*"> & 1967 (@*J 4 b&:b,HFb F,(@*>b (:"&>Z@"JR>@-4FF:,*@&"H,:\F8J` 4 @$D"2@&"H,:\>J` *,bH,:\>@FH4. AD,*F,*"H,:\ %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*" ES! &N@*4H & BD"&:,>4, O,>HD". 7D@,(@ & BD"&:,>4, H"80, &N@*bH *4D,8H@D !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" 4 F,>ZN EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6. AD"&:,>4, &Z$4D",H F&@,(@ BD,*F,*"H,:b 4 ,(@ 2"@@(@ EJ*,$>@(@ O,>HD" @ &Z*,:4H\: § BD@&,*,>4, @$D"2@&"H,:\>ZN BD@(D"ZN BD@(D"48@& FJ*", >"BD4@FH>ZN :4P, BD,*FH"&:b`V4N F:J0$J B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:" 4 @FJV,FH&:b`V4N >"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Z4, >"JR>ZN 4FF:,*@&">46 FJ*,$>@(@ BD@P,FF" >" L,*,D":\>@,, FJ*,$>@(@ JBD"&:,>4b 4 D,T,>4, *DJ(4N &@BD@F@&, 8"F"`V4NFb FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4; § 42*">4, B,R"H>ZN ZN FJ*,6 B@ Db*J H,4, $4$:4@H,84 4FHD"H4&>@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4 FJ*@&;



56



§ D"2D"$@H8" BD@(D"@6 &:"FH4 4 B@42"P4b BD@(D"J F 4>@FHD">>Z@6 F4FH,FHDJ8P44 *:b D"$@H>48@& L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&, 2">4ZHD@:\ >"* *,bH,:\>@FH\` *@:0>@FH>ZN :4P, @FJV,FH&:b`V4N >"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Z>Z">4b % 2>"8 D,8@*"P4b4` BD4(@&@D". 7@FH4HJP4@>>@(@ &,*,H 4FF:,*@&"H,:\F8J` BD@(D"4b &:"FH,6 >" BD4&:,R,>4,@6 B":"HZ 4 L,*,D":\>@, 4>L@D>@(@ P,>HD" B@ BD"8H48, 7@>(D,FF BD,*@FH"&4: &Z>,F,>4b L,*,D":\>ZN D,T,>46. % FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 B@:>@,>4` BD,*F,*"H,:\ 4 T,FH\ R:,>@&, F&@,(@ $`*0,H". >"2>"R"," T,FH4:,H>46 FD@8 AD,24*,>H@>Z, E,>"H@"R":" D"FFZZ6 $`*0,H EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P44, 2"H, B@:JR4H\ % 2>"8 BD42>">4b 8@>FH4HJP4@>>@(@ @*@$D,>4, F"4b &:"FH,6 >" L,*,D":\>@, 7@>(D,FF BD,*@FH"&4: FJ*,$>@6 B@F:, R,(@ B,D,*",HFb & &:"FH4 B@:>@(D,FF F B@*D@$>Z4,@ 2"8@>J AD,24*,>H >, 4@F4H\ 42,>4b & BD@,8H $`*0,H" FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4. &ZB@:>,>4` F&@,(@ $`*0,H". !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD BD@&@*4H 8@>FJ:\H"P44 F FJ*"Z@6 !FF@P4"P44 4 (@H@&4H (@*@&@6 BD@,8H $`*0,H", 8@H@DZ6 @F>@&"> BD,0*, &F,(@ F



57



JR,H@ZN FJ*@&. AD@,8H BD,*JF4, FD,*FH& *:b B@**,D084 8"*D@& 4 "*4FHD"H4&>ZN F:J0$ 8"0*@(@ FJ*". % >,ZN 8@">F4D@&">44 >@&ZN 4:4 D"FT4Db`V4NFb *,6FH&J`V4N BD@(D">Z6 BD@,8H F>"R":" D"FF@4b >"BD"&:b,HFb >,B@FD,*FH&,>>@ & 7@>(D,FF &Z,>4b8H"J AD,24*,>H BD48:"*Z&",H BD@,8H $`*0,H" FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 8 @$V,,F,>4b & >,(@ 8"84N-:4$@ 42,>46 4:4 *@B@:>,>46. 7@@&">4b(D,FF" ES! BD@&@*4H F:JT">4,, >" 8@H@D@>Z6 BD@,8H $`*0,H". % F:JT">44 BD4>44FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD", 8@H@D@6 8@H4DJ,H 2":@0,>>Z, & $`*0,H D"FN@*>Z, FH"H\4. A@F:, JH&,D0*,>4b 7@>(D,FF@@6 &:"FH4 3FB@:>4H,:\>Z6 7@@6 !FF@P4"P44 D"2D"$"HZ&",H B:"> D"FBD,*,:,>4b *,>,0>ZN FD,*FH&, " !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD D"FBD,*,:b,H FD,*FH&" 8"0*@J F4FH," 4FB@:>,>4, 8@>8D,H>ZN BD@(D"@6 &:"FH4. )4D,8H@D !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" B,D,*": Db* JFH">@&:,>>ZN 2"8@>@@ZN FJ*@& ,FH\ &@2@FH\ JFH">"&:4&"H\ $`*0,H>Z, BD4@D4H,HZ, BD4>44b, 8"F"`V4,Fb *,bH,:\>@FH4 FJ*", >">4":, BD@&@*4H\ 2"8JB84, ,F:4 ^H4 D"FN@*Z @BD"&*">Z *,bH,:\>@FH\` FJ*" 4 >, BD,&ZT"`H JFH">@&:,>>ZN D"@6 &:"FH4 &8:`R"`HFb H"80, 4 2"D"$@H>Z, B:"HZ FJ*,6 4 FJ*,$>@(@ B,DF@>":". ?$ZR>@ @>4 & FJ" &ZB:"HJ "D,>*>@6 B:"HZ 4 8@":\>ZN JF:J( 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4. ?FH"&T4,Fb 20% HD"HbHFb >" 8@@, @$,FB,R,>4,, 8@*4D@&84, F>"$0,>4,, @$,FB,R,>4, $,2@B"F>@FH4 FJ*,6, 8@F"P44 "*&@8"H"48"ZN.



1*">4b FJ*". ED,*FH&" @$F:J04&">4b. ?$,FB,R,>4, $,2@B"F>@FH4

K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z D"FB@:@0,>Z & $@:,,, R,4bN B@ &F,6 !"*:,04H (@FJ*"DFH&J 4 F*",HFb FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4. 7"8 4 $@:\T4>FH&@ *DJ(4N L,*,D":\>ZN @D(">@&, @D(">Z FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4 >, @ D,T"H\ &@BD@F @ 2*">4bN *:b F@$FH&,>>ZN >J0*. ]H" @$b2">>@FH\ @H>,F,>" 2"8@>@P44 !*4FHD"P44 @$V4N F:J0$ (GSA) – @D(">J 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4. %ZFHJB"b & 8"R,FH&, "D,>*@*"H,:b *:b @D(">@& FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,4FHD"P4b @$V4N F:J0$ JB@:>@" @$,FB,R4&"H\ 4N @$V,FH&,>>Z*@&">>Z4bH4D@&"H\ @BD,*,:,>>Z6 JD@&,>\ JF:J( BD4 D"244 & >4N @D(">@& FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD F@HDJ*>4R",H F !*4FHD"P4,6 @$V4N F:J0$ B@ &@BD@F"4b FJ*@&, BD,*@FH"&:,>4b 446 *:b 2":@& 2"F,*">4b 4 B":"H FJ*,6. % 1984 (@*Z EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6 $Z:4 JH&,D0*,>Z FBD"&@R>48 4 Db* *DJ(4N *@8JH@&, D"F8DZ&"`V4N FN,4b FJ*@&. % ^H@48, B,D,R4F:,>Z HD,$@&">4b 8 "DN4H,8H@D"46 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&, *42"6>,D"4FHD"P4b @$V4N F:J0$ BD4>b:" ^H@H FBD"&@R>48 & 8"R,FH&, F&@,(@ *@8JH", D,(:"H4DJ`V,(@ JF:@&4b FHD@4H,:\FH&", B:">4D@&84, @H*,:84 2*">46 L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& 4 H,F>Z4R",H F !*4FHD"H4&>ZHD@>Z4FH,DFH&" `FH4P44, @$,FB,R4&",H $,2@B"F>@FH\ FJ*,6 &>, 2"&4F4"N@0*,>4b. % F:JR", J(D@2Z 042>4 FJ*\4 :4$@ R:,>" @$,FB,R4H\ ,(@ 2"V4HJ *@ JFHD">,>4b &@2@FH4 @FJV,FH&:,>4b J(D@2Z. E:J0$@6 ;"DT":@& @$,FB,R4&",HFb $,2@B"F>@FH\ 2*">46 FJ*" 4 2":@& 2"F,*">4b, 8@H@D"b @FJV,FH&:b,HFb *&J@, H,F>@ F@HDJ*>4R"`H F R:,>"48"Z46 4 Z4H,:\>Z"4b $,2@B"F>@FH4 FJ*,6 4 FJ*,$>ZN B@46. %@-&H@DZN, ;"DT": @6 &:"FH4 *:b >"6ZN @ND">>ZN "(,>HFH& 4 B@@FH4 FJ*@& & 4N B@&F,*>,&>@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4 & @$,FB,R,>44 $,2@B"F>@FH4.



3>L@D>Z, H,N>@:@(44 4 FJ*,$>"b &:"FH\

="R4>"b F 1975 (@*", 8@(*" & L,*,D":\>@4, 4>L@D>ZN H,N>@:@(46 2>"R4H,:\>@ J&,:4R4:@F\. A@*(@H@&8" ,>46 4 D,T,>46 F,(@*>b @FJV,FH&:b,HFb 4F8:`R4H,:\>@ & H,8FH@&ZN D,*"8H@D"N - 8@ZN



BD@(D"44 4FF:,*@&">46 FJ*Z B@:\2J`HFb @>:"6>@&Z4` &@ &F,N FJ*"N F,(@*>b "&H@. )@8:"*Z @ :4R>@FH4 4 @$FH@bH,:\FH&"N 042>4 B@*FJ*444 FJ*,$>@(@ F:,*FH&4b (@H@&bHFb F B@ZN 8@ZN BD@(D",>4, BD@(D"@(@ @$,FB,R,>4b JBD@V",H F$@D *">>ZN, BD@&,*,>4, FH"H4FH4R,F84N 4FF:,*@&">46. !&H@>Z, F4FH,,@P,>4@":\>@44 F&@4*"Z *DJ( F *DJ(@"P4@>":\>@6 F,H\` *">>ZN. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD 4 K,*,D":\>Z6 EJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD BD,*@FH"&:b`H @$V,FH&,>>@FH4 4>L@DH,D>,H". !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD H"80, 4FB@:\2J,H &>JHD,>>`` F4FH,HD">,H) *:b BJ$:48"P46, B@F@$46, *J,6 4 BD@R,6 *@8JH"P44 *:b FJ*,6 4 D"$@H>48@& FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,,*D,>4b 4>L@D>ZN H,N>@:@(46 & L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*"N @FJV,FH&:b,HFb >" @F>@&, *@:(@FD@R>@(@ B:">", & 8@H@DZ6 ,0,(@*>@ &>@FbHFb 42,>4b 4 *@B@:>,>4b >" @F>@&, B@0,:">46 FJ*@& 4 8@H@DZ6 B@*:,04H JH&,D0*,>4` EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6 B@F:, @*@$D,>4b ,(@ 7@,*D,>4` H,N>@:@(46. K4>">F4D@&">4, &>,*D,>4b >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46 @FJV,FH&:b,HFb >" @F>@&, *">>@(@ B:">". % *@B@:>,>4, 8 ^H@484 FJ*" H"80, ,*D,>4, >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46 8"8 B@ @$V4"BD"&:,>4bH4,6 H@(@, RH@ BD@(D"@, @$,FB,R,>4,, 444 @D(">@& FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4, @H&,R",H HD,$@&">4bJ0*"ZN FJ*@&.



EHD"H,(4R,F8@, B:">4D@&">4, 4 BD@*J8H4&>@FH\ JBD"&:,>4b & L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*"N

% B@F:,*>4, (@*Z FHD"H,(4R,F8@, B:">4D@&">4, 4 BD@*J8H4&>@FH\ JBD"&:,>4b FH":4 8D"6>, &"0>Z,>44 "&H@>@,2"&4F4@6 &:"FH4. 3 N@Hb J L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& >, H"8 @(@ &@2@FH,6 JBD"&:bH\ @$X,4 J0, FH@:8>J:4F\ F BD@$:,4b @$X,,N&"H84 *,>,0>ZN D,FJDF@&. % 1995 (@*J FJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6 $Z: @*@$D,> B,D&Z6 &F,FH@D@>>46 *@:(@FD@R>Z6 B:"> D"2&4H4b L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&. % D"" 2"HD"(4&",HFb &,F\@FH4, &8:`R"b *,H":\>Z, D,8@*"P44 B@ &@BD@F"Z,, BD@P,FFJ":\>Z, 4 JBD"&:,>R,F84, &@BD@FZ L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&. ?H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ 2" FHD"H,(4R,F8@, B:">4D@&">4, 4 D,":42"P4` D,8@*"P46, F@*,D0"V4NFb & B:">,, &@2:"(",HFb >" 8@@6 !FF@P4"P44, @H&,HFH&,>>Z, 2" @H*,:\>Z, &4*Z *,bH,:\>@FH4. EJ*,$>"b F4FH,@FH,6 J&,:4R,>4b 4 J:JRT,>4b D"$@H@FB@F@$>@FH4 FJ*", " H"80, F*,D04&">4b D"FN@*@& >" ,(@ F@*,D0">4,. K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*\4 >"*,:,>Z ("D">H4b,>4b D"$@HZ, ("D">H4b@6 >,2"&4F4bH44 D,T,>46. ?*>"8@ FJ*\4 4 F:J0"V4, FJ*" >,FJH @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ B,D,* @$V,FH&@,>4, F&@4N @$b2">>@FH,6 F F@$:`*,>4,@D@FH\ 4FB@:\2@&">4b



*,>,0>ZN FD,*FH& 4 F@$FH&,>>@FH4, L@D":@(@B:"H,:\V48@&. %@BD@FZ, F&b2">>Z, F >,B@*@$"`V44,4,Z@ D"2D,T"`HFb BD,*F,*"H,:,"8@ BD,*JFZ 4 >,8@H@DZ, *DJ(4, 42>Z, ("D">H4D@&"H\ @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ FJ*,6 4 FJ*,$>@(@ B,DF@>":".



60



?H&,HFH&,>>@FH\

)4FP4B:4>"D>Z, 42 & *,b>44, >">@FbV,@, FBD"&:b,HFb F@ F&@4>@FHb>@6 >,FB@F@$>@FH4, >Z6 FJ* @8DJ(", & 8@H@D@>Z6 FJ*\b. AD,*F,*"H,:\ "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*" 4H\ 0":@$J, ,F:4 BD,*FH"&:,>>Z, & >,6 @$&4>,>4b >, F@@H>@FbHFb F @BD,*,:,>4,bH46 «&,FH4 F,$b >,B@*@$"`V4,HDJ*@FB@F@$>@FH\»; ,F:4 @$&4>,>4b FFZ:"`HFb >" 8@>8D,H>Z, @$FH@bH,:\FH&" D"FF>@(@ FJ*\,6 *,:" 4:4 ,F:4 @$&4>,>4, >,F,D\,2>@. AD,*F,*"H,:\ FJ*" 44H\ 0":@$J 4 & H@bHZ 4` @B:@T>@FH,6 4:4 ,F:4 BD@Z, *,6FH&4b 4:4 F@$ZH4b *,:"`H *":\>,6T,, D"FF4, &@BD@F" $,FF>Z46 @H8:@>b,HFb. +F:4 0, FJ*\b >, @H8:@>b,H 2"b&:,>4,, H@ @> *@:0,> F@$D"H\ FB,P4":\>J` 8@4b BD,*Xb&:,>>ZN @$&4>,>46 4 B@*(@H@&84 B4F\>@(@ @HR,H" 4 D,8@*"P46 EJ*,$>@4b @HR,H" 8@"2>"R4H\ *":\>,6T,, D"FF:,*@&">4, @$&4>,>46 4:4 BD4>bH\ @*>@ 42 F:,*J`V4N D,T,>46: § BD,*:@04H\ FJ*\, *@$D@&@:\>@ B@*"H\ & @HFH"&8J; § BD42>"H\ >,HDJ*@FB@F@$>@FH\ FJ*\4 (4 H"84F4` >" 2"4, *@:0>@FH4 FJ*\4); § *"H\ J8"2">4, >, *@BJF8"H\ FJ*\` 8 D"FF4` *,: &



61



H,R,>4, @BD,*,:,>>@(@ B,D4@*" &D,4; § @$Xb&4H\ &Z(@&@D (@$V,FH&,>>Z6 4:4 R"FH>Z6); § BD4>bH\ *DJ(@, D,T,>4, & D">@FH4. +F:4 E@&,H JFH">@&4H, RH@ FJ*\b GD,H\,6 EH"H\4 &@&:,R,> & J(@:@&>@>"8"2J,@FH\ 4:4 RH@ 0":@$" >, " E@&,H@ *@:0,> B,D,>"BD"&4H\ *,:@ & EJ*,$>J` !FF@P4"P4` ES!. !FF@P4"P4b &BD"&, R,D,2 (@:@F@&">4, B,D,*"H\ *,:@ & 7@>(D,FF *:b &@2@(@ BD@&,*,>4b BD@P,*JDZ 4H" 4 @HFHD">,>4b @H *@:0>@FH4. =" BD"8H48, 4H 4 @HFHD">,>4, @H *@:0>@FH4 – b&:,>4b &,F\@ BD4b,"> &4>@&>Z44 Hb08@(@ BD,FHJB:,>4b. EJ*,$>Z6 B,DF@>": >, &N@*4H & F4FH," >,(@ >, D"FBD@FHD">b`HFb H"84, FJD@&Z, FB@F@$Z @HFHD">,>4b @H *@:0>@FH4 F BD4&:,R,>4,@& &:"FH4. ?*>"8@ & 8"0*@4b HDJ*@&ZN FB@D@&, 8@H@D"b 2"V4V",H F:J0"V4N 4 @$,FB,R4&",H *@:0>@, D"2$4D"H,:\FH&@ 4 &@24, JV,D$". AD,*F,*"H,:\ FJ*", 8"8 BD"&4:@, 444 FB@D@& F F:J0"V4@ D"$@H>484 &BD"&, B@*"H\ "B,::bP4` >" D,T,>4, FJ*" & EJ*,$>Z6 E@&,H @8DJ(". 9`$@, *,:@, B@ 8@H@D@"&:4&",HFb, RH@ BD"&@>"DJT,>4,, BD,F:,*J,Z@*"H,:\FH&@@ :4$@ FJ*\,6, :4$@ F:J0"V4"BD"&:b,HFb >,B@FD,*FH&,>>@ & ;4>4FH,DFH&@ `FH4P44 *:b &@2@(@ J(@:@&>@(@ D"FF:,*@&">4b.



AD@R4, @L4P4":\>Z, 42"b !FF@P4"P4b, BD4>4@6 &:"FH4, JFH">"&:4&",H R,H84, BD,*,:Z HD"H >" BD4@$D,H,>4, 8"8@6-:4$@ F@$FH&,>>@FH4, :4$@ &ZB@:>,>4, BD@(D"@ BD"&@ D"FB@Db0"H\Fb F&@4, &ZN@*b BD4 ^H@FHDJ8P46, BD4>bHZN EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6, 4 BD@R4N 2"8@>@& 4 BD"&4:, D,(:"H4DJ`V4N 4FB@:\2@&">4, *,>,0>ZN FD,*FH&, BD4@$D,H,>4, 4 ^8FB:J"H"P4` F@$FH&,>>@FH4. A@ &@BD@F"4b BD,*F,*"H,:\ :`$@(@ FJ*", *,6FH&Jb @H 44 &F,N FJ*,6, >,F,H @H&,HFH&,>>@FH\ 2" @FJV,FH&:,>4, 8@>HD@:b >"* FJ*,$>Z"* *,bH,:\>@FH\` F:J0"V4N FJ*", @> @H&,R",H 2" H@, RH@ *,>,0>Z, L@>*Z D"FN@*J`HFb @$@F>@&">>@, ^LL,8H4&>@ 4 & F@@H&,HFH&44 F 2"8@>@4FHD"H4&>Z, HDJ*>@FH4 4 BD4 >,@$N@*44` ^H4N &@BD@F@&. )4D,8H@D !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD", @FJV,FH&:b`V46 F&@` *,bH,:\>@FH\ B@* >"*2@D@@6 !FF@P4"P44, 4Z4FHD"H4&>Z"BD"&4H\ ,, & FJ*, ,F:4 ,@ @ BD,&ZT,>44 D"FN@*@& FJ*", BD,*JF>ZN 4>FHDJ8P4b"DJT,>44 BD"&4: BD@P,FF" 4 BD4,>4b BD"&". )4D,8H@D "BD"&:bH\ F&@4 2"4b & EJ*,$>Z6 E@&,H @8DJ(" *:b BD4>bH4b 44b. EJ*,$>Z6 E@&,H @8DJ(" @FJV,FH&:b,H @$V46 8@>HD@:\ >"* "*4FHD"H4&>Z bH\ >,@$N@*44FHD"H4&>Z, 4:4 JBD"&:,>R,F84, 4FHD"H4&>Z6 FJ* B,D4@*4R,F84 BD@&@*4H BD@&,D8J *@8JH@& B@ @HR,H>@FH4 &F,N FJ*@& 4 B@ &F,Z4` @> " FJ:\H"P44 B@ JBD"&:,>4`. % *@B@:>,>4, 8 ^H@"b $JN(":H,D4b, L4>">F@&"b DJ8" 7@>(D,FF", JB@:>@" BD@&@*4H\ @$VJ` BD@&,D8J FJ*,$>ZN @B,D"P46. E"(D,FF & @BD,*,:,>>ZN F:JR"bN 4b 4:4 2"BD@F4H\ >,@$N@*4L@D>ZN FJ*,$>ZN @B,D"P4bN: & ,(@ @$b2">>@FH4 &N@*4H @BD,*,:,>4, "FF4(>@&">46 >" J*@&:,H&@D,>4, B@HD,$>@FH,6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,4, >,@$N@*4,>46 & *,6FH&J`V," "B,::bP4b, " &F, D,T,>4b L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*,6 D"FBD@FHD">b`HFb R,D,2 FD,*FH&" L@DH,D>,H FD,*4 "*&@8"H@& 4 @$V,FH&". ?>4 B@*&,D("`HFb ">":42J BD"&@&,*@& 4 "8"*,48@&. 1"R"FHJ` F@FH"&:b,HFb >,@L4P4":\>Z6 «D,6H4>(» FJ*,6 >" @F>@&">44 @BD@F@& D"$@H>48@& "*&@8"HJDZ 4 `D4*4R,F84N 42*">46. ="8@>,P, D@:\ FD,*FH& L@D, \T,>". ?F@$,>>@ F,6R"F, & ^B@NJ «F:,*@&"H,:\F8@(@» 0JD>":42@ HV"H,:\>@6 BD@&,D8, 4 8D4H48,.



=,@L4P4":\>Z, 42Z, FJ*\4 4 B,DF@>": FJ*@& 4FBZHZ&"`H @(D@@, RJ&FH&@ :4R>@6 4 8@::,8H4&>@6 (@D*@FH4 2" L,*,D":\>J` FJ*,$>J` F4FH,@(@ FJ*". K,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* 2"F:J04: &ZF@8J` D,BJH"P4` 2" ^LL,8H4&>@FH\ 4 @H:4R>J` D"$@HJ, 4 FJ*\4 &,JFZB>@ B@**,D04&"`H 4 J8D,B:b`H ,,. 7 BD4Z,>4, 8@:4R,FH&" D"$@HZ. A@ 2"8@>J FJ*\4 JB@:>@Z F@&@ D"FBD,*,:bH\ FJ*,$>Z, *,:", D,T"H\, (*, 2"F,*",H FJ*\b, 4 @BD,*,:bH\ BD@P,FFJ":\>Z6 B@Db*@8. )">>Z, B@ @$X,@ *,:bHFb FD,*4 8@::,(, " !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD BJ$:48J,H >,8@H@DZ, &"0>Z, *">>Z, @ D"$@H, @H*,:\>ZN FJ*,6. % *@B@:>,>4, 8 ^H@" BD"8H4R,F84 &F, FJ*,$>Z, D,T,>4b @ZN FJ*"N



@FH"&:bH\ >,8@H@DZ, B@T:4>Z & F@$FH&,>>@, D"FB@Db0,>4,. ]H@ 8"F",HFb, >"BD4Z 2" *@FHJB 8 FJ*,$>ZH,D>,H.



7"8 >"R4>",HFb J(@:@&>Z6 BD@P,FF?

K424R,F84, :4P" >, ,>4b & J(@:@&>ZN BD,FHJB:,>4bN & L,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z. I(@:@&>Z6 BD@P,FF >"R4>",HFb 4F8:`R4H,:\>@ B@ 4>4P4"H4&, BD"&4H,:\FH&" – @$ZR>@ R,D,2 F:J0$J L,*,D":\>@(@ BD@8JD@D" B@ F@(:"F@&">4` F BD"&@@ND">4H,:\>Z"" "D,FH @$&4>b,"R":" F:,*FH&4b B@ *,:J 4 B4F\>ZN B@8"2">46 B@* BD4Fb(@6 F&4*,H,:,6, *">>ZN L,*,D":\>@6 BD@8JD"HJD, 4:4 BD"&@@ND">4H,:\>Z"4b *"`H @F>@&">4, B@:"("H\, RH@ BD,FHJB:,>4, $Z:@ F@&,DT,>@ 4 RH@ F $@:\T@6 FH,B,>\` &,D@bH>@FH4 @ BD,*B@:@04H\, RH@ @>@ $Z:@ F@&,DT,>@ @$&4>b,4b, , BD,*Xb&4H F@&, @$&4>,>4,.



7"8 >"R4>",HFb (D"0*">F846 BD@P,FF? IFH">@&:,>" :4 2" ^H@ B:"H"?

'D"0*">F846 BD@P,FF >"R4>",HFb F H" B@*"R4 0":@$Z (4F8@&@(@ 2"b&:,>4b). EH@D@>", B@ R\,6 4>4P4"H4&, >"R4>",HFb BD@P,FF, *@:0>" 2"B:"H4H\ B@T:4>J & D"2>@@, 4@FH4 @B:"H4H\ &2>@F, 44 *,:" in forma pauperis, H.,. $,2 JB:"HZ B@T:4>Z. +F:4 FJ* J*@&:,H&@Db,H N@*"H"6FH&@, @B:"H" >, HD,$J,HFb. EJ*,$>Z, B@T:4>Z F@FH"&:b`H :4T\ >,$@:\TJ` R"FH\ FJ*,$>@(@ $`*0,H". #@:\T"b R"FH\ B@T:4> B,D,&@*4HFb >" FR,H L,*,D":\>@(@ 8"2>"R,6FH&". 7@>(D,FF H,, ,, BD,*@FH"&4: FJ*"@ >"R"H\ *,:@ @ 2"V4H, @H $">8D@HFH&"? IFH">@&:,>Z :4 2" ^H@ 8"84,-H@ B@T:4>Z?

),:@ @ BD42>">44 *@:0>48" >,F@FH@bH,:\>Z"R4>",HFb F B@*"R4 2"b&:,>4b & FJ* B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. A@T:4>" 2" B@*"RJ 2"b&:,>4b @6 & 2"&4F4,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 B@*",HFb 2"b&:,>4,. ':"&" 7 7@*,8F", >" @F>@&">44 8@H@D@6 B@*",HFb



64



$@:\T4>FH&@ 2"b&:,>46 L424R,F84N :4P, BD,*JF48", D"&>@ 8"8 4 FB4F">4, ,(@ *@:(".



F,DH4L48"P4`. +(@ JF:J(4 @B:"R4&"`HFb BD"&4H,:\FH&@F8@"N@*4H F,$, 2"V4H>48"?

;,FH>Z, 8@::,(44 "*&@8"H@& @$ZR>@ BD,*:"("`H `D4*4R,F84, JF:J(4 4 B,D,*"RJ *,:" >" D"FF4, FJ*@@(@ 8:,D8" (FB,P4":4FH") @$ZR>@ "6H4 2"V4H>48". =@ F:J0"V4, FJ*" >, @8"2Z&"`H `D4*4R,F84, 8@>FJ:\H"P44 FH@D@>"b,ZN BD,FHJB:,>4bN ,FH\ 8@>FH4HJP4@>>@, BD"&@ >" 2"V4H>48", BD4R,4 4" 2"V4H>48", BD,*@FH"&:,>>@(@ 2" FR,H 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4, ,F:4 >, @ @B:"H4H\ BD@L,FF4@>":\>@(@ BD,*FH"&4H,:b. !8H @$ J(@:@&>@@, B@FH">@&:,>4, @ H@Z6 4" "*&@8"H", >"2>"R,>>@(@ FJ*@F8@Z B@ @$V," 2"V4H>48", >@ J >4N >,H BD"&" >" $,FB:"H>@(@ (@FJ*"DFH&,>>@(@ "*&@8"H". =,8@H@DZ"6H4 $,FB:"H>@(@ 4:4 &,F\,*@D@(@(@ 2"V4H>48" R,D,2 8@::,(4` 4:4 "*&@8"H", 8@H@DZ6 B,D4@*4R,F84 BD,*FH"&:b,H 4>H,D,FZ 8:4,>H" $,FB:"H>@, 4:4 R,D,2 `D4*4R,F8J` F:J0$J. EH@D@>Z 48" 4 BD,*FH"&:bH\ F&@4 4>H,D,FZ & FJ*, F"@.



7"844, *,: 4, *,: @@ & $@:\T4>FH&, FJ*@& BD@4FN@*4H >"J("*, @ @*4>"8@&@, 8@:4R,FH&@ *,: 8 D"FF4`.



7H@ H"8@6 @FH>Z, :4P", BD,*FH"&:b`V4, FJ*,$>J` &:"FH\, >"2>"R",FH">P44 >" &@F\46 FD@8. 3N @$b2">>@FH4 @ &Z*,:4H\ & R,HZD, @F>@&>ZN 8"H,(@D44: 1) BD@42&@*FH&@ *@FJ*,$>@6 FH"*44 B@ BD"8H4R,F84 &F,@ BD,F:,*J,4b" @$ZF8 4 "D,FH, 2"*,D0">4, BD,FHJB>48", BD@&,*,>4, 42JR,>4b *@FH"H@R>ZN @F>@&">46 *:b @$&4>,>4b 4 >"2>"R,>4, 2"V4H>48"; 2) BD@42&@*FH&@ B@ $@:\T4>FH&J FJ*,$>@>"8"2J,>ZN FH">P44, >"BD44, B,H4P46 2"8:`R,>>ZN, BD@&,*,>4, *@FJ*,$>ZN F:JT">46 4 B,D,(@&@D@& @ BD444 FH@D@>; 4) BD@42&@*FH&@ B@ (D"0*">F84.



?$,FB,R4&"`HFb :4 FH@D@>Z, >, &:"*,`V4, ">(:46F84b,@44 @$,FB,R4&",HFb B,D,&@*R48@@ J2>"H\ BD"&@&@6 FH"HJF *,:"?



65



7:,D8 @H&,H4H >" &F, &@BD@FZ, 8"F"`V4,Fb FH"HJF" *,:" F@&,DT,>>@ $,FB:"H>@. ?*>"8@ BD4 >,@$N@*44b 8"84N-H@ 4FF:,*@&">46 4:4 B@:JR,>4b @BD,*,:,>>@6 4>L@D44 *@8JH@& FH&, L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& BD@&,FH4 4FF:,*@&">4, 4:4 >"6H4 >J0>J` 4>L@D@ J FB,P4":\>ZN FH@,8, ^H@H 0, B@4F8 @ BD@&,FH4 4 R,D,2 4>H,D>,H 42 :`$@(@ @(4N "B,::bP4@>>ZN FJ*"N 4 FJ*"N B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 4>L@D@ B@:JR4H\ F B@", B@**,D04&"`V,(@ H@>@&Z6 >"$@D. EB4F@8 *,: 8 F:JT">4`, &ZB4F8" D,T,>46 FJ*", " H"80, ,>4b *@FHJB>Z 4 R,D,2 4>H,D>,H. ?L4P4":\>Z6 F"6H L,*,D":\>@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,"N@*4HFb B@ "*D,FJ: www. uscourts.gov, >" >,Z FFZ:84 >" F"6HZ FJ*@&, " H"80, J8"2"H,:\ >" FJ*,$>Z, ^:,8HD@>>Z, F:J0$Z.



2"b&:,>4b *@ BD4>bH4b D,T,>4b B@ FJV,FH&J B@ (D"0*">F84ZN FJ*"N BD@N@*4H &@F,@FH4 *,:" ^H@H FD@8 \T,. C"2D,T,>4, *,:" , @(4, 42 >4N >, 2"&4FbH @H FJ*", " @ &&4*J BD@&@*444 FH@D@> 4:4 & F4:J >,N&"H84 FJ*,6 4 FJ*,$>ZN B@46.



7"8 JFHD@4H\Fb >" D"$@HJ & L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ*?

EJ*,$>"b !FF@P4"P4b F@&@ F !*4FHD"H4&>ZHD@"&:4&",H @$V4, HD,$@&">4b 4 D"48@& FJ*". C,T,>4b @ BD4," D"$@HJ BD4>4@. 7"0*Z6 FJ* F"F4`, BD@&@*4H @H$@D 4 >">4" D"$@HJ. EJ*\4 4@ L@D":. 7:,D8 4 Db* *DJ(4N *@:0>@FH>ZN :4P BD4>4" D"$@HJ >, 8,bHZ >" D"$@HJ B@ D,T,>4` 8:,D8", *,6FH&J`V,(@ @H 44 4 B@* 8@>HD@:,F44 @ >"6H4 >" @L4P4":\>@@6 FJ*,$>@6 F4FH,@ B@:>Z6 FB4F@8 &"8">F46 P,:,F@@$D"2>,, B@:JR4H\ J 8:,D8" FJ*" 4:4 R,D,2 F"6H @H*,:\>@ &2bH@(@ FJ*". =" L,*,D":\>J` FJ*,$>J` &:"FH\ D"FBD@FHD">b`HFb @$V,(@FJ*"DFH&,>>Z, BD"&4:" @ D"&>ZN &@2@FHbN &F,N :4P 4 @$ @HFJHFH&44 *4F8D4"P44 BD4 BD4," D"$@HJ.



7"8 $ZFHD@ D"FF@ @04*"H\ D,T,>4b FJ*"?

%F, *,:" D"FF@ 4 F @ &@2@6 F8@D@FH\`. !8H @ $,2@H:"("H,:\>@@4b *,:" 4 BD4>bH4b D,T,>4b B@ FJV,FH&J *:b D"6@>>ZN FJ*@&. % D,2J:\H"H, FJ* &Z>J0*,> @H*"&"H\ BD,*B@RH,>4, J(@:@&>ZF84,. E@(:"F>@ !8HJ @H H" "D,FH" @$&4>b,"R":" FJ*,$>@(@ F:JT">4b ,6. A@*@$>ZN FD@8@& *:b (D"0*">F84N *,: >, JFH">@&:,>@, >@ & P,:@, BD,&ZT"`V46 @*4> (@*. % FD,*>,H" B@*"R4



66



=,8@H@DZ, `D4*4R,F84, H,DZ:

!:\H,D>"H4&>@, D"2D,T,>4, FB@D": ;,H@*Z D"2D,T,>4b &@2>48T,(@ FB@D" $,2 BD@&,*,>4b FJ*", &8:`R"b B@FD,*>4R,FH&@ 4 HD,H,6F846 FJ*. !B,::bP4b: AD@T,>4, @ B,D,F4b FJ*" B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 4 @BD,*,:,>4b ,(@ BD"&@HZ, B@*"&",@6 & FJ* F:,*J`V,6 4>FH">P44 ("B,::bP4@>>Z6 FJ*). !LL4*^&4H: A4F\>Z, B@8"2">4b B@ *,:J B@* BD4Fb(@6, BD,*@FH"&:b`HFb H@:\8@ JB@:>@>@@FH\: ?HBD"&:,>4, BD"&@FJ*4b >" @F>@&, FBD"&,*:4&@FH4, BD"&@ FBD"&,*:4&@FH4; BD"&@FJ*4, >" @F>@&, BD"&" FBD"&,*:4&@FH4 – F4FH,@*"H,:\>ZN "8H@&, FJV,FH&J`V"b >" Db*J F @$ZR>Z@*"H,:\>Z,F@@H&,HFH&4b *DJ( *DJ(J. #@:\T@, 0`D4: ?D(">, &8:`R"`V46 16-23 (D"0*">4>", 2"F:JT4&"`V46 @$&4>,>4b, B@*(@H@&:,>>Z, FH@D@>@6 @$&4>,>4b (BD@8JD@D@@ :4 @F>@&">46 *:b BD,*Xb&:,>4b @L4P4":\>@(@ @$&4>,>4b 4 BD@&,*,>4b FJ*,$>@(@ 2"F,*">4b. E4H,:\>Z6 "8H». %,D*48H: D,T,>4, 8@::,(44 BD4Fb0>ZN (4:4 FJ*\4 BD4 @HFJHFH&44 BD4Fb0>ZN) @$@ @H>@T,>44 @$&4>b,>@4`, BD42>">4, ,(@ &4>@&>@FH4 4:4 >,&4>@&>@FH4.



%@2&D"V,>4, & B,D&@>"R":\>J` 4>FH">P4`: D,T,>4, "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*" B,D,*"H\ *,:@ & FJ* >40,FH@bV,6 4>FH">P44 *:b BD@&,*,>4b *@B@:>4H,:\>ZN D"FF:,*@&">46 4 >@&@(@ FJ*,$>@(@ F:JT">4b. %DJR,>4, FJ*,$>@(@ *@8JH": %Z2@& & FJ* B@&,FH8@6, *@FH"&8" *@8JH@& *DJ(@6 FH@D@>, 4 BD@R46 @$ B4F\>@6 J&,*@@6 4>L@D"8"2">4b 4:4 THD"L" & F:JR", >,b&84, &Z*"&",, B@ *,:J 4:4 F&4*,H,:bF8@, BD"&@>"DJT,>4,, JV,"DJT,>4b FH&@ H"84N *,: D"FF4,J` F@$FH&,>>@FH\ (>"BD4" &@,>>ZN $"2"N), B@ 8@H@DZ@(@ (D"0*">FH&" FH@D@>. ),:@: 1"B4F\ &F,N H"P4b & @*>@Z6 F@$FH&,>>48: % *,:"N @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 :4P@, D"FB@Db0"`V,,Fb 4" >"R":"N *@&,D4H,:\>@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4. % ,(@ @$b2">>@FH4 >@FH4, JBD"&:,>4, *,:@BD@42&@*FH&@48", @ND">" ,(@ 44, FD,*FH& >@FH4 @H >,2"8@>>ZN *,6FH&46 F@ FH@D@>Z 8D,*4H@D@& 4 *@:0>48". ;4>4FH,DFH&@ `FH4P44 >"2>"R",H & 8"0*Z6 FJ*,$>Z6 D"6@> F&@,(@ BD,*FH"&4H,:b *:b @FJV,FH&:,>4b 4@"*2@DJ 2" BD@42&@*FH&@,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. % @$b2">>@FH4 ^H@(@ :4P" &N@*bH >"2>"R,>4, *@&,D4H,:\>ZN F@$FH&,>>48@& B@ 8"0*@4, 4FF:,*@&">46 *:b @$,FB,R,>4b ("D">H46 F@$:`*,>4b 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&" @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4.



1"b&:,>4, @$&4>b,@">4, 4:4 >,BD42>">4, &4>Z @$&4>b,FHDJ8P4b B@ &Z>,F,>4` BD4(@&@D": ="$@D BD"&4: 4 BD4>P4B@&, JFH">@&:,>>ZN 7@"b 8 4FB@:\2@&">4` FJ*\b44 "8"2">4b. 3H: 1) AD@P,FF @FB"D4&">4b F&4*,H,:\F84N B@8"2">46. +F:4 "*&@8"H 4b F&4*,H,:b >, F@@H&,HFH&J`H *,6FH&4H,:\>@FH4 4 FL"$D48@&">Z, @> HJ *">>@4` ,(@ B@8"2">46; 2) 8@>FH4HJP4@>>Z6 BD@P,FF @HFHD">,>4b &ZF@8@B@FH"&:,>>ZN R4>@&>48@& 2" *@:0>@FH>Z, BD,FHJB:,>4b A":"H@6 AD,*FH"&4H,:,6 4 B,D,*"R" *,:" >" @8@>R"H,:\>@, D"FF4, & E,>"H. 3FH,P: 94P@, B@*"`V,, 4F8@&@, 2"b&:,>4, & FJ*. 7:,D8 FJ*": )@:0>@FH>@, :4P@, D"$@H"`V,, & FJ*,, 8@H@D@, @D(">42J,H D"$@HJ FJ*", JBD"&:b,H B@H@8@>@FH\ FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46, 2">4">F@&Z4FHD"H4&>J` B@@ D"FFZN: 'DJBB" (D"0*">, JB@:>@>"b 2"F:JT4&"H\ B@8"2">4b FH@D@>, F&4*,H,:\F84, B@8"2">4b 4 D"2D,T"H\ L"8HZ & FB@D,. % L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*"N F@FH@4H 42 12 R:,>@& BD4 D"FF44 J(@:@&>@(@ *,:" 4, 8"8 4@& BD4 D"FF44 (D"0*">F8@(@ FB@D". EHD"8H): E@(:"T,>4, "4N @BD,*,:,>>Z, @$b2"H,:\FH&". )@8:"* B@ *,:J: )@8:"* B@ *,:J B,D,* &Z>,F,>4,>Z6 *@:0>@FH>Z"*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>Zb,,F,>4b BD"&4:\>@(@ D,T,>4b. )@:0>48: EH@D@>" & BD@P,FF, @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 ($">8D@HFH&,). )@FJ*,$>@, 2"F,*">4,: 1"F,*">4, FJ*" F JR"FH4,, >" 8@H@D@>Z, *@8"2"H,:\FH&" FH@D@>, B@Db*@8 4N BD,*FH"&:,>4b & FJ*,, B@Db*@8 &Z2@&" F&4*,H,:,6 4 D"2D"$"HZ&",HFb B:"> FJ*,$>@(@ 2"F,*">4b. ?$ZR>@ >" *@FJ*,$>@44 D"FF@FH4 BD44b FH@D@>. /":@$": 3F8@&@, 2"b&:,>4,, B@*"&",F8@(@ BD@P,FF", & 8@H@D@" >,BD"&@Z, *,6FH&4b, F@&,DT,>>Z,, B@ ,(@ J$,0*,>4`, @H&,HR48@>J` 8@F"P4`.



68



H"80, «AD4Fb0>Z6» 4 «#@:\T@, 0`D4». ;,FH@ D"FF4b *,:": EJ*,$>Z6 D"6@> 4:4 @8DJ(, & 8@H@D@@ F:JT"H\Fb *,:@, @BD,*,:b,@6 B@*FJ*>@FH4, B@*FJ*>@FH4 B@ 4b *,6FH&4b. ;4D@&@6 FJ*\b (@FH>@, :4P@, *,6FH&J`V,, & D">@(@ FJ*", @H&,HFH&,>>@, 2" BD@42&@*FH&@ B@ *,:J >" B,D&ZN FH"*4bN, BD4>44b B@ >,Hb0844bZ, 4 4 B@ B@DJR,>4` FJ*", D"2D,T",H (D"0*">F84, FB@DZ BD4 F@(:"F44 >" ^H@ FH@D@>. ;4F*4@D: I(@:@&>@>"8"2J,4b FD,*>,6 Hb0,FH4, >"8"2">4, 2" 8@H@DZ, >, BD,&ZT",H @*>@(@ (@*" :4T,>4b F&@$@*Z. ;>,>4,: A4F\>@, @$XbF>,>4, FJ*\4 B@ B@&@*J &Z>,F,>>@(@ 44b. A@F8@:\8J & "B,::bP4@>>@,>4, @ B@D"2>@@(:"F>@44 @*4> 42 FJ*,6 F@FH"&:b,H @$V,, ,>4,. +F:4 FJ*\4 >, BD4T:4 8 @$V,6 H@R8, 2D,>4b, H@ D,T,>4, $J*,H BD4>bH@ >" @F>@&, ,>4b $@:\T4>FH&". =,F@(:"F4&T46Fb FJ*\b ,>4,, BD,*FH"&:b`V,, ,(@ B@24P4` B@ *">>@@ $ZH\ @$@F>@&">@: FJ*\b P4BZ BD"&" $Z:4 4FH@:8@&">Z $@:\T4>FH&@,BD"&4:\>@. %@2" F4HJ"P4b, 8@(*" FJ*\b F@(:"F,> F &Z>,F,>>Z4,@ >, F@(:"F,> F ,(@ H@@&4HFb :4T\ D,T,>4, $@:\T4>FH&". EH». ="N@0*,>4, *@8JH@& 4 *@8"2"H,:\FH&: EH"*4b BD@P,FF", >" 8@H@D@6 F@$4D"`HFb *@8"2"H,:\FH&", 8@H@DZ, 44 HD,$@&">46 H@6 4:4 4>@6 FH@D@>Z, "*&@8"HZ FH@D@> (@H@&bHFb 8 FJ*,$>Z4bZ" ^H@6 FH"*44 b&:b`HFb: B@8"2">4b F&4*,H,:,6, *@BD@FZ, 42XbH4, *@8JH@&, BD@&,*,>4, @$ZF8@&. ]H4 H"P4` 8 FJ*,$>Z4b"R4H,:\>@, BD"&@>"DJT,>4,: AD"&@>"DJT,>4b, >"8"2">4, 2" 8@H@DZ, >, @(@ 2"8:`R,>4b. =,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH\ ($">8D@HFH&@): _D4*4R,F846 BD@P,FF, (*, L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* B@ *,:",F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 D,T",H &@BD@F F&@,6 4F8:`R4H,:\>@6 8@P44 L424R,F84, 4 `D4*4R,F84, :4P", 8@H@DZ, >, & F@FH@b>44 B:"H4H\ B@ *@:("42@&"H\ 4N *@:(4 4 @$b2"H,:\FH&". A@ D,T,>4` FJ*" *@:( B@:>@FH\` :4$@ R"FH4R>@. 1"F,*">4, BD@&@*4HFb FJ*\b8D@HFH&" (>,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4). ?$&4>4H,:\>Z6 "8H: ?L4P4":\>@, @$&4>,>4,, &Z*"&",>ZN FH@D@>@6 @$&4>,>4b *@8"2"H,:\FH& *@FH"H@R>@ *:b H@(@, RH@$Z B@:"("H\, RH@ BD,FHJB:,>4, $Z:@ F@&,DT,>@ B@*@2D,&",@ 4FB@:\2J,HFb



69



BD4 @$&4>,>44 & Hb084N BD,FHJB:,>4bN. ?$&4>b,Z6): 94P@, 8 8@H@D@Z @$&4>,>4b & F@&,DT,>44 J(@:@&>@BD,F:,*J,46. ?$V,, BD"&@: E4FH,48T"b & !>(:44 4 *@ F4N B@D BD4b,@&Z&"`V"bFb >" H@:8@&">44 >@DZ4bbHZ,,. AD4>P4BZ BD"&" bH\Fb 2"8@>@*"H,:\>@, @*>"8@ @>4 *@:0>Z $ZH\ B@*&,D(>JHZ H@:8@&">4` FJ*@@(4, FL,DZ BD"&" (8"8, >"BD4,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4) F,(@*>b 8@*4L4P4D@&">Z, >@ ^H4 8@*,8FZ 4 2"8@>Z BD4b`HFb & F@@H&,HFH&44 F 4N B@F:,*J`V44,4,: EJ*,$>@, D,T,>4,, @$Xb&:b`V,,, RH@ &4>" @$&4>b,, *@8"2">" «&>, &Fb8@(@ F@,>4b», *DJ(4,&4>@&>@FH4. A@BD"&8" V 8 7@>FH4HJP44 ES! 2"BD,V",H *&"0*Z BD4&:,8"H\ :4P@ 8 J(@:@&>@6 @H&,HFH&,>>@FH4 2" @*>@ 4 H@ 0, BD,FHJB:,>4,. ?FJ0*,>4,: AD42>">4, @$&4>b,@&>Z44 BD,FHJB:,>4b.



">>J:4DJ`V,, &Z>,F,>>@, FJ*@FH">P44 D,T,>4,; @$ZR>@ F@BD@&@0*",HFb B,D,*"R,6 & >40,FH@bV46 FJ* >" >@&@, D"FF:,*@&">4, 4 D"FF4,. A":"H": 7"$4>,H FJ*\4, & 8@H@D@Z6 B,DF@>": – «B,DF@>": B":"HZ». A4F\>@, 42:@0,>4, *,:": 7D"H8@, B4F\>@, 42:@0,>4, *,:" F BD4&:,R,>4,H@&, F 8@H@DZ" &ZFHJB",H & FJ*,. % 2"b&:,>44 @$@F>@&Z&",HFb, B@R," FR4H",H, RH@ FJ* *@:0,> D"2D,T4H\ H@H 4:4 4>@6 &@BD@F & ,, B@:\2J. A4F\>Z6 @BD@F FH@D@> 4 F&4*,H,:,6: %@BD@FZ, D"FFZ:",@6 FH@D@>@6 *:b *DJ(@6, " H"80, F&4*,H,:bL@D"R":" FJ*,$>@(@ F:JT">4b B@ (D"0*">F8@@ @H&,H4H\, ^H4 B@8"2">4b BD4D"&>4&"`HFb 8 B@8"2">4b>Z4b: ?$XbF>,>4b F&4*,H,:,6, F@@$V,>4, 4L@D@T,>4, & *,:J, B,D,* BD4Fb0>Z4b B@* BD4Fb(@6: A@8"2">4b, BD,*@FH"&:b,@>Z4b 8 *,:J & 8"R,FH&, &@2ZN *@8"2"H,:\FH&. ;@(JH $ZH\ 4FB@:\2@&">Z & FJ*,, *:b *@BD@F" F&4*,H,:,6 4 &Zb&:,>4b *@8"2"H,:\FH&. A@8"2">4b F RJ04N F:@&: )@8"2"H,:\FH&", @F>@&">>Z, >" F:JN"N; JH&,D0*,>4b F&4*,H,:b @ L"8H"N, 8@H@DZ, @> >, &4*,: :4R>@, >@ F:ZT": @ >4N, :4$@ 2>",H @$ ^H4N L"8H"N 42 B,D,F8"2@& HD,H\4N :4P. ?$ZR>@ >,



?H&,HR48: 94P@, 8 8@H@D@244 & D"F8@(@ BD@P,FF". ?H2Z&: A4F\>@, 2"b&:,>4, @H&,HR48", BD,*FH"&:b`V,, @H&,H >" 4F8@&@, 2"b&:,>4, F @$@F>@&">4," FJ*,$>@(@ D,T,>4b: A@FH">@&:,>4, "B,::bP4@>>@(@ FJ*",



70



*@BJF8",HFb & 8"R,FH&, *@8"2"H,:\FH&, B@F8@:\8J FR4H",HFb, RH@ @>4 >, b&:b`HFb >"*,0>Z@ @H ^H@(@ BD"&4:" R"FH@ @HFHJB"`H. AD,*4b. AD,*B4F">4,: FJ*,$>Z6 BD48"2, @$b2Z&"`V46 8@(@-:4$@ 8 &ZB@:>,>4` 8"8@(@-:4$@ *,6FH&4b (BD,*B4F">4,, B@&,FH8"). AD,*F,*"H,:\ FJ*": EJ*\b, @FJV,FH&:b`V46 DJ8@&@*FH&@ *,bH,:\>@FH\` 4 "*4FHD"P4,6 FJ*", @$ZR>@ >"2>"R",H: EJ*,$>@, D,T,>4,, BD4>bH@, B@ D"FF>@,, *,:J, L"8HZ 4 FJH\ FB@D" & 8@H@D@H4R>Z *,:J, D"FF"FH@bV,, &D,bbF\ @$V,H". ?>4 4FB@:\2J`H BD4>P4BZ, JFH">@&:,>>Z, D">,, *:b D"2D,T,>4b >@&ZN *,: F@ FN@*>Z, JR4HZ&"H\ BD,P,*,>H, ,F:4 $J*,H *@8"2">@, RH@ H@ D,T,>4, $Z:@ &Z>,F,>@ >,BD"&4:\>@ 4:4 ,F:4 $J*,H JFH">@&:,>@, RH@ *,:" B@ F&@,6 FJH4 >,F@B@FH"&442T,6 4>FH">P44 @$b2">Z B@*R4>bH\Fb D,T,>4bFH">P44. AD,P,*,>H>@, BD"&@: AD"&@, >@D,, BD4>bHZN FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46. AD4&:,R,>4, 8 FJ*J: EH"*4b J(@:@&>@(@ BD@P,FF", >" 8@H@D@6 B@*@2D,&",,>4,, *,:@ B,D,*",HFb >" D"FF4, & FJ*, @$&4>b,,>46, B@F:, R,(@ @> BD42>",H :4$@ >, BD42>",H F,$b &4>@&>Z4, @$ @H8"2, @FB"D4&"H\ BD,*Xb&:,>>@, @$&4>,>4, – nolo contendere («b >, 0,:"` @FB"D4&"H\»). AD4(@&@D: ;,D" >"8"2">4b, BD,*B4F">>"b FJ*@>@4b BD,FHJB:,>4b. AD48"2 @$ 4FHD,$@&">44 *,:": A@FH">@&:,>4, FJ*" @ BD4>bH44 8 F&@,4` *,:" 42 >40,FH@bV,(@ FJ*". AD4Fb0>Z,: 'DJBB" (D"0*">, @H$4D",4b B@8"2">46 & N@*, FJ*,$>@(@ 2"F,*">4b, JB@:>@>"b BD4>4R"H,:\>Z6 &,D*48H. E4H,:\>J` &:"FH\ 4 JB@:>@>@, BD,*FH"&:bH\ 4>H,D,FZ (@FJ*"DFH&" BD4 @$&4>,>44 8@(@-:4$@ & J(@:@&>@>"8"2J,44. AD@H@8@:: )@8JH, &8:`R"`V46 &F, 2"b&:,>4b, N@*"H"6FH&", *@8"2"H,:\FH&", BD,*FH"&:,>>Z, 4 D"FF>Z, FJ*@@(@ D"2$4D"H,:\FH&".



AD@H@8@:4FH: 94P@, @FJV,FH&:b`V,, B@F:@&>J` 2"B4F\ &F,(@ F8"2">>@(@ & FJ*,$>@44, @$ZR>@ F 4FB@:\2@&">4,@(D"L4R,F8@6 H,N>484 4:4 "J*4@2"B4F,6. ]H" 2"B4F\ " B@ HD,$@&">4`. AD@P,FF: AD"&4:" D"2D,T,>4b FB@D" 4 BD@&,*,>4b Hb0$Z. %Z*,:b`H BD@P,FFJ":\>Z, >@DF8@@>@,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4. AD@P,FFJ":\>Z, >@DZN FJ*@&, &8:`R"`V4, BD"&4:" 4FF:,*@&">4b *@8"2"H,:\FH&, BD"&4:" D"FF4b (D"0*">F84N, J(@:@&>ZN, "B,::bP4@>>ZN *,:, *,: @ >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, @$b2"H,:\>ZN *:b 4FB@:>,>4b L,*,D":\>Z44H,:\>Z, BD"&4:" FJ*@BD@42&@*FH&". C,@D(">42"P4b: AD@P,FF, BD,*JF>Z6 11 ':"&@6 7@*,8F" @ #">8D@HFH&,, BD,*JF">F@&@ >,FH"$4:\>@(@ BD,*BD4bH4b. AD,*BD4bH4,, 4>4P44DJ`V,, BD@42&@*FH&@ @ F@$FH&,>>@6 >,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4, BD@*@:0",H D"$@H"H\, FJ* 4b 4" D,@D(">42"P44. A@F:, JH&,D0*,>4b B:">" D,@D(">42"P44 FH"DZ, @$b2"H,:\FH&" 8@44 ">>J:4DJ`HFb, & F4:J &FHJB"`H @$b2"H,:\FH&", BD,*JF>Z, BD4>bHZ@4,: A@FH">@&:,>4, FJ*", D"2D,T"`V,, FB@D "@6 B@ *,:J, *:b *"R4 B@8"2">46 B,D,* BD4Fb0>Z4b 42&,FH>@6 ,L@D4b: 3>L@D44 L"8H@& 4 *:b J$,0*,>4b BD4Fb0>ZN (FJ*") & >,@$N@*44b *,:" & B@:\2J H@6 4:4 4>@6 FH@D@>Z. K,*,D":\>Z, FJ*Z *@:0>Z F:,*@&"H\ L,*,D":\>Z46. E@(:"T,>4, FH@D@>: EB@F@$ D"2D,T,>4b FB@D" "@(@ F:JT">4b. E@(:"T,>4, R"FH@ BD,*JFF"P44 @*>@6 FH@D@>Z *DJ(@6 & D"2,@$b2"H,:\>@ F@@H&,HFH&J`V,>@4b4`: EB4F@8 *,:, B,D,*">>ZN >" D"FF4, FJ*J F J8"2">4,@6 4FH@D44 8"0*@(@ *,:", B@*D@$>Z>ZN *,6FH&46 & D"ZN FJ*"N F@*,D0"HFb & ^:,8HD@>>@6 L@D@ *@FHJB>Z T4D@8@6 @$V,FH&,>>@FH4 R,D,2 8@, BD4>bHZ6 7@>(D,FF@@*"H,:\>Z@": Gb0JV46Fb. % FJ*"N B,D&@6 4>FH">P44 D"2:4R"`H 4FHP" 4 @H&,HR48" (@$&4>,>4, 4 @$&4>b,>@6 4>FH">P44 – :4P@, B@*"`V,, "B,::bP4`, 4 :4P@, @H&,R"`V,, B@ "B,::bP44.



72



EJ*: ?D(">, 2"8@>@*"H,:\>@ JB@:>@>Z6 D"2D,T"H\ BD"&@&Z, FB@DZ. 3>@(*" FJ*\4 (@&@DbH @ F,$, & HD,H\,4,"BD44b FH@D@>. EJ* $,2 JR"FH4b BD4Fb0>ZN (FJ* F8"" 8@H@D@@ BD4N@*4HFb D"2D,T"H\ 8@>L:48H ""b F:J0$" B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:": F:J0$", *,6FH&J`V"b & D">@(@ FJ*", @H&,HFH&,>>"b 2" 42JR,>4, BD@T:@(@ @$&4>b,@FH4 @F&@$@0*,>44 B@*@2D,&",4b FJ*,$>@(@ F:JT">4b. ]H@6 0, F:J0$@6 "*2@D 2" JF:@&>@ @FJ0*,>>ZZ6 2"BD,H: 1"BD,H4H,:\>"b >@Db,4` 8"8@(@-H@ *,6FH&4b. EJ*,$>Z6 BD@P,FF: ),6FH&4b FJ*" B@ D"FF4` *,:", >"R4>"`V,,Fb B@F:, B@*"R4 4FHP@4b B@ @$&4>,>4` @H&,HR48" & >,4FB@:>,>44 @$b2">>@FH4, B@&:,8T,6 @HD4P"H,:\>Z, B@F:,*FH&4b *:b 4FHP". EJ*\b: )@:0>@FH>@, :4P@, JB@:>@>@, D"2D,T"H\



BD"&@&Z, FB@DZ & JFH">@&:,>>@@"R"H\ &F,N FJ*,6, &8:`R"b FJ*,6 %,DN@&>@(@ EJ*", L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*,6 4 FJ*,6 TH"H", &@,>>ZN FJ*,6, " H"80, JB@:>@>ZN BD,*FH"&4H,:,6 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &:"FH4, 4>Z, BD"&@&Z, FB@DZ. EJ*\b B@ "*4FHD"H4&>Z"DJT,>4b@FH>@, :4P@, BD,*FH"&:b`V,, (@FJ*"DFH&,>>@, "(,>HFH&@ (@D(">), JB@:>@>@, D"2D,T"H\ &@2>48T46 FB@D F@(:"F>@ 2"8@>@*"H,:\FH&J 4 &>JHD,>>4HFH&". C,T,>4, FJ*\4 @ & FJ*"N GD,H\,6 EH"H\4. EJ@, FJ*@BD@42&@*FH&@: IBD@V,>>@, FJ*@BD@42&@*FH&@; BD@42&@*FH&@, BD4 8@H@D@Z >, @FB"D4&"`H L"8HZ, " :4T\ BD@FbH FJ* @ &Z>,F,>44 D,T,>4b. GD">F8D4BH: A@F:@&>"b 2"B4F\ &F,(@ F8"2">>@(@ &@ &D,@(@ 2"F,*">4b, *"R4 B@8"2">46 B@* BD4Fb(@6 4 BD@R4N @L4P4":\>ZN 4, 8@>L:48H". EH@D@>Z & BD@P,FF, ,V, >"2Z&"`H Hb0JV44b: )@FH"H@R>@ F,D\,2>Z, BD,FHJB:,>4b, BD,*JF4, F&@$@*Z >" FD@8 >, ,, @*>@(@ (@*".



73



IF:@&>@, @F&@$@0*,>4,: !:\H,D>"H4&" D,T,>4` @ :4T,>44 BD,FHJB>48" F&@$@*Z, ,(@ @F&@$@0*,>4, @H H`D,@(@ 2"8:`R,>4b, 8"8 BD"&4:@, >" B@DJ84 4 B@* >"*2@D FB,P4":\>@6 F:J0$Z. IFH>@, &ZFHJB:,>4,: C,R\ 2"V4H>48", @HD"0"`V"b ,(@ B@24P4` B@ *,:J B,D,* FJ*@" 2"*"&","b 8@P4b: 7@P4b L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@& D"FF4, 4 BD4,>4, 7@>FH4HJP44, "8H@& 7@>(D,FF", *@(@&@D@&. K,*,D":\>Z6 ;"DT":: )@:0>@FH>@, :4P@, >"2>"R",H@Z6 D"6@> *:b @$,FB,R,>4b $,2@B"F>@FH4 FJ*,6, BD@8JD@D@& 4 BD@R4N :4P, D"$@H"`V4N & F4FH,FB@DH4D@&8J 2"8:`R,>>ZN, BD4>44` FJ*,$>ZN D,T,>46. K,*,D":\>Z6 @$V,FH&,>>Z6 2"V4H>48: !*&@8"H, D"$@H"`V46 >" B@:>J` FH"&8J & L,*,D":\>@H,D,FZ @$&4>b,, 48". EJ* >"2>"R",H 2"V4H>48" & F@@H&,HFH&44 F !8H@@Z6 BD@8JD@D: AD@8JD@D, >"2>"R",H@Z6 D"6@>, BD,*FH"&:b,H (@FJ*"DFH&,>>@(@ @$&4>4H,:b 4:4 2"V4H>48" B@ *,:"@(@ BD@8JD@D" ,FH\ F&@6 TH"H 2"48@& B@ 8@>8D,H>ZZ6 FJ* B@ &@BD@F""D@*>@6 H@D(@&:4: EJ*, BD,*JF>Z6 III EH"H\,6 7@>FH4HJP44 4 F@2*">>Z6 7@>(D,FF@4b *,:, 8"F"`V4NFb "D@*>@(@ H@D(@&@(@ BD"&", &8:`R"b H"D4LZ, D"FP,>84, *,(, 8@F"P4@>>Z, B@T:4>Z 4 &@BD@FZ "D@*>@6 4>H,::,8HJ":\>@6 F@$FH&,>>@FH4. M@*"H"6FH&@: A@*"&",4, D,T4H\ &@BD@F, F&b2">>Z6 F D"FFP4b FJ*" BD4>44`; 2) H,DD4H@D4":\>"b B@*FJ*>@FH\. En banc (LD.): % B@:>@@F4HFb 8 2"F,*">4bZ, "B,::bP4@>>Z, FJ*Z @$ZR>@ 2"F,*"`H 8@::,(4,6 B@ HD@,, >@ @BD,*,:,>>Z, &@BD@FZ @>4 @4, @ BD,*FH"&:,>44 "D,FH@&">>@(@ & FJ* (@F@$,>>@ *:b D"FF4b 2"8@>>@FH4 "D,FH"). !D,FH@&">>@, B@ D,T,>4` FJ*" TH"H" :4P@



74



4, & L,*,D":\>Z6 FJ* 4 B@BD@F4H\ ,(@ BD@&,D4H\, >, $Z:4 :4 >"DJT,>Z ,(@ BD"&", BD,*JF>Z, 7@>FH4HJP4,6. !D,FH@&">>Z, B@ D,T,>4` L,*,D":\>@(@ FJ*" H"80, 44b "D,FH@&">>@(@ & FJ* @6: *"R" B@8"2">46, BD,*Xb&:,>4, >@&ZN @$&4>,>46. In forma pauperis (:"H.): ?F&@$@0*,>4, 4FHP" @H JB:"HZ B@T:4> B@ BD4R4>, ,(@ $,*>@FH4. Pro se (:"H.): ? :4P,, BD,*FH"&:b`V,H,D,FZ F"@, $,2 BD4&:,R,>4b BD@L,FF4@>":\>@(@ 2"V4H>48". Voir-dire (LD.): «(@&@D4H\ BD"&*J»: *@BD@F FJ*@@(@ >" BD,*,>4b ,(@ $,FBD4FHD"FH>@FH4 4 >,BD,*J$,0*,>>@FH4.



?$ !*4FHD"H4&>@HD, FJ*@& ES!



3FH@R>484 *@B@:>4H,:\>@6 4>L@DZ, F"6HZ:

%,DN@&>Z6 EJ* ES! www. supremecourtus.gov



!*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD FJ*@& ES! www. uscourts.gov K,*,D":\>Z6 EJ*,$>Z6 O,>HD www. fjc.gov



)">>@, 42*">4, $Z:@ D"2D"$@H">@ 7@Z4FHD"H4&>@HD, FJ*@& ES!. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD $Z: F@2*"> & 1939 (@*J >" @F>@&">44 D,T,>4b 7@>(D,FF", @> 2">4"P4,6 D"$@HZ L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&. )4D,8H@D O,>HD" >"2>"R",HFb AD,*F,*"H,:,@(@ EJ*" B@ F@(:"F@&">4` F EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P4,6. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD 2">44,@6 !FF@P4"P44, ,, 8@4FJ:\H"P44. ?> BD@&@*4H @P,>8J *,6FH&46 @D(">@& FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4, *",H 2"8:`R,>4b B@ >@&Z\ B@:4H48J EJ*,$>@6 !FF@P4"P44. !*4FHD"H4&>Z6 O,>HD D"2D"$"HZ&",H BD@(D"@FH4 FJ*,$>ZN @D(">@&. +(@ *,bH,:\>@FH\ &,F\4FHD"H4&>Z,, BD"&@&Z,, H,N>4R,F84,, 8@48"P4@>>Z, 4 BD@R4, "FB,8HZ, @8"2Z&"`V4, F@*,6FH&4, L,*,D":\>Z>Z>Z,F@FH@bH,:\>@FH4 4 @$,FB,R4&"`V4, F@$:`*,>4, BD"& @$&4>b,"BD"&:b`VJ` *,bH,:\>@FH\ F:J0$Z B@ @FJV,FH&:,>4` >"*2@D" 2" JF:@&>@



76



@FJ0*,>>Z4` >,@$N@*4"R":" F:JT">4b *,:". ED,*4 LJ>8P46 !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" ES! @ >"2&"H\ D"2D"$@H8J $`*0,H" FJ*,$>@6 &:"FH4, BD@&,*,>4, D,&4244 $JN(":H,DF84N 8>4(, *@8JH@& 4 @HR,H>@FH4 &F,N L,*,D":\>ZN FJ*@&, 8@@D*4>4D@&">4, 8"*D@&ZN &@BD@F@&, F$@D 4 ">":42 FH"H4FH4R,F84N *">>ZN *:b B@*(@H@&84 @HR,H" @ B@:@0,>44 FJ*@&, BD,H&@D,>4, BD@(D",*D,>4` >@&ZN H,N>@:@(46, D"2D"$@H8" >@&ZN @FH4 FJ*@&, 42*">4, JR,$>ZN B@F@$46, BD"&4:, 4>FHDJ8P46 4 BD@R,6 :4H,D"HJDZ, F@HDJ*>4R,FH&@ F 2"8@>@*"H,:\>@6 4 4FB@:>4H,:\>@6 &,H&b4, 4>L@D>@FH4. )4D,8H@D !*4FHD"H4&>@(@ O,>HD" ES! B,D,*": @(4, 42 F&@4N B@:>@>ZN 2"8@>@" 42@&Z&"H\ 4 JBD"&:bH\ F&@,6 *,bH,:\>@FH\`, $`*0,H@>Z, BD"&4:" 4 JFH">@&:,>>Z, @(D">4R,>4b. ]H@ *@:0>@ FB@F@$FH&@&"H\ :JRT,4` 4>*4&4*J":\>ZN B@HD,$>@FH,6 FJ*". ),P,>HD":42"P4b "*4FHD"H4&>@6 &:"FH4 B@:@04H,:\>@ @HD"24:"F\ >" FJ*,$>@6 *,bH,:\>@FH4, &Z2&":" @*@$D,>4, >":@(@B:"H,:\V48@&, H.8. @>" FB@F@$FH&J,H F@8D"V,>4` $`D@8D"H44 4 B@@VDb,H >@&@&&,*,>4b 4 ^8@>@4H,:\>Z@ @$D"H4H\Fb B@ "*D,FJ: Administrative Office of the US Courts Thurgood Marshall Federal Judiciary Building One Columbus Circle, N.E. Washington, D.C. 20544 G,:.: 202-502-1860 K"8F: 202-502-1888