Plaintiff's Statement of material facts in Support of the Motion for Summary Judgment by cocoselul

VIEWS: 9 PAGES: 5

More Info
									Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 1 of 5
                                                                      LE y        c.
                                                                     FI D b P #' o.
                                                                                01
                                                                        DEC 1! 2 1          '
                                                                               ! .' :
                                                                                   , MORE
                                                                       STEVEK M 1'RI$
                                                                              / . tl CT.
                                                                              'f )
                                                                       CLFRit S..ST.
                                                                         : ''1L ' A. A
                                                                         k .1 'f
                                                                        6 f,. bL VM I M I
                                                                            .- .
                                                                        w -

                       N      J TED STA TES DI
                      I TH E I NI                 CT
                                              STRI CO URT FO R
                                               CT
                         THE SO UTHERN DISTRI OF FLORI  DA

                                 : ZOIZO- V- TZ/ M ONTON
                         CASE NO. 1I-   CI SEI SI


     TRAG N BUJDW EAN U,
      ai if
     Pl ntf,

     VS.

    olsM A s cl    r Es x         spE
               txm 'I ,I c ,ANA Gl RT,
    DEREK THOM AS AND LASHANDA Aoo s
    Defendants
                                           l



         NTI S                       AL      N                         O
     PLAI FF' STATEM ENTS O F M ATERI FA CTS I SUPPO RT O F TH E M O TI N FO R
                                  J             I
                                SJMM ARX ;VPGM #ST

       rua t o D. a R. 5()2) d.'      v. 6() 1A) ani aa j uv a u,
     Pu s n t S. Fl .L. 7. c ( ,Fe R.Ci P.5 c ( ) ,PlitF Tr in Bu d e n
       o     tgant r na t           t    nt' ubm t he olowi t ement of m a e i
     Pr Se Lii ,he ei fer known as tM ova ' s i t f l ng sat      s       t ral
      act o ch he e e         ne s ues or ral
     f sast whi t r ar no genui is f ti .

              ul       0, t he    oval        r or l        gtez he
       1. On J y,28,201 wih t appr ofCCM Diect CarosRodri z t M ovantwas
           r er r      m n       r i      ciiy o s       rtes, nc. f
          tansf fom Col a Low CorectonalFa lt t Dim asCha ii l halway house,
           oc t d n n a Flrda Exhi t .
           l ae i Da i , o i ( bi A)
            f n nt s s rte , nc, s on-r i o p ai 01c ( r nz to
       2. De e da Dima Chaiis l . i n p ottc r orton 5 ()3)o ga iain,who
               a es    Y y     es n   t t hat r r he S                  ,
           oper t 28 hal a hous i l8 s a est contactfom t U . Govem ment ofwhihc
              def     s       s q
           Co- endant Ana Giper Der Tomas a Las nda Adam s a e em pl
                                     ek         nd   ha           r      oyees of
            s s rte , nc a s vde n h Exhbi .
           Dima Cha iis l . si e i nti te( i tB)
             s        ii      e     i t nde          s plna y s eton, hus vi t
           D imas Chartes hous has lm ied i pendent dici i r dicr i t gi ng i
            icei v r n r f rhbt cs y eiu a ci s e urd p rv l f
               o                  e                  o
           dsrt n o e mio o y o ii d at.An sro s sn t n rq ie a po a o
                US nd      mt n ton e e e ttve Exhi t .
           CCM , PO a Commu ySa ci srpr s nai s( bi C)
                ri        s         ii aciiy,     nt i d he     edge        l
       4. Upon a rval at Dim as Chartes f lt m ova sgne t acknowl m ent of a1
           egul i        l he ecept        s       ii            ve he
          r atonsaswel ast r i ofaDi masChartesHandbook. How e r,t M ovant
            d t e eve r o s hee r ne valbl Ex bt .
           di no rc i ahadc pya t r weeno a ia e( hii C)
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 2 of 5




                   nt ovi    he    oprat t f        s     es    i r i e, i ng
          The M ova pr ded t appr i e saf member copi of drve lcens drvi
            st y r he vi i           or tcl n l           ee, hi e egi taton,
          hi or f om t Di son of M ot Veli es i Talahass ve cl r sr i and
             i nsmance, i c
          vald i t              i      t he er             tons     s y o
                        n omplance wih t t m s and condii neces ar t obt n    ai
             m sson o   at      or   cl     ng upe son.      hat t
          per i i t oper e a mot vehi e duri s rvii Be t asi may,t r on  he eas
           or ch he
          f whi t M ovant was not appr       o i       ont        he    e nt, s
                                       oved t drve,as c ended by t Def nda s i
            kn   ve o y Exhbi .
          un owne nt da ( i tD)


          f             ovi  he ppr i e t r mber copi of a1 medi r ds
       6. rhe M ovant pr ded t a oprat saf m e    s    es     1   cal ecor
          ndi tng he eve iy      s di      tons nd ny      t ec
          i ca i t s rt of hi m e cal condii a a doc or r omm enda i   tons
                 ng ogr eqliement f m anual l
          concem i pr am r zr      s or                 k    sde   he a lt
                                             abor and wor out i of t f ciiy
          Ex bi .
          ( hi tE)
             i    s esdency at Di mas Hous t M ovant was cons a l t r orzed,
          Durng hi r i           s        e, he              t nty e r i
          ntm dat nd      laed t      ny e d or s   cal    tons    s gniy,
          i i i ed,a humii t wihouta r gar f hi m edi condii orhi di t
          n ha e s or e o o la i o         n n a t n i ain f s co ' r r,
          i t th wa f c d t d ce nngj bswhe i fc i volto o hi do trso des
           v n ng s a s o r v n s dc l r ame , d n ns l o nur
          e e goi a fra t p e e thi me ia te t nt a dig i utt ij y. W hen
          as    i s d ha t l ts on t sm a tr t doct ort f der lprs '
            ked,Ewho houl ve he as ay hi te , he        or he e a i on'  ,
             ek          wer           r        hi onver ton. He e t Bur
          Der Thom asans ed,uW ehave aleady had t sc   sa i     r he eau
           f rs t nd ot h oco '( hi t .
                   l
          o p ionrzesa n t ed tr' Ex bi F)
                 e    s nl ni he             ' e t o te          i ous rvies
       8. The Def ndant ope y de ed t M ovants r ques t a tnd Relgi Se c at a
            ma in tod hurh n un ys o ae 6 n t s a 9. ls r m he
          Ro na Orh ox c c o S da ,lc td 1 miu e by c r( 5mie )fo t
            s       rtes f y
          Dim as Cha ii halwa hous t       he et           al delnes. '' M ovant s
                                    e, mdert pr extofFeder Gui i        lhe     '
           es c
          r ear h has s      uch delnes          xit nd he der       m
                       hown s gui i do not e s a t Fe al Gove m ent r ai     em ns
              r egar ng elgi       a i
          neutalr di r i ous pr ctce ordit          o    r      elgi   nsitton
                                            sances t and fom a r i ous i ttzi ata
             fwa     e, hus     tt i     ol i      he      s i s o elgi      r
          hal y hous t consiutng a vi aton of t m ovant rght t r i ous f eedom
           nd he r xer i e her , nd urt       ol tng he t
          a t f ee e c s t eof a f hervi ai t Unied St ess                  e ai
                                                              at tnceon s par ton
             hu c nd tt Ex bi .
          ofc r ha sae( hi tG)
           n olton      s te l otctons he                s mi ed nd r se
          l vi a i of hi Til V1 pr e i ,t M ovantwas dicn' nat a ha as d
              t l     he enda s, ca e         or gne , poke Engls wih a acce ,
          consanty,by t Def nt be us he wasa f ei r s          ih t n       nt
            ac i d ee orhodox Relgi a he was whie. Si iary stz ed r i nt a
          pr tce Gr k- t         i on nd         t m l l itat esde s t
           s s us r ot rae lke Exhi t n .
          Dima ho ewe en te tdai ( bisF a dG)
       10.On Sept              , he      nt    ppr        he         r t
                 ember 28, 2011 t M ova was a oved by t CCM Diec or Caros    l
              i     o   r ns ered o         i   nt    o ve e      cal oblm
          Rodrguez,t be ta f r t home confnem e ,due t se r m edi pr e s.The
                  t          s        eed        '         i       r f , equii
          USPO Ofk e wasadvied and agr on M ovantshom econfnem enttanser r rng
          he va t o e or on e e o s s af y o e Ex biH)
          t M o n t r p t c awe kt Dima h lwa h us ( hi t .
               t r 3, 0, he      nt ove s am l  cl o s        f        e or
       l1.On Oc obe 1 201 t M ova dr hi f iy vehi e t Dim ashalway hous f
           i - e y e r ( i t)
          h sbiwe kl rpo tExhbiI.


                                             2
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 3 of 5




        12.An il       ear
                legal s ch was conduct of t vehi e t t M ovant dr and pr t was
                                     ed    he   cl ha            ove      opery
            e       r he      cl t      he
           r m oved fom t vehi e wihoutt knowl edge oft M ova and wihoutt M ovant
                                                      he     nt      t    he
              ng es nt he ear h. f        s s rt hat     l a elphone,a phonecha ge
           bei pr e att s c De endant as e ed t acelulrt e                      r r
                        t   gar tes
           and a packe of ci e t wer f         n he ove c
                                       e ound i t gl           rm        he
                                                           ompa t ent of t car and
               icaed. a        vi nce r he ur la       am as ha
           confs t Dat and e de fom t s veilnce c er t tconli i or a ined nf m ton
            egar ng he legal ear        zur        i at y toyed by t Def
           r di t il s ch and sei e,was delber el desr                 he endant. s
          Ex bis nd )
          ( hi t Ia J


             vi        l ar elphone i t ca ,does not r pr e a vi ai f prs r on
        13.Ha ng a celul t e         n he r           e es nt olton or i one s
                    i            f y      e l       egul i     e     he am
           hom e contnement as halwa hous nzes and r atons ar not t s e as hom e
               i         l       e atons. M ova does not s oke, and oper i a m ot
           confnem ent nzes and r gul i        nt          m            atng     or
              cl     t      i ppr       epr ent      nor ol i
           vehi e wihout pror a oval r es s a m i vi aton, and does not r r  equie
          nc re in Ex bt )
          i ac mto ( hiisI.

         4.     es t hi nci , he        nt     ve hr epar e ol i          fer
        1 A sa r ul oft s i dent t M ova was gi n t ee s at vi atons,on dif ent
              es or he am nci     ha   ured n he nm    y, i      ace, t
           dat ,f t s e i dentt tocc r i t s e da tm e and pl wihoutDue
             oces           1 es he hr        itn ol i      r el ed equesed
           Pr s ofLaw.Notal copi oft t ee wrte vi atons we e r eas asr      t
           y he ic vey Ex bi .
          b t d s o r ( hi tK)
                obe      0,   30 M , l l pi n s            t s           he
       15.On Oct r 20,201 at6: A . . whie see ng i hi bed a Dim as House,t
              nt     r td    wo S. r hal        s nd r ns ed o D C. ami
          mova was ares e by t U . M a s l agent a ta port t F. . M i ,
            t ut ny h r s e e g i t m nd to     e oc s w. Ex bt
          wiho a c a ge lvid a ans hi a wih utDu Pr e sLa ( hii K)
         6.    ncar r i             t     he
        1 The i ce aton was done wihoutt knowl                 nd       r ct , l
                                                 edge ofU SPO a CCM Die or Caros
               i           d    i he per or he ncar r i hus ki t ea hat he
           Rodrguez,ashedi notsgn t pa sf t i ce aton,t m a ng i cl rt t
           Def      s nga    n         gn    asng vi nce        a iatng
              endant e ged i a campai of er i e de and f brc i doctm ent i  l sn
             de o             us ci      he vent              s    e hat he olowi
           or r t coverup any s pi on oft e s. The M ovanti awar t t f l ng
           oc nt a e a iae D. #38 41 5 58 0, , 6 Ex bt .
          d ume s h vebe nfbrc td( E. , , 3, ,6 61 6 ) ( hii L)
          W l ncar a ed    D.     am ,     r s r ver e ed       ns he
       l7. hie i cer t atF. C.M i i no cha ge w e e e lvi agai tt M ovanta   nd
              nvesi ton      nd       red       ns m.     eder
          no i tga i ofany ki wascari outagai thi No f alempl              D.
                                                                   oyee ofF. C.
             nt o t nvol d t s e, he r            e he       rt   legal i
          w a ed t ge i ve wih hi cas t y we e awar oft cove and il actonsof
           he    e nt      'al
          t Def nda . Fedet Deparment of Corectons M i iCol s or Prce a Uni
                                   t         r i      am     m el    i nd     t
               ger r ion,  r he ti uggesi oft F. . W a de Li T.M cGr w ,
          M ana Ha rs unde t srcts        tons he D C. r n nda              e
            t ed n ew nsancest cont t ofi ofCCM Diec or CarosRodrguez,t
          atempt i a f i t      o    act he fce          r t , l         i    o
           o val Ex bis , , nd
          n a i.( hi t 1 J a L)

                                             3
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 4 of 5




         8 The vr s ee e r m D. M ani n a ua y ,      .Exhi t
        l . M o twa r lasdfo F. C. ir o J n r 03 201 1 ( bi M )
           l      te    o ns e hat he            d     t       bl nf m ton n i o
        19. n an a tm ptt e ur t t M ovantw oul notge any usa e i or a i i tm e,t
              bl m o              nvesi i       he
           ena e hi t conductany i tgaton on t backgr           he e     s       l
                                                        ound oft Def ndant,aswel as
            he s omm it by t Def nt Def nda s ha r us t com pl wih t
           t act c       ted    he     endn s. e nt ve ef ed o             y t he
             s     y tl , n
           dicover rzes i a cl         y, ki hei         zes n he ence of any court
                               ever w a m a ng t r own rtl i t abs
            ' i ega di he s
            u                       y.      s       oye     kgr md
           l lng r r ng t dicover No Dim as empl esbac ot ornam e t wer   s, hat e
                e he nci ,        m o st he         t t ami D.         e
           awar oft i dent or ca e t vii t m ovmz a M i F. C.wer everr al    eve ed,
                he            d ver nt vi           e         hes     e ha
           and t M ovant coul ne i er ew or depos any of t e peopl t t hol ve yd r
          mpora n o main n hs a e Ex bi .
          i tntif r to i t i c s ( hi tN)




                  tdDce e 52 1
                Dae: cmbr1,0 1                         e?cfly t t
                                                      R setul mi/,
                                                            y
                                                            ,     e   ns
                                                                  z wyc v
                                                     A      DU        o
                                                  TRAI N BUJ VEANU ,Pr Se




                                           4
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 5 of 5

								
To top