Docstoc

Plaintiff's Statement of material facts in Support of the Motion for Summary Judgment

Document Sample
Plaintiff's Statement of material facts in Support of the Motion for Summary Judgment Powered By Docstoc
					Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 1 of 5
                                                                      LE y        c.
                                                                     FI D b P #' o.
                                                                                01
                                                                        DEC 1! 2 1          '
                                                                               ! .' :
                                                                                   , MORE
                                                                       STEVEK M 1'RI$
                                                                              / . tl CT.
                                                                              'f )
                                                                       CLFRit S..ST.
                                                                         : ''1L ' A. A
                                                                         k .1 'f
                                                                        6 f,. bL VM I M I
                                                                            .- .
                                                                        w -

                       N      J TED STA TES DI
                      I TH E I NI                 CT
                                              STRI CO URT FO R
                                               CT
                         THE SO UTHERN DISTRI OF FLORI  DA

                                 : ZOIZO- V- TZ/ M ONTON
                         CASE NO. 1I-   CI SEI SI


     TRAG N BUJDW EAN U,
      ai if
     Pl ntf,

     VS.

    olsM A s cl    r Es x         spE
               txm 'I ,I c ,ANA Gl RT,
    DEREK THOM AS AND LASHANDA Aoo s
    Defendants
                                           l



         NTI S                       AL      N                         O
     PLAI FF' STATEM ENTS O F M ATERI FA CTS I SUPPO RT O F TH E M O TI N FO R
                                  J             I
                                SJMM ARX ;VPGM #ST

       rua t o D. a R. 5()2) d.'      v. 6() 1A) ani aa j uv a u,
     Pu s n t S. Fl .L. 7. c ( ,Fe R.Ci P.5 c ( ) ,PlitF Tr in Bu d e n
       o     tgant r na t           t    nt' ubm t he olowi t ement of m a e i
     Pr Se Lii ,he ei fer known as tM ova ' s i t f l ng sat      s       t ral
      act o ch he e e         ne s ues or ral
     f sast whi t r ar no genui is f ti .

              ul       0, t he    oval        r or l        gtez he
       1. On J y,28,201 wih t appr ofCCM Diect CarosRodri z t M ovantwas
           r er r      m n       r i      ciiy o s       rtes, nc. f
          tansf fom Col a Low CorectonalFa lt t Dim asCha ii l halway house,
           oc t d n n a Flrda Exhi t .
           l ae i Da i , o i ( bi A)
            f n nt s s rte , nc, s on-r i o p ai 01c ( r nz to
       2. De e da Dima Chaiis l . i n p ottc r orton 5 ()3)o ga iain,who
               a es    Y y     es n   t t hat r r he S                  ,
           oper t 28 hal a hous i l8 s a est contactfom t U . Govem ment ofwhihc
              def     s       s q
           Co- endant Ana Giper Der Tomas a Las nda Adam s a e em pl
                                     ek         nd   ha           r      oyees of
            s s rte , nc a s vde n h Exhbi .
           Dima Cha iis l . si e i nti te( i tB)
             s        ii      e     i t nde          s plna y s eton, hus vi t
           D imas Chartes hous has lm ied i pendent dici i r dicr i t gi ng i
            icei v r n r f rhbt cs y eiu a ci s e urd p rv l f
               o                  e                  o
           dsrt n o e mio o y o ii d at.An sro s sn t n rq ie a po a o
                US nd      mt n ton e e e ttve Exhi t .
           CCM , PO a Commu ySa ci srpr s nai s( bi C)
                ri        s         ii aciiy,     nt i d he     edge        l
       4. Upon a rval at Dim as Chartes f lt m ova sgne t acknowl m ent of a1
           egul i        l he ecept        s       ii            ve he
          r atonsaswel ast r i ofaDi masChartesHandbook. How e r,t M ovant
            d t e eve r o s hee r ne valbl Ex bt .
           di no rc i ahadc pya t r weeno a ia e( hii C)
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 2 of 5




                   nt ovi    he    oprat t f        s     es    i r i e, i ng
          The M ova pr ded t appr i e saf member copi of drve lcens drvi
            st y r he vi i           or tcl n l           ee, hi e egi taton,
          hi or f om t Di son of M ot Veli es i Talahass ve cl r sr i and
             i nsmance, i c
          vald i t              i      t he er             tons     s y o
                        n omplance wih t t m s and condii neces ar t obt n    ai
             m sson o   at      or   cl     ng upe son.      hat t
          per i i t oper e a mot vehi e duri s rvii Be t asi may,t r on  he eas
           or ch he
          f whi t M ovant was not appr       o i       ont        he    e nt, s
                                       oved t drve,as c ended by t Def nda s i
            kn   ve o y Exhbi .
          un owne nt da ( i tD)


          f             ovi  he ppr i e t r mber copi of a1 medi r ds
       6. rhe M ovant pr ded t a oprat saf m e    s    es     1   cal ecor
          ndi tng he eve iy      s di      tons nd ny      t ec
          i ca i t s rt of hi m e cal condii a a doc or r omm enda i   tons
                 ng ogr eqliement f m anual l
          concem i pr am r zr      s or                 k    sde   he a lt
                                             abor and wor out i of t f ciiy
          Ex bi .
          ( hi tE)
             i    s esdency at Di mas Hous t M ovant was cons a l t r orzed,
          Durng hi r i           s        e, he              t nty e r i
          ntm dat nd      laed t      ny e d or s   cal    tons    s gniy,
          i i i ed,a humii t wihouta r gar f hi m edi condii orhi di t
          n ha e s or e o o la i o         n n a t n i ain f s co ' r r,
          i t th wa f c d t d ce nngj bswhe i fc i volto o hi do trso des
           v n ng s a s o r v n s dc l r ame , d n ns l o nur
          e e goi a fra t p e e thi me ia te t nt a dig i utt ij y. W hen
          as    i s d ha t l ts on t sm a tr t doct ort f der lprs '
            ked,Ewho houl ve he as ay hi te , he        or he e a i on'  ,
             ek          wer           r        hi onver ton. He e t Bur
          Der Thom asans ed,uW ehave aleady had t sc   sa i     r he eau
           f rs t nd ot h oco '( hi t .
                   l
          o p ionrzesa n t ed tr' Ex bi F)
                 e    s nl ni he             ' e t o te          i ous rvies
       8. The Def ndant ope y de ed t M ovants r ques t a tnd Relgi Se c at a
            ma in tod hurh n un ys o ae 6 n t s a 9. ls r m he
          Ro na Orh ox c c o S da ,lc td 1 miu e by c r( 5mie )fo t
            s       rtes f y
          Dim as Cha ii halwa hous t       he et           al delnes. '' M ovant s
                                    e, mdert pr extofFeder Gui i        lhe     '
           es c
          r ear h has s      uch delnes          xit nd he der       m
                       hown s gui i do not e s a t Fe al Gove m ent r ai     em ns
              r egar ng elgi       a i
          neutalr di r i ous pr ctce ordit          o    r      elgi   nsitton
                                            sances t and fom a r i ous i ttzi ata
             fwa     e, hus     tt i     ol i      he      s i s o elgi      r
          hal y hous t consiutng a vi aton of t m ovant rght t r i ous f eedom
           nd he r xer i e her , nd urt       ol tng he t
          a t f ee e c s t eof a f hervi ai t Unied St ess                  e ai
                                                              at tnceon s par ton
             hu c nd tt Ex bi .
          ofc r ha sae( hi tG)
           n olton      s te l otctons he                s mi ed nd r se
          l vi a i of hi Til V1 pr e i ,t M ovantwas dicn' nat a ha as d
              t l     he enda s, ca e         or gne , poke Engls wih a acce ,
          consanty,by t Def nt be us he wasa f ei r s          ih t n       nt
            ac i d ee orhodox Relgi a he was whie. Si iary stz ed r i nt a
          pr tce Gr k- t         i on nd         t m l l itat esde s t
           s s us r ot rae lke Exhi t n .
          Dima ho ewe en te tdai ( bisF a dG)
       10.On Sept              , he      nt    ppr        he         r t
                 ember 28, 2011 t M ova was a oved by t CCM Diec or Caros    l
              i     o   r ns ered o         i   nt    o ve e      cal oblm
          Rodrguez,t be ta f r t home confnem e ,due t se r m edi pr e s.The
                  t          s        eed        '         i       r f , equii
          USPO Ofk e wasadvied and agr on M ovantshom econfnem enttanser r rng
          he va t o e or on e e o s s af y o e Ex biH)
          t M o n t r p t c awe kt Dima h lwa h us ( hi t .
               t r 3, 0, he      nt ove s am l  cl o s        f        e or
       l1.On Oc obe 1 201 t M ova dr hi f iy vehi e t Dim ashalway hous f
           i - e y e r ( i t)
          h sbiwe kl rpo tExhbiI.


                                             2
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 3 of 5




        12.An il       ear
                legal s ch was conduct of t vehi e t t M ovant dr and pr t was
                                     ed    he   cl ha            ove      opery
            e       r he      cl t      he
           r m oved fom t vehi e wihoutt knowl edge oft M ova and wihoutt M ovant
                                                      he     nt      t    he
              ng es nt he ear h. f        s s rt hat     l a elphone,a phonecha ge
           bei pr e att s c De endant as e ed t acelulrt e                      r r
                        t   gar tes
           and a packe of ci e t wer f         n he ove c
                                       e ound i t gl           rm        he
                                                           ompa t ent of t car and
               icaed. a        vi nce r he ur la       am as ha
           confs t Dat and e de fom t s veilnce c er t tconli i or a ined nf m ton
            egar ng he legal ear        zur        i at y toyed by t Def
           r di t il s ch and sei e,was delber el desr                 he endant. s
          Ex bis nd )
          ( hi t Ia J


             vi        l ar elphone i t ca ,does not r pr e a vi ai f prs r on
        13.Ha ng a celul t e         n he r           e es nt olton or i one s
                    i            f y      e l       egul i     e     he am
           hom e contnement as halwa hous nzes and r atons ar not t s e as hom e
               i         l       e atons. M ova does not s oke, and oper i a m ot
           confnem ent nzes and r gul i        nt          m            atng     or
              cl     t      i ppr       epr ent      nor ol i
           vehi e wihout pror a oval r es s a m i vi aton, and does not r r  equie
          nc re in Ex bt )
          i ac mto ( hiisI.

         4.     es t hi nci , he        nt     ve hr epar e ol i          fer
        1 A sa r ul oft s i dent t M ova was gi n t ee s at vi atons,on dif ent
              es or he am nci     ha   ured n he nm    y, i      ace, t
           dat ,f t s e i dentt tocc r i t s e da tm e and pl wihoutDue
             oces           1 es he hr        itn ol i      r el ed equesed
           Pr s ofLaw.Notal copi oft t ee wrte vi atons we e r eas asr      t
           y he ic vey Ex bi .
          b t d s o r ( hi tK)
                obe      0,   30 M , l l pi n s            t s           he
       15.On Oct r 20,201 at6: A . . whie see ng i hi bed a Dim as House,t
              nt     r td    wo S. r hal        s nd r ns ed o D C. ami
          mova was ares e by t U . M a s l agent a ta port t F. . M i ,
            t ut ny h r s e e g i t m nd to     e oc s w. Ex bt
          wiho a c a ge lvid a ans hi a wih utDu Pr e sLa ( hii K)
         6.    ncar r i             t     he
        1 The i ce aton was done wihoutt knowl                 nd       r ct , l
                                                 edge ofU SPO a CCM Die or Caros
               i           d    i he per or he ncar r i hus ki t ea hat he
           Rodrguez,ashedi notsgn t pa sf t i ce aton,t m a ng i cl rt t
           Def      s nga    n         gn    asng vi nce        a iatng
              endant e ged i a campai of er i e de and f brc i doctm ent i  l sn
             de o             us ci      he vent              s    e hat he olowi
           or r t coverup any s pi on oft e s. The M ovanti awar t t f l ng
           oc nt a e a iae D. #38 41 5 58 0, , 6 Ex bt .
          d ume s h vebe nfbrc td( E. , , 3, ,6 61 6 ) ( hii L)
          W l ncar a ed    D.     am ,     r s r ver e ed       ns he
       l7. hie i cer t atF. C.M i i no cha ge w e e e lvi agai tt M ovanta   nd
              nvesi ton      nd       red       ns m.     eder
          no i tga i ofany ki wascari outagai thi No f alempl              D.
                                                                   oyee ofF. C.
             nt o t nvol d t s e, he r            e he       rt   legal i
          w a ed t ge i ve wih hi cas t y we e awar oft cove and il actonsof
           he    e nt      'al
          t Def nda . Fedet Deparment of Corectons M i iCol s or Prce a Uni
                                   t         r i      am     m el    i nd     t
               ger r ion,  r he ti uggesi oft F. . W a de Li T.M cGr w ,
          M ana Ha rs unde t srcts        tons he D C. r n nda              e
            t ed n ew nsancest cont t ofi ofCCM Diec or CarosRodrguez,t
          atempt i a f i t      o    act he fce          r t , l         i    o
           o val Ex bis , , nd
          n a i.( hi t 1 J a L)

                                             3
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 4 of 5




         8 The vr s ee e r m D. M ani n a ua y ,      .Exhi t
        l . M o twa r lasdfo F. C. ir o J n r 03 201 1 ( bi M )
           l      te    o ns e hat he            d     t       bl nf m ton n i o
        19. n an a tm ptt e ur t t M ovantw oul notge any usa e i or a i i tm e,t
              bl m o              nvesi i       he
           ena e hi t conductany i tgaton on t backgr           he e     s       l
                                                        ound oft Def ndant,aswel as
            he s omm it by t Def nt Def nda s ha r us t com pl wih t
           t act c       ted    he     endn s. e nt ve ef ed o             y t he
             s     y tl , n
           dicover rzes i a cl         y, ki hei         zes n he ence of any court
                               ever w a m a ng t r own rtl i t abs
            ' i ega di he s
            u                       y.      s       oye     kgr md
           l lng r r ng t dicover No Dim as empl esbac ot ornam e t wer   s, hat e
                e he nci ,        m o st he         t t ami D.         e
           awar oft i dent or ca e t vii t m ovmz a M i F. C.wer everr al    eve ed,
                he            d ver nt vi           e         hes     e ha
           and t M ovant coul ne i er ew or depos any of t e peopl t t hol ve yd r
          mpora n o main n hs a e Ex bi .
          i tntif r to i t i c s ( hi tN)




                  tdDce e 52 1
                Dae: cmbr1,0 1                         e?cfly t t
                                                      R setul mi/,
                                                            y
                                                            ,     e   ns
                                                                  z wyc v
                                                     A      DU        o
                                                  TRAI N BUJ VEANU ,Pr Se




                                           4
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 84 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/20/2011 Page 5 of 5

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Description: United States Courthouse,Southern District Of Florida,Traian Bujduveanu v. Dismas Charities,Ana Gispert,Derek Thomas,lashanda Adams