Zappos class action by paidcontent

VIEWS: 5,251 PAGES: 17

									Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                   Filed 01/16/12 Page 1 of 17 PageID #: 1



                               
    

  
                                 

     
                                   




 





        8   5 )( "& )
                                                                      3:12cv-32 M
",-& ( && ).",- -#'#&,&3 -#./.5                  !  %$

                                &#(.# 5                  
       
 
 


08                                                                    
 


  8 5 
 8 <<  8 5

                                    ((.8



       &#(.# 5 ",-    8 .0(- ?:&#(.# ;@5 )( "& ) ",-& ( && ).",- -#'#&,&3

-#./.5 )'*&#(- ) ." .#)(- )             ((.5     '4)(8)'5 
(8 << **)-8)'

?:  ((.;@5 ( ,-*. /&&3 &&!- ." )&&)1#(!7

                                                       

       K8      "#- #-  )(-/', &-- .#)( &1-/#. ,)/!". 3 &#(.# 5 #(#0#/&&3 (

)( "& ) )0, LN '#&&#)( -#'#&,&3 -#./. *,-)(- ?
 85 ."             &-- ',-@5 1")-

**)-8)'     *,-)(&    /-.)',      )/(.       #( ),'.#)(    ?:   
;@5   #(&/#(!   ('-5

)/(. (/',-5 *--1),-5 ='#& ,---5 #&&#(! ( -"#**#(! ,---5 *")( (/',-

( ." &-. )/, #!#.- ) ,#. ,- /- .) '% */,"--5 1- -.)&( 3 "%,-

1") !#( -- .) **)-8)'9- #(.,(& (.1),% .",)/!" ." )'*(39- /(*,)..

-,0,- &). #( 1-.,( (./%38

       L8        ((. 1- (.,/-. 1#."5 ')(! ).", ."#(!-5 - !/,#(! &#(.# 9- (

 &-- ',-9      
8 
( 0#)&.#)( ) ." #, ,#. *),.#(! .5 KO 88 8 C KPRK   



                                                   1
                                       CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                 Filed 01/16/12 Page 2 of 17 PageID #: 2



?:  ;@5        ((. #& .) )*. ( '#(.#( +/. *,)/,- .) *,).. -/"

#( ),'.#)( ( &#'#. #.- #--'#(.#)( )(&3 ), ." *,'#--#& */,*)-- -. ),." #(             8

 -  #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )         ((.9- 1#&& /&5 ,%&-- (<), !,)--&3 (!&#!(.

0#)&.#)(- )       5 ( /(/."),#4 ."#, *,.3 ).#( &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9              


 ), () *,'#--#& */,*)- /(,        8

       M8          ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)( &-) )(-.#./. )'')( &1

#(0-#)( ) *,#03 3 ." */&# #-&)-/, ) *,#0. .- ( )'')( &1 (!&#!(8

       N8        &#(.# 5 )( "& ) ",-& ( ." &-- ',-5 -%- ?#@ ./& '!-5

)()'# '!-5 '(.& (!/#-" '!-5 -../.),3 '!- (<), ()'#(& '!-5 ?##@

2'*&,3 '!-5 ?###@ #($/(.#0 ,&# 5 ( ?#0@ ..),(3-9 -5 &#.#!.#)( 2*(-- ( )-.-8

                                    
 
 
   

       O8        "#- )/,. "- -/$. '.., $/,#-#.#)( )0, &#(.# 9-    &#'- */,-/(. .)

?#@ LR 88 8 C KMMK ? ,& +/-.#)(@ ( ?##@ LR C KMML?@ ?      @ /- ?@ .", , KJJ ),

'), &-- ',-5 ?@ . &-. )( &-- ', #-  #.#4( )  -.. .". #- #0,- ,)'

  ((.9- #.#4(-"#*5 ( ?@ ." '.., #( )(.,)0,-3 2- GO5JJJ5JJJ  2&/-#0 )

#(.,-. ( )-.-8 "#- )/,. &-) "- -/$. '.., $/,#-#.#)( )0, &#(.# 9- -.. &1

&#'- */,-/(. .) LR 88 8 C KMPQ8 "#- )/,. "- *,-)(& $/,#-#.#)( )0,              ((.

/- . && ,&0(. .#'-5       ((. )(/. ?( )(.#(/- .) )(/.@ -/-.(.#&

/-#(-- #( ." -.,( #-.,#. ) (./%38

       P8        ( #( ),'.#)( ( &# 5 ." /(*,).. **)-8)' -,0, .",)/!" 1"#"

." . ."#0- !#( -- .) ." **)-8)' (.1),% ( -.)& &#(.# 9- (               &--

',-9        
 #- &). #( "*",-0#&&5 (./%38      ),#(!&35 0(/ #- *,)*, #( ."



                                                  2
                                       CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                   Filed 01/16/12 Page 3 of 17 PageID #: 3



-.,( #-.,#. ) (./%3 */,-/(. .) LR 88 8 CKMSK?@ ( ?@ /-  -/-.(.#& *,.5

# (). &&5 ) ." 0(.- !#0#(! ,#- .) ."#- .#)( )/,, #( ." -.,( #-.,#. ) (./%3 (

     ((. ,-#-5 #- &).5 (  )/(5 (<), )(/.- -/-.(.#& /-#(--5 #( ."

-.,( #-.,#. ) (./%38

                                                 
 

            Q8      &#(.# 5 ",-   8 .0(-5 #-  ,-#(. ) ." #.3 )     /')(.5 .. )

2-8 ( (/,3 KP5 LJKL5 &#(.# ,#0 ( ='#& ,)' **)-8)' ().# 3#(! &#(.#

.". ",         
 " ( -.)&( (<), )'*,)'#- - *,. ) ." **)-8)' . ,"8

            R8        ((.5 '4)(8)'5 
(85 #-  &1, ),*),.#)( 1#." #.- *,#(#*& *&

) /-#(-- #( ." #.3 ) ..&5 .. ) -"#(!.)(8               )/( #( KSSS5 **)-8)' #- (

)(&#( -") ( **,& ,.#&, /,,(.&3 - #( ." #.3 )            (,-)(5 .. ) 08

**)-8)' 1- +/#, 3              '4)(8)'5 
(8 #( LJJS (5 )( #( ),'.#)( ( &# 5

)*,.- - ( /(#(),*),. #0#-#)( )           '4)(8)'5 
(8      '4)(8)'5 
(89- ),*),.

"+/,.,- #- &). . NKJ ,,3             0(/ ),."5 ..&5 -"#(!.)( SRKJS=OLKJ8

    '4)(8)'5 
(8 << **)-8)' '3  -,0 1#." /'')(- (  )*3 ) ."#- &--

    .#)(    )'*&#(. ( /,3      '( 3 -,0#(! #.- -#!(. ,!#-., !(.5 1"#" #-

     =
13,- 
(),*),.#(! ,0# )'*(35 NLK 8 #( .85 ,(% ),.5 (./%3 NJPJK8

                                                        

            S8      ( (/,3 KP5 LJKL5 &#(.# ( )0, LN '#&&#)( &-- ',- ,#0 (

='#& ,)' **)-8)' ().# 3#(! ."' .". ."#,           
 " ( -.)&( (<), )'*,)'#-8

            KJ8      ),#(! .) )(3     -#"5 ." **)-8)'      5 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9

     
 #(&/#(!5 

  
 5 ."#, ('-5 )/(. (/',-5 *--1),-5 ='#& ,---5 #&&#(!



                                                    3
                                          CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                  Filed 01/16/12 Page 4 of 17 PageID #: 4



( -"#**#(! ,---5 *")( (/',-5 ( ." &-. )/, #!#.- ) ." ,#. ,- /- .)

'% */,"--5 1- -.)&( 3 "%,- 1") !#( -- .) **)-8)'9- #(.,(& (.1),%

.",)/!" #.- /(*,).. -,0,- &). #(5 )( #( ),'.#)( ( &# 5 "*",-0#&&5 (./%38

          KK8    -  ,-/&. )    ((.9- #&/, .) *,)*,&3 -/, #.- -,0,- ( - !/,

&#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9       
5 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9 *,#03 "- ( #(08

&#(.# ( &-- ',- 1#&& ()1  ,+/#, .) .% ." .#' .) "(! ." *--1),- )(

."#, **)-8)' )/(.- ?- ,)''( 3 **)-8)'@5 "(! ." *--1),- :)( (3

).", 1 -#. 1", A&#(.# ( &-- ',-B /- ." -' ),  -#'#&, *--1),; ?-

 /,.", ,)''( 3 **)-8)'@5 ( "(! ).", &'(.- ) ."#, )'*,)'#-             
8

 &-)5 &#(.# ( &-- ',- ()1   !,., ,#-% ) #(.#.3 ." .>#(&/#(!5 /. ().

&#'#. .)5 #(.#.3 ." . ,)' :*"#-"#(!; ( :*",'#(!8;

          KL8   
(.#.3 ." . )/,- 1"(  *,-)(9- *,-)(&&3 #(.# 3#(! #( ),'.#)(5

-/" - ." *,-)(9- ('5 ='#& ,--5 #&&#(! ( -"#**#(! ,---5 *")( (/',

( ,#. , #( ),'.#)( #- /- 1#.")/. "#- ), ", *,'#--#)( .) )''#. ,/ ), ).",

,#'-8          ,& ,    )''#--#)(5       #!".#(!   % !#(-. 
(.#.3 " .8      

1118 .8!)0<*</<'#,)-#.-<#." .<)(-/',-<)/.=#(.#.3=." .8".'& ?.8 KS5 LJKK@8

          KM8   " ,& ,     )''#--#)( -.#'.- .". ." #(.#.#- ) - '(3 -

S '#&&#)( ',#(- , -.)&( " 3,8      

          KN8   :"#-"#(!; #-  ),' ) )(&#( #(.#.3 ." . .". &/,- )(-/',- #(.) #0/&!#(!

."#, *,-)(& #((#& #( ),'.#)( .) ,//&(. 1-#.-5 &-) %()1( - -*))  1-#.-8

 ), 2'*&5  *"#-", -(- ( '#& '--! .) ( /(-/-*.#(! 0#.#' #(-.,/.#(! "#' .)

&#% )( ." &#(% .)  (%9- 1-#. ?*,)0# #( ." '#&@ .) )( #,' ." )(-/',9- )/(.



                                                   4
                                     CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                Filed 01/16/12 Page 5 of 17 PageID #: 5



#( ),'.#)(8 (%()1(-. .) ." )(-/',5 ." 1-#. #-  )(0#(#(! % ), )*3 ) ."

/."(.# 1-#.8 " /(-/-*.#(! /-.)', .%- ." #. ( *,)0#- ." #( ),'.#)(5

.",3 (&#(! ." *"#-", .) -.& "#- ), ", *,-)(& #((#& #( ),'.#)(8 " *"#-", (

."( /- ."#- #( ),'.#)( .) &( )/. ." 0#.#'9- (% )/(.- ), )''#. ).", ),'- )

#(.#.3 ." .8

        KO8       :",'#(!; #- -#'#&, .) *"#-"#(! /. '), -)*"#-.#.8 ",',- &-) -(

='#&-8      )(-/',-5 ")10,5 (  /* 3 ." *",', 1#.")/. 0( )*(#(! ( ='#&

.."'(.8         )(-/', )'*,)'#-- "#- ), ", *,-)(& #((#& #( ),'.#)( -#'*&3 3

)*(#(! ." ='#& '--!8 " *",'#(! ='#& '--! )(.#(-  0#,/- ?), ,)$( "),-@

.". #(-.&&-  -'&& -) .1, *,)!,' )( ." /-,9- )'*/.,8 ", .,5 1"( ." )(-/',

.,#- .) 0#-#. ( ) ##& 1-#.5 ." *",',9- -) .1, *,)!,' ,#,.- ." ,)1-, .) ."

*",',9- % 0,-#)( ) ." 1-#.8 
( ."#- 135 ." *",', #- & .) *./, ." *,-)(&

 #((#& #( ),'.#)( .". ." )(-/', (.,- #(.) ." )/(., #. 1-#.5 .",3

)'*,)'#-#(! ." )(-/',9- )/(.8

        KP8        -  #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. ) ." **)-8)' . ,"5 ." "%,?-@

(<), ."#, /-.)',- ?.", #-  ,)/-. #(.,(.#)(& ',%. ), #( ),'.#)( -/" - ."

*/,&)#(        
@ ()1 "0 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9     
5 - 1&& - ." %()1&! .".

&#(.# ( &-- ',- , /-.)' .) ,#0#(! '#&- ,)' **)-8)'8 "#-5 #( ./,(5

'%- &#(.# ( &-- ',- '/" '), &#%&3 .) ,-*)( .) ,+/-.- ,)' **)-8)'

 ), '), *,-)(& #( ),'.#)(5 -/" - (% )/(. (/',-5 &)!#( #( ),'.#)( ), 0( )#&

/,#.3 (/',-8       - -/"5 )(-/',->-/" - &#(.# ( &-- ',->, '), &#%&3

.) /(%()1#(!&3 !#0 13 ."#, -(-#.#0 *,-)(& #( ),'.#)( .) :*"#-"#(!; ( :*",'#(!;



                                                 5
                                       CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1              Filed 01/16/12 Page 6 of 17 PageID #: 6



."#0- 1") -*#&#4 #( )(-.,/.#(! -*)) 1-#.- ( '#&- .". '#,,), ." ,( ."39,

-*)) #(!>-/" - **)-8)' (<), ).", *)*/&, )(&#( ,.#&,- ( #((#& #(-.#./.#)(-8

       KQ8      ),#(! .) ." ,& , )''#--#)(5 :
(.#.3 ." . #- -,#)/-8 "#&

-)' #(.#.3 ." . 0#.#'- ( ,-)&0 ."#, *,)&'- +/#%&35 ).",- -*( "/(,- ) )&&,-

( '(3 3- ,*#,#(! '! .) ."#, !)) (' ( ,#. ,),8 )' )(-/',-

0#.#'#4 3 #(.#.3 ." . '3 &)- )/. )( $) )**),./(#.#-5 ),  (# &)(- ), /.#)(5

")/-#(! ), ,- /- ) (!.#0 #( ),'.#)( )( ."#, ,#. ,*),.-8 
( ,, --5 ."3 '3

0(  ,,-. ), ,#'- ."3 # (). )''#.8;

       KR8    
(.#.3 ." . ,#'- ) .( #(0)&0 '), ."( $/-. ,#'- ) #((#& &)--5 -/" -

0,#)/- .3*- ) !)0,('(. ,/ ?-/" - ).#(#(!  ,#0,9- &#(- ), ) ##& #(.# #.#)(

, #( ." 0#.#'9- (' /. 1#." ."#, *#./,@5 /-#(!  0#.#'9- (' ( )#& /,#.3

(/', .) ).#( !)0,('(. ( #.-5 (<), #&#(!  ,//&(. .2 ,./,( /-#(!  0#.#'9-

#( ),'.#)(8 
(.#.3 ."#0- &-) ).#( $)- /-#(! -.)&( )#& /,#.3 (/',-5 ,(. ")/--

( *,.'(.- (<), ).#( '#& -,0#- #(  0#.#'9- ('8 
(.#.3 ."#0- &-) "0

( %()1( .) !#0  0#.#'9- *,-)(& #( ),'.#)( .) *)&# /,#(! ( ,,-.5 ,-/&.#(! #( ."

#--/( ) ( ,,-. 1,,(. #( ." 0#.#'9- (' ( ( /(1,,(. ,#'#(& ,),8

       KS8       ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)( ", #,.&3 (<), *,)2#'.&3

/- ." ." . ( #--'#(.#)( #(.) ." */&# )'#( ) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9

   
 1#.")/. ."#, %()1&!5 /."),#4.#)( (<), )(-(.8         -  /,.", #,. (<),

*,)2#'. ,-/&. )    ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)(5 &#(.# ( &-- ',-

"0 -/ ,5 ( 1#&& )(.#(/ .) -/ ,5 '!- #(&/#(!5 1#.")/. &#'#..#)(5 &)-- ) ."

/((/', /- ) ."#, 2.(. *--1),- ( ." &)-- ) ."#, *--1),-5 2*(-- ),



                                               6
                                     CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                     Filed 01/16/12 Page 7 of 17 PageID #: 7



,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5 (2#.35 ').#)(&

#-.,--5 &)-- ) *,#035 ( ).", )()'# ( ()(=)()'# ",'8

       LJ8        &.")/!" #( #.- ='#&- .) &#(.#             (    &-- ',-5 **)-8)'

,)''( .". ."3 ,-. ."#, **)-8)' )/(. *--1),- ( "(! ." *--1),-

:)( (3 ).", 1 -#. 1", A."3B /- ." -' ),  -#'#&, *--1),5; .) .5  ((.

"- (). ) , &#(.# ( &-- ',- (3 )'*(-.#)( ), #,. *,-)(& *,)..#)(

 ,)' ." . ,">-/" - ,#. ')(#.),#(! -,0#- (<), #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(8

"#- - "- ,-/&.8

                                     
     
 

           


       LK8       /,-/(. .) /& LM ) ." ,& /&- )          #0#& ,)/,5 &#(.# ,#(!- ."#-

&-- .#)( -  (.#)(& &-- .#)( )( "& ) ",-& ( ." )&&)1#(! &-- ) -#'#&,&3

-#./. #(#0#/&-7

                   && *,-)(- 1")- **)-8)' *,-)(& /-.)', )/(.
                 #( ),'.#)( #(&/#(!5 

  
 5 ('5 )/(. (/',5
                 *--1),5 ='#& ,--5 #&&#(! ( -"#**#(! ,---5
                 *")( (/',5 ( ." &-. )/, #!#.- ) ." ,#. ,- /-
                 .) '% */,"--5 1- -.)&( 3 "%,- 1") !#( --
                 .) **)-8)'9- #(.,(& (.1),% .",)/!" /(*,).. -,0,-
                 &). #( (./%38

       LL8       "    &-- -*# #&&3 2&/-        ((. ( #.- ) #,-5 #,.),-5 !(.-

(<), '*&)3-5 ." )/,. ( )/,. *,-)((&8

       LM8       " */..#0    &-- #- )'*,#- ) )0, LN '#&&#)( *,-)(-5 '%#(! $)#(,

#'*,.#&8     #-*)-#.#)( ) ."#- '.., -  &-- .#)( 1#&& *,)0# -/-.(.#& ( #.- (

 ##(#- .) ." ,.#- ( ." )/,.8




                                                     7
                                        CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                Filed 01/16/12 Page 8 of 17 PageID #: 8



       LN8     " ,#!".- ) " &-- ', 1, 0#)&. #(  0#,./&&3 #(.#& '((, -

 ,-/&. )    ((.9- 1#&& /&5 ,%&-- (<), (!&#!(. .#)(- (<), #(.#)(8

       LO8     /-.#)(- ) &1 ( . )'')( .) && &-- ',- 2#-. ( *,)'#(.

)0, (3 +/-.#)(-  .#(! )(&3 #(#0#/& &-- ',- #(&/#(!5 

  
 7


               a)       ".",  ((. 0#)&.  3 #&#(! .) *,)*,&3 -/, (
                        .,(-*),. &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9  
6

               b)       ".",  ((. 0#)&.  3 #&#(! .) (,3*. &#(.# 9- (
                         &-- ',-9  
 #( ),( 1#." ,& -.(,-6


               c)       ".",  ((. 1#&& /&&35 ,%&--&3 (<), (!&#!(.&3 #& .)
                        '#(.#( (<), 2/. ,-)(& *,)/,- -#!( .) *,0(.
                        /(/."),#4 -- .) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9  
6

               d)       ".",  ((. 1- (!&#!(. #( -.),#(! &#(.# 9- (         &--
                        ',-9  
6

               e)       ".",  ((. )1  /.3 .) &#(.# ( &-- ',- .)
                        2,#- ,-)(& , #( *,)..#(! ( -/,#(! ."#,  
6

               f)       ".",  ((. ," #.- /.3 .) 2,#- ,-)(& , #(
                        #&#(! .) *,).. ( -/, &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9  
6

               g)       ".",  ((. 1- (!&#!(. #( #&#(! .) -/, &#(.# 9- (
                         &-- ',-9  
6

               h)       ".", 3 */&#&3 #-&)-#(! &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9  

                        1#.")/. /."),#4.#)(5  ((. #(0 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9
                        *,#036 (

               i)       ".", &#(.# ( &-- ',- -/-.#( '!- -  ,-/&. )
                          ((.9- #&/, .) -/, ( *,).. ."#,  
8

       LP8     &#(.# ( ."#, )/(-& 1#&& #,&3 ( +/.&3 ,*,-(. ." #(.,-.- )

 &-- ',-8 &#(.# "- () #(.,-.- (.!)(#-.# .)5 ), #( )( &#. 1#."5 &-- ',-9




                                                 8
                                      CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                   Filed 01/16/12 Page 9 of 17 PageID #: 9



#(.,-.-8 &#(.# 9- &13,- , "#!"&3 2*,#( #( ." *,)-/.#)( ) )(-/', &-- .#)(

( . ," --8

           LQ8   &#(.# 9- &#'- , .3*#& )   &-- ',-9 &#'- #( .". &#(.# 9- &#'- (

    &-- ',-9 &#'- && ,#- ,)'  ((.9- #&/, .) *,)*,&3 -/, ( *,).. ."#,

     
8

           LR8      &-- .#)( #- -/*,#), .) && ).", 0#&& '.")- ), #,&3 (  ##(.&3

$/#.#(! &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9 &#'-8 &#(.#            ( &-- ',- "0 (

#,,*,&3 ",' -  ,-/&. )         ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)(8 
#.#!.#(! ."#-

- -  &-- .#)( 1#&& ,/ ." *)--##&#.3 ) ,*.#.#)/- &#.#!.#)( ,&.#(! .)  ((.9-

 #&/, .) -/, ( *,).. &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9          
8

           LS8     &-- ,.# #.#)(5 .", ),5 #- **,)*,#. */,-/(. .)           8 8   
8   8 LM?@?M@

/- ." )0 )'')( +/-.#)(- ) &1 ), . *,)'#(. )0, (3 +/-.#)(-  .#(!

#(#0#/& &-- ',-5 (  &-- .#)( #- -/*,#), .) ).", 0#&& '.")- ), ." #, (

 ##(. $/#.#)( ) ."#- )(.,)0,-38

           MJ8     &-- ,.# #.#)( &-) #- **,)*,#. */,-/(. .)     8 8   
8   8 LM?@?L@ /-

     ((. "- . ), , /- .) . )( !,)/(- !(,&&3 **&#& .) ." &--5 -) .". #(&

#($/(.#0 ,&# ), ),,-*)(#(! &,.),3 ,&# #- **,)*,#. - .) ." &-- -  1")&8

           MK8   " 2*(- ( /,( ) &#.#!.#)( 1)/& -/-.(.#&&3 #'*#, ." #&#.3 )              &--

',- .) */,-/ #(#0#/& &1-/#.- #( ),, .) 0#(#. ."#, ,#!".-8          -(.  &-- .#)(5

     ((. 1#&& ,.#( ." ( #.- ) #.- 1,)(!)#(! -*#. #.- -,#)/- 0#)&.#)(- ) ." &18




                                                    9
                                         CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1               Filed 01/16/12 Page 10 of 17 PageID #: 10



                              
 
   
 '               


                                              


                    


 
 

 
             
    
  
      

        ML8     " *,#(! ./& -..'(.- ( &&!.#)(- , #(),*),. ",#( 3

 , ,(8

        MM8        ,+/#,- )(-/', ,*),.#(! !(#- .) )*. ( '#(.#( *,)/,-

  ), '.#(! ." (- ) )'', ), )(-/', ,#.5 *,-)((&5 #(-/,( ( ).",

 #( ),'.#)( #(  '((, #, ( +/#.& .) )(-/',- 1"#& '#(.#(#(! ." )( #(.#&#.35

 /,35 ,&0(3 ( *,)*, /.#&#4.#)( ) -/" #( ),'.#)(8 KO 88 8 C KPRK?@8


        MN8         #(-  :)(-/', ,*),.#(! !(3; -7

                 (3 *,-)( 1"#"5 ), ')(.,3 -5 /-5 ), )(  ))*,.#0 ()(*,) #.
                -#-5 ,!/&,&3 (!!- #( 1")& ), #( *,. #( ." *,.# ) --'&#(!
                ), 0&/.#(! )(-/', ,#. #( ),'.#)( ), ).", #( ),'.#)( )(
                )(-/',- ), ." */,*)- ) /,(#-"#(! )(-/', ,*),.- .) ."#,
                *,.#-5 ( 1"#" /-- (3 '(- ), #&#.3 ) #(.,-.. )'', ),
                ." */,*)- ) *,*,#(! ), /,(#-"#(! )(-/', ,*),.-8

 KO 88 8 C KPRK? @8

        MO8         #(-  :)(-/', ,*),.; -7

                A B(3 1,#..(5 ),&5 ), ).", )''/(#.#)( ) (3 #( ),'.#)( 3 
                )(-/', ,*),.#(! !(3 ,#(! )(  )(-/',9- ,#. 1),."#(--5
                ,#. -.(#(!5 ,#. *#.35 ",.,5 !(,& ,*/..#)(5 *,-)(&
                ",.,#-.#-5 ), ') ) &#0#(! 1"#" #- /- ), 2*. .)  /- ),
                )&&. #( 1")& ), #( *,. ), ." */,*)- ) -.&#-"#(! ."
                )(-/',9- &#!##&#.3 ), ,#. ), #(-/,( .)  /- *,#',#&3 ),
                *,-)(&5 '#&35 ), ")/-")& */,*)--6 '*&)3'(. */,*)--5 ), (3
                ).", */,*)- /."),#4 /(, AKO 88 8 CB KPRK?@8

 KO 88 8 C KPRK?@?K@8




                                               10
                                      CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1               Filed 01/16/12 Page 11 of 17 PageID #: 11



        MP8       ((. #-  )(-/', *),.#(! !(3 -  #( /(,            /- )( 

 ))*,.#0 ()(*,) #. -#- (<), ), ')(.,3 -5  ((. ,!/&,&3 (!!-5 #( 1")& ),

 #( *,.5 #( ." *,.# ) --'&#(! #( ),'.#)( )( )(-/',- ), ." */,*)- ) /,(#-"#(!

  )(-/', *),.- .) ."#, *,.#- (<), /-- #(.,-.. )'', ), ." */,*)- )

 *,*,#(! (<), /,(#-"#(! )(-/', *),.-8

        MQ8      -  )(-/', *),.#(! !(35  ((. 1- ?( )(.#(/- .) @ ,+/#,

 .) )*. ( '#(.#( *,)/,- -#!( .) *,).. ( &#'#. ." #--'#(.#)( ) )(-/',

 ,#.5 *,-)((&5 #(-/,( ( ).", #( ),'.#)( #(  '((, #, ( +/#.& .) )(-/',-

 1"#& '#(.#(#(! ." )( #(.#&#.35 /,35 ,&0(3 ( *,)*, /.#&#4.#)( ) -/"

 #( ),'.#)(8     ((.5 ")10,5 0#)&.           3 #&#(! .) )*. ( '#(.#( -/"

 *,)..#0 *,)/,- 1"#"5 #( ./,(5 #,.&3 (<), *,)2#'.&3 ,-/&. #( ." ." . (

 1,)(! /& #--'#(.#)( ) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9        
 #(.) ." */&# )'#(8

        MR8       ((.9- 0#)&.#)( )    5 - -. ),." )05 1- 1#&& /& ),5 . ." 0,3 &-.5

 ,%&--8

        MS8      -  #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )           ((.9- 1#&& /& (<), ,%&--

 0#)&.#)(- )     5 - -,# )05 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9           
 1- -.)&( (

 ' --#& .) /(/."),#4 ."#, *,.#- #( ." */&# )'#(8

        NJ8      -  /,.", #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )      ((.9- 1#&& /& (<), ,%&--

 0#)&.#)(- )    5 - -,# )05 &#(.# ( &-- ',- 1, ?( )(.#(/ .) @

 '! #( ." ),' ) 5 1#.")/. &#'#..#)(5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." .

 #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5 (2#.35 ').#)(& #-.,--5 &)-- ) *,#03 ( ).",




                                               11
                                      CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                 Filed 01/16/12 Page 12 of 17 PageID #: 12



 )()'# ( ()(=)()'# ",'8            ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)( 0#)&.

    8

           NK8    &#(.# ( &-- ',-5 .", ),5 , (.#.& .) )'*(-.#)( ), ."#,

 ./& '!- #(&/#(!5 

        
 5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." .

 #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5 ( ).", )()'# ( ()(=)()'# ",'5 ), -../.),3

 '!- ) (). &-- ."( GKJJ5 ( (). '), ."( GKJJJ5 "5 - 1&& - ..),(3-9 -5

 &#.#!.#)( 2*(-- ( )-.-5 */,-/(. .) KO 88 8 CKPRK(?@8

                                                



                       
    

 
            
       
  
    

           NL8    " *,#(! ./& -..'(.- ( &&!.#)(- , #(),*),. ",#( 3

 , ,(8

           NM8      ((. )1  /.3 .) &#(.# ( &-- ',- .) - !/, ( *,)..

 ."#,      
8 
( ." &.,(.#05 ( - -,# )05  ((. (!&#!(.&3 0#)&.    3

  #&#(! .) )*. ( '#(.#( *,)/,- -#!( .) *,).. ( &#'#. ." #--'#(.#)( )

 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9         
 ), ." *,'#--#& */,*)-- )/.&#( 3           1"#"5

 #( ./,(5 #,.&3 (<), *,)2#'.&3 ,-/&. #( ." ." . ( 1,)(! /& #--'#(.#)( )

 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9       
 #(.) ." */&# )'#(8

           NN8    
. 1- ,-)(&3 ),-& .".  ((.9- #&/, .) '#(.#( *,)/,- .)

 *,).. ( -/, &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9          
 1)/& ,-/&. #( ( /(/."),#4 ."#,

 *,.3 !#(#(! -- .) ."#,    
 ), () *,'#--#& */,*)- /(,      8




                                                 12
                                        CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                 Filed 01/16/12 Page 13 of 17 PageID #: 13



           NO8    -  #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )     ((.9- (!&#!(. 0#)&.#)(- )    5

 - -,# )05 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9          
 1- -.)&( ( ' --#& .)

 /(/."),#4 ."#, *,.#- #( ." */&# )'#(8

           NP8    -  /,.", #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )    ((.9- (!&#!(. 0#)&.#)(- )

    5 - -,# )05 &#(.# ( ." &-- ',- 1, ?( )(.#(/ .) @ '!

 #( ." ),' ) 5 1#.")/. &#'#..#)(5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(5

 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5 (2#.35 ').#)(& #-.,--5 &)-- ) *,#035 ( ).", )()'# (

 ()(=)()'# ",'8       ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)( 0#)&.       8

           NQ8   &#(.# ( &-- ',-5 .", ),5 , (.#.& .) )'*(-.#)( ), ."#,

 ./& '!-5 #(&/#(!5 

      
 5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." .

 #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5 ( ).", )()'# ( ()(=)()'# ",'5 - 1&& -

 ..),(3-9 -5 &#.#!.#)( 2*(-- ( )-.-5 */,-/(. .) KO 88 8 CKPRK)?@8

                                                




                                               
    

           NR8   " *,#(! ./& -..'(.- ( &&!.#)(- , #(),*),. ",#( 3

 , ,(8

           NS8     ((. )1  /.3 .) &#(.# ( &-- ',- .) - !/, ( *,)..

 ."#,     
8

           OJ8     ((. ," #.- /.3 3 #&#(! .) 2,#- ,-)(& , #( #.-

 - !/,#(! ( *,)..#)( ) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9        
8




                                                 13
                                      CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                 Filed 01/16/12 Page 14 of 17 PageID #: 14



        OK8     
. 1- ,-)(&3 ),-& .".         ((.9- #&/, .) 2,#- ,-)(&

 , #( - !/,#(! ( *,)..#(! &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9           
 1)/& ,-/&. #( (

 /(/."),#4 ."#, *,.3 !#(#(! -- .) -/" #( ),'.#)( ), () &1 /& */,*)-8

        OL8     &#(.# ( ." &-- ',- 1, ?( )(.#(/ .) @ '! -  #,.

 (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )       ((.9- #&/, .) -/, ( *,).. ."#,    
 #( ." ),' ) 5

 

  
 5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5

 (2#.35 ').#)(& #-.,--5 &)-- ) *,#035 ( ).", )()'# ( ()(=)()'# ",'> ),

 1"#" ."3 , (.#.& .) )'*(-.#)(8

        OM8       ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)( ?- -,# )0@ )(-.#./.

 ?( )(.#(/ .) )(-.#./.@ (!&#!( . )'')( &18

                                               


                
 
  
          
       
 
  
            


        ON8     " *,#(! ./& -..'(.- ( &&!.#)(- , #(),*),. ",#( 3

 , ,(8

        OO8     &#(.# 9- (     &-- ',-9        
 1, ?( )(.#(/ .) @ *,#0.

 #( ),'.#)(8

        OP8       ((.9- #&/, .) -/, ( *,).. &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9            


 #,.&3 ,-/&. #( ." */&# #-&)-/, ) -/" *,#0. #( ),'.#)(8

        OQ8      #--'#(.#)( ) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9        
 #- (). )  &!#.#'. */&#

 )(,(6 */&##.3 ) ."#,     
 1)/& 5 #- ( 1#&& )(.#(/ .) 5 ) (-#0 .) &#(.# 5 &--

 ',-5 ( ).", ,-)(& *)*&8

        OR8     &#(.# ( ." &-- ',- 1, ?( )(.#(/ .) @ '! -  #,.

 (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )        ((.9- #(0-#)( ) ."#, *,#03 3 */&#&3 #-&)-#(! ."#,

 *,#0. .- ?
 85 ."#,     
@ #( ." ),' ) 5 

  
 5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! (


                                                 14
                                       CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                         Filed 01/16/12 Page 15 of 17 PageID #: 15



 #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%. 2*(--5 (2#.35 ').#)(& #-.,--5 &)-- ) *,#035

 ( ).", )()'# ( ()(=)()'# ",'> ), 1"#" ."3 , (.#.& .) )'*(-.#)(8                .

 ." 0,3 &-.5 &#(.# ( ." &-- ',- , (.#.& .) ()'#(& '!-8

          OS8      ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(- (<), #(.#)( ?- -,# )0@ )(-.#./.

 ?( )(.#(/ .) )(-.#./.@ ( #(0-#)( ) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9 *,#03 3 */&#&3

 #-&)-#(! ."#, *,#0. .- ?
 85 ."#,      
@8

                                            
           

          PJ8    " *,#(! ./& -..'(.- ( &&!.#)(- , #(),*),. ",#( 3

 , ,(8

          PK8           %   -  #,. (<), *,)2#'. ,-/&. )           ((.9- 1,)(! /& .#)(-

 (<), #(.#)( ?- -,# )0@5 &#(.# ( &-- ',- -/ , ?( )(.#(/ .)

 -/ ,@ '!- #( ." ),' ) 5 

  
 5 &)-- ) /((/', /- ) 2.(. *--1),- (

 &)-- ) *--1),-5 2*(-- ), ,#. ')(#.),#(! ( #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(5 )/.=) =*)%.

 2*(--5 (2#.35 ').#)(& #-.,--5 &)-- ) *,#035 ( ).", )()'# ( ()(=)()'#

 ",'> ), 1"#" ."3 , (.#.& .) )'*(-.#)(8 &#(.#                 ( &-- ',- &-) ,

 (.#.& .) ,)0, -../.),3 '!- (<), ()'#(& '!-8 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9

 '!- 1, ),-& 3  ((. ( 2 ." '#(#'/' $/,#-#.#)(& &#'#.- ) ."#-

  )/,.8    && )(#.#)(- *,(. .) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9 &#'- "0 ( *, ),'

 (<), )/,,8

          PL8      
           %   &#(.# ( &-- ',- &-) , (.#.& .) 2'*&,3

 '!- - */(#-"'(. ( .) ., -/" 1,)(! /& )(/. #( ." /./,8                    && )(#.#)(-

 *,(. .) &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9 &#'- "0 ( *, ),' (<), )/,,8




                                                         15
                                          CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                            Filed 01/16/12 Page 16 of 17 PageID #: 16



        PM8       
   
      
     % &#(.# ( &-- ',- &-) , (.#.& .) #($/(.#0 ,&#

 #( ." ),' ) 5 1#.")/. &#'#..#)(5 ?#@ ,#. ')(#.),#(!5 ?##@ #(.#.3 ." . #(-/,(5 ( ?###@

 ,+/#,#(!       ((. .) -/'#. .) *,#)# )'*&#( /#.- 3  ."#, *,.3 ,!,#(! ."

 -/,#.3 ) )(-/',-9             
 #( #.- *)----#)(5 /-.)3 ( )(.,)&8          && )(#.#)(- *,(. .)

 &#(.# 9- ( &-- ',-9 &#'- ), ,&# "0 ( *, ),' (<), )/,,8

        PN8          &            # 

   
        %   &#(.# ( &-- ',- &-) ,

 (.#.& .) ,)0, ."#, ..),(3-9 -5 &#.#!.#)( 2*(--5 ( )/,. )-.- #( *,)-/.#(! ."#-

 .#)( */,-/(. .)5 

  
 5 KO 88 8 CC KPRK(?@6 )?@8                 && )(#.#)(- *,(. .) &#(.# 9-

 ( &-- ',-9 &#'- ), ,&# "0 ( *, ),' (<), )/,,8

                 # &#(.# 5 )( "& ) ",-& ( ." &-- ',-5 ,-*. /&&3 ,+/-.-

 .". ?#@  ((.  #. .) **, ( (-1, ."#- &1-/#.5 ?##@ ."#- .#)(  ,.# # - 

  &-- .#)(5 ?###@ &#(.#  -#!(. ." &-- *,-(..#05 ( ?#0@ &#(.# 9- )/(-& 

 **)#(. - &-- )/(-&8 &#(.# 5 )( "& ) ",-& ( ." &-- ',-5 /,.", ,+/-.-

 .". /*)( #(& .,#& ), ",#(!5 $/!'(.  1, !#(-.  ((.-5 #( 0), ) &#(.#

 ( ." &-- ',-5 ),7

        ?#@       ./& '!-5 )(-+/(.#& '!-5  -../.),3 '!- (<), ()'#(&
                  '!- ?- -,# )0@ #( ( ')/(. .)  .,'#( 3 ." .,#, ) .6

        ?##@      2'*&,3 '!-7

        ?###@     #($/(.#0 ,&# - -. ),." )06

        ?#0@      *,= ( *)-.=$/!'(. #(.,-. . ." "#!"-. **&#& &!& ,.-6

        ?0@       ..),(3-9 - ( &#.#!.#)( 2*(-- #(/,, .",)/!" .,#& ( (3 **&-6

        ?#0@      )-.- ) &1-/#.6 (

        ?0@       -/" ).", ( /,.", ,&# .". ."#- )/,. '- $/-. ( *,)*,8


                                                            16
                                                   CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
Case 3:12-cv-00032-JHM-JDM Document 1                Filed 01/16/12 Page 17 of 17 PageID #: 17



                                               

         &#(.# 5 )( "& ) ",-& ( ." &-- ',-5 ,-*. /&&3 '(-  .,#& 3

 $/,3 ) (3 ( && ) ", &#'- ( /-- ) .#)( -) .,#&8

  .7 (/,3 KP5 LJKL
                                                      -*. /&&3 -/'#..5

                                                               
                                                      ,% 8 ,3
                                                          D  

                                                      QKM 8 ,%. .,.5 )( &)),
                                                      
)/#-0#&&5 (./%3 NJLJL
                                                      &*")(7 ?OJL@ RJO=KRJJ
                                                       -#'#&7 ?OJL@ PKR=NJOS
                                                       ='#&7 '!,3E!,3(1"#.&18)'

                                                        
 
 
                
 

      "!$

  ( ,()1
  ,#" 8 "),%
  &% 8 .,/.#(-
                       8
                  
  5 8
 ( 8 
&& .,.5 /#. NPJJ
  "#!)5 
&&#()#- PJPJL
 &*")(7 ?MKL@ PLK=LJJJ
  -#'#&7 ?MKL@ PNK=OOJN
  ='#&7 8,()1E,()1&18)'
  ='#&7 8-"),%E,()1&18)'
  ='#&7 8-.,/.#(-E,()1&18)'

 #", 
8 ) '(
        
  

  #,-. #.3 /#&#(!
 OJO ,&(- .,.5 /#. OJO
   /')(.5 2- QQQJK
 &*")(7 ?NJS@ RMM=QQJJ
  -#'#&7 ?RPP@ RMO=RLOJ
   '#&7 ,E) &18)'




                                                17
                                      CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT

								
To top