Docstoc

ASSURING QUALITY LEARNING SUPPORT FOR TEACHERS

Document Sample
ASSURING QUALITY LEARNING SUPPORT FOR TEACHERS Powered By Docstoc
					                     ASSURING QUALITY LEARNING SUPPORT FOR
                     TEACHERS’ DISTANCE EDUCATION PROGRAM


                                       Daing Zaidah Ibrahim
                                       Abu Daud Silong, Ph.D.



Abstract

Research has indicated that learning support is an important component of distance education.
However, many distance education institutions provide those supports based on their own
presumptions, beliefs and conditions. Too often the needs of distance learners are not taken
into considerations. The learning supports given such as the module, tutorial, face-to-face
session, learning centres, course information and administration may not facilitate students’
learning and may not meet their needs. This study attempts to establish empirical evidence for
the needs of learner supports and their quality. The data are collected from a survey of
teachers enrolled in a distance education program at the Institute for Distance Education and
Learning (IDEAL), Universiti Putra Malaysia and from observations and feedbacks of those
involved in administering the program. Based on the results guidelines for assuring quality in
learning supports for teachers in distance learning is proposed.


Introduction

The early years of the nineties in Malaysia has witnessed a remarkable increase in the number
of distance education programs offered by local institutions. The number of distance education
students enrolment increased from a few thousand before 1990 to 17,756 in 1996. The number
of providers also increased from two in 1990 to seven in 1996. This increase is a result of
greater demand for tertiary among adult population in the country.

The increase and greater demand for tertiary education in Malaysia experienced in the early
nineties showed that there is a grater need among working adults to continue their education.
______________________
*     Paper presented at the 11th Annual Conference in Distance and Open Learning , Nov. 11-14, 1997,
      Putra World Trade Centre, Kuala Lumpur.

**    Graduate Student (Ph.D.), Faculty of Educational Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia/
      General Manager, IDEAL, UPM

***   Assoc. Professor, Faculty of Educational Studies, UPM, Director, IDEAL, UPM




                                                                                                   1
The increase and greater demand for tertiary education in Malaysia experienced in the early
nineties showed that there is a grater need among working adults to continue their education.
However, they are not able to continue their studies using the conventional means because of
their work and family commitments. Distance education provides the flexibility for them to
continue their studies.


Thus, when the Institute for Distance Education and Learning (IDEAL), Universiti Putra
Malaysia (UPM) offered degree programs for teachers there was a tremendous response. But
because of certain limitations, IDEAL was only able to register about 1,220 teachers, enrolled
in three programs i.e. Teaching Bahasa Malaysia as The First Language, Teaching English as a
Second language (TESL) and counseling and guidance.


It is the interest of this study to find out who are our distance education students i.e. their
demographic characteristics. By knowing their characteristics IDEAL will be more prepare to
understand the needs of distance education learners.


Distance learners depend of self-directed learning which give them the flexibility to learn at
their own place, time and pace. However, research have indicated that self-directed learning
requires certain supports to facilitate the student learning. Research have found that most
learning supports provided by institutions are not based on the needs of students. It is also the
purpose of this research then to determine whether the learning supports provided by IDEAL
meet the needs of the students.


Finally, the research attempts to establish the quality service i.e. in terms of the learning
support provided.    Quality is seen as meeting the satisfaction of the students when they
received the learning support provided to facilitate their learning.


It is hoped that from the results of the study IDEAL can find better ways of how to fulfil those
needs and draw implications towards better management of those support services and
providing continuous evaluation. In doing so IDEAL will make learner support a critical and
integral part of the distance education system.


                                                                                                2
Learner Support in Distance Education
Learner support is a very important component of distance education. It is an integral part of
open and distance learning system. However, determining what are the kinds of support
students need is a difficult task. It appears that support services provided by distance learning
centres are still based on presumptions, belief and conditions of the provider. Priyadarshini
(1994) pointed out that models of “good practice” of learner support developed in western
institutions are not always appropriate for other countries and culture. Distance education
providers must bear in mind that while planning a support system, people’s customs and
traditions must not be violated.


In determining the learner support needed, it is useful to look at the concepts of learner support.
Robinson (1995) said that the definitions of learner support very. To take just three: One
describes it as the element of an open learning system capable of responding to a particular
individual learner (Thorpe, 1988); another as the support incorporated within the self-learning
materials, the learning system marking (Hui, 1989); and a third as the requisite student services
essential to ensure the successful delivery of learning experience at a distance (Wright, 1991).


There are authors who include learner support as an integral part of a course, while others place
it as a supplement. Some authors include administration and delivery operations in their
definitions of learner support while others do not. The range of services included in models of
learner support also varies, some include pre-entry services, others do not. In some cases
support services are provided in partnership with other agencies, adding yet another dimension
of variation.   Bajaj (1996) said that student (learner) support services means input like
technologies and numerous others that contribute to the enhancement of the level of
comprehension of the student.


Learner support can be viewed as having various components i.e. the elements that make up the
system, their configuration, and the interaction between them and the learners, which creates its
dynamic. (Robinson, 1995).




                                                                                                   3
The elements are:
•   Personal contact between learners and support agency people acting in a variety of support
    roles and with a range of titles, individual or group, face-to-face or via other means;
•   Peer contact
•   The activity of giving feedback to individuals on their learning;
•   Additional materials such handbooks, advice, notes or guides;
•   Study groups and centers, actual or ‘virtual’ (electronic);
•   Access to libraries, laboratories, equipment and communication networks.


There will be varying configuration of these elements depending on the requirements of course
design, infrastructure of a country, distribution of learners, available resources and the value of
philosophy of the distance education provider.


It must be recognised that with deliberate support services and scientific instructional
methodology, the limitations for distance education has been converted into a source of greater
strength.   The self-instructional materials, multi-channel learning packages for learners to
choose, combined with varied support services for learners to avail are praiseworthy efforts.


However, the facts that learners will need support from human beings – people who can help
them with their learning and respond to them as individuals. Learners without support are most
liable to delay their completion of a program or drop out altogether (Rowntree, 1992).
Distance learners may need help before they even begin learning, as well as during and after a
learning program.


The ideal distance learning program should allow Paolo Freire (1974) call a “convivial
dialogue” between providers and their learners.          This would enable content, objective,
methods, assessment and systems to be continuously renegotiated.




                                                                                                 4
As Boot and Hodgson (1988) point out, this involves:


       “… a commitment to engaging with the aspiration,
       demands and experience of those whose learning interests
       we are claiming to serve. This implies a continuos process,
       not a on-off piece of market research”.


However, it can be concluded that learner support is needed in order to facilitate students’
learning. These support can be in the forms of facilities, administrative, learning materials,
reading materials and references, human interaction and advice and moral support.


In distance education where the responsibility of learning is in the “hands” of the students it is
logical then that they are the best to know what are the kinds of support needed. In this kind of
learning environment where it is learner-centered there is a strong possibility that in spite of the
holistic approach of the system, scientific justifications of education and best intentions of the
providers, these support services are not what is required by distance learners. The students –
the takers – may not want the goods delivered to them and may not find the services suitable.


Probably they do not want the regular tutorial sessions, they do not appreciate the techniques
adopted by the tutors, the face-to-face sessions that the instructors held with them, the support
given by the study centers may not contribute to their learning and instead of facilitating their
learning these support services are hindering their learning. Mishra (1996) said that as the
distance education system at present lacks any such learner-based survey there is no research-
based confirmation regarding this matter. He believes that the adult learners who have a
conceptual clarity regarding their learning objectives can propose their own views and
suggestions on the ways the distance education providers could help them in facilitating their
learning. They themselves are capable of defining, designing and deciding the services they
require.




                                                                                                  5
Quality and Quality Assurance of Learner Support
In providing learning support, the major question that is often asked – are the clients (students)
satisfied with the services provided? In other words are the services meeting the standards
required in providing quality in distance education. Failures of quality in distance education
are easily recognisable and they can often be traced to failures in systems in some way.


Of course it is not simple to define quality and to manage the processes effectively. In distance
education quality will mean different things to different people. There are the course designers,
students, program managers, tutors and content providers to whom the notion of quality will
differ. It is not value free and its meaning is created by the social group using the term in its
cultural context.


Quality is therefore an elusive term difficult to define and even more difficult to measure,
particularly as it applies to higher education. Despite the growing importance government and
the public attached to matters of educational quality and efficiency, no suggestion were made
as to how they would be measured.


Scriven (1997) listen some indicators to provide a starting point from which to measure the
quality of an institution’s distance education program.      Drawing upon the findings of an
national project undertaken in Australia in 991 and 1992, these indicators are for consideration
and are suggestions of some benchmarks, which might be used to measure quality.
The indicators have been classified under four headings:
•   Policy development and management
•   Staff development
•   Service provision
•   Processes of distance learning


Quality assurance is a process directed towards achieving the quality or characteristics of
quality. Robinson (1994) regards “quality” as a characteristic and ‘quality assurance’ as a
process directed towards achieving the characteristics. It is one way of managing an enterprise
in order to achieve a stated standard or quality of performance. Quality assurance is the set of


                                                                                                6
activities that an organization undertakes to ensure to ensure that standards are specified and
reached consistently for a product or services. It has as its goal the avoidance of faulty
products or services.


Quality assurance focuses attention on operational processes and systems. It is a simple idea
with three main elements:
•   Standards are set for a product or service
•   Production or delivery of a product or service is organised so that the standards are
    consistently met.
•   Consequently clients or recipients’ confidence are created because what is promised is what
    will happen.


Quality assurances are not so simple to implement although they may sound easy and
straightforward.    However quality assurance and accreditation are very important in
development of any educational program especially through the distance education mode.
Education has no meaning unless there is credibility in quality and its acceptance. If quality
distance education is an obsession, there is hardly any place for complacence. Therefore,
concerned providers and institutions have to strive hard to achieve higher quality.


Meeting The Needs and Satisfaction in Learner Support
In this area where education can be perceived as one of many business activities, students or
learners as clients, can influence the educational system. As stated earlier an important element
of ensuring the success of teaching and learning through distance education is by knowing the
learners.   Information such as age, sex, work experiences, income, cultures and beliefs,
occupation, etc. are very much needed in the building and preparation of learner support
services. The information too will help to determine the support needed. Normally learners
support services needed are in the form of advice and counseling; acquiring learning and
examination skills; support from other learners; feedback regarding assessments and carrier
guidance.




                                                                                               7
It is safe to say that in distance education it is the meeting of the students needs that is the
concern of the provider. However in providing the services in distance education (such as
learning support and advising, tutoring, responding to enquiries) there has been complaints and
grievance from students. These complaints and grievances can be taken to indicate that support
and services are not adequate in meeting the needs of the student. Empirical data is needed to
prove the gap between the services provided and quality expected.


Tait (1995) developed a model for the planning of learner support in distance education. The
model illustrate that we need to know who are the learners, what are their needs and how can
we fulfill their needs. The models also indicate that the support needs to be managed, needs
expenses and also continuous evaluation.

                              Who are they

   How can we
    evaluate                                        How can we fulfill the needs



                                                         How can the services
  What are the expenses                                     be managed
 required for the services


                             What are their needs


Model for The Planning and Managing of Learner Support Services
Source: Tait (1995)


The Study of Learner Support
Based on the model, this study is designed to determine the demographic characteristics of
IDEAL’s students, their needs in terms of learner support and their satisfaction regarding the
services provided. From the findings inferences are made to provide a guideline for quality
assurance.


The study is based on data collected from a survey, records, observation and feedbacks by
students and those involved in distance education. The survey was conducted on distance



                                                                                              8
education students in the Bachelor of Education program (Teaching Bahasa Malaysia as the
First Language). The students were the first group enrolled and were in their second semester.
There were about 472 students in this program.       They were the largest group of students
pursuing the Bachelor of Education program.


The study was carried out on one group only because they were using the same modules, same
references, do similar assignment topics and use same support that are made available to them.
The demographic profile of these students were analysed to assess the effect of the different
variables had on the needs of the students and their satisfaction of the learning support
provided.


The study was carried out on students from a number of learning centres all over the country.
There were 17 learning centres altogether. They were in Alor Setar, Kulim Taiping, Ipoh,
Lumut, Banting, Shah Alam, Cheras, UPM, Melaka, Muar, Johor Bharu, Kuantan, Kuala
Terengganu, Kota Bharu, Bintulu and Kota Kinabalu. These centers were divided into four
regions, northern, central, southern and eastern region. It was decided that the sample should
comprise of students from centers of each of the region. The sample was then picked at
random and the centers of Lumut, Cheras, Muar and Kuantan were picked representing the four
regions mentioned above. All students of Teaching Bahasa Malaysia as the First Language at
these centres were taken respondents. There were 31 respondents in Lumut, 12 in Kuantan, 14
in Muar and 35 in Cheras.


For the purpose of data collection a set of questionnaire was constructed. The questionnaire
was made up of nine sections, with the first sections consisting of data pertaining to the
background of the respondent. Data collected were on age, years of teaching experience, sex
and salary.


Data were also collected on support needed by respondents in carrying out self-directed
learning and whether they like the self-directed learning method and were able to carry it out.
The support listed were module, tutorial, face-to-face sessions; learning centres; courses
information, guide to preparation of assignments and administration of the program. Data were



                                                                                             9
collected on each support service provided with questions on learner satisfaction and their
quality. The questionnaires were distributed to the respondents of the four learning centres
while they were having their tutorial and the administration of the questionnaires was explained
to them.


The researchers explained to the respondents how the respondents should be administrated and
remained with them while they were responding to ensure that they answer the questions
correctly. Frequency and percentage analysis were used to explain the students’ perception on
the adequacy of learner support provided.


Learners Demographic
IDEAL distance learners are adults, majority (80%) are above 30 years old and with an average
age of 35 years old; more male (62%) than female; all are working and a majority (95%) have
more than 5 years of working experience and an average working experience of 11 years; a
majority (84%) of them earn more than RM1,000 per month with an average earning of
RM1.320 per month with a range of RM769 to RM2,315 per month (Appendix 1).


The study indicates that IDEAL’s learners are matured working adults who have commitments
at office and at home. Due to these commitments, the conventional mode of full-time learning
hinders them from continuing their education. Given the opportunity, they want to further their
education. IDEAL’s distance education programs provide them the flexibility they need,
especially in terms of flexible scheduling through self-directed learning. If they decide to
follow the full-time study in campus they have to take leave from work, which in most cases
they are not able to do. Even if they manage to get leave then they have to forego their
seniority in service and also lose certain portion of their pay. Teachers who study full-time are
only paid half of their salaries. Thus, for working teachers, distance education is one the best
options they have if they want to pursue further education.


Most of the students are very experienced teachers and this experience provides them the
necessary maturity to handle self-directed learning. This requires more responsibility and
discipline from students, especially to face the challenges of studying and at the same time



                                                                                              10
working full-time in addition to family commitments that they have, They really have to be
very disciplined in order to complete their readings and assignments. Their working experience
can help them in planning and organizing well, there is a better chance that they can follow and
complete their studies. Many times their studies are interrupted by work they need to attend to
and solve problems related to family matters.


This kind of problems are enough to make any average person withdraw from the program,
especially when several assignments and examinations are due. It is during this time that we
find many students are giving excuses to withdraw or postpone their studies. Only very
matured students can handle these trying times and proceed with their studies and complete
their courses.


Many of the students have a reasonable income. Financially the students have to be stable
because they have to pay the full fee and at the same time they have to spend monthly for
books, transport and other expenses. With an average income of RM1,000, students may find it
quite tough to make ends meet. Some of them have savings while others have to resort to
borrowings. Studying pose additional financial burden for these students and they have to find
means to support the additional financial commitments. Usually the have made certain amount
of commitments such as for their homes, transport, work, children education and others. Many
students make monthly deduction provided by IDEAL and by doing so spread out their
expenses over a period of about 4 years. But for teachers the amount of money they spend on
distance education will be less compared if they study full-time, in terms of actual cost as well
as opportunity cost. This is a very important factor for institutions that try to introduce a
distance education program that is self-financing. The students must be able to pay and at the
same time they must have the education that is relatively cheap. Pricing of self-sustaining
program is very critical, otherwise it may not be able to attract adequate and hence the program
will not be viable.




                                                                                              11
Learner Support Needed
The mean score for each learner support was calculated. The study found that all the support
are very important. The students need these supports as indicated by the high mean scores for
each support. The scores range from 4.5 to 4.9 from am minimum score of 1 and a maximum
score of 5, with module placed as the highest learner support needed (Appendix 2). It is quite
understandable because the module is the main guide for them to study.          It contains the
scheduling, information about the instructors, the activities, readings, references, contents,
assignments and examinations. Without the module the students will not be able to follow the
course.


Other supports that the students perceived to be very important are information about courses,
feedback from lecturers (mean score 4.8) and tutorials (mean of 4.7). The information about
courses are incomplete and in some cases are not clear. There are also cases where additional
information and changes are made and thus they need to make further inquiries about those
changes.


When the students are following courses, they are given assignments, tests, quizzes and mid-
term examinations.    In almost all cases they need to know how they are doing in their
assignments and examinations so that they can learn from their mistakes and improve. Also
they have to make sure they pass their courses so that they can graduate and do well in their
studies.   Besides that they need to know about the general academic procedures and
regulations. Even though these rules and regulations have been written and explained during
the registration but then as they go along they face certain problems related to exemptions,
withdrawals and postponement of their studies and they need to talk to somebody. Usually
they would be comfortable to refer to lecturers who they think would provide them the
necessary information about courses.


During the course of study, they also need interactions with peers, tutors and lecturers. They
gave tutorial a mean score of 4.7 and the same for interaction with peers and instructors. The
scores indicates while self-study is the main way of study, human interaction is a major support
for them to solve academic problems. They depend quite a lot on their friends and tutors who



                                                                                             12
are closer to them while less on the lecturers because of distance. Anyway, problems that be
solved by friends and tutors will be referred to lecturers during the face-to-face sessions,
through the a-mail, e-mail and telephones. But interactions with lecturers seem to be more
difficult and hence they rely more on the tutors who they meet more often and are located in
their own areas of residence.


Other supports are also seen to be important such as feedbacks from tutors, place to forward
problems and administrative questions with mean scores of 4.7, learning centres (mean score
4.6), face-to-face sessions, flexibility in learning, guidance to preparation of assignment and
academic advisor (mean scores of 4.5). These support facilitate their learning. The learning
centres provide them the facilities to meet and have discussions, study and refer to certain
references reading materials and also some sense of belonging to a group. The face-to-face
sessions give the change to come to campus and give them the chance to come to campus and
give them the sense of belonging to a university, to see fellow students from other centres and
meet the lecturers. This further will give confidence and motivation to continue their studies,
especially they see that others are facing the same problems and they get some assurance from
the lecturers. However, all the tutorial and face-to-face sessions are not compulsory and this
gave them further flexibility of following the program. Majority of the students does come for
tutorials and face-to-face but then they do not have to come if they have other commitments
during the week-ends. These help them to go ahead with work or personal commitments but if
they come, they can interact with friends, tutors and lecturers.


Satisfaction With Learner Support
The students satisfaction towards the learning support provided by IDEAL, is measured on a
scale of 1 to 5. Generally it was found that the students are satisfied with the service provided,
ranging in mean scores from 3.0 to 4.4 (Appendix 3).


Generally the students are satisfied with the module saying that the content of the module
meets the objectives of the course (mean score 4.0), the format is helpful to students (mean
score 3.9), it is clear (mean score 4.2) encourage learners’ participation through activities
(mean score 3.9) allow some interactivity (mean score 3.6), scheduled at good pace for learning



                                                                                               13
(mean score 3.7), contain enough examples and illustration (mean score 3.3). Taking into
account that the module is the most important support for distance learning, students
satisfaction with module will contribute to positive learning and also certain level of quality has
been based on the standards required for quality learning materials.


Learners are also satisfied with the tutors.     The study indicated that the scores on their
evaluation of tutors are high ranging from 3.7 to 4.3 on selected standards that have been
measured. They are very satisfied with their relationship with the tutors (mean score 4.3), the
tutors are good facilitators to guide discussion and encourage learning (mean score 3.8) the
tutors can benefit the students through the tutorials (mean score 3.9), that the tutors have
adequate experience (mean score 3.9), can guide the students in preparing the assignment
(mean score 3.9), the tutors have the ability to deliver (mean score 3.7) and the tutors have a
good knowledge on the subject matter (mean score 3.7).


Tutor is a critical learner support in distance education. As such the selection are done based
on certain criteria. Most important among these criteria is that they have gone through the
program, know the system in UPM and know the lecturers teaching the courses. Because they
have gone through the program and courses they are comfortable with advising students on
matters related to academic and content. Besides that tutors are given training at the beginning
of the semester as well as other times to familiarise them with the modules, the contents, their
jobs expectations, the contacts with relevant people and some motivation so that they
understand and are committed to distance learning.


The interactions with peers and tutors are reinforced by face-to-face sessions with lecturers in
the campus. This further reinforced students learning through meetings with others from all
over the country as well as the lecturers. The students are satisfied with meetings that were
provided giving a mean score 3.4.


Students are also satisfied with the physical facilities (classrooms, seats, lighting, equipment
etc.). However the collection of assignment needs further improvement (mean score 2.7).




                                                                                                14
Guidelines for Quality Assurance
To meet the challenges of producing quality distance education several steps have to be taken.
They study has proven that distance learners needs support whatever support can be provided
by the institutions as well as support from peers and other individuals. It is therefore crucial for
IDEAL to continue providing the support to its distance education learners and in the process
improve its service based on the feedback and evaluation by the learners themselves. It is
hoped that all the support provided would reduce the drop out rate among learners.


It is believed that in assuring quality of distance education, standards has to be set and delivery
of the product or service must be organized to meet the standards. This will lead to the creation
of confidence in the learners.


It is therefore suggested that as a guideline for quality assurance IDEAL has to take the
following steps:
•   Develop a quality policy and plan
•   Ensure a specified and clearly defined standards that are communicated t al concern
    including partners
•   Identify critical functions for achieving the standards and analyse the procedures
•   Document clearly procedures to be followed and make them accessible to all concerned
•   Involve all staff in the organization and take into account their ideas and suggestions in the
    development of the quality-assurance system. Establish a systematic monitoring mechanism
    to check whether standards are being met and procedures followed.
•   Involve staff, learners and other clients in setting and monitoring standards
•   Provide adequate training and development opportunities for staff that are linked to the
    achievement of standards
•   Monitor the cost of implementing and maintaining quality assurance activities




                                                                                                 15
Conclusion
Suggestions and guidelines given above are only means of assisting in improving the
operational aspects of distance education, ad hoc practices, uncertainly, lack of coordination
and inconsistency. They are nor recipes for a perfect system. There are needs for establishing
continuing research, evaluation and development besides creating a culture of commitment
among all parties in providing distance education.




                                                                                           16

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Stats:
views:3
posted:12/15/2011
language:
pages:16
Description: distance learning degree program